Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Meditation and Attachment
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:22It is August 4th 2022. It's 7:38 p.m.
- 0:27Pacific Daylight Time. And we haven't talked in the
- 0:33last few weeks about the politics of our, the body
- 0:40politics of the u.s. mainly in response to Roe v-- Wade.
- 0:47And I thought that actually, maybe we would return toward
- 0:51conversation about attachment and meditation.
- 0:57Since that's actually, Our primary focus here.
- 1:02Metal group We've been trying to plan a retreat, an Asia.
- 1:09One of the things that I like to do about retreating an Asia is
- 1:14to do a traditional Focus, Tera vaada practice there it is
- 1:21possible to have the experience of meditation and an experience
- 1:26of terabyte of Buddhism that centered in the way that it's
- 1:30taught here and in the west and have a sense of that being The
- 1:37way that it's traditionally practice in Asia.
- 1:40I think if you actually go to Asian sit there, you'll see that
- 1:44it's, it is quite different. And I think that that can be
- 1:51helpful in terms of understanding practice, we had
- 1:56been going to Myanmar and sitting a meta Retreat there
- 2:03with who into cassette sayadaw and He teaches meta-genome,
- 2:08which is one of the Maha see sad approaches to meta practice
- 2:14which is centered on a concentration practice so that
- 2:18you use the object of meta mind or the Mind, state or view of
- 2:25meta as the object of meditation and attempt to come into, high
- 2:29concentration states around that.
- 2:33His approach is Centered on the mint of a Parson approach which
- 2:39is this integrated practice of the to the hard practices and
- 2:43the Insight practice and that you begin that by developing
- 2:48intentional positivity in the capacity to hold positive
- 2:52States. But the purpose of that that is
- 2:55to create a container that you can withdraw into if you need
- 2:59to, if the inside side, heats up too much.
- 3:04So when you move into pulling apart the experience in the way
- 3:10that the vipassana or the that style of insight practice tends
- 3:21to do. You can sometimes come into the
- 3:27the views that you use to create the experience of your self and
- 3:32of the world and then that can put you in touch with some
- 3:36painful emotional experiences in response to that.
- 3:41And in a combined met of a positive approach to practice
- 3:43you pull into the meta side, to the positive side, when the the
- 3:50positive side becomes distressing.
- 3:53One of the problems in the West for people particularly new
- 3:57people who come into a main leave a pasta or Insight focused
- 4:03practice is that it does often put you in touch with difficult,
- 4:09emotional experiences in response to seeing things
- 4:12clearly. And if you don't have a strongly
- 4:17developed capacity for positivity that you can use as a
- 4:22refuge, Often. What happens is that people
- 4:26simply stop meditating in order to moderate the painful
- 4:31experiences. And so you have the starting and
- 4:36stopping which is very common in in householder practice or what
- 4:41you have is a very limited meditation, practice the think
- 4:51about Pursuing meditation as an alignment oriented practice is
- 4:57that you have to go that whole distance in order to have those
- 5:03experiences that are transformative transformative in
- 5:08that classical, Enlightenment way, each of the different
- 5:13Traditions creates different experiences of that and
- 5:19depending on how you practice. You have different experiences.
- 5:25I know that Dan Brown and Judd Brewer did some, fmri studies on
- 5:32Tibetan practitioners that on Tara Bata practitioners and
- 5:37found that the different techniques created different
- 5:42reactivity in the brain and that the Tera vaada practice was
- 5:46really centered around the ACC and shutting down the experience
- 5:49of Self in the Tibetan practice was Or or the parts of the brain
- 5:55that responded were shift of the identification of the self
- 6:01experience in the left. Prefrontal cortex into the
- 6:05parietal lobe which is more local Global.
- 6:09So that that big expansiveness experience that often comes from
- 6:13the Tibetan practices actually related to the brain activity.
