Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [2017] Berkshire Hathaway Letter to Shareholders
Transcript
- 0:00Berkshire Hathaway, Inc to the shareholders of Berkshire
- 0:03Hathaway Incorporated. Berkshires gain in net worth
- 0:06during 2016 was $27.5 billion, which increased the per share
- 0:11book value of both our Class A and Class B stock by 10.7%.
- 0:17Over the last 52 years, that is since present management took
- 0:21over, per share book value has grown from $19.00 to
- 0:24$172,108.00, a rate of 19% compounded annually.
- 0:30During the first half of those years, Berkshire's net worth was
- 0:33roughly equal to the number that really counts the intrinsic
- 0:37value of the business. The similarity of the two
- 0:40figures existed then because most of our resources were
- 0:44deployed in marketable securities that were regularly
- 0:47revalued to their quoted prices list, the tax that would be
- 0:50incurred if they were to be sold.
- 0:52In Wall Street parlance, our balance sheet was then in very
- 0:55large part mark to market. By the early 1990, yes.
- 0:59However, our focus was changing to the outright ownership of
- 1:03businesses, a shift that materially diminished the
- 1:06relevance of balance sheet figures.
- 1:08That disconnect occurred because the accounting rules commonly
- 1:12referred to as J that apply to companies we control differ in
- 1:15important ways from those used to value marketable securities.
- 1:20Specifically, the accounting for businesses we own requires that
- 1:23the carrying value of losers be written down when their failures
- 1:27become apparent. Winners, conversely, are never
- 1:31revalued upwards. We've experienced both outcomes.
- 1:34As is the case in marriage business acquisitions often
- 1:38deliver surprises. After the Edos, I've made some
- 1:41dumb purchases, paying far too much for the economic goodwill
- 1:44off companies we acquired that later led to goodwill write offs
- 1:49and to consequent reductions in Berkshire's book value.
- 1:52We've also had some winners among the businesses.
- 1:55We've purchased a few of the winners very big, but have not
- 1:58written those up by a penny. We have no quarrel with the
- 2:01asymmetrical accounting that applies here, but over time it
- 2:04necessarily widens the gap between Berkshire's intrinsic
- 2:08value and its book value. Today, the large and growing
- 2:12unrecorded gains at our winners produce an intrinsic value for
- 2:15Berkshire's shares that far exceeds their book value.
- 2:19The overage is truly huge in our property casualty insurance
- 2:23business and significant also in many other operations.
- 2:27Over time, stock prices gravitate toward intrinsic
- 2:30value. That's what has happened at
- 2:32Berkshire, a fact explaining why the company's 52 year market
- 2:36price gain shown on the facing page materially exceeds its book
- 2:40value gain. All per share figures used in
- 2:43this report apply to Berkshire's A shares.
- 2:45Figures for the B shares are 11,500 THF those shown for A
- 2:51three. What we hope to accomplish
- 2:53Charlie and Munger, Berkshire's Vice Chairman and my partner and
- 2:57I expect Berkshire's normalized earning power per share to
- 3:00increase every year. Actual earnings, of course, will
- 3:04sometimes decline because of periodic weakness in the US
- 3:09economy. In addition, insurance mega
- 3:12catastrophes or other industry specific events may occasionally
- 3:16reduce earnings at Berkshire even when most American
- 3:19businesses are doing well. It's our job, though, to
- 3:22overtime deliver significant growth, bumpy or not.
- 3:26After all, as stewards of yore, capital Berkshire directors have
- 3:30opted to retain all earnings. Indeed, in both 2015 and 2016,
- 3:37Berkshire ranked first among American businesses in the
- 3:40dollar volume of earnings retained in each year,
- 3:43reinvesting many billions of dollars more than did the runner
- 3:46up. Those reinvested dollars must
- 3:49earn their keep. Some years, the gains in
- 3:51underlying earning power we achieve will be minor.
- 3:54Very occasionally, the cash register will ring loud.
- 3:58Charlie and I have no magic plan to add earnings except to dream
- 4:02big and to be prepared mentally and financially to act fast when
- 4:06opportunities present themselves.
- 4:08Every decade or so, dark clouds will fill the economic skies and
- 4:13they will briefly rain gold. When downpours of that sort
- 4:16occur, it's imperative that we rush outdoors carrying wash
- 4:20tubs, not teaspoons. And that we will do.
- 4:23I earlier described our gradual shift from a company obtaining
- 4:27most of its gains from investment activities to one
- 4:30that grows in value by owning businesses launching that
- 4:33transition. We took baby steps, making small
- 4:36acquisitions whose impact on Berkshire's profits was dwarfed
- 4:40by our gains from marketable securities.
- 4:43Despite that cautious approach, I made one particularly
- 4:46egregious error, acquiring Dexter Shoe for $434 million in
- 4:521993. Dexter's value promptly went to
- 4:55zero. The story gets worse.
- 4:57I used stock for the purchase, giving the sellers 25,203 shares
- 5:02of Berkshire that a year in 2016 were worth more than $6 billion.
- 5:08That wreck was followed by three key happenings, 2 positive, one
- 5:11negative that set us firmly on our present course.
- 5:15At the beginning of 1996, we acquired the half of GEICO we
- 5:19didn't already own, a cash transaction that changed our
- 5:22holding from a portfolio investment into a wholly owned
- 5:25operating business. GEICO, with its almost unlimited
- 5:29potential, quickly became the centerpiece around which we
- 5:32built what I believe is now the world's premier property
- 5:35casualty business. Unfortunately, I followed the
- 5:38GEICO purchase by foolishly using Berkshire stock, a
- 5:41boatload of stock, to buy General Reinsurance in late
- 5:451998. After some early problems,
- 5:48General Rhee has become a fine insurance operation that we
- 5:51prize. It was nevertheless a terrible
- 5:54mistake on my part to issue 272,200 shares of Berkshire and
- 6:00buying General Rhee, an act that increased our outstanding shares
- 6:04by a whopping 21.8%. My error caused Berkshire
- 6:08shareholders to give far more than they received, a practice
- 6:11that despite the biblical endorsement, is far from blessed
- 6:15when you are buying businesses. Early in 2000 I atoned for that
- 6:19folly by buying 76% since grown to 90% of Mid American Energy, a
- 6:25brilliantly managed utility business that has delivered us
- 6:28many large opportunities to make profitable and socially useful
- 6:32investments. The Mid American cash purchase I
- 6:35was learning firmly launched us on our present course of one,
- 6:39continuing to build our insurance operation, 2
- 6:42energetically acquiring large and diversified non insurance
- 6:46businesses and three, largely making our deals from internally
- 6:49generated cash. Today I would rather prep for a
- 6:53Colon OS copy than issue Berkshire shares.
- 6:56Our portfolio of bonds and stocks de emphasized though it
- 6:59is has continued in the post 1998 period too grow and to
- 7:04deliver us hefty capital gains, interest and dividends.
- 7:08Those portfolio earnings have provided us major help in
- 7:11financing the purchase of businesses.
- 7:14Though unconventional, Berkshire's two pronged approach
- 7:17to capital allocation gives USA real edge. 4 Hey Race.
- 7:22Our financial record since 1999 when the redirection of our
- 7:26business began in earnest during the 18 year period covered
- 7:30Berkshire's outstanding shares grew by only 8.3% with most of
- 7:35the increase occurring when we purchased BNSF.
- 7:39That I'm happy to say was 1 Issuance of stock that made good
- 7:42sense after tax earnings. One including interest and
- 7:46dividends from investments, but excluding capital gains or
- 7:50losses. 2IN very large part, this tabulation includes only
- 7:55realized capital gains or losses.
- 7:57Unrealized gains and losses are also included.
- 8:01However, when GAAP requires that treatment, our expectation is
- 8:05that investment gains will continue to be substantial
- 8:08though totally random as to timing and that these will
- 8:11supply significant funds for business purchases.
- 8:14Concurrently, Berkshire is superb core of operating.
- 8:17CEOs will focus on increasing earnings at the individual
- 8:21businesses they manage, sometimes helping them to grow
- 8:24by making bolt on acquisitions. By our avoiding the issuance of
- 8:28Berkshire stock, any improvement in earnings will translate into
- 8:32equivalent per share gains. Our efforts to materially
- 8:35increase the normalized earnings of Berkshire will be a dos they
- 8:39have been throughout our managerial tenure.
- 8:41By America's economic dynamism, one word sums up our countries
- 8:46achievements. Miraculous from a standing start
- 8:49240 years ago, a span of time less than triple my days on
- 8:53Earth. Americans have combined human
- 8:55ingenuity, a market system, a tide of talented and ambitious
- 9:00immigrants, and the rule of law to deliver abundance beyond any
- 9:04dreams of our forefathers. You need not be an economist to
- 9:08understand how well our system has worked.
- 9:10Just look around, you see the 75,000,000 owner occupied homes,
- 9:15the bountiful farmland, the 260 million vehicles, the hyper
- 9:19productive factories, the great medical centers, the talent
- 9:23filled universities, you name it.
- 9:25They all represent a net gain for Americans from the barren
- 9:29lands, primitive structures and meager output of 1776.
- 9:34Starting from scratch, America has amassed wealth totaling $90
- 9:38trillion. Five.
- 9:40It's true, of course, that American owners of homes, autos,
- 9:44and other assets have often borrowed heavily to finance
- 9:47their purchases. If an owner defaults, however,
- 9:51his or her asset does not disappear or lose its
- 9:54usefulness. Rather, ownership customarily
- 9:58passes to an American lending institution that then disposes
- 10:01of it to an American buyer. Our nation's wealth remains
- 10:05intact. As Gertrude Stein put it, money
- 10:08is always there, but the pockets change.
- 10:11Above all, it's our market system, an economic traffic cop
- 10:14ably directing capital, brains and labor that has created
- 10:18America's abundance. This system has also been the
- 10:21primary factor in allocating rewards.
- 10:24Governmental redirection through federal, state and local
- 10:27taxation has, in addition, determined the distribution of a
- 10:31significant portion of the bounty.
- 10:33America has, for example, decided that those citizens in
- 10:37their productive years should help both the old and the young.
- 10:41Such forms of aid sometimes enshrined as entitlements.
- 10:44They're generally thought of as applying to the aged.
- 10:47But don't forget that 4 million American babies are born each
- 10:51year with an entitlement to a public education.
- 10:54That societal commitment, largely financed at the local
- 10:57level, costs about $150,000 per baby.
- 11:01The annual cost totals more than $600 billion, which is about 31
- 11:06two percent of GDP. However our wealth may be
- 11:09divided, the mind boggling amounts you see around you
- 11:13belong almost exclusively to Americans.
- 11:16Foreigners, of course, own or have claims on a modest portion
- 11:20of our wealth. Those holdings, however, are of
- 11:24little importance to our national balance sheet.
- 11:27Our citizens own assets abroad that are roughly comparable in
- 11:30value. Early Americans, we should
- 11:33emphasize, we're neither smarter nor more hardworking than those
- 11:36people who toiled century after century before them.
- 11:40But those venturesome pioneers crafted a system that unleashed
- 11:44human potential and their successors built upon it.
- 11:47This economic creation will deliver increasing wealth to our
- 11:51progeny far into the future. Yes, the build up of wealth will
- 11:55be interrupted for short periods from time to time.
- 11:58It will not, however, be stopped.
- 12:01I'll repeat what I've both said in the past and expect to say in
- 12:04future years. Babies born in America today are
- 12:07the luckiest crop in history. America's economic achievements
- 12:12have led to staggering profits for stockholders.
- 12:15During the 20 TH century, the Dow Jones industrials advanced
- 12:19from 66 to 11497, a 17,320% capital gain that was materially
- 12:27boosted by steadily increasing dividends.
