Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mediating Lemon Law Cases Timing, Valuation, and Strategy
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Mediating Lemon Law Cases, Timing, Valuation,
- 0:10and Strategy. I'm Alapoli Castro, BHBA's Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development, and
- 0:16it's my pleasure to introduce our speaker for
- 0:18this program, Jacob William Cutler. Jacob is
- 0:22an accomplished civil litigator and mediator
- 0:24with over 15 years of experience representing
- 0:27both plaintiffs and defendants throughout California.
- 0:30He co -founded Cutler Mediation Group to bring
- 0:33results driven, neutral, and highly informed
- 0:35approach to mediation with a particular focus
- 0:38on lemon law and personal injury disputes. Over
- 0:42Jacob's career handling cases under California's
- 0:45Song Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, he has seen
- 0:48cases through hundreds of mediations and dozens
- 0:51of jury trials, and brings this dual experience
- 0:54to his approach as a neutral. We're so excited
- 0:56to hear what he has to share with us today, so
- 0:58I'm now gonna turn it over to him. All right,
- 1:01good afternoon, everyone, and thank you to the
- 1:03Beverly Hills Bar Association for that warm welcome.
- 1:07As mentioned, my name is Jacob Cutler, and I
- 1:09am the principal mediator and co -founder at
- 1:12Cutler Mediation Group. Prior to working as a
- 1:15mediator, I had the opportunity to work on these
- 1:17lemon law cases for over 12 years on the plaintiff's
- 1:20side. going through motions and depositions,
- 1:23negotiating settlements, and taking cases through
- 1:25trial. And so this experience enabled me to learn
- 1:28why some cases resolve efficiently while others
- 1:31continue all the way toward trial and sometimes
- 1:35through trial. But today, I'm no longer a litigant.
- 1:38I'm approaching this from a different seat, the
- 1:41mediator's chair. And so my goal today isn't
- 1:43to tell plaintiff's counsel or defense counsel
- 1:45how to practice lemon law. I'm sure they're good
- 1:47at that and they know what they're doing. I wanted
- 1:49to talk about from a mediation perspective specifically.
- 1:53So getting a case evaluated accurately, getting
- 1:56the right information in front of decision makers,
- 1:58and creating a realistic path toward resolution.
- 2:01We're going to talk about when mediation makes
- 2:03sense, how these cases should be valued, common
- 2:06mistakes that interfere with settlement, and
- 2:09strategies both sides can use to make mediation
- 2:12more productive. The question I want to explore
- 2:14today is how do we take a lemon law case from
- 2:17being a litigation problem and turn it into a
- 2:20resolution opportunity. All right, so I am going
- 2:24to share my slide presentation. All right, so
- 2:39I wanna next get into, again, I mentioned it
- 2:42briefly in the introduction, but talking about
- 2:44the goals. So first, when a mediation makes sense,
- 2:48right? So there are various stages in litigation
- 2:51in terms of, you know, towards case inception.
- 2:55after some discoveries taking place right up
- 2:57before trial. So I want to talk about the pros
- 2:59and cons of each of each stage and how you can
- 3:04use that to successfully mediate cases. Next,
- 3:09I'm going to talk about how cases should be valued.
- 3:13So I know there, you know, lemon lock cases are
- 3:16fairly delineated in terms of the damages, but
- 3:19I want to go over that, explain how the damages
- 3:22are calculated and sort of what are the numbers
- 3:25that go into mediating these cases and figuring
- 3:28out if a resolution is possible. We're also going
- 3:32to talk about common mistakes that interfere
- 3:34with settlement. Some of those include lack of
- 3:37preparation or ignoring bad facts for your case,
- 3:43strategies to make mediation more productive.
- 3:45And those include being ready and able to explain
- 3:49to the mediator how you're going to respond to
- 3:52those bad facts or frame them in your case. And
- 3:55hopefully it'll be able to explain how lemon
- 3:58law litigation can become an opportunity for
- 4:01resolution. All right, so before we do that,
- 4:05I wanna talk about why lemon law cases can be
- 4:09difficult to resolve. And what I have here is
- 4:12that the parties often see completely different
- 4:14cases. So as I said, I spent all of my time on
- 4:19plaintiff's side. And that said, going to meeting
- 4:23defense attorneys, going to hearings, going to
- 4:26trial, hearing them talk about cases, you can
- 4:29tell that both sides have a very strong mindset
- 4:33and preconceived ideas about lemon law and fact
- 4:37patterns. You could show the same fact pattern
- 4:40to a lemon law plaintiff and a lemon law defendant,
- 4:43and they will come up with sort of a very different
- 4:46theory of the case. And that's fine. And I'm
- 4:49not saying anyone needs to abandon or change
- 4:52their position, but I think it's important to
- 4:58realize and acknowledge how the other side sees
- 5:01the fact pattern for a few reasons. One, to be
- 5:05able to come up with an effective strategy should
- 5:08you need to rebut it. But also just in terms
- 5:10of evaluating your case, right? When you're going
- 5:13to mediation and you're thinking of ranges of
- 5:16how much a case should settle for, you're going
- 5:18to need to take into account how those facts
- 5:22look. Because I've seen it, right? I've seen
- 5:24juries agree with everything we're saying on
- 5:28the plaintiff's side. And I've seen juries agree
- 5:29with everything the defense is saying. So you're
- 5:32going to have to deal with it one way or another.
- 5:33So you might as well get ahead of it and utilize
- 5:37that into your case evaluation. And specifically,
- 5:44what do I mean by that? So in terms of the basic
- 5:48elements of a song Beverly claim, we know that
- 5:51you have to prove there was a defect covered
- 5:55by the warranty. that's substantially impaired
- 5:57use value or safety. And so the first issue that
- 6:03often comes up either in mediation or just in
- 6:05litigation is, is there a defect at all, right?
- 6:08Is what the person is experiencing with the vehicle
- 6:13normal use? Is that sound supposed to happen
- 6:16or is it abnormal? Is it actually a defect? Sometimes
- 6:21there's also a causation question. There could
- 6:25be a real defect, but is there an argument that
- 6:27it's caused by abuse, lack of maintenance? You
- 6:31weren't changing the oil or changing the brakes
- 6:35or things like that. Or third party modification.
- 6:38Sometimes people take their car to a non -dealer
- 6:41and they get something done to it. And then there's
- 6:43the theory that that is causing or exacerbating
- 6:47the problems. As we all know, it's plaintiff's
- 6:52burden to prove this defect and that it substantially
- 6:54impairs use value or safety. So that's sort of,
- 6:57again, the first element. So how each side sees
- 7:00use from what I've seen often is a plaintiff's
- 7:03counsel is focusing on days out of service, lack
- 7:07of trust, and change plans. So days out of service,
- 7:12fairly obvious what that means in terms of days
- 7:14the vehicle was at the dealership that their
- 7:18client couldn't use their car. which we'll get
- 7:23to with the next prong too, but they're often
- 7:25considering days out of service for every presentation
- 7:28that's not maintenance. So they're counting all
- 7:30of those. Lack of trust goes into quality of
- 7:34use. So they're gonna focus on the customer who
- 7:38feels scared, who feels they can't trust their
- 7:40car, they're worried about it. And so when they're
- 7:43driving around, they don't have that same faith
- 7:46that the vehicle's gonna get them from point
- 7:49A to point B. And then change plans is often
- 7:52emphasized. That is, you know, because of the
- 7:56defects, I missed a doctor's appointment or I
- 7:59couldn't take my kids to their soccer game. So
- 8:02these are all points that are gonna come out
- 8:05at trial to explain how use was affected. Now,
- 8:09looking at that same fact pattern, defense counsel
- 8:12will often see continued use, right? So did the
- 8:16customer continue to drive the vehicle? throughout
- 8:20their ownership, how many miles were driven,
- 8:24both at the time the problems were happening
- 8:26and then today. And then again, causation questions,
- 8:29as I was talking about earlier, did the customer
- 8:32have some responsibility in terms of causing
- 8:36the issues or the defects? So this is showing
- 8:38how use can be viewed, similar facts in a very
- 8:42different light. Similarly, the other two prongs,
- 8:46Plain Invest approved one of these, as we all
- 8:47know, use. value or safety, they were substantially
- 8:53impaired. Again, so it's substantial is another
- 8:57issue. If something is just annoying versus it's
- 9:01substantial, that's something that gets debated
- 9:03quite a bit. In terms of value, common point
- 9:07of view is that an honest person, they have their
- 9:10car. If they were to sell it, they would tell
- 9:14a willing buyer, I had my engine replaced or
- 9:17I had my transmission replaced. And so knowing
- 9:19that or disclosing the repair orders, the person's
- 9:23going to want to pay them less money. Now I've
- 9:25seen in a similar situation, defense counsel
- 9:27is actually saying, no, wait a minute. A warranty
- 9:30repair could actually increase value. For example,
- 9:33if you had 60 ,000 miles on your engine and then
- 9:35your engine blew out and you replaced it, you
- 9:38could argue that now you have a new engine as
- 9:40opposed to the engine that had 60 ,000 miles
- 9:41on it. And that other aspects affect value more.
