Latest / The Vegan Report / Revolutionizing Vegan Cheese. With Betty Zoller | Ep. 22
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report. If you are an
- 0:05ethical vegan and you care to do more to end animal abuse, then this podcast is for you.
- 0:12Every Tuesday, discover passionate, thought-provoking and inspiring vegan leaders from all walks of life
- 0:20who will inspire you to take action. I could be vegan if it was not for the cheese.
- 0:27I heard this phrase so many times, I stopped counting. I'm at a point where I think cheese
- 0:33is an addiction and a major obstacle to the vegan cause and I'm no better than the next person.
- 0:40I have to confess that, as a vegan, I have been in a never-ending quest for the best plant-based cheese
- 0:47out there. As you might know from listening to episode 11 of the show, I visited the vegan
- 0:53festival of Montreal and I was definitely hoping to discover a startup that makes excellent vegan
- 1:01cheese. And against all expectations, I did. This company is called Aviva and this is what you can
- 1:09read on their website. Aviva is the first plant-based cheese alternative made from chickpeas,
- 1:16beans and seeds and centered around nutrition. Our three products are made in Montreal,
- 1:24a source of protein, calcium, iron and fiber, suitable for people with not allergies,
- 1:31not a source of saturated fat as other alternatives in the market. I thought I need to get the founder
- 1:38of this company on the show and maybe inspire some of you listeners to launch your own vegan business.
- 1:45So, Betty Zoller, welcome to the show. Thank you, Ryan. So excited. Love to hear
- 1:51your introduction. Thank you so much. Amazing. I'm curious, Betty, when did you first identify
- 1:58the need for better plant-based cheese? Well, when I started trying to become vegan,
- 2:07and definitely we'll talk a bit more about that, but definitely cheese is a pain point. I need to
- 2:15say it was for me and it is for a lot of people. So at first, a vegan friend, I wasn't vegan at
- 2:24the moment, I was just a vegetarian and we'll talk about that after, but this friend introduced me to
- 2:32vegan cheese making and we were making cashew-based cheese. And I loved it. I'm like, wow. But it's
- 2:42definitely hard to make your own. It is very time consuming. After the cashew alternatives,
- 2:50I started looking at something maybe a bit more nutritious. I had children and I was feeling like,
- 2:57well, there was a lot of allergy suspected, allergies situations with my children. So the nuts
- 3:08and cheeses were a bit out of the question. Also, I wanted something that I could have for an everyday
- 3:15product, a bit less expensive as well. So I saw that the other cheeses that were not nut-based,
- 3:24where they were a bit more affordable, they didn't have any protein or basically no nutrition at all.
- 3:33And they're perfect. There's definitely a time and place for each of the vegan cheeses that are in
- 3:39the market. But that was not the type of cheese that I was looking for to have, for example, cubed
- 3:45with just some crackers, with some grapes as a snack. It was more just to maybe use in recipes
- 3:52for melting or something like that, as an ingredient for something else. So that's when I said,
- 3:58well, let's explore and see because I used to eat cheese not only as a vegetarian, not only
- 4:06for the pleasure of it, but also to get some protein, to get some nutrients. So that was the
- 4:12part that was missing in the offer that was in that moment in the market.
- 4:17Yeah. And as you mentioned, most of the cheese out there, the big brands like Dahlia,
- 4:25they're not really good. First of all, it's not really good. I have to say, I have to confess that
- 4:31I never find it very good. And also you don't eat it raw. You always use it in a recipe. So you try
- 4:42to, I guess, minimize its presence in the meal. It's a weird, it's not the way I learned how to
- 4:51eat it. So yeah, you're completely right about that. And I'm so glad to hear you talk about
- 4:58proteins, because this is something that not many vegans in the food space talk about.
- 5:07Even when I look at vegan influencers and the meals they take, pictures of the meals they make,
- 5:15I always wonder where are the proteins in that meal? It's like we have forgotten about proteins,
- 5:21but it's essential. We need it. As someone who works out, I always think about my,
- 5:29the portion of protein I need every day. So I'm so glad to hear you talk about this.
- 5:37Yes, absolutely. It definitely needs to be something that, yeah, there's also a joke about
- 5:42how many times you have heard as a vegan or a vegetarian, where do you get your protein?
- 5:47And that's also, some people are fed up with that. But it is true that you have to pay a bit
- 5:53of attention in what you're eating. It's not that you're going to just start eating vegetables and
- 5:59rice and feel great. You can also, maybe if you're not paying attention to your iron as well, you can
- 6:07be anemic. So it's better if you're like a well-rounded and really try to pay attention.
- 6:11It's not always super easy, but yes, the idea was to try to make it a bit easier. So it was so simple
- 6:17for me to just cut some, cube some cheese, dairy cheese back in the time, and just eat like that
- 6:24with crackers. And I would feel I'm having like something more, you know, sustained or maybe that's
- 6:31not the word sustained, but something more nutritious basically. And that's more, that's what I wanted
- 6:37to mimic with Aviva. Yes. And when you give up cheese, you're also giving up some meals that are
- 6:47a bit very important in the culture, in the way you've been brought up. And what I'm thinking
- 6:54about right now is a pizza. And that was something I had to grieve. You know, I'm not getting a good
- 7:05pizza anymore because there's no cheese available out there to make a good pizza recipe. So I have
- 7:14to eat pizza without the cheese topping or just to, you know, manage with the alternatives out
- 7:24there. So yeah, did you have to give up any meals because of becoming vegan and having to cut off cheese?
