Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 9: Whole Life Insurance: Smart Strategy or Expensive Mistake?
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to episode nine of Portfolio Talks. We are recording this one a little bit late as we have some morning meetings that we're just super busy, but we want to jump on and make sure we keep to our regular scheduled programming. filming this on July 6th, so Team Canada is out of the World Cup, but hope you're still enjoying FIFA World Cup and all the craziness that's on there. we wanted to make sure that we put this episode out to talk about something that's very important for all of you. Which is life insurance, specifically whole life insurance for doctors. And it's usually people belong in one or two camps, either whole life is a scam or everybody should have it. The answer is probably neither. too often this is more of a product conversation as opposed to a strategy conversation and a timing conversation. and we're gonna jump into all that kind of stuff. As always, if you appreciate the podcast, if you learn from the podcast, we would love if you Subscribe. It really helps us up the ranking on the podcast so your colleagues and the next generation of doctors can hear about us and and and learn the things they need to learn for their career. And if you haven't yet, give us a five-star review and share if possible to your colleagues as well. We want to make sure that we're educating you all so you can run your finances, not have your finances run you. So stay tuned. Episode nine, we're talking about whole life insurance. Is it a scam? Is it not? We're gonna go through all that stuff right now. All right, your favorite financial planners, we are back. Portfolio Talks Episode 9: Whole Life Insurance is a scam, is it not? We're gonna talk about all that fun stuff, plus more. as usual, we're gonna kind of start off by talking conceptually about our episode topic. After that, we'll we're gonna kind of talk about it in the lens of is it a myth? Is it not? Then we'll educate you a little bit more in our learning segment and then wrapping off with our mailbag section, our medical mailbag. As a reminder, as always, if you want to get your questions into the mailbag, make sure you join our closed Facebook group, which is for doctors across Canada. It's going to be you, your colleagues, your friends, all those people are going to be in that group and gives you a space to ask your questions and gives a way to answer your questions and keep on educating you guys as opposed to waiting for every two weeks when the next episode comes out. Because as always, life happens at random time. So being able to have that space to learn and ask your questions is very, very important. And we'll put that link as always into our show notes. And let's jump into it. So Tyson, first off, World Cup's been going on. Who you cheering for? Have you had some heartbreak? W what's going on? Tyson Nagasaka: Nope, I'm actually not invested at all in this year's World Cup. I respect the talent, I respect the work ethic, but I'm not a fan of any one team and I've not been to a lot of these watch parties. I've walked by them. I got a cool one. It was on my Snapchat yesterday. Vishal Gill, CFP: I know I saw, I was shocked. I was like, this guy's out here. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I was out I was just out for my walk. I'm doing my my responsible midlife thing that you're supposed to do. And I go for a walk at about eight eight PM at night. And there was like a hundred and fifty people i at this little watch place that our city has set up and it was awesome. I mean the vibes were good, energy was good. and they were there till the end. So that was pretty cool. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Yeah, it's unreal. I I'm just a vibe chaser, to be honest. I'm I'm 100% a bandwagoner. Anyone that knows me knows I'm a fan bandwagoner. I I'm a Blue Jays fan when the playoffs start, and I'm a soccer fan when the World Cup happens, and I'm like an Olympic and a Lujing fan. I'm just I'm there for the sporting events. I like the energy and the vibes. but I've always been a Brazil fan. So ever since I was younger I remember playing my first FIFA game on the PC and Ronaldo was was the striker. All I did was just score with Ronaldo. and I have some friends that live in Brazil. And Sao Paulo. So if you're listening, my Sao Paulo contingent, hope you guys are doing well. Shout out to Sao Paulo. And yeah, honestly, it's just it's great. So I was hoping for Brazil to win, obviously Canada as well, but both my teams got knocked out within a week. So it is what it is. I if I cheer for you, you're apparently gonna lose. so I don't even know who I'm cheering for now, but the buzz have been great. but I may cough a couple times on the podcast. I'm not sick. I was doing the same thing after the game. I was going for the walkthrough Granville and all these Tyson Nagasaka: Shout out, John Paulo. Vishal Gill, CFP: I don't know if it's smoke bombs or what it is, but when all those they pull in the smoke that has like the color of their team. There was so much going on in the street. And I felt like a chain smoke the next day when I woke up in the morning, I was like, coffee, I could tell taste the smoke. I texted my friends that I was with, and they're like, Yeah, we're all messed up too. So it it was it was brutal. But the funny thing about it was there was a guy that was handing out masks, and and I was like, no, no, it's okay. I was like, I don't want to like pay for it. I felt like I was in like Italy or something and getting hit by tourists. or sorry, the tourism tax where they're trying to, you know, make you pay so much for something. but he's like, No, no, I'm just giving it for free. Like just you you guys seem like you're struggling, so just take it. And then we all laugh for like, man, people are much nicer than you give them credit for. They're just trying to give us stuff for free to help you out. And you're like, no, no, I don't have cash, I don't want pay for it or or whatever. So it's weird, man. It's weird. But everyone's just so nice. Like, I think the vibes are so great this time of year. if you haven't got a chance, whoever's there, just even if you stay on the outskirts of like the main craziness, is just being there. watch the game, walk the streets, see people getting together. it's super, super nice. And you know it's just expensive to go to the game. So you don't have to spend that kind of money. You can go to you know watch parties that are around. Wild. anyways what's more fun than FIFA is some life insurance. So let's talk about that. you know for for you listening you're a doctor and as a doctor whether it's like your diamond learns that you get through Tyson Nagasaka: That's right. Vishal Gill, CFP: uni or if it's afterwards and you're getting bombarded on like LinkedIn or or cold emails or anytime you go to an event and these life insurance advisors are like, like you gotta have the whole life insurance, you gotta have whole life insurance. Every doctor should have it. You know, this it's far too often, like anything in finances, people belong to a camp and they just die on that hill. So there's the contingent of the life