Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter two in our deep dive series on
- 0:05the Duggers, two out of one hundred from the reality TV show Realm.
- 0:09In the last chapter, we talked about some introduction things and we went down
- 0:14some tangents. So if you want to listen to that, you have to
- 0:17become a patron of the podcast the full episode and this episode will also have
- 0:21a free portion and then a patron only patron. I want to reward the
- 0:25patrons for actually giving us the ability to pull time away from our jobs so
- 0:30that we can actually spend a month of our all of our free time and
- 0:34really just my worktime, because that's what I do. I don't know how
- 0:38many hours I've spent looking into this, probably just like fifty sixty hours straight,
- 0:43maybe more honestly, But it's also really interesting. It's entertaining to look
- 0:47into I think. So anyway, let's start with the next bit of my
- 0:51notes here. Let's get into the Dugger family themselves. So some specifics about
- 0:57them. So, the Dugger family lives in rural Arkansas. They are conservative
- 1:02Christians or Fundies as they might be called, or even called themselves. The
- 1:07parents are Jim Bob who is fifty eight currently right now and or mid twenty
- 1:11twenty three, and Michelle is the mom who's fifty six. They have nineteen
- 1:17children. You know, they've had some miscarriages, it doesn't count that,
- 1:22but so they have nineteen children that are living and twenty eight grandchildren. So
- 1:27among their nineteen children, several of them are married with kids, and there
- 1:30are twenty eight grandchildren. The oldest is Josh, which we'll get into later.
- 1:37He's currently thirty five. He's married to a woman named Annash who was
- 1:42also thirty five, and they have seven children and also all the way,
- 1:46so you got Josh who's thirty five, and then the youngest is Josie at
- 1:49thirteen. Oh, the youngest is already thirteen, so yeah, interesting,
- 1:53So that's thirteen years ago was their last wow. Yeah. So it's a
- 1:59good thing though that Josh when they named Josh, because we'll get into the
- 2:02timeline later. They didn't plan on having this many kids. But it's a
- 2:07good thing that they didn't name Josh with a Q, x U or Z
- 2:12name, right, because that would have really hampered things and hampered things.
- 2:17So all dame there because it's all Jay. By the way, if you
- 2:21didn't know. So you got Josh, Janna, John David, Jill,
- 2:25Jessa, Ginger, Joseph, Josiah, Joe, Joey, Anna, Jed,
- 2:30Jeremiah, Jason, James, Justin Jackson, Johanna, Jennifer, Jordan,
- 2:36Grace, and Josie. Is that like because of Jesus? Is that
- 2:40the idea? Like? I don't think so. I think they probably you
- 2:45know, a lot of Josh's who are thirty five right now, by the
- 2:46way, there's a lot of just wondering why they decided, like, Okay,
- 2:50we're going all Jays. Yeah, I mean they went Josh, Janna,
- 2:54John, David, so who knows, but there are a lot of
- 2:59those are biblic names. But yeah, yeah. So with Q though,
- 3:05berto I was thinking about if they had named, for example, what's a
- 3:10que first name's what's a cat? Quinn? Okay, Quinny. So if
- 3:19Josh was named Quinn and they had to followed up with a bunch of quincy,
- 3:22okay, you got Quincy, Quincy Jones, right, any other qu
- 3:25que names, Well, I actually looked it up. You got Quentin,
- 3:30Tarantino, quin Quintin's, you got quest love. Quest is a thing?
- 3:37Is is it a name? I mean, and there's a seahawk free Safety
- 3:42by the name of Quandre Digs. So that's all. That's all the ques.