- 6:18That the the meditation, the specific practices cause we're a
- 6:23As the no self experience, which is prominent in the Tara bada
- 6:28practice comes from the shutting down or the muting of the ACC
- 6:35activity. So when we talk about
- 6:41Enlightenment experiences and they're centered in different
- 6:44kinds of practice of the they're different because the practice
- 6:48is produce different results. Based on what you do we had in
- 6:54the west tend to particularly in the US, In the u.s. we have this
- 7:02thing called cultural appropriation.
- 7:04I don't know if you've heard of it, but we like to take the
- 7:07things that really are shining and work well and collect them
- 7:11and discard everything else. And so we tend to create these
- 7:15practices which we think of as traditional practices, but
- 7:19actually they're just sort of cherry-picked practices and we
- 7:23even mix-and-match, you know, for the longest time, sitting
- 7:29with Shin Zen Who said that he was a primarily at are Vada
- 7:35teacher and teacher of insight when you actually pull apart the
- 7:40techniques that he's offering it's from all all of the
- 7:43different meninges sort of gathered together and
- 7:46secularized. So it's harder to tell the what
- 7:49the origins of the practices are When we went to Myanmar, and I
- 7:57was looking around for a retreat center where we could do some
- 8:00longer Retreats, I met a monk who was, who had been at the
- 8:07monastery for five years and he was still doing breath counting
- 8:13and that he hadn't actually been offered any other techniques
- 8:15besides breath counting because this monk that was ahead of him
- 8:20more. In charge of his practice was
- 8:23not yet satisfied to the depth of his technique in breath
- 8:28counting Christian. Was he also doing like a meta
- 8:35practice is that like really into it in there?
- 8:39No, in this particular Monastery.
- 8:41It was just straight for pasta. There wasn't really much in the
- 8:44way of metal but he wasn't doing the positive or meta.
- 8:47He was simply doing a schemata concentration, Focus practice.
- 8:52Okay. Now in the u.s. who do you know,
- 8:59that's willing to do, five years of a basic breath, counting
- 9:03practice anyone, we don't want to do the preliminary practices,
- 9:11we want to jump into the advanced practices because we
- 9:14have this idea about our go to itness.
- 9:19I think might be a way to describe that.
- 9:25And we're also very Orient. We're oriented very differently.
- 9:30we have a long tradition of psychological work that we do
- 9:37sense of psychological Health that we were supposed to have,
- 9:42and really, I think of the policemen are e practices, which
- 9:48we don't really do much of here as the attachment investigation.
- 9:57One of the things that we need in order to do deep practice and
- 10:00to do it in long enough to have an effect in the time.
- 10:04Element, of course is serendipitous, I remember a
- 10:08story shins and I used to tell of being at a monastery in Kyoto
- 10:14and Every single day white-knuckling, it just to get
- 10:19through the day and, you know, sort of a middle management.
- 10:24Accountant, type guy comes in and goes from never having
- 10:29meditated before to stream entry in six weeks, which really irked
- 10:35all of the apis monks place. There's a quote right love, I'm
- 10:46thinking it's Robert Thurman but I'm not sure about it that early
- 10:54on in his sitting in Asia that local people would come in and
- 11:00sit and in a few weeks, have these deep insights into
- 11:03practice and the westerners would come in and spend the same
- 11:09amount of time and get nowhere. And The teacher said that the
- 11:14local people were coming in and meditating and The Westerns were
- 11:17coming in and thinking. So that's that psychological.
- 11:22He's trying to make sense of it using a logic.
- 11:27In the US and in the west, mainly, what I've seen is people
- 11:35at the hardly functioning end of the spectrum and people at the
- 11:39super functioning end of the spectrum, come into practice
- 11:43meditation, and not many people in the middle.
- 11:46And the reason for that is that the, the hardly functioning
- 11:51people who've tried many of the approaches that that were
- 11:55offered to them to help. Increase their functioning
- 11:58didn't make much progress, using them.
- 12:01And as a last resort, turned toward meditation and at the
- 12:06other end of the spectrum, people that function super well,
- 12:09but remain unhappy. In the achievements of that
- 12:13level of functioning come because they're looking for
- 12:17something that actually is going to provide meaning.