- 12:30The trend continues. By year end 2016, the index had
- 12:34advanced a further 72% to 19763. American business and
- 12:41consequently a basket of stocks is virtually certain to be worth
- 12:44far more in the years ahead. Innovation, productivity gains,
- 12:49entrepreneurial spirit and an abundance of capital will see to
- 12:53that. Ever present naysayers may
- 12:55prosper by marketing their gloomy forecasts, but heaven
- 12:58help them if they act in the nonsense they peddle.
- 13:01Many companies, of course, will fall behind, and some will fail.
- 13:05Winnowing of that sort is a product of market dynamism.
- 13:09Moreover, the years ahead will occasionally deliver major
- 13:12market declines, even panics that will affect virtually all
- 13:16stocks. Noon can tell you when these
- 13:19traumas will occur. Not me, not Charlie, not
- 13:22economists, not the media. Meg McConnell of the New York
- 13:25Fed aptly described the reality of panics.
- 13:28We spend a lot of time looking for systemic risk.
- 13:32In truth, however, it tend SD of Indus.
- 13:35During such scary periods, you should never forget two things.
- 13:40First, widespread fear is your friend as an investor because it
- 13:44serves up bargain purchases. Second, personal fear is your
- 13:48enemy. It will also be unwarranted.
- 13:51Investors who avoid high and unnecessary costs and simply
- 13:55asset for an extended period with a collection of large,
- 13:58conservatively financed American businesses will almost certainly
- 14:02dowel. As for Berkshire, our size
- 14:04precludes a brilliant result. Prospective returns fall as
- 14:08assets increase. Nonetheless, Berkshire's
- 14:11collection of good businesses, along with the company's
- 14:14impregnable financial strength and owner oriented culture
- 14:18should deliver decent results. We won't be satisfied with less
- 14:22Six Share repurchase S In the investment world, discussions
- 14:26about share repurchase S often become heated, but ID suggests
- 14:30that participants in this debate take a deep breath.
- 14:34Assessing the desirability of repurchase S isn't that
- 14:37complicated. From the standpoint of exiting
- 14:40shareholders, repurchase S are always A+.
- 14:43Though the day-to-day impact of these purchases is usually
- 14:47minuscule, it's always better for a seller to have an
- 14:50additional buyer in the market. For continuing shareholders,
- 14:53however, repurchase S only makes sense if the shares are bought
- 14:57at a price below intrinsic value.
- 15:00When that rule is followed, the remaining shares experience an
- 15:03immediate gain in intrinsic value.
- 15:06Consider a simple analogy. If there are three equal
- 15:09partners in a business worth $3000 and one is bought out by
- 15:14the partnership for $900, each of the remaining partners
- 15:17realizes an immediate gain of $50.
- 15:21If the exiting partner is paid $1100, however, the continuing
- 15:26partners each suffer a loss of $50.00 The same math applies
- 15:30with corporations and their shareholders.
- 15:33Ergo, the question of whether a repurchase action is value
- 15:37enhancing or value destroying for continuing shareholders is
- 15:41entirely purchase price dependent.
- 15:43It is puzzling, therefore, that corporate repurchase
- 15:46announcements almost never refer to a price above which
- 15:50repurchase S will be issued. That certainly wouldn't be the
- 15:53case if a management was buying an outside business.
- 15:57There, price would always factor into a buy or pass decision.
- 16:01When CEOs or boards are buying a small part of their own company,
- 16:04though, they all too often seem oblivious to price.
- 16:08Would they behave similarly if they were managing a private
- 16:11company with just a few owners and we're evaluating the wisdom
- 16:15of buying out one of them? Of course not.
- 16:17It is important to remember that there are two occasions in which
- 16:20repurchase S should not take place, even if the company's
- 16:23shares are underpriced. 1 is when a business both needs all
- 16:27its available money to protect or expand its own operations and
- 16:31is also uncomfortable adding further debt.
- 16:34Here, the internal need for funds should take priority.
- 16:38This exception assumes, of course, that the business has a
- 16:41decent future awaiting it after the needed expenditures are
- 16:45made. The second exception, less
- 16:47common, materializes when a business acquisition or some
- 16:50other investment opportunity offers far greater value than do
- 16:54the undervalued shares of the potential repurchaser.
- 16:57Long ago, Berkshire itself often had to choose between these
- 17:01alternatives. A tour present size, the issue
- 17:04is far less likely to arise. My suggestion before even
- 17:09discussing repurchase as ACEO and his or her board should
- 17:13stand join hands and in unison declare what is smart at 1 price
- 17:17is stupid at another. To recap Berkshire's own
- 17:20repurchase policy, I am authorized to buy large amounts
- 17:24of Berkshire shares at 120% or less of book value because our
- 17:29board has concluded that purchases at that level clearly
- 17:32bring an instant and material benefit to continuing
- 17:35shareholders. By our estimate, a 120% of book
- 17:39price is a significant discount too Berkshire's intrinsic value
- 17:44a spread that is appropriate because calculations of
- 17:46intrinsic value can't be precise.
- 17:49The authorization given me does not mean that we will prop our
- 17:53stocks price at the 120% ratio. If that level is reached.
- 17:58We will instead attempt to blend a desire to make meaningful
- 18:01purchases at a value creating price with a related goal of not
- 18:05over influencing the market. To date, repurchasing our shares
- 18:09has proved hard to do. That may well be because we have
- 18:12been clear in describing our repurchase policy and thereby
- 18:16have signaled our view that Berkshire's intrinsic value is
- 18:20significantly higher than 120% of book value.
- 18:24If so, that's fine. Charlie and I prefer to see
- 18:26Berkshire shares sell in a fairly narrow range around
- 18:30intrinsic value, neither wishing them to sell at an unwarranted
- 18:33high price. It's now fun having owners who
- 18:36are disappointed with their purchases, nor one too low.
- 18:39Furthermore, are buying out partners at a discount is not a
- 18:43particularly gratifying way of making money.
- 18:45Still, market circumstances could create a situation in
- 18:49which repurchase S would benefit both continuing and exiting
- 18:53shareholders. If so, we will be ready to Act
- 18:577. One final observation for this
- 18:59section. As the subject of repurchase S
- 19:02has come to a boil, some people have come close to calling them
- 19:06UN American, characterizing them as corporate misdeeds that
- 19:09divert funds needed for productive endeavors.
- 19:12That simply isn't the case. Both American corporations and
- 19:16private investors are today awash in funds looking to be
- 19:19sensibly deployed. Am not aware of any enticing
- 19:23project that in recent years has died for lack of capital.
- 19:26Callous if you have a candidate. Insurance.
- 19:29Let's now look at Berkshire's various businesses, starting
- 19:32with our most important sector, insurance.
- 19:35The Property casualty PC branch of that industry has been the
- 19:38engine that has propelled our growth since 1967, the year we
- 19:43acquired National Indemnity and its sister company, National
- 19:47Fire and Marine, for $8.6 million.
- 19:50Today, National Indemnity is the largest property casualty
- 19:54company in the world as measured by net worth.
- 19:57One reason we were attracted to the PC business was its
- 20:00financial characteristics. PC insurers receive premiums
- 20:04upfront and pay claims later. In extreme cases, such as claims
- 20:08arising from exposure to asbestos, payments can stretch
- 20:12over many decades. This collect now, pay later
- 20:15model leaves PC companies holding large sums, money we
- 20:19call float that will eventually go to others.
- 20:21Meanwhile, insurers get to invest this float for their own
- 20:25benefit. Though individual policies and
- 20:27claims come and go, the amount of float an insurer holds
- 20:31usually remains fairly stable in relation to premium volume.
- 20:35Consequently, as our business grows so does our float and how
- 20:39it has grown as the following table shows.
- 20:42Year flaught in millions 1970 dollars Thirty Nine 1980230719
- 20:5191,632 Two Thousand 27,871 2010 65,832 2016 91,577 We recently
- 21:06wrote a huge policy that increased float to more than
- 21:09$100 billion beyond that one time boost float at GEICO and
- 21:14several of our specialized operations is almost certain to
- 21:17grow at a good clip. National Indemnity's reinsurance
- 21:21division however is party to a number of large runoff contracts
- 21:25whose float is certain to drift downward.
- 21:28We may in time experience a decline in float.
- 21:31If so, the decline will be very gradual.
- 21:34At the outside no more than 3% in any year.
- 21:37The nature of our insurance contracts is such that we can
- 21:40never be subject to immediate or near term demands for sums that
- 21:44are of significance to our cash resources.
- 21:47This structure is by design and is a key component in the
- 21:51unequalled financial strength of our insurance companies.
- 21:54It will never be compromised if our premiums exceed the total of
- 21:58our expenses and eventual losses.
- 22:01Our insurance operation registers an underwriting profit
- 22:04that adds to the investment income the flow produces.
- 22:08When such a profit is earned, we enjoy the use of free money and
- 22:12better yet, get paid for holding it.
- 22:14Unfortunately, the wish of all insurers to achieve this happy
- 22:18result creates intense competition, so vigorous indeed
- 22:22that it sometimes causes the PC industry as a whole to operate
- 22:26at a significant underwriting loss.
- 22:28This loss, in effect, is what the industry pays to hold its
- 22:32float. Competitive dynamics almost
- 22:34guarantee that the insurance industry, despite the float
- 22:38income all its companies enjoy, will continue its dismal record
- 22:42of earning subnormal returns on tangible net worth as compared
- 22:46to other American businesses. 8 This outcome is made more
- 22:50certain by the dramatically lower interest rates that now
- 22:53exist throughout the world. The investment portfolios of
- 22:57almost all PC companies, though not those of Berkshire, are
- 23:00heavily concentrated in bonds. As these high yielding legacy
- 23:04investments mature and are replaced by bonds yielding a
- 23:08pittance, earnings from float will steadily fall.
- 23:11For that reason, and others as well, it's a good bet that
- 23:14industry results over the next 10 years will fall short of
- 23:18those recorded in the past decade, particularly in the case
- 23:21of companies that specialize in reinsurance.
- 23:24Nevertheless, I very much like our own prospects.
- 23:28Berkshire's unrivaled financial strength allows us far more
- 23:32flexibility in investing than that generally available to PC
- 23:35companies. The many alternatives available
- 23:38to us are always an advantage. Occasionally they offer us major
- 23:42opportunities. When others are constrained, our
- 23:46choices expand. Moreover, our PC companies have
- 23:49an excellent underwriting record.
- 23:51Berkshire has now operated at an underwriting profit for 14
- 23:55consecutive years, our pre tax gain for the period having
- 23:58totaled $28 billion. That record is no accident.
- 24:03Disciplined risk evaluation is the daily focus of all of our
- 24:07insurance managers, who know that while float is valuable,
- 24:11its benefits can be drowned by poor underwriting results.
- 24:14All insurers give that message lip service.
- 24:17At Berkshire, it is a religion, Old Testament style.
- 24:21So how does our float affect intrinsic value?
- 24:23When Berkshire's book value is calculated, the full amount of
- 24:27our float is deducted as a liability, just as if we had to
- 24:30pay it out tomorrow and could not replenish it.
- 24:33But two think of float as a typical liability is a major
- 24:37mistake. It should instead be viewed as a
- 24:40revolving fund. Daily we pay old claims and
- 24:43related expenses a huge $27 billion to more than 6,000,000
- 24:48claimants in 2016. And that reduces float.
- 24:52Just as surely, we each day write new business that will
- 24:55soon generate its own claims Adding to float I4 revolving
- 25:00float is both cost less and long enduring, which I believe it
- 25:04will be. The true value of this liability
- 25:07is dramatically less than the accounting liability owing
- 25:10$1.00. That in effect will never leave
- 25:13the premises because new business is almost certain to
- 25:16deliver a substitutious worlds different from owing $1.00 that
- 25:20will go out the door tomorrow and not be replaced.
- 25:23The two types of liabilities however are treated as equals
- 25:27under GAAP. A partial offset to this
- 25:30overstated liability is a $15.5 billion goodwill asset that we
- 25:35incurred in buying our insurance companies and that is included
- 25:38in our book value figure. In very large part, this
- 25:42goodwill represents the price we pay for the float generating
- 25:45capabilities of our insurance operations.
