Latest / Immanuel Truro: Sermons / Four Theories of the Atonement | Rev. Michael Fredericks
Transcript
- 0:00All right. So, our series is called what
- 0:01Christians believe.
- 0:05And we have been
- 0:08looking at some major doctrines of the
- 0:10church, working through them little by
- 0:12little. Here's what we've covered so
- 0:14far. We have said in our series that
- 0:17Christians believe God has made himself
- 0:20known, especially in Jesus. That was the
- 0:22sermon on the word of God. What it means
- 0:24that we can know God, how we can know
- 0:26God. Christians believe that God is
- 0:28triune. That was a sermon on the
- 0:29trinity. Christians believe that God
- 0:31created the universe. So we talked about
- 0:34creation. Christians believe that all
- 0:36human beings are made in the image of
- 0:38God. Christians believe that a spiritual
- 0:41enemy of God exists called Satan.
- 0:44Christians believe that all human beings
- 0:46have sinned, turning to our own way.
- 0:49Next slide, please.
- 0:51And uh last Sunday, Christians believe
- 0:54that despite our sin, God pursues
- 0:58relationship with us because of his
- 1:00unfailing love. We talked about how God
- 1:02pursues us with the chairs. Um okay.
- 1:05Today, today we are saying this that
- 1:09Christians believe that the greatest
- 1:11demonstration of God's love was on the
- 1:14cross where Christ atoned for our sins
- 1:17that we may be saved.
- 1:20Yes, sir.
- 1:25>> There's no Okay. All right. Well, if if
- 1:28you follow along with the highlighted
- 1:30parts in the text, hopefully the next
- 1:32slide is the right one. Should be good.
- 1:34Okay. So, with our with our theological
- 1:37focus now squarely on Jesus in our
- 1:39series, I want to start uh this morning
- 1:42by just reminding ourselves of the
- 1:44fundamentals of Christian belief
- 1:47regarding Jesus Christ. And uh and I
- 1:51think a good way to do that is to look
- 1:53at the Nyian creed. We've talked about
- 1:55this already. 3:25 AD is when the Nyian
- 1:59creed was written. So this very old,
- 2:01very ancient statement of belief from
- 2:03the church. This is just the Jesus part
- 2:06of the Nyine creed. So there's bit
- 2:08before that about the father. Then
- 2:09there's the big Jesus section and
- 2:10there's a little bit at the end about
- 2:11the Holy Spirit and the church. Uh, so I
- 2:14just want us to actually, just like
- 2:16we're not Baptists, stand together and
- 2:19recite this part of the Nian Creed
- 2:21together. Can we do that? If you're able
- 2:23to, please join us.
- 2:27All right. It says this. We believe in
- 2:30one Lord Jesus Christ, the only son of
- 2:33God, eternally begotten of the Father,
- 2:37God from God, light from light, true God
- 2:41from true God, begotten not made, of one
- 2:45being with the Father. Through him all
- 2:49things were made. For us and for our
- 2:52salvation, he came down from heaven, was
- 2:55incarnate from the Holy Spirit and the
- 2:58Virgin Mary, and was made man. For our
- 3:02sake, he was crucified under Pontious
- 3:05Pilate. He suffered death and was
- 3:08buried. On the third day, he rose again
- 3:11in accordance with the scriptures. He
- 3:14ascended into heaven and is seated at
- 3:17the right hand of the Father. He will
- 3:20come again in glory to judge the living
- 3:24and the dead and his kingdom will have
- 3:27no end. Amen. You can be seated.
- 3:31These are statements. These are
- 3:34statements which unite the church. This
- 3:38is one of the reasons I love the Nyian
- 3:40creed because thousands of different
- 3:42denominations of every single variety of
- 3:45Christianity say amen to these words. I
- 3:49think that's pretty cool. Of all the
- 3:50things that we think about that divide
- 3:52us as Christians, we are united in these
- 3:54words, which is beautiful.
- 3:57Now, I want to just look quickly at the
- 3:59different parts and the next slide shows
- 4:01you um I've I've broken them into color
- 4:03sections. So, the first part there, that
- 4:05green section, that's a section of the
- 4:07Nying creed that speaks about Jesus's
- 4:09identity. We covered that in the Trinity
- 4:12sermon. And then in the next part there,
- 4:14the second part speaks about his
- 4:16incarnation, his coming to earth as a
- 4:18human being. And I thought about doing a
- 4:20sermon on that in the series, but I did
- 4:23a whole sermon on that at Christmas time
- 4:25uh as we talked about Jesus's birth. So,
- 4:28we're not going to spend time on that
- 4:29today. Then it says in the white part
- 4:31there, for our sake, he was crucified
- 4:33under Pontius Pilate. He suffered death
- 4:35and was buried. That's what we're going
- 4:36to look at today. And then the next
- 4:38section on the third day he rose again
- 4:40in accordance with the scriptures and so
- 4:42on. We're going to talk about that on
- 4:44Easter. You might have guessed. Uh and
- 4:46then in the very last message in this
- 4:49series, we're going to cover what's in
- 4:51the blue there about Jesus's return and
- 4:54his kingdom and what that's going to
- 4:55look like. So that's how we're using the
- 4:59Nyine Creed. But today, as the countdown
- 5:02to Good Friday is on, let's zero in on
- 5:05the cross.
