Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Cersei Lannister (Game of Thrones)(2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hello, deserving listeners. So after I posted episodes on Jeoffrey and Ramsey from
- 0:14Game of Thrones, a lot of people will have asked me, really yelled
- 0:19at me to do an episode about Circe Lanister. So let's do a deep
- 0:24dive on Circe. This episode is going to be long, so strap in
- 0:29and get ready for a long Is that the right phrase? Strap yourself in
- 0:34and get ready for a long episode. Today we're going to talk about the
- 0:37family history of Circe and her family going back to her grandfather. We're going
- 0:42to talk about her childhood, her life. Maybe I'll speculate about where this
- 0:47character will end up in the books and on the TV show in the future.
- 0:51We're going to analyze her personality, and at the end, I'll talk
- 0:54about some trivia regarding Lena Hetty, the the the actress who wonderfully on the
- 1:00HBO TV show. Also know that I'm going to spoil the entire seasons one
- 1:07through six, So as I'm posting this, it's early twenty seventeen, before
- 1:12season seven, so this won't include any information from season seven of the TV
- 1:17show or from the sixth book. But I'm here to spoil everything, so
- 1:23but I'm going to take a guest and say that anyone who is interested in
- 1:27listening to this has already watched all the episodes at least once, if not
- 1:33a number of times like I have. So just know that, and if
- 1:40you haven't ever watched the show, I highly recommend it. This is the
- 1:45Psychology and Seattle Podcast. I am your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I
- 1:51am chair of the Couple in Family Therapy program at Antioch University in Seattle,
- 1:57and I'm also a licensed marriage of Family therapists. So let's provide some background.
- 2:04Let's go back to Circe's grandfather, Titus Titos Lanister. I'm not sure
- 2:08how to pronounce his name, Titos Lanister, so I'm going to give a
- 2:14lot of information that precedes the books in the TV show. So he was
- 2:21Lord of Casterly Rock and head of House Lanister, just as you would suspect.
- 2:27He was the father of Taiwan Lanister and Kevin Lanister. He also had
- 2:31some other children that I won't go into. He is the grandfather, as
- 2:37I said, of Sir c Jamie, Tirian and Lancel among other great grandchildren.
- 2:42Titos presided over a period of decline for House Lanister. He lost much
- 2:49of the family fortune on poor investments. He was mocked by others in court.
- 2:55He was perceived as being a very weak life leader. So just think
- 3:00about that for a second. It's hard to imagine. This is Taiwan's father,
- 3:05Titus Leinster was bad with money and he was weak. So this perception
- 3:12of weakness. You know, in the world of Game of Thrones, whenever
- 3:15there's a perception of weakness. The lesser houses rebelled against House Lanister in an
- 3:23attempt to overthrow it or gain power themselves or something. But the young Taiwan,
- 3:30who was old enough to fight himself, he was a ruthless general and
- 3:38put down the rebellion. And his ruthlessness in the war against these lesser houses
- 3:46gave a darker meaning to the common phrase for the Lanisters, a lanister always
- 3:53pays his debts. So, you know, before Taiwan came along, the
- 3:58phrase a lanister always pays his debts just referred to money because cashlely Rock is
- 4:04they own a bunch of gold mines. There's a lot of gold mines where
- 4:09in that land, and so they just have they can just print their own
- 4:13money, so to speak, and so they always have a ton of money.
- 4:15So they've always been they've always been able to lancers have always been able
- 4:17to pay their debts because they have a ton of money. But after Taiwan
- 4:21put down this rebellion that was against his father, a lanister always pays his
- 4:28debts has a darker meaning which is often referred to in the TV show and
- 4:33in the books. So so let's just pause for a second in this story
- 4:40and really look at this. So Taiwan Circe's father grew up in a house
- 4:46that was declining. He was taiwand is probably ashamed of his father. He
- 4:54probably internalized that shame, and Taiwan's pride and his fierceness and is ruthlessness brought
- 5:01the house back from the dead. So just think about that for a second.
- 5:05You're you're, I don't know, twenty years old or something, and
- 5:10your father is slowly, you know, declining, the house is slowly what
- 5:18do you call it? Presiding over a house that's that's failing his you know,
- 5:23So you're watching your father just fail and fail and fail, and all
- 5:27these other people are looking at you as the son of a failure, and
- 5:30then just as your house is about to completely be obliterated. You, you
- 5:36know, engage with your own rage and your own ruthlessness, and you march
- 5:44and you have to, you're afraid. You know, imagine Taiwan and his
- 5:47fear of this rebellion, because it could have gone another way. But Taiwan
- 5:55and his ruthlessness and his and his and his fierceness puts down this rebellion for
- 6:00his father. You know, his father didn't do it. He did it.
- 6:05So now he's rising above his own father. He's been elevated above his
- 6:11father. His father is probably looking to Taiwan as as stronger than he is.
- 6:17And this, you know what this would do to your personality. For
- 6:21Taiwan's personality in terms of giving him his perhaps his only source of self esteem,
- 6:30which was to was to be ruthless. He grew up probably feeling lesser
- 6:36self esteem. But then when he was ruthless and eliminated this because it's not
- 6:42just eliminating the rebellion, but the news via the crows spread throughout the kingdoms
- 6:50and talk about Taiwan, this young upstart who you know was ruthless and managed
- 6:57to put the Lanister House back on the map. There's a lot of fame,
- 7:01and there's a lot of there's a lot of power in that, and
- 7:06the amount of self esteem that Tailan would have would have gotten from that,
- 7:11and also how he might be He might develop narcissism because of this, because
- 7:19a lot of people probably praised him, including his own father, and so
- 7:25at a young age he was considered better than his own father. Now I'm
- 7:29making a lot of speculations, and obviously this is a fictional book, a
- 7:31fictional story, so it didn't really happen. But but you know, I
- 7:35think the way that Martin writes it's close enough to reality that we could think
- 7:41of it as being an accurate portrayal of what could happen in an example like
- 7:46this. And so you know, Taiwin might have developed a complex regarding his
- 7:53self esteem, linking it to all of these things, and that informs us
- 7:59in terms of looking forward. Plus, Taiwan knows what it's like to have
- 8:03his house decline, he knows what it's like to have weakness perceived by others,
- 8:11and what bad things can happen because of that, and so he is
- 8:16hyper vigilant, perhaps even suffering from some trauma reactions. He's hyper vigilant about
- 8:20making sure that his house is always perceived as strong and ruthless and himself as
- 8:28always perceived as strong and ruthless. He's because he's worried about things going back
- 8:35to the way he was when he was a kid, and so it's a
- 8:39lot of weight to carry and probably doesn't leave a lot of room for him
- 8:43to be a nice, warm father, because his way of loving his children
- 8:50is to keep his house strong, which is akin to keeping his children alive,
- 8:56because if you're perceived as weak, then other people will destroy you and
- 9:00maybe even kill your kids. And so his dedication to his family is very
- 9:03clear, and he equates ruthlessness with with love. So that's just something to
- 9:13keep in mind that Taiwin, we can understand why he became the way that
- 9:18he was. So Taiwin married his cousin Joanna l Anister, which was common
- 9:26in real royalty at the time and in the Game of Thrones world. Their
- 9:33first children were the twins Circe and Jamie. Circe was born first, and
- 9:39I always think it's funny how that matters to us with twins. It's like
- 9:43who just randomly came out first. But when you talk to twins. Most
- 9:48twins, they're they're they're always pretty clear about who was born first. Plus
- 9:54people often ask I have a friend who's a twin, and on Sunday I
- 9:58asked him who was born first? Because I probably asked them that question before,
- 10:03but I don't know. I was just making conversation and you know so,
- 10:07and I actually forgot the answer, so I have to ask again.
- 10:09But anyway, the point is is that it's funny that it matters to us
- 10:13because you know your bigger brother or sister, you're older quote unquote brothers.
- 10:20Even if it's just ten minutes older, that persons still your older sibling,
- 10:24right, And I don't know, it's just funny how age plays such a
- 10:30role, even if it's just ten minutes older. And can you really call
- 10:33it older? I mean, anyway, you were conceived at the exact same
- 10:39time, right, Yeah, we're actually can fraternal twins? I think fraternal
- 10:45twins can can be conceived at different times, So that'd be the real question
- 10:50is who was conceived first, which of course they wouldn't know the answer unless
- 10:54there was a test to baby situation. Anyway, I'm going down a road
- 10:58I should probably avoid since I have no idea what I'm talking about. But
- 11:01anyway, Circe was born first, Jamie was holding onto Circe's foot as as
- 11:07he was born. So just imagine that that, you know, they're pulling
- 11:13Circe free and there's this little hands holding onto Circe's foot. Is this a
- 11:20symbolism? Is this symbolic of their relationship? Perhaps? And then four years
- 11:28later, when Circe was for Jamie was for Joanna Lanister, Taiwan's wife,
- 11:35Circe's mom died giving birth to the Tyrian and Taiwan took this very hard.
- 11:41I'm guessing that Joanna was quite dear to Taiwan, and naturally Circe took it
- 11:48pretty hard too. It appears to me that Joanna Lanister, Taiwan's Taiwan's wife
- 11:56was perhaps the warmth and attachment oriented person in the family, and when she
- 12:03was gone, the whole family just lost its glue and its central warmth in
- 12:09the family. There's not a lot of evidence of that, but it seems
- 12:13like a viable hypothesis. Taiwan blamed Tyrian for the death, which is quite
- 12:20stupid, but there's that, and Circe did also, So Circe and Taiwan
- 12:28both blamed Tyrian for the death of Joanna. She prayed for days, Circe
- 12:35did, hoping that the gods would give her mother back. So Circe was
- 12:41was really obviously upset that her mother died. So suddenly. By the way,
- 12:46there's a theory that Joanna cheated on Taiwan and that Tyrian is not Taiwan's
- 12:52son, and that's why Taiwan is always so mean to Tyrian and refuses and
- 12:58refuses to let Tyrian become the head of the household because Taiwand either knows or
- 13:03suspects that Tyrian is not actually his own son, but he acted as if
- 13:09Tyrian was his son so he could save his wife and his family the the
- 13:15indignity of his wife giving birth to a quote unquote Bastard. So uh and
- 13:22and I at first didn't think this, but as time went on, as
- 13:26I rewatched a lot of episodes, there's there's some hints. There's some Game
- 13:31of Thrones hints, let's just put it that way. They're not really hints,
- 13:35but they're there's. You know, it's like the hints that John Snow
- 13:39was actually not at ARD's son. There were quote unquote hints sprinkled throughout the
- 13:48seasons, but I never picked up on them until someone pointed them out to
- 13:50me. And so in the same way, if you really look for these
- 13:54quote unquote hints, there's sort of hints that Tyrian is not Taiwand's son,
- 13:58But I I don't know, it doesn't there I'm not hearing a lot of
- 14:01talk about that one, so I'm not sure if I'm just completely making it
- 14:05up or not. But anyway, so Taiwan became head hand of the king
- 14:11to Aries the second aries Tigerian the second for twenty years. This is the
- 14:16mad King. So so Taiwan was for twenty years handed the king to the
- 14:22mad King. And I'm guessing that Taiwan had a lot to do with holding
- 14:26the kingdom together during this time. So at this time when Taiwan is handed
- 14:31the king and he has to spend all his time in King's Landing with the
- 14:35king, Circe is basically an orphan because dad's in King's Landing. He came
- 14:39home very infrequently, and he was reportedly not a very warm father to begin
- 14:45with. Circe's mother is dead, and so Circe, Jamie and and Tyrian
- 14:52are all raised by servants, which had just occurred to me why Tyrian might
- 14:56be so attracted to prostitutes because he was raised by servants. I know that
- 15:05sounds kind of ugly, but I don't know, just the random thought.
- 15:07But anyway, So, so Circe was raised by servants. Mom was dead,
- 15:13dad was absent. So just imagine that you know, you're you're raised
- 15:20and these aren't the sort of servants like nannies today. I mean these these
- 15:24are servants, servits. You know, these are sometimes slaves, and you,
- 15:28as a six year old somewhat know that if you wanted to, you
- 15:33could have your caregiver killed. You know, if you accused one of your
- 15:39one of your servants of stealing or doing something evil, your your dad would
- 15:46kill the servant. And imagine what that would do to your personality, Meaning
- 15:54that you know, when you're six and you do something wrong, particularly if
- 15:58you have a propensity to do something wrong, as I'm sir Circe was,
- 16:02you need limits. You need someone to impose discipline and to be close and
- 16:08warm with you, but also to provide you with limits so that you understand
- 16:14that you aren't the center of the universe. And although this wasn't commented on
- 16:18in the books. As far as I remember, Circe was raised in an
- 16:22environment where that was not the case. She was essentially spoiled beyond spoiled,
- 16:27right, and so there's that. Now. She did have her twin brother,
- 16:33and they were very close, so Jamie was really the only person that
- 16:37she felt close to. And something that was not really portrayed in the TV
- 16:44show is that in the books, Jamie and Circe look extremely similar. In
- 16:48fact, as young children, they would trick other people by dressing up as
- 16:55each other into thinking that the other person was the other person. Circe would
- 17:00dress up as a little boy and she was allowed to and everyone thought she
- 17:06was Jamie, and then she would practice with swords and weapons and stuff as
- 17:08if she were Jamie, and even Taiwan, her own father, couldn't tell
- 17:15them apart when they were dressed the same. And they also slept together in
- 17:21the same bed, which you know, you could imagine that being true among
- 17:25young twins. They began to experiment sexually with each other, which isn't terrible.
- 17:32I mean, let's you know, let's not be puritanical here. Young
- 17:34children will will experiment age appropriate and they did as very young children, as
- 17:42three four year olds, they would, I don't know, they didn't describe
- 17:47it in detail in the books, but they would. They would do stuff
- 17:51to each other. And you know, there's a lot of thoughts about that
- 17:59that I could. On one hand, it's completely natural and understandable. If
- 18:04you have young children, it's likely that you've seen your young daughter or young
- 18:11son sort of touch themselves as a curiosity or even as a self soothing thing.
- 18:19And it's completely normal, and it's normal for twins to sort of participate
- 18:26in that together. But you know, it could become problematic if it leads
- 18:30to abuse or developing sexual issues, which it seems that it did for Cercy
- 18:37and Jamie. But anyway, so they're very young and they were discovered by
- 18:44a servant experimenting in this way with each other, and the servant told their
- 18:52parents know their mother, sorry, the father was never told about this,
- 18:56So this is when the mother was still alive. When they were so Circe
- 19:00and Jamie were three or four years old. The servant ran and told their
- 19:04mother, and their mother demanded that the servants separate them, and so they
- 19:11were never able to sleep in the same bed again. And Jamie slept on
- 19:15the other side of the castle, and they didn't have a lot of contact.
- 19:21So just imagine that one you're Circe, you're a young child, and
- 19:27your father is cold and distant. You have your mother, which is good,
- 19:32and you also have your twin brother, and so you have these two
- 19:34people that are very important in some ways. Your twin brother is perhaps even
- 19:40more important than your mom, because your mom comes and goes, but your
- 19:44twin brother is always there. You're always, you know, since since conception,
- 19:48you're right next to your twin brother, and you develop a language amongst
- 19:52yourselves and you're extremely close. And then among your various activity ease, you
- 20:00engage in one of them happens to be a sexual experimentation, which is again
- 20:04normal. And then one day a servant catches you, and again an underlink.
- 20:11Just think remember that a servant catches you, and you're just instantly separated
- 20:19from one of the two people that you are attached to. And we're not
- 20:25talking just you know, emotional attachment. We're talking physical attachment. Where she's
- 20:30you know, they're they're probably cuddling at night, which is a good thing
- 20:36for human beings to have human contact and then boom, you're just completely separated
- 20:42because of sexual experimentation, which of course is you know, at risk of
- 20:51creating a complex for you regarding sexuality and sexuality with your brother. A more
- 21:00a healthy approach might have been to allow them to still have contact with each
- 21:07other and slowly kind of wean them away from each other, while at the
- 21:10same time helping them understand their bodies and sexuality and what they're doing so that
- 21:18they can be quote quote unquote appropriate. But so this is a pretty big
- 21:23deal. So we have Circe losing her mother, which is a big deal,
- 21:27and then we have Circe as a young child being completely ripped away from
- 21:33her twin brother, which is not going to be a good thing for you
- 21:38and your emotional development. So I just want to take a little pause here
- 21:45to talk about some evidence of psychopathy regarding Circe, probably as a result of
- 21:53maybe even a result of genetics, since Taiwand has some psychopathic traits clearly,
- 22:02but she also was neglected and she had, you know, significant losses as
- 22:08a young child, which raises the risk of psychopathy. Essentially, when you're
- 22:14not given enough empathy, you don't learn how to have empathy for other people,
- 22:19and you don't develop the brain pathways involved in empathy and blah blah blah,
- 22:23especially if you have a genetic disposition as such, which it seems likely
- 22:29that she would have. But let's look at some other evidence of psychopathy.
- 22:33One, she was fearless. She wasn't afraid of these pet lions that they
- 22:38kept in the dungeon, and Jamie had to save her from these lions because
- 22:41she was running around in the cages she was. And there's other evidence throughout
- 22:48her life that she doesn't have any fears or she doesn't heed fears anyway.
- 22:52And also that she was sadistic, she took pleasure in harming other people and
- 22:59didn't have empathy for other people as a as a young person, as a
- 23:03not as a three or a four year old, but older than that.
