Latest / Interfaiths / Beyond Insularity: Reimagining Interfaith Literacy in Islamic Schools
Transcript
- 0:00A thousand years ago, there was this prominent
- 0:03Islamic scholar. Right. Al -Biruni. Exactly.
- 0:06And he traveled all the way to South Asia, which,
- 0:08you know, back then was a massive undertaking.
- 0:10He completely immersed himself in a totally foreign
- 0:13culture. Oh, yeah. And he actually mastered Sanskrit,
- 0:17which is an incredibly difficult language. I
- 0:20mean, it's notoriously complex. Yeah. Right.
- 0:22And he did all this just to write this ethnographic
- 0:24masterpiece on Hinduism. It was a study so generous
- 0:30and so stunningly objective and deeply curious
- 0:35about the religious other that modern anthropologists
- 0:38literally still use it as a model today. It's
- 0:40just wild to think about. It is. But then if
- 0:43you fast forward to like a typical Tuesday morning
- 0:46in 2026. Yeah, quite a leak. Right. You walk
- 0:49into an Islamic studies classroom in an American
- 0:51school. You crack open a textbook and you find
- 0:53that it barely mentions other religions at all.
- 0:56Or if it does, it's, you know, not exactly flattering.
- 0:59Exactly. When it finally does mention them, it
- 1:01is almost exclusively just to prove them wrong.
- 1:03The profound curiosity that Al -Biruni had, it's
- 1:06just gone. Completely absent. So the question
- 1:08we are tackling today is this. How did an intellectual
- 1:12tradition lose a thousand years of its own history?
- 1:15It's a heavy question. It really is. So welcome
- 1:18to this deep dive. If you are joining us today,
- 1:21I am so glad you are here with us. Because whether
- 1:24you are a parent trying to raise grounded kids,
- 1:27or maybe an educator wrestling with curriculum,
- 1:29or... Just someone trying to navigate the incredibly
- 1:34diverse and sometimes totally chaotic American
- 1:37public square. The mystery we are looking at
- 1:39today is going to completely change how you view
- 1:43religious education. It really shifts your entire
- 1:45perspective. It changes how you see civic duty
- 1:48and that massive tension between holding deep
- 1:51convictions and embracing pluralism. Right. And
- 1:54it is a tension we all face in one way or another.
- 1:56You know, how do you remain deeply rooted in
- 1:58who you are while actively and, well, generously
- 2:01engaging with people who are fundamentally different?
- 2:03And as you pointed out with that incredible historical
- 2:05contrast, the way we answer that question today
- 2:08looks very different than it did a millennium
- 2:10ago. OK, let's unpack this. Our mission today
- 2:13is to figure out exactly how U .S. Islamic schools
- 2:16are preparing their students for a radically
- 2:19diverse society. And we are pulling from a really
- 2:22fascinating stack of materials for this. We have
- 2:24some great sources today. Yeah, we have an academic
- 2:27abstract, a super comprehensive conference presentation
- 2:30slide deck, and this deeply reflective, almost
- 2:34personal blog post. And all of these are from
- 2:37the same researcher, right? Yes, all of these
- 2:38come from Dr. Iqbal Akhtar. He presented this
- 2:41research at the ISLA, that's the Islamic Schools
- 2:44League of America Research Symposium, on April
- 2:4726th, 2026. And Dr. Akhtar's... background is
- 2:50uh it's really essential context for the listener
- 2:52to keep in mind here oh for sure tell us about
- 2:54him well he is an associate professor of religious
- 2:56studies as well as politics and international
- 2:58relations at florida international university
- 3:01but beyond just his academic titles he is the
- 3:03founding director of fiu's jane studies and western
- 3:06indian ocean studies programs wow jane studies
- 3:09too Yeah. And he's a co -founder of Miami Interfaith.
- 3:12So he is a scholar who truly lives and breathes
- 3:16the intersection of different religious traditions.
- 3:19He's right in the middle of it. Exactly. He isn't
- 3:21observing this tension from some distant ivory
- 3:24tower. I mean, he is in the thick of it every
- 3:27single day. Which sets up our core mystery perfectly,
- 3:31I think. How did this ancient... breathtakingly
- 3:34curious intellectual tradition turn into a modern
- 3:38curriculum that seems to, well, kind of turn
- 3:41its back on the outside world. That's quite a
- 3:43shift. Yeah. Let's start with the reality on
- 3:45the ground right now. Just paint a picture for
- 3:47us. What does the landscape of Islamic education
- 3:50in the U .S. actually look like today? Sure.
- 3:52So according to Dr. Akhtar's data, we are currently
- 3:55looking at over 300 full time Islamic schools
- 3:58operating across the United States. Over 300.
- 4:00That's a lot more than people might think. Oh,
- 4:02absolutely. And that number represents a massive
- 4:04infrastructure. We are talking about tens of
- 4:06thousands of Muslim students walking through
- 4:08these doors every single day. That is a highly
- 4:11significant footprint. I mean, we aren't just
- 4:13talking about a handful of weekend programs in
- 4:16church basements or something. This is a sprawling
- 4:19national educational. Exactly. And we have to
- 4:23recognize the vital, necessary work these schools
- 4:27are doing. They are providing moral and spiritual
- 4:29grounding in a world that, let's be honest, often
- 4:33feels entirely untethered. Yeah. It really does.
- 4:36They foster this profound sense of belonging
- 4:38and they actively cultivate Islamic identity.