- 3:47Then they would have had to stop having kids because that's only five names,
- 3:52and hopefully all of them were uh, you know boys. Okay,
- 3:58so dougger fandom. Let's get into this for a little bit because this is
- 4:01something I didn't know about. Of course, I knew that they had fans,
- 4:04because why would they be famous? But during the deep dive, I'm
- 4:09sure you realize this too. They have a very dedicated fan base, like
- 4:15very dedicated. They stand for a lot of things to that following. What
- 4:19do you mean it's not just the fame from like, oh they were that
- 4:24family on TV, because see, like, to me, let's say I
- 4:27had been into the show, which I never watched, but let's say I
- 4:30had been, then for me it would have been like, oh, there's
- 4:31that family from TV. But I think for a lot of their core fan
- 4:35base, it is that's that life that we need to live, That is
- 4:41that vision of who we need to be. That is, you know,
- 4:44the embodiment of these philosophies. And so right, well, are you saying
- 4:48other fundamentalist Christians or are you're just talking about people in general? I know,
- 4:54I think a lot of the Christian community that would that would be,
- 4:57which is tons and tons of people, Ye would see them as more than
- 5:00just like that famous family from TV, but rather again a symbol, right,
- 5:05and so yes, it's kind of like if if you and I watched
- 5:09the reality show but it was about a musician, but it wasn't just that,
- 5:13Oh it's that famous musician, but he was like the singer songwriter movement
- 5:16of the of the new resurgence of that or something, and it was like
- 5:19a symbol to us. But this is like a symbol that that represents who
- 5:25who they need to be as families, who they need to be as communities,
- 5:27who they need to be for their their religion. So guidance, Yeah,
- 5:30why else would they gravitate so much? Why do you think they needed
- 5:34a show like this, This this subculture. I'm gonna say it was not
- 5:39perceived as being okay in modern post two thousand Society'd be like I have nineteen
- 5:44kids, I have fourteen kids, you know, I I and and I
- 5:47think this this flies in the face of that. It's like, what,
- 5:49no, not only is it okay? That's what unique to do. And
- 5:54so it's it's like a vindication maybe of legitimizes legitimizes their humanizes, you know,
- 6:00because if you heard of a conservative, fundamentalist Christian family in rural Arkansas
- 6:06with nineteen kids, I think a lot of people would have the stereotype of
- 6:11like people who are extremely uneducated, who are in inbreeding, that kind of
- 6:21thing. So they just percent on the surface like, oh, okay,
- 6:28yeah, it turns out their work things. But at least on the service,
- 6:31right, it looked like it's just a regular family. Yeah, they
- 6:34really love each other. Yeah. And I didn't watch much of this show
- 6:38obviously because it would take forever, but from my understanding and from the clips
- 6:44I saw, they really shaved off a lot of the specifics of this family
- 6:49that we would learn later or yeah, what what they were saying in the
- 6:53documentary. Again, I didn't watch the show, but what I was seeing
- 6:56was that a lot of it, and it makes sense. A lot of
- 7:00it was like problem solving, right, like how do you do this when
- 7:02you have this many people? Right? You? So I've noticed this about
- 7:06ninety day fiance that I was watching that show, and then I would notice
- 7:13it kind of that they didn't go into politics. You know, there'd be
- 7:16a character from like rural Georgia or Alabama, and I'm and in the background,
- 7:24I'm seeing little paraphernalia bits, you know, like literally a Confederate flag
- 7:30with with one of the characters on a shot glass. You know. The
- 7:33editors didn't see it too to like, or the producers didn't because it was
- 7:39a small thing. And I noticed that they didn't go into politics, they
- 7:43didn't go into you know, certain hot button topics, and I was like,
- 7:47huh. And then I watched another show that's not on TLC, I
- 7:50believe anyway, called Married at First Sight, where people literally get married as
- 7:56soon as they meet and then you follow them after that to see if they
- 8:00stay married essentially, And on that show, they go full into their religious
- 8:05and political beliefs. Yeah, like it's I mean, it's whatever the cast
- 8:11member wants to talk about, and for some of them, for a lot
- 8:15of people, their religion is front and center in their life. And I
- 8:18was like, oh, yeah, yeah, that really contrasts with ninety Fiance
- 8:22that's on TLC that there's nothing there, but there were indications of it.
- 8:28Right. There'd be someone that would say like, well, you know,
- 8:31men and women can't be friends this sort of thing. I'd be like huh,
- 8:35and I'm thinking, well, that is some religious people believe that,
- 8:39or it kind of evokes some conservative notions or something. Or or you have
- 8:43a ninety eight fiance. You have a white person dating or or engaged to
- 8:50someone from another country, maybe like Africa or something, and the person isn't
- 8:56white. And then the very common trope on ninety fiance is the American individual
- 9:03will be in conflict with their family as their family is saying, you know,
- 9:09you can't marry this person, you don't even know them, and the
- 9:11kinds of things. So there's just one family in Florida that I remember,
- 9:16Elizabeth and Andre for people following along, and they the way they would talk
- 9:22about Now, Andre is from Eastern Europe, but I think it's in line
- 9:26with this, like Member Donald Trump said, like from shit countries, you
- 9:31know that one of those Eastern European countries, right, It's not like France
- 9:35or England. It's like one of those shit Eastern Bloc countries, you know.
- 9:41And the I mean I don't know that, but because they don't go
- 9:43into it. But the way they talked about him, and then they actually
- 9:48go to his country because the wedding is going to be in his country,
- 9:52or they had a second wedding in his country, and they were just publicly
- 9:58ridiculing everything about culture, you know, the food and the way they were
- 10:03talking about it. You know, the way they were talking about it.
