Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Policy Limit Demands – The New Legal Landscape: CACI 2334, CCP Section 999 and B
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to today's program, Policy Limit Demands,
- 0:06The New Legal Landscape, CASI 2334, CCP Section
- 0:10999, and Beyond. I'm Alla Policastro, Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:16Beverly Hills Bar Association, and today I am
- 0:19delighted to introduce our speakers, Arne Levinson,
- 0:22Peter Klee, and Daniel Eli. Arnie is a mediator
- 0:25with signature resolution. He brings nearly 40
- 0:28years of legal experience and close to a decade
- 0:31in mediation to his practice. He's a nationally
- 0:33recognized expert in insurance coverage and bad
- 0:36faith law with prestigious industry awards that
- 0:39are far too many to list here today. Peter Klee
- 0:43is a partner in the business trial practice group
- 0:46at Shepherd Mullen based in the firm San Diego
- 0:49office. Over the last four decades, Peter has
- 0:52handled over 3 ,000 bad faith cases, including
- 0:55dozens of jury trials. Peter is a member of ABOTA
- 0:58and a fellow of the American College of Trial
- 1:01Lawyers. He's also a co -author of the Rudder
- 1:03Group's Insurance Litigation California Practice
- 1:06Guide. Last but not least, Daniel Eli is of counsel
- 1:10at Paris Law Firm, where he heads the firm's
- 1:12insurance coverage and bad faith practice. He
- 1:15has devoted his almost 30 years of practice to
- 1:18disputes involving insurance coverage and bad
- 1:20faith. Dan's phenomenal results have earned him
- 1:23recognition in the prestigious Southern California
- 1:26Super Lawyers List since 2011. We can't wait
- 1:28to hear what they have to share with us today,
- 1:30so I'm going to turn it over to our speakers.
- 1:33Thank you. We're lucky to have both Peter and
- 1:38Dan here today who are outstanding experts in
- 1:41this particular area of policy limit demands.
- 1:44We're going to go through the presentation today
- 1:49and we're going to focus on two sources of law
- 1:57here. We're going to focus on Casey 2334, which
- 2:02is a Casey instruction on third party policy
- 2:06limit demands. And then we're going to talk about
- 2:10CCP section 999 to 999 .5, which is the relatively
- 2:15new statute for policy limit demands, which are
- 2:20prior to litigation. And we'll be going through
- 2:22that statute. And as we talk through that statute,
- 2:26we'll break off and talk about some of the key
- 2:28issues. that are in the statute and that also
- 2:32relate to policy limit demands during pending
- 2:38litigation. Let me get the PowerPoint presentation
- 2:41up here. So first we're going to start out with
- 2:55KC 2334. I put a snippet of Casey 2034 in here.
- 3:04These are the two things that we're going to
- 3:06be concentrating on in this presentation. The
- 3:11first is that a claimant made a reasonable demand
- 3:16to settle within his or her policy claim against
- 3:20the insured for an amount within policy limits.
- 3:24The insurer failed to accept the settlement demand
- 3:27and the insurer's failure to accept the settlement
- 3:29demand was the result of unreasonable conduct.
- 3:33We've sort of broken this down into two areas.
- 3:37One is a reasonable policy limit demand and the
- 3:41second is the unreasonable conduct of the insurance
- 3:45company. You've got to establish both at this
- 3:49point, and Peter, a little later in the show,
- 3:52is going to talk about the history and development
- 3:56of this Casey instruction. The pre -litigation
- 4:01statutes apply to demands that started on January
- 4:051st, 2023. We'll look at this statute. The first
- 4:12part of the statute says a policy limit demand
- 4:16must be labeled as a time limit demand or refer
- 4:22to this section. And it must contain the following
- 4:26items, which are fairly significant. The time
- 4:35period has to be 30 days or if it's 33 days by
- 4:38mail. You can't have a shorter period of time
- 4:42than 30 days for a pre -litigation demand. It's
- 4:48got to be a clear and unequivocal offer to settle
- 4:50all claims within the policy limits, including
- 4:53the satisfaction of all liens. We will talk about
- 4:57that concept also a little later in the show.
- 5:01An offer for a complete release from the claimant
- 5:04for the liability insurers insured from all present
- 5:08and future liability for the occurrence again.
- 5:12We'll talk about that a little later in the presentation.
- 5:19The date, location of the loss, the claim number
- 5:21of known, and then these two items are very significant.
- 5:25A description of all known injuries sustained
- 5:28by the claimant, and then probably the key provision
- 5:31is reasonable proof, which may include if applicable,
- 5:35medical records or bills sufficient to support
- 5:39the claim. And note that this section says may
- 5:43include, it doesn't say shall include. So there's
- 5:47a question of what exactly is required under
- 5:49this statute, and Peter and Dan are both going
- 5:52to talk about that. So this brings us to the
- 5:55question of what is a reasonable demand? And
- 6:02for that, our first topic under this is what
- 6:05supporting evidence needs to be submitted or
- 6:08a reasonable demand. And Dan, I'm going to turn
- 6:10it over to you at this point. Thanks, Artie.
- 6:16As a caveat, just to go back to section 999,
- 6:21just point out again. It applies pre -litigation
- 6:25only, so it does not apply to litigation settlement
- 6:28demands, and it only applies to policy limit
- 6:32demands by attorneys. It does not apply to these
- 6:35policy limit demands by individuals. And so when
- 6:39we're talking about this, that's what we're talking
- 6:41about is pre -litigation attorney demands. What
- 6:45supporting evidence needs to be submitted? I
- 6:50maintain and given the nature of my practice,
- 6:53of course, I maintain that it really depends
- 6:56on the circumstances of the case. And depending
- 7:00on what information the insurance company knows,
- 7:04what information is available, you may not need
- 7:07to provide very much. Some of the cases that
- 7:11are up here on this slide, I'll let Peter discuss
- 7:17them. but I don't think they reflect the correct,
- 7:21a lot of them, most of them, all of them are
- 7:23federal cases. I don't know that they reflect
- 7:25the correct California law on the issue. We can
- 7:28address that when Peter gets into it. But the
- 7:31bottom line is, you're really looking for reasonableness.
- 7:34Does the insurance company have enough information
- 7:37indicating that the loss is likely to exceed
- 7:41or substantially likely to exceed whatever the
- 7:43formulation is? the policy limits. And that's
- 7:49really what the statute gets at. The insurance
- 7:51company has to have sufficient information from
- 7:53which it can conclude the value of the claim
- 7:56exceeds the policy limits. Peter, if you want
- 8:02to. Sure, let me jump in. Some of these are Peter's
- 8:05cases. Well, look, let me let me step back for
- 8:10a moment and talk about why 999 was enacted.
- 8:13It was enacted By the legislature in california
- 8:17which everybody knows is a very. Liberal pro
- 8:23planet flora legislature but but the legislature
- 8:26itself recognize that there have been some abuses
- 8:29going on in this area of the law. And they enacted
- 8:32the statute to address those abuses and the interesting
- 8:37thing about the statute is it didn't really create
- 8:39any new law is really a codification of the state
- 8:42of law that existed. before the statute was enacted,
- 8:46but it made it very clear what those rules are
- 8:49regarding settlement demands and what needs to
- 8:51exist and what not exist. So, for example, Ernie
- 8:53just talked about the fact that you have to identify
- 8:56all the known injuries. For those of you that
- 8:59have been practicing in this area, you all know
- 9:01that there are cases where you get a policy limit
- 9:04demand where the claimant intentionally conceals
- 9:07the nature and extent of the injuries because
- 9:09they don't want the insurance company to know
- 9:12that there are significant injuries because they
- 9:15know that if they inform the insurance company
- 9:18of that and they back that up with actual medical
- 9:20information, the case will settle for the policy
- 9:22limit. And that's actually a bad thing if you're
- 9:25a plaintiff lawyer that has a catastrophic or
- 9:29serious injury case in which the limits that
- 9:32are available are well below the total amount
- 9:35of the damages. So What happened is a lot of
- 9:38plaintiff lawyers were engaging in tactics to
- 9:41try to lull the insurance company into not accepting
- 9:44a policy limit demand in a case in which the
- 9:47damage has vastly exceeded the demand. And so
- 9:50the 999 was enacted in part to address some of
- 9:54those problems. And the two provisions that Arnie
- 9:59talked about a moment ago that he said were among
- 10:03the more important ones were Basically providing
- 10:06the insurance company with information that is
- 10:08known by the claimants attorney and also providing
- 10:11medical records to back up that information because
- 10:14you can't just make a demand and say either hide
- 10:17hide the nature and extent of your clients injuries
- 10:19or. Make claims that the injuries are super significant
- 10:23but not provide medical information that actually
- 10:25backs it up insurance companies are required
- 10:28to rely on. uncorroborated assertions of medical
- 10:33injury. And so that was a big problem where they
- 10:35would get claims that the claimant had suffered
- 10:38a brain injury, but there would be no record
- 10:40medical records to support it. And a lot of insurance
- 10:44companies were sued for not accepting policy
- 10:47limit demands under circumstances like that.
- 10:49So this statute addresses that situation and
- 10:53it requires that the claimant attorney disclose
- 10:57The true nature and extent of the injuries and.
