Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E079: Onramp X Google Fiber in Nashville
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the last trade. This week we're excited to bring
- 0:03you a special edition of the show.
- 0:05The following round table discussion was recorded on
- 0:07December 2nd in Nashville, TN during an Onramp Private Client
- 0:11event Co hosted by Google Fiber at the Gibson Garage event
- 0:14space. Moderated by Onramp's Brian
- 0:16Cabela's, the panel features Michael Tanguma, CEO and Co
- 0:19founder of Onramp and partner at Early Riders, Emily Trapani,
- 0:23head of sales at Google Fiber, and Cam Duty, founder of
- 0:26Brickyard Venture, based in Chattanooga.
- 0:28The conversation explores the intersection of technology
- 0:31investment in the evolving landscape of Bitcoin, with a
- 0:34focus on Nashville as a burgeoning hub for innovation.
- 0:37Panelists discuss their experiences in the tech
- 0:39industry, the importance of information asymmetries and
- 0:41driving value creation, and the implications of Bitcoin as a
- 0:45digital protocol for value. The discussion also highlights
- 0:48the cultural and economic factors that position Nashville
- 0:51and Chattanooga as key players in the tech ecosystem, while
- 0:54examining the challenges of traditional venture capital and
- 0:57the objective properties that make Bitcoin a superior form of
- 1:00money. Now time for the show.
- 1:03What you're telling me is that music is about stock, and we're
- 1:07going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 1:11ever assembled in the history of Gutless 9074 198792972000 and
- 1:20whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 1:23over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:26I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 1:30I say when we sell. And it's my great pleasure to
- 1:37moderate today's discussion featuring esteemed panelists
- 1:40across the technological landscape, each with their own
- 1:43unique disciplines and ties to the great city of Nashville.
- 1:47So without further ado, let's begin with some brief intros.
- 1:50We can just go down the line here.
- 1:52Please introduce yourselves to the folks and speak a bit about
- 1:55what you're focused on at your respective phones.
- 1:57Awesome. So Michael, thank you.
- 1:59CEO of on rampant partner also and early writers really excited
- 2:04to have you guys here. I was trying to, we're walking
- 2:06over from our office. I was thinking about how do we
- 2:08get in the frame of mind we've been talking about Bitcoin for
- 2:10so long, thinking about like, how do we make this exciting and
- 2:14engaging. And I went back to, I wasn't
- 2:17really by any means to, to the space, but early enough in 2018
- 2:21in New York, I went to one of the 1st events like this and I
- 2:23was super excited. I left work and there was four
- 2:26people in that room. There was 3 panelists like this
- 2:28or you know, something like this, but only four people in
- 2:30the room. And the price of Bitcoin at the
- 2:31time was like $3500. And at the time, like I felt
- 2:35like I wanted to pinch myself, like, Oh my God, I know about
- 2:37this. The world doesn't know.
- 2:39And I promise you today, risk adjusted, whether somebody's
- 2:42building and allocating to the asset or companies in the space
- 2:45is a much better time. There's been no shortage of
- 2:48regulation risk and everything that we'll talk about today.
- 2:51So really pumped to have this conversation.
- 2:55I'm Emily Chapani. I'm the head of sales at Google
- 2:57Fiber and I've been in Nashville a little over 10 years at Google
- 3:01Fiber. There'll be 10 years this year.
- 3:03Our 10 year anniversary of announcing that we are building
- 3:07in Nashville is coming up in February.
- 3:09So really exciting time for us. It feels like a nostalgic moment
- 3:12a little bit, but also have seen all this happen in the last 10
- 3:16years. Saying Guma was on the team with
- 3:18me when we first started. We were both the sales team, but
- 3:21excited to talk today about Nashville being a place that you
- 3:23can build, where you can raise funds, raise your family.
- 3:26I had four kids in that time and that 10th 10 year period also
- 3:30here in town. So I think my perspective today
- 3:34will be about Google Fiber in this building and growing.
- 3:36But also when we started our business, it was really anchored
- 3:39here. This is one of the first cities
- 3:40that we built, so continuing to expand and grow from from here.
- 3:44What we've learned in Nashville, I think it's really exciting.
- 3:49My name is Cam Duty and I am, I guess I'm now a venture
- 3:55capitalist. I started, I started my career
- 3:59building company called Bellhops and we started back in 2012 and
- 4:03then moving the relocation space and then we sold part of our
- 4:09company right before COVID and my Co founder and I just had
- 4:15seen part of venture capital. We really didn't like something
- 4:20we thought was really missing. One of the we thought we were
- 4:23going to start another company. We ended up starting a venture
- 4:25firm called Brickyard. And so we invest in early stage
- 4:29companies and and technology and you know, preceding seed was
- 4:34really worth we focus. But my affliction, my personal
- 4:39affliction is just holy with Bitcoin, which is really funny
- 4:44because venture capital and Bitcoin are almost diametrically
- 4:49opposed things and go through life not feeling kind of feeling
- 5:00unsettled. But hopefully we we can kind of
- 5:04get into to some of the reason why they're.
- 5:06But I think that that what we'll talk about tonight, hopefully we
- 5:11can, we can shed some light on how Bitcoin is going to start
- 5:14permeate through capital allocators and how that is
- 5:19really going to change, actually change the world And not, you
- 5:23know, you know, from a perspective of how everybody
- 5:26talks about, you know, where we invest in world changing
- 5:28companies. You can't change you, you can't
- 5:32back or fund enough world changing companies if we
- 5:37maintain a positive inflation rate.
- 5:39And so Bitcoin is the key to all of that.
- 5:43So hopefully we can get into that tonight, yeah.
- 5:46Very well said. Thank you guys for that.
- 5:49So maybe to start, you know, the sort of for underlying thematic
- 5:54between all three of you is, is, you know, working in the
- 5:58technology space, emerging technology.
- 6:00So when when people talk about emerging or disruptive
- 6:03technology, you know, in my mind really what they're talking
- 6:06about is some form of information asymmetry.
- 6:09So if we think about technological adoption curves,
- 6:13it's really the innovators and the early movers to those, you
- 6:17know, new forms of technology that actually accrue the most
- 6:19value by building out key infrastructure and also backing
- 6:23founders that allow those new technologies to flourish.
- 6:26So this ability to really see around foreigners and see how
- 6:30new technologies will impact and influence society, culture and
- 6:34and the economy is really what drives value creation and
- 6:37ultimately asymmetric returns over time.
- 6:39So this question is really for all of you.
- 6:41Maybe Pam, we'll start with you. Can you just share some
- 6:44perspectives on, you know, how your firm navigates and
- 6:48capitalizes on information asymmetries to really Dr.
- 6:51innovation and value creation? Well, I'd say Brickyard's
- 6:55pretty. We're investing so early, 70% of
- 7:02our, our investments are pre seed investments, which is
- 7:05really the earliest that you can possibly invest in, in a, in a
- 7:09company. And normally a company is you
- 7:14know, before we'll consider investment.
- 7:16We've backed a few pre revenue companies, but normally the
- 7:19companies that we back are like post revenue in some small way,
- 7:23like 5 or 7K in, in monthly revenue kind of thing where they
- 7:27they have customers and and they're now you know, cross
- 7:30executing towards product market fit.
- 7:34But like we know that we're not category investors.
- 7:39We were curious about pretty much everything.
- 7:44We we aren't. Evaluating business models, so
- 7:47to speak, like when you're investing this early in
- 7:50companies, we know that almost 100% of our companies are going
- 7:54to be wildly tweaked and adjusted over the next, you
- 8:00know, 12 to 18 months post investment.
- 8:03And So what we really look for is that sort of intrinsic Dr.
- 8:08that that that real founders have like our our taking
- 8:14Brickyard is deserve era really broke a lot of space in that
- 8:19there was too much money, not enough deals to venture had to
- 8:22market itself as this like sexy pop culture thing with Forbes 30
- 8:28under 30 and celebrity investors.
- 8:30And like you guys have heard said this trope so much, but
- 8:33it's like the the the space had to attract founders in which the
- 8:39beginning of venture capital was the opposite of that.
- 8:42Like venture capital was just a, a financing option, the only
- 8:47option that you have for a company that didn't cash flow.
- 8:50And, and so founders have changed a lot and you have a lot
- 8:55of like probably 80 or 90% of founders there that are in the
- 8:57space today are in it for the wrong reasons.
- 9:01And so we created, you know, Brickyard business thing where
- 9:05if you, we get to a charm sheet with, with you as a company, you
- 9:09have to move to the middle of nowhere Chattanooga, TN
- 9:11throughout the tech and put your head down for 18 to 24 months
- 9:18and just put the blinders on. And founders that are chasing
- 9:22the status of the acclaim or all the other kind of tangential
- 9:26reasons for why you would get into venture capital that, you
- 9:28know, a lot of that happens kind of everywhere in some of the
- 9:32large tech hubs. You know, you're not going to
- 9:35move to Chattanooga and, and put your head down for eight months
- 9:38if you're in that category. So our edge is like, how do you
- 9:41find the founders that are ready to go to battle in the trenches
- 9:45for a decade? Because that's that's really
- 9:47what. You know, venture is Michael,
- 9:50how about for you? Obviously Bitcoin, there's
- 9:53certain information asymmetries just with the asset itself, but
- 9:56also with the business that we're building in terms of, you
- 10:00know, financial services on a Bitcoin standard.
- 10:01What does that look like? What are the information
- 10:03asymmetries that you're focused on?
- 10:06Yeah, I think so. A couple things going back to to
- 10:10Cam and I'm always pointing the question.
- 10:12This reminds me of like when I was cutting my teeth outside of
- 10:15school, I worked randomly and all tied back to this at a high
- 10:18end auction house and had to learn about like value, a value
- 10:21of like most things. And the reality is value of most
- 10:24things, there is no value. Like you find old boxes of
- 10:26stuff, you bring it in. And the thing we would say is
- 10:27the definition of values you don't have or definition of
- 10:30scarcity is like you don't have it right.
- 10:32Because it's like very, it'd be very rare somebody would come in
- 10:34with a coin, you know, jewelry that did an AD melted, things
- 10:39like that. And so when I think about what
- 10:41we discussed here in the definition of value and
- 10:44especially specifically value investing as it's not widely
- 10:46known because if it was widely known, there wouldn't be value
- 10:48there. So today we're sitting at, you
- 10:50know, whether it's in. So this ties back into this
- 10:53conversation. Everyone here has had some
- 10:56vision of a future that probably was most likely right in their
- 10:59own professional experience with Cam.
- 11:03It may not fully share what he does, but like to to signal what
- 11:07he's doing special today is because of 0 interest rates and
- 11:12the cost of capital relatively low if not 0.
- 11:16For a very long time, what was a cottage industry and required
- 11:19experts turned into a just manifested as like effectively a
- 11:23beast that nobody recognizes and it's money chasing anything that
- 11:27under the sun. Kim had the asymmetry of
- 11:29building Brickyard with blood, sweat and tears and recognizable
- 11:32wait, there's actually value to understand not only the pain an
- 11:37entrepreneur goes through, but then ultimately what's the
- 11:40heuristic to know if they're real or not?
- 11:41It was setting them up with having them come out to
- 11:43Chattanooga. Chattanooga in my mind, and
- 11:45maybe this isn't doing a justice, but it could have been
- 11:47like any random place in the United States.
- 11:49It was showing that a founder was serious about building.
- 11:52And then so for Emily, I don't know a full story, but we to tie
- 11:55this back to going together is that we work together at Google
- 11:58about 10 years ago. And there was a vision of Emily
- 12:01taking leading her career at a well known company, Sprint, I
- 12:04believe, and effectively building out infrastructure in
- 12:10at the time, 2nd and 3rd tier cities, which again goes back to
- 12:13being right about things because now this is not a second or
- 12:15third tier city. I would make the case that this
- 12:17is a first tier city because people have woken up from the
- 12:20asymmetries that most markets globally still haven't
- 12:22recognized. Is that like people don't need
- 12:23to sit in front of a computer at a desk in an office space
- 12:27anywhere. They can work anywhere.
- 12:28And those who understand that best will benefit from a like a
- 12:32musical perspective. So all these things tie into
- 12:36effectively what we'll talk about today with Bitcoin.