- 9:47For instance, you know, when you go to Kelley
- 9:49Blue Book, you're valuing your car mileage. How
- 9:52many total miles on the car is something that's
- 9:54asked for, as opposed to repair history. Safety
- 9:58is another divergent path of how these cases
- 10:01are viewed. So, plaintiffs' counsel often focused
- 10:05on defects that increase the chance of an accident
- 10:08or dangerous driving condition. So, for example,
- 10:11a transmission hesitation. So, would you be turning
- 10:15left? you're trying to get by oncoming traffic,
- 10:18if your vehicle were to hesitate, that could
- 10:21increase the chance of oncoming traffic hitting
- 10:23you. Whereas defense counsel is often focused
- 10:27on the safety, the actual accident never really
- 10:30occurred. So let's say it's an oil consumption
- 10:33case increasing the propensity of a stall, but
- 10:38then defense counsel is focused on there actually
- 10:40wasn't a stall and they never were stranded.
- 10:43So these are kind of the points of view that
- 10:45you want to think about on the other side in
- 10:48terms of how they apply to the facts of your
- 10:51case. Do they affect your case valuation at all?
- 10:55And do you have an answer or a response to it
- 10:58in terms of your litigation strategy? All right.
- 11:04The next prong that the plaintiff has to prove
- 11:07is the number of repair attempts. And they have
- 11:11to prove that a defendant was unable to repair
- 11:14the vehicle within a reasonable number of repair
- 11:17opportunities. And this is something that defense
- 11:20counsel and plaintiff's counsel constantly have
- 11:24a different vision of. And it's actually interesting
- 11:26that this is somewhat of an unsettled area of
- 11:28law, right? So plaintiff's counsel sees the total
- 11:32number of repair attempts and days out of service
- 11:34for the entire vehicle. And they often reference
- 11:38the Casey in terms of explanation as to that.
- 11:42And so they're not just seeing, you know, this
- 11:44is a transmission case or this is an engine case.
- 11:47They're saying, no. Maybe there's several transmission
- 11:50or engine cases, but don't forget about the air
- 11:53conditioning, or the windows, or the sunroof.
- 11:57Those all count. And the days out of service
- 11:59count, and those repairs count in terms of fixing
- 12:02the vehicle. And defense counsel, typically at
- 12:06mediation and at trial, they say, no, was a particular
- 12:10issue repaired within a reasonable number of
- 12:12repair opportunities? And how many days out of
- 12:14service was it for that? And in motion in limine,
- 12:17virtually every trial, they will try to limit
- 12:20repairs that will happen to perhaps once or two
- 12:23or less under a case called Silvio versus Ford,
- 12:27which again, plaintiff's council interprets differently
- 12:29in terms of two repairs for the entire vehicle
- 12:32versus two repairs for a particular issue. But
- 12:35you don't know, right, how a judge is going to
- 12:38rule on motions in limine. And you don't know
- 12:41how a jury is going to come down on this issue
- 12:45and I've seen both. I've seen jurors adopt plaintiffs
- 12:48theory or defense theory and I've seen judges
- 12:51eliminate repairs that only happened once and
- 12:54I've seen judges say if it's under warranty it's
- 12:56all coming in. So in terms of mediation it's
- 13:00important to identify that and some cases it'll
- 13:04be less important because maybe there only were
- 13:06four transmissions and nothing else but many
- 13:09cases will have a mix of repairs and so in terms
- 13:12of preparing your case for mediation and evaluating
- 13:15it, I think it's important to have a response
- 13:18to this issue or how you're going to frame it.
- 13:24All right, so I think everyone in the practice
- 13:27area is firmly aware of the new law that came
- 13:30out and it does have some effect in terms of
- 13:33mediation, right? You're supposed to, for those
- 13:35manufacturers that have opted in, there's what's
- 13:38called early mediation and there's certain deadlines
- 13:41ascribed to that. And in addition to having an
- 13:45early mediation, there is supposed to be more
- 13:49involvement from the clients themselves. So before
- 13:54the new law or the early mediation, oftentimes
- 13:57you would mediate on your client's behalf and
- 14:02be in touch with them via phone to make sure
- 14:05they're apprised of what's going on and if they
- 14:08want to accept any offers. But now under the
- 14:11new law, there's supposed to be more involvement.
- 14:13And so that changes things up a little bit in
- 14:16terms of mediation, because from the perspective
- 14:20of plaintiff, they're obviously a lay person,
- 14:23right? They don't have a full understanding of
- 14:25the lemon law. And they're the one that's also
- 14:28been individually burdened by the car, right?
- 14:33So they spent substantial money, tens of thousands
- 14:36of dollars. They have the stories about the vehicle's
- 14:40been out of service or that they've missed work.
- 14:45They often like to focus on the value of their
- 14:48time, as I'm sure we all do. We think our time
- 14:50is valuable and you don't want to spend it in
- 14:53the repair shop. You like to be able to rely
- 14:55on your vehicle to take you where you need to
- 14:57go and go to work. And they express losing confidence
- 15:01and overall frustration. And so I think defendant
- 15:06becomes more aware of this typically either a
- 15:09deposition when they take their deposition or
- 15:12sometimes now through an early mediation, if
- 15:14the plaintiff is more involved. Some of that
- 15:17information can be shared. And not all of it
- 15:20obviously will be relevant. And I'll talk about
- 15:23more in a minute, but there's no loss of time
- 15:27or emotional distress damages, but plaintiff
- 15:32is gonna get on the stand and they're going to
- 15:34explain their experience. And that has to go
- 15:37to substantiality, right? So they're gonna talk
- 15:40about how upset it made them and why and what
- 15:44it caused. And so these are things that I think
- 15:46it's good that defense can see this, not only
- 15:50at deposition, but at mediation if they can get
- 15:53some of this information either in a joint session
- 15:56or through the mediator, because it helps them
- 15:59figure out valuing the case too. Because a strong
- 16:03plaintiff or someone who's explaining why they're
- 16:06so upset as opposed to just, oh, it was not that
- 16:09big a deal, right? that's gonna make the case
- 16:12more valuable. And so this is what I was alluding
- 16:17to a second ago earlier is as the mediator, when
- 16:21the plaintiff is more involved, I think it's
- 16:23important to explain the process to them, let
- 16:26them know everyone's role and kind of with the
- 16:30assistance of counsel, you can guide them in
- 16:31terms of what's actually recoverable and not
- 16:34because they do get sometimes confused about
- 16:36that in terms of damages. From the defense perspective,
- 16:43In terms of an early mediation or really any
- 16:46mediation, they're looking at things such as,
- 16:49can we get a defense verdict? Is plaintiff going
- 16:54to meet the elements? We talked about some of
- 16:55the elements earlier. Are they going to be able
- 16:57to do that? Can we avoid civil penalties? And
- 17:01so again, if you're not familiar with civil penalties,
- 17:03they're penalties to really to punish certain
- 17:07conduct. It's a willful failure to repurchase.
