Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / ALCO GOVERNANCE ESSENTIALS: BUILDING AN EFFECTIVE COMMITTEE STRUCTURE
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:07In today's episode, we are diving into the governance side of Elko asset
- 0:12and liability management committees.
- 0:15Todd Miller and I will discuss best practices for structuring Alco charters.
- 0:20Defining roles and responsibilities and fostering an effective governance culture.
- 0:25Whether you're part of a small or large credit union.
- 0:27This episode is packed with actionable advice to strengthen
- 0:31your credit unions foundation.
- 0:33And here we go.
- 0:34Ah, here's the episode, Todd and I discussing all of the above.
- 0:37Treichel: Todd, how are you doing today?
- 0:40Todd Miller: I'm doing good this morning.
- 0:41Treichel: Very good.
- 0:42Glad to hear it.
- 0:43And today we're going to talk about asset liability.
- 0:46And I got to go to with the acronym.
- 0:48And so he loves their acronyms, ALM.
- 0:51We're gonna talk about ALM and specifically we're going to talk
- 0:53about ALM reporting and different nuances that might relate to that.
- 0:57But Todd, before we jump into that most of our listeners have probably
- 1:01know what your background is, but we might have some first time listeners
- 1:04if you could give a little bit of your background at NCUA and what you did
- 1:08there before retiring a few years ago and and switching teams like I did.
- 1:13Todd Miller: I retired in 2021 after 34 years with N.
- 1:17C.
- 1:17U.
- 1:17A.
- 1:18I think I can probably break my career down into three big, broad parts.
- 1:22The 1st 3rd of my career.
- 1:24I spent that as an examiner and a problem case officers.
- 1:28The middle 3rd of my career.
- 1:29I spent that as a regional capital market specialist, even developing a lot of N.
- 1:35C.
- 1:35U.
- 1:35A.
- 1:35's.
- 1:36So I'm going to go through some of the different things that we do.
- 1:39And then the training for examiners.
- 1:41And then the last third of my career from 2009 and on, I had a
- 1:46last year at West core with you when they were in conservatorship.
- 1:50But then I spent the last decade of my career as a director of special actions,
- 1:53supervising problem case officers.
- 1:56Dealing with troubled credit unions, and I also supervised regional capital
- 2:00market specialist and regional lending specialist in that last 3rd as well.
- 2:06Treichel: So that fits perfectly with this topic of reporting as they say,
- 2:11you've forgotten more about that.
- 2:13I ever knew.
- 2:14So I'm looking forward to walking through.
- 2:17This topic and provide credit unions with some key points on some
- 2:22things that they might be doing.
- 2:24So with that, I'm going to, I'm going to turn the keys over to you and
- 2:27I'll jump in here as appropriate.
- 2:29Todd Miller: I have a feeling you remember more than you
- 2:31give yourself credit for, Mark.
- 2:33So today we're going to talk a little bit about ALCO reporting.
- 2:36Most credit unions, they have an ALCO committee, they have a finance
- 2:40committee, they call this different names, but generally there's a committee
- 2:44group of people in charge of managing interest rate risk, liquidity risk.
- 2:48More and more today, ALCO committees are becoming an overall risk function.
- 2:53They're in charge of managing capital and credit quality as well.
- 2:58It's very difficult to manage liquidity and interest rate risk.
- 3:01If you don't also have your fingers in that pie of managing credit risk and
- 3:06capital as well, before we talk about ALCO reporting, maybe let's just go back
- 3:12and talk about ALCO in general, because these are the communities that manage it.
- 3:17Most credit unions and very large organizations.
- 3:20What you'll see is committees will have charters in smaller organization.
- 3:25These committee functions will be laid out within policies and ALM
- 3:30policies and liquidity policy.
- 3:32A financial management policy,
- 3:35Cedric: I would just recommend credit is even at the smaller size.
- 3:37Start thinking about developing charters for their committees where they're
- 3:43putting these in 1 spot, rather than having 5 or 6 different policies.
