Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use Office Rivalry Productively
Transcript
- Lucas: There's this moment in Uber's 2014 playbook that still fascinates me. When they were trying to break into new cities, they'd actually target Lyft drivers specifically — offering them guaranteed earnings, sign-on bonuses, the whole thing. Not just any driver, Lyft drivers. Luna: Right, the head to head poaching. I remember reading that in some markets, Uber would even set up shop literally across the street from Lyft's driver onboarding events. Lucas: Exactly. And look, that kind of rivalry is brutal. It cost both companies millions. But here's the thing — that same competitive fire, when you look at it from the individual driver's perspective, probably made both of them better. Drivers had to step up their game, cleaner cars, better route knowledge, friendlier service. The rivalry created a forcing function. Luna: So you're saying office rivalry can be productive? Because my experience has mostly been the opposite — the person who treats you like a competitor usually just ends up hoarding information or throwing you under the bus. Lucas: That's the destructive version, absolutely. But there is a productive version. And I think the difference comes down to a few specific rules. Let me walk through them. Luna: Okay, I'm listening. But first — are we talking about rivalry between teams, or between individuals sitting three cubicles apart? Lucas: Both, actually. The dynamics are similar, though the stakes feel different. Let's start with the individual level because that's where most of us feel it most acutely. Rule one: pick the right opponent. Luna: Meaning someone who's roughly at your level, not your boss or someone way more junior. Lucas: Exactly. The ideal rival is someone whose skills you respect, whose performance is in the same ballpark as yours, and who you believe plays fair. If you pick someone who's significantly ahead, you get discouraged. If you pick someone who's behind, you get complacent. The sweet spot is someone who keeps you on your toes without making you feel hopeless. Luna: That sounds almost like a workout buddy for your career. Someone who pushes you but doesn't crush you. Lucas: That's exactly the analogy. And it leads to rule two: keep the comparison metrics objective. This is where most office rivalries go off the rails. When you start comparing subjective things — who got more praise in the meeting, who the boss seems to like more — it becomes a resentment spiral. But if you compare something measurable, like sales numbers, project completion rates, customer satisfaction scores, it stays productive. Luna: I've seen that go wrong too, though. There was a team at my old company where two account managers were pitted against each other on quarterly revenue. It got so toxic they stopped sharing leads, and the team's overall numbers actually dropped. Lucas: That's a perfect example of why rule three is crucial: limit the scope. Don't let rivalry bleed into every interaction. Decide together, or with your manager, that you're competing on one or two specific dimensions — say, new client acquisition or speed of response — and everywhere else you're collaborators. The problem in your example was that the rivalry became total. Luna: So compartmentalize it. Like, 'We're rivals on the sales leaderboard, but we still share market intel.' Lucas: Right. And rule four is the one people forget most often: have a post-rivalry decompression ritual. After the quarter ends, after the project wraps, you need a moment where you both acknowledge the competition is paused. Go get coffee, talk about something completely unrelated. It signals that the rivalry isn't personal, it's situational. Luna: That's smart. Because otherwise the tension just accumulates. You never get to reset. Lucas: Exactly. And there's actually some research backing this up. A study out of Stanford a few years back looked at what they called 'competitive helping' — people who saw a colleague as a rival but still shared knowledge. The ones who did best were the ones who had clear, bounded competition and a reset ritual. Luna: So it's not about eliminating rivalry, it's about structuring it. That actually reminds me of something from sports — like how tennis players can be fierce competitors on court and then have dinner together after. Lucas: Perfect analogy. Federer and Nadal. They pushed each other to be better, but they never let the rivalry define their entire relationship. That's the model. Luna: And if you're on the receiving end of someone else's rivalry — say a coworker starts treating you like a competitor without your consent — how do you handle that? Lucas: That's the tough scenario, because you can't control someone else's behavior. But you can try to reframe it. First, don't escalate. If they're being aggressive, the worst thing you can do is match their energy. Second, try to have a direct conversation — 'I notice we seem to be competing for X. Is that intentional? Can we set some ground rules?' Nine times out of ten, naming it defuses it. Luna: And if they don't want