Latest / Future Engineering Bets / Why Energy Management Decides Performance with Mark Preston | Future Engineering Bets
Transcript
- Drea & Fred Warner: welcome another episode of Future Engineering Bets, where we look at the innovation of the future in advanced engineering, today I'm really pleased to welcome Mark Preston ⁓ Mark is the team principal of Lola Yamaha ABT in Formula E. welcome to another episode of Future Engineering Bets, where we look at the innovation of the future in advanced engineering, particularly in electrification and the motive and motorsport sector. And today I'm really pleased to welcome Mark Preston onto the episode. ⁓ Mark is the team principal of Lola Yamaha ABT Formula E. If you don't know anything about Formula E, should get involved and you should watch it because it's really pushing the boundaries electrification in cars and energy management. so Mark, welcome. How are you doing? Mark: Thank you, yeah, looking forward to having a chat with you. Drea & Fred Warner: Brilliant. so, mean, Mark, you have an extensive history in motorsport. those that don't know you, would you like to just sort of wet our appetites with just a of the Formula One teams and other motorsport things you've been involved in? Mark: Yeah, so maybe going way back, I came over from Australia in 1996 when Tom Walkinshaw bought Arrows Grand Prix. He had a facility and activities over in Australia, so I came over from there. Joined them then, ⁓ worked up my way up to head of R&D, running the test team at Arrows. After that, on to ⁓ McLaren, where worked with Adrian Newey and Mike Coughlan on some famous cars like the MP4-18A, which was the only car that never ran with the I call it the technology demonstrator when we look back. And went and did my MBA actually at Oxford and started to switch more across to the, I suppose you call it the business side of things of engineering. ⁓ then went on to start Super Aguri Formula One team with Honda and Aguri Suzuki, which was great fun. We had to start the ⁓ team in a days. So that was, ⁓ you know, something quite ⁓ novel those days. Drea & Fred Warner: Ha Mark: We had to run that for a couple of years as technical director and then started to look at ⁓ what was the future of automotive and my world of, I suppose, mobility and our world of mobility and got involved in the spin out of an electric motor company out of Oxford University called ⁓ Yasa Motors, which is actually still running and is part of Mercedes now. And that got me interested in electrification even more. And then when Formula E started, got involved from the beginning with Alejandro Agag and all of the people at Formula E. Started again Aguri and so we had Amlin Aguri Formula E team in the very first season. ⁓ And then we changed names to ⁓ DS TECHEETAH five championships total. Three drivers in two teams. And then now we're back in Formula E as Lola with as our partner. So that's a bit of a potted history, I suppose. Drea & Fred Warner: Wow, a wonderful history that is, Mark, as well. And ⁓ so many different race formats and types and probably regulations and boundary settings that you've seen in your career. And you've seen how it spins out into automotive and to other technologies it goes through. So from today's point of view, we're going to talk energy which is a really key aspect of Formula E. Mark: He. Drea & Fred Warner: start off where Formula E principles like yourself, what's the biggest challenge you're worrying about as you're going to a weekend in terms of how you're going to win that race? Mark: Yeah. So, ⁓ what makes them from three different to, let's say my previous experience in internal combustion engine motorsport is that it takes place over one day. So you've got a very small window for a driver to, and a team to arrive basically the track in a free practice one and two, and then straight into qualifying and a race. And it's not, it's quite a big difference to, internal combustion or let's say traditional motorsport where you might have a Friday. couple of sessions on a Friday, then have overnight to look at data, then a free practice on a Saturday morning, then a qualifying in the afternoon, and then a race on Sunday with lots of big gaps in between. So we have to hit the ground running with a much smaller ⁓ period for the drivers to get up to speed ⁓ the engineers. So that really puts a lot of emphasis on preparation in the simulator with simulation and optimizing software before we arrive at the track. it's a I see it as kind of like it a good place for what I would say a driver with explosive talent. ⁓ got to hit the track and not any mistakes, deliver what's necessary, qualify and go racing in one day. And so it's a high pressure environment and a different environment than ⁓ other of racing. Drea & Fred Warner: Yeah, it really is, isn't it? And it has a mixed reaction from people, doesn't it, for me, in all truth. You're obviously very immersed in it. some people absolutely see the brilliance in it, and some people are kind of very purist and argue against it. ⁓ have you seen that evolve over the last, I guess, five to 10 years? Mark: Yeah, I think when you look at it from a sort of a fan's point of view, I think you can get caught up. was listening to a podcast with Stefano Domenicali actually a couple of days ago about what's happening in F1 at the moment with respect to the electrification