- 25:48The cost of the goodwill, however, has no bearing on its
- 25:51true value. For example, if an insurance
- 25:54company sustains large and prolonged underwriting losses,
- 25:58any goodwill asset carried on the books should be deemed
- 26:01valueless, whatever its original cost.
- 26:04Fortunately, that does not describe Berkshire.
- 26:06Charlie and I believe the true economic value of our insurance
- 26:11goodwill, What we would happily pay for float of similar quality
- 26:14were we to purchase an insurance operation possessing it'll be
- 26:18far in excess of its historic carrying value.
- 26:21Indeed, almost the entire $15.5 billion we carry for goodwill in
- 26:27our insurance business was already on our books in 2000
- 26:31when float was $28 billion. Yet we have subsequently
- 26:34increased our float by $64 billion.
- 26:38Again, that in no way is reflected in our book value.
- 26:41This unrecorded asset is one reason, a huge reason, why we
- 26:45believe Berkshire's intrinsic business value far exceeds its
- 26:49book value. Berkshire's attractive insurance
- 26:52economics exist only because we have some terrific managers
- 26:55running disciplined operations that in most cases possess hard
- 26:59to replicate business models. Let me tell you about the major
- 27:03units. First by float size is the
- 27:05Berkshire Hathaway Reinsurance Group, managed by AJ at Jane AJ.
- 27:10It insures risks that no one else has the desire or the
- 27:13capital to take on. His operation combines capacity,
- 27:17speed, decisiveness and, most important, brains in a manner
- 27:21unique in the insurance business.
- 27:24Yet he never exposes Berkshire to risks that are inappropriate
- 27:27in relation to our resources. 9 Indeed, Berkshire is far more
- 27:32conservative in avoiding risk than most large insurers.
- 27:36For example, if the insurance industry should experience a
- 27:39$250 billion loss from some mega catastrophe, a loss about triple
- 27:44anything it has ever experienced, Berkshire as a
- 27:47whole would likely record a large profit for the year are
- 27:51many streams of non insurance earnings would see to that.
- 27:54Additionally, we would remain awash in cash and be eager to
- 27:58write business in an insurance market that might well be in
- 28:01disarray. Meanwhile, other major insurers
- 28:04and reinsurers would be swimming in red ink if not facing
- 28:08insolvency. When AJ entered Berkshire's
- 28:11office on a Saturday in 1986, he did not have a day's experience
- 28:15in the insurance business. Nevertheless, Mike Goldberg,
- 28:19then our Manager of Insurance, handed him the keys to our small
- 28:23and struggling reinsurance business.
- 28:25With that move, Mike achieved sainthood.
- 28:28Since then AJ IT has created 10s of billions of value for
- 28:32Berkshire shareholders. If there were ever to be another
- 28:35AJ it and you could swap me for him.
- 28:37Don't hesitate, make the trade. We have another reinsurance
- 28:41powerhouse in General Ree, managed until recently by T
- 28:45Admat Ross. After 39 years at General Rhee,
- 28:49Tad retired in 2016. Tad was a class act in every way
- 28:53and we owe him a ton of thanks. Kara Ryguewell, who has worked
- 28:57with AJ for 16 years, is now CEO of General Rhee.
- 29:01At bottom, a sound insurance operation needs to adhere to 4
- 29:05disciplines. It must, one, understand all
- 29:08exposures that might cause a policy to incur losses, Two,
- 29:12conservatively assess the likelihood of any exposure
- 29:15actually causing a loss and the probable cost if it does. 3 set
- 29:19a premium that on average will deliver a profit after both
- 29:23prospective loss costs and operating expenses are covered,
- 29:27and four, be willing to walk away if the appropriate premium
- 29:30can't be obtained. Many insurers pass the first
- 29:33three tests and flunk the 4th. They simply can't turn their
- 29:37back on business that is being eagerly written by their
- 29:40competitors. That old line, the other guy is
- 29:43doing it, so we must as well. Spells trouble in any business,
- 29:47but in none more so than insurance.
- 29:50Tad never listened to that nonsensical excuse for sloppy
- 29:53underwriting, and neither will Cara.
- 29:55Finally, there is GEICO, the company that set my heart of
- 29:59fire 66 years ago and for which the flame still burns.
- 30:03GEICO is managed by Tony Nicely, who joined the company at 18 and
- 30:07completed 55 years of service in 2016.
- 30:11Tony became CEO of GEICO in 1993 and since then the company has
- 30:16been flying. There is no better manager than
- 30:19Tony, who brings his combination of brilliance, dedication and
- 30:23soundness to the job. The latter quality is essential
- 30:27to sustain success. As Charlie says, it's great to
- 30:30have a manager with a 160 icon less he thinks it's 180 dot like
- 30:35AJ it Tony has created 10s of billions of value for Berkshire.
- 30:39On my initial visit to GEICO in 1951, I was blown away by the
- 30:44huge cost advantage the company enjoyed over the giants of the
- 30:47industry. It was clear to me that GEICO
- 30:50would succeed because it deserved to succeed.
- 30:53The company's annual sales were then $8 million in 2016.
- 30:58GEICO did that much business every three hours of the year.
- 31:02Auto insurance is a major expenditure for most families.
- 31:06Savings matter to them and only a low cost operation can deliver
- 31:10those. In fact, at least 40% of the
- 31:13people reading this letter can save money by insuring with
- 31:16GEICO. So stop reading right now and go
- 31:19to geico.com or call 800-847-7536.
- 31:24Gicos. Low costs create a Moat and
- 31:27enduring one that competitors are unable to cross.
- 31:30As a result, the company gobbles up market share year after year,
- 31:34ending 2016 with about 12% of industry volume.
- 31:39That's up from 2.5% in 1995, the year Berkshire acquired control
- 31:44of GEICO. Employment, meanwhile, grew from
- 31:478575 to 36,000 and 8510. Geico's growth accelerated
- 31:54dramatically during the second-half of 2016.
- 31:58Lost costs throughout the auto insurance industry had been
- 32:01increasing at an unexpected pace, and some competitors lost
- 32:05their enthusiasm for taking on new customers.
- 32:08Geico's reaction to the profit squeeze, however, was to
- 32:11accelerate its new business efforts.
- 32:14We like to make hay while the sunsets, knowing that it will
- 32:17surely rise again. GEICO continues on a roll as is
- 32:21end you this letter. When insurance prices increase,
- 32:24people shop more and when they shop, GEICO wins.
- 32:27Have you called yet? 800-847-7536 or go to geico.com.
- 32:34In addition to our three major insurance operations, we own a
- 32:38collection of smaller companies that primarily write commercial
- 32:41coverage S In aggregate, these companies area large, growing
- 32:46and valuable operation that consistently delivers an
- 32:49underwriting profit, usually one much superior to that reported
- 32:53by their competitors. Over the past 14 years, this
- 32:56group has earned $4.7 billion from underwriting about 13% of
- 33:01its premium volume, while increasing its float from
- 33:04$943,000,000 to $11.6 billion. Less than three years ago, we
- 33:11formed Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance B HSI, which
- 33:15is included in this grouping. Our first decision was to put
- 33:18Peter Eastwood in charge, a move that proved to be a home run.
- 33:23We expected significant losses in the early years while Peter
- 33:26built the personnel and infrastructure needed for a
- 33:29worldwide operation. Instead, he and his crew
- 33:33delivered significant underwriting profits throughout
- 33:36the startup period. BHS ICE volume increased 40% in
- 33:402016, reaching $1.3 billion. It's clear to me that the
- 33:46company is destined to become one of the world's leading PC
- 33:49insurers. Payrace our cap of pre tax
- 33:52underwriting earnings and float by division underwriting profit
- 33:55year and float in millions. Insurance Operations 2016 2015
- 34:022016 2015 BH Reinsurance 822 Dollars 421 Dollars Forty 5081
- 34:12Dollars $44,108.00 General Rhee 191 Hundred 321769918560 GEICO
- 34:25462 Four 601714815148 Other Primary 650 Seven 800-2411
- 34:35649-9906 2001 131 Dollars 1837 Dollars 91,577 Dollars $87,722
- 34:51Berkshire's great managers premier financial strength and a
- 34:54range of business models protected by wide moats amount
- 34:58to something unique in the insurance world.
- 35:00This assemblage of strengths is a huge asset for Berkshire
- 35:04shareholders. That time will only make more
- 35:06valuable regulated capital intensive businesses.
- 35:10Our BNSF Railroad and Berkshire Hathaway Energy B he are 90%
- 35:16owned utility business share important characteristics that
- 35:19distinguish them from Berkshire's other activities.
- 35:22Consequently, we assign them their own section in this letter
- 35:26and split out their combined financial statistics in our GAAP
- 35:29balance sheet and income statement.
- 35:32These two very major companies accounted for 33% of Berkshire's
- 35:36after tax operating earnings last year. 11 A key
- 35:40characteristic of both companies is their huge investment in very
- 35:44long lived regulated assets with these partially funded by large
- 35:48amounts of long term debt that is not guaranteed by Berkshire.
- 35:52Our credit is in fact not needed because each company has earning
- 35:56power that even under terrible economic conditions would far
- 36:00exceed its interest requirements.
- 36:02Last year, for example, in a disappointing year for railroads
- 36:06be NSF's interest coverage was more than 6 colon one.
- 36:10Our definition of coverage is the ratio of earnings before
- 36:13interest and taxes too interest note bit dangerous, a commonly
- 36:18used measure we view as seriously flawed.
- 36:21At Behe, meanwhile, two factors ensure the company's ability to
- 36:25service its debt under all circumstances.
- 36:28The first is common to all utilities, recession resistant
- 36:32earnings, which result from these companies offering an
- 36:35essential service for which demand is remarkably steady.
- 36:38The second is enjoyed by few other utilities, a never
- 36:42widening diversity of earnings streams, which shield be he from
- 36:46being seriously harmed by any single regulatory body.
- 36:49These many sources of profit, supplemented by the inherent
- 36:53advantage of the company being owned by a strong parent, have
- 36:57allowed be HE and its utility subsidiaries to significantly
- 37:00lower their cost of debt. That economic fact benefits both
- 37:04us and our customers. All told, be He and BNSF
- 37:08invested $8.9 billion in plant and equipment last year, a
- 37:13massive commitment to their segments of America's
- 37:16infrastructure. We relish making such
- 37:18investments as long as they promise reasonable returns, and
- 37:22on that front, we put a large amount of trust in future
- 37:25regulation. Our confidence is justified both
- 37:29by our past experience and by the knowledge that society will
- 37:32forever need huge investments in both transportation and energy.
- 37:37It is in the self-interest of governments to treat capital
- 37:40providers in a manner that will ensure the continued flow of
- 37:43funds to essential projects. It is concomitantly in our
- 37:47self-interest to conduct our operations in a way that earns
- 37:51the approval of our regulators and the people they represent.
- 37:55Low prices area powerful way to keep these constituencies happy.
- 37:59In Iowa, BH ES average retail rate is 7.1 per kWh.
- 38:04All I and the other major electric utility in the state
- 38:08averages 9.9. Here are the comparable industry
- 38:12figures for adjacent states, Nebraska 9.0, Missouri 9.5,
- 38:17Illinois 9.2, Minnesota 10.0. The national average is 10.3.
- 38:24We have promised Iowa, NS that our base rates will not increase
- 38:27until 2029 at the earliest. Our rock bottom prices add up to
- 38:32real money for paycheck strapped customers at BNSF.
- 38:36Price comparisons between major railroads are far more difficult
- 38:39to make because of significant differences in both their mix of
- 38:43cargo and the average distance the load is carried to supply a
- 38:47very crude measure. However, our revenue per ton
- 38:50mile was three last year while shipping costs for customers of
- 38:54the other four major US based railroads range from 4:00 to
- 38:595:00. Both B he and BNSF have been
- 39:02leaders in pursuing planet friendly technology.