- 5:09I remember when Mel Gibson's The Passion
- 5:12of the Christ film came to theaters back
- 5:16in 2004.
- 5:19It was a Hollywood movie about the
- 5:21suffering and death of Jesus Christ. And
- 5:24it was weird. It was weird because
- 5:27conservative churches like mine
- 5:31were encouraging their people to go to
- 5:34the movies, right? Some of us remember a
- 5:36time when good Christians don't go to
- 5:38the movies. Um but uh it was a time
- 5:41churches were not only were churches
- 5:43saying you should go see this but they
- 5:44were like booking whole theaters. They
- 5:47were like buying all the tickets and
- 5:48like handing them out on the street as
- 5:50like an evangelistic thing. Anyone
- 5:51remember that? Anyone was around for
- 5:53that? Yeah, I remember that. Did anyone
- 5:54go see The Passion of the Christ? Yeah,
- 5:56some of you did. Um
- 5:59u what's even more wild about it was
- 6:00that the movie was rated R. an R-rated
- 6:03movie, but it was rated R because it
- 6:06accurately portrays what Jesus went
- 6:10through, the horrible, bloody, gruesome
- 6:13violence he experienced at the hands of
- 6:16his Roman captives.
- 6:18And I think that for many people, seeing
- 6:20that movie was the first time that they
- 6:22really grasped just how terrible the
- 6:25cross was for Jesus. And I know a lot of
- 6:29people can't bring themselves to watch
- 6:31it again or to watch it at all for that
- 6:34reason. He suffered a cruel,
- 6:38humiliating, and excruciating death on
- 6:41the cross. The word excruciating
- 6:43actually comes from crucifixion.
- 6:48We could talk we could talk more about
- 6:50the nature of that experience. I don't
- 6:52want to get into that today. If you're a
- 6:54podcast person, uh there's a podcast
- 6:56called The Rest is History. Some of you
- 6:58may have listened to that before if
- 6:59you're a history person. And they had a
- 7:01whole episode a couple years ago on
- 7:03crucifixion. Um it's it lays out a
- 7:06precise historical account of how the
- 7:09Romans crucified people including Jesus.
- 7:12Uh if you want to dig deeper on that.
- 7:14But today I want to focus less on what
- 7:16happened on the uh in terms of the
- 7:18physical death of Jesus and more on why
- 7:22it happened.
- 7:24The question for us today is why did
- 7:27Jesus die on the cross?
- 7:33And there's two ways to answer that
- 7:35question. There's like the very like
- 7:38literal reason, the kind of historical
- 7:40reason where you could say, well, at
- 7:42that point in time, uh Jesus was
- 7:44starting a new religious movement and
- 7:46people were calling him the Messiah and
- 7:47that made people in power uncomfortable.
- 7:49It made the the Jewish leaders
- 7:51uncomfortable that he was uh you know
- 7:53they were calling him a heretic and he
- 7:54was stirring up this new religious
- 7:56understanding and made the Roman uh
- 7:59officials uncomfortable because they
- 8:01liked things to be calm and steady and
- 8:03didn't want disruption and so he was a
- 8:05disruptor right and because of that uh
- 8:08he was arrested and crucified. So that's
- 8:12that's sort of you know like the the the
- 8:15why. But why on a deeper level? Why on a
- 8:19deeper level? Why did Jesus die on the
- 8:21cross? And the way we we learned it in
- 8:24Sunday school, right, was that well,
- 8:26Jesus died on the cross for our sins,
- 8:28right? For my sin, for your sin, so we
- 8:31can be saved from our sin. And we say
- 8:35amen to that. Yes. Amen to that. Uh like
- 8:38we said last week with our chairs, our
- 8:41sin has separated us from God. There's
- 8:43been a separation between God and man.
- 8:46And we can attempt to turn our lives
- 8:48around, but we're never going to sustain
- 8:50it very long before we mess up again.
- 8:52So, we've we've got this problem, this
- 8:54terminal sin condition. And if it's not
- 8:56resolved, each of us will die in this
- 8:58state of separation from God for
- 9:01eternity. So, that's why Jesus died. He
- 9:04God so loved the world that he gave his
- 9:06son. And in his death, Jesus took our
- 9:09sin upon himself and in doing so makes
- 9:11it possible for us to be reconciled to
- 9:14God. So these are these are truths of
- 9:16the gospel. Why did Jesus die on the
- 9:18cross? Another simple way of
- 9:19illustrating it is like this. So I'm
- 9:22going to use the white board here. Okay.
- 9:24So we've got the cross here and we have
- 9:27people
- 9:29here, sinful people.
- 9:32And uh there's a a verse. It's uh 2
- 9:35Corinthians 5:21. It says, "He became
- 9:38sin who knew no sin that in him we might
- 9:44become the righteousness of God." He
- 9:48became sin. Jesus took sin upon himself.