side of things. And he was very much focused on what is the fan's experience of the activity, let's say, and not let's say not the engineers. All of us engineers love to play with all these. Amazing technologies, but you know, a normal fan wants to watch motor racing. And so, you know, if you look at some of the best races that certainly I've had where Antonio Felix de Costa won the race in Monaco, coming out of the tunnel, overtaking Mitch Evans, and you know, on the last lap of the race, where I haven't seen a F1 do that for God knows how long. And that kind of really super close racing is the exciting part of Formula E. Yes, you have the traditionalists. grew up with V8 supercars in Australia, so I appreciate obviously those cars and how they go racing. But certainly Formula E has changed a little bit over the years and we've adapted the racing formats. And I think we've settled on quite a good racing format now with duels in qualifying, so that ⁓ throws a bit of a difficulty for drivers because ⁓ they one lap ⁓ to at it and they have to go up against. their competitors so they can make mistakes and then you end up with a spread out grid which is what everybody wants or let's say it's not the fastest goes first and then there's no overtaking in the race. There's some of it's down to the driver to deliver on the day then in the race we have something called attack mode which is in some ways like a very short pit stop but because we don't fuel loads board and because we don't switch tires to different ⁓ of tires, it means that it's quite hard to predict when to take that effectively short pit stop in the race because it's quite, I'll use the word probabilistic instead of deterministic in ⁓ series. it throws up a lot of different elements into racing. And so if you're a purist, maybe you don't like some of the new formats, in terms of some of the racing it delivers, like that example in Monaco, it's spectacular and you're jumping out of your chair, shouting at the TV, I'm sure. Drea & Fred Warner: Amazing, And when people look at Formula One racing and the Formula E racing and the other forms now, the Extreme H and others, they're of looking for that inference on how it rolls over into real life practicality. And I know that that's what Lola cars are all about as well. But when look at that rollover, what have you seen the biggest things that are hitting the market in terms of Formula E and going out? Mark: Okay. So maybe if I go back to my experience with Honda when I was in F1, I learned a lot from my colleagues at Honda in how they saw racing. And certainly ⁓ founder, Mr. Honda, ⁓ he looked at racing as a way improve the breed, but he also looked at it a way to develop engineers, processes, procedures, and the things that you can carry over. So many of the times that ⁓ I had discussions with them was that You're going to, when you go to motor racing, the sky's the limit. You know, you can push the boundaries. can potentially use some of the more expensive technologies that, you know, are out there to solve a problem. saying that that will directly go to a road car immediately, but once you know what's possible, so you know, the art of the possible means once you know what you can achieve, sometimes it's possible to achieve that ⁓ a lesser cost component or maybe a different way of doing things. So the same is true in Formula E, we're pushing the boundaries. I was talking to an OEM that has been in Formula E since close to the beginning and I said, did you expect to make so many gains in something, electric motor, that's a hundred and something years old, of an efficiency in the, let's say the 80 % to early 90 % ranges? And he's like, no, I didn't expect that we'd get as far as we got. And so without... competing at this level against other OEMs and really pushing the boundaries, they didn't know that it was possible to get up to the very high percentages of efficiency. so then they know what is possible and then they know that they can take that over into the road cars. Another example was that there was a way of dealing with some of the ⁓ high systems on the car. And because, you know, in road cars, you haven't had to deal with high voltage systems ever in the last 100 years into development, you come into Formula E running things on the absolute bleeding edge and find that some just simple procedures don't work you would expect and all of a sudden you have to understand how ⁓ high-voltage systems work in a car company. ⁓ that is a ⁓ experience in itself. So think there's always elements that cross over. Not always is it the exact component crosses over, but certainly A lot of the processes and procedures and simulation methodologies and proof of concepts crossover. I mentioned earlier about ⁓ the that I call the technology demonstrator. do think that motor racing, when you look at what is a technology demonstrator, they really are the proof of concepts of what's possible. And that allows ⁓ people to things over to the road cars in that respect. Drea & Fred Warner: It does, you know what, there's a thing that I think motorsport people, especially the engineers like yourself, and you had a history of developing things, you understand that competitive engineering, and it was a word that came up at that recent MIA event that you were also a guest speaker at, that competitive engineering is something not to be