- 39:05In wind generation, no state comes close to rivaling Iowa,
- 39:09where last year the MW hours we generated from wind equaled 55%
- 39:14of all MW hours sold to our Iowa retail customers.
- 39:18New wind projects that are underway will take that figure
- 39:21to 89% by 2020. Bargain basement electric rates
- 39:25carry 2nd order benefits with them.
- 39:27Iowa has attracted large, high tech installations both because
- 39:32of its low prices for electricity, which data centers
- 39:35use in huge quantities, and because most tech CE OS are
- 39:38enthusiastic about using renewable energy.
- 39:41When it comes to wind energy, Iowa is the Saudi Arabia of
- 39:45America. BNSF, like other Class 1
- 39:48railroads, uses only a single gallon of diesel fuel to move a
- 39:52ton of freight almost 500 miles. Those economics make railroads 4
- 39:57times as fuel efficient as trucks.
- 40:00Furthermore, railroads alleviate Hwy. congestion and the taxpayer
- 40:04funded maintenance expenditures that come with heavier Travis in
- 40:08a major way. 12 all told. Be he and BNSF own assets that
- 40:13are of major importance to our country as well as to
- 40:16shareholders of Berkshire. Here are the key financial
- 40:19figures for both. BNSF earnings in millions.
- 40:23Included in this financial summary are 44 businesses that
- 40:26report directly to headquarters. But some of these companies, in
- 40:30turn, have many individual operations under their umbrella.
- 40:34For example, Marmont has 175 separate business units serving
- 40:40widely disparate markets, and Berkshire Hathaway Automotive
- 40:43owns 83 dealerships operating in nine states.
- 40:47This collection of businesses is truly a motley crew.
- 40:51Some operations, measured by earnings on unleveraged net
- 40:55tangible assets, enjoy terrific returns that in a couple of
- 40:59instances exceed 100%. Most are solid businesses
- 41:03generating good returns in the area of 12% to 20% fourteen a
- 41:09few. However, these are serious
- 41:11blunders I made in my job of capital allocation produced very
- 41:14poor returns in most cases. I was wrong when I originally
- 41:19sized up the economic characteristics of these
- 41:21companies or the industries in which they operate, and we are
- 41:25now paying the price for my misjudgments.
- 41:27In a couple of instances is tumbled in assessing either the
- 41:31fidelity or ability of incumbent managers or ones I later put in
- 41:35place. I will commit more errors.
- 41:37You can count on that. Fortunately, Charlie never
- 41:40bashfuless around to say no to my worst ideas.
- 41:44Viewed as a single entity, the companies in the manufacturing
- 41:48service and retailing group are an excellent business.
- 41:51They employed an average of $24 billion of net tangible assets
- 41:55during 2016 and despite their holding large quantities of
- 42:00excess cash and carrying very little debt, earned 24% after
- 42:05tax on that capital. Of course, a business with
- 42:08terrific economics can be a bad investment if it is bought at
- 42:11too high a price. We have paid substantial
- 42:14premiums to net tangible assets for most of our businesses, a
- 42:18cost that is reflected in that large figure we show on our
- 42:21balance sheet for goodwill and other intangibles.
- 42:24Overall, however, we are getting a decent return on the capital
- 42:28we have deployed in this sector. Absent a recession, earnings
- 42:32from the group will likely grow in 2017, in part because
- 42:36Duracell and Precision Cast Parts, both bought in 2016, will
- 42:40for the first time contribute a full year's earnings to this
- 42:44group. Additionally, Duracell incurred
- 42:46significant transitional costs in 2016 that will not recur.
- 42:52We have far too many companies in this group to comment on them
- 42:54individually. Moreover, there competitors both
- 42:57current and potential, read this report.
- 43:00In a few of our businesses, we might be disadvantaged if
- 43:04outsiders knew our numbers. Therefore, in certain of our
- 43:07operations that are not of a size material to 1 evaluation of
- 43:11Berkshire, we only disclose what is required.
- 43:14You can nevertheless find a good bit of detail about many of our
- 43:17operations on pages 90 to 94. Be aware though that it's the
- 43:22growth of the Berkshire Forest that counts.
- 43:26It would be foolish to focus over intently on any single tree
- 43:30for several years. I have told you that the income
- 43:32and expense data shown in this section does not conform to
- 43:36GAAP. I have explained that this
- 43:37divergent occurs primarily because of gap ordered rules
- 43:41regarding purchase accounting adjustments that require the
- 43:44full amortization of certain intangibles over periods
- 43:47averaging about 19 years. In our opinion, most of those
- 43:51amortization expenses are not truly an economic cost.
- 43:55Our goal in diverging from gap in this section is to present
- 43:58the figures to you in a manner reflecting the way in which
- 44:02Charlie and I view and analyze them.
- 44:04On page 54, we itemize $15.4 billion of intangibles that are
- 44:09yet to be amortized by annual charges to earnings.
- 44:13More intangibles to be amortized will be created as we make new
- 44:17acquisitions done on that page, we show that the 2016
- 44:21amortization charge to gap earnings was $1.5 billion, up
- 44:25$384 million from 2015. My judgement is that about 20%
- 44:31of the 2016 charge is aerial cost.
- 44:35Eventually amortization charges fully right off the related
- 44:38asset. When that happens most often at
- 44:40the 15 year mark, the gap earnings we report will increase
- 44:44without any true improvement in the underlying economics of
- 44:48Berkshire's business that MY gift to my successor.
- 44:51Now that I've described a gap expense that I believe to be
- 44:54overstated, let me move on to a less pleasant distortion
- 44:58produced by accounting rules. The subject this time is GAAP
- 45:02prescribed depreciation charges, which are necessarily based on
- 45:05historical cost. Yet in certain cases, those
- 45:09charges materially understate true economic costs.
- 45:12Countless words were written about this phenomenon in the
- 45:151970s and early 1980s when inflation was rampant.
- 45:21As inflation subsided thanks to heroic actions by Paul Volcker,
- 45:25the inadequacy of depreciation charges became less of an issue.
- 45:29But the problem still prevails big time in the railroad
- 45:33industry, where current costs for many depreciable items far
- 45:37outstrip historical costs. The inevitable result is that
- 45:41reported earnings throughout the railroad industry are
- 45:44considerably higher than true economic earnings. 15-ATB NSF.
- 45:49To get down to particulars, our gap depreciation charge last
- 45:53year was $2.1 billion. But were we to spend that sum
- 45:57and no more annually, our railroad would soon deteriorate
- 46:01and become less competitive. The reality is that simply to
- 46:04hold our own, we need to spend far more than the cost we show
- 46:08for depreciation. Moreover, a wide disparity will
- 46:11prevail for decades. All that said, Charlie and I
- 46:14love our railroad, which was one of our better purchases.
- 46:18Too many management asks and the number seems to grow every year,
- 46:21are looking for any means to report and indeed feature
- 46:25adjusted earnings that are higher than their company's gap
- 46:28earnings. There are many ways for
- 46:30practitioners to perform this Ledger domain.
- 46:33Two of their favorites are the omission of restructuring costs
- 46:37and stock based compensation as expenses.
- 46:40Charlie and I want management S in their commentary to describe
- 46:44unusual items, good or bad, that affect the gap numbers.
- 46:48After all, the reason we look at these numbers of the past is to
- 46:52make estimates of the future. But a management that regularly
- 46:55attempts to wave away very real costs by highlighting adjusted
- 46:59per share earnings makes us nervous.
- 47:01That's because bad behavior is contagious.
- 47:04CE OS who overtly look for ways to report high numbers, tend to
- 47:08foster a culture in which subordinates strive to be
- 47:11helpful as well. Goals like that can lead, for
- 47:15example, to insurers underestimating their loss
- 47:18reserves, a practice that has destroyed many industry
- 47:21participants. Charlie and I cringe when we
- 47:24hear analysts talk admiringly about management S who always
- 47:28make the numbers. In truth, business is too
- 47:31unpredictable for the numbers always to be met.
- 47:34Inevitably, surprises occur. When they do, ACEO, whose focus
- 47:39is centered on Wall Street, will be tempted to make up the
- 47:41numbers. Let's get back to the two
- 47:43favorites of Don't Count This managers, starting with
- 47:46restructuring. Berkshire, I would say, has been
- 47:49restructuring from the first day we took over in 1965.
- 47:53Owning only a northern textile business then gave us no other
- 47:57choice and today a fair amount of restructuring occurs every
- 48:00year at Berkshire. That's because there are always
- 48:03things that need to change in our hundreds of businesses Last
- 48:07year asked I mentioned earlier we spent significant sums
- 48:10getting Duracell in shape for the decades ahead.
- 48:13We have never however singled out restructuring charges and
- 48:17told you to ignore them. An estimating hour normal
- 48:20earning power. If there were to be some truly
- 48:22major expenses in a single year, I would of course mention it in
- 48:27my commentary. Indeed, when there is a total
- 48:30rebasing of a business, such as occurred when Kraft and Heinz
- 48:34merged, it is imperative that for several years the huge one
- 48:37time costs of rationalizing the combined operations be explained
- 48:42clearly to owners. That's precisely what the CEO of
- 48:45Kraft Heinz has done in a manner approved by the company's
- 48:49directors, who include me. But to tell owners year after
- 48:52year don't count this when management is simply making
- 48:56business adjustments that are necessary is misleading and too
- 48:59many analysts and journalists fall for this baloney.
- 49:03To say stock based compensation is not an expense is even more
- 49:07cavalier. CE OS who go down that road R in
- 49:10effect saying to shareholders, if you pay me a bundle in
- 49:14options or restricted stock, don't worry about its effect on
- 49:18earnings. I'll adjusted a way to explore
- 49:21this maneuver further. Join me for a moment in a visit
- 49:24to a make believe accounting laboratory whose sole mission is
- 49:27to juice Berkshires reported earnings.
- 49:30Imaginative technicians await us eager to show their stuff. 16
- 49:35Listen carefully while I tell. These enable Rs that stock based
- 49:38compensation usually comprises at least 20% of total
- 49:43compensation for the top 3 or 4 executives at most large
- 49:46companies. Pay attention to.
- 49:49As I explained that Berkshire has several hundred such
- 49:52executives at its subsidiaries and pays them similar amounts
- 49:56but uses only cash to do so. I further confess that lacking
- 50:01imagination, I have counted all of these payments to Berkshire's
- 50:05executives as an expense. My accounting minions suppress A
- 50:08giggle and immediately point out that 20% of what is paid these
- 50:13Berkshire managers is tantamount to cash paid in lieu of stock
- 50:16based compensation and is therefore not a true expense
- 50:20suppressedo Berkshire too can have adjusted earnings back to
- 50:25reality. If CEOs want to leave out stock
- 50:28based compensation in reporting earnings, they should be
- 50:31required to affirm to their owners one of two propositions
- 50:35why items of value used to pay employees are not a cost or why
- 50:39a payroll cost should be excluded when calculating
- 50:42earnings. During the accounting nonsense
- 50:45that flourished during the 1960's, the story was told of
- 50:48ACEO, who, as his company revved up to go public, asked
- 50:53prospective auditors, what is 2 + 2?
- 50:55The answer That one. The assignment, of course, was
- 50:59what number do you have in mind? Finance and financial products.
- 51:03Our three leasing and rental operations are conducted by
- 51:06Court Furniture, XDRA, Semi Trailers and MARM on primarily
- 51:11tank cars, but also freight cars, intermodal tank containers
- 51:15and cranes. Each is the leader in it's
- 51:17field. We also include Clayton Homes in
- 51:20this section. This company receives most of
- 51:22its revenue from the sale of manufactured homes, but derives
- 51:26the bulk of its earnings from its large mortgage portfolio.
- 51:30Last year, Clayton became America's largest home builder,
- 51:33delivering 42,000 and 75 units. That accounted for 5% of all new
- 51:39American homes. In fairness, other large
- 51:42builders do far more dollar volume than Clayton because they
- 51:45sell site built homes that command much higher prices.
