Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The World According to Irina Tsukerman: India, USA, China, Russia, Gaza War & More
Transcript
- 0:21Welcome to the one more episode of The World According to Irina
- 0:25Superman, our very special series on global politics on the
- 0:29KJ Master class live Irina Superman.
- 0:31As you can see, she's on the screen.
- 0:33She's AUS based national security and human rights lawyer
- 0:37as well as a renowned geopolitical analyst.
- 0:40Her writings and commentary have appeared in diverse US and
- 0:43international media and have been translated to over a dozen
- 0:47languages every fortnight in the world according to Irena
- 0:50Shukerman. We traversed the geopolitical
- 0:53landscape and delve into pressing international issues
- 0:57and gain insight from Arena's expert perspective.
- 1:01Welcome to the show once again, IRENA.
- 1:05Thank you so much and I'm happy to be back again.
- 1:09Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:10Several big topics today, Irina. A lot of happened in the last
- 1:15few days, two weeks, so let's take them one by one this time.
- 1:19Let's start with II. US 2 + 2 dialogue recently
- 1:24happened. Let's touch upon that.
- 1:30Indeed, it has been so far the biggest and most important one
- 1:34out of the series that US and India have been conducting over
- 1:40the past several years. There are also other countries
- 1:42and they're also new new new countries joining into this
- 1:46format including UK 2 + 2 means essentially 2 counterparts from
- 1:54each country meeting to discuss foreign policy defence
- 1:56relations. Commerce, economy and other
- 1:59issues. And this time, US and India
- 2:03touched on such important issues as critical minerals, cutting
- 2:08the exchange in cutting edge technologies that is actually
- 2:14progressing and moving forward cooperation on issues such as
- 2:19student visas for Indian nationals coming to the United
- 2:23States. And also issues that issues
- 2:27related to Indo Pacific security as well as concerns and
- 2:32differences over matter such as Indian relations with Russia and
- 2:37Indian Russian defence relations, the arms situation
- 2:41why India cannot simply drop it as a partner.
- 2:46So all of these things came to the surface and it was a very
- 2:51fruitful and important discussion and hopefully the
- 2:54next step will be the continuity of building on this relations,
- 2:59building on on cooperation, and one of the most important
- 3:03outcomes from an economic perspective is the discussion of
- 3:08joint development and not merely production or trade of various.
- 3:16Technologies and elements that we were talking about.
- 3:18So we are seeing more integrated levels of Economic Cooperation,
- 3:26right? Right, Edena, this is this was
- 3:29the 5th, you know, US India 2 + 2 ministerial dialogue.
- 3:35So where are we heading towards this sort of, you know,
- 3:40arrangement between the two countries?
- 3:42Are there challenges? Also differences also that they
- 3:46have not been able to look towards a very intently and that
- 3:51needs to be taken care of? I think the biggest issue is the
- 3:57issue of trust building. I wouldn't say it's so much a
- 4:00challenge in the sense that it's you know that there's some
- 4:04hostility that Mister will come. It's the fact that the
- 4:08relationship has built being building relatively recently in
- 4:12in, but at a very quick phase phase.
- 4:15So with certain issues there, it's just a matter of time and
- 4:19it's going to take. Time to build up these
- 4:22relations, for instance, in the area of security cooperation, in
- 4:26the area of arm straight US. Obviously, once we get to move
- 4:32away from dependency of Russian on Russian weapons, that's a
- 4:35critical. The issue.
- 4:37But the problem is, of course, India's relationship with Russia
- 4:41has been very long standing, historic and logistically
- 4:45speaking, it is not an easy thing to do because Russia
- 4:48actually controls some of the technologies that that are
- 4:53critical to India's infrastructure.
- 4:56India has also been looking to develop its own industry.
- 4:59It has been diversifying. It's technologies buying more
- 5:05from from France, from Israel and other countries.
- 5:09US will probably want to eventually transition into
- 5:13selling more of its technologies and more of its arms to India.
- 5:17But this is the trust part that I am talking about.
- 5:20I think this is the main obstacle to why do sales have
- 5:24not happened yet? I think it will take time before
- 5:27US is ready to sell some of its more advanced.
- 5:32Weapons to India. And of course, the question is
- 5:35whether the chicken or the egg should come first, whether India
- 5:39should first move away from working with Russia.
- 5:43Or for the OR the US should first sell of its technologies.
- 5:49It's a it's a complicated situation because of course
- 5:52there is concern about American weapons from into their own
- 5:55hands. On the other hand, India cannot
- 5:58do that some of the those critical weapons.
- 6:01So I think US is simply waiting until India gets enough weapons
- 6:06from other Western countries or other allied countries.
- 6:10It is no longer quite as dependent and then US can
- 6:13compliment them and start providing more advanced
- 6:17technologies. I think that is the main right
- 6:19now concern. There is also the fact that the
- 6:23India in general is moving away economically from China.
- 6:27But it also takes time to decouple.
- 6:30Gestures is it will take us to decouple probably decades, not
- 6:35not years, it's a matter of decades.
- 6:38But there is an interest in. Helping move that forward
- 6:41because India is becoming a very welcome destination for American
- 6:45industry and there is hope that the that this business friendly
- 6:50environment will accelerate and become faster integrated with US
- 6:55businesses over time as well. Again, this is not so much an
- 6:59obstacle or challenge, but it's just also a mental matter of
- 7:04building up capacity and simply. Is a matter of moving in the
- 7:09right direction over time, right, right.
- 7:12You know, you see India has a lot of this 2 + 2 ministerial
- 7:16dialogues including Russia, Australia, we had just recently
- 7:20had that meeting. We already have one with Japan,
- 7:24we have got with the UK. So the world is moving more
- 7:27towards 1 to one talks though in the 2 + 2 format and rather than
- 7:32talking less at the international level.
- 7:36So is it the norm that is going to be happening globally much
- 7:40more and and how does this is is different than the other formats
- 7:45it means the global all these big forums will actually you
- 7:48know there will be only much more for optics and less for
- 7:52actual talks. More talks will happen globally
- 7:55in this format. What is what is your
- 7:58understanding of this? I just want to understand, you
- 8:00know, the way global diplomacy will move forward with this sort
- 8:04of dialogues? Well, to be honest, I think we
- 8:09are going through phases. I think there are periods of
- 8:13time and a lot of it depends on who is in, who is in power in
- 8:18any given country, particularly in the US but also elsewhere.
- 8:22And there are different vast differences in preferences among
- 8:26administrations. The Obama administration was
- 8:29very much in favour of Big. Format the Trump administration
- 8:32was not. The Biden administration was
- 8:35very much initially in favor of the diplomacy, but the
- 8:40polarization and the various conflicts created a lot of
- 8:44differences in among even NATO countries, much less anyone
- 8:48else. There's been a building up of
- 8:51new alliances and I think they discovered that logistically
- 8:54speaking, smaller groups of countries and one and bilateral
- 8:58relations just make it easier to work out individual differences
- 9:02and to come to arrangements that faster.
- 9:05However, it is inevitable that some forms of.
- 9:10Multilateral discussions will stay.
- 9:13The court, for instance, is a welcome format because you do
- 9:16need groups of countries coordinating among themselves
- 9:19against common threats and in favour of Commons problem
- 9:24solving. But of course, I think the
- 9:26future is kind of in smaller regional alliances rather than
- 9:32huge. Huge alliances.