- 7:37Yes. Well, my journey was, it's still, it's very, has been very progressive. My journey to veganism
- 7:44has been really, really, yeah, progressive is the best word. I've been in like a transition,
- 7:53getting more and more for definitely when I launched the company, I, when I, not only when
- 8:02I launched the company, when I started making these bean based cheese or like you base cheese,
- 8:09I found that finally there was a lot of things that I could like incorporate. I was very happy
- 8:14because that really helped me overcome a big challenge that I was having that was with cheese. But
- 8:25other than that, I don't mind, for example, we don't have any mozzarella yet. It's because I
- 8:31really, I hear you. It's not easy at all. And since the company has nutrition, the nutrition is very,
- 8:38very top of mind. It's very important. It was important for me to start the company. It is
- 8:43something, it's in our values to have the nutrition aspect. Mozzarella is a bit hard to imitate. It is
- 8:53hard to imitate and as well to be nutritious because you needed to melt a lot. You need to really
- 8:59melt very, very well. So we, I haven't really, we haven't ventured in mozzarella yet. It is,
- 9:08I, there are some that are good in the market, but really the best that I would say is to make
- 9:14your own, your own fresh mozzarella from cashews. I think that cashews are really, work pretty well
- 9:22for, for like a fresh mozzarella. You know, that one, the white one that's in a bowl of mozzarella.
- 9:28If you have the time or I mean, it's a project, but you can probably freeze it. I think the part
- 9:37that was a little hard for me was the extra cooking. That is, I, you can eat, I think you
- 9:46can eat almost anything. I really find that I, what, if I put the time into it, I can get a very,
- 9:54very decent, you know, mock or version or vegan version of many things. And the things that I
- 10:03cannot, I mean, there are different options in the market. You, what I find is that you need to put
- 10:08in the time. Okay. And that's what I said. Okay. I mean, who's going to be making their own cheese
- 10:15all the time. So I mean, let's, I think there's opportunity here for something. And so that's the
- 10:22thing that I have had to give up. I mean, I, I have gotten used to the, the mozzarella out there
- 10:30for the pizza, for example, the part that I was, is still the hardest for me is when going out,
- 10:40be visiting friends, going to dinner parties. That was really the last milestone in my journey
- 10:49to transitioning vegan has been that. And when things are under my control, I usually find a way
- 10:58to make it work. But when things are not, that is when things get, I, it might feel very limiting.
- 11:07Well, let's talk about the beginning of your vegan journey. What triggered that transition
- 11:12in your life? What made you want to make that change?
- 11:17Yes. Well, I became vegetarian 10 years ago when I moved to Canada. And it was basically,
- 11:25because it's not that I overnight, I moved to Canada and then I knew what happened to animals
- 11:30that I was eating. No, it's mainly a fact. The factor was the cooking part. When I was in
- 11:37Venezuela, it's very cultural. People usually live with their parents until they get married,
- 11:43or do they move some another to another city. But if you live in the same city as your parents,
- 11:48you most likely live with your parents. And my mom was doing all the cooking. And I was
- 11:55doing all the cooking. And I just found too disruptive. I basically, to be completely
- 12:02honest, did not want to embark on making all my food. It really sounds, I'm not someone who
- 12:10loves cooking. I need to say that. I really am not someone I love. That's also why this is the type
- 12:17that I felt super happy to make, because it kind of makes things easier for other people to maybe
- 12:25just put together a quick meal without spending so much time cooking. So I didn't want to do all the
- 12:33cooking. I thought it was just going to be too complicated, get all my things. Also in Venezuela,
- 12:37there are not so many. Vegetarianism is super easy. Now for me, it's like, oh, vegetarian,
- 12:43that's so easy. Really for me, it's like, how can someone think it's hard to become a vegetarian?
- 12:49It's extremely easy. For me, that's really level one in difficulty. But at the moment, I saw it as
- 12:56a huge thing. So even though I had this, I really felt for animals. I was an animal lover. I tried
- 13:05as many, many people just to kind of not think about it. That's probably what's most omnivores
- 13:10do. They just don't think about it. And then I moved to Canada and I said, okay, I'm going to
- 13:16have to cook for myself anyways. So this is the moment. I can cook. It's under my control. So I
- 13:22can cook whatever I want. And I'm going to start cooking vegetarian. And I found it really easy.
- 13:27I need to say vegetarianism was super easy. Then I started looking at more documentaries, hearing
- 13:37more. Really in my head, it was, okay, you don't have to kill animals. So I am perfectly not eating
- 13:44the meat, not eating like golden like that. I felt like I was doing everything I could. It was
- 13:50perfect. I met this vegan friend as well in the university. I came here to do my masters. So we
- 13:57studied together and started talking to be a bit more about that. And I also started in Canada,
- 14:02it's much more common. Definitely in Minnesota, it's not common to hear about veganism. I mean,
- 14:0710 years ago it wasn't. I don't know how it is now. But I started hearing more about it and
- 14:13looking at documentaries and thinking like, oh my God, maybe vegan, maybe vegetarian is not enough.
- 14:20Then I started, I went to, it was a program called Clinique Rennes Versantes. They were also at the
- 14:30Vegan Fest. She's a dietitian called Anne-Marie Roy. I have always been very health conscious. I
- 14:39love to read the labels when I purchase any product. I read the nutritional facts, I read
- 14:45the ingredient list. I have always been like that. I think my mom is like that and I kind of picked
- 14:50that up. So she was proposing to teach you how to eat in a very healthy way, plant-based. So her
- 14:59thing is this whole theory, this whole movement of whole foods, plant-based. And I started learning
- 15:06about it and I was, wow, this is, it's perfect. It's not only because of the animals, but look at
- 15:12all the health benefits of this. And it completely resonated with me, but I was working at a dairy
- 15:19company. Okay. Yes, I was working in marketing right after my masters. I started working at a
- 15:27dairy company when I was a vegetarian. And actually for me, I mean, cheese was a very
- 15:34important part of many meals. It was sometimes like cheese centered. Many of the vegetarian
- 15:41options, that's the protein they have is cheese. So I was like, oh my God, so happy. It's perfect
- 15:46that I work here. It just happened to be. And of course it was super convenient to get so much.
- 15:55I would get amazing prices on the products that are usually very expensive. I would get really
- 16:01good discounts. I would get always, I was in marketing, I would get samples on my, I was
- 16:05product manager at some point. So I was like really working with the product itself. So getting
- 16:11tons of samples of cheese all the time, it's just, it was just not going to happen. It was just
- 16:17really hard. There was, I at home, I would cook more and more plant-based following this advice
- 16:25from this nutrition program that I took. It was like a three month thing. I learned a lot of tools,
- 16:31but I just was not ready, especially in the environment where I was in, really basically
- 16:36food, cheese everywhere I looked. So then I started, I went on maternity leave.
