Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The Thick Red Line with Tory Haggerty
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:40Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:41This is Mark Treichel with another episode of with flying colors.
- 0:44I'm excited today to be back with a former guest of the podcast.
- 0:49Tori Hagerty.
- 0:50Tori, how you doing today?
- 0:52I'm great, Mark.
- 0:53I appreciate
- 0:53Tory Haggerty: you having me here today.
- 0:55Treichel: You got it.
- 0:55And it's it's exciting times later this week while we're recording this
- 0:59a little early later this week that I'm releasing this podcast, you've
- 1:03got your second book coming out, your first book we talked about on my last
- 1:07podcast, which was called unfair lending.
- 1:10What's the title of your new book that's coming out this week, Tori?
- 1:13Tory Haggerty: So my new book is called Thick Red Line, and we dive
- 1:17deeply into specific redlining in American communities and how redlining
- 1:22devastates our communities and how solving this problem can have our whole,
- 1:27allow our whole country to prosper.
- 1:29Treichel: Now that it's it's in the news a lot lately, both, all these topics
- 1:34tied to this, and I'm excited to do a little bit of a deep dive on your book.
- 1:38But for for.
- 1:40Obviously, most of my listeners are credit unions or people related
- 1:43to credit unions for listeners who didn't know who you were until this
- 1:49episode popped up on their app today.
- 1:52Give us a little bit of background.
- 1:53In addition to writing those two books, if you could give us a
- 1:56little background about the Tuscan.
- 1:58Consulting and what you did before that, et cetera, et cetera.
- 2:02That brought you to the point of being able to write these two great books.
- 2:05Tory Haggerty: Sure.
- 2:05Absolutely.
- 2:06I started my career as an examiner with the FDIC.
- 2:09That's really how I learned the trade of compliance and fair lending.
- 2:12Had the chance to go through their fair lending school, do
- 2:14dozens of fair lending exams.
- 2:16I went to work for a few different organizations after that, before
- 2:19starting my own company, Tuscan Club Consulting back in 2017.
- 2:23And I had several clients reach out to me right away, asking
- 2:26me to do a fair lending on it.
- 2:27And I quickly realized that not a lot of organizations do fair lending audits.
- 2:32And some of them that do, they're just pretty high level.
- 2:35And I said, yeah, absolutely.
- 2:37I can do a fair lending audit.
- 2:38I learned as an examiner, I know that the techniques I have access to tools.
- 2:42So I started doing them and then eventually.
- 2:45I had people ask me what are you doing?
- 2:47How do you do this?
- 2:48So then I started offering to train people.
- 2:51And then that sprouted into the idea, why not create a fair lending school?
- 2:55There's no commercially available fair lending school in the industry, at least
- 2:58not at the time when I created mine.
- 3:01So back in 2019, we got the idea.
- 3:03I literally spent a year of my life writing this manual, filming videos
- 3:07and creating the fair lending school under Tuscan club university and our
- 3:11fair lending expert FLE certification.
- 3:14And then over the span of my career, over a decade and a half and over 400
- 3:18exams and audits, I just, I saw so much.
- 3:23So many different organizations, so many different ways of doing things.
- 3:26Some of them really good, really smart.
- 3:27And some of them really bad and really dumb.
- 3:29And I collectively put those together, created the school.
- 3:34And then, I got the idea let's put this into a book.
- 3:37Not everyone's going to go through the fair lending school and not
- 3:38everyone should, it's really devoted to compliance officers and auditors.
- 3:43But what about the average lender?
- 3:45What about the average.
- 3:46President or CEO or chief credit officer.
- 3:48They need to learn these things too.
- 3:50So we summarize some of the best ideas, put them in the book.
- 3:53Now in the original book, unfair lending, we walk through the whole light loan
- 3:57life cycle of fair lending risks.
- 3:59It's not just redlining there's application risk and steering customers
- 4:02into products, obviously underwriting and pricing are big ones and several others.
- 4:06redlining is really the culmination of kind of fair lending overall.
- 4:12And.
- 4:13We just, I just determined that this really is a large enough
- 4:17topic to write another book on now.
- 4:20You probably heard of and most of the listeners probably have heard of the
- 4:23combating redlining initiative from 2021 from the federal government.
- 4:26And they basically said, we're going to really dig deep into this.
- 4:30And that's why we've seen so many redlining cases over the last 2 or
- 4:333 years, because the DOJ and the federal regulators are partnering
- 4:36to, try to put an end to redlining.
- 4:39The sad thing is, or the odd thing is these issues just keep getting
- 4:44repeated over and over and over again.
- 4:46I mean, you can look at redlining cases from 20 years ago, and the exact
- 4:49same problems are getting repeated over and over again, which leads me to
- 4:52believe that it's an education issue.
- 4:55We need to teach people, and that's what this book is focused on.
- 4:58Here's what the issues that you run into, here's how you fix them, here's some
- 5:02other things that lead to redlining risk.