- 12:20So we have this piece about engaging in the activities of
- 12:25the world, engage Aging in activities that have meaning to
- 12:29us. there was a quote, I was I think it's by a lard who was a
- 12:47French philosopher who wrote in the postmodern school, we have
- 12:56more and more meaning as the technology improves.
- 13:03More and more information as the technology, improves a and less
- 13:07and less meaning coming from it more, and more information.
- 13:13Less meaning in the attachment approach, we have these three
- 13:22main activities that make up the experience of the attachment
- 13:29system activates. And we seek proximity to people
- 13:32that make us Feel safe that will protect us and will help
- 13:36emotionally regulate us. Once were emotionally regulated,
- 13:39the attachment system shuts down and the exploration system turns
- 13:43on. And so then we're free to go and
- 13:47pursue the things that actually have meaning to us.
- 13:52And then the third aspect is collaboration with other people.
- 13:56One of the things about pursuing, a deep meditation
- 13:58path. Is that consistency?
- 14:01And practice opportunities to practice a in a retreat setting
- 14:10or in a an extended period of practice is very useful.
- 14:13In order to do that, you need the time energy and resources to
- 14:17be able to do that. But then also it can be Nerving
- 14:22were destabilizing little bit to go into that deep practice and
- 14:28so you need then to have the social network that you can rely
- 14:34on to support you. Or you begin to inhibit the
- 14:38progress of the investigation now and the traditional way of
- 14:42practicing in Asia in the monasteries you have the
- 14:46community of the monastics to support you in that.
- 14:51But in as householders in the west, we don't really have much
- 14:56in the way of a monastic community that we would rely on.
- 14:59And most of us who are householders are actually not
- 15:02interested in withdrawing from a householders life and entering
- 15:06into the monastery. The.
- 15:19Monastic life. Of course, is a patriarchal
- 15:22life, a hierarchical life and there's very little wiggle room
- 15:29in that way. The people who are senior to
- 15:32have authority and you don't if you're not in that role in the
- 15:37monastery. And so you do have to comply and
- 15:42particularly in the mirror and my that compliance is sought to
- 15:49be. You an insight into the nature
- 15:52of self and not self. Then it depends really also on
- 15:59who you have and what the culture of the monastic
- 16:03Community is that you're involved in in the west as
- 16:09householders. We have the the relational
- 16:13Community around us that either comes from our family life or
- 16:20our work life or our friendship life.
- 16:24And we don't always have the Advantage of the whole of our
- 16:30social Community being engaged in meditation, practice in Tech.
- 16:35Sometimes most of them are not and so then, How do you manage
- 16:43the time energy and resources that you would need to take away
- 16:46from your commitments, to other people other work cited work
- 16:53situation and be able to focus on practice.
- 16:56That's part of the balancing. So, in attachment conditioning,
- 17:10some people are secure, some people are dismissing, some
- 17:13people are preoccupied, some people are disorganized.
- 17:19Disorganized the disorganized enter, this of this scale,
- 17:24people tend to function quite a bit less well than the organized
- 17:28side which is the secure assisting and be occupied.
- 17:36A people secure people tend to be able to build around
- 17:41themselves, social support and social networks that work with
- 17:47work for. And they tend to be organized
- 17:50around primary exploration which is where the activity itself
- 17:56provides meaning or whereas dismissing, people tend to be
- 18:01more organized around secondary exploration, which is the
- 18:05pursuit of resources. So that you can in some sense
- 18:09transact, the things that you need.
- 18:14Preoccupied people don't explore particularly well as part of the
- 18:17conditioning. And the reason that this is
- 18:21something that's important to understand is that you could
- 18:25express a meditation practice as an exploration.
- 18:30And for many for most people who practice, I think it's a primary
- 18:34exploration and has meaning to practice and what you're finding
- 18:37out is that direct sense of Understanding yourself and your
- 18:46place in the social world that you are in Buddhism.
- 18:50We would call that inside and outside inside, is that sense of
- 18:54self and the peace with your own beingness.
- 18:58And then the world, which is the other people that you're in
- 19:01relationship to On the secure and that's probably it.