- 9:51He became sinful. Not he didn't become
- 9:53sinful, but he bore our sins. He became
- 9:55sin who knew no sin. He was spotless. He
- 9:57was sinless. So that we might become the
- 10:00righteousness of God. So there's this
- 10:02sort of exchange that happens
- 10:05with Christ's death on the cross and
- 10:07through faith. This beautiful exchange
- 10:10takes place. He takes our sin, shame,
- 10:15guilt, wickedness, brokenness on the
- 10:18cross. He bears it for us and removes it
- 10:21from us. And when we believe that in
- 10:24faith and we trust in him as our savior,
- 10:26we receive his righteousness.
- 10:30The the apostle Paul calls it
- 10:33justification by faith. Justification by
- 10:37faith. That is righteousness, holiness,
- 10:40purification,
- 10:42holiness through faith.
- 10:44And as a result of that, because Jesus
- 10:47deals with this sin problem, we can have
- 10:50a restored relationship with God
- 10:53forever. We have the availability to
- 10:56have relationship with God. We'll put
- 10:59God there in a cloud. We don't know
- 11:01again how to how to draw God
- 11:03effectively. Okay, there we go. Okay, so
- 11:10this uh this basic sort of summary of
- 11:14what Christ did on the cross is laid out
- 11:16beautifully in the book of Isaiah.
- 11:18There's a passage in Isaiah. We I I
- 11:20quoted it last week a little bit, but I
- 11:22want to read the whole thing today. It's
- 11:24it's known as the suffering servant
- 11:26passage. This was written, you know,
- 11:28hundreds of years before Jesus came and
- 11:32it just vividly um portrays what would
- 11:36happen when when the Messiah comes and
- 11:39dies for us. So, I'm going to read that
- 11:42um starting in Isaiah 52:13.
- 11:46It's on the screen as well.
- 11:48So this is the prophet Isaiah sort of
- 11:50prophesying about the coming of the
- 11:52Messiah and what he would experience his
- 11:55death, the degree of his suffering and
- 11:57what it would accomplish.
- 11:59It says, "See my servant will prosper.
- 12:01He will be highly exalted." But many
- 12:04were amazed when they saw him. Amazed in
- 12:06a bad way. His face was so disfigured he
- 12:10seemed hardly human. And from his
- 12:13appearance, one would scarcely know he
- 12:14was a man. and he will startle many
- 12:17nations. Kings will stand speechless in
- 12:20his presence for they will see what they
- 12:23had not been told. They will understand
- 12:25what they had not heard about. And then
- 12:27to chapter 53, who has believed our
- 12:31message? To whom has the Lord revealed
- 12:35his powerful arm? My servant will My
- 12:38servant grew up in the Lord's presence
- 12:40like a tender green chute, like a root
- 12:42in dry ground. There was nothing
- 12:44beautiful or majestic about his
- 12:46appearance. Nothing to attract us to
- 12:48him. Just a normal guy Jesus was. But he
- 12:52was despised and rejected. A man of
- 12:55sorrows acquainted with deepest grief.
- 12:58We turned our backs on him and looked
- 13:00the other way. He was despised and we
- 13:03did not care.
- 13:05Yet it was our weakness he carried. It
- 13:09was our sorrows that weighed him down.
- 13:13And we thought his troubles were a
- 13:15punishment from God, a punishment for
- 13:16his own sins. But he was pierced for our
- 13:20rebellion, crushed for our sins. He was
- 13:25beaten so we could be whole. He was
- 13:28whipped so we could be healed. This is
- 13:30that ex beautiful exchange that takes
- 13:32place. All of us like sheep have strayed
- 13:34away. We've left God's path to follow
- 13:37our own. Yet the Lord laid on him the
- 13:40sins of us all.
- 13:42He was oppressed and treated harshly.
- 13:44Yet he never said a word. He was little
- 13:46like a lamb to the slaughter. And as a
- 13:49sheep is silent before the shears, he
- 13:51did not open his mouth.
- 13:55Unjustly condemned. He was led away.
- 13:59No one cared that he died without
- 14:01descendants,
- 14:03that his life was cut short in
- 14:04midstream. But he was struck down for
- 14:07the rebellion of my people. He had done
- 14:09no wrong. He had never deceived anyone,
- 14:12but he was buried like a criminal. He
- 14:14was put in a rich man's grave.
- 14:16Incredible, precise uh prophecy, isn't
- 14:19it? This is written hundreds of years
- 14:20before, and it just lays out exactly
- 14:21what happened. But it was the Lord's
- 14:23good plan to crush him and cause him
- 14:25grief.
- 14:27Yet, when he made his life, yet when his
- 14:29life is made an offering for sin, he
- 14:31will have many descendants. He will
- 14:33enjoy a long life, and the Lord's good
- 14:36plan will prosper in his hands. When he
- 14:39sees all that is accomplished by his
- 14:41anguish, he will be satisfied. And
- 14:44because of his experience, my righteous
- 14:46servant will make it possible for many
- 14:48to be counted righteous, for he will
- 14:51bear all their sins.
- 14:53I will give him the honors of a
- 14:55victorious soldier because he exposed
- 14:58himself to death. He was counted among
- 15:00the rebels. He bore the sins of many and
- 15:04interceded for rebels. Wow.
- 15:08He bore the sins of many and interceded
- 15:12for rebels.
- 15:16So this we call the atonement.
- 15:20The atonement.
