Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / New Law Update: SB 940 - ADR Certification and Changes to California Arbitration Law with Ana M. Sambold and Paul E. Burns
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening everyone and welcome to the new law update SB940, ADR certification and challenges
- 0:15to California arbitration law.
- 0:17I'm Ola Policastro, CLE advisor with the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:22Today I am delighted to introduce our panelists, Anna Sambold and Paul Burns.
- 0:28Anna is internationally recognized as a leading figure in the field of dispute resolution.
- 0:34As a California attorney, mediator and arbitrator, she has facilitated the resolution of over
- 0:391,000 commercial and civil litigation matters with expertise in cases involving multinational
- 0:45and multilingual parties.
- 0:48She handles cases in English and Spanish and is inexperienced in both common and civil
- 0:52law.
- 0:53Paul Burns is the managing attorney of Burns Legal, a best lawyer, best law firm for 2025.
- 1:00Congratulations Paul.
- 1:02His career in complex intellectual property and commercial litigation spans over 30 years.
- 1:09Paul is an arbitrator and mediator for the American Arbitration Association with over
- 1:1320 years of experience there.
- 1:15He is an adjunct professor at Pepperdine Caruso School of Law where he teaches courses focused
- 1:20on arbitration and advocacy.
- 1:23We can't wait to hear what they have to share with us today.
- 1:25Over to you.
- 1:27Thank you, Ella.
- 1:29Well, hello everyone.
- 1:32It's a great pleasure to be here with my colleague Paul Burns to provide you an update on the
- 1:38new law SB 940.
- 1:42Before we start, I just want to remind everyone that we have provided the PowerPoint presentation
- 1:49to the Verbal Hills Bar Association so you will have a copy of this PowerPoint.
- 1:55We have also provided an official copy of the law so you can have it and it's available
- 2:01online anyway, but you can have the copy.
- 2:05We have provided that as silly and we're excited to have all what is it, 200 attendees
- 2:14today.
- 2:15That's pretty exciting.
- 2:17We invite you to submit questions for us anytime during the program.
- 2:21You can submit them using the Q&A function on the bottom of the Zoom toolbar.
- 2:28We will address questions on hopefully at the end of the program.
- 2:33We will cover everything.
- 2:36We will have time to answer all the questions.
- 2:39But let's dive right in.
- 2:43So SB 940 was introduced by Senator Tom Umberg on January 17, 2024.
- 2:55Governor Newsland signed it into law on September 29, 2024.
- 3:01The most important part, it will be effective on January 1, 2025.
- 3:08These laws substantially affect ADR in California.
- 3:15Why?
- 3:16Well, basically, it adds a new article to the Business and Professions Code.
- 3:25It's called the State Bar Act.
- 3:28It requires the State Bar of California to create a certification program for mediators,
- 3:34arbitrators, and other ADR providers, and also make substantial changes to California
- 3:44arbitration law by adding two sections to the Civil Code and amending the sections 1281,
- 3:5493.3, and repealing section 1283.1 of the Code of the Civil Procedure relating to civil
- 4:02disputes.
- 4:04So like I mentioned, the law is available online, but we have provided a copy of the
- 4:11official test of the SB 940.
- 4:15And this is kind of our agenda today.
- 4:21We're going to be covering the eight substantive sections of SB 940.
- 4:28So the first section is about the ADR certification program.
- 4:36Section 2 is about consumer arbitration, the local, the venue, and the applicable law.
- 4:41Section number three talks about consumer arbitration and its more claims.
- 4:45Section 4 talks about arbitrator disclosures and solicitation.
- 4:50Section 5 talks about consumer arbitration solicitation.
- 4:55Section 6 subpoenas, section 7 depots, and section 8 discovery.
- 5:02So let's start right in.
- 5:07Let's start with section 1 that talks about ADR certification program.
- 5:14As I mentioned, the law basically directs the State Bar of California to create a certification
- 5:22program requiring to develop a voluntary certification program for ADR firms, providers, and practitioners.
- 5:35These programs shall not require a firm or provider or practitioner to be a licensee
- 5:43of the State Bar in order to be certified under the program.
- 5:47So it will be available to lawyers and non-lawyers.
- 5:55So to be eligible to be certified under this program, basically the law provides the following.
- 6:05The firm, the firm, the provider of the neutral most require its arbitrators or its mediators
- 6:14to comply with the ethics standards for neutral arbitrators and contractual arbitration, or
- 6:21require its mediators to comply with the equivalent to the rules of conduct for mediators in
- 6:28core connected mediation programs for general civil cases.
- 6:34In addition, the firm or the ADR provider or the neutral most have procedures in place
- 6:41for people to make complaints regarding the failure of an arbitrator or mediator to comply
- 6:48with the ethical standards to remedy that failure.
- 6:54So what are the specific standards of conduct with which arbitrators, mediators, and ADR
- 7:04providers will have to prove compliance where this can be found?
- 7:11So for mediators, as I mentioned, the law provides the equivalent to the rules of conduct
- 7:20for mediators in core connected mediation programs for general civil cases, and those
- 7:27are provided in the California Rules of Court.
- 7:31The standards are available online.
- 7:35Here's the link.
- 7:37And they begin at Title III, Division VIII, Chapter III, Article II.
- 7:43And basically, these rules of conduct for mediators in core connected mediation program
- 7:50cases talk about the principles of voluntary participation, self-determination, confidentiality,
- 7:59impartiality, complex of interest, disclosure, and withdrawal, competence, quality of the
- 8:05process, marketing, compensation, and gift, and agreements to disclose.
- 8:13So in regard to the complaint procedures for mediators, Article III of these rules, the
- 8:21California Rules of Court, provides a process for all the mediators that are panels and
- 8:33court panels.
- 8:37They have a specific procedure defined.
- 8:41So this is what the SB940 is providing, that the mediator or the ADR provider have some
- 8:51type of complaint process that is similar to this process provided in the California
- 8:56Rules of Court.
- 8:59Some things that you need to keep in mind is that Article III includes that the complaint
- 9:04proceedings must be private and confidential.
- 9:07The mediators must agree to disclose mediation communication if there's a complaint about
- 9:12their conduct.
- 9:15People who participate or receive a complaint cannot hear the term in any contested issues
- 9:22related to the dispute and in court action of proceeding.
- 9:27At the same time, SB940, as I mentioned, requires that in order to be eligible for the certification,
- 9:36ADR providers must require its arbitrators to comply with ethics standards for neutral
- 9:45arbitrators and contractual arbitration.