- 51:49In 2015, Clayton branched out, purchasing its first site
- 51:53builder. 2 Similar acquisitions followed in 2016 and more will
- 51:58come. Site built houses are expected
- 52:01to amount to 3% or so of Clayton's unit sales in 2017 and
- 52:06will likely deliver about 14% of its dollar volume.
- 52:10Even so, Clayton's focus will always be manufactured homes,
- 52:14which account for about 70% of new American homes costing less
- 52:18than $150,000 Clayton manufacturers, close to 1/2 of
- 52:23the total. That is a far cry from Clayton's
- 52:26position. In 2003, when Berkshire
- 52:28purchased the company, it then ranked third in the industry in
- 52:32units sold and employed 6731 people.
- 52:37Now, when its new acquisitions are included, the employee count
- 52:40is 14677 and that number will increase in the future.
- 52:45Clayton's earnings in recent years have materially benefited
- 52:49from extraordinarily low interest rates.
- 52:51The company's mortgage loans to home buyers are at fixed rates
- 52:55and for long terms, averaging 25 years at inception.
- 52:59But Clayton's own borrowing, as are short term credits that
- 53:02reprice frequently. When rates plunge, Clayton's
- 53:05earnings from its portfolio greatly increase.
- 53:08We normally would shun that kind of lend long borrow short
- 53:11approach, which can cause major problems for financial
- 53:14institutions as a whole. However, Berkshire is always
- 53:19asset sensitive, meaning that higher short term rates will
- 53:21benefit our consolidated earnings, even as they heard at
- 53:25Clayton 17. Last year, Clayton had to
- 53:28foreclose on 8304 manufactured housing mortgages, about 2.5% of
- 53:34its total portfolio. Customer demographics help
- 53:38explain that percentage. Clayton's customers are usually
- 53:41lower income families with mediocre credit scores.
- 53:45Many are supported by jobs that will be at risk in any
- 53:48recession. Many similarly have financial
- 53:51profiles that will be damaged by divorce or death to an extent
- 53:55that would not be typical for a high income family.
- 53:58Those risks that our customers face are partly mitigated
- 54:01because almost all have a strong desire to own a home and because
- 54:05they enjoy reasonable monthly payments that average only
- 54:09$587.00, including the cost of insurance and property taxes.
- 54:14Clayton also has long had programs that help borrowers
- 54:17through difficulties. The two most popular are loan
- 54:20extensions and payment forgiveness.
- 54:22Last year, about 11,000 borrowers received extensions
- 54:26and 3800 had $3.4 million of scheduled payments permanently
- 54:32cancelled by Clayton. The company does not earn
- 54:34interest or fees when these loss mitigation moves are made.
- 54:38Our experience is that 93% of borrowers help through these
- 54:42programs in the last two years now remain in their homes since
- 54:46we lose significant sums on foreclosures.
- 54:49Losses last year totaled $150 million.
- 54:52Our assistance programs end up helping Clayton as well as its
- 54:56borrowers. Clayton and Berkshire have been
- 54:58a wonderful partnership. Kevin Clayton came to us with a
- 55:01best in class management group and culture.
- 55:05Berkshire in turn provided unmatched staying power when the
- 55:08manufactured home industry fell apart during the Great
- 55:12Recession. AS other lenders to the industry
- 55:14vanished, Clayton supplied credit not only to its own
- 55:18dealers but also to dealers who sold the products of its
- 55:21competitors. At Berkshire, we never count on
- 55:24sign or geese when we acquire companies.
- 55:27Truly important ones, however, surfaced after our purchase of
- 55:31Clayton. Marmont's railcar business
- 55:33experienced a major slowdown in demand last year, which will
- 55:37cost earnings to decline in 2017.
- 55:41Fleet utilization was 91% in December, down from 97% a year
- 55:46earlier, with the drop particularly severe at the large
- 55:49fleet we purchased from General Electric in 2015.
- 55:53Marmons crane and container rentals have weakened as well.
- 55:57Big swings in rail car demand have occurred in the past and
- 56:01they will continue. Nevertheless, we vary much like
- 56:04this business and expect decent returns on equity capital over
- 56:08the years. Tank cars are Marmons specialty.
- 56:11People often associate tank cars with the transportation of crude
- 56:15oil. In fact they are essential to a
- 56:18great variety of shippers. Over time we expect to expand
- 56:22our railcar operation. Meanwhile, Marmont is making a
- 56:25number of bolt on acquisitions whose results are included in
- 56:29the manufacturing service and retailing section pay race.
- 56:33The pre tax earnings recap for our finance related companies
- 56:37investments. Below we list our 15 common
- 56:40stock investments that at year end had the largest market
- 56:43value. We exclude our Kraft Heinz
- 56:46holding because Berkshire is part of a control group and
- 56:49therefore must account for this investment on the equity method.
- 56:53The 325442152 shares Berkshire owns of Kraft Heinz are carried
- 56:58on our balance sheet at a gap figure of $15.3 billion and had
- 57:03a year in market value of $28.4 billion.
- 57:07Our cost basis for the shares is $9.8 billion.
- 57:11Some of the stocks in the table are the responsibility of either
- 57:15todkom sorted. We SC Hiller who work with me in
- 57:19managing Berkshires investments. Each independently manages more
- 57:23than $10 billion. I usually learn about decisions
- 57:27they have made by looking at monthly trade sheets.
- 57:29Included in the $21 billion that the two manage is about $7.6
- 57:35billion of pension trust assets of certain Berkshire
- 57:38subsidiaries. As noted, pension investments
- 57:41are not included in the preceding tabulation of
- 57:44Berkshire holdings. Excluded from the table, but
- 57:47important is our ownership of $5 billion of preferred stock
- 57:51issued by Bank of America. This stock, which pays us $300
- 57:55million per year, also carries with it a valuable warrant
- 58:00allowing Berkshire to purchase 700 million common shares of
- 58:03Bank of America for $5 billion at any time before September
- 58:082nd, 2021. At year end, that privilege
- 58:12would have delivered us a profit of $10.5 billion.
- 58:15If it wishes, Berkshire can use its preferred shares to satisfy
- 58:19the $5 billion cost of exercising the warrant.
- 58:23If the dividend rate on Bank of America common stock, now $0.30
- 58:26annually, should rise above $0.44 before 2021, we would
- 58:31anticipate making a cashless exchange of our preferred into
- 58:35common. If the common dividend remains
- 58:38below $0.44, it is highly probable that we will exercise
- 58:42the warrant immediately before it expires.
- 58:45Many of our invest EES, including Bank of America, have
- 58:49been repurchasing shares, some quite aggressively.
- 58:52We very much like this behavior because we believe the
- 58:55repurchase shares have in most cases been underpriced.
- 58:59Undervaluation, after all, is why we own these positions.
- 59:03When a company grows and outstanding shares shrink, good
- 59:07things happen for shareholders. It's important for you to
- 59:10understand that 95% of the $86 billion off cash and
- 59:14equivalents, which in mind mind includes U.S.
- 59:18Treasury bills shown on our balance sheet are held by
- 59:21entities in the United States and consequently is not subject
- 59:25to any repatriation tax. Moreover, repatriation of the
- 59:29remaining funds would trigger only minor taxes because much of
- 59:33that money has been earned in countries that themselves impose
- 59:36meaningful corporate taxes. Those payments become an offset
- 59:40to you S dot tax when money is brought home.
- 59:43These explanations are important because many cash rich American
- 59:46companies hold a large portion of their funds and jurisdictions
- 59:50imposing very low taxes. Such companies hope Ann may well
- 59:54be proved right that the tax levied for bringing these funds
- 59:57to America will soon be materially reduced.
- 1:00:00In the meantime, fees companies are limited as to how they can
- 1:00:04use that cash. In other words, offshore cash is
- 1:00:07simply not worth ass much. Is cash held at home?
- 1:00:11Berkshire has a partial offset to the favorable geographical
- 1:00:14location of its cash, which is that much of it is held in our
- 1:00:17insurance subsidiaries. Though we have many alternatives
- 1:00:21for investing this cash, we do not have the unlimited choices
- 1:00:25that we would enjoy if the cash were held by the parent company,
- 1:00:28Berkshire. We do have an ability annually
- 1:00:31to distribute large amounts of cash from our insurers to the
- 1:00:35parent, though here too there are limits.
- 1:00:38Overall, cash held at tour insurers is a very valuable
- 1:00:42asset, but one slightly less valuable to us than is cash held
- 1:00:46at the parent level. Sometimes the comments of
- 1:00:49shareholders or media imply that we will own certain stocks
- 1:00:52forever. It is true that we own some
- 1:00:55stocks that I have no intention of selling for as far as the eye
- 1:00:58can see, and we're talking 2020 vision, But we have made no
- 1:01:02commitment that Berkshire will hold any of its marketable
- 1:01:05securities forever. Confusion about this point may
- 1:01:08have resulted from a too casual reading of Economic Principle 11
- 1:01:12on pages 110 to 111, which has been included in our annual
- 1:01:17reports since 1983. That principle covers controlled
- 1:01:21businesses, not marketable securities.
- 1:01:24This year I've added a final sentence to 11 to ensure that
- 1:01:27our owners understand that regard any marketable security
- 1:01:31as available for sale, however unlikely such a sale now seems.
- 1:01:36Before we leave this investment section, a few educational words
- 1:01:39about dividends and taxes. Berkshire, Like most
- 1:01:43corporations, that's considerably more from a dollar
- 1:01:45of dividends than it reaps from a dollar of capital gains.
- 1:01:49That will probably surprise those of our shareholders who
- 1:01:52are accustomed to thinking of capital gains as the route to
- 1:01:55tax favored returns. But hey, race the corporate
- 1:01:58math. Every $1.00 of capital gains
- 1:02:01that a corporation realizes carries with it $0.35 of federal
- 1:02:05income tax. In often state income tax as
- 1:02:08well. The tax on dividends received
- 1:02:10from domestic corporations, however, is consistently lower,
- 1:02:14though rates vary depending on the status of the recipient. 20
- 1:02:18For an on insurance company, which describes Berkshire
- 1:02:21Hathaway, the parent of federal tax rate is effectively 101 two
- 1:02:26cents per $1.00 of dividends received.
- 1:02:28Furthermore, an on insurance company that owns more than 20%
- 1:02:33of an Invest EE OS taxes of only $0.07 per $1.00 of dividends.
- 1:02:38That rate applies for example, to the substantial dividends we
- 1:02:42receive from our 27% ownership of Kraft Heinz, all of it held
- 1:02:46by the parent company. The rationale for the low
- 1:02:49corporate taxes on dividends is that the dividend paying Invest
- 1:02:52EE has already paid its own corporate tax on the earnings
- 1:02:56being distributed. Berkshires insurance
- 1:02:58subsidiaries pay a tax rate on dividends that is somewhat
- 1:03:02higher than that applying to non insurance companies, though the
- 1:03:05rate is still well below the 35% hitting capital gains.
- 1:03:09Property casualty companies owe about 14% in taxes on most
- 1:03:14dividends they receive. Their tax rate falls though to
- 1:03:18about 11% if they own more than 20% of OS based invest EE.
- 1:03:23And that's our tax lesson for today.
- 1:03:25The better how your money finds its way to Wall Street.
- 1:03:28In this section, you will encounter early on the story of
- 1:03:32an investment bet I made nine years ago, and next some strong
- 1:03:37opinions I have about investing. As a starter, though, I want to
- 1:03:40briefly describe Long Bets, a unique establishment that played
- 1:03:44a role in the bet. Long Bets was seeded by Amazon's
- 1:03:48Jeff Bezos and operates as a nonprofit organization that
- 1:03:52administers just what you'd guess long term bets to
- 1:03:55participateproposerspostaproposition@longbets.org that will be proved right or
- 1:04:01wrong at a distant date. They then wait for a contrary
- 1:04:04minded party to take the other side of the bet.