underestimated. That in the pressure of design, build, test, design, build, test, design, build, test, which drives progress, Mark: Hmm. Drea & Fred Warner: When you set several different teams against each other and say you all need to go into a design, build, test cycle, it forces something out of people, which is brainstorming, and you talk about the prototyping, for me, ⁓ you to use the word breadboarding all the time, know, just, let's get it on a breadboard, which is just, it doesn't need to look like it's in a pretty package, it doesn't need to be the finished article, we prove it. Mark: Hmm. Drea & Fred Warner: We prove the idea and if the idea has some basis to do something, we then take it forward and develop further. And motorsport, it can be well underestimated for how it can really take, and you talk about the efficiency of the, let's say the motors and maybe the inverters and what have you that have been used in Formula ⁓ huge, isn't it? ⁓ when I like to think of the energy management, which we're going to come onto, then talk about how that ⁓ out because Mark: Mm. Drea & Fred Warner: The automakers, for what they invest in motorsport, in theory, if you do it right and you pick the right motorsport for you, all that learning can come out and help guide the design phases and the requirement setting phases of your OEM product requirements, can't they? Mark: Let me answer that first ⁓ thing you said about competitive engineering, because a lot of people always ask me, did you race cars ever? I say, well, I had a go-kart with one of my best mates when we were ⁓ and we were at university. And I pretty quickly I could make him faster than he could make me. ⁓ So decided I could be competitive by being the engineer that made him want to race. ⁓ And I kind of took that ⁓ methodology as a ⁓ really is my... competitive advantages that I can figure out how to make a driver go faster. So that's what I've always on instead of perhaps ⁓ being a driver myself. But to the second question about elements that can cross over, think, yeah, it's ⁓ motorsport pushes to the boundaries because every two weeks ⁓ or every weeks you're judged against your peers. in the ⁓ big wide are You have the answer. Did we, did we succeed in our two week sprint between the last race and this race? Did we make an impact or did the others make more of an impact? And so you get to measure yourself. You're let's say your KPI is the lap time. And so every two weeks you get to see whether what you did last week made an impact. I know that's certainly what makes it fun for an engineer is that you get to see that answer every two weeks. Drea & Fred Warner: so when we look at motorsport and we look at, let's take Formula One as the example a lot of people use. There's a lot of R and D goes into Formula One in terms of how much of the car is actually developed individually from other teams. And then you move over to something like Formula E where a lot more of it is Mark: Yep. Drea & Fred Warner: preset and there's a single source supplier. you describe the difference between the two? Because when ⁓ actually an interesting and when you can ⁓ everybody to one set of equipment with only a few things you can really vary, it drives other kinds of creativity than if you could vary everything. Mark: Mm-hmm. So probably the easiest way to do this comparison is to look at the cost cap. So F1's cost cap is somewhere in the region of 150 million. cost cap is more like 15 million. And so that's all in the FIA documentation. So you can see that, ⁓ pretty much drives a 10 times difference in ⁓ amount of R &D and resources you have to deliver a project. So was settled on early in Formula E was that you would say, okay, let's not develop the monocoque. because that's not a differentiator anymore. probably was back in the days when I started doing monocoques in the ⁓ but nowadays it's not the differentiator in a road car. What's the differentiator is the electrification element and the software element. So as you probably know, software defined vehicles are the buzzword of the future of automotive in my opinion. Tesla is probably the leader in that in terms of ⁓ going vehicles and obviously a lot of others are chasing along behind them now. But ⁓ the... specific task was for the rule set was to make sure that competition was happening in the area that was the most to transfer across or the best technology transfer. ⁓ the area that we focus on is the electric powertrain itself and then the software and all the processes and procedures ⁓ that with that. If you know the classic V diagram in engineering, when you think the, start with a specification and then you obviously do ⁓ all of the analysis and then you do the testing and you do an iteration loop. What you could say is a lot of people talk about shifting that to the left. We're doing more more and more simulation, which is completely relevant to road cars because road cars are doing more and more simulation, more and more digital twins and all of those buzzwords. And what for is defining modern engineering, I would say, ⁓ is that process element to it. So more simulation, more driver in the loop testing, use of AI that's obviously coming really, really fast and is ⁓ of the moment. And what I think about that is quite funny is it's only of the moment in the last year or so. You know, it's very recent. That's when these models have