Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / You Need to Worry If ... NCUA Asks for an Org Review
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trankel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm back again with Steve Farr and Todd Miller, formerly of NCUA, currently of
- 0:08my team at Credit Union Exam Solutions.
- 0:11How are you guys doing today?
- 0:13Feeling good.
- 0:13Feeling good.
- 0:15Feeling great.
- 0:15All right.
- 0:16All right.
- 0:17That's good.
- 0:17That's good.
- 0:18And we, a lot of our, we have a lot of longtime listeners and we appreciate
- 0:23that, but occasionally we, every week we get a few new listeners.
- 0:26Steve, if you could give a little bit of your background for someone who may not
- 0:29have heard you on the podcast previously.
- 0:32Miller: I'm going to take my background and make it up more specific of this
- 0:35topic, but I spent 30 plus years at N.
- 0:38C.
- 0:38U.
- 0:38A.
- 0:39the 1st, 15 was predominantly as a problem case officer and as a problem
- 0:44case officer, you're working with, of course, most troubled credit unions
- 0:47and I did a pretty much throughout the nation, but in those cases, I dealt
- 0:51with a number of issues where we had to deal with underperforming management
- 0:56or underperforming boards of directors.
- 0:58So that was a good experience there.
- 1:00Then for the last.
- 1:0115 plus years, I was in the central office and one of my duties in there was that I
- 1:09wrote the enforcement manual, which deals a bit with this topic inside of there.
- 1:15Definitely.
- 1:15I did get to deal with was seeing what regions.
- 1:19We're putting out in dealing with problem management in particular, they
- 1:23can take that experience going forward.
- 1:25And, lately, we've been focused a lot on corporate governance.
- 1:28So I think that as in this job, and I think that'll come into play.
- 1:33Treichel: You got a great summary and Todd.
- 1:36Farrar: I was with NCUA for 34 years or so.
- 1:38I'll break my career down into three parts.
- 1:42The first third of it, roughly, I spent as an examiner and a problem case officer.
- 1:48Interesting, Steve and I, we actually started under the same supervisor.
- 1:53And got a lot of shared experiences early on in our career.
- 1:55We're problem case officers together for a few years as well.
- 2:00The middle 3rd of my career, I was a regional capital market specialist
- 2:04and then the last 3rd of my career.
- 2:06I was a director of special actions supervising problem case officers.
- 2:11Capital market specialist, regional lending specialist, dealing with
- 2:15a lot of troubled credit unions and those underperforming ones
- 2:20as Steve characterized them.
- 2:23Treichel: But I'm going to guess that you guys work for the same director,
- 2:28special actions, but without naming names, is it the guy that you had a
- 2:32secret code where if you dropped the pen, he was supposed to stop talking?
- 2:36Farrar: Yes, we did work for him together.
- 2:38Yeah.
- 2:39Yeah.
- 2:39And we love him.
- 2:41Treichel: Yeah, we love love to death.
- 2:42I worked for him too, and another job and he never when I tried
- 2:46dropping the pen, he just ignored it.
- 2:47Yeah,
- 2:49Farrar: Generally ignored ours too.
- 2:51Treichel: Very good.
- 2:52All right.
- 2:53So with that organizational reviews, we've seen this in a small number of situations,
- 2:58but nonetheless, I'd say it's a growing trend that NC, from our client sample
- 3:03that we've seen situations where credit unions have been asked in some form or
- 3:07another to do an organizational review.
- 3:09So with that, I'll just leave it as a broad statement like that.
- 3:12And Steve kick it to you to give some.
- 3:15Your thoughts on this whole process, this whole requirement, excuse me.
- 3:19Miller: Yeah I would start by saying, if you're ever in a point to where
- 3:24your examiner starts talking about the need for the credit union to
- 3:28get an organizational study or an assessment of senior management,
- 3:34things are serious, very serious.
- 3:37And your camel code should be reflective of that.
- 3:40And it shouldn't come as a surprise to your credit union because either your
- 3:46professional management's underperforming.
- 3:48Or your board of directors underperforming and possibly not
- 3:52holding senior management accountable.
- 3:54So in sui and other regulars, look for what's a tool that we can use.
- 3:59To get a independent review as to how the credit union is managing its own business.
- 4:07I think that's a, it's a big step for and so it's why we don't see it a lot.
- 4:13We have had just a handful of cases, but it is very disturbing,
- 4:18of course, the place to it.
- 4:19And the other thing is it's expensive.
- 4:22I come through the usually 1 of the, it's put in and it starts as
- 4:26a door and it usually says, engage for an organization organizational
- 4:31structure and management assessment.