- 9:35I don't think very big groups of countries talking to this is
- 9:38efficient. I think there are too many
- 9:40divergent interests and problems and issues and it's just very
- 9:43difficult to coordinate. So I think most likely the
- 9:47future is going to be a mixture of bilateral and small
- 9:51multilateral gatherings bilaterals to coordinate
- 9:54individual. Relations and to work out those
- 9:57separate conversations that you need to have privately
- 10:00one-on-one and multilateral to small multilateral to coordinate
- 10:05in a flexible format and the issues that are joined of joint
- 10:12common interest and they are going to be based on common
- 10:16interest more and less or just strictly geographical locations
- 10:20and. And in all sorts of previous
- 10:26criteria, they didn't really make much sense.
- 10:30Absolutely, absolutely. And now let's move on to the
- 10:33Gaza. What is happening there means I
- 10:36just read statements from both the parties and both our parties
- 10:41we are reaching towards a solute towards some sort of, you know,
- 10:44ceasefire or whatever they want to call it, some agreement about
- 10:47hostage release. Palestinians under, you know
- 10:50even and even Israeli leadership and Hamas leadership, they both
- 10:54have come out with the with some positive statement about this.
- 10:58Then what was this all war about?
- 11:01What is that that they have gotten now?
- 11:03What is it that they have achieved now after the loss of
- 11:07so many lives? What did this, all this
- 11:10brinksmanship you know, lead to this?
- 11:12Why couldn't they have talked to you from an outsiders
- 11:14perspective? Why couldn't they talk earlier
- 11:18on? What?
- 11:18What stops them to find a permanent solution to these
- 11:21things, you know, or is it? Is it after this again they will
- 11:25go back to fighting. You know that after these great
- 11:27talks and great statements I am, I want to understand for a lot
- 11:31of people in the in this part of the world wondering what is
- 11:35happening. You know, suddenly all these
- 11:36fights and suddenly all these talk of some breakthrough.
- 11:42Well, first of all, I think Israel made it clear that the
- 11:46release of prisoners is not, is not going to put an end to the
- 11:52hostilities because Israel's military have not been met yet.
- 12:05Stop Israel's Iran proxies are still coordinating and attacking
- 12:09Israeli targets. And the Hamas leadership has not
- 12:13been eliminated. They've killed a number of
- 12:16commanders and they've eliminated a lot of foot
- 12:19soldiers in their infrastructure, but not nearly
- 12:22all of the tunnels and not any of the leading heads of heads of
- 12:26this, of these separations and attacks.
- 12:29So that is bound to continue. This particular force is only to
- 12:32give relief to some of the most vulnerable vulnerable.
- 12:41Hostages, women and children. Hamas has been playing games the
- 12:46entire time. Every day there's a new
- 12:48condition and this four day pause will also for that.
- 12:52For that, from their perspective, is a huge victory
- 12:55because they will be, despite the fact that they abducted all
- 12:59these innocent people, they will still come out looking like
- 13:02heroes for releasing them and for getting some of their own
- 13:05people back. And their own people are all
- 13:07violent prisoners. Including women and underage
- 13:11minors. They've all been convicted of
- 13:13crimes of terrorism. These are not innocent people
- 13:16that Israel abducted of the street in Gaza at all.
- 13:19These were people who tried to kill Israelis and then try to
- 13:23commit terrorist attacks. So Hamas will look great.
- 13:28They will. They're counting on this to
- 13:31essentially gain even more support around the world.
- 13:35They. One of the conditions is a four
- 13:38day ceasefire, but Hamas has traditionally not been trusted
- 13:44with this at all and it will also allow their leaders to
- 13:47relocate from their from their targeted areas of attack in the
- 13:52north to the South through the tunnels and keep them under they
- 13:57from from away from danger zone and help them relocate among
- 14:02the. ID PS And Gaza residents who
- 14:06reside in this S another issue is that this will allow the one
- 14:12of the conditions was that Israel will will bring 350
- 14:16trucks of eight a day. Now it seems like a noble
- 14:20gesture that everybody wouldn't win for everyone and not.
- 14:23But let's recall what happened when Israel gave just a couple
- 14:26of trucks of fuel that was supposed to go to civilians
- 14:30whose fuel was stolen by Hamas. Immediately the level of rocket
- 14:35attacks was increased against Israel because Hamas simply
- 14:39confiscated the fuel for the war effort and nothing has changed.
- 14:43It did not go to the hospitals. The children in this hospital
- 14:47still had to be evacuated and normal function was not resumed
- 14:51because because Hamas quite simply lies to the population it
- 14:57it doesn't do not tell, inform everyone that killed.
- 15:01Civilians in Israel. It claimed that Israel killed
- 15:04its own civilians and it's also lied to them and said that this
- 15:08is already happening. But of course Israel just
- 15:10decided to invade Gaza out of the blue and that they are
- 15:15defending Gaza from these foreign invaders.
- 15:18And according to the poor, 74% of the civilian population in
- 15:23Gaza want Israel to be destroyed as a state that many of them
- 15:28don't like Hamas. They find it.
- 15:30It's corrupt. It's mismanage, mismanaging the
- 15:34situation economically. It's cruel to them.
- 15:37But they hate Israel more. So this, this situation is by no
- 15:42means a victory for Israel. It's no, it's nothing to
- 15:45celebrate because Israel is not getting all of its all of its
- 15:49people back. And it's being seen as an equal
- 15:54exchange instead of an unconditional release of people
- 15:57abducted by a terrorist organization.
- 16:00So it is giving Hamas a level of legitimacy not only for its own
- 16:04people, but international, international community.
- 16:07And yes, people are asking, well, what's it all about?
- 16:10If this is what they could have done a month ago, the the
- 16:13problem is they couldn't because.
- 16:14Hamas would not agree to anything remotely reasonably.
- 16:17We're asking for impossible things.
- 16:19And 2nd, it's not, you know, there's Israel is facing a lot
- 16:23of pressure from the families, from the United States, from the
- 16:26international community. Let's try to get these innocent
- 16:30people as quickly as possible to prevent them from getting killed
- 16:34during the course of operation while also pursuing the defense
- 16:39of its security, the defense of its borders.
- 16:41It's. An extremely complicated
- 16:43situation, and while I think it's, you know, having saving
- 16:48lives is extremely important and it should be absolutely pursued
- 16:55in in any reasonable manner. We should not be celebrating
- 16:59Hamas. It's not doing anything heroic.
- 17:01It shouldn't. It shouldn't have happened to
- 17:03begin with. There shouldn't have been any
- 17:05people to release because it shouldn't be abducting people
- 17:08over the streets at all, right. Right, Arena, let's look at it
- 17:14from three points of view. You want one is that you know,
- 17:17Israel, if I understand military personnel will not be released.
- 17:21So in a staggered manner, whatever the terms of agreement
- 17:24is, some something will happens. Hostages will get released from
- 17:29both sides. Some, you know, prisoners from
- 17:31the Palestinian prisoners from the Israeli, Israeli side, they
- 17:34will be released and hostages will release on in a staggered
- 17:37manner, if I understand, but no military personnel.
- 17:40So who gets what here in terms of what does Hamas get about?
