Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP332: How Mature Is Shopify’s POS? Feature Strengths & Operational Limitations, With Kubix Operations Director Joseph Brown
Transcript
- 0:00So someone coming into a store to exchange an item, but the
- 0:04item that they're exchanging not being available in that store.
- 0:08Now that's where Shopify's a lack of inventory management
- 0:12maturity is it's downfall. And that is a key theme
- 0:15throughout Shopify. Inventory management is
- 0:18maturing, but in my opinion a bit too slowly in comparison
- 0:22with the the actual platform and the robustness of everything
- 0:25else. You're listening to Inside
- 0:27Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX
- 0:30focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:32and RE platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:35Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:37industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:39practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:45This podcast is sponsored by Worldpay.
- 0:48We've got a topic that Paul and I have talked about for a while
- 0:50about how we tackle this and, and what's the right way of
- 0:53doing it. And we always decided we needed
- 0:54to get a an expert in on this and we're very glad to to work
- 0:57on that expert. Say, I intro you in a minute and
- 0:59this is about Shopify Pause. So Shopify is well known as
- 1:03market leader and ecom Pause has been an integral part of his
- 1:05offering for the last couple of years and they're rapidly
- 1:07expanding the pause product. But it's coming from a point of
- 1:11quite a infant product compared with some of the mature ones in
- 1:15the market and lots of pros and cons and those are changing and
- 1:19also lots of challenges about what type of retail environment
- 1:22does it work well in versus where it's a challenge.
- 1:24So we're looking at the reality of choosing Shopify Pause.
- 1:28In the context there in the context that poses this can be
- 1:30deceptively complex and it's not just a question of turning on
- 1:33some new software and hardware So we've got really happy to
- 1:36welcome Joe Brown, who's the operations director at Cubix,
- 1:39who are a Shopify platinum partner based stock in Berlin So
- 1:42warm welcome Joe, thank you very much Yeah, it's a it's a
- 1:45pleasure. So yeah I'm the OPS director at
- 1:47Cubix. I primarily lead technical
- 1:50discovery on platform fit feasibility with a particular
- 1:54focus on on retail. So establishing if how Shopify
- 1:58POS will fit into an organization.
- 2:00And yeah, looking forward to sharing a bit more about how the
- 2:03platform's evolved and how we approach it.
- 2:05Yeah, brilliant. And for those of you listening,
- 2:07this is going to be real pragmatic and open debate about
- 2:09where it's good, where it might have some weaknesses or
- 2:11challenges, where customisation is needed and some of the
- 2:13gotchas that. That that we all know and Joe's
- 2:16team specifically as they work on a lot of these projects have
- 2:18seen and how to make it work and that decision part.
- 2:21So real practical advice in here and the reason why we invite Joe
- 2:25on this is Cubic's got a wide range of clients.
- 2:28It's not just like one particular part of retail, like
- 2:30fashion for example. They work with fashion,
- 2:32homewares, food and each of those, the store estates have
- 2:35different legacy tech stacks, different operational processes,
- 2:38all the management flows, you name it.
- 2:39And therefore the challenges have to be solved in different
- 2:42ways. So there Joe, I've totally
- 2:44bigged you up. It's quite a pedestal there,
- 2:47isn't it going to go One Direction now?
- 2:50Exactly. And for those of you who listen
- 2:52to audio not seen the video, there is this this shining Halo
- 2:54coming from Bo's head and so beautiful.
- 2:58Let's get let's get into this then.
- 2:59So let's do a bit of market positioning first, because
- 3:02Shopify has product development has accelerated quite a lot in
- 3:05the last couple of years. And I think some of the previous
- 3:08objections to its limitations are starting to be unpicked.
- 3:11But let's be really practical. What has impressed you and the
- 3:14team at Cubics the most? And how's that relevant to
- 3:16retailers? Well, I think it relates to the
- 3:19point you've made there about how it's, it's come from a place
- 3:22of, of infancy. And I think over the last year,
- 3:252 years, there's been a real focus on gearing up the platform
- 3:29so it can support retailers that have a larger estate.
- 3:32So talking specifically things like centralised control and
- 3:37customisation. So you talk about the to the
- 3:39smart grid, the actual interface of the PLS itself.
- 3:43Back in the day, that was localised, so you had to
- 3:46physically go to devices and make those changes.
- 3:48There's definitely this intentional shift with Shopify
- 3:51now where they recognise that they're talking mass deployment.
- 3:55You would customise that grid in the admin much like you would a
- 3:58Shopify theme and these are the kind of signs of that as well.
- 4:03Really good one is permissions. We know permissions in the
- 4:06Shopify admin have become a lot more granular.
- 4:08But now in the retail, in kind of the retail context, you've
- 4:12got things like manager approvals and things are
- 4:15becoming a lot more granular. So POS specific roles, for
- 4:19example, is really good. And I suppose again, just
- 4:22generally they've managed to add a lot more complexity into the,
- 4:26the application without it becoming kind of a big
- 4:29compromise on UX and usability. And that's probably the one
- 4:32thing that anyone that's moved to Shopify POS from a legacy
- 4:36system, they really, really appreciate how straightforward
- 4:39and easy it is to use and navigate.
- 4:41So I hope that does remain a focus for, for Shopify.
- 4:45And you know, in terms of depth, there's still a long way to go,
- 4:47but it's, it's really positive momentum.
- 4:51Great. And so big question for me, it's
- 4:54so I'm actually I'm not as close to POS as I used to be.