- 16:45Well, I was with my second child and I was okay. I didn't have the tons of cheese on my desk anymore.
- 16:54That really helped. And on top of it, my daughter had a lot of issues, like gastrointestinal issues.
- 17:04And we were thinking, we started with elimination diets. And one of the things that they took away,
- 17:10the doctors, was dairy, but in a very, very, very strict way. Like not, I had to, every time I would
- 17:19order anywhere, I would have to ask what, I discovered that there was dairy in so many places
- 17:27that I didn't know. That felt extremely frustrating for me, but I had to take it super
- 17:34seriously because we needed to see what was causing these issues. And because I was breastfeeding,
- 17:41the thing is that because I was breastfeeding her, I needed to eliminate everything from my diet.
- 17:46And then that was really like the moment when it wasn't under my control anymore. And I didn't have
- 17:53all the time, my eight hours a day didn't revolve around cheese anymore because I was not working.
- 18:00So that was the moment when I started taking it much more seriously, but it was only dairy.
- 18:07And I was eliminating many other things because of this elimination diet was extreme, was brutal,
- 18:12was really difficult because there were many, many things that I couldn't eat. I was not ready to
- 18:18take out eggs at the point. It's like, I really, I couldn't eat almost, I couldn't eat soy at some
- 18:23point. So without soy, for me, that was extremely hard, like too hard. So I said, forget about eggs.
- 18:32I'm keeping eggs. And then when this whole gastrointestinal problem got resolved, I started
- 18:44being a bit less strict with all the ingredients, like asking everywhere. I would ask in a restaurant
- 18:54what if all the ingredients for everything. And I would notice that the rice had butter, for example.
- 19:01And I felt so limited that after this GI issue was solved, and I didn't have to do that anymore,
- 19:10I went back to a bit more like a relaxed place where if I was at home, I would control everything
- 19:16I would eat. And it wasn't really hard for me to get the vegan versions of things, especially now.
- 19:23But when I was out, I would, and I saw that I'm going to eat like the Greek salad with pieces of
- 19:30feta in it. That was evident that was dairy, but I wasn't so inquisitive with what's in the
- 19:38here, reading everything. Sometimes you know that they even have different names in the ingredient
- 19:45list that you have to be super. So I relaxed that a bit because it was feeling a bit obsessive,
- 19:52to be honest, at first when I was with the elimination diet, not only with dairy, but with
- 19:56other products. And then I stayed like that for a little while of being food-savvy,
- 20:05being flexible. For me, a huge wall that I had in front of me was friends eating out.
- 20:18We have many friends who invite us for dinner parties. And that was like, what am I gonna do?
- 20:26I felt like, what am I gonna tell them? They knew I was vegetarian. People always had a vegetarian
- 20:32option for me. Like, oh my god, am I gonna tell them now? I'm vegan, cook something vegan for me.
- 20:40I don't know. That felt like a mountain for me to overcome that. I was being just so apologetic
- 20:49about it. Am I gonna just inconvenience these people, causing them trouble to see what they're
- 20:55gonna feed me now? I can bring my own things. I did a couple times, but then it felt so weird to me
- 21:03to bring my own food, do things, and just eat what I was eating and not eating what they were eating.
- 21:09That, I need to say, was a complete... That was very hard, I need to say for me. So I was being
- 21:17vegan almost completely when I could control and then when I would be out. But I am a big
- 21:24proponent. I know that a lot of people, I hear in many vegan discussions that people are completely
- 21:29against that, against being progress, like doing a transition and being very in a progressive way,
- 21:39because they say, well, if you were against, if you're against pedophilia, would you do what?
- 21:44Pedophilia once in a while. I don't... Anyways, I completely understand that point of view.
- 21:51I understand, I get it. I respect everyone's positions, but for me, I think it's still better
- 21:59that I ate vegan when I was at home and every time I was to go into a restaurant that I could
- 22:05order things instead of doing everything at the same time and then feeling so overwhelmed and
- 22:11isolated and just giving up after because I was feeling I was, I don't know, losing my friends.
- 22:17I have no clue, but it worked for me. And that's something that I tell people that it works. If you
- 22:23say just don't, if it doesn't feel like you can manage or that it's going to feel like really a
- 22:30mountain for you to climb, I don't see the problem of doing it progressively. And I think it's going
- 22:36to become a little easier. If I had become vegan right away instead of vegetarian first, I think
- 22:41it would have been much harder for me because it's just so easy to become vegetarian. So I personally
- 22:47think that that's the best way. That part of the eating out part and telling my friends, only this
- 22:54year I was in that position of just almost getting out of the closet and telling people like,
- 23:03okay friends, I am vegan and I am going to bring my things and I hope that's okay with you. You
- 23:12don't have to worry at all about me. I can figure out. But if someone would, I don't know, the other
- 23:20time I went to someone's place and they were like, oh, the carrots, the only thing I could eat in my,
- 23:25when I got there with my food. I'm like, oh well, I can try their, I can eat their carrots. They had
- 23:31carrots. They had carrots. And I was like, oh well, I can eat their carrots, you know, to share some
- 23:34food together. It's a big, I think that's, I don't know, not a lot of people talk about this, I find.
- 23:41But I think that's important. The fact of sitting together and eating the same food has brought us
- 23:46together for centuries. I mean, I don't know, for thousands of years. So that is a big, was big for
- 23:52me. And I said, okay, I'm going to eat their carrots, you know. And then he said, oh, sorry,
- 23:57the carrots have butter. And I was like, oh my God, I hope he didn't. I wish he didn't say that.