- 10:07They were very you know, blonde, just superior, just talking down and
- 10:13no mention of their political beliefs, no mention of other things like this,
- 10:18and where their influences, Like where do they get these kinds of ridiculous notions.
- 10:22I mean, generally in America you have these notions, but but specifically
- 10:26there's you know, their echo chambers in our country. And so with the
- 10:31Dugger show, I imagine, and it sounds like it's very similar, right
- 10:35like where they like they certainly because they were the Duggers were saying like they
- 10:41made a deal that they would agree to the show if they let them show
- 10:45their religion. But I get the sense that it was like the vanilla flavors,
- 10:50right, and everything about like the thing was more about how do you
- 10:54make a family with so many people work? Everything is a problem. How
- 10:58do you transport them? How do you feed them? How do you coordinate
- 11:00a party, how do you do this? How do you live together?
- 11:03How do you share a room? Like all these kinds of things, and
- 11:05then fights that emanate from that or conflict resolution and then and in there,
- 11:11of course, sprinkled in are their beliefs and their community and all these things.
- 11:18But it's not like every episode is like we're going to convert you.
- 11:20Well, and also the more atrocious beliefs and behaviors and practices were completely left
- 11:28out. Yeah, you know, they had things like in this show that
- 11:31the courting in that you it's chaperone and you can't kiss until you're married or
- 11:37something, and that can all seem it's quaint, but yeah, it seems
- 11:43quaint, and the kids are okay with it, seemingly at least of the
- 11:46service. But the show doesn't go into this prescriptive abuse of the children,
- 11:52and you know, it doesn't go into Bill Gothard and his controversies. I
- 11:56watched the series on YouTube with two dudes that were in the IBOP and they're
- 12:03they're not no longer, of course they haven't been for years and years,
- 12:05but they grew up in it. Yeah, so like, first of all,
- 12:07there was no talking between a guy and a girl, like you just
- 12:11don't talk unless there's official courting happening, and in which case there's very specific
- 12:16things, but often like the woman really didn't have a say in the matter.
- 12:20So like, if this guy wants to approach this parent and say,
- 12:24Hi, I'm interested in courting your daughter for a marriage, right because that
- 12:28was the only possible reason for courting. Then if they're like, cool,
- 12:31this guy's cool, Like that's going to happen. And not only what the
- 12:35way they were talking about it, not only would a woman not have any
- 12:37say in the matter, or the girl often not have any say in the
- 12:39matter, but in her mind, if she had an opinion about it,
- 12:45she would think it would be very disruptive and against the family and the community
- 12:48and everything to express set up in and so she wouldn't. So and you've
- 12:54been groomed since you were born to not have a self essentially and not understand
- 13:00that you have any rights of any preference for anything. And we're going to
- 13:03get that's a whole set of chapters right there in terms of the religion,
- 13:07because I did a whole deep dive on that. That's what you're saying.
- 13:11It's like all this stuff is kind of like, you know, colored loosely,
- 13:15right. So not only for people who are living in this world of
- 13:20look, they're showing the good side of us. Other places will highlight the
- 13:24bad side. But also you have non religious people because there were other sorts
- 13:28of Christians, there were other sorts of religious people. There were atheists who
- 13:33loved this show. So I actually took some notes on different ideas as to
- 13:37why I think people love this show. You mentioned a bunch they needed a
- 13:41wholesome Oh. I think another one is that generally speaking, I think people
- 13:46some people. I don't think I'm one of these people, but I think
- 13:50many people do legitimately in a non harmful way, they really want to watch
- 13:54wholesome television, you know, because there's so much on television, particularly now,
- 14:00Like so this is kind of a tangent, but I think it's related
- 14:03that my my wife, Stacy, her mom loves these Korean sitcoms, I
- 14:13think is what you would call them, or kind of drama das I guess
- 14:16and what and so we watched a bit of it, and what I the
- 14:22sort of style that I could glean was that it's kind of eighties American style
- 14:28it's sort of the Huxtables, And is it translated or is it like you
- 14:33have subtitles or yeah, you can listen to it with with English or you
- 14:37can you know, have the subtitles. So it's like a sitcom, like
- 14:43yeah, like one of them is this lawyer who's autistic or something. I
- 14:48can't remember, but but I've heard. So I heard that, and I
- 14:52thought, what's kind of interesting because Stacy's mom has never been interested in Asian
- 14:56television or anything. So I'm like, and how did you How did that
- 15:01algorithm on Netflix even suggest this to you? I don't know. But then
- 15:03I started hearing from more people who are our parents' age who are watching Korean
- 15:11sort of regular mainstream television shows, you know. And because it's more wholesome.