started to be able to do more and more. And so I think what we always try to focus on, I think in motorsport is to be as relevant as possible to what's happening in the road car industry. And in my Very strong opinion, software defined vehicles, AI, the whole development cycle is what everyone's talking about at the moment. in OEM circles, speed of development, model turnover, how fast you can do over the year updates, all those things are like the core of what's happening in the automotive world. And so I think ⁓ E focuses ⁓ really ⁓ on that aspect. ⁓ that's what we compete in. So we're all trying to compete in the energy management element of that. We're trying to compete in the control systems, the way we can make the driver able to adapt to the car the most quickly when they arrive. As I said earlier, you've only got one day, so you've got to hit the track with the most preparation, with the most knowledge that you can to give the driver ⁓ the amount of time possible to get up to speed and ⁓ with others. Drea & Fred Warner: Yeah, And ⁓ was a subject I was going to touch on actually. ⁓ we go into the energy management piece, it's interesting you talk about it. I know that, well, every business is either ⁓ it or thinking of using it. But in the development cycle and the R&D development cycle, the power of AI potentially is huge in of defining futures, the simulations, ⁓ know, 100x. But in the cycle and the R&D development cycle, the power of AI potentially huge in terms of defining futures, the simulations, 100x. X simulations that you can run as long as you can extract from it useful progress it's always you know there is an element of crap ideas in you'll get crap ideas out X simulations that you can potentially run as long as you can extract from it ⁓ progress because it's always you know there is an element of crap in and you'll get crap ideas out type scenario but so AI is something you're using it's a cross motorsport already is it it helping you in terms of as a against others is it does it stay the same as everybody uses it together Mark: So I think ⁓ I did a recent article because I've been thinking about this quite heavily as to how it affects our process. And so I took a little bit of a reminisce about when I started programming, about a long, time ago with Pascal in the nineties. And my best example ⁓ sort where I've got to is the knowledge asymmetry of an LLM and yourself is one of the most important aspects. So when first started, and this is going back a long time, I used to have to go to the bookshop I've been thinking about this quite heavily as to how it affects our process. So when I first started, and this is going back a long time, I used to have to go to the bookshop to figure out how to write a new piece of code to do something for my software program. to figure out how to write a new piece of code to do something for my software program. So I started programming a simulation back in engineering ⁓ in Monash University a long, time ago. And the amount of time it took me to do the research to then get around to implementing it. And what I found also along the time was it also just writing the GUI, the interface with yourself. to actually input the data took me probably 80% of the time to write the interface to then spend 20% of the time writing the software that was actually gonna give me the insights into the race car. All of that is speeding up like a house on fire. I'm finding personally, I dug out an old simulation that I hadn't touched for 15 years and thought, let me have a look at this. It was my personal pet project and I put it into one of the LMS and took me probably 80% of the time to write the interface to then spend 20% of the time writing the software that was actually gonna give me the insights into the race car. All of that is speeding up like a house on fire. Within about two or three hours, I had a version that was transferred from Visual Basic to the latest web-based tools. And I could see how quickly now, with the knowledge asymmetry with the model, how fast you could develop new ideas. So for me, that's one of the more exciting elements. Not just asking it a question, please tell me the density of steel or something. It's more saying, I'm trying to figure out how to write this piece of software. I don't know how to do that. That call to a hard disk or something like that, or to a cloud service. How do I do that? And two seconds later, ⁓ have the answer and you, so it just sort of speeds up what I've been calling it, ⁓ friction around all of our jobs. And so that's the most exciting bit for me. I'm calling it the friction tax. So the knowledge asymmetry and the friction tax that we've all, ⁓ got all these examples from the ⁓ days. that's the most exciting bit for me. I'm calling it the friction tax. Drea & Fred Warner: I it. Mark: which I can use in my process. But I've kind of tried to map that out. So that's just one element before we get into all the other data analytics and all of the other speeding up of using cloud tools. And ⁓ just a lot of things going on in the background. So they're the ones that are probably more, let's say public domain. That's obvious for everybody. Drea & Fred Warner: Yeah, and I understand it. And I imagine what will be very active now is because you're in these compressed time windows with a lot of things got to happen in a day, the AI will potentially