- 5:04Treichel: Got it.
- 5:05So before we get into more of the details of what's in the books and,
- 5:09how financial institutions can do better, et cetera, et cetera let's
- 5:13do a reminder of the definition of redlining by law and, or by Tory.
- 5:20Tory Haggerty: The definition of redlining is long.
- 5:22It's a form of a legal disparate treatment in which an institution provides unequal
- 5:26access to credit or unequal terms.
- 5:28There's a long formal definition, but it basically means an organization
- 5:32is not lending in a particular geographic region and spoiler
- 5:36alert, it's high minority areas.
- 5:38So redlining dates back, nearly a century, well, probably longer than that, but
- 5:42really with the creation of the FHA in the 1930s, then later the VA, they
- 5:48literally would not approve home loans and guaranteed home loans for people of color.
- 5:53Now, notice I said the VA, and I mentioned this in my book,
- 5:56I'm a 20 year Air Force veteran.
- 5:57So that, it pains me to believe that an African American can go fight in
- 6:01World War II, three years, come back, and then can't get a home loan approved
- 6:05because of the color of their skin.
- 6:07And this happened for decades and the federal government along with state and
- 6:12local and municipal governments created neighborhoods and barred people of color
- 6:18from living there and people of color were not allowed to get home loans often
- 6:22had to rent government housing often run down far away from where you work.
- 6:27Near maybe landfills or power plants and undesirable areas.
- 6:31Obviously, that has higher pollution, which leads to more health issues, not
- 6:35building equity in a home, which is the best way for almost all families to build
- 6:40up wealth, including generational wealth.
- 6:43And that's why there's such a wealth gap in a home ownership gap between
- 6:47white and any other race of people in this country, because, anyone
- 6:52of color was just restricted from getting a home loan for so long.
- 6:55And it's so hard to catch up.
- 6:57And now with housing prices and, rates where they are.
- 7:00It's literally impossible unless we do something out
- 7:04of our way to make it happen.
- 7:06Treichel: And that red line that we're referring to was literally a red
- 7:09line on a map that said where people could and could not, could not live.
- 7:14Tory Haggerty: It was basically maps for banks to say what are
- 7:16desirable areas and undesirable areas.
- 7:19Desirable areas implying white neighborhoods.
- 7:22Undesirable areas implying neighborhoods with, minority individuals.
- 7:26And the red shaded neighborhoods where those were people of color resided
- 7:31and that's where you don't make loans.
- 7:32That was the whole.
- 7:33That's a great summary here.
- 7:34Treichel: Yep.
- 7:35Yep.
- 7:35That's a great summary as we now we'll start a deep dive.
- 7:38And you can go
- 7:38Tory Haggerty: out and Google those too.
- 7:40For anyone that doesn't believe me, which I don't think there are
- 7:42many, but literally Google red line maps and boom, every major
- 7:45metro area has them pretty much.
- 7:47Treichel: Interesting.
- 7:48Yep.
- 7:48No that's Again, a great primer for what we want to chat about here today.
- 7:52Redlining examples, you talked about the different examples you've seen
- 7:56in all the audits you've done and probably the people that you've taught
- 7:58have told, I've shown you some others.
- 8:00You said there's a definite theme to the mistakes that are happening.
- 8:04What would you say most redlining cases actually have in common?
- 8:09Tory Haggerty: Yeah, that's a great question one of the first things that
- 8:11we look at is brand is their branching structure So we want to know or the
- 8:16regulators want to know do you have branches in high minority areas?
- 8:19Oftentimes they use the term majority minority census tracts a census track is
- 8:24just a smaller subdivision of a county, and they look to see does a lending
- 8:30institution actually have branches in and around these high minority areas.
- 8:35So, number one, we look at your branching structure.
- 8:37Number two, the applications that an organization has received.
- 8:41If you receive applications two and three and four times less
- 8:45often, from high minority areas and minority individuals than your
- 8:50peers are, that's a major red flag.
- 8:53The next thing we look at, factor number three, is advertising
- 8:56and marketing efforts.
- 8:58Now, you can have branches in high minority areas or near them, but if you
- 9:03are not advertising and marketing in those areas, or another issue that we've seen
- 9:08a lot lately is devoting lenders to those areas, most specifically mortgage lenders.
- 9:14If, You have a branch, one branch in a high minority area.
- 9:17You're not marketing, you're not advertising, and you don't
- 9:19have any mortgage lenders there.
- 9:21Guess what?
- 9:21You're probably not going to get applications and you're
- 9:23not going to be making loans.
- 9:25The fourth factor, we look at loan origination rates.
- 9:27Now this is one where we use ratios a lot.
- 9:30If you have good, if you're a HMDA reporter where you have to collect
- 9:33information on all your home loan applications, And you have significant
- 9:37data, and sometimes that can even be a few hundred applications is enough to get
- 9:41some good indicators on your performance.