- 15:22How Christ through his death brought
- 15:25about the reconciliation
- 15:27of God and humankind. That's what
- 15:30atonement kind of means. in our um in
- 15:33our denomination, the CBAC, the Canadian
- 15:35Baptist of Atlantic Canada, we we formed
- 15:37as a denomination in 1906. And in that
- 15:40year, uh some very wise people sat down
- 15:43and wrote what's called the basis of
- 15:45union, which is a doctrinal statement
- 15:48that we ha we hold together as a
- 15:49denomination. Uh a statement of agreed u
- 15:53beliefs. And they have this to say about
- 15:56atonement.
- 15:58It says atonement, the perfect life,
- 16:02vicarious death, and resurrection of
- 16:04Jesus Christ have removed the obstacles
- 16:07in the way of the Holy Spirit's
- 16:10regenerating power and of the Father's
- 16:13forgiving grace being extended to the
- 16:16sinner and constitute for every
- 16:18believing soul an allprevailing plea and
- 16:22sufficient ground for righteousness
- 16:25before God.
- 16:27Now, I know that's wordy, but boy,
- 16:28that's beautiful. Hey, kudos to our
- 16:31Baptist forefathers who wrote that and
- 16:33four mothers. Uh, just it's lovely.
- 16:37Here's a simplified way to express the
- 16:38meaning of atonement. Atonement, if you
- 16:41break it down, you could say at onement.
- 16:44At onement, it literally brings us back
- 16:47into one with God, into harmony with God
- 16:52instead of separation from God. It makes
- 16:55amends in a way between us and God
- 16:58through the vicarious death of Christ.
- 17:01Now, a lot of people hear all of that
- 17:06and they follow it up with a question.
- 17:08Say, "Cool. Yeah, that sounds cool. I
- 17:10like that. But how how
- 17:15does Jesus's death make our salvation
- 17:18possible? How did the death of the God
- 17:21man on a Roman cross 2,000 years ago
- 17:25make it possible for our sins to be
- 17:29atoned for? Make it possible for us to
- 17:31be reconciled back to God. What was it
- 17:33about this experience of Jesus dying on
- 17:36a cross that makes all this true?
- 17:40I had a I had a professor at St. Vex
- 17:42University uh when I was studying there.
- 17:44Not a Christian. It wasn't even a
- 17:45religious studies course. I don't
- 17:46remember what the course was, but I
- 17:48remember this. I remember that he knew
- 17:50that there was a small group of us in
- 17:51our class that were Christians and for
- 17:53one reason or another, he called us out
- 17:54in class one day and and uh he he cuz we
- 17:58had somehow mentioned Jesus or our faith
- 18:00in class and he said, "Okay, you
- 18:02Christians, answer me this." Uh and I
- 18:04remember the spotlight's on us, the
- 18:05whole class is staring at us. Tell me,
- 18:07how does Jesus's death on a cross save
- 18:09you from your sins?
- 18:11Oh well um yeah good good question. We
- 18:17really didn't have an answer and I'm
- 18:19actually very thankful for that moment.
- 18:22Some people would say oh those secular
- 18:23professors I was like no thank you thank
- 18:25you for asking that question actually
- 18:27because it forced me to do a big deep
- 18:30study on how the death of Jesus on the
- 18:33cross saves us from our sins. And it has
- 18:36led me to uh discover that there are
- 18:39these theories of the atonement.
- 18:42Theories of the atonement. Uh it's this
- 18:44is a question that people have wrestled
- 18:46with over the whole lifetime of the
- 18:48church from the earliest years. They've
- 18:51said how is this what how does this
- 18:54work? So they developed these theories
- 18:57of how it works. There's actually seven
- 18:59or more theories of the atonement.
- 19:04Um, today we're going to look at at four
- 19:06of them that are kind of the most widely
- 19:10accepted and I'm going to go through
- 19:12them. I'm going to use the whiteboard,
- 19:13go through these and then um make one
- 19:16last point. Okay.
- 19:20So,
- 19:21to answer that question, how does
- 19:24Jesus's death on the cross actually
- 19:26bring about the possibility of
- 19:28salvation? The first theory of the
- 19:30atonement I want to look at is called
- 19:31the ransom theory. The ransom theory.
- 19:35The ransom theory was the most prominent
- 19:37view in the early church for the first
- 19:39thousand years of the church. Actually,
- 19:42this was the most prominent view. It was
- 19:45uh articulated well by a man named
- 19:48origin in the 3rd century, one of the
- 19:50early church fathers.
- 19:52And the key idea of the ransom theory is
- 19:55that Jesus gives his life as a ransom.
- 19:58And that's from a couple of key texts.
- 20:00Mark 10:45 where Jesus says, "The Son of
- 20:03Man came to give his life as a ransom
- 20:06for many." And then Paul repeats that in
- 20:091 Timothy chapter 2, where he says, "For
- 20:11there is one God, there is one mediator
- 20:13between God and man, the man Christ
- 20:16Jesus, who gave himself as a ransom for
- 20:20all, which is the testimony given at the
- 20:22proper time.
- 20:24Jesus gave his life as a ransom.