- 15:16Yeah, because if you turn on the television in the United States or
- 15:22Netflix and you start looking at mainstream kinds of things that people watch, you
- 15:26know, some does not come to mind. No, we have you know.
- 15:31I always think of how if you listen to bebop jazz, for example,
- 15:35in the forties fifties, you just think it sounds like a jumbled mess,
- 15:41But if you actually have heard everything that those people and their fans listen
- 15:45to. You know, if you listen to early early, if you see
- 15:50the progression, yeah, then you understand how they got there. It's similar
- 15:54with hip hop. You know, there's certain hip hop, alternative hip hop.
- 15:56When you listen to it, you're just like, what is happening right
- 16:00now? But if you listen to all the simple hip hop and you go
- 16:03through it, then you listen to the more avant garde stuff, you're like,
- 16:07oh, I know what they're doing there, and that's different, and
- 16:10I like that, you know, because a lot of music enjoyment is when
- 16:11it diverts. It's familiar, but it diverges a little bit. Well,
- 16:15in American television in the fifties and sixties, it was a lot of Ozzy
- 16:22and Harriet and stuff, right, and then we diverge from that a little
- 16:25bit, right, you have like mash and this kind of thing. But
- 16:27then eventually though, we started going sopranos and Euphoria and that show you like
- 16:36Sex Education. You know, I think it's it's it riffs, it's familiar,
- 16:40but it goes in a different direction, and so I think it leaves
- 16:45behind a lot of people that aren't really looking for that or aren't ready for
- 16:49it, or something like Beef Beef was a crazy yeah different show. Yeah,
- 16:53it's intense, the visuals are intense, the subject matters. Okay,
- 16:57yeah, people want us to watch there, and so maybe if the patrons
- 17:02or the YouTube members well for it, you know. But the so I
- 17:07think that similar to that the Duggers was in the odds, this other sort
- 17:15of thing that wasn't offered very often. So it's interesting because when I see
- 17:19even a little bit of it, because obviously I did see clips through all
- 17:22these documentaries and stuff, many clips, and I don't think it's because I
- 17:26know the context, I feel like I immediately get like very anxious and a
- 17:32little nauseous about it. So to me, it doesn't feel wholesome at all.
- 17:36Well, is that because you watched the documentary or so? No,
- 17:38what I mean is that, like there's things, there's certain triggers. Her
- 17:44voice, the mom's voice, just worries me so much because she it sounds
- 17:51like a movie, Like it sounds like this is an exaggerated character in a
- 17:55movie about a cult. You know, She's just like this and it's just
- 18:00so wonderful, And I'm immediately like, oh God, what is going on
- 18:04same thing with like the little situations I watched. I just so don't want
- 18:10to be part of that world. So I immediately like cocoon and be like,
- 18:14that's not wholesome. But I can understand for other people that could feel
- 18:18wholesome. Yeah, yeah, right, right. So the other question,
- 18:22though, it leads to, is well, why do people want wholesome?
- 18:26Well, there are some direct things where folks on especially on some of those
- 18:30religious pockets, feel that the world is literally going to hell, that everything
- 18:34is corrupt, wokeism, everything's got to be about sexuality and about horrible sexuality
- 18:41and devian sexuality, and so seeing the opposite of that to them is literally
- 18:45an oasis in the middle of this horrible desert, right, because I think
- 18:49there might be a heuristic that difference or change is scary. But also in
- 18:55these echo chambers, they're literally being brainwashed to think that it's the end of
- 19:00the world, that they're coming to convert your children to be trans or something.
- 19:06Oh my god. So Rebecca the co host, she posted a thing
- 19:11on Facebook and I think it kind of points in this direction. So,
- 19:17you know, truck Nuts, is that a show? Oh, you don't
- 19:19know what truck nuts are you've seen them. They're testicles that people will hang
- 19:25off the back of their trucks. Okay, you've never seen it, but
- 19:29I mean it's not a seat, it's not a seattle thing. I didn't
- 19:30know that was a thing. If I've seen them, I didn't recognize them.
- 19:34Yeah, I mean, I think it's been around for twenty years,
- 19:37and it's like a masculine thing to do. Like, here's my truck nuts.
- 19:41Yeah, my truck has testicles, has balls. And so this fairly
- 19:47realistic looking testicle thing is dangling off usually the hitch in the back of sound
- 19:52truck. And so someone took a picture of it, and then they had
- 19:56the caption maybe it's on Twitter or something or ex as they call it.
- 20:00God, Well, that's a whole other tangent. We shouldn't go down by.