- 9:43You can employ fair lending software, either purchase the software yourself or
- 9:48have somebody review it for you and look and see what are our origination rates.
- 9:53Two minority individuals in high minority areas compared to peers.
- 9:57When you are two, three, and four times lagging behind what peers are
- 10:00doing, those cases, those are cases that have been settled by the DOJ.
- 10:04Those have already been referred and settled.
- 10:06So I've seen, and had clients that are five and six times behind there.
- 10:10So what we do is we identify those issues and those anomalies and
- 10:14determine what the root cause is.
- 10:16And then immediately put corrective action in place.
- 10:18If you catch these things early and you're serious about it and you devote the
- 10:22resources to fix these problems, I've had clients where we found these issues early,
- 10:27they've implemented corrective action.
- 10:29The regulators said, okay, we're good with that, but you better, make
- 10:33good on your promises and we're going to be reviewing that and they have
- 10:37staved off, referrals to the DOJ.
- 10:39The fifth factor I like to talk about is product offerings.
- 10:42If you don't offer products.
- 10:45In an area that people are going to qualify for, they're probably
- 10:47not going to get loans from you.
- 10:49Because of the racist history of our country in barring people
- 10:55of color from home loans, they appear less credit worthy.
- 10:59Okay?
- 11:00A credit score is a great example.
- 11:01A credit score is not a perfect process.
- 11:04It takes your, repayment history and your debt utilization on
- 11:07a lot of different things and comes up with a numerical score.
- 11:11What about somebody who rents?
- 11:12If you're, if your family or you've been barred from getting a home
- 11:16loan, you got to live somewhere.
- 11:17That means you're going to rent, but rent doesn't get reported to the credit
- 11:20bureau oftentimes where a mortgage does.
- 11:22So somebody could be for the last 10 years living, and paying their mortgage
- 11:26every, or paying the rent every single month and not get credit for it.
- 11:29Therefore they're going to look less credit worthy on paper.
- 11:32If we don't consider other factors like that.
- 11:35Factor number six is community involvement.
- 11:38With banks and credit unions, one of the best ways to get customers and be
- 11:42involved with your community is know those community members and those organizations
- 11:47that can reach the people that you are potentially currently not reaching.
- 11:51Those high minority areas, those minority individuals, sometimes
- 11:55low and moderate income areas.
- 11:57So those are some of the things that, that we see as continual problems.
- 12:04That pop up in almost every single redlining case.
- 12:06It's just like one gets copied and then we slap another organization's name on there
- 12:11and it just gets repeated over and over,
- 12:13Treichel: As you're going through those, I got my mind's popping in a few
- 12:17different directions but so just a general statement, there, there's intentional and
- 12:21there's unintentional and there's bias and there's unconscious bias and some of the
- 12:25things I think probably some of the, yeah.
- 12:27Listeners are probably hearing some of those things going,
- 12:29Oh, I could do better in this.
- 12:30And I could do better in that.
- 12:31And we can maybe get into that a little bit, but one other, so you talked about
- 12:35advertising and if you don't advertise in a particular area you're, they're not
- 12:40going to know what you have available and they're not going to come into the branch.
- 12:43And then they're not presuming you have a good brand structure.
- 12:46And advertising has kind of morphed over time, right?
- 12:49It used to be when.
- 12:51When when these maps we talked about were published in hard copy advertising
- 12:56was the morning and the afternoon paper, then it went from just the two
- 13:00papers a day to the morning paper.
- 13:02And today you got, you got people that, and TV over the air versus cable.
- 13:08And it, advertising on Facebook, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:12When I throw that out there Advertising today versus advertising in the
- 13:17days long ago, does that trigger any examples or of any situations where,
- 13:23aha, someone could do better on advertising in today's world in this way?
- 13:28Tory Haggerty: If you have issues with redlining, if your application rates
- 13:32and your loan origination rates are lagging significantly behind peers, one
- 13:35of the first places regulators go is your marketing, is your advertising.
- 13:39Are you even advertising in these areas?
- 13:41And you can't really use advertising as an excuse anymore.
- 13:44Yes.
- 13:45Back in the day when there was only a few networks and maybe TV was the most
- 13:49prevalent advertising that was expensive.
- 13:51And you're broadcasting it over a mass market.
- 13:53Now you have obviously local markets.
- 13:55If you work in a Metro area, you can do as well, but now you can target
- 13:59market into certain geographies, into certain individuals, if you do that,
- 14:03when it comes to loan products, though, the equal credit opportunity access,
- 14:06you can't discriminate based on race, color, religion, sex, and national
- 14:09origin, and there's other characteristics in the fair housing act as well, age
- 14:13and marital status, things like that.
- 14:14So when you target market an area, a lot of times what organizations
- 14:17will do is they'll geo fence.
- 14:19In other words, they will say everyone within, two miles or
- 14:22five miles of our branches, that's where we're going to market.
- 14:23And that's generally safe, but guess what?