- 17:11So it's if they knew what they were supposed
- 17:13to do, and they intentionally declined not to
- 17:17follow that. They can be liable for civil penalties
- 17:19up to two times the actual damages. And the last
- 17:23point is very important in lemon law, and we're
- 17:24going to come back to this throughout the presentation,
- 17:27but they have to think about, especially at early
- 17:31mediation, what's it going to cost us to continue
- 17:34fighting the case, right? So there's a one -way
- 17:37fee -shifting statute in song Beverly cases.
- 17:39So the meter is running for plaintiff, right?
- 17:42the longer the case goes on, the greater the
- 17:44risk to defendant that they're going to have
- 17:46to pay a large bill. And so sometimes it may
- 17:49be beneficial to them to pay a few thousand or
- 17:5310 ,000 more early, as opposed to six figures
- 17:55in attorney's fees later on. So that's something
- 17:58that they have to wrestle with in terms of the
- 17:59merits of the case and whether they want to fight
- 18:02it or try it. But that's always going to be an
- 18:05instrumental part of negotiation with lemon law
- 18:07cases is, where are we at with attorney's fees?
- 18:10um in the case and so that that's in terms of
- 18:14that being low that's sort of one of the advantages
- 18:16um of the early mediation so next is when should
- 18:22we when should you go to mediation uh the common
- 18:25misconception and this is probably with litigation
- 18:28um in general is that people sort of think you
- 18:31have to wait until trial right the closer you
- 18:33are to trial uh that's when case is resolved
- 18:36and sometimes that's true but Not necessarily.
- 18:40And in lemon law, if you're going to consistently
- 18:42do that, you're going to be paying, if you're
- 18:44going to settle the cases, you're going to be
- 18:46paying a lot of attorney's fees because now you've
- 18:49had depositions, motions, discovery, expert work,
- 18:54trial preparation. And so it's going to be a
- 18:56lot closer to trial. So it's not always your
- 18:59best bet to wait. So again, going back to the
- 19:03early stage mediation, the advantages are it's
- 19:06going to be the lowest attorney's fees. You potentially,
- 19:10for both sides, have faster resolution. Plaintiff,
- 19:13they've already likely owned the car for several
- 19:16years. They've taken it back multiple times for
- 19:19repairs. Then they had to file the lawsuit and
- 19:21get to this stage. So they want a fast resolution.
- 19:24And defendant wants it because they'll pay less.
- 19:27Each side has had to do less discovery and less
- 19:30attorney involvement. The biggest disadvantage,
- 19:33I would say, is that there's insufficient information.
- 19:38unclear case value, and one side may feel it's
- 19:41premature. So under the new law, there is certain
- 19:45disclosures, and we'll talk about that in the
- 19:47next few slides, things that you're supposed
- 19:49to give the other side that are important in
- 19:51lemon law cases. And there's also initial depositions
- 19:55of both the plaintiff and the person most knowledgeable.
- 20:00But these documents are limited and the depositions
- 20:03are limited in time and scope. And so if you're
- 20:05able to get those, the documents and the depositions,
- 20:09it's going to help. I mean, you're going to have
- 20:11more information to be able to go into the mediation
- 20:14and try to resolve it. If you weren't able to
- 20:17accomplish all those things, there's a good chance
- 20:19it won't work. And so let's look at some of the
- 20:23sources of those information. So in the Lemon
- 20:25Law case, I would say the three main prongs are
- 20:29your written discovery, your depositions, and
- 20:32your vehicle inspection. So the written discovery.
- 20:39Under the new law, you are supposed to disclose
- 20:42sales contract, things like that, repair orders,
- 20:46warranty history from the manufacturer, that's
- 20:47something they're supposed to disclose, and the
- 20:49call log, which documents the pre -litigation
- 20:53repurchase request, what did the person say or
- 20:55request, and what did the defendant do in response.
- 20:59However, this might not be the entire story,
- 21:01right? So in terms of damages, you may not have
- 21:06registration insurance, or some of the other
- 21:09statutory incidental damages like rental car,
- 21:13towing, repairs. You may not have payment history
- 21:17or a payoff. And then in terms of other documents,
- 21:24I've seen, for example, defendants sometimes
- 21:30want to subpoena certain documents, right? Perhaps
- 21:32the vehicle was used in rideshare, so they want
- 21:35to subpoena Uber. or the vehicle had some tickets
- 21:38that are relevant. So they want to subpoena DMV,
- 21:41or they want to subpoena a third party body shop
- 21:46because maybe there's allegations about an accident
- 21:49or things like that. So those are the kinds of
- 21:51things that you likely will not have, unfortunately,
- 21:55in the early mediation and things that you will
- 21:59get as the case progresses. So in terms of depositions,
- 22:05again, if you can get that initial deposition
- 22:08of Plano for the PMK, that is helpful. But if
- 22:12you didn't or you didn't, you know, even if you
- 22:15did, I think it's still having that full deposition
- 22:18is going to help you resolve the case. And this
- 22:21is why I'm going to sort of advocate lightly
- 22:23because I don't think every case is the same
- 22:24in the coming slides that what I call sort of
- 22:27the mid case sweet spot when you've performed
- 22:31enough discovery, but neither side is put out
- 22:37exorbitant attorney's fees. That might be, in
- 22:39most cases, the best place to resolve a case.
- 22:43But that's not said that there isn't value to
- 22:45mediating early or at trial either. So I've heard
- 22:50from talking to defendants for mediation, sometimes
- 22:54they don't even want to mediate a case until
- 22:55they have deposed plaintiff, because it's just
- 22:57so critically important. I mean, how that person
- 23:01presents as a witness, are they credible? Are
- 23:04they believable? Do you understand what they're
- 23:06talking about? Does it make sense? Can they explain
- 23:10the problems and how it affected them? Those
- 23:13are all things that go into, I think, case valuation
- 23:15and how much is going to potentially be offered
- 23:19in mediation or how much that a defendant wants
- 23:23to take the case to trial. And then similarly,
- 23:27from plaintiff's perspective, the PMK deposition,
- 23:30this is how plaintiff is going to try to establish
- 23:33civil penalties. Their client made a repurchase
- 23:37request. Were they taken seriously? Did the defendant
- 23:42gather the repair orders? Did they talk to their
- 23:46dealership? Did they take the problem seriously?
- 23:50Did they promptly get back to the person and
- 23:53so forth? And what are the manufacturer's policies?
- 23:57What are they supposed to do? Do they understand
- 23:59the law? And do they have a process in place
- 24:01to evaluate customers' complaints? And did they
- 24:04do that here? So this is something that, from
- 24:07the plaintiff's perspective, you'd like to see.
- 24:09You have the call log, or hopefully you have
- 24:11the call log, which is going to write down, on
- 24:15certain date, certain time, plaintiff called
- 24:18in and said, I want my money back, and what defendant
- 24:21wrote down in response. But you get a lot more
- 24:23nuance to the deposition. And that may not fully
- 24:27have happened at the early mediation. And then
- 24:31experts, obviously in an early mediation, they're
- 24:35not going to be an expert deposition. You probably
- 24:37haven't even talked to your expert or designated
- 24:39them. And so that can be something that can be
- 24:43beneficial in mediation. That's certainly more
- 24:47fleshed out at pretrial mediation when you have
- 24:50their opinions and their basis. You've tested
- 24:52those opinions and basises at deposition. You've
- 24:56thought about how persuasive they are. Do they
- 24:58have holes or would a jury buy them? But at least
- 25:03at midpoint, Hopefully, you're starting to see
- 25:05some of the expert issues formulate and you've
- 25:08thought about them. So you can kind of think
- 25:10about that in your case valuation. And then lastly,
- 25:16the other piece of discovery that I think is
- 25:18important to have for mediations, not always
- 25:20possible, again, especially vehicle inspections
- 25:23often happen closer to trial. But sometimes you
- 25:27can get them done before the midpoint mediation.