- 23:07As an example, she would abuse Tyrian when Tyrian was a baby. There's
- 23:12talk on the TVN in the books of how she would torture the baby Tyrian
- 23:18and show off to other people and you know, see look what I can
- 23:23do. I can you know, pinch him and torture them. And so
- 23:27you know, that's that's signs of developing psychopathy. I think some people are
- 23:33confused about psychopathic children because they just can't imagine children being psychopathic, but but
- 23:41they absolutely can be. We don't typically diagnose children with psychopathy, but we
- 23:48usually will. The childhood version of psychopathy or any social personality disorder is conduct
- 23:53disorder, and to a lesser extent, oppostion for defin it. But we
- 24:00certainly see it and it can be very distressing. And we're cautious about diagnosing
- 24:07kids with psychopathy because there are plenty of kids who exhibit psychopathic traits as children,
- 24:11but quote unquote grow out of it or as an adult don't exhibit any
- 24:18psycho or they don't exhibit significant psychopathic traits, and therefore, when we look
- 24:22back, we might hypothesize that their environment was creating the circumstances by which they
- 24:29would have difficulty empathizing with other people. But as adults they access their empathy
- 24:34or something. And so anyway, why do I go down that road?
- 24:40Okay, So at fifteen years old, Circe and her friend this is depicted
- 24:44at the beginning of season five, Circe and her friend visited a witch in
- 24:48the woods to Circe wanted to have her fortune told and I think she was
- 24:52trying to show off to her friend that she was brave and fearless and that
- 24:56cool, and that she could go to the witch in the woods. I'm
- 25:00just trying to imagine what that would be like today. You know, you
- 25:03have two fifteen year old girls today, and one of them is I guess
- 25:07it'd be drugs, right, So two fifteen year old girls today. One
- 25:11of them's trying to show off and she's like, you know, I could
- 25:12spoke pot or I can you know, I can drink a whole bunch of
- 25:17booze or or I don't know. I don't know what it would be two
- 25:21fifteen year olds today, but anyway, so that's essentially the tone of it.
- 25:26And the witch gives Circe her fortune, and she says a very interesting
- 25:30fortune. She says that Circe would marry the king. You know, sir,
- 25:36She's like, you know what, prince am I going to marry?
- 25:37And this fortuite teller says, she says, actually, you're not going to
- 25:41marry a prince. You're going to marry the king. And while the king
- 25:45will have twenty sons, you Circe will bear only three children. So that
- 25:51was a confusing prophecy to her fifteen year old mind because she was still romantic
- 25:55about love and marriage and stuff. And so she's like, so, my
- 26:00husband, the king will have twenty children, but I'm only but I'm only
- 26:03going to have three. That doesn't make any sense. And the fortune said
- 26:10the fortune the witch said that she would outlive her children, that her children
- 26:14would die. And the fortune teller said that although Circe, you will be
- 26:21queen, you will be cast down by a younger and more beautiful queen.
- 26:26So just think about that one. And then she also said that she used
- 26:30the High Valerian word for younger brother, but she said that a younger brother
- 26:37will end your life. Circe, a younger brother. Okay, so let's
- 26:41look at this fortune really carefully here. So the witch was right about a
- 26:45lot of things. She did indeed marry the king. She didn't marry a
- 26:48prince. She married King Robert Brathian. The king did have many children,
- 26:53maybe you know, twentyish or something. But the king did have a lot
- 26:59of children because he had sex with a lot of women in the kingdom.
- 27:04And Circe did indeed have three children. And as we know, against spoiler
- 27:10alert, we learned that she outlived all of her children, but she has
- 27:15yet to be cast down, so you know, they she's you know,
- 27:19she says she will be cast down by a younger and more beautiful queen.
- 27:23Not a younger more beautiful woman, but a but a younger, more beautiful
- 27:26queen. So when we first saw this, this prophecy, we I did.
- 27:34I thought it was Marjorie. I thought they were referring to Marjorie,
- 27:37right, a younger, more beautiful queen. Marjorie will will put you down.
- 27:44But Marjorie's dead now, so that it's not unless Marjorie comes back for
- 27:49the dead or something, but that does seem likely. So so now it's
- 27:55like, well, what other queen. Well, we have Queen Tanari's or
- 27:57Danny. Certainly you could say she's younger and more beautiful, although the talk
- 28:07of Circe's beauty is such that no one's more beautiful than her. But anyway,
- 28:11at least Denarius is younger. Another person I started around we thought was
- 28:18was Melissandra. Maybe she'll become queen and she'll put her down. Another person
- 28:22is Ilaria sand She's the woman in the south who is rising up and might
- 28:33and obviously she hates Circe for killing her brother, her brother, her lover
- 28:41for killing the viper. Anyway Sansa is, will Sansa be the one to
- 28:47put her down? Aria Gilly will? Maybe Gilly will rise up and be
- 28:52queen and put Circe down. But I'm gonna guess that it's either Danny or
- 28:59Sansa is going to be the younger queen who puts down Circe. Although I
- 29:06really hope it's sant so that would be really satisfying, but it's I don't
- 29:10know. It seems likely it's Denari's. So we'll see this other line in
- 29:14the prophecy is a younger brother will end her life. Younger brother. Now
- 29:18is it her younger brother or is it just a younger brother. I don't
- 29:23really know. So the obvious person to choose here is Tyrian, Right,
- 29:29It's got to be Tyrian. Well, Okay, I got to take a
- 29:30break and we'll get back. We'll continue this conversation. Okay, we're back
- 29:40from the break. Before I go into talking about about this younger brother that
- 29:45is going to end Circe's life, I just want to remind everyone that they
- 29:48should become a patron by going to patreon dot com. That's Patreon dot com.
- 29:52Go to pat Go to patreon dot com. Become a patren of that
- 29:55podcast. When you become a patron, you get access to all of our
- 29:57premium episodes. We do a lot of deep dives on a lot of topics,
- 30:03and about half of the deep dives are only available to patrons of the
- 30:07podcast. Plus, know that part of your pledge goes towards charities that we
- 30:14support, including charities for homeless people, LGBT people, and also to animals
- 30:22for pets. Petfinder dot com is our next charity of choice. Also,
- 30:26tell a friend or colleague about the show. That's how people learn about us.
- 30:30Also rate us on iTunes because that's also people learn about us. Also,
- 30:36if you're interested, you can join the Facebook fan group that's run by
- 30:38famous patron Linden. And you can also follow us on Instagram. Although I
- 30:45don't know really how Instagram exactly works, I'm giving it a shot. Okay,
- 30:49So the Witch says to Circe, a younger brother will end your life
- 30:53as this Tyrian could be. He's at the end of season six on the
- 30:57TV show. Anyway, He's coming for her with denaries and her armies and
- 31:03her dragons. So it seems possible that Tyrian could be the one to end
- 31:07her life. Or is it John Snow? I mean, John Snow is
- 31:10the younger brother of Rob Stark, So is it John Snow the one?
- 31:15Now this prophecy? When she heard it circ here's this probably Wait, my
- 31:18younger brother is going to end my life? She instantly thought a Tyrian because
- 31:22she already had a really you know, conflictual relationship with Tyrian and hated Tyrian.
- 31:29So she's like, of course Tyrian is going to be the one to
- 31:32put me down, and so this just fueled her anger and hatred towards Tyrian.
- 31:40The other one here is what about Jamie? Right, Jamie was younger,
- 31:45so to speak, just by a couple of minutes. And Jamie is
- 31:51the king slayer, So why can't he be the queen slayer? You know,
- 31:56maybe, you know, maybe this is all gonna turn out just like
- 32:00the mad King did. This is the mad queen in terms of her her
- 32:06propensity to use wildfire to obliterate you know, lots of people to her benefit.
- 32:14You know, we can imagine a scenario which Genari's and Tyrian and varies
- 32:19are closing in on King's landing, and then Circe is like, Okay,
- 32:27you know, I'm going to blow up the city and kill everyone, including
- 32:30myself because if I'm going to die, Everyone's going to die. And then
- 32:34Jamie comes out of nowhere and kills Circe to prevent that from happening. We
- 32:39can you know that would be poetic. It'd be a little too poetic,
- 32:45a little too obvious in some ways, but you know, we could,
- 32:47we could imagine that happening, and man, can you just imagine that scene,
- 32:52Jesus, which makes me just I just can't wait for the next couple
- 32:58of seasons to see what's going to happen. And I mean just the last
- 33:01couple episodes of season six were just I mean, if I saw those as
- 33:07individual movies in the theater, I'd be like, whoa, that was an
- 33:09amazing movie. I mean, these episodes are just so good. So I
- 33:13just I have high expectations for seasons seven and eight. But anyway, so
- 33:19younger brother going to enter life? Is it Tyrian? Is it John Snow?
- 33:22Is it Jamie? Is it someone else? I mean, the Witch
- 33:24was right about all the other elements of the prophecy, and so we shall
- 33:32see. Anyway, So this prophecy freaked Circe out, and apparently the superstition
- 33:39at the time was that if you never spoke of the prophecy again, it
- 33:44wouldn't come true. And so her and her friend are are the only ones
- 33:49who have heard this prophecy. And so Circe's like, okay, if me
- 33:52and my friend never never talk about this prophecy, it won't come true because
- 33:57it sounds horrible. I mean, my kids going to die before me.
- 34:00Some queen's going to kill me, Tyrian's going to kill me. I mean,
- 34:04this is this is awful. Well, of course, of course,
- 34:07the psychopathic Circe, what does she do? I mean, because you know
- 34:10she could asked her friend please do not ever say this prophecy ever again.
- 34:15I beg you do not repeat it because I'm worried about it. Is Circe,
- 34:21even a young fifteen year old Circe, the sort of person that's going
- 34:23to leave that up to chance. No, of course, the friend mysteriously
- 34:29dies soon after this visit with the witch. It's implied that Circe killed her
- 34:35to prevent her from speaking the prophecy, but we don't know that. For
- 34:37sure, but let's let's just assume that Circe had had the girl killed.
- 34:43Okay, So now Taiwan, let's get back to Taiwan. Here, he's
- 34:49handed the king to the mad King. Aris. So Taiwan asks the mad
- 34:52King if his daughter Circe could marry Prince Ragar. This would make this would
- 35:00make Seirce the queen eventually, and the king I think I think Raygar was
- 35:07next in line. The King rejected Taiwan's proposal. Why the king rejected Taiwan's
- 35:15proposal, It's unclear. I think the mad King was just crazy and kind
- 35:21of a dick. But anyway, Taiwan, you know, was a loyal
- 35:25hand of the king for twenty years, and he's like, hey, I
- 35:28just like my you know, prince Reager to marry my daughter. And the
- 35:30King's like nope. And Circe then learns that Taiwan was because you know,
- 35:39Taiwan again, think Taiwan. Okay. All he's thinking about is I got
- 35:44to uphold the family household. I've got to make it strong. And one
- 35:47of the one of the biggest tools you have as as the head of a
- 35:52household is marrying your daughters off. And when you marry your daughters off.
- 35:57You you cement alliance's with that, with that house, because presumably you wouldn't
- 36:04attack another house if your daughter was a part of that. And also you
- 36:09wouldn't attack your you know, wife's father's house, right, So it really,
- 36:15you know, Cement's houses together. So Circe learns that Taiwan is thinking
- 36:21about Jamie. At this point, he's saying, okay, well, I
- 36:22can't get rid of Circe, but I could get rid of Jamie. I
- 36:25mean, get rid of it, you know, marry Jamie off. And
- 36:29so Taiwan is like, okay, I'm going to marry Jamie into the Tully
- 36:34household. Lisa Tully, you know, she's in the TV show. She's
- 36:38the crazy moon door woman who flies out of the moon door moon door.
- 36:43That's what's called, right. So Circe learns that Taiwan is going to marry
- 36:46Jamie to Lisa Tully. Imagine that match. But Circe wanted Jamie for herself,
- 36:54so she seduces Jamie and convinces him to ask the king to make him
- 37:01one of the king's guards because, as we know, the king's guards they
- 37:05can't get married. And Jamie asked the King to become a king's guard to
- 37:08avoid having to move out of kings landing, and mary Lysa Tulley and the
- 37:15King agreed and made Jamie join the King's guard. And what this did was
- 37:20it robbed Taiwan of his soul air that he liked. Right, So Taiwan
- 37:25has one has two sons. He has Jamie and Tyrian, but he hates
- 37:30Tyrian and Tyrian has a bad repetition anyway, And so and he has a
- 37:35daughter and in his family he's in the Lanister household. Other other households are
- 37:40more liberal about allowing women to rule or have power, like the Martel's,
- 37:47I believe, are like the Tyrell's. But Taiwan and the Lanisters didn't hold
- 37:53to this liberal attitude about women. And so he just has he just has
- 37:59his son, Jamie. And now Jamie has been made the King's guard by
- 38:04the king. And so this robbed Taiwan of his heir, which was a
- 38:07bad idea for the mad king. You know, it's like, why would
- 38:10you piss off the richest man in westros. In fact, if if the
- 38:15King had not done this to Jamie, if the King had said no Jamie,
- 38:21you can't become the King's guard to Taiwan's only heir. And also if
- 38:25the Mad King had said yes, Taiwan Circe can marry my son, the
- 38:30Mad King and the Tigerians would probably still be in power because I'll get more
- 38:36to that in a second. But anyway, so then Taiwan resigns his hand
- 38:39of the king. He's like, fuck this shit, and he goes back
- 38:43to castlely Rock. So then Robert's rebellion happens. So Robert and Eduard rise
- 38:50up against the Mad King, and Taiwan remains neutral, even though it was
- 38:55would be assumed that Taiwan would rush to the Mad King's aid. Taiwan's like,
- 39:02look, I'm gonna stay out of this because i hate the king and
- 39:05I hate the bis, I hate everyone, and I'm just gonna hold tight
- 39:10on this one. But when it was clear that that Robert Brathian was going
- 39:15to win the war, Taiwan joined the fight. But instead of fighting,
- 39:21he decided to use a trick and he marched his armies to kings Landing and
- 39:29sent a message to the Mad King and he said, I'm here to help
- 39:31you defend the King's Landing against the Brathians and the Starks, and you know,
- 39:38the Mad King's advisors was like, I don't know if you should trust
- 39:42Taiwan, and even Jamie, since he was one of the king's guard,
- 39:45said, look, I don't think Taiwan, my father is likely to be
- 39:50on your side on this. But the King fell for Taiwan's trick and opened
- 39:54the gates for him, and Taiwan immediately ordered his men to sack the city
- 40:00and massacre of the royal family. Well King aries. The Mad King then
- 40:06ordered Jamie to bring him Taiwan's head, which you know is an interesting order.
- 40:12And Jamie also knew that the Mad King had a bunch of wildfire spread
- 40:19throughout the city, and the Mad King was, you know, told his
- 40:23royal pyromancer. He has a royal pyromancer to set the entire city ablaze,
- 40:30which you know would have killed I don't know how many people. But King
- 40:35met the Mad King is like, okay, it's over for me. Taiwan
- 40:37is in the city, Brathian and Stark are going to be here soon.
- 40:44It's over for me. I'm a crazy man and I want to I want
- 40:47to kill everybody. Now there are theories that the mad just as a site.
- 40:53Many of you may know this, but there's a theory that the Mad
- 40:57King uh was seeing the future in that he was seeing the Army of the
- 41:05Dead and the White Walkers and everything invade the South, and he was confusing
- 41:13that future with the current, and he he wanted to set the city on
- 41:19fire because he thought he was actually destroying the Army of Dead, when in
- 41:22fact he was actually destroying his own people. And it's you know, you
- 41:28know how Hodor became hod Or because of Bran and the Man in the tree
- 41:35and all that kind of mind stuff. If you know, he basically accidentally
- 41:42fried Hodor's brain. Well, I think in seasons seven and eight. And
- 41:47again I have no inside knowledge on this, so I'm not spoiling anything.
- 41:52I'm just I'm just spouting. I'm gonna be spouting a lot of speculation.
- 41:55I'm usually wrong about these sorts of things, by the way, I'm usually
- 42:00very wrong. But anyway, to spout a little bit about this, I
- 42:06think it's possible that Bran is going to fry the Mad King's brain on accident
- 42:10and make them in the past. Because we know that Bran can actually travel
- 42:15time now he can, and because that's how he fried hod Or's brain.
- 42:19He went into the past and fried hod Or's brain, and so I think
- 42:23it's possible that Bran or somebody is going to go back in time and potentially
- 42:30fry the mad King's brain, and then that's going to cause the mad King
- 42:32to, you know, try to do all the weird stuff that he was
- 42:35doing. But anyway, so so King Aris says to Jamie, I want
- 42:40you to kill your father and bring me his head. And I want and
- 42:45I'm also, you know, by the way, I'm going to blow up
- 42:46the entire city. So Jamie's like, okay, I think it's time to
- 42:52kill this king. And so he stabs the mad King in the back and
- 42:57thus saving I don't know countless people, including his own father, and really
- 43:00just putting the mad King out of his misery. And he got the horrible
- 43:07nickname the King Slayer for his service to the community, which is I think
- 43:14just mean. So when Robert Brathyan and Edward Stark reached the Red Keep,
- 43:19Taiwan presented the bodies of the royal family as proof that he was on their
- 43:22side. And this is no small feat considering how hard it is to take
- 43:27a defended keep so you know, Taiwan, you know, did did something
- 43:32pretty great for the community and for Brathian and Stark. So Robert brathy becomes
- 43:39king. Taiwan asked Robert to marry Cerce to cement the alliance between House Brathian
- 43:47and House Lanister, and Robert probably recognized the importance of this alliance because Taiwan
- 43:55had a lot of money in a very strong army, so he said yes.
- 44:00Robert Brathley said yes, I will marry Circe, even though Robert was
- 44:05in love with Leanna. Okay, so let's go on to the marriage,
- 44:10all right. So again, after I go through all this back history,
- 44:15which I think is important to understand to understand Circe's personality, I'm going to
- 44:20talk about her personality and a bunch of other stuff. But anyway, so
- 44:22now we're again, we're still before the books and the TV show. So
- 44:27the royal marriage between Circe and Robert King Robert Brathian. She was There's different
- 44:34accounts of this, but I think in the books she was seventeen maybe eighteen
- 44:38when she got married, and he was twenty one, so pretty I think
- 44:44typical age range for people getting married at the time. The morning of the
- 44:49wedding, Circe had sex with Jamie. By the way, that's a little
- 44:52tidbit for you. At first, Circe was really infatuated with the handsome,
- 45:00strapping Robert. Now, if you remember from the TV shows, Robert brathy
- 45:04And is played by a rather rotund guy who can't fit into his armor anymore.