- 20:28So then that raises a question. You read
- 20:30those passages and you go, okay, I kind
- 20:32of understand the idea of a ransom,
- 20:33right? Someone's sort of been kidnapped
- 20:35or held hostage and then someone's
- 20:36asking for a ransom and you pay the
- 20:38ransom and then those people are
- 20:39released. That's what a ransom does. So
- 20:41in this scenario, uh if Jesus paid a
- 20:43ransom, the question then is well who
- 20:45did he pay a ransom to? To whom is the
- 20:47ransom paid? And in the dramatic imagery
- 20:51of this view, the idea is that actually
- 20:54the ransom was paid to the devil.
- 20:57So again, don't really know how to
- 20:58depict the devil. So we'll go with a
- 20:59pitchfork.
- 21:01All right.
- 21:03Okay. So rant. So the devil play
- 21:07features predominantly Satan in features
- 21:09predominantly in this theory going back
- 21:11to the garden, right? It starts with
- 21:13Satan where he tempts Adam and Eve,
- 21:16deceives them and they that causes them
- 21:19to sin.
- 21:21And because he did that and they sinned,
- 21:24now humanity has been ins snared by the
- 21:28devil. So we'll put a sort of a lasso
- 21:30around the human race. The human race
- 21:33has been ins snared by the devil,
- 21:36trapped,
- 21:37held captive to sin and death and and to
- 21:40the devil. held captive and because of
- 21:43this captivity that we have because of
- 21:45these chains that bind us, we are
- 21:48there's a separation between us and God.
- 21:50That's where the separation comes in.
- 21:52We're unable to have relationship with
- 21:53God because we're being held captive to
- 21:55sin.
- 21:57Okay? So then God comes up with an idea,
- 22:01a rescue plan, the plan of salvation.
- 22:04And this plan involves making a deal
- 22:07with the devil.
- 22:09Okay? And so the idea is, okay, all
- 22:12right, the devil's got you held captive.
- 22:15We need and I'm going to we're going to
- 22:16pay a ransom so that you will release
- 22:18people. And the price that I will pay is
- 22:22the price of Jesus. So Jesus is the
- 22:25ransom.
- 22:28He gave his life as a ransom for many, a
- 22:30ransom paid to the devil. And so this so
- 22:34Satan thinks, okay, do I want to take
- 22:36this deal? Hm.
- 22:39I have to release all of humanity, but I
- 22:43get Jesus.
- 22:45And he thinks, "Yeah, yeah, that's a
- 22:47good deal. I want that deal. I want that
- 22:49deal. Good trade." So, Satan agrees to
- 22:52the deal. And then Satan then enacts the
- 22:56plan. He enters Judas. Luke 22, it says,
- 22:58"Satan entered Judas, one of the 12. And
- 23:01Judas went to the chief priests and
- 23:03officers of the temple guard and
- 23:04discussed it with them how they might
- 23:06betray Jesus. So sa uh Satan influencing
- 23:10Judas leads to Jesus's betrayal, arrest,
- 23:13crucifixion,
- 23:15and on the cross Jesus pays the ransom.
- 23:20And it works. It works. Humanity, Satan
- 23:23says, "Okay, a deal's a deal." And he
- 23:25releases human beings from their
- 23:28captivity
- 23:30to sin. And now the ability for us to
- 23:32have a relationship with God has been
- 23:35made possible. And Satan is feeling
- 23:38pretty good. You say, "I won. I won. I
- 23:41got the better deal. Woohoo."
- 23:44But but
- 23:47Satan has been outsmarted. Surprise,
- 23:50surprise.
- 23:51Because actually the cross was the bait
- 23:57on a hook. Okay. The cross was like the
- 24:01bait on a hook. And Satan fell for it.
- 24:04He took the bait. Satan saw the bait. He
- 24:07saw he saw Jesus's humanity, Jesus's
- 24:09death, his ability to be to be killed as
- 24:12this very tempting bait. But what he
- 24:15didn't see behind that bait was Jesus's
- 24:17divinity. The hook is the divinity of
- 24:19Christ, you see. And so, because Jesus
- 24:22is God, he is not able to be held by
- 24:26death or the devil. and he rises from
- 24:29the grave. All right. And Satan on on
- 24:33resurrection morning, Satan realizes,
- 24:36"Oh no.
- 24:38OH NO. OH NO. HE TRICKED ME." OKAY. And
- 24:42so Satan is furious. And that's why from
- 24:45now until Christ returns, he's so angry
- 24:48and he's always trying to continually
- 24:51ins snare us again and pull us back into
- 24:53sin and and trap us once again. but he
- 24:56will lose in the end. Okay, so that's
- 24:59the ransom theory in a nutshell. Okay, I
- 25:02mean there's different ways we could
- 25:03discuss that, but in summary, that's
- 25:05kind of how it goes. And the key word um
- 25:08that you might use or the key idea of
- 25:10the ransom theory is freedom.
- 25:14That what Christ accomplishes on the
- 25:17cross is our freedom, our freedom from
- 25:20sin.
- 25:22Okay, that's the ransom theory. Uh held
- 25:24as the kind of the main idea of the
- 25:26church for a thousand years. Not the
- 25:28only one, but for the first thousand
- 25:29years of the church, this was the
- 25:30predominant theory. Um then um there was
- 25:34a theory developed called the Christ
- 25:36Victor theory, which is very similar to
- 25:40ransom theory. That's why I'm using
- 25:41going to use the same color marker.