- 25:30And these are critical because it gets both lawyers
- 25:33there physically at the dealership. They get
- 25:36to see the car. They get to see it put on a rack.
- 25:39They're experts there. He gets to put his hands
- 25:42on it. Their expert gets to put their hands on
- 25:43it. You got to take it on a test drive. And so
- 25:46you get to see, you know, is there a defect still?
- 25:49Is there something wrong? Was it never fixed
- 25:51or was it fixed? How did the vehicle perform?
- 25:55And this is no doubt the vehicle inspection,
- 25:58whether there was one, how it went, who was there,
- 26:00that's all gonna come into trial. So it's good
- 26:04to know in terms of case valuation and trial
- 26:07strategy. All right, so I was talking a second
- 26:11ago about in terms of timing, the mid case mediation,
- 26:16right? The sweet spot is what I like to call
- 26:18it. So at this point, hopefully you've had substantial
- 26:23fact discovery, right? You have a clear repair
- 26:26history and you have that because you've talked
- 26:30to your client, you've gathered repair orders,
- 26:32You've seen the warranty history. Maybe you've
- 26:35gathered some third party repairs or you've had
- 26:38to subpoena a dealership. You've got that information
- 26:41and you've made what we used to call a repair
- 26:45chronology, which is an important document that
- 26:48I would suspect plaintiff and defense attorneys
- 26:50both use. It lays out the mileage days in and
- 26:56days out and what happened. and perhaps a column
- 27:00for your analysis as to why that repair is significant
- 27:02or not. Hopefully by now, at least your expert
- 27:06issues are developing. You're kind of thinking
- 27:07to yourself, how and where and how can an expert
- 27:12assist in developing our case? You know, damage
- 27:16is more, and obviously if you've deposed plaintiff,
- 27:19you've asked them what their damages are, and
- 27:21you've gotten that in discovery. So hopefully
- 27:24by now you've gotten a payment history, the payoff.
- 27:28the sales contract, and then the incidental damages.
- 27:31So at this point, both sides have enough information
- 27:34to evaluate risk. And that's important because
- 27:37that's what they're trying to do, essentially
- 27:39mediation. You're trying to figure out what is
- 27:42the case worth. And to do that, you have to understand
- 27:45what are the odds of it prevailing a trial and
- 27:48what are the odds of getting civil penalties.
- 27:50So those are things you have to think about.
- 27:52So at this point, you can have enough information
- 27:55to evaluate risk. Critically, in a lemon law
- 27:58case, at this point, neither side has expended
- 28:02significant attorney's fees and costs. Again,
- 28:06that one -way fee -shifting statute is critical
- 28:08in mediating lemon law cases. So another problem
- 28:11I wanted to mention with earlier mediation is
- 28:14sometimes, whether it's an early mediation or
- 28:17an early 998, and I get why defense does it.
- 28:19They want to throw that out there to protect
- 28:21themselves. They send a 998 for a buyback or
- 28:24thereabouts. From the plaintiff's perspective,
- 28:28sometimes there's, and I think this happens with
- 28:31other people too, you're a little bit, you don't
- 28:35believe as much in the, or you don't put as much
- 28:36weight in a first offer, right? You think, oh,
- 28:38there's gonna be more, this is the first offer.
- 28:41And so at a mid case mediation, hopefully there's
- 28:44been a first offer, either at a prior mediation
- 28:48or 998. And unlike a trial, the defendant can
- 28:53beat a 998 and feel okay about it, right? So
- 28:55if they offered a buyback and now it's six months
- 28:59later and they wanna add 10, $20 ,000 to it,
- 29:03they know that beating that 998 won't open the
- 29:06door to that much more attorney's fees because
- 29:09not that much has happened. Perhaps a couple
- 29:11of depots, some written discovery, maybe a motion
- 29:14to compel. But in that same scenario, obviously
- 29:17a trial, and I'll show you, if you even increasing
- 29:22your 998 by 500 or $1 ,000, it could open the
- 29:26door for hundreds of thousands of dollars in
- 29:27attorney's fees potentially, right? So that in
- 29:29and of itself can sometimes just be a non -starter
- 29:34for mediating the case too late. So that is the
- 29:40last sort of option is right before trial. The
- 29:44advantages are you do have obviously the most
- 29:46information you're ever gonna have. Unlike mid
- 29:48-case mediation, you've actually done the inspection
- 29:53You've deposed both experts. You've perhaps thought
- 29:57about your voir dire. You've maybe made a PowerPoint
- 30:00for your opening statement. And I think everyone
- 30:03knows the trial is the ultimate settlement incentive.
- 30:06And judges certainly know that when you go in
- 30:08and try to get your trial continued. And sometimes
- 30:10they don't want to because they know holding
- 30:12your feet to the fire is the most likely way
- 30:15the case will get resolved. And the reason that
- 30:18is, obviously, is because of both risk and expense.
- 30:23So at this point, the problems, as I said, is
- 30:26significant fees have been incurred. There is
- 30:29a bit of litigation fatigue and positions may
- 30:32have hardened. You may just sort of just say,
- 30:35you know what? I like my case. I'm going to try
- 30:36it. So settlement authority can become more complicated
- 30:40by the problem that I said earlier in terms of
- 30:43if you beat a 998, you're opening yourself up
- 30:46to all those fees. That said, I think there's
- 30:49certainly still value in pretrial mediation.
- 30:52I've seen cases resolve at this stage because
- 30:55there's still more, right? From the plaintiff's
- 30:58perspective, and they don't always realize this
- 31:00when you tell them, a lemon law case is typically
- 31:02a week. That person's going to have to be there
- 31:05every single day, all day for that week if they
- 31:09want to present well to the jury. And they're
- 31:11going to miss all that work. And then there's
- 31:13a risk of doing all that and getting nothing,
- 31:15right? And then from defendant, there's the risk
- 31:18of going to trial paying not only their own attorneys,
- 31:22but also plaintiff's attorneys. If they lose,
- 31:24they're going to have to pay both. So that is
- 31:26an expensive gamble. So that still can sometimes
- 31:29be used to settle cases, especially if you don't
- 31:32have to worry about an early 998 beating it with
- 31:36attorney's fees. All right. So we've talked about
- 31:42the timing for mediation. So next, I want to
- 31:45talk about case valuation. So what is the case
- 31:48really worth? And that's obviously sort of the
- 31:51million dollar question when you're mediating
- 31:53a lemon law case. Luckily, unlike personal injury
- 31:56or other areas of law, it's at least to me, it
- 31:59seems like it's more straightforward and delineated
- 32:02in the statute as to what you can get. So you
- 32:06have your compensatory damages, you have your
- 32:08incidental damages, and you have your civil penalties.
- 32:11And that's really it in a lemon law case. And
- 32:13so your actual damages is the amount you paid
- 32:17or payable, so your loan on your vehicle, Less
- 32:20certain statutory exclusions, and those become
- 32:24sometimes a sticking point in terms of there's
- 32:28things like manufacturer's rebate, negative equity,
- 32:31service contracts. One side may want to deduct
- 32:34it, the other side may not. Mileage offset. So
- 32:38that is the amount of time you drove the vehicle
- 32:41before the problem started. That could be another
- 32:43area of dispute that we'll get into in a minute.