- 4:34And normally they'll point out that the reason for that is under
- 4:37performance of the board, or sometimes it's just lack of doing.
- 4:42Appraisals of senior management, but I've noticed that some of the things.
- 4:47It says ensure the assessment addresses at a minimum the following
- 4:51organizational structure and staffing to ensure sufficient oversight and
- 4:57appropriate separation of duties, senior management, qualifications
- 5:01and performance evaluations, effectiveness of job descriptions.
- 5:06To ensure they clearly outline duties and responsibilities of senior management,
- 5:11staff training and development.
- 5:13Management's reporting to the board of directors to ensure sufficient information
- 5:17is provided for sound governance.
- 5:21The other 1 that I have access to tell said to, to hire, obtain an
- 5:28organizational structure assessment, and it says 3rd party to perform
- 5:35a written assessment of the credit union's organizational structure.
- 5:39Including assessment of senior management to identify potential
- 5:43weaknesses and to improve management's oversight or effectiveness as
- 5:47well as the board's governance.
- 5:50And it really just says the same thing as I said before, job descriptions,
- 5:54staff training, management reporting.
- 5:57And what they'll often say is obtain approval of the 3rd party from your
- 6:02assigned supervisor and examiner prior to entering into an engagement.
- 6:08That's what the once have been saying, and they've been really consistent.
- 6:13I have throughout my career looked at what is doing in this same area and
- 6:20I do much prefer the way they write.
- 6:24What they're asking their institutions to do when they are requiring
- 6:29management analysis, and I'll say develop written analysis and
- 6:32assessment to the banks management needs for the purpose of providing
- 6:37qualified management to the bank.
- 6:39And there's a juice is a little more.
- 6:41I like.
- 6:42Some items inside of what they require the management study shall include a
- 6:47minimum identification of both the type and number of officers positions needed
- 6:53identification and establishment of such bank committees that are needed.
- 6:58Evaluation of all bank officers to determine these individuals, but since
- 7:02the ability experience and qualifications required to perform their duties.
- 7:06Evaluation of all bank officers compensation, including salaries.
- 7:11These and other benefits the plan to recruit and hire any
- 7:15additional replacement personnel with requisite ability experience
- 7:19and other qualifications.
- 7:21The other thing that FDIC does a lot is they address this in that the engagement
- 7:27letter needs to address these items.
- 7:29So it's right up front to make sure that what they're asking the
- 7:34institutions to do is clear within the agreement with the 3rd party.
- 7:39And this 1 usually has the description of work to be performed under the contract.
- 7:44The responsibilities of the consultant.
- 7:47Identifications of the specific procedures to be used when carrying
- 7:51out the work performed, qualifications of the consultant, provision for
- 7:56unrestricted access by the supervisory authorities to the consultant work papers.
- 8:02I think that 1 is a real important 1 there and that that's, the regular can
- 8:06look at what they're, what they've done.
- 8:09The statement that the consultant is not affiliated with any,
- 8:11in any manner with the bank.
- 8:13And a requirement, the consultants analysis and assessment be
- 8:17several summarized in a written report within 90 days from the
- 8:21date of the engagement letter.
- 8:23The thing I really like about the things is they address what
- 8:27do you do with that report?
- 8:29And it says, usually, it says within 30 days of the consultant study.
- 8:34The board must submit to the supervisor authorities and acceptable written
- 8:39management plan that addresses the findings in the consultant study.
- 8:43And I think that is item that is often missed in that are
- 8:46just requires that it's done.
- 8:48And then doesn't have that follow up requirement for what
- 8:52needs to take place in there.
- 8:53I'm looking through the 3rd letter that I have here.
- 8:58See if there's anything different.
- 9:00No they're pretty consistent there.
- 9:02The big thing on that is, is now it comes down to who are those 3rd parties?
- 9:07And they're not easy to find.
- 9:10I'll open it up for you guys as to, what we're finding out there in
- 9:14terms of, if you're asked to do this.
- 9:17What is the availability of good 3rd parties?
- 9:22So I'll throw that 1 out there for our discussion.
- 9:26Treichel: Very good.
- 9:26A lot.
- 9:27A lot.
- 9:27A lot.
- 9:28You walk through there.
- 9:29I'm going to Todd any thoughts on what Steve said there at the end
- 9:32relative to good 3rd parties or.
- 9:35Any anything beyond that you want to highlight that
- 9:38relative to what Steve said.
- 9:40I
- 9:40Farrar: just want to re emphasize a couple things that Steve said
- 9:43before we answer his question about who are these third parties.