- 4:41And for a minority population, that is critical.
- 4:45I actually want to push on that word minority
- 4:47for a second, because let's be real about the
- 4:49cultural water these kids are swimming in. It
- 4:51is not always a friendly environment out there.
- 4:53Not at all. If we connect this to the bigger
- 4:55picture, you have to look at the sociological
- 4:57scholarship on this. OK, lay it on us. So Dr.
- 5:00Akhtar cites this philosopher, Michael S. Mary,
- 5:03writing back in 2007. And Mary analyzed the unique
- 5:06dual burden that's placed on minority religious
- 5:09schools. Dual burden, meaning they had to do
- 5:12two very different things at once. Yes. Mary
- 5:15points out that Muslim youth in America are growing
- 5:17up against a backdrop of societal misunderstanding,
- 5:20relentless media scrutiny, and, frankly, outright
- 5:24prejudice. Yeah, that's undeniably true. So the
- 5:27school isn't just a place to, you know, learn
- 5:29math and theology. It functions as a sanctuary.
- 5:32Precisely. The school has a mandate to fortify
- 5:34a specific identity for these kids so they feel
- 5:37safe, so they feel grounded. They need to know
- 5:39who they are before they can face a world that
- 5:41often misrepresents them. That makes total sense.
- 5:44But here is the tension. At the exact same time
- 5:47they are doing this intense fortification work,
- 5:50they have an equally urgent mandate to prepare
- 5:53these kids for civic life. And civic life in
- 5:55America means stepping into one of the most religiously
- 5:58diverse democracies in human history. Exactly.
- 6:00I mean, we aren't talking about some hypothetical
- 6:02scenario where these kids might meet someone
- 6:05of a different faith on vacation once. No, it's
- 6:07everyday life. When they graduate, they will
- 6:10go to massive state universities, right? They
- 6:12will eventually vote on local and national policies.
- 6:15They will work in corporate offices. They will
- 6:17be neighbors. Yes, to all kinds of people. Exactly.
- 6:20They will raise their own children alongside
- 6:23Christians. Jews, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs, and
- 6:27frankly, millions of people who are completely
- 6:29religiously unaffiliated. That is the modern
- 6:32civic horizon. You simply cannot escape it. So
- 6:36the question that plagues these administrators
- 6:38is, how do you reconcile the fortification of
- 6:42a fragile minority identity with the necessary
- 6:45preparation for that overwhelming pluralistic
- 6:48reality? Well, I have to ask, and I think you,
- 6:51the listener, might be wondering the exact same
- 6:53thing, right? now it's that if you are a school
- 6:55principal right and your primary overriding goal
- 6:59is to protect this fragile identity from a society
- 7:02that doesn't understand you doesn't teaching
- 7:04your students about other religions feel totally
- 7:07counterproductive it feels like a risk yeah right
- 7:09I mean think of it this way it's like spending
- 7:11all your time your money your energy fortifying
- 7:14the walls of a house you're making them thicker
- 7:15and stronger to keep the elements out but you
- 7:17completely forget to install any windows to see
- 7:20who your neighbors are That is exactly the psychological
- 7:22trap. It's a perfect analogy. Because if your
- 7:25entire operational paradigm is defense, then
- 7:29windows aren't features. Right, they're weak
- 7:31points. Exactly. They are vulnerabilities. They
- 7:33are literal gaps in your armor. If your job is
- 7:37to keep the cold wind out, why on earth would
- 7:39you open a window? You might think, if I show
- 7:42them the beautiful house across the street...
- 7:44They might leave this one. Right. You're thinking,
- 7:46let's just keep the blinds drawn, lock the doors,
- 7:49and focus purely on what's inside. And honestly,
- 7:52it makes perfect logical sense from a defensive
- 7:55posture. It makes complete sense, yes. But the
- 7:58irony, and this is what Dr. Akhtar's research
- 8:00wants forcefully to the surface, is that building
- 8:03a house with no windows is not actually how the
- 8:07House of Islamic Scholarship was originally designed.
- 8:09It wasn't built that way. No, not at all. The
- 8:11natural question that arises from this modern
- 8:13insular posture is whether this defensive crouch
- 8:16is a core feature of Islam itself or if it is
- 8:20a completely modern invention. And that brings
- 8:22us to what Dr. Akhtar calls the embarrassing
- 8:24paradox, which is such a striking phrase. It
- 8:28really is. In his blog post, he writes that it's
- 8:30embarrassing once you see it because you can't
- 8:32unsee the discrepancy. He points out that the
- 8:35classical Islamic intellectual tradition produced
- 8:38some of the most generous, rigorous, and ethnographically
- 8:42curious works of comparative religion that human
- 8:44beings have ever written. It is a stunning historical
- 8:47contrast. And it completely shatters the modern
- 8:51assumption that religious devotion somehow requires
- 8:53ignorance of other faiths. Right. Let's look
- 8:56at the historical exemplars he provides, starting
- 8:58with the one you mentioned in the hook, Abu Ryan
- 9:00al -Biruni. Let's really dig into Al -Biruni
- 9:03because we are talking about the 11th century
- 9:05here. 973 to 1048 CE. Yeah, so a long time ago.