- 4:58So maybe a few years ago I would have been a bit more hands on
- 5:00with it. And I feel like whenever we'd
- 5:03talk to like an Omni channel brand that's maybe got 5 or 6
- 5:06stores and just generally like viewing the ecosystem, the view
- 5:11wise, Shop 5 great up until you have about 10 stores and then,
- 5:16you know, you start to outgrow it and certain parts of the
- 5:19product, yeah, maybe aren't as solid as some of the other
- 5:24solutions out there. What's your view on that?
- 5:28And like was that the case a couple of years ago?
- 5:30And how has that kind of, yeah, how Shopify moved on from that?
- 5:34I think a couple of years ago it was definitely the case.
- 5:36So just as I say, managing a store estates with Shopify POS,
- 5:43I think that I'd be perceived as quite an interesting challenge
- 5:45as opposed to a very viable thing to go and do.
- 5:49But I think can it handle a large store estate?
- 5:52Can it really handle enterprise? Well, it all depends on what
- 5:56role it's playing in the stack. So if, if it's approached with
- 6:00the right mindset and I say to clients a lot, we're just going
- 6:03through some discovery of the week and ringing in my ears was
- 6:06why not Shopify and if it's approached in that way of OK,
- 6:11why don't we use Shopify? Where did the boundaries of the
- 6:13application start and stop what actually is handled by the
- 6:16platform? Then I, I wouldn't perceive
- 6:20number of stores being a limiting factor.
- 6:22It comes down to what the specific workflows or
- 6:25requirements are when you hit those stores.
- 6:29And you know, do we run Shopify as the transactional layer
- 6:33that's doing the commerce piece? And do we have a retail
- 6:35management system, for example, that's doing, you know, all the
- 6:38kind of transactional stuff that relates to say, I don't know,
- 6:41things like barcode printing stock takes all the all the
- 6:46stuff that isn't serving a customer tends to where the
- 6:49growing pains start. And for the kind of emerging
- 6:53maturing retailers, the solution to that problem is like sticking
- 6:57an app, let's try to use an app, let's put another app in and you
- 6:59kind of get this sprawl of tech, which for a certain store state
- 7:04is absolutely fine. But then when things need to
- 7:07become localized to regions or if there are maybe specific
- 7:12compliance concerns, I'd say that's when we'd start to look
- 7:16at, OK, do we need to kind of tighten the role Shopify plays
- 7:20in a retail environment and do we need to get some other tech
- 7:23in to run alongside it? Great.
- 7:26And I think that takes us nicely on to discovery and you, James
- 7:32and I were chatting a bit before we started recording around what
- 7:36discovery looks like and maybe how a discovery around POS would
- 7:42differ to maybe discovery when it comes to an EPON platform or
- 7:45an EPON project. So can you talk us through like,
- 7:50yeah, how a discovery should be approached and why and when
- 7:54that's kind of, you know, not being mapped in certain
- 7:58scenarios and then, yeah, how like some of the important
- 8:01things to cover off in discovery?
- 8:03Yeah. I think one thing we always say
- 8:06to clients is that kind of retail and POS is deceptively
- 8:11complex because it's wrapped up into this really neat little
- 8:14bundle at Shopify going to, you know, is essentially an app.
- 8:17But when you start to kind of peel away the layers of what the
- 8:20workflows look like, and again, those workflows become
- 8:25significantly more complex on a large store estate, because I
- 8:29speak to so many, usually ecom managers end up speaking to ecom
- 8:32managers or marketing managers. And the first thing they'll say
- 8:35to you. Oh, yeah.
- 8:36POS yeah, Unified commerce. We really want to be unifying
- 8:39all this. And, you know, it always has a
- 8:41really positive sense. Now, the trade off of that is
- 8:44that the processes need to be unified to use the unified tech.
- 8:48And the biggest kind of piece of advice I can give to anyone
- 8:52considering a retail project is, you know, similar to ECOM, have
- 8:56the right people in the room because nine times out of 10,
- 8:59you'll get through configuration, you'll get
- 9:02through UAT, and then you'll get, I don't know, a store
- 9:06manager from a particular store. And it will kind of bubble up to
- 9:09the surface that oh, well, actually in this store we sell a
- 9:12combination of products and we actually do this promotion.
- 9:15But it's always been a historic thing.
- 9:16It doesn't really happen. And then that's when you kind of
- 9:20need to assess is that unification and does unification
- 9:25compromise on the agility? Because knowing sometimes I
- 9:28attend it does. Don't go wrong.
- 9:29The platform's getting a lot more deep with things like
- 9:32location specific catalogues. Everyone's crying out for that
- 9:35for a really long time. But I would say to anyone going
- 9:39into that discovery phase, just be really clear from the outset.
- 9:43Are you discovering for viability and feasibility of the
- 9:47product or are you going into it with the the lens of, OK, what
- 9:51is the opportunity and what does this unlock?
- 9:53You know, the latter takes more time.
- 9:56But if you're if you're building up that road map, much like you
- 9:59would do with an ECOM road map from the get go, that is really,
- 10:03really insightful kind of organization wide.
- 10:05And because the second people start to get a flavour for,
- 10:09well, the interface and the ease, the ideas start to come
- 10:13in. So just knowing about where
- 10:15they're going to come from. And you know, bonus points if
- 10:19you can start to weave some of this into ECOM as well.
- 10:21Had the conversation the other week around tech selection and
- 10:26as a client using a loyalty program.
- 10:28And I know that on the road map POS and retail, how's that
- 10:33loyalty program going to interact?