- 19:11We also have in the west and I'm going to guess also in the East
- 19:16although it's harder to crack the the sort of Silence of the
- 19:27monastic community you know, people acting in ways that are
- 19:37not skillful and then we might look at the orientation of
- 19:42pursuing positions of power within the meditation community
- 19:50and what the purpose of that is I tend to like DARPA Vamps and
- 20:03so one of the things I like quite a bit is the Tera vaada
- 20:06map of the 16 stages or the of the progress of insight which
- 20:10takes you through this series of insights that you need in order
- 20:14to find your way into Pascal enlightenment.
- 20:24But I also like the Tibetan approach of finding the
- 20:31sacredness of everything and holding that view of sacredness,
- 20:48I think when I was 18 or 19, I had decided that I would stop
- 20:52trying to answer the big questions in life.
- 20:57What is it mean to be alive? Who am I?
- 21:00Why am I here? What am I supposed to do?
- 21:04All of these questions? I found an inscrutable and
- 21:07unanswerable and I thought that it was a waste of time to try
- 21:11and solve them. But then I found coming, you
- 21:24know, into my 20s in New York in the 80s as the the AIDS epidemic
- 21:30swept through the social world that I inhabited, and the
- 21:36extreme difficulty of of caring for that.
- 21:42For the people, I knew in my community as as they died
- 21:48something Something about succession of people in their
- 21:5420s who are in one season vibrant and energetic and a
- 22:02couple of Seasons later decimated and dying.
- 22:12Then I realized that I'm going to have to answer these
- 22:14questions in a way, because the avoidance of them is unbearable.
- 22:20And so that practice for me, was the The Catalyst to practice in
- 22:25earnest. But mainly, what I find out in
- 22:30practicing in the Tera vaada tradition is that the experience
- 22:35of self is just this little pressure cooker of suffering and
- 22:38if you can stay out of it, it's not that bad.
- 22:41You don't suffer that much. And so, there's that shift out
- 22:45of the identification with this limited identity into this
- 22:49vastness. This unfixed, sated
- 22:52undifferentiated space. But then it's to reconstruct a
- 23:03sense of self and explain it is is not that easy.
- 23:11I could tell you how to practice so that you could come into the
- 23:14to the experiences of that. And I can nod as you describe
- 23:19those experiences in the, the self language that we will end
- 23:23up using In the Tibetan practices.
- 23:30It's this, it's quite different than that.
- 23:32It's this expansiveness. This spaciousness is thinning
- 23:38out. And then everything takes on
- 23:42this quality of sacredness. And I can, I can explain how
- 23:46awesome that is, that that experience of sacredness and how
- 23:51every little thing seems important.
- 23:56And, and, and valuable, and how to hold that view. but not
- 24:03neither one of those actually produces an answer that the self
- 24:07is satisfied with in terms of the big questions at least on
- 24:13for me, Why am I here? What am I supposed to do?
- 24:22I do track the outcomes of things, I make my calculations
- 24:29of what I should do. And then I take the actions in
- 24:31an attempt to bring those things into fruition.
- 24:34And then what happens happens and I understand that that is
- 24:39Karma and I tried to live an ethical life and I understand
- 24:45the things that happen are good karma but very often.
- 24:50They're not the thing that I wanted to have happen and
- 24:57there's some suffering in that self experience of that isn't
- 25:04what I had in mind. I'm reminded of my grandmother.
- 25:11She lived to be 97 and she was a Christian scientist who also
- 25:18used Western medicine. There's a lot of accommodations
- 25:22that people can make and she looked at me and she said, you
- 25:26know, I am I'm absolutely convinced that God has a plan
- 25:31for me. I just wish you'd let me in on
- 25:34it. At 97.
- 25:44She said, I don't know anybody anymore and I said, do you have
- 25:47lots of friendship said? Oh those people, I've only known
- 25:49them 10 years. I used to know people seventy.
- 25:54So there's this process of Life, depending where you're at, I am
- 26:00in my life. Coming to the end of old age and
- 26:04looking forward to old old age. Wondering how different that
- 26:13will be. I already already notice my
- 26:18energy capacities diminishing in a way that a lot of the things
- 26:23that I did routinely now, I finding challenging to do.
