Latest / The So What? / Budgets and Tariffs: So Where Are We Now?
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26This podcast goes with J .P.'s newsletter dated
- 0:31the 4th of June, 2025. And the title, Budgets
- 0:35and Tariffs, So Where Are We Now? I feel we've
- 0:40been here before. Yes, indeed. This is the third
- 0:43note that we're doing on budgets and tariffs,
- 0:46because the thing has been developing so much
- 0:49and in so many directions. But this is hopefully
- 0:52a conclusion of the budgets and tariffs story,
- 0:55certainly the budget story. Last time, you made
- 0:58the point that for the first time now, Parliament
- 1:01has the right, the freedom. to change the budget.
- 1:06And you were quite worried. You said this was
- 1:09a decisive moment. Absolutely. And you just have
- 1:12to look at the US to see what can happen if parliamentarians,
- 1:15in the case of the US, the Congress, dive into
- 1:19the budget and start changing numbers as it suits
- 1:22them. So it was what I labeled it in the last
- 1:26newsletter was it was a moment of decision. And
- 1:30I'm happy to say at the time of writing this
- 1:32note, the correct decisions seem to have been
- 1:36taken. The centre is holding in the sense that
- 1:41most of the middle parties are coming together
- 1:43around the budget as proposed by Treasury. Treasury's
- 1:47integrity and reputation is intact. And there's
- 1:50no splurge of either expenditure or higher debt.
- 1:54So I'm quite happy that the moment of decision.
- 1:57That moment has come and passed and we've taken
- 2:00the right decisions. For you, it is mainly about
- 2:03debt. Oh, absolutely. It's about debt stabilization.
- 2:07There's simply no question about it. The biggest
- 2:10single issue is to stabilize South Africa's debt,
- 2:14bring it down and save money on interest. And
- 2:17for that, the most important number in the budget,
- 2:19for me at least, is the primary surplus. And
- 2:22the primary surplus is simply whether your income
- 2:25is more than your expenditure before you start
- 2:28paying interest. We've run a primary deficit
- 2:30for a long time. Three years ago, we started
- 2:33with a primary surplus. This year in the budget
- 2:36that has now been tabled, budget number three,
- 2:38the primary surplus is budgeted to be 65 billion
- 2:42this year. Now, it means you will still run on
- 2:45a deficit. It means that you will still incur
- 2:47debt, take on debt, but with 65 billion. more
- 2:51in income than expenditure, the debt that you
- 2:54take on is decreasing. And over time, that helps
- 2:57to stabilize debt. So the primary surplus is
- 2:59a very important number. What's happening to
- 3:03the debt to GDP ratio? That has gone up a little
- 3:06bit, not because there's more expenditure, but
- 3:09because economic growth is budgeted to be lower.
- 3:12In February, with the first budget, economic
- 3:14growth was assumed that it would be 1 .9 % for
- 3:18the year. After the Trump tariffs that we've
- 3:21had and so on, the assumption in the budget now
- 3:23is that growth will be 1 .4%. So because there's
- 3:27less growth, but all the other numbers remain
- 3:30the same, therefore the percentage goes up a
- 3:33little bit. It goes up by 1 .2 % and it goes
- 3:36to 77 .5%, which is a high number. But if you
- 3:40compare it to many other countries in the world,
- 3:43you know, it's still doable. The trick is to
- 3:45bring that number down and you do that by way
- 3:47of primary surpluses. And that can only happen
- 3:50over years. It's not a short -term thing. You
- 3:53need time for that. But when you start running
- 3:55primary surpluses, as we are now doing, this
- 3:58will be the third year, then people sit up and
- 4:00they notice and the markets start responding
- 4:02and your interest burdens start declining. How
- 4:06has the market reacted? Actually quite good.
- 4:09If you take the rate when Budget 2 was tabled
- 4:16in April, the long rate, the long yield was sitting
- 4:20at 10 .75%. It has slowly come down, drifted
- 4:24downwards, about 38 basis points. Now, 0 .38%.
- 4:29Now, you can say 38 basis points is not a lot,
- 4:33but on the amount of money that the minister
- 4:35wants to borrow this year, 588 billion rand,
- 4:41it implies an interest saving of 2 .2 billion
- 4:45rand over 12 months. So it's a huge amount of
- 4:49money that you save in interest with a lower
- 4:51rate. With 2 .2 billion, you can appoint a lot
- 4:54of teachers and you can appoint a lot of doctors
- 4:56and you can fix up a lot of hospitals. So the
- 5:00long rate is not just a theoretical concept.