- 17:45What does Israel get after this and what does the world get out
- 17:50after this? Can they all the politics, other
- 17:52international players who have been speaking about it, US,
- 17:55Europe and other players also? What do they get?
- 17:58Can the world, these people, rest easy and get back to their
- 18:01work? Can the people can people like
- 18:04me or not like me? In Israel is the world, how do
- 18:08we understand of this? Can we think one crisis is over
- 18:11or will it be again back to the same things after all these
- 18:15hostages are released? Because military personnel will
- 18:17still be under, you know, under being hostage.
- 18:25Well, first of all, Israel is only getting about 50, three
- 18:30women and children back and they are not getting all these people
- 18:34back at the same time. It's supposed to come in phases
- 18:38and we you know how much has the history of lying and and playing
- 18:42games. So I wouldn't hold my breath to
- 18:45for things to work hard exactly as they arranged at the moment
- 18:49because they've come close to agreements previously and then
- 18:53nothing happened. So I'm not I'm not really sure
- 18:57that it will work out the way it's predicted.
- 18:59I hope that it will, but we don't know until it's until
- 19:04until it actually happens and. I I, you know, between the
- 19:09exchange, the exchange is supposed to start on Thursday,
- 19:13so there's a whole day for something to go terribly wrong,
- 19:16either intentionally or by accident.
- 19:19The other issue that's of grave concern in Scatter's role in all
- 19:22of this, they could have data means fund one of the main
- 19:26funders of Hamas. They could have led to this
- 19:29exact results a month ago. A few days after the operation,
- 19:35in the beginning they could have just said Hamas to release all
- 19:39these people because Israel is not going to stop.
- 19:42But they played alone and as a result, all these people were
- 19:45suffering and several people that, you know, got killed in
- 19:48the process and their bodies were found.
- 19:51So they are getting credit completely and undeservedly for
- 19:56this operation that they prolonged.
- 19:59Without using the leverage that they could have in a literal
- 20:02playing with Hamas games. So no, this is not over.
- 20:07The negotiations over the military personnel will continue
- 20:11even if this exchange is actually successful.
- 20:15The DO the prisoners that Israel is releasing will probably go
- 20:20back to the field and they will probably be assisting Hamas in
- 20:24their operations in attacking Israel.
- 20:27Hamas even now is trying to infiltrate different points in
- 20:31Israel and to exploit border security issues.
- 20:35So they're not actually stopping and they've actually said on
- 20:38record that they will try. If they have an opportunity,
- 20:41they will try to do the same thing again.
- 20:45And is also has no reason to to stop military operations.
- 20:49It just wants to get its innocent citizens back.
- 20:53And you know, and if it means releasing some of the less
- 20:57dangerous prisoners by comparison, so be it and giving
- 21:01a short pause because it probably at the end of the day
- 21:04not change all that much in the grand scheme of things.
- 21:09But but but it's not going to solve any of the long term
- 21:14security problems. Hamas still needs to be
- 21:17destroyed. It's as a military and a
- 21:19political organization, it is still extremely dangerous and it
- 21:23continues fighting. It has not stopped firing, It
- 21:26has not stopped exploiting. And by the way, just because
- 21:30there is a ceasefire with Hamas doesn't mean that there is a
- 21:34ceasefire with Hezbollah, which has been ramping up its
- 21:37operations. All the cookies that just
- 21:39hijacked the A ship, or for that matter with Iraqi and Syria
- 21:46militias who are continuing to attack U.S. troops in the
- 21:50region. So there's no ceasefire with any
- 21:52of those groups. So the war is not, not, not
- 21:55anywhere over. Right, right.
- 22:00Let's move on from this, from the Gaza war to the to the
- 22:05Ukraine, Russia war. What is happening there?
- 22:09What? Because lots of reports are
- 22:11there, it will that US will not be provided but more aid to
- 22:16Ukraine and. Ukraine There are reports that
- 22:19Ukraine has gained some ground. Help us understand what exactly
- 22:23is happening in this war in another region.
- 22:33So far there is There's reports that Ukraine and aid will resume
- 22:39once the Republicans settle on the final budget towards the end
- 22:43of the year, which they have to they need to come up with the
- 22:45budget for the next year or go into shutdown the same.
- 22:50There's also an issue with A to Israel, which has been
- 22:53conditioned on the budget cuts from them, from the US tax
- 22:58agency. The IRS and the publicans are
- 23:02facing increasing discontent over that the Israelis need
- 23:07weapons they need to recharge and other of their defense
- 23:14systems. So this has been a growing
- 23:16problem so far. US is still providing both
- 23:19Ukraine and Israel with those weapons that have been in the
- 23:23pipeline and whatever. And the US of course has a put
- 23:27the aid that it's expecting to share as close as possible to
- 23:31delivery points near Ukraine. So the moment it's has approved,
- 23:36it is good to go. It's not with the old aid that
- 23:39has been previously approved, but with new packages, and the
- 23:43US is pushing for additional new packages, including $100 million
- 23:47package for Ukraine. Meanwhile, on the ground,
- 23:50Russia's for the past two weeks has focused its combat effort on
- 23:54Bahamut, which is not all that strategically important.
- 23:57But it seems to be a psychological point for Russia
- 24:02and Ukraine has changed its strategy.
- 24:04It's counter offensive is ramping up speed because there
- 24:07is a concern that the winter weather will make it very
- 24:10difficult to move forward. So it's looking to recapture as
- 24:13much territory as it can and has made progress to the tune of 42
- 24:18miles in just a few days, which is a big improvement over the
- 24:23previous issues. It is breaking to Russian
- 24:25defenses and it has destroyed a lot have Russian weapons with
- 24:31with Heimers with the American weapons which it has received
- 24:35relatively recently compared to the rest of their counter
- 24:38offensive in the preceding war. So this is not surprising.
- 24:41The more advanced weapons they receive the easier it will be to
- 24:45fight back. Russia has been scrambling to
- 24:47buy back old equipment from countries like Egypt and others
- 24:52where which it has sold to them in previous years.
- 24:55Now it's running out of weapons, so it's it's facing logistical
- 25:01difficulties. Right.
- 25:04Right. So let's keep on watching these
- 25:08two wars. One is the Middle East and one
- 25:10is the in in Russia and Ukraine war.
- 25:13Let's move on from here to to the US by.
- 25:17He had been meeting a lot of people including, you know,
- 25:21including. Xi Jinping and South Korea and
- 25:25Japan. So help us understand what what
- 25:28what is happening there? What does this meeting with all
- 25:32these top leaders, especially from the Indo Pacific region?
- 25:36What does all this all mean? Well, the biggest issue for for
- 25:41Biden was to try to settle things down with China and the
- 25:46general role of this trial act, this, this Tri factor of summits
- 25:51with Asian leaders, was to move some sort of a economic and
- 25:55security agreement forward. So far with China, that has been
- 26:02quite disappointing. Many people have criticized
- 26:05Biden for hanging over a military victory to China by
- 26:10unilaterally proposing this AI related limitation on forces and
- 26:19and so on nuclear and excluding AI from nuclear weapons
- 26:24development. China is very reluctant to enter
- 26:28such an agreement. So far it only has agreed to
- 26:31continue talking about this issue, which is not surprising
- 26:35because first of all, it has not been brought up previously.
