Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 09/17/26 EPISODE 025: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: GEORGE T. STAGG 2025 RELEASE (BTAC)
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: folks, we are back. And I'm excited. I have honestly been we started this podcast. I don't was it May? May. We're in August right now. This when I before I filmed the very we we filmed the very first episode, I put three bottles out into a poll, a William LaRue Weller, Heaven Hill twenty two year old, and George T. Sag 2025 release. And I said, hey, vote on it. What do you want to what do you want us to review first? And the Heaven or the William LaRue Weller came in first with a close second of Heaven Hill. But I said, listen, I like George T. Stag. We're not gonna leave him out of the out of the review. So we are now gonna pop the 2025 release. George T Stag. This thing is hazmat. 142.8 proof. ⁓ I'm excited about this, but let's go around, do some introductions. Who do we got tonight? I'm Scott. John Carlo, James, and ⁓ Shane Rox Bourbon Review. And everybody that doesn't want to tell their Instagram tags, we've got a Life Well Lived Well Made. Life Well Made Co. And 10 to A Z whiskey. You're gonna have some random. We're trying to get my buddy some follows here. Please follow James. Dude. Please wanna see you guys wanna see bottle kills. Follow 10 to A Z whiskey. With no nose, no Listen, lots of family event updates. That is awesome. So listen, George C. Seg, there's a lot of history behind this. I I grabbed some notes. I I definitely want to share some of this information with y'all ⁓ before we pop it. I'm gonna let everybody just ⁓ wait patiently and then we'll pop it. And then we'll dive into the nose, we'll get it poured up and we'll dive in. So the n the history's short here, at least what I got. There's there is a lot of history, but I don't want to drone on for hours. So George Thomas Stag, born in eighteen thirty five, died in eighteen ninety three. He was one of the most aggressive, resilient, and influential business minds of the nineteenth century American whisty whiskey industry. Rather than a master distiller, Stag was a masterful salesman and a brilliant financier who helped build what would eventually become the world's most f famous distillery. Born in Kentucky, Stag served as a captain in the U Union Army during the Civil War. After the war, he moved to St. Louis, Missouri, where he founded a successful ⁓ found success as a whiskey salesman. It was here that his path crossed pass with Colonel E. H. Taylor, Junior. Not Albert Blands. A legendary and visionary distiller who was running at the time the OFC Old Fire. Copper distillery in Frankfurt, Kentucky. Taylor was a visionary but a terrible money manager. When Taylor found himself drowning in debt, Stagg stepped in to finance him. By 1878, Taylor was forced into bankruptcy, and Stagg bought the OFC distillery outright. The two worked as uneasy partners for a few years, with Stagg managing the business and Taylor acting as the face and the distiller. However, their clashing personalities, which is Crazy that there's two bottles from Buffalo Trace with a couple of dudes that hated each other ⁓ donning their names, right? eventually led to a bitter and a permanent split. Left entirely in control, Stag provided proved to be an absolute powerhouse. He expanded the distillery into one of the largest and most technologically advanced operations of its era. In eighteen ninety, the facility was named the George T. Stag Distillery in his honor. Stagg led the company until his death in 1893, leaving behind an industrial Titan that survived prohibition. Weathered the mid-century whiskey crash, and eventually was renamed Buffalo Trace Distillery in 1999. Today, George T. Stag lives on as the name of Buffalo Trace's boldest high proof annual offering in the Buffalo Trace antique collection known as BTAC. Alongside its younger counterpart, Stag, formerly known as Stag Jr., ⁓ George T. Stag, specifically this bottle, fifteen years, one hundred and forty two point eight proof, and it just took home the single highest honor at the two thousand twenty six Ascot Awards, being crowned best in show whiskey across every single category and style in the competition. The judges praised it. The judges Put your hand down. You can't just come in and the judges praised it during the blind testing tasting, excuse me, for a rich velvet like texture with notes of clove, sarsaparilla, dark chocolate, and a leathery finish. Interestingly, it also took home a top best of show spot at the 2026 Global Whiskey Challenge with a score of ninety-six points. Here's the breakdown for this specific This specific whiskey that won. 142.8 proof. It is fifteen years, two months. It's the Buffalo Trace mash bill number one. ⁓ MSRP on this bottle. Anybody in the room? Is it 200? Is it 190? ⁓ 150 bucks. 150. 