- 10:35And similar to, as mentioned, your clients when they're
- 10:38discussing integrations and it's not good enough to say, Oh yeah,
- 10:42integrate Shopify POS take a little bit of extra time.
- 10:46How does it integrate? What does the actual UX look
- 10:48like? Does it actually allow you to do
- 10:50those free gift redemptions or is there going to be a discount
- 10:52going to work around, you know, you always have to kind of draw
- 10:55a line in the tan somewhere and say, OK, we've discovered
- 10:58enough. But take definitely take the
- 11:01time because it is a, it's an emerging ecosystem.
- 11:05There's a lot that you can do with it that it's beyond
- 11:07transactional workflows, that's for sure.
- 11:09Ready to grow your business online?
- 11:12With World Pay e-commerce you can deliver fast, secure
- 11:15payments your customers love, backed by global reach and real
- 11:20people powered support. Scale with confidence and
- 11:23enhance your customers experience with World Pay
- 11:26E-commerce. Yeah, I've just, I know that
- 11:30you've worked. I know you guys have worked in
- 11:31big furniture projects as well and just to done the same and
- 11:37and a POS discovery. And I think a couple of the
- 11:39principles that that that struck me is, is it's the, it's the
- 11:43same, it's the same methodology as an econ one, but the custom
- 11:47flows and the edge cases are very different in terms of, I
- 11:52guess like may may to order products and extended
- 11:55catalogues, which are very different in a store
- 11:58environment. Because it can be literally
- 12:00somebody who's currently working off of APDF or a physical
- 12:03catalog and just inputting random strings of text, adding a
- 12:06price place in order for a SKU that doesn't exist.
- 12:09Versus in an ECOM where is a it's a controlled uploaded set
- 12:13of additional products for a particular customer segment or a
- 12:16particular market. So I think it's, it's, it's
- 12:19having that discipline, isn't it, of understanding the current
- 12:21process. But equally, and this is the
- 12:24important thing I find with with technology is if you're going to
- 12:27buy into a new tech, whether it's a Shopify pods or another
- 12:31pods, to then say, no, we want to, we want to bend that entire
- 12:35tech to do exactly how we currently work our processes is
- 12:38the wrong way of thinking things.
- 12:40Because you, you probably, if you've got to completely hack a
- 12:43tech in order to get your process support, you've probably
- 12:45got the wrong tech rather than, well, actually what, how does
- 12:48our process fit into this new environment?
- 12:50And is this the right process and are there?
- 12:52Things that we do now that aren't best practice and we
- 12:54shouldn't be supporting them because that will simplify us
- 12:57going forward. Yeah, certainly we we see a lot
- 13:01of kind of work flow mapping in, in kind of retail discovery.
- 13:07And it it I'd say I said there's a lot more nuance that happens
- 13:11in retail in comparison to E com.
- 13:13And, you know, we're, we're in a blessed position where E com,
- 13:16I'd like to say is, is relatively predictable because
- 13:19is, is, is, you know, is unique as a storefront experience.
- 13:22Maybe the fundamental phases of e-commerce and the checkout and
- 13:27how orders are managed is is by and large predictable.
- 13:31But when it comes to workflows, and I and I emphasize the point
- 13:35in store workflows that are not transactional, that is an
- 13:38absolute black hole and no one, no one, everyone does it
- 13:42differently. You know, do your products come
- 13:44barcoded? Who's printing the barcodes?
- 13:46Where are they printed? Have you got the right hardware?
- 13:48All that kind of info, you have to go in with your eyes open
- 13:53because, you know, I've made assumptions in the past,
- 13:56assumptions that I consider safe assumptions and you know, it,
- 14:01it's OK. Well, actually, yeah, that that
- 14:03store, because it's an outlet store, uses actually slightly
- 14:05different barcodes to the rest of the store.
- 14:08Oh, OK. Oh, that's, that's, you know,
- 14:10oh, and the 2D barcodes as well. Oh, all right.
- 14:12OK. So yeah, it's, it's, it can be,
- 14:16it can be a labyrinth for sure. Yeah, I think this this stuff
- 14:19tells nice into the next question around the hardware
- 14:21considerations because I I what you've just said just trigger me
- 14:24from another project where I've got a client at the moment.
- 14:26And one of the reasons they're not considering Shopify pods as
- 14:29a phase one is because of the complexity around the custom
- 14:31development they've done. And they've got custom
- 14:33integrations on the existing pods for things like specific
- 14:37size, receipt printing and all the.
- 14:40So they've spent money investing that and you can't replicate it.
- 14:43You'd either have to RIP it up and do something different or
- 14:46you'd have to custom build it again.
- 14:49But it you're right in leaks, they've got a they've got a
- 14:52specific type of printer, which are the pods as connected, which
- 14:55leads on to the hardware question in stores.
- 14:57And when you switch pause, it's not just a software decision.
- 15:00It's a hardware because the new software you might want to buy
- 15:03that might deliver a great UI and advantages from an Omni
- 15:07channel point of view suddenly isn't compatible with existing
- 15:10hardware tech. You got to go through hardware
- 15:11selection plus that's a change in the store.
- 15:14It could also remain mean moving from desk terminals into mobile
- 15:19like tablet based terminals. So what what?
- 15:22Where do you see? How do you see the challenge of
- 15:24this and like how do you help customers understand what the
- 15:27impact is and make the right decisions?
- 15:29Well, first thing, obviously you can't, you can't do it with
- 15:32testing and validation when it comes to to hardware.