- 9:10Yes, and Al -Biruni was a total polymath. But
- 9:13the key thing is he wasn't just sitting in a
- 9:14library in the Middle East reading secondhand
- 9:16accounts of other religions. He wasn't just reading
- 9:18Wikipedia pages. Huh, right. He physically traveled
- 9:21to South Asia. He lived among Hindu communities.
- 9:24And most importantly, he took the time to actually
- 9:27learn Sanskrit. I really want the listener to
- 9:29grasp the magnitude of that. Just think about
- 9:32the logistical and intellectual difficulty of
- 9:35a Muslim scholar moving to South Asia in the
- 9:3811th century. It's mind boggling. There are no
- 9:40modern translation tools. There's no Internet.
- 9:42There's no Rosetta Stone. He's overcoming massive
- 9:45cultural barriers. Yeah. And he didn't just learn
- 9:47like a few conversational phrases to buy bread
- 9:50in the market. He mastered a highly complex,
- 9:54sacred language so he could read their texts
- 9:57in the original. And the result of all that effort
- 9:59was his book. Takma Lil Hind. And you have to
- 10:02understand, this was not a polemic. Right. It
- 10:05wasn't an attack. Exactly. It wasn't some hit
- 10:07piece designed to make Hinduism look bad and
- 10:09Islam look good. It was a model of cross -cultural
- 10:12ethnographic inquiry. Wow. Dr. Akhtar notes that
- 10:16its patient interior accuracy is so profound
- 10:18that modern scholars today still rely on it.
- 10:21Al -Biruni genuinely wanted to understand Hinduism
- 10:24on its own terms. It's like he was conducting
- 10:26modern, peer -reviewed anthropology a millennia
- 10:29before the discipline was even formally invented.
- 10:31And he isn't an isolated genius either. I mean,
- 10:35Dr. Akhtar also brings up al -Sharastani, who
- 10:37lived shortly after, from 1086 to 1153 CE. Yes,
- 10:42al -Sharastani is another great example. He compiled
- 10:44this massive work called Al -Milal wa al -Niyal.
- 10:47What is that exactly? It was an encyclopedic
- 10:50survey of religious communities and philosophical
- 10:52schools, and it was so incredibly comprehensive
- 10:55and detailed that modern historians of religion
- 10:58are still studying it, and they're still arguing
- 11:01with its categorizations today. Here is my question,
- 11:04though. Why were they doing this? What do you
- 11:07mean? Like, were they just secular academics
- 11:09who happen to be Muslim? Because today, you know,
- 11:12we often associate that kind of objective comparative
- 11:14study with secular universities, not really with
- 11:18deeply religious environments. And that is the
- 11:20core misconception Dr. Akhtar is trying to dismantle
- 11:23right there. They were not doing this in spite
- 11:25of their faith. They were doing it because of
- 11:27their faith. Really? Yes. This intellectual curiosity
- 11:30was rooted directly in their scriptural foundation.
- 11:33The Quran itself, specifically verse 49 .13,
- 11:36mandates a concept called Tawroof. Tawroof. Okay,
- 11:39what does that actually mean in practice? It
- 11:42translates roughly to mutual recognition across
- 11:46human difference. The Quran explicitly states
- 11:49that God created humanity in different nations
- 11:52and tribes specifically so that they might come
- 11:54to know one another. Oh, wow. Yeah. So it is
- 11:57framed not as some sociological accident, but
- 12:01as a divine mandate for pluralism. The diversity
- 12:04of the human race isn't a mistake that needs
- 12:06to be corrected. It is the intent of the creator.
- 12:10That completely flips the script. It really does.
- 12:12So the diversity is the point. It's not a test
- 12:14of your faith to see if you can ignore the neighbors.
- 12:16It's a literal command to engage with them. Exactly.
- 12:19Furthermore, the Quran teaches the concept of
- 12:22universal prophecy. Which is what? It's the idea
- 12:24that God sent messengers to every single people
- 12:27on earth. Therefore, it doesn't view other religious
- 12:30traditions as complete, dark voids of truth.
- 12:33It specifically addresses Christians and Jews
- 12:36as al -al -kitab, which translates to the people
- 12:39of the book. They are viewed as partners in a
- 12:42historical, covenantal relationship. And it wasn't
- 12:46just theoretical theology happening in a vacuum,
- 12:48right? There was a very real, very tangible political
- 12:51precedent for this kind of pluralism, right at
- 12:53the inception of the community. Dr. Akhtar points
- 12:56to the Al -Madinah, the Madunan covenant of 622
- 13:00CE. Yes, and this is a crucial piece of the puzzle.
- 13:04The Medinan covenant was established by the Prophet
- 13:06Muhammad himself. It was a formal framework for
- 13:09pluralistic governance. So it was a political
- 13:12document? Yes, and it explicitly recognized the
- 13:15rights, the duties, and the religious autonomy
- 13:17of non -Muslim communities, specifically Jewish
- 13:20tribes, who were living within the same political
- 13:23body as the early Muslims. This is the critical
- 13:26takeaway for our listener to understand here.
- 13:28These historical examples, al -Biruni's deep
- 13:31ethnography, al -Sharistani's massive encyclopedia,
- 13:34the Medinan Covenant's political framework, these
- 13:37were not concessions. They were absolutely not
- 13:40concessions. They were not watering. down their
- 13:42faith to appease some secular power, they were
- 13:45expressions of supremely confident Muslim scholarship.