- 20:03The person was saying, hey, I really like, so this is
- 20:07a known queer person on the internet and they're saying, hey, you know
- 20:11what I saw. I do you know where this is going? Where do
- 20:15you think it's going? Like making it all sexual but in the queer way?
- 20:19What I meaning? Like, Oh, I was maybe I'm wrong,
- 20:22but I was just thinking because they did this recently something else that where you
- 20:26turn it into this like, oh, like you're being very queer positive by
- 20:30showing you know, male testicles and you're you know, well yes, but
- 20:34to be specific, they're saying, this truck originally did not have balls,
- 20:40so oh it's a trans truck you gender confirm. Oh my god, this
- 20:45truck. This person is really great. What a good person that they that
- 20:51they did trans affirming. Yeah, because I've seen it. Like I said
- 20:56something recently too where some I don't know that detail, but someone was basically
- 21:00turning it around me like, oh this is great you support the gay community
- 21:03or something. Yeah, tangent really quick tangent, So anyone out there,
- 21:07tangent, tescicle, tangent, anyone out there that's like, oh, I
- 21:11hate Elon must by the way, I hate Elon Musk. But but it's
- 21:15like, oh and he's still stupid and he's ruining Twitter and stuff, and
- 21:17then you ask him like, yeah, well, how did it feel to
- 21:19quit because oh no, I'm still on it. Why well I need to
- 21:22be Why Oh because my livelihood I have to tweet? Dude, I don't
- 21:26want to hear it. Because there's a lot of YouTubers like this where though,
- 21:30and I'm totally on Boord like, I don't like the guy. I
- 21:32think he's very dangerous. I think what he's done is ridiculing all these things.
- 21:34That's why the day he took over, I deleted my app and I
- 21:40and I canceled my account, close my accounts. Anyone who's still like,
- 21:44oh, yeah, it's horrible, he's stupid stuff, but he's still tweeting,
- 21:47come on, get out of here, stop supporting the dude. Yeah,
- 21:49I don't know. I have a friend who is still on it,
- 21:53and yeah, yeah, I mean, it'd just be nice if you're still
- 21:56on it and you believe in it. But if you're still on it and
- 21:59you're like me, like I think, it's like, get out. I
- 22:03think I think there's room. Certainly, That's how I feel, because I
- 22:06don't care. I've I've never liked Twitter from the beginning, middle and end.
- 22:11I only had a Twitter account very begrudgingly over the years, and I
- 22:15would cancel it every once in a while because as a podcaster in media,
- 22:19you apparently have to have a Twitter account just so people can DM you,
- 22:23I think, but I've always disliked that, just the way it's laid out.
- 22:27I don't I don't really understand why it's laid out that way. But
- 22:30anyway, so I think it's totally it's hard right for someone that even if
- 22:37it's just for entertainment, they don't even post anything, right, they don't
- 22:41have any followers, but they like the format of the feed, right,
- 22:45don't come crawling to me with your complaints. But at the same time,
- 22:49if you're that person, I think you're totally okay for complaining about where things
- 22:55are going. You know that you're just like, I don't like what.
- 22:57I don't like that this is happening, and I don't like it. I'm
- 23:00not going to call it exs you're supporting the dude, Yeah, yeah,
- 23:03But you know it's like, imagine you're like concern about the environment and you
- 23:07buy it like a sports car, right, that'd be I was ridiculous actually
- 23:11going to bring that up. I just I think with this particular topic,
- 23:15I drew my line. I'm like, I'm not buying a Tesla, I'm
- 23:17not using Twitter or whatever that you want to call it. Yeah, I'm
- 23:19always gonna call it. But it's easy for you and I to do that
- 23:22because we didn't use them to begin with, you know what I mean,
- 23:25I guess. I mean, there are problems with Zuckerberg, but we use
- 23:29their products. You don't. You don't use them that often, but I
- 23:32do. And the problems, I agree, are there. But it's there's
- 23:34a difference between an egomaniacal billionaire who could watch it all burn if it was
- 23:40the right day, versus someone who like doesn't always do the best things privacy
- 23:45wise, who like you know, there's huge kit chasm between. I mean,
- 23:48if your hope is that by rejecting those people who stay but complain,
- 23:56is that they will leave and that will shut down and he will just go
- 24:02away Elon Musk, then yeah, I have the same fantasy. But I
- 24:07gave up on that fantasy like a few months ago because I thought it was
- 24:11going to burn down right away. But yeah, anyway, anyway, So
- 24:17going back to my notes, why do people need it to be a wholesome