- 14:26If you don't have branches in high minority areas, you're not going
- 14:28to market in high minority areas.
- 14:29So there are things that you need to be aware of.
- 14:33But yeah, the first thing you do is you look at why aren't
- 14:35you taking an application?
- 14:37You don't have any branches there.
- 14:38You're not marketing there.
- 14:39You can't expect somebody to drive 30 minutes to your closest location, pass,
- 14:43five banks and credit unions on the way or not want to go online and come into
- 14:47your branch and fill out an application.
- 14:49Treichel: Yeah.
- 14:49Great example.
- 14:50Great example.
- 14:51As I mentioned I, my audience is credit unions or credit union listening today.
- 14:57Who's going, gosh, I might have some blind spots here.
- 15:00What would you recommend they do so that they could identify those blind spots
- 15:06or any issues that they may be where they're not meeting their members needs
- 15:09in the way that they actually should.
- 15:11Tory Haggerty: Yeah, absolutely.
- 15:12Some of the things that we covered are great ways, looking at what
- 15:16your brand structure is, figuring out what your marketing is.
- 15:19Doing a fair lending audit, if you don't know how to do a fair lending audit,
- 15:22that's one of the things that our fair lending school teaches you how to do.
- 15:25It's tcuniversity.
- 15:27us for Tuscan Club University and our fair lending school, it's designed
- 15:31for audit and compliance professionals on how to do these types of reviews.
- 15:35You can also pay, external auditors to do audits.
- 15:38We also do audits as well, but we're a pretty small company.
- 15:41Some of the corrective actions to put in place, though, so we talked
- 15:44about what are some of the issues and how do you identify those?
- 15:46Now, if you find those issues, what are you supposed to do?
- 15:48Number one, obviously, open some branches in previous red line areas.
- 15:52There are tools out there with the fair lending software that will
- 15:55geocode your branch locations, overlay it on a minority map.
- 16:01And it will show you where your branches are and where they are not and how
- 16:04they are avoiding high minority areas.
- 16:06And guess what?
- 16:07They often make what's called a horseshoe.
- 16:08If you don't know what a horseshoe is, it's like the letter C,
- 16:11except, maybe turn sideways.
- 16:12But a horseshoe basically is where the branches surround.
- 16:16high minority areas, but they're not in those high minority areas.
- 16:20Now, obviously opening a branch is not cheap either, especially
- 16:22if you're going to have cash and a vault and all the security.
- 16:24So sometimes a loan production office is a great way to get yourself a
- 16:28physical presence in an area, test it out for much cheaper than a branch.
- 16:33And organizations use those as well to see is this area going to be profitable?
- 16:38And oftentimes they turn it The second one is doing a community needs assessment.
- 16:43And that's where you go out and you say, okay, let's figure out
- 16:46what our community actually needs.
- 16:48Do we need low income housing?
- 16:50Do we need, to finance small businesses?
- 16:53Or, what kind of needs does our area, basically talking with individuals,
- 16:58talking with real estate agents, talking with the small business administration,
- 17:02talking with experts in the industry to find out, Okay, are our credit products
- 17:06matched up with the needs of our area?
- 17:08The third one is forming those community partnerships, getting
- 17:11your loan officers and getting your, management team out into the community
- 17:16and becoming members of these groups and reaching out to these groups.
- 17:19Oftentimes one or two connections in the right group can get your foot in the door.
- 17:23And I've seen it over and over again, especially with immigrant populations
- 17:28who have a language barrier.
- 17:30Let's imagine Mark, you move your entire family over to Japan and you don't speak
- 17:35a word of Japanese, but then all of a sudden you find one bank over there
- 17:40that has English speaking personnel.
- 17:42Guess what?
- 17:43You're probably going to bank with them and then you're going to tell
- 17:45your family and your friends who also moved over there with you.
- 17:47Hey, these guys understand us, so it's a matter of meeting those community
- 17:52needs and forming those partnerships.
- 17:54The next one is a loan subsidy fund.
- 17:56You don't have to go out of your way to do this, but this is one of
- 17:59the items that frequently shows up in every settled redlining case.
- 18:05The regulators force you to create a loan subsidy fund, which is used to
- 18:09subsidize loans for people that need them.
- 18:11They otherwise couldn't afford it.
- 18:12And that could buy down rates that could buy down or help
- 18:15with down payment assistance.
- 18:16And, Make payments more affordable.
- 18:18Another one is special credit purpose special credit special
- 18:21purpose credit programs.
- 18:23And that's basically where you develop products specifically to meet areas
- 18:27or meet needs of those individuals that otherwise wouldn't qualify.
- 18:32Now, one of the downfalls with that is if you see a need for a special credit.
- 18:37Credit product in your area, see who else is offering it as well, because if
- 18:41three or four other organizations are offering it, you offering it may not have
- 18:45as much impact as another product would.
- 18:48And then of course, invest in marketing and advertising, take some
- 18:51money and invest it into, to Google searches and Google advertising.