- 13:48I love that phrase, supremely confident. It's
- 13:51true. Al -Biruni didn't feel his Islamic identity
- 13:54threatened by learning Sanskrit. His worldview
- 13:57literally demanded a rigorous, curious engagement
- 14:00with the diverse world God created. Here's where
- 14:03it gets really interesting, though. If this deep,
- 14:06profound curiosity, this mandate for mutual recognition
- 14:10is literally baked into the DNA of the religion,
- 14:14how did it go so entirely quiet in American classrooms?
- 14:18It's the big question. I mean, you don't just
- 14:20misplace an encyclopedic tradition of comparative
- 14:22religion like you misplace your car keys. How
- 14:25do you lose a thousand years of intellectual
- 14:27heritage? Well, you don't lose it overnight.
- 14:29It is a slow, profound institutional shift driven
- 14:33by context. And to answer how this heritage was
- 14:36lost, we have to move away from the history books
- 14:38for a minute. Okay, where do we look? We have
- 14:40to look at the ground reality of how these subjects
- 14:42are actually being taught today. And this brings
- 14:44us directly to the core of Dr. Akhtar's research
- 14:47design, because he wanted to scientifically measure
- 14:50the gap between that brilliant historical heritage
- 14:52and the modern classroom. Let's break down how
- 14:55he actually did this, because the methodology
- 14:57here is vital. It really is. If I'm a parent
- 15:00listening to this, I want to know this isn't
- 15:02just one guy's opinion. He didn't just send out
- 15:05a quick SurveyMonkey link to a few friends. This
- 15:07was a qualitative, multi -method study. He spent
- 15:12time investigating 12 different Islamic schools
- 15:14across five U .S. metropolitan regions. And the
- 15:18variation in his sample is what gives the study
- 15:20its real weight. Right. He didn't just look at
- 15:22one type of school. Exactly. He looked at full
- 15:24-time schools and he looked at weekend programs.
- 15:26He captured schools across different sectarian
- 15:29orientations within Islam and across completely
- 15:32different geographic contexts. Why is that so
- 15:35important? Because he needed to see if this loss
- 15:37of curiosity was just a localized issue, say
- 15:40just a problem in one specific city, or if it
- 15:43was a field -wide pattern. That makes sense.
- 15:45And he utilized three intersecting tracks for
- 15:47his research to figure this out. Track one was
- 15:50a content analysis of widely used textbooks and
- 15:53curricular materials. He is literally reading
- 15:55the books the kids are assigned. Track two was
- 15:58conducting 24 semi -structured interviews with
- 16:01the actual educators, the teachers, and the curriculum
- 16:03coordinators. And track three, this is where
- 16:06it gets really interesting to me, was direct
- 16:09classroom observation. He literally sat in the
- 16:12rooms and watched the teaching happen. The value
- 16:14of this specific research design, this triangulation,
- 16:17cannot be overstated. Triangulation, you mean
- 16:20getting data from three different angles? Right.
- 16:22By looking at the textbooks, talking to the teachers
- 16:24behind closed doors, and watching the actual
- 16:27teaching in real time, the study separates what
- 16:30schools claim to do with their glossy mission
- 16:33statements from what is actually happening when
- 16:35the bell rings. Now, he does offer a caveat in
- 16:37his presentation, which we should mention. He
- 16:39notes that this study is exploratory. Twelve
- 16:42schools is not nationally representative in a
- 16:44strict statistical quantitative sense. Sure.
- 16:46But the patterns he found are what he calls field
- 16:49level. They are remarkably consistent across
- 16:52all those sectarian and regional lines. And that's
- 16:55key. When you see the exact same pedagogical
- 16:58gap in a full time, well -funded school on the
- 17:01East Coast and a volunteer run weekend school
- 17:03in the Midwest, you know you are looking at a
- 17:06systemic reality. It's not an isolated quirk.
- 17:09The system itself is producing this outcome.
- 17:12I want you, the listener, to pause for a second.
- 17:15Imagine being a fly on the wall in one of those
- 17:1712 schools. Okay. You are sitting in the back
- 17:20row of an Islamic studies class. You're a high
- 17:22schooler. When the topic of another religion
- 17:25naturally comes up. Because, again, you live
- 17:27in America. It has to come up. What are these
- 17:30textbooks actually telling the students? Well,
- 17:32this leads us to the first major and honestly
- 17:34quite sobering finding from Dr. Akhtar's content
- 17:37analysis track. What did he find? He identifies
- 17:40what he terms the comparative deficit. The comparative
- 17:43deficit. Break that down for us. What are we
- 17:46actually seeing on the pages of these textbooks?
- 17:48We are seeing a profound absence. Dr. Akhtar
- 17:51points out that very often other religious traditions
- 17:54simply do not appear at all. They just aren't
- 17:56there. Right. But when they do appear, they are
- 17:59framed almost exclusively as foils for Islamic
- 18:03truth claims. So they're just props to make the
- 18:06home team look better. Precisely. Christianity
- 18:08and Judaism, for example, are introduced mainly
- 18:11through their alleged corruptions, their theological
- 18:14deficiencies, and their cautionary value. Wow.
- 18:18Yeah. The textbooks do not treat them as living,
- 18:20breathing traditions with their own internal
- 18:22coherence and sincere communities of believers.
- 18:25They exist in the text only to demonstrate why
- 18:28Islam is the corrective. Dr. Akhtar sums this
- 18:31up in his blog post with a devastating line.