- 45:08But when he was younger, he was he was a manly man,
- 45:13you know, think young Bert Reynolds or something, you know, a hairy
- 45:19manly man or Marlon, a young Marlon Brando, shall we say. And
- 45:23Circe still had this very romantic prince and princess kind of view of marriage.
- 45:30And Robert was a rock star. He was super He was young and exciting
- 45:37and powerful and manly and and everyone loved him because he got rid of the
- 45:44mad king and and he was, you know, the savior. And she
- 45:47was gonna, she was gonna marry this guy. And she was really infatuated
- 45:52with him. And although she was still having sex with Jamie, which seems
- 45:57like a constant sort of element in her life, she she legitimately wanted things
- 46:01to work out between her and Robert Brathian, but then on their wedding night.
- 46:07I think while they're having sex, Robert called out to Leanna, to
- 46:12Leanna Stark, to Edward's sister, and Circe was naturally hurt by that.
- 46:20She's like, wait, what you you love someone else? You don't love
- 46:24me. And in the books Circe became pregnant with Robert's child, and the
- 46:32TV and in the books she became pregnant, but in the books she aborted
- 46:37Robert's child because she hated Robert by this point, and the TV she actually
- 46:43did have to give birth to the sun but the son died shortly after birth,
- 46:50and so that's a major difference between the books and the TV show,
- 46:52and I'm I think it's because maybe the TV people wanted sir to be more
- 47:00likable because there were so many reasons to hate Circe. There's this, I
- 47:05think it's a scene where Circe's actually talking to Edward's wife, Catlyn Stark,
- 47:12and Circe is saying like, yeah, I did have a son with dark
- 47:15hair and he died certainly after birth, And I think they were trying to
- 47:21humanize Circe a little bit. But in the books, Circe, upon becoming
- 47:25pregnant with Robert's son, aborts it somehow because she hates Robert so much.
- 47:34So this is a traumatic experience. Imagine you get married, things you know,
- 47:42become completely different than you thought it would. Your husband is in love
- 47:46with this other woman. You're you know, second fiddle to this other woman.
- 47:52You become pregnant, You're angry, you don't know what to do your
- 47:55you know, you want to strike back at your husband. And he's he
- 48:00drinks a lot, he's violent, he's you know, braggadocious. So you
- 48:07to decide to have an abortion. I mean, abortions are traumatic regardless of
- 48:12the circumstances, and under this circumstance, it's you know, highly traumatic.
- 48:17And so then Circe just and Robert become more and more conflictual. Over time,
- 48:25Circe's hatred for Robert deepens. She actively avoids getting pregnant by Robert,
- 48:32and she returned to her safe place, her brother, Jamie. Jamie's the
- 48:37only person on the planet who she's been able to depend upon other than her
- 48:42mother, But her mother's dead. She can't depend on her father, she
- 48:45can't depend on Tai when she hates tailand and no one else she can depend
- 48:49on so she goes to Jamie and guess what. She has three children,
- 48:53three children by Jamie, Jeoffrey, Marcella, and Tommon, all product of
- 48:58the relationship with Jamie, and Jamie was actually even present at some of the
- 49:02burths if and at least Jeffrey's birth, even though Robert was not present.
- 49:07Robert was always out hunting on purpose. He avoided whenever Circe went into labor.
- 49:15Robert would go hunting because he thought, well, I don't want to
- 49:17be around for that, and so, so this is just more reasons why
- 49:22Circe hated hated Robert. They fought a lot, they drank a lot,
- 49:28They were violent. Circe hit him with a drinking horn, you know,
- 49:32some sort of drinking thing, and chipped his tooth. So they were quite
- 49:38quite violent with each other. I'm guessing Circe got the short end of the
- 49:44stick on that one, since Robert is so much larger than she is and
- 49:47he's the king. So she has her three children, and as Jeoffrey her
- 49:53oldest son, his sadism becomes more apparent. Robert wanted to have one of
- 50:00his bastard children become his heir, so so just imagine that your son,
- 50:07your beautiful blonde son, Geoffrey, is you know, the next king,
- 50:15and you're so proud of that. You're like, my son is going to
- 50:19be king of west Ros and Westros seven kingdoms, and my husband hates our
- 50:27son and is going to bring one of his mistress's children. And I think
- 50:32it was like a girl too home and live with us and groom that child
- 50:40to be his heir. You know that's not going to go over so well,
- 50:45especially with a person like Circe. And so Circe said, if you
- 50:51bring that child into this castle, I cannot I mean, this is paraphrasy,
- 50:57but I can't vouch for the safety of that child. So Robert's like,
- 51:00whoa, did she just threaten to kill my child from another woman?
- 51:06Okay? And so Robert, from that point for it, said, Okay,
- 51:08I guess I have to never reveal these bastard kids to Circe. My
- 51:15wife. Circe even was rumored to have killed two of the bastard children as
- 51:21babies or had them killed. Right, she learned about these twins who were
- 51:27born to Robert by another woman and had them killed. So there was all
- 51:34that kind of interesting dynamic between Robert and Circe. So now we're almost at
- 51:40the beginning of the books. In the TV show, Stanis Barathian, Robert's
- 51:45younger brother, noticed that the three children were all blonde and blue eyed,
- 51:51even though King Robert and all the other Barathians for that matter, were all
- 51:55dark haired and dark eyed. So wait a second. You know, we
- 52:01all know that when you put a blonde and a brunette together, you tend
- 52:06to get more brunette children. And Stanis is like, that's this is weird.
- 52:10All three of Robert's children are like the Lanisters, super blonde, beautiful,
- 52:19blue eyed creatures. And so he's like, wait a second, I
- 52:24bet you anything. And it's and the rumors about Jamie and Circe were,
- 52:30you know, in the society, and so but at the very least Stanus
- 52:34is like, I don't know if these are Jamie's kids, but these clearly
- 52:37are not brought my brother Robert's kids. And if this was true, this
- 52:43would make Stanis the heir to the throne. I think there's a complicated way
- 52:50of calculating things when you don't have an air, a legitimate air in the
- 52:54royal family, and these kinds of societies and so I think the way that
- 53:00it worked was that if Robert didn't have any legitimate children, then that would
- 53:06make Stanis, the younger brother, potentially next in line. And so Stanis
- 53:12talks with John Aaron, hand to the king. John Aaron was the mentor
- 53:17of King Robert and ed Ard Stark. So Stanis talks with John Aaron,
- 53:23and you know, I'm guessing others suspected that this too. They're looking at
- 53:27the kids and they're like, I don't think those are Robert's kids. But
- 53:30no one else really stood to gain from the risk of making that accusation.
- 53:35I mean, if you're just some random noble person and you just are like,
- 53:38hey, I think those kids are not Robert Brathian's kids, I mean,
- 53:42not only would Robert potentially be insulted and have you killed, but certainly
- 53:45Circe, what have you killed? Right, So there's not a lot of
- 53:50reason for anyone to come out and just you know, say it publicly.
- 53:54But Stanis benefited because if Stannis came forward and managed to get everyone and on
- 54:00his side, then he potentially would be next in line as king. And
- 54:06I'm also guessing that John Aaron was concerned about you know. So John Aaron
- 54:10is the hand of the king and he's watching a little Draffrey grow up,
- 54:14and he's like, I don't know, I don't think Jeoffrey's going to be
- 54:17that great of a king because he's a little sadistic person. And so when
- 54:23Stanis Brathy comes to John Aaron and says, look, I think all these
- 54:25kids are not Robert's kids, John Aaron's like, huh, that might be
- 54:30a good thing at this point, because that Draffrey kid is a piece of
- 54:34work. So John Aaron, handed the king, starts investigating, but then
- 54:37he dies mysteriously. Isn't that interesting? It's never said, but it seems
- 54:44likely that Circe had him killed. Now let's just look, so this is
- 54:49one of the first instances that we have in which Circe sort of crosses over
- 54:54into this other world. Because killing bastard children in this world not that big
- 55:00of a deal. You're not as queen. It's not going to be that
- 55:02big of a deal for you in the society too. You know, it's
- 55:07not going to be smiled upon, but it's it's not a huge it's not
- 55:14a huge story to people that, oh, you know, the queen killed
- 55:15these bastard kids. So so this is where Circe really crosses over into a
- 55:25realm that sort of cascades in a sense. And so it's likely that Circe
- 55:31poison had someone poisoned John Aaron and had him killed. I think the help
- 55:37of the Master, by the way. But anyway, so just imagine you're
- 55:40Circe and you know that your three children, your three beloved children, whom
- 55:47you love more than anything, and you love so you love Jamie, and
- 55:53you love your three kids, and you hate Robert, and you hate everyone
- 55:57else. You just love Jamie and you love your three kids. And then
- 56:04all the while, every day that goes by, you're just terrified that someone
- 56:09is going to figure this out, or someone's going to say something, or
- 56:14because if the entire society and the entire court, or even most people decide
- 56:20that this is true, then you're done. You know, Robert will have
- 56:24you killed and your kids will be killed. Life is over for you and
- 56:29your children. Imagine that, so not only would life end for you,
- 56:31which would be terrible, but your only your three little children. And think
- 56:36a little Tomman and little Marcella, these these you know, forget about Jeoffrey,
- 56:40you know, sadistic, little prick that he was a little Tomman,
- 56:45little cute little Toman. So if if word gets out that these kids are
- 56:50are Jamie's kids, then little Toman is going to be killed. And so
- 56:53she has a choice here. She can either just sit back and hope that
- 56:58nothing happens, or she can take control. And she's a woman of action,
- 57:02and so she conspires to kill John Aaron to get rid of that element.
- 57:10And it works, you know, so imagine that too. Imagine that
- 57:15one you are thinking, Okay, what do I do here? I could
- 57:20kill John Aaron. I could try to seduce John Aaron that you know,
- 57:22I could try to do this or that, and there's what do I do?
- 57:27What do I do? Okay, I'll conspire to kill them? Okay,
- 57:30I killed him. Hey it worked, and boy, what a load
- 57:35off my mind now that he's gone. Wow. Killing people is a very
- 57:39useful thing. And she learned this long ago, perhaps when she killed her
- 57:45friend when she was fifteen, and perhaps when she killed the bastard kids.
- 57:49So you know, there's sort of a ramp up to this in terms of
- 57:52killing. Killing. The hand of the king is you know, it's a
- 57:54big deal. You think about today, It's like it'd be like killing the
- 57:59second Terry of State or something. It's different if you're a psychopath. That's
- 58:04a different kind of thing than if you just killed one of your friends.
- 58:07Right, this is pretty dark conversation when you bring it into the real world.
- 58:13But anyway, she essentially killed the Secretary of State, and you know
- 58:17that's a big and she got away with it and it benefited her. So
- 58:22just think about how that would solidify or reward that behavior and how she proceeds
- 58:29from that point forward. She's been socialized by her society and by her own
- 58:35life to kill again that when she gets pushed into a corner, just kill
- 58:39them, you know, just get rid of them and everything will be fine.
- 58:43And I'll save my children. I will save my children from death or
- 58:47torture or something if I kill other people. So that's a very important point
- 58:54in her development as a human being. But let's take a break and get
- 59:00back. We will start at the beginning of the TV show and the books.
- 59:10All right, we're back again. The most important thing you can do
- 59:14if you want to support the podcast is become a patron of the podcast by
- 59:17going to Patreon dot com. I know there are thousands of you who listen
- 59:22to the podcast and are not patrons. So if just a portion of you
- 59:27decide to become a patron this podcast, could I could dedicate more time to
- 59:32the podcast. I already dedicate quite a bit of time, and I would
- 59:37love to dedicate more time, more deep dives, more time for me to
- 59:44research things, more time for me to become knowledgeable enough to talk about things.
- 59:47And that all depends on you. So if you haven't already done so,
- 59:52please do that. That probably means you have to actually go to your
- 59:54computer whatever you use to browse the internet, and you actually have to go
- 59:59to patreont. Come. Okay, Now we are at the beginning of Game
- 1:00:04of Thrones TV show and the books, first book being A Game of Thrones,
- 1:00:08which is in the larger book series called The Song of Ice and Fire.
- 1:00:12Okay, so we first introduced to Circe as she arrives at Winterfill.
- 1:00:19Robert is coming to Winterfel to ask ed Ard to become hand of the king
- 1:00:24because because John Aaron is dead and so Robert brath and he is like,
- 1:00:30well who do I trust? Well? I trust Edward. So I'm going
- 1:00:31to go to Edward and while Circe and Jamie are at Winterfel, Brand is
- 1:00:38climbing his way across the winterfil castle, I don't know what you call it,
- 1:00:45winterfill walls and discovers that Circe and Jamie are having sex. In the
- 1:00:50books, they describe this in full detail, and there's a lot of graphic
- 1:00:54things that Brand sees in the TV show, It's Blessed So and then Circe
- 1:01:00and Jamie are kind of panicking, and Circe demands that Jamie do something about
- 1:01:04Bran, and so Jamie says something like the things we do for love and
- 1:01:08pushes Bran from the tower. Bran almost dies. When he wakes up,
- 1:01:14he doesn't remember anything, and he's lost his ability to walk. Later in
- 1:01:17the books, Circe yells at Jamie for pushing Bran out of the window because
- 1:01:22and she says, you know, we could have intimidated him to be silent,
- 1:01:25which honestly seems a little silly to me, because that doesn't seem like
- 1:01:30a Circe thing to think. And also it doesn't seem likely that Bran would
- 1:01:37keep silent about that for the rest of his life. So I'm guessing that
- 1:01:42Circe was just looking for something to yell at Jamie about, and found that
- 1:01:46to yell at him about. I mean, it seems like a more logical
- 1:01:52thing to yell at Jamie for not making sure that he died right. But
- 1:01:55anyway, So, after Aria and Jeffrey have their spat in the woods,
- 1:02:02as as ed Ard and Robert Brathy and are heading back to King's landing after
- 1:02:08Edward agrees to become out of the King, Aria and Jeoffrey have this fight
- 1:02:15in the woods and Aria runs and hides in the woods. This is when
- 1:02:19Jeoffrey was bullying the boy. Circe seduces Jamie and says that I want you
- 1:02:27to Jamie, I want you to hunt down Aria and have her killed for
- 1:02:30what she did to Jeoffrey. So if you so, But anyway, in
- 1:02:37the end, Jamie tries to do this, tries to and admitted later that
- 1:02:43if he found Aria he would have killed her. But Aria was found by
- 1:02:47the Stark people, and then Circe pressures Robert to order the execution of Sansus
- 1:02:53Direwolf because they can't find Aria's direwolf, and so Sansus dire Wolf Lady is
- 1:02:59ex cuted, and of course ed Ard carries that out because that's the noble
- 1:03:04thing to do or the honorable thing to do. Okay, So pet owners
- 1:03:07just think about this. So in modern times, it would be Trump.
- 1:03:13So Trump's son, you know that that little kid, he's bullying some underprivileged
- 1:03:20boy. And then you witness this bullying of Trump's son, and you try
- 1:03:25to stop Trump's son from bullying the poor boy. And then Trump's son pulls
- 1:03:30a gun on you, and your your pet dog, who is a very
- 1:03:37loyal, wonderful dog, jumps on Trump's son to stop him from shooting you.
- 1:03:44And then Trump's son drops the gun, and you pick up the gun
- 1:03:47and you throw it in the river, and then later on you get caught.
- 1:03:52And then you're sitting before Trump, Donald Trump, and Donald Trump orders
- 1:03:58the execution of your sister dog because of what happened. Imagine how upset you
- 1:04:03would be at that. So that was all Circe's doing. Now, on
- 1:04:10one hand, you could say it's because Circe is a terrible psychopath, But
- 1:04:14on other hand, you could say it's because she's very protective of Joffrey,
- 1:04:17which you could say both are true. All right, So back in King's
- 1:04:21Landing, Circe is looking for a way to kill Robert. She's done with
- 1:04:27Robert, she hates him. Jeoffrey is old enough to become king, and
- 1:04:30so she just wants to move on to the next phase of life. So
- 1:04:35she wants to get rid of Robert, and the only way she can do
- 1:04:38that is to kill him. Plus, by killing Robert, she eliminates the
- 1:04:43threat of being found out that the sons are not or that Joffrey isn't Robert's
- 1:04:47son, and so she really needs to get to this next phase in order
- 1:04:53to solidify her security and her power, and at first she plans to kill
- 1:05:00Robert. She prides to have Robert killed in the tourney. In the TV
- 1:05:04show, you remember, Robert is trying to put on his armor it can't
- 1:05:09fit and ed Ard and him having a laugh about it. But that didn't
- 1:05:12work out. So Circe is looking for a way to kill Robert. Meanwhile,
- 1:05:20Edward Stark is figuring out figuring out that her three kids are not Robert's
- 1:05:25kids, and Circe is beginning to panic around this. As I was saying
- 1:05:30before, I imagine the situation soon because of ed Ard, everyone will know
- 1:05:36that you've been secretly sleeping with your twin brother, and Robert will find out
- 1:05:43and kill not only you, They'll kill you but also your kids or banish
- 1:05:48them or something. Then there would be a war, probably between your father
- 1:05:55Taiwan and between the Brathians and the Starks, and people would start to suspect
- 1:06:01that John Aaron was killed by you, and there would just be total chaos.