150 bucks. But the secondary market sits anywhere between 700 and 1,500. So this ⁓ so the most common comment from the blind tasting was that despite sitting at the massive hazmat 142.8 proof, it drinks incredibly smooth. Holds the heat beautifully without drowning out the dark cherry, oak, and spice notes. ⁓ so before we pop this thing, a little history on on George C. Sag and specifically the the BTAC release history. George C. Sag was introduced in 2002 and it was famed for being a monster bourbon, uncut, unfiltered, aged for at least 15 years. ⁓ and in and in 2021 Buffalo Trace made the historic decision to completely skip the George T Stag release because the barrels selected for that vintage did not meet the brand's rigorous quality standards. So from 2002 all the way to 2021, it was released every year. 2021, they didn't make a release. ⁓ so let's see here. The highest aged release that's ever been released was in 2011. It was released at 18 years, five months. The hottest proof it was ever been released at was in two thousand and seven, one hundred and forty four point eight proof. Anybody any guesses on the lowest proof it's ever been released? Don't read the screen. ⁓ 120 123. 2019, 116.9. ⁓ and so this is the first this one is a hazmat. The last time we got a hazmat release was in 2016, ⁓ nine years ago, and that one was released at 144.1 proof. So ⁓ last but not least, before we crack this thing, there's a fun fact that we've already covered that. Let's get this thing popped. What the people want to hear. Let's all welcome Molly to the podcast, even though she's not on a microphone. You may hear her in the background. Let's get ⁓ let's get the pop. Nice pop. Sure. Alright, let's dive into this thing, see what we got. We got it all poured up. Everybody's got one in their glass. Monster nose. Monster nose? Monster nose. You got in there too far. So so before we all get into the notes, any who who's had a stag, George T stag specifically, before? Everybody had one or tried one? I have, yeah. Everyone in the room's tried one? Never tried it. You've never tried it. Really? Stag Jr.? Yes. You've had a f ⁓ a stag junior. Okay. I own one of these, I haven't opened it. This the twenty twenty five release? Yes. Okay. ⁓ nice, great. Very cool. Ooh. Man, that nose. Mm-hmm. Yeah, that'll that you get your nose in it, it'll bite your face off. Yeah. The the the the pardon my language, the fucking cherry on that nose is pronounced, incredible. I I love that deep, dark black Luxardo cherry syrup. Black cherry syrup. James, strap it on. God damn. ⁓ Our our friend that doesn't know has already gone in. He just beat Ruff. Kicked him in the dick. Holy And that's that's a fun thing about I I even remember my ⁓ my twenty twenty four. I didn't do the same thing. It kinda it it takes you back a little. Yeah. ⁓ I've got the twenty twenty yeah, twenty twenty four open. it's so good. Like we we popped it, I don't know, it was like a probably year ago. It was for your like celebration. Whatever my wife did party. That was great. I've never had a hazmat one, so I mean I'm you said it was something to be aware of, so just take a big old goal. See, it's going. That drinks all of the hundred and forty two point absolutely point eight proof. I've had has I've got a hundred and fifty three proof downstairs. And I don't know if it drinks this warm. That one but that that one is more sweet. This one it the I think what what you're getting with the with the proof is you're also getting those like leathery tobacco. Yeah. Like rich oak notes. Turned up the volume on it. It's like that almost yeah, I was gonna say just turned up amped the proof. Yeah. But it but it's not super overpowering though. It it's not like something that's so good. I mean my first sip overpowering, but it definitely calms down like in a good way. I like I like that. I like I like it to fight fight me. I it's I like a high proof, I like the extremely intense flavors. This is every bit of that. Yeah, my wife always says she wants to chew her bourbon. This is like a chewy bourbon. Like there's there's some thickness to this thing. Mm-hmm. Dick. Wow. That wasn't the note I was looking for, but I think that's a different podcast too. Chewy indeed. ⁓ I'm I'm on that same line of thinking. The chewiness. I I like to chew my bourbons as well. Cause I usually only like to have one. I'm not a drinking bourbon all day or an all night guy. Except for tonight. we have had quite a few pores, but when I when I have a a Bourbon, it's usually just one, and this gets it done for ya. This is incredible. I mean, like, just it is I'm going back to the nose, and I'm ⁓ and I'm thinking about like, okay, I'm I'm let me put myself in ⁓ Fred Minnick's shoes at the Ascot Awards. They're tasting whatever it is, hundred, two hundred whiskeys, and this came out as the best whiskey that they had. Going back to the nose, it is everything I want in a bourbon. Mm-hmm. It's got those deep fruit notes, that vanilla sweetness, some caramel. So Shane, we recorded a little bit earlier and you gave the nose on that one. I believe it was the rare character. Yeah. A ten. Yeah. ⁓ you know, I I actually don't give the nose as high as I did the rare character, only because on this I get the ethanol, you know, the alcohol nose on this for me. You're not you don't completely disagree. I cinch some nose hairs if I get too close. So like put your put your nose and your mouth in the glass. And breathe through both. Heavy cherry for sure. ⁓ my gosh. It's different. It's different when you when you leave your nose in with your mouth out. Don't don't get me wrong, it's great. It's great. ⁓ yeah. It's great. And like nine, five plus, right? We're talking very, very little very splitting hairs. And the taste of this blows the other one. Maybe