- 25:43Okay. Um we got different colors for
- 25:45different theories. Um but uh this in
- 25:48very similar to the ransom theory it but
- 25:51uh this term christrist victor was
- 25:53coined in the 1930s
- 25:56uh but it reflects an ancient belief
- 25:59and and the variation with Christ victor
- 26:02is basically that uh a lot of people
- 26:04sort of felt well we don't like the idea
- 26:06of of God having to make a deal with
- 26:08Satan like it seems like that's giving
- 26:10Satan entirely too much credit and
- 26:12entirely too much power that he has the
- 26:14power to ensnare all of the human
- 26:16Um and so um instead what they focused
- 26:19on more is Christ's victory over evil.
- 26:23So they still say yes, humanity's in
- 26:25bondage, but not really in a sense of to
- 26:28the being of Satan, but humanity is in
- 26:30bondage to to sin and to death
- 26:35and and the devil. Yes, he's got us in
- 26:38bondage. Or in general, how you might
- 26:40describe that is just humanity's in
- 26:42bondage to evil.
- 26:45Okay, so evil has us ins snared.
- 26:52And as if that wasn't bad enough,
- 26:54in the act of crucifying Jesus,
- 26:58we see the worst of human depravity on
- 27:01display.
- 27:04At the cross,
- 27:07all the powers of evil
- 27:10converge
- 27:12on this hill of Calvary.
- 27:15All the powers of the world and all the
- 27:17the wickedness of the human heart
- 27:20converge in this moment when Jesus is
- 27:22crucified, when he's nailed to a Roman
- 27:24cross.
- 27:26And humans did the most unthinkable
- 27:28thing imaginable.
- 27:31They killed the son of God. Can you
- 27:34imagine a more evil thing to do?
- 27:37And in that moment, it looks like evil
- 27:39has won.
- 27:42Not only has evil ins snared humanity,
- 27:44but now it has also conquered God in the
- 27:47flesh.
- 27:49Evil has won.
- 27:53Ah, but the paradox is that what seems
- 27:57like a loss for Jesus is actually a
- 28:00victory. In Colossians 2:15 it says,
- 28:03"Having disarmed the powers and
- 28:05authorities, he made a public spectacle
- 28:08of them, triumphing triumphing over them
- 28:11by the cross." The cross was a victory
- 28:15over the powers and authorities.
- 28:18So the victory is won on the cross but
- 28:22not revealed until the resurrection.
- 28:26When Jesus rises, it becomes clear.
- 28:29When Jesus rises, everyone realizes,
- 28:32"Oh, actually, evil doesn't get the last
- 28:35word." And Jesus conquers sin, death,
- 28:38and the devil. Evil does its worst, but
- 28:42Christ still wins.
- 28:45Our sin put him there. His love held him
- 28:48there. And his power over death sets us
- 28:52free. So once again, it's about this
- 28:56idea of setting us free from our sins
- 29:00and from evil. And if we were to use a
- 29:03key word
- 29:05to summarize this, we might say victory.
- 29:07Christrist victor, Christ the victor.
- 29:11My chains are gone. I've been set free.
- 29:14God, my savior has ransomed me.
- 29:18So we are set free from sin and death
- 29:20and Christ has the victory. Okay. So
- 29:23that's one way to frame it and
- 29:25understand it. And for much of the early
- 29:27church history, this was the major way
- 29:30of understanding the cross. And then a
- 29:34guy named an Anselm comes along. Um this
- 29:37was in about the year 1000. And Anselm
- 29:40says, "Well, I'm not sure that that's
- 29:42the main thing that happened on the
- 29:45cross, Jesus paying a ransom or winning
- 29:47a victory. He sees something else."
- 29:51And so he proposes what is known as the
- 29:55satisfaction theory
- 29:58aka the penal substitution theory.
- 30:02This microphone is bugging me. Okay. So
- 30:07um I'm going to use the red marker for
- 30:08that one. Okay. So satisfaction theory
- 30:11is sort of the title that Ansom gave it
- 30:12but it became known as the penal
- 30:15substitution theory after the Protestant
- 30:17Reformation.
- 30:19This is probably the view that most
- 30:20Baptists know best. Um, it it's not
- 30:24mainly about a transaction with the
- 30:26devil or evil, but more so about a
- 30:30transaction with God the Father.
- 30:33The starting point is that human sin is
- 30:37very serious and God is very holy and
- 30:41our sin creates the separation.
- 30:44God is also very just.
- 30:47He is a just judge and because of that
- 30:51sin must be punished.
- 30:54The Bible says that the wages of sin is
- 30:56death. The wages of sin is death. We
- 30:59understand that as eternal separation
- 31:01from God. So you can imagine a courtroom
- 31:03scene in this in this theory. Hold on.
- 31:06This mic, if I don't fix this, I'm just
- 31:08going to be going crazy for the Yeah,
- 31:11I'm having a problem with the mic. Ever
- 31:13since Hudson preached and used my mic
- 31:14and changed the shape of it to fit his
- 31:17weird ears,
- 31:20now it doesn't fit my ears.
