Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 444. How to Intermittent Fast to IMPROVE Thyroid Function and Lose Weight
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where I'm all about helping you lose that stubborn weight that won't come off no matter what you do. Get off your couch at 2 p.m. and get through your day with energy and stop counting the hairs that come out of your head.
- 0:16I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and I'm here to help you get optimized with your thyroid and your hormones. It's all part of living our mantra, better thyroid, better hormones equals a better life. So let's get you back to being the badass human that you're meant to be. Let's approach it from a thyroid and hormone optimization standpoint.
- 0:38Between myself and my guests, you will be loaded down with information to take control of your health and get back to being you. So let's get started.
- 0:50You know, there's so much talk about fasting and hypothyroidism. So I wanted to dive into that and actually give you a focused answer as to whether or not fasting is actually good with hypothyroidism or Hashimoto's. Now, we did another podcast on fasting. We're going to link to that in the show notes. I'm going to suggest that you go back and listen to that podcast first. Okay.
- 1:15That's the big overview, pros, cons, everything that fasting does. And you'll hear me repeat some things on this episode as well. But that's kind of your starting point with fasting. Now we're going to hyper focus on fasting and thyroid disease. So you have hypothyroidism, you have Hashimoto's. You're like, what should I do? Should I fast? Should I not fast? There's so much information out there. It gets so freaking confusing. Okay, well, we have to break that down.
- 1:43So first of all, we do know that there are many different kinds of fasting. I mean, even if you go 12 hours without eating, you're doing a fast. You are not eating for 12 hours. That's fasting.
- 1:58Now, there are some benefits that come with a 12-hour eating window. Things like rest and digest, letting your digestive system rest, letting your pancreas get a break to stop pumping out insulin, to deal with your glucose from the food that you're eating. But you really don't get that repair mechanism until you hit right around the 14-hour mark. So at the 14-hour mark, this is where autophagy starts to kick in. And autophagy is...
- 2:27like a spring cleaning of your cells. You have these dead zombie cells that just, they don't know what to do. They should be shedding. They should be turning over. They should be clearing out of your body, but they just kind of wander around like the walking dead and just wreak havoc and take up space. And then they bite another cell. That cell turns into a zombie. And so you can have a bunch of zombie cells running around your body.
- 2:51And these zombie cells can potentially turn into cancer. I mean, we have a boatload of cancer cells in our body, but these zombie cells, they don't help us. So we want to clear them out. Autophagy is the clearing out of these dead zombie cells. So obviously we want to clean house every so often.
- 3:09Now, autophagy can be achieved or triggered by any activity that stresses the cell. So this is why fasting is a stressor, because it actually puts a stress on your body and it puts a stress on the cell itself. And what happens when we fast and we essentially deprive our body of any kind of nutrients is
- 3:33your cells go into survival mode and they repurpose cell components into fuel. So when that happens, your body kicks into high gear and starts cleaning. Now we can do exercise that can damage the cell, triggering autophagy, caloric restriction. Now you don't want to do this too long, too often. I'm talking about, let's say one day you eat less, you're at a
- 4:00800 calories, 900 calories, severe caloric restriction, but then the next day you bring it back up. So you don't stay there forever and damage your metabolism. You come out of that calorie restriction. A ketogenic diet. That also triggers autophagy when the body shifts over to burning fat instead of glucose for fuel. So there's a boatload of other things that you can do to trigger autophagy, jumping in cold plunges.
- 4:29leafy green vegetables, turmeric. I mean, there's many different things, but really fasting is the most studied and the most impactful component to triggering autophagy.
- 4:45Now, when it comes to weight loss and fasting, and I promise I'm tying this into thyroid, but of course, weight loss and the inability to lose weight, I hear you all. This is one of your main symptoms of hypothyroidism. That fatigue and hair loss, top three, top three. But weight loss is so frustrating when you're doing all the things. And it's really frustrating when you're fasting because
- 5:09and you're not able to trigger that weight loss. Well, that absolutely points back to, is your thyroid optimized? Because you have to start there or else you're gonna be doing this fasting thing and you're just gonna get really frustrated because it's not gonna work. Now, it will still be working at the cell level. Just because you have hypothyroidism doesn't mean that you're not going to get the benefits of autophagy and zombie cell cleaning. Right.
