Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / Geopolitics in Motion: U.S.–Russia Energy Risks and Brazil’s Crude Shockwave into China - Part II
Transcript
- 0:11Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the Segal Sea Trade
- 0:14Podcast. I'm research analyst Trisha
- 0:17Mohiti, and I'll be your host for today's episode.
- 0:19So in today's episode, we have research analyst Shruti Hebli
- 0:24and shipping and commodity expert Mr. Sandesh Khantat.
- 0:27So welcome back to the episode. Well, thanks Trisha.
- 0:31Thanks for inviting me once again.
- 0:34And today we have a lot to unpack to well, we also have
- 0:38Shruti today with us. Well, thank you, Trisha and
- 0:41Sandesh, and it's great to be back and definitely there's a
- 0:44lot to talk about. So let's begin.
- 0:48Well, now, Shruti, let me ask you this and I want you to take
- 0:51it very slow and take it all the way across the politics, the
- 0:55energy math, the sanctions architecture, the Iraq angle,
- 0:59and even the quite corporate deal making that doesn't show up
- 1:03on Bloomberg tickers. So will you tell me or what
- 1:06would be your opinion about if the US actually ends up taking
- 1:10over Russian oil assets in Iraq? And more importantly, why is
- 1:14this moment such a decisive flashpoint for the of global
- 1:18energy flows? Well, Trisha, the short answer
- 1:22here is that the US government will not take over Russian oil
- 1:26assets in Iraq. I think the longer answer is far
- 1:30more interesting here because what's happening right now at
- 1:33West Korna too is I think one of the clearest examples of how
- 1:37modern energy power actually works.
- 1:40So when Washington sanctioned Lukoil and Rosneft on October
- 1:4422nd with a hard wind down deadline of November 21st, it
- 1:49actually set off a chain reaction that Iraq simply
- 1:52couldn't duck. So the banks froze, insurers
- 1:55froze, and Baghdad was forced to haul payments immediately to
- 2:00avoid secondary sanctions. Now here Lukoil was unable to
- 2:04receive funds or export crude, so it declared forced measure on
- 2:09November 10th, something that historically creates 45 to 60%
- 2:13probability of eventual operator change and around more than 70%
- 2:18likelihood of a sale or restructuring within two years.
- 2:22So based on past cases in Venezuela or Iran, Libya and
- 2:27Sudan, we can see the same thing.
- 2:29So the field is enormous, around 480,000 barrels per day,
- 2:35representing around 8 to 10% of Iraq's production and a
- 2:39prolonged freeze risk of about 6 to 7 billion in lost revenues
- 2:44over six months. That's huge.
- 2:46So Iraq has secured a temporary US waiver and it's pushing hard
- 2:51for a six month extension, but that's only a bandage.
- 2:55Now Lukoil holds 75% of the field.
- 2:58And as long as sanctions block payment channels, I think their
- 3:01operational future is boxed in. And you see, I think that's
- 3:06where the real story begins because it's not with AUS
- 3:09takeover, but with AUS controlled disinvestment
- 3:12process. So Sandesh again I would like to
- 3:15know what your opinion is and how do you look at this?
- 3:18Well, Shruti, I will say that Lukoil's global behaviour over
- 3:23the past three years, it makes the trajectory even clearer.
- 3:27So I know between 2022 and 2025, they tried to sell six of the
- 3:32foreign assets and in that 4 failed because you know, the
- 3:36sanctions, they scared buyers away and only two went through
- 3:40and they were both 2 non Western partners.
- 3:43So they're trading arms, are kind of a cutting staff.
- 3:46And then the European regulators are focusing divestment from in
- 3:50both storage and refining assets and even the Ukrainian strike,
- 3:55they are kind of a knocking Russian refineries and it puts
- 3:58offline at record levels and nearly 400 million barrels of
- 4:02Russian oil are currently idling at sea in the shadow fleet.
- 4:06So if you do maths, each tanker costing even more than $100,000
- 4:12per day for just to sit still in the water and add in rising cost
- 4:17financing restriction and even the shrinking global reach and
- 4:22then they have a waste corner. 2, it becomes less surprised for
- 4:25in general and more geopolitical liability.