- 32:46And then incidental damages. So your incidental
- 32:49damages, under the statute or explicitly or if
- 32:52you had to pay any rental cars, towing or repairs.
- 32:56And then under important cases, we have post
- 33:00breach registration and insurance. So you have
- 33:03after the date, the vehicle is determined to
- 33:06be a lemon by the jury, you could recover your
- 33:08registration and insurance premiums. There is
- 33:14some dispute that as to what portion of your
- 33:16insurance premiums, but in any event, those are
- 33:18sort of the main incidental damages. And then
- 33:20civil penalties. Again, this is something that's
- 33:22always sort of one of the main things that's
- 33:26being disputed is whether civil penalties are
- 33:28warranted and how much you can get up to a maximum
- 33:32of two times your actual damages for a defendant's
- 33:35willful failure to repurchase. So everyone knows
- 33:38what the damages are. They're pretty straightforward.
- 33:42But when you're preparing for a deposition, you
- 33:46want to have a good handle of that. So what are
- 33:49the base damages? And I think it's best to have
- 33:52a little calculator, a form where you write it
- 33:55out and you have an explanation and a reasoning.
- 33:59So you have your total paid or payable, you have
- 34:03what's being deducted and why, you have what
- 34:06mileage offset, you have what incidentals. And
- 34:09so you have this number because it's helpful
- 34:12to the mediator to know. Especially I would say
- 34:15when I'm mediating lemon log cases, The vast
- 34:18majority of the time defendant and plaintiff
- 34:19are actually, as to question one, they're kind
- 34:22of in the same boat, maybe a tiny difference.
- 34:24But there is sometimes when it's way off, and
- 34:26then you have to go to each side, sort of figure
- 34:29it out. Because if you're not on board with what
- 34:33the base damages are, you most likely will not
- 34:35settle the case. Because then you're not even
- 34:37agreeing on what the buyback is. And because
- 34:40the civil penalties are based on the buyback,
- 34:42they're going to vary wildly if the base damages
- 34:45are different. So usually they're very similar,
- 34:47and that's fine. If not, important during the
- 34:51mediation, figure out why. And for counsel, they
- 34:54should be having an explanation as to how they
- 34:56came up with it. And so a second ago, I was talking
- 35:01about the mileage offset. And this is an important
- 35:03issue in terms of damages and one that's sometimes
- 35:05in dispute. So again, the amount of vehicles,
- 35:09that amount of miles, the vehicle is driven before
- 35:13presentation of the problem. That can be disputed
- 35:17in terms of what is the problem or the substantially
- 35:20impairing defect. Is it this air conditioning?
- 35:23Is it this oil leak? What is the first presentation?
- 35:28And again, if it's not an issue, great. But if
- 35:31it is an issue, it can make the damages swing
- 35:34wildly. For example, if you have a 4 ,000 mileage
- 35:37offset when the presentation happened versus
- 35:39a 40 ,000, you could be looking at thousands
- 35:42or tens of thousands of dollars in difference.
- 35:44and damages, and now you're not even talking
- 35:46about the same thing, because both sides have
- 35:49a completely different valuation in the case.
- 35:51So you have to get to a similar starting point.
- 35:56And if there is a different mileage offset, then
- 35:58what I would like to do is talk to counsel and
- 36:01ask them why. Why did they select that offset?
- 36:05And that's the only thing that really can be
- 36:07in dispute, because it's just the mileage, the
- 36:09actual formula, where you divide by 120 ,000
- 36:13times to buy the cash price. That's not a dispute,
- 36:15so everyone knows that. So the dispute would
- 36:17be why they picked a particular mileage, and
- 36:21that's something the jury is going to get to
- 36:22decide too, right? So it's important for counsel
- 36:25both in preparing and for mediation and for trial
- 36:30to be able to explain the mileage offset. Number
- 36:35three, again, is probably one of the biggest
- 36:37things that's disputed at mediations, right?
- 36:39If the manufacturer wants to buy the car back,
- 36:42then there's the issue of is civil penalties
- 36:44warranted? And again, how much. And this goes,
- 36:51well, it goes primarily to the pre -litigation
- 36:53repurchase, although it also can be established
- 36:55through repairs, right? So the severity of the
- 36:58repairs, what did the dealership do or not do?
- 37:03Are there certain bulletins or recalls that made
- 37:06the manufacturer aware of certain things that
- 37:08they didn't do? How did they treat the customer
- 37:11at the dealership? And then you again, as I was
- 37:15talking about earlier, you're looking at the
- 37:16call and did they gather the repair orders? Did
- 37:21they make a good faith evaluation? Did they go
- 37:24up the corporate chain? Every manufacturer has
- 37:27a process, right? Where you talk to someone when
- 37:29you call in and that person is typically an intake
- 37:32and then they'll escalate your repurchase request
- 37:35to someone. And sometimes there's even a third
- 37:37level but there's at least that second level
- 37:39and someone's supposed to review it, maybe talk
- 37:43to a supervisor, figure out what's wrong, take
- 37:46it seriously, and get back to the customer. And
- 37:48so obviously both sides will have a different
- 37:51opinion as to the manufacturer's response and
- 37:55how sufficient it was. So understanding what
- 37:58transpired there is important at mediation to
- 38:01use that as ammunition or pushback for the other
- 38:03side if they think that a lot of civil penalties
- 38:06warranted when the manufacturer We did great,
- 38:09right, and fully evaluated it and looked at everything
- 38:11and got back to the person and, you know, explain
- 38:14why they were turning it down. That's going to
- 38:17be harder to explain why you need a lot of civil
- 38:18penalty versus, you know, they blew off the customer.
- 38:22They never got back to them. They never even
- 38:24evaluated it. And then the manufacturer is going
- 38:26to have a little bit more difficulty in explaining
- 38:29why civil penalty is not warranted. All right.
- 38:33We talked about this, but that's another issue
- 38:35that's important is the attorney fee implications.
- 38:38So as a plaintiff, you know, you can go into
- 38:42your sales force or wherever you have, and you
- 38:44can look up your attorney's fees and costs for
- 38:46a case. As a defendant, you can do that for your
- 38:48own fees and costs, but you can't look up plaintiffs,
- 38:52right? And so typically I've seen them get a
- 38:56pretty good estimate based on, you know, they've
- 38:58seen the work. They know how much a depot costs.
- 39:01They know how much they charge for it. They know
- 39:03whether or not there was a motion to compel.
- 39:06whether there was an in -person hearing, how
- 39:09many depositions went forth. So they hopefully
- 39:12have a decent idea, right? And just as obviously,
- 39:15as a rule of thumb, they know that early in the
- 39:17case, you have barely any fees, in the middle
- 39:19you have some, and then toward the end you have
- 39:21a lot. So they know that. And so in my experience,
- 39:26it's been most productive to separate that out,
- 39:29right? So you wanna resolve the damages. and
- 39:35then say plus fees by motion. And later, plaintiff's
- 39:38counsel can file that motion or mean confer and
- 39:41come to an agreement with the opposing counsel.
- 39:43But they file the motion. They ask the judge
- 39:45for their reasonable attorney's fees and defend
- 39:47it as all their arguments as to why certain items
- 39:50are unreasonable, excessive, what have you. But
- 39:53I've found that if you try to do both, it's typically,
- 39:57it can create an impediment because now you're
- 40:00negotiating two numbers. You're trying to agree
- 40:02on damages and attorney's fees. Usually better
- 40:04to separate. I will say there are times there
- 40:07are some times when it's not and we'll get to
- 40:09that and you know sometimes defendant wants to
- 40:12know what the attorneys fees are and plaintiff
- 40:14may share that and if so great and there are
- 40:17certain instances in terms of. Especially with
- 40:20a 998 about whether they can beat the 998 or
- 40:23not. Sometimes that can be turned into an all
- 40:26inclusive number. And that I'll talk about later
- 40:30is having some flexibility with the mediator,
- 40:32but generally it's better to keep it separate.