- 24:06So I'm an imperfect vegan. And I'm fine saying that because I'm an imperfect vegan in the sense
- 24:13that I told him, you know what, next time just don't tell me. It's okay. It's okay. If they have
- 24:19a bit of butter, it's fine. If I see the cheese right there, or if I, I mean, if you're baked
- 24:25muffins, it's obvious that they have, you know, that, oh, I don't see the, I don't see the egg
- 24:30in the muffin. So it's not there. Not to that point. But I mean, if it's something a bit like that,
- 24:35I can get it a bit, I can let it slip. And that's why I consider myself like an imperfect vegan,
- 24:45still working and still doing progress. And that's maybe at some point, I think I'm just
- 24:51going to feel completely okay or bringing all my food or I don't know. I think it's going to happen.
- 24:56And I'm striving to become a more perfect, let's say in quotes, vegan. But that's my journey was a
- 25:05little, a little long and bumpy. I think you're completely reasonable. And I wholeheartedly agree
- 25:13with everything you said. You know, I'm someone who do things in a quite a radical way. When I
- 25:20decided to become vegan, I became vegan overnight. And it was tough because I did not know what to
- 25:27cook or how to cook. And I starved for a few weeks after that. But this is my way. I know that
- 25:37if I had taken a more gradual approach like yours, I would never have reached that vegan goal.
- 25:44But we're all different people with different personalities. And we should not be thinking about
- 25:52converting people to veganism as just a single formula that we can apply to every different,
- 25:59you know, personalities. And I think that one of the reasons why it's very difficult for you is,
- 26:09I think you come from a culture where it's important to be together. And I understand that,
- 26:18because I also come from a culture where it is important to, like you said, share a meal together
- 26:25as a family, as a tribe, and a culture where you don't leave the family nest before you get married.
- 26:35You know, I come from North Africa. It's very important to that social creation aspect,
- 26:44you know, that cultural value of food. It takes a big, big place. And when I became vegan, I felt
- 26:55like I was cutting myself out of my family in a way. I don't know if you understand that. So
- 27:06I wonder how what what was the reaction of your family from Venezuela who learned that you were
- 27:14becoming vegan? Did you experience that same feeling of alienation from your culture or your
- 27:22family ways? Yes. Well, first, I take my hat off with you because, yes, I completely understand it.
- 27:30So, yes, it takes a lot to come in and say, like, I'm a vegan. I'm sorry, but I'm not going to eat
- 27:39this food. It takes a lot of courage. So, yes, I need to recognize it. I mean, I think that sometimes
- 27:47people are like, oh, becoming vegan is so easy. I mean, I think that if you put that expectation
- 27:53there and people then are faced with the reality, I and I understand we want more people to join and
- 28:01we want really the cages to be empty forever and no animals to be exploited anymore. So we think
- 28:07that, yes, come in. It's so easy. It's so fun. I understand. But it's also like parenthood.
- 28:16Sometimes I give somebody, oh, it's a bit. Yeah, but now you hear more and more about the struggles
- 28:21of it, too. So when you go in, you know what you're going to be dealing with and you're like,
- 28:27OK, I'm going to take this. I'm going to learn along the way. So, well, a lot of courage. You
- 28:33really have a lot of courage. OK, since I became a more like at this last stage of vegan, like
- 28:40not caring about anyone, just going in with my own food and just telling everyone like I'm not
- 28:45going to eat this food. I'm sorry. I haven't been back to Venezuela since then. Last time I went to
- 28:51Venezuela was five years ago. So I was only a vegetarian and I mean, I was. Yeah, I was
- 28:57only I was just vegetarian. So I haven't been in that position yet. I think with vegetarian,
- 29:05it was it was I just told them right away after I moved that I go look, I'm not me. I'm in Canada
- 29:12and I decided that I'm going to become vegetarian. I'm going to cook my own food. So I think there's
- 29:16no problem. And when I when I got there after, yes, I mean, they had to. But as I said, the journey
- 29:23is so easy. It is. It is super easy. So if there's anyone listening who are like, oh, we're eating
- 29:29meat, that's very easy to really to give up. And you're already doing something. So maybe start
- 29:39start there. I don't know. That's that's my own personality. But they when I go next time,
- 29:48I really don't know what I'm going to do. Like to be. Yeah, I don't know. I think I'm going to
- 29:55probably cook something with my mom. She I mean, she's my mom. She's there. It was a small family,
- 30:04like the just the family unit. So it's going to be just my family and her. She you know, my father
- 30:12passed away. I don't have siblings. So that's very easy. She's very understanding. And anyway, so when
- 30:17I go to my bit more, my extended family, like my aunt, the dinner, na na na, maybe I won't just say
- 30:23anything. I won't say anything. And I will just eat their salad and eat their rice. And that's it.
- 30:31I don't I am more the type of like no, no fuss too much about it, because then I don't want it to
- 30:38become, you know, a topic for the night. No one has to inspect what I'm putting on my plate.
- 30:45And yeah, and I am fine. Like if the right if she happened to put butter in the rice, I'm okay.
- 30:53Okay, so that I'm not gonna go there. And they say, Okay, so what's in the rice? And what's in
- 30:58the vegetables? I said vegan. I am I'm not gonna do that right now. Next time I go that I'm planning
- 31:05on going in a couple months. That's gonna be my my strategy. But I yes, I they they know the business
- 31:13I have. So they know that my business is a vegan business. So it makes sense for them. It makes
- 31:18total sense that I'm that I don't need dairy that I don't need. Maybe eggs are not too aware. But
- 31:23yeah, that's that's that's what I'm taking it. And for us of now what when I was faced with the
- 31:30vegetarian thing that was super easy. Well, you can expect that your veganism is going to be
- 31:39the discussion of every family, you know, gathering, because that that was my case, you know,
- 31:47every time I was with mostly extended family, but even close family like aunts and uncles.
- 31:56Every meal, you know, it was I had to give a speech on veganism and how I did not need to be vegan.