- 5:03It's very real. It determines the interest that
- 5:06you pay and the lower it is, the lower interest
- 5:09you pay, the more money you have available for
- 5:11other things. Well, we all know what interest
- 5:14rates mean on... a bond on your house or a loan
- 5:18on your car. Exactly. You mentioned something
- 5:22really unexpected, a possible source of extra
- 5:25money. It sounds as if the nation has a sock
- 5:27full of money under the mattress. In a manner
- 5:31of speaking, almost, yes. It is called the Gold
- 5:35and Foreign Exchange Reserve Account, which is
- 5:37held at the Reserve Bank. And basically there
- 5:39are surpluses that build up in that account.
- 5:42And last year, the minister drew money from that
- 5:46account to pay off on debt. Where does that money
- 5:50come from? Well, when the RAND depreciates against
- 5:53foreign currencies, it generates a surplus on
- 5:56the reserves that the Reserve Bank are holding.
- 5:59And the question then is, to whom does that surplus
- 6:01belong? Does it belong to the Reserve Bank or
- 6:05does it belong to the nation? And it's a kind
- 6:06of a... iterative process between the two. So
- 6:10after last year's experience, what will happen
- 6:13this year is in the second half of the year,
- 6:15going towards October, the Treasury and the Reserve
- 6:18Bank will sit together and they will decide,
- 6:20is there a sufficient surplus in the GFRAC account
- 6:24that can again be drawn, 10 billion, 20 billion,
- 6:28whatever. And then if you draw that money, that'll
- 6:30be a bonus. You pay it off on debt and you save
- 6:34the interest. Just for context, last year, the
- 6:37bank paid over or the government drew 250 billion
- 6:42from that account. 100 billion went back to the
- 6:45Reserve Bank as equity capital. So you reinforce
- 6:48the balance sheet of the Reserve Bank and 150
- 6:51billion was used to repay debt. And that's why
- 6:54if you look at the numbers, you will see there
- 6:55was a sharp decline in interest payments last
- 6:58year, precisely because there is this extra money
- 7:01that was used to repay debt. There's a huge difference
- 7:05between drawing the money to repay debt and drawing
- 7:08the money to pay current expenditure. There are
- 7:10people who would like the money to be used for
- 7:12current expenditure, but that's, of course, a
- 7:15crazy idea. A slippery slope. It's a very slippery
- 7:18slope. So all, in your perspective, all good
- 7:22news up to now, but it's still a long road. There
- 7:24are still, what, four voting dates? Yeah, as
- 7:27we discussed in our very first note that we did
- 7:30on the budget three notes ago, there are four.
- 7:33decision -making stages. The first one is the
- 7:36approval of the fiscal framework. That is at
- 7:39the moment penciled into the parliamentary calendar
- 7:41for 11 June, basically the week after next. Then
- 7:45the second decision is the division of revenue
- 7:47bill that is put down for 25 June when parliament
- 7:52has to decide on that. And then the third one
- 7:55is the Appropriation Bill, which will start,
- 7:59the discussion will start on 27 June. And the
- 8:02Appropriation Bill is basically the approval
- 8:04of each individual department in government.
- 8:07In a jargon, it's called a parliamentary vote.
- 8:11All those individual departmental budgets must
- 8:13be approved. And then the final approval of the
- 8:16Appropriation Bill will be on 23 July. So it's
- 8:20about seven, eight weeks from now. And then in
- 8:23October, we'll get the medium -term budget policy
- 8:25statement. And after that, there will be the
- 8:29revenue bills that will be tabled to Parliament.
- 8:32So it's basically four decision -making rounds,
- 8:35and each one of them is quite important. If one
- 8:37of them falls by the wayside, then you don't
- 8:39have a budget. You've got to have all four decisions.
- 8:43And this is where the party whips come in. They
- 8:45have to keep the members in line and make sure
- 8:48that people vote. according to the party's position.
- 8:51Now, so far, the parties, the main parties in
- 8:53Parliament, all support the budget. MK and EFF
- 8:57is against it, and EFF is taking the increase
- 9:00in the fuel levies to the High Court. We will
- 9:03have to see what the court decides on that. So,
- 9:06the second half of the newsletter, post the White
- 9:11House meeting that had us all glued to our screens,
- 9:14when the dust has settled, it's really about
- 9:18trade. Where are we on that? That's where I want
- 9:21to focus. I think, you know, millions of people
- 9:23have got trillions of opinions on the theater
- 9:26and the theatrics around it, be that as it may.
- 9:29I think the important point for us is trade.
- 9:32So let me first summarize where we are now. First
- 9:35of all, Agawa is dead. That's quite clear. Trump's
- 9:39general 10 % import levy that he's imposed against
- 9:42the whole world, not just against AGOA members,
- 9:46drove a stake through the AGOA agreement. So
- 9:49that one is dead. And people must, I've said
- 9:51it before, people must just forget about it.