- 1:06:05There would be a lot of dead people. She's sitting there thinking,
- 1:06:10if Edward gets this out there, then this is discovered, not only will
- 1:06:14me and my kids be killed, which is a terrible thought, but also
- 1:06:17the entire realm will be thrown into chaos. There will likely be a lot
- 1:06:21of people dead because of this. Or I can kill Edard somehow. So
- 1:06:28what should I do? And what now? She has a third option so
- 1:06:33to say, Well, I can try to kill Edward, which isn't great
- 1:06:36but you know for me, because if I got found out, it's kind
- 1:06:40of risky. Or I can let Edward talk and risk killing me, my
- 1:06:44kids and everyone else. So what could I what's a third option? So
- 1:06:50Circe tries to you know, so Edward comes to Circe about it, which
- 1:06:56is weird, but anyway, Edward says, hey, Circe. It just
- 1:06:59wants you to want to let you know I have proof that your children are
- 1:07:02not Robert's. And Circe strangely admits it. She's like, Yep, you're
- 1:07:08right, at Ard, It's true. This is in the books, not
- 1:07:11TV show. It's a little different TV show. But anyway, Circe tries
- 1:07:14to seduce ed Art. She says, well, the third options, you
- 1:07:19know, kill at Ard, you know, not easy, difficult, risky,
- 1:07:25don't kill Edard, total chaos, or if I seduce at Art,
- 1:07:30then problem solved. So she tries to seduce him, as she has done
- 1:07:35with many people before him, but she doesn't know Art. Edart is the
- 1:07:42most stubbornly honorable person of all time. He's not persuade Art. But he's
- 1:07:50not Persuadart. He's not persuaded. Ed Ard then says, I'm going to
- 1:07:56tell Robert about this, and I just want you to know that I'm gonna
- 1:08:00tell Robert because I want you to flee with your children, because when I
- 1:08:04tell Robert, he's gonna kill you and your kids, and I don't want
- 1:08:08that to happen. So I want you to get out of town. What
- 1:08:13a nice guy, you know, super nice guy. But what a stupid
- 1:08:15guy. I mean, you're telling Circe, the one person who is already
- 1:08:21conspiring to kill you and Robert. Why would you tell her. It's just
- 1:08:26it's everything could have been solved if he would have just gone straight to Robert
- 1:08:30with this. But he tell Circe first, which is a big mistake,
- 1:08:33but it's the honorable thing to do, right, You're gonna tell Robert and
- 1:08:39then you're gonna let Circe get away with the kids. And maybe actually Edward
- 1:08:44was thinking about the big picture here, that if Circe and the kids managed
- 1:08:48to get away, maybe Taiwan won't go to war against Robert for killing Circe,
- 1:08:56right because if Robert goes into a rage kill Circe and the kids,
- 1:08:59twain and by necessity has to revenge blah blah blah. Anyway, So maybe
- 1:09:05Ottard was being political there, but it seems more likely that Edward was just
- 1:09:11being the super nice guy that he is overly nice guy and didn't think the
- 1:09:15whole thing through, or didn't know that Circe was as ruthless as she was
- 1:09:20well before Edward can tell Robert about Jeoffrey, Marcella and Tom and just then
- 1:09:30Robert is injured while hunting a boar. The boar you know, attacks him,
- 1:09:35gets him with his whatever boor's attack with. And I've never hunted boor,
- 1:09:41so you know, forgive me. But anyway, Lancell Lanister, which
- 1:09:45who is Circe's cousin. You remember him from the TV show he joins with
- 1:09:51the High Sparrow. Lancell. Now, so normally Robert drinks wine when he
- 1:09:59does every thing, he drinks wine all the time. But apparently there's this
- 1:10:02thing called strong wine, and Lancell switched the wine for the strong So so
- 1:10:08Circe's like, okay, Lancell, my cousin, I want to kill Robert
- 1:10:15and you're gonna help me the next and so, and Lancell is like squire
- 1:10:18for King Robert, and he says, okay, when you go hunting next
- 1:10:23time, I want you to switch out strong wine because this will get Robert
- 1:10:27super drunk and will raise the risk of him being injured and killed. And
- 1:10:31Lancell does this that Robert gets super drunk. And I'm just trying to imagine
- 1:10:34what strong wine is. Is that like Colt forty five or something, or
- 1:10:40in college, I remember there was this thing called night Train that what we
- 1:10:44would find in stores. It was like this cheap what they called fortified wine,
- 1:10:50which I'm trying to imagine what that is. I'm guessing it's cheap wine
- 1:10:55with fl alcohol infused into it or something. But anyway, so he gives
- 1:11:01Robert night train, and I mean night train. What I mean that just
- 1:11:06sounds like a nasty drink, right, imagine a big bottle at something called
- 1:11:12night train. Although a lot of alcohol names are funny, I mean cold
- 1:11:16forty five. It's a gun that doesn't make any sense. Old English eight
- 1:11:23hundred old. I guess English you think of beer, but I don't know
- 1:11:30anyway, strong wine he gives them that goes strong gets super drunk. Robert
- 1:11:35does indeed get super drunk and gets injured by a bore. Everyone knows he's
- 1:11:40going to die soon. He's he has a huge wound in his gut,
- 1:11:44and they know from experience that if you have an open wound in your gut,
- 1:11:47you die somehow. And at this point Eduard could tell Robert, by
- 1:11:53the way, your children are not your children, and Sirci even confirmed this,
- 1:11:59so you know you should know that because and I know Jeoffrey to be
- 1:12:03a sadistic dumbass and so so. Edward at this point could completely save everybody,
- 1:12:12but he decides not to tell Robert again because he's trying to be nice
- 1:12:18by trying to be nice to Robert, because he doesn't want to hurt his
- 1:12:21feelings. On his deathbed, he doesn't tell Robert that these kids are not
- 1:12:28his kids. Maybe because he thought, well, maybe Jeoffrey will be okay,
- 1:12:32you know, maybe you know, maybe Jeoffrey will be okay. I
- 1:12:35don't know, but it's just interesting that what could have happened differently if Robert
- 1:12:42had Eduard told Robert at this moment. But anyway, big mistake. Robert
- 1:12:46dies, Joffrey is crowned, Circe takes control. Circe accuses Eduard of conspiring
- 1:12:51against Jeoffrey, which is true, and throws him in the dungeon. She
- 1:12:56convinces Eduard to confess and take the Black degrees. But Jeffrey, if you
- 1:13:01remember from the TV show and for the books, Jeoffrey impulsively orders his men
- 1:13:04to execute Edward. They chop off Edward's head, and at this point,
- 1:13:10if you hadn't read the books when you're watching the TV show, you were
- 1:13:13just like, WHOA this is gonna be that kind of TV show, or
- 1:13:16they kill the main character. Like I mean, believe me, when I
- 1:13:20was reading the books, I was like, wait a second, I had
- 1:13:23to go back. This can't have happened. I mean, Edward's the star,
- 1:13:28he's the main dude, he's the good guys, He's done everything good.
- 1:13:31He's the Golden Warrior. And Jeffrey just chopped his head off. Ah.
- 1:13:38You know, so Circe did not want Edard to have his head cut
- 1:13:44off. I'm sure Circe would have loved to kill him, but she was
- 1:13:46thinking in terms of politically, you can't kill Edard because if you kill Edard,
- 1:13:53then how Stark and all the Northern Men, the Bannermen of Winterfel will
- 1:14:00have to go to war with us, and we need to avoid that.
- 1:14:01So let's not do that right now. But Jeoffrey, because he's a sadistic
- 1:14:08dumbass, it bulsively orders his man to kill Edward, and Circe's like,
- 1:14:11oh b bah bah bah and then head cut off, and then Circe's like,
- 1:14:14oh shit, So the war the Five Kings begin between Jeoffrey, Stanis
- 1:14:18Renley, Rob Stark, and Baylon Grayjoy. Whenever you think about the War
- 1:14:23of the Five Kings, you think, okay, well you got Jeoffrey,
- 1:14:26you got Stanis Brath, and you have Rerinley Brathy, and of course you
- 1:14:29have King of the North Rob Stark. Who's the fifth king of the War
- 1:14:32of the Five Kings. It's Baylon Grayjoy. For some reason, he also
- 1:14:36said I'm king too, and even though he's completely ineffectual or just relatively ineffectual.
- 1:14:42But anyway, Jamie is captured during the War of the Five Kings by
- 1:14:46Rob Stark in a battle, and Circe is very distraught about this. Again,
- 1:14:53she can only depend on one other adult and that's Jamie and needs Jamie
- 1:15:00and he gets captured. So it seems as though Jamie arab. Circe has
- 1:15:04legitimate, genuine love for Jamie and to soothe her self, what does she
- 1:15:12turned to, Well, her cousin Lancell. She has sex with Lancell.
- 1:15:16I'm not sure if I'm saying Lancell right, I'm sort of pronouncing it like
- 1:15:19Denzel Lancell. Maybe it's Lancel. I don't know. Anyway, Tyrian convinces
- 1:15:26Circe to allow Marcella, So now Tirian is handed the king for Geoffrey Tirian
- 1:15:31convinces Circe to allow Marcella to go to Dorin to strengthen the alliance between the
- 1:15:40Barathian Lanisters and House Martel. Another big loss here for Circe. So not
- 1:15:48only is her brother and lover and husband ish person Jamie captured by Rob Starkin
- 1:15:56potentially executed who knows what will happen to him, but her one of her
- 1:16:02three children is sent to Dorn and skipping forward the story here, she never
- 1:16:09sees Marcella again. Marcella on her way back home dies and so that is
- 1:16:15she's she's losing one of her three kids, which was not good for her.
- 1:16:21And she blamed Tyrian for this whole thing because she's convinced that Tyrian is
- 1:16:26just trying to destroy her by selling Marcella away. But and it's maybe Tyrian
- 1:16:31is, but Tyrian did have reasons for this anyway. So then we have
- 1:16:34the Battle of the Blackwater during the War of the Five Kings, and if
- 1:16:39you remember this from the movie and from the books, she invites all the
- 1:16:43noble women for a party in one room, and all the women are like,
- 1:16:47oh, we're here for a party for the Battle of the Blackwater.
- 1:16:51But or we're here for protection. We have these guards to protect us.
- 1:16:56But in reality, she had them all there because she plans and killing all
- 1:17:00them in case the Battle of Blackwater goes badly. She plans she's ordered the
- 1:17:08guards to kill all the noble women so that they can't be hostages if the
- 1:17:13battle is lost, which is sort of weird considering that all of our family
- 1:17:17would likely be slaughtered if the Battle of the Blackwater went badly for her,
- 1:17:24So why would Stanis even need hostages at that point? But maybe Stanis would
- 1:17:30keep Joffrey alive and you know, so that he could negotiate with Taiwan or
- 1:17:36I don't know. It's that one's a little confusing to me, But anyway,
- 1:17:40that's that scene. Tyrian is injured in the battle, and remember Circe
- 1:17:45hates Tyrian to this point. In fact, I think it's implied, at
- 1:17:47least in the TV show. I forget in the books. It's been a
- 1:17:50while since I read the books. But Tyrian is injured in the battle,
- 1:17:55and I think it's because Circe actually hired someone to try to kill him in
- 1:17:58the middle of the battle. So by she tried to hire one of Tyrian's
- 1:18:01own men to kill him. And so while Tyrian is is recovering, Circe
- 1:18:12uses this time to influence Taiwan and turn Taiwan against Tyrian, which works,
- 1:18:16and when Tyrian wakes up, he's been stripped of all his power and now
- 1:18:20he's afraid that Circe will have him killed like she tried to do during the
- 1:18:26Battle of Blackwater. Taiwan at this point is like, Okay, Circe is
- 1:18:30getting a little old. She is now a widow, and I can use
- 1:18:38her for political gain, which is completely normal for this world and for this
- 1:18:43time in Europe. And I'm guessing your royal family is all over the world.
- 1:18:47And so Taiwan's like, okay, who can I marry Circe off to
- 1:18:51that will benefit the house, because remember Taiwan is all about the house.
- 1:18:56He doesn't you know, He's not a warm, cuddly dad, which can't
- 1:19:00be good for Circe. And and by the way, in the books in
- 1:19:04particular, it's very clear that Circe and Jamie are desperate for approval from Taiwan.
- 1:19:14So Taiwan plans to marry Circe off, and Tyan was like, okay,
- 1:19:17how about Circe Mary Baylon gray Joy, remember one of the five quote
- 1:19:24unquote kings, as a way of gaining the alliance with Baylon gray Joy against
- 1:19:29Rob Stark, because if because if Baylon gray Joy joins, because you know,
- 1:19:33the Iron Islands are in the north, and so if gray Joy allies
- 1:19:40themselves with the Lanister's Brathians, then the grade Joys can come in from behind
- 1:19:45on Rob Stark or something anyway. Also, Tyan's like, huh, how
- 1:19:48about I Mary Circe to Ober and Martel the Viper, or how about Theon
- 1:19:54gray Joy? Imagine that one. So instead of Bailon, how about how
- 1:19:58about the Prince Theon? Imagine Circe and Theon getting married and several other men
- 1:20:04princes and kings and stuff that she was thinking or princess anyway that Taiwan was
- 1:20:11thinking about marrying off to or not princess anyway, young men. Then the
- 1:20:15wedding, the wedding, the Red Wedding happens. Rob is killed. Also
- 1:20:20around this time, Brindley is killed by the Stantis Ghosts. Stanis loses the
- 1:20:25Battle Blackwater. He's powerless. Baylon great Joy never had power. So basically,
- 1:20:30Jeoffrey has won the War of the five Kings. It's decided that Jeoffrey
- 1:20:34will marry Marjorie Terrell instead of Sansa because that's a more important alliance, because
- 1:20:41the Terrells are an important group of people. And then Circe precedes the torment
- 1:20:45Sansa for the fun of it. And Circe is now slowly realizing that her
- 1:20:51son, now that Jeoffrey is king, she is slowly realizing that her son
- 1:20:57is a sadistic dumbass. And you know, just imagine how embarrassing that is.
- 1:21:01You're just watching the king act like a dumbass and you're his mother.
- 1:21:08So she's embarrassed about that, but she also is thinking, well, he's
- 1:21:12the king, so he gets to do whatever he wants to do, so
- 1:21:14screw it. Then Jeoffrey is killed right before her eyes at his wedding reception,
- 1:21:21the feast for the wedding. This is nicknamed the Purple Wedding. It's
- 1:21:26not, you know, officially in the books called the Purple wedding, but
- 1:21:30it's a fan nickname because it's called the purple wedding because purple is the color
- 1:21:35of royalty. It's also the color of the purple amethyst. And Sansus hairnet
- 1:21:43where the poison came from came from an amethyst in sansus hairnet. In the
- 1:21:48books, it's a necklace thing, or in the TV show it's a necklace
- 1:21:51thing. Also, the poison turned Jeoffrey's wine from red to purple, and
- 1:21:57also Jeoffrey's face turned to purple as he was choking. That's why it's called
- 1:22:01the Purple Wedding, which I have to say was a highly satisfying moment for
- 1:22:06me in the books and in the TV show to watch his face turn purple.
- 1:22:12Circe blames Tyrian for just yet another thing that Tyrian shouldn't be blamed for,
- 1:22:18and she has several people testify against Tyrian that Tyrian was the one that
- 1:22:24poisoned Geoffrey. She is totally convinced. She's not just against Tyran. She
- 1:22:30is one hundred percent convinced that Tyrian killed Jeoffrey. She's one hundred percent convinced
- 1:22:33that Tyrian killed her mother. She's one hundred percent convinced that Tyrian sent Marcella
- 1:22:39away just to spite her. She has, according to her cognitive reality,
- 1:22:45she has a lot of reasons to hate Tyrian, and she hates him.
- 1:22:48Tyrian calls her trial by combat, And of course you remember that terrible scene
- 1:22:54in which the mountain splits the viper's head open like a melon. Jiminy Crickets,
- 1:23:01I'm remembering that in my head right now. But anyway, Tyrian escapes
- 1:23:04with the help of Jamie and Varies, and Tyrian kills Timon on the way
- 1:23:09out. So this is a huge, huge loss for Circe. In the
- 1:23:15span of a very short amount of time. Her son dies before her eyes.
- 1:23:20Now, all of us hated everyone hated Geoffrey. I'm guessing even his
- 1:23:25own brother and sister hated Jeoffrey. But there was one person who loved Geoffrey,
- 1:23:28and that was Circe. Circe loved her kids. There's speculation people will
- 1:23:35write about Circe as if, you know, how could she really love her
- 1:23:39kids. She's a psychopathic, terrible person. But I if I could crawl
- 1:23:44inside Circe's olympic system, I believe I would see genuine love and affection from
- 1:23:48a mother to her children. She certainly acted that way in the books and
- 1:23:55in the movies. There's evidence that maybe she just needed them for political game,
- 1:23:59But I think she's human in some level, and which is why she's
- 1:24:03such an interesting character. I mean, she you know, she was not
- 1:24:05a Ramsey Bolton. You know, she's not like a Ramsey. She seems
- 1:24:10to have some normalcy to her, some humanness to her. And I think
- 1:24:14she genuinely loved, loved her children and Jamie and she in the span of
- 1:24:21a very short amount of time, her son dies before her eyes just and
- 1:24:29is killed by her brother, she thinks, and then her father is murdered
- 1:24:34by her brother. Imagine that one You know, your son is murdered by
- 1:24:39your brother, then your father is murdered by your brother. That's a traumatic
- 1:24:42experience. And Circe experiences a wide variety of motion of emotions at this point
- 1:24:47in the books. They don't really portray this in the TV show so much,
- 1:24:53but in the books she is. She's quite emotional, which is natural,
- 1:24:57right. I just imagine again telling me that she's a human being.
- 1:25:00There's a there's a there's a humanist to her that we could all relate to.
- 1:25:06So, but there's one huge gain in her life. During the Purple
- 1:25:12Wedding, Jamie comes back and Jamie, uh, you know, brand of
- 1:25:16Tarth brings Jamie back. Jamie asks if he can tell everyone about their incests.
- 1:25:23He's like, look, my hand is cut off. I thought I
- 1:25:26was gonna die. I've I've turned a new leaf here. I'm done with
- 1:25:30this whole society thing. And I want to I want to announce from the
- 1:25:34mountaintops that you and I are in a relationship. Your Toman is is Tooman's
- 1:25:43king now or Jeoffrey's King now. I can't remember exactly when this conversation takes
- 1:25:45place. You know, Robert's gone the way the Five Kings is over.