make huge difference in gain between one session and another session enables very fast data crunching analysis. Mark: So that exact point, sometimes it's not the AI, for example, that's doing the actual crunching, but what might have been something you, there's certainly a lot of things that I've dreamt about doing over years, but never had the time or the inclination and thought, you know what, I haven't got time to spend doing that piece of software that could analyze that piece of data in a different way. And I would've just put it to the side and thought one day, maybe I'll have a look at that idea. Now you can basically just do a long prompt. And within half an hour, you'll have at least a prototype that you'll able to say written in Python or something like that and go, actually, that could work. And then you can perhaps go, okay, now let's take it a bit further. Whereas before you would have said, too much work. I can't quite see over the horizon whether that's going to be worthwhile doing. So, know, when you think about ⁓ where you don't know where the local maximum or minima are, ⁓ you're thinking, ⁓ think I'm at the local minima. But actually over the hill is another lower ⁓ minima, but you haven't got the bandwidth to maybe find new tools and new concepts. So basically now you can just say run off six different ideas just with a really large prompt and then it'll come back with answers. It's obviously garbage in, garbage out, and you still have to look at it. But what I think is it just opens up all these possibilities that you just didn't have the bandwidth to do, or maybe the resources or the people. So going back to your earlier question about sort of F1 versus E, if they've got 10 times the budget of us, that means they've got 10 times the people. We want to see if we can use AI to augment the people that we do have. Drea & Fred Warner: Yeah, as they will be doing as well to 10X their budgets as well. absolutely. And so looking at the energy management side of things, and one of the things that seems really relevant in energy management today in the road car setting is getting the most range or long-term durability and performance out of the battery in the whole car. And as you see the different car companies with often similar battery techs getting different ranges in real world. Mark: Exactly. Yeah Yep. Drea & Fred Warner: And so, you know, regardless of what the lab says and the lab test, and then a lot of that comes down to software, which comes down to energy management. Some of it's thermal, but we'll go also into the energy management side. And then when that plays itself back into motorsport, the challenge against your competitors and peers is who can refine the energy management cycle to get it working best. And just before I hand to you on that one to ask. Well, the question is, how are you finding the energy management? Where do you push into to get that race cycle? Because for me, the cars have exploded in weight. One of the things that we've not got quite right in the transition so far is what was a 1500, 1600 kilogram family car has now become a 2.2 to 2.5 ton family car. And so the drive naturally will be to, through efficiency, through software and... understanding where your energy losses are in the overall system architecture, which might not be software, might be other things, electromechanical, whatever, you know, that must be the same things you're struggling with. Mark: Yeah, so maybe I can use ⁓ some examples from like the first season because you know, just you know, looking back, I remember our first season. I don't know if it's quite true, but I remember in the first races or at least the first practice races, some of the drivers remember that their team was just like, OK, you've got this much energy. That means at the end of every lap, you're just going to have to look on the dash and approximately say it's you've used 5 % lap. You know, that was the early days of everybody. trying to figure this out, you know, 12 years ago. then we probably go a little bit further and we got a spreadsheet that we could at least, you know, map out over a spreadsheet, the usage every lap. maybe not clear, but deliberately the FIA made sure that telemetry is only, ⁓ is quite in formulary ⁓ to make more difficult for us engineers. And so ⁓ driver has tell us what energy the car's got every lap. ⁓ And that's really to create a more difficult situation because otherwise we'd be doing way more optimization. Again, it's to do with budgets and to create more difficulty as always for the teams. so in ⁓ following the spreadsheets got more complicated. But then some of the drivers, like we had ⁓ Antonio de Costa as our driver in the first couple of seasons. And he figured out that this is an example. when you're going through low speed corners where nobody can overtake you, you can just go on part throttle and actually save energy on the others who are on off their throttle, like a taxi driver, you know, in London or something. he found these extra bits of efficiency that we hadn't calculated. And so we're like, why do you always able to catch up, you know, XYZ energy? And he's like, well, you know, I think I just drive differently through the low speed corners and others. And we had to look at the data and and behold, that's what he was doing. So over time, of course, that's got more sophisticated and you