insurance advice first, and they're just trying to sell a product and get a commission, they're like everybody should have whole life insurance. That's not true. Then there's the other camp that people are like, whole life insurance is a scam. You should never have it. There's other things that you should always do. And that's not always true. Like usual, the answer is somewhere in the middle. So what we want to talk about today is educate you on the problems that it solves. And this is framing that, you know, if you're if you're a client of ours, you you probably laugh because this is the framing of our entire conversations we always have. What problem does this thing solve? And what problem do you have? So we'll talk about that. And so you can self-identify. My Apple Watch is talking to me. You can self-identify, you know, if this problem is yours, and then, you know, how does it solve it? And and when should you feel that your finances justify you looking into this? And we'll talk about all that kind stuff. So you know, the pain point is you usually get conflicting insurance advice and you hear something from your colleague, you hear something from LinkedIn, and you just process by analysis, you're like what is real? So, Tyson, from your perspective, whole life insurance is a A smart corporate strategy? Is it expensive mistake? Is it something in the middle? What are your thoughts? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, it's funny that you know you talked about the two different campses because I came into the industry and I started at a buy-term invest the difference firm. They didn't do financial planning, the the target market was not doctors, it was middle class Canadians. So that advice kind of makes sense. Low cost, you're supposed to save money, you're supposed to do whatever. The challenge in this modern age in Canada is buy-term invest the difference doesn't work because. Because cost of living is so high. Anytime we save a client $20, the $20 is not going into savings. The $20 is just being deployed into something else. I think I just saw a Starbucks cup in your hand. It's very easy. It's very easy for you to nickel and dime this money away with things like convenience and Amazon and food and products that show up at your door in 24 hours. The modern day age. Vishal Gill, CFP: You got me. You got me. Tyson Nagasaka: Buy term invest the difference in concept makes a ton of sense, but in practice, it's very hard for Canadians. Now, for our doctor clients, I think it depends on the season of finance that you're in. Like you were saying, they may not be in a place where it's appropriate where you want to deploy that much capital to a permanent structure. When, like how many family physicians do we see that retire and sell their business? It's not as many as it used to be. so then what happens? Do they just close up shop and like disappear? I've actually had a few clients that we were doing their medicals for their insurance and the doctor had just closed shop, gone. didn't tell yeah. so so the estate planning and the unraveling of the corporation, do you want to have a permanent product in there? It really, really ties back to the planning. What are we trying to accomplish? Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep. And it's so hard to get up in the ministry, it takes forever. Tyson Nagasaka: What's the short term, midterm, long-term goal? where do we see ourselves going? And then implementing a strategy to address that. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, honestly, really well said. And you know, one thing that Tyson and I we always chat about when talks to our clients, because we we talk often behind the scenes when we have financial planning clients. You'll have the lead planner, but we collaborate on almost every plan and and strategize stuff. So one thing that we always say internally, that we should say more externally, but internally we always say that every every dollar is competing for all the strategies that are available to you. So If you are a doctor and you're you're working whether it's the dollar inside the corporation or the dollar on the personal side, it's kind of irrelevant because every strategy that's on the table for you is all competing for this one dollar or opportunity cost. So you want to really make sure that the most efficient options for that dollar are solved first before allocating money to something else that isn't really relevant for you yet. And the reason why I say that is because far too often people are like, well. Your doctor, you're gonna need whole life at some point. So you might as well get it now when you're young and insurable because your cost is never gonna be cheaper than it is now. That's true, but it's not like entirely true because my counter argument would be that a dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow. And we'll get into it in a second of what are the kind of sequence of events that that should happen prior to you looking at this. But although it's true that your insurance is never cheaper than it is in 2026 on July 6th. it it's not gonna be a make or break until later unless you're unassurable, some crazy health concern happens. But for the most part, no one really knows that. And there's ways to mitigate that, which again, we'll talk about in second. but keep in mind that every strategy available to you is competing for that same dollar. So you wanna make sure that in the stage of life that you're in right now, for the opportunity cost, if you quantify that down the road in your career, it's really gonna make sense and tick a lot of boxes before you implement that strategy. Tyson Nagasaka: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: So that's why we always say it's it's not really is it good or is it bad in regards to insurance? Is is it now or is it later? I think is the better way to think about that. So why don't we talk about the competing strategies of of almost like a checklist that that we can give the audience of you know, you have money, someone approaches you, hey, you should do some insurance. What are some prerequisites that they should cross off before even looking at that that that opportunity? Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. Yeah. Yeah, I I mean there's a whole bunch, but the easy ones. it it it's a question we kind of use to diffuse the situation. And a lot of times it's because the doctor that we've been referred to has a friend or a family member that is an insurance advisor, and their first their first stop on the roadmap is the most expensive one. And unfortunately it's sometimes commission driven or maybe they're trying to hit some sales numbers. E everybody's gotta go through it. We go through it too. We just Do our business very differently. The first thing that we ask somebody wants to do this big program is have you maxed out all of your registered programs that are available to you? RRSP, tax-free savings account. If you're a brand new graduate, FHSA, right? We did a whole episode on this. FHSA is unknown, underutilized. Tax-free savings account has been around since 2009. It is unknown, underutilized, improperly implemented. People have $100,000 in a cash savings account in tax-free savings because the label has tax-free savings account in it. So we just want to make sure you're utilizing all of the tools that are available to us that essentially there's no there's no barrier to entry. You can put $100,000 in, you could put $5 in. we want to make sure that you're utilizing those. And if you've maxed out your RRSPs, if you've maxed out your TFSA, if you've maxed out your FHSA, then we can have the conversation. Hey, what are we doing with the XS? And then it starts to unravel from there. That's the first stop. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And you know, before we go to the next one, but I think what you said is really good. It's it's such a low barrier to entry. It's not like you have to get approved for it or you have to have a certain net worth before you can open these accounts. It's there, it's free. So before you start spending a ton of money on sexy, extravagant, sophisticated approaches, and it's always the same thing. Like, you know, here's something the rich don't want you to know is you can close the cap on your water bottle and you can keep using the same water. They don't want you to know that. It's like, no, it's not a secret. Like it's in the Income Tax Act, it's available everywhere. It's not a secret. It's just it's a way for people to frame stuff to try and make it seem exclusive or whatever. It is not. So, you know, anyone can really get life insurance as long as you're insurable. And these strategies aren't complicated or or or secrets to put into place. But before you do that, your competing dollar is almost always. I've never crossed a situation where this is not true yet, but it's almost always better to use it in a registered account because. Going to allow you to tap into that money in the future and plan for taxes because you smooth out your tax rate a lot better. Oversimplification, TFSA, you don't get the deduction now, but all your money's growing tax-free. RSPs, FHSAs, you get some deductions, so you can reduce your tax bill and let that money compound and grow and do all the stuff, you know, buy it, buy a home, let that grow tax-free. So there's so many different ways that you can do that. But if you're young in your career, you're losing so much compounding growth if you're spending. two thousand in dollars a month on a whole life policy before you're investing that same two thousand dollars a month into your TFSA. So registered accounts is always one of the first things that we look at when it comes to people being pitched insurance and why we tell them not to yet. Tyson Nagasaka: Absolutely. Vishal Gill, CFP: what about debt? Is is there any thing you'd say about debt as a prerequisite before going into whole life? Tyson Nagasaka: This is a huge conversation for us. We do whole courses on debt, especially with our student demographic that they're graduating. You're gonna be a brand new practicing doctor, whether you're a dentist, an OD, a ph family physician. there are questions around student debt, lines of credit, mortgage if you've just bought a home. And we wanna look at these things and assess how is your debt to value ratio, your debt to income ratio, like. How much of a bite is debt taking out of the Apple? Should we look to address debt? It doesn't mean you have to be debt-free, but it just means do we have a really good handle on it? Is it well below a threshold? you know, we see some people sometimes, you know, they have a $2 million home and they have a $1.9 million mortgage. It's not ideal. Maybe we should focus over a couple of years on paying down debt because that's money that's no longer going to interest. You could refinance in the future interest rates. Even though they're not at 0% today, they're still at historical lows. 25 years ago when I worked for the bank, my staff rate was like four and a half percent. And they told me it would never go lower ever in our lifetime, right? It's just like when you bought a computer 20 years ago. You'll never need more storage than this. So addressing these things, you don't want to have too much going to interest where it's eating up your ability to earn income and build wealth. А I think that's something that we should address. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and I I and to be even more specific on that would be if you have non-deductible debt. Cause sometimes deductible debt can be good, especially for those of you that don't have much other opportunities to get some deductions. Like let's say you're a associate optometrist or you know, you're a general dentist working at different clinics. You don't own the clinic, you don't have a lot of deductions in the way of like paying staff or or you know, all the things that happen with being on the show losses in your clinic. You just earn a great income, which is fantastic. So one of the only deductions that you can get then is if you have some debt that is deductible. So let's say you have a line of credit that's been used to do leverage. let's say you have a line of credit and you tap into that line of credit to do an RSP catch-up loan because you had RSP room, but you never contributed to it till you're like 36. So you do a large catch-up loan. well, that's a bad example. That actually won't be deductible. But as an example, you take some debt to to invest into something and now it's deductible. That debt isn't always the worst. So sometimes we would say, okay, you do need whole life insurance, for example. Let's not pay down this deductible debt because it's actually saving you some money on your tax return. That can make sense for you a little bit earlier. But even non-tax deductible debt, things like your primary residence, line of credits, credit cards, things of that type, that would make a whole lot of sense to pay off first before you even look at the conversation of again using that competing dollar to go towards whole life, because you get a guaranteed rate of returns. Before people trying to show you, like, okay, well, here's the dividend scale rate of life insurance. It's this much, it's never lost money in I don't know, 100 years or whatever they say. the dividend scale rate is good, but really whole life insurance is just it's like a bond, basically. that's kind of the returns you'll be getting as like bond type investments. it'll be predictable, it'll be consistent, it'll be good. But you can take zero risk, which is paying off your debt. That's gonna free up more cash flow. So now You have more dollars to do more competing strategies. so non-tax deductible debt, to be specific, is a really attractive thing to look at to knock off the checklist before you start looking at getting some whole life insurance. because again, the compounding effects are are quite significant. You carry that debt on for for many, many years. what about retained earnings inside the corporation or like that and passive income tax? Like, is there some kind of trigger point of You got money inside your corporation, starting to cause you some pain points. Now whole life might be an option for you. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think so. I think when you have substantial retained earnings built, this might be two, three, five million dollars in an investment portfolio inside your company that's doing something. It's not exactly trapped because these were lightly taxed corporate dollars. Even if you're doing very well, you're successful, and you're earning the general rate or you're paying the general rate for your taxes, that's still less than paying that out as salary or dividend to yourself and investing it personally. because you're gonna you're gonna have that money influenced by tax. so retained earnings that is substantial, that's growing, and then we also look at how that is being deployed. We have seen businesses that they feel they have to be very risk averse inside the business, or someone's told them that. So they have millions of dollars in GICs. Well, GICs pays interest regularly. And so you're gonna get a T slip every year for the GIC interest. That is gonna directly impact the tax situation and it's gonna impact your compounding growth ability. So that money is earning half essentially of what the interest rate that you're receiving on those corporate GICs. And you'd be better to be in a portfolio that grows and will earn through dividends or capital gains. They're taxed a little more favorably. And then if it's capital gains and you can have it grow long term, we can look talk about timing and mechanisms of when we want to trigger some of those gains. And you might have the small business deduction grind, but we can control the time period when that happens and you might be a tax cycle or two, and then get back to your small business small business deduction. So Definitely a conversation to have. Retained earnings are not bad. Retained earnings are good. Those profits. Growing the profits by investing it is good. how you're doing it and what's going on, definitely a conversation to monitor. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, yeah, exactly. So that's a bit of a checklist just to kind of review like before you look at allocating your money towards a whole life policy, a couple prerequisites for you to look that would kind of eliminate you would be do you have registered room available? Registered room meaning your TFSAs, your RSPs, your FHSAs, for example. If you have available room, whole life insurance probably doesn't make sense for you as a as a doctor in Canada. next one would be if you have non-deductible debt. That's a guaranteed rate of return that's sitting there waiting for you that you can have zero volatility, zero market risk, but you can get that rate of return. So you have a 7% interest line of credit, you can pay that money and get a 7% return for every dollar you're paying off onto your debt. After that, you want to make sure that you have the corporation structure so you're incorporated. And if you don't have meaningful retained earnings or leftover money inside your corporation, it's not worth looking into these advanced concepts. there's other things that you can do with with a corporate dollars. Until you start running into that passive income problem, for the most part, you don't really need to look at this. But once you have enough meaningful retained earnings or leftover money inside your corp, that you start running into small business tax problem where you know what, this is kind of tough because as I'm investing money, it's starting to take away from my small business limit. Now there's a conversation we could look at about allocating that money into whole life insurance corporately. So hopefully that little checklist helps you. One thing we did talk about early on, which we'll circle back to now. was I was mentioning that there is strategies that you can use to make two things happen at the same time. So people will tell you your cost of insurance is never going to be cheaper than it is today because what if you're not insurable in the future? Sure, that's a valid point, but it's so hard to know obviously. but you know it is a valid point that what if you're uninsurable and then you lose that planning opportunity. but the second thing is also true, which is a dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow. And you have all these strategies competing for the same dollar that you have to spend. So one way we can do that, and and one thing that you know we preach quite often is if you have a problem that needs solving. And and again, this to our earlier point, there should be a problem, a clear problem that these strategies attach to or solve. Some examples of problems for life insurance for for you guys on this podcast listening would be if you have like an estate tax problem that's projected. So you're gonna spend below your means, you're earning a significant income. So you Eventually your corporation will have a huge amount of leftover money or you know money that's sitting there that will eventually cause potentially double taxation. That's one example. estate equalization. You have multiple kids, and let's say you are a dentist and you do have a clinic, and one of your kids are is following in your footsteps as a dentist, other ones aren't. So are you gonna pass the practice down to one of them? How do you make the other one whole? And sneak peek will talk about this at a later episode, but you legally have to equalize your estate. so how do you do that? And does insurance help you with that? or solving some other kind of tax tax problems. So those are problems that insurance can solve. The way you can make all these things happen at the same time is getting term insurance now that you can convert later on in the future when all the pre prerequisites have been met, and now you need the whole life policy to solve these problems. So Tyson, if you want to chat a little bit about conversion and and and and what that looks like. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So what one of the talking points that we go through with our our clients regularly is especially with my history of where the companies that I've worked at before is we only use term insurance options that have convertibility. We always want to make sure that we have an escape hatch for our clients so that this situation that you talked about, if we buy something and you're 35 years old, number one, you're young, you're healthy, life insurance is really cheap. It's easy to get. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: so you want to buy a lot of it then, especially for professionals. Underwriting departments look very favorably on our professional demographic, and it's easy to get approved for a little bit extra life insurance. So we usually look at what are your needs, get a little bit extra, especially because we know billings and business is gonna grow over time. let's get a little extra insurance today. But we want to have convertibility as an option. that allows us the ability to pivot should something happen. had clients in the past, I've had lots of stories, but had somebody that discovered late in life that he was type one diabetic and I don't know how he skated through, but had a diabetic stroke. And then he's no longer at that time, he was no longer approvable for a life insurance option. There are life insurance options now for hard to insure clients. But we if we had a term insurance option on him. And he's got a contract, he could always convert to something more permanent down the road when the time and the money make sense for him to do so. Vishal Gill, CFP: Love that. So is it fair to say that with term insurance conversion options, you're let's say you're twenty six years old, you're locking in your insurability, but you're not locking in the high cost of permanent whole life insurance. You can trigger that later on once all the prerequisites are met. Tyson Nagasaka: That's correct. Yeah. So when you convert, if you had a million dollar policy and you needed to convert $300,000 15 years from now, you could do that and you don't have to go through the health underwriting anymore. You just you just buy it, it'll be based on your age at that time, but not your health. And you convert the chunk that you want to convert. And great strategy to lock in some permanent coverage once we have permanent insurance needs. Vishal Gill, CFP: Love that. I'll give you an example. So actually just this morning, one of my meetings, I was doing one of these strategies. So everything honestly is a lot easier when it's part of a financial plan as opposed to just being approached by product salespeople. that's my my pitch to you to do financial planning and take the time to build out your your whole careers. but I had a meeting with the clients we delivered their financial plan and we built it over the last couple of weeks and they're projected to earn significant money, have significant retained earnings, like most of you on this call or on listening to the podcast and eventually it's gonna be a huge tax problem. so we talked about insurability and and doing term now because he wanted to get full life insurance. He's like, I'd rather own instead of rent. And I knew right away he probably saw something on social media because that's the terminology that's pitched a lot is, you know, you would rather own a house instead of renting a house. So own your policy instead of renting your policy, don't do term insurance. so I had a conversation with him. I was like, listen, you can like I I can't talk you out of it and and not let you do it. But at the end of the day, I don't advise it because again, that dollar can be better spent for all these other things. What we should do instead is if we look at your financial plan, all the modeling is showing that you're gonna have roughly this net worth at life expectancy at 86. So we looked at age 86 for life expectancy forum. Like this is what your projected net worth is going to be corporately and personally. so based off the entire net worth, we're able to track roughly what his estate tax would be. what I did mention is obviously. Capital gains tax, who knows what's ever gonna happen? It's like, is it one half? Is it three quarters? Is it seven eighths? Who knows what's gonna happen in the future? But based off the numbers that we do know, this is what your tax bill is going to be at life expectancy. So we looked at the prerequisites, and in four years' time, if this client does nothing, he's not gonna have a small business rate anymore corporately in four years because he'll have too much passive income income inside the corporation. So our time frame to convert is four years. I was like, let's not do it now, whole life. It doesn't solve a problem yet. And until you get to that problem, your dollars are better spent investing. Like, I want you to get to the point where you're almost having the problem with passive income because that means you're growing, you're having investments, and you're realizing the gains. So I want you to get to that problem. It's a good problem to have. So let's invest your money to that first. So we reverse did the math. Here's what your tax bills are projected to be at age 85. We know you're gonna run into this problem in four years. So let's calculate in four years' time how much insurance do we need to let that grow to solve what your eventual tax bill is gonna be at age 85. Now we know that tax bill, for example is eight million dollars. Okay, so now we know we need eight million dollars in four years' time. Let's just get the term insurance for eight million dollars for the next four years. So your cost is significantly, significantly, significantly cheaper. Just get the term insurance for the next four years. And in four years' time, maybe five, maybe six, depending what else happens. We can convert later on. So even if your health does change, it doesn't really change much for us. We can convert your entire policy to permanent inside the corporation. But why spend that money now when we don't have to? So the next four years, you're gonna rent the coverage, but it's rent to own. And I think that's a good framing for you guys to think of when it comes to conversion term insurance policies. It's not renting or buying, it's renting to own. so with that framing in mind, I think that'll hopefully resolve that for you. Where you might as well spend the cheaper amount, lock in all your options and then flip it over or convert it when you need to. Okay, on that point, there's term insurance and whole life insurance. So we won't get too caught up into the weeds, but Tyson, there's obviously situations. You mentioned it before, your previous shop was, you know, buy term and invest the rest. But it is true that term insurance wins for certain situations. So your audience is listening, when would term insurance be the better option for them as opposed to whole life? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think term insurance is really good when you're younger. And like why lock up those dollars when there's so many things that they can do? So when we talk about opportunity costs, some of the things that we've seen is like you're a young graduate associate dentist or an OD and you want to buy into a practice. We've seen several of these this year. And we know just by demographics that we have a lot of the older generations that want to retire and sell their business, and they need younger. generations that have capital to come in and buy these practices. So you may want to buy a practice as a young doctor. And if your all of your cash flow is tied up into expensive programs that run forever, you know, you might not have the cash flow available to to do some of these things. Just it's the same thing as like you have the money, you can go and lease an expensive car, but you're never going to get that money Back. you can't convert that into something in the future. We want to look at opportunities. Term insurance, you get a lot of, you can it's very cheap. And then the other thing that we see too sometimes is clients that come to us and they have lots of term insurance, which is great, but they've never talked about disability insurance. They've never talked about critical illness. They've never built an emergency fund. Like they don't have the pieces of a financial plan. And Term insurance wins most of the time. That that's like the general rule of thumb. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And I think you you made a good point about like corporations' short time horizons. I think if your time horizon of the problem that you have is short, so it's not for the entirety of your life, term is usually really good for that. So mortgages, funding shareholder purchases, buying out somebody, collateral loan for buying into a clinic, you know extra cash while your kids are still dependent age. Those are all examples of term insurance needs. Like if someone came up to me was like, I'm thinking about getting a whole life insurance policy because my kids are young and I want to make sure if I were to pass away young, they have the money to continue to do whatever they want to. I'd like well, is that like, are they not gonna be financially independent until the age eighty? Like it that doesn't make much sense, right? So i if your time horizon isn't permanent, is not a permanent insurance product. It's term. and you kind of reminded me of something because this this happens sometimes too, where Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. That's right. Vishal Gill, CFP: We'll have, you know, shareholder, or let's say it's a partner. Let's say it's a dental clinic or or orthodontic clinic who has three or four shareholders. They'll have a shareholder agreement where they have a contractual obligation to buy out each other in case one person were pass away. We'll do a different episode and explain this properly. But basically, insurance will be used to buy out the partners, and that'll be like a permanent product that they want to have because they may never sell. They may just take on another partner and just keep their shares or whatever. but the problem that they had sometimes was they hold it incorrectly as well. so these people had all these permanent policies held inside the one corporation that they're eventually gonna want to sell the shares of, whether they take on a new partner or sell it to somebody else. The problem of that is it wasn't gonna qualify for a lifetime capital gains exemption because it didn't meet that 90% rule. So there's so many different planning needs that need to come into place of how you hold stuff, how you do things. But a a simple way to think. Tyson Nagasaka: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: Is this a term product or a whole life product? If it's anything that's not for the entirety of your life, it's usually term insurance wins. If it's something that's gonna be a permanent thing, paying for your tax, equalizing your estate, those those are really the big ones I can think off the top of my head, then whole life insurance is gonna be good for you because it's gonna be a problem that's gonna get larger and larger and larger as time goes on, not smaller and smaller and smaller like term insurance. Awesome. You know, let's start some math to it perhaps a little bit. so you know, when when we come to the math of estate liquidity, and we've kind of talked about that a few different ways. you know, where's the value in the estate? Like how does life insurance so they they've met the prerequisites, it meets all the checks and balances, now they're gonna get whole life insurance. How does it solve the problem that we talked about? So it is a permanent need, not a temporary need. So they need permanent insurance. How does it solve the problem for them? Let's say estate tax. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So I mean, I I think we mentioned this in in an earlier episode, but one of the risks of investing in a corporation is like double and triple taxation on death that you can experience. And so if you're a doctor and your spouse predeceases you and so now it's just you. You and then when you pass on everything goes to your children. if you have a large investment portfolio inside your corporation, whether that was formerly your operating company and it's now a holding company or it was your holding company, and that's where all your assets are are held and you draw your retirement income from there. Well, if you have 10 million bucks and you know you invested one million bucks and there's nine million dollars of capital gains, when you pass away, that capital gain or that that portfolio is deemed to have been disposed of, and you pay capital gains at the corporate level on that nine million dollar gain, which which is a lot. And then you have to get that money out of your corporation. So you're going to pay tax to dividend that out to your estate. And then your estate will pay probate and you may pay additional taxes at the estate personal estate level to flow that out to your beneficiaries. So for situations where there's a large amount of wealth that's been accumulated, we want to take that into account because we can soften that blow and create estate liquidity With that life insurance amount. One of the things that life insurance does very well that we talk about is something called a CDA credit or a capital dividend account. It exists on paper somewhere, but it doesn't actually exist like at your bank or in your investments brokerage. The capital dividend account is a nominal thing that your accountant tracks, and it is how much money you can flow tax free out of your corporation. And you flow it out to your to yourself, or you can flow it out to your beneficiaries. And that is a great thing. Where even once the life insurance need has gone away, if you can afford to keep and maintain that life insurance inside your corporation, sometimes that's worth it just for the CDA credit, right? If it's a million dollar death benefit and it's deemed to have a hundred and fifty thousand dollar adjusted cost base or ACB. We take the death benefit minus the ACB, and that is typically your full CDA credit that you're gonna get just from the life insurance, right? So if it was a million dollar life insurance policy and it's a $150,000 ACB, it's an $850,000 CDA credit, which is a tax-free pipeline to get money out of your corporation and onto the personal side so that it can flow out through your estate. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And people sometimes hear CDA room, like, okay, well, it's just the insurance amount. it'll be in addition to whatever other CDA room you have. most people will have C DA accumulated through capital gains. So today's point, you have investments that you put, let's say, a hundred thousand dollars into, it turned into five hundred K. so you'll have that taxable capital gains. The portion that's not taxable, the other fifty percent, is added to your CDA room. But for the most part, people won't use their C DA room until they pass away or until Tyson Nagasaka: Yes. Vishal Gill, CFP: you know, they they retire things like that, because it costs quite a bit of money to use your CDA room. There's like a bunch of tax forms that need be completed, a lot of work for your accountant to do. So C DA room doesn't get cleared every single year as as a housekeeping rule. It's I guess I should do two quotes. but it's something that accumulates over time that you can use later on for the most part to clear the estate or to purge a corporation. So that's usually what will happen. Another way to think of it is people a little bit more familiar with lifetime capital gains exempt exemption of the tax-free money when you sell your business. You can think of CD like a capital gains lifetime capital gains exemption, but for when you pass away. just another way for for you know to connect that in into your own situation. awesome. So we're doing pretty good for timing. What I wanted to do was leave time for mailbag. I think our last couple episodes have been so heavy content-wise that we haven't had a chance to properly do our mailbag, but As a reminder, if you want to get your questions in the mail big, join our Facebook group that's going to be in the show notes. You can ask your questions that we can answer live on the podcast. And the ones that we don't get to, we'll answer back on the Facebook group. But one question came in was when it comes to registered accounts, what are some examples of registered accounts that we should do prior to investing into whole life insurance? So we talked those already, but maybe we can do a quick rebrief debrief again. but also you know, that terminology of investing inside your whole life policy. I don't know if you wanna say anything about that as well. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, okay. So let's tackle the first one, which was registered accounts. RRSPs, tax-free savings accounts, FHSA, if you're a brand new graduate, you haven't owned a home yet, or if you owned a home but it hasn't been for five years or more, and so you're FHSA eligible. all of these are parking places. So even if you're paying money out of your corporation to yourself and depositing into these accounts for the RSP and the FHSA, you're gonna get a tax refund. So it doesn't Cancel each other out, but it's pretty close. Then it's gonna go tax deferred on the personal side. Tax-free savings account is I like to harp on this one a lot. We only have four things in in Canada that are tax-free. And if you're not utilizing your tax-free savings account properly, or if you want to review, we'll have our calendar link in in the show notes. I mean, book a chat with us. We'd love to talk to you about how it can work and how it should work. So for people who have been investing since 2009, when Tax-free savings account started. We've seen balances of three, four, five hundred thousand dollars because of compounding and constantly ensuring that they are contributing the maximum amount, which this year is seven thousand dollars. so you want to make sure you're using your registered accounts first. Easy, low barrier to entry. what was the next part of the question? Investing in whole life? Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, like even though people say like, okay, well I've invested in my registered accounts now. I now should I invest in whole life. So is whole life like an investment or is it an expense? Like what's your thoughts on that? Tyson Nagasaka: Whole life for the first couple of years on the balance sheet for your corporation, it is a hundred percent expense. It's just money that's going in, it's not deductible, the premiums are not deductible in most cases, and you don't have a lot of cash value. But you'll eventually turn the corner, depending on which company you're using, three years, four years, six years, it starts to have residual value and it'll show as an asset on the balance sheet. So some companies like to talk about that and promote that. How the money grows inside is you are being paid dividends inside your policy. It's not traditionally like investments like everybody thinks about, but you are getting growth in there and you're seeing four to six percent growth inside your policy on the regular. And because it's held and owned by a life insurance company, you're not getting a tax slip every year. It is tax deferred. It is inside of the life insurance policy that that investment is accumulating. So it sort of is an investment. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, well said. and the one thing I'd say on that is is going back to our point about a dollar today's worth more than a dollar tomorrow. life insurance corp or whole life insurance or permanent life insurance is built to show you most of your returns and your value on the back end, not the front end. so that's why we always say that investments using your registered accounts in particular are way more advantageous because if you invest, you know, five hundred bucks, you're getting five hundred bucks for the most part. You Could have some volatility and rebounds, but you get the money that you're putting into it. Whereas to Tyson's point, when you put money into permanent insurance, it's going to be less and you don't have liquidity until later on in the back end or the medium side where it starts to catch up and then turns a corner and now you have excess money that's in there, tax deferred. So just some context on that. But Tyson, you kind of segued perfectly actually to our next question, which came in and was asking what's the best insurance company to look for for permanent insurance? Tyson Nagasaka: I think you want companies that have flexibility built in. And your advisor should be showing you one or two or three options. every company has certain nuances, and as soon as they come out with something that's better than everybody else, fourteen to twenty-four months later, another company is gonna copy them because you're gonna lose market share. So at any one given moment that we're recording this, there will be a company that is really good, whether they're yellow or green or red or blue, like whatever their color is. they're gonna have some things that are really, really good and every company's gonna have slightly different features. Flexibility is something that I look for for my clients because we want to ensure that we can dial things up or dial things down depending on the needs of the client. I g I I I try not to go on a tangent. I don't want to go on a tangent. But we look for flexibility. We wanna make sure that the client has the ability to maneuver and is not locked into a very particular thing forever. Vishal Gill, CFP: For you to learn to go on tangents, I'm like the tangent king. So it's good that we balance each other hook. Once you figure it out, you teach me to. I have a bit of a different answer. I would say all those things are are correct. my simple answer would be the best insurance company is the one that's gonna approve you. because I think more important than anything else, getting an approval is the most important one. And sometimes companies will have their own little niches or nuances where they'll they'll give you more favorable results. Tyson Nagasaka: I'm trying. I'm trying. I'm trying. Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: For the most part, they'd be roughly about the same, but there's gonna be small pockets where you don't get a favorable decision from one company, you go to a different company. So I would say the best insurance company is the one that's gonna give you a good offer. and maybe we'll make a separate episode about that a little bit later. But yeah, that's what we might answer. we got time for one, maybe two more. So next question was regarding where to hold the policy. by that I mean should you own it personally, should you own it corporately, another company, hold co maybe wink, wink, nudge, nudge. so what does that look like? Where's where should we hold the policy? And I'm assuming this came from someone that is incorporated. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, right. So for for the majority of our clients that we work with, they're incorporated. They have a med co. So they're a doctor, a dentist, optometrist, and they ha they get paid and it goes to their medical corporation. Now, we have to have some discussions about putting permanent things in potentially temporary corporations. So if your corporation's gonna shut down or you're gonna s do a share sale in the future, that's how you're gonna sell your business. You don't want to hold permanent items in a corporation that's going to not be permanent, which is to your point where hold co might come into play, where they're going to accumulate all of their assets. We see a lot of clients that hold the real estate in their corporations. There was just a case where we read about the the accountant did a section 86 rollover of a rental property to balance out something else. And so there are a lot of complications that could occur and arise. And I think you want Vishal Gill, CFP: Yes. Tyson Nagasaka: to be flexible. And so putting things in your operating medical company that are permanent, it's probably not a good idea. We do see some clients that they don't plan to sell their business ever. They're just going to close down shop and then convert it into a holding company. It could work for you then. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, nothing to add. Perfectly said. and great because you finished just in time for us to have one more question. So our our last question here is does permanent insurance solve the passive income grind? Again, I'm assuming this person's incorporated. they're probably not at that problem yet, but they're projecting to be that problem in few few amount of years. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. It could potentially solve the passive income grind. like I said, with flexibility, there are some companies that allow us to build the structure so we can overfund the policy. So instead of it being, you know, three parts insurance and one part savings, is we can build it in such a way where we're doing, you know, four parts savings and two parts insurance. And now we're Over investing in the policy, and that allows us to do a couple of things. shift retained earnings from cash and investments into a tax-deferred growth vehicle, which is the policy. And so that might lower your tax profile. We don't want to put all your money in there. I think putting all your money in any one thing is disadvantaged or not advantaged to you because eventually you want to spend some of those money, you want to access it. If all your money is tied up in one product. then you lose flexibility and maneuverability, which is like a a big thing. but there are ways where you could structure. Sorry? Vishal Gill, CFP: But the ri but the rich don't want me to know the rich don't want me to know that. But the rich don't want you to know that. Tyson Nagasaka: Right. ev everything the when we see these like, hey, this is what the rich people do or whatever, there should be there should be disclaimers on it, just like it like on cigarette packages. number one, is the advice that you're watching, is it Canadian? Because you can't put all your assets in a trust and then buy life insurance on it in Canada. We have different trust rules. Maybe we'll do a trust episode. doesn't work the same way. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: Trusts in Canada are not tax advantaged. They're actually taxed pretty harsh. so they're not going to lower your tax profile at all. And so just be very very, very careful with the advice that you're getting. And you might want to talk to one or two different financial planning shops to see what their opinion is on that thing you're thinking about. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And just to kind of wrap up about the passive income doesn't solve it. I think Tyson's last point was one of the best ones where you don't want to have all your eggs in any one particular basket. So you know, even if you get to the point where you've done all the prerequisites, now it makes sense for you to convert your term insurance that you had before now to permanent to solve that eventual tax problem that's scaled up to happen to you at life expectancy. Doesn't mean that all your corporate money should now be in this asset class. It's just another planning avenue that's available to you. so long as you get approved earlier on. So kind of in summary, I would say that you know, corporate whole life insurance is not a conclusion, it's a starting point. So whether you start with it now, for most people, I would say r take a real good look, especially if you're starting your career, like your your mid-ish career, maybe three, five years, something like that, you can start to roughly project out what your runway is gonna look like. And you can start to get some term insurance in place while you're young and you're healthy. Healthy being the more important part as opposed to being young. Like your rates will increase, but nothing super, super crazy. But healthy is the big part. So while you're healthy and insurable, look to get some term insurance now, whether you own it personally or corporately, it doesn't matter. You can roll it over later on if need be. But lock in your insurance now in terms to keep your costs low. And then once you pass all the prerequisites and it makes sense for you from a sequencing standpoint that now you're at that point where You know, whole life insurance can solve some of your problems, and you have that definitive problem to solve, you can then convert it and it's gonna cost you more, but it's solving a problem for you as opposed to just having it because people said that all doctors should have it. So, in in closing, hopefully this stuff helps. All you guys will probably get insurance in one way or the other, but when it comes to permanent whole life insurance or permanent life insurance, this episode is really about educating you on. Is it a good thing? Is it a bad thing? The answer is probably somewhere in the middle where you will most likely need it, but you can do it in a very cost effective way if you start early, keep your costs low, convert it later. We give you some framework about structuring, we give you some framework about things you should do prior to looking to convert it. And any questions you guys have, as Tyson mentioned, we'll put in the a link to our meetings in sorry, our meeting link in the show notes so you can book a call with us and just kind of talk it over and be like, hey, like what does this mean in in my situation. in addition to that, you can join our closed Facebook group for Doctors Across Canada to join in and ask some questions. and besides that, if you haven't already done so, make sure you share and subscribe and give us a rating on the podcast as well. All these things help us rank higher up when it comes to the messy, messy and noisy world of the podcasting. it's a that big running joke that you know the podcasts and mics are too cheap to get because everyone has a podcast nowadays. So if we can help Educate doctors. We want to be able to stand out of the noise and your guys' rankings and your subscriptions and all that kind of stuff really, really help us out on that front. So until then, this is episode nine, Portfolio Talks. We'll see you guys on the next episode. Take care.