- 9:47I have something that I want to emphasize that is that these ethical standards were adopted
- 9:57by the Judicial Council in July 2002.
- 10:05Since that, they have been amended and reorganized and effective since January 1, 2003.
- 10:13These ethics standards for neutral arbitrators are available online.
- 10:19Here's the link.
- 10:21Here's a little overview of what these ethics standards provide.
- 10:27The duration of the duty, the general duty, duty to refuse appointment, disclosure, some
- 10:33additional disclosure in consumer arbitrations administered by a provider organization.
- 10:39Duty to inform themselves about matters to be disclosed, disqualification, duties to
- 10:45refuse gift, and conduct of proceedings and expatriate communications and confidentiality
- 10:51and compensation and marketing.
- 10:55I invited to check out those ethics standards that are available online.
- 11:05At the same time, I want to emphasize that these ethics standards for neutral arbitrators
- 11:13are the minimum standards of conduct for neutral arbitrators.
- 11:18They are intended to guide the conduct of arbitrators and to inform and protect participants
- 11:23in arbitration and to promote public confidence in the arbitration process.
- 11:27I'm very proud to say that California has been enforcing arbitrators in California.
- 11:38We have the most stringent disclosures because of these ethics standards for neutral arbitrators.
- 11:51The SB940 in section 1 provides some tiers for ADR certification.
- 11:58These tiers are basically the higher level or the higher tier are awarded to firms or
- 12:10providers or neutrals that demonstrate a higher level of commitment to accountability and
- 12:15consumer protection.
- 12:18I want to emphasize that these levels of tiers do not reflect an assessment of the quality
- 12:24of the firm or provider or practitioner.
- 12:28These tiers are levels of only reference to standards of conduct.
- 12:39At the same time, SB940 provides authority to the state bar to deny or revoke certification
- 12:55for failure to meet or maintain certification standards.
- 13:00The state bar will be charging a fee for practitioners that are seeking certification.
- 13:11This charge, this fee will be probably higher in the early years of the program while they
- 13:17set up the program and they set up the whole structure.
- 13:22The SB940 does not allow the state bar to use any money received from the annual license
- 13:31fees collected for purposes of developing the certification program.
- 13:38Lastly, in section 1, section 1 defines what is alternative dispute resolution and includes
- 13:46mediation, arbitration, conciliation and other non-judicial procedures that involve a neutral
- 13:53party in the decision-making process.
- 13:56I have a little concern about that definition because as you may know, mediators don't have
- 14:04any decision-making power.
- 14:07It's one of those things that I always had when people confused those terms and that
- 14:14terminology, mediation and arbitration, they're totally different concepts.
- 14:18An arbitrator has decision-making power while the mediator doesn't have any decision power,
- 14:24especially here in California.
- 14:27But some key points that I want to highlight about this ADR certification program is, first
- 14:34of all, the program is non-mandatory, is voluntary for ADR firms, for neutral, for providers
- 14:42and practitioners.
- 14:44They will apply to lawyers and non-lawyers.
- 14:47I don't know about that.
- 14:51I don't know the state bar has the authority to regulate certifying non-lawyers, but here
- 14:57it is.
- 14:59Also the certification is not assigned to assess the quality of the dispute resolution
- 15:03services.
- 15:06Neutrals do not have to prove how competent or training, how experienced they are in mediation
- 15:13or arbitration to become certified because, as I mentioned, the levels of tiers only reference
- 15:21standards of conduct.
- 15:24So that can be a little misleading to the public because anyone willing to pay the fees and
- 15:32get certified with no competence, no training, or no experience whatsoever can apply to get
- 15:40certified.
- 15:41And that will be very misleading to the public because the public will believe that, oh,
- 15:51this neutral is certified and this one is not, must be because there's something wrong
- 15:55with this one.
- 15:56So let's go for the one that is certified by the state bar that they probably believe
- 16:02that has extensive experience or is more competent than the one is not certified.
- 16:08At the same time, the bill authorizes the state bar to charge fees and I'm pretty sure
- 16:15they're going to be significant in the beginning while they establish a whole program.
- 16:21Remember the state bar is not authorized to use licensing fees to fund this program, so
- 16:29I expect those fees to be significant in the beginning.
- 16:34At the same time, it's interesting that the law provides or gives authority to the state
- 16:40bar to deny or revoke certification for any failure to meet or maintain certification
- 16:47standards.
- 16:48That's going to be interesting to see what criteria they're going to use to revoke or
- 16:54deny a certification to somebody, to an ADR provider or to a practitioner.
- 17:01And another point that I'm wondering how that's going to work is about solo practitioners
- 17:08and wondering how they're going to provide credible evidence that they're effectively
- 17:13handling complaints against themselves because as I mentioned, the certification program
- 17:20requires that the mediators and arbitrators most comply with the ethics standards and
- 17:28most provide a process to handle complaints against them.
- 17:34So let's see how that works with solo practitioners.
- 17:39What is next?
- 17:40Well, the state bar is going to create a working group that is going to involve all the key
- 17:44stakeholders and it's going to be finalizing the program probably on a launcher program
- 17:52in mid to late 2025.
- 17:57Section two to section eight basically are amendments to California arbitration law,
- 18:08specifically to consumer arbitration rules.
- 18:13So we believe it's important to define first the concept before we're getting to dive deep
- 18:20into what exactly those section two to eight provides.
- 18:27So Paul, could you please define for us consumer arbitration?
- 18:31Yes, of course, Anna.
- 18:34And hi, everybody.
- 18:36It's really great to be here.
- 18:37Thank you for participating.
- 18:40So one interesting thing about Senate Bill 940 is that it does not have in and of itself
- 18:46a definition of consumer arbitration.
- 18:49So when I was working on this, I thought, where am I going to find the definition of consumer
- 18:54arbitration?
- 18:55It seems to be a very important thing as you will see because even though we could spend
- 19:01a whole hour talking about section one, we've got these other seven sections to talk about.
- 19:07So where I went was the ethics standards for mutual arbitrators and the longer title of
- 19:14it is in contractual arbitration.
- 19:18And as Anna was referring to this earlier and showing you the different sections of
- 19:26it, what's interesting is that the ethics standards has the force of law in California.
- 19:33And when we get down to talking about the disclosures that are required in Senate Bill
- 19:39940, we're going to see a lot of overlap.
- 19:42And because we don't have enough time to go over everything, we'll try to breeze through
- 19:47it a little bit, but we did want to put it in the slides for you so that you can go back
- 19:51and refer to it if you ever needed to.