- 4:28So the probability of Lukoil exiting is I guess about 65 to
- 4:3475% and the probability that eventual buyer, let's say it
- 4:40would be AUS or US approved entity is again 70 to 80%.
- 4:45And then in the reports from the global media, it says that
- 4:49Carlyle, again, the US companies exploring the asset after gun
- 4:54war backed out under the US criticism.
- 4:56And that's incredibly telling. So when OFAC sanctions an asset,
- 5:02Washington effectively controls who can largely touch it, even
- 5:05if the US never claims the ownership.
- 5:08The fascinating part is that despite all this pressure like
- 5:13sanctions and force measures that you have mentioned, should
- 5:16the threatened 10% loss of Iraqi supply meaning what Brent is
- 5:22behaving almost unnaturally calm.
- 5:24So the reason isn't luck, it's a math.
- 5:26So because OPEC Plus is kind of a holding nearly 5.9 million
- 5:31barrels per day of what we called as a spare capacity and
- 5:36it's highest since 2020. So with Saudi Arabia alone
- 5:40carrying over 3.1 to 3.2 million barrels per day.
- 5:44And then just at the start of the this month, that is on
- 5:48November 2nd, OPEC Plus cancelled it's entire Q12026
- 5:53plan to raise production by around 0.41 million barrels per
- 5:59day. And then it keeping only 137
- 6:02thousand barrels per day increase.
- 6:05You know, that was implemented in November 2025 S at the same
- 6:09time, non OPEC supply in 2026 is kind of a forecast to grow by
- 6:15about 1.4 million barrels per day.
- 6:18And you know what, it's mainly driven by the US, Zealand,
- 6:22Guyana, which we usually call as the usual suspect in the
- 6:27Atlantic basin and they create a global surplus of another 0.7 to
- 6:321.2 million barrels per day. So even though the sanctions
- 6:36initially cost Brent to, you know, kind of a spike around 6%
- 6:42or we can say precisely 5.4% to nearly dollar 66 per barrel,
- 6:48prices settled back into the low 60s because the world is simply
- 6:53too well supplied and there was not that much demand from China,
- 6:58which is, you know, kind of a driver for oil over the decade.
- 7:01Now the Brent is forecasted around 70 to $72 per barrel for
- 7:062025 and closer to dollar 65 for 2026.
- 7:10So in other words east corner to maybe you know geopolitically
- 7:16explosive but the market is sitting on the thick insulation
- 7:19and you know Trisha beneath that surface calm you have the
- 7:25quietly shifting current of physical barrel flows.
- 7:28If the waste could not tools take eventually transitions, the
- 7:33shipping market kind of feels it at first because at 300,000
- 7:39barrels per day of redirected or we can rephrase that reorganized
- 7:45volumes, you would see around 3 VLCC voyages a month and around
- 7:494 AFRAM X voyages a month and that eventually raising VLCC
- 7:53utilization by around 1%. So at 700,000 barrels per day
- 7:58that becomes around 8 VLCC and 9 AFRAM XS per month.
- 8:03So tightening VLCC utilization by around 1-2 point 1% and in
- 8:08the high stress scenario of 1.3 million barrels per day, you get
- 8:13nearly 14 VLCC cargos and close to 16 AFRAM access every month
- 8:17and that's the additional cargos.
- 8:19So lifting VLCC utilization by almost 4% which is meaningful,
- 8:25tightening that cascade across Suez Max and Afromax market.
- 8:29So your closing question, will the US take over Russian oil
- 8:32assets in Iraq? Has a simple answer and a
- 8:35profound 1. The simple answer is no and
- 8:38Washington can't and won't. But the deeper truth is that
- 8:42let's say US will shape who gets the asset next because
- 8:46sanctions, not soldiers, are now the frontline of the global
- 8:50energy power. So whoever replaces low oil in
- 8:54Iraq won't just inherit the field, they will inherit the
- 8:58geopolitical pivot where the US, Russia, Iraq, and even the OPEC
- 9:03Plus quietly renegotiate the balance of global supply.
- 9:07And then the years from now, the market will look back on
- 9:11October, November 2025 as the exact moment when the quiet
- 9:15rearrangement begin. Well, Sandesh, now I'd like to
- 9:19ask this question to you on what is your opinion on what actually
- 9:24happened behind the Brazil's October crude flood into China?