- 9:54It's not going to be around. Then Trump has also
- 9:59threatened to impose 31 % reciprocal tariffs
- 10:02on many countries also on South Africa. It's
- 10:08important those tariffs, as you know, have been
- 10:11suspended until 9 July and we will have to see
- 10:13whether he brings them back or not. It's important
- 10:16to note that half of South Africa's exports to
- 10:19the US have not been tariffed because it consists
- 10:22of minerals, various mineral products that the
- 10:25US is keen to have and Trump has therefore exempted
- 10:28those minerals from tariffs. So there's a general
- 10:3210 % on everything, but not on minerals. Minerals
- 10:35have been exempted. And then there is a 25 %
- 10:39tariff on steel, aluminium, automobiles, motorcars,
- 10:44and also automobile spare parts, which are used
- 10:47in the US to assemble motorcars there. What will
- 10:51happen on the 25 % we don't know. We've started
- 10:56writing this note. Trump has, in fact, doubled
- 10:59down and increased the steel tariffs to 50%.
- 11:03So we'll have to see how that turns out. So in
- 11:06summary, half the exports are not tariffed. The
- 11:10rest is subject to 10%. But steel, aluminium
- 11:14and motor cars are subject to 25 % and steel
- 11:17now apparently to 50%. So that's where we stand.
- 11:22What has South Africa put on the table? Well,
- 11:25the details of the South African proposal have
- 11:29not been made public yet, but thanks to Reuters,
- 11:32some of the details have come out. And South
- 11:37Africa is basically offered to buy liquefied
- 11:40natural gas, LNG, from the United States for
- 11:44a period of 10 years at a rate of between 75
- 11:47and 100 million cubic meters per annum. Now,
- 11:51as listeners will know, South Africa is facing
- 11:55a gas cliff by 28, 29 when gas from Mozambique
- 11:59will run out and we'll have to find other gas
- 12:02sources to satisfy internal demand. So buying
- 12:05LNG from America is not a bad idea. And that's
- 12:11one of the things that South Africa has put on
- 12:13the table. South Africa has also proposed, secondly,
- 12:16that 40 ,000 motor vehicles can be exported to
- 12:20the U .S. every year duty -free. Now, last year,
- 12:23we only exported 20 ,000. So the 40 ,000 is quite
- 12:26a generous claim, if I can put it that way. Again,
- 12:31we'll have to see whether that's acceptable.
- 12:33And thirdly, on steel, we have proposed that
- 12:39385 million kilograms of steel and 132 million
- 12:44kilograms of aluminium can be exported duty -free
- 12:47to the US every year. Those are the free... very
- 12:50tangible things that Reuters have picked up.
- 12:53Now, whether that's acceptable to the Americans,
- 12:57we'll have to see. I think one must look at the
- 12:59negotiating position. America clearly wants some
- 13:02of our minerals. They also want the American
- 13:04companies to be involved in gas exploration in
- 13:07South Africa, which we're undertaking. They also
- 13:10would like to sell gas to us. On the other hand,
- 13:13we would like to sell... motor car parts to them
- 13:16and automotive parts and we would like to sell
- 13:18steel and aluminium. So they want access here,
- 13:21we want access there. We'll have to see whether
- 13:24these two things, these two sets of demands can
- 13:29be turned into an agreement. And that really
- 13:31is perhaps the most important comment on a White
- 13:33House meeting. The proof of the pudding is in
- 13:36the eating. And if the meeting in the White House
- 13:40can help to keep These have African proposal
- 13:42on the table and at the front of the queue. And
- 13:46we can negotiate it quicker than what we otherwise
- 13:48would have had negotiated it. That would be a
- 13:51very clear win. Trump himself has said that the
- 13:54United States cannot negotiate all these agreements.
- 13:58They just don't have the people and the time.
- 14:00They just don't have the people and the capacity.