- 19:54So under standard 2D of the ethics standards, which has been around as Anna said since 2003
- 20:03and it was amended again in 2014 in some parts, consumer arbitration means an arbitration
- 20:10conducted under a pre-dispute arbitration provision contained in a contract that meets
- 20:15the criteria listed in paragraphs 1-3-3 below.
- 20:19So it's got to be with a consumer party, which we'll talk about in a second.
- 20:25That consumer party term is further defined.
- 20:30Number two, the contract was drafted by or on behalf of the non-consumer party.
- 20:36So maybe it's got this adhesion contract element to it.
- 20:40And number three, the consumer party was required to accept the arbitration provision in the
- 20:46contract.
- 20:48Some of us were participating in a program earlier last week with the principal drafter
- 20:57of this statute and he made reference to cell phone contracts, for example, where you sign
- 21:06off on that cell phone contract or that account with whatever big cell provider and you don't
- 21:13really realize it, but there's an arbitration provision in there that you've agreed to.
- 21:19We can go to the next slide and see about the definition of consumer party in the ethics
- 21:26standards.
- 21:27So ethics standard 2E, consumer party is a party to an arbitration agreement who in the
- 21:33context of that arbitration agreement is any of the following.
- 21:36And I'm not going to go through all of this, but you can get the idea.
- 21:40An individual who seeks or requires, including by lease, any goods or services primarily
- 21:46for personal family or household purposes.
- 21:50And then it goes on to talk about other examples as well.
- 21:54But one really interesting component to this is an employee or an applicant for employment
- 22:02in a dispute arising out of or relating to the employee's employment or the applicant's
- 22:08prospective employment that is subject to the arbitration agreement.
- 22:12So if you use the term consumer arbitration, it doesn't usually evoke the idea of an employment
- 22:19arbitration.
- 22:21And on top of everything else, it's not clear from Senate Bill 940, which definition they're
- 22:27going to use, but these are the definitions that are in the ethics standards that have
- 22:31been around for over 20 years.
- 22:35So now we'll continue on with section 2 and back to Anna.
- 22:39Thank you, Paul.
- 22:40Okay, so let's continue with section 2.
- 22:44So section 2 creates a new section of the civil code.
- 22:51And basically this new section specifies two new restrictions on consumer arbitration agreements.
- 23:00The first one, attention, all of you who draft consumer contracts, arbitration clause all
- 23:10over the country, you're doing business in California, I wanted to pay attention to this
- 23:17one because for now on, well, starting January 1st, 2025, a seller had not required a consumer
- 23:27to agree to arbitrate outside of California, a claim arising in California, and required
- 23:36the consumer to arbitrate on the claim under the substantive law of another state different
- 23:43than California.
- 23:45So that section applies to any contract entering to modify or spend it on after January 1st,
- 23:562025.
- 23:58So if any provision of a contract, a consumer contract violates that section, it's going
- 24:05to be avoidable by the consumer, and the matter shall be adjudicated in California, and California
- 24:12law shall govern the dispute on the consumer who is enforcing the rights under this section
- 24:22and not for reasonable attorney's fees and enforcing those rights.
- 24:26For the first process of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
- 24:33So it's interesting in this section that the claimant doesn't have to be domicile or have
- 24:43to have a residence in California.
- 24:46Any claim arising in California does the key, and can be the consumer cannot be required
- 24:54to arbitrate outside of California and under another substantive law that is different
- 25:00from California.
- 25:02So keep that in mind now when you're drafting your consumer contracts and arbitration clauses.
- 25:10Remember, this law is effective and it applies to any contract entering to modify or spend
- 25:18it on or after January 1st, 2025.
- 25:23Then we have section three.
- 25:26Section three provides that basically any, it provides, it adds another section to the
- 25:36civil code.
- 25:37It basically provides that a consumer must be given the option of taking a qualifying
- 25:43dispute to a small claims court instead of arbitration.
- 25:49If the amount in controversy is less than required by this small claims court.
- 25:57Currently, the small claims are, provides that any claiming controversy that is less
- 26:03than $12,500 is eligible for a small claims court.
- 26:10So the consumer now shall have that option to have the dispute adjudicated on and the
- 26:17small claims court instead of being an arbitration.
- 26:24So this section applies to a contract at the same time, just like the section two applies
- 26:30to a contract entering to modify or spend it on or after January 1st, 2025.
- 26:38It's interesting that this section doesn't specify who is required to give the consumer
- 26:46the option to proceed with small claims court.
- 26:48So I assume that the obligation will likely fall on the arbitration provider or the neutral,
- 26:55the arbitrator, depending on when the amount of damages at issue is disclosed.
- 27:02It's interesting because I arbitrate a lot of consumer cases.
- 27:08I remember sometimes having consumers wanted to stay in arbitration and the business wanted
- 27:16to send them to a small claims court because the amount in controversy.
- 27:22But so it was hard for the arbitrator for me to determine what was the amount in dispute
- 27:28because the claimant keep saying that the amount in dispute was over the $12,500 limit
- 27:35while the business were saying, well, it is a perfect, it's eligible for a small claims
- 27:41court for claims to your case to a small claims court.
- 27:47So that anyway.
- 27:49So Paul, what about the section?
- 27:51And that's the following section about disclosure results.
- 27:54Yeah, thank you.
- 27:56I'm going to cover sections four, five and six.
- 28:01Section four is the longest one, and it deals with the requirement of arbitrators making
- 28:08disclosures.
- 28:10And with regard to the disclosures, the language in Senate Bill 940 does not limit it to consumer
- 28:19arbitrations.
- 28:21So I think we have to assume that these disclosures would be required in any type of arbitration.
- 28:28I know that there was a question about whether these provisions applied international arbitration.
- 28:36There's a separate scheme for that.
- 28:39But again, Senate Bill 940 does not address that issue, doesn't say that it doesn't apply
- 28:46to international arbitrations.
- 28:50But in any event, let's dive into it.
- 28:52And we don't have time to go over every single item since I violated the rule against packing
- 28:58your PowerPoint slides.
- 29:00But I just wanted to make sure that you went away with a parting gift.
- 29:04And that gift is to have someplace that you could go to reference all of these disclosure
- 29:10rules, at least in summary.
- 29:13So section 1281.9a, in any arbitration pursuant to an arbitration agreement, and notice again,
- 29:23it's not limited, when a person is to serve as a neutral arbitrator, the proposed neutral
- 29:29arbitrator shall disclose all matters that could cause a person aware of the facts to
- 29:36reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed neutral arbitrator would be able to be impartial.