- 26:39A second, there is an issue of trust and there's also an issue
- 26:43that you can't really check the other the other countries
- 26:48progress in that this whether they actually abiding with their
- 26:51commitment. So it's not really advantageous
- 26:54to China to commit to something like that.
- 26:56They can play this to appear conciliatory in agreeing to
- 27:02continue the discussions, but they do not necessarily agree to
- 27:07it. At the end of the day, they've
- 27:09agreed to discuss an issue related to fentanyl because
- 27:13China is a main export of fentanyl through the Mexican
- 27:16contestant to the US But again, what leverage does US have to
- 27:20check whether China is actually abiding by its commitments If
- 27:23the results are negative, China can always say that they tried,
- 27:27but they're failing and there's some things are just out of
- 27:29their control or that they're coming from some other
- 27:31direction. So I don't really see how such
- 27:36things are enforceable in terms of Economic Cooperation.
- 27:42There's been minor developments, but they're mostly advantageous
- 27:46to China. It has not committed to stopping
- 27:49the harassment of American companies.
- 27:51It certainly has not committed to any geopolitical major
- 27:54geopolitical breakthrough is concerned.
- 27:57It hasn't changed its position on Taiwan or the Indo Pacific.
- 28:02In fact, very close to the day of the summit, it basically
- 28:07attacked the Philippines with territorial claims it's looking
- 28:12to make halfway into towards Indonesia and elsewhere.
- 28:16And the this is all not a very good situation, to put it
- 28:19mildly. And USUS actually reiterated its
- 28:24commitment to A1 China policy, which in my opinion was a
- 28:28mistake to even word it that way, even if that's what the
- 28:31policy is, because that sort of language does not bring
- 28:37confidence to Taiwan. And actually a recent process
- 28:41showed that seven in 10 Taiwanese do not trust the
- 28:45United States. So US is not, is not gaining
- 28:48anything from that sort of rhetoric.
- 28:50China has not suddenly decided to become best friends and
- 28:54Taiwan now is losing trust. You, you need to US, needs to
- 28:58figure out what its position actually is and realize that
- 29:02these policies are mutually they're not usually compatible.
- 29:06Either it's going to record this, they won and fully
- 29:10bracket, or it has to give up completely.
- 29:13But then it will realize, it will have, it will have a cost
- 29:17in in this international standing.
- 29:19It wants to continue doing this business with China.
- 29:22It will never be able to do that as an equal partner because
- 29:26China simply does not view anybody as an equal partner
- 29:29including the United States. So that's simply a philosophical
- 29:34recognition of reality that US has to come to accept.
- 29:37Regarding South Korea and Japan, it's has been somewhat over
- 29:41downer because the main point of those meetings were economic.
- 29:45I mean no major breakthroughs for the US came out of them and
- 29:50I think there's a lot of distractions concerning security
- 29:55measures right now. North Korea just notified Japan
- 29:58about the launch of its new spy satellite.
- 30:03Unclear whether it was successful or not.
- 30:05Two previous attempts failed. But it's also not a great
- 30:09development because it's you know, North Korea is becoming
- 30:12more active again and nobody wants to see that.
- 30:17There's also an election coming up in Taiwan.
- 30:20The current administration is seeking to to return.
- 30:24They're much more aggressive. Although the vice president has
- 30:28strategically refrained from pushing for complete open
- 30:32independence, their opponents are much more conciliatory
- 30:36towards China, and they're looking to restart a dialogue
- 30:40with a China, so it's not clear Who Will Win.
- 30:43It looks like it might be the return of the incumbent
- 30:48administration because the mood in Taiwan is not particularly
- 30:51open to China. But we don't know.
- 30:53China is looking to avoid direct aggression.
- 30:56It's in their interest to back the opposition in Taiwan and to
- 31:01get what they want to get to peaceful and political rather
- 31:07than military means if possible. So I would not rule out some
- 31:11sort of a political meddling in the upcoming elections either.
- 31:17Right, right. I didn't.
- 31:19And one more thing. Why didn't Biden have to call
- 31:22the Chinese leadership a dictator?
- 31:25Because. It is happened.
- 31:26It happened several times and and and if it was a slip of, you
- 31:31know, tongue then it could be so.
- 31:33Is there a, is there a diplomatic sort of a thing that
- 31:37they want to achieve? Is there a different sort of a
- 31:40message that the US leadership want to pass?
- 31:44This cannot be a slip of tongue if it's happening again and
- 31:48again. Help us understand this part,
- 31:50especially when you have a leadership coming.
- 31:53To your place and you are trying to look at, you know, much more
- 31:56closer relationship between the two nations.
- 31:59How does this work? I want to understand this sort
- 32:02of diplomacy for a lot of people who are not diplomat general
- 32:06people, but who thought that, you know, there will be a much
- 32:09more cohesion between the two countries.
- 32:12I think that's meant to send a message of strength.
- 32:15And the fact that the US is realistic about who they're
- 32:18dealing with, especially since China is, remains uncompromising
- 32:22and main points of security interest to you, to the US.
- 32:28It has purged its own ranks. It has repeatedly, you know, did
- 32:33very odd things with its senior officials, foreign minister or
- 32:36defence minister. It's just been acting very
- 32:39erratically from the US perspective, and all of that
- 32:42seems to be some suit to the whim of one of the one leader
- 32:46who seems to be not listening to any criticism.
- 32:50And how how these actions are seen as destabilizing not just
- 32:53by the US but by the international community does not
- 32:57bode well when you have sudden changes in the cabinet for no
- 33:01reason, when people go missing for weeks at the time.
- 33:04And the explanations for all of that are very unclear.
- 33:10So, so I, I, I I think this message was to send the fact
- 33:15that the US is not being naive, especially since China is
- 33:18refusing to make any real serious concessions on any major
- 33:22issues to reevaluate its behavior.
- 33:25It will be treated as an authoritarian regime that is not
- 33:29following the will of its people or you know any sort of popular
- 33:33consensus of democratic norms. We'll be dealing with one guy
- 33:37who is calling the shots and it is what it is.
- 33:42Right, right. Let's move on from there to
- 33:45Bahrain. The Manama dialogue, what do we
- 33:48understand of this? It just concluded there, what
- 33:51are the gains or what are the challenges?
- 33:54What did we get out of this? For the world, normally, the
- 33:58purpose of the man of a dialogue was to bring Israelis,
- 34:01Palestinians and the Middle East community under the economic
- 34:06umbrella, to integrate them through economic and social
- 34:11rather than political means, and to move away from the
- 34:15politicization of the Palestinian issues.
- 34:18But this dialogue came at the time of war.
- 34:22There's no avoiding politics. There's no getting around it.
- 34:26And the big the big breaking news from the summit was when
- 34:30the Bahraini Crown Prince essentially condemned Hamas,
- 34:35while also calling and pushing for this hostage situation to be
- 34:40resolved by the means that we are seeing them being resolved
- 34:44as we speak. So he seemed to be on board with
- 34:47this plan that we're discussing. And he also made a very clear
- 34:51position of Bahrain regarding Hamas.
- 34:53And not for the first time previously, Bahrain issued both
- 34:59its own individual statement and a joint statement with the US
- 35:04condemning Hamas's actions and calling them barbaric and
- 35:08terrorists. And there was a backlash from
- 35:10Hamas which essentially insulted them and called them Arabs.
- 35:13And and it's a very clear message which is divergent from
- 35:19the entire Arab and Muslim community in many respects.
