Latest / B2B SaaS Talks with Fexingo: Enterprise Software, Sales Cycles, and Procurement / The One Number That Predicts Enterprise Software Renewals
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this number that a lot of enterprise SaaS companies obsess over — it's not revenue, it's not churn rate, it's something they call the 'adoption score.' And I think it actually predicts renewals better than any other metric I've seen. Luna: Adoption score — I've heard that term bounced around in customer success teams. What exactly is it? A composite of login frequency and feature usage? Lucas: Basically, yes. But the specific formula varies. The one I find most interesting comes from a mid-market ERP company I talked to — private equity backed, about 350 employees. They score each account monthly on a scale from 0 to 100, and the inputs are: daily active users relative to licensed seats, number of modules or features active, and something they call 'stickiness' — like, do users come back within a 7-day window? Luna: Right, so it's not just logging in once a month. It's about habitual use. That makes sense. Lucas: Exactly. And what they found — after looking at three years of renewal data — is that any account with an adoption score below 40 at the six-month mark had a 78 percent probability of churning at the next renewal. Above 65, the renewal rate was 94 percent. Luna: Those are stark numbers. So they're identifying at-risk accounts halfway through the contract, not waiting until the last quarter. Lucas: Right. And the real insight is that contract value alone doesn't tell you much. They had a $2 million dollar account that scored a 35 — and sure enough, they almost lost it. Meanwhile, a $200,000 account with a score of 80 renewed without any exec intervention. Luna: So the big accounts aren't necessarily safe. That's a tough lesson for sales leaders who think 'high revenue equals low risk.' Lucas: It is. And here's the thing — procurement teams are starting to ask for this data. Some buyers now include a clause in the contract requiring the vendor to share quarterly adoption reports. They want proof that their employees are actually using the software before they agree to a multi-year renewal. Luna: That's a massive shift. A few years ago, procurement just looked at price and compliance. Now they're acting like a mini customer success team. Lucas: Yeah, I think it signals that enterprise software buying is maturing. The CFO wants to know: are we getting value from this tool? And adoption score is the closest proxy they have. Luna: So if you're a vendor, you'd better be tracking this internally before the buyer asks. Otherwise you're caught flat-footed. Lucas: Exactly. And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, I'll just mention — a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Yeah, it makes a real difference. Keeps us independent and ad-free. Lucas: So back to the adoption score — the ERP company I mentioned, they also found that the score tends to plateau after month three. If it hasn't crossed 50 by then, it rarely ever does. Luna: That's a critical window. So the first quarter of a contract is everything for onboarding and training. Lucas: Absolutely. They now assign a customer success manager within the first week — not just a sales handoff — and they run a structured 30-60-90 day adoption plan. The CSM's bonus is tied to the adoption score, not just renewal dollars. Luna: That changes incentives entirely. Instead of chasing a signature at the end, they're chasing actual usage from day one. Lucas: Right. And it's not just a vendor tool. I've talked to a couple of procurement leaders who use their own internal adoption tracking — they poll department heads quarterly on a 1-to-5 scale for each major software tool. They cross-reference that with login data from IT. Luna: So they're building their own version of an adoption score. That's smart. It gives them leverage at renewal time. Lucas: Exactly. One procurement director told me, 'If your tool scores below a 3, I'm not approving a price increase. Period.' That's a hard line. Luna: So the adoption score is becoming a bargaining chip. Vendors need to help buyers see that number go up — or they'll face resistance. Lucas: And to be fair, some vendors are ahead of this. I saw a demo from a data analytics company — they have a dashboard that shows the buyer their own team's adoption metrics in real time. It's a retention tool disguised as a transparency play. Luna: That's clever. It turns a potential objection into proof of value. 'Look, your team is using this 80% of licensed seats — you're getting ROI.' Lucas: Exactly. And the buyer can't argue with their own data. Luna: One thing I wonder though — is adoption score truly causal, or just correlated? Maybe the accounts that were going to renew anyway just happen to use the product more. Lucas: That's a fair challenge. The ERP company did a controlled test: they identified 20 accounts with scores between 35 and 45 — in the gray zone — and randomly assigned half to an intensive adoption program. The program group saw scores rise to 55 on average, and 8 out of 10 renewed. The control group stayed flat, and only 3 out of 10 renewed. Luna: So there is a causal effect. Improving adoption actually drives renewal. That's powerful evidence. Lucas: Yeah, and it suggests that a lot of 'inevitable churn' might actually be preventable with the right intervention early on. Luna: So the metric isn't just a flag — it's a lever. You can pull it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think adoption score is more useful than NPS or satisfaction surveys. Those are sentiment-based; this is behavior-based. Luna: Behavior doesn't lie. Or at least, it's harder to fake than a survey response. Lucas: Right. So the takeaway for vendors: build your own adoption score, tie CSM comp to it, and start sharing it with buyers proactively. For buyers: demand this data in your next renewal negotiation. Luna: And for both sides: don't wait until the last quarter to look at it. The first three months tell you everything. Lucas: Exactly. And I think we'll see more procurement teams codifying this into their RFPs. 'Vendor must provide adoption metrics quarterly.' It's coming. Luna: It's a better way to buy software. Less gut feel, more data. Lucas: And less wasted spend on tools nobody uses. Honestly, that's a win for everyone. Luna: Alright, I'm convinced. Next time I'm up for a renewal, I'm asking for the adoption score. Lucas: Good. And if the vendor hesitates, that tells you something too.