- 29:47So the standard there is reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed neutral arbitrator
- 29:55would be able to be impartial.
- 29:57And so we have these different sections.
- 29:59But the thing of it is, nobody went in and looked at all these sections because there's
- 30:05a lot of overlap.
- 30:07And some of the sections cover the same type of disclosure and require the arbitrator to
- 30:14go back, say, two years.
- 30:17Others require the arbitrator to go back five years when we're talking about prior conduct.
- 30:24So this particular list on this slide is what's listed in section 170.1 for disqualification
- 30:34of a judge.
- 30:36And we'll focus a little bit more on some of the others, like the ethics standard, so
- 30:42we can advance this slide and go to the next one.
- 30:52I want to point out here that one provision in section 170.1 for disqualification of a
- 31:01judge is interesting because we don't really see that come out in some of the other areas.
- 31:12And that is bias or prejudice toward a lawyer in the proceeding, maybe grounds for disqualification.
- 31:18So those of you out there who are arbitrators, keep in mind in terms of your demeanor and
- 31:28keep in mind in terms of your overall conduct and the arbitration that to do everything
- 31:37you possibly can to avoid having a lawyer feel like you are becoming biased or prejudiced
- 31:46against that lawyer.
- 31:49We can go to the next slide.
- 31:53So the next set of rules that have to be disclosed or have to be complied with is any
- 32:00matters required to be disclosed by the ethics standards for neutral arbitrators, which you've
- 32:05been hearing about, brought it up initially.
- 32:08And I just put on this slide the language that introduces the ethics standards as they've
- 32:15been published by the Judicial Council.
- 32:19And to also point out that there's a separate set of amendments that you can get online that
- 32:27show what amendments took place effective July 1, 2014.
- 32:33Next slide.
- 32:37So this is one that will go over really quickly.
- 32:41And there's a lot of overlap with what we just saw with the provision that's applicable
- 32:48to disqualification of judges.
- 32:51So number one, you have to disclose whether the arbitrator or family member is a party,
- 32:56the spouse of the party, or officer, director, or trustee of a party.
- 33:03There could be a situation where someone in the arbitrator's family might be serving as
- 33:08a director of some company that comes and appears before the arbitrator.
- 33:12The arbitrator has no knowledge of that.
- 33:16But nevertheless, it has to be disclosed.
- 33:18And the arbitrator, as we will see, has to do a reasonable investigation.
- 33:23If the arbitrator doesn't know about it, has done a reasonable investigation, it turns
- 33:28out some family member does have some kind of a relationship here.
- 33:33Then the argument that's going to be made by the party that's opposing a vacator proceeding
- 33:39is that the arbitrator didn't know.
- 33:41And the arbitrator can't disclose what the arbitrator doesn't know.
- 33:46The arbitrator family member has a family relationship with a lawyer in the arbitration.
- 33:55And that also includes whether or not the arbitrator or family member was associated
- 34:02in the practice of law with a lawyer that's appearing in the arbitration within the past
- 34:07two years.
- 34:11Number three, arbitrator or a family member of the arbitrator has or has had, with no
- 34:17time limit, by the way, a significant personal relationship with a party or a lawyer for
- 34:23a party.
- 34:25And the definition of significant personal relationship is one where it just merely
- 34:30says includes a close personal friendship.
- 34:36A lawyer for a party means the lawyer hired to represent a party in the arbitration and
- 34:42a lawyer or law firm currently associated in the practice of law with the lawyer hired
- 34:47to represent a party in the arbitration.
- 34:50That when you really start thinking about that, it can really make your head explode,
- 34:54especially if lawyers are moving around from firms to firms.
- 35:00Number four, service as an arbitrator for a party or a lawyer for a party in the arbitration
- 35:06within the past five years.
- 35:09And if that is the case, the arbitrator is supposed to disclose the names of the parties,
- 35:16the name of the attorney representing the party in the current arbitration who was involved
- 35:20in the pending case, who was involved in the prior case, or whose current associate is
- 35:26involved in the pending case or was involved in the prior case.
- 35:30And interestingly, the results of each prior case arbitrated to conclusion, including the
- 35:35date of the arbitration award, identification of the prevailing party, the amount of monetary
- 35:41damages awarded, if any, and the names of the parties attorneys.
- 35:45And so obviously having to disclose this in an existing new case really trumps arbitration
- 35:54confidentiality.
- 35:57And then number five, compensated service as other dispute resolution neutral, such as
- 36:03a mediator within the prior two years.
- 36:06Next slide.
- 36:09I'm not going to go over all of these because of the limited amount of time we have, but
- 36:17I just want to point out, number 15, that there's a catch all here.
- 36:23Any other matter that might cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain
- 36:29a doubt that the arbitrator would be able to be impartial, bias or prejudice toward a party
- 36:36lawyer or a law firm, or otherwise leads the arbitrator to believe that is or her disqualification
- 36:41would further the interest of justice.
- 36:44Everybody's going to ask, how do we know whether or not there might be something that would
- 36:48cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain a doubt?
- 36:52And that's a really good question.
- 36:55Probably a judge or an appellate panel is going to end up deciding that in a scenario
- 37:01where the award of the arbitrator is attacked in a vacancy proceeding.
- 37:09Next slide.
- 37:13Now we're back into the provisions of Senate Bill 940 itself.
- 37:20So recall A1 was all of the disclosures that judges are required to make that could result
- 37:28in a disqualification of a judge.
- 37:30We just went over A2, which are the disclosures that are required in Section 7 of the ethics
- 37:37standards for neutral arbitrators.
- 37:39And now these sections that we're going to go over now are actually in the new statute.
- 37:44And as you can see, there's a lot of overlap.
- 37:47So in 1281.9 A3, the names of the parties to all prior or pending non-collective bargaining
- 37:55cases in which the proposed neutral arbitrator served or is serving as a party arbitrator
- 38:03for a party to the arbitration proceeding or for a lawyer for a party.
- 38:08So that would be a scenario where a party has the right to appoint an arbitrator.
- 38:16And then again, we have to make all of these disclosures that I just indicated before regarding
- 38:24the award and the names of the parties and the amount awarded, again, with defeats confidentiality,
- 38:33although this provision here to try to preserve confidentiality says it shall be sufficient
- 38:39to give the name of any party who is not a party to the pending arbitration as just claim
- 38:44it or respond it.
- 38:45So not to actually disclose the name of the other parties in the pending or prior arbitration.