- 11:01Ordinarily that support those with corroborating
- 11:04evidence, which ordinarily would mean medical
- 11:06records and bills. Now the cases that are shown
- 11:08on this screen. McGranahan Capital Specialty
- 11:12and Spradlin are cases where the insurance company
- 11:17was not provided with actual medical information
- 11:20that corroborated the claimed injuries and the
- 11:23courts in those cases held that. That was not
- 11:27a reasonable demand in the insurance company
- 11:28was not obligated to accept it because they are
- 11:31entitled to medical information and just stepping
- 11:33back for a moment. Just ask yourselves why wouldn't
- 11:36insurance company be entitled to the actual medical
- 11:39information that supports a claim i miss pretty
- 11:41basic element of a claim for personal injury
- 11:44insurance companies at least we argue and have
- 11:47successfully argued are entitled to that information
- 11:50at least enough information to show that it's
- 11:52worth the policy number more. and if it's not
- 11:55provided, then they shouldn't be held liable
- 11:58for not accepting a demand that's not supported
- 12:01by that information. Yeah, I would just, you
- 12:07know, I'm going to respectfully disagree with
- 12:12Peter that this statute was somehow the legislature's
- 12:17response to a need in the legal field. If you
- 12:24actually trace this piece of legislation back,
- 12:28it was enacted as part and parcel with raising
- 12:30the minimum liability limits from 30 ,000 to
- 12:3260 ,000. I wasn't involved with the statute,
- 12:36but My understanding is it was basically a deal
- 12:38made between the plaintiff's bar and the defense
- 12:41bar, the insurance companies, that the insurance
- 12:44companies would not object to raising the limits
- 12:46and the plaintiff's bar would not object to the
- 12:49statute. I think that's what drove the statute.
- 12:53I also disagree that the statute codifies existing
- 12:56law. It doesn't. Nothing in existing law required
- 13:00a 30 -day acceptance period for policy limit
- 13:04demand. Nothing in existing law said that a request
- 13:09for additional time doesn't constitute a rejection.
- 13:14This statute was drafted by the insurance industry
- 13:18to protect against open limits claims. And I
- 13:24do think this statute does change significantly
- 13:27California law because there's a thing called
- 13:29a duty to investigate. An insurance company owes
- 13:32its obligations not to the claimant, not to the
- 13:36person that's injured. They owe their obligations
- 13:37to the policyholder. If you're an insurance company
- 13:40and you get a police report that says the claimant
- 13:45has been rendered a paraplegic, based on the
- 13:49police department's investigation that places
- 13:51the insured at fault for the loss, why would
- 13:54you need medical records or medical billing to
- 13:58determine that the loss exceeds $15 ,000? You
- 14:02don't need any of that information. Based on
- 14:04the information that you have, it is clear that
- 14:07someone that's in a wheelchair, paraplegic, quadriplegic,
- 14:11if there's been a death, it's clear that the
- 14:14loss exceeds the policy limits. And I think that's
- 14:17why the statute's written the way it is, by the
- 14:19way. It's, you know, reasonable proof. It's not
- 14:23medical records. If the statute required medical
- 14:26records, it would have so provided. It's reasonable
- 14:29proof of the value. And some of these cases,
- 14:33like for example, McGranahan versus Geico, is
- 14:36a case where you have, I believe it was a motorcycle
- 14:38accident, I believe it was $100 ,000 in limits,
- 14:42but it was a Prop 213 case. And the insurance
- 14:46company, Geico, was attempting to find out what
- 14:49the medical specials were, because under Prop
- 14:52213, you can't recover pain and suffering. It's
- 14:56only your special damages. And couldn't get that
- 15:01information from the claimant, including after
- 15:04a policy limit demand was made. And there the
- 15:06court said, look, without medical... billing
- 15:11information, the insurance company was reasonable
- 15:13and not accepting the demand. Capital Specialty
- 15:18was a similar situation. It was a Prop 213 case,
- 15:22horrific accident, but Prop 213, the insurance
- 15:26company attempted to get medical billing. They
- 15:29couldn't, and I believe in Capital Specialty,
- 15:31they actually had medical records indicating
- 15:33that it was a severe injury, but the court said,
- 15:35look, they needed medical billing to assess whether
- 15:38it's worth I want to say in that case, it was
- 15:41a $50 ,000 policy. And so what is reasonable,
- 15:47what is required is necessarily going to be based
- 15:51on the individual facts of this case. In Intagon
- 15:55Preferred Insurance versus Saavedra there, that's
- 16:00an order denying a motion for a new trial by
- 16:03the insurance company. And a similar argument
- 16:06to what was made in McGradahan and Capital Specialty
- 16:08was made. An Intagon carrier said, we didn't
- 16:13have billing records. We didn't have medical
- 16:17records. And therefore, we couldn't accept the
- 16:19demand. And Judge Wu of the central district
- 16:21said, no, you had other information. It was clear
- 16:25that the case was worth $15 ,000 and denied the
- 16:28motion for a new trial after a jury verdict finding
- 16:31the insurance company acted unreasonably. What
- 16:35I was getting at is, there are statements in
- 16:37the Granahan and Capital Specialty and in Spradlin
- 16:40to the effect that without medical billing or
- 16:43without medical records, it is not a reasonable
- 16:46demand. You have to consider all those statements
- 16:49in context of the facts of the individual case.
- 16:53What is reasonable proof in one case may not
- 16:57be necessary in another case, just given the
- 17:00facts of the loss. Be labor this point i agree
- 17:05with dan that you do need to look at the individual
- 17:07facts of the case to determine what an appropriate
- 17:09outcome would be but these the general rule that
- 17:12medical. Records that insurance companies entitled
- 17:15them i think has been recognized over and over
- 17:18by. By courts the in the intercom case where
- 17:22as dan mentioned the court said that they didn't
- 17:25need the medical records well. the insurance
- 17:27company's employees in that case all testified
- 17:31that they didn't need the medical records in
- 17:33order to determine that the claim was worth more
- 17:35than the policy limit. So that case doesn't stand
- 17:39for the proposition that an insurance company
- 17:41that believes it does need medical records is
- 17:45acting in bad faith if it asks for them. And
- 17:48lastly, before we move on to the slide, I'd encourage
- 17:52those who are interested to read the Ninth Circuit
- 17:57Unpublished Opinion in McGrathahan was a two
- 18:00-three decision, well, two -one decision, sorry,
- 18:04one justice dissented, and that justice said,
- 18:06even on the facts of McGrathahan, it should have
- 18:09gone to the jury. And so just, if anything goes
- 18:12to show you that, you know, what's reasonable
- 18:14is subject to argument, and again, it's a very
- 18:17fact -specific analysis. So it sounds like What
- 18:23you're saying, Dan, is that there are situations
- 18:26where the insurance company might want further
- 18:28information, because that's the way they normally
- 18:31do it. But you're saying that in certain situations,
- 18:35they have enough information, even though they
- 18:37want more information. They have enough information
- 18:41to know that it's a policy limit case. And in
- 18:44those situations, they don't have the right to
- 18:46go ahead and ask for more information that they
- 18:49don't necessarily need. That's basically it.
- 18:53I mean, it really depends on what the insurance
- 18:55company knows, what's available to them. And,
- 18:59you know, a lot of this turns on the policy limit.
- 19:01If you have a million dollar policy limit, obviously
- 19:03you need a little more information to justify
- 19:05it. If you have a minimum policy, 15 or 30 now,
- 19:09you don't need very much if it's a severe loss.
- 19:13to justify paying the policy limits. So like
- 19:16I said, it's a highly factual analysis and it's
- 19:21based on individual facts of each case. I'm not
- 19:25sure you disagree with that proposition, Peter.
- 19:30I agree with the proposition that if the insurance
- 19:33company has sufficient information to know its
- 19:35policy limit case, that it should tender the
- 19:38limits in response to a policy limit demand.
- 19:40But the issue is whether it's entitled to actual
- 19:43medical records corroborating the nature and
- 19:45extent of the injuries. And that's what each
- 19:46of those courts that are listed on the slide
- 19:50here found. The first three cases found that
- 19:53they were entitled to that information. They
- 19:55don't have to just speculate about what the actual
- 19:59nature and extent is and or what the medical
- 20:01billing is. They're entitled to actually get
- 20:02that information and just stepping back and looking
- 20:05at it from a practical standpoint. Why not just
- 20:08give the insurance company the medical records
- 20:10that show what the injury is? I mean, there's
- 20:12no reason not to do that other than to, you know,
- 20:17be trying to set the insurance company up so
- 20:20that they won't accept the demand. And then you
- 20:21can argue that they should have known that the
- 20:24injuries were worth more than the policy limit
- 20:28at the time that they didn't accept the demand.
- 20:31So do you think it's it's it's not a reasonable
- 20:35demand if as Dan said, somebody's a quadriplegic
- 20:39or a paraplegic and you've got a 15 ,030 policy
- 20:43or a 3060 policy, that you would still need the
- 20:47medical records to make that a reasonable demand?
- 20:52I think that if you have information showing
- 20:55that the claimant is a quadriplegic because of
- 20:57the accident, then you have an obligation to
- 21:01pay a lot more than $15 ,000 if your limit is
- 21:03higher than that. That my point is, though, that
- 21:06you are entitled to get information actually
- 21:08corroborating the nature and extent of the injuries,
- 21:10at least to the extent to show that they exceed
- 21:14the policy limit. In your hypothetical, Arnie,
- 21:17if they knew that the claimant was a quadriplegic
- 21:21because of the accident, then that's all they
- 21:23need to know. And that's the whole point. How
- 21:24do they know that? They don't know that because
- 21:26the lawyer said my client's a paraplegic or the
- 21:29claimant said I'm in the hospital and I'm a paraplegic.
- 21:32They know that because they actually got objective
- 21:35evidence establishing the nature and extent of
- 21:37the injury. Which would be the medical records
- 21:40would be the primary evidence. The primary. And
- 21:44I want to agree with Dan, if it's a wrongful
- 21:47death, maybe you don't need medical records because
- 21:48they're not going to determine what the injury
- 21:50is. A death certificate would do that. But are
- 21:53you entitled to a death certificate or some other
- 21:55objective proof of the death? Yes, you are. OK.