- 15:35And what one thing I also would say is obviously Shopify
- 15:38themselves will advocate for certain hardware and there'll be
- 15:41things on their website you can buy the kits and things like
- 15:44that. I generally wouldn't advise that
- 15:48the the list of compatible hardware is really broad,
- 15:52particularly down to things I know it sounds, this sounds
- 15:55trivial, Even things like the actual stand and the way in
- 15:57which the iPod is mounted in the store, there's so many more
- 16:01options out there just to make things a bit more ergonomic.
- 16:04You can flip the kind of actual thing around.
- 16:06You can get everything nicely kind of mounted into the desk,
- 16:09you know, the cable showing. So there is there is the
- 16:12perception that I think the hardware that Shopify advocates
- 16:17for and would recommend that hasn't really changed a great
- 16:21deal in the last few years. Granted POSPOS Hub has been
- 16:27announced that's now in general release that is again another
- 16:29fantastic nod to how we're supporting enterprise merchants,
- 16:32larger merchants that have a store estate to need all the
- 16:35remote monitoring. But all that's done is just
- 16:38opened up. And I suppose the availability
- 16:41to a broader set of hardware like barcode scanners, for
- 16:44example, you know, practically limitless amount of barcode
- 16:46scanners you can go and do. You're not just limited to the
- 16:49little kind of socket scanners that Shopify advise.
- 16:52So I'd always say hardware selection, definitely test it,
- 16:56but that's kind of half the equation because then you've got
- 16:58your actual existing store state hardware, your Wi-Fi, your
- 17:02firewalls and all that kind of stuff.
- 17:05That's where it puts simply. You just need really good to
- 17:08coordination with iti always say as well, if you're going live in
- 17:12a store, definitely get a unit in the store in the back office.
- 17:16But basically it's a physical staging site, you know, get
- 17:19people playing around with it, see if it all works, get on the
- 17:21network. It's, it's never one to be an
- 17:24afterthought. The hardware, you know, people
- 17:27are very much living with it day in, day out.
- 17:29So it's generally hardware discovering.
- 17:32Procurement would do right at the start.
- 17:34At the same time, we would do the the discovery and
- 17:36feasibility analysis. Great.
- 17:39And I guess you see you and I, as James said, have been working
- 17:43or not you and I because I've certainly not going to bother,
- 17:45but we've been all about your career to the project.
- 17:48But you and people from our team have been working on a mutual
- 17:52project recently. And within that, there was quite
- 17:54a lot of custom requirements that you guys have built
- 17:57solutions for what where do you see custom development needed
- 18:04most commonly and what are the kind of gotchas I guess here?
- 18:09Oh, there's, there's quite a few and I'd say there's rarely kind
- 18:14of key themes to where custom development's required.
- 18:16I do see it as a massive opportunity to kind of sand off
- 18:20the the sharp edges of the platform, particularly in a kind
- 18:24of change management sense. So if you're able to get kind of
- 18:28the client to walk you through their existing system and
- 18:31they're used to seeing say it might be advised, products,
- 18:36complete bundles, just kind of visual UI prompts on the screen
- 18:42that everyone's very used to and it all works.
- 18:44If you're able to then kind of just build little UI extension
- 18:47to replicate that. That really helps.
- 18:51There's, there's a lot to be said for the ecosystem.
- 18:57I'd say obviously the Shopify ecosystem as far as econ's
- 19:00concerned is really diverse, well trodden path in the context
- 19:05of retail. I'd say definitely don't dismiss
- 19:08it because it is, don't get wrong, it is budding.
- 19:12You know, there's a lot of apps out there.
- 19:13There's a lot of people that are kind of moving out there with
- 19:16the the intention of building for PLS.
- 19:20It just needs, you just need to try them out.
- 19:22So few things that come to mind immediately are roles often
- 19:26closing the gap between, you know, what should happen in a
- 19:30store outside of transactional workflows.
- 19:33The things like label printing, stock takes, transfer orders is
- 19:38common. Now you're either going to be
- 19:41doing that natively within an existing system like a, you
- 19:45know, an ERP or NetSuite or something or a Shopify app.
- 19:50So things like I'd say just off the top of my head, things like
- 19:53shop fields, brilliant Shopify app for POS for essentially
- 19:58custom fields, adding fields to line items, adding fields to
- 20:01orders. Often you'll find, particularly
- 20:04with clients that have got very rigid requirements around ERP
- 20:08that there needs to be certain fields populated.
- 20:10So again, that is a lovely off the shelf app and sports
- 20:14conditional logic for showing fields depending on the
- 20:17characteristics of the order. But yeah, it's just, it's just
- 20:21exploring that ecosystem. I wouldn't, I wouldn't seek to
- 20:24go and develop something without properly investigating that
- 20:28because it is a, it's a hot space at the moment, I'd say.
- 20:32Yeah, absolutely. So you just you just mentioned
- 20:35mapping fields from a kind of operational ERP back office
- 20:39perspective. We, we had a question around
- 20:43kind of how do you manage some of the back office complexities
- 20:49because I'm sure you've worked with lots of brands or retailers
- 20:52sort of got kind of legacy, yeah, back office systems that
- 20:57are, you know, really annoying to integrate with.
- 21:00And then you've got like how those have them been set up and
- 21:03how data structured everything cut us.
- 21:06How can you get around those types of situations with POS?
- 21:11Well, the to the first point about integration, there's one
- 21:15thing I've learned with the retail is that one of the most
- 21:17important things is attribution tracking, particularly large
- 21:22store estate very, very common to start doing things like pay
- 21:25by link, IE I've kind of semi served this order and they're
- 21:29going to give you a draft order, you go and check it out three
- 21:32weeks later. Is that going to be attribute to
- 21:34me or is that going to go to E com?