- 40:35And then another point is what are the disputed
- 40:39factual issues, right? So I think it's important
- 40:43for both sides to hone in on their strongest
- 40:46facts and their weakest facts and be able to
- 40:50explain those during the course of mediation.
- 40:52They can use it as ammo for the mediator to explain
- 40:55to the other side. And they can just think about
- 40:57it themselves in terms of preparing their case,
- 40:59right? It helps. And along with disputed factual
- 41:03issues, There's also the possibility of procedural
- 41:06issues. We haven't talked about that really as
- 41:08much yet. But sometimes, defendant has a statute
- 41:12of limitations or motion for summary judgment
- 41:14argument in their pocket. And if that hasn't
- 41:17happened yet, then you may not be able to resolve
- 41:20the case either. So if that's potentially an
- 41:24issue, it's helpful to get one side's response
- 41:28on that as to how they're going to deal with
- 41:30that because they're going to have to deal with
- 41:31it eventually. Perhaps there's an allegation
- 41:34that the car is used, or that it wasn't filed
- 41:37timely, or that they did offer a purchase, or
- 41:40some other issue that could dispose of the case.
- 41:43And then there's other procedural issues that
- 41:46come into play. One I see a lot is experts and
- 41:50timely designating your experts, timely producing
- 41:53your expert for deposition, and motions and lemonade
- 41:57to try to exclude the expert. That is often used
- 42:00as ammo at a mediation. knowing if, you know,
- 42:04if counsel is going to make that argument, it's
- 42:06helpful to be able to say, no, wait a minute,
- 42:08we did, we did timely designate our expert. And
- 42:11so we don't put much stock into that. Or you
- 42:13know what? He's right. We blew it with our expert
- 42:15and this, this judge may not let us use our expert.
- 42:19And so now we need to, you know, incorporate
- 42:22that into our demand. All right. So all of this
- 42:28goes into sort of preparation, right? So if you're
- 42:31preparing for a mediation, it's going to be more
- 42:33likely to succeed. And that's preparing both
- 42:37counsel and the mediator. From counsel's perspective,
- 42:42you want to understand your client's settlement
- 42:43objective. I know from working with a lot of
- 42:47plaintiffs, some people want to just be done,
- 42:49get it over with, get on with their lives. And
- 42:52some people really want to push and want to get
- 42:55sort of maximum value for the case. So it's helpful
- 42:58before if you know your client's objective and
- 43:03sort of that range. You should be able to know
- 43:06what your damages are and why, as we talked about,
- 43:09and where you're at with trial readiness. Have
- 43:11you taken the depositions that you need? Have
- 43:16you propounded the discovery you need? How's
- 43:19it going with the experts? Are those lined up?
- 43:22Are you ready to go to trial? Because the more
- 43:24ready you are to go to trial, the stronger your
- 43:27case is in terms of mediating it. And the other
- 43:29side can sense that. Obviously, in litigation,
- 43:33any time you do something, you're not only filing
- 43:35it, you're serving it on the other side. So they're
- 43:37receiving it, so they can see that readiness
- 43:40and it helps in terms of strength in the negotiation.
- 43:46I talked a little bit earlier about having your
- 43:48strongest evidence and having a detailed repair
- 43:50chronology. So if you have that detailed repair
- 43:53chronology, you can talk about exactly how many
- 43:56times it went in, when it went in, what happened,
- 44:00was there some incident with a toe or... customer
- 44:04was stranded or some significant thing, you would
- 44:07know more about whether or not things are repeat.
- 44:11You would also be able to identify weakest evidence,
- 44:14right? So maybe your client isn't so great at
- 44:19planning it. Maybe there is an allegation of
- 44:21a third party modification. Maybe they didn't
- 44:25really do a good job of asking for a repurchase.
- 44:27So whatever it is, I mean, it's good to be able
- 44:30to identify it and figure out how you're going
- 44:32to deal with it. And then the last point, procedural
- 44:36is what I was talking about a second ago in terms
- 44:38of expert designations and potential emotions
- 44:42for summary judgment, things like that. So here
- 44:47are some common mistakes that I see. The first
- 44:51one is unrealistic opening positions. So I don't
- 44:55think it's bad or it's not abnormal for plaintiff,
- 44:58obviously, to start at max damages, which is
- 45:01sometimes called 3X or two times civil penalties.
- 45:04What I do think is bad is if they're starting
- 45:06above that, right? So we're not helpful, rather.
- 45:09Not that it's bad, but it's not helpful if you're
- 45:12starting beyond what you can recover under the
- 45:14law. So if you're starting with the maximum,
- 45:16fine. But don't ask for things you can't recover
- 45:19or a number that doesn't make sense. From just
- 45:23defense perspective, they obviously are free
- 45:25to offer nothing or whatever they want. However,
- 45:28if they want to settle the case, it's better
- 45:30not to start with trivial amounts, a few hundred
- 45:32bucks or a few thousand bucks. That often makes
- 45:35plaintiffs harden their position and not come
- 45:39back. And so at least start, if you don't want
- 45:43to settle the case, fine. You think it's a great
- 45:44case, you want to try it, okay. But if you really
- 45:47want to try to settle it, it makes sense to start
- 45:49at least some real amount of money. You don't
- 45:54want to focus on only your strong facts and ignore
- 45:56your weak ones. That's not helpful. Waiting until
- 45:59mediation to obtain your authority. So if you
- 46:01don't even know, what your goal is, right? You
- 46:04want to go in knowing your damages and what you
- 46:07can get, what's the range, what you think you'll
- 46:09likely get, what your client want to accept,
- 46:12or what your client's willing to offer from the
- 46:15dispense perspective. You should know that ahead
- 46:17of time. And sometimes these things can become
- 46:20a little emotional. There is a little bit of
- 46:27wanting to win or get the other side sometimes.
- 46:29And so you want to be able to kind of put that
- 46:31aside. You can see sometimes in, you know, hopefully
- 46:36in a productive joint session, but otherwise
- 46:38through the mediator, you know, you can calm
- 46:41things down a little and not let emotion influence
- 46:44your negotiation. All right, so specifically
- 46:48for plaintiffs council, and, you know, we've
- 46:50gone over some of this, but knowing your damages
- 46:53and their basis, that's critical because everything
- 46:56is going to flow from that in terms of what the
- 46:58buyback is and what civil penalties are possible.
- 47:03anticipating the factual and procedural challenges,
- 47:05preparing your client. So if this is a mediation
- 47:10in which your clients can actually appear, you're
- 47:12gonna need to prepare them more, right? So you're
- 47:14gonna have to have a little session with them
- 47:17and more so on the plaintiff side and the manufacturer
- 47:20is more familiar, but just explaining what a
- 47:22mediation is, what everyone's role is, and what
- 47:26you're looking for is gonna help. If they're
- 47:29less involved, then at least you wanna get their
- 47:31authority. and figure out what they want from
- 47:34the case. In terms of sometimes, I mean, it's
- 47:37primarily about money, but there's other considerations
- 47:39too, sometimes for plan. For example, perhaps
- 47:46they want to keep the car and get a cash settlement
- 47:48is one example. So there's things, there's little
- 47:50nuances like that that may go into the process.
- 47:55Focusing on what actually creates settlement
- 47:56value. And I think we talked a lot about that
- 47:59in terms of both the facts and getting yourself
- 48:03trial ready. and which facts are going to help
- 48:05you get the most settlement value, having a realistic
- 48:08settlement range, and giving the mediator room
- 48:11to work. So even if they start at maximum damages
- 48:16and defendant has started a very low, I think
- 48:18it's important to have some patience because
- 48:20I've seen cases where even moves are still productive.