- 32:06And no, I was not getting skinnier, you know, every time it was so tiring. So yeah,
- 32:15family dinners become a bit painful, you know. But, you know, as an immigrant, we don't go there
- 32:23very often. So we don't have to experience that. Yes, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Another fascinating thing
- 32:33about your cultural background is that you got inspired from Venezuelan cooking to make
- 32:43the vegan cheese. And I was wondering, how did that happen? How do you start making vegan cheese
- 32:52as a professional, you know, not just making mozzarella with quesadillas in your
- 33:00kitchen, you know, for your household, but really making cheese that you're going to sell to
- 33:08strangers. So how did how did that happen? How did you make the recipe and how did you get inspired
- 33:15from your cultural background? Yes, well, the first the beans itself pulses like legumes, that
- 33:25legumes, that is the aspect that they were a huge staple for me from before. So we do we do it
- 33:34legumes very often in Latin America, I would say. Yeah, super early know with Mexican food,
- 33:42everywhere. I don't know if everywhere really, but in many countries from Latin America, legumes,
- 33:48meaning chickpeas, beans, lentils are common, or at least more common than in Canada. And that's
- 33:58that. So I was eating them often, and as a vegetarian, and then in my transition to veganism
- 34:04and all this, they were really a big part of our weekly meal rotation, there was always beans.
- 34:12And I just love beans. I love not only I think they are like a super food. I yes, like I because
- 34:21they are so nutritious. They are affordable. And on top of it, when I learned that Canada was one
- 34:31of the largest producers of pulses in the world, like, oh, my God, like, this is like, perfect.
- 34:36Like this is the there's really sustainability wise, they are great. They are a crop that doesn't
- 34:45require almost any nitrogen fertilizers. They have a property to fixate nitrogen to the soil.
- 34:51So they're used for agriculture to as a rotational crop. So when they need the soil to gather
- 34:57nutrients, again, they plant legumes to to kind of enrich their soil. So I just love this. I love
- 35:04the fact that they are seeds. I got so inspired by the seed aspect of it. Like, wow, they imagine
- 35:12how much life there's inside a seed and really every legume is a seed. So yeah, so nerd with this
- 35:20legume thing. And when I was thinking about an alternative cheese, something that's not made from
- 35:28nuts, because of allergies, and because of also environmental, I don't want to get into into that.
- 35:36Look, I do eat cashew cheese from time to time. I love variety. I think it's great. I do have the
- 35:43the diazo. Look, the diafeta, of course, Aviva Feta is something else. But I need to say the
- 35:49diafeta is not bad. They've gone a long way from what they were a long time ago. Yes, they've been
- 35:54they have improved a lot. So there's space for for all sorts. Okay. And for the cashew cheese as well.
- 36:01But there are some issues with the harvest methods of cashews. That's also why they're so
- 36:09expensive. They come from so far away. So maybe it's not like the most sustainable, you know, option
- 36:15out there. So then I thought, okay, I want something that has protein, something that has no
- 36:22allergen, it's not an allergen that has no allergens. Because I'm telling you, when I had to
- 36:27eliminate all allergens from my diet, to test for it, this elimination diet, it was hell for me.
- 36:36I couldn't eat anything. Yeah, I was like, really, people with severe allergies or things like that,
- 36:40they cannot eat anything. They are, they must feel very miserable, really. So I said, I'm going to do
- 36:46maybe something or then, yeah, you have the other options that have no no allergens, but they also
- 36:52have no nutrition. So I started, well, okay, I think really pulses make so much sense. They also
- 36:58have a very neutral taste. I mean, neutral compared to you have seen probably chickpea brown,
- 37:05it's or things like that. So you can play with them. And so I said, okay, let's let's do this. I
- 37:13looked for a couple recipes. There was not much online. When we started making our cashew cheese
- 37:19back in the day, there were many recipes online. There were books about it. For pulses, no. I found
- 37:28some videos, but very not much. Some of them were using like chickpea flour, which is completely
- 37:34different. But I made a couple tests just to see. It has potential. It has potential. But as I
- 37:42mentioned at first, I don't love spending hours in the kitchen. I was working in marketing. I also,
- 37:50the thing of why I said to sell it for other people, because I was working in marketing for
- 37:56a dairy company for packaged foods. I was already in the market, let's say, I mean completely,
- 38:02but the market that I was trying to mimic. So yes, I was a bit familiar on how the industry works,
- 38:08how consumer foods get created. That's what I was doing as a job. I was looking at trends in the
- 38:16market, looking at gaps in the market and saying, okay, how can we adapt our portfolio? What line
- 38:21extensions we could do? How can we improve this product that's been maybe has this ingredients
- 38:27we are not liking it anymore. So how can we make it better? So I was doing that as that was my job
- 38:32for some. So that made things much easier. I was already kind of used to how to doing this. And I
- 38:39did that exercise, the product management, but for my own idea. But I'm very conscious about my
- 38:48limitations. I think that in general, as an entrepreneur, I mean, some people, of course,
- 38:52you have to almost do it all. But I think I was lucky enough to have, because it's a very
- 39:02innovative area. Also, the fact of using beans or the pulses was very innovative.
- 39:10I did some postings when you mentioned about the interns for interns to get interns from food
- 39:18science. So I did my MBA at McGill. And I was in contact with people from food science from
- 39:26the faculty. So I reached out to them. And they said, okay, send me your job posting, we're going
- 39:32to actually create among students. And that's what I did. And I said, like, it's to develop a new
- 39:38plant based cheese. And I think, well, I guess a lot of people were attracted to it. People wanted
- 39:43to get real life experience developing a new product. And yeah, I got my first two students
- 39:52in summer of 2021. That's when we started working on more prototypes. So after I made my first test,
- 40:01then I really handed it over to them and told them, okay, this is what I've done so far.
- 40:05This is the objective. The objective back when I first started was, no, because I was with all
- 40:12this whole foods plant based mentality. I was like, I don't know, I don't want any oil in it.
- 40:20I just want it to be all the fat, because of course you need fat to mimic cheese. Cheese is
- 40:26basically fat, more or less. I mean, it has of course many other things, but fat is a very
- 40:31important component of cheese. So I said, okay, all the fat, I want it to come from seeds. So from
- 40:36nut butters and things, not nuts, but seed butters or things like that, no oil. And I wanted to have
- 40:44like this, I wanted to hit the same macros as dairy cheese. So I wanted to have six grams of
- 40:51protein per serving. And I wanted to have this much, but half the saturated fat or almost no
- 40:58saturated fat, this and that and that. I mean, we started with the first prototype.