- 1:04:08When a doubter steps forward, each side names a charity that
- 1:04:11will be the beneficiary if it's side wins, parks its wager with
- 1:04:15Long Bets, and posts a short essay defending its position on
- 1:04:19the Long Bets website. When the Batiste concluded, Long
- 1:04:22Bets pays off the winning charity.
- 1:04:24Here are examples of what you will find on Long Bets.
- 1:04:27Very interesting site. In 2002, entrepreneur Mitch Capp
- 1:04:31or asserted that by 2029, no computer or machine intelligence
- 1:04:35will have passed the Turing Test, which deals with whether a
- 1:04:39computer can successfully impersonate a human being.
- 1:04:42Inventor Ray Kurzweil took the opposing view.
- 1:04:45Each backed up his opinion with $10,000.
- 1:04:48I don't know Who Will Win this bet, but I will confidently
- 1:04:51wager that no computer will ever replicate Charlie.
- 1:04:55That same year, Craig Mundy E of Microsoft asserted that Pilot
- 1:04:59Less planes would routinely fly passengers by 2030, while Eric
- 1:05:03Schmidt of Google argued otherwise.
- 1:05:05The stakes were $1000 each. To ease any heartburn Eric might
- 1:05:10be experiencing from his outsized exposure, I recently
- 1:05:13offered to take a piece of his action.
- 1:05:15He promptly laid off $500.00 with me.
- 1:05:19I like his assumption that it'll be around in 20-30 to contribute
- 1:05:22my payment should we lose now to my bet and its history.
- 1:05:27In Berkshire's 2005 annual report, I argued that active
- 1:05:31investment management by professionals in aggregate
- 1:05:34would, over a period of years, underperform the returns
- 1:05:37achieved by rank amateurs who simply ass it.
- 1:05:40Still, I explained that the massive fees levied by a variety
- 1:05:44of helpers would leave their clients, again in aggregate,
- 1:05:47worse off than if the amateurs simply invested in a non managed
- 1:05:50low cost index fund. See pages 114 to 115 for a print
- 1:05:56of the argument as I originally stated it in the 2005 report. 21
- 1:06:02Subsequently, I publicly offered to wager $500,000 that no
- 1:06:06investment pro could select a set of at least five hedge
- 1:06:10funds, wildly popular and high fee investing vehicles that
- 1:06:13would, over an extended period, match the performance of an
- 1:06:17unmanaged S&P 500 index fund charging only token fees.
- 1:06:22I suggested Aiden your bet and named a low cost Vanguard S&P
- 1:06:27fund as my contender. I then S it back and waited
- 1:06:30expectantly for a parade of fund managers who could include their
- 1:06:34own fund as one of the five to come forth and defend their
- 1:06:38occupation. After all these managers surged
- 1:06:41others to bet billions on their abilities, why should they fear
- 1:06:44putting a little of their own money on the line?
- 1:06:47What followed was the sound of silence.
- 1:06:49Though there are thousands of professional investment managers
- 1:06:53who have amassed staggering fortunes by touting their stock
- 1:06:56selecting prowess, only one man, Ted Seda, stepped up to my
- 1:07:00challenge. Ted was a Co manager of Proc
- 1:07:02Partners, an asset manager that had raised money from limited
- 1:07:06partners to form a fund of funds.
- 1:07:08In other words, a fund that invests in multiple hedge funds.
- 1:07:12I hadn't known Ted before our wager, but I like him and admire
- 1:07:15his willingness to put his money where his mouth was.
- 1:07:19He has been both straightforward with me and meticulous in
- 1:07:22supplying all the data that both he and I have needed to monitor
- 1:07:26the bet. For Proc Partners side of our 10
- 1:07:28year bet, Ted picked 5 funds of funds whose results were to be
- 1:07:32averaged and compared against my Vanguards and P Index fund.
- 1:07:36The five he selected had invested their money in more
- 1:07:39than 100 hedge funds, which meant that the overall
- 1:07:42performance of the funds of funds would not be distorted by
- 1:07:46the good or poor results of a single manager.
- 1:07:49Each fund of funds of course, operated with a layer of fees
- 1:07:52that S at above the fees charged by the hedge funds in which it
- 1:07:56had invested. In this doubling up arrangement,
- 1:07:59the larger fees were levied by the underlying hedge funds.
- 1:08:03Each of the fund of funds imposed an additional fee for
- 1:08:06its presumed skills in selecting hedge fund managers.
- 1:08:10Here are the results for the first nine years of the BET
- 1:08:13figures. Leaving no doubt that Girls
- 1:08:15Incorporated of Omaha, the charitable beneficiary I
- 1:08:18designated to get any B twinning SI earned, will be the
- 1:08:22organization eagerly opening the mail next January.
- 1:08:26Footnote Under my agreement with PROC Partners, the names of
- 1:08:29these funds of funds have never been publicly disclosed.
- 1:08:33I, however, see their annual audits.
- 1:08:36The compounded annual increase to date for the index fund is
- 1:08:397.1%, which is a return that could easily prove typical for
- 1:08:44the stock market over time. That's an important fact.
- 1:08:47A particularly weak nine years for the market over the lifetime
- 1:08:51of this bet would have probably helped the relative performance
- 1:08:54of the hedge funds because many hold large short positions.
- 1:08:58Conversely, 9 years of exceptionally high returns from
- 1:09:01stocks would have provided A tailwind for index funds.
- 1:09:05Instead, we operated in what I would call a neutral
- 1:09:07environment. In it, the five funds of funds
- 1:09:11delivered through 2016 an average of only 2.2%.
- 1:09:16Compounded annually, that means $1 million invested in those
- 1:09:20funds would have gained $220,000.
- 1:09:23The index fund would meanwhile have gained $854,000.22.
- 1:09:29Bear in mind that every one of the 100 plus managers of the
- 1:09:32underlying hedge funds had a huge financial incentive to do
- 1:09:36his or her best. Moreover, the five funds of
- 1:09:40funds managers that Ted selected were Similarly in Cinevis Ed to
- 1:09:44select the best hedge fund managers possible because the
- 1:09:47five were entitled to performance fees based on the
- 1:09:50results of the underlying funds. Am certain that in almost all
- 1:09:54cases the managers at both levels were honest and
- 1:09:57intelligent people. But the results for their
- 1:10:00investors were dismal. Really dismal.
- 1:10:02And alas, the huge fixed fees charged by all of the funds and
- 1:10:07funds of funds involved, fees that were totally unwarranted by
- 1:10:10performance, were such that their managers were showered
- 1:10:13with compensation over the nine years that have passed.
- 1:10:16As Gordon Gek Kale might have put it, fees never sleep.
- 1:10:20The underlying hedge fund managers in our bet receive
- 1:10:23payments from their limited partners that likely averaged a
- 1:10:26bit under the prevailing hedge fund standard of 2 and 20,
- 1:10:30meaning a 2% annual fixed fee payable even when losses are
- 1:10:34huge and 20% of profits with no claw back if good years were
- 1:10:38followed by bad once under this lopsided arrangement, a hedge
- 1:10:43fund operator's ability to simply pile up assets under
- 1:10:47management has made many of these managers extraordinarily
- 1:10:50rich, even as their investments have performed poorly.
- 1:10:54Still, we're not through with fees.
- 1:10:56Remember, there were the fund of funds managers to be fed as
- 1:11:00well. These managers received an
- 1:11:02additional fixed amount that was usually set at 1% of assets.
- 1:11:06Then despite the terrible overall record of the five funds
- 1:11:10of funds, some experienced a few good years and collected
- 1:11:13performance fees. Consequently, I estimate that
- 1:11:17over the nine year period, roughly 60% gulp of all gains
- 1:11:21achieved by the five funds of funds were diverted to the 2
- 1:11:24levels of managers. That was their misbegotten
- 1:11:27reward for accomplishing something far short of what
- 1:11:30their many hundreds of limited partners could have effortlessly
- 1:11:34Ann with virtually no cost achieved on their own.
- 1:11:37In my opinion, the disappointing results for hedge fund investors
- 1:11:40that this bet exposed are almost certain to recur in the future.
- 1:11:45I laid out my reasons for that belief in a statement that was
- 1:11:48posted on the Long Bets website when the bet commenced Ann that
- 1:11:52is still posted there. Here's what I asserted Over 18
- 1:11:55year period commencing on January 12008 and ending on
- 1:11:59December 312017, the S&P 500 will outperform a portfolio of
- 1:12:06funds of hedge funds when performances measured on a basis
- 1:12:10any Toffees costs and expenses. A lot of very smart people set
- 1:12:14out to do better than average in securities markets.
- 1:12:17Call them active investors, they're opposites.
- 1:12:20Passive investors will by definition do about average in
- 1:12:24aggregate. There positions will more or
- 1:12:27less approximate those of an index fund.
- 1:12:29Therefore, the balance of the universe of active investors
- 1:12:33must do about average as well. However, these investors will
- 1:12:36incur far greater costs, so on balance, their aggregate results
- 1:12:41after these costs will be worse than those of the passive
- 1:12:44investors. Costs skyrocket when large
- 1:12:47annual fees, large performance fees, and active trading costs
- 1:12:51are all added to the active investors equation.
- 1:12:54Funds of hedge funds accentuate this cost problem because their
- 1:12:58fees are superimposed on the large fees charged by the hedge
- 1:13:01funds in which the funds of funds are invested.
- 1:13:05A number of smart people are involved in running hedge funds,
- 1:13:08but to a great extent there efforts are self neutralizing
- 1:13:12and their IQ will not overcome the cost they impose on
- 1:13:16investors. Investors on average and over
- 1:13:19time will do better with a low cost index fund than with a
- 1:13:22group of funds of funds. 23 So that was my argument and now let
- 1:13:27me put it into a simple equation.
- 1:13:29If Group active investors and Group B do nothing, investors
- 1:13:33comprise the total investing universe, and B is destined to
- 1:13:37achieve average results before costs, so 2 must A.
- 1:13:42Whichever group has the lower costs will win.
- 1:13:45The academic in me requires me to mention that there is a very
- 1:13:48minor point, not worth detailing that slightly modifies this
- 1:13:52formulation. And if Group A has exorbitant
- 1:13:54costs, its shortfall will be substantial.
- 1:13:57There are, of course, some skilled individuals who are
- 1:14:00highly likely to outperform the S&P over long stretches.
- 1:14:05In my lifetime, though, I've identified early on only 10 or
- 1:14:09so professionals that I expected would accomplish this feat.
- 1:14:13There are no doubt many hundreds of people, perhaps thousands,
- 1:14:16who me have never met and whose abilities would equal those of
- 1:14:20the people I've identified. The job, after all, is not
- 1:14:23impossible. The problem simply is that the
- 1:14:26great majority of managers who attempt to over perform will
- 1:14:29fail. The probability is also very
- 1:14:32high that the person soliciting your funds will not be the
- 1:14:35exception. Who does well, Bill Rua.
- 1:14:38NEA truly wonderful human being Andaman, whom he identified 60
- 1:14:43years ago as almost certain to deliver superior investment
- 1:14:46returns over the long haul, said it well.
- 1:14:49In investment management, the progression is from the
- 1:14:52innovators to the imitators to the swarming incompetence.
- 1:14:55Further complicating the search for the rare high fee manager
- 1:14:59who is worth his or her pay is the fact that some investment
- 1:15:02professionals, just as some amateurs, will be lucky over
- 1:15:06short periods. If 1000 managers make a market
- 1:15:10prediction at the beginning of a year, it's very likely that the
- 1:15:13calls of at least one will be correct for 9 consecutive years.
- 1:15:17Of course, 1000 monkeys would be just as likely to produce a
- 1:15:21seemingly all wise profit, but there would remain a difference.
- 1:15:25The lucky monkey would not find people standing in line to
- 1:15:28invest with him. Finally, there are three
- 1:15:31connected realities that cause investing success to breed
- 1:15:35failure. First, a good record quickly
- 1:15:37attracts a torrent of money. Second, huge sums invariably act
- 1:15:42as an anchor on investment performance.