- 26:30And I think that all of us have the experience of Aging if we
- 26:33live long enough where the those things kinds of change and what
- 26:39we're interested in what we can, pursue may not line up and then
- 26:43we have to adjust for that. I met a group.
- 26:52We focus initially on attachment as a preliminary practice
- 26:59because we want people to be able to stabilize their social
- 27:05network and environment and how they live.
- 27:09So that they actually do have the time energy and resources to
- 27:13pursue deep practice, which we do think is the end goal of
- 27:16practice. That pursuit of classical
- 27:20Enlightenment using, whatever approach actually resonates for
- 27:25you. To see clearly the nature of The
- 27:30Human Condition. To see clearly the nature of
- 27:34your experience. I was working with a student,
- 27:41and Under a high level of stress, they acted in ways that
- 27:50they didn't like about themselves.
- 27:59And saw it as a failing. But then my sense of that is
- 28:11that they're there is the bind of identification with self that
- 28:17I am this person, who does these things, rather than that.
- 28:22Stepping out of that sense of self into awareness, where you
- 28:28really do, watch what you do. Rather than identify with what
- 28:33you do, you watch what you do with the kind of open curiosity
- 28:38and attempt to redirect yourself view C or go off the rails but
- 28:44all of those things happen automatically you are not ever
- 28:49making the decision to do them in that sense.
- 28:53And so we in some sense that that is a description of seeing
- 28:59clearly Christian. you think in that case, the acting from
- 29:07awareness, Would allow the student or the anyone to is the
- 29:16point that it makes you not judge yourself.
- 29:21Or is the point that it actually makes you gives you like a
- 29:25buffer to make better decisions? Well, it gives you a buffer to
- 29:31make better decisions, but also, if you lose awareness lose
- 29:35mindfulness and have a moment of mindlessness that is actually
- 29:42even harmful or causes a difficulty, you don't Self
- 29:50emulate in the rigid identification with self.
- 29:54You can re-establish your mentalizing faster and then
- 29:59correct Aster. We tend to most of the time in
- 30:09the process of forming the sense of self in the sense of the
- 30:12world, that all happens automatically, all happens,
- 30:17unconsciously based on conditioning.
- 30:20And then at the last second it appears in consciousness.
- 30:24I like to call that the veto possibility, the window of
- 30:31vetoing, a boneheaded move so you have the object that can be
- 30:35sensed the capacity to sense it when they have contact
- 30:39consciousness of that sensing experience, arises.
- 30:42One of the problems with the English is that we use the same
- 30:46word to mean different things. But Consciousness is the active
- 30:53sensing. Variance.
- 30:55That awareness would know. And then it's process.
- 31:01It's evaluated for urgency as a matter Pleasant.
- 31:05If there's time it's compared to the perceptual database.
- 31:08If there's a match that's close enough, the meaning of the
- 31:12particular pattern of sensing activates into conceptual
- 31:18reality and in that moment of activation and appears in the
- 31:23self experience, as this is what we think is happening.
- 31:33Because we're creating conceptual reality and it's an
- 31:36extremely elastic thing. You can make it in so many
- 31:40different ways that if you're monitoring that process in that
- 31:46moment of coming into being, if you see that, it's not a good
- 31:52match to what actually is being sense.
- 31:55So that's the word in Pali for that, it's Taja pranati, which
- 32:01Constant looking back on the Ultimate Reality and comparing
- 32:09it to conceptual reality to make sure that they match.
- 32:13Well then you can correct and recreate a conceptual reality
- 32:21that's more in line with what's happening.
- 32:23But most of the process of sensing and evaluating for
- 32:29urgency and and applying meaning happens before it reaches
- 32:37conscious awareness. So, these versions of reality
- 32:42are coming into conscious awareness fully formed.
- 32:47And so we don't necessarily see behind the curtain or under the
- 32:51hood as to how we've created them.