- 18:55So when they search best deposit account, best consumer loan, best
- 18:58home loan, your name shows up.
- 19:01Invest in social media marketing, And then the last one is you can hire experts to
- 19:06assess your compliance management system.
- 19:08Every fair lending review we do, that's the heart of the fair lending review
- 19:11is, do you have policies in place?
- 19:13Are they clear?
- 19:14Are your procedures clear?
- 19:15Are they free from guesswork?
- 19:17Are you training your individuals?
- 19:18What type of monitoring and auditing are you doing?
- 19:21Having somebody that understands that and then gets into the testing,
- 19:24then test interest rates, then test denial rates, then looks at HMDA data.
- 19:29And that can tell you where your holes are and where you have room for improvement.
- 19:33Treichel: That loan subsidy fund.
- 19:34I like that.
- 19:35It's if you see it and if you see it as a resolution on how to get back
- 19:39to doing it right, why not build it in on the front end as part of the
- 19:44offerings that you do have to make sure that you are doing all that you can.
- 19:49I like that a lot.
- 19:50Tory Haggerty: If your listeners are wondering how I came up with my list.
- 19:53I read every single enforcement action.
- 19:56There were about a dozen of them in 2023 and I studied them and I took
- 20:01notes and I said, what do we see in pretty much every single one of these?
- 20:04And these enforcement actions are set out to ensure that a bank or a credit union
- 20:09or even a mortgage company, yeah, actually makes a difference and fixes these issues.
- 20:13So why not steal those ideas and start them now before you're forced to.
- 20:18Treichel: Yep.
- 20:18Love it.
- 20:18Love it.
- 20:19Love it.
- 20:20We've talked a little bit, I think, last time we were you were on the podcast, we
- 20:25talked a little bit about appraisal bias.
- 20:27Any thoughts on the link of appraisal bias to the topic of redlining and
- 20:35anything you'd want to discuss on that?
- 20:39Tory Haggerty: Yeah, absolutely.
- 20:40So appraisal bias, I hate using a buzzword or a hot topic because this
- 20:44is a major issue and it's been a major issue for a long, long time.
- 20:48So I hate when people even say fair lending is a hot topic.
- 20:51It's not it's something that we need to do.
- 20:53It's something we must do just because the regulators are focusing on it
- 20:57more doesn't mean it's a hot topic.
- 20:59It's a major issue and it always has been.
- 21:02So appraisal bias is basically where an appraiser is.
- 21:06allows their personal bias or unconscious bias to come through
- 21:10in the appraisal process.
- 21:11So it's not like buying a car.
- 21:13You go out to the, Kelly Blue Book or NADA, and it gives you
- 21:16a pretty fair value, right?
- 21:18You may put your zip code in there because it wants to know what part of
- 21:20the country you're in, but it doesn't know what neighborhood you live in.
- 21:23It doesn't know your race.
- 21:24It basically says, here's a fair market value of your vehicle.
- 21:27Obviously on a mortgage or on a home loan, if you've ever went through that process,
- 21:30which a lot of your listeners have.
- 21:33We don't have that.
- 21:34You can't plug and play and get a value out there.
- 21:36A person has to go out there, a licensed appraiser, and give their value based on
- 21:40a lot of factors, based on comps, based on improvements, based on the market.
- 21:44Unconscious bias comes through, and those appraisals are often devalued
- 21:50by sometimes as much as 50 percent for individuals of color, or if a home
- 21:55is located, In a high minority area.
- 21:58So there have been a several major cases lately, but the Austin's out in
- 22:04the San Francisco Marin County region.
- 22:06I do reference them in my book.
- 22:09They were one of a one of the big examples.
- 22:11So back in about 2016, they had purchased a home and they spent a lot of money
- 22:16and did a lot of renovations on it.
- 22:18And the original home, they, I think they purchased for
- 22:21just under a million dollars.
- 22:22And.
- 22:23Through all these renovations and whatnot, the value is up to about 1.
- 22:254 million.
- 22:27And then they go back in to refinance it all, put it into OneNote, and the,
- 22:32they just had an appraisal done a year prior, and then they had a female
- 22:36white appraiser come out and they appraised the value at about 950, 000.
- 22:41And they knew this is, this can't be, there's no way it was just appraised
- 22:44for almost a half a million dollars more than that just a year ago.
- 22:47So they complained to the bank and the bank said, yeah, let's get another
- 22:50appraisal and what they did was they caught, they whitewashed their home.
- 22:54Now, if you're a person of color listening, this is probably old news to
- 22:57you, a 40 year old white male like me living in, the middle of upper Midwest
- 23:02and South Dakota, I've never heard of this term before a few years ago.
- 23:05And essentially whitewashing is where you.
- 23:07You remove all evidence of who lives there.
- 23:09Now, when you sell your home, it's probably a good idea anyway.