- 38:55Some section A4 talks about the names of the parties to all prior or pending non-collective
- 39:00bargaining cases involving a part of the arbitration or lawyer for a party for which the proposed
- 39:06neutral arbitrator served or is serving as a neutral arbitrator, which is the most common
- 39:13scenario.
- 39:14So in almost all of my cases as an arbitrator, for example, I'm serving as a neutral arbitrator
- 39:20that was selected by the parties or selected as a part of the selection process of the
- 39:28parties.
- 39:29I wasn't appointed by one party, but in drafting this statute, the author thought it was significant
- 39:36to separate these out.
- 39:38And yet the requirements are pretty much identical.
- 39:43In subsection A5, any attorney-client relationship the proposed neutral arbitrator has or had
- 39:50with a party or lawyer for a party to the arbitration proceeding.
- 39:55Another example of a provision, a disclosure provision that doesn't seem to have any time
- 40:00limitation.
- 40:03Subsection A6, any professional or significant personal relationship, the proposed neutral
- 40:08arbitrator or their spouse or minor child living in the household has or has had with
- 40:14any party to the arbitration or lawyer for a party.
- 40:18In A7, in a consumer arbitration case, this is where we get into the provision regarding
- 40:25solicitations.
- 40:26And we'll talk about in the next slide what that is.
- 40:30But in a consumer arbitration case, any solicitation made after January 1, 2025, when the statute
- 40:37becomes effective, and within the last two years, by or at the direction of the private
- 40:43arbitration company to a party or lawyer for a party to the consumer arbitration.
- 40:50And we're going to learn about what those solicitations, what constitutes a solicitation
- 40:56in a moment.
- 40:58And 1281.9b says subject only to the disclosure requirements of law, the proposed neutral arbitrator
- 41:06shall disclose all matters required to be disclosed pursuant to this section to all
- 41:11parties in writing within 10 calendar days of service of notice of the proposed.
- 41:17And go to the next one.
- 41:31Paul, you were frozen for a little bit.
- 41:37Oh, OK.
- 41:40I was focusing really on A7.
- 41:43Did everybody get to hear that one?
- 41:45I think so.
- 41:46OK, so yeah, we can go to the next slide.
- 41:48I just want to be mindful of the time and run through the next one really quickly.
- 41:55So for purposes of this section, lawyer for a party includes any lawyer or law firm currently
- 42:02associated in the practice of law with the lawyer hired to represent a party.
- 42:07And prior cases means non-collective bargaining cases in which an arbitration award was rendered
- 42:13within five years prior to the date of the proposed nomination.
- 42:16So the look back is five years.
- 42:19And let's talk about in the next minute or two solicitation.
- 42:26It includes either of the following, private presentations made by a party, I'm sorry,
- 42:33made to a party or lawyer for a party by the private arbitration company or the arbitrator,
- 42:41oral or written discussions, meetings or negotiations to designate the private arbitration
- 42:47company or the arbitrator as the arbitration provider or arbitrator for a party in specific
- 42:53contracts.
- 42:55And then we get subparagraph B, which says what solicitation does not include.
- 43:03Solicitation does not include any advertising directed to the general public communications,
- 43:09indicating a general willingness to serve as an arbitrator, private arbitration company,
- 43:15is made by the private arbitration company or the arbitrator at a program or seminar
- 43:20held open to the public.
- 43:23I hope this would be considered to be open to the public.
- 43:28Responding to inquiries regarding the arbitration provider's cost, rules, procedures or standards.
- 43:34Next slide.
- 43:37And now we have the prohibition in section five.
- 43:40Regarding the penance of the consumer arbitration, a solicitation shall not be made of a party
- 43:46to the arbitration or of a lawyer for a party to the arbitration.
- 43:51So for purposes of this section, lawyer of a party and solicitation is the same meaning
- 43:56we just discussed.
- 44:00And this is the absolute prohibition.
- 44:04So if you're an arbitrator that's presiding over consumer arbitrations, you can't make
- 44:11any solicitations not only to the parties, but to a lawyer for a party, which would also
- 44:18include that law for that the party's a part of or works for.
- 44:23I'm sorry, that the lawyer works for or is a part of.
- 44:28Next slide.
- 44:31And section six, and I'm just going to go over this really quickly because it has to
- 44:35do with the mechanics.
- 44:37Essentially, this is sort of the preview to the fact that now in California, at least
- 44:43with respect to cases that to which California arbitration Act applies, we now as arbitrators
- 44:54have the right to issue subpoenas or the organization can issue subpoenas for the attendance of
- 45:03witnesses at depositions for purpose of discovery and subpoena uses to come to bring document
- 45:10documents and electronically stored information and other evidence.
- 45:15And so Anna is going to get into the other the main discovery provision, but this is
- 45:20the provision that talks about the mechanics of subpoenas, which is very much like a situation
- 45:27in certain certain courts where the subpoena would be issued in blank and it's going to
- 45:32be filled out by the party serving the subpoena.
- 45:37And it needs to be served and enforced in accordance with chapter two commencing with
- 45:41section 1985 of Title III, Part four of this code.
- 45:46So let's move on to the discovery provisions and Anna, back to you.
- 45:52Thank you, Paul.
- 45:54Okay.
- 45:55So basically, section six to eight are basically expanding the discovery rights and arbitration
- 46:01on specifically section seven provides that the positions may be taken and discovery,
- 46:13and arbitration proceeding as if the subject matter, the arbitration were pending before
- 46:19a superior court for this state in a civil action.
- 46:23So basically is expanding all the discovery rights and arbitration is in to my opinion
- 46:32is basically transforming arbitration into litigation.
- 46:38Now parties can request and they're going to have all the discovery rights that they
- 46:45have and in a superior court case in a civil action.
- 46:51And it's basically section seven is emphasizing that the arbitrator have the power to determine
- 46:58the merits of the arbitration to enforce the rights, the remedies, the procedures, the
- 47:02duties, the abilities and obligations of discovery.
- 47:05Anna at the same time is emphasizing that it has the power to enforce on any discovery
- 47:16request.
- 47:17And interestingly, depots, they need to be taken, they cannot be taken unless lead to
- 47:27do so is first granted by the arbitrator or arbitrators.
- 47:31So that's kind of the only limitation that the position for discovery shall not be taken
- 47:38unless lead to do so is first granted by the arbitrator or arbitrators.
- 47:45Section eight is basically repealing section of the code of civil procedure.