- 22:00All right, well, let's move on. The next issue
- 22:03is whether all claimants need to be part of the
- 22:06demand. And I should modify that a little bit
- 22:11to include whether all people that might be claimants
- 22:15need to be part of the demand. Dan, what's your
- 22:19take on that? Yeah, I think in not anyone. we
- 22:23wouldn't be there that you're citing. I think,
- 22:25yeah, absolutely. If there are multiple claimants,
- 22:28well, let me qualify that. It really depends
- 22:32on the policy limits. If you have a 1530 policy
- 22:36or 3060 policy now and you have 200 claimants,
- 22:41each claimant can make their own demand. Each
- 22:43can demand 30 ,000 because you don't have a limits
- 22:45issue or you don't have a potential of exhausting
- 22:47the limits while leaving other claimants out
- 22:49there. So if you have, let's say, 100, 300 thousand
- 22:53dollar policy and there are three claimants.
- 22:55Each claimant can make their own independent
- 22:57demand without joining the other claimants in
- 23:00the demand. If however you have more claimants
- 23:03than per person limits, for example on a 3060
- 23:07you have three claimants If you're gonna demand
- 23:11the policy, you're gonna need to join the other
- 23:15claimants, or there has to be some significant
- 23:17information out there indicating that the other
- 23:20two claimants, their claims will not exceed the
- 23:24other $30 ,000 policy limit. That's my take on
- 23:28it. So for example, if you have... three claimants
- 23:31that are injured. One person's in a wheelchair.
- 23:33The other two, you know, soft tissue. They went
- 23:36to the emergency room and never treated again.
- 23:38I don't know that the person that's in the wheelchair
- 23:42needs to join the other two soft tissue claimants
- 23:46in his demand. That claimant's claim clearly
- 23:51exceeds 30 ,000. The other two don't. But it's
- 23:55a good practice if you have multiple claimants,
- 23:58more claimants than per person limits to try
- 24:00to get everybody to join in the demand. Peter?
- 24:06Yeah, I would point out that 999 by its terms
- 24:11does require that all claimants join. And the
- 24:14reason why that requirement exists is because
- 24:17insurance companies are not allowed to exhaust
- 24:19their policy limits. on some but not all claimants
- 24:22leaving their insured exposed to additional claims
- 24:24without insurance to protect them. So in the
- 24:28scenario where you have, as Dan mentioned, you
- 24:31have a policy with, for example, 100, 300 limits,
- 24:35100 per person, 300 per accident. It may not
- 24:40be a reasonable demand for one of multiple claimants
- 24:44to demand one of those $100 ,000 per person limits,
- 24:51if that will exhaust a portion of the policy
- 24:56and leave the insured exposed to all the other
- 24:59remaining claims. There may be circumstances
- 25:02where a court might hold that under a unique
- 25:05set of circumstances, that is an appropriate
- 25:07demand, but at least under the language of the
- 25:09statute, that would not be an appropriate demand.
- 25:12You need to make sure that the insurance company
- 25:14is paying its limits and in return completely
- 25:17protecting the insured and exhausting a part
- 25:20of those limits may not meet that requirement.
- 25:24Yeah, I agree with Peter again in the situation
- 25:29where there are more claimants than per person
- 25:32limits. Also just really quickly wanted to point
- 25:34out that 999 .1b speaks to satisfaction of all
- 25:39leaves and where you have a a worker's compensation
- 25:44lien or a Medi -Cal lien, Medi -Care lien, those
- 25:47all have to be satisfied within the same per
- 25:50-person limit as a claimant. And so there, even
- 25:54though there's only one injured party, if there
- 25:57are statutory hospital liens, worker's comps
- 26:00liens, Medi -Cal liens, you have to be able to
- 26:04include all those in the settlement in order
- 26:07for it to be a reasonable demand. We're going
- 26:11to talk about liens in a minute. I think that's
- 26:13coming up. But I have a couple of questions.
- 26:19Say you have 100, 300 policy, and you have three
- 26:28claimants, or say there's five claimants, and
- 26:32they're represented by a different council. Do
- 26:35you have to get an agreement among all councils
- 26:38so that you could submit one policy limit demand
- 26:41letter? Or what do you do if there's a dispute
- 26:45among the parties as to who's going to get how
- 26:48much of the funds? I can answer that or at least
- 26:52attempt to answer it because the law is not crystal
- 26:55clear on that in California. The answer is, I
- 27:00mean, typically what happens is the insurance
- 27:03company itself will tender the limits globally
- 27:05to all the claimants. And if the claimants don't
- 27:09accept that, but they then want to make individual
- 27:11demands, they're facing an argument later that
- 27:14those demands were not reasonable and don't open
- 27:16the policy for the reasons that we talked about.
- 27:20So I've seen more recently policy limit demands
- 27:24that take that problem into account. by saying,
- 27:28if there are other claimants, then we'll agree
- 27:30to a global settlement for all the limits. And
- 27:33sometimes they say things like, we also want
- 27:36you to pay for the cost of a mediation between
- 27:39the claimants in order to determine how those
- 27:45proceeds should be allocated. So I've seen different
- 27:47things like that that I think are Attempts to
- 27:51address the problem i'm not saying that necessarily
- 27:55requiring the insurance company to pay for a
- 27:57mediation after standard pages policy limits
- 27:59is something that would be reasonable but it
- 28:02is something that i'm seeing done in order to
- 28:05address the problem but at the end of the day.
- 28:08We don't have a case that provides specific guidance
- 28:11on what to do in that situation so what we have
- 28:14is the statute and the general principle that.
- 28:18The one way you will open a policy is if you
- 28:21have claims that are worth more than the policy
- 28:23limits and you make a settlement offer for those
- 28:26policy limits that includes all claimants. That's
- 28:28the one way that you can be sure you'll open
- 28:30it. Anything else is open to debate at this point.
- 28:35What happens if you have one person that is very
- 28:40seriously injured and the others are not? And
- 28:46there's a policy limit demand made by the person
- 28:49that's seriously injured, particularly if it's
- 28:52a combined single limit policy. So let's say
- 28:54there's $500 ,000 in benefits and payable. You
- 28:59get a $500 ,000 demand from the person who's
- 29:03very seriously injured, the argument being that
- 29:06for the insured, he or she is better off to accept
- 29:12that policy limit demand and be uninsured as
- 29:16to the small claims as opposed to being exposed
- 29:20to the large claim that might come in well over
- 29:23the, say, 500 ,000, in my example, limits. Would
- 29:28that trigger a bad faith complaint? I think in
- 29:36that situation, my approach would to it would
- 29:39be that the carrier has an obligation to disclose
- 29:42to the policyholder, which they do anyways. Insurance
- 29:46company has a good faith obligation to inform
- 29:49the insured of all settlement demands, not just
- 29:52policy limit demands, settlement demands, be
- 29:55they for below the limits or above the limits.
- 29:58In your hypothetical, Arne, I think the insurance
- 30:02company has to disclose that to the insured and
- 30:05has to explain to the insured based on its investigation
- 30:09to the extent it has the information that the
- 30:13insurance is facing significant exposure to the
- 30:15one claimant and exposure to the other claimants
- 30:19as well, although it appears to be that that
- 30:22exposure can be a lot lower. And then put it
- 30:25to the insured to decide what they want to do.
- 30:28Allow the insured to make an informed decision
- 30:32regarding his or her own fate. And that's really,
- 30:37if you read the case law regarding the duty to
- 30:40communicate settlement offers, that's really
- 30:42what the courts are getting at. Insurance company
- 30:45has to tell the insured about a settlement offer
- 30:47so the insured can make a decision, even though
- 30:50the insurance company fully controls the ability
- 30:52to settle, but the insured should have some input
- 30:55into his or her own financial well -being. especially
- 31:02in the case we have like a significant injury
- 31:04for one claimant and not for the others. Let
- 31:08me just say Arnie that the point Dan is making
- 31:13though is that it's possible that under the circumstances
- 31:16you articulated an insurance company could potentially
- 31:20face liability under a different theory which
- 31:23is a theory relating to the duty to communicate
- 31:25with the insured. I do not believe however that
- 31:28the demand would be considered reasonable under
- 31:31the circumstances that you outlined, which I
- 31:32understood to be that one of multiple claimants
- 31:35demanded the entirety of the policy limit because
- 31:38that claimant was the most seriously injured.
- 31:40By definition, that would not be a reasonable
- 31:42demand. There could be a basis for other types
- 31:46of extra contractual liability based on duties
- 31:50to communicate to the insured, which is separate
- 31:52and apart from whether the demand is reasonable.
- 31:54Right. The last question I had is, what happens
- 31:57when you have a claimant out there that hasn't
- 32:00made a claim yet but is a potential claimant?
- 32:03An heir in a wrongful death case or someone who
- 32:07was in an accident and was injured but hasn't
- 32:10made a claim yet. What do you do about that?
- 32:18That's a tough one. because the claimants that
- 32:23are making claims in a lot of situations don't
- 32:27have control over other claimants that may be
- 32:30unwrapped or have no interest in settling. And
- 32:35the insurance company can sit back and say, look,
- 32:37we can't do anything until we get a claim where
- 32:42we get some confirmation by the other claimant
- 32:46that hasn't come forward, that they're not going
- 32:49to come forward, that they're not making a claim.