add in more permutations and combinations and validations. But now, we're still finding ways of ⁓ energy because once you've done that sort of things, then you've got to worry about at some races, you've got to worry about temperatures in some areas. And so you have to optimize how much regeneration you put back into the battery. So An example of your mobile phone, you know, when you plug it in, gets hot because you're charging it quickly. as we put energy back into the battery, we do have to be careful of the amount you put in in some circumstances. ⁓ there's obviously ⁓ element of thermal management ⁓ the battery and not pushing it too hard. So back to your question about road cars, I think I actually had to do a trip ⁓ yesterday. did two runs to the airport. your mobile phone, when you plug it in, gets hot because you're charging it quickly. So as we put energy into the battery, we do have to be careful of the amount you put in in some circumstances. there's obviously ⁓ an element of management on the and not pushing it too and airports. ⁓ ⁓ was doing too many of the calculations in my head, looking at the screen and looking at my Google Maps and figuring out, when at the energy usage on the ⁓ dash. in my previous Tesla, that was all calculated for you. so there are elements where road cars are still quite different. And that's to your point of what's ⁓ the temperature the moment in the in the country and that information can come from the internet and what's your, know, putting together all these elements of things together. So ⁓ don't think everybody's cracked it because there's a lot of parameters still to go. And so part of it is also teaching our drivers when to use energy, how to use energy. This is what the system's trying to tell you, but if you need to overtake somebody, you know, these are the parameters around. how much energy you can use and then how much you're have to save if you overtake a driver. there's a huge amount of aspects that are associated with the management. Drea & Fred Warner: Yeah, really interesting. I'm really interested in both sides, energy management. I'm also interested as a motorsport fan on the driver's side to also think of what it must be like being a driver in Formula E when, know, it's not just a car that you get in and drive it as fast as you can because you may not reach the end of the race. ⁓ ⁓ must be so much conditioning and discipline required in them. Mark: Mm. Yeah. You can imagine that at the moment there's quite a lot of discussions around F1 and Formula E. As Max Verstappen's been making comments, as you know, and obviously I think it's public domain that a lot of Formula E drivers do a lot of sim work for the F1 teams. So there's a number of things that go backwards and forwards between the two elements. I was actually looking, I found an article from 2015 on the BBC website that said, It was about ⁓ management then. ⁓ think it was tires. And the question on ⁓ BBC was, has it always been about management of, and it's like, that's 10 years ago. So I think we've always been talking about management of, ⁓ and think some of the points were in the old days, know, Alan Prost was better at managing the mechanical reliability of his car ⁓ versus Nigel Mansell. When it was a tire war, had people who were better at managing tires versus their competitors. And so I think it's, it's not, it's hard to find a time when you weren't managing or the drivers weren't managing something, whether it's engine reliability, energy ⁓ flow, you're looking WEC at the moment. It's a, ⁓ got an energy element to it as well. which provides a lot of ⁓ interest the strategies, ⁓ over Lamont and things like that. So I do think, I suppose one of the differences perhaps at the moment is that at least in qualifying the driver is flat out. And then in the race, there's a lot of energy management, but in terms of if there's safety cars and full course yellows and other things that affect the race, there is also elements of races that are flat out as well, depending on the things that happen in a race. I think it does reward the drivers that are really good, a large... cognitive capability that can think around all the things that are going on in a race and understand the energy usage. Like I said earlier about Antonio and certainly with Lucas de Grassi, those guys have got a massive amount of capability to be racing, but then also asking us questions on the radio. What if this happens? What if that happens? What if I use energy now? I reckon I could get past these guys now. Can you quickly do a calculation and tell me if it's going to affect too much the end of the race? So a number of the drivers have the capacity to also be asking questions and giving us feedback to say the race is playing out like this. I think I should be going past people. You guys tell me if that makes sense. And then the strategy guys do a set of calculations and either say, yes, good idea. Let's go. Because the drivers are reading what's actually happening in the race as well. Perhaps it's not completely clear to us in the garage. Drea & Fred Warner: Hmm, fascinating, isn't it? So it's fascinating to think, and I like you say, there's the Max Verstappen's all over the news at the moment. And, but I think partly because there's not a lot of Formula One going on because of the brakes. So it's just been circulated around and around as