- 41:04And then I started doing a lot of consumer panels with their help. We had a next group of students
- 41:12the next summer. So after we gathered data from the first prototype, we adapted for the second
- 41:17prototype. And now we're really in the third iteration of the product. And that was basically
- 41:26based on feedback because you need to reach a middle point, let's say, between the super ultra
- 41:36nutritious, healthy thing and something that resembles cheese. Cheese itself is not the most
- 41:43nutritious, super healthy thing. It has saturated fat and you cannot not have saturated fat and be
- 41:51called cheese. You can be called something else. So that was also something at some point I was in
- 41:56a crossroads, like should I maybe go with this super healthy version that I cannot really call
- 42:02cheese because it's too far. So that was a bit the process. And then I said, no, I think we need
- 42:10more cheese. People need more cheese. Cheese is a struggle for so many people. If we really, so
- 42:17that's why I said, no, I'm not going to make a healthy, nice, great tasting pate. I'm full of
- 42:25following with cheese. So we continued, continued working. And yes, now it doesn't have six grams
- 42:30of protein. Okay. Now we had to incorporate starches for the texture. The texture was too
- 42:39soft. So we need to do, you know, but now I think we reached a very good middle point of
- 42:45something that is still nutritious, is still healthy. And it's much closer to the Rio cheese.
- 42:53We're still making the one you tested at the Vegan Fest wasn't as hard as this one. So we haven't
- 43:00been, we have been like continuously improving the recipe and I think we're now almost, almost ready.
- 43:07So even the Vegan Fest, that was really what, a couple of months ago,
- 43:13now we already have a version that's a bit harder because that's what people told us. People in the
- 43:18Vegan Fest were like, yeah, we, we love it. It's amazing. And that we had a little, an iPad there
- 43:25and a QR code for people to fill out. So we gathered the feedback right away. Okay. People
- 43:30want it harder. Let's work on it. So we went back and making it now harder. So we have it kind of
- 43:35our version that I think it's the final one. Are you saying there's a better version of the vegan
- 43:41one? Are you saying there's a better version out there than what I can say? Yes. I'm so happy to
- 43:47say, well, it's just a little, it's just firmer. That's the only difference. It has more bite.
- 43:53So that, that, that, that was the only, the only missing part. And that's what we, we confirmed.
- 44:00That was what people wanted. Are you in Montreal? Because I should send you. Yes, yes, I am.
- 44:06So yeah, you're going to get your harder version. You're going to get it after we,
- 44:12you'll tell me your address and I'll send you the harder version of Aviva.
- 44:16You're amazing, Betty. Seriously. I mean, and this is getting me hungry. This conversation is getting
- 44:22me hungry. I want to talk about entrepreneurship because you mentioned, you mentioned that, but
- 44:30first, I just want to address something that has been a struggle for many big brands out there.
- 44:38And it's how to label their products because many will use the label plant-based and not use the
- 44:47label vegan. And you use both, I think plant-based and vegan, but many shy away from the vegan label
- 44:56because they find it a bit too maybe partisan or political, or maybe it has a certain social
- 45:04connotation or cultural connotation that they don't like. And I love the fact that you don't shy away
- 45:10from the vegan label. So how did you make that decision of writing vegan on, on the packaging?
- 45:19Oh, I'm so happy you noticed. Really very, you observed. Because the reasons for
- 45:32me to, and I say me even though I've had a lot of help. So many times I say we,
- 45:38but in this conversation, I have led these efforts from the people that who have helped me along the
- 45:46way. But I had the objective is the, of this product is to get more people to switch away from
- 45:59animal based products because of the ethical reasons behind it. So that is the original.
- 46:07There's many more people who are interested in this type of products and it's not at all because
- 46:12of animal ethics, but the main motivation behind this company was animal rights. So that's why I
- 46:25wanted to have it there. And I also wanted people to know, I think plant-based, it's can be more
- 46:33flexible, I think. That's what comes to mind. So that's why when I was doing this thing of,
- 46:40when I was faced with a very problematic situation of no options out there and nothing to eat,
- 46:45and instead of just getting the fries, I would maybe get something with the fries. Because that's
- 46:51many times, you know, that's the only option in some places. Sometimes I would get the vegetarian
- 46:56option or things like that. And I would consider myself more like plant-based because I, in my head,
- 47:03it's a bit more flexible, let's say. And in the developing of the product and the ingredients we
- 47:11choose, we are not being flexible at all. So that is something that I ask every supplier. So that's
- 47:20why I think vegan represents more the values behind the company and also the not letting anything,
- 47:29look, I am not in a position to see, I cannot see if the companies have done animal testing.
- 47:34That would be when I'm more powerful. I hope that one day, now it's really a struggle to find
- 47:41suppliers to start with that would sell you in lower quantities. But I think that when you have
- 47:47purchasing power, you can start getting much more picky about your suppliers and even asking
- 47:55more things about because there's not so much information. You can see information that there's
- 47:59no dairy at all in the products. For example, the things with bacterial cultures, something with vegan
- 48:04versus plant-based. There's something with bacterial cultures that I used to use, now I don't.
- 48:09But some of them, they don't have any dairy in it. There's no dairy in the product. So
- 48:16even if you're extremely sensitive, you can have a ton and nothing's going to happen because
- 48:20there's no traces of dairy at all in this culture. But the origin of that culture was dairy. So even
- 48:33though there was no dairy, I think that would be considered plant-based, I think. That would be
- 48:38considered plant-based because there's really no animal products in the product. But they used
- 48:46animal at the beginning. So I made the choice back then to not go with that culture because of that.