- 32:52It's, you know, we've had those situations come
- 32:55up and you have to wait. You have to look for
- 33:00the other claimant or yeah, I think you have
- 33:02to present. some evidence of the insurance company
- 33:05that the other claimant has maybe a middle injury,
- 33:08minimal claim. And if your client happens to
- 33:13have a significant injury, that it would make
- 33:15sense for them and it would make sense for their
- 33:17insured to settle out your client, even though
- 33:20it may leave the insured exposed to a potential
- 33:26unowned claim by an unowned claimant. So once
- 33:32the limits are paid out, there's no further duty
- 33:37to defend, is there, Peter? There's not a duty
- 33:42to defend once the limits are paid out, and that's
- 33:44one of the reasons why insurance companies are
- 33:47not allowed to unilaterally exhaust their limits
- 33:50to settle out some but not all claims. Are there
- 33:55circumstances where interpolating the funds would
- 33:57be appropriate? Well, there's case law that says
- 34:01that interpleading funds is, in fact, an act
- 34:06of good faith. The Lado versus Allstate case
- 34:09says that. But interpleading funds is probably
- 34:15not the best way to resolve the case. If you
- 34:17can resolve the case by settling with all claimants
- 34:21and obtaining a release, that would be a preferable
- 34:23way. Right. So you would think that tendering
- 34:26the limits would be sufficient without having
- 34:28the need to file an interpletor action. I think
- 34:33that a tender of the limits or an offer to pay
- 34:37the limits naming all claimants on the settlement
- 34:40check is a form of informal interpletor. Right.
- 34:44So it's similar and it requires them to agree
- 34:47how they're going to allocate it. So putting
- 34:51aside What demands insurance company may have
- 34:54done i think that tendering the limits to globally
- 34:57like that is by definition an act of good faith
- 35:01the whole concept of bad faith in the failure
- 35:03to settle setting is. Premise on the theory that
- 35:07the insurance company is. making an economic
- 35:10decision in which it thinks it can save money
- 35:12by paying less than the policy limit. And that
- 35:14just doesn't apply to a situation where the insurance
- 35:17company is tendering all its limits to all claimants.
- 35:20So that goes a long way towards insulating the
- 35:23insurance company from a bad faith claim if it
- 35:25does that. Okay, so Dan mentioned liens. What
- 35:33does a plaintiff normally do in liens? Because
- 35:37I've seen a lot of policy limit demands where
- 35:40the plaintiff doesn't say anything about liens.
- 35:44And liens is specifically in the statute, as
- 35:47we've read. But during the course of litigation,
- 35:54when the statute doesn't apply, What's the situation
- 35:59in terms of whether you've got to put in the
- 36:01demand that you'll take care of any liens? Yeah,
- 36:06I think we have to separate liens into two different
- 36:10types of liens. There's liens that are asserted
- 36:12by medical providers that are non -statutory
- 36:18liens. So not a hospital lien act lien, not a
- 36:20workers' comp lien, not a Medi -Cal Medicare
- 36:23lien. Those lien holders have liens on the recovery.
- 36:26They don't necessarily have a right to subrogate
- 36:29against the defendant to recover their out -of
- 36:35-pocket. Workers comp, Medi -Cal, Medicare, statutorily
- 36:40are entitled to pursue the defendant, and in
- 36:44some cases, the defendant's attorneys, and the
- 36:47insurance company if their liens aren't satisfied
- 36:50out of any settlement. And so with the first
- 36:53type of lien, where it's just a provider, somebody
- 36:56went see a doctor on a lien. That doctor's lien
- 37:02is against the recovery. So long as the demand
- 37:06says, hey, I will take care of that, I think
- 37:08you're OK. But if you have a situation, and Coe
- 37:13and Gallardo are two examples of that. Coe was
- 37:18a worker's comp lien. Gallardo was a Medi -Cal
- 37:22lead. Both Workers' Comp and Medi -Cal have a
- 37:25right of direct action against the third party
- 37:30tortfeasor. In the case of Medi -Cal, you have
- 37:34to take care of their lead as a part of the settlement.
- 37:37You can't just... leave their lien out there.
- 37:40And so with those types of liens, you need to,
- 37:44and what I've seen on the Medi -Cal liens is
- 37:46the carrier will say, look, we'll settle with
- 37:48you, but we're not paying you until we get a
- 37:51final Medi -Cal lien and we're gonna cut them
- 37:53a separate check. And typically that's how that's
- 37:57handled. And with workers comp, typically you'll
- 38:01get the comp carrier to join in the demand or
- 38:04the policy limits with an agreement. who share
- 38:07the proceeds of anti -settlement. Peter, what's
- 38:12your take on that? I agree with Dan on everything
- 38:16that Dan said. The difference is when you're
- 38:19dealing with a statutory lien, you're dealing
- 38:21with a right of action by the lien holder directly
- 38:26against the insurance company, which is totally
- 38:27independent of any claims that the claim that
- 38:30the injured claimant might have and so if you
- 38:33so the injured claimant has no right or ability
- 38:36to settle some other claimants claims i'm talking
- 38:40by other claimants i'm talking about a lien holder
- 38:43who has its own independent right to go after
- 38:45the insurance company and the insured for the
- 38:49amount of the lien and so any settlement demand
- 38:52that purports to um settle the claims of these
- 38:57other lean holder claimants who have statutory
- 39:00rights is invalid unless those lean holder claimants
- 39:04join in the demand. And so this goes back to
- 39:07joining all claimants in the demand. So I see
- 39:11that's a a rule that is honored in the breach
- 39:13more often than not. And plaintiff lawyers make
- 39:17demands that require that all the money be paid
- 39:19to them. And and they do not the demand is not
- 39:23allow the insurance company to cut a separate
- 39:26check to the lien holder who's entitled to a
- 39:27separate amount. And as indicated in the cases
- 39:32that you have up on the screen there, those are
- 39:34unreasonable demands and the insurance company
- 39:36won't be liable for not accepting them. Is it
- 39:39enough to say for the demand to say we will be
- 39:43responsible for all liens or we will hold you
- 39:45harmless from all liens? Would that be sufficient
- 39:49or do you have to actually have the lien holder
- 39:50join in the demand? Because getting somebody
- 39:53like Medicaid or Medicare to join in the demand
- 39:56would be pretty difficult. Well, it isn't sufficient
- 40:00because they don't have the right to control
- 40:03the rights of Medi -Cal or workers comp or any
- 40:07other statutory lien holder. It may be difficult
- 40:10to get the statutory lien holder to join in the
- 40:13demand. And so what the demand should do is have
- 40:17a carve out that enables the insurance company
- 40:20to Satisfy the lien separately from the settlement
- 40:25with the claimant. And maybe that just involves
- 40:28getting more information from the lien holder
- 40:30so they can determine the amount of the lien.
- 40:31It may involve negotiating with the lien holder
- 40:33in advance of a settlement so that they know
- 40:36what the lien holder will accept and so that
- 40:38that obligation can be satisfied as part of the
- 40:41settlement. But to simply require that pay as
- 40:45a third party claimant to say, hey, pay me all
- 40:48the money and I'll take care of the liens. Don't
- 40:49worry about it. that's not sufficient because
- 40:52that doesn't protect the insurance company from
- 40:54being sued by the lien holder. It doesn't protect
- 40:56the insured from being sued by the lien holder.
- 40:59You don't have to settle a claim that leaves
- 41:00your fate in the hands of an adverse third -party
- 41:04claimant as to whether or not they're going to
- 41:07honor their obligation to satisfy liens or not.
- 41:12Yeah, so I generally agree with Peter. And I
- 41:16was also going to note, you know, going a couple
- 41:18slides back, we had the the claimants slide and
- 41:22mentioned 991 .1B. And that's why in the case
- 41:28of a statutory lien, the lien holder actually
- 41:32becomes another claimant to the policy limit.
- 41:35That's why there are multiple claimants in that
- 41:37situation. And there has to be, and I've seen
- 41:42creative ways of doing it. It's a case -by -case
- 41:45basis, but there has to be some resolution of
- 41:48that statutory lien as a part of the policy limit
- 41:53settlement. So you have to get their consent
- 41:56to be part of the policy limit settlement demand,
- 42:00then? In workers' compensation, the way I've
- 42:04seen it is the comp carrier will sort of lien,
- 42:07and then you'll get them to agree to release
- 42:13their claim in exchange for the global tender
- 42:15of the policy limit. With Medi -Cal, typically
- 42:19what happens is there's an agreement to settle
- 42:22for the policy limits and either the settlement
- 42:26amount is left in the carrier's possession pending
- 42:32resolution of the Medi -Cal lien and then the
- 42:35insurance company sends a separate check to Medi
- 42:39-Cal and a separate check to the claimant. Or
- 42:42I've seen it where we've agreed to hold the funds
- 42:45in trust and not disperse anything pending the
- 42:50final Medi -Cal or Medicare lien, and then we
- 42:53satisfy it out of the settlement proceeds. And
- 42:56once that's done, a distribution is made to the
- 42:59client. There's different creative ways of getting
- 43:03around that, because we've had cases where Medi
- 43:07-Cal has taken a year. to provide us the final
- 43:10lien amount because the client is still treating.
- 43:13Well, you know, nobody wants to hold this settlement
- 43:15up for a year waiting for Medi -Cal. In that
- 43:18situation, we've had some insurance companies,
- 43:21like I said, we'll take the check, we'll put
- 43:24it in our trust account. We agreed not to disperse
- 43:26it until there's a final Medi -Cal lien. And
- 43:30in that situation, typically there's an agreement
- 43:32to indemnify the defendant and the insurance
- 43:35company in case for some reason the lien isn't
- 43:38satisfied and Medi -Cal, Medicare or whatever
- 43:42case may be ends up pursuing a claim. You can
- 43:47put that arrangement. I'm sorry, Peter, go ahead.