- 1:25:49We're in control, honey, can't let's just come out and and then we
- 1:25:55can just be out in the open about it. I think Jamie was quite
- 1:25:58desperate just to get closer to Circe at this point. Plus Jamie doesn't really
- 1:26:02understand politics as much as Circe does, and so Circe's like, uh no,
- 1:26:08we can't. We can't tell everyone about this. And Jamie's like,
- 1:26:11well, what about the Targarians. They there was the brothers and sisters had
- 1:26:15were married all the time back in the Targerian days. Why can't we just
- 1:26:19be like them? And Circe's like, nope, let's not do that.
- 1:26:23I think maybe even because Circe didn't want Jamie to have power. I don't
- 1:26:28know, but anyway, so Circe does that. Now at this point,
- 1:26:31Circe is hell bent on finding Tyrian, which alienates Jamie because Jamie is not
- 1:26:38so convinced that Tyrian. I mean, Jamie was the one who let Tyrian
- 1:26:41go right, but then Tyrian kills Jamie's father, so that can't go over
- 1:26:45well Jamie, but Jamie's Jamie has a warm place in his heart for Tyrian.
- 1:26:50Jamie leaves King Landing to fight in the river Lands. And this is
- 1:26:56basically the last time up until the end of season six of the TV show
- 1:27:00and end of book five of the books that Jamie and Circe are nice to
- 1:27:10each other. But anyway, Circe takes complete control of everything now that Tom
- 1:27:15is king, and Tom's very young at this point. I don't know exactly
- 1:27:20how old he is, but I think he's like in the TV show,
- 1:27:23he seems maybe like he's twelve, thirteen, fourteen, or something, but
- 1:27:27in the books he I think he's like seven or eight. I mean,
- 1:27:31Jeoffrey was only twelve or thirteen when he was king in the books, and
- 1:27:36Toman is you know, two siblings down and so I'm guessing he was like
- 1:27:42eight or something, and so so Circe takes complete control of everything, and
- 1:27:47she becomes paranoid. She becomes one of those classic rulers who thinks that everyone's
- 1:27:56against her, and instead of trying to make friends, she just proceeds to
- 1:28:02make enemies. It's sort of like stalin Russia or something. She instead of
- 1:28:09being political, she just eliminates or gets rid or you know, demotes her
- 1:28:14enemies and just promotes a bunch of yes men. And that's and she's pretty
- 1:28:20emotional at this point. She's not she's not very smart in the things that
- 1:28:26she's doing, but she's quite determined. And she starts to get rid of
- 1:28:32the Terrells in terms of their positions of power. She's drinking more, she's
- 1:28:39gaining weight in the books. She obviously doesn't gain weight in the TV show,
- 1:28:44but she does in the books or not obviously, but they don't show
- 1:28:46her gaining weight in the TV show as far as I remember. But she's
- 1:28:50she's pretty emotional, and we need to take a break, and when I
- 1:28:54get back, I'll provide some psychological blah blah blah about that. Okay,
- 1:29:03we're back before moving on here. Just remember to rate us on iTunes.
- 1:29:09Please. If you do, let me know and I will send you some
- 1:29:12swag. Also, tell a friend or a colleague about it. If you're
- 1:29:16in the field, tell some you know, tell one of your colleagues,
- 1:29:18send an email out, let other people know, because that's how people find
- 1:29:21out about this thing. Okay, So in the in the TV show,
- 1:29:29it's not as a parent I think they I think at some point Circe's drinking
- 1:29:33has commented on, like geez, you're drinking a lot. But in the
- 1:29:36books it's they have much more time to go into Circe's emotional life and how
- 1:29:44she is exhibiting some kind of emotional difficulty. Again, her son is murdered
- 1:29:51by she believes by her brother, right before her eyes, in front of
- 1:29:56a huge crowd. That is a traumatic experience. Again for us, we
- 1:30:00hated Jeoffrey, and so it was the opposite of trauma. For us,
- 1:30:03it was a wonderful, elated experience. But for the you know, for
- 1:30:12Circe, it was terrible. Imagine your thirteen twelve year old son is murdered
- 1:30:19by your brother in front of a crowd of people and slowly dies by suffocating
- 1:30:29and is in utter pain as he dies. That's a terrible experience. Then
- 1:30:34your brother proceeds to kill your father, that's going to take a toll.
- 1:30:41That's big time grief. Her father was a huge source of security for her.
- 1:30:46She always knew that her father would save the day because he often did
- 1:30:51for the sake of the house. And now she's just on her own.
- 1:30:58Jamie doesn't seem to be interesting did in leading Toman is an eight year old
- 1:31:02child. She's basically in control of the Seven kingdoms. And people have been
- 1:31:11conspiring prior to Geoffrey's wedding to kill Jeoffrey at least one person, and maybe
- 1:31:17someone will try to kill Tom, and maybe someone will conspire to kill her.
- 1:31:20I mean, she has reasons to be paranoid, So she's grief stricken.
- 1:31:25She is justifiably paranoid. She is upset, she's angry, she is
- 1:31:31determined to find Tyrian, and Jamie isn't around to comfort her. She's all
- 1:31:39alone, and she begins to drink. Alcohol is a very effective tool to
- 1:31:50calm the nerves when you're going through traumas. When you have it's sort of
- 1:31:57like in the movies in the Old People would be upset, and they would
- 1:32:02always offer you a shot of bourbon or something. I don't know if you've
- 1:32:09seen these sort of scenes, but you know someone's like quote unquote hysterical.
- 1:32:14They're like, oh my god, oh my god, oh my god.
- 1:32:15And then someone's like, you know, here, have a shot of whiskey.
- 1:32:18Alcohol will slow your nervous system down. It actually slows your nervous system
- 1:32:28down, so that you and numbs you. Right. I mean, I'm
- 1:32:33not saying anything that you guys don't know, but I think that George Martin
- 1:32:38was smart to include this. And she starts to gain weight, which means
- 1:32:43that she's losing one of her prime sources of self confidence, which is her
- 1:32:48her beauty. Assuming that gaining weight means that you're not as beautiful anymore in
- 1:32:54this world, I'm not quite so sure about that. But anyway, actually,
- 1:32:59no, that's confirmed because Circe is in denial of her weight gain because
- 1:33:04she wants to stay beautiful. And she thinks that her servants are slowly are
- 1:33:12like gaslighting her by making her dresses smaller and smaller, and so she yells
- 1:33:15at her servants saying that why are you making my dresses smaller or something like
- 1:33:20that. So she's quite upset about gaining weight, so she's not happy about
- 1:33:25it. Anyway, we see here that Circe's psyche is starting to take a
- 1:33:33serious downturn, and keep that in mind as we move forward in the story,
- 1:33:40that she has been massively emotionally impacted by what is happening right here,
- 1:33:46and she's trying to you know, control seven kingdoms with several factions and lots
- 1:33:54of you know, the game of thrones, right, all these people trying
- 1:33:58to gain power. Well, she fails at gaining control of the Southern kingdoms,
- 1:34:03partially because she is paranoid, but also partially just because of the way
- 1:34:09the kingdom was situated. It was just a hard sort of machine to control,
- 1:34:16and even if some smarter person was in control, it still might have
- 1:34:21been tough. After the War of Five Kings, so the kingdom is in
- 1:34:28a lot of debt and there are a lot of angry factions, including the
- 1:34:30Church. The Church was quite upset about things, which the people are very
- 1:34:38supportive of the Church, and so the people are upset and it's tough and
- 1:34:43things aren't going her way. So again, little Tomman is an inefectual King.
- 1:34:47Marjorie is Marjorie the Queen, and Circe is trying to control things are
- 1:34:54falling apart and her in Taiwan isn't there to help her. Jamie's not there
- 1:34:59to help her. She's all alone. Tyrian could have been there to help
- 1:35:02her, but she he's on the run. In s Os, she plots
- 1:35:08to kill some of her enemies, and at this point Marjorie is starting to
- 1:35:13gain power over Tommon. So Marjorie becomes the main threat to her power in
- 1:35:23a very real way because Marjorie is the queen. She's the queen, she's
- 1:35:28the wife of the king and so so technically Circe has less power than Marjorie,
- 1:35:34and she Circe does not want Marjorie to take power now. Instead of
- 1:35:40making friends with Marjorie, which is what I would have done given my personality
- 1:35:45at say hey, you know, let's be friends and let's let's be allies
- 1:35:48and blah blah blah. But instead of doing that, she proceeds to try
- 1:35:54to get rid of Marjorie, which is another example of the way Circe operates.
- 1:36:00Again, she doesn't trust because she was given a life in which she
- 1:36:04couldn't trust other people. She could only trust Jamie and her kids. And
- 1:36:09so she manipulates the system in this game of thronesy sort of way to get
- 1:36:15the High Sparrow into power, and she seduces men into framing Marjorie for adultery
- 1:36:19and treason, and so so she thinks the High Sparrow is her ally since
- 1:36:27she managed to get the High Sparrow into power, and she gets the High
- 1:36:32Sparrow to arrest Marjorie for adultery and treason. But then the High Sparrow also
- 1:36:39it's a long story, and you a little bit of us portray to this
- 1:36:42in the TV show, But the High Sparrow arrests Circe as well. So
- 1:36:46her whole plan to get rid of Marjorie backfires in getting her arrested for things
- 1:36:54that she actually did. So she tried to frame Marjorie for something that Marjorie
- 1:36:58didn't do and then proceeds to get arrested for things that Circe actually did do.
- 1:37:03And so Circe is and you've seen this in the TV show, is
- 1:37:08humiliated and tortured, and she asked for a trial by combat and she's like,
- 1:37:14I'm gonna win that one because I got this mountain thing on my side.
- 1:37:18But Tom and outlaws trial by combat, saying that it's a it's a
- 1:37:24way for rich people to snub their nose, that the gods is that another
- 1:37:30phrase? I'm terrible with these idioms snub their nose anyway, Tom and outlaws
- 1:37:34trial by combat, and which is a total betrayal to to Circe. Again,
- 1:37:43let's just look at this from Circe's standpoint. She's like, Okay,
- 1:37:46this whole plan backfired. Holy crap, I'm now being tortured and beaten by
- 1:37:53these religious zelots and I'm in prison for the first time of my life.
- 1:37:59This is terrible, and my one way out of this is trial by combat,
- 1:38:04and then I'll get out, like you know, the way that things
- 1:38:09should be, since I'm a privileged, rich person, and although this is
- 1:38:14terrible and humiliating, I'll fight my way back. Well then one of the
- 1:38:19Now, so Jamie's kind of gone at this point, and she basically just
- 1:38:24has Tomon at this point, Marcella's far away, Geoffrey's dead, she hates
- 1:38:29everyone else. She just has little sweet Toman that she believes loves her.
- 1:38:34She has Tom and that loves her, and then Tom and is convinced by
- 1:38:41Marjorie. I think, well, maybe not Marjorie, but anyway, the
- 1:38:43high spare out on all these other people. I think Marjorie too. But
- 1:38:45anyway, Tom is convinced to outlaw trial by combat as a direct affront to
- 1:38:51Circe. And so Tom has been subsumed by the Church who is against Circe.
- 1:39:00And now Circe has nobody. So again, think about that her own
- 1:39:04son betrayed her and this is rock bottom for her. She's in total despair.
- 1:39:12She is thinking, my god, I am truly alone, with no
- 1:39:17power, no way out of this. So and by the way, which
- 1:39:23it wasn't really portrayed in the book, or the or the TV show quite
- 1:39:28well, is that she could be beheaded because of the things she was being
- 1:39:32accused of. The things she was being accused of, she could be put
- 1:39:36to death. It wasn't just like prison time or something or pay a fine.
- 1:39:42The things that the High Sparrow was accusing her of and others, she
- 1:39:46could die. And so really, so the trial by combat being made illegal
- 1:39:55meant tom and was basically killing Circe. He was eliminating try by Comba.
- 1:40:01Toman was saying basically the system now has the power and almost the duty to
- 1:40:06kill my own mother, which is kind of a mind screw for Tom.
- 1:40:10And so Circe confesses to having sex with Lancell and many other men, but
- 1:40:16not Jamie. So Circe confesses to some of it, hoping that if she
- 1:40:20confesses to some of it, she'll get away with a lesser sentence or something,
- 1:40:25which is unclear to me exactly what that means. But anyway, she's
- 1:40:28allowed to leave the sept to await her trial. She is completely shaved.
- 1:40:33In the TV show, they leave some hair on her head, but in
- 1:40:39the books she's completely shaved of all hair, and she's stripped naked, and
- 1:40:46she walks to the red keep from the sept and there's a bell, and
- 1:40:53this is in the book too Shame, Shame. Everyone yells at her.
- 1:40:58They throw nasty shit at her face and on her walk, which is not
- 1:41:03portrayed in the TV show as well as it is as severely as it is
- 1:41:09in the books. On her walk, she starts to mentally break down.
- 1:41:12She starts to hallucinate. This is a very difficult moment for her emotionally and
- 1:41:17mentally. She starts to hallucinate that she sees Edard in the crowd, who's
- 1:41:24dead. She sees Taiwan in the crowd, who's dead. She sees Tyrian
- 1:41:28in the crowd. She sees her son Jeoffrey in the crowd, and many
- 1:41:30other people, and she starts to lose it, and she breaks down and
- 1:41:34she's crying, but she manages to make it to the Red Keep. Okay,
- 1:41:41now we are in the TV zone. We were in the zone of
- 1:41:46the story that is beyond the books. In the books, after the point
- 1:41:53when she gets back to the Red Keep, Kevin Lanister, who's in charge
- 1:41:57at this point. So when Circe goes to the prison, Kevin Lanister comes
- 1:42:02back from because because Circe basically made it so that Kevin would leave King's Landing
- 1:42:10when Circe's in prison, Kevin comes back and says, Okay, I'm taking
- 1:42:13over. And Kevin does a pretty good job. And Kevin's smart. So
- 1:42:18you know, Circe, the nasty, psychopathic Circe has been imprisoned and is
- 1:42:26coming back to the Red Keep, and Kevin in the books is smarter than
- 1:42:29Kevin in the TV show. He's in the books, Kevin's like, okay,
- 1:42:33so I have no use for Circe, and she's a huge liability,
- 1:42:40and she's prone to revenge and killing people and doing all these horrible things.
- 1:42:44And at the very least, she's a chaotic element in this story. So
- 1:42:47I'm going to make I'm going to marginalize her and make sure that she has
- 1:42:50no power. And so Kevin gets rid of all of her servants, He
- 1:42:54gets rid of all of her guards, and I think he even sends her
- 1:42:57to Cashley Rock to just basely brought away, not in prison, but but
- 1:43:03you know, basically in house bound, if that makes any sense, without
- 1:43:09any power. Kevin is very smart in the books in that way. Now,
- 1:43:16looking forward, I suspect George Martin Inten's on a completely different path for
- 1:43:23Circe than the TV show, but we'll find out. But in the in
- 1:43:26the TV show, this is a very different situation. Nobody checks Circe's power
- 1:43:34upon her leaving the the prison there she still has people who are loyal to
- 1:43:42her, and and this is the moment of truth for her. She has
- 1:43:47she has reached a critical crossroads. She could face the music and go to
- 1:43:56the trial and probably get executed, or or she could fight back. But
- 1:44:01how can she fight back? Because and I'm sure this is what she's thinking.
- 1:44:04She's thinking, Okay, I'm not going down without a fight. But
- 1:44:09but what can I do? I could kill the high Sparrow, but that
- 1:44:13won't work because the people will rise against me and other high Sparrows will replace
- 1:44:18him, so let's not do that. I could kill Marjorie and get rid
- 1:44:26of her, but Toman won't be happy with that, and Toman might turn
- 1:44:30against me. He's already turning against me, so I don't know if killing
- 1:44:34Marjorie. Plus, if I kill Marjorie, the high Sparrow will still will
- 1:44:39still, you know, put me on trial and kill me. I could
- 1:44:43kill Toman, but that would make Marjorie the ruler. And plus if I
- 1:44:47kill Toman, then Stanis would be king, and that doesn't make you know,
- 1:44:54So she can't kill Toman. She could run, but how would she
- 1:44:59survive? And I always, by the way, I always wonder why people
- 1:45:01don't run More often. I have a feeling like writers are like, well,
- 1:45:05if they run, that sort of ends the story. But but in
- 1:45:09my mind that's what I would do. I'd probably just well, fuck it,
- 1:45:12I'm out of here. I'd rather be a poor peasant on a farm
- 1:45:16in Esos than be killed in westros So. But maybe that wasn't an option.
- 1:45:25You know, Tyrian managed to get away, so why couldn't. I
- 1:45:28mean, she could get a bunch of gold, maybe get a couple loyal
- 1:45:31servants, and just head out of town. But maybe that's not an option.
- 1:45:35Maybe she would be really recognizable, but Tyrian certainly is recognizable. I
- 1:45:41don't know, so she obviously didn't decide that. She decided to stay.
- 1:45:45You know, you could say that's consistent with her character, which is a
- 1:45:49fighter. So Circe says, well, I can't go to this trout because
- 1:45:56I'm probably going to be executed, and I can't take this in a measured,
- 1:46:01slow way. The only way out of this is if I kill everybody.