- 5:34from fasting, but you're probably not gonna see the weight loss benefits from fasting. And you might not even see the blood sugar control and the cell repair from fasting because when you're in that hypothyroid state and you're not optimized and you're super low and slow functioning,
- 5:50your whole body has trouble balancing. So when your body's in that low and slow state, blood sugar control can still be off. The thyroid gland has a direct impact on glucose control and insulin regulation. So when that is off, it doesn't matter what else you do, what other lifestyle components you do, eating, exercise, nutrition, lifestyle, fasting, not gonna work because you're not focused on your thyroid and optimizing your thyroid.
- 6:19Other benefits of fasting, like I said, I'm kind of doing this high level overview, but blood sugar control, we mentioned that, heart health, cell repair, we mentioned that, that's tied into autophagy, gene expression. So fasting can actually cause changes in genes and the molecules related to longevity and disease prevention.
- 6:40So this is why we are fasting for two, three, five, seven days, because we know that by doing that, even once a year has been proven to lower your risk of cancer because it shuts off those genes that turn on that can trigger cell death and cell replication as in cancer cell replication. Now, let's tie this with hypothyroidism.
- 7:10So you have hypothyroidism, whether you're optimized or not, doesn't matter. We're just doing the broad overview of hypothyroidism. I already said you probably should get optimized because otherwise you're not going to see the benefits. But when we look at the thyroid gland itself, we know in that hypothyroid state, either A,
- 7:27You have Hashimoto's. It's attacking your thyroid. Your thyroid can no longer produce T4 and T3 in adequate amounts. And it's also having trouble, most likely, converting T4 to T3 because the thyroid gland is one of your main conversion glands of T4 to T3.
- 7:43Scenario number two would be that your thyroid gland just directly and primarily is not producing the thyroid hormones that it should. This might be because of long-term use of birth control. This could be other medications you've taken, chemotherapy, radiation, beta blockers, all of those meds and conditions and treatments.
- 8:06can tank the thyroid gland as can eating disorders and overexercising. Now, if you're in that camp, you probably shouldn't be fasting anyways, because that's a huge trigger. But eating disorders and overexercising can directly affect the thyroid gland, shutting down the thyroid function. And then last but not least...
- 8:26you have this hypothyroid state in people who are not even diagnosed. Now, this will fall into one of those two camps, hypothyroidism or Hashimoto's. But these four people are just walking around completely undiagnosed. They don't even know they have a thyroid problem. So they're trying to fast.
- 8:45in order to take care of their symptoms. And they're just looking for that magic bullet. But it turns out the fasting might actually be kicking their ass a little bit. Oh, and there is one more category, all y'all without a thyroid. So you've had your thyroid gland removed, total thyroidectomy, partial thyroidectomy or radioactive iodine. And now you should be on T4 and T3.
- 9:07Many of you are on T4 only, and that's a problem because T4 only does not work. But if you do not have a thyroid gland for whatever reason, you're trying fasting in order to take care of your symptoms. So you're going to fall in one of those categories. Now, here's the thing. If you are optimized, we don't worry as much.
- 9:30about fasting impacting your thyroid and your metabolism. And I still want you to do fasting correctly, but we don't worry as much because you're on the thyroid hormone that your body needs.
- 9:42So here's the thing with fasting. It can temporarily lower thyroid hormone levels, particularly T3, your active thyroid hormone. And it can actually increase reverse T3 because it's a stressor in the body and because the body loses energy during fasting. So this is gonna lead to
- 10:02lower metabolic activity all throughout your body and a decrease in thyroid hormone levels in order to conserve energy. Because remember, when our bodies detect that there is not enough food, that survival mechanism kicks in. And I remember hearing about this back in the 80s and 90s when I was
- 10:21working out and then competing, of course, 90s and 2000s competing. And you heard about starvation mode. Oh, you don't want to eat too low of calories because you don't want to go into starvation mode. And this is where your body literally holds on to fat for dear life. Now we've kind of gotten away from that talk because we're such an obese society and there's food on every corner and we're constantly feeding our faces. But if you're in the health and fitness space, you might still hear about
- 10:49starvation mode because you're still actually paying attention to what goes into your mouth. And you're really trying to be the healthiest version of you. But if you've noticed, you don't hear about this much, right? But there still is starvation mode, whether we are talking about it, whether the media is talking about it, doesn't matter. It still exists. There is starvation mode. And this is where your body, because our bodies are so smart, says, you know what? There's not enough food coming in.
