Latest / Crypto Coin Show / What are Bitcoin Ordinals, BRC-20 and more with Bob Bodily of Toniq | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:01I'm Ashon Addison from block West Capital for Investment Pitch Media, and today on
- 0:05the Cryptocoin Show we have Bob Bodiley, the CEO and founder of Tonic.
- 0:09Bob, welcome to the show and thank you for taking the time. Ashton,
- 0:13thanks so much for having me. I'm really excited to talk all things
- 0:16bitcoin and ordinals today. So definitely there's a lot to learn about ordinals.
- 0:22I'm interested in the ICP ecosystem as well. I know that's up and coming,
- 0:26but I feel like bitcoin and the growing ecosystem is something that not a
- 0:32lot of people are getting into yet, but it's going to be very important
- 0:35moving forward. I know you have a leg up already working in that part
- 0:39for a while now, so I'd love to dive into your insights. But
- 0:43first let's start from the top on just a little bit about you know,
- 0:46what you and your team have built at Tonic, how that relates to the
- 0:50whole thing, and then we'll dive into all the details. Oh yeah,
- 0:54so me and my team we've been building on the Internet Computer Protocol for almost
- 0:59two years years now. Main Net launched for ICP May of twenty twenty one,
- 1:04and that was about when we started building. We built a wallet,
- 1:08we built an NFT marketplace. We have the largest NFT marketplace on ICP called
- 1:12Tonic. We recently rebranded from Entrepo Entrepose, our French port marketplace name,
- 1:19recently doing some brand consolidation to Tonic. And so we've been building on ICP
- 1:26because it makes a lot of interesting trade offs that makes it very scalable,
- 1:30very fast, very performant. For those who don't know what ICP is,
- 1:34you can think about it like decentralized web services. So think about what AWS
- 1:40offers you. You know, Amazon, they'll give you compute, hosting and
- 1:44storage, and it's affordable storage, it's good scalable compute, it's hosting services
- 1:49for front ends. You can do all of that in a decentralized way on
- 1:53ICP. So you can store your assets on ICP, you can store your
- 1:57front ends on ICP. You can host and ends directly from a smart contract
- 2:01on ICP. Data storage is affordable and compute is affordable, and so it's
- 2:07really trying to be like the blockchain of the web. You know, pick
- 2:12any social media application and run it one hundred percent on chain on ICP.
- 2:15And so that was the reason why we were interested in ICP, like we
- 2:20didn't have to cobble together different kinds of like ethereum plus IPFS plus maybe some
- 2:27are we even maybe some aws still for some business logic, we just want
- 2:30to kind of a unify cloud platform. So, you know, built on
- 2:36ICP for a solid two years almost and then there are some recent Bitcoin integrations
- 2:43into the protocol layer that we were chatting about earlier, and you can actually
- 2:50sign Bitcoin transactions directly from an ICP smart contract. And then they also have
- 2:55h you know, it's it's it's it's like a wrapped a wrapped version of
- 3:01Bitcoin on ICP as well, called c KPTC, and so that means you
- 3:06can you know, wrap bitcoin in onto ICP. It's kind of like a
- 3:08Bitcoin side chain in that sense, and you can leverage the speeding cost of
- 3:15the Internet computer instead of the speeding cost of Bitcoin. So very fast transactions
- 3:19like five second finality, and very very low fees essentially no gas fees,
- 3:24no no network fees. So there's a lot to love about ICP. Recently
- 3:30been kind of pivoting and building a building Bionic. Bionic is our ordinals marketplace,
- 3:37and we'll be building that entirely on ICP, so you'll be able to
- 3:40trade trade ordinals on bionic using bitcoin and CCBTC as as the main currency.