- 9:48The first one, Steve said, hey, these are serious problems.
- 9:50Usually they're systemic and by the time NCUA issues a DOR of this nature,
- 9:57they've reached the conclusion that management is unwilling or unable
- 10:01to address the underlying problems.
- 10:04They don't do this lightly.
- 10:05They do it.
- 10:07On a rare occasion, just another little side piece to this.
- 10:11It's also not uncommon where you'll see this targeted at one department
- 10:15within the credit union, basically exact same language addressed to
- 10:20the commercial lending department or the same exact language addressed
- 10:24to an accounting department.
- 10:26That probably happens, especially with the commercial lending more often
- 10:30than the overall organizational 1.
- 10:33For credit unions that get one of these or boards that get one of these, it's really
- 10:36important to e read that fine print.
- 10:40You don't want to go out and hire someone and get them started when
- 10:44your LUA or document or resolution says NCUA approval of the vendor and
- 10:50you start down the path of paying the money without getting NCUA approval.
- 10:54So you have to be careful with that your accrediting that receives one of those.
- 10:59And the second piece of it is.
- 11:00Oftentimes, not always, but NCUA will say, Hey, we want to approve the scope
- 11:05engagement letter with that vendor.
- 11:08Make sure you do that before they start work.
- 11:10But like Steve said, it's a pretty critical issue when a credit union starts
- 11:15getting one of these, because you're at the point where NCUA probably correctly
- 11:21believes the current management team is unwilling, unable to address the
- 11:26problem without the Changes of some sort.
- 11:29And it doesn't always mean that it's the CEO.
- 11:33Maybe you just need the right people in the right departments.
- 11:36And it's not always, hey, get rid of everyone.
- 11:39It's get the right people in the right departments.
- 11:42Treichel: The words unwilling and unable that unwilling and unable.
- 11:44That's where Chris is going with that.
- 11:46That's code words for at least a management code 3, right?
- 11:49Because the camel code 3 definition for management is unwilling or
- 11:53unable to resolve the problems.
- 11:55I've seen, I think I've seen a handful of 4, maybe 4 of such.
- 12:03Such requests since I started consulting.
- 12:06I'm aware of 2 different parties that dealt with it.
- 12:10One of whom, if I was to recommend, I'd be comfortable recommending, and another
- 12:14one, which was an East Coast State Chartered Credit Union, and the report
- 12:20they got was draconian, might be a better way to put it, and in that situation,
- 12:26the document resolution, which was being driven more by the state than in CUA,
- 12:31had a clause in there that said, and you will adopt every recommendation of
- 12:36the report, which to me was overzealous unwarranted because just because a
- 12:42consultant recommends, it doesn't mean a credit union should have to do it.
- 12:45The board should have the ability to ultimately decide that.
- 12:49And I think the language Steve, that you Sighted there from the FDIC reports
- 12:55that essentially said and develop a plan within X number of days to deal
- 12:59with what the findings of the report are that gives more flexibility to
- 13:04the board to do what needs to be done.
- 13:06And as Todd, as you pointed out there.
- 13:08It doesn't necessarily mean the CEO.
- 13:10It doesn't mean necessarily that you need to let people go, but you might need to
- 13:15add people to your team in a particular department, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:19When the results of these ports come out and the board decides
- 13:23how to best deal with that.
- 13:25Yeah, and.
- 13:27The, what I, what we might wanna do too is maybe I can put a link or two
- 13:33in the show notes to some of those examples that are out there from FDIC.
- 13:38'cause those are public.
- 13:38What happens in the nnc, Steven, the reason you have access to
- 13:42those is those are in the form of a public cease and desist order.
- 13:46Where they've made it public that the bank needs to do that.
- 13:51I've not.
- 13:52I don't recall, I know I never used that at NCUA where I went
- 13:55with a C and D and made it public that a credit union need to do it.
- 13:59That's a tool that FDIC uses far more than NCUA, but we could put a link to
- 14:03that in the show notes of this exam.
- 14:07Miller: Yeah, one other item that has come up with these items was that one examiner
- 14:12asked and really was insistent upon that the consultant would send them directly.
- 14:18The final report and I really was uncomfortable with that because the
- 14:24credit union has engaged this person.
- 14:26They have done that report for the credit union.
- 14:30I think it's only right that the credit union should be able
- 14:33to receive the report, attach a cover letter on it saying that it.
- 14:37Here's the report basically stating their understanding of what the report
- 14:42says and what they're going to do with it to provide at least some insight
- 14:47to the examiner versus just getting the report from directly from the
- 14:52vendor and which the credit would at the same time be seeing the report.