- 48:54So that's why vegan, yeah. But I would like to take it a step further and start asking suppliers
- 49:02or getting more information about animal testing. I don't think it's so common. I don't really think
- 49:09it's common for food products to do animal testing. It's more for really pharmaceuticals or
- 49:19cosmetics or things like that. But yeah, if I could, I would really try and verify as much as
- 49:26possible to really make sure that there was no animals exploited or harmed in the process.
- 49:31Yeah, that's what's important. I mean, what if a few microbes were taken away from an animal
- 49:40and then cultivated in a lab a few years ago? I don't think this is going a bit too far with
- 49:48the vegan label, but I love that. I love that you use the vegan brand with the ethical
- 49:57reasons that you mentioned. I truly think it's amazing. And anyway, I think about 75% of the
- 50:08world population is intolerant to dairy products. So you have a market of people out there for
- 50:17mock cheese, plant-based cheese, people who just like vegans want to enjoy pizza and want to have
- 50:26an option for that. But let's talk about the entrepreneurial aspect of it. You are the sole
- 50:35owner and founder of your company, which is a bit rare in these days. Usually you have at least two
- 50:45co-founders for a company. And I just can't imagine how much work there is behind launching Aviva.
- 50:55So can you mention a bit how it's like to be an entrepreneur? What were your fears before launching
- 51:04your business? And how is your reality right now as the sole owner and founder of your company?
- 51:14And founder of your business? Yes. Well, the fears before, I think
- 51:22most people, I think the elephant in the room for many, for entrepreneurship sometimes is
- 51:29how are you going to make a living out of it? It's like, how are you going to pay your bills?
- 51:35That is a, that's a limitation for many people. I need to say that I have been extremely lucky
- 51:42that I am in a household. I have my husband as well. We have agreed on making adjustments
- 51:52in our budget. We were, our plan was to buy a house a couple of years ago. And then we decided
- 52:01we will have to postpone it because I need to do this now before we buy a house. So of course,
- 52:08financial, it's a big impact. You're going to have to really cut your budget. If you,
- 52:15I think the two best moments would be maybe if you have a very understanding, supportive partner
- 52:22who can take on more of the weight. I have done things here and there. I do things here and there
- 52:28to also get some extra revenue because now at first you cannot really take money from the company,
- 52:36everything that you make, you have to put it back to the company. So that is a big aspect that
- 52:43made me doubt if at first, how are we going to make this work? I mean, we're supposed to buy a
- 52:51house. Now we have to really just postpone that plan or things like that. So that's a big aspect
- 52:57of it. And, or also when, if anyone listening who still lives with their parents, that is an amazing
- 53:04moment to also launch a company when you, like that is, it's perfect because you look, it's not
- 53:09that you have to pay rent. You can even get some food from your parents. It's like economically
- 53:15make it work. So, and the, the thing of taking the risk and leaving a job that's of course,
- 53:24it's like, okay, I'm going to leave my, but that was not, I wasn't so scared of that because I,
- 53:31what I thought is like, look, I try now. I see if the market is ready to pay for it, if they like it,
- 53:39if they feel that there's a need, if it's solving a problem for them and if they are
- 53:43able to pay the price because unfortunately that's a very, that's a huge barrier is for small
- 53:51companies. Now you're not going to have the volume of the dairy business for sure. And even compared
- 53:59to Daiya or other, some other brands, they, if you see they're imported from Greece, Greece, they,
- 54:06they make, they have big volumes of, they make, I don't know what's going on in Greece, but
- 54:13many vegan brands of vegan cheese you see, they imported from Greece and they make, they make it
- 54:19work with a lot of volume. So when you're doing whatever you're doing, if it's not a food business
- 54:26or anything you're doing, probably you're going to start with a small volume and everything's going
- 54:30to be more expensive for you. Labor, ingredients, everything is going to be more expensive. So
- 54:39people will have to pay more for your product. So you need to make sure that the value you're
- 54:44offering is high enough for people to be able to pay that price. So the, the quitting the job,
- 54:51okay, continuing just on that idea for a second. So I said, look, and if, if after a couple of years,
- 54:57I realized that, you know, it just, there's no, what it's called product market fit,
- 55:02I can always go back and find a job again. It's not the end of the world. So, and about the amount
- 55:09of work it's, yeah, it is, I would love to have a business partner. It's just that it hasn't,
- 55:16it hasn't happened yet. I had other, like the previous, before earlier in my life, I've had
- 55:23other intents of launching businesses and it was with, with business partners. And it was
- 55:31easier in the sense of less responsibility and less load on your shoulders. But for some reason
- 55:37they, they didn't work out. These, these other businesses didn't work out, didn't last as long
- 55:42as Aviva is lasting. So yes, at some point, maybe it happens that I, that I meet someone
- 55:49with, that we share the same values and someone who's passionate and who's also someone who is
- 55:54willing to put the effort without getting the money. That is very hard. It's like people need
- 56:00to pay their bills. So finding someone who also wants to just bet on this without getting the
- 56:07economic benefit right away, it would be amazing. I would, I would love to have someone to share
- 56:15the responsibilities. The downside, I mean, yes, a lot of work. And also,
- 56:21now I have a family. I have two young kids. My day has to finish at five. I have no option.
- 56:31And then it can start again at nine, nine thirty after the kids are in bed. That I mean, of course
- 56:37I cannot personally, I cannot be extremely productive. I mean, then they have to wake up
- 56:40early again. So, so by working hours are limited and I, it just makes me go much slower. And well,
- 56:50and I have to be okay with that. I just have to be okay with not growing at the pace that I would
- 56:56have grown if I, if I had other partners. Absolutely. Sometimes it's a bit frustrating.
- 57:02Like I have a list of to do. I have so many people that need to get back to who have sent
- 57:09me emails and I haven't. And it's just that I do, I say, I do what I can. I, I, and if,
- 57:19and if they follow up and then, okay, okay, I put this, move this to the top of my, of my to do list,
- 57:26but the to do list is never going to, to finish. Of course you're doing your best. And let me ask
- 57:34you about this. Do you think there is a relation between being an immigrant and launching your own
- 57:41business? Because I feel like there are so many immigrants who launched their own business. And
- 57:48I think that has to do with how immigrating to a new country is the ultimate sacrifice. You know,
- 57:54you're sacrificing everything that is familiar to you. Literally you're sacrificing relationships
- 58:02with your family for the hope of a better world. It's the biggest risk that you could take, I think.