- 24:21Why do people need to watch a wholesome family show? I think it's because
- 24:25of the things you're saying that they're not only to validate their fundy culture,
- 24:32but also because for people in general, change is scary, and maybe specifically
- 24:37around things becoming more progressive and more inclusive and not including their religion, their
- 24:44specific god believes, right. I mean, you gotta have an atheist who
- 24:47is racist and anti LGBTQ P, you know, just to big it and
- 24:52wants to watch the show because it's comforting to watch an watch a bunch of
- 24:56blonde white kids do their blonde white thing. But I think another reason is
- 25:03that most people are suffering most of the time, and some of those suffering
- 25:08people are soothed when they watch a happy family. Actually, when I posted
- 25:15my episodes with my mom, I did a series of interviews with my mom,
- 25:19and it was a very wholesome aside from a couple of moments where my
- 25:26mom was crying and really breaking down, you know, it was just us
- 25:30talking about my wholesome childhood and how everything was perfect. Really, and I
- 25:37would get some a lot of comments, very kind people saying a lot of
- 25:41nice things to my mom and me, but there were there was a theme
- 25:45among some of the individuals saying like this was a corrective experience for me hearing
- 25:51you talk about how your childhood was good, because for me, I've never
- 25:55I didn't have that. I the opposite, and I don't hear a lot
- 25:59of stories like that, and it gives me faith in humanity. And also
- 26:03I can kind of imagine, fantasize that I was in her shoes, and
- 26:07it feels good to have a mom that listen to. I mean, some
- 26:11people were even reacting of just like I could never have even you know a
- 26:15little bit of the conversation that you had with your mom on the air,
- 26:19not only just the way that my mom raised me and we've been together my
- 26:23entire life, but just the way that we were talking about things, just
- 26:27casually and fluidly and honestly. For these individuals are just like I can't imagine
- 26:34ever having that conversation with my parents. And I think for some people it's
- 26:40it's soothing, yeah, And so I think people would watching Duggers for that
- 26:42reason. Also, I think it could give parents ideas. You know,
- 26:48parents often are really isolated and ashamed, especially if they're dealing with difficulties with
- 26:53their families and the kids. And the show is centered around procedures on how
- 27:00to manage nineteen kids, so you know, maybe you get some ideas.
- 27:03I can't imagine them translating that well to the real world, but you know,
- 27:07as you said, it validates fundamentalists out there in the world, because
- 27:12can we think of another show. I'm sure they're out there, but is
- 27:15there another show that would even just center the story? Okay, right,
- 27:22that was not that was fiction, but which I'm sure was huge and had
- 27:26a huge controversy. Yeah, which is interesting. Yeah, and we'll get
- 27:30into that too. Why are so many of these ultra from the outside wholesome
- 27:37looking families. Underneath the surface, there's rampant sexual abuse happening, you know
- 27:44what I mean. I think you can say, well, law of averages,
- 27:48right, you just you sprinkle enough people who are going to abuse people
- 27:53around in the world. Some of them are gonna be fundamentals, and some
- 27:56of them are fundamentals, are not. But I think there is a part
- 27:59of the culture that actually might be kind of creating problem without a doubt that
- 28:04the systems that they had in place. I mean, it's hard to design
- 28:10systems that would make it possible for you to hide abuse, hide but actually
- 28:15promote or develop the motivation up Because for someone to be attracted and want to
- 28:22have sex with a four year old even if you're twelve years old, right,
- 28:26that is aberrant, Right, That's not normal. That's a disorder,
- 28:30right. So the fact that it was covered up, yeah, but I
- 28:34was talking even more generally just because well, I don't know how prevalent the
- 28:38Maybe you have the data of like the child like the pedophilia type stuff,
- 28:45but I meant even just the and maybe a lot of it was because they
- 28:48were underage girls. But I was thinking just the system of hierarchy set up
- 28:52in such a way where you never question, and authority is very rigid,
- 28:56and it happens to be the males in control, and it's set up similar
- 29:00to how like the Catholic Church had a system or has a system that also
- 29:04produces an environment that makes it easy to cover up these horrible situations. And
- 29:10we're going to go into that in full later. So another reason that I
- 29:14wrote down here is that it's a show that the whole family can watch.