- 11:17We don't have the fuel to run this body. So what we're going to do is just lower thyroid hormone because the thyroid gives this person a metabolism and we don't want them burning fat. We don't want them expending energy. So lower that thyroid hormone. My God, they don't need that.
- 11:37And now let's increase reverse T3 because reverse T3 is this beautiful built-in mechanism into our body that protects us when we are injured, in trauma, just lying there in the hospital bed dying. Reverse T3 is going to go up because again, it knows that we don't have to be burning fat for fuel. We don't have to be using our energy.
- 12:01We need to conserve it so that we can survive and heal. So reverse T3 goes up and free T3 goes down. Now, if this continues on and on, so let's say I'm gonna use, I'm gonna pull from my past when I was competing. There was this crazy ass trainer and he would put all the girls, thank God I didn't work with him, but he would put all the girls on, I kid you not, like 800 and 900 calorie a day diets and he would be having them do cardio twice a day. So obviously-
- 12:30they were expending way, way, way more calories than what they were taking in. And their body went into survival mode. So what would happen is many of them would gain weight or completely stop losing weight. So what would trainer do? What would bad trainer do? He would give them a cheat day. So they would exponentially increase.
- 12:51increase their caloric consumption because you know these girls went out because I was one of them I didn't go that low calories but I have my cheat days we go out let's let's eat half of the pizza and a bowl of cereal and a bowl of ice cream and then get really really sick afterwards and have massive stomach pains and then let's do it all over again so caloric consumption that day would be 3,000 or more
- 13:16So they jack up the calories and then that tells the body, hey, hey, there's food here. You can come out of your starvation mode. Now that sounds like fun, but it really screws up the body and puts a boatload of stress on the body. And what can happen to the thyroid gland after doing that, which I see so often after a show, people come out the other side with a thyroid problem. Because really doing a show and reducing your calories to 800 or 900 and doing cardio twice a day is no different from an eating disorder. It's just tagged as...
- 13:45contest prep because that person is then going to get on stage and compete as an athlete. Now, if it continues, then it's a full-blown eating disorder. This type of extreme, so we're still pulling and fasting here, this type of extreme can put your body in survival mode, lower your T3 and increase reverse T3. Now, here's the thing. That's the extreme.
- 14:08These are the people, you OMADers out there, one meal a day. There's a whole boatload of other issues with that too that I went over in the other podcast that you need to go back and listen to. I believe it's 358, but we'll link it in the show notes. The other issues are low protein intake when you're doing OMAD. There's no possible way you're getting in the amount of calories that you need to keep your body out of survival mode when you're doing OMAD.
- 14:35So what we see in terms of lowering thyroid hormone, increasing reverse T3, lowering free T3, that's extreme fasting. Now, it can still happen to my ladies that do maybe not an OMAD, but let's say you're doing a 20-hour fast, four-hour eating window.
- 14:57or even 16-8, some of you ladies doing eight hours of eating, 16 hours of fasting, while that is amazing and comes with a host of benefits that we talked about in the other podcast, it still is a little bit of a crunch time for you to get your protein intake in. Now, if you're doing it in those eight hours and you're hitting your protein gram total, which is one gram per pound of lean body mass, then fine, keep doing it. You're a rockstar, you're good. Okay.
- 15:25You're going to get all the benefits of fasting, plus you're going to get in your protein intake. Your calories are where they should be to not go into survival mode. I'm good with that. I'm good with that. Now, even with that 16-8, okay, I'm still going to say a couple days a week, can you do 12-12? Can you just do that and give yourself a little bit more food, a little wider eating window? Let's say you're really stressed one day.
- 15:52And listen, when you are stressed and you push past a fast when you're stressed, that's bad. That's bad. You're going to increase your cortisol. Your body's not going to like it and it's going to work against you. But let's say you're super stressed one day. You're like, I don't know. I'm just really hungry. Like, I don't want to go 16 hours. I'm hungry now. It's 7 a.m. Listen to your body. That is not a day to fast. Maybe you do a 12-hour eating window.
- 16:18Maybe you do a 14 hour eating window. I don't care. Give yourself a break. So as long as you're coming out of that 16, 8 mode a couple times a week, even once a week, I think that's perfect. That's good. As long as you're getting your protein intake in, I'm going to add that in as a caveat as well, then you'll be good. Now, short term intermittent fasting, like the 12-12s, that can actually improve the absorption of thyroid medications.