not blow it out of the por park because I loved that other one, but this is great. Yeah. So much depth of flavor. It's layered. Like it I I would agree. Yeah. I I would totally agree with you. I love it. I love it. Like I mean, I'm done. Like I love it. ⁓ dude, this is this is incredible. Incredible. I I think about what I want in a pour. Mm-hmm. I want some sort of fruitiness. I want sweetness. If it's got some spice and some oak, specifically like sweet oak, I don't I I'll deal with tannic oak. I I like it, but it's not gonna be one that like rises the top of what I want. This thing has that in the nose. I also get it in the palette. these are not cheap bottles. No. But if you can find one or a back, I mean I'll th this is I would want to back this is this by f so we haven't side by side. Maybe stay tuned. Maybe we'll do that on a future episode. Try this against the twenty twenty four release. I'm trying to recall the twenty twenty four. It's not it it is not as flavorful as this for sure. So either. ⁓ this one is given those like deep, rich flavors from the fruit to the sweetness to the oak, all in there. Obviously, the proof is up there. ⁓ Yeah, the proof is up there, but it's still really well balanced. Yeah. This is I mean, this is the best what the this is the best of what Buffalo Trace can put out. It is, right? Like I think they look at this because this is Buffalo Trace mash bill number one. Yep. This is you go get a Buffalo Trace at AD proof. This the big dog. That's it? That's the same juice. It just happens to be fifteen years and uncat uncut castraint. Incredible. the pinnacle of bourbon is right there. Yeah. I I mean if I could trade the entire collection and just drink these. Yes. From here on out, I would be absolutely fine. Absolutely. I don't I need no that's pretty I need no other I need no other variety other than maybe if I swap this in with a William LaRue Weller and then I'd be good. And I could bounce back and forth between cast strength weeded and cast strength rye bourbon. But yeah, I think if you compare like ⁓ Shane, what you alluded to earlier, well, one and done like You're gonna have one glass and that's it. That's all you're gonna have for the night. It's great. If you wanna have a few more, going with an Eagle Rare. It's a great sipper. You can have three or four, what have you. Big contrast. Big contrast. This is I think that's a wild. I mean, here's my hot take. Wild take. If you're a one and done and you're gonna st one and done a hazmat on an evening and that's the only pour you're having, yeah. No warmup. Sorry, my friend. That is not what I want to do with my life. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ I wanted to. I'm not working up. I'm not working up to anything. I am just going in. Listen. I prepare myself for the night and then listen. Walk out to the garage. Walk out to the garage. Grab just grab a ball peen hammer out of your out of your tool chest. Put your dick on the table and just beat it with that hammer, is what this whiskey is. If this is the only pour you're having in one evening. Wait, you don't want to do that? No, not at all. No, I want a little let's warm up to it. Let's start off with a Eagle Rare or a Weller one ⁓ seven or something. ⁓ yeah. James has had seventeen pores already this evening. It still knocked his dick in the dirt on first sip. You're right. Yeah. I mean it got me. I was like, whoa. It's hot. It's hot. But after that it's fantastic. Like the first I mean I mean, I think you probably took a big old gulp and probably did. Yeah. Like I didn't get that same re I didn't I didn't get that same reaction. Feel free if you need another a top off. ⁓ such a good nose. It's incredible. ⁓ this this thing is a monster. So I'm gonna go out not on a limb. I'm gonna I'm saying ⁓ we have filmed and it will be coming out soon. By the time this podcast ⁓ airs, you will all have already have seen it. ⁓ my best bottles of twenty twenty six through mid year. ⁓ obviously we're filming this in August. This was not on the list, but this is going on the list for a contender for best bottle of twenty twenty six. For sure. and we'll see. Maybe if we happen to get the twenty twenty six release of George C Sag this year and we get it in review, maybe it's GTS versus GTS in the competition. If not, twenty twenty six will go on twenty twenty six does anyone know what the Proof point of twenty twenty six is? No, no. No, though it'll drop in like you might get a hint of it in October and it'll drop in November, December, depending on your market. So usually for me, I've always picked these up like after the new year and the year after they come out for some reason. Do you have in your ⁓ information the lowest age? Yeah, yeah. The lowest age of a George T of a George T Stag ever 'Cause you said the highest age was like an eighteen year. Yeah, so they've they've they've always been fifteen years. Okay, they always been fifteen. So the very first three releases, two thousand two, two thousand three, two thousand four, were released right at fifteen years. Okay. And that was one thirty seven point six proof, one forty two point seven, and then one twenty nine. So a lot of variation in the first three years. ⁓ since then the next lowest was fifteen years, one month in twenty fifteen. Interesting. It kind of makes me wonder if they