- 32:55So you might say that the purpose of practice is to be
- 32:58able to track that so that you're constantly in a position
- 33:03of knowing what the Ultimate Reality is and what you've made
- 33:08it into so that your actions are more and more oriented in a
- 33:12skillful way. So that making sense when we
- 33:19don't do that, then the version of conceptual reality we create
- 33:23we just assumed to be accurate. And then we form intention and
- 33:27take action based on that even if it's wildly laws.
- 33:30So the Buddha talked about that, but one of the stories that he
- 33:35used was the farmer who went into the Hut and it was dark and
- 33:40he looked into the corner and he saw a coiled snake.
- 33:42And he took his machete and he chopped it up and then he lit a
- 33:45candle and he saw that he chopped up a coil of rope but in
- 33:51the moment the mind made it into a snake and he responded. as if
- 33:58it were a snake that making sense, So what we want to do is
- 34:05be constantly present constantly monitoring this construction.
- 34:10That we make of the world, constantly comparing it to what
- 34:14we're taking in to. Make sure that the constructions
- 34:18that we made are an accurate reflection of what's actually
- 34:22happening. Now, your constructions of
- 34:26everything are going to be based on your perceptual database
- 34:29based on your conditioning. So you're always going to be
- 34:33Creating a version of conceptual reality based on that and
- 34:37everybody has their own database.
- 34:39So everybody is creating their own version And so, we need to
- 34:48engage in a dialogue about each person's version.
- 34:57In a postmodern view you might say that there is no truth
- 35:00because it's all subject to what our conditioning is but in a
- 35:06meta modern version of that you would say what's true is that
- 35:10everybody is creating their own reality and what we need to do
- 35:13in order to understand each other as dialogue about that
- 35:16without being defensive of it. Just to be open.
- 35:21Christine, you had a question. So what you're saying is that
- 35:26this practice will remove our fear of snakes.
- 35:33Sorry. Well, that would not be a
- 35:42skillful practice. Because sometimes when you go
- 35:46into the Hut, the coil in the corner will be a snake.
- 35:50It's actually to see clearly and distinguish a snake from a not
- 35:55snake. all right, so let's do some positive.
- 36:11What do you think? So any comments or questions
- 36:23about the practice we just did? So on Saturday, we're doing the
- 36:34third in the level 1 attachment series, I'm teaching with Jack
- 36:41Oldenburg, two weeks from Saturday.
- 36:46We're going to do the The relational, I mean, the
- 36:53collaborative relationship day long.
- 36:56So if you're familiar with the three pillars approach to
- 37:00attaching repair that Dan Brown developed with his group, that
- 37:05is the third pillar collaborative, relationship
- 37:08systems and understanding how they work.
- 37:11We'll do some dyads with that. So are you can practice in
- 37:15October? We're doing our final retreat at
- 37:18seven circles. As seven circles is closing.
- 37:23So that if you have any Nostalgia for that, as a retreat
- 37:26center, please join us. We won't be able to go back to
- 37:29their after the October Retreat November.
- 37:33We're doing our first level one class for Europe, European
- 37:39Central time. So if you're a night owl or will
- 37:42be teaching from 1:00 a.m. until 10:00 in the morning.
- 37:48We're still trying to put together our Retreat for Asia
- 37:52and February but not sure what's happening with that at the
- 37:56moment. Keep you abreast of it and then
- 38:01next June, I'm going to do our first European retreated and the
- 38:10Netherlands. The Netherlands.
- 38:13So that's the stuff that's coming up a lot of it is on the
- 38:17website. Take a look.
- 38:20I do offer the teaching on it. Carol.
- 38:23Yeah. Can you just jump in for the
- 38:26day? Long on the collaborative
- 38:27relationships is. Yeah, sure.
- 38:32We offered separately from the The first part of level 1.
- 38:40It's on the website and yeah. I think it's August 20th. so, I
- 38:53offer the teacher on a database is done is the Pali word for
- 38:56generosity, so where there's a link on the website to make a
- 38:59donation, if you wish we really appreciate any amount because it
- 39:04helps support me and also the work that many group is doing.
- 39:07Thank you for your practice and we will see you soon.
- 39:12I,