- 14:01You're talking about something like 90 countries,
- 14:049 -0. that have indicated that they want to negotiate
- 14:07with the US. Now, obviously, you would much rather
- 14:10be country number 10 than country number 90 or
- 14:14country number 80. And if the White House meeting
- 14:16helped to achieve that, then I think it would
- 14:19have been a clear win. What about Starlink? Starlink
- 14:24is about a lot of dust and noise. The principle
- 14:29is very simple. BBBE Act, Broad -Based Black
- 14:38Economic Empowerment Act of 2003, there's a very
- 14:42clear stipulation that an equity ownership requirement
- 14:46can be replaced by what is called equity alternative
- 14:50investments. And there are several big American
- 14:53and global companies operating in South Africa
- 14:55who've made use of this. For example, Citibank,
- 14:58I think Amazon and so on. So what those companies
- 15:01are saying is we can't give away or we can't
- 15:04do a deal around equity in our South African
- 15:08subsidiary, but we're happy to do more for training
- 15:11or more for people development or more for enterprise
- 15:13development. There we will do more than what
- 15:16is required in the various scorecards and those
- 15:19equity equivalents then make up. for the equity
- 15:22component so that is not a new principle it's
- 15:26it's an act it's also in the be each other for
- 15:29the ict sector so what is in what is this fight
- 15:33then about this fight is because in the electronic
- 15:35communications act there's a specific requirement
- 15:39that before a license can be issued under the
- 15:43act there must be a 30 ownership component now
- 15:46that is what the act currently says the minister
- 15:50has now issued a government gazette to say that
- 15:54that can be changed by way of regulations that
- 15:57is very dubious because if it's an act it's an
- 16:00act and if you want to change it you will have
- 16:02to change the act and that's a lengthy process
- 16:04it can take a couple of months to do that he's
- 16:07trying to take a shortcut by saying that the
- 16:09regulator icasa can take a decision around that
- 16:13by way of regulations. And that's what the debate
- 16:15is about. I suspect in the end it will have to
- 16:18be determined by a court ruling. But it's certainly
- 16:22not a new principle. It is something that has
- 16:24been used in South Africa, and there's no reason
- 16:27why it cannot be used again. Who will take it
- 16:29to court? Well, anybody who's unhappy. You know,
- 16:34anybody who's unhappy can take it to court. I
- 16:38just want to point out, people are focused on
- 16:40Starlink, but there are other operators in the
- 16:43world who also operate LEO's low -Earth orbit
- 16:48satellites. CAPER, for example, which is the
- 16:53name of some galaxy somewhere in the universe,
- 16:55is a project run by Amazon. Amazon has started
- 16:59launching satellites to introduce Project CAPER
- 17:03to do exactly the same thing as Starlink. Eurotel
- 17:07is doing the same thing in Europe, exactly the
- 17:09same story. They're talking to MTN. Vodacom is
- 17:14talking to Project Caper. So there are other
- 17:18alternatives. There are also alternatives in
- 17:20China. So Starlink is not the only game in town.
- 17:25But these other companies, should they want to
- 17:28come in, they would also have to meet the 30
- 17:30% requirement. So this exemption can apply to
- 17:33more than just Starlink. In summary, so what?
- 17:37Well, I think, first of all, the drama that we
- 17:40had around budget when Parliament flexed its
- 17:43muscles and the budget first couldn't be tabled
- 17:46and then the increase in the VAT rate couldn't
- 17:48go through and so on, that is now behind us.
- 17:51And I think the bottom line is that the central
- 17:54focus of debt stabilisation and debt consolidation
- 17:57has not been lost. There's a clear political
- 18:01focus on that. There's a clear political will
- 18:05to bring that down. The increase that we've seen
- 18:09in the percentage is because the GDP growth is
- 18:12lower, not because there's more expenditure.
- 18:14So I think that's a plus. The centre is holding
- 18:17around the budget. There's a kind of a fiscal
- 18:20conservatism or a fiscal middle -of -the -roadism,
- 18:24which I think is to be welcomed. That's a very
- 18:27important so what. And I think, secondly, the
- 18:32mere fact that the budget in South Africa, after
- 18:35the shaky start, has taken this way, stands in
- 18:39very sharp contrast to the way the US is now
- 18:42finalizing their budget. It went through the
- 18:44House of Congress last week. So you've got a
- 18:47clear comparison. If you look at how that budget
- 18:50is just exploding in terms of deficit and more
- 18:53debt, and you look at how the South African budget
- 18:56is being... controlled or managed down by way
- 19:00of discipline, it's an interesting contrast to
- 19:02take note of. And then South Africa, I think
- 19:06the third show what it does, that South Africa
- 19:07now has tabled the proposal. We must now see
- 19:11how the US reacts to it. Now, when the US will
- 19:13pay attention to it, when there will be serious
- 19:15negotiations, that is up in the air, we don't
- 19:18know. But at least there's a proposal on the
- 19:21table and hopefully that will help to stabilize
- 19:24the trade relationship between the two countries.
- 19:28What's the Chinese curse? May we live in interesting
- 19:31times. I hope it becomes boring soon. Absolutely.
- 19:36Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you for
- 19:42listening to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy
- 19:44this content, please don't forget to leave a
- 19:47review and a rating, and please consider subscribing
- 19:50so you don't miss any future episodes. Also,
- 19:53tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written
- 19:56version of all JP's content at jplandman .co
- 20:00.za.