- 1:46:09So circ decides I'm gonna kill I'm gonna kill all y'all. And she
- 1:46:15gets someone I think Kay burn to put wildfire under the Great scept where the
- 1:46:18trial is going to take place. And on the morning of the trial,
- 1:46:23she gets all dressed up, but she doesn't go, and she manages to
- 1:46:27get tom And not to go. She prevents Toman from going to the Great
- 1:46:31sept and once everyone is there, she blows it up. And again,
- 1:46:38this is not in the books, and I have a feeling that this won't
- 1:46:41actually happen in the books, but this is what's going on on the TV
- 1:46:44show. And just a side note on this, I have a feeling that
- 1:46:47George Martin doesn't know how to write the last couple of books, because books
- 1:46:55four and five. If you've read the books, I hope you can relate
- 1:46:59to me and that books like one and two are just awesome. It's particularly
- 1:47:03book one, but as the series progressed, he started introducing more characters instead
- 1:47:11of focusing on the ones that we loved and cared about, and he wasn't
- 1:47:15really wrapping up any stories. And so to me, I don't know if
- 1:47:19I think George Martin may have painted himself into a corner because it's hard to
- 1:47:24imagine how he's going to wrap this story up. I have a feeling that
- 1:47:30he's going to not wrap it up, that he's just going to end it
- 1:47:33basically on cliffhangers. At the not cliffhangers, but I have a feeling that
- 1:47:39it's not going to have a satisfying ending. You know, Harry Potter,
- 1:47:44the books in the end, the end of book seven it's all it's satisfying.
- 1:47:48You know, Harry spoiler, Harry Potter wins, Boldemort dies. You
- 1:47:53know, some other people die too in the battles, but mostly everyone survives
- 1:47:57and it's a happy ending. Well, I don't think George Martin writes like
- 1:48:01that, and I don't I think everyone hopes he's going to write like that
- 1:48:05because I think that's what people want, and he's given a lot of interviews
- 1:48:10about how he's going to write. But even from my interviews, the interviews
- 1:48:15that I that I've read and listened to, I'm not confident that George Martin
- 1:48:18will be able to write an ending that will be satisfying. Now, the
- 1:48:23TV show producers who are in conversation with George Martin, by the way,
- 1:48:28and George Martin always approves of these things, and I think George Martin has
- 1:48:30even said, look, the TV show is going to go a different direction
- 1:48:32than the books. But I think the TV show people know how to wrap
- 1:48:38this up and I think they know what the fans want. And season six
- 1:48:45kind of proves that there were there were a lot of things that happened after
- 1:48:49the point of the So the books end and then the TV show continues beyond
- 1:48:53the books and pretty much everything that happened after that threshold was crossed. There's
- 1:49:00a lot of very satisfying things that happen right that the fans are like,
- 1:49:04yeah, and so I have a feeling that things are gonna and I think
- 1:49:11the blowing up of the stept is part of Although you're not going to go
- 1:49:14like yay, I think it's actually a good writing move because it's a way
- 1:49:19of elevating Sirce very quickly to absolute power, so you can kind of move
- 1:49:26the story forward. Plus it eliminates a bunch of secondary characters that you no
- 1:49:30longer have to write for. For instance, the High Sparrow is now dead
- 1:49:36and all of his followers. You no longer have to write anything about the
- 1:49:42High Sparrow and all the religious people. Queen Marjorie is dead, Mace Terrell
- 1:49:48is dead, Kevin Lanister is dead. I wonder what's her face? Terrell,
- 1:49:55the grandmother Terrell. I don't think she's dead. I think she's back
- 1:49:58at home. Sir Laurs Terrell, the Night of Flowers's he's dead. Just
- 1:50:02all these people are just eliminated in one fell swoop, and so now you
- 1:50:09can concentrate the stories on Circe in terms of being in total power, and
- 1:50:16you can focus on Denari's. You can focus now on Sants and John Snow
- 1:50:23and on Brand like the stories are a lot of side stories are being eliminated
- 1:50:28by this, by this but anyway, so Circe, in a true stroke
- 1:50:33of infamous genius, he just blows everyone up and one fell swoop and Tom
- 1:50:42and learns of this. I think he even sees the stept blowing up and
- 1:50:46he's like piecing two and two together and he's thinking, Okay, my mom
- 1:50:50prevented me from going. The sept just blew up. My mom's okay,
- 1:50:57wow, my mom. Just you know, Tom's been through a lot in
- 1:51:02a very short amount of time. His father died, his older brother was
- 1:51:09murdered by his uncle. I think Toman believes that Tyrian was involved. His
- 1:51:15older sister was murdered by the people in Dorn. Have I talked about that
- 1:51:20yet? You know that's another huge loss for Circe. Right then his mother
- 1:51:30kills his wife and many of his in laws and many of and his great
- 1:51:35uncle and many other people. And he's still the king, so by law
- 1:51:41he now has to kill his own mother. Let me just think about that
- 1:51:44one. Tom's thinking, my mom just killed my wife and the high Sparrow
- 1:51:48and all these other people, and I am the law. The king is
- 1:51:51the law. Therefore I have to arrest my mother and have her executed immediately.
- 1:52:00And you know, this is too much for the little guy. He's
- 1:52:03a fragile, nice, empathic, sweet little boy, and it's too much
- 1:52:10for the little guy, so he kills himself. In an amazing scene in
- 1:52:15the TV show. Again not in the books, but maybe not likely,
- 1:52:19Circe is crowned King of the Southern Kingdoms because everyone else who has claim to
- 1:52:28the Iron throne is dead. I don't maybe there's some kind of weird a
- 1:52:33line of succession that would not include Circe. But Robert's dead, Jeoffrey's dead,
- 1:52:40Marcella is dead, tom And is dead, Stanis is dead. Stanis
- 1:52:44only had one kid and she's dead. By this point, Renley is dead.
- 1:52:47Redley didn't amity kids. All the main Tyrrell's are dead, Kevin Lanister
- 1:52:53is dead, Taiwan Lanister is dead, Lancell Lanister is dead in the explosion.
- 1:52:59Jamie isn't around and probably couldn't become king anyway, Tyrian is an enemy
- 1:53:03of the state, and so so with Circe. Sirce is queen of the
- 1:53:09Southern Kingdoms, and she dons her Darth Vader outfit and sits on the iron
- 1:53:13thrown at a TV show. Jamie returns to King's landing, I think during
- 1:53:18the coronation, and Jamie looks sideways at his sister, who was who's you
- 1:53:26know, being crowned. I'm very curious to find out how Jamie feels about
- 1:53:30all this, because at this point in the story he seems to have a
- 1:53:34moral code and is not likely to be super enthusiastic about what his sisters has
- 1:53:42done. But if history shows anything, he is extremely devoted to his lover
- 1:53:49sister. But anyway, all right, so now I'm going to speculate about
- 1:53:56the future of Circe, and before moving forward, I just want to tell
- 1:54:01everyone that I hate it when people spoil things for me. So I'm here
- 1:54:06to tell you that I have no insider knowledge, and I'm as I said
- 1:54:10earlier, I'm usually wrong about predictions of storylines, So just keep all that
- 1:54:15in mind as I talk about this stuff. But I think it's it's interesting
- 1:54:19to think about what the future for Circe is and again this isn't spoilers because
- 1:54:29I just don't know. And if you're listening to this in the future,
- 1:54:31you know the answer to these questions, all right. So in the books,
- 1:54:35in books six and seven, George Martin, I'm guessing that Circe will
- 1:54:43continue to suffer and be laid low. She's one of the narrators. So
- 1:54:48in the books, if you haven't read the books, each chapter is narrated
- 1:54:51by a different character, so you know, chapter five, Sansa tells her
- 1:54:57story, and chapter and Circe tells her story. Originally, Circe was not
- 1:55:02a narrator, and then somewhere around for book four book five, Circe became
- 1:55:09one of the narrators, which is interesting because George Martin loves to have his
- 1:55:15narrators suffer. You know, the narrators typically are the ones who we identify
- 1:55:21with and they tend to suffer a lot. So I'm guessing that her story
- 1:55:28in the books will not mirror that of the TV show. If I was
- 1:55:31taking guess, I'm gonna guess that Circe will continue to hit rock bottom in
- 1:55:34the next book and that she'll manage to climb somewhat out of the hole,
- 1:55:39but still not have that much power, because that's typically how George Martin tends
- 1:55:43to do these things. But we'll see, because at the end of book
- 1:55:46five she is being kept down by Kevin. Now maybe she'll figure out some
- 1:55:51way of eliminating Kevin and returning to power. I don't know, but all
- 1:55:57that presumes that tom And is still king. You know, who knows what's
- 1:55:59going to happen books. I have a feeling that the books are not going
- 1:56:03to be as as again as I said before, as satisfying. I think
- 1:56:06there's just going to be a lot of meandering. Because George Martin, I
- 1:56:11think he has an interesting relationship with the readers. I think on one level
- 1:56:15he writes in a very entertaining way, but on another level, I think
- 1:56:18he is constantly attempting to subvert our expectations around what happens, because I think
- 1:56:26one of his big points that he's trying to make to all of us is
- 1:56:30that life is not fair and there is no happy ending. I think that
- 1:56:39is one of George Martin's primary social engineering goals. And so I don't know
- 1:56:46anyway, but the tee producers have a different sort of goal. They want
- 1:56:50to make money and to be praised, and so they're choosing a different tact.
- 1:56:56So on the TV show, I think now that we have Circe,
- 1:57:00Queen of the Southern Kingdoms, I think there will be a major battle between
- 1:57:05Denaries and Circe. I predict that Denaris will win this battle, and Denaries
- 1:57:13and enter Dragons will then proceed north to battle the Army of the Dead.
- 1:57:18It just seems like a likely battle that will happen between Denaries and the Army
- 1:57:25of the Dead and the White Walkers. It's the whole Song of Ice and
- 1:57:29Fire, right. You have the fire breathing dragons against the frozen undead.
- 1:57:33It seems like it'd be an unfair battle because when you have fire breathing dragons
- 1:57:39that fly, it seems like there's not much you can do against that.
- 1:57:43But maybe the White Walkers will have some sort of magic against the dragons.
- 1:57:47In fact ooh maybe one of the dragons will be killed then turned into a
- 1:57:51cold breathing dragon. Cold you know, you know, if you're a D
- 1:57:55and D person, that will appeal to you White Dragons. But anyway,
- 1:58:00I predict that Denari's army will defeat Circe. Danny will become Queen of the
- 1:58:06Southern Kingdoms to sit in the Iron throne, and I predict that Jamie will
- 1:58:13kill Circe. No idea, but that's what the witch said, right,
- 1:58:18But that I'm guessing will happen because it'd be pretty pretty poignant event in the
- 1:58:26storyline. And I'm guessing that Circe will actually ask Jamie to kill her,
- 1:58:32because Jamie would never kill her in cold blood, so you know, that'd
- 1:58:36be a badass way to die, right for Circe to say king Slayer,
- 1:58:42kill the Queen or something. I don't know. I'm not a writer,
- 1:58:44so don't listen to any of that stuff. But regardless, Circe, I
- 1:58:48believe in the TV show she has to die eventually. I just can't see
- 1:58:54any other option for the writers. I mean, she's so evil and Genaries
- 1:58:59would never ally with Circe in my opinions, and Danny has to in order.
- 1:59:06Again, the whole army of the Undead, they are the ultimate bad
- 1:59:11guy, right. Someone has to defeat them, someone has to battle them,
- 1:59:15and it doesn't seem like that's going to be Circe. It has to
- 1:59:18be Denaries and the Dragons and so in order for that to happen, it
- 1:59:24seems likely that Circe has to be unthrowned and killed. Maybe maybe Denaries will
- 1:59:31keep Circe alive. I don't know. Maybe Denaries will even just circumvent kings
- 1:59:35landing altogether and just go north to attack the army that I don't know.
- 1:59:40So there's just a lot of questions that I have. All Right, I
- 1:59:44need to take a break. But when we get back, we'll talk about
- 1:59:46Circe's personality. I'm gonna treater like she's a client and comment on how her
- 1:59:53personality developed. Okay, we're back. I have, in a very lengthy,
- 2:00:04deep divy sort of way, talked about all of Circe's story. Now
- 2:00:11let's analyze her personality. I've already commented quite a bit on her personality,
- 2:00:14but just to really concentrate on this for a second, let's talk about her
- 2:00:17early childhood. Things are mostly good for her. She had a good mother,
- 2:00:23Joanna was I think, a warm, good mother. She had a
- 2:00:27tight relationship with her twin brother was that had not been interfered with yet,
- 2:00:31and everything was going well for her. Tyrian wasn't born yet. Her mother
- 2:00:35was still alive, and although Taiwand was gone a lot and wasn't a very
- 2:00:41warm father, she had her mother, she had Jamie, and everything was
- 2:00:45good. Then around age three or four, she's caught experimenting with her brother
- 2:00:50and she's shamed and she doesn't know why. I mean, imagine you're three
- 2:00:54or four and you're just kind of fooling around with your brother, and then
- 2:01:00you're abruptly separated from your brother, and she's probably given the impression that she's
- 2:01:06done something very shameful, and she's probably given the impression that she doesn't deserve
- 2:01:12to have her brother because she's some sort of shameful pervert or something. Again,
- 2:01:17you're three or four years old. Your notions of life are not very
- 2:01:23complex or very wise, and so you tend to internalize a lot of these
- 2:01:29things, and it could feel like an abandonment from Jamie and some affront from
- 2:01:34her own mother. Then, around age four or no at age four,
- 2:01:40her mother dies suddenly while Tyrian is being born. Tyrian arrives, Dad is
- 2:01:45still gone. Jamie is her only attachment, but she's not allowed to have
- 2:01:47that much contact with him, and she has no caregiver. She has only
- 2:01:51servants so she went from total bliss to total unbliss, and she feels a
- 2:01:59banded by everyone. She's hurt, she's angry, she feels weak and vulnerable,
- 2:02:02and she doesn't talk about that, but I'm guessing she does, and
- 2:02:06she targets Tyrian with all of her anger. She makes Tyrian feel her pain.
- 2:02:11This is an externalization of an inner conflict in object relations terms. She's
- 2:02:16she feels weak and vulnerable, and she perceives other people as abandoning her or
- 2:02:24harming her or both, and so she internalizes this relationship of the weak,
- 2:02:29vulnerable self and the abandoning, harmful other, and this internal this external conflict
- 2:02:34is made internal, and she has battling forces inside of her as a young
- 2:02:40person, between telling herself that she's that she's weak, she's vulnerable, she's
- 2:02:45not worth it, she's worth abandoning, and then she has another side of
- 2:02:47her that just desperately wants someone to love her and to be there for her,
- 2:02:54and to be a warm presence and a non shaming presence. And so
- 2:03:00to cope with this internal conflict, she externalizes part of it by making Tyrian
- 2:03:09by projecting on a Tyrian the weak, vulnerable self and identifying with the abandoning,
- 2:03:13harmful other, and then proceeds because she hates the weak, vulnerable part
- 2:03:17of herself, because that's the part of herself that led to so much pain
- 2:03:21for her. And of course she's not weak, she's just human. But
- 2:03:26we would all love to get rid like Spock of our emotions, right,
- 2:03:29And so she has this fantasy that if she projects the weak, vulnerable part
- 2:03:33of herself on a Tyrian and attacks it, she can become stronger. And
- 2:03:38of course this never works, but it's a fantasy of the ego, and
- 2:03:42that's what she proceeds to do. And she proceeds to attack Tyrian, making
- 2:03:45him vulnerable, making him weak, pointing out his weaknesses, and abusing him.
- 2:03:51Also, she learns that she can control people with her power and her
- 2:03:56sadism and her aggression and her sexuality, and she uses all of these things
- 2:04:03in a false way of trying to stave off abandonment. She seduces Jamie a
- 2:04:10lot to keep him close. She seduces a lot of people to have power
- 2:04:16in a desperate attempt to have some security in her life. Then she gets
- 2:04:24married and she romanticizes marriage. It's all good in her mind. Marriage is
- 2:04:30the oasis where she can finally have a husband and children who love her,
- 2:04:35and she can finally have emotional stability, like a fairy tale, and she
- 2:04:41needs this fantasy as a young person. She needs this fantasy to cope with
- 2:04:46all the vulnerability in the abandonment she feels. But then she gets married and
- 2:04:51her husband, who's supposed to love her and cherish her, her husband cries
- 2:04:57out Leanna while they're having sex, and she realizes, wait, my husband
- 2:05:02doesn't love me. He loves someone else, and now I'm stuck in this
- 2:05:08marriage. And then she gets pregnant and she aborts it, and this is
- 2:05:14another trauma for her, and her husband is getting drunk and her husband is
- 2:05:17getting violent, and she's once again abandoned, and she turns back to Jamie,
- 2:05:21but she has shame around that, because that's wrong, and she has
- 2:05:26to hide around that, and she decides that no one else can be trusted,
- 2:05:30and she also learns that she has to fight for security, otherwise that'll
- 2:05:34be taken from her. She pushes Robert away, and Robert pushes her away,
- 2:05:39and her marriage becomes a sham. But all the while, she has
- 2:05:43to act like everything's fine, because she's the queen and it's important to uphold
- 2:05:46appearances, and so she returns to the sexuality she knows she can control,
- 2:05:53which is her mainly through her brother Jamie, and she feels comfortable in that
- 2:05:58place. It's like when you are abused as a child and you choose an
- 2:06:04abusive spouse partially because it's the love. It's the devil, you know,
- 2:06:12and it's the love you feel comfortable with when you were growing up. If
- 2:06:16you were abused as a child, you grew up associating love and warmth and
- 2:06:21affection with abuse. And that's the one thing that a lot I'm always sort
- 2:06:28of beating into a therapist's head and students' heads is that because a lot of
- 2:06:34times a trainee will come to me with a case and and they'll say,
- 2:06:42so, the father doesn't live with the kids anymore, and he was abusive
- 2:06:45and he's you know, he's a bad element in this family. And then
- 2:06:50the kids come into session and they have a lot of good things to say
- 2:06:55about the dad, and the therapist is thinking, why, you know,
- 2:06:57this is what the therapist is thinking and telling me, why is this kid
- 2:07:00talking saying good things about this dad? I mean, this dad is a
- 2:07:03monster. And what I always say is, although the dad is indeed a
- 2:07:10monster, it's still the child's father, and the child still desperately wants love
- 2:07:16and attention from this person, and that will never end. I have clients
- 2:07:21who are sixty plus years old and are still desperate for their abusive parents' attention.