- 43:49Yeah, let me just. I mean, an insurance company
- 43:53can agree to do whatever it wants to agree to
- 43:56do. But the question of whether it's obligated
- 43:58to do that is a very different question. I don't
- 44:01think an insurance company is obligated to provide
- 44:03all the money to the claimant and the claimant's
- 44:06attorney and trust them to live up to their promises
- 44:09of what they're going to do with it. So I agree
- 44:15with Dan that the first approach that he mentioned
- 44:19would be appropriate, which is to wait until
- 44:23you find out what the obligations are and then
- 44:26honor those obligations separately. There may
- 44:28be a situation with based on the nature of statutory
- 44:31lien that you know that the claimant will be
- 44:33entitled to at least a certain portion of the
- 44:36policy proceeds and that would be appropriate
- 44:39to pay that portion. But I don't believe it would
- 44:42be appropriate to put control of the policy proceeds
- 44:45in the hands of the claimant and his or her lawyer.
- 44:53The next topic we were going to talk about is
- 44:56that the policy limit demand is reasonable if
- 45:06there's a likelihood or sometimes a substantial
- 45:09likelihood of an excess verdict. And it's phrased
- 45:13differently in different cases. Does it make
- 45:16a difference? Here's some of the cases where
- 45:19it says that Casey only says likely. Some of
- 45:24the cases say substantial likelihood. Dan, what's
- 45:29your take on that? I think likely, substantially
- 45:34likely, substantial probability. I think those
- 45:39are all basically used interchangeably. And really,
- 45:44in front of a jury, because ultimately, whether
- 45:47this determination will be made by a jury. I
- 45:51really don't think a jury is going to make much
- 45:53of a distinction between substantial likelihood
- 45:57versus strong probability. I mean, the issue
- 46:00is going to be based on the information the insurance
- 46:02company had. Did it appear at the time that a
- 46:08judgment would exceed the policy limits? I think
- 46:11where this may make a difference is on a summary
- 46:14judgment filed by the insurance company. where
- 46:19a judge could say, well, no reasonable jury could
- 46:22find that it was substantially likely it would
- 46:24exceed. I think that's really where this plays
- 46:26out. In front of a jury, I really don't think
- 46:29it makes much of a difference which formulation
- 46:32of that you use. And as you know, KC 2334, which
- 46:36is the open limits instruction, uses the word
- 46:39likely. It doesn't say it's substantially likely
- 46:41or strong probability. It just says likely it
- 46:46will exceed. I agree with everything Dan just
- 46:51said, but let me point this out. While it may
- 46:55be that a jury or juror may not appreciate the
- 47:01distinction between likely and substantially
- 47:03likely, when it becomes a problem is if it ends
- 47:07up resulting in a jury instruction that doesn't
- 47:10adequately state the law. And so we're talking
- 47:13about one of several aspects of Cassie 2334,
- 47:18that may not be consistent with the law. And
- 47:22at some point, there's going to be a challenge
- 47:25to claimant that relied on Cassie and the word
- 47:29likely and did not say substantially likely.
- 47:33And that challenge may end up with a reversal.
- 47:36So I think plaintiff lawyers, if you accept Dan's
- 47:39point, which I actually agree with, which it
- 47:41probably won't make a difference to a jury, it
- 47:43may make strategic sense for a claimant lawyer
- 47:47to allow the term substantial likelihood to be
- 47:50in there so that if they get their judgment,
- 47:51it won't be vulnerable to an appeal because I
- 47:53think it's a flaw in the Cassie instruction and
- 47:57they should have followed the California Supreme
- 47:59Court authority that uses the term substantial
- 48:02likelihood. Okay. So then we come to the second
- 48:07prong of KC 2334, which is not only must the
- 48:12demand be reasonable, but the conduct of the
- 48:16insurer must be unreasonable in rejecting the
- 48:21demand. And that brings us to Minto and the evolution
- 48:26of 2334. Peter, you're going to give us a quick
- 48:30review of the evolution of 2334. I'm going to
- 48:33make it really quick because I see that we're
- 48:36using a lot of our time. allocated time. So let
- 48:39me just say this. Under California law, the law
- 48:44that relates to insurance bad faith in the third
- 48:47party failure to settle context, it is always
- 48:50the Supreme Court on down have always held that
- 48:54you have to show that an insurance company unreasonably
- 48:57refused to accept a demand within policy limits.
- 49:01And the original jury instruction in California
- 49:04said just that, and that was a badge instruction
- 49:07way back in the days pre -Cassie. And the badge
- 49:10instruction basically had the two elements. The
- 49:13two elements, as Arne pointed out at the beginning
- 49:15of this proceeding, were are the demand has to
- 49:18be reasonable and the insurance company's failure
- 49:20to accept the demand has to be unreasonable.
- 49:23Those are the essential two elements of a bad
- 49:26faith failure to settle claim. And those elements
- 49:29were listed in the badge instruction. Then Cassie
- 49:32came along and Cassie actually accurately included
- 49:35those two elements. And then for reasons that
- 49:38I would take half an hour to go into and so I
- 49:40won't do it here. Justice Krosky tried to improve
- 49:45the Cassie instruction because he felt it was.
- 49:50It was not as favorable to the insurance industry
- 49:54as the law required, and in that process things
- 49:58went back and forth and there were different
- 50:00drafts and. Somehow the second element got omitted.
- 50:04And it's ironic because because actually, Justice
- 50:07Krosky was trying to make the instruction more
- 50:10favorable to the insurance industry, and the
- 50:12result of it was that it actually left out one
- 50:16of the critical components of a bad faith failure
- 50:18to settle claim, which was the second component
- 50:20that the insurance company, even if it gets a
- 50:23reasonable demand, it's not liable if its failure
- 50:25to accept that demand was not unreasonable. So.
- 50:29That resulted in countless battles. I was involved
- 50:35in them, Dan was probably involved in them, where
- 50:37we would go to trial in these bad faith cases
- 50:40and the plaintiff would argue, it doesn't matter
- 50:42what the insurance company did, why it did it,
- 50:45whether it was reasonable or not, all that matters
- 50:46is whether the demand was reasonable. And so,
- 50:51finally, the Pinto case came down and corrected
- 50:56that and in fact, In the in the pinto case there
- 51:00were plaintiff lawyers that had a very large
- 51:02at the time it seemed very large these days maybe
- 51:04not so but it was a ten million dollar. Excess
- 51:07judgment and they made the argument that i just
- 51:11talked about and they said oh no no it doesn't
- 51:12matter what the insurance company's conduct was
- 51:14all we have to show is that the demand was reasonable
- 51:16who cares whether the insurance company's failure
- 51:18except it was reasonable or unreasonable. And
- 51:21the court of appeal reversed. and ordered judgment
- 51:25to be entered in favor of the defendant insurance
- 51:28company because the plaintiff and the plaintiff's
- 51:33lawyer did not ask the jury to consider the reasonableness
- 51:37of the insurance company's conduct. Following
- 51:39Pinto, Cassie 2334 was amended again and brought
- 51:45back into the Cassie instruction was the mandatory
- 51:49second element. That's the evolution. Okay. And
- 51:54I would add that to Peter's point about 2334
- 51:58and the challenge on appeal. I believe, Peter,
- 52:01correct me if I'm wrong, that Pinto actually
- 52:03went up on appeal on a challenge to a jury instruction.
- 52:06Is that right? It did. And it, well. On that
- 52:13issue? Yes, that was the very issue that Pinto
- 52:16went up on appeal on was whether or not the insurance
- 52:20company is entitled to show that its conduct.
- 52:22in failing to accept the demand was reasonable.
- 52:27Correct. So what are situations where the demand
- 52:35was reasonable, but the demand was a reasonable
- 52:39demand, which was rejected, but the conduct was
- 52:41not unreasonable? Where do we get into those
- 52:45situations? So again, your reasonableness is
- 52:53in the eye of the holder. It's a deeply, deeply
- 52:57factual circumstance. But kind of the general
- 53:01guidelines we can discern from the cases is if
- 53:07it's just a mistake, the insurance company miscalendered
- 53:14or there was confusion or a mistake in the claim
- 53:17number. And that's why there wasn't a timely
- 53:20response. But as soon as the insurance company
- 53:22figured it out, it's that, you know, it accepted
- 53:25things like that. The court's going to say are
- 53:29probably reasonable or not unreasonable. But
- 53:34where the insurance company kind of, you know,
- 53:36if you read Hetty Yachty and Hetty Yachty factually,
- 53:39it's very, very dense. But the bottom line is
- 53:42it was a horrific, horrific injury. And the insurance
- 53:46company was really lackadaisical about getting
- 53:48it resolved. It got a policy limit demand. I
- 53:55want to say that the week of Thanksgiving and
- 53:59the person that was in the office to process
- 54:04FedEx or UPS envelopes happened to be out that
- 54:07day. So the demand just kind of sat in the mailroom.
- 54:10until the day after it expired. At that point,
- 54:14somebody picked it up and said, oh, a policy
- 54:16limit demand, handed it over, put it on the desk
- 54:21of the claim supervisor who had happened to be
- 54:24left early that day. And so the court looked
- 54:27at that and said, hey, you know what? That's
- 54:29not reasonable. I mean, you really should have
- 54:31processes in place so that... when a demand comes
- 54:35in, but your mail person's out, somebody is there
- 54:38to pick up the mail and deliver it to the right
- 54:40person. And if the claim supervisor is out that
- 54:43day, somebody is there to monitor the desk to
- 54:45make sure that when a demand comes in, it gets
- 54:47responded to on a timely basis. And so it's facts
- 54:53like that. And again, it's highly factual. So
- 54:55you really need to take a look at what happened
- 54:59and determine, was it just the insurance company
- 55:02being non -responsive understaffed whatever the
- 55:09case may be or was it just a mistake and they
- 55:11were trying to figure out what was going on there
- 55:14was a mistake regarding the claim number they
- 55:16couldn't figure out who the insured or sometimes
- 55:18they can't get a hold of their insured to verify
- 55:21the permission to disclose limits things of that
- 55:26nature so you know you really have to read the
- 55:30cases and take a look at those factual circumstances,
- 55:34kind of get a feel for it. Right. Peter, anything
- 55:38you wanted to add? No, I agree with what Dan
- 55:41said. I point out that in the Hettiaty case,
- 55:43court didn't make a finding that the insurance
- 55:45company's conduct was unreasonable. It just said
- 55:47that there's evidence here that should allow
- 55:50these issues to go to the jury because there's
- 55:52evidence that if believed might cause a jury
- 55:55to believe the conduct was unreasonable. But
- 55:57it really comes down to the difference between
- 55:59negligence mistakes, inadvertent errors, and
- 56:05something that is at a higher level, which is
- 56:07the unreasonable conduct required to hold an
- 56:10insurance company extra contractually liable.