- 3:50So that's kind of a you know, yeah, yeah, it's a lot
- 3:53of moving pieces, especially for people that and you know, they've they've heard
- 3:58of NFTs and maybe they have one or two sort of the blue chip ones
- 4:01that they've got off an NFT marketplace. But there's so many up and coming
- 4:05ecosystems where you can get NFTs and transfer them or use them or trade them
- 4:11with you know, lower fees and faster that I think people are still trying
- 4:15to figure out all of the different moving pieces, especially when Bitcoin came in
- 4:19with their ordinals. Even people with NFTs, we're like, okay, this
- 4:23is another you know, a little bit added complexity. What exactly is the
- 4:27difference between this and you know, the NFT that I have on a theoryum
- 4:30that I just bought off of the open Sea marketplace. But I feel like
- 4:34it's it's important because the Bitcoin network is one of the strongest, most decentralized
- 4:41UH blockchain protocols ever, so to be able to add extra functionality on that,
- 4:46I feel like it's a huge added bonus. Yeah, a lot of
- 4:49people have been talking about it like, uh, they've they've been using words
- 4:55like inscribing instead of minting, and then like digital artifacts instead of NFTs.
- 5:01It's kind of these more permanent sounding solutions. So it's like catching your artwork
- 5:10into stone as opposed to like writing it on paper. That's that's the analogy
- 5:15that people like to use, where uh, you know, Bitcoin being the
- 5:18most decentralized, secure, sense censorship resistant blockchain, being able to inscribe or
- 5:28put data on chain in an immutable way, and it's a it's a pay
- 5:31once store forever model forever forever so far where you don't really have the pay
- 5:39one store forever in other places. That's kind of a hard business model to
- 5:44achieve. And so I think that's another really interesting thing that that people enjoy
- 5:48about putting artwork on bitcoin directly. H And I've saw some of these major
- 5:58NFT collections people being able to inscribe them or mint them on ordinal on bitcoin.
- 6:04Is that creating a new NFT altogether? Or can you take NFTs that
- 6:09you have in some of the popular ecosystems and you know, merge it over
- 6:14there or create a duplicate that's tied to the original. How exactly does that
- 6:17work? Yeah, so it's probably worth mentioning the kind of array of protocols
- 6:27that are starting to be built on bitcoin. So leveraging bitcoin as a storage
- 6:30layer, you can have some kind of messaging protocol that stores messages on bitcoin.
- 6:35You can take advantage of the security and the decentralization of bitcoin at the
- 6:42messaging layer, meaning you can't double spend your messages. The messages have a
- 6:46single order, and it's all kind of written into the Bitcoin blockchain itself.
- 6:53Some of these standards are like BRC twenty, this is a fungible token standard.
- 6:57There's o RC twenty which is a relatively new kind of competing fungible token
- 7:02standard. There's also DRC twenty and BRC thirty and BRC twenty one and s
- 7:09RC twenty, like lots of different fungable token standards. And then if we
- 7:13move into the non fungible token arena, we have BRC seven twenty one,
- 7:19BRC seven twenty one E or g BRC seven twenty one and these are all
- 7:25different non fungible token standards trying to bring programmability to bitcoin. So one of
- 7:31the ones that you mentioned was the BRC seven twenty one E. H.
- 7:35This is a it's it's trying to bridge between Ethereum and Bitcoin. And so
- 7:43the way that BRC seven twenty one E works is you add a function to
- 7:47a smart contract, which is essentially a burn. I don't know if it's
- 7:53like its own smart contract or whether you build it into your own Ethereum smart
- 7:57contract, but there's a function somewhere where it's like a burn, and you
- 8:00burn your token using this function, and you give it a Bitcoin receiving address,
- 8:07and this basically white list that Bitcoin receiving address to be able to inscribe
- 8:11it on Bitcoin. So then you go to that address and you say,
- 8:13yeah, I want to inscribe, I want to inscribe you. You inscribe
- 8:18the Ethereum contract address and the token ID and other metadata if you want,
- 8:22and then that inscription becomes your new NFT. So you've essentially burned it on
- 8:30the Ethereum blockchain, and now you've inscribed it to life again on Bitcoin.
- 8:35It does use pointers still, so it points back to the contract and then
- 8:39grabs where the metadata stored, grabs where the image is stored, and so
- 8:43it could be still stored on ipfs or somewhere somewhere else like that. But
- 8:48the BRC seven twenty one doesn't specifically say where you have to store your data.