the most popular topic that they can come up with. But when you look at it in terms of energy management and going into the electrified world, it's interesting you said even your older Tesla had features that your current car doesn't have. Mark: Yes. Yeah. Yes. Yes. Drea & Fred Warner: And that's from a UI point of view, from understanding it. But when you're looking at the OEMs and where they're pushing, presumably you in motorsport and obviously when you're in cars and looking at sustainable tech, where are the biggest pushes in terms of energy management in the future? it in the battery management in itself? would you say the biggest challenges are faced? Mark: Yeah. Yeah. I suppose my joining the comments about AI together with this thought about modeling, I've always found the more you understand something, the more you can make a model that perhaps is close to reality. So one of the aspects is, you know, you've seen some of the road cars, certainly the Tesla can preheat the battery if it knows you're leaving the house at a certain time. And so it just brings the batteries, you know, into a more efficient range. But that's done automatically on the Tesla, but other cars are not quite so looking. And I think when you think about the ⁓ to find vehicles, so I'll give you an example from F1. When first did active differentials long, long time ago, we were very ⁓ hesitant we were saying, okay, the active differentials are going to be more expensive and it's going to be ⁓ all extra software and complexity. But actually what happened was we reduced a whole lot of when we did active differentials because we didn't have to have 20 different types of mechanical diff available to be spares and sitting around at the race track, it meant that we could make changes last minute to the way the differential works so we could do effectively over the air updates of the car. And so all this flexibility was opened up by having an a software defined element to it. So I think what existing legacy OEMs are finding compared to say a Tesla who's been able to reinvent their entire system is that the Tesla has been designed with active control in mind, whereas a legacy OEM may be still sitting with a, I think Jim Farley made the example of an electric window winder, ⁓ an electric, sorry, a controller that's completely separate to the core ⁓ of the car, or computer of the car. and let's say a seat, to use some examples of things that don't need to be active, but could be active. And I think that's where the software defined element of it is really suits racing, because in motorsports, we want to be able to make changes to the absolute last minute. Maybe it's a bit risky to say 10 minutes before qualifying, but you know, on the day before first practice, an update comes from the driver in the loop simulator, tested. in the factory and decide is it worth the risk to put that on in free practice one on one car and maybe we do it on the out lap and the in lap to check that it works as per what's being defined and hopefully all of our processes and procedures are rigorous enough on the hardware in the loop system and the driver in the loop system back at the factory that we've minimized risks enough that we can do a effectively and over the air update. a few hours before free practice one. I see all of that ⁓ similar to road cars. And I'm to say almost finally road cars are becoming capable of accepting these updates. The last minute, let's call it. Drea & Fred Warner: It's a really fascinating area, the software updates, over the air updates. Assuming that companies were always putting the customer first, you could even imagine a world where you'd buy a car and the range ⁓ may get longer ⁓ over next six to 12 months as they release software updates. Now, you then take the customer first view away from it and say, well, no, they probably wouldn't do that because they'd want to put that in the next model and make you sell the car and buy the next model as the way it goes. Mark: Mm-hmm. Yep. Yep. Drea & Fred Warner: So with energy management then, presumably this then rolls into the hardware within the car and vehicle, because I know there's quite a difference sometimes between, let's say, a Tesla who have been very forward with their hardware and architecture in the car. So, and then maybe the more traditional OEMs that may be still using a lot of energy consuming hardware, maybe the way the communications are handled or the wiring is handled or the sensors. And ⁓ still an area that can potentially consume quite a bit of energy. Mark: Mm-hmm. Yep. Yeah. Drea & Fred Warner: Do the life sack of the car. Mark: Yeah, I probably haven't got a great, a good example of that. Although I do know our competitors, Jaguar, if you do have a look at, ⁓ think on their website, they say that something they've learned from E, they were able to update on the I-PACE, I believe, to a better range on the battery that was already in manufacture. I do think that there are, so let's say when you first develop a battery, and I'm not a battery expert, but when you first develop a battery, you've certainly done a certain amount of validation, durability testing ⁓ everything and you're happy that it meets the requirements, let's say the base requirements of OEM standard. But then let's say learn something in Formula E ⁓ and realize, maybe you could push that ⁓ cell harder you knew