- 48:25So as long as people are moving, you're giving
- 48:28the mediator a chance to kind of bridge the gap.
- 48:33And moving towards now for defense counsel in
- 48:37that same vein, skipping to the last point, giving
- 48:40flexibility to explore creative solutions. You
- 48:43have, I talked about earlier, there's the cash
- 48:44and keep. There is the inclusive option. If we're
- 48:49worried about fees after a 998, then perhaps
- 48:52you can, sometimes it's helpful to combine attorney's
- 48:56fees and damages into one number. Other things
- 49:01would include bracketing. or a mediator's proposal.
- 49:05Sometimes you get to a point where both sides
- 49:07say it's their best and final, and a mediator's
- 49:09proposal can bridge the difference. Otherwise,
- 49:13a lot of the same stuff for plaintiff, knowing
- 49:15your damages. Defendants have more risk, right?
- 49:20I mean, plaintiff, yes, they may go to trial
- 49:22and they may get nothing, but they're not going
- 49:24to have to pay all the attorney's fees. They
- 49:26may have to pay costs, but not attorney's fees.
- 49:28So understanding what those are, how they play
- 49:30in, is important. For a defendant, sometimes
- 49:35I think they may underestimate the value of early
- 49:38resolution, right? That even offering a more
- 49:41sizable offer at early or at mid -case mediation
- 49:44may save them on attorney's fees for a viable
- 49:46case, because attorney's fees will be so much
- 49:49more later on. Neither side should focus solely
- 49:52on winning, but on getting the best result for
- 49:55their client and identifying what information
- 50:00can change the plan's valuation. So we talked
- 50:02about this, but. you know, through the mediator,
- 50:06a defendant can identify, you know, problems
- 50:08with the plaintiff or the repair history, things
- 50:12being out of warranty. And so those can be used
- 50:14to explain to the plaintiff why they're making
- 50:17a certain offer that they are. All right. And
- 50:22then as a mediator, you get to play devil's advocate.
- 50:26You get to be the neutral party. You can test
- 50:30those assumptions and litigates and positions
- 50:32as needed. You know, I think as I've been told
- 50:34by mediators more senior than me, the most important
- 50:37thing you can do is listen. And so that's the
- 50:40primary thing is listening to both sides, but
- 50:42sometimes you do need to kind of prod and poke
- 50:46a little bit as to those assumptions or positions.
- 50:50Sometimes you can help identify missing information.
- 50:54So plaintiff or defendant may have a theory of
- 50:56the case and they're looking at it from a certain
- 50:59perspective and you're able to identify a missing
- 51:02link, right? might prevent a jury from getting
- 51:05to that conclusion. And that can help in terms
- 51:08of case valuation, as is communicating information
- 51:13that they don't always want to hear and exploring
- 51:15different settlement structures that I talked
- 51:18about a second ago as needed. All right. So that
- 51:23is the main part of my presentation in terms
- 51:27of information. So now as we sort of get to the
- 51:31tail end of the presentation, I wanted to present
- 51:33a hypothetical 11 law case. So let's pretend
- 51:38this case is going to be mediated, and I wanted
- 51:42to get some input from the audience in terms
- 51:46of their thoughts. So I'm going to give you some
- 51:49information and not all. So then you can think
- 51:52about what information you'd want to know, both
- 51:55from plaintiff and from defendant, in terms of
- 52:01being able to value the case more accurately.
- 52:03Or what would the mediator need to know? to help
- 52:07push the case toward resolution. All right, so
- 52:10this vehicle, it was purchased for $60 ,000,
- 52:14and the first presentation is for a window squeak,
- 52:18all right, and that happened at 10 ,000 miles.
- 52:22The customer took it back at 12 ,000 miles for
- 52:26the same window squeak, and they claim that that
- 52:30issue has never been repaired. And now, At 30
- 52:36,000 miles, they have a complaint about transmission
- 52:39shift quality. So perhaps a hesitation or a bucking,
- 52:44a common thing that you see with how transmissions
- 52:47shift. So the first time they take it to the
- 52:50dealership, not verified. Second time, again,
- 52:53not verified. Third time, there is a software
- 52:57update. You often see these with transmissions.
- 53:00There is the modules. the TCM and the PCM, so
- 53:04perhaps one of those was updated, and then that
- 53:07didn't work, and so there's a fourth repair for
- 53:09a transmission replacement. After that, no further
- 53:12repairs for the transmission, and you have an
- 53:18unhappy client who files a loss. Before they
- 53:22do that though, however, they request a repurchase,
- 53:25which is denied, and the case is filed, and it
- 53:31goes forward, some discovery, I have trial of
- 53:33six months away. And now we're sitting in mediation,
- 53:37and the mediator started this by saying, OK,
- 53:40plaintiff, what is your demand? And they say
- 53:44$180 ,000 plus a motion for attorney's fees,
- 53:47costs, and expenses. That's communicated to defendant
- 53:50whose response is a buyback, right? So $60 ,000
- 53:56plus attorney's fees and costs. They're not offering
- 53:59civil penalties. So the parties are, at those
- 54:04points, And it's now a mediation. Some questions
- 54:13I wanted to ask the audience. If you were representing
- 54:15the plaintiff, what additional information would
- 54:18you want? Or if you were representing the manufacturer,
- 54:21what would you want to know in terms of how you
- 54:24would evaluate this case? And maybe it helps
- 54:26if I go back to the screens that had information
- 54:30from that. One second. All right. So let me look
- 54:44at some of these. Oops, sorry. I see there's
- 54:50actually some earlier questions. Before we even
- 54:55get to the questions I posed, I'll answer these
- 54:58to the best that I can. The first is, is there
- 55:03a standard date a warranty starts or is it per
- 55:06the written terms? Typically, it's the date of
- 55:12sale. If the data goes in service, sometimes
- 55:17that issue comes up if it's a certified pre -owned,
- 55:19but for a new car, typically, it's you know,
- 55:21the day you bought the car, that's the day the
- 55:23warranty starts. And they ask also about what
- 55:29if the terms are different from what the dealer
- 55:31stated and the dealer gave a car fax stating
- 55:34expected date of warranty start date was a year
- 55:36later. So this is kind of getting into some issues
- 55:40I think that are sort of outside the lemon law
- 55:42in terms of now we're not at the manufacturer,
- 55:46the dealership themselves, we're at car fax.
- 55:49And so this is sort of unfortunately a different
- 55:52area of law that's a bit outside the scope of
- 55:55this presentation. All right. Another question
- 55:58is, how long does the dealership have to apply
- 56:00to a demand letter without filing a lawsuit?
- 56:03What if they reject the demand letter and say
- 56:05the client has no claim? So the demand now with
- 56:11the lemon law cases is typically to the manufacturer.
- 56:14And now under the new law, it's got to be written,
- 56:17a written demand. You used to be able to call
- 56:19or write in. But now, if you want civil penalties,
- 56:22you got to do a written demand to the manufacturer
- 56:24themselves. And they're going to decide, as opposed
- 56:27to the dealership, whether or not they think
- 56:29that the car is eligible for repurchase. They
- 56:32may say yes, buy it back. They may say no. And
- 56:35then you can decide whether or not you want to
- 56:37try to investigate whether you have a claim.
- 56:41The next question is, have you had any experience
- 56:45with the Better Business Bureau process? And
- 56:47is that an avenue worth pursuing? I haven't.
- 56:51As a plaintiff's attorney, we're dealing with
- 56:54cases that are actually filed. So either people
- 56:56that have used BBB and weren't satisfied or just
- 57:00didn't want to do that and they wanted to go
- 57:02about getting their remedies through a lawsuit.