- 21:36So those kind that that is a quite a common gotcha of OK,
- 21:41where's the origin location of that order and how we actually
- 21:45mapping the attribution back. And similar to what I mentioned
- 21:48about the discovery, having a really kind of robust tech
- 21:54partner or using a really good eye pass, particularly with
- 21:57someone in the room from ECOM, I will can't stress that enough,
- 22:01particularly if you're kind of tacking PLS onto an existing
- 22:03Shopify instance is really useful because there's often
- 22:08cases where, OK, we've had to support Shopify web orders and
- 22:11we're doing all this quirky stuff.
- 22:13But technically speaking, those integration flows are by and
- 22:17large the same. So that that kind of quirky
- 22:20stuff you might have done for ECOM might have to either be
- 22:24changed. It might not be respected.
- 22:27And it's kind of keeping close, close contact and close sharing
- 22:31of context between what would be an econ team and then when a lot
- 22:36of businesses, a tech team or an IT team.
- 22:40And that's either an amazing relationship or it's oil of
- 22:43water. And you kind of need to really
- 22:45push them together to work out what needs to change.
- 22:48But yeah, you can't. You can't test.
- 22:50You can't test the integration side enough.
- 22:53One of the areas I want to get into a bit more into is Omni
- 22:55channel because I think I think there's a lot of use of the term
- 22:59and actually when people use it, it often means very superficial
- 23:02things like I'll be able to store stock and that's it's not
- 23:05really Omni channel user journeys, is it?
- 23:08It's just a data point surfaced on another channel.
- 23:11The bits where we're actually retail staff are really
- 23:14interested in is I've got a customer, I want to know what's
- 23:18been happening with them, what products they've been looking
- 23:20at, what's been in their basket. They come into the store and say
- 23:23they've been looking at something.
- 23:24I don't know what they're looking at.
- 23:25How can I help them? How do I find it?
- 23:26They can't remember. And it's that ability for, for
- 23:30that data from an online to be accessible to store.
- 23:34So I'd love it in that context. So we talked about this and I
- 23:36think you probably, I mean, you, you've got a better detail as
- 23:39well as things like a customer who's created a basket on the
- 23:41website, They come into store and say, oh, I've got this thing
- 23:44in my basket and the people go where and they can't see it.
- 23:46That's a blocked Omni channel journey.
- 23:49Where is Shopify POS strong now and where are its gaps?
- 23:54So it is very, very strong. Essentially if we break it down,
- 23:58all shop IPS is doing is either surfacing data or we're
- 24:02gathering data, the mechanism in which we're displaying it to an
- 24:05operator. So someone actually at the POS
- 24:08device is really slick and really quick.
- 24:11So historically in a lot of legacy systems, it's quite
- 24:17common to see an E com integration.
- 24:18But because that was calling it from E Com, it wasn't very
- 24:22trusted. It always took a while to load.
- 24:24It just wasn't particularly fluid.
- 24:26So things like loyalty, wish lists, Omni channel order
- 24:32history, I'd say a really strong and they're strong because
- 24:37they're native to the platform. When you're using, you're using
- 24:40Shopify core as that explain it, you wouldn't necessarily be
- 24:43reliant on data being passed from external means, again,
- 24:48dependent on things like permissions and store workflows,
- 24:50but the ability to return products from another store and
- 24:54just scan a receipt and everything be visible.
- 24:57And that is particularly strong. I can see it getting stronger
- 25:02and stronger little things. I'm talking things like customer
- 25:04meta fields being visible in POS.
- 25:06That was a that's a big thing. Everyone was waiting for that
- 25:08for a really long time. So in the context of Omni
- 25:14channels, well, another point as well, when I deal with retail
- 25:18teams, they would typically perceive the typically see like
- 25:22E com and the website as almost like the enemy against retail.
- 25:27So assuming the narrative is right, this is a really good
- 25:32opportunity to reverse the narrative and the website be
- 25:35essentially an extension of your store.
- 25:38And that's where the kind of pay by link and store originated
- 25:42draft orders is really, really useful.
- 25:46Not just to the sense of, OK, I'm going to put this order on
- 25:49for, you know, Mrs. Smith, put it in.
- 25:51There's your link, away you go. You can get into a kind of
- 25:55borderline clienteling solution with that, whereby stores can
- 25:58then actually have a pipeline of orders that they've sent out.
- 26:02What's going on with those customers?
- 26:03Have they been online since there's been any interaction on
- 26:06their wish list? And I suppose it can.
- 26:09It can unify the focus if nothing else.
- 26:14Yeah, I think that's really nice point actually.
- 26:15And and that it's almost like we planned this episode because
- 26:18that will Duff tail into the next question.
- 26:19Quite it's a bit yeah, I can see that being a really nice one
- 26:23where where the the where it's joined up to the point that that
- 26:27people who have access to like customer service ticketing
- 26:29solutions, whether it's a gorgeous zender.
- 26:31So whoever you're using that ability to, to have the, that
- 26:35unified view where the, the person who's who's originally
- 26:41initiated transaction for store staff has had the first
- 26:43interaction and they've put a basket in and they've put that
- 26:46notice assigned to them. Well, that might actually end up
- 26:49being a, a follow up where the customer needs additional
- 26:53support. And maybe it ends up in Tele
- 26:54sales queue and that Tele sales person closes it.
- 26:56But they've got the details and the the history, but the store
- 26:59person gets the recognition and now we've got a proper joined up
- 27:02process. Exactly, Yeah, exactly.