- 12:38It's the same setup, individuals with background having time,
- 12:41looking at the space, understanding whether the the
- 12:44thing that's hard about Bitcoin and we'll tie it into, you know,
- 12:46Google infrastructure and technology is Bitcoin has two
- 12:49different properties. It's the technology.
- 12:51So there's a bunch of things being built similar to like
- 12:53fiber building out into a networking, the things that will
- 12:55be built on a city, but it also has monetary value.
- 12:59And so it has this weird hybrid of almost like there's a lot of
- 13:01real estate investors in here. That's like getting a piece of
- 13:04real estate super early because the underlying is valuable, but
- 13:07then everything that goes up and everything around it becomes
- 13:09really valuable. And that's really, it's an
- 13:12interesting paradox. And when during the Q&A come
- 13:14into it is like real estate investors historically, my
- 13:16experience, and they do this for kind of a while now for my age,
- 13:19about half a decade, talking to people about it professionally
- 13:22is real estate investors are generally the last.
- 13:26And it's scary to me because when we look at global real
- 13:28estate when it comes to commercial and I was at we work
- 13:31by the way. So I I was lighting money on
- 13:33fire with with Adam. You man, I was sitting.
- 13:37We've seen in documentary. So it's around that hour is
- 13:42like, it's like a door that's just like closing on individuals
- 13:48and people are waking up. The thing that there there's two
- 13:51tropes that have come to mind about Real Estate 1 is Bitcoin
- 13:54doesn't call you at 2:00 AM to complain about the leaky pipe.
- 13:58Jeff, who's in in the room who I lease a place here in Nashville
- 14:01and I won't call him at 2:00 AM, but if there's a leaky pipe,
- 14:04he's going to get a call. And then the other thing that's.
- 14:08Less. Than $500 does it have to be
- 14:12lost if I were you? The other thing about real
- 14:15estate is have a good friend, his dad was in real estate, he
- 14:17said. You know, the thing about real
- 14:20estate is even though it's not very liquid, it's always there.
- 14:25And he deeply understands Bitcoin, he says, well, you
- 14:27know, the thing about Bitcoin is even though it's not really
- 14:29there, it's highly liquid, right?
- 14:32And most people looked at real estate and then COVID happened
- 14:34in 2020. And individuals recognize, well,
- 14:36wait, I should have underwritten risk in a different way when it
- 14:38comes to, you know, city hubs and the flea and the town and
- 14:41all the things we know about it. And Emily, how about for you,
- 14:44just in terms of sort of what you alluded to earlier around
- 14:48Google being very early mover to Nashville and sort of, you know,
- 14:51seeing what could become of a city like this, Yeah.
- 14:54You know, what kind of information asymmetries have you
- 14:56honed in on and that sticky? The information asymmetry,
- 14:59whether it be symmetrical speeds, everybody get their
- 15:02information as quickly as possible.
- 15:04Obviously we're talking about like getting information as fast
- 15:06you can. There's a currency to that.
- 15:08So I think that our part in that is enabling that for people
- 15:11access to information speed. It's funny you said his company
- 15:14could happen anywhere because it probably couldn't.
- 15:16I think when you think about China, go the first gig city,
- 15:19like the sensibilities that go into a municipality starting a
- 15:23gig network, there's a sense of of culture that has to be shared
- 15:29to to even kind of prioritize something like that.
- 15:32So I think the thinkers and the doers and the dreamers that are
- 15:35in Chattanooga when that was happening all come share that
- 15:38that sensibility. And so for Nashville, I think
- 15:40something that makes it so special and this is, you know,
- 15:4310 years later is you have a culture in a city where you've
- 15:47got like the top three healthcare companies globally,
- 15:51right? So you got like a lot of smart
- 15:52people here, right? Well, 15 universities, I think
- 15:56people who graduate from a school here, stay here, build
- 15:58their families here, build their businesses here.
- 16:01But then you've also got music from and people just are like,
- 16:04I'm going to come here and like play the guitar on the corner
- 16:06and become the next Chris Stapleton.
- 16:08So you've got crazy people, very talented people who are like a
- 16:11little bit crazy, right? So our culture is like very
- 16:15smart, really intelligent, then very creative, but then also a
- 16:19little crazy. And I think that that is the
- 16:21recipe for a successful entrepreneur, a startup and in
- 16:25business. But also, I think that's
- 16:26probably the Bitcoin recipe, yeah.
- 16:28Right. Very well said and and a great
- 16:30transition to my next question, which is more specifically
- 16:33around Nashville as an innovative hub.
- 16:35So if we think about, you know, the early days of the Internet,
- 16:39call it sort of 90s and early 2000s, local communities were
- 16:43very critical in cultivating innovation hubs.
- 16:46So really the hub of the Internet was effectively Silicon
- 16:49Valley. And if we Fast forward to today,
- 16:52you know, I think you could make the argument that the
- 16:54technological Nexus of the United States at least has
- 16:57really shifted and become almost more decentralized.
- 17:00So you'll, you're seeing founders and startups, you know,
- 17:02relocate to places like Austin, Denver, and of course,
- 17:05Nashville. So question for everyone, you
- 17:08know, why is Nashville and by extension Chattanooga very well
- 17:12positioned to be one of these modern hubs of tech innovation
- 17:16and what has drawn your respective firms to focus on
- 17:19this this region? So so as a native Texan, it kind
- 17:23of pains me to say this question.
- 17:25Nashville probably the best city in America in my opinion from
- 17:30what you just referenced. From innovation to culture to
- 17:33conserve the conservative ideals, like what Emily's
- 17:36referencing goes back to like the founding, founding of
- 17:39America. We kind of forget.
- 17:39I was thinking a lot about this independent of who anybody was
- 17:42signing for in the election of like America, why it's so
- 17:45innovative. We do a lot of business in the
- 17:46Middle East and there's this natural friction because we're
- 17:48progressive here, which they're they're naturally conservative,
- 17:52but they also really like the innovation that comes from the
- 17:54progressive nature. So they're always trying to
- 17:56import people out there. And the reality is America's the
- 18:00best run startup that's ever existed.
- 18:02When you think about it from just all the things you said,
- 18:05everything you described on National is what America was
- 18:06founded on. Like you have to have
- 18:07entrepreneur divers, you have to get on a ship, all the things
- 18:10associated. And you kind of like lost that a
- 18:11little bit. When you think about incumbents,
- 18:14incumbents in all the large sectors of a world naturally get
- 18:18stifled with bureaucracy and all the things that everybody
- 18:20probably knows about. And so there's this resurgence
- 18:23with technology, and one of them is an open decentralized
- 18:28Internet and that allows for the dissemination of information
- 18:31companies to be built, all the things associated, but you need
- 18:35the infrastructure in place. And so Nashville having that or
- 18:38Google having the vision to go to these markets in Nashville
- 18:41just emerging. I kind of joke that everyone's
- 18:43afraid to go down to Texas. They ended up in Nashville, but
- 18:47it's just like some truth. And I ended up here.
- 18:49And so anyway, it's a fantastic place.
- 18:51And I think that's where Nashville embodies a lot of the
- 18:53spirits of like the conservative nature, but also the ethos of
- 18:57entrepreneurship that a lot in in the friendliness of it.
- 19:01Because when I was in New York City, I moved back to Texas at
- 19:03the time because there's like, I saw a lot of the bureaucracy in
- 19:07building and it was like, well, if you want to run a business,
- 19:09you're trying to give yourself the best chance to succeed and
- 19:11you you go to places that allow for that.
- 19:14Yeah, there's some stat, there's a lot of like e-commerce the
- 19:18space in Nashville. I think you can get to like 50%
- 19:21of the the US population within six hours of Nashville.
- 19:24So there's a lot of like kind of logistics from here.
- 19:27But there's also this connectiveness.
- 19:29Not just like you're, you know, not too far from your mom, you
- 19:32can like drive home and see or whatever for holidays.
- 19:33But there's also just like this connectivity, I think in our
- 19:36culture and our community and some of that for the same
- 19:39reasons we were talking about like you're really intelligent,
- 19:41you're really creative, you're a little crazy.
- 19:42But there's also this like cooperation, not competition.
- 19:46And when you look at healthcare, like any successful surgery,
- 19:49there's everyone's working together in pursuit of a goal.
- 19:52You can have to put your ego aside even like surgeons, right
- 19:54to like violate on on this, this collaboration that's happening
- 19:57in the music industry. It's the same thing.
- 19:59And you would think it'd be more cutthroat and competitive, but
- 20:01it's actually everyone is working together.
- 20:03Look at any, any recent top song, you know, TikTok song,
- 20:08there's like 10 Co writes. There's a lot of people in the
- 20:10same room, like working on the same thing.
- 20:12So our culture in. Nashville comes from that.
- 20:14Even the sports team here, you know, everything is very much
- 20:17who how can we work together to the point that if you're not
- 20:20like that, it's it's weird. You know, it's like you see Reba
- 20:24when you're out at dinner and you strip from autographs, like
- 20:26that's weird. You would feel like you're not
- 20:28from Nashville. And if someone's like, hey, can
- 20:30you on LinkedIn? Hey, my recent job, let's get
- 20:32lunch and chat about like if you say no to something like that,
- 20:35that's weird. Like it's good that we have a
- 20:37culture where like when you're not behaving in the right way
- 20:40like that, that stands out more so than like it's kind of
- 20:43expected that everybody would cooperate.
- 20:45So building a business here, whatever it is, you have the
- 20:48assumption that people are going to show up and be helpful and be
- 20:51collaborative and cooperate versus compete.
- 20:54So I think that's something that's very special, also
- 20:57fosters any kind of like startup or a new company, but then also
- 21:00when you're trying to scale, you have to be able to do that to do
- 21:03that as well. This was Emily's nice way of
- 21:05saying she's not really sure about Bitcoin, but she's down to
- 21:08yeah. Right, yeah, I was like, I don't
- 21:11want to. What is it when you go with
- 21:12those like timeshare things? We're having lunch.
- 21:14She's like telling me this presentation, like, are you
- 21:15going to sell me some knives with?
- 21:19Bitcoin salesman that's. A lot you haven't sold me, No.
- 21:24Kim, how about you? Any any Chattanooga specific
- 21:26thoughts? I'm.
- 21:28Thinking about cities like that, thinking about startups, So like
- 21:32Nashville is great, it's awesome, but it's kind of like a
- 21:37pre IPO city, you know, like your best days are kind of mine,
- 21:42you know, like I'm AI am like a heroin addict of the early days,
- 21:49like kind of the early where's. The falling with this.
- 21:53So I, I, I like the acceleration, like, you know,
- 21:58building Bellhouse, for example, going from zero to 200
- 22:02employees, it was super exhilarating.
- 22:05Going from like 200 to 500 sucked.
- 22:08Like it wasn't fun. And I think, you know what I'm
- 22:13drawn to. I mean, I'm going to, I'm going
- 22:15to, you know, shout out for Chattanooga because I think it's
- 22:18the greatest place in the world, but it's not Nashville.
- 22:20It'll never be Nashville. We're we're like a seed stage
- 22:25city, you know, where like every day, you know, when we get a new
- 22:30great restaurant town, like that's awesome.
- 22:32It's like we feel that it's that actually moves the needle for
- 22:37us. And so building a city like
- 22:41Chattanooga for us, being able to do what we do with Brickyard.
- 22:47Is it it we've kind of figured out how to stay in a city like
- 22:52Chattanooga and also do what we do.
- 22:54I mean, it's conducive to to early stage company builders to
- 22:58be in a place where you don't have a lot of distraction.
- 23:01And that's like a lot of value that we provide at brickyards.
- 23:03Like we're pulling, you know, teams out of SF, out of New
- 23:07York, out of, you know, out of Boston, Austin, you know,
- 23:12London, etcetera, putting them in this like mid sized city
- 23:16that's totally relevant to technology.
- 23:18But like in that through of sorrow in the early days, none
- 23:21of that stuff matters. It's like talking to customers
- 23:24and shipping code and you know, one week to the next, you can
- 23:29like really move the needle. And I, I kind of feel the same
- 23:31way about Chattanooga is we're still small enough to where year
- 23:35to year you can kind of look back and see you can feel the
- 23:38acceleration of the city and, and that's what I love about it.