- 14:58Treichel: Yeah, great point.
- 14:59I would say that, you definitely, the credit union should definitely
- 15:02have the opportunity to see it first and then forward it along.
- 15:06Obviously, NCOA can get access, but it's a little bit of an overstep there.
- 15:10I agree with your thoughts relative to that.
- 15:13The other thing that, that pops into my mind is and I've advised a lot of
- 15:18credit unions relative to this, who the credit union employs is 100 percent up
- 15:24to The credit union now, if you're a troubled institution, and you're needing
- 15:28to bring somebody on and your code for your code 5, some higher level positions
- 15:32and board positions need to be approved by, but you get to propose who you want.
- 15:37But as far as staff that are on site, cannot stay, you need to fire
- 15:42person X, person Y, or person Z, and they cannot be that direct.
- 15:47These approaches where they're looking for organizational.
- 15:51Reviews, if there is someone that in NCOA's mind, they believe shouldn't
- 15:56be at the credit union, this is a little bit of leading the course to
- 16:00water saying, hey, we know you have weaknesses here, hire a consultant to
- 16:04help you figure out where they are.
- 16:05That's as close as NCOA can come in those situations to to addressing
- 16:11deficiencies in management.
- 16:13Any general thoughts on what I just said there?
- 16:15Farrar: The 1 or 2 times where I've done this as a DSA or a problem case officer,
- 16:21it's exactly the situation you outlined.
- 16:24We generally knew who the problem employees were that needed to be
- 16:29replaced either by terminated or by someone else stepping into their role
- 16:33and demoting people or what have you almost always As examiners, or as the
- 16:37director of special actions, we knew who that person was having an organization
- 16:42review like this done was a way to get in convey that same information to the
- 16:48board because a competent third party is going to identify the same areas.
- 16:52And it was generally effective.
- 16:54The times we've used it in that manner
- 16:58Treichel: point.
- 16:59Great point.
- 17:00All right.
- 17:01What else?
- 17:01What else here, guys?
- 17:02Do we want to talk about on this topic?
- 17:04It's a serious situation.
- 17:06Make sure that you get a scope that is acceptable to you and N.
- 17:11C.
- 17:11U.
- 17:11A.
- 17:12Steve, when you talked about When you were reading through how the
- 17:15FDIC does it, it sounded a lot to me like one thing that popped in my head
- 17:18is if you ask the wrong question, you're going to get the wrong answer.
- 17:21And then it almost sounded like the way they were doing it was like an
- 17:24agreed upon procedures from a CPA firm.
- 17:27What are the procedures that you're going to get done that will comply
- 17:31with what you need done and what NCUA is wanting you to get done?
- 17:36Those are some wrapping thoughts I have.
- 17:37But you guys have any general other thoughts before we close?
- 17:41We put this 1 out there live for the listening of audience.
- 17:46Miller: I think one of the main thing is if you're, if you get one of these
- 17:50things, you're going to probably have to practice some humility and
- 17:53that'll probably get you through it a lot easier and to recognize that.
- 17:57Yeah.
- 17:57You're not perfect and you may have some blind spots that this can help you with,
- 18:02but those, Credit unions to deal with it in that if it's the CEO thereafter,
- 18:07but if the CEO can say, you know what, I don't need to be the smartest person
- 18:11in the room anymore, I really just need to get better people underneath me and
- 18:16get an understanding of what skills are needed there that can be, as Todd says,
- 18:20some things as simple as the fixes to what it is he's looking for, because.
- 18:25We all were in institutions that had CEOs that we weren't overly impressed
- 18:31with, but 1 about them is, was they were willing to hire good people and
- 18:36let them do what they needed to do.
- 18:38And, they took more of a role that actually ended up being
- 18:41more of a figurehead and take care of all those other.
- 18:46Items at the credit union, but let the smarter people they brought
- 18:49in actually do the operations and fix the things that are there.
- 18:52So it isn't, isn't into the world, but it is a great tool for boards
- 18:57board of directors and those to do.
- 18:58But 1 of the common things you'll see on these was poor assessments being done by
- 19:04the board of directors is they need that you need to make sure that you as a board.
- 19:09Are doing good assessments of your professional management and that
- 19:12you're making it clear, when those will be done and what you're looking
- 19:15for and what you're expecting from those top level managers.
- 19:21Treichel: Great point.
- 19:21Great point.
- 19:22And Todd any Steve, you just reminded me of something I'm going to, I'm
- 19:25going to mention here in a second.
- 19:26But Todd any final thoughts from you?
- 19:29Farrar: No, other than that, these are costly.
- 19:32You need to take them seriously.