- 56:12And it is a higher standard, and it will be great
- 56:16if we can ever get some courts to weigh in on
- 56:19examples of conduct that does not reach that
- 56:21standard and is merely negligence or mistake
- 56:24so that we can have more guidance on that. So
- 56:28I'm gonna skip a couple of slides here and go
- 56:31to this one. Do you even need a demand? Can you
- 56:35find bad faith without a demand? Dan? Yeah, so
- 56:42in very, very, very limited circumstances, the
- 56:47courts will allow a bad faith claim to go forward
- 56:51without a formal domain. the cases, boy court
- 56:57kind of sets out one of the guidelines for it.
- 57:02And then the rest of the cases kind of build
- 57:04on it. And the bottom line is if the claimant
- 57:07indicates an interest in settlement to the carrier
- 57:12and the carrier engages in conduct that prevents
- 57:16a settlement from ever being made, a demand from
- 57:20ever being made. In that situation, you may be
- 57:24able to plead a bad faith failure settle claim,
- 57:30subject to proof at trial that, but for the insurer's
- 57:35conduct, the case would have settled. So just
- 57:39a couple of really quick factual scenarios. In
- 57:42Boyd Court versus Amex, Amex Assurance Company
- 57:45had a rule that they never disclose policy limits.
- 57:49And the court said, well, if you never disclose
- 57:52policy limits, you're preventing policy limit
- 57:54demands from being made. And then the facts in
- 57:57that case was the claimant requested wanted to
- 58:00know what the policy limits are because he said
- 58:02he wanted to make a policy limit demand. Amics
- 58:04said no. The court said that leads a cause of
- 58:08action subject to proof that had they disclosed
- 58:11the policy limits, the case would have settled.
- 58:14In Planet Bingo, it was actually a subrogation
- 58:17claim. by one insurance company against the insured
- 58:21of another insurance company. The carrier denied
- 58:26coverage. The defendant's insurance company denied
- 58:29coverage. Before denied coverage, it received
- 58:32a subrogation demand in excess of the policy
- 58:35limits. And in response to that excess demand,
- 58:38it denied coverage. And there was evidence presented
- 58:41to the court that in these subrogation claims,
- 58:44when a demand is made, it typically settles for
- 58:46the policy limits. And on that basis, Planet
- 58:49Bingo said the case can go to the jury on whether
- 58:53it would have settled. And interestingly enough,
- 58:57Planet Bingo was not even an excess exposure
- 58:59case. The insurance company ended up paying the
- 59:02sub role claim, but the insured claim that it
- 59:05went out of business because it ultimately got
- 59:08sued. I generally agree with everything Dan just
- 59:12said. I just clarify that in Planet Bingo, the
- 59:17claimant requested to go to mediation to discuss
- 59:20settlement, and the insurance company refused
- 59:22to. And I think that's the critical factor in
- 59:25that case. The point being, if an insurance company
- 59:28does not allow the opportunity to discuss a policy
- 59:32limit settlement, then it may end up being liable
- 59:34even in the absence of a demand. And that's what
- 59:36happened in boy court and planet bingo but the
- 59:39mirror but the but but contrast that with whether
- 59:42an insurance company has some sort of unilateral
- 59:44obligation to tender the policy limit in the
- 59:47absence of a demand and the laws to the contrary
- 59:50there there is no such duty but you well you
- 59:53don't have to tender the policy limits when you
- 59:55know or should know the claim is worth that amount
- 59:57you cannot engage in conduct that effectively
- 1:00:03prevents the claimant from ever making a policy
- 1:00:06limit demand. And that's what happened in those
- 1:00:08two cases. Okay. And I agree with Peter's characterization.
- 1:00:13What if the claimant proposes a stipulated judgment?
- 1:00:18Yeah, this is an issue that's near and dear to
- 1:00:22my heart. So what are we talking about here?
- 1:00:24Every case where the liability clearly exceeds
- 1:00:28the policy limits, it's a clear liability case.
- 1:00:32no question that there's gonna be a judgment
- 1:00:35against the insured, the cases and litigation.
- 1:00:38And the plaintiff says to the insurance company,
- 1:00:43hey, if you agree to have a stipulated, to consent
- 1:00:47to have a stipulated judgment or X amount in
- 1:00:51excess of the policy limits against your insured
- 1:00:53entered, we will give the insured a covenant
- 1:00:56not to execute. that excess judgment against
- 1:01:01the insurance personal assets, in exchange the
- 1:01:04insured is going to assign their rights against
- 1:01:06the insurance company to us. And the defendant
- 1:01:09insured in that case says, yes, absolutely, I
- 1:01:11wanna do the deal because I get a covenant not
- 1:01:13to execute. And the case is done, I don't have
- 1:01:16to go to trial. And the insurance company says,
- 1:01:19no, we're not gonna consent to that, forces the
- 1:01:22case to trial. And then a judgment that is, far
- 1:01:26in excess of what the stipulated judgment proposal
- 1:01:29has been entered. Now that judgment is executable
- 1:01:33against the insured and there is no covenant
- 1:01:34not to execute. And the insured is sitting there
- 1:01:37going, well, wait a minute, insurance company,
- 1:01:39you forced the case to go to trial against me.
- 1:01:42I could have had a covenant not to execute. Now
- 1:01:44I don't have a covenant not to execute. And you
- 1:01:47never offered to pay the judgment. You said you're
- 1:01:51only going to pay your $15 ,000 policy limits.
- 1:01:53In that situation, is the insurance company's
- 1:01:57refusal to consent to the entry of a stipulated
- 1:01:59judgment and forcing the insured to proceed to
- 1:02:03trial. Is that bad? That's what we're talking
- 1:02:07about. Peter and I have a really healthy dispute
- 1:02:09over this. I maintain that in controlling the
- 1:02:13insurance defense and maintaining an absolute
- 1:02:15right to consent to settlements, the insurance
- 1:02:18company has to exercise that right reasonably.
- 1:02:22And when the insurance company just says, No,
- 1:02:25we're not going to do it. And that ends up causing
- 1:02:28harm to the insured in a form of a judgment for
- 1:02:31which there is no company not to execute. The
- 1:02:33insurance company is liable. It may not be liable
- 1:02:36on a failure to accept a reasonable policy limit
- 1:02:40demand theory, but it can be held liable on other
- 1:02:45bases, including unreasonably exercising its
- 1:02:49rights under the policy. to the detriment of
- 1:02:52the insured, placing its interests ahead of the
- 1:02:55insured's interest. I note in Dora versus Dearbrook,
- 1:03:01the district court said that is not a viable
- 1:03:07cause of action. You can't sue the insurance
- 1:03:10company. In Spradlin versus Geico, which is my
- 1:03:14case, the central district punted on that issue,
- 1:03:19denied the Geico's summary judgment on the issue,
- 1:03:22but didn't really decide it. Dora versus Dearbrook
- 1:03:26was appealed to the Ninth Circuit, affirmed on
- 1:03:30appeal, but the plaintiff didn't appeal that
- 1:03:33issue, so we don't have a ruling from the Ninth
- 1:03:35Circuit on that. Spradlin ended up resolving,
- 1:03:39and so this is kind of up in the air. Well, I
- 1:03:44would disagree with the last point, to the extent
- 1:03:48that every court does ever published a decision
- 1:03:52on this issue and there have been many across
- 1:03:53the country has said that. This approach is not
- 1:03:58a way to open insurance policy let let me start
- 1:04:01by saying that i don't have any problem at all
- 1:04:03with a claimant proposing a stipulated judgment
- 1:04:06with the terms that dan outlined that maybe something
- 1:04:09that insurance company thinks makes sense and
- 1:04:11is willing to agree to the issue is can insurance
- 1:04:14company be sued for bad faith and for the amount
- 1:04:16of an excess judgment. by not agreeing to it.
- 1:04:18And the fact of the matter is it's not an obligation
- 1:04:22that exists under the policy. Insurance companies
- 1:04:24have an obligation to try to settle within limits
- 1:04:28in exchange for a release for their insured.