- 31:22Okay,
- 31:24maybe I got it that time.
- 31:27All right. So imagine a courtroom scene
- 31:30and and God is the judge and he's seated
- 31:34at his judge's desk and we are seated
- 31:37across from him
- 31:40and the case has been made that we are
- 31:42sinners
- 31:44and the verdict has come down guilty.
- 31:48Yes, he's guilty. Yes, she is guilty of
- 31:51sin. And because the Bible says the
- 31:54wages of sin is death or the just
- 31:56penalty for sin is death, then God
- 31:59declares the death penalty.
- 32:02And this is a good and just decision of
- 32:06God in this scenario. So there's a
- 32:08lightning bolt that kind of depict the
- 32:10idea of God's justice and judgment
- 32:12coming down on us.
- 32:16And just as he's about to put us in
- 32:19handcuffs and say, "Take them away.
- 32:22Something stirs at the back of the
- 32:25courtroom. All right. And and then next
- 32:28thing you know, bursting through the
- 32:30doors enters Jesus. BOOM. THE DOORS OPEN
- 32:33UP AND THE whole room is stunned in
- 32:36silence and they watch as Jesus walks up
- 32:38the aisle and HE SAYS, "STOP THE
- 32:41PROCEEDINGS. EVERYONE STOP THE
- 32:43PROCEEDINGS."
- 32:46He says, "I
- 32:49will take his place. I will take his
- 32:54punishment."
- 32:56And God the Father, the just judge
- 32:58considers this.
- 33:01And he says, "Yes.
- 33:04He is a spotless lamb. He is a suitable
- 33:08substitute that satisfies
- 33:11my justice." That's why it's called the
- 33:14satisfaction theory.
- 33:17And so God says, "Okay, I will accept
- 33:20that." And the death penalty falls on
- 33:23Jesus,
- 33:24not us.
- 33:27So what would have been our punishment
- 33:31instead goes to Christ.
- 33:34And he's taken away and he's crucified.
- 33:39And the penalty
- 33:41goes to a substitute. That's why it's
- 33:43the penal substitution theory. The
- 33:47penalty, our penalty goes to a suitable
- 33:50substitute in our place.
- 33:53And the result then for us is that our
- 33:55sins are forgiven.
- 33:57Our debt has been paid. We have peace
- 34:00with God. And we walk out of the
- 34:03courtroom scot-free.
- 34:07Now this this approach, this
- 34:09satisfaction theory, this penal
- 34:11substitution theory is very consistent
- 34:13with the Old Testament picture of
- 34:15sacrifice. We have animal sacrifices
- 34:18particularly on the day of atonement.
- 34:21The day of atonement when a uh when a
- 34:25scapegoat is selected from amongst the
- 34:27animals and all of the sins of the
- 34:30nation are symbolically put onto this
- 34:33scapegoat who is then sent out into the
- 34:36wilderness to die
- 34:39and the sins of the people are forgiven
- 34:40for another year.
- 34:43So Jesus in is in a way in this theory
- 34:46our scapegoat as we read in Isaiah 53
- 34:49the punishment that brought us peace was
- 34:51upon him
- 34:53and as we talked about last Sunday with
- 34:55Abram cutting this covenant with God
- 34:58where God walks the bloody path. God
- 35:01says I will take the punishment if Abram
- 35:05doesn't fulfill his side of the
- 35:07covenant. And this is what happens on
- 35:09the cross. Jesus takes the covenant
- 35:11curse upon himself.
- 35:15So the main uh if you were to use one
- 35:17word to kind of summarize this uh this
- 35:21theory of the atonement, you might say
- 35:22the main thing that is accomplished is
- 35:27forgiveness. Forgiveness.
- 35:33And then one last theory I want to look
- 35:35at is called the moral influence theory.
- 35:38the moral influence theory. So around
- 35:41the same time that Anselm in the year
- 35:43roughly the year 1000 uh said I think
- 35:46that the satisfaction theory is the
- 35:48right approach there was another guy
- 35:49named Abalard who responded to Anselm
- 35:52and said Ansom I don't think you've got
- 35:54it right I think it's this and he
- 35:58proposed what has become known as the
- 36:01moral influence theory and this theory
- 36:04focuses less on what the cross
- 36:07accomplishes
- 36:09and more on what the cross reveals or
- 36:12communicates or says.
- 36:14So the question is not what does the
- 36:16cross do, what does Jesus's death do,
- 36:19but what does it say? What is it
- 36:22communicating?
- 36:25And in the moral influence theory, you
- 36:27would say the cross is saying something.
- 36:29It's radiating a message. When you look
- 36:32at the cross, it's speaking. And the
- 36:35thing that it is speaking is love.
- 36:39Love,
- 36:41love. When you stare at the cross and
- 36:43you think about the death of Christ and
- 36:44what he did, it's shouting love.
- 36:48God is love. God loves you. In Romans
- 36:525:8, it says, "God demonstrates his love
- 36:57for us in that while we were yet
- 36:58sinners, Christ died for us." That's his
- 37:01demonstration of his love. Jesus's life
- 37:04was a life of love.
- 37:06and he died as a martyr for the cause of
- 37:09love.