- 19:33Read those reports closely when you get them back.
- 19:35You paid a lot of money for them.
- 19:38I think Steve hit a great point that you need to approach it with some humility.
- 19:42Just getting the report done and throwing it in the drawer is not
- 19:45going to appease the examiners and it's not going to address the
- 19:48issues that they want addressed.
- 19:51And generally when you get one of these, it's not one problem that you're facing.
- 19:57It's generally systemic problems.
- 19:59Throughout the credit union, and it does require, as Steve
- 20:03said, some smarter people with, deeper backgrounds to fix them.
- 20:08Ultimately, if you continue to be unwilling or unable your credit may
- 20:13end up in conservatorship or insolvent.
- 20:15Take it very seriously because we've done podcasts on
- 20:18conservatorship in the past and.
- 20:21That's the next step after one of these if this doesn't address the
- 20:25problems in an effective manner.
- 20:28Treichel: That's another great set of points there.
- 20:32And Todd, you segued into 1 thing that I, the example I was going
- 20:35to give here to wrap it up and that's the word conservatorship.
- 20:39And, of course, conservatorship is when has removed the board and is running
- 20:43the credit union, and the credit union can be merged or Or can be returned to
- 20:47the members and I was watching going back to a situation where we had a
- 20:53conservatorship in the region I was in and I was watching the Super Bowl and
- 20:56the phone rang and it was my, it was the regional director and we were supposed
- 21:01to be flying on Wednesday to recommend a credit union come out of conservatorship.
- 21:07And of course, you put in a long package saying all the problems are
- 21:10fixed and the team that's running.
- 21:11This is the premium.
- 21:14And so that's the documentation we had sent in and the regional
- 21:18director called me and said.
- 21:20The CEO is upset because he didn't like the performance appraisal he
- 21:25got from the problem case officer.
- 21:28And they had they had given the CEO a bad review between when we sent the package
- 21:35in and when and when we were going to do the presentation that it was a really
- 21:41bad performance review for the CEO.
- 21:43So I had to call the director of special actions during halftime.
- 21:47And I said director of special actions, we have this situation.
- 21:51We've just told the industry board, this is going on.
- 21:54The CEO is upset and isn't going to accept this appraisal.
- 21:58I said, you need to talk to the problem case officer and resolve this issue.
- 22:02He called the problem case officer who didn't want to change it.
- 22:05He called me back and said, he's not going to change it.
- 22:08I said, okay, so here's my question for you.
- 22:10I said, he's not going to change it.
- 22:13Tell him to call me and explain why he put a package into the end to a board
- 22:16that said everything is fantastic.
- 22:19But this guy is unacceptable.
- 22:20Okay, if he can answer that question, he doesn't have to change that appraisal.
- 22:24And by the end of the game, I got a call back and said, we've revised the
- 22:29appraisal and sent it to him, but the.
- 22:32Regional director ended up flying and meeting with the.
- 22:35CEO, I believe it was in the Philadelphia airport.
- 22:39They rented a, he rented a hotel office meeting room at the hotel,
- 22:45got him to agree to stay so that then he could go make the presentation
- 22:49and say that everything was fine.
- 22:51Those appraisals, sometimes, everybody, nobody's perfect, right?
- 22:56There's things that need to be approved.
- 22:58But in this instance, NCUA was trying to make a point that went awry because
- 23:02again, the individual was doing.
- 23:04A really good job.
- 23:05There were just some personality conflicts between NCOA and the CEO.
- 23:10I always wondered if I'd ever weave that story into one of these
- 23:12podcasts, and this is the one where it seemed to have happened.
- 23:15So we'll see if I edit that out.
- 23:17I don't any edit anything out, so it'll be here.
- 23:19All right guys, as always,
- 23:22Farrar: that was a good, that was a good story.
- 23:24If I was a DSA, I'd have been really upset if my PCO did something like that.
- 23:28Treichel: Yeah, and the poor guy, we both, if I told you the
- 23:32name, you'd know who it was.
- 23:34And he was in an acting role.
- 23:36He was a PCO, basically having to work for his boss, who was somewhere else.
- 23:40So he was actually having to call his peer and tell him, and he did a
- 23:44really good job once I, once once I explained what the real options were.
- 23:49Okay, guys, thanks so much.
- 23:51I appreciate it as always.
- 23:52It's nice that we can share some of these war stories.
- 23:55I appreciate your time today, guys.
- 23:57And listeners, I want to thank you.
- 23:58I appreciate your time.
- 23:59I hope you'll give us more time down the road.
- 24:01We appreciate you listening.
- 24:03And this is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.