- 23:12You don't want pictures of your family all over the place because people won't
- 23:15imagine that their family lives there.
- 23:17They'll see your family.
- 23:18But what about the Austins?
- 23:19They're just refinancing.
- 23:20Why do they have to pull down pictures of their, of their
- 23:22family and things like that.
- 23:24So they whitewashed their home.
- 23:25They pulled everything off the walls and they actually went so far as to have a
- 23:28white neighbor pose as the homeowner.
- 23:31On the new appraisal came back almost 500, 000 higher and higher than the one
- 23:36a year prior, which is pretty common.
- 23:38Although, appraisals can fluctuate in the short term and of course, and they filed
- 23:42a complaint and it's settled out of court, but issues like this happen all the time.
- 23:47And oftentimes the average consumer may not know it.
- 23:50They may suspect it.
- 23:52They may say, Hey, that value seems artificially low.
- 23:55Now, in this case, it was so obvious that it was an easy slam dunk and they had
- 23:59the resources and they wanted to fight it and they did and they took it to court.
- 24:02And there's a few other cases of that where it happens, but
- 24:04oftentimes we don't know it.
- 24:06So how can a lender, how can a credit union.
- 24:10Or ensure these things don't happen because there was a recent court ruling
- 24:13as well, that basically says you as an organization, you as a lender, if you
- 24:17rely on an appraisal that we know has appraisal bias, that is artificially
- 24:24low, and you could have, or should have known that you can be held liable.
- 24:28So now some of this liability is falling on lenders,
- 24:31following on underwriting staff.
- 24:34The biggest thing you could do is number one, understand your area.
- 24:37Be educated.
- 24:38What is the typical value, a home value in this area?
- 24:41Number two, if you suspect something, say something.
- 24:44I understand appraisals are slow, and they are expensive.
- 24:48But if you know that something is wrong, you have to say something.
- 24:51Challenge the valuation.
- 24:53Work with the appraiser, and if they're unwilling to work with you, and you
- 24:56know that this appraisal is not good, Then you have to go out and get a second
- 25:00one is basically what they're saying.
- 25:02So it's a matter of understanding and knowing.
- 25:05And if you see something, say something, cause bury your, burying your head in
- 25:08the sand is no longer going to fly.
- 25:11And it's unfortunate.
- 25:12And it's a lot of training that needs to be done, not just in the lending
- 25:16industry, but in the appraisal industry and as more of these cases happen,
- 25:20hopefully we'll see them less and less, but as of right now, it's still
- 25:23a major issue that we're working with.
- 25:26Treichel: That's a great example.
- 25:27And so the, you talk about the lending industry, you talk
- 25:29about the appraisal industry.
- 25:30Are there any other players that we should discuss here today that play a
- 25:34role in this type of discrimination?
- 25:37Tory Haggerty: There is.
- 25:38And, Mark I'm not here to throw anyone under the bus.
- 25:41I'm very impartial.
- 25:42I'm not a, I'm not a political guy.
- 25:45I think both.
- 25:46Political parties are terrible and most politicians are terrible, but, I'm just
- 25:51here's the facts and I see them and that's how I present them and a lot of
- 25:55people like the fair lending school that I built and they liked the books because
- 25:58I don't really have a lot of bias.
- 26:00I, or I might, I just, I try not to let that come out.
- 26:03So that disclaimer out of the way the real estate agent industry is another big one.
- 26:08And this is one that really hit me.
- 26:10Oh, I don't know, maybe six months after the last book came out in 2022.
- 26:15Now I live in the upper Midwest.
- 26:17I live in South Dakota in the biggest community in Sioux Falls.
- 26:19Not a lot of, minority population, maybe 15%, but there was a major bank and I
- 26:25don't even remember which bank it was.
- 26:26If I remembered, I wouldn't even say it, but a major bank came out with
- 26:29a special purpose credit program and it was designed to help people of
- 26:33color get into homes because of the reasons why we've already explained,
- 26:37because they've been denied these.
- 26:39Opportunities for a century or longer.
- 26:41And so this bank came out with a special credit program to help, black
- 26:46and Latinos in a certain metro area.
- 26:48I don't remember what metro area was.
- 26:50Let's just say it was Dallas and a local realtor, a real estate agent
- 26:55saw that and shared the story.
- 26:57And they just said, this is illegal.
- 26:58You can't do that.
- 27:00And somebody knew who I was and knew what I did.
- 27:04And I just wrote a book on this and they forwarded it to me.
- 27:06They're like, Tori, look at this.
- 27:08What are you going to, what are you going to do?
- 27:09And so of course I just, Oh what's illegal about it?
- 27:12What law is it breaking?
- 27:13And it, and their response was all of them.
- 27:15And I'm like, could you be more specific?
- 27:17And they're like there's federal laws that prevent this.
- 27:19And so obviously I know right off the bat, they have no idea
- 27:21what they're talking about.
- 27:22So I start actually the equal credit equal credit opportunity act, fair housing act.