- 47:53This previous section of the code of civil procedure provides that arbitration of ground
- 48:06pool debt or personally in cases, the parties of all the provisions of the discovery act
- 48:16were deemed to be incorporated into every agreement to arbitrate.
- 48:22And now by repealing that section, that means that full rights under the discovery act are
- 48:30then incorporated into every arbitration agreement.
- 48:34If the subject matter of the arbitration were pending before a superior court, oh, this
- 48:39is state in a civil action other than a limited civil case.
- 48:44I know you got more to cover, but I just wanted to make one practice point about the whole
- 48:50idea of now under California law, we have the authority as arbitrators and counsel can
- 48:58request subpoenas to enforce deposition attendance and the production of documents and electronically
- 49:07sort of information.
- 49:09And that is that this differs tremendously from the law under the Federal Arbitration
- 49:17Act because the Federal Arbitration Act, there's night circuit case law, for example, that
- 49:27expressly states that arbitrators do not have the authority to issue subpoenas to compel
- 49:34third parties were not signatories to an arbitration agreement to come to a discovery deposition
- 49:42or to produce documents.
- 49:45And so it's really sort of beyond the scope of talking about this statutory provision,
- 49:50but one of the determinations in any arbitration is going to be, does this provision now open
- 49:59the door, does it apply, or will it be deemed by the federal courts to conflict with their
- 50:06rulings under the Federal Arbitration Act?
- 50:08And the Federal Arbitration Act's applicability is pretty broad, much broader in many cases
- 50:17than maybe an attorney might think, but I don't want to take divert too much time on
- 50:22that point.
- 50:23That's a whole nother program that maybe we'll do sometime in the future.
- 50:27So Anna, back to you.
- 50:29Sure.
- 50:30So my recommendation to all of you arbitrators and litigators representing clients in an
- 50:38arbitration is that effective January 1st, 2025, when you have your preliminary hearing
- 50:47with the arbitrator, hopefully you can discuss with your arbitrator all the anticipated discovery
- 50:54issues, all the depots, third parties' opinion procedures, and just memorize that discussion
- 51:01in an arbitration case management order.
- 51:06At the same time, I believe that these sections 6-8, as I mentioned, are just going to be
- 51:17transforming arbitration into litigation, basically allowing broader discovery rights
- 51:26because on one of the benefits and one of the advantages of arbitration, it was supposed
- 51:34to be more efficient than litigation because it's usually less expensive and quicker than
- 51:41litigation because there's not so much discovery.
- 51:45But these sections 2-6 are basically allowing full discovery rights and arbitration, with
- 51:56the exception that the parties wanted to take any depots, they will have to ask for leave
- 52:06from the arbitrator.
- 52:09Section 9 provides that all the provisions of the Act are severable.
- 52:15So if any other provision is held invalid, that doesn't affect other provisions or applications
- 52:22that can be given without the invalid provision.
- 52:27I want to quickly just mention a little bit about the legislative background of SB 940.
- 52:35Well, the law author is Senator Tom Umberg.
- 52:40He's the chair of the Senate's judiciary committee.
- 52:44He provided an interview last week and he confirmed that this law is a reaction to the
- 52:53Tom Giardi scandal for all of you that don't know.
- 53:00Tom Giardi was a famous personal injury lawyer and he was accused of stealing all the money
- 53:10from their clients, from his clients, and it was an article written about the whole incident
- 53:20on that, but I believe unfairly involved mediators and arbitrators when the neutral that were
- 53:32involved in working with Tom Giardi were not serving as mediators and arbitrators.
- 53:39They were serving as special masters or court appointing neutrals.
- 53:46I believe that was unfair because the neutrals, no even special masters, they never had access
- 53:53to an attorney trust account.
- 53:57It was later found out that the Tom Giardi was basically misusing the funds from his
- 54:07clients, one of those funds were in his trust account, and no mediator, no arbitrator, no
- 54:12small, no a court appointing neutral or special master has any access to an attorney trust
- 54:22account.
- 54:24But we ended up with the certification program and with all these changes to California arbitration.
- 54:33I don't know, I'm wondering how this is really addressing the issue that they were trying
- 54:40to address.
- 54:41They misused funds by the attorney on the center, Tom Hamburg, he mentioned in regard to the
- 54:53changes to the arbitration law that his intent was to better even the playing field for consumers,
- 55:02improving consumer awareness and public protection.
- 55:08With that, I think so, let's take some questions.
- 55:14Let me just stop sharing and that way we can see the questions.
- 55:21So let's see.
- 55:22Paul, could you see the questions too?
- 55:25Yes.
- 55:26Okay, good.
- 55:27So perfect.
- 55:28We have five more minutes.
- 55:31So let's see.
- 55:33Under the new 1283.05, it appears that in all arbitrations, there's unlimited written
- 55:41discovery.
- 55:42Thus, that provision replays the rules of jams relating to discovery.
- 55:50So Paul, I want to hear what you think.
- 55:54But I believe the law, obviously, all the ADR providers, they're going to be able to
- 56:01have to modify the rules to make them consistent and in compliance with this new law that is
- 56:10effective January 1st, 2025.
- 56:13Oh, what do you think?
- 56:16Well, there's a landmark decision that dates back to the early 2000s called Armanderas by
- 56:22the California Supreme Court, which dealt with an employment arbitration.
- 56:29But in that case, the Supreme Court of California said that in order for an employment arbitration
- 56:37provision or agreement to be fair, it had to allow for discovery.
- 56:42And so I think the reason why this found its way into this Senate Bill 940 is that the
- 56:51idea was, again, with the focus on consumer arbitrations, which is often, as I indicated
- 56:56earlier, deemed to include employee employment arbitrations, the idea that the counsel for
- 57:05the employees would be able to do the discovery that's needed to be done.
- 57:10I have a slightly different view of this based on my experience because most of my arbitrations
- 57:17are large, complex cases.
- 57:20And the lawyers actually insist on discovery.
- 57:25And in cases that I've been on where I'm a member of a panel, but I'm not the chair
- 57:31of the panel, for example.
- 57:33And there's a panel chair who's very, very much against discovery.
- 57:39I really worry that the lawyers get so upset about it that they will tell their clients,
- 57:44hey, you should never agree to arbitration.
- 57:47So there's certainly a happy medium, but at least the arbitrator's job is to manage
- 57:52the case a little bit more closely than maybe a judge can and only allow discovery that's
- 58:00reasonable.
- 58:01So the arbitrator will always put some reasonable limits on discovery.
- 58:05But interestingly, this statute does appear broad and allows for any type of discovery
- 58:12that you can do in court.