- 1:15:44What is easy with millions struggles with billions SOB.
- 1:15:48Third, most managers will nevertheless seek new money
- 1:15:52because of their personal equation, Namely, the more funds
- 1:15:55they have under management, the more their fees.
- 1:15:58These three points are hardly new ground form.
- 1:16:01In January 1966, when I was managing $44 million, I wrote my
- 1:16:07limited partners. I feel substantially greater
- 1:16:10size is more likely to harm future results than to help
- 1:16:13them. This might not be true for my
- 1:16:15own personal results, but it is likely to be true for your
- 1:16:18results. Therefore, I intend to admit no
- 1:16:21additional partners to be PL. I have notified Susie that if we
- 1:16:25have any more children, it is up to her to find some other
- 1:16:28partnership for them. The bottom line, when trillions
- 1:16:31of dollars are managed by Wall Streeter S charging high fees,
- 1:16:35it will usually be the managers who reap outsized profits, not
- 1:16:39the clients. Both large and small investors
- 1:16:42should stick with low cost index funds.
- 1:16:45If a statue is ever erected to honor the person who has done
- 1:16:49the most for American investors, the hands down choice should be
- 1:16:53Jack Bjogle. For decades, Jack has urged
- 1:16:56investors to invest in ultra low cost index funds.
- 1:16:59In his crusade, he amassed only a tiny percentage of the wealth
- 1:17:03that has typically flowed to managers who have promised their
- 1:17:07investors large rewards while delivering them nothing or, as
- 1:17:10in our bet, less than nothing of added value.
- 1:17:14In his early years, Jack was frequently mocked by the
- 1:17:17investment management industry. Today, however, he has the
- 1:17:21satisfaction of knowing that he helped millions of investors
- 1:17:24realize far better returns on their savings than they
- 1:17:27otherwise would have earned. He is a hero to them and tome.
- 1:17:31Over the years I've often been asked for investment advice and
- 1:17:34in the process of answering I've learned a good deal about human
- 1:17:37behavior. My regular recommendation has
- 1:17:40been a low cost S&P 500 index fund.
- 1:17:44To their credit, my friends who possess only modest means have
- 1:17:47usually followed my suggestion 24.
- 1:17:50I believe, however, that none of the mega rich individuals,
- 1:17:54institutions or pension funds has followed that same advice
- 1:17:58when I've given it to them. Instead, these investors
- 1:18:01politely thank me for my thoughts and depart to listen to
- 1:18:04the siren song of a high fee manager or in the case of many
- 1:18:08institutions, to seek out another breed of hyper helper
- 1:18:12called a consultant. That professional, however,
- 1:18:15faces a problem. Can you imagine an investment
- 1:18:18consultant telling clients year after year to keep adding to an
- 1:18:22index fund replicating the S&P 500?
- 1:18:25That would be career suicide. Large fees flow to these hyper
- 1:18:29helpers. However, if they recommend small
- 1:18:32managerial shifts every year or so, that advice is often
- 1:18:36delivered in esoteric gibberish that explains why fashionable
- 1:18:39investment styles are current. Economic trends make the shift
- 1:18:43appropriate. The wealthy are accustomed to
- 1:18:46feeling that it is their lot in life to get the best food,
- 1:18:49schooling, entertainment, housing, plastic surgery, sports
- 1:18:53ticket, you name it. Their money, they feel, should
- 1:18:56buy them something superior compared to what the masses
- 1:18:59receive in many aspects of life. Indeed, wealth does command top
- 1:19:04grade products or services. For that reason, the financial
- 1:19:08elets, wealthy individuals, pension funds, college
- 1:19:11endowments and the like have great trouble meekly signing up
- 1:19:14for a financial product or service that is available as
- 1:19:17well to people investing only a few $1000.
- 1:19:21This reluctance of the rich normally prevails, even though
- 1:19:24the product at issue is, on an expectancy basis, clearly the
- 1:19:28best choice. My calculation, admittedly very
- 1:19:32rough, is that the search by the elite for superior investment
- 1:19:36advice has caused it, in aggregate to waste more than
- 1:19:39$100 billion over the past decade.
- 1:19:42Figure it out. Even a 1% fee on a few trillion
- 1:19:45dollars adds up. Of course, not every investor
- 1:19:48who put money in hedge funds 10 years ago lagged S&P returns.
- 1:19:53But I believe my calculation of the aggregate shortfall is
- 1:19:57conservative. Much of the financial damage
- 1:19:59befell pension funds for public employees.
- 1:20:02Many of these funds are woefully underfunded, in part because
- 1:20:06they have suffered a double whammy, poor investment
- 1:20:09performance accompanied by huge fees.
- 1:20:12The resulting shortfalls in their assets will, for decades,
- 1:20:14have to be made-up by local taxpayers.
- 1:20:17Human behavior won't change. Wealthy individuals, pension
- 1:20:21funds, endowments and the like will continue to feel they
- 1:20:25deserve something extra in investment advice.
- 1:20:28Those advisors who cleverly play to this expectation will get
- 1:20:31very rich. This year the magic potion may
- 1:20:34be hedge funds. Next year, something else.
- 1:20:37The likely result from this parade of promises is predicted
- 1:20:41in an adage when a person with money meets a person with
- 1:20:45experience, the one with experience ends up with the
- 1:20:47money and the one with money leaves with experience.
- 1:20:51Long ago a brother-in-law of mine, Homer Rogers, was a
- 1:20:55Commission agent working in the Omaha stockyards.
- 1:20:59I asked him how he induced a farmer or rancher to hire him to
- 1:21:02handle the sale of their hogs or cattle to the buyers from the
- 1:21:05BIG4 Packers, Swift, CUDA, High, Wilson, and Armor.
- 1:21:09After all, hogs were hogs. In the buyers were experts who
- 1:21:13knew to the penny how much any animal was worth.
- 1:21:16How then, I asked Homer, could any sales agent get a better
- 1:21:20result than any other? Homer gave me a pitying look and
- 1:21:23said, Warren, it's not how you sell them, it's how you tell
- 1:21:27them what worked in the stock yards continues to work in Wall
- 1:21:30Street. And finally, let me offer an
- 1:21:33olive branch to Wall Street or S many of them good friends of
- 1:21:36mine. Berkshire loves to pay fees,
- 1:21:38even outrageous fiesto investment bankers who bring us
- 1:21:42acquisitions. Moreover, we have paid
- 1:21:44substantial sums for over performance to our two in house
- 1:21:48investment managers and we hope to make even larger payments to
- 1:21:51them in the future. To get biblical Ephesians 3
- 1:21:55verse 18. I know the height and the depth
- 1:21:57and the length and the breadth of the energy flowing from that
- 1:22:01simple 4 letter word fusion. It is spoken to Wall Street and
- 1:22:04when that energy delivers value to Berkshire, I will cheerfully
- 1:22:08write a big check. 25 the annual meeting Last year, we partnered
- 1:22:13with Yahoo to air the first ever webcast of our annual meeting.
- 1:22:17Thanks to Andy SER Wer and his Yahoo crew.
- 1:22:20The production was a success in all respects, registering 1.1
- 1:22:25million unique visits in real time viewing and 11.5 million
- 1:22:29more in replays. Many of those, to be sure,
- 1:22:32called up by viewers interested in only certain segments of the
- 1:22:36webcast. Berkshire's thank you mail for
- 1:22:38initiating the webcast included many notes from three
- 1:22:42constituencies, the elderly who find travel difficult, the
- 1:22:46thrifty who find it expensive to travel to Omaha, and those who
- 1:22:50cannot attend a Saturday meeting for religious reasons.
- 1:22:53The webcast cut attendance at last year's meeting to about
- 1:22:5737,000 people. We can't get a precise count,
- 1:23:00which was down about 10%. Nevertheless, both Berkshire
- 1:23:04subsidiaries and Omaha hotels and restaurants racked up huge
- 1:23:08sales. Nebraska Furniture Mart sales
- 1:23:11broke their 2015 record volume by 3% with the Omaha store
- 1:23:16recording one week volume of $45.5 million.
- 1:23:21Our Berkshire exhibitors at CenturyLink were open from noon
- 1:23:24until 5:00 PM on Friday and drew a crowd of 12,000 bargain
- 1:23:28hunting shareholders. We will repeat those Friday
- 1:23:31shopping hours this year on May 5th TH.
- 1:23:33Bring money. The Annual meeting falls on May
- 1:23:366th TH and will again be webcast by Yahoo, whose web address is
- 1:23:41https://finance.yahoo.comber K live stream.
- 1:23:45The webcast will go live at 9:00 AM Central Daylight Time.
- 1:23:49Yahoo will interview directors, managers, stockholders and
- 1:23:53celebrities before the meeting and during the lunch break.
- 1:23:56Both those interviews and meeting will be translated
- 1:24:00simultaneously into Mandarin for those attending the meeting in
- 1:24:03person. The doors at the CenturyLink
- 1:24:05will open at 7:00 AM on Saturday to facilitate shopping prior to
- 1:24:10our shareholder movie which begins at 8:30.
- 1:24:13The question and answer period will start at 9:30 and run until
- 1:24:173:30 with a one hour lunch break at noon.
- 1:24:20Finally, at 3:45 we will begin the formal shareholder meeting.
- 1:24:25It will run an hour or so. That is somewhat longer than
- 1:24:28usual because 3 proxy items are to be presented by their
- 1:24:32proponents who will be given a reasonable amount of time to
- 1:24:35state their case. On Saturday morning we will have
- 1:24:38our 6th International Newspaper Tossing Challenge.
- 1:24:41Our target will again be the porch of a Clayton home located
- 1:24:45precisely 35 feet from the throwing line.
- 1:24:48When I was a teenager, in my 1 brief flirtation with honest
- 1:24:52labor, I delivered about 500,000 papers.
- 1:24:56So I think I'm pretty good at this game.
- 1:24:58Challenge me, humiliate me, knock me down a peg.
- 1:25:01The papers will run 36 to 42 pages, and you must fold them
- 1:25:06yourself. No rubber bands allowed.
- 1:25:08The competition will begin about 7:45 and it'll take on 10 or so
- 1:25:12competitors selected a few minutes earlier by my assistant
- 1:25:16dev Boss and neck. Your venue for shopping will be
- 1:25:18the 194,300 square foot hall that adjoins the meeting and in
- 1:25:24which products from dozens of our subsidiaries will be for
- 1:25:27sale. Say hello to the many Berkshire
- 1:25:29managers who will be captaining their exhibits and be sure to
- 1:25:33view the terrific BNSF railroad layout that salutes all of our
- 1:25:37companies. Your children and you will be
- 1:25:40enchanted with it. Brooks, our running shoe
- 1:25:42company, will again have a special commemorative shoe to
- 1:25:46offer at the meeting after you purchase a pair with them on
- 1:25:49Sunday at our 4th Annual Berkshire 5K, an 8:00 AM race
- 1:25:54starting at the CenturyLink. Full details for participating
- 1:25:57will be included in the Visitor's Guide that will be
- 1:26:00sent to you with your meeting credentials.
- 1:26:03Entrance in the race will find themselves running alongside
- 1:26:06many of Berkshire's managers, directors and associates.
- 1:26:10Charlie and I, however, will sleep in the fudge and peanut
- 1:26:14brittle we eat throughout. The Saturday meeting takes its
- 1:26:17toll. Participation in the 5K grows
- 1:26:20every year. Help us set another record 26.
- 1:26:25A GEICO booth in the shopping area will be staffed by a number
- 1:26:28of the company stop counselors from around the country.
- 1:26:31At last year's meeting, we set a record for policy sales, up 21%
- 1:26:36from 2015. I predict we will be up again
- 1:26:39this year, so stop by for a quote.