- 2:07:28It's paradoxical, and that the more abuse that a parent will commit against
- 2:07:34a child, paradoxically, the longer the child will long for attention and love
- 2:07:42from that parent, which makes some sense which I won't go into. But
- 2:07:46anyway, so she Circe. When she was growing up, her one place
- 2:07:55of love and affection was through her brother, and so as an adult,
- 2:08:00when she is upset, she returned to that. She recreates this and Jamie
- 2:08:05too, that similar context of involving her brother, being secret about it,
- 2:08:11having shame involved in it, having it being just her and Jamie against the
- 2:08:16world. And so this is a very comfortable place for her to find love
- 2:08:20and security. But of course she's not. She's very ambivalent about it because
- 2:08:26she can't announce it to other people and it's it can't last, right,
- 2:08:33So she's between a rock and a hard place. She either gets the warm
- 2:08:37the warmth and love and affection and security and attachment, or and and has
- 2:08:43to hide it and has to be shameful about it, and and if outed,
- 2:08:46she could be completely stripped of all her power, or she could deny
- 2:08:50her self love and attachment and just drink all the time. So she she
- 2:08:54has no option, no good option in that situation. And deep down,
- 2:09:00I'm guessing that if I got Circe into therapy and she were to trust me,
- 2:09:03she would tell me that deep down she feels like a dirty, little
- 2:09:07worthless girl, the way she was made to feel by her family when her
- 2:09:15and Jamie were discovered, and that she instead of trying to reject that identity,
- 2:09:22she just identifies with it and says, fine, I'll be the dirty,
- 2:09:26worthless person that everyone hates, which is what people will do sometimes when
- 2:09:31you treat someone like a worthless person and like a terrible human being, then
- 2:09:35people say, screwt okay, fine, I'll be terrible. I'll be that
- 2:09:39person. If that's how you consider me. Fine, I'm going to be
- 2:09:43that person, which just furthers the tragedy. So she manages to have three
- 2:09:50children, and she loves these children and you know, these are good attachments
- 2:09:54for her. She doesn't think that they'll a that they'll ever leave her because
- 2:10:00they can't leave her, and she finally has legitimate security and attachment with these
- 2:10:07kids. She can't be open about her attachment to Jamie, but she can
- 2:10:11be open about her attachment to her children. And so you can see how
- 2:10:16a human being so desperate for love and affection in her life would be so
- 2:10:20attached to her kids and so protective of her kids. And you know that's
- 2:10:26my thoughts on that. But then John Aaron comes along and Edward Start comes
- 2:10:31along, and they threaten to take away this security, and so she takes
- 2:10:37care of them in a way, learning lessons from her father Taiwan, when
- 2:10:43when Taiwan would find a barrier, he would take care of it. I'm
- 2:10:48a little tentative in terms of that because I don't know if Taiwan conspired to
- 2:10:52kill people behind the scenes the way that Circe did. But anyway, so
- 2:10:58she takes care of them, and then Tyrian seemingly takes away her son by
- 2:11:03killing him, and takes away her daughter by sending her daughter to Dorin,
- 2:11:09and then Tyrian kills her own father. Then her daughter is killed partially because
- 2:11:15Terrian sent the daughter to Dorn, and Terrian becomes the total focus of her
- 2:11:20anger. Then Marjorie steals her last child from her Tommin, and so she
- 2:11:28conspires to get rid of her, first by locking her up in the church
- 2:11:31and then by murdering her along with everyone else in the Great Sept. So
- 2:11:37when you really understand her story and how each thing progressed, and if you
- 2:11:45sprinkle in a genetic disposition for psychopathy and lack of empathy and impulsivity and a
- 2:11:50lack of fear, then you get what you get. It's a progression.
- 2:11:54She didn't She didn't just start by blowing up the sept and killing hundreds of
- 2:11:58people. It was a progression and a story that, in my theory,
- 2:12:05is a story based on her attempt to gain attachment and warmth and affection and
- 2:12:13also a way of coping with grief. I believe, deep down she's a
- 2:12:20human being similar to other people, again with a pretty big slice of psychopathy
- 2:12:26in there, which is not very typical. But there is something human in
- 2:12:31there, I think. And she isn't like Ramsey Bolton. She she's more
- 2:12:37like us, I would say. In the scheme of things. She's not
- 2:12:43as bad as Jeoffrey, but she is definitely. So you got ed Art
- 2:12:50on one end of the spectrum and on the other end of the spectrum you
- 2:12:54have Sir c Jeoffrey and then Ramsey. Anyway, so let's look at cluster
- 2:13:00be personality traits. We have narcissism. Is she narcissistic? Well, not
- 2:13:05in the clinical sense. She's not constantly trying to make herself look good in
- 2:13:07other people's eyes, although you could say that her constant efforts to gain power
- 2:13:13as a sign of narcissism. She was very ambitious, which is which is
- 2:13:18a red flag for narcissic personality. It was particularly noticeable when Toman was king.
- 2:13:24You know, she she could have just kicked when Tom. This is
- 2:13:28a very interesting part of the story, right when when Toman became king and
- 2:13:31Marjorie was gaining power as queen, Sirce could have just kicked back and said,
- 2:13:37look, all all my enemies are dead. The realm is stable.
- 2:13:43I can let the small council run things, and maybe I'll even be on
- 2:13:48the small council, who knows, but maybe not. I'll just kick back,
- 2:13:52enjoy my time, have sex with Lancel and just let Marjorie have power.
- 2:13:58No big deal. Marjorie seems like a nice enough person. She's not
- 2:14:03going to destroy me. She'll probably just be fine. But she couldn't have
- 2:14:07that, And this is one of the major turning points in the story.
- 2:14:11Circe has a lot to do with how all this story plays out. I
- 2:14:16mean, just think about it. If she had just been like one of
- 2:14:18the other queen mothers, Queen regents or whatever they call him, everything would
- 2:14:22have been fine. But no, she had to grab for power, and
- 2:14:24so she conspired against Marjorie by getting the High Sparrow into power, and then
- 2:14:31Circe gets wrapped up in that, and then Circe has to take revenge,
- 2:14:33and then Circe has to kill everybody. So it's just interesting how that all
- 2:14:37played out. But is that narcissistic. I would say that her thirst for
- 2:14:43power was for self preservation and for an attempt for emotional security, not necessarily
- 2:14:52for narcissism. Remember that narcissistic personality is based on the notion that when you
- 2:14:58are truly narcissistic as a young person, when you're one, two, three,
- 2:15:03four years old and you're super narcissistic, you think the world revolves around
- 2:15:07you, because you should, because that's developmentally appropriate. When you're that age,
- 2:15:13you're denied something, and what she was denied was Jamie was ripped away
- 2:15:16from her, and then her mother was ripped away from her. And so
- 2:15:20because she had those incursions on her olympic system and in her brain development and
- 2:15:26in her attachment, she was arrested in that phase of life in which she
- 2:15:31would become narcissistic. Now, if she were truly narcissistic in the sense of
- 2:15:37the personality sore, she would have been more boastful, she would have been
- 2:15:43more show offie, she would have been more envious of other people. And
- 2:15:48whenever I say this to people, people will say, like, well,
- 2:15:50surely she was very boastful and very envious of other people, And yeah,
- 2:15:56you can make an argument for that. But when you have a personality disorder,
- 2:16:01it's very apparent. You're not typically very If you have narcisists personality disorder,
- 2:16:07you don't hide it because it's it's compelled to come out of you,
- 2:16:11partially because you think you're completely justified in doing it, and also partially because
- 2:16:18there's so much energy behind the personality disorder. That you just it becomes clear
- 2:16:22very quickly. And the way that it becomes very clear very quickly is people
- 2:16:28will either talk so much that you can't get a word in edgewise, so
- 2:16:35upon you everyone knows someone like this right when you talk to them, they
- 2:16:41refuse to let you talk, and even if you do get a word in,
- 2:16:46they don't really listen, or they talk over you, and they just
- 2:16:50proceed to talk even more. This is this is narcissism. This is a
- 2:16:56result when when someone's three or four, you want to tell your parents a
- 2:17:03story and you don't care if it lands well with your parents. Little Johnny
- 2:17:09comes back from peace school and says, Mommy, Mommy, I want to
- 2:17:11tell you what happened. And then Mommy's like, oh what happened? And
- 2:17:13Johnny says, okay, I was on the playground and Emily did this thing.
- 2:17:20This is verbatim, did this thing, and then I did this other
- 2:17:22thing, and then that was a thing, and then the teacher the thing,
- 2:17:28and I if you've ever heard a three or four year old tell story,
- 2:17:33you know what I'm talking about. Unless they're extremely verbal and super bright,
- 2:17:37the story doesn't make a lot of sense. You know, you're just
- 2:17:41thinking, huh, what's going on. But if you know what you're doing
- 2:17:45as a caregiver or as an uncle or aunt or someone, you just listen.
- 2:17:48You go, oh my gosh, that sounds so interesting. No,
- 2:17:50no, and you just move on in life. But if you're if you're
- 2:17:54a bad caregiver, then then you either say I'm not going to listen to
- 2:17:56you or whatever, or if you're abused or you die, then you're taken
- 2:18:01away from that child. And then that child is stuck in that zone.
- 2:18:03And so that's one trade of narcissism is you just you. You're stuck in
- 2:18:09that place where you just want someone to listen to you. And that's that's
- 2:18:13what three and four year olds are doing, is they just want you to
- 2:18:16listen because they need that attention. They're not they're not trying to give you
- 2:18:22a entertaining story. That's not the point of that exercise. What they want
- 2:18:28is for you to pay attention to them because that's what they need. That's
- 2:18:31what they crave. They crave that like water and like food. They need
- 2:18:37you to pay attention because that's what developmentally they need, and that's what we
- 2:18:41need throughout our entire life, and particularly when we're that age, and if
- 2:18:43we're not given it at that age, then we develop personality and they proceed
- 2:18:48to bore everyone with our stories. And we also don't have a lot of
- 2:18:52empathy for that person, and we also don't even care if the story is
- 2:18:54entertaining, because that's not the point. The point of talking is to get
- 2:18:58attention, because we were denied that as a young person. And the other
- 2:19:05thing that people will do is at that age of life, three or four
- 2:19:09years old, is people tend to not have a lot of empathy and tend
- 2:19:13to want things for themselves. And you will see well adjusted four year olds
- 2:19:20go ballistic when their brother or sister gets something and they believe that they deserve
- 2:19:26it. And if you're hurt during this time emotionally, like your mother dying
- 2:19:31and your brother being ripped away from you, then you're stuck in that zone.
- 2:19:37And as an adult, you're going to feel completely entitled to other people's
- 2:19:41things. And you could make the argument that Circe possessed those qualities, but
- 2:19:48in terms of the way narcissistic personalities store typically looks, Sirce doesn't exhibit that.
- 2:19:52If Sirce did have that she would have been much more ineffectual actually as
- 2:19:58a political figure, because people would be laughing at her more. She would
- 2:20:03just talk over people all the time. She would be seen as petty because
- 2:20:09she would worry about some other woman's dress looking better than hers or something.
- 2:20:16And so she was much more in control of her faculties, I think.
- 2:20:22And so that's why I would say that she doesn't exhibit to me the profiles
- 2:20:28someone with narcissistic personality, although she definitely has some narcissistic traits. Okay,
- 2:20:33so let's move on psychopathy or any social personality sort of. Is she psychopathic?
- 2:20:39Yes? Absolutely, She has no problem breaking the rules and she has
- 2:20:46no problem killing people. She has no conscience at all, seemingly, I
- 2:20:50mean no conscience she has. She potentially killed her fifteen year old friend because
- 2:20:56she didn't want that prophecy to be told. She seemingly has no fear even
- 2:21:01as a child, which is a sign of psychopathy. Again, due to
- 2:21:05her abandonment and her having Jamie ripped away from her and her mother ripped away
- 2:21:11from her when she was young, she was not given enough empathy and enough
- 2:21:18stability as a young child to develop a well rounded personality and psychopathy emerged as
- 2:21:24a result, possibly also because she inherited some disposition for psychopathy from her lineage,
- 2:21:33because you could make the argument that Tyrian and Jamie also have slight psychopathic
- 2:21:39traits as well, But I won't go into that. Is she sadistic?
- 2:21:45I would say no, Jeffrey is a better example of someone who's sadistic.
- 2:21:50He took pleasure in harming other people. Does Circe take pleasure? Does she
- 2:21:56get off on making other people suffer? You know, maybe in some ways,
- 2:22:01but she didn't. She seemed to exhibit that under extreme circumstances, like
- 2:22:09she has the Mountain torture that won none at the end of the season six.
- 2:22:16She certainly probably takes some pleasure in that, But that seems more normal
- 2:22:20revenge than Jeoffrey's way. Jeoffrey would torture people that hadn't wronged him at all.
- 2:22:26He Jeoffrey would torture and do terrible things to people just for no reason,
- 2:22:31just because he really got off on making other people suffer. So I
- 2:22:35wouldn't call Circe sadistic, but I would absolutely call her psychopathic, and that
- 2:22:39she doesn't have empathy and doesn't have a conscience and doesn't have a lot of
- 2:22:43fear. Is Circe borderline Not really, She wasn't overly emotional and overly reactive
- 2:22:52when she was betrayed. She certainly didn't like being betrayed. She has trust
- 2:22:56issues. But people with border line, when betrayed, will often become highly
- 2:23:03dysregulated, and they'll become they'll decompensate, they will become they'll become out of
- 2:23:09control even for themselves. Borderline people with borderline personality when they are betrayed by
- 2:23:16other people, unhurt and abandoned, they come on glued because of the irrelational
- 2:23:20traumas they went through because they were abandoned. And she she would have been
- 2:23:24a good candidate for borderline given her history. She developed psychopathy instead, but
- 2:23:28she was a good candidate given that she was abandoned at that critical age.
- 2:23:33And if she were borderline when people in her story betrayed her, she would
- 2:23:41have in the storyline, she would have she would have decompensated rapidly and become
- 2:23:48somewhat unable to function, because that's what happens with people with borderline. It
- 2:23:54wents when that trauma is triggered, and that abandonment is sort of poked at.
- 2:24:01They are extreme, you know, they become extremely hurt naturally and it's
- 2:24:05hard for them to function. And Circey never really had trouble functioning. You
- 2:24:11know, is she histrionic? I would say no, I won't go into
- 2:24:15the details, but she didn't exhibit a craving for attention the way that full
- 2:24:18blown historyonic people do, so, so I would characterize her as psychopathic,
- 2:24:24lack of empathy any social person and leave it at that. Another question worth
- 2:24:31asking is how smart how intelligent is she? At first, when I thought
- 2:24:37about this question, I said, well, of course, she's a brilliant
- 2:24:39person. I mean, look at she's queen. Now, she's brilliant.
- 2:24:43She's so adept at being able to scheme, and she reads people so well,
- 2:24:48and she does all these things. But from another angle, you could
- 2:24:52look at it as she's not that smart because she makes so many mistakes.
- 2:24:58She has babies with Jamie, her brother she has she's queen of the Southern
- 2:25:03Kingdoms, and instead of just swallowing her pride and having some children with Robert,
- 2:25:11or at least one child with Robert, she has all of her kids
- 2:25:16with Jamie, almost on purpose. This is a huge mistake. And if
- 2:25:22if if I were there with her as she was making this decision prior to
- 2:25:28Jeoffrey being conceived, I would have said to her, look, sir Ce,
- 2:25:31what do you think is going to happen from this? If if Robert
- 2:25:35finds out, what do you think is gonna happen? This is not gonna
- 2:25:37be good for you. You find be with Jamie, have sex with him,
- 2:25:41but have babies with Robert. If there's some way to control that,
- 2:25:46then you know, let's let's let's go with that, and then you can
- 2:25:50have everything you want. So so that was a big mistake and not smart.
- 2:25:56She also had sex with Jamie at went. Now they are in a
- 2:26:01tower that they thought they wouldn't be discovered, but couldn't they keep their hands
- 2:26:03off each other for just a little bit of time? And then brand you
- 2:26:07know, saw them, and so then they had to do something about it.
- 2:26:11And in the book they're not very quiet about having sex, So someone
- 2:26:16walking by the tower maybe could have heard them or see them coming out of
- 2:26:20the tower. I don't know anyway, Plus Robert is nearby. What if
- 2:26:22Robert anyway, then Circe accuses that art of treason and fails to keep him
- 2:26:30alive, So another another You could say she was not super dumb in that
- 2:26:35instance because she didn't predict that Jeoffrey would lop off Atard's head head. But
- 2:26:41but again, she was part of that stupid thing that led to the beginning
- 2:26:46of the War of the Five Kings. Circe makes Tyrian her enemy when Tyrian
- 2:26:52was handed the king, when she could have just been nicey nice and made
- 2:26:56him a powerful ally. Again not smart. She proceeds later in the story
- 2:27:01to alienate Jamie, which is the one adult that seems to actually love her.
- 2:27:07She also manages to get the High Sparrow into power and the Faith militant,
- 2:27:11and fails to realize that the High Sparrow is not loyal to her.
- 2:27:16If anything, the High Sparrow would be her mortal enemy and she met and
- 2:27:20she gets the High Sparrow into power just because she, in a short sighted
- 2:27:22move, wants to get rid of Marjorie, but doesn't realize that this is
- 2:27:26going to lead to getting rid of her. She doesn't prepare tom In for
- 2:27:31what happened, so when she actually blows up the Great sept, she tells
- 2:27:37a guard to keep tom And from going to the trial and then proceeds to
- 2:27:43take revenge on the nun and some other people, rather than going straight to
- 2:27:46tom And and saying, Tom, I just blew up the Great sept I'm
- 2:27:52so sorry, and I'm going to make sure you don't kill yourself by having
- 2:27:56these few guards watch you. In a year and a couple of years,
- 2:28:01you'll get over this and that, believe me, this is this is good
- 2:28:05for the realm or whatever she says. She doesn't do that, and she
- 2:28:09stupidly allows the last person on earth that she loves to kill himself because of
- 2:28:15her, which is just a huge blow to you know, that's just not
- 2:28:18smart unless she wanted tom And to die, but I doubt that. I
- 2:28:20really doubt she wanted tom And to die. And then at the end of
- 2:28:26the TV series, she's queen. Okay, she's she's won, She's she
- 2:28:28got what she wanted. She's she's queen. But now what she's all alone.