- 37:10So Jesus's death shows us how sinful we
- 37:14are
- 37:16and how deeply how deeply God loves us
- 37:19anyway despite our sin.
- 37:22And the idea here is that the as as we
- 37:24gaze at the cross,
- 37:27it influences us deeply. As we gaze at
- 37:31the cross, our hearts are moved.
- 37:35Love awakens love in us and we therefore
- 37:41repent of sin and turn towards Christ.
- 37:46We follow his example and become people
- 37:48of love. And so in this in this
- 37:51approach, salvation is not so much a
- 37:54legal transaction that happens between,
- 37:57you know, Jesus and the devil or between
- 38:00Jesus and God and man and God. It's not
- 38:02about a legal transaction. It's that
- 38:05salvation is experienced when we become
- 38:08devoted followers
- 38:11shaped by Christ's love. Humanity is
- 38:13saved by being inspired through ex
- 38:16through the example of the death of
- 38:17Christ to repent and turn to God.
- 38:22So we're influenced by the death of
- 38:24Christ, by the love displayed on the
- 38:26cross. That's the moral influence
- 38:28theory.
- 38:30The main emphasis of the moral influence
- 38:32theory is love.
- 38:37Okay. So,
- 38:40so is it this one or this one or this
- 38:44one or this one?
- 38:47>> Or some other one?
- 38:50Which one is it?
- 38:52And and I What did you say, Shirley?
- 38:55>> Or all of them. Yeah. Hey, I think
- 38:59you're on to something, Shirley.
- 39:01I would say to all of these theories of
- 39:04the atonement, I would say a resounding
- 39:07yes.
- 39:08>> Yes, he did all of that. He I don't
- 39:12think we have to pick. He did all of
- 39:15that and more. Uh William Lane Craig
- 39:18says, "The atonement is a diamond with
- 39:21many facets."
- 39:24And Joel B. Green refers to the
- 39:25atonement as a kaleidoscope.
- 39:28Many different colors and aspects to it
- 39:31that all at once show us the picture of
- 39:34what Christ accomplished.
- 39:37So if you were to ask me which one,
- 39:39Michael, do you think is the right one?
- 39:41I say I think they all have truth.
- 39:43That's what I believe. And you may
- 39:44prefer a particular theory of the
- 39:46atonement. Some people say that they're
- 39:47incompatible with each other. Um I don't
- 39:50think they are, but some people think
- 39:51they are. For me, I see that all of them
- 39:54point us to the truth. Did Jesus's death
- 39:56on the cross win our freedom from death,
- 40:00sin, and the devil, and declare victory
- 40:02over evil?
- 40:03>> Yes. Did Jesus's death on the cross take
- 40:06the just punishment we all deserve for
- 40:08our sin, diverting the penalty of sin
- 40:10onto himself rather than on us, allowing
- 40:13us to be forgiven?
- 40:15>> Yes. Did Jesus's death on the cross
- 40:17reveal the extent of God's love? That he
- 40:20was willing even to let mankind kill him
- 40:23and yet still he loves us, motivating
- 40:25us, influencing us to turn our hearts
- 40:28fully toward him and live new lives.
- 40:31>> Yes.
- 40:32Honestly, I see little to no conflict.
- 40:34Rather, I praise God and thank him that
- 40:38in one act, in one brilliant
- 40:42and yet enormously painful, horrible,
- 40:45excruciating, sacrificial act, he was
- 40:48able to accomplish so much.
- 40:53In 1 Corinthians 1:18, it says this,
- 40:57"For the message, next slide, for the
- 40:59message of the cross is foolishness to
- 41:03those who are perishing, but to us who
- 41:05are being saved, it is the power of
- 41:07God." You know, my professor at St. X,
- 41:10he didn't get it right. He just thought,
- 41:13"It's foolishness. It's foolishness. You
- 41:16you Christians and your weird mythology
- 41:20that somehow the death of a guy on a
- 41:22cross can save you from your sin and
- 41:24give you eternal life. Foolishness
- 41:28to those who are perishing. Yeah, they
- 41:31don't get it. They don't get his
- 41:32nonsense.
- 41:34But to us who are being saved,
- 41:38it's the power of God. It's like, oh my
- 41:40goodness, God is so incredibly powerful.
- 41:45Look at all that he could do through
- 41:47this one sacrificial act. It is the
- 41:50power of God. It is everything.
- 41:54And for you, if you have already
- 41:56experienced this beautiful exchange,
- 42:01praise God. I hope that this message
- 42:02causes you to love Jesus even more, to
- 42:06understand even more richly the depth
- 42:10and beauty of the incredible sacrifice
- 42:12he underwent for you. I really
- 42:13appreciate it.
- 42:16And if you haven't experienced that
- 42:18beautiful exchange through faith in
- 42:20Christ, my prayer is that something that
- 42:23said today will help you recognize your
- 42:25own need for atonement, your own need
- 42:28for salvation,
- 42:30that you will accept it and receive it.
- 42:32Because the wages of sin is death, but
- 42:35the free gift of God is eternal life
- 42:38through Christ Jesus our Lord. Believe
- 42:41it in faith and be saved.
- 42:46>> Amen.
- 42:47>> Hey, cool.