more accurately or could predict better the air temperature. And then you think, okay, can we take more of a risk on knowing the air temperature act? and air temperature over this drive that this person's going on, ⁓ perhaps could make a modification to one of the parameters associated with regen, let's say. Because as spoke earlier, maybe you could put more regen back in the battery than you were. And as long as you could predict a little bit further forward, and this is potentially AI and machine learning comes in, as you look at the time that calls out in ⁓ the ⁓ market, you can start to take a few more risks because you understand it better and you can change some of your parameters. And so in motor racing, you could see the art of the possible and say, wow, this is possible in Formula E. Let's see if we could find a way in a road car to mimic that learning. So I think there's still ways to optimize even when the hardware is fixed per se. Drea & Fred Warner: It's really interesting subject area, let's dive on into that because my brain starts to tickle with things like if you could work out the current and future forecast temperature for the duration of the race, both air and track presumably, and then humidity, and then the software is able to auto update, as in it can take the current temperature of the race car, it's telling me, we've got an ambient air sensor so we know what the ambient air is. my brain starts to tickle with things like if you could work out the current and future forecast temperature for the duration of the race, both air and track presumably, and then humidity, and then the software is able to auto update, Mark: You You Yes. Yes. Okay. Okay. Drea & Fred Warner: then the car can automatically be updating the driver And for that to be just live being fed through to the driver to say, whether that's a competitive advantage, the first person that gets to that fully automated module is the first team that can really exploit energy to the maximum, isn't it? then the car can automatically be updating the driver and saying, well, basically you're either going to be able to carry this race cycle to the end of the race and be okay, or maybe there's more energy because of the changing positions. And for that to be just live being fed through to the driver to say, actually, you know, whether that's a competitive advantage, the first person that gets to that fully automated module type that the driver can be kept up to date is the first team that can really exploit energy to the maximum, isn't it? Mark: Yeah, yeah, and I think all of these ideas can keep adding. Maybe we'll use that one. Let's see if we can find a way. But yeah, you can imagine over a, know, a WEC program like a, ⁓ that's got, that's running a hybrid system over 24 hours. That really does, the temperature really does change a lot of obviously in the middle of the night. So, ⁓ the, know, those, all those elements about predictions. Now, maybe you predict forward and it doesn't end up the way you thought, but then you just kind of have to make a different. yeah, we'll use that one. Let's see if we can find a ⁓ way. Drea & Fred Warner: You sure? Mark: to the system ⁓ if it doesn't turn out as you thought but if make the bet let's say and ⁓ on tools and then someone else doesn't that's obviously always the best way of doing it in motorsport. Drea & Fred Warner: Fantastic. Well, Mark, it's been wonderful to talk with you today and really enjoyed talking about motorsport, Formula E, electrification and the OEMs and the impacts. Tell us more about Lola car project with Formula E and tell us how people can find you ⁓ ⁓ to see you. Mark: Yeah, so if the the fans don't know, Lola's back after 10 years away. It wasn't racing for 10 years since 2012 to 2022. We've come back in the World Championship, obviously Formula E, which is at the highest level of motorsport in the world, but on the obviously the electrified side of things. We see the future being very much multi-energy world. Obviously, we hope to get back into Le Mans. That's something that Lola's got a deep history with, so we think that a lot of the technology that we're developing in Formula E is quite relevant to series like Mans, obviously relevant to F1, although we're not going back to F1, but you know, that's kind of area where we feel that there's a lot of crossover in technology. ⁓ And that it crosses over with lot of ⁓ road elements that ⁓ are out there in the world, ⁓ all learning that we're doing here is super important. We just released a T70S, which is a... based on the original T70 from the 60s, ⁓ is a very, it's a fully sustainable car. ⁓ all sorts of elements you can check out on the website. So, lola-cars.co.uk, you can see, and you can get links to all of the elements that we're doing. And obviously you can see us on ⁓ of ⁓ normal channels, Instagrams and Facebooks and ⁓ as well. So, yeah, reach out if you ⁓ have more interest in what we're doing at Lola Cars. Drea & Fred Warner: Thank you so much Mark and if you've enjoyed this episode make sure you share this with somebody you know, follow and subscribe and remember future engineering bets is all about looking at the future innovation in advanced engineering and looking at where people are going to be investing their capital, where they're going to be seeing a return. My name is Fred Warner and I'll see you again in the future.