- 27:05And I think, I think to to the point about the the the platform
- 27:09as well. I think Shopify is a brilliant
- 27:11foundation, but really the onus is on kind of merchants to
- 27:16enhance the coal Omni channel experience with the ecosystem.
- 27:21So what I was speaking to client a week ago about reporting
- 27:25attribution, things like visits, accounting that's coming up in
- 27:28conversation a lot more and actually tracking conversion
- 27:31rates in store and how can I actually interact with Shopify.
- 27:35Seen some brilliant things around loyalty about not
- 27:38necessarily tracking transactions, but tracking store
- 27:42visits. So using things like Apple
- 27:45Wallet to surface the pass and then kind of know if that
- 27:49person's been in the vicinity of a store and has that person then
- 27:52visited. There's a lot that you can do
- 27:53with it. But put bluntly, a lot of
- 27:57clients that I'm speaking to and dealing with at the moment, it
- 28:00is very much about the foundations and getting a really
- 28:03robust foundations in much like ecom and then tacking this stuff
- 28:06on later or integrating their existing tech.
- 28:09And we're at a we're an interesting point, I think of of
- 28:13maturity where, you know, those serious conversations are
- 28:16happening and I think the app ecosystems just lagging behind.
- 28:21So, you know, give it a year or so, I think we'll be having more
- 28:24and more interesting conversations.
- 28:26Yeah. And I think there's a really
- 28:27good point to see Zach, because we want people coming away from
- 28:29our podcast having like a real practical view and seeing where
- 28:32something's really good, but where there are gaps, they have
- 28:34to ask better questions to plug those gaps.
- 28:37And yeah, the ecosystem is a good one because yeah, we we
- 28:39talked about it before we would, we started recording this about
- 28:41one of the areas we both have found is finance and where you
- 28:46have a finance option in the checkout and that's a third
- 28:48party and you have to go through that third party flow for the
- 28:50authorization piece. But finance where they app not
- 28:55for the econ, but no app for parts.
- 28:58So finance is 1 area where there's a gap and that creates
- 29:00extra costs. And I've seen it in mind there's
- 29:02a bit of additional cost crept into the project that wasn't
- 29:05anticipated when we initially ballpark pause.
- 29:09Where else do you see the gaps? What other kind of functional
- 29:11areas where the ecosystem is not quite as mature as the ECOM
- 29:14side? There's a few key themes, which
- 29:18I'll mention in a second, but I suppose the granular nature of
- 29:23POS workflows will dictate ideally A deeper discovery.
- 29:29So if I was to give a laundry list, it'd be really lengthy,
- 29:33but the likelihood of the matching impacts of merchants
- 29:35would be very, very slim. I'll give you an example so you
- 29:38can kind of get a sense of it. So someone coming into a store
- 29:41to exchange an item, but the item that they're exchanging not
- 29:47being available in that store. So they're essentially bringing
- 29:49a physical item back, but they're exchanging for a mail
- 29:51order. Now that's where Shopify is a
- 29:54lack of kind of inventory management maturity is it's
- 29:57downfall. And that is a key theme
- 30:00throughout POS. And, and you know, dare I say
- 30:03Shopify as well as a platform inventory management is
- 30:07maturing, but in my opinion a bit too slowly in comparison
- 30:11with the, the actual platform and the, the general robustness
- 30:14of everything else. Inventory just just needs to
- 30:18level up. And there's, there's, there's so
- 30:20many areas without bleeding too key things as well.
- 30:24We've been kind of, everyone's been talking about gift cards,
- 30:27multi channel gift cards for a while.
- 30:28So we've got retail catalogues that support multi currency,
- 30:31multi entity. We haven't got gift cards that
- 30:34natively support that. So clients are leaning on third
- 30:37parties and things. B to BI was kind of surprised by
- 30:42that not being supported because it is a catalog and retail
- 30:45catalog are supported, but we haven't got B to B support yet.
- 30:48So company catalogues aren't supported.
- 30:52They're the key ones. But yeah, there's just, there's
- 30:54so many little granular areas where you'll think, oh, you
- 30:56should do that, why doesn't it do that?
- 30:58Yeah, it's just the strength of discovery, really.
- 31:03Right. And then we've added in a new
- 31:06question while you've been talking because you're really
- 31:09interesting one and but what are some of the most challenging
- 31:13implementations that you've worked on and also some that
- 31:17have had large amount of systems?
- 31:20OK. And also, why were they
- 31:23challenging and what did you learn from it?
- 31:28So this isn't, this isn't one that's actually started yet, but
- 31:31it's the feasibility analysis that's very, very interesting.
- 31:35This is anytime a product is a variable in any kind of nature,
- 31:40I, I tend to wince a bit. So made to order NCO products is
- 31:45always a key one. But I had a curveball from a
- 31:48client a couple of months ago who wanted to sell products by
- 31:51weight, but then also in code weight based barcodes.
- 31:54So is actually using pricing scales and then printing,
- 31:57printing much like you would do in say on a butcher's or
- 32:00something like that. My initial reaction was
- 32:04absolutely not a chance. This is thank you very much for
- 32:06thinking about us, but absolutely not.
- 32:09But turns out there is said hearing that.
- 32:12Yeah, they don't. Want to believe in implementers
- 32:14of? No, we're not doing.
- 32:15Yeah, yeah. Well, I think they, I think they
- 32:18thought it was a bit of a a bit of a point of an ask anyway, but
- 32:23it turns out that it's possible. There is a company in Canada,
- 32:28company name escapes me, but they do, there is a Shopify app
- 32:32that connects to certain scales that will do variable based
- 32:35pricing and it connects to POS5 Bluetooth and it's really slick.