- 2:28:31She doesn't have any allies. Everyone hates her, no one's gonna trust
- 2:28:35her. This isn't smart. She knows enough about how this game of Thrones
- 2:28:41works that when you're like the mad King and you rule like the mad King,
- 2:28:46eventually someone is going to rebel against you and kill you. Because the
- 2:28:52support of the people is a big deal. She just blew up essentially.
- 2:28:56Imagine if Trump blew up where the pope lives? Where does the pope whatever
- 2:29:03big church is there, the Vatican. Let's say that the Pope blows up
- 2:29:07the Vatican. How long do you think Americans would let Trump stay in power
- 2:29:15if he blew up the Vatican? Not long? Right, And the people
- 2:29:18are a powerful force in the world of Game of Thrones. When when the
- 2:29:22people turn against you, you can they can riot against you. Guards could
- 2:29:30be overwhelmed by the crowds. Guards could guards could go with the people and
- 2:29:33turn against you. And so it's it's just it. There is some evidence
- 2:29:37that Circe just is not a smart person. And also all the problems that
- 2:29:45plagued her before, like the bad debt. When you know, when tom
- 2:29:50In was alive and she was queen regent, she was having all these problems
- 2:29:54trying to hold the kingdom together and make it solvent. Well, all those
- 2:29:58problems are still around now that she's queen. They those problems didn't go away.
- 2:30:01The Iron Bank or whatever, the bank, you know, the main
- 2:30:05Federal Reserve Bank. Essentially, they still hate you, and that's a big
- 2:30:11deal. And so so now she rules over a seven kingdoms that everyone hates
- 2:30:20her in at least half of everyone is just waiting to kill her. And
- 2:30:24your financial situation is terrible. And I don't know, it's just it.
- 2:30:30Maybe she's not as smart as we think she is, or she's too smart
- 2:30:33for her own good. I don't know, or she's smart, but her
- 2:30:37intelligence gets clouded by her emotions. I don't know, all right. The
- 2:30:43last thing I'll say about the story here is you could make a case that
- 2:30:50her story is completely characterized by sexism. She's just as capable as her brother
- 2:30:58from an early age, if not more capable. However, the best she
- 2:31:03could achieve in this society was to be a political bride or the mother of
- 2:31:09errors, right, the mother of children who will have heir to the throne.
- 2:31:13And although women are allowed to rise in power in this world, in
- 2:31:18this society, the landisters, as they said earlier, particularly conservative Taiwan was
- 2:31:22particularly conservative and didn't want women to rise in that way. And that's that's
- 2:31:26got to be a bummer. Imagine you have aspirations and have you want to
- 2:31:31be worth something, and all you're going to be is be married off to
- 2:31:37to create some alliance, and you're gonna have to move to that household and
- 2:31:41be a second rate citizen over there. And you could say that this whole
- 2:31:46story is a result of her trying to gain the power that she feels that
- 2:31:50she deserves as a woman. And if the society, particularly her father,
- 2:31:56had let her have as much power as men, maybe this whole thing could
- 2:32:00been avoided. I don't know, it's an interesting thought. If we just
- 2:32:03roll back the sands of history and when Jamie becomes kingsguard and Taiwan is going,
- 2:32:15huh, you know, my daughter is she's smart, so I could
- 2:32:18probably groom her to be head of the household. Imagine that story. She
- 2:32:24becomes head of a household, she goes back to this is after Robert dies,
- 2:32:31she goes back to Cashley Rock. She's happy ruling things over there.
- 2:32:35She has self esteem, she has her security. Maybe she manages to marry
- 2:32:39someone of her liking, and Da da da, and that could have been
- 2:32:45a different story. And due to sexism, it pushed her into a corner
- 2:32:50that she had to fight her way out of. And so it's just interesting.
- 2:32:52All right again, if you haven't become a patron, if you don't
- 2:32:56remember me saying this ten million times before, please become a patron in the
- 2:33:01podcast by going to Patreon dot com. You might have to go to your
- 2:33:03computer Patreon dot com. Become a patron. When when I get more patrons,
- 2:33:09it justifies me doing these deep dives. I don't know how long we're
- 2:33:13into this episode right now. This is an hour three and I spent I
- 2:33:18don't know, thirty hours preparing for this episode. It takes a long time.
- 2:33:22I have to take a lot of notes, I have to do a
- 2:33:24lot of research, and when people become patrons, it really justifies me taking
- 2:33:31time away from work so that I could do this for you guys. And
- 2:33:35it's fun, right, It's fun, fun time, fun times. So
- 2:33:39become a patron and we can have fun times together. That sounds funny,
- 2:33:43but anyway, So trivia Lena Hetty, I think I think that's how you
- 2:33:46pronounce it. Lena Hetty her personal life. She's born seventy three. She's
- 2:33:52forty three years old, which is similar to my age. She's born in
- 2:33:56Bermuda. Her father was a police officer and stationed in Bermuda at the time
- 2:34:01she moved her Her family moved back to England when she was five, and
- 2:34:05so she moved to England when she was five. Here's a little interesting tidbit.
- 2:34:09She dated Bron, the guy who plays Bron in the in Game of
- 2:34:13Thrones. She dated Bron for a bit, which I just can't see those
- 2:34:18two together. But anyway, she dated Bron for a bit. But it
- 2:34:22was rumored and I don't know if it's true or not, but it was
- 2:34:24rumored that the relationship between the guy who plays Braun and Lena, the relationship
- 2:34:31ended badly, which resulted in the two being kept apart on the set.
- 2:34:37So that's interesting. Again, I just can't imagine those two together. But
- 2:34:41anyway, Lena dated Jason Fleming for nine years if in late nineties early two
- 2:34:50thousands. Jason Fleming, if you remember The Black Mirror season two, he
- 2:34:56played the producer of Waldo. He's that guy. He was in Lockstock and
- 2:35:03Two Smoking Barrels in ninety eight and Snatch in the year two thousand. He's
- 2:35:07been in a lot of movies. But anyway, she dated him for a
- 2:35:11long time. She married an Irish musician in two thousand and seven, so
- 2:35:18it's before Game of Thrones. He's not a huge musician as far as I
- 2:35:22can tell. He's not even on Wikipedia. There's some videos of him singing.
- 2:35:28But anyway, they had a son in twenty ten during the filming of
- 2:35:33season one, so while they were filming season season one, she was fairly
- 2:35:41pregnant and they had to use clever camera shots and costumes and body doubles to
- 2:35:46hide her baby bump, So that's interesting trivia for you. After the birth,
- 2:35:52she suffered from postpart and depression, which can be very terrible for people.
- 2:35:58She divorced or they divorced. Peter and Lena divorced in twenty thirteen.
- 2:36:03In twenty fifteen, she gave birth to a second child, but she apparently
- 2:36:09hates the tabloids, so she isn't open about who the father is or even
- 2:36:15if she's with them, which is of course her right to be private about
- 2:36:18that. But she did announce that she had a second child. So she
- 2:36:22has two kids, two fairly young kids. She's very good friends with Peter
- 2:36:26Dankledge, which I have to say makes me very happy. So her and
- 2:36:30Tyrian are very close, and I've seen featurettes with the two of them pranking
- 2:36:37each other on set and stuff. I think it's rumored that Peter d Clidge
- 2:36:43was cast as Tyrian and then suggested Lena be cast as as Circe. I
- 2:36:52think from what I the little I read about about Lena is that I think
- 2:36:56she has a somewhat hostile relationship with the press, because they've been hounding her
- 2:37:01ever since Game of Thrones began. I don't know much about this because I
- 2:37:05don't participate in tabloid media, but I'm guessing she's one of the primary targets
- 2:37:09of the tabloid media, particularly in the UK, because she's, you know,
- 2:37:16she's glamorous, and she has an edge to her, and she plays
- 2:37:20Circe, which is such an interesting character, and she's a woman. I
- 2:37:22think women are often treated worse by the tabloid press. Sometimes I wish that
- 2:37:28there would be more public shaming of particular immoral tabloid people, because there's there's
- 2:37:35so much immoral there's so much immorality in the tabloid media, and ninety five
- 2:37:41percent of people would say that's not right. You can't do that now.
- 2:37:43Of course, you don't want to make a law against it, because it's
- 2:37:46freedom of the press, but a lot of what we do in our society
- 2:37:52is dictated not by law but by social norms. Well, when you're a
- 2:37:56tabloid press person, you're a faceless person and you're on the other side of
- 2:38:01the camera, and so you do bad things and then you get paid for
- 2:38:05it and me and you might even look at the tabloid and go like,
- 2:38:09wow, whoever did that? That's not good. But I'm glad, I
- 2:38:13know, because I love this sort of information. But imagine if these tabloid
- 2:38:18people were somehow outed and it was made known what they were doing. I
- 2:38:22think it would happen less. You know, like in the Amanda Knox documentary
- 2:38:28on the Netflix amn in Ox documentary, that one guy who was outed for
- 2:38:35being very I don't other word terrible as a tabloid press person. You know,
- 2:38:43maybe that maybe some of that would curb that sort of behavior. I
- 2:38:46don't know, because it just seems terrible, the sort of and a lot
- 2:38:50of it is sexist too. A lot of it is targeted against women and
- 2:38:54has to do with how they look and ooh she's aging, Ooh she's fat,
- 2:38:58and ooh she got dumped again, and ooh. You know, when's
- 2:39:03someone going to give her a baby? And da da da. It's just
- 2:39:05a lot of really awful things that I imagine is not good to the person
- 2:39:13that it's all being said about, especially when it's lies. There's a lot
- 2:39:16of tabloid information that's just flat out lies, like with the amount of ox
- 2:39:20situation. Watch that documentary that'll open your eyes to some terrible tabloid stuff.
- 2:39:26But anyway, all right, so Lena Hetty, I believe that's how you
- 2:39:30pronounce her name. Heati Lena Heady. I don't even know if it's Lena
- 2:39:33or Lenny. Anyway, I'm just gonna say Lena Hetty. Filmography, she's
- 2:39:39been in many, many movies. It seems like she's in at least one
- 2:39:41movie or TV show each year starting in the early nineties, none of which
- 2:39:46I've seen, but I've seen Brothers Grim in two thousand and five. She
- 2:39:50was in Brothers Grim in two thousand and six, which is the role I
- 2:39:54really remember seeing her first, and she was in three hundred. She was
- 2:39:58Queen of Spata. She was in I don't know why I talked to that
- 2:40:01voice just then. But then the one role I love her in is in
- 2:40:07Dread from twenty twelve. She plays Mama Madeline Madrigal and Dread is not for
- 2:40:15everybody, but I think it's a great movie. It's a fun, interesting
- 2:40:20story and I liked it and Mama Lena Hetty plays the bad person. She
- 2:40:28was also in the sequel to three hundred and obviously, she was in Game
- 2:40:31of Throws, and she was a voice actress in the Game of Thrones video
- 2:40:35game. The Telltale game released in twenty fourteen. If you like video games,
- 2:40:41you will love the game. Well, I'll just say I loved the
- 2:40:46Telltale Game of Throws. I've played other Telltale games, like The Walking Dead
- 2:40:52Telltale game and didn't like it as much. It was just a little It
- 2:40:56was interesting for a little bit, but a got a little boring. But
- 2:40:58the Game of Thrones Telltale games is just so interesting. If you're a Game
- 2:41:03of Thrones fan, play the telle even if you don't like video games,
- 2:41:07because it doesn't play like a video game. It plays more like a choose
- 2:41:11your own adventure book and it has some video game aspects to it, but
- 2:41:16for the most part it is just another episode of Game of Thrones, the
- 2:41:22TV show, but you get to participate in some of the decisions, and
- 2:41:28they have all the characters do their characters. Lena Hetty does Circe, voices
- 2:41:33the Circi character, and Peter Dinklag is in it and others. It's pretty
- 2:41:37interesting. She is reportedly, according to Wikipedia, an activist for animal rights
- 2:41:43and LGBT rights, which is great. In twenty seventeen, she became one
- 2:41:48of the highest paid actors on television, earning one point one million per episode
- 2:41:54one point one million prevosols. So that means that this next season, due
- 2:41:58to a dissipation in seven episodes, she'll get seven or eight million dollars,
- 2:42:03which is money well spent because I'm sure it's making a shit ton more than
- 2:42:09that, and so pay your actors well. Awards, she's never won an
- 2:42:15Emmy or a Golden Globe, which is very upsetting to me. She's been
- 2:42:18dominated, She's been dominated. She's been nominated for one Golden Globe last year
- 2:42:26and the three most recent Emmys she was nominated as well, but she's never
- 2:42:33won. Just as an example, last year for the Emmy for Best Supporting
- 2:42:39Actress and Drama Series, I believe she was up against Constant Zimmer from Unreal,
- 2:42:45which I've never seen. She's up against Mora Tyranny from The Affair,
- 2:42:48which I heard as good which I've ever seen. And she was up against
- 2:42:52two other Game of Thrones people, the woman who plays Scenarios and the and
- 2:42:54the girl plays Aria. And she also is against Maggie Smith Downton Abby,
- 2:43:01who won the Emmy, which makes sense. I mean, Maggie Smith,
- 2:43:03She's great, But I don't know. It seems like Lena Hetty should should
- 2:43:07win for her walk of atonement. Remember that when she did her shame thing,
- 2:43:15shame Walk, she made the producers use a body double. Her head
- 2:43:20was digitally added onto the body of the body double, which I don't blame
- 2:43:24her. There's a lot of nudity in that scene. I'd probably do the
- 2:43:28same if I if I thought it wouldn't interfere with the TV show, Because
- 2:43:33when I watched the TV show and they you know, there's a lot of
- 2:43:37just like stark nakedness in that scene. It's not you know, just glancing
- 2:43:43camera work, and I could not tell. Maybe if I rewatched it,
- 2:43:48I could say, oh, I can see the digital but it looked I
- 2:43:50thought. In fact, I until I read this yesterday, I was like,
- 2:43:56totally convinced that she had done that. It's pretty real. But anyway,
- 2:44:01they used the body double and you know, unknown as to why other
- 2:44:07than she just didn't want to do it. She also has a lot of
- 2:44:11tattoos. She has a ton of tattoos apparently, and so that would have
- 2:44:15been kind of tough to get rid of. In fact, she has a
- 2:44:18tattoo of her when she was with her boyfriend what's his face, Jason Fleming
- 2:44:26if I remember right, she had his name in some other language tattooed on
- 2:44:30her body and then later had to have it covered when they broke up.
- 2:44:33I always just wonder about that. It's like, I suppose, if you're
- 2:44:37just one hundred percent convinced you'll be with the person forever, go ahead and
- 2:44:39put their name on your body. But you know, it's taking a big
- 2:44:45risk. In my mind, and this is just me as an old person,
- 2:44:50but putting someone's name on your body is a hundred times more of a
- 2:44:54commitment than marrying them. That sounds terrible to say out loud, but in
- 2:45:01my head that's how it feels. Is that okay? Anyway? That is
- 2:45:07Circe Lanister an analysis of her personality. Her primary traumas brother being ripped away
- 2:45:15from her, and her mother dying. Sprinkle in some genetic disposition for psychopathy,
- 2:45:22lack of empathy, lack of fear, and give her a life of
- 2:45:28strife and difficulty and struggle. Give her a husband that loves someone else.
- 2:45:37Give her twin brother who is always there for her, in like a warm
- 2:45:41security blanket for her. Give her the history of Game of Thrones and how
- 2:45:48things played out, And this is what you get. And the more I
- 2:45:52think about her story, the more I see her as a human being,
- 2:45:56And the more I see the more I understand her the story and the story
- 2:46:00as it unfolded around her, the more I realized that it didn't have to
- 2:46:03be this way. If Robert was a better husband, I'm guessing that things
- 2:46:09would have turned out better. She could have grown to love Robert, and
- 2:46:13she could have slowly moved away from Jamie. She could have replaced Jamie's love
- 2:46:18and affection with Robert's. I think there was time when she was open to
- 2:46:24that, and then she could have had kids with Robert, and then this
- 2:46:28whole thing could have never ever happened. Robert could have had heirs, and
- 2:46:33maybe Robert wouldn't have cheated on her as much or at all because they had
- 2:46:39a relationship. It's just so clear to me the importance of warmth and affection
- 2:46:45and security in our lives. And for Circe, she didn't have that,
- 2:46:50and I wish that she did. But if she did, then the story
- 2:46:54would be a lot more boring, a lot more boring. No, it's
- 2:46:58not boring at all. It would have been very boring. The story would
- 2:47:01have been very boring if Circe had been given a good life. So in
- 2:47:05some ways, for my entertainment sake, I'm glad that she was treated terribly.
- 2:47:13But she's a fictional character, so it's different. It's I'm not wishing
- 2:47:18bad things for somebody. You stop judging me, all right, Well,
- 2:47:20that does it for that episode of Psychology in Seattle. Again, if you
- 2:47:24like this sort of thing, please become a patron of the podcast by going
- 2:47:28to patreon dot com, because when you do that, it tells me that
- 2:47:33you are seriously into this sort of stuff. And I will do more deep
- 2:47:37dives if I had it my way, and if we get more patrons,
- 2:47:39I will do a deep dive on every episode, on every single episode,
- 2:47:43and every single character on Game of Thrones, and I'll even hunt down the
- 2:47:48actors and try to get them to come on the podcast. So if that
- 2:47:52doesn't trick a few people and to become patrins I don't know what will.
- 2:47:54All right, Well, that does it for that episode of Psychology and Seattle,
- 2:47:58thanks for joining me. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it.