- 23:43You're building this multi $1,000,000 asset.
- 23:46You should put Google Fiber in it.
- 23:47And our job 10 years ago was to explain why.
- 23:51And this is a brand new company that everyone was just hearing
- 23:53about for the first time. Why should this developer put
- 23:55our infrastructure in, which was kind of painted the time because
- 23:58you're like under construction. We don't want to get in the way
- 24:01or you just built this beautiful asset and we're like, yeah,
- 24:03we're going to do some construction after they just
- 24:05painted. So we were trying to find ways
- 24:07for them to say yes to this. And one of them was like with
- 24:10your Lisa, we'll do free moving. We hired them.
- 24:12Do you remember we put 2 little fiber shirts on your wet on your
- 24:18fell hop guys? Yes.
- 24:22In the same. Like I did deal with Uber a
- 24:24couple years ago, same, same idea, but I was also laughing
- 24:27'cause your whole thing is like, let's get these founders not
- 24:29distracted with them in a room for 18 months.
- 24:32Like have them focus and like my preferred leadership style, it's
- 24:37like no walls, no focus, The more the merrier.
- 24:41Everybody overhearing everybody's other conversation
- 24:43because so much sparks and you like slam into each other and
- 24:46that I think it's very much it's a Google thing, but it's also a
- 24:48Nashville thing. Everyone here, probably this
- 24:51whole audience, there's like a slash like when my husband got,
- 24:54we moved here 10 years ago, 11 years ago, most he was just in
- 24:58medical school, just graduated his first year outside of
- 25:00medical school and then got a record deal.
- 25:02So his backup plan was to be a doctor, which by the way, it's
- 25:06not the worst bathroom plan in Nashville.
- 25:08But the idea is like, you move here, you're pursuing this music
- 25:11career, but you have something else.
- 25:13You may be doing something else at the same time.
- 25:15This year was the first year that he stopped working in the
- 25:17hospital. That's doing.
- 25:19We have a music studio now full time and it took 10 years to
- 25:21kind of get the cluster's kids, you know, so we get that get
- 25:26everything in order to like make that leap.
- 25:28But sure, everybody has like a slash in their bio.
- 25:31You're like finance person, but slash, you know, you're singing
- 25:34karaoke on Friday trying to get your your vector deal or
- 25:37whatever it is, or you're doing a podcast while also working
- 25:41your 9:00 to 5:00 or you've got like your 5 to 9, your 9:00 to
- 25:445:00 and then you're you're 5:00 to 9:00.
- 25:45So I like that about Nashville because there's like this baby
- 25:49that's part of what drives people to be helping each other,
- 25:51but not kind of catering to like the focus and rather having that
- 25:56that distraction. There's like magic that kind of
- 25:58comes from those different parts of people kind of bumping into
- 26:01each other, I think. Yeah, yeah, I think, yeah.
- 26:05Change your business policy. Well, to be fair to Cam, I think
- 26:08part of his format, what he's built is exactly to spark what
- 26:13you're leveraging is because all of his teams that he funds are
- 26:16in the same same room effectively.
- 26:18And so they are bouncing ideas off of each other.
- 26:20And so you do get collaborative and if I go?
- 26:23Back to the apples and workers, because like what you're
- 26:25describing is like conducive part of Nashville as a part of
- 26:28like remote work. Like there was a study that just
- 26:31recently came out. I was like, no, it's like 33% of
- 26:33people have two jobs that work remotely, right, Because it's
- 26:35just like the most functioning, the side where cams coming from
- 26:39and they both sides make sense. It's like if you are in the
- 26:42fight for your life, like that's what effectively is when you're
- 26:44starting a business and especially you're taking on
- 26:46external capital because now you're fighting for other
- 26:48people's lives too, right? Yeah, they're investing.
- 26:51Yeah. You don't want any of what
- 26:53you're describing. You want them literally, like he
- 26:55references a brand of ships. And I love it because like,
- 26:57you're just like saying like, I'm taking my stand.
- 26:59I'm going to try to make my impact in the world, and it's
- 27:01the only thing that can. Yeah.
- 27:02Well, you don't want a backup plan, right?
- 27:04You eliminate the option for a Plan B.
- 27:07Like extraordinary different. It's like they know that their
- 27:09sacrifices that can be made and so there's just a natural
- 27:12balance and then post that they don't like.
- 27:14Maybe some people stay in Chattanooga when others go to
- 27:16these cities and go get to indulge and they become
- 27:18successful, but they're there's always that sacrifice in it.
- 27:21That's why I look back at like, what Cam's doing a special
- 27:24because as special as Chattanooga it is, it's still
- 27:26for most people, just a random place in the middle of the
- 27:28Tennessee. I mean, most of our teams are
- 27:30not going to stay in Chattanooga and they should.
- 27:35I hope a lot of our teams come to Nashville because Nashville
- 27:41has the talent density it has. Like, you know, it's a city that
- 27:45you can recruit to really well and I think that's going to
- 27:50happen. We've already had a couple teams
- 27:52open offices in both in Chattanooga and and are looking
- 27:57open offices. Usually it's like has to do
- 28:00customer service or product, but Nashville's is, I'm hoping we
- 28:06can funnel a ton of teams here. There's a couple of real estate
- 28:08investors in here. They were talking about, you
- 28:10know, some of this like stuff that's been the news about
- 28:12infusing, you know, a lot of alone on real estate with some
- 28:16Bitcoin and, you know, maybe canvas that picks up.
- 28:18We'll, you know, owners gonna need officers.
- 28:20Collab and. Then we'll get some 8 gig Google
- 28:22Fiber and. You mentioned like people
- 28:27working from home. I thought it was like during the
- 28:29pandemic, everybody kind of had to work from home where they,
- 28:32you know, shifted how people work.
- 28:34And so if given the chance to work anywhere, a lot of people
- 28:37chose Nashville. There was a ton of Googlers.
- 28:39Like there's we had like a listserv of how many people
- 28:41chose to move to Nashville. And it was shocking where when
- 28:44given the choice and nothing else, this is where people chose
- 28:47to be. So now with the return back to
- 28:50office and a lot of companies are mandating it or going to a
- 28:53hybrid schedule. It used to be that you would
- 28:55recruit companies to move to Nashville.
- 28:57You go to the C-Suite and like get them to kind of invest here,
- 29:00create a headquarters here. Now it's kind of like this
- 29:03opposite is happening where people who chose to move here
- 29:06don't want to move back to wherever.
- 29:08So now those companies are like, oh, the talent is there.
- 29:10They already live there. Now we're going to build a
- 29:12second office there or satellite office.
- 29:14So it's kind of being led by the the will of the employer or the
- 29:17choice of the employee, which I think is fascinating.
- 29:19I haven't heard of that happening in any other cities.
- 29:22Probably not many besides Nashville.
- 29:24I mean, I think this ties into the theme you're talking about
- 29:26is like the market's changed and the market gets to decide what
- 29:31the incumbents will do and some larger will be able to hold off
- 29:34longer. But your point, I mean, would
- 29:36you to be fair like this happens in Austin and Land and others
- 29:38just in their different scales? People from Austin Financial or
- 29:42during the pandemic. I mean.
- 29:44You did. I mean, I have, I'm still over
- 29:47there, but. Let's talk about there so.
- 29:49Well, what I do, what I didn't want to share is that people
- 29:53little time. So people leave the people leave
- 29:57the cities because they can work anywhere.
- 30:00They're not going to come back and other talent will take them
- 30:03in the same way people have fallen capital flight.
- 30:05So you see this, whether it's it's prevalent on a net like
- 30:09nation state perspective, and the UAE has been big for this,
- 30:12where you know, they'll welcome from a tax perspective,
- 30:15Singapore, where the countries start to operate like, you know,
- 30:19companies and they have to create the most advantageous
- 30:21environment for be employee. It's not like somebody who just
- 30:25tax and you have to this is what we're still seeing like legacy
- 30:28for both states or cities like a San Francisco, New York, not get
- 30:32and that's where you have this like fleeing of capital.
- 30:35The point being is used to be very hard to move your money
- 30:38because you have real estate and you had all this physical
- 30:40infrastructure, you know, all these different like assets that
- 30:42you have to move. And going with Bitcoin, well,
- 30:46there's no shortage of value problems.
- 30:48But one of them is that point about it's, it's not always
- 30:51there. It's not there.
- 30:51It's not tangible, but it's highly liquid and it's easily
- 30:54movable. And so it goes to what Emily's
- 30:56describing is as the market wakes up, they just realize they
- 30:58have to compete for talent from not only a job, a real estate
- 31:04perspective, but then also how do you actually treat from taxes
- 31:08and all the other things that you would want in a place to
- 31:10live more? The money will just leave
- 31:12because you don't have the legacy ways of, oh, you're going
- 31:15to just sell all this all. I mean, obviously family,
- 31:17there's some still things that hold us down, but it's changing
- 31:20drastically. And most places don't really
- 31:21pick the crock that Yeah, I think.
- 31:23That's very well said. And I'm going to pull us back.
- 31:25I'm going to pull us back. I'm going to pull us back to
- 31:27the, the thread of the Internet analogy, you know, with respect
- 31:31to Bitcoin. So, you know, similar to the
- 31:35Internet, which emerged via a set of open protocols, Bitcoin
- 31:40is, is very simply just an open protocol for value.
- 31:43So if if the Internet, you know, if you look at the Internet as
- 31:47the digitization of information, Bitcoin really represents the
- 31:52digitization of value. And the key difference here is
- 31:55that, you know, between, you know, the early 90s and now is
- 31:58that owning a piece of the underlying infrastructure is
- 32:02actually possible with Bitcoin. So, you know, owning Bitcoin
- 32:05today, buying Bitcoin today is as if you were able to purchase
- 32:08a piece of the Internet back then.
- 32:10So, Michael, maybe we can start with you, but can you speak to,
- 32:14you know, at a high level the innovation that is Bitcoin and,
- 32:18and specifically why now more than ever, it's important to
- 32:21understand what's happening and really why Bitcoin is currently
- 32:24having, you know, sort of its mainstream moment with, you
- 32:27know, the likes of of various corporations and also now nation
- 32:30states considering adopting Bitcoin as a reserve asset.
- 32:34Yeah, So it's mainstream for us. It's still, it's so insanely
- 32:37really, we talked to so many people about all this stuff and
- 32:39it's just like you really have to get know your audience and
- 32:42and be careful how you describe these things.
- 32:44There's two components of this. So the nation state adoption,
- 32:48personal account adoption, there's only 21 million Bitcoin
- 32:50that will ever exist. And if you can come to that
- 32:53conclusion and why that's credible, well then you start to
- 32:55underwrite, well, what's the value of it?
- 32:57So there's the monetary aspect of it and we can go into that or
- 33:00we can have separate conversations about that.
- 33:02We are our firm helps with the education.
- 33:04There's the other aspect that Brian's referencing is that it's
- 33:07a piece of technology and allows for transfer value.
- 33:10So there's a lot of folks that will think about gold or like
- 33:13we'll go back to like interchange with Amex and credit
- 33:16cards. Like all those things in an
- 33:18Internet world when your Tesla's going across tolls or you need
- 33:21to do microtransactions just cannot be done because the
- 33:23intermediary problem. That's the problem.
- 33:25If you have an intermediary that has to facilitate the
- 33:27transaction and it's not economical to move.
- 33:31This goes back to how browsers were set up.
- 33:33I forget, I'll butcher it, but there's like the four O 2 or
- 33:35whatever the error code is that you actually get.
- 33:37There's an error code where you were they were going to put
- 33:39micro payments, but you just couldn't figure it out.
- 33:42The way you figure it out is why I started with there's only 21
- 33:44million because if you can derive, there's only 21 million
- 33:46and some value will be from it and then all the value stems
- 33:49from it. Now you can actually associate
- 33:51when you're online. While you would want more of
- 33:53that, you can't do the other version.
- 33:54You can't create a technology and make people value it.
- 33:56You have to have the underlying properties make sense.