- 1:26:42In most cases, GEICO will be able to give you a shareholder
- 1:26:45discount, usually 8%. This special offer is permitted
- 1:26:49by 44 of the 51 jurisdictions in which we operate. 1 supplemental
- 1:26:53point. The discount is not additive.
- 1:26:56If you qualify for another discount, such as that available
- 1:26:59to certain groups, bring the details of your existing
- 1:27:02insurance and check out our price.
- 1:27:04We can save many of you real money.
- 1:27:06Spend the savings on other Berkshire products.
- 1:27:09Be sure to visit the Bookworm. This Omaha based retailer will
- 1:27:13carry about 35 books and DVD's, among them a couple of new
- 1:27:17titles. The best book I read last year
- 1:27:20was Shoe Dog by Nike's Phil Knight.
- 1:27:22Phil is a very wise, intelligent and competitive fellow who is
- 1:27:26also a gifted storyteller. The Bookworm will have piles of
- 1:27:30Shoe Dog as well as several investment classics by Jack
- 1:27:33Biogel. The Bookworm will once again
- 1:27:36offer our history of the highlights and low lights off
- 1:27:38Berkshire's first 50 years. Non attendees of the meeting can
- 1:27:43find the book on eBay, just type in Berkshire Hathaway, Inc
- 1:27:47celebrating 50 years of a profitable partnership to Indy
- 1:27:51Edition. An attachment to the proxy
- 1:27:53material that is enclosed with this report explains how you can
- 1:27:56obtain the credential you will need for admission to both the
- 1:27:59meeting and other events. Keep in mind that airlines have
- 1:28:03sometimes jacked up prices for the Berkshire weekend, though I
- 1:28:06must admit I have developed some tolerance bordering on
- 1:28:10enthusiasm for that practice now that Berkshire has made large
- 1:28:13investments in America's four major carriers.
- 1:28:17Nevertheless, if you were coming from far away, compare the cost
- 1:28:20of flying to Kansas City versus Omaha.
- 1:28:23The drive between the two cities is about 21 hours, and it may be
- 1:28:27that Kansas City can save you 2 significant money.
- 1:28:31The savings for a couple could run to $1000 or more.
- 1:28:35Spend that money with us at Nebraska Furniture Mart located
- 1:28:39on a 77 acre site on 72 in D Street between Dodge and
- 1:28:43Pacific. We will again be having.
- 1:28:46Berkshire Weekend Discount Pricing To obtain the Berkshire
- 1:28:49discount at NFM you must make your purchases between Tuesday,
- 1:28:53May 2nd in D and Monday, May 8th TH inclusive and must also
- 1:28:58present your meeting credential. The period special pricing will
- 1:29:02even apply to the products of several prestigious
- 1:29:05manufacturers that normally have ironclad rules against
- 1:29:08discounting, but which in the spirit of our shareholder
- 1:29:12weekend, have made an exception for you.
- 1:29:15We appreciate their cooperation during Berkshire Weekend NFM.
- 1:29:19We'll be open from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Friday,
- 1:29:2310:00 AM to 9:30 PM on Saturday, and 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM on
- 1:29:28Sunday. From 5 Colon 30P dot m.to 8:00
- 1:29:32PM on Saturday, NFM is hosting a picnic to which you are all
- 1:29:36invited. This year we have good news for
- 1:29:38shareholders in the Kansas City and Dallas metro markets who
- 1:29:41can't attend the meeting or perhaps prefer the webcast.
- 1:29:45From May 2nd in D through May 8th TH.
- 1:29:48Shareholders who present meeting credentials or other evidence of
- 1:29:52their Berkshire ownership such as brokerage statements though
- 1:29:55their local NFM store will receive the same discounts
- 1:29:58enjoyed by those visiting the Omaha store.
- 1:30:01At Borschi IMS, we will again have two shareholder only
- 1:30:04events. The first will be a cocktail
- 1:30:06reception from 6:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Friday, May 5th TH.
- 1:30:12The second, the main Gala, will be held on Sunday, May 7th TH
- 1:30:17from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM. On Saturday, we will remain open
- 1:30:21until 6:00 PM. Remember, the more you buy, the
- 1:30:25more you save, or so my daughter tells me.
- 1:30:27When we visit the store 27, we will have huge crowds at Borschi
- 1:30:31IMS throughout the weekend. For your convenience.
- 1:30:34Therefore, shareholder prices will be available from Monday,
- 1:30:38May 1st SD through Saturday, May 13th TH.
- 1:30:42During that period, please identify yourself as a
- 1:30:44shareholder either by presenting your meeting credential or a
- 1:30:48brokerage statement showing you on our stock.
- 1:30:50On Sunday in the mall outside of Borshi IMS, Norman Beck, a
- 1:30:55remarkable magician and motivational speaker from
- 1:30:58Dallas, will bewilder onlookers on the upper level.
- 1:31:01We will have Bob Ham and and Sharon OS Berg, 2 of the world's
- 1:31:06top bridge experts, available to play with our shareholders on
- 1:31:09Sunday afternoon. If they suggest wagering on the
- 1:31:13game, change the subject. I will join them at some point
- 1:31:16and hope a Jayet, Charlie and Bill Gates will do so also.
- 1:31:20My friend Ariel Shing will be in the mall as well on Sunday,
- 1:31:24taking on challengers at table tennis.
- 1:31:26I met Ariel when she was 9, and even then I was unable to score
- 1:31:30a point against her. Ariel represented the United
- 1:31:34States in the 2012 Olympics. Now she's a senior at Princeton
- 1:31:38after interning last summer at JP Morgan Chase.
- 1:31:42If you don't mind embarrassing yourself, test your skills
- 1:31:45against her beginning at 1:00 PM.
- 1:31:47Bill Gates did pretty well playing Ariel last year, so he
- 1:31:50may be ready to again challenge her. dot, MY advice?
- 1:31:53Bed and Ariel Gore Otts will be open exclusively for Berkshire
- 1:31:57shareholders on Sunday, May 7th TH serving from 1:00 PM until
- 1:32:0210:00 PM. To make a reservation at Gore
- 1:32:04Otts, call 402-551-3733. On April 3rd or but not before
- 1:32:12show you are a sophisticated diner.
- 1:32:14By ordering the T-bone with hash Browns, we will have the same
- 1:32:18three financial journalists lead the question and answer period
- 1:32:21at the meeting asking Charlie and me questions that
- 1:32:24shareholders have submitted to them by e-mail.
- 1:32:26The journalists and their e-mail addresses are Carol Loomis, the
- 1:32:31pre eminent business journalist of her time, who may be emailed
- 1:32:34at loomisbrkgmail.com, becky.quickofcnbc@berkshirequestioncnbc.com
- 1:32:42and Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times
- 1:32:45addersorkanytimes.com. From the questions submitted,
- 1:32:49each journalist will choose the six he or she decides are the
- 1:32:53most interesting and important to shareholders.
- 1:32:56The journalists have told me your question has the best
- 1:32:59chance of being selected if you keep it concise, Avoid sending
- 1:33:02it in at the last moment, make it Berkshire related and include
- 1:33:06no more than two questions in any e-mail you send them.
- 1:33:09In your e-mail, let the journalist know if you would
- 1:33:12like your name mentioned. If your question is asked, an
- 1:33:15accompanying set of questions will be asked by three analysts
- 1:33:18who follow Berkshire this year. The insurance specialist will be
- 1:33:22Jay Gelb of Barclays. Questions that deal with our non
- 1:33:25insurance operations will come from Jonathan Brandt of Rua
- 1:33:29Northeast, CUNNIFF and Gold Far B and Greg Warren of
- 1:33:33Morningstar. Since what we will be conducting
- 1:33:36is a shareholders meeting, our hope is that the analysts and
- 1:33:39journalists will ask questions that add to our owners
- 1:33:42understanding and knowledge of their investment.
- 1:33:45Neither Charlie nor I will get so much as a clue about the
- 1:33:48questions headed our way. Some will be tough for sure and
- 1:33:52that's the way we like it. Multi part questions aren't
- 1:33:55allowed. We want to give as many
- 1:33:57questioners as possible a shot at us.
- 1:33:59Our goal is for you to leave the meeting knowing more about
- 1:34:02Berkshire then when you came and for you to have a good time
- 1:34:05while in Omaha. All told, we expect at least 54
- 1:34:09questions, which will allow for six from each analyst and
- 1:34:12journalist and for eighteen from the audience.
- 1:34:15The questioners from the audience will be chosen by means
- 1:34:18of 11 drawings that will take place at 8:15 AM on the morning
- 1:34:22of the annual meeting. Each of the 11 microphones
- 1:34:25installed in the arena and main overflow room will host, so to
- 1:34:29speak, a drawing 28. While I'm on the subject of our
- 1:34:33owners gaining knowledge, let me remind you that Charlie and I
- 1:34:37believe all shareholders should simultaneously have access to
- 1:34:40new information that Berkshire releases and if possible, should
- 1:34:45also have adequate time to digest and analyze it before any
- 1:34:48trading takes place. That's why we try to issue
- 1:34:52financial data late on Fridays or early on Saturdays, and why
- 1:34:56our annual meeting is always held on a Saturday, a day that
- 1:34:59also eases traffic and parking problems.
- 1:35:02We do not follow the common practice of talking one-on-one
- 1:35:05with large institutional investors or analysts, treating
- 1:35:09them instead as we do all other shareholders.
- 1:35:12There is no one more important to us than that shareholder of
- 1:35:16limited means who trusts us with a substantial portion of his or
- 1:35:20her savings. As I run the company day-to-day
- 1:35:23and as I write this letter, that is the shareholder whose image
- 1:35:26is in my mind. For good reason, I regularly
- 1:35:29extol the accomplishments of our operating managers.
- 1:35:32They are truly All Stars who run their businesses as if they were
- 1:35:36the only asset owned by their families.
- 1:35:38I also believe that mindset of our managers to be as
- 1:35:42shareholder oriented as can be found in the universe of large
- 1:35:45publicly owned companies. Most of our managers have no
- 1:35:49financial need to work. The joy of hitting business home
- 1:35:52runs means as much to them as their paycheck.
- 1:35:56Equally important, however, are the men and women who work with
- 1:35:59me at our corporate office. This team efficiently deals with
- 1:36:03a multitude of SEC and other regulatory requirements.
- 1:36:07Files a 30,450 page federal income tax return overseas, the
- 1:36:13filing of 3580 state tax returns.
- 1:36:17Responds to countless shareholder and media inquiries.
- 1:36:20Gets out the annual report. Prepares for the country's
- 1:36:23largest annual meeting. Coordinates the boards
- 1:36:26activities, fact checks this letter in the list goes on and
- 1:36:30on. They handle all of these
- 1:36:32business tasks cheerfully and with unbelievable efficiency,
- 1:36:35making my life easy and pleasant.
- 1:36:38Their efforts go beyond activities strictly related to
- 1:36:41Berkshire. Last year, for example, they
- 1:36:44dealt with the 40 universities selected from 200 applicants who
- 1:36:48sent students to Omaha for AQ and a day with me.
- 1:36:52They also handle all kinds of requests that I receive, arrange
- 1:36:55my travel and even get me hamburgers in French fries,
- 1:36:59smothered in Heinz ketchup, of course, for lunch.
- 1:37:02In addition, they cheerfully pitch into help carries OVA, our
- 1:37:06talented ringmaster at the annual meeting deliver an
- 1:37:09interesting and entertaining weekend for our shareholders.
- 1:37:13They are proud to work for Berkshire and I am proud of
- 1:37:15them. I'm a lucky guy, very fortunate
- 1:37:18in being surrounded by this excellent staff.
- 1:37:20A team of highly talented operating managers in a
- 1:37:24boardroom of very wise and experienced directors.
- 1:37:27Come to Omaha, the cradle of capitalism, in May 6th TH and
- 1:37:31meet the Berkshire bunch. All of us look forward to seeing
- 1:37:34you. February 252017 Warren E
- 1:37:38Buffett, Chairman of the Board.