- 3:47Todd Miller: Saying, And ALCO is responsible for A, B, C
- 3:51and policy in the ALM policy.
- 3:54ALCO is responsible for X, Y, Z and the liquidity policy.
- 3:59I think it's better to just follow the template that large organizations
- 4:02do and create a committee charter and put this committee all in one spot.
- 4:06And then let's talk a little bit about before we talk about
- 4:09reporting, what should be in a charter or what should be in your.
- 4:13Policy statements regarding an ALCO committee.
- 4:17We'll use the term ALCO today, even though a lot of parties name this
- 4:21committee different things, in a charter, they should lay out the
- 4:25purpose and role of the committee.
- 4:26What is the committee's purpose?
- 4:28Are they going to oversee that interest rate risk liquidity risk?
- 4:33They're going to be.
- 4:34In charge of capital adequacy, they're going to have credit risk in it or not.
- 4:38I do think all those pieces should be in it, but that's not always the case.
- 4:43Some committees keep credit risk and other parts of the risk
- 4:46management in other committees.
- 4:48Either way, they should lay out purpose and roles of the committee.
- 4:51They should specify who's on these committees.
- 4:54Outgo committees are generally drawn from a wide range of staff.
- 4:57Usually you have a CEO, some lending people, some member service
- 5:03people, occasionally a marketing person on there as a non voting.
- 5:09Over the years, what really.
- 5:12Gets to become a challenge for board is, do you put board members on these
- 5:15committees or not, and smaller credit, especially you'll see examiners
- 5:19recommend that board members be on these committees in larger credit unions.
- 5:24It's very difficult to put an unpaid board member on a committee that has a very
- 5:29significant hour and time obligation.
- 5:32So what in a lot of organizations now are mid sized and has larger
- 5:35credeins is you end up seeing a staff ALCO that handles those everyday
- 5:40tactics and strategy adjustments.
- 5:44And it's not uncommon to see a board risk management or a board ALCO that's
- 5:48separate, that meets less frequently.
- 5:52Like I said, I think it's very challenging to recruit.
- 5:54Put board members on something like an ALCO, because there's a lot of
- 5:58daily work and board members are not really paid for that daily work.
- 6:02Your committee charter should outline your meetings.
- 6:06How frequently do you expect them to meet?
- 6:08Under what conditions?
- 6:10Basic responsibilities of the committee, what are they going to be responsible for
- 6:15in terms of different risk categories?
- 6:18The committee's authority, what can they or not do?
- 6:22Are they responsible for pricing?
- 6:24Do they get to change investment strategies?
- 6:26Can they change lending strategies in the midst of a business
- 6:29plan as conditions change?
- 6:31You should lay out just exactly what kind of authority they
- 6:35have and responsibilities.
- 6:37Also I would think for larger credit unions you should lay out what can that
- 6:41committee re delegate to someone else.
- 6:43If you give ALCO, pricing authority, can they do that?
- 6:46Redelegate that down to a smaller subgroup and pricing becomes a pretty
- 6:51important function of communities.
- 6:53Your charters policy statement should specify reporting and we'll talk
- 6:57about reports in a couple of minutes.
- 7:01And your committee charter should lay out what kind of performance metrics.
- 7:07Revaluation review and evaluation are going to be doing how well
- 7:09does this committee operate?
- 7:11How often do we have to relook at it?
- 7:13And committee charter should probably also lay out what kind of documentation
- 7:17that committee is responsible for and we'll talk about that in a
- 7:20little bit as well under reporting.
- 7:24Treichel: Good.
- 7:25And so on a couple of things popped into my head and what popped into it
- 7:29is some of the conversations we've had with credit unions over the past year.
- 7:34And I do remember 1 situation where an NCWA exam report actually.
- 7:39Was requiring board participation on it.
- 7:44It was in the midsize or large category, I would say, but had
- 7:47actually put in a document resolution.
- 7:49And I remember us advising the credit union.
- 7:51We thought.