- 35:23I would say the closest to that is Egypt, which has avoided
- 35:28directly naming Israel in most recent comments by its minister.
- 35:33It has described the situation and the impact.
- 35:36It goes to Achiever the results it is looking for.
- 35:40But it has refrained from individually attacking Israel by
- 35:44name. So Bahrain is very much in that
- 35:46same line. And that is nice in sharp
- 35:49contrast with many of the other GCC and Middle Eastern and
- 35:54otherwise Islamic governments which have been repeatedly
- 35:58attacking Israel, calling not just for this temporary
- 36:02ceasefire or hostage exchange, but for a complete end of the
- 36:06war, and have now collectively have gone to employ China at the
- 36:11BRICS summit in South Africa specifically for that purpose.
- 36:15They've also been calls for, for embargo, for for, for an end to
- 36:22arms at that Brooks Summit and and so forth.
- 36:25That is actually a meaningless comment because Israel does not
- 36:30import weapons from most of the international community.
- 36:34Mostly it gets its weapons from from the United States.
- 36:38Several European countries that are close allies in are not
- 36:42likely to listen to that sort of rhetoric to begin with.
- 36:44So it was a kind of a Middle Eastern virtue signaling to say
- 36:49to express symbolic outreach without having to actually do
- 36:53anything that would harm their own interests.
- 36:56That's that's what they're saying.
- 36:58So Bahrain took a very clear moral position and I think that
- 37:01will send a message where it stands, particularly to the
- 37:05United States, not just to Israel and to other countries.
- 37:09I think Bahrain is very much aligning itself with the Western
- 37:13camp in that regard and I think that will be duly noted.
- 37:18Right, right. Serena, a lot of talk, a lot of
- 37:22meetings over Middle East crisis.
- 37:25A lot of talk also happened on Ukraine.
- 37:28Still happening. But on the Sudan conflict,
- 37:31everyone, the international community is silent.
- 37:35You know, 800 Sudanese civilians.
- 37:37Butchered. Why is it so?
- 37:39What is happening in Sudan or a person outside?
- 37:43Are they who who want to understand why killing?
- 37:48Who are the bad guys? Who are the good guys?
- 37:50Where do they want to go with whatever they are doing?
- 37:55Unfortunately, they're not real, real good guys in Sudan war
- 38:00other than the civilians who are being butchered.
- 38:03Because what we're seeing is a war between 2:00.
- 38:08Two generals, one from the secular but very black.
- 38:13They're see Janjaweed, the Rapid Support Forces that were
- 38:18introduced as a militia to take care of the government's jerky
- 38:21work in the past. And they're efficient, they're
- 38:25good at what they do, better than the military, But they are
- 38:28also completely ruthless and immoral.
- 38:32And they work with back there. They work with several other
- 38:35with UE and after for reasons of very just one issue, interest by
- 38:42those countries, you know, they're completely pragmatic
- 38:46considerations. These are not real.
- 38:48For fresh alliances SA of the government military, IS has
- 38:54included a lot of the old Bashir Islamist bodies, even though it
- 38:59did not start out that way. The whole point of the rule, the
- 39:03coup, the revolution, the uprising was to put an end to
- 39:06Bashir and his complete, overreaching human rights
- 39:09abuses. They're not respectful of human
- 39:12rights either. These two groups are divided by
- 39:15curatorial and tribal loyalties. There's also the resentment from
- 39:20the Western Sudanese, therefore reaching Arab militias and other
- 39:26groups comprising the RSF loyalists at the fact that
- 39:32they've been used for years by the Eastern military and they
- 39:36have just now. They're looking to to gain power
- 39:39and they're actually moving forward rather quickly, not as
- 39:44quickly as one would scope. It will take some time, but they
- 39:46are making gains. Surprisingly, the army has
- 39:50superior means. They have more backing, more
- 39:53funding, somewhat more international legitimacy, and
- 39:56they have better weapons. But our self has just better
- 40:02fighters who have more experience in Libya, in Yemen
- 40:06and other places, and they've got a flow of mercenaries and
- 40:10assorted foreign fighters from Chad and other nearby countries.
- 40:13So this is just. It's it's going in that
- 40:20direction. Where it will end is unclear.
- 40:24Probably not. Not.
- 40:26Not anytime soon because both parties are being funded and
- 40:29they're being backed by various different states.
- 40:34But in the meantime, it's created a huge humanitarian
- 40:38disaster that people literally starving there.
- 40:42There's been a displacement of 10 million Sudanese civilians.
- 40:46Communitarian aid is not reaching people.
- 40:48There's also skirmishes with S South Sudan over disputed
- 40:54territories and oil. So it's a it's a complete mess,
- 40:58but it's does not so far have a much wider regional or
- 41:03international impact compared to for instance, Israel, Gaza war
- 41:08or Ukraine and Russia. They don't have major economic
- 41:14or international investments or or influences for that reason.
- 41:20It's just simply taking a back burner compared to those two
- 41:24other conflicts that just have more stakeholders who are more
- 41:28active and are more interested. And there's more impact over
- 41:33military impact, trade impact, economic impact, social impact
- 41:39from and more money for companies and media and more
- 41:44people directly affected internationally.
- 41:48So unfortunately it's being ignored.
- 41:50There's no real policy by anybody in the US There's also
- 41:55no real policy because there's just not enough resources and
- 42:02pressuring the other geopolitical actors who are
- 42:07fueling those the conflict with the additional weapons and
- 42:11provisions could backfire because then those actors will
- 42:16not be cooperative in other matters that the higher priority
- 42:19for the US So we're seeing a very tragic situation.
- 42:23Unfortunately, that is, you know, that we are distracted
- 42:27from. It's not getting enough
- 42:28coverage, it's not getting enough support, it's not and
- 42:31it's no less tragic than what's happening in Gaza.
- 42:37There are more people affected, actually significantly more.
- 42:41It's 45 million people in in a very vast territory.
- 42:44But because of the way things are, people are just not that
- 42:47interested. Right, right.
- 42:50Very unfortunate. Hope you know these sort of
- 42:53things get equal attention and this gets sorted.
- 42:56This is not good from any any way you you see it, any conflict
- 43:01is it? In my personal opinion, I don't
- 43:04really like to see any bloodbath happening, but then that is all
- 43:07a utopian idea. Let's move away from the utopian
- 43:10idea to the real ground world. And there it is, former Russian
- 43:14general Smiri Dog. He's been found dead.
- 43:18Mysterious circumstances. Along with the lady, I don't
- 43:21know. People call that it was his
- 43:23wife. I'm not sure you'll be able to
- 43:25tell why this killing? Why not?
- 43:27Why now? What is happening?
- 43:29You know what what what? What is this all about?
- 43:32Anyone. He was.
- 43:33See, he's he's he I guess criticized Russian President
- 43:38Putin some time back. So is it related to that?
- 43:41That's not not where it is mentioned.
- 43:43Help us understand this. Yes, he has been critical of
- 43:47Russia's strategy in Ukraine. He basically regards this whole
- 43:52idea and the way it was executed as a complete failure.
- 43:57Not because he's such a humanitarian, but he just
- 44:00doesn't believe it was well executed or sort out.
- 44:03And he thought it was a complete disaster for the Russian
- 44:06military forces. And the payback came in time.