to collaborate? If they're genuinely out to get you? Lucas: Then you involve your manager. Not as a complaint, but as a request for clarity — 'I want to perform well, but I'm feeling some tension with X. Can we clarify roles or expectations?' A good manager will see that as a sign of maturity, not weakness. Luna: Quick honest thing — a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these episodes possible. If you've gotten something useful out of episodes like this one, that's the simplest way to keep the show ad-free and independent. Lucas: Yeah, it really does make a difference. And we don't run ads or ask for much — just that if the show has helped you think through a career move or a workplace challenge, you can toss a few bucks in the virtual jar. No pressure, but it genuinely keeps us going. Luna: Alright, back to rivalry. So you mentioned the Stanford study — what exactly did it find? Lucas: The researchers looked at knowledge-sharing among pharmaceutical sales reps. They found that when reps saw a colleague as a rival, they were less likely to share tips — unless the competition was framed around a common goal, like beating another region's numbers. Then rivalry actually increased sharing, because helping your rival helped the team, and the team's success mattered more than individual ranking. Luna: So the key is aligning rivalry with a shared superordinate goal. That makes sense. If we're both trying to get promoted, that's zero-sum. But if we're both trying to make our department the best in the company, we can compete on who contributes more while still cooperating. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the best managers deliberately create that kind of structure. They set team goals first, individual goals second. They celebrate team wins more loudly than individual ones. And they rotate who gets the spotlight so rivalry doesn't calcify into resentment. Luna: I've also seen rivalry work well when the competitors have different strengths. Like one person is great at closing deals, another is great at relationship building. They can compete on overall performance while learning from each other. Lucas: That's a great point. Complementary rivalry — where you're not competing on the exact same dimension but on overall output — tends to be more productive because it's less threatening. You're not trying to beat them at their game, you're trying to beat them at yours. Luna: And it forces you to develop your own distinctive edge. If you try to copy your rival's style, you'll always be second best. But if you double down on what makes you unique, you create your own lane. Lucas: Right. And that's actually the hidden benefit of productive rivalry — it clarifies your own value proposition. When you're competing, you have to ask yourself: what do I do better than anyone else? And that's a question worth answering even if you never had a rival. Luna: So let's say someone listening wants to intentionally cultivate a productive rivalry. How do they start? Do they just go up to a coworker and say, 'Hey, want to be rivals?' Lucas: Maybe not that directly. But you can create conditions. Start by tracking your own performance more rigorously. Then, when you see a colleague whose numbers are close to yours, find a natural way to mention it — 'Hey, I noticed we both closed around the same amount last quarter. Want to see if we can both push higher this quarter?' Frame it as mutual improvement, not competition. Luna: That's a softer entry. And it gives the other person an out — they can say no if they're not interested. Lucas: Exactly. And if they say yes, you agree on the rules upfront. 'Let's share our best practices once a month. Let's not badmouth each other. And at the end of the quarter, whoever wins buys coffee.' That kind of thing. Luna: The coffee bet is a nice ritual. It keeps it light. Lucas: It does. And it gives you that decompression moment we talked about. The loser buys, you sit down, you talk about something else. The rivalry resets. Luna: What about rivalries that form organically — like you join a company and there's already someone who's seen as your peer. You didn't choose it, but it's there. Lucas: That's actually more common than the intentional kind. And the same rules apply, but you have to be more proactive. If you sense someone is treating you as a rival, you can try to turn it productive by suggesting the framework. 'I feel like we're both aiming for the same opportunities. Can we make this work for both of us?' Luna: And if they refuse? If they're determined to make it adversarial? Lucas: Then you protect yourself. Document your contributions. Build allies. And focus on your own performance so much that the rivalry becomes irrelevant. The best response to a toxic rival is to outgrow them. Luna: That's a good place to land. So the takeaway: rivalry is a tool, not a poison. Use it deliberately, set boundaries, and always have a reset button. Lucas: And remember — the goal isn't to beat the other person. It's to become a better version of yourself. If the rivalry helps you do that, it's worth having. If it doesn't, it's not.