you know, just tried just to get it to that fifteen year point for the first couple and then just put it out and not really care as much what the juice was. And they were just like, I want it fifteen years. It's fifteen years, let's put it out. When they have the extra age on it. It's quite interesting. So Buffalo Trace, I believe what did we say earlier? I think I got the note here. Nineteen James did it. Ninety nine. He couldn't resist. Yeah, nineteen ninety nine is when the distillery was distilled so three years after they they ⁓ released or or rebranded the distillery, is when they released the BTAC collection. So obviously their those first three elite releases were what was it, George T. Stag Distillery or ⁓ probably not Stitzel Weller, 'cause no, that's two different distilleries. But I think that mash bill number one, I feel like was probably right in that time frame. So it was mash bill number one, the first three releases. Cause those would have been 15 years. Who knows? In 2002. So 15 years. Those are 1987 distillates. Yeah. 87. That's crazy to think, right? Right? 87 plus five. Yeah. Yeah. 87 distillates. So what was George T. Stag's distillate at The George T. Stag distillery in 1987. It wasn't Buffalo Trace Mash Bill number one. No. Or at least I mean, not it wasn't called Buffalo Trace Mash Bill. It wasn't, but was it the same recipe? Yeah, I wonder. Who knows? It is interesting. ⁓ more facts for a future episode. Yeah. I'll have to dig a little dig a little deeper. Listen, let let us know in the comments. George T Stag, James has already poured up his second pour. He got me one. I'm gonna finish talking here and I I actually just wanna just sit back and enjoy this thing. This thing is an incredible bottle. It really is. ⁓ if you can get one, do they're expensive. So if you're a fifty dollar, seventy five dollar and below drinker, That's okay. I'm sorry. This is not the episode for you. Or get you some good friends. well even the even the MSRP on this is a hundred and fifty bucks. So there are people out there to say, I'm not spending over a hundred dollars for bottle and In that case, Buffalo Trace Antique Collection is not in your wheelhouse, even at MSRP. but this thing's absolutely worth it. Yeah. I don't know about twelve hundred dollars. I I there's not a lot of no I think that's kind of crazy. Like what would you pay? What would I pay? I don't know. I'll say I've never paid that much for a yeah for a antique collection. I think secondary is around seven eight hundred for this right now in our area at least. Yep. So thousand twelve hundred or secondary on this? No, seven eight hundred. Seven eight hundred? Okay. Yeah, I think that's what we're kind of going for in our area here. Yeah. ⁓ I feel like it's not that's not crazy. I don't ⁓ as as crazy as it sounds saying it's not crazy. It is not crazy. It's not the the liquid like It blows you away. Comparative to what's like ⁓ Big anniversary. This is like retirement. This is like the biggest occasion you can think of if someone loved a higher proof and they liked a Saturday night in August in Phoenix. There we go. Cheers. You know. ⁓ it's it's true. I I mean, we are incredibly lucky to be able to do something like this. Agreed. Incredibly lucky. ⁓ but it is wonderful and ⁓ it It's not an everyday thing. So like it's yeah, ⁓ for that kind of price, it is that special though. So if someone appreciated high proof ⁓ higher age bourbon, this is something that they would absolutely appreciate. For sure. If you're looking for a bottle to celebrate a special occasion and you want to put it away and save it, or even you got a wedding or something you want to really make a pop off to, this this as long as you're not going to to drink a bunch of like ⁓ champagne with somebody or a bunch of beer guys, but if you got some bourbon friends you want to make an impression, this is a great bottle to don't don't be mixing it with Diet Coke, is that what trying to say? Yeah. No, no. We didn't invite those friends tonight that that wanted to put the the Diet Coke or the Mr. Pib with it. Drink whiskey how you like it except for George T sag. So I'm sorry. Drink how you like it at your house. Yeah. Leave ⁓ listen, I like a Diet Coke, but I'm not gonna put it in my George T sag. ⁓ Anyway, let us know in the comments. Have you got a George T. Stag? Is this the price range ridiculous? Are we crazy for thinking that seven hundred dollars isn't ridiculous for a George T. Stag? Are we are we crazy? Sure. Are we the crazy ones? Yeah. I I just just ⁓ people ask me all the time, ⁓ what'd you pay for the bottle? I paid four hundred fifty dollars for this bottle. So felt like it was a a decent deal, a little bit more than MSRP. Great deal. Not full secondary. And I said I'm buying it because I'm gonna. Hop it on the podcast. We're going to review it. We're going to talk about it. I think that's what we're going to do on everybody moving forward. So if you're here, we appreciate it. Thanks for all the support. If you like this episode or any of the episodes, like, subscribe, follow. Love to hear your comments. I try to respond to everybody's comments. We'll see you very soon for another episode on the three two three Bourbon Library podcast. Again, Ronnie, thanks for the pour. Yeah. Thanks, Roddy. Absolutely. Appreciate you sharing. Cheers. Cheers. Cheers.