- 27:26This is what it says.
- 27:27This is what you can and can't do.
- 27:29Here's a brief history of why we need these programs.
- 27:31So explain to me what's going on here.
- 27:33And then in the meantime.
- 27:35You're friends with a lot of other people that you work with and in your profession.
- 27:38So this person that made the post had a lot of real estate agents that were
- 27:41friends and they started commenting, you can't do this, you can't do that.
- 27:44And it just blew up.
- 27:45And as I'm watching this unfold over the span of about 20 minutes, Oh, right after
- 27:51supper one evening, I just realized, I've been so ingrained In banking and mortgage
- 27:59and credit unions and just lending.
- 28:02Treichel: Right.
- 28:02Tory Haggerty: And I haven't considered appraisers.
- 28:03I haven't considered real estate agents.
- 28:05I haven't considered policymakers.
- 28:08And when I started watching this unfold, I just thought, wow this problem
- 28:13is way bigger than I ever expected.
- 28:16While I was doing research for my current book.
- 28:19I had, I spoke with an expert in the appraisal industry and yeah, I'm
- 28:23doing, research on appraisal bias and whitewashing and things like that.
- 28:27And I interviewed this person and they told me to go to this
- 28:32appraiser Facebook group and they said, yeah, this is a big one.
- 28:36They're a little bit lax on who they let in.
- 28:38Just fib it a little bit.
- 28:39And so you work in the industry, which I do, and they let me join.
- 28:43And this person said, you will be amazed at some of the comments
- 28:46that you will see in here.
- 28:48And I'm like, okay, I'll join.
- 28:50I'll monitor for a few weeks and I'll see what happens.
- 28:52They let me in.
- 28:53And the very first post was some of the just worst, most
- 28:58racist crap I'd ever seen.
- 29:00Somebody posed a question and said, how are you using the term master bedroom?
- 29:05Are you still using that?
- 29:06Are you replacing it?
- 29:06Master bedroom implies, an homage to slavery.
- 29:10And my wife and I, we watch all the HGTV shows and we've known over the
- 29:14last two or three years, they don't use that term, they use primary.
- 29:16They stopped using it.
- 29:17They
- 29:17Treichel: stopped using it.
- 29:18Yeah.
- 29:18Primary
- 29:18Tory Haggerty: Or secondary bedroom or primary bathroom.
- 29:20I was like it makes sense.
- 29:21I understood why it's a racist term.
- 29:24And then of course as people are like what, why are you changing it?
- 29:27When are we gonna stop having master's degrees and master
- 29:30plumbers and all this other stuff?
- 29:31And somebody responds to that and they're like, we're trying to, be
- 29:34sensitive and change with the times.
- 29:36And then a whole bunch of people, laughed at that and thought that was ridiculous.
- 29:40And of course there was all these other just really insensitive
- 29:43comments, which leads me to believe.
- 29:44I'm like, do you understand the history that we're fighting against and the
- 29:51problems that we're fighting against?
- 29:52And when you can't acknowledge these problems.
- 29:56Even something as simple as terminology and the, so the appraisal industry, the
- 30:01lending industry, real estate agents, it's a hard problem and it's going to,
- 30:06it's going to be a hard one to solve.
- 30:08And, at the beginning of my book I make the argument deliberately racist policies.
- 30:13And a lack of education got us where we are today.
- 30:15And by that, the racist policies implemented by the government, not
- 30:19allowing people of color to buy homes and the lack of education, which,
- 30:23I've described a lot of examples.
- 30:24And then at the end of the book, I talk about deliberately anti racist policies.
- 30:29In other words, special purpose credit programs and loan subsidies
- 30:32and doing things to make sure people that cannot afford a home
- 30:36loan because we've discriminated against them for so long, get access.
- 30:40And the education piece.
- 30:41I don't set policy and I don't ever want to be a politician.
- 30:44So there's probably a little I can do on that, but I can
- 30:47help on the education side.
- 30:49And that's why I'm writing books and that's why I'm doing podcasts.
- 30:51And that's why, I speak on this topic often because I feel the more people
- 30:56that understand these problems and the root causes of them and what
- 30:58it's going to take to fix them.
- 31:00The more actual impact we're going to have.
- 31:02And, one of my life goals is to see an ending to, discrimination
- 31:06in the lending industry.
- 31:07And I know that's a big lofty goal, but I'm going to do whatever I can to
- 31:10make a dent in that before I'm done.
- 31:12Treichel: It's a good goal.
- 31:13And it reminds me, it makes me think we've come so far, but then those
- 31:17examples show that we have so far to go.
- 31:19And there's a quote, we haven't come this far.
- 31:22Just to come this far, there's a long way to go and a lot more improvement,
- 31:25a lot more improvement to come.
- 31:27There's no doubt your book and your training is is adding to
- 31:31people's abilities to do that.