- 32:40So yeah, I kind of bit my tongue with no, it can't do that and
- 32:44thought there's this company, it's probably worth having a
- 32:47conversation. And yeah, that was, that was a
- 32:51surprising 1. So yeah, they're, they're
- 32:54contemplating that at the moment.
- 32:55So that was. How did you discover that?
- 32:59Because that that's not like a ChatGPT.
- 33:02Find me this news case. There's a real niche service.
- 33:07Yeah. So I mean that that's one of our
- 33:09existing clients and on the road map was and it always tends to
- 33:12start of, oh, you know, Joe, we want to do Omni channel gift
- 33:16cards and then obviously all gift cards turns into oh, well,
- 33:19you know, if we've got shop IPS anyway, can we do a bit of
- 33:21discovery around this? And the app that I was using for
- 33:25variably variable based products I've actually used in the past,
- 33:29but not with the scales. The scales is a new one on me.
- 33:32So thinking. So yeah, I always enjoy
- 33:35something like that where it's completely different.
- 33:39I'd say what else? Yeah.
- 33:41And MTO again, it's, it's always variable things.
- 33:43And so nto products, that was interesting.
- 33:49And I suppose it doesn't answer the question directly, but a
- 33:52general point I really wanted to make was this particular client
- 33:56add nto products, the transactional workflow required
- 33:59for made to order involved other steps.
- 34:04So things like disclaimer forms, so they had triplicate paper
- 34:08that had to be scanned and all that kind of stuff.
- 34:11Now, if you can think of POS as a as a surface beyond just
- 34:17transactional stuff, you know, it's a means to show customers
- 34:20forms and actually kind of get an involved in the transaction.
- 34:24That's when particularly retail leaders get really excited about
- 34:27it because that is actually very positive unification because all
- 34:32the little gaps that fall down when things don't get stapled
- 34:35and sent to the right person or go on to NetSuite, there's less
- 34:39chance for error and it's a more engaging process for for the
- 34:43client. So that is a very interesting
- 34:46use case. And that's a good theme actually
- 34:48to explore in, in Discovery, you know, we're not just focused
- 34:52about, you know, necessary transactional stuff.
- 34:54Where can it actually help beyond the the transaction
- 34:58itself? Yeah, the what what I've really
- 35:01enjoyed in the in the last discovery I did was around the
- 35:05the inventory and the stock status and the lead time.
- 35:08And actually the challenge is when you have like you said,
- 35:11you've got made to order products and the lead times vary
- 35:13massively. You have in stock items, but
- 35:15those in stock are either physically stocked in a
- 35:17warehouse or they're incoming on POS and certain certain POS,
- 35:21sorry and seller he owes that are sellable and others that
- 35:24aren't. And then you've you've realised
- 35:26that there isn't just this, Oh, is it in stock?
- 35:29Is it not? No, it's is it in stock?
- 35:31Is it incoming? Can we sell from incoming?
- 35:33So what's the available on hand then in a store?
- 35:36You have store stock across the store estate, but some store
- 35:39stocks only display stock or not walk away stock.
- 35:41So partly soles and somebody coming into store A wants to
- 35:46look at product B, but it's not available.
- 35:48But actually you can look up the the the display stock and you
- 35:52then you have you, you initially go mad and think you're in some
- 35:56opiate nightmare and then you actually realise that it's a
- 35:59logic tree. And I think one of the biggest
- 36:02challenges with these things is building a logic tree and define
- 36:05it clearly before you even try to solution.
- 36:08It, it's a really good point. He's giving me flashbacks then
- 36:11to another, another furniture, another furniture on.
- 36:15And that was, that was a really interesting use case actually,
- 36:17because when we broke, when we broke down the requirements, we
- 36:21often use like an incumbent system as, OK, what's this
- 36:24doing? What's it used to day-to-day?
- 36:27That was the first mistake because this incumbent system
- 36:29was just so far too much information for someone behind
- 36:32the tail. So I'd say that's a kind of a
- 36:34point to take away really is, you know, if you're, if you're
- 36:37designing this system based upon something overly complex, then
- 36:41it's going to be an uphill struggle anyway.
- 36:43And it was actually on NTO and saleable stock.
- 36:47So it was how within Shopify POS can we present the available
- 36:54kind of unallocated stock that is on open PO that will arrive
- 36:59within the kind of X amount of weeks?
- 37:02Now this is always a challenge because you know, Shopify has
- 37:05these different statuses, but the amount of clients have
- 37:08actually seen use purchases and transfers in Shopify probably
- 37:11count on one hand because of it's just immature.
- 37:15You know, the last few, I think only, you know, 2-3 weeks ago
- 37:20we've had the ability to actually receive inbound
- 37:24transfers directly on POS natively.
- 37:27So the realistically that that solution is where you draw the
- 37:31line. And we went for the simplest
- 37:34solution, which was let's just get some pinned meta fields,
- 37:37retail specific meta fields, sync the data in from ERP and
- 37:41essentially set a default location as the warehouse for
- 37:45selling those particular products.
- 37:47So yeah, it always tends to be inventory workflows that that
- 37:51scope of viability. So yeah, it's it's an
- 37:56interesting one. Yeah, the the fun one that we
- 37:59had was the client sells off multiple POS and each PO is a
- 38:03different lead time and they want to display the most
- 38:05relevant lead time based on the the quantity this customer.