- 8:54So if you wanted to, you could have an indexer that essentially goes
- 8:58to the con trek to address grabs, the image grabs, the metadata,
- 9:01stores them in kind of companion inscriptions. And now you've essentially burned in ethereum
- 9:07NFT and you've inscribed it on bitcoin. So yeah, lots of these standards,
- 9:13you know, popping up people trying to do interesting smart contract type functionality
- 9:18directly on bitcoin. M very interesting, Bob, and thank you for explaining
- 9:22that, and maybe you could elaborate on some of the reasons why someone who
- 9:28has, you know, a very expensive NFT worth tens of thousands or more
- 9:33would want to move that over to bitcoin. Is it just the strength of
- 9:37the network or were there be other advantages? Yeah, I think in a
- 9:46lot of ways it feels kind of silly because from my perspective, if you
- 9:58look at an NFT, you have to different layers. One layer is artwork,
- 10:03one layer is community and culture. One layer is you know, how
- 10:05can you use it? Can you use it in a game, can you
- 10:07use it as an access pass? Another layer is like can you use it
- 10:15for like verification purposes or so take take all of these layers, and I
- 10:20think a lot of them are tied to they're like blockchain specific. So if
- 10:24you want to have utility in your community and it's an ethereum project, then
- 10:30if you burn it over to bitcoin, you could lose out on a lot
- 10:33of the community ecosystem benefits of owning that NFT in the first place. If
- 10:39it was an NFT that was just the artwork and you just loved the art
- 10:43and you wanted to preserve the artwork forever, you could burn it on ethereum
- 10:50and then inscribe it on bitcoin, or you could leave it on ethereum and
- 10:54inscribe it to bitcoin. I don't know that it's an either or necessarily,
- 11:00and so I think one of the big value propositions of storing data on bitcoin
- 11:05is that it will just last forever as like an enduring, you know,
- 11:09decentralized database. And so having multiple means of storing your artwork I think is
- 11:13a good way to perhaps even increase the value of your artwork. So from
- 11:18that use case, I think it could be interesting. I know, like
- 11:22as a collection, some some collections are thinking about bridging over and that also
- 11:26might make sense if you're a collection on ethereum and you might want to say,
- 11:30well, you know, we're we're going to be bridging over to bitcoin.
- 11:33You know, everyone can go use these tools to bridge over, so
- 11:37some something like that might also make sense. Okay, And I'm curious on
- 11:41where, you know, where you see the growth and the potential for this
- 11:46birth of ordinals on bitcoin compared to when NFT started on athereum and just the
- 11:52ease of use of going to a marketplace and you know, everyone seems to
- 11:56have an Ethereum Arc twenty wallet to easily store their NFTs. Are you seeing
- 12:03on the Bitcoin side the growth being you know, just as strong and just
- 12:07as fast, or are there other barriers to entry that are still to overcome
- 12:13to grow Bitcoin NFTs more. Yeah, I think if you tried to get
- 12:20involved with ordinals in February, you would be very disappointed with the user experience.
- 12:26You had to have a sparal wallet, you had to manually manage your
- 12:30own utxos to make sure you're not spending your ordinals, and it was very
- 12:35complicated but you know, fast forward four months to where we are now and
- 12:39it's a very similar experience. You have browser extension based wallets, you can
- 12:43load them up with bitcoin, you can go to any number of marketplaces that
- 12:48you know have it's not complete parody with like a blur or an open c
- 12:54but you have generally good collection filters, you have good metadata support, you
- 13:01have good analytics on on collections, and it's generally pretty easy to just go
- 13:07in and buy, buy what you want. Magic even has a has a
- 13:11good Ordinal's marketplace. Ordinal's Wallet has another one, and the UNITSA is probably
- 13:18the other. Between those three, they probably share the majority of the volume
- 13:22so far. And user experience is really good, it's not all the way
- 13:28there, and that's that's kind of what we're trying to do with Bionic BECA
- 13:31is how can we take it, you know, how how can we get
- 13:33the next ten x in user experience? And so you know, we're we're
- 13:39making some some trade offs compared to these other marketplaces. Most marketplaces use something
- 13:45called psbts that's a partially signed bitcoin transaction. Essentially, if I have one
- 13:52bitcoin and you have a really cool ordinal you could sign is it essentially signing
- 13:56half of the transaction that says, I will give you this ordinal if you
- 14:01give me one BTC, and then I can sign the other half. And
- 14:05it's a trustless swamp, essentially leveraging bitcoin technology. So the majority of marketplaces
- 14:13used this PSBT tech, which is really good. The downside is it's slow
- 14:18and expensive, expensive because you're paying network fees, and slow because you know,
- 14:24bitcoin has probabilistic finality, so it could take ten minutes or it could
- 14:28take one hundred and twenty minutes depending on when blocks fall. And so with
- 14:33Bionic, what we wanted to do is we wanted to wrap bitcoin over,
- 14:37wrap ordinals over and give you five second transaction times always no matter what,
- 14:43and no network fees and no gas fees, and make it a really really
- 14:48easy and great user experience, so easy to log in, easy to top
- 14:52up with bitcoin, easy to kind of get into the ecosystem, and then
- 14:56how to just be really really fast, you know, like a like a
- 15:01you know, like a layer one or layer two kind of kind of bitcoin
- 15:05trading experience. So yeah, yeah, I'm looking forward to seeing that.