- 44:10He was first removed from power, but it was not sufficient.
- 44:15We have seen dozens and dozens of mysterious deaths of close
- 44:20Putin associates and former friends and allies, including
- 44:23some who have been critical of at various points in time of the
- 44:28decision making process regarding the war in Ukraine.
- 44:31And a variety of people ranging from doctors in provinces to
- 44:39Blue Coil and other energy executives to generals in the
- 44:44military, other military personnel ended up meeting the
- 44:48deaths in the way that, you know, clearly indicates untimely
- 44:53demise, not from natural causes. So it's very clearly an
- 44:59intimidation tactic and approach by Putin and his close
- 45:03associates to to prevent any sort of criticism or
- 45:06disagreement with his action. And of course the downside or
- 45:10that, besides apparent obvious ruthless authoritarianism, is
- 45:15that anyone who's professional, who can give good advice, gets
- 45:21removed permanently. And therefore Putin and his
- 45:26closer crew end up being surrounded by yes men who only
- 45:33capable of supporting whatever crazy idea that comes to to
- 45:37their heads. And that does not bode well for
- 45:40the success of anything over any endeavours.
- 45:43You know, from that side. It never works well.
- 45:46This is what Stalin used to do. It ended up bringing him into
- 45:50World War 2 because he disregarded the intelligence and
- 45:53then he disregarded advice from many people.
- 45:57And it turns up when the more authoritarian somebody is, the
- 46:01less inclined there to listen to criticism.
- 46:04They see it as a form of disloyalty and betrayal.
- 46:07They become paranoid that any sort of response, positive
- 46:11response to criticism could make them look weak and they end up
- 46:18ultimately shooting themselves in the foot, which is I think
- 46:21very much the direction Russia is going through right now.
- 46:25Right, right. Thank you for your perspective
- 46:28on that. RINA Now let's move on to this
- 46:3157 attacks on U.S. forces in Iraq and Syria by Iraq forces.
- 46:37What? What?
- 46:38What does this mean with little response?
- 46:41Is US US now becoming much more nonviolent or something?
- 46:45Help us understand why these attacks and why the US, You
- 46:49know, with little response. Well, it's actually been already
- 46:55over 60 attacks between October summit and now and there's been
- 47:01over you know, over 100 and 100 plus this year aside from that.
- 47:12But this period has been very intense finally you know and
- 47:16there's been many many injuries and there even deaths among his
- 47:20personnel. Finally after the latest attack
- 47:25today US finally responded with the with the deadly blow to some
- 47:30of the Iran backed groups. Whether that will finally put an
- 47:34end to these attacks remains to be seen but this is but there
- 47:38has been actually a very polarized response within the
- 47:43Biden administration as to what to do earlier.
- 47:47A number of these antiques have been put on the sanctions list.
- 47:51To be honest, I'm not entirely sure what that does because most
- 47:54of them will never travel to the United States and I doubt that
- 47:58they have assets either in the US or in any western country.
- 48:01They probably all their all their money is probably in some
- 48:07non western banking systems. So I don't know whether
- 48:11sanctioning them is anything more than a symbolic response,
- 48:14but there's been a great deal of internal disagreement over
- 48:17whether to respond and risk escalation and also what kind of
- 48:23a signal that will send to Iran because he is still trying to
- 48:27pursue some sort of an agreement.
- 48:29I'm not entirely sure about what at this point, but others
- 48:33believed that we need some level of deterrence because otherwise
- 48:37it will just keep happening. So finally, after you know, this
- 48:42latest and very brazen attack, I think that that faction won out
- 48:48and we will see if there's going to be, if that will put an end
- 48:52to things. Because up until now the only
- 48:54responses were attacks on empty warehouses in Syria, which
- 48:58certainly didn't do anything either in Syria or in Iraq.
- 49:01It did not prevent further escalation.
- 49:05Right, right. Let's look at, you know, the US
- 49:08China relationship, not from the business perspective.
- 49:11Also you know China has received.
- 49:14US equipment to make chips despite restrictions and So what
- 49:18does that mean for the semiconductor wars?
- 49:20And also let's, when we are talking of China, China's plans
- 49:24for Navy base in Oman that has come out.
- 49:27So what has, what does that mean in terms of geopolitics,
- 49:31navigation in the Middle East? Let's touch these two topics
- 49:35here. The China has been making
- 49:41breakthroughs with the chip production domestically, not as
- 49:45quickly as it could with the full corporation, but it it has,
- 49:49it has personnel that's trained in that production, it has the
- 49:54elements, the raw materials necessary for production.
- 49:57It has stolen a great deal of technology and it has previously
- 50:02cooperated with other countries and you it was frozen out.
- 50:06And by the way, these restrictions were not 100%
- 50:09complete and they were also gradual.
- 50:11So none of that came at the same time.
- 50:15Now we're seeing that some countries are essentially
- 50:18circumventing sanctions and providing China with what it
- 50:22needs to continue the production and it's been making some
- 50:26progress. It still needs some of the most
- 50:29advanced know how. I think it's trying to
- 50:32infiltrate the industries outside its own borders where
- 50:36that is possible. But for now, it will take
- 50:39whatever it can get and try to use it against the West.
- 50:43And I think that's why US and other partners should be much
- 50:48more aggressive in ensuring that none of this equipment makes its
- 50:52way to China and penalizing companies or individuals who are
- 50:58involved in this sort of smuggling.
- 51:00When it comes to the base, astonishingly enough China has
- 51:06already completed the agreement towards the building of that
- 51:10base in Amman, which puts it in a very sensitive position with
- 51:15respect to Red Sea security. The strategically important
- 51:18Strait of Hormuz where 1/5 of international oil and gates
- 51:23trade passes and bubble bubble mandeb, another sensitive area
- 51:30which is a very narrow Strait where cookies have been
- 51:34abducting and attacking ships. So having China with this access
- 51:40to the Middle East, right where the US base is located, right
- 51:43where many international western navies have have put their
- 51:52forces is creating a very, very explosive, problematic
- 51:57situation. The fact that the US has only
- 52:00been informed about it recently and have taken no action to
- 52:05disrupt this process by putting pressure on the Mon to prevent
- 52:10them from this agreement that it speaks does not speak well for
- 52:15the US political well, will or whatever.
- 52:18Whatever caused this process to happen.
- 52:21Previously when China was planning a second military naval
- 52:25base in Africa after Djibouti, US was able to disrupt this
- 52:30process by putting pressure on the relevant countries.
- 52:32The fact that they were not able or willing to do so in this case
- 52:38shows that the US political influence in the Middle East is
- 52:43waning and we are facing a very dangerous situation.
- 52:48Right, right. Let's move on to India once
- 52:52again about this diplomat. Report mysterious death of
- 52:56accused Kalistani extremists. So it's talking about an
- 52:59assassination, allegedly an assassination, you know,
- 53:03program. How do you see that?
- 53:05What is this report about? What?
- 53:08Why? Why do they think India will
- 53:10have some sort of a program like this?
- 53:13What is your understanding of this whole report?
- 53:18Well, the report talks about a number of Palestinian terrorists
- 53:22around the world, not just the guy who was who met his end in
- 53:27Canada and caused this whole uproar between India and Canada.
