Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Political Differences, Forced Forgiveness, and Being Too Much
Transcript
- 0:00All right, it's a Rebecca Soode, so let's get into it. What
- 0:04do you say? There's some good questions here. Okay, I'm excited,
- 0:07annual Uppertier patron anonymous, She says, dear doctor k and Rebecca, can
- 0:13you educate our older listeners about non binary people? What is it? And
- 0:19why do they feel the need to be part of one gender or the other?
- 0:23I want to understand, so I'm compassionate to these people. I grew
- 0:27up in the eighties in a very conservative area, and most people my age
- 0:30here have no understanding of this, but the younger generation does. My son
- 0:35is in his first year of college and he has two non binary friends.
- 0:39They are both biologically girls. So what would you say to this individual,
- 0:44Rebecca, Well, I think it's really hard in our culture. That's so
- 0:50there's so many rules around male and female to realize that you can step out
- 0:55of that really binary story. So if the term non binary suggests that there
- 1:00has been a binary in the past and we are existing in a binary,
- 1:03that there's two poles. There's a way to really be a man and there's
- 1:08a way to really be a woman, and you can live in those stories
- 1:14and it's great for a lot of people. But then there's a sense that
- 1:19there's a lot of gray area. So what if you weren't firmly in one
- 1:23of those poles. What if you rejected some of being masculine and went towards
- 1:30some of being feminine, but enjoyed some parts of being masculine. So it's
- 1:34like, I don't know, It's like if you opened up the whole color
- 1:38palette and just got to, you know, choose what you wanted, dress
- 1:44the way you want to dress outside of gender norms, view your internal landscape
- 1:49outside of gender norms. So it's accepting of a very wide variety of presentation
- 1:57and thought style and being in the world. So me having a team this
- 2:04age, when we discuss gender, me and my kiddo, they believe that
- 2:12gender is gone, and most of the people of their generation do here in
- 2:17Seattle do as well. There's no reason to exist in that binary at all,
- 2:23and they can present in all kinds of ways. So if anything gets
- 2:28discussed in a very gender specific way, I get a lot of pushback.
- 2:32Why would I think that way? Why would I think that that's a man's
- 2:35job, Why would I think that that's the way a woman should dress,
- 2:39So it's like everything's just kind of wide open and there's all kinds of ways
- 2:44to be. And I had a beautiful conversation with my aunt about this,
- 2:50who said that some of the people of her generation in the town that she
- 2:53lives in are starting to identify as non binary. And we just have really
- 3:00interesting conversation about how gender has it worked out for a lot of people.
- 3:05I mean, gender hasn't worked out for me being female. Being considered a
- 3:10wife and a mother is my primary role. It's not really great, doesn't
- 3:15really get me anything. Having a wide variety of ways that I can present
- 3:21myself in dress and talk. I mean, even on this podcast, the
- 3:23way that I get reacted to as the quote woman is very intense. A
- 3:30lot of negativity comes at me because I'm speaking from the female voice. People
- 3:36don't want me to be this smart and gracious and opinionated, right, because
- 3:40that's not the way that a woman presents. I find the way that I
- 3:46find those crazy kids these days, it's very liberating and joyful. I mean,
- 3:51the way that so many people are scared of it. If you just
- 3:54spend time with somebody who's reveling in their non binariness, really beautiful. Yeah,
- 4:02the Internet and the news and Fox News are presenting a straw person if
- 4:09you will, and if you actually hang out with these people, there's no
- 4:15threat. There's a lot of flexibility. All the non broinary people that I
- 4:19know in my life are frequently misgendered, but they don't react. They're they're
- 4:26not happy about it, but they don't think ill of someone, particularly if
- 4:30they are older, and recognize that it is harder for some people. They
- 4:33are lovely, wonderful, free, liberated individuals leading the way. So it's
- 4:41unfortunate that the public discourse is just so backward and angry and straw persony,
- 4:48you know well, and scared to release their own identities. I mean,
- 4:53I you might have seen on Facebook that somebody that I got a lot from
- 4:58in my early twenty passed away of a brain aneurysm at fifty six. So
- 5:04I met this person identified by this name their whole life, Chip Phillips,
- 5:09and I met them when they were the administrator at Alice B Theater, which
- 5:15is a wonderful game lesbian theater company here in Seattle, and over their lifetime
- 5:21they had lots of jobs and towards the end of their lives they identified as
- 5:26non binary, and the Gender Justice League spoke at their at the memorial that
- 5:34was the Saturday, But probably the most touching moment was the slide show that
- 5:40put up of Chip's life and so you saw this young, very butch person
- 5:47all through their lives being really masculine identified and what did look like for them
- 5:56and the world they had to straddle. And many of the people there spoke
- 6:02to the joy that Ship found at the end of their lives being non bronary.
- 6:09And that was the first funeral I had attended of a non bronary person,
- 6:13and pronouns were discussed at the beginning of the funeral, and everyone identified
- 6:19by their pronouns and half the people they're messed up ships pronouns as they were
- 6:26speaking, and you know, it was just kind of beautiful as we all
- 6:29kind of fumbled around in it for ourselves, you know, but there we
- 6:32were celebrating the life of someone