- 33:59And so very often, again, you've been doing this for a long time
- 34:03that we get on the defensive and this is to Emily because she
- 34:06doesn't know what's happening. It's very often people will go
- 34:10back, we've done this for years and they'll go, it's 3020
- 34:13thousand, 60,000, go back to 20. All the numbers and individuals
- 34:16will come up and say, well, why is it explain Bitcoin?
- 34:20Why is it going? Why is it 100?
- 34:22Why is it going to be a million? Why isn't it zero?
- 34:23And all is it's like, look, if you want to have a conversation
- 34:26about value, what gives things value?
- 34:29Because there's objective things that give things value when it
- 34:32comes to we all know why scarcity.
- 34:33That's why we like these guitars behind us and other things like
- 34:36that. And then it needs to be
- 34:36divisible because you need to be able to transfer it up, needs to
- 34:39be able to teleport across time, right?
- 34:41Because and space because if you can't send it to you, then
- 34:43what's the value of it? So we can have that
- 34:46conversation. But the way I like to frame it
- 34:48now, because it's just, it's been working for 15 years and it
- 34:52only goes one thing up and to the right is why isn't it?
- 34:55It's a $2 trillion asset today. Why isn't a $10 trillion asset?
- 34:59And the reason why it's not a $10 trillion asset is because
- 35:02there hasn't been historically a good way to store it.
- 35:05So everybody here, no matter what they know about Bitcoin,
- 35:07they know two things. Either it ends up in a landfill
- 35:10in like the UK and some like hard drive or some North Korean
- 35:14takes it and you wake up and you're, you're, you're all your
- 35:16bitcoins are gone. That's what you know, grandma's
- 35:19now. And so this notion of wool, OK,
- 35:22so somebody has exposure, a couple people I know in here,
- 35:25probably the exposure, everybody has like some exposure, if not
- 35:27like maybe 0 or a little bit. But they're drastically under
- 35:32allocated because the gravity of what we're talking about,
- 35:35whether it's from there's 450 roughly trillion dollars in
- 35:39assets that are all like what Bitcoin's competing with.
- 35:41And it all competes with them head on and just completely
- 35:44crushes it when you really break it down.
- 35:45And so there's that aspect. But then there's a secondary
- 35:48part on the technology side, and that's the easy part to anchor
- 35:51to because it's looks like when Brian was referencing technology
- 35:54companies adopted every technology companies going to
- 35:56hold Bitcoin, every business going to hold Bitcoin, every
- 35:58individual's going to hold Bitcoin in the same way
- 36:00everybody uses the Internet. And at the time everybody like,
- 36:03are you going to be an Internet company?
- 36:04And yeah, the.com and all those things happen in the same way
- 36:08today. Everybody's like, are you a
- 36:09Bitcoin company? It's just if it's money and it's
- 36:13a form of value that people hold, everyone will just be
- 36:15utilizing it, whether it's part of their technology technology
- 36:18stack or part of their sadies. They're not mutually exclusive,
- 36:22and that ultimately leads it to be intertwined in everything.
- 36:27So, yeah, yeah, there's no such thing as a Internet company
- 36:32today, right? You're just a company and
- 36:34obviously you're leveraging the Internet.
- 36:35Is that. For mine, you know, that's all
- 36:38we do. Google Farmers Internet Company
- 36:40built the Internet. Maybe an exception, that's all.
- 36:43But the point being like, you know, there was, you know,
- 36:47companies in the early 2000s that that was their whole thing.
- 36:49They just add to their name. And we saw this even with with
- 36:52Bitcoin and blockchain to some extent in our cycles where it's,
- 36:55you know, a company adds blockchain to their name and
- 36:57stock price jumps. It's like, well, that won't
- 36:59exist in a world where to Michael's point, Bitcoin is just
- 37:03globally recognized as a form of money.
- 37:05Well, then obviously, if you're a company and you're operating
- 37:07with money, which most companies do, then you're going to be
- 37:09leveraging Bitcoin in some way. Ken, did you have any thoughts
- 37:12along these lines, sort of the Internet analogy?
- 37:15I mean, I'm going to, I'm going to like block and bridge.
- 37:18I have a very. I have a pretty like narrow
- 37:23beat. On Bitcoin.
- 37:25It's not what I do for a living like what I do for a living.
- 37:29Yes, I'm a capital allocator, but because I'm the capital
- 37:34allocator and I also understand Bitcoin, the, the thing that I
- 37:39feel like compelled to, to, to say if, if I, I tweeted
- 37:43something out recently, I was like this one Bitcoin was going
- 37:46from like 60 to 90. And I tweeted something like,
- 37:50you know, if, if, if I've spent, you know, last the, you know, if
- 37:54I've spent 5 minutes with you in the last two years, like you are
- 37:58in my iMessage thread right now. People are just texting me
- 38:01constantly. Like, holy shit, what's
- 38:02happening? Like, thank you so much for
- 38:04getting me into Bitcoin. Like for me, the, the thing that
- 38:11matters most for, for folks in the crowd that don't fully
- 38:15understand what Bitcoin is, is you have AI, which is Moore's
- 38:23law. Just it's the training that will
- 38:25not stop. There's nothing we can stop this
- 38:27thing. Our productivity is right at the
- 38:31precipice of a, of the J curve where we're going to get way
- 38:36more productive faster than we've ever been, you know,
- 38:39faster than than has ever happened in human history.
- 38:42You know, we're 4% more productive every year in the US.
- 38:45That's about to go to 10. It's about to go to 15.
- 38:48It's better to go to 20% a year, OK, over the next 2025 years,
- 38:53Like this is we're at the point where stuff is going to be
- 38:56moving so fast, no one can keep up.
- 39:01All right? That's the power production side
- 39:05of the economy. These are like these nuclear
- 39:07power plants that do everything better for less inputs, like
- 39:13more outputs, less inputs. And that's what productivity is.
- 39:17And these companies, they're building on top of this modern
- 39:19technology, you know, AKA AI, you know, the cost of all things
- 39:26should be dropping, but it's not.
- 39:29Why is it not? Like how are we in a position
- 39:31here where we're better at everything and accelerated pace
- 39:35and yet all our shit cost more every single year?
- 39:39Like everything should be costing less and less and less.
- 39:42The what's happening is the US has 36 1/2 trillion dollars in
- 39:47debt, OK. And the Fed has one job, and
- 39:53that job is don't default, OK. And with technology accelerating
- 39:59its pace of productivity, we're ramming more economic energy
- 40:03into the same number of units. OK, so if the Fed never printed
- 40:06another dollar, we would default because paying back that 36 1/2
- 40:11trillion would be way harder because each unit is buys more.
- 40:15So if each unit buys more, you have to do more work to pay off
- 40:19each unit. OK.
- 40:20And so for every game that we have on on productivity side,
- 40:26the Fed has to offset by printing money just to avoid
- 40:30default, OK. And that what that is how that
- 40:33is manifesting in all of our lives is our eggs that should be
- 40:38getting 4 to 6% cheaper every year are getting 2 to 3% more
- 40:45expensive every year. And so what's actually happening
- 40:47is, is the Fed is stealing the 45% production gains that we
- 40:53have earned plus 3 or 4%, All right.
- 40:57So inflation is not stuff getting 4% more expensive is it
- 41:01should be getting 5% cheaper, but it's actually 4% more.
- 41:06So that's. And so what's going to happen
- 41:08over the next decade is AI is about to accelerate the pace of
- 41:14deflation, all right? And the Fed is going to have to
- 41:17print like, like no tomorrow to offset it just to avoid default,
- 41:21All right? So we're going to go from 4% to
- 41:245% to 7% to 10%. Stuff should be getting 10%
- 41:30cheaper for us every year. But really it's going to, all
- 41:34they have to do is maintain a 2% inflation rate.
- 41:37But now they're stealing 12%, right, The 10% of gains that
- 41:41we've earned in the economy plus 2% on the other side.
- 41:44And so AI and Bitcoin are two sides of the same coin.
- 41:48You have the power production side that's ramming energy into
- 41:51our money. And then you have our batteries
- 41:53that are storing monetary energy that we produce.
- 41:57And I'll just wrap it all up to say money always converges on
- 42:05the best money. And so USD is the best Fiat
- 42:08money in the world. And what we're about to
- 42:11experience over the next 15 years, people are going to
- 42:14realize there is a better money than the best money on earth.
- 42:18And people are going to start jumping ship and the entire
- 42:22world is going to be repriced in Bitcoin.
- 42:25And you know, the thing that's going to offset that is, is you
- 42:29guys are going to be, you know, talking about, you know, does
- 42:32this change the dynamic of the world reserve currency?
- 42:36You know, if we implement a strategic Bitcoin reserve and if
- 42:40we start actually hedging, you know, the debt that we have, not
- 42:44trying to grow our way out of try to grow our way out of our
- 42:47debt, but also allocate our capital and resources into
- 42:52something that's going to to hedge the debt that we carry.
- 42:55We will we will retain the world reserve currency.
- 43:00Bitcoin will bolster the US dollar.
- 43:03We will save in Bitcoin and we will spend in U.S. dollars.
- 43:08And because more monetary energy is being stored in this pristine
- 43:14asset, the prices of all things are going to fall. the Fed is
- 43:18likely to go away like the world gets repriced in a fixed
- 43:22monetary policy where we all benefit from the gains of the
- 43:28hard work and innovation that that, you know, that we produce
- 43:33every single year. So that's that's what big point
- 43:35is. It's the perfect battery.
- 43:36There's no intrinsic value to Bitcoin.
- 43:38You know, Bitcoin without AI would never live up to what it
- 43:42was capable of. AI without Bitcoin would never
- 43:46live up to what it is capable of, you know, in terms of
- 43:49benefiting humanity. So that's my beef.
- 43:55I mean, we haven't changed our price and our one gig products
- 43:58in 10 years. Eggs are more expensive,
- 44:01everything's more expensive. Our price is the same 10 years.
- 44:05Ago is the money franker? No.
- 44:07No, no, no. I think.
- 44:10One of the maybe problem or opportunity you have is that
- 44:13reminds me of 10 years ago is when we were first out trying to
- 44:17tell people you need a gig or you should have said, why?
- 44:19What am I going to do with that? We didn't really have, we didn't
- 44:22know, we didn't have the best answer for it.
- 44:24So at the time we went to the creators, the doers, the people
- 44:28that crazed people I keep referencing and we're like,
- 44:31here, we're going to give you this resource and then you tell
- 44:34us what you do with it. And it was like the most
- 44:35exciting time because we've heard from our users what this
- 44:40meant. And there's, there's one story
- 44:41in Nashville that I wouldn't have been able to think up until
- 44:44after it happened, which was we went to Music Row.
- 44:46It was like RCA studio AI think this is who we sold.
- 44:49And they, they finally had a gig in the studio.
- 44:53And before that you're, you're building a song, right?
- 44:56So you do your parts, your stems, whatever it is.
- 44:58Maybe you're playing a track with some guitars.
- 45:00OK, what they would do is record it, download it to an external
- 45:04hard drive, get the Courier on a bicycle, come pick this thing
- 45:07up, which by the way, jostle around.
- 45:09It's a little risky. OK, so you've got like your your
- 45:11precious cargo. And they would drive it to the
- 45:13next studio, plug it in and lay the next track, drums or
- 45:17whatever. And this would happen over a
- 45:19period of weeks, months, whatever.
- 45:20To build a song. It was like a physical thing
- 45:22that you had to move around once you have a gig.
- 45:26Now all of a sudden, and this is a music producer that told me
- 45:28the story, he's laying a track recording with another person
- 45:32collaborating with him who is in Paris.
- 45:34And now we're doing this in real time.
- 45:36This was 10 years ago. So you can imagine this takes
- 45:38somebody who's like a Music Row producer, so obviously very
- 45:41successful and suddenly are they are now a global business
- 45:45collaborating internationally and can finish a song quickly
- 45:47the in real time. So imagine like having that to
- 45:51building you go into the pandemic, it gives you like a
- 45:53superpower. So now we were talking about
- 45:56this recently. We just launched a couple weeks
- 45:58ago, 8 gig in Nashville. I'm having the same
- 46:01conversations and it feels so nostalgic because I'm like, I
- 46:03don't know what you're going to do with this.
- 46:05And I can't even imagine to dream it up.