- 29:17There are certain shows that will only appeal to kids or only adults should be
- 29:21watching, like the Sopranos or something, right, whereas a show like this,
- 29:23like you could actually have it with your family, can sit down with
- 29:26the whole family and watch it. I'd say, watch Bluey. Have you
- 29:29ever heard of Bluey? No, it's this Australian cartoon. It's a wonderful
- 29:33show. It's these dogs. It's a dog family. You want to talk
- 29:36wholesome, It's the most wholesome dog family. Yea. And you learn all
- 29:40these valuable lessons. It's good for kids and adults. Did they see that
- 29:44from Blues Clues, because well, I'm sure there was some influence, but
- 29:47it's called Bluey and it's great. But first, Bruto, it's actually take
- 29:51a break. What do you say, Let's do it all right? Back
- 29:57from the break, So continuing with my oats here, because it's a show
- 30:00on television and maybe the parents liked or something. If you're a kid and
- 30:03you start watching the show when you're five, you probably identify with the kids
- 30:08that are around your rage. Yeah, like when I watched The Brady Bunch,
- 30:11I identified with the ones around my age who did well, it didn't
- 30:15air when you were it as for you, I was watching it right,
- 30:19but I was watching it when I was five. So who did you identify
- 30:22the youngest boree three to five? No, it was actually like the lower
- 30:27it was like not the littlest girl, but like the two above that you
- 30:30identified with Janby and uh, you said girl that the two I said,
- 30:37not the littlest girl what's her name, but not the youngest one in girls,
- 30:41but like Bobby and the other little girl. No, jan and Marcia.
- 30:44No, they're the older ones. There's literally only three girls in the
- 30:48then only like maybe Bobby then or something. Bobby's a boy. Yeah,
- 30:52I know, I identified most with that like that. I was confused,
- 30:56okay anyway, yeah, okay, yeah, So for me, for I
- 31:00watched The Brady Bunch when I was a kid, and I was about three
- 31:03to five, so I definitely identified most with the younger kids because that was
- 31:07my age range. Yeah, yeah, I meet you. And I think
- 31:10The Brady Bunch wasn't even on that long. But so imagine having a show
- 31:15that you started watching, maybe even when you were born, right, and
- 31:18you watch your entire life and you see new kids, and then you see
- 31:22him growing up and you see the whole thing. Yeah, you see them
- 31:25growing up. Yeah, you see their older siblings. That would be quite
- 31:29a thing, right, And so that will add to the how it's just
- 31:33infused in your bones. And so I heard from a lot of fans of
- 31:37the show who were later disappointed by the controversies, who would talk about it
- 31:41this way, where it was a show that was beloved. It was it
- 31:44was you know, imagine it's sort of like Harry Potter, right if you
- 31:47grew up, Because for me, when I watched the movies, I Harry
- 31:52Potter came on the scene when I was around thirty or something. Yeah,
- 31:56so you know it's good, but imagine that attachment of growing up with it.
- 32:01Yeah, imagine you're literally ten when the first book comes out, and
- 32:06Harry Potters and then you know, in the actors in the movies. It
- 32:10would just feel like it's the most important thing on television stars. Yeah.
- 32:15Yeah, so I think that's another thing. And I would hear from fans
- 32:21online, like apparently after one of the dugger teen girls wore a jean skirt,
- 32:27but many teen fan well it was probably long. It's probably very long
- 32:31jean skirt, many teen fans ran out to buy the same so they could
- 32:37be like the Duggers kids would have hairstyles, they try to copy the hairstyles,
- 32:42that kind of thing. Yeah, I could see that. Oh,
- 32:46so here's an interesting thing. Apparently, and I read some accounts of this.
- 32:52Many kids and teens loved the Duggers. Reality TV show so much,
- 32:57but they were in a family that didn't go to church, but they love
- 33:00the show so much that they convinced their parents to drive them to church by
- 33:06themselves. The parents would pull up outside the church and drop the kid off
- 33:10so the kid could go to church because the kids the kid wanted to be
- 33:14an evangelical, just like the Duggers. Wow. Actually I have a parallel.
- 33:20So, when I was four or five six years old, my best
- 33:24friend Steve lived right next door and his family was very proud of their German
- 33:30heritage, which you don't see so much anymore, right, Yeah, but
- 33:36and they weren't. They're not racist or bigoted or anything, but they were
- 33:39proud of their of their German heritage. And by the way, they named
- 33:45their dog after Rammel, the general who during World War Two, So apparently
- 33:52I think the reason why they named their dog after Rama was because, and
- 33:58I don't think this is a super act it, but the story was that
- 34:00he actually opposed the third the third Reich, that kind of thing. I
- 34:06don't remember this really, but this will get to a story that my parents
- 34:09would later tell me that I apparently just really loved Germany or something. I
- 34:15didn't know anything about it. I just sort of picked it up at the
- 34:17age of four from my friend and their family, and I was always over
- 34:21there. And then when my little brother was soon to be born, and
- 34:25back then they I don't think they at least it wasn't common to have sonograms
- 34:30for uh, you know, to find out gender that sort of thing.