- 9:28And most importantly, what does this tell us about how Brazilian
- 9:32pre salt barrels now function inside China's import system?
- 9:37And maybe you could also expand a little bit on Atlantic Pacific
- 9:40balance and mainly the VLCC fleet cycle?
- 9:44Well, Trisha, when we peel back the layers, we have found about
- 9:49the Brazil's October crude and the crude was flooding into the
- 9:53China. So if you monitor the overall
- 9:56export from the Brazil, they are actually declined.
- 9:59But for the crude that is going to China, it has surged
- 10:02significantly and it's just for the October month.
- 10:05So Brazil's October over crude flood into China, it stopped
- 10:09being a simple spike and becomes a multi dimensional event
- 10:13specifically for the tanker owners that exposed how the
- 10:17modern oil trade system behaves under synchronized supply
- 10:22demand, then freight and geopolitical alignment.
- 10:27So let's start with the raw geometry first.
- 10:30Flows jump from the roughly 1.8 million tons in September to
- 10:356.73 million tons in October. It's a massive surge around
- 10:40274%. If you calculate from the
- 10:44million barrel perspective, it's around approximately 38 million
- 10:48barrels peak to through swing that kind of a produce one of
- 10:53the noises distributions in China's import.
- 10:56If we find this from the statistical point of view and if
- 11:00you see the coefficient and the relationship with the same, the
- 11:04differentiation is kind of a variety and it's a volatile
- 11:09because the Middle East medium suppliers which are the real
- 11:13reason for the structural pre salt supply, it's kind of
- 11:16looking fat tailed. And it was mostly because the
- 11:19FPS, because we all know the Brazils for oil producing is
- 11:25only in the offshore, most of them in the offshore salt
- 11:28basins. So FPS OS don't ramp smoothly,
- 11:33but kind of a leap in the steps changes whenever Wellstein and
- 11:37subsea floor lines we turn and then we have seen the
- 11:40compressors they kind of stabilize or again the weather
- 11:43windows aligned, which is exactly what happened in
- 11:47entering into October. So when the multi Fpsos backs
- 11:50came back online almost In Sync with you know they're kind of
- 11:55creating a sudden export swell. So then you have to add
- 11:59arbitrage mathematics into it because we have seen the brand
- 12:02Dubai, it collapsed into a pocket where Brazilian medium
- 12:06sweet barrel suddenly become competitive on the delivered
- 12:09basis versus Middle East mediums.
- 12:12Even though Middle East crude is also rushed by Indian
- 12:15refineries. And over all the the refineries
- 12:19over the globe, especially when the freight dip temporarily we
- 12:22see the US Gulf grid hits the tariff friction.
- 12:25And on the other hand, we have Russian ESPY Ural, they carried
- 12:30kind of a sanction shadow pricing and kind of a opening
- 12:34clean window for the oil importers and even the traders.
- 12:38Then meanwhile, we have a China, which you know kind of a subject
- 12:43of our topic, the Chinese refineries, they are kind of
- 12:46operating favouring mediums with yield because the main diesel
- 12:51cracks which they usually focus on where they ramp up refinery
- 12:56operating rate. So it's strained and while
- 12:58residue cracks lag and that's why they're making the specific
- 13:04Buzios, Artapo and 2P ideal because this particular grade
- 13:09they delivered high middle distillate output with lower
- 13:12desulfurization cost. And in global when diesel cracks
- 13:17surpass gas oil swap by around 4:00 to 6:00 barrels.
- 13:20This is just about the refinery economics that played well and
- 13:25Brazilian barrels mathematically displaced 8 to 12% of Middle
- 13:30Eastern medium import in optimizing models.
- 13:33If we calculate this from the import and freight perspective
- 13:38and that is what exactly October setup was.
- 13:41And the main pressure was from the Chinese point of view was
- 13:45China's SPR that is Strategic Petroleum Reserve which behave
- 13:50differently from the Western SPR.
- 13:52So this has different prospective in the Chinese SPR
- 13:57because it buys volatility and stepping in aggressively when
- 14:02the arbitrage windows open. Then on the freight side, 37.6
- 14:06million barrel surge, this means roughly around 19 additional
- 14:12VLCC cargos and with the Brazil, China round trip is around 105
- 14:16days. Octopus program observed closely
- 14:202500 VLCC days compared to 586 the month before.