- 46:07But I'm going to find the people who are the dreamers who are
- 46:09going to figure it out and then they'll tell me.
- 46:11So we're going to the podcasters and the creatives and music are
- 46:14the same. It's the same people we went to
- 46:1610 years ago, often the same person and saying like we not
- 46:20have this resource like to sit out.
- 46:21You tell us what this means to your business.
- 46:23And I feel like you have a similar opportunity with bit
- 46:26fling where you're saying like there's a a million things.
- 46:28We can't even imagine what this is going to unlock or the
- 46:31potential that it has, but it's getting it into the hands of the
- 46:33people who are able to think that way in the abstract and
- 46:37they can start to build. And this is probably a lot of
- 46:38the entrepreneurs that you work with, but once you that's the
- 46:42early, the early phases, it's like finding those people,
- 46:45giving them the resource and then just kind of waiting for
- 46:48the what feels like the magic to kind of happen.
- 46:51Yeah, it's a, it's a fantastic way to title and I didn't know
- 46:53if you were going to be able to do with the Cam referencing the
- 46:56dollar to. Me, I could do it.
- 46:59I want to. I want to.
- 47:00Brexit, the early like so, so the capital allocation piece.
- 47:04The thing that that is really interesting to me about Bitcoin
- 47:07is when you denominate your world in Bitcoin, your capital
- 47:12allocation strategy totally changes because you realize the
- 47:16hurdle is not the S&P, OK, 7% of your, that's not the hurdle rate
- 47:21to be the hurdle rate is a 60% for your CAGR asset called
- 47:26Bitcoin. And so how you allocate capital,
- 47:30Do I hire this person for $100,000 a year?
- 47:33Well, do I think, would I rather have this person or would I
- 47:36rather have Bitcoin, right? And so talk about early riders
- 47:41like how you're thinking about how companies should be thinking
- 47:43about allocating capital. At Onramp, we believe that
- 47:46Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 47:49The hard part is securing it right.
- 47:52There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 47:54exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 47:57arrangement. Onramp solves for these
- 47:59concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 48:02solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 48:06ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 48:09possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 48:12your family is protected as well.
- 48:15Onramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 48:18whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 48:21to your existing self custody setup.
- 48:23For more information, check us out at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 48:27Yeah, there's a few threads to tie in.
- 48:29So Cam was referencing the, the dollar Bitcoin and Emily was
- 48:36referencing the, you know, state of viewers.
- 48:39And like that there's so much room, right?
- 48:41A lot of this stuff is open to interpretation.
- 48:42So there's like 2 points. What do you build is open to the
- 48:44smartest people? And then in, in this room, how
- 48:47do you think about why it matters to you?
- 48:48Everybody's different. It's such a, it's
- 48:50multidisciplinary. That's why it's so hard.
- 48:51And there's no, like there's no marketing effort.
- 48:53So everybody comes in at their own kind of conclusion on like a
- 48:55they need it. But what Cam was alluding to and
- 48:58what Em was alluding to is it's very asymmetric.
- 49:00And we keep using this term. But generally when people think
- 49:02about asymmetric and the only thing about the upside, the
- 49:04problem is technology is asymmetric in the truest sense.
- 49:07It's upside and downside risk. If you adopt it early, you get
- 49:10to benefit the upside. If you don't adopt it at all,
- 49:13you get to experience with the downside.
- 49:15On the monetary side, you basically get the lifeblood
- 49:18sucked out of you, as Cam was referencing from a number of
- 49:20reasons we can talk about. And then from the technology
- 49:23side, to Emily's point, well, if you don't have those rails that
- 49:26you needed, well then you're just naturally behind the
- 49:28competitor that has it. To go to Cam's point, to make it
- 49:32very like easy, not polarizing. It's like Bitcoin just allows
- 49:34individuals to buy more eggs every week than less.
- 49:37And the dollar lets you buy less.
- 49:38It's a, it's a battery to consume the dollars.
- 49:40There's only 20 million. So if you have all these scarce
- 49:42assets that exist and they all go up year over year, Bitcoin it
- 49:45just is the most scarce asset. So it goes up the fastest.
- 49:47And will it continue? That's like, no, that's the nice
- 49:50version without saying that we're going to lose as well.
- 49:52But so now to go to Emily's Cam's question about.
- 49:57So when you come to that conclusion, well then you
- 49:59naturally like everything you look at to what Cam was
- 50:03referencing. Well, why would I buy the water?
- 50:06Why would I buy invest in this business if this asset just goes
- 50:10up X year over year? And it's not to say you don't
- 50:13spend your money because money is meant to be spent.
- 50:15You're just naturally looking at things in a more discerning way.
- 50:18And we all grew up where a lot of people are older, grew up
- 50:20with their parents sound of money doesn't grow on trees.
- 50:22I think we probably all recognize like it doesn't
- 50:25physically grow on trees, but it might as well grow on trees
- 50:27because it just continues to get spun out.
- 50:29Like no matter what you try on the news, we're printing the
- 50:31next, you know, 100 billion, sending it wherever.
- 50:34And so you look at that through a lens of an entrepreneurial,
- 50:37from an entrepreneurial perspective was what we did at
- 50:39Onrint. You start to realize, wait, I
- 50:41can actually build much more efficiently if I look in a more
- 50:44discerning way of how do I allocate capital?
- 50:46Because you're the old, the ultimate form of capital
- 50:48allocation is run out of business because you like have
- 50:50to move the money or go out of business if you don't do it
- 50:52correctly. And the easy examples of this is
- 50:54like flexible work in contract in an age of going back to, you
- 50:58know, working remotely, a lot of people again are interested to
- 51:02work in the space. There's only so many businesses
- 51:03that will happily work for a percentage of what they would in
- 51:08a full time job in kind of quote UN quote Moonlight, especially
- 51:10high performers because high performers that everybody knows,
- 51:14you know, earmuffs. But like at Google, the best
- 51:16performer work 20% of the time. And this is just like I'm
- 51:19speaking as I was there. It's like I didn't work that
- 51:21much 'cause like I'm juicy. Are you like?
- 51:23Speak for yourself. I was talking about myself, but
- 51:26I was also, I mean, was that OK? So.
- 51:29No, Yeah, no. Like hire the person that's
- 51:32gonna like, you know, try to do more in the less time or hire
- 51:34that's a lazy person. But sometimes they phrase it
- 51:37like hire the diva, like the person that's gonna like, I'm
- 51:40not doing that, but they have to get it.
- 51:41So figure the shortcut, or figure out the way to make it to
- 51:44make it work. That's the most efficient, not
- 51:48lazy. Basically getting that is that
- 51:50like there's a lot of talent charges that the rest of the
- 51:53market doesn't know. And so normally it can notice
- 51:57this in order to hope, you know, advise the end state.
- 51:58But like when businesses raise capital, especially venture
- 52:01capital, like there's a whole it gives the question there's
- 52:06there's misalignment of incentives across the board.
- 52:09So you have misalignment from the person that's giving the
- 52:12dollars, which is a limited partner because they're looking
- 52:14at everything through the melting ice cube that Cam was
- 52:18referencing that it's inflating away.
- 52:20So you're just less discerned about where do I put this money?
- 52:22Do I put it in the S&P? Do I put it in this like
- 52:24Lamborghini know a few people in here on this one that has one of
- 52:28those. And so the order I put in that
- 52:31real estate. And so then they're just less
- 52:33discerning about the venture capital that you give the money
- 52:36to. And then the venture capitalist
- 52:38is to nominate everything in dollars.
- 52:39Their goal generally is to raise larger funds, take management
- 52:42fees. And so they're looking and to
- 52:44mark up their portfolio companies.
- 52:46So they're naturally always telling the person, the second
- 52:49they give the dollar to them, he's like, run, run as fast.
- 52:51And they're like where it's like, I don't know, just keep
- 52:53running and keep growing. And so the first thing he says,
- 52:55go hire a bunch of people. And so when you hire, everyone
- 52:58knows that's one of the only the two hardest things in life are,
- 53:01well, maybe 3, building a business, allocating capital to
- 53:04businesses and hiring people in any order you can.
- 53:07You either probably like order of operations, but it's hard to
- 53:10hire. So if you just have to get told
- 53:12to go hire a bunch of people, you're literally just cutting
- 53:15your burn. And if not by 50% to 75% because
- 53:17most people we've all worked in places and hired every at best
- 53:22came back 50%. And so the approach we took at
- 53:26early writers is we denominate everything in Bitcoin.
- 53:30And so this ties back to the the ultimate allocator being the
- 53:33entrepreneur. If you're allocating to somebody
- 53:35that looks at the world through this lens of the prices,
- 53:37appreciating Bitcoin at X year over year, well, you want them
- 53:41to spend the money. You just want them to spend it
- 53:43with the highest level of discernment and scrutiny because
- 53:47that's I mean, they have to have other, you know, expertise as
- 53:52founder market fit, all the things you would naturally hear
- 53:53in the common tropes. But it's this notion that Cam
- 53:58alluded to is that it gets harder and harder year over year
- 54:02to invest in companies or build if you're losing X purchasing
- 54:07power because you're effectively trying to build with one hand
- 54:11time when you're behind your back now two hands, the next
- 54:13thing you know, you're just like stuck in mud.
- 54:16And this is where businesses and the deflation comes into because
- 54:19the harder and harder it gets to build a business means that unit
- 54:22economic margins are decreasing because you have to raise
- 54:25prices, which means that you have less users, which lowers
- 54:28the likelihood to be successful. And so we've kind of taken on
- 54:32the very far fringes of, you know, we're still early to
- 54:36explain why Bitcoin has value, but on the very bleeding edges
- 54:40of that, we're investing in companies and they're across the
- 54:42spectrum. We have a gentleman here, we'll
- 54:45call him out publicly, but he ran a successful software
- 54:50company with venture backed and then realized that Bitcoin was
- 54:54the thing and he basically was able to allocate to Bitcoin.
- 54:58And I want to say 21 has experienced significant
- 55:01appreciation and had to re underwrite everything he does
- 55:04because majority of the markets on a rat race, just like humans
- 55:07are on a rat race. Like if you talk to anybody that
- 55:10gets to this point of speaking about Bitcoin, they'll all come
- 55:13down to or majority will say 2020 was the biggest time for
- 55:17them to recognize this because this isn't really an IQ test.
- 55:20It's a common sense test. It's like, do I want something
- 55:22that can be infinite or do I want the thing that only has 21
- 55:25million? The problem is the only way you
- 55:26get to that is with a certain amount of time off the rat
- 55:29racing during 2020. We all know how much time we had
- 55:31to think and look into these things.
- 55:33And so that's ultimately where this asymmetry goes.
- 55:35Look, the more time people have to hear about these pods and get
- 55:38to meet with us is where you have that.
- 55:39What? Y'all what what Michael is doing
- 55:41with early riders is insane. Like it's totally insane.
- 55:45So insane, like Brickyard, for our next fund, we're going to
- 55:49allocate 10% of the fund Bitcoin because I will not raise another
- 55:54fund and not have an allocation Bitcoin.
- 55:57I'm burning the bullets on the line.
- 56:00You're going to hear what? Will not be a top decile fund if
- 56:08you don't in this next decade. But like what he's doing is
- 56:13absolutely insane. What he is promising his LP's is
- 56:18I'm going to return you more Bitcoin than you gave me.
- 56:24His hurdle rate is a 60% CAGR asset.
- 56:28Like, let me just go back to the, you know, the 50th
- 56:32percentile venture capital firm returns Goosek.
- 56:38Half of venture firms do not return.
- 56:41Capital any cap, All right. You have to get to the 70th
- 56:46percentile to like 1X, right? I mean, these numbers are
- 56:50insane. And so my take is I'm going to
- 56:54take 10% of our next fund and I'm going to allocate a Bitcoin.
- 56:58And that one allocation, you know, even if it grows at a 20%
- 57:02CAGR over the next 10 years, I'm a top desil fund and on that
- 57:08allocation alone. And so I'm starting at like a 3X
- 57:14fund when everybody else is starting at a 0X fund because
- 57:19LP's live in in like a nominal multiple mindset.