- 58:13So I agree with Anna that I don't think that the providers will be able to essentially
- 58:22invalidate that statute by limiting discovery even further.
- 58:28So they had to be consistent and change the rules to make it consistent and compliance
- 58:33with SB 940, right?
- 58:35Yeah.
- 58:36Okay.
- 58:37So next question, I have a certificate of completion in basic mediation training from
- 58:42Los Angeles County Bar Association and an uncurrently and full of partial compliance with
- 58:48the new requirements of SB 940.
- 58:51Do I need to recertify under the coursework?
- 58:55Yeah, the certification provided in SB 940 is totally different from any other certification
- 59:03that you may have obtained from other organizations.
- 59:08So but the good news, as I mentioned, is the certification is voluntary.
- 59:15You don't have to.
- 59:16Because you want to be certified by the state bar.
- 59:21Paul, you want to add something?
- 59:23Yeah.
- 59:24I mean, the thing of it is, is that when I first became aware of this Senate Bill 940
- 59:30and the certification, I was like, oh, how many hours are they going to make us take
- 59:33a training in?
- 59:36Are we all going to have to take some new training where we've already had the training?
- 59:39Is there going to be anybody grandfathered in?
- 59:42And the thing of it is, is now we discover that the certification really doesn't have
- 59:45anything to do with the quality or training of the arbitrator or mediator at all.
- 59:51It has to do with compliance with the applicable ethical and disclosure rules, really.
- 1:00:00And the complaint processes Anna explained earlier.
- 1:00:03So I think it's not a question of recertifying because there never was a certification requirement
- 1:00:10like this before.
- 1:00:12It's a question of whatever our training in the background or however many years we've
- 1:00:16been acting as arbitrator or mediator, we're going to have to comply with the certification
- 1:00:23if we want to be able to say that we're certified.
- 1:00:25And it has to really do with the procedures and the compliance with the applicable ethical
- 1:00:31standards that Anna talked about.
- 1:00:34I have a question for you.
- 1:00:36Does any of the grounds for disqualifications of an arbitrator relate directly to allegations
- 1:00:41to disqualifications of a mediator?
- 1:00:46Oh, on this one.
- 1:00:50No.
- 1:00:51I mean, the provisions that we talked about are very clear with regard to applying to arbitrators.
- 1:01:02Mediators remember not making any kind of a decision.
- 1:01:06Mediators facilitating and Anna gave the link earlier in the slides to the code applicable
- 1:01:17to mediators that the certification will require compliance with.
- 1:01:23There's a little bit of overlap.
- 1:01:25For example, in terms of disclosing prior, agreeing prior relationships, you know, prior
- 1:01:35conduct with respect to the parties or the lawyers.
- 1:01:39And you do have to be neutral as a mediator, but I don't believe that the disclosures are
- 1:01:44as extensive and wide ranging as they are for arbitrators.
- 1:01:49And there's no award to invalidate or to get vacated.
- 1:01:55Now will someone try to say, hey, there was a biased mediator, so I should be able to
- 1:01:59undo the settlement agreement?
- 1:02:02The statute does not address that.
- 1:02:06Next question.
- 1:02:07They may know how access to the accounts, but they can give permission for him to access
- 1:02:14the accounts.
- 1:02:15No.
- 1:02:16I guess they're referring to what I was, is flaning that happened with Tom Giardari.
- 1:02:24As a mediator, as an arbitrator, in my experience, I have never had access to a trust account,
- 1:02:34one of the lawyers in my case.
- 1:02:36So I have a hard time believing that neutral will have access to the attorney trust account.
- 1:02:43Paul, what do you think?
- 1:02:47I mean, I think the scenario where there is a neutral person that is appointed by a court
- 1:02:57to oversee a lawyer's access to an account, I mean, that may certainly occur down the
- 1:03:06road, but that's definitely not anything that an arbitrator or mediator would typically
- 1:03:13do as part of those duties.
- 1:03:17Are the disclosures you mentioned for arbitrators applied to those who only mediate?
- 1:03:23Well, I think under the statute, it's specifically all those disclosures we're talking about
- 1:03:31apply to arbitrators.
- 1:03:34There aren't any disclosures that apply to mediators except through the certification
- 1:03:40process where the mediator would have to certify that they're in compliance with the
- 1:03:46code applicable to mediators, which we really didn't go over in any kind of a detail, didn't
- 1:03:51have time to.
- 1:03:55So under current law, a state-barred rule 2.3, inactive licensees cannot be private arbitrators
- 1:04:04or mediators, does a new business and profession 61.73 abrogate a state-barred rule 2.3?
- 1:04:20Well, the new business and professionals code creates this certification process for ADR
- 1:04:29providers and neutrals, and that applies to lawyers and non-lawyers.
- 1:04:36So I guess you can think about an inactive licensee as a non-lawyer, right, Paul?
- 1:04:45You know, that's a really, really interesting question that I think an argument can be
- 1:04:51made for that, but it's not really clear to me how the state-bar will view this.
- 1:05:00An inactive licensee is still a lawyer even though they're not licensed to practice law
- 1:05:07because they're inactive.
- 1:05:09So maybe that was the original reason for the rule of the state-bar, and if the state-bar
- 1:05:16really views that rule as being contradictory or unclear now because of the statute and the
- 1:05:25certification process for non-lawyers, then maybe the state-bar will change that rule.
- 1:05:29But in the meantime, there's nothing in the statute that abrogates that rule.
- 1:05:37Expressly, by the way, is what I mean to say, is that the statute doesn't say that it abrogates
- 1:05:42the rule.
- 1:05:43I think you can assume that it's been abrogated.
- 1:05:48So how about the provision that the mediators serve as a resolution neutral with the prior
- 1:05:55two years?
- 1:05:57Is this now a disclosure for mediators?
- 1:06:01Well, when we were going over it, it was something that was in the ethics standards and in the
- 1:06:07statute.
- 1:06:08So it's a disclosure for the arbitrator to make.
- 1:06:14As a mediator, it would be something that when I act as a mediator, I do disclose whether
- 1:06:21or not the parties or the attorneys have appeared before me.
- 1:06:25And the California Rules of Court provide that as a mediator, you have to disclose any
- 1:06:32potential conflicts, any potential reasons.
- 1:06:39I will disclose voluntarily under the California Rules of Court.
- 1:06:46Let's see.
- 1:06:50What did you expect will happen when there is conflicting language in the arbitration
- 1:06:54contracts and in the new bill?