- 58:09And so then after the idea of launching a business seems a bit, you know,
- 58:15less intense than immigrating actually. Would you agree with that?
- 58:20Ah, yes. I think it does take a risk taking personality to both immigrate and launch a
- 58:30business. Yes. I think, yeah, yeah, yeah. I never, you know what? I didn't think of that.
- 58:37Yes. But it's probably the personality of people who immigrate. Yeah. There might be some overlap
- 58:41with the person, with, with those who are willing to just leave their jobs and yeah, jump, make,
- 58:47take the leap. Yes. Take the leap. What would you say to people who are hesitating to take that leap,
- 58:56to take that extra step, to follow their convictions and dreams? What is your message to
- 59:03those listeners? Yeah. So as I said at the, for the previous question about the risk and is really,
- 59:14how are you, think how are you going to make it work financially? Okay. Are you going to save up
- 59:22enough to then be able to do that? Or because that's, of course, it's a survival. It's basically
- 59:28survival. You have to figure that out first. You have someone who can take more of the financial
- 59:35load in the meantime while things get, or you could also, I mean, my job, I couldn't have
- 59:42continued in my job and doing this at the same time. It just was not, I mean, I worked in a dairy,
- 59:47I mean, it just, it's not possible at all. But at first, what I would say, the ideal scenario
- 59:55would be in my opinion, that if you can keep your job and start doing this, if you don't have kids,
- 1:00:02you have a lot of time, my friend. I need to say, even if you think that you are super busy,
- 1:00:09you have time. You can, after you come back from your job at five, at six, have dinner, and then
- 1:00:18work on your business. You can work on your business from 7 p.m. to 10 p.m. every day.
- 1:00:26And get it first, understand, get it to the idea, get it off the ground a little, take off. And then
- 1:00:35take off. And then when you see that it's working, that it's getting traction, then maybe take the
- 1:00:44leap and quit your job then. Or if you can go to a part-time or something like that. So, that would
- 1:00:54be probably the main thing of taking the leap is planning for it. And maybe don't leave everything
- 1:01:01right away if you haven't figured out a way to make it work financially. That's amazing advice.
- 1:01:09So, Betty, I think we answered most of the questions I had. Did you want to
- 1:01:16add something before we end this conversation? Okay, yes. I would say it's linked with what I
- 1:01:28mentioned about the cost and the price. If you want more companies to launch products that
- 1:01:37are innovative, that are good for you, that have good ingredients, that are not using, I don't know,
- 1:01:46child labor, who knows where, or sourcing from any random place. We need to make the decision
- 1:01:57of also supporting these businesses with our wallets. We cannot always try to find the cheapest.
- 1:02:05Because I can tell you for sure that it's not... Some people have this misconception that,
- 1:02:12oh, it's because vegan products, I have heard, vegan products are more expensive. Yes, that's
- 1:02:16yes. But the misconception is because they're vegan, they are trying to charge more or something
- 1:02:24to go because it's new, then they try to charge more because they are new, and then they lower the
- 1:02:28price. It's not that because it's new, it's not that people, their businesses were trying to
- 1:02:36be expensive. Everyone is trying to be cheaper. Everyone is trying to be cheap. If you
- 1:02:44really want to be super cheap, if I wanted to make the product as cheap as possible,
- 1:02:49then I could have done something like that and just have no nutrition at all, make a product that
- 1:02:56doesn't really add any value to your body, to when you eat it, or making, I don't know, the cheapest.
- 1:03:04So in the end, it's like, yes, people want to see startups, want to see products that are good for
- 1:03:12them, that they don't use any crap in their ingredients, and they want to do this and that.
- 1:03:17And then in the end, if they're going to always the cheapest version, you're not being consistent
- 1:03:24because making the products in Canada, making the products starting, starting the idea and taking it
- 1:03:33from zero to one, you are going to be more expensive at first until you reach a point of maybe
- 1:03:42then achieving a certain volume to then compete on price. So that's probably what I would say to
- 1:03:48people. And for people who want to become an entrepreneur, yes, it's just, I think, it's not
- 1:03:55for everyone, but if you have that itch, yeah, plan for it and do it. And you can always go back
- 1:04:03and find a job if it didn't work out. So that's all I would leave you with that.
- 1:04:09If there are some listeners who are in Montreal, how can they try your product?
- 1:04:18Yeah. So right now we have been working on the recipes and all that. So I took the products out
- 1:04:25from the stores where I was right now. They're going back in soon, like now in the next few weeks.
- 1:04:32So if you're, it depends when are you listening, but the most, the easiest way, the best way is
- 1:04:38to go on avivaalternative.com, the company's website, avivaalternative.com. And you're going
- 1:04:46to have two options. It's going to either take you online to another website who does all the,
- 1:04:51takes care of all the shipping and all the paying, the purchasing process. It's not done in our
- 1:04:59website and they take care of delivery and all that. Or you can also see in the where to buy
- 1:05:06and find a store that's close to you and try, so try the products and see, see what you think.
- 1:05:14Amazing. And of course there will be a link in the description to your company's website.
- 1:05:20Betty, thank you so much for your time. This was such a pleasant and inspiring conversation.
- 1:05:28Really thank you for your great work. And it shows that you're putting all of your heart
- 1:05:35in your product. So thank you for that. Thank you very much for the invitation. And yes,
- 1:05:41I had so much fun. Love talking to you, Ryan. Thank you everyone for listening and thank you
- 1:05:47so much for being a friend of this show. As always, please share this episode with your community.
- 1:05:53Let's inspire more people to take action. If you're listening to this on Apple podcasts,
- 1:06:00please leave a five star review. Finally, you can always follow me on Instagram at veganreportpodcast.
- 1:06:07Thank you again for listening. Take care and see you soon.