- 57:23Like we're all in this world of like what, you know, what was
- 57:27your fund? What was your last funds return,
- 57:30right? But we're a 5X fund.
- 57:31All right, let me tell you something.
- 57:33This decade there will be a ton of venture firms that are 5X
- 57:38funds that return less purchasing power to LP's than
- 57:42they took from them 10 minutes ago.
- 57:45Like, think about that. That's crazy.
- 57:48That's absolutely crazy. Yeah, Yeah.
- 57:50I think what Cam reference about the returning like the reality
- 57:54is this like this isn't really debate even though someone is
- 57:58the 50% in our return capital like majority more than 50% of
- 58:01venture capital firms should not exist.
- 58:03It's a function of the amount of capital that's been infused in
- 58:05this system. You cannot allocate capital
- 58:09effectively if you never built anything.
- 58:11It's just it's just impossible. I like to go back 100 years.
- 58:14If you went to Henry Ford, who was, you know, Randy's in the
- 58:18most efficient way, If you told him or any anybody that's ever
- 58:22run something insanely successful, you're going to give
- 58:26this money to an academic or somebody that went to school and
- 58:28learned about finance, never built anything, never hired
- 58:30anybody, but you're going to give the money to even laughing
- 58:32out the room. But that's what we do today.
- 58:34So that's why there's 50% return.
- 58:36I mean, that's part of it. I would also say venture capital
- 58:40operates under power law, which which means 95% of your returns
- 58:45are going to come from 5% of your investments.
- 58:49Well, that's where we kind of defer on.
- 58:51So when we there's a, there's a conflation on we have to out
- 58:57compete 60% the K or whatever the reference reference rate.
- 59:05I think the term venture capital is kind of like a misnomer in
- 59:09the sense of the power law. And again, that's like in my
- 59:14mind of fallacy itself that 9 out of 10 businesses go to 0.
- 59:16It's a product of like bad money because why would anybody
- 59:18allocate to anything? We're 90% go to 0.
- 59:21So when we do this, well, it seems insane, just like
- 59:23everything that anybody's done, anything that's against
- 59:25consensus looks completely rational, look insane not to do
- 59:28it. And the way we came to this
- 59:30conclusion was not looking at cagers and all this like
- 59:32versions of what Bitcoin does was we built the business.
- 59:35We weren't insanely early, but we are early enough A, to to
- 59:40holding a Bitcoin to take a chance and B watch everybody
- 59:43like money on fire. So without naming names in the
- 59:45existing Bitcoin space, I'll reference the traditional
- 59:48venture space that everybody knows and we work was that
- 59:50example. I saw liquidity drawn up, all
- 59:52unit economics. I saw all soundness in
- 59:56businesses. If anybody in a room today
- 59:59started a business tomorrow with us and you give us $1,000,000 or
- 1:00:02$100 million, I can guarantee you on a long enough time
- 1:00:05horizon and build a much Better Business with less money.
- 1:00:07That's just the nature of humans.
- 1:00:09And so when we built the business, we realized because we
- 1:00:12just feel like we're not taking money because again, the
- 1:00:14definition of having something, you don't give it away.
- 1:00:16So it's like the first thing, like maybe the initial tranche,
- 1:00:18you need a little capital to get out of bed.
- 1:00:20But you hear about open AI and these companies raising all this
- 1:00:22money, it's like, well, who would do that?
- 1:00:24If you could make a bunch of money, why would you keep giving
- 1:00:2610% year over year? So we thought we were on to
- 1:00:29something. We still think we're on to
- 1:00:30something. But the other part of that was,
- 1:00:33well, so you know, why would you get away if you're going to make
- 1:00:37more money in the future? We like, there's a longer story
- 1:00:39about Grayscale. We're just seeing a company that
- 1:00:42printed about 10,000 bitcoins a year and they have product
- 1:00:46market fit and we're like, well, if we can get anywhere near
- 1:00:48that, any equity we give up today means we're giving up
- 1:00:50Bitcoin in the future. Well, if we value Bitcoin, why
- 1:00:52would we do that? We would spend the Bitcoin
- 1:00:54today. That's how you get to the level
- 1:00:55of spending the asset that's finite and scarce.
- 1:00:59But it wasn't looking at it for we got to throw an extra right.
- 1:01:01Maybe you can underwrite it that way.
- 1:01:02It was just looking at it at what's called a 10 bit when you
- 1:01:04start the business. I'm going to make more than 10
- 1:01:07Bitcoin back from the business and the downside is going to
- 1:01:10protect of being a cash flow nice positive business,
- 1:01:12something raise a family, have some people run a good be a
- 1:01:15contributing member of society and the upside, Well, the
- 1:01:18upside's as big as you can dream, and that's how businesses
- 1:01:21should be run. Nobody goes in a business 9 out
- 1:01:23of 10 times thinking about. So that's the whole notion about
- 1:01:25venture capital. Like this whole thing gets re
- 1:01:27underwritten because the way we understand venture capital is
- 1:01:30absolutely like not true, is like nobody in their right mind
- 1:01:32would go into a bet 9 out of 10. It's something we've sold to
- 1:01:35people. And when you re underwrite that
- 1:01:37the money is scarce and you want to return it.
- 1:01:40Now when you get out of bed to allocate your time and capital,
- 1:01:42it's to return the base level, all the money back to yourself
- 1:01:46or your investors. And then the upside is just
- 1:01:48making more Bitcoin than you do and paying out the dividends.
- 1:01:51And you're now not always going for an exit.
- 1:01:53So we like to underwrite from returning the Bitcoin plus some
- 1:01:57to investors and then you get, and so that's via dividends and
- 1:02:00then you get the upside and somebody exits, right?
- 1:02:03If somebody goes for it and they turn it in Michael Jordan, then
- 1:02:07you get your return times 10X or whatever, or 100, whatever the
- 1:02:11number is. So it's just a different way to
- 1:02:13look at this whole space. It's a similar idea to what Cam
- 1:02:16was saying earlier around, you know the the venture firm today
- 1:02:20that decides to put 10% in Bitcoin is going to be a top to
- 1:02:23sell reform over the next decade.
- 1:02:25Call it the same idea is true of company XYZ that decides to hold
- 1:02:31X amount of Bitcoin on their balance sheet.
- 1:02:33The the frame of reference that you're mentioning around 9 out
- 1:02:37of 10 bets go to 0 that that #9 going to 0 is actually decreased
- 1:02:42overtime if they're, you know, storing value in a better form
- 1:02:45of money, right. So that's that's part of the
- 1:02:46thesis as well is like we are actually de risking the business
- 1:02:51venture by having them, you know, sold some amount of their
- 1:02:55value and increasingly have their cash flows flow into a
- 1:02:58better form of money that is more resilient and grow their
- 1:03:00purchasing power over time. So it actually D risk the the
- 1:03:03number that will go to 0. So we think that, you know, in
- 1:03:07our fund it'll be less than 9 out of 10 or going to 0.
- 1:03:09Let's see what. What you guys are doing, like
- 1:03:12what we do at Brickyard is we're like kind of guaranteeing that
- 1:03:15none of our teams are treating this like a project, right?
- 1:03:19What you guys are guaranteeing is that every one of your
- 1:03:22entrepreneurs that you back is allocating capital with bitcoins
- 1:03:26the hurdle, right, right. And like how many founders have
- 1:03:30you been over the years coming from we were, I mean, it just
- 1:03:36comes back to human nature. If you didn't earn the money, it
- 1:03:40takes a really special person to allocate that capital as if it's
- 1:03:44there, right? And like every venture back
- 1:03:48founder, you know, they're taking other people's money and
- 1:03:53they are, you know, in in most cases, the venture firms are
- 1:03:57actually like pushing them to spend it faster than they would
- 1:04:00man, because the the general partnerships incentives are they
- 1:04:05want markups. Right, Yeah, there's an apples
- 1:04:10of mortgage thing like it's in the sense of like Kim said, I
- 1:04:15was insane like he's kind of right in the sense of like from
- 1:04:18the the sentiment and status quo into what Cam's doing is very
- 1:04:21innovative and will be very successful in the sense of if
- 1:04:24you're underwriting and you're able to underwrite knowing what
- 1:04:27Bitcoins CAGR is, then you can adopt that.
- 1:04:30The the way we ended up on the other side is we're building a
- 1:04:32private Bitcoin bank. And so the people we work with
- 1:04:35generally crock a big points appreciation B, they don't want
- 1:04:39dollars. I think y'all are going to be
- 1:04:41more successful than us like. Like.
- 1:04:43Shane and we're Shane. Shane are coming away over here
- 1:04:46like your model is the model. Yeah, we're just in the, we're
- 1:04:50just on the other side of it. And there's like everyone to
- 1:04:53your point, because we've talked to a lot of traditional venture
- 1:04:55capitalists, but I'll send institutions or other
- 1:04:59individuals with looking for exposure, like to individuals
- 1:05:04like Cam and others, because I definitely recognize that like
- 1:05:06what we're talking about here is meant for somebody that like
- 1:05:09deeply understands Bitcoin and now understands that they want
- 1:05:12exposure to companies that are going to make more Bitcoin and
- 1:05:15that's how they underwrite. But that's this tiniest small,
- 1:05:18like it's, it's whatever the smallest percentage of people
- 1:05:20like rock Bitcoin, it's one 100th of that and want exposure
- 1:05:23to that. So that's the, to Ken's point,
- 1:05:26like it's just a different person.
- 1:05:28I was just saying like you guys, you guys are planning on hard
- 1:05:31mode with the right model. Like if I go to RLPS and I say,
- 1:05:36hey, we're going to denominate Bitcoin, All our companies are
- 1:05:39going to carry Bitcoin. All our companies are going to
- 1:05:42make all our capital allocation decisions against Bitcoin as a
- 1:05:44hurdle. They're going to be like.
- 1:05:47Give me one event. Yeah, take a what?
- 1:05:49And like this really, Bitcoin is like this ego test in that if I
- 1:05:55really told my own piece what I felt, what do you think I would
- 1:06:01tell them? They might see this and.
- 1:06:05That's. Fine, but the fact is they won't
- 1:06:11do this. OK.
- 1:06:13But what they should do is they should take the entire
- 1:06:15allocation and they should put it in Bitcoin.
- 1:06:19This might you, you were talking about Henry Ford, which by the
- 1:06:21way, like at that time there were probably a bunch of people
- 1:06:24who thought he was like a looney tune, like anybody selling
- 1:06:26wooden axles or horses. But talking like that guy does
- 1:06:30not have it all together. What's he doing?
- 1:06:32You look crazy when you're early, right?
- 1:06:34Like isn't that like, but there's like some kind of phrase
- 1:06:36about that. Like when you're first to it,
- 1:06:38you look a little, you're only crazy until everybody kind of
- 1:06:40catches on. But what it might do you, you
- 1:06:43made the comment earlier, like do you spend 100K on like human
- 1:06:46brain in the room or just buy more big with that sensibility,
- 1:06:51it might make purpose driven investments matter more because
- 1:06:55it's not just about the return that you're going to get.
- 1:06:58Now businesses that have a purpose or a value or something
- 1:07:01else that they're adding to society that's not just your
- 1:07:04return becomes more important. Like what's the mission behind
- 1:07:07whatever company it is or what, what are we getting out of this?
- 1:07:10Otherwise there aren't none of those companies and it's just
- 1:07:13buy more Bitcoin and sit back and wait, right like you and
- 1:07:16maybe it democratizes a little bit the the purpose behind some
- 1:07:21of these businesses that you're able to invest in.
- 1:07:24Yeah. I mean, I think you're, I think
- 1:07:27you're spot on. I mean, I think, yeah.
- 1:07:31I mean, as it it, it would be a speculative thing if I were
- 1:07:38saying this and Bitcoin had like a a four year history.
- 1:07:41Bitcoin has a 15 year history of growing at the rate it's the
- 1:07:45best performing asset in the last one year, in the last five
- 1:07:48years, in the last 10 years, in the last 15 years, it's the best
- 1:07:51performing asset, right. And so yeah, I think all of us,
- 1:07:59we you just reached this point where you just want to shake
- 1:08:02people and it's like, what are you missing here, right?