- 53:31But apparently a number of such people from these networks have
- 53:35been found dead under strange circumstances in other
- 53:38countries, which presumes that somebody that they didn't all
- 53:42die coincidentally of natural causes, that they haven't all
- 53:46contracted some pandemic, but that somebody has been killing
- 53:50them and who who would have an interest in their deaths if not?
- 53:53It's a logical conclusion, and it's also logical to conclude
- 53:57that most intelligence Jesus around the world may or may not
- 54:02have a formal assassination program, but they're certainly
- 54:06willing to take actions when they feel that they're when
- 54:09there's a cause for that, there is some sort of a security issue
- 54:12and somebody needs to be eliminated.
- 54:14So I don't know whether India has a formal program of that
- 54:17sort or not. I do think that they may find it
- 54:20in the interest to go after people who caused them problems
- 54:25if the countries in question are not willing to cooperate in in
- 54:34in the legal in basically deporting them by legal means or
- 54:41going through other legal forms of cooperation to to put any
- 54:45anyone involved in extremism on trial.
- 54:48So on the one hand that expedites the problem and you
- 54:54don't have to deal with decades of hearings in in Canada.
- 54:58Over on the other hand, you know country that can cause
- 55:02additional conflicts over sovereignty issues.
- 55:06It's certainly you should be the one that end up in a situation
- 55:10where that's just a norm to assassinate anyone suspected
- 55:14extremism because frankly, you could get the wrong person,
- 55:18somebody there, you know somebody could be mistaken,
- 55:25somebody could be set up or framed by their colleagues and
- 55:29not actually be presenting a danger it.
- 55:32And it could also invite reciprocal assassinations of
- 55:37your own, of your own personnel by the other side or by
- 55:41somebody, some other third party.
- 55:43So that's obviously not an ideal scene scenario, but let's look
- 55:46at, let's zoom out from whether or not these people are actually
- 55:50being assassinated and by India or by some guns for hire or
- 55:53whoever. And look, let's look what's
- 55:56actually going on. What's actually going on is that
- 55:59the situation is actually the situation with Palestine, and
- 56:02extremism has been spiraling out of control for years.
- 56:07Conventional means of dealing with it internally have
- 56:10apparently failed because a lot of the masterminds do seem to
- 56:13reside. Just like Hamas operatives who
- 56:17are pulling, calling the shot in Gaza have reside outside Gaza,
- 56:22they reside in Turkey and Qatar. And what did Prime Minister
- 56:25Netanyahu say at the recent hearing in?
- 56:28In my opinion, he should have said it out loud, but that his
- 56:32position was clear that anyone who resides anywhere and is
- 56:36connected to Hamas will be eliminated, whether they're in
- 56:41Qatar or somewhere else. So this is a Prime Minister of a
- 56:45country openly acknowledging their course of action once they
- 56:48have decided that Hamas needs to be eliminated as an
- 56:51organization. And if India is taking a similar
- 56:54position regarding Harvestan and and considers that particular
- 56:59network of operatives of a comparable of comparable threat
- 57:03as what Hamas presents to Israel, can people really blame
- 57:06them if they need the same type of.
- 57:08And now whether or not Halston is comparable to Hamas is
- 57:13another discussion. I think.
- 57:15I think it is worthy discussion understanding who they are, how
- 57:21they operate and whether they can be reasoned with by any
- 57:23other means. But if in theory if they are in
- 57:27fact comparable to Hamas and and they end up getting killed in
- 57:31the process and other countries do nothing to put an end to the
- 57:34activity and harbor them knowing that they are planning
- 57:37operations in India, I really think we can't blame India too
- 57:42much if they do undertake such action any more than anyone can
- 57:46can blame Israel if they do go after terrorists somewhere else.
- 57:52Absolutely, 11 more. Thing, you know, I wanted to
- 57:54understand, curious to understand is there was already
- 57:57a war of words between India and Canada over the allegations that
- 58:01they made earlier on. So what?
- 58:03And then they quoted the five and then they have.
- 58:05So why? Why have they not come out with
- 58:07more? You know so-called evidence.
- 58:10Again, in the other cases, did Diplomat mentioned anything
- 58:15about any other evidence that they have that these people may
- 58:19have had if they are alleging or or this sort of a story is
- 58:23coming out in the open. Quite simply, this is an
- 58:26embarrassing situation for everybody, I think.
- 58:30I think if they did have, even if they did have such evidence,
- 58:35I think it's customary not to reveal that if depending on what
- 58:38methods were used to detect what happened.
- 58:40So that could be one reason why they're not doing it.
- 58:43Another reason is that they simply don't want the situation
- 58:46to get out of hand even more than they do.
- 58:49Thirdly, they may have evidence, but it's not complete.
- 58:52They may have something that could be completely bad, means
- 58:57they could have other reasons in consideration that are political
- 59:02in nature there. All of that could be true, but
- 59:06the bottom line is remains the same.
- 59:10Why was Canada giving asylum to such people in the 1st place?
- 59:14And also, why hasn't there been yet a scheduled discussion about
- 59:19how to move go forward in addressing potential security
- 59:26claims and concerns by India? After all, these Palestinian
- 59:30extremists have been responsible for acts of aggression inside
- 59:34Canada against Canadian citizens as well.
- 59:37So there is actually a point of common ground that I think
- 59:41should be room for fruitful dialogue rather than, rather
- 59:46than a breakdown in diplomatic relations.
- 59:49I think it's an opportunity personally to avoid problems.
- 59:56Absolutely, absolutely there is, there are a lot of questions
- 59:59like earlier on let's see what this all means.
- 1:00:02As of now I understand that you know that India is a very
- 1:00:06peaceful nation and in terms of diplomacy also we always try to
- 1:00:10maintain good relations with everyone.
- 1:00:13But then as I said we do not know how how how governments
- 1:00:17operate. But then governments can also
- 1:00:20look at, you know, the wider aspects of sovereignty and and
- 1:00:24if other. Countries are harbouring this,
- 1:00:26but it's a curious thing. You know, I would like to read
- 1:00:28that report myself, you know, after learning from you arena.
- 1:00:32So let's move on to that, from that war of words from India and
- 1:00:36Canada to the war of words between Netanyahu and Turkey.
- 1:00:41So what is this all about? Where is this going to going?
- 1:00:45Is the will this lead to the, you know, break in diplomatic
- 1:00:49relations between these two countries?
- 1:00:52Why are they fighting? Well, you know, Erdogan has
- 1:00:57escalated his rhetoric. He's sending a Feculiar over
- 1:01:021000 boats allegedly with humanitarian aid to Gaza.
- 1:01:07But we have seen that the last time he did that, in 2010, it
- 1:01:10was not a humanitarian by a military operation that has
- 1:01:15ended with a brutal attack on Israeli naval officers who were
- 1:01:20inspecting those boats for weapons and.
- 1:01:23It led to a complete breakdown in relations for between the
- 1:01:26countries for 12 years, which were only recently resumed.
- 1:01:30And now we're back to the same situation.
- 1:01:34Erdogan repeatedly not only refused to condemn Hamas for
- 1:01:40anything that happened, but he attacked Israel as a terrorist
- 1:01:43state, which led to Netanyahu's response.
- 1:01:47He also is threatening to break. Break diplomatic relations all
- 1:01:54together in both countries, recalled each other's respective
- 1:01:58ambassadors already. So then these relations have
- 1:02:02been downgraded but not yet completely depleted.