- 15:09And what's the progress on bionic? Is that? Are you guys? Just
- 15:13releasing it. Yeah, Bionic should be released in the next couple of weeks.
- 15:18It's been kind of a longer road than other bitcoin marketplaces. We started
- 15:24early February building. As we were building, we had to build rapper tech,
- 15:30kind of like Emblem Vault. We also had to build wallet tech because
- 15:35we we we have to support both sides of the rap We have to support
- 15:41the bitcoin side and the Bionic ICP side, and so we we can't just
- 15:46leverage the existing bitcoin wallet. So building a wallet and building a wrapper and
- 15:50building a marketplace, so you know, throw throw all of that together,
- 15:54and you have a lot of moving pieces, and you got to make sure
- 15:58you get the tech right. You got to make sure it's all secure,
- 16:02you gotta get good code reviews. So yeah, it's it's coming. It's
- 16:06coming. M Yeah, No, definitely a lot of moving pieces. But
- 16:11I feel like we're still early on the on the bitcoin market NT marketplace sides,
- 16:17so there is time. I haven't seen any crazy explosions yet, though
- 16:21I've heard of many people who, you know, the early adopters that are
- 16:26benefiting from it. I'm curious as the NFT marketplaces for bitcoin emerge and more
- 16:33collections become more widely available and maybe become widely popular. We sort of saw
- 16:40with the Ethereum NFT collections, you know, the punks, the board apes,
- 16:44some blue chips that these people who even had free mints of these NFTs
- 16:49way back in the day now have NFTs that are worth hundreds of thousands or
- 16:53tens of thousands. Are you are you seeing an emergence of some blue chip
- 17:00ordinals or bitcoin NFC's or is it those same ones that you talked about where
- 17:04you can sort of merge them over or are there new collections as well?
- 17:10Yeah, definitely new collections. Be gods. Uh did a Bitcoin d gods
- 17:17collection? Floor for that is around one one btc right now. There's also
- 17:23a couple of collections like Ordinal Maxi biz that's being run by ZK Shark that
- 17:29that collection has a floor around two or three bitcoin right now. And then
- 17:33there are other collections like big ten K collections that have done really really well
- 17:38with lots of volume, like Bitcoin Frogs or a few others, like most
- 17:44of these are native bigcoin collections where they've kind of been able to capitalize on
- 17:49the unique friends and rarity, attributes and community of the bitcoin network, and
- 17:57then there are others as well, like I'm you can see I'm sporting my
- 18:02on chain Monkey hat here. Just bought into the on chain Monkey ecosystem last
- 18:07week because I really like the founders, Danny and Amanda are doing a really
- 18:11good job of pushing the boundaries on the technical fram They were one of the
- 18:17first, if not the first ten K on chain collections on Ethereum, so
- 18:22they actually have code that generates the NFT and it's all on chain, so
- 18:29they're taking you know, their expertise there, and they were the first generative
- 18:33ten K collection on bitcoin as well. And Danny's been pushing pushing the boundaries
- 18:38on kind of how can you generate art straight from the blockchain, And so
- 18:44their upcoming collection, Dimensions is actually going to be a three D collection,
- 18:48but it will be all generated. It'll be generated all on chain via code
- 18:52as well. So there's lots of interesting ways to kind of succeed as an
- 18:59end decollection on bitcoin. H great to know and thank you for giving some
- 19:04examples there. That's a decent floor price for you know. Ordinals just big
- 19:10one of the newest NFT ecosystems, and I feel like right now with the
- 19:15conditions of the market, you know, bitcoins sort of being boring, sideways,
- 19:19a little down, there's not a lot of interest. But I feel
- 19:22like when that time comes, when when the four year cycle gets to that
- 19:26point and it starts rising, all the whole ecosystem could probably rise with the
- 19:30tides. Yeah, yeah, I've I've seen more experimentation on bitcoin in the
- 19:36last four months than I've seen and maybe the last three years on bitcoin.