- 1:08:06This is this is not. You know this is this simple
- 1:08:09but. Maybe that's maybe that's a good
- 1:08:13place to wrap. I know I'm cognizant of time and
- 1:08:15and want to save some time for some question and answer.
- 1:08:17So thank you guys for participating.
- 1:08:20And Jasmine, any questions from the audience?
- 1:08:25Let's let's open it up. We have no, we have time for
- 1:08:28maybe two to three questions. So could.
- 1:08:31Be on anything discussed. Yes, and Bernie from.
- 1:08:34Monetary policy to Bitcoin to five shout.
- 1:08:37At it, and we'll repeat it. What is Bitcoin?
- 1:08:40What is Bitcoin? Michael, you want to take that?
- 1:08:46I mean it's the best form of money humanities ever seen Gold
- 1:08:51Is that for thousands of years in bitcoins?
- 1:08:53Just gold perfected. Can you give me a better
- 1:08:56descriptive of what it is? So like you guys talked about
- 1:09:00value and as a real estate investor, you all love this
- 1:09:05country music venue that we have here in Nashville.
- 1:09:08We've all heard the song by here.
- 1:09:11They're not making any more dirt.
- 1:09:12And that's where I can see the similarity with 21.
- 1:09:16I mean, they're not making any more Bitcoin, but I know what
- 1:09:20the dirt is. I know what the dirt is, but I
- 1:09:24don't know what the Bitcoin is. Do I own Bitcoin?
- 1:09:27Yeah, but I don't know what it is and I don't know how to use
- 1:09:31it. And yet my Bitcoin goes up.
- 1:09:32How can I take the Bitcoin to buy eggs?
- 1:09:34And am I going to have less Bitcoin because I bought the
- 1:09:36eggs? It's like stock for me.
- 1:09:38When I think it's stock, I sell the stock to to buy the eggs.
- 1:09:41And I don't have any more shares of stock because the stock's
- 1:09:43going to go up, but the bitcoin's going to go up in
- 1:09:44value. And I get that side of it.
- 1:09:46But I've also seen Bitcoin go from one round in volatile, drop
- 1:09:53halfway and then come back to where it is now, which is a
- 1:09:56beautiful thing. And you and I, I told you I've
- 1:09:58been watching all for the past two years because you told me in
- 1:10:01life it's going to hit 100 and I believe and I still do and I'm.
- 1:10:05Waiting and then he texted me. So the question just I don't
- 1:10:07know if it's going to go through on the pod, but the question was
- 1:10:09like what is Bitcoin and value, you know, being able to touch
- 1:10:14things and then other things not being able to touch.
- 1:10:16And when Jeff had texted me about 100, I didn't even give
- 1:10:20him a like and he was like millions next.
- 1:10:23That was it. So the reality is this is going
- 1:10:27to sound like, you know, it's going to sound like it's not
- 1:10:35true or whatever. I can't remember what I'm trying
- 1:10:38to say, but value is objective. It's not or value subjective.
- 1:10:45Money is the things that give money properties, properties
- 1:10:51that make a good form of money are objective.
- 1:10:54They're they're indisputable. So value subjective, we can all
- 1:10:57have our own preference, but what makes a good form of money
- 1:11:01and why gold is money for 1000 years.
- 1:11:02That is objective. It has certain properties,
- 1:11:05scarcities, one of them, right? It just, we all know again, it
- 1:11:09goes back to the guitar, if there was one that was hand
- 1:11:11signed by somebody that's going to be more valuable than the
- 1:11:14others. But that's not enough.
- 1:11:16It also needs to be divisible because you got to be able to
- 1:11:17break it down. If you're going to be able to
- 1:11:19transfer for whether it's the water or the eggs that you want
- 1:11:21or you want to, you know, net settle escrow for a large real
- 1:11:25estate or anything, the oil tank for billions of dollars.
- 1:11:27So it needs to be able to be divisible because again, house
- 1:11:30is a great example where if you have a big house, you can cut it
- 1:11:33in half, but the value isn't there.
- 1:11:35You can cut a Bitcoin in half and it's still 50% of a Bitcoin.
- 1:11:37It doesn't diminish the value. It needs to be transferred, be
- 1:11:41able to be transferred over time and space.
- 1:11:42Gold failed at this because gold ultimately had the
- 1:11:45centralization problem because it's physical and you need lots
- 1:11:46of armed cards. This is where Bitcoin shines
- 1:11:48because it can transfer wherever.
- 1:11:51So these are the things that make a good form of money.
- 1:11:53This is how we ended up because money is just a technology and
- 1:11:55technologies we all know upgrade.
- 1:11:57And so gold was at for a long time, gold had this issue of
- 1:11:59centralization because of the, you know, physical nature.
- 1:12:02So you had to have more, you had to you put claims on it.
- 1:12:04Think about the dollar as like a next level.
- 1:12:07And then Amex is another because they don't net settle when you
- 1:12:09spend your Amex card, right? They didn't settle on a nightly
- 1:12:12or monthly, whatever it is from banks and interchange.
- 1:12:14So point being is Bitcoin just has objective properties that
- 1:12:19make it a better form of money and that's what people wake up
- 1:12:21every day and allocate more capital to it.
- 1:12:24Now to your point, all it is is a Ledger, like all banks are
- 1:12:28ledgers. All The Cave is that you store
- 1:12:30the gold as a Ledger and you have guards that are hoping to
- 1:12:33protect that Ledger, which is your gold or the bank that's
- 1:12:36protecting your balance. And most ledgers if you
- 1:12:40something happens, your account gets hacked, you just reverse
- 1:12:42the Ledger because it's not a digital finite asset.
- 1:12:45That's why Bitcoin has its hard property to understand because
- 1:12:48it was all Bitcoin. That's what our business focuses
- 1:12:50on is custody of it. We've been building for about
- 1:12:53half a decade now in this space, so deeply understanding how to
- 1:12:55like secure it because that's the only real way we build
- 1:12:58products for ourselves because we have a lot of money in it.
- 1:13:00And you can only put all your money in it if you understand
- 1:13:02from a first principle way how it'll be there tomorrow and it
- 1:13:04won't end up in North Korean hackers hands or won't also end
- 1:13:08up in a landfill. So it's all it is, it's just
- 1:13:11money. It should.
- 1:13:12And all money is it's just a Ledger on who owns what.
- 1:13:15And again, just to go a little deeper is gold was a bearer
- 1:13:19asset. So who had gold had the gold in
- 1:13:22Bitcoin? It's addresses like a physical,
- 1:13:25like an e-mail address. And whoever has the password to
- 1:13:27your e-mail can read all your emails in the same way who has
- 1:13:29the password to to move the Bitcoin from that address has
- 1:13:32the Bitcoin. Well, historically people, the
- 1:13:34only way to keep it safe is they have to keep it in their homes
- 1:13:36on these little plastic devices. But that obviously becomes a
- 1:13:39problem when people break in your house and all the things
- 1:13:41associated or you lose it. Because historically in Bitcoin,
- 1:13:44you can't leave it on what would be like a custodial relationship
- 1:13:47like a Coinbase. Because for every Coinbase,
- 1:13:49there's like 10 other places that have lost all the Bitcoin.
- 1:13:52This is what caused the crashes. So it goes back to 21 in the
- 1:13:56asymmetries is that people conflate what happens with the
- 1:13:59volatility to Bitcoin. It's just the world pricing in
- 1:14:01and that new asset. Again, going back to like
- 1:14:04history, if you have thought about gold, so the gold
- 1:14:07infinities had experience in the tryouts or a bar when you picked
- 1:14:10up that bar, that gold, it's beautiful, it's nice, it's
- 1:14:12refined. Everybody knows the Kruger and
- 1:14:14you know, Golden Eagle, I think that's what it's called the
- 1:14:17United States. But when you when it came about,
- 1:14:20it looked like that. It was like a nasty rock with a
- 1:14:22bunch of dirt and somebody was giving you something else that
- 1:14:24didn't have that objective value.
- 1:14:26And over time we're coalescing as humans.
- 1:14:28I'm like, what is objective value?
- 1:14:29What can I shave off? What like can go to the bottom
- 1:14:32of the ocean or somebody passed away and I can pick up 150 years
- 1:14:34and it's still exactly that. Like that's what gold does.
- 1:14:36That's what Bitcoin does. And so when you go through that,
- 1:14:39then we're all just re pricing like what is this asset to Cam's
- 1:14:41point, Like how does this store my value?
- 1:14:43How do like somebody will give me more cows for this thing?
- 1:14:46And then people were trading the, you know, the, the,
- 1:14:50whatever the lock was or platinum or whatever.
- 1:14:53And thinking about this analogy, it's very similar to crypto.
- 1:14:56So this is also a big conflation of the spaces.
- 1:14:58People will hear digital assets or crypto and they assume
- 1:15:03Bitcoin either they're the most fundamental different thing.
- 1:15:05It's the similar the same way as describing aluminum and gold.
- 1:15:08You would never trade any of your gold for aluminum.
- 1:15:10And that's the same thing that people are trying to talk about
- 1:15:12here. And one can be speculative and
- 1:15:13you can make some money. And if we want to be diplomatic,
- 1:15:15I'm thinking that it's like an adventure met.
- 1:15:17We're 9 out of 10 go to 0. Bickering is just a completely
- 1:15:20different asset. And now the rest of the
- 1:15:22mainstream is waking up to that. So everything CEO of black fuck,
- 1:15:25we just had Microsoft and largest companies in the world
- 1:15:30just had a pitch putting on their corporate treasury.
- 1:15:34It's it's just a different asset or it's a different asset to be
- 1:15:38treated. But in while it's happening, the
- 1:15:40monetization, we've never in our lives had an asset monetized in
- 1:15:44real time. So we don't understand it.
- 1:15:47We're just like looking around seeing this thing and it's going
- 1:15:50up and down. Well, that makes complete sense
- 1:15:52because there's $450 trillion of total value in the whole world
- 1:15:56and this asset is just barely at 100K2 trillion.
- 1:15:59So of course it's going to go every time somebody had a
- 1:16:01conversation with somebody, market buys the UAE, put it on
- 1:16:04their, you know, balance sheet for their sovereign nation, Like
- 1:16:07all these things will move that price and then somebody else
- 1:16:09will lose the asset. Somebody else will have a Ponzi
- 1:16:12and it'll crash and it'll look like it's doing the same thing.
- 1:16:14But the noticing point while you're interested is it always
- 1:16:16finds a higher high. So.
- 1:16:20I would, I would add it to that and I would just say real estate
- 1:16:25should be priced for its utility value.
- 1:16:28Real estate's value is based on what someone's ready and willing
- 1:16:31to pay, sure, but beside the same thing with Bitcoin.
- 1:16:35If they're ready, but. But today, but today you have
- 1:16:37people that are buying real estate as a store of value and
- 1:16:41not as a utility of I need a roof over my head or I need a
- 1:16:44place to put a restaurant or I need a right.
- 1:16:47Like real estate should be priced as with its utility value
- 1:16:52in mind. But because we've broken the
- 1:16:54money, because our money loses, you know, 7% a year, people are
- 1:17:00not holding cash. Like my parents when I was in
- 1:17:03high school, we had like, savings accounts, right?
- 1:17:06We like held cash in a savings. No one holds cash.
- 1:17:11Anymore. Does anybody have any money in a
- 1:17:13savings? Account You're a venture
- 1:17:14capitalist. Yeah, well, we have the money
- 1:17:18market, but I'm talking about it when it my first year at a
- 1:17:23college, I was one step above a teller at a bank in a mall
- 1:17:26parking lot in Birmingham and we sold savings accounts at .5%
- 1:17:34interest. OK.
- 1:17:37And a lot of people had that today.
- 1:17:39None like this is probably not going to So you you have people
- 1:17:44that you're not holding your your value in cash anymore.
- 1:17:48And so people are, that's why we have such a, a huge rise in
- 1:17:52asset prices in housing. People are, are not, they're not
- 1:17:56pricing housing for its utility value.
- 1:17:59They're pricing it for its utility value plus for its, its,
- 1:18:03you know, it's a better store value than cash, right?