- 18:33He writes that it was a sentence he almost cut
- 18:36from his presentation because it felt so heavy,
- 18:38but he realized he had to leave it in because
- 18:40it was a factual finding. Well, it's a lie. He
- 18:42said, our curricula are, in a real sense, less
- 18:45Quranic than the Quran. Let that sink in. The
- 18:48holy text itself offers a more generous, complex,
- 18:50and relational view of other faiths than the
- 18:53modern textbooks designed to teach that very
- 18:55religion to children. It's wild. As Akhtar bluntly
- 18:58puts it, there is absolutely no al -Buruni in
- 19:01these curricula. The ethnographic curiosity is
- 19:04dead on arrival. It's staggering. I'm trying
- 19:07to think of an analogy for how limiting this
- 19:08is. Oh, analogies are great here. Like, imagine
- 19:11you are trying to understand a rival sports team.
- 19:14You really want to know how they play, what their
- 19:16strategy is, how their offense works. Sure. But
- 19:19the only tape you are legally allowed to watch
- 19:22is a highly edited compilation of their absolute
- 19:26worst bloopers, their fumbles, their missed shots,
- 19:29and their penalties. Right, a low -light reel.
- 19:31Exactly. You would walk away thinking they are
- 19:34totally incompetent, but you would never actually
- 19:36learn how they play the game. You would be totally
- 19:39unprepared to actually face them on the field
- 19:41or understand why millions of people are fans
- 19:42of that team. That is a fantastic analogy because
- 19:45it highlights the intentional curation of the
- 19:47negative. What's fascinating here is the academic
- 19:50term Dr. Akhtar uses to describe this textbook
- 19:53phenomenon. He calls it a heresiographical lens.
- 19:56Heresiographical. Okay, let's define that for
- 19:59the listener. Horaciography is the study of,
- 20:02or the writing about, heresies. When you apply
- 20:05a horaciographical lens to another group, you
- 20:09are analyzing them only to prove why they are
- 20:11wrong. You're not looking for the good stuff.
- 20:13No, not at all. You are sorting truth from falsehood,
- 20:17but the result is completely predetermined before
- 20:19you even start the inquiry. You aren't asking,
- 20:22what do they believe and why does it bring them
- 20:24meaning? You are asking, how can I quickly demonstrate
- 20:27that their belief is flawed? So if a textbook,
- 20:31using a heresiographical lens, brings up the
- 20:34Christian concept of the Trinity, for instance,
- 20:36it's not going to spend time explaining the deep
- 20:39mystery and historical development of Trinitarian
- 20:41theology. It's just going to immediately present
- 20:43it as a mathematical error to be debunked. Exactly.
- 20:46It's entirely defensive. It's an intellectual
- 20:48closed circuit. And you have to contrast this
- 20:51with the empathetic covenantal approaches modeled
- 20:54by those early scholars we talked about. Right.
- 20:56Al -Biruni. Yes. Well, the runa didn't use a
- 20:59heresiographical lens. He used an ethnographic
- 21:01one. He wanted to understand the interior logic
- 21:04of the Hindu community. The modern textbooks
- 21:06have basically abandoned the ethnographic for
- 21:10the heresiographical. So naturally, this begs
- 21:12a massive question. If the books are this restrictive,
- 21:15this defensive, who is to blame? That's where
- 21:18people's minds go immediately. Because as a parent
- 21:21or an outside observer, it's really easy to jump
- 21:23to conclusions. You might assume that there's
- 21:26some ideological conspiracy by the educators.
- 21:28You might think, oh, these administrators are
- 21:30deliberately trying to brainwash kids to hate
- 21:32other religions. Right. You assume malicious
- 21:34intent. But the interview track of Dr. Oktar's
- 21:37research, when he actually sat down behind closed
- 21:40doors and talked to these 24 educators, reveals
- 21:42a surprisingly human and, frankly, deeply sympathetic
- 21:46answer. Yes, the narrative completely shifts
- 21:49when we move from analyzing the texts to talking
- 21:51to the actual teachers. It's not about malice
- 21:54or a grand conspiracy of intolerance. It's about
- 21:56what Dr. Octor calls the pedagogical default.
- 21:59Let's talk about the psychology of the teachers
- 22:01here. In these interviews, they were remarkably
- 22:03honest, weren't they? They really were. They
- 22:06confessed that they feel entirely underprepared,
- 22:09both theologically and pedagogically, to facilitate
- 22:12interfaith discussions in the classroom. They
- 22:15just don't know how. No, they want to do a good
- 22:17job, but they feel like they are flying blind.
- 22:20They explicitly named four major obstacles that
- 22:23they face every single day. Let's walk through
- 22:26them. Sure. First, a total lack of training.
- 22:28They simply haven't been taught how to teach
- 22:31comparative religion. Second, a lack of age appropriate
- 22:34resources. I mean, even if teacher wanted to
- 22:37explain Buddhism to an eighth grader, they don't
- 22:40have the materials to do it fairly. There's no
- 22:41good book to hand them. Right. Third, a lack
- 22:45of institutional encouragement. The administration
- 22:48isn't pushing them to explore these topics. It's
- 22:51not on the standardized tests, you know. And
- 22:54the fourth obstacle is the one that really drives
- 22:56the behavior, I think. What's that? They expressed
- 22:59an intense, palpable fear of pushback from parents
- 23:03and administrators. Yes, they are terrified that
- 23:06if they spend substantive time discussing Christianity
- 23:09or Judaism or Hinduism, they will be perceived
- 23:13as elevating other religions alongside Islam
- 23:16or somehow watering down the faith. Just paint
- 23:19that picture for us. How does that fear actually
- 23:22manifest in a classroom setting? Imagine you
- 23:25are a sixth grade Islamic studies teacher. OK.