- 19:41There are a lot of people coming in from Headera or Cardano or Salona or
- 19:45Ethereum where they've always held bitcoin and they've always been bitcoiners, but they haven't
- 19:52been able to build very easily on bitcoin because it's been very hard. But
- 19:56with the ordinals and these kind of meta protocols that said on up, now
- 20:00you have this layer of experimentation where builders can come in and finally start to
- 20:04do more interesting things on bitcoin. And so there there have been a lot
- 20:10of people kind of returning to their mother chain in a sense, their mother
- 20:15chain, love it, Bob, and moving forward with with Tonic and Bionic.
- 20:22What do you think it's going to be that aha moment that you know
- 20:25creates that hockey stick effect. Will it just be the industry overall ready to
- 20:29adopt uh and more NFT collecting and trading, or is it some kind of
- 20:34user experience update, you know, how else can we drive more mainstreament option
- 20:38towards this tech? Yeah, I think that's a great question, and it's
- 20:42a question I think about a lot, uh, you know, building building
- 20:45on ICP and bitcoin. Uh. I think for us, our strategy with
- 20:51Bionic is, how can we make the user experience you know, ten to
- 20:56one hundred x better and how can we give people uh, you know,
- 21:03like the coin base or the robin hood of the bitcoin NFTs. Essentially,
- 21:08let's make it really really easy, let's make it really intuitive, and let's
- 21:15make it really fast. And you know, I think our target market,
- 21:18I think the ordinals community is still fairly small. There have been some big
- 21:23collectors coming in kind of getting their feet wet, kind of the the more
- 21:26innovator hype in investors, but you know, the early majority, late majority
- 21:36parts of the crypto community. I think that's that's really who who we want
- 21:40to target with Bionic. We want to bring in anyone that's ever owned any
- 21:44crypto anywhere, and we want to make it really easy for them to get
- 21:47started on bitcoin. Let's bring them to bitcoin, Let's show them how ICP
- 21:51can make bitcoin better. And that's that's kind of our our strategy with Bionic.
- 21:56Very cool, looking forward to it. And what's the best way for
- 22:00people to follow along with the launch of Bionic and just to learn more about
- 22:03Tonic and what your team's working on. Yeah, I think you can.
- 22:07You can always follow me on Twitter. I'm very active. It's just at
- 22:11Bob Bodily. You can also follow Bionic on Twitter. We're a little bit
- 22:15less less active on the Bionic account, but it's at Bionic market. That's
- 22:22Bionic with the queue, just like Tonic Tonics with the queue. And you
- 22:27can look at our explorer. We have an Ordinal's explorer that's live right now
- 22:32at Bionic dot ido. Those are probably the three best ways to stay involved.
- 22:37Very cool. Thank you so much, Bob. I will leave all
- 22:40those links in the description box below as well. Appreciate you coming on to
- 22:44speak about the ICP ecosystem, about bitcoin ordinals. I think this is going
- 22:49to be huge moving forward. It's just a matter of when. So it's
- 22:52good to learn about it now. So thank you so much, and let's
- 22:55follow up in the near future. Yeah, thanks for having me Ashton