- 1:04:30But this is what Dan is proposing or outlined
- 1:04:34is not a settlement, doesn't provide the insured
- 1:04:38with a release. All it really is doing is Asking
- 1:04:43the insurance company to agree to the amount
- 1:04:45of damages that the insurance company will then
- 1:04:47be sued for in a subsequent bad faith case. I
- 1:04:51don't believe there's any contract provision
- 1:04:54that would require an insurance company to do
- 1:04:56that either express or implied and the courts
- 1:04:58have agreed that that doesn't fall within the
- 1:05:01narrow exceptions that must be met in order to
- 1:05:04sue an insurance company. for bad faith in the
- 1:05:06failure to in the third party context so we do
- 1:05:09have a disagreement i agree with dan's characterization
- 1:05:13of the cases though the spraddling court simply
- 1:05:16said noted some reasons why it wasn't going to
- 1:05:22decide the issue and decide to punt on it but
- 1:05:24among other reasons it's a situation where the
- 1:05:27the insurance companies asked to enter into an
- 1:05:29agreement that Of course, the insured has no
- 1:05:32downside, so they'll just agree to stipulate
- 1:05:34to it and they're essentially stipulating that
- 1:05:38they won't be sued for the excess amount. They're
- 1:05:40saying, yeah, I won't be sued for the excess
- 1:05:42amount, but I'm going to maintain and be able
- 1:05:45to pursue and or assign my bad faith claim and
- 1:05:49sue the insurance company for this excess amount
- 1:05:51that I've never actually been subjected to. Now,
- 1:05:54if there's an actual judgment, then an insured
- 1:05:56can do that. But I don't believe the insurance
- 1:05:58company has to agree to set the damages for a
- 1:06:01bad faith case in advance of an actual trial.
- 1:06:04And that's why there's a lot of room for disagreement
- 1:06:07on this issue. OK, well, I think that's our time
- 1:06:12is up. I don't know whether there are any questions
- 1:06:14here. It looks like there are a few questions.
- 1:06:22Let's see. The first question is, does this statute
- 1:06:25apply? to personal injury matters, only to personal
- 1:06:29injury matters. Does anybody know the answer
- 1:06:35right off the top of their head? I think it's
- 1:06:40in 999 .5. It says the chapter will shall apply,
- 1:06:48only apply to causes of action and claims. covered
- 1:06:52under automobile, motor vehicle, homeowner, or
- 1:06:56commercial premises liability insurance policies
- 1:06:59for property damage, personal or bodily injury,
- 1:07:03and wrongful death claims, is what the statute
- 1:07:05says. Here's another question. If in good faith
- 1:07:12you dispute liability in a premises liability
- 1:07:15slip and fall case, de minimis or open and obvious,
- 1:07:21Do you risk a bad -faith determination by refusing
- 1:07:23to tender limits in a case where a plaintiff
- 1:07:26has astronomical medical bills? I think we address
- 1:07:32that. An insurance company doesn't have an obligation
- 1:07:35to unilaterally tender in that scenario, but
- 1:07:38an insurance company may have an obligation to
- 1:07:40accept a demand within limits under that factual
- 1:07:43pattern. Can you ask the carrier to leave some
- 1:07:49small amount of money to protect the duty to
- 1:07:53defend against possible future claims? That addresses
- 1:08:02the situation where you've got a policy limit
- 1:08:04demand that exhausts the policy. There's no more
- 1:08:06duty to defend. Yeah, as a plaintiff, you can
- 1:08:10make a settlement demand that leaves a penny
- 1:08:12on the policy. And that penny would allow GD
- 1:08:18to defend to exist. Now, indemnity would be limited
- 1:08:21to that penny, but at least the insured would
- 1:08:23have the benefit of counsel to defend them against
- 1:08:26the other claims. So yeah, you can structure
- 1:08:28it that way. I'm not sure that the insurance
- 1:08:32company's rejection of a demand that's structured
- 1:08:34that way, that leaves a penny or $10 or whatever
- 1:08:37it is on the policy would be deemed unreasonable,
- 1:08:42but you can certainly structure it that way.
- 1:08:46Yeah, Peter, I'm assuming you're saying that
- 1:08:50the insurance company does not have an obligation
- 1:08:52to accept such a demand. Well, if the demand
- 1:08:58would exhaust 99 .9 % of the policy limits in
- 1:09:03favor of one claim and and leave the insured
- 1:09:06exposed with only a dollar of indemnity to a
- 1:09:09bunch of other claimants, it would not be reasonable
- 1:09:11demand. So that's why I was interpreting the
- 1:09:13question. Now, can a demand be made structured
- 1:09:16that way? Absolutely. But what we're dealing
- 1:09:18with here is whether the insurance company will
- 1:09:20be liable for not accepting a demand like that.
- 1:09:23And that goes back to the issues we talked about
- 1:09:25earlier. How do you resolve the conflict negotiated
- 1:09:29after or before? It could be, you could do it
- 1:09:38either way. We've had cases where we've agreed
- 1:09:41with the comp carrier that it's a minimal policy.
- 1:09:45We're gonna do a joint demand, get the 15 ,000
- 1:09:47and then we'll negotiate what the lien is afterwards.
- 1:09:53Or we've agreed that, you know, a third, a third,
- 1:09:56a third and then make the demand. It's really
- 1:10:01up to. the plaintiff, attorney, and the comp
- 1:10:05carrier. So I'm not sure how much time we have
- 1:10:11for these questions, but I will keep going for
- 1:10:13the time being. In this situation where demand
- 1:10:18is reasonable in the earlier and the carrier
- 1:10:21nonetheless thinks liability is in dispute, is
- 1:10:26it not unreasonable to refuse the demand? The
- 1:10:32issue there is whether the information presented
- 1:10:36to the insurance company does or does not establish
- 1:10:39a likelihood or substantial likelihood that if
- 1:10:43they don't settle within the policy and it goes
- 1:10:45to judgment, there will be a judgment in excess
- 1:10:49of the policy limit against the insurer. That's
- 1:10:51the test. And so, as Dan and I have been saying,
- 1:10:56Throughout the hour, every case needs to be evaluated
- 1:10:59on its own merits, and so it would depend on
- 1:11:01the evidence. There may be circumstances where
- 1:11:05the liability is in question, but the damages
- 1:11:08are so significant that the risk is too high
- 1:11:12for the insurance company to gamble and go to
- 1:11:14trial. There may be circumstances where that
- 1:11:16could impact whether the insurance company would
- 1:11:18be liable. There may be circumstances where There's
- 1:11:22just such a minute possibility that the insurance
- 1:11:24company would ever be held liable at all, that
- 1:11:27it would be reasonable to reject a $15 ,000 demand
- 1:11:31in a catastrophic injury case. It just all depends.
- 1:11:34And it's not something that you can answer with
- 1:11:35a blanket rule. Can a coverage issue with ROR
- 1:11:41dispute equal unreasonable conduct? No. An insurance
- 1:11:49company has a right to assert a reservation of
- 1:11:54rights that's not a withholding of policy benefits.
- 1:11:56So the whole concept of bad faith is whether
- 1:11:59the insurance company is withholding the payment
- 1:12:00of policy benefits unreasonably. And asserting
- 1:12:04rights under an ROR is not a withholding of policy
- 1:12:09benefits. In fact, there's a case called Griffin
- 1:12:11de Watering that addresses that. and says that
- 1:12:14the insurance company's reservations of rights
- 1:12:16does not mean that they're withholding benefits.
- 1:12:19It just means they're reserving their right to
- 1:12:21dispute whether benefits are owed in the future.
- 1:12:26Reservation rights can trigger a cumus conflict,
- 1:12:28which would entitle the insured to independent
- 1:12:30counsel. But Peter's right. An insurance company
- 1:12:33is entitled to unilaterally reserve rights, including
- 1:12:36to reserve rights to seek reimbursement from
- 1:12:38the insured. They're not entitled under Johanson
- 1:12:42to make a decision on settling the claim based
- 1:12:46upon a coverage issue. They are entitled to,
- 1:12:50but they're strictly liable if they turn out
- 1:12:51to be wrong. That's a distinction which is probably
- 1:12:55worth noting, which is that if the reason that
- 1:12:58the insurance company does not accept the policy
- 1:13:00limit demand is because there is a coverage dispute,
- 1:13:05and it turns out that the insurance company is
- 1:13:08wrong in that coverage dispute, That is the one
- 1:13:11circumstance under California law in which an
- 1:13:13insurance company is in fact strictly liable.
- 1:13:16But if the basis for not accepting is anything
- 1:13:19other than coverage, then that strict liability
- 1:13:21rule would not apply. Can you make a claim against
- 1:13:26the insurance company for bad faith or open policy
- 1:13:29where they offered the policy but are unable
- 1:13:32or unwilling to provide proof that the insured
- 1:13:35was not driving in the course of scope of his
- 1:13:37employment, his or her employment at the time
- 1:13:40of the accident. So that, again, just going back
- 1:13:46to what we talked about, it all depends on the
- 1:13:49circumstances. If the demand requires a declaration
- 1:13:53from the insured that they weren't in the course
- 1:13:56of scope and the insurance company attempts to
- 1:13:58get it but can't, then no, that's something that's
- 1:14:02beyond the insurance company's control. However,
- 1:14:05if the demand requires it and the insurance company
- 1:14:07blows that requirement off and doesn't go to
- 1:14:10its insurer, doesn't try to find out the information,
- 1:14:13then possibly, depending on the circumstances,
- 1:14:15that could be deemed unreasonable conduct. I
- 1:14:19agree with that. Okay, when dealing with employment
- 1:14:23liability, insurance, EPLI. Are there any special
- 1:14:26considerations different from what we've reviewed
- 1:14:29already? That's a pretty big question. I think
- 1:14:35the rules we talked about apply across the board
- 1:14:38to all liability policies and all settlement
- 1:14:40domains. So something unique in EPLI may be that
- 1:14:43it's a burning limits policy. So there may be
- 1:14:46an additional consideration by the insurance
- 1:14:48company of diminishing limits if they don't accept
- 1:14:53the demand now. But beyond that, it's all the
- 1:14:56same. It just depends on the circumstances. Right.
- 1:15:00I have two more questions here. Talk about the
- 1:15:02situation when a carrier tries to accept a policy
- 1:15:05limit demand but does not meet one of the reasonable
- 1:15:09conditions. Well, you just talked about one,
- 1:15:11Dan. Yeah. So, yeah. And I think Hediyati, if
- 1:15:17you read the... the facts of that case had to
- 1:15:20do with, you know, not getting a declaration
- 1:15:23from the insured regarding, I think, his assets.