- 57:05So I don't really know. I don't have much information,
- 57:07unfortunately, about whether that's something
- 57:09you can try. I know it's available and I know
- 57:11you can do it if you want to. You don't have
- 57:14to. So sorry, I don't have too much information
- 57:17about that. Next question, someone posed their
- 57:20own hypothetical. A car went in for a safety
- 57:25recall and the seatbelt doesn't work, stayed
- 57:27there for 100 days, lemon question mark. All
- 57:30right, so there is a cause of, so typically as
- 57:34I mentioned actually earlier, and I don't want
- 57:36to offer legal advice or anything, but there
- 57:37is a Silvio versus Ford case that says you have
- 57:40to have at least two repairs to be a lemon. There
- 57:43is a cause of action about a repair taking longer
- 57:45than 30 days. and it gets a bit nuanced. There's
- 57:49a case called Ramos versus Mercedes -Benz. And
- 57:53so, you know, you could investigate this. I'm
- 57:56not going to answer, obviously, whether you have
- 57:57a lemon or not, but there is a cause of action
- 58:00you could look into in terms of repairs lasting
- 58:03longer than 30 days. Next question. Is the use
- 58:10element affected if the car dealership provides
- 58:13the car owner with an equivalent rental car at
- 58:16the dealer's cost? Good question. And the answer,
- 58:19I guess, is yes and no, right? That's a great
- 58:22point, right? So typically at trial, someone
- 58:24would say, you know, I couldn't even use this
- 58:27car. It was so terrible. And then the defendant
- 58:29will bring out the, wait a minute, didn't you
- 58:31get a rental car? And so those are things the
- 58:34jury will weigh, right, in terms of whether there
- 58:38are substantial impairment to use. Maybe they
- 58:42think that getting the rental car was enough.
- 58:44Maybe they think, no, you should be able to get
- 58:47the car you paid for, and not get the rental
- 58:49car. All right, next question I have is, as a
- 58:54mediator, I would ask plaintiff if they really
- 58:56want to go to trial solely over the issue of
- 58:59CP. This may upset a judge jury to listen to
- 59:02a case solely for CP. Yeah, that is a good point.
- 59:07I think that's, and you know, plaintiffs have
- 59:10a very different perspective. So some plaintiffs
- 59:14and some clients and some counsel are much more
- 59:17aggressive about pursuing civil penalty than
- 59:19others. But I will say that I've been to many
- 59:24lemon law trials, and judges are not surprised
- 59:28to learn that the fight is over civil penalty
- 59:32as opposed to the buyback. So that may be true,
- 59:35and that may get them to listen to reason, but
- 59:40it may not. All right. The next question is If
- 59:46the defendant forces the plaintiff to arbitrate
- 59:48attorney's fees and the issue of fees only under
- 59:52CCP 871 .25, who pays for the arbitration? So
- 59:59yeah, again, that's kind of outside the scope.
- 1:00:05Arbitration clauses, certain manufacturers that
- 1:00:08comes up, especially with manufacturers that
- 1:00:11don't have a dealership, like Tesla, for example.
- 1:00:14but it's getting into things that I think are
- 1:00:16outside the scope here, so I'm not gonna fully
- 1:00:18get into that, fortunately. All right, so next
- 1:00:21question is, if I were plaintiff's attorney,
- 1:00:25I'd wanna know, do the physical repair orders
- 1:00:28explicitly state the customer's complaint and
- 1:00:30the window squeak at 10 ,000 and 12 ,000, or
- 1:00:33did the service advisor write, cannot replicate?
- 1:00:36That's a good point, and it's something that's
- 1:00:38very important. Both just, I guess, as a person
- 1:00:43who has a car, which is probably everybody listening,
- 1:00:45whenever you take your car into the dealership,
- 1:00:47you want to get everything written down. Because
- 1:00:49if something's not written down, it's just your
- 1:00:51word against theirs, right? So you do want to
- 1:00:54have that on there. And the more detail and the
- 1:00:57more it confirms their story, the better. And
- 1:01:00so that would be good to know whether or not
- 1:01:03it was written down. I think another thing I
- 1:01:07guess would be good to think about in terms of
- 1:01:09the window squeak, is the substantiality of it.
- 1:01:14Is that a substantial defect that it makes a
- 1:01:17noise? Maybe. Is it affecting your ability to
- 1:01:19roll it up and roll it down? That could be more
- 1:01:22substantial. It also comes into play in terms
- 1:01:25of the mileage offset. So should the mileage
- 1:01:28offset, in this case, be taken at 10 ,000 miles?
- 1:01:31Or should it be taken at 30 ,000 miles? So that
- 1:01:34could be a dispute in terms of damages. The next
- 1:01:38question. What are the specific nature, dates,
- 1:01:42and mileage logs for the additional problems
- 1:01:45referenced on the slide? Do they involve safety,
- 1:01:48use, or value impairments? Okay, good question.
- 1:01:51And I think that was just my own not making it
- 1:01:54clear on the slide. By additional problems appear,
- 1:01:57I meant now we have the transmission, right?
- 1:02:00So that's the additional problems that I was
- 1:02:01talking about. But you're right. Does the transmission
- 1:02:05involve use, value, or safety? Certainly plaintiffs
- 1:02:09get to say it does. that it affects shift quality
- 1:02:11and how you're driving, the defendant's going
- 1:02:13to say, no, it's just how it feels. And that's
- 1:02:15not substantial. And then another thing is, is
- 1:02:20there some kind of a technical service bulletin
- 1:02:23or something that relates to that transmission?
- 1:02:27And I think the jury is going to have to wrestle
- 1:02:28with potentially. If the fourth transmission
- 1:02:33replacement fixed it, how many more miles did
- 1:02:37they drive after that? Has the carbon totally
- 1:02:39fine since then? And then at the same time, well,
- 1:02:42maybe, but this four repairs sort of unreasonable
- 1:02:45in replacing your whole transmission unreasonable
- 1:02:47for a new car. And that's something a jury could
- 1:02:50frankly come down either way on that. Did you
- 1:02:53get the use of your car? Did you not? So those
- 1:02:56are things you'd want to take into account when
- 1:02:58you're trying to value your case. All right,
- 1:03:01last question I see here is, how many cumulative
- 1:03:03days has the vehicle spent sitting at the dealership
- 1:03:06waiting for parts? That's a great question. Days
- 1:03:10out of service is going to be in the jury instructions
- 1:03:13for things you can consider. Again, I was talking
- 1:03:16about there is a cause of action for being over
- 1:03:1930 days. And then just in terms of the story
- 1:03:22to the jury, is there an explanation as to why
- 1:03:25the vehicle is sitting there? Is it because there
- 1:03:27was a parts delay or what's the reason? Did the
- 1:03:30defendant have what's called a field service
- 1:03:32engineer come in and try to figure it out? Do
- 1:03:34they have a good reason for the delay or is there
- 1:03:36no reason for the delay? And then lastly here,
- 1:03:40I guess the two -part question, someone asked,
- 1:03:42did the client send a direct written demand or
- 1:03:45notice to the manufacturer's corporate address?
- 1:03:47And that's exactly what I was talking about earlier.
- 1:03:50You used to be able to send an email, write a
- 1:03:54letter, and make a phone call. But now, if you
- 1:03:56want civil penalties, you have to make that written
- 1:03:59direct demand to the manufacturer. So if they
- 1:04:02didn't do that, you're right. They're gonna be
- 1:04:03in trouble in terms of their civil penalties.
- 1:04:05If they did do that, then I think you'd wanna
- 1:04:07talk about what happened with that pre litigation
- 1:04:12repurchase request and the severity of the repairs.
- 1:04:16That is all the questions that I see unless there's
- 1:04:25any others. All right. Doesn't look like we have
- 1:04:36any more questions. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:04:38I would like to take this moment to thank Jacob
- 1:04:40Cutler for an excellent presentation and also
- 1:04:43thank our audience for joining us today. Have
- 1:04:45a great day, everybody. Thank you.