- 38:10So imagine there's, there's none in stock, but there's five on
- 38:13APO and they're due in two weeks and there's another 5 on another
- 38:16PO during four weeks, but a current wants to buy six that
- 38:19eats into the second PO. Therefore, the logic has to know
- 38:23that only 5 are held on the first one we're into the second
- 38:26one. Now update the the metal fuel
- 38:28value that is 4 weeks so that the store staff have accurate
- 38:31lead times. So the promise to the customer
- 38:34and then that is imprinted into the order as a line item
- 38:36attribute. So that is stored in case
- 38:38someone comes out, comes out of seven.
- 38:39So I thought it was only two weeks.
- 38:41So you got all I think I think stuff like that is brilliant.
- 38:44I mean, you see people weeping in rooms, but it's.
- 38:46Yeah, yeah, yeah. You've, you've reminded me of
- 38:50probably one of the most granular limitations that we'll
- 38:52disclose before people get caught out, which is so Shopify
- 38:56will natively support essentially split fulfillment
- 39:00orders in POS. So and take that away, we're
- 39:02going to ship that to you. But we can't split anything on a
- 39:06line item level. So if we've got 5 cushions, but
- 39:11you know the customer wants 85 are going to be taken away, the
- 39:15rest of them are going to be shipped.
- 39:16We currently cannot do that natively.
- 39:19The only solution is 2 orders, which is horrible.
- 39:24So yeah, it's those little things again that that, that
- 39:27bubble up to the surface generally when it's too late
- 39:31because it is really, really specific.
- 39:32But those again it's just give you that, that perception of
- 39:36maturity or or or kind of lack of maturity for being you know
- 39:39completely candid around inventory and workflows
- 39:43etcetera. And it will it will get there.
- 39:46The direction of travel is really positive.
- 39:47But it's just you know, first questions used you've kind of
- 39:51asking around will it suit you know, particular large sprawl in
- 39:54stores, store estate. Ultimately, it always comes down
- 39:58to the business, the nature of the products, nature of
- 40:00transactions, etcetera and when you are dealing with, you know,
- 40:05their furniture home. Obviously things are
- 40:07significantly more complex. And I guess a a final like catch
- 40:15all one then is what would be on your wish you wish list or no?
- 40:21You've said there's loads of stuff, but let's take away the
- 40:23granular, the rural education stuff.
- 40:25If they could ship one major capability or one major fix
- 40:29improvement, what would it be for you and why?
- 40:32I. The tars tars narrow down to 1
- 40:35because the, the platform, the platform itself, the
- 40:38fundamentals are, are great and again, very stable and very
- 40:42predictable. But there's a few kind of core
- 40:45areas. The, the, the first one being
- 40:48payments. You know, let's, let's let's
- 40:50break that down. You know, it is a retail product
- 40:52and currently the ecosystem or lack thereof around Shopify
- 40:57Payments card processing, particularly if clients can't
- 41:01for every reason use Shopify Payments.
- 41:03So there's kind of commercial concerns around that.
- 41:06Currently it's a non starter. So we've we've not had a great
- 41:10deal of momentum recently from Shopify around what the
- 41:15evolution of Shopify Payments is going to look like as a
- 41:19platform. But I would say that would
- 41:22probably be the biggest game changer for viability,
- 41:25particularly looking at market now there are some interesting
- 41:30signals. So Shopify and Verifone
- 41:33announced a partnership I think about two months ago.
- 41:36So we're going to see some interesting new hardware, I'm
- 41:38sure. And hopefully this is a sign to,
- 41:41you know, things to come in terms of the payment.
- 41:44I suppose the payment network of the payment seats ecosystem
- 41:46becoming a bit more diversified, similar to, I suppose similar to
- 41:50what we've got on ecom. So Shopify Payments being kind
- 41:53of a de facto, but probably the couple of catches along the way.
- 41:57You can use other things as well and still have an integrated
- 42:00experience. Currently it's you Shopify
- 42:02Payments or it's a very unintegrated experience and
- 42:08generally a non starter. Yes, and I won't even get down
- 42:13into the having to pay the transaction, the using third
- 42:17party payment stuff that is honestly makes me but G so but
- 42:24Joel, I really, you know, I've really enjoyed this and I've
- 42:27also I've I've I've learnt loads from you as well, which is
- 42:29great. Thank you for anyone listening
- 42:32whose interest is Pete who wants to reach out and and ask Joe a
- 42:35few questions. You've got these challenges
- 42:37where you want like an objective viewpoint or his contact details
- 42:40are on the landing page. You can go to their website and
- 42:45also you can stalk Joe on LinkedIn.
- 42:47You certainly can. Thank you very much.
- 42:50And yeah, look, thanks so much a lot.
- 42:52I love these episodes because no tech is perfect.
- 42:54And we say this all the time. And understanding the pros and
- 42:57cons and knowing where to ask questions is the critical thing,
- 43:01deceptively. Complex.
- 43:03That's all we'll end up. Yeah, exactly.
- 43:05Well, that's and thanks as always, everyone.
- 43:07Listen. Hope you enjoyed the episode.
- 43:08Any questions, do reach out. We always love a chat.
- 43:12You're listening to the Inside Comments podcast, hosted by
- 43:15experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 43:18Inside Commerce is your fast tracked digital knowledge,
- 43:20featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 43:23industry thought leads and the C-Suite.
- 43:24Key tech companies to explore the latest digital strategy,
- 43:28customer experience and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 43:31really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 43:34to help fine tune your ecom strategy and techs.
- 43:37Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 43:40like to discuss an ecommerce project.
- 43:42We hope you enjoy the latest episode.