- 7:52That had really overstep their bounds there.
- 7:54There were some issues that, that might have triggered there to be more board
- 7:58involvement in some way, but I was a little surprised to see that NCOA was
- 8:03actually saying these are the types of folks that should be on the committee.
- 8:07And then on the other side, we've had some conversations where more and
- 8:12more as at the tail end of our time at NCOA, and even more since we left
- 8:17the position of chief risk officer is more prevalent in credit unions.
- 8:21And we've seen some situations where chief risk officers.
- 8:25Have been on the committee and have not been on the committee.
- 8:28And also where where N2A was trying to truncate what responsibilities
- 8:34that chief risk officer had as it related to the charter.
- 8:38I guess in general, I would say as you're building.
- 8:42Out this charter and who's on it and what the responsibilities are.
- 8:45You might sometimes find that and see you ask questions relative to that.
- 8:50In the end, there's best practices, but there's really what makes sense for you.
- 8:55And there's not a lot.
- 8:56There's not a regulation that ties to who should be on these committees, et cetera.
- 9:00Anything based on what I just said there that you either want
- 9:03to correct or maybe opine on.
- 9:06Todd Miller: No, I think it comes back to, you have a board governance structure
- 9:10and the board is responsible that.
- 9:11And for instance, do you put a chief risk officer or a board
- 9:15member on an ELCO committee?
- 9:16I think those are individual decisions by the credit unions and it has
- 9:21to tie in what are the knowledge, skills and ability of their entire
- 9:25management staff and directors.
- 9:27Do you want a school board member on your ELCO?
- 9:30Probably not.
- 9:31If you have a board member, he's a CPA, he's been a chief financial officer,
- 9:35chief risk officer somewhere, and has time available and wants to be on the
- 9:39committee, absolutely make room for them.
- 9:42If that fits in with the whole culture of the organization the
- 9:46chief risk officer one, I thought that one was really interesting.
- 9:50When one of our clients was told to take their chief risk officer off of the Elko,
- 9:55because I thought that was, allowing a chief risk officer to be basically making
- 10:00decisions or making decisions on risk.
- 10:03But as part of that, I did some research and even in the very,
- 10:06very super large banks, Elko.
- 10:10Because they're not making individual risk decisions, like buying an
- 10:14investment or what have you.
- 10:15They're part of the strategy team.
- 10:17Putting them there actually probably helps their function.
- 10:21It probably helps the Alco when they've got responsibilities over
- 10:25here with compliance and other issues.
- 10:27And good risk managers, but you know who to put on committees and not just Elko,
- 10:32but any committee, a loan committee I.
- 10:35T.
- 10:35steering committee or what have you, those are individual decisions that
- 10:40boards and executive management make and you structure those based on
- 10:43the knowledge skills of your people and the needs of the organization.
- 10:48On any given place, maybe that chief risk officer should be on
- 10:52the alcohol at another place.
- 10:53Maybe the chief risk officer shouldn't be because the way you define that individual
- 10:57roles and responsibilities, it's more of a legal compliance CRM, and they don't
- 11:02have the knowledge, skills and ability to contribute, so I think you leave those
- 11:07decisions to individual credit unions.
- 11:09This is part of board governance and how you set up your risk management culture.
- 11:13And like I said, you put people on committees because it meets the credit
- 11:16union's needs, and they have the knowledge, skills, and abilities to be
- 11:19there, or you put them there because you want to improve their knowledge,
- 11:24skills, and abilities as you prepare them for other roles in the organization.
- 11:28That's a wrap on this episode on Elko governance and committee charters.
- 11:32If you found this helpful, please be sure to share it with your
- 11:35board members and colleagues at the credit union or other credit unions.
- 11:39And don't forget to subscribe for more deep dives into credit union
- 11:43management and strategies on how to pass your exam with flying colors.
- 11:47Todd, thanks for being a guest again today and listeners , as I
- 11:51always say, thanks for listening.
- 11:52I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 11:55Park Treichel signing off with flying colors.