- 16:44Depending on when you take your thyroid med, you should always take your thyroid medication on an empty stomach, but that can actually improve it. So short-term fast, really good. Long-term fast might kick your ass a little bit when it comes to the thyroid because it's a stressor.
- 17:01And just remember, fasting has a boatload of effects on the HPT axis. This is the hypothalamus pituitary thyroid axis, which regulates our thyroid function. Now, there was one study that found that fasting can actually downregulate that HPT axis function, which could make it harder for obese people to lose weight. My God, we don't want that. No, we don't want that.
- 17:29But this study looked at Ramadan fasting and how it affects hypothyroidism. And that's really not a long fast. It's sundown to sun up, but that was enough for researchers to actually see that it had an impact on the HPT axis.
- 17:48Okay, I'm going to go deeper here. And we're going to debunk some myths. Does fasting actually cause hypothyroidism? So we talked about the HPT axis. Can that be affected? Yes. With long, long, long fast, never coming out of it. Too long of a fast during the day. Going OMAD-ing. Not a great idea, but you can do this safely. You really can. That's the good news. So if you've heard that fasting causes hypothyroidism, it does not.
- 18:15It does not. Just like we said in the very beginning, eating disorders, severe prolonged calorie restriction or just even protein deficiency. So this is where it comes back to the OMADs or the 20-hour fast, four-hour eating window or the 18-6, a little bit too long. You're not gonna get in your protein intake. So that absolutely can cause...
- 18:40hypothyroidism, but it's not fasting itself that causes the hypothyroidism when it's done correctly, when it is paired up with consistent energy intake and adequate nutrition.
- 18:53Now, myth number two that we hear around fasting and thyroid function is just that negative impact. Now, we already went over this, but I want to review a study in young adults with obesity. And this study compared the effect of an 18-6 fasting pattern on thyroid hormones. So one group's six-hour eating window was early. It was 7 a.m. to 1 p.m.
- 19:23Typical like 12 p.m. to 6 p.m. And then the control group just ate whenever the hell they wanted to. So in that early group, T3 and TSH were depressed at four weeks. Within by eight weeks, their levels normalized. Now, I don't know if we really want to go four to eight weeks with a low...
- 19:44T3 and depressing the TSH is not a big deal, but what that's going to do, it's going to send a signal back to the thyroid gland to not make thyroid hormones. So here you are with low T3 and your thyroid gland has just shit the bed and isn't producing enough anyway. So we don't really want that. But what I would do there is sure, you can do the 18-6 from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. fasting window.
- 20:12Well, eating window rather. So you're eating between 7 a.m. and 1 p.m. You can do that, but I would still encourage you to break out of that 18-6 pattern once or twice a week. So moving on with the study, the typical fasting group, meaning their eating window was between noon and 6 p.m.,
- 20:32saw no hormone reduction. And then of course, neither did the control group because they were eating anytime they wanted. Now, both fasting groups saw significant body weight loss compared to the control group, of course. So we know that the fasting is good for you, but it is going to affect your hormone levels. So number one, I would say if you're going to fast, have your eating window between noon and six or 10 and six and,
- 21:00And if you're going to do an 18-6 or anything longer than that, you have to come out of it at least twice a week and do a much shorter fasting window, a 12-12 or 14-8. All right, myth number three, just that fasting is going to make your thyroid conditions worse.
- 21:16Well, we've kind of covered all of this, but I've heard from people that they're worried that fasting could make their hypothyroidism worse and they're already dealing with getting optimized or they're stuck on T4 only. So this is really where it comes back to being optimized.
- 21:38So if you fast and you're on T4 only, you're going to get a slight depression in thyroid function and thyroid hormone production. Remember your thyroid gland itself produces T4 and T3. But here you are taking T4 only and then you're fasting, you're pushing up your reverse T3. That would be a scenario where I might actually advise against fasting.
- 22:00until you get your thyroid optimized, because there, that would prove the myth true that fasting could make your thyroid condition worse. But again, how we would break out of that would be to add in T3 or get you on the right thyroid hormone replacement. And then you could incorporate fasting for all the health benefits in addition to the assistance with weight loss that you're going to most likely see once you get your thyroid optimized as well.