- 1:02:09And fraternity. On the one hand, they don't want
- 1:02:11to lose the economic and tourist advantage from Israel, but on
- 1:02:17the other hand? For Aragon, it's a great
- 1:02:19opportunity to rile up that's only his base, but to put
- 1:02:23himself out as a leader of Islamists around the entire
- 1:02:26Muslim world. And he's in competition with the
- 1:02:31with the Arab states over this matter.
- 1:02:32So for him it's a point of pride, even if because economic
- 1:02:37down, Johnson, Israel's economy right now is suffering greatly
- 1:02:41from the war anyway. So Turkey may find that this
- 1:02:43point is the best. Time to do so if they are going
- 1:02:47to do exactly that. We're seeing the South Africa
- 1:02:50has very much moved in the direction with the parliament
- 1:02:54voting to shut down the Israeli embassy altogether.
- 1:02:58So Turkey may may see that once that the momentum is in that
- 1:03:02direction and it will not be seen as anything particular.
- 1:03:07Radicals, should they do the same and satisfy this street
- 1:03:12flyer that's ongoing and. To put pressure on Israel in
- 1:03:18this particular way. Right.
- 1:03:22And there has been no pushback by the way from the West against
- 1:03:26this rhetoric. So there are no consequences as
- 1:03:28well, right, Right, Edina. So let's let's now, you know,
- 1:03:34talk about something happening in Spain there in terms of the
- 1:03:38whole Catalonian movement there. We have seen a lot of talk about
- 1:03:45this, you know, Catalonian movement and Spain and all that.
- 1:03:50And certainly now we read about this Spanish Prime Minister and
- 1:03:54ruling parties engage in dialogue with separatist leaders
- 1:03:57in Brazil. So is it, is it going to be a
- 1:03:59solution for this long long difficult moment for both, both
- 1:04:05the sides? How do we look at it, you know,
- 1:04:08even though the Spanish judges looking, you know, investigating
- 1:04:11some of these people for terrorism, how does this look
- 1:04:14like a solution or after a long? Time.
- 1:04:20It looks actually really bad for the ruling parties because the
- 1:04:23ruling parties in Spain are quite socialist, they're quite
- 1:04:26radical and they've been losing political ground with the right
- 1:04:30wing parties increasingly gaining seats in the parliament.
- 1:04:34So they are expecting a complete defeat in the next elections and
- 1:04:38in order to avoid it they're cutting down, they're putting
- 1:04:41aside all principles, all their high minded rhetoric about
- 1:04:45sovereignty that led to the expulsion of the push among the
- 1:04:50the separatist leader who has been taking money from the
- 1:04:53Russians for this activity. There's been various scandals
- 1:04:57involving Russian intelligence agencies and so public
- 1:05:00information nothing dispute. Then not only willing went to
- 1:05:05Brussels to negotiate with him and to bring his party and have
- 1:05:09them after this separatist, you know, claims ironically join the
- 1:05:14government, but they're willing to consider full amnesty to to
- 1:05:18him and his associates. After all these spy scandals and
- 1:05:22all these attacks on Spanish government and intelligence,
- 1:05:25where these people accusing them of spyware abuses and so forth?
- 1:05:29So essentially everybody, you know, these people who have been
- 1:05:34pushing the separatists are combo.
- 1:05:36They've achieved completely victory due to the weakness and
- 1:05:39corruption of these parties who in order to stay in power are
- 1:05:42willing to sacrifice all these security and sovereignty
- 1:05:46concerns. So it looks really bad and you
- 1:05:49And then there have been mass mass demonstrations in Spain
- 1:05:53against this, but no, but they've been.
- 1:05:57And they reported among all the coverage of the pro Hamas
- 1:06:00rallies. These are internal domestic
- 1:06:04matters which have caused the mass just complete shock among
- 1:06:10the population. They have been not supported at
- 1:06:13all, right. Right now let's let's we have
- 1:06:20already discussed quite a lot of issues you know across the world
- 1:06:24arena. One more issue is now you know
- 1:06:27Osama bin Laden seems to have come back to you know come back
- 1:06:31to life with a lot of love for Osama bin Laden on TikTok.
- 1:06:35What is this whole idea of thing about why video has been banned.
- 1:06:40We can't, we don't, we can't watch that video here in India.
- 1:06:43TikTok is banned here since 2020.
- 1:06:46So tell us about this. Why?
- 1:06:48There is certainly a lot of talk about TikTok and Osama bin
- 1:06:51Laden. Well, I don't personally believe
- 1:06:54in coincidences. As you know, TikTok is blooms is
- 1:06:58produced by a company that has links to the Chinese government.
- 1:07:03It's been used as a weapon. Against the West in many ways.
- 1:07:07Propaganda targeting biometrics, keystrokes pushing stupid
- 1:07:12challenges that cause addiction and harm among children and
- 1:07:17teenagers. But this this this particular
- 1:07:24incident that involved the sudden release of Osama bin
- 1:07:28Laden's letter, which attacked the West and which became
- 1:07:31popular among. Young people who have no idea
- 1:07:35who he even is or what really happened, who were born and grew
- 1:07:39up after 911, and who are completely ignorant and easily
- 1:07:44manipulated. This I am.
- 1:07:46I believe this was a targeted attack designed to achieve this
- 1:07:49particular impact among influencers.
- 1:07:52And of course, once it was once the damage was done, Tiktok
- 1:07:56banned that particular video. But the damage was done, and now
- 1:08:00that's all anyone's talking about it.
- 1:08:02And besides that particular video, there's many a lot of
- 1:08:06other propaganda circulating and supposedly TikTok is fighting
- 1:08:09it. But it's already too late and
- 1:08:11mainstream media in China is also spreading pro Hamas and
- 1:08:15anti-Semitic content and attacking the United States day
- 1:08:18and night. Supposedly they turned it down
- 1:08:20for the for the summit in the US, but the main point is still
- 1:08:23there, right? So does that that does mean it
- 1:08:30will strengthen the case for banning TikTok in the US?
- 1:08:44Sorry, what? Yes, Irina, if you Yeah.
- 1:08:48So does this mean that this will strengthen the case for, you
- 1:08:51know, TikTok getting banned in the US?
- 1:08:54Because this is something a lot of people may not want to see.
- 1:09:02Well, I couldn't. Million Americans have
- 1:09:09downloaded Tick Tock, but honestly, I think people it's
- 1:09:13been used as a weapon and the same type of content is not
- 1:09:16available inside China. So clearly it's aimed at Western
- 1:09:19countries, aimed at manipulation, and it's clearly a
- 1:09:23tool. You know, I I I think there are
- 1:09:26plenty of American and other companies that can fill in the
- 1:09:29gap if TIF TAC receives to exist, and I think we'd be all
- 1:09:33be better off if that happened. That's my personal opinion,
- 1:09:38absolutely, absolutely. There is a lot of happening in
- 1:09:41the world that is a lot of, you know, things that we covered and
- 1:09:45we will come back back again, you know, again in the next two
- 1:09:48weeks to bring more about what has happened in the world.
- 1:09:52You'll be able to help us understand all those things,
- 1:09:55analyze all those things, and bring it to the world for us in
- 1:09:59the world according to Adina Superman, thank you so much
- 1:10:02indeed for joining us in this episode.
- 1:10:06Thank you. Thank you so much.