- 31:33So Tori, if if I haven't, if there's a question I should have
- 31:37asked you today that I haven't, what would that be and what would
- 31:40you have to say in response to it?
- 31:42Tory Haggerty: I just re echo, just become educated, become educated on
- 31:46this topic and learn more about it.
- 31:48My books this is my second book.
- 31:50Now they're quick reads.
- 31:51They take about two hours to read, maybe even less.
- 31:54I realized that if it's a topic you're not highly interested in, you're not going to
- 31:58spend 10 or 15 hours reading through it.
- 32:01And actually on Thursday, on May 23rd, we're having a free download on Amazon.
- 32:07So at 9 AM, you can hop on Amazon, download the book for free, spend an
- 32:11hour and a half, spend the 30 minutes.
- 32:13And if it's not for you, it's not for you, but you spend the 30 minutes,
- 32:15you're going to be a fourth of the way through the book and you're going to
- 32:18start seeing, okay, there is a lot more to us, to this than, what I realized.
- 32:23And it's the education piece that I'm trying to do.
- 32:27And the more people I can get.
- 32:29To understand these problems and especially in the lending
- 32:32industry where, I spend my time.
- 32:34I'm a compliance auditor by trade and I audit clients across the country to
- 32:39try to find these problems internally.
- 32:41But guess what?
- 32:42If we for all educated on it, we build prevention into our programs, which
- 32:46is what I addressed in my first book.
- 32:48And we don't really need auditors.
- 32:50We don't really need those types of things.
- 32:52Now That's a nice way to think about it and it may never happen.
- 32:55I know, Mark, you spent your career in the regulatory industry and your
- 32:58company too, helps credit unions suffer through and get through their exams
- 33:03just the same way I do on the bank side.
- 33:05And there will always be a need for us and what we do, but just
- 33:09imagine if people were educated on these things and implemented them.
- 33:13Simple corrective action internally, the impact we can have on our nation.
- 33:17And the last thing I want to say is when you have whole communities and
- 33:22whole groups of individuals that can't buy a home, let, take an entire
- 33:26neighborhood in any metro area.
- 33:28Guess what?
- 33:28If you don't have all these homeowners and small business owners, you're
- 33:32not going to collect that much in property taxes and income taxes.
- 33:35So what does that mean?
- 33:36You have less tax revenue.
- 33:39Which means you have less support, you have less fire, hospitals are
- 33:43run down, schools are run down.
- 33:45So these communities become impoverished and generationally they're impoverished.
- 33:50Guess what?
- 33:50If we actually get them access to credit, get them in a home, start
- 33:54building equity, make sure they can go to college, make sure they can start
- 33:57a business, those communities will start to prosper and we will start
- 34:01to see poverty shrink in our country.
- 34:04So whether or not you're a minority, whether or not you've been redlined,
- 34:08whether or not where you live, if we can solve these problems, every
- 34:11community will become stronger.
- 34:13Our country will become stronger.
- 34:15We'll have more revenue and everyone will prosper for it.
- 34:18So if that's a selfish reason and that's the only reason, then fine.
- 34:22Whatever reason you have to get educated and do something is going to
- 34:26be good enough for me at this point.
- 34:27Treichel: That's a great place to wrap, Tori.
- 34:30Great summary there.
- 34:31And so if someone's listening and number one, they need to take advantage of that
- 34:36free download on Amazon later this week, number two, after they read it, or if they
- 34:41just listen to this and they want to reach out to see how you might be able to help
- 34:45them with training or otherwise, or just converse with something you've said here,
- 34:49what's the best way for them to find you?
- 34:52Tory Haggerty: Mark.
- 34:52It's a great question.
- 34:53Find me on LinkedIn.
- 34:54First of all, I'm very active on there.
- 34:56Just search Tory Hagerty.
- 34:57You'll find me on LinkedIn or you can shoot me an email as well.
- 35:00Tory T O R Y at TC consulting.
- 35:03us.
- 35:03You can go to our website, TC consulting.
- 35:06us is our consulting website.
- 35:08TC university.
- 35:09us is where we house our fair learning school.
- 35:11So any of those are.
- 35:12Great ways to get ahold of me.
- 35:13I love connecting with people on LinkedIn and sharing ideas.
- 35:16I'm a lifelong learner.
- 35:17So I read, on appraisal bias and AI, that might be my next book.
- 35:21I don't know, I'm trying to always learn and I learned from other people.
- 35:24LinkedIn is a great way to get ahold of me and share ideas.
- 35:27Treichel: That's great.
- 35:28Thanks, Tori.
- 35:29Thank you for your time today, Tori.
- 35:30Appreciate it.
- 35:32All right, Mark.
- 35:32Thanks so much for having me.
- 35:34You got it.
- 35:34And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 35:36I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 35:38This is Mark Treichel signing off.
- 35:40With flying colors.
- 35:47Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 35:51your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 35:55of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 35:59If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 36:02out our services at marktreichel.
- 36:04com.