- 14:25And it's an extraordinary net tightening of around 1880 VLCC
- 14:31days, which effectively removing 18 to 20 VLCCS from the global
- 14:36availability for a full month. And that's why we have seen the
- 14:40tightening of AG list and that's why we have seen the freight
- 14:45rates specifically the time charter equivalence day rose
- 14:49about $100,000 per day and that's kind of a huge earning
- 14:55opportunity for sheep owner. But at the same time we have
- 14:59seen the constraining West Africa is triangulation.
- 15:03It was specifically important because you know, it kind of a
- 15:06squeeze the balusters and it again kind of a disrupting raft
- 15:12China and AG China freight benchmark and they were kind of
- 15:18a setting off knock on effects that traders failed for the
- 15:21weeks. And again when you see that
- 15:26Brazil China flow not as deterministic volume, but a kind
- 15:30of a stochastic process driven by FBS first time up time and
- 15:35the freight volatility. But another factor that played
- 15:38here was US tariff dynamics and the Russian sanction risk.
- 15:43You see a 2 regime in relation to that one is normal regime and
- 15:49then another is alignment regime.
- 15:51Because October was a textbook of alignment movement where 4
- 15:56drivers clicked and they were clicked sharply within a small
- 16:01amount of time, 1 was supplier and another one was soft Fred.
- 16:05Then the third one was geopolitical substitution and
- 16:094th 1 was the price discounts Chinese refineries were getting.
- 16:14And then it pushed the probability of around more than
- 16:176,000,000 metric tons a month from less than 5% in neutral
- 16:22condition to roughly 32% in the configuration.
- 16:25Meaning the so-called anomaly is actually predictable once you
- 16:29treat frame and arbitrage as tightly coupled variable.
- 16:34So overall the strategically this event shows us that Brazil
- 16:38is now China's highest supplier ever, not the last, not the
- 16:43cheapest, not the most stable, but the most reactive.
- 16:47The core reason behind that because every moment in the
- 16:50diesel margin, every freight rally or deep or every FPS or
- 16:55maintenance cycle, the geopolitical shock transmits
- 16:59immediately Rajil China flows and instantly reshapes the
- 17:02global turn mile balance or tightening or kind of a
- 17:06loosening the VLCC market by hundreds of holidays within a
- 17:09single monthly export program. So these turning the Brazil from
- 17:15a simple Atlantic basin exporter into a volatility amplifier and
- 17:20it is due to the embedded in the China's import architecture and
- 17:25October proves that Brazil is no longer just a source of barrel,
- 17:29it's a pivot point that can war freight economic.
- 17:32And in addition to that it can also distort the regional
- 17:35benchmark because we have seen the ballasters they kind of
- 17:39redirected from one basin to another.
- 17:41But here we are talking about the VLCCS those you know kind of
- 17:45focus on the long haul voyages and it directly impact the
- 17:49tennis list which kind of a stress for the limited point of
- 17:53time when we saw more than $100,000 per day increase in
- 17:58PCs. And if we see from the strategic
- 18:03variable point of view world's biggest crude importing nation
- 18:07in other world, October wasn't a spike, it was a signal, a kind
- 18:13of a revelation of new market geometry where Brazil's pre salt
- 18:18behaves like a high frequency driver.
- 18:20Because till date we have just seen a specific exporter
- 18:26specifically from the Middle East region which sending long
- 18:32haul VLCCS to China. Now that momentum has shifted
- 18:37from one basin to another, meaning VLCCS which were going
- 18:42to east of Suez now change from the east of Suez to the West of
- 18:47Suez market or a kind of a quasi strategic variable.
- 18:52So to summarize, Brazil's pre salt behaves like a high
- 18:56frequency driver inside China's long haul crude ecosystem.
- 19:01And when you have a Brazil China corridor, it now function as the
- 19:06one's most powerful volatility generators in the global VLCC
- 19:09cycle. Well, and with that, I think
- 19:13we've reached to the end of today's episode, but stay tuned
- 19:18for more of this playlist. And to all our listeners, thank
- 19:22you so much for tuning in. Until next time, navigate safely
- 19:25and stay informed.