- 34:34But the my parents asked us kids, my older brother and sister and me,
- 34:38what they wanted my little brother to be. He said, I want
- 34:43him to be a German. That's literally what I said. So my brother,
- 34:46of course, says I want a brother. My sister says I want
- 34:49a sister, and then I said, I want him to be a German.
- 34:52That's hilarious. Yeah, So you know, when it's your world and
- 34:58you have no idea of the con text, right, if you're watching The
- 35:01Duggers when you're twelve, you don't understand the bigger picture. You're just like
- 35:07it'd be like if you're watching I don't know, well, Harry Potter and
- 35:13you want to dress up in that robe or something. Yeah. Like So
- 35:15for me, we've talked about this before because I was a little younger than
- 35:20you. So Star Wars to me, not only was it super important,
- 35:23but it was reality. There was an aspect about Star Wars that felt completely
- 35:30real. I looked at it almost as like history, and so you know,
- 35:35when I went to see Empire, I'm like, and then when I
- 35:37was waiting for a return to come out, there was so many, so
- 35:40many expectations to me that all felt real, and those characters felt real,
- 35:44and of course I wanted to be in that universe. Yeah, yeah,
- 35:47right, So imagine if there was a building down the street that was literally
- 35:52like a cantina and tattooine and you could go in there, right, you
- 35:58would you would have wanted to go. It's sort of like costplaying or something
- 36:01for these kids going to church. Right. So I also mentioned how it
- 36:06humanizes these individuals because they're not usually depicted and they're you know, they're usually
- 36:09ridiculed and at least mainstream culture. Yeah. Certainly, like I was saying
- 36:15before, the idea of like having that many kids was I mean, I
- 36:19think that was why they did it in the first place, because it was
- 36:21kind of this weird circus spectacle, but this kind of legitimized it. You
- 36:24know, it's like it's okay to do this, yeah, and it's okay
- 36:29to be a conservative Christian, right. I think it also might have humanized
- 36:34and I think that's important to humanize. I think that's a good thing people
- 36:37from rural Arkansas. Again, there's a stereotype. I think it also humanized
- 36:42homeschool kids because and I think still to this day, but I think particularly
- 36:46in the past. I mean, did you have associations with American homeschool homeschool
- 36:52kids when you were a teen in your twenties as an adult, yes,
- 36:57I've met many, not many, but a few people that were homeschool and
- 37:00they are a certain type. They're very in this case, they're very actually
- 37:05well read, and very almost nerdy about several topics, but also a little
- 37:09funny. But I'm funny, so whatever. But as a kid, I
- 37:14don't know, Yes, I feel like I did. Well, maybe as
- 37:17a kid, I didn't even know homeschooling exists, because honestly, my friends
- 37:22would have been from school. Yeah, so I don't think it was a
- 37:24very common thing. In fact, I think the documentary or a documentary I
- 37:29watched, went into this that at some point, yeah, at some point
- 37:31the government allowed homeschooling to happen, maybe because of movements similar to this or
- 37:37because of this movement. Well they talked, yeah, they specifically talked about
- 37:40that in the documentary that what was happening was the it was truancy you had
- 37:45to send kids to school. But because of the changes, basically social changes
- 37:52where they felt like, hey, wait a minute, now they're teaching things
- 37:54that we don't want taught, then there was this movement to change the laws
- 38:00to let them homeschool. Okay, yeah, so, but lots of stigma
- 38:05around homeschool get in fact, your suggestion that you know, at least anecdotally
- 38:09that the homeschool kids are a little weird socially or something like quirky or is
- 38:15not shown in the data. You know what I mean. There's a lot
- 38:19of Oh yeah, there's a lot of experiences one can have as a homeschool
- 38:22kid. You can be isolated and lack social opportunities, but you can also
- 38:29be homeschooled and have a lot of social activities. You know, there's a
- 38:31lot of different styles of homeschooling, so the stereotype doesn't and you know,
- 38:38there's a lot of stigma. So there's that Also, Middle America isn't usually
- 38:43you know what we will call on the coasts flyover states. Right, they're
- 38:49not usually depicted at all. Right, it's always Los Angeles or New York
- 38:52or something, So there's that. We also talked about how a lot of
- 38:57people might watch it as a freak show, but then maybe they would fall
- 39:00in love with the show anyway. Actually, I'm just gonna a quick pause
- 39:04right now, and the rest of the rest of this well, that's the
- 39:07tangent the rest of this episode. Oh that's good. Yeah, yeah,
- 39:10the rest of this episode is just going to be for patrons of the This
- 39:16is going to be for patrons of the podcast. So if you want to
- 39:19listen to the rest of this chapter, you have to become a patron by
- 39:22going to patreon dot com. Do so now if you want otherwise, if
- 39:25you don't, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.