- 1:06:57Well, let's see what's going to happen, but that's what I believe is important for everyone
- 1:07:05to be aware of this new law.
- 1:07:11And it's going to take effect in a few weeks, January 1st, 2025, and it will be applicable
- 1:07:20to any contract, enter, extend, or modify after that date.
- 1:07:28So that is going to be interesting to see how everything is going to work.
- 1:07:36I don't think there was enough time for everyone to get ready.
- 1:07:39And I can imagine that a lot of people still don't know anything about this.
- 1:07:44So let's see.
- 1:07:46I mean, my comment on that would be that I think, unless we're talking about consumer
- 1:07:52arbitrations where we have a potential adhesion contract, as we discussed, how do you define
- 1:07:59a consumer arbitration?
- 1:08:01But if it's a commercial arbitration and there's been actual negotiation over the arbitration
- 1:08:07provision, and the parties decide notwithstanding the right to do discovery in Senate Bill 940,
- 1:08:16and assuming that the California Arbitration Act applies, then my opinion is that parties
- 1:08:28can always decide to agree to a different procedure or to discovery limitations, unless
- 1:08:39the statute said that by having some kind of a provision in there, it would invalidate
- 1:08:46the whole arbitration agreement or that the provision would be invalid, such as with the
- 1:08:53venue provision.
- 1:08:54The venue provision is not something that is waivable.
- 1:08:57Wouldn't you say, Ana?
- 1:08:59Yes, I believe so.
- 1:09:01The arbitration clause provides that the location of the venue for the arbitration is in another
- 1:09:10state.
- 1:09:11And that will be invalid.
- 1:09:14So of the applicable law is the law of another state.
- 1:09:19That will be invalid too.
- 1:09:21But the legislature wasn't concerned about commercial parties to an arbitration agreement
- 1:09:27agreeing to some other venue outside of California?
- 1:09:30Yes.
- 1:09:33It seems like the main intent of these changes were consumer arbitration and protect the consumer
- 1:09:42or in some way because in consumer arbitration, the consumer just agreed to the arbitration
- 1:09:54provision by using the service.
- 1:09:58So we have another interesting question, and I think you mentioned something about it.
- 1:10:04To what extent does SB 940 apply to international arbitrations?
- 1:10:12It doesn't say whether it does or it doesn't.
- 1:10:18This came up in another presentation that Ana and I did.
- 1:10:23And I know that one of the—it was a presentation that we gave to a group of experienced neutrals,
- 1:10:32most of whom were arbitrators.
- 1:10:33And I know that during that presentation, it was pointed out that there are separate provisions
- 1:10:39applicable to international arbitration that were originally passed to make California a
- 1:10:45more attractive seat for international arbitration.
- 1:10:49So the feeling during that presentation was that some of the people that were involved
- 1:10:56in that were saying that that would apply.
- 1:11:00But in my view, unless Senate Bill 940 specifically excludes some type of arbitration, say international
- 1:11:10arbitration, my default would be that I would comply with it.
- 1:11:18Okay.
- 1:11:21Another question is, will the state bar provide arbitration certification?
- 1:11:30Well the state bar will provide certification to arbitrators, mediators, ADR providers.
- 1:11:42And so arbitration, yes, it will be included in there.
- 1:11:49That's the same question.
- 1:11:50Do international contracts now have to insert California law if one of the parties is based
- 1:11:57in California?
- 1:11:59I think if it's a consumer arbitration, the answer might very well be yes.
- 1:12:04Well, as I mentioned, the law is very specific about if the claim arises in California.
- 1:12:12The claimant doesn't have to have a residence or a domicile in California.
- 1:12:18So it's not the party's location is the claim arises in California.
- 1:12:24It will have to be in consumer arbitration.
- 1:12:29The arbitration will have to take place in California and the applicable law will be
- 1:12:34California law.
- 1:12:37So next question, is there a contact for volunteering to be part of the state bar committee working
- 1:12:44on the certification process?
- 1:12:45You know what, I'm trying to figure that out myself.
- 1:12:50And I guess the state bar may probably has something on the website.
- 1:12:59I was planning to check.
- 1:13:01So let's check the website to see if they have something.
- 1:13:06Do you have any information about the working group?
- 1:13:11The only thing I could suggest is that the organization that exists on behalf of the
- 1:13:18dispute resolution community that keeps track of all the legislation and that that employs
- 1:13:24a lobbyist to comment on legislation affecting dispute resolution is the California dispute
- 1:13:31resolution council.
- 1:13:33I previously served on the board for a number of years before the pandemic came along.
- 1:13:39And they were very much involved in commenting during the development of Senate Bill 940.
- 1:13:47And so contacting officers or board members of that organization, the California dispute
- 1:13:53resolution council, they might be able to answer that.
- 1:13:57A last question.
- 1:14:00How do you think this new law affects online terms and conditions?
- 1:14:08It seems to me that with respect to, I mean, one of the reasons why arbitration has exploded
- 1:14:14is because of the terms of use of just about every website and application there is.
- 1:14:22And I serve as an arbitrator in lots of those.
- 1:14:26And one of the first things I have to try to figure out is, is this a consumer arbitration?
- 1:14:32And I just had that come up like a week ago in a preliminary hearing.
- 1:14:37And it was a situation where you have lots of different situations with terms of use
- 1:14:42and terms of conditions of online contracts where sometimes it will say the arbitrations
- 1:14:50will be under the consumer rules of whatever organization, regardless of whether the person
- 1:14:56is actually acting in their capacity as a consumer.
- 1:14:59It could be a business, for example, that a commercial business that has a dispute with
- 1:15:05a commercial service provider.
- 1:15:13So the answer is I think it will.
- 1:15:15And certainly if these agreements are applicable to consumers, they're going to have to comply
- 1:15:20with the provisions that Anna talked about.
- 1:15:24So I just want to thank everyone for joining us today.
- 1:15:29I hope you hopefully you learn all the key aspects of this new law.
- 1:15:38And if you have any questions, feel free to reach out to Paul or to me.
- 1:15:44Here's our contact information, our emails on LinkedIn.
- 1:15:52You can find me on LinkedIn too on Assemble.
- 1:15:55Here's our phone numbers.
- 1:15:57If you have any questions, feel free to reach out.
- 1:16:01We'll be happy to answer any questions you may have.
- 1:16:06And thank you everyone for joining us.
- 1:16:08Thank you.
- 1:16:09It was really a pleasure.
- 1:16:10Thanks for coming out.
- 1:16:11Thank you.
- 1:16:12You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:16:15Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.