Latest / Braver New Worlds / Preparing Young People for a World That Keeps Changing with Dr. Sydney Sharkey
Transcript
- Nathan Young: Hello, welcome back to Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. And if you're anything like me, you probably spend way more time on social media than you'd like. Perhaps you do get some basic utility out of it. It's part of your job. Or again, like me, you've made the devil's bargain of using social media to promote yourself and your projects for your own entrepreneurial endeavors. And even if you're getting something out of it, you've probably also felt the effects of this too. Where try as you might, you still get sucked in more than you'd like. Your attention gets fractured, you catch yourself engaging with content that is anything from dumb to unhelpful or even harmful. And this is to say nothing of the privacy concerns, especially in our AI world. And I'm speaking as an adult here, talking to other adults, presumably. We have some maturity and some agency to make thoughtful and well informed choices here with our fully developed prefrontal cortexes. so then the question is how is this all manifesting for young people as each new generation is one that has had social media as an influence earlier and earlier in their lives? How are they managing this? How are they coping with this? How are we preparing them for the world that they're gonna be growing up into? We have this notion that maybe we can quit social media or not engage, but like it or not, social media is media now. And much of what our emerging world is asking of us is to Be present and engaged with social media on some level. Yeah, I'm sure we can all find ways to decrease it or take breaks for it from time to time, but to just completely opt out of it is a binary that very few of us really have the luxury of having anymore. So my guest today is Dr. Sydney Sharkey and she is an educator and researcher whose work focuses on social media well being and media literacy. And her work also revolves around one big question. If digital media is part of the world young people are growing up into, how do we help them understand what it's all about? What it's doing, what it wants from them, why they're seeing the content they're seeing and how to make thoughtful choices within all that. And she's interested not just in what adults think is happening to students, but what students themselves say about their experience and what they think would be helpful. her work primarily revolves around college students, but in this conversation we talk about everywhere from, you know, preschool to twelfth grade and beyond. So if you are struggling with your own social media usage or you have a young person in your life that you hope to engage in conversations about media in a thoughtful way, or just, you know, are curious to know more, this is gonna be the conversation for you. So let's get into it. Sydney Sharkey, welcome to the podcast. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Thank you so much. I'm happy to be here. Nathan Young: Cool. Well, as I'd like to start all these off, just introduce yourself real quick to the folks at home. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, so my name's Dr. Sydney Sharkey. I'm a lecturer at San Diego State University and a couple other colleges around San Diego. And I have a doctorate in education and my focus is on social media and well-being. So I have a book coming out in October around social media, well-being, and then how we can, as educators, essentially create classes around these conversations that are more in alignment with what students want to talk about and also in alignment with with what might be actually improving or helping students' well-being. Nathan Young: Yeah, okay, cool. And and just so I kinda understand your primary thesis as far as I understand it here, which I thought was really fascinating, i is just that there's this balance between social media is not the best thing for our mental health and our brains, but also it's not going anywhere. And it's actually like media now. This is how Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: we interact with the world. And Yeah, we have to be realistic of what that balance is and how we understand the way we interact with social media. Is that essentially your point? And then vis-à-vis young people. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, absolutely. So I think one of the biggest issues with online narratives right now around social media and well-being is kind of this all in, all out mentality. It does really well online. So people like Jonathan Hike, for example, have become very popularized online because they're very good at expressing a one message, which is that phone bans or we don't need social media. And so one of the things that's very popular about that, it's very easy to grasp. It's very easy for us as people, as individuals, to say, okay, well, I could just not be on my phone or I could delete the app. That would be easy for me. And it's very digestible. What's difficult about that is that there's actually not one, a lot of evidence or research around this idea of well-being and deleting social media apps and our well-being increasing. And two, there's not a lot of evidence around our ability to actually stay off of apps. So people do a lot of what we call detoxing and then binging where they go off for quite a while and then they re-download the apps and then all of a sudden it's almost like a worse habit that they have been off for so long, now they kind of have to binge eat or like binge be on social media now. So that's kind Nathan Young: Interesting. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of some of the two most common issues that we see with more simplistic narratives around just getting off of the online space. And then Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: what's very interesting Interesting about current research around social media in particular. Some scholars like Pete Etchells does a really good job of explaining this idea of the balance of how social media in and of itself is neither good nor bad, but the habits we form around it could be. So one of the examples that Peach Etchells gives in their book is this idea that we could have a phone and be using it for navigation, and that could be really helpful to us. But if all of a sudden And we aren't able to be off our phones or it dings and we need to check it while we're driving, that's a bad habit. And so I love this idea of this concept that social media in and of itself isn't good or bad, but rather our habits around it are. And so my Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: research is very much focused around what kind of habits are we building, what's kind of normal to us, and then what Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: can we do to be able to have habits that are more in a alignment with our well-being and that has a lot to do more so with like reflecting on ourselves and what Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: feels good for us and what is like the boundaries we can have around social media just like we have boundaries around anything Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: else in our lives and what that really looks like. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. I think about this a lot too, because as somebody works in media and I've got a podcast and I've got an event series and I gotta promote all this stuff via social media Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: because that is how you interact with audiences Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: on media these days is via that. And Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: there's also part of me that's like I would love to just not have to be on there, but it there's just not Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: a reality for me and this lifestyle I've chosen for myself and I sort of did that very Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: consciously of like I want to live this way as opposed to my friends that are not on social media at all, they're accountants and architects and stuff and Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: very straight kind of jobs with a very straightforward thing that's not how my life is at all. But yeah, at the same time also generally I keep in touch with friends on there and I Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: do enjoy the entertainment. But yes, there is always This challenge of it can take a little bit more and I've also had to do some work to really balance myself to not get too wrapped up into what I see on there sometimes too. So yeah, I get it. Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, especially when it's your job, having boundaries around your job. I know so many Nathan Young: Totally. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: people, especially in COVID, could really relate to this idea of how do I have boundaries when my office and my bedroom are in the same space? it's not Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: being able to break away or have some kind of space from these devices or from work can be really difficult for us, mentally. And so I can definitely relate to that as well. Nathan Young: Yeah. And then so your work specifically is about young people, maybe you could tell us what age is, but also how these issues show up for them and how to maybe get them going on the right track as far as their understanding of the media they're consuming and their habits and stuff. is that right? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, so I focus a lot on the college space because I teach college. So 18 Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: to 22 is typical for what I work with. and the study that I did that is part of the book that's coming out in October is also on the age groups of 18 to 22. What I like about that age group is that they're young adults, but they still are starting to finally have some of their own freedoms, some of their Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: own ability to do and make their own habits, especially when it comes to social Social media. In fact, I feel a lot of people, when they are out of the space of their home, if they have a very protectionist approach around social media time, for example, and then all of that is gone now that they're not in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the home space, that can become very difficult for young Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: adults. And so I focus a lot of my time and space in that area, especially because I teach in there too. I've been Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: asked a lot to participate more and more in the K through 12 Space just because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: one of the biggest issues around social media that so many scholars talk about is that when do we need to start addressing these issues? So is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: it that we need to start talking about media habits when kids are five or is it when they're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: 10? Should they not be introduced to media at all before then? And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: there are more and more guidelines and regulations around media usage that vary scholars within that specific field have been implementing. I think one of the most recent ones is like under two years old is no screen time at all. From two to five is like, yes, but only an hour a day. And it must be Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: something like learning or educational. Five and up is things like movies, things that don't provide any kind of dopamine hits essentially. They don't Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: want you or your child to be in Engaging in something like scrolling on a phone Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: where there's just so much of a detention span. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And so more and more scholars are starting to give us age limits and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: age restrictions around these different areas. I think what's been frustrating so far as someone in the field is seeing then kind of the school's responses to things too. So I'm in the education sector, and one of the most interesting parts of this is watching The ways that schools have simultaneously called for media literacy to be implemented across schools, but then called for phone bans as well. And so I think Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: there's kind of a tension that's happening in school districts, across administrations, that there's not a clear consensus about Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: what is and is not working. And I think Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that teachers themselves are also getting frustrated because they want to be implementing things like media literacy, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: literacy education, how to spot disinformation or misinformation, how to be able to spot trolls online or what AI videos look like. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: But then they're being told that they can't use phones in classroom or be able Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: to like see those actual real life examples. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: so I think that becomes difficult from a educational point of view and especially in Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that K through 12 space. I think that's probably the most frustrating thing about working Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: in that space is the regulations that get put on you as a teacher. That's why I enjoy the college space. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I like to be able to actually talk about the things that I study and be able to actually teach media literacy. So that's a very important part of what I do. And I think that I have seen a lot of frustration from other teachers around not being able to do that in certain districts. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Well yeah, and for young people too, the schools live I don't know if it'd be upstream or downstream is a term, but they're live from the parents, and the parents are gonna bring bringing their Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Yes. Nathan Young: own points of view also, right? and some parents would eat like just would be lackadaisical about it. Some parents would be like, I want my kids on social media. Some parents would be like, I want my kids on no screens at all and Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: school's gotta balance all that. I'd imagine that'd be part of it, right? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, it reminds me sex education, like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the just difficulties of having parents agree what is and is not appropriate for their child. And especially Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: as we get more and more into the AI issues of things. And especially I know there's a new topic right now about AI child pornography. Is that or is that not an appropriate topic to talk about in a middle school classroom, a high school classroom? How do you convey to children, to middle schoolers, the importance of online online presence and people in an online space who could be taking images of you while also Nathan Young: Mm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: not conveying that this is what they might use them for. So I think Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that can be a tricky or a slippery slope too in terms of what is not appropriate for different age groups. Yeah. Nathan Young: Oh man. See, I don't have kids myself, so I don't think whenever I have these conversations I go so much stuff comes up because I then there could be bullying involved here too. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: And kids can be doing it to each other and they Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: might just be doing it as jokes. They don't quite realize how harmful it is. Then Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: they're and they're probably finding out about new apps faster than teachers are on some level too, right? Like Yeah. it's so okay. it does strike me that sex ed piece is interesting too, because a lot Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: of it strikes me as very similar when you talked about the college students, it struck me as very similar to the way we talked about like drugs and alcohol when I was of the age of going to college and Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: and how that was like a dynamic, especially that thing you said about the freedom and suddenly getting this new freedom and all of a sudden, drugs and alcohol become a concern. So It is such an interesting analogy there, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, well and so much of social media is compared using analogies that are very similar to drugs and alcohol. we Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: say that social media you can have an addiction to it, which is true in a sense. Pete Etchels again talks about this in his book, the defining term of addiction and what addiction means versus like overusage of social media and what that means. And it is difficult to kind of like pinpoint the line of where addiction starts and over usage stops. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: so that part is really kind of interesting. And then the other part is that students, I think it was the Humane Center for Technology which did that Netflix documentary about social media, the social dilemma, where they talk about Nathan Young: Mm. Okay, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: people on social media being referred to as users and they call them users, like social media Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: users, like drug users. Nathan Young: I Dr. Sydney Sharkey: It Nathan Young: never made that. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: yeah, it very much is a terminology that the media itself uses for people who are online and that scholars and other people use to describe someone who has an over reliance on social media as well. So they're very similar in that fashion, I Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: would say, very different in terms of maybe like the approaches we have to them. Again, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I don't necessarily see social media. media as one of those aspects of maybe drug use or it's like you have to go cold turkey on social media because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: it has the fallback of well now I want to do this more when I don't have it. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. what is the problem with social media when it comes to like well being and stuff too? We've been sort of dancing around Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: it, but rather than let people assume what we're talking about as far as what the problems are, what are the problems? What are the well being challenges? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, so there's been lots of studies. One of the studies, the one that I conducted when I was going through the book, was really focusing on what students said. So I conducted a study in which I went across different parts of the UC system, so University of California, and did a survey for a bunch of students and essentially asked questions like, What do you feel is positive parts of social media and what do you feel are the negative parts of social media for your well-being personally. And a lot of people talked about the positives, which were things you kind of talked about, like social connection, being able to see different parts of the world, being able to experience new cultures. If they hadn't been able to travel, a lot of young people who are just getting into college but hadn't had been able to have an experience yet of going to a new country we're talking about their ability to kind of see culture on social media spaces. Which was interesting, staying connected to people maybe they wouldn't have been connected to before. But the most common thing that I've seen and that I read studies about is this idea of wasted time. we waste our time in lots of different areas Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of life. I mean, of course, we used to waste time, maybe people would say binge watching TV shows or Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: be playing too many video games. We Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: kind of consistently in life can waste time in Certain areas or fashions. I think what's a little bit different about social media in particular or unique about it is it's very isolating. When you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: have TV, when you have video games, it can still be a social process. So you're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: still capable of engaging with someone else. Maybe you're gaming online in a like live virtual setting so you can talk to people who are real. Maybe you're watching a movie with a loved one. So these are a little bit different in terms of just our ability to be able to still have a social connection. The Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: irony about social media is that we really aren't getting that face-to-face or that live time social interaction unless you're like on live, which a Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: lot of people aren't doing unless you're a producer or a creator. And so I think one of the biggest issues or some of the most common themes that pop up is loneliness. And our inability or our time wasted that happens in online spaces, too. So depression and anxiety are two other ones that pretty consistently pop up in the literature as well. Something that Jonathan Haidt and Jean Twenge both do really well is they've collected a lot of data that has shown us a very deep, if not correlation, a very deep probable cause of anxiety and depression being Connected to social media. There are other scholars who kind of debate about this, say that there's not enough evidence around this particular topic in relationship to so many other factors that could contribute to anxiety and well-being over the course of different generations. But I would say there is a lot of evidence to at least suggest that in some fashion. we are, or the most recent Generation is the most anxious and most depressed generation, and it has kind of increased over time. And so, again, there could be a lot of factors to that, and there are plenty of scholars who really go over correlations of like why that might not be the most accurate data, but also there is a lot of data to suggest that that could be a possibility. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Well yeah, no, isn't that part of the scrolling and the way that sort of rewires our dopamine receptors and we get Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Uh-huh. Nathan Young: used to these like little quick kinda hollow hits of dopamine. 'cause yeah, I'm old enough remember before all this and you watch T V and stuff and it would be like once upon a time, you'd be flipped through the channels and there might just not be anything on. And you're like, well, I'm just I guess there's nothing on. I guess I'll do something else. But Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: but even then, even when you had access to more like on demand entertainment, it would still be in increments, pretty Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: solid increments. okay, show's over, turn it off, go do something else. And now it's so easy to just get caught scrolling forever. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yes. Yeah. Nathan Young: And, I see how that has messed with my attention span and ability to focus and dopamine probably receptors too. And then also Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: the comparisons, right? 'cause it's so easy to see other people, these seemingly normal people on there that, they've got a life that you want or they've got something Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: you want. And it seems tantalizingly available if only Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: you put your own life on the screen. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yes, a hundred percent. And students do talk about that as well. That is one of the negative side effects or negative well-being causes that a lot of people talked about. In studies, it's actually predominantly women who talk about this too. They talk a lot about this inability to compare themselves to other women online, whether that be the way their skin looks or the way that their hair is or the new clothes that they have. And it does become so much about like how can I achieve that that this person has. And kind of the sinister part of social media is this idea that influencers are our friends. They're someone we're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: connected to or have a relationship with. And because they've shown me like they're beautiful, have so much they've achieved, they have so much they've accomplished. Like if I just buy what they are promoting, then Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: maybe I can also emulate That as well. And so I think maybe similar to advice we would take from a good friend, it becomes, well, I'm really interested or like this person. Maybe I can also emulate part of that as well. And I think that's very different than traditional commercials we used to see just on Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: television, even 20 years ago, where we would see someone advertising something as like, okay, like that was a funny commercial, but I'm Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: not acting, I don't care about these people. They're actors and I think that's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: something we don't quite make a connection with now anymore is that the we don't see influencers as actors we see them as people and I think Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that's kind of the mistake that gets made a lot especially when it comes to the comparison issue online and in these spaces with women and with men that Nathan Young: Uh-huh. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: these are people who care about us who love us who want the best for us Who are our friends. And in reality, they're just people making a livelihood who need to sell a product. And that's just Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: part of their job. And that's okay. But our inability to recognize that as consumers is kind of where that line is getting a little blurred. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. And so it sounds like part of your work then too is different approaches towards managing that, approaching that and understanding that. could you maybe tell us a little bit about that or what what you Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, yeah. So my work is very centered around media literacy, which is this idea that when we come into online spaces or we engage in online spaces, we know what's being set up for us. So that idea of the influencer, for example. If I am media literate, I can sit there and say, huh, I wonder why this particular person is selling this product. I wonder Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: why their hair looks this way or their adverse. Advertising like this particular brand. And I can begin to question a little bit more behind not only their intention, but my need or desire for something as well. It's a media literacy is a lot about the intentionality of the people who are producing something, but then also thinking a lot more critically about ourselves as consumers and do I need this thing or do I just want this thing? What is this person doing? Telling me about myself that is incomplete or feels incomplete, and how Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: can I be addressing that or having that in other ways that also aren't bankrupting me? Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally, totally. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, so it is very much about a self-reflection and also Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: about being more critically aware of just other people's influence on us. I think that one of the most difficult things about social media. It's just that we become so I don't want to say uncritical, but it does become a little bit of just like you're just scrolling. You're just not thinking. And you and you want that. I think part of Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the draw of social media, and I know like my feed, for example, my feed is no advertised, it's just dogs. It's just dogs and funny videos. Nathan Young: Mm-mm mm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And every once in a while I'll get like a if you watch this video, like you should buy. This for your dog, or you should get this for your baby. And so I still do get a lot of ads, but I have enough wherewithal with media literacy to say, do I need that product or Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: do I want something else instead that I could easily just get myself? And so I think that it's difficult, especially when people are making a livelihood around these ideas as well that they need to sell their particular product. I think that that's totally fine. Where the difficulty becomes is the disingenuous personality of making someone believe that they need this thing in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: order to feel good about themselves. And I think that's like where we toe the line with women and men growing up in a space where they don't feel good enough. And I think that's kind of the space I really want students to know too that they can continue to cultivate or feel good about themselves without Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the need to purchase items or be a part of an online community that asks them to change who they are too. Nathan Young: Yeah. So I gotta be honest, that sounds like a lot to ask of the consumer to have that level of awareness about themselves and the media Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: they're taking in and stuff. Is that something that comes up? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, no that's a great question. I think it's a lot in general, just being a human. So sometimes Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I do think about that and I'm like, it is difficult. it is difficult to have a level of self-awareness that allows us to not just kind of like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: typical term would be now, brain rot in front of our screens all day. Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: But I also think it can kind of contributes to this philosophy that so many of us in education have as well, which is that we don't just become educated For a purpose of like a job or a title. We become educated for the purpose of a social good, of creating a society where people engage with each other more, care about each other more, want the best for your neighbor. So I think it's less about education in terms of how can I reach this level of education that will allow me to obtain a degree or obtain a job? Because if that was the purpose Of media literacy, it would be that a lot of people probably wouldn't care about it. It very Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: much is more rooted in this intrinsic value that a social good is why we learn certain skill sets or why we care about certain skill sets. I think it's Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the same reason so many people now are in therapy is because people want to be better for themselves, for their families, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: for other people that they interact with every day, and they want to be able to be good contributing members of society in terms of how kind they are, how they engage and how they're able to come to conflict resolution, all of those things. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. You may have noticed that one of the recurring themes of this podcast is that the world as it is isn't the only world that's possible. And the people I talk with on here are often exploring different ways of leading, working, building community and creating change in the world here too. And you also may have noticed that we have a few problems in our world. Things aren't the way that a lot of us would like them. And many of the guests I've had on here have had on specifically for the ideas they have to share about what could make our world a better place. and this all gets back to the kind of work that I do too. This connection of leadership and social change. Very much part of the work I do. I work with leaders to help them own and share their own bold vision for a better world. Sometimes this means helping someone find the message in the heart of a talk they're giving or an overall message they're sharing about who they are and the kind of work they're doing. Sometimes it means helping an organization tell a clearer and more compelling story about the work they're doing and the change they're trying to make. And sometimes this even means helping my clients understand what it means to be courageous and applying that courage to the message they wanna share. Right now I do this primarily through coaching and consulting with leaders specifically, but also with some small organizations. I'm also developing a set of tools and training models an idea I call narrative leadership, which is a framework for understanding how the stories we tell shape what we believe is possible and our ability to make these stories real. And I'll be sharing much more about this work here soon. So if any of this sounds interesting, it sounds like something that you could use help with for your either for yourself or for your organization, I'd love to hear from you. I'd love to see if we could work together. you can start by visiting my website which is storyculture consulting dot com or finding me on social media and all the channels. It's Nathan Cody Young on all of them. There are ways you can message me either through social media, through the website. So get in touch with me that way. And of course keep listening here. I plan to roll out some pieces of this here very soon. So as more and more of that comes together, you're all gonna be the first to hear about it. So thanks so much for listening to my little commercial here, And now let's get back to the episode. so I have a background in media and I worked in advertising and I worked in journalism for a long time my previous career and in media now. And you're doctor you've studied this and you're in this field Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: and it is but even I'll even catch myself and a lot of emotional exhaustion or something like that. So Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm. Nathan Young: I'm much more susceptible at like ten PM to just go down some weird scroll, doom scrolling tunnel or like a rage bait tunnel. And my feed is all dogs or you know, ice agents being shitty. And so Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: I just get like jogged around. Then I'll yeah, we'll kind of like go into some weird like rage bait thing at 10 30 p.m. Like fuck, I'm trying to go to sleep here, but yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I didn't want to get rage baited this late at night. Nathan Young: So but even sort of as being aware it, that's kind of my point is like it takes a lot of vigilance even for somebody that's like aware to keep up with it and the way that this that Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: it's working on us. And it just does strike me as something that's difficult for somebody that isn't conscientious of it. And I think a lot of times too, or there's just so many pieces to understand about how it all works also, to understand how Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: the marketing world works and the advertising world works and why certain products are being sold to you in certain ways and yeah, I don't know. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I think one of the most simple things people can do if this is an overwhelming topic or learning about this feels overwhelming in any way it's just being more aware of how you feel after so very similar I'm using a lot of food metaphors but for some reason that helps me Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: as a person but it's very similar to like after you eat something do you feel good and do you feel Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: energetic and do you feel like you could go do something that gives you a lot of energy throughout the day. Day or do you feel sick? Does your stomach hurt? Do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: you not exactly want to do anything after? And so similarly, I ask students sometimes keep a journal, and in that journal write down how you feel after you scroll for a certain amount of time. what kind of emotions came up for you during that time? What were you looking at? Did you feel accomplished? Did you feel Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: any kind of Just feelings that pull up for you. And then they kind of do this through other parts of their life too, if they go on a Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: walk versus if they go and read a book versus if they're talking with friends and family. And I think what's nice about this is it allows us again just to be more aware of our own bodies, of our Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: minds. how does this impact me without me even realizing it? Because there are so many Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: times where social media will instantly put you in a bad situation. Mood you're watching a right an ice video and a raid, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Totally. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: and then all of a sudden you're in a horrible mood for an hour, two hours of the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yes. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: day, and you interact with colleagues and they don't get a good version of you. And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I think what's nice about just sitting and being with those feelings a little bit more is recognizing, like, yeah, I don't feel good most of the time that I Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: do this activity. I tell my partner a lot, if I I ever scroll. We've been doing a thing lately where we've been watching movies. I have a whole fall list of movies I want to see, movies I've never seen before that are old classics that I have just never happened to watch. And I was like, can we put our phones away and just watch a movie for two hours? And yes, that's screen time, but then afterwards we talk about it and we engage with each other. And I was thinking about the other day how I would feel if I scrolled on my phone for two hours and I was like I don't I've done it a few times Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: and I don't feel good at all. Like I do not feel good about myself. I don't remember anything that I was watching. And it sometimes gives me a little I'll laugh at something in the moment, but I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: won't remember it a few days later versus Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: a movie I talked about it with my mom the next day. She had seen it. She loved it. We talked about it for an hour. It's just like providing I feel more points of connection for people. And if that's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: something you can cultivate on social media and you're constantly just sending reels to people that you don't see and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: you're engaging with friends all the time, I think that could maybe bring a little bit of joy and have a different experience for you. But if it's just you alone and you're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: never kind of getting that interaction with others, that is usually contributing to this loneliness epidemic that so many of us talk about. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well yeah, and what comes up for me is you share too. that's that's great. That's good for those of us that have the awareness and ability to implement those. But yeah, just whether it's from a social condition or economic condition or mental condition where if you don't have those faculties, it seems like it'd be really rough. Like, I should get more in shape. I should start running or go the gym and it just takes a little bit of a mental load to get over that first initial hump, right? And you know, and or Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, a hundred percent. Yeah. Nathan Young: I'm on GLP ones now, so not as much, but I'm the definitely the type that would have eaten a whole bag of chips and felt terrible and then been like, Why the fuck did I do that? And then do it again two nights later. So like Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Cause it tastes good. And that's the issue with social media, is that in the moment it feels great. Nathan Young: Yeah, for sure, for sure. but it is a cheap good feeling. It's not like a very Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: yeah, totally. well so let's see. so you talked about also you know asking young people themselves like how they felt and what they experienced with it. Can you tell us a bit more about Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: that? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, I think when I was looking at studies, one of the biggest parts of what I noticed in my dissertation when I was in grad school was just there were so many people talking about students or talking about Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: social media users, but not Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: a lot of people directly asking them what their experiences were or how they felt. And I think that that was something that I really wanted to understand more of was just how are people experiencing This and not only that, but how would they solve it? I think that was Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: something that I really wanted to know because sometimes I feel I'm a millennial, so I feel like sometimes I can be in tune with Gen Z. I'm very much like one of those border generations where I'm Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: right on the edge. But a lot of times I feel like I miss cues and marks too. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And so what's nice about directly asking people and not just doing a study on them Is this ability to get an insight into what they personally feel would be helpful? when I'm teaching, there are so many days where yes, my expertise and having a background in teaching is giving me a leg up and allowing Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: me to facilitate the classroom in a way that's useful and helpful and guided. But at the same time, I might not pull relevant examples for the students. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: So They a lot of times bring in examples from their own culture, their own life. Everyone Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: just has such different experiences from us. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And so the ability to have that much insight is what I felt like was valuable to me as a researcher. Because even though I have an expertise in something, it doesn't mean that I have an all-knowing eye to what is going to solve the social media debacle. Yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah. Totally, totally, yeah, yeah. Well I imagine it's gotta be valuable for the students too to feel like they have a little bit more agency in their own learning, Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: right? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, and not very much agency is a part of media literacy too. Being able Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, toy. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: to have your own say in things, to use your own voice. One of the biggest shifts that happened when we talk about media literacy, we also talk about kind of the different cycles learning and learning about media that happened before. And one of those is called the protectionist approach, which is just like you can't be on social media, we need to ban media, it's just too much for kids. And it kind of came from this idea that we can't trust students to learn about this because they're not capable of understanding. And I very much, along with other scholars, agreed that that's not true. I've always thought students come with all of this insight into their world, their ideas. And really us as teachers is just to kind of facilitate a deeper conversation about those rather Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Rather than to give our ideas of what the world should look like and say, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Well, this isn't actually the way you should be thinking, you should be thinking how I'm thinking. Instead, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: we very much kind of open up a conversation of, well, if this is something you saw on your social media feed, not only how did that make you feel, but why do you think like that was on your feed? Or Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: in what ways does this impact other people? That's something that comes up a lot too is being able to recognize the ways that certain narratives online can stereotype others or can Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: create conflict or violence for others in the real world. And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that's something that you can talk about and be able to facilitate in a classroom space without really indoctrinating ideas because we never Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: want to indoctrinate students into thinking the way that we think or believing the way Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that we believe because that wouldn't create a society of open-minded thinkers who can all Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: have different ideas and values and beliefs. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Well I wonder how aware do the young people that you're talking to or working with how aware are they of the forces at play in the media that they see? Dr. Sydney Sharkey: It's such a big range. It is so interesting to see because I work with freshmen and then I work with a lot of upper division too. So this semester I'm primarily upper division, but I have so many students in my class where we were talking about Google ads the other day. And Google does such a good job using emotion to really get you either tied to them as a loyal follower or just to buy the product at hand. They're very, very good at it. All my students cried at the ad that I showed for the Google ad. It's just very emotional. It's about this Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: old man who is trying to remember his wife who's past. And it's a great commercial. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: then afterwards, we talked about what is the purpose of a commercial like this? what does this make us forget or not think about in terms of this Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: particular company? And so many students were like, ethical Issues, environmental issues, morality, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: labor issues. they had so Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: many things where they already just knew right off the bat, or had done their own research and had kind Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of gone into this rabbit hole of like, these are the different things contributing to this particular company that we know Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of, or that we're aware of. That Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: and even then, this ad still impacted us, and we're aware of it. And I was Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah, Dr. Sydney Sharkey: a hundred percent and that is the Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: fear is that even when you're aware of it you're impacted Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: by it and it makes kind of a movement on you and so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I would say but then I have students where I'll ask them how do you think this ad might influence you at all? And they're like, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: hmm I don't know. it just it kind of it just takes longer. It just takes longer. And that's okay. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: But I think that that's always the way it is in education. some people are trying really hard and some people are kind of just trying to get there and especially freshmen, everybody comes from really, really different high school experiences. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And so then for all of them to be in the same college classroom space, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I have people where they've never learned how to do citations. they were just like, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I've never learned that I didn't know you were supposed to put someone's last name after you quoted Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: them. I didn't know what crediting Nathan Young: Mm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: someone is. I'm like, no. And then you Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: have other people where they could write an honors paper. And you're like, are you in the right class? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: it's just such a variety. But that is the nice part about asking from students' experiences and having them bring in their Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: own life experience because then you can really say, okay, you have had this particular experience around social media and you feel this way, but then there's somebody else in the classroom who maybe isn't on social media at all and has had these interactions or relationships with talking about this. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. it's interesting. it's funny you mentioned those Google ads too because I've used those in the workshops I do for organizations and what I do professional development training I do around storytelling communication. And they've got a couple. I know, Dr. Sydney Sharkey: They're so good. Nathan Young: I know. Well they have one in particular that has these courses that they offer for technical training and I shared Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: this commercial and every time I'll be working with people very dedicated to their field and career they're on. But I'm like, did you think about signing up for this course? did you think about changing careers doing this course? 'cause Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: the commercial is compelling and yeah, they do a good job. What so okay, I got one more kind of field here I want to ask you about. And I'm not sure how much you can comment on this, but I'm just definitely kind of curious to hear your thoughts. as we're having this conversation, one of the things that just strikes me is just Almost like how much maybe education just needs to fundamentally change. and I don't know what goes on in for grade level education or even college level education to be perfectly honest with Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: you. But I remember when I was a kid and we were learning our mathematics tables and we're like, why do we need to learn this as calculators now? And as we got into high school, 'cause I'm like a younger Gen X and I got into high school and Just feeling like, we should learning about computers. there's gonna be this thing called the internet soon. We should learn about computers and stuff. And Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: it just seems like, yeah, now, I don't know if to the degree that young people are still learning those very rote subjects like I learned, but so much of our world involves media now. And Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: it just seems like, yeah, media literacy should be a core competency, maybe even Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: over some advanced science, even or Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Y yeah, so one of the biggest I would say Is it the biggest conflicts in our field in particular? Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Is this discussion around should we be integrating media literacy into every class, or Nathan Young: Mm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: should there be one class dedicated to media literacy? And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I think there is a lot of really compelling conversations from both sides of the argument. there's this idea that people won't integrate media literacy into their classrooms just because it's something That is recommended for them to do. It's actually Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: in California got passed in through a bill that it is recommended that you have media literacy requirements in K through 12 classrooms. But I think we can probably Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: attest that we don't know if that is or is not happening. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I know in my own classrooms that I have plenty of students who've never even heard the word media literacy before. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: But they know concepts. So sometimes it's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: hard to, and this is something I talked about in the book: is that There's kind of weird concept that happens that people know what it Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: is that they're doing or they know about media literacy, but they've never heard that specific term before. So they'll Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: learn something like how to spot misinformation online. Or Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: they'll learn about how algorithms can trick us. But Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: if I were to say, are you media literate or have you ever taken a class on media literacy, they'd be like, no, I don't even know what that is. So one Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of the things I suggest in the book is being more Explicit both in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: curriculums and then also on titles for classes around Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: like does this class integrate media literacy and having Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that as an actual definition and part of the class? Because the issue is that a lot of times what happens with students is that when they're learning concepts but they don't get told what that concept is, there can be an issue with retention there too, like, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I know this skill set but I'm Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: not quite sure what it is that I'm learning. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. where how to contextualize it, which box to put it in and that type of thing, right? Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yes, exactly, exactly. And so then another comparison I'll make, and this is probably the biggest issue that we're dealing with right now. I actually find media literacy and AI literacy to be the two biggest issues we Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: have right now. And AI literacy has now become maybe the same issue that media literacy used to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: be, and people are so fixated on it now that this Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: is all we're talking about, which is that AI literacy as people are saying needs to be integrated into every class. That's just Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: every teacher needs to talk about it. Well in the college space, you don't have to force a teacher to do anything. They can do whatever they want. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: As lecturers, we have rights to be able to include whatever we want in the classroom. there is a rule now that we have to have an AI policy, but Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that can include anything from I don't allow AI into my classroom to Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I allow AI and it looks like this to you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: can use AI whenever you want as long as you cite it. And that range is just Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: so enormous. And there's no way to really measure or mitigate any of this. And so what becomes difficult is that we're then trying to rewire or as you're saying, rethink education while simultaneously Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: not having a foundation. Because so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: many people are doing so many different things on this topic Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that is fundamentally changing the way that education looks right now. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that's kind of one of the biggest difficulties is that it used to be media literacy. That was the biggest one people were missing out on. Or if you Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: didn't get this teacher, you wouldn't learn it. And then it's now it's AI. And so I think Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: that it'll continue to happen with different Parts of our lives, but I would say those are the two biggest sectors that have happened so far in the last century is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: media literacy and AI literacy have become just like pillars that we're expected to teach about. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: the last thing I'll say is that we're expected to teach about them, but then don't get any resources on teaching them or how to integrate them into our classroom. Or if we Nathan Young: Mhm. Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah, yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: do get Them, they're not paid for. And so we're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: expecting teachers to do this kind of unpaid professional development Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: in order to achieve a classroom that administrators want from us, but that we're not sure we want for ourselves or for our Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: students. And so it just has become a very interesting environment in terms of the relationship between students and teachers, the relationship between Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: teachers and administrators, everybody's Perspective is a little bit different, and because Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: of that, it creates a lot of tension between all of the groups. Yeah. Nathan Young: totally. Well it strikes me too, yeah, how are we preparing young people for the world that they're gonna entering into and I don't Dr. Sydney Sharkey: No. Nathan Young: know I don't know how on point this is or not, but I grew up we learned chemistry, biology, physics. And I think that yeah, there was some value to that for sure, but also I think that I understood that as coming from a very sort of post post World War Two Cold War mentality of America's gonna win by having the best scientists and the best mathematicians and the best writers and the best engineers and and Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: that's what we learned that sort of like rote science in that way. And that rote science is great, important to learn now too, but there's probably the less scientists as a percentage of population, maybe, I don't know, to be honest with you. But like but yeah, like Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Maybe. Nathan Young: but you're right though, but the media is such a yeah, it's so integral to our world that we live in. It almost seems there's a vocational dynamic of understanding how media works in everything we Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: do because also one of the things I know is people in entrepreneurship, like well, I thought my entrepreneurial thing was to be selling this thing, but really what my entrepreneurial thing is to make videos about this thing. And so, you know, Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Mm. Mm. Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: And that could go part and parcel with just awareness also. But yeah, and what you're describing also takes requires a lot of savvy on the teachers that Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: might not necessarily have it themselves. And that's not unreasonable for them not to suddenly be experts on media and AI. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. No, it's frustrating and for to defend a lot of teachers. from their point of view, they signed up and became experts on English as a subject. Nathan Young: Totally. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And they're like, I love English and I love teaching it. And I love helping people learn how to write. And this is my passion. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: And that became something where everyone was expected to write papers. And then they were like, well guess what? This thing can write it for me. So why do I have to? And so I think Nathan Young: Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: it's made a lot of teachers really sad where that was their passion in life was to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: cultivate that For other students, and so in defense of them, I do feel like it is so frustrating when you spend so much time building your life around something, and then that thing kind of falls apart overnight, if you will. Nathan Young: welcome to the club. Sorry. Yeah. I don't know. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Maybe that's just life, but Nathan Young: but yeah, my pevious career And this is like six or seven careers ago, I sold advertising for newspapers, and it was a great Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: career while it lasted. I was in my late twenties on track to be making a hundred K and twenty years ago, and that just disappeared very quickly one day. And it was So yeah, I don't know. So on one hand I get ya and I'm with the teachers and I think this is just the big challenge of the world we live in is that things change so fast and even Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah. Nathan Young: for teachers to keep up is a difficult thing. Yeah. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Well and I feel it makes me feel bad for the students for the same reason. They're trying Nathan Young: Totally. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: to keep up with technology and they're like, Well, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: I feel that people are going to need to know how to work with AI and I need to know this skill set in order to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: have a job. And then some teachers are teaching it and some aren't, and then they're just kind of confused and worried and they're like, Well, what career can I take that's going to allow me to be not only fulfilled but live in the future. I have a bad for everyone. Everybody involved. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah, yeah, for sure. All right. Yeah, right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think I think it's a question a lot of us are asking. I think it's probably a good place for us to wrap it up here on that note. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Okay. Nathan Young: so for people that really like what they're hearing from you, tell us about you your book and tell us how people can get in touch with you, find more about you. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, it's Dr. Sydney Sharkey everywhere on social media. I do a Substack that I really enjoy Nathan Young: Cool. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: for teachers primarily. So I write about classroom experiences, kind of things that I'm trying out or doing. I found this to be really approachable, especially because publishing an article in a scholarly journal takes so long. I was like, I really want to get some of these ideas out here. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Mm-hmm. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: so Substack's a great place to get in touch with me. And then the book is coming out late October October and Nathan Young: Okay, cool. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: so yeah I will definitely be posting about it on all of my social feeds and on Substack as well. Yeah Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Cool. And we'll put links to all of this in the show notes as well for people. So all right, well Doctor Sidney Sharkey, thank you so much for coming on the podcast with us today. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Yeah, thank you so much for having me again. I had such a great time. Nathan Young: Awesome. All right. Well, talk to you again later. Bye. Dr. Sydney Sharkey: Bye. Nathan Young: Thanks so much to Dr. Sydney Sharkey for joining us. one thing I'm taking from this conversation is that the answer to a complicated media environment can't just be telling people to avoid it. Just opt out, just just just step back. It's just not gonna work. There's gotta be boundaries, but we also need the ability to recognize what's influencing us and talk about that openly, including in schools. And I also keep coming back to Sydney's point that students shouldn't just be the subjects of these conversations. they should have some agency and they should have some involvement in the conversation. They have their own experiences and insights that adults can miss. And making room for those perspectives is part of how we teach critical thinking rather than simply handing down conclusions to them. So if you want to explore more of Sydney's work, she writes about teaching and classroom experiences on Substack, and we'll include her links in the show notes below. And thank you so much for listening to Braver New Worlds, and we'll see you at the next one.