- 23:28You are in the middle of a lesson and a student
- 23:30raises their hand and asks an innocent question
- 23:33about their Hindu neighbors Diwali celebration.
- 23:37They just want to know what it means and how
- 23:39a Muslim should view it. Very common question.
- 23:41If you don't have the training, the resources,
- 23:43or the institutional backing, that question isn't
- 23:46an educational opportunity. It is a trap. Wow,
- 23:49a trap. Yeah. If you answer it too generously,
- 23:52a student goes home, tells their parents you're
- 23:54promoting Hinduism, and you get an angry email.
- 23:56Or worse, you get called into the principal's
- 23:58office. You panic. And what happens when you
- 24:00panic? You default to safety. The consequence
- 24:02of all this fear is the pedagogical default.
- 24:06The teachers rely on rote memorization and doctrinal
- 24:09recitation. Just read the page, memorize the
- 24:12verse, and let's move on. Because that is the
- 24:14only place they feel safe and confident. It's
- 24:16an omission born of fear. Dr. Akhtar points out
- 24:19that this aligns perfectly with broader systemic
- 24:21gaps in U .S. Islamic teacher education. Who
- 24:25else talks about this? He cites scholars like
- 24:27Nadeem Memon from 2011 and Claire Al -Kuwatli
- 24:30from 2018, who have extensively documented how
- 24:34under -resourced teacher training is in this
- 24:36specific sector. The tragic reality is that the
- 24:39analytical engagement with religious diversity
- 24:41doesn't fall out of the curriculum because of
- 24:43some malicious ideological design. Right. It
- 24:46falls out simply because nobody in the room feels
- 24:48equipped to handle the conversation. Wait, I
- 24:50have to challenge this expectation we put on
- 24:52educators, though. Okay, go ahead. If I am an
- 24:54underpaid, overworked teacher, and I am terrified
- 24:57of getting angry emails from parents, isn't sticking
- 25:01to rote memorization just a basic survival tactic?
- 25:04How can we possibly expect these teachers to
- 25:06be the bold vanguards of pluralism if we don't
- 25:10give them a safety net? It feels completely unfair.
- 25:13Oh, it is unfair. You cannot place the burden
- 25:15of repairing a thousand year intellectual gap
- 25:17on the shoulders of a sixth grade teacher who
- 25:19doesn't even have a decent textbook. Exactly.
- 25:21But recognizing this is actually the good news
- 25:24in Dr. Akhtar's findings. Good news. How so?
- 25:27Because a problem of resources, training and
- 25:29formation is a solvable problem. If the educators
- 25:32were driven by deep seated ideological hatred,
- 25:35that would be incredibly difficult to uproot.
- 25:38but a lack of training, a fear of parents. We
- 25:40know how to fix those structural issues. I see.
- 25:43But fixing it requires more than just like a
- 25:46new syllabus. Yes, much more. It requires a massive
- 25:49shift in perspective. It requires a fundamental
- 25:52paradigm shift in how these schools, the administrators,
- 25:55and most importantly, the parents view pluralism
- 25:58itself, which leads us to the pivot point of
- 26:01Dr. Akhtar's entire argument. Pluralism has to
- 26:04be seen as a recovery, not a concession. This
- 26:07is the absolute core of his message. And as he
- 26:09warns in his presentation, it is the most easily
- 26:12misheard part of his research. So we must be
- 26:14very clear. Let's lay it out. Integrating interfaith
- 26:17literacy into Islamic education is not a dilution
- 26:20of Islamic identity. It is not an attempt to
- 26:23appease a secular, liberal American version of
- 26:26pluralism. That is such a key distinction because
- 26:29I think a lot of conservative religious communities,
- 26:31and this is true whether they're Muslim, Christian
- 26:33or Orthodox Jewish, they hear the word pluralism
- 26:36or. interfaith, and their defenses immediately
- 26:39go up. Right. They see a threat. They think,
- 26:41oh, they want us to water down our beliefs so
- 26:43we can all hold hands and sing songs. They want
- 26:45us to say all paths are exactly the same and
- 26:47theology doesn't matter. Exactly. They view pluralism
- 26:50as a secular imposition from the outside, a threat
- 26:53to their distinctiveness. But Dr. Akhtar argues
- 26:57the exact opposite. He says this is a recovery
- 26:59of an authentically Islamic intellectual tradition.
- 27:02You aren't importing a Western secular concept.
- 27:05No, you are dusting off a classical Islamic one.
- 27:08He introduces this framework called covenantal
- 27:10pluralism, which he wrote about in the Journal
- 27:12of Interreligious Studies in 2024. And this is
- 27:16where his unique background becomes so rich.
- 27:19Yes, his Jain studies background really comes
- 27:21in here. Right. He draws on the Hebrew concept
- 27:23of Brit, which means covenant. He draws on the
- 27:26Medinan Mitak, the early Islamic covenant we
- 27:28discussed. And he synthesizes this with a profound
- 27:31Jain epistemology called Anakantavada. Let's
- 27:35really unpack Anakantavada for a moment because
- 27:37it provides the philosophical scaffolding for
- 27:39this recovery. Go for it. It is a core Jain concept
- 27:42that literally translates to many -sidedness.