- 1:15:29Yeah, the carrier could be liable for, liable
- 1:15:35next to the limits where it fails to satisfy
- 1:15:39one or more of the conditions in the demand.
- 1:15:44The caveat is the insurance company has to act
- 1:15:46unreasonably in failing to do so. So, like we
- 1:15:49talked about, if the insurance company can't
- 1:15:51get the declaration because the policyholder
- 1:15:54won't respond, then they haven't acted unreasonably.
- 1:15:57They tried, they couldn't get it. So, again,
- 1:16:00it comes back down to the factual circumstances
- 1:16:02of each case. And last question, does reasonable
- 1:16:07demand include providing liability video evidence?
- 1:16:14I don't think you're required to do it. To the
- 1:16:18extent you want to provide it, to the extent
- 1:16:23it would help the insurance company, you certainly
- 1:16:25can provide it. But there's no requirement that
- 1:16:27you provide. The statute, especially the statute,
- 1:16:31doesn't require you to provide anything in particular.
- 1:16:33You just have to have information that is sufficient
- 1:16:37for the insurance company to evaluate the claim.
- 1:16:40Okay. Well, we got two more questions that came
- 1:16:43in. Are policy limit demands made during pending
- 1:16:47litigation analyzed pursuant only to case law
- 1:16:50and reasonableness of demands without any consideration
- 1:16:53of 999's requirements? I think the answer is
- 1:16:57yes. They're independent. 999 only applies prior
- 1:17:02to litigation. I would agree that 999 doesn't
- 1:17:08apply, but I do think that 999 reflects the legislature's
- 1:17:13determination of what's reasonable. And so it
- 1:17:15may indirectly have some impact on a demand that
- 1:17:19was made during litigation. It just depends on
- 1:17:21what the circumstances are. But it doesn't govern
- 1:17:24it. So aren't you? Let's see. Do you think the
- 1:17:34carriers following legal advice cover them from
- 1:17:37being seen as unreasonable? It can, it depends
- 1:17:43on the circumstances. So again, it's an objective
- 1:17:48standard. Was the insurance company's failure
- 1:17:52to accept the demand reasonable based on the
- 1:17:55circumstances that existed at the time? And we're
- 1:17:58setting aside the coverage reason that we carved
- 1:18:01out in which there's strict liability. So putting
- 1:18:03aside that, if they're relying on an attorney's
- 1:18:09advice, regarding an issue that would impact
- 1:18:13whether they should accept a demand, then that
- 1:18:15could be reasonable and that could be a defense.
- 1:18:19The California law recognizes a quote advice
- 1:18:22of counsel defense. That's a recognized defense
- 1:18:25to bad faith liability. And so depending on the
- 1:18:27circumstances, it could apply. The only I would
- 1:18:31add to that is when the insurance company asserts
- 1:18:35advice of counsel as a defense to a bad faith
- 1:18:38case, it waives the attorney -client privilege
- 1:18:40with that counsel. So typically in open limits
- 1:18:45cases, that's not much of an issue because the
- 1:18:47assignment gives you also the attorney -client
- 1:18:50privilege from the insured. But let's say the
- 1:18:53insurance companies rely on coverage counsel
- 1:18:55to advise it on responding to a demand. If the
- 1:18:59insurance company attempts to defend its decision
- 1:19:03by saying it relied on coverage counsel, that
- 1:19:06will waive the attorney client privilege with
- 1:19:08respect to what coverage counsel said. So that's
- 1:19:11always a consideration when asserting that defense.
- 1:19:15What if there's $500 ,000 in limits and there's
- 1:19:18a $500 ,000 on demand and defense counsel says
- 1:19:22the case is only worth $250 ,000 and so they
- 1:19:25reject the demand? That is evidence. that goes
- 1:19:29to the issue of whether the insurance companies
- 1:19:31fail to accept the demand was reasonable. That
- 1:19:33is definitely relevant evidence that can be considered
- 1:19:37along with all the other evidence in making that
- 1:19:40determination. I agree with that. Is it a reasonable
- 1:19:55demand if it was clearly written by an attorney
- 1:19:58but claimant is claiming to be unrepresented?
- 1:20:03I should probably let Dan answer that question.
- 1:20:08Go ahead, Dan. You've probably never seen anything
- 1:20:10like that, have you? Not a single time. I think
- 1:20:14it's a reasonable demand so long as it meets
- 1:20:17the definition of what a reasonable demand is,
- 1:20:20whether it's sent by an attorney or a claimant.
- 1:20:23or authored by an attorney for a claimant to
- 1:20:25send the applied covenant of good faith and fair
- 1:20:29dealings applies to insurance companies. The
- 1:20:31issue is what the insurance company does with
- 1:20:33the demand, not who authored it. Well, the statute
- 1:20:37999 does not apply to people who are unrepresented.
- 1:20:47Would that be unrepresented if the claimant had
- 1:20:50some help from an attorney to write the letter?
- 1:20:53That was the question that I understood to be
- 1:20:56posed. And that is an issue that has not been
- 1:20:58decided in California. An argument could be made
- 1:21:05that because the insured actually had counsel,
- 1:21:09which means, I mean, think about it. Why does
- 1:21:12999 not apply to unrepresented claimants? It
- 1:21:15doesn't apply to them because they don't go around
- 1:21:17and read statutes. They don't know what their
- 1:21:18legal obligations are. And so they're not bound
- 1:21:20or shouldn't be bound by a statute with all kinds
- 1:21:23of detailed provisions regarding how you do and
- 1:21:25don't make a settlement demand. But a claimant
- 1:21:28who has consulted with an attorney and who writes
- 1:21:31a letter pursuant to the attorney's advice on
- 1:21:35what to include and not include, an argument
- 1:21:37could be made that that is not a unrepresented
- 1:21:42claimant, because with respect to the demand
- 1:21:45letter and the components of the demand letter,
- 1:21:47the claimant was represented. Having said that,
- 1:21:50that's going to be a subject for the courts to
- 1:21:52decide in the future, and there is no law on
- 1:21:55that today. What's the scope of the privilege
- 1:22:02waiver in advice of counsel defense? You waive
- 1:22:08all communications that relate to the advice
- 1:22:12in question. And sometimes an argument will be
- 1:22:15made that the waiver should go beyond that. And
- 1:22:17that would be decided by a judge on a case by
- 1:22:21case basis, depending on what what it does not
- 1:22:27mean that every communication you've ever had
- 1:22:28with a lawyer is suddenly disclosable. But there
- 1:22:32are arguments about whether more should be disclosed
- 1:22:36than just the communications relating to the
- 1:22:39specific opinion. So there are fights about that.
- 1:22:44Okay, this will be our last question. How about
- 1:22:46in terms of a release that are in direct conflict
- 1:22:49to the conditions of the demand? An example,
- 1:22:52plaintiff will not release the defendant's attorney
- 1:22:55and the release includes the defendant's attorney.
- 1:23:01Yeah, that goes to, there's a case called Berkman
- 1:23:04versus Mercury where the Mercury was held liable
- 1:23:08in excess of the policy limits because it refused
- 1:23:11to make changes to a settlement agreement. And
- 1:23:17then the case called Hogwarts that followed Mercury
- 1:23:21that talked about what happens when the insurance
- 1:23:23company accepts all the material terms of a settlement
- 1:23:25demand. But then there's a disagreement on the
- 1:23:29scope of the release agreement. And then the
- 1:23:32HOD Roger court said, well, there's a settlement
- 1:23:33there even though you didn't execute a release
- 1:23:37agreement. But the short answer is yes, the insurance
- 1:23:42company can be held liable if it refuses to make
- 1:23:45changes to the settlement agreement. But again,
- 1:23:48it's a case by case basis. What were the changes?
- 1:23:55did the demand go out and say hey we don't want
- 1:23:58to we don't want it to include x we don't want
- 1:24:01the release to include x y and z and the insurance
- 1:24:04company sends a release that has x y and z because
- 1:24:06that's the standard release the adjuster sends
- 1:24:09and then the the plaintiff says oh open limits
- 1:24:14bad faith doesn't give the insurance company
- 1:24:17an opportunity to make changes to the release
- 1:24:19agreement. In that situation, there's probably
- 1:24:22a pretty good argument that it's not unreasonable.
- 1:24:24The insurance company was just following what
- 1:24:27it does and had the plaintiff request the changes,
- 1:24:30they would have been made. But if you have a
- 1:24:33situation where changes are requested and the
- 1:24:35insurance company repeatedly says no, the situation
- 1:24:37could be different. I agree with Dan, and just
- 1:24:42to clarify what the issue is, if the insurance
- 1:24:46company inadvertently provides a release that
- 1:24:50doesn't perfectly comply with the terms of the
- 1:24:52demand, that may not constitute bad faith. And
- 1:24:55in fact, there are cases that can be found online
- 1:24:58where courts have refused to hold insurance companies
- 1:25:00liable for bad faith under that circumstance.
- 1:25:03However, If a reasonable release term is demanded
- 1:25:07as part of a settlement by the claimant and the
- 1:25:09insurance company knowingly refuses to provide
- 1:25:13that reasonable term, then that could qualify
- 1:25:17as unreasonable conduct that prevented the case
- 1:25:19from settling and opens to policy. Okay. All
- 1:25:24right. Well, that's the end of our presentation.
- 1:25:27Thank you, Peter. Thank you, Dan. It's been a
- 1:25:30great discussion. And good day, everyone. Thank
- 1:25:35you, Arnie. Thank you.