Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Owned community vs rented reach: the strategic choice CMOs keep getting wrong
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:08Today's episode, owned community versus rented reach.
- 0:11Why the consensus is half right.
- 0:13Every marketing conference this year has the same slide.
- 0:16Own your audience, escape the algorithm.
- 0:19You're telling me that's wrong?
- 0:21No, the diagnosis is right.
- 0:23The prescription is where teams quietly poison themselves.
- 0:27They hear owned community and build the wrong thing entirely.
- 0:30Define the terms first because owned and rented get thrown around like everyone agrees.
- 0:36Rented reach is any audience you access through a platform you don't control.
- 0:41Your Instagram followers, your TikTok reach.
- 0:44The platform can throttle it, charge for it, or delete you on a Tuesday.
- 0:48Owned means a direct line.
- 0:50Email addresses, phone numbers, an app, a forum you host.
- 0:54So the instinct to move off rented land makes sense.
- 0:57Where's the poison?
- 0:59Teams collapse two different things into one word.
- 1:02There's an owned audience, a list you can contact, and an owned community.
- 1:07People who talk to each other, not just to you.
- 1:09Those require completely different work.
- 1:11And most CMOs build the first while promising the board the second.
- 1:15Walk me through why that gap matters.
- 1:18A big email list sounds like a community.
- 1:20An email list is a megaphone pointed at strangers who happen to share your inbox.
- 1:25A community is a dinner party where the guests like each other.
- 1:29If you leave the dinner party, it keeps going.
- 1:31If you stop emailing your list, there's silence.
- 1:34That's a nice line, but give me the failure mode in practice.
- 1:37Peloton is the cautionary tale.
- 1:40Their real asset was never the bike.
- 1:42It was riders tagging each other, the Facebook groups, the leaderboard rivalries.
- 1:47When they cut costs in 2022 and 2023, they treated the community like a marketing channel
- 1:53to optimize rather than a room to host.
- 1:57Engagement cooled, and the flywheel they'd bragged about slowed with it.
- 2:00So the mistake is building broadcast infrastructure and calling it a community.
- 2:05Exactly.
- 2:06And here's the sharper version.
- 2:08A lot of owned community platforms teams buy are just email tools wearing a hoodie.
- 2:13You end up paying a subscription to broadcast, which is renting again, only now you're also
- 2:18doing the moderation for free.
- 2:20That's a dry way to say they bought their own trap.
- 2:23But isn't some rented reach unavoidable?
- 2:25You can't cold start a community from nothing.
- 2:28Correct, and that's the half the consensus gets wrong from the other side.
- 2:33Rented reach is how you find people.
- 2:35Owned is how you keep them.
- 2:37Telling a CMO to abandon paid social is like telling a shop to board up the front
- 2:41window because rent is high.
- 2:43So the two aren't rivals.
- 2:44What's the actual sequence?
- 2:47Three moves.
- 2:48One, use rented reach to reach strangers.
- 2:50That's what it's good at.
- 2:52Two, convert a slice of them to owned contact, an email or a login, so the platform can't
- 2:58stand between you.
- 3:00Three, and this is the one everyone skips, give those people a reason to talk to each
- 3:04other, not just receive your newsletter.
- 3:07How do you know if you've actually got a community versus a fancy list?
- 3:11One test.
- 3:13Turn off your own posting for two weeks.
- 3:15If it goes quiet, you have a list.
- 3:17If members keep answering each other's questions, you have a community.
- 3:21Notions user forums pass that test.
- 3:24People troubleshoot templates without the company in the room.
- 3:28Most brand communities fail it in about four days.
- 3:31Give me a number that makes the case to a finance-minded board.
- 3:35According to Sprout Social, a social media management vendor, so rate it with that in
- 3:39mind.
- 3:40Members who feel connected to a brand community spend meaningfully more over their lifetime
- 3:45and churn less.
- 3:47Churn being the share who walk away.
- 3:50The mechanism is simple.
- 3:52Leaving a community means leaving people, not unsubscribing from a company.
- 3:56So the connection is switching costs, dressed up as belonging.
- 4:00That's the honest version, yes.
- 4:03People stay for the other people, you're just the one who set the table.
- 4:06One thing a CMO should do Monday morning?
- 4:08Open the two-week silence test on whatever you're already calling a community.
- 4:13If it flatlines, stop buying broadcast tools and start funding one thing that gets members
- 4:18talking to each other.
- 4:19A single ritual, a weekly thread.
- 4:22Belonging is the asset.
- 4:24Everything else is postage.
- 4:25Done.
- 4:26Want to know where you actually stand?
- 4:28Take the CMO self-assessment at MBA-training.com.