- 22:25Now let's go over how fasting can actually help your thyroid condition, because I don't want this to be a bashing of fasting. In fact, it's not a bashing of fasting podcast. It's how about you do fasting correctly podcast. But let's go over how it could actually help your thyroid. So first of all, whenever we are walking around with excess adipose tissue, i.e. fat on our body, that increases stress on thyroid hormone regulation. Right.
- 22:53Now, I know you're going to sit there and say, yeah, but it's because of my thyroid that I can't lose weight. And that's why I'm walking around with extra body fat on me. Right. I get it. I get it. But that's why we're kind of hitting it both at the same time. That's why I encourage you to get your thyroid optimized as well. So we know that fasting can lower insulin and improve insulin sensitivity. Right.
- 23:20Insulin is hugely inflammatory. Being insulin resistant is inflammatory. So if we incorporate an intervention that's actually working and improving our blood sugar control and insulin sensitivity like intermittent fasting,
- 23:36then it could lower our inflammation and actually help our thyroid gland work better. Now here's the kicker is that having a thyroid problem can cause insulin resistance in and of itself. So back to optimize your thyroid, maybe take some berberine, control your diet, but also add in intermittent fasting.
- 23:55And then there's the inflammation reduction that we talked about already, but you can get a direct inflammation reduction from fasting, not just from lowering your insulin, although that's gonna help, but even just that time-restricted eating, going without food for 12, 14, or 16 hours
- 24:15reduces inflammatory markers in the body outside of thyroid condition. So we can see a lowering of C-reactive protein or high-sensitivity C-reactive protein, an improvement in EGFR. We're seeing all of these markers start to improve. We know that there's an increase in brain-derived neurotropic factor. So many different things improve.
- 24:36when we lower that inflammation through fasting. Now we talked about autophagy cell cleanup, but it's interesting when we're looking at this autophagy with the thyroid. So some research actually shows that autophagy can help improve thyroid health
- 24:54by promoting the elimination of the damaged or cancerous thyroid cells. So this is not only important to prevent cancer, but also to keep the downstream targets of thyroid hormones, like most of the organs in your body, and especially your muscle, healthy. Now we know too that those dysfunctional cells around the thyroid can also call in your troops, right?
- 25:20So you're walking around with Hashimoto's. You have those soldiers that are confused. They think your thyroid is the bad guy. Now you have inflammation around your thyroid. That's hurting your thyroid gland itself. But that inflammation and those dysfunctional cells, if they're not cleaned out, they can kind of send a smoke signal to your soldiers. Be like, hey, there's a war up here. Why don't you come attack? So you are actually improving your...
- 25:46autoimmunity in your body, you're suppressing the soldiers, telling them to stay in their barracks. There's no war here. There's no need to come out by incorporating fasting. So we could have a direct impact on the improvement and the lowering of our antibodies. And just think, if you stacked fasting, done the right way with black cumin seed oil, maybe low dose naltrexone, you've already eliminated gluten, you're controlling your stress levels, you could essentially put your Hashimoto's into remission.
- 26:16So this is an excellent tool for that as well. So I think we can see from all the evidence, all the research, as I've combed through it all to give you this on a silver platter so you can digest it all and not have to, no pun intended, not have to weed through all this internet advice. I've done it for you.
- 26:38So the bottom line, I guess the recap is, yes, fasting is amazing. I encourage you to do it. It has a host of benefits for your thyroid gland. You absolutely must do it correctly. I'm not a fan of extended fasts, like the two, three, five, seven days. Those need to be monitored. If you want to do that once a year, that's fine. But you better be working with somebody to do that. I'm not a fan of OMADs, one meal a day.
- 27:05I'm not really a fan of a 28-hour fast, four-hour eating window. I really, really do like a 12-12, a 16-8, a 14-10, something in that area. Nothing over 16 hours. And even if you're doing 16-8,
- 27:26I want you to break it up once, twice a week with a much shorter, fast, bigger eating window. Jack up that protein and jack up that protein every day. So again, if you rock stars out there are getting in your protein in that eight hour eating window, awesome.
- 27:42I mean, do a couple of protein shakes. It's cool. You can do it. Anybody can do it, but you have to be really focused on doing it because we don't want increased reverse T3 from you having low protein intake. This can be done, people, and it has a host of benefits. You just have to do it the right way, especially if you have a thyroid problem.