- 1:18:06And so, you know, what Bitcoin does is it's a money that
- 1:18:10doesn't lose value. And so you no longer have to,
- 1:18:14right? The irony is that we're buying
- 1:18:15it with our Love U.S. dollars, which is fine.
- 1:18:18It's just like I'd be buying gold like you talked about.
- 1:18:20And my question isn't to discredit what you're saying.
- 1:18:23My question is for everybody to hear what I want to hear.
- 1:18:27Sure, you guys. So I appreciate your answer.
- 1:18:28Yeah, for the on. On around guys, you mentioned
- 1:18:33your business is returning your own Bitcoin and just curious if
- 1:18:38you could elaborate on your on your bottle and what your focus
- 1:18:41is. So there's two businesses
- 1:18:45there's honoring, which is thinking about like a private
- 1:18:47Bitcoin bank for individuals all the way to institutions.
- 1:18:50We worked with some of the IT was public about two weeks ago,
- 1:18:52the first UK pensions we helped get an allocation to Bitcoin.
- 1:18:55And then what Cam was referencing in the the Bitcoin
- 1:18:58denominated. It's a early riders is a venture
- 1:19:00firm. So I think it was like almost
- 1:19:01like the investment bank on its side.
- 1:19:03So we hope whether it's our clients or external, you don't
- 1:19:05have to be a client to to be an investor and early riders.
- 1:19:08We allocate capital in the ecosystem and of course not only
- 1:19:12in just Bitcoin, but in companies that are producing
- 1:19:14cash flows that are sweeping that excess into BTC, looking to
- 1:19:19out compete competitors that are, you know, playing on, you
- 1:19:23know, the hand tied behind their back.
- 1:19:25Yeah, at a very high level, just to add to that, the whole idea
- 1:19:29in denominating the fund in Bitcoin is we we get Bitcoin
- 1:19:32from our LP's, we then invest that Bitcoin into businesses for
- 1:19:37those founders then, you know, have the same reverence for the
- 1:19:40Bitcoin in terms of their opportunity cost.
- 1:19:41So what they're going to go out and spend on.
- 1:19:44And then ultimately at the end of the day, our goal is to
- 1:19:46return more Bitcoin back to our LP's than they gave us.
- 1:19:50And and you know that that's sort of at a very high level of
- 1:19:53the model. But the way you can sort of
- 1:19:55abstract the way you know what I just said and just think about
- 1:19:57it like this is, you know, we're taking the Bitcoin, we're going
- 1:20:00out and producing value in the real world with XYZ business
- 1:20:03that we think is able to produce basically.
- 1:20:07Whether it's OK if they're producing, you know, dollars, as
- 1:20:09long as we're sweeping those dollars into Bitcoin over time
- 1:20:12so that we end up with more Bitcoin than we put in
- 1:20:14effectively. So that's at a very high level
- 1:20:16the model. And maybe just because I don't
- 1:20:18know if you got to introduce yourself, like I think we're not
- 1:20:21all Cowboys out here. I think, you know, Kim and
- 1:20:23myself, Kim had a great story about being that teller and we
- 1:20:26were listening to a podcast where he was doing it.
- 1:20:28And just like, I don't know if he laughed in the middle of the
- 1:20:30job, this I'd like to remember, but he just basically laughed.
- 1:20:32He's like, I can't do this my whole life, you know, and I've
- 1:20:35had those experiences. But Brian?
- 1:20:39Yeah, but I guess before before starting the Bitcoin private
- 1:20:41bank, I worked at a natural private bank, Brown Brothers
- 1:20:44Harriman for about nine years on the allocation side.
- 1:20:48And then after that, sort of, you know, personally catching
- 1:20:51the Bitcoin bug in 1718, worked at Flame Base for a year and in
- 1:20:562022 before joining Michael and building on ramp.
- 1:21:00So come from the traditional finance space and and sort of
- 1:21:04the allocation side in general. This will be our last question
- 1:21:07of the evening, but there will be time to ask.
- 1:21:11I was just going to say, can you talk about the mindset shift or
- 1:21:16difference that we see in the founders you get a Bitcoin to
- 1:21:19versus the ones that you get dollars?
- 1:21:22What are they? How do they operate?
- 1:21:24It's funny you, you have said, because it's like anything you
- 1:21:29come from your frame of references and like there was a
- 1:21:31lot of doing things the wrong way and sometimes the right way
- 1:21:34that built into like what you're referencing.
- 1:21:37And it goes back to the incentives all the way down.
- 1:21:41So like to it was kind of tongue in cheek, but like a venture
- 1:21:43capitalist takes the money and they do capital calls and
- 1:21:46depending on how they structure it, that money sits in a money
- 1:21:48market fund that's still losing in real terms, right?
- 1:21:51That's put you on the spot like it is.
- 1:21:53And so you do that and then so your incentive is to get that
- 1:21:58money out because you want to raise more money and you want to
- 1:22:01raise it in the next 12 and 18. You want to have a larger fund.
- 1:22:04The need one that really looks at stuff like critically knows
- 1:22:07that larger funds are harder to churn Capital like you like
- 1:22:11smaller and tiger is always better and like, and so like by
- 1:22:15aligning all that, sometimes you get to do all of it.
- 1:22:17You get to play the most. So again, Cam says it's hard
- 1:22:19mode. I think of it as easy mode
- 1:22:20because going back to like to allocate capital, if you look at
- 1:22:24the best investors, the best value investors in the world,
- 1:22:26they like sat on their hands. They don't do much.
- 1:22:29They like find this the right pitch and then they swing, but
- 1:22:33they don't they don't swing much.
- 1:22:34And when you're in traditional venture capital, like you have a
- 1:22:37nail, you have a hammer and everything needs to look like a
- 1:22:38nail. So you're looking for everyone
- 1:22:40to make it make sense versus you put the thing in Bitcoin, you do
- 1:22:44your capital, you leverage, you know, good form of custody.
- 1:22:47So you know it'll be there are sitting on our hands as we're
- 1:22:50building all day long. And by building, you get to spot
- 1:22:53spot all the gaps, all the inefficiencies in the market.
- 1:22:56You get to come in If you have too many ideas, Well, you start
- 1:22:59to figure out like what do we need to see?
- 1:23:02And then to your point where this gets really exciting is
- 1:23:06that because I'm a product of this, so I kind of live this,
- 1:23:10but the best entrepreneurs and best founders we all know go to
- 1:23:13the best technology. This is just like how things
- 1:23:15happen to go to the best cities. They go, they just leave.
- 1:23:17They're the first people by definition.
- 1:23:19They look crazy until they're not.
- 1:23:21And so I've seen this from hiring from that past half
- 1:23:23decade, The best people need to get out of the space because
- 1:23:27once they recognize This is why I love talking about canvas.
- 1:23:30Canvas is in trouble struggle right now, but it's just a
- 1:23:35reality. I just had some of these
- 1:23:36conversations and I realized like the best people hiring all
- 1:23:38the things, it's like you find the person that's like, look, I
- 1:23:40can't like I found I had a frame of reference.
- 1:23:42I had this version of the world and it's kind of changed.
- 1:23:44I have to re underwrite it. And that person, they have to
- 1:23:47jump out of that job and they're the best people to bring on your
- 1:23:49team, like Brian. And and so to your point on the
- 1:23:53founder side, it's very similar because in traditional
- 1:23:56investing, you need like founder market fit, you need to grit,
- 1:23:58you need to hustle, you need all the things that you would need
- 1:24:00for somebody for the whole world to tell them like, you're
- 1:24:02insane. Still say like, no, I know what
- 1:24:04I'm doing, I'm going to do it. But the last part is they you,
- 1:24:07you like de risk that by saying, Oh, and I'm going to hold the
- 1:24:09best for more money. And to like Emily's point
- 1:24:12earlier, it's not that you don't spend it, it's just that you're
- 1:24:14thinking more critically about how you spend it.
- 1:24:16Because we've all been in the position where you have too many
- 1:24:18dollars and you're just like moving around.
- 1:24:21This is if you have this asset, you know, it's going to
- 1:24:22appreciate, you're just going to be thinking more critically.
- 1:24:24So you layer all those things on top and now you're really
- 1:24:27cooking with like jet fuel because you're working with the
- 1:24:30best founder. That's thinking in the clearest
- 1:24:32way because once you see what Cam's described with the money,
- 1:24:36you start to look at the world in a completely new lens.
- 1:24:38And you're just basically running in a cheap mode at that
- 1:24:40point because everyone else is like running into the building
- 1:24:43that, you know, it's on fire and you're just like running out
- 1:24:45with the crew and being like, we're going to go build in
- 1:24:47another building. I don't know.
- 1:24:50And this is what's happening at companies because companies are
- 1:24:53by definition like especially large ones.
- 1:24:55They have the bureaucracy, they have a lot of the things that
- 1:25:01like like ties are being behind their back to games point on the
- 1:25:04AI side. They're not able to have like a
- 1:25:06certain level of thing. Every company has a certain
- 1:25:08amount of fact because if you have any money that's not sound,
- 1:25:12then you're naturally you're always going to suspend it in an
- 1:25:15unsound way. And it's just at what level?
- 1:25:17And so that those entrepreneurs are seeing at that broth what
- 1:25:20we're talking about here. And they say, oh, I'm going to
- 1:25:22leave because they first try to go like hell.
- 1:25:24Again, this is from experience. They first try to go ho and they
- 1:25:27try to say, we need to put Bitcoin on balance sheet.
- 1:25:28We need to like get more efficient.
- 1:25:29You need to start sweeping. But the reality is it's too hard
- 1:25:32to like. This is why in Bitcoin being
- 1:25:35very emergent, individuals adopt it first and institutions are
- 1:25:39slowly coming because these concepts are really hard, but
- 1:25:42individuals can get them pretty simply if they ought to take the
- 1:25:44time. But imagine from a board level
- 1:25:46to drive you consensus, it becomes nearly impossible.
- 1:25:49So those individuals at the same level trying to get their
- 1:25:51company to adopt any of this, it's whether they know it or
- 1:25:54not. I like to call it the carrot or
- 1:25:55stick. They're going to leave by the
- 1:25:57carrot because they're going to realize I can have a better
- 1:25:59opportunity to go out compete by leveraging all these
- 1:26:01deflationary tools for the stick is by their unfortunate
- 1:26:05circumstance of having to try to spend 2 years to convince them
- 1:26:09and then wake up one day and realize there was all the fools
- 1:26:11there and I should just go out and now compete them because I
- 1:26:13know how to leverage the tools and I have a better form of
- 1:26:16money. And so while they were having to
- 1:26:17complete compete with inflation, I have a better form of money.
- 1:26:20I don't have to raise my prices. Let's, let's, let's, let's them
- 1:26:22out compete them. So hopefully that high.
- 1:26:28You have a final thought for this evening and.
- 1:26:31Google Fiber, what is my final thought?
- 1:26:33Well, thank you guys for having this conversation, inviting me
- 1:26:36to be a part of it. I do own some Bitcoin by the
- 1:26:40way. I'm not a complete noob.
- 1:26:43I think these conversations that we, we talked about the
- 1:26:45beginning, Google Fiber just launched what we call our
- 1:26:48lifestyle products. You had one gig for the last 10
- 1:26:50years that we've got 8. And I'm having conversations
- 1:26:53like I did two years ago, going to the creators, the dreamers,
- 1:26:56the doers and things like what are you going to do with with
- 1:26:59eight? It's not just Bitcoin, it's not
- 1:27:02just entrepreneurs, it's really anybody that's in that mindset.
- 1:27:04It's I think who we're after. And I think the take home
- 1:27:07message, I hope about Google Fiber is you are the why and the
- 1:27:11what in your business. Anybody watching this has their
- 1:27:14own why and their what. And Google Fiber just wants to
- 1:27:16be the how all of that happened. So we can be the stage.
- 1:27:21Everyone else can kind of perform on top of it, whether
- 1:27:23this is a national or any other city that we're in, we just want
- 1:27:26to be able to to provide and be the, the how that stuff gets
- 1:27:29done. Very well said.
- 1:27:31Thank you guys. Thanks for having us.
- 1:27:33Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:27:36If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:27:38episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:27:41app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:27:43today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:27:45Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:27:48for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:27:51nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:27:54Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:27:56to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:28:00to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:28:03advisors.