- 27:45It is the idea that ultimate truth and reality
- 27:48are infinitely complex and have multiple aspects.
- 27:50So no one has the whole picture. Exactly. Therefore,
- 27:53no single specific human perspective can capture
- 27:57the absolute totality of truth. I think the classic
- 28:00analogy here is the blind man and the elephant,
- 28:02right? That is the perfect analogy. Several blind
- 28:04men touch an elephant to learn what it is like.
- 28:07One touches the trunk and says, it's like a snake.
- 28:09Another touches the leg and says, it's like a
- 28:12tree trunk. Another touches the side and says,
- 28:14it's like a wall. None of them are entirely wrong,
- 28:17but none of them possess the total truth of the
- 28:20elephant. They all have a piece of it. Yes. Anakantavada
- 28:24requires the humility to recognize that other
- 28:27perspectives hold fragments of the reality you're
- 28:30seeking. So Dr. Akhtar is pulling from his expertise
- 28:32in Jain studies, Jewish dialogue, and Islamic
- 28:35history to build this framework. But he insists
- 28:38the covenantal grammar, the capacity for this
- 28:41kind of many -sidedness. is already inside the
- 28:44Islamic tradition. Already there. The schools
- 28:46don't need to reinvent the wheel or borrow from
- 28:48secular sociology. The work is merely to remember
- 28:51what was forgotten. This raises an important
- 28:53question about the psychology of religious education
- 28:56itself. When you design a curriculum from a place
- 29:00of fear, fear of the secular world, fear of the
- 29:03Christian majority, fear of losing identity,
- 29:06you inevitably create brittle identities in your
- 29:10students. Brittle. That's a good word for it.
- 29:13A fortress might seem strong, but if the walls
- 29:15are rigid enough, they shatter when struck by
- 29:18an unexpected force. But when you teach from
- 29:21a place of historical confidence, like al -Biruni
- 29:25learning Sanskrit without a shred of fear that
- 29:28he'd lose his soul, you create something entirely
- 29:30different. You create resilient, deeply rooted
- 29:33students. Yes. They can step out of the fortress,
- 29:36walk into a diverse public square, and engage
- 29:38the religious other without feeling threatened.
- 29:40It completely changes their posture in the world.
- 29:43So what does this all mean for the schools today?
- 29:45It means realizing that embracing pluralism isn't
- 29:48about becoming more Western. It's about becoming
- 29:50more historically Islamic. That is the paradigm
- 29:54shift that unlocks everything else. Once the
- 29:56educators and the parents grasp that, the fear
- 29:59begins to dissipate. Pluralism stops being a
- 30:02secular threat and becomes a religious obligation.
- 30:05OK. Theory is great. The historical philosophy
- 30:08of the Mennonite covenant is beautiful. But I
- 30:11want to push back on the logistics here. OK.
- 30:13Let's get practical. How does a school actually
- 30:15implement this on a random Tuesday morning in
- 30:18November? We have to get practical. Dr. Akhtar
- 30:20proposes three specific pathways forward for
- 30:24the field. Yes. He moves from the theoretical
- 30:26to the highly actionable. The first pathway,
- 30:29and he argues this is the highest leverage intervention
- 30:31available, is teacher formation. Which makes
- 30:34total sense based on what we just uncovered.
- 30:36If the teachers are terrified of parental backlash,
- 30:38nothing changes. Exactly. This means targeted
- 30:41professional development specifically for Islamic
- 30:44studies, teachers in the areas of comparative
- 30:46religion, and facilitated dialogue pedagogy.
- 30:49So actually teaching the teachers how to teach
- 30:51this stuff. Yeah. Yes. As Oktar bluntly puts
- 30:54it, teachers cannot teach what they do not know.
- 30:58We have to invest in the educators first. We
- 31:01have to give them the theological grounding to
- 31:03know that it is OK to teach this and the pedagogical
- 31:06tools to manage complex, sensitive conversations
- 31:09in the classroom without panicking. Pathway number
- 31:13two is curricular resources, because you can't
- 31:16just train the teachers and then send them back
- 31:18to the classroom with the exact same heresiographical
- 31:20textbooks. Right. That would defeat the purpose.
- 31:22Right. Dr. Akhtar calls for developing textbook
- 31:25supplements that are grounded in Islamic sources.
- 31:28He points right back to the classical Malalwanyal
- 31:30genre we discussed earlier. He says, we do not
- 31:33need to invent a method. We need to remember
- 31:35one. These resources need to engage other traditions
- 31:38with theological generosity. And then we come
- 31:41to the third pathway, which is perhaps the most
- 31:43transformative, but also the most challenging.
- 31:45What's that? Lived partnerships. This is about
- 31:49establishing sustained pedagogical relationships
- 31:51with neighboring religious communities. We are
- 31:54talking about partnerships with local synagogues,
- 31:56churches, Hindu temples, and Sikh gudwaras. Now,
- 32:00I have to challenge this. Why? If I'm a teacher,
- 32:03who is already afraid of getting angry emails
- 32:04just for mentioning Judaism in a lecture. Actually,
- 32:08bringing my students to a synagogue feels like
- 32:11career suicide. How does Dr. Akhtar expect them
- 32:14to bridge that gap in reality? Well, he's very
- 32:17careful to distinguish this from what he calls
- 32:19performative interfaith gestures. We all know
- 32:22what those look like, right? The photo op where
- 32:25leaders from different faiths stand together,
- 32:28smile for the camera, maybe plant a tree, and
- 32:31then never speak to each other again. Right.
- 32:33That performative model is not what he is advocating
- 32:35for at all. To address your point about the teacher's
- 32:39fear, this is why the paradigm shift must happen
- 32:42at the administrative and parental level first.
- 32:44The school board has to sanction this. Oh, so
- 32:47the teacher isn't acting alone. Exactly. And
- 32:49when they do, Dr. Akhtar references the work
- 32:51of Eboo Patel, specifically his 2016 book, Inner
- 32:55Faith Leadership. Doc Star Oktar is calling for
- 32:58slow, respectful engagement across differences
- 33:01that is actually bumped into the rhythm of the
- 33:03school year. So it's not just a one -off field
- 33:05trip on a Thursday. It's an ongoing relationship.
- 33:08Exactly. Patel's model emphasizes that pluralism
- 33:12is a muscle. A muscle. Yes. You only learn it,
- 33:15you only build it by actually being in the room
- 33:17with people who are fundamentally different from
- 33:19you and navigating that space together. The students
- 33:23need to experience the lived reality of another
- 33:26community. I want to address you, the listener,
- 33:29directly for a second. Think about your own education,
- 33:32regardless of your religious or cultural background.
- 33:35Yeah, reflect on it. Did you learn the most about
- 33:38other cultures or other belief systems from reading
- 33:42a dry, defensive paragraph in a textbook? Or
- 33:45did you learn it from actually sitting next to
- 33:47someone? From sharing a meal with them, working
- 33:50on a community service project together, or just
- 33:52really listening to their story. The lived experience
- 33:55is where the empathy actually forms. Exactly.
- 33:57That lived experience is the modern equivalent
- 33:59of what Al -Biruni was doing a thousand years
- 34:01ago. He didn't just read a scroll about Hinduism.
- 34:04He went and lives with the community. And these
- 34:06schools have the opportunity to recreate that
- 34:08ethnographic curiosity for their students right
- 34:11in their own neighborhoods. It has been an incredible
- 34:14journey unpacking this. We started with the classical
- 34:16golden age scholars like Al -Biruni and Al -Jaristani
- 34:19modeling supreme intellectual confidence. Truly
- 34:22a golden age of curiosity. Then we move through
- 34:25the modern reality of fearful insular classrooms,
- 34:29the comparative deficit, the heresiographical
- 34:31lens. But we are ending on a genuinely hopeful
- 34:35note. We really are. The educators Dr. Akhtar
- 34:38interviewed aren't resistant to this change.
- 34:40They are hungry for it. They want to do the right
- 34:42thing for their students. They just need the
- 34:44permission, the training, and the resources to
- 34:46do it. As Dr. Akhtar concludes in his blog, the
- 34:49heritage is theirs. The classrooms are theirs.
- 34:52The work is theirs to reclaim. And we need to
- 34:54remember the broader civic implication here,
- 34:57too. This isn't just an internal theological
- 34:59debate for Islamic schools. No, it affects everyone.
- 35:02Right. The tens of thousands of young Muslims
- 35:04graduating from these institutions are stepping
- 35:06out into an American public square that is highly
- 35:09polarized. fearful, and often totally fractured.
- 35:13Islam, at its historical best, offers that public
- 35:17square a beautiful vision of human dignity grounded
- 35:20in divine intent. It's a vision we really need.
- 35:23The United States desperately needs the working
- 35:25philosophy of religious co -citizenship that
- 35:28was modeled in the Medinan Covenant all those
- 35:30centuries ago. The health of a diverse democracy
- 35:32relies entirely on citizens who are deeply rooted
- 35:35in their own convictions, yet entirely capable
- 35:38of extending grace, curiosity, and respect to
- 35:40their neighbors. So as we wrap up, I want to
- 35:42leave you with a final provocative thought. Okay,
- 35:45let's hear it. We've spent this time exploring
- 35:47how a return to ancient roots, the covenantal
- 35:50grammar of early Islam. is actually the key to
- 35:53modern pluralism for these specific schools.
- 35:55But let's extrapolate that out. What if we applied
- 35:58Dr. Oktar's concept of covenantal pluralism and
- 36:01that Jane idea of anacontovada, that reality
- 36:04is perceived differently from diverse points
- 36:06of view to everyone? It's a very compelling thought
- 36:08experiment. What would happen if every religious
- 36:10and secular institution in America stopped building
- 36:13defensive walls? What if every church, every
- 36:17synagogue, every secular university dug deep
- 36:20into their own ancient texts, their own founding
- 36:23documents to find their own hidden mandates for
- 36:26mutual recognition? That would change the country.
- 36:29Could the cure for our modern, hyper -polarized,
- 36:32fearful society actually be hiding right there
- 36:35in the dusty, forgotten pages of our oldest traditions?
- 36:38Maybe the way forward isn't inventing something
- 36:41new, but finally remembering what we already
- 36:43knew a long time ago. That is something worth
- 36:45pondering deeply. Thank you so much for joining
- 36:47us on this deep dive. Keep asking questions,
- 36:50keep looking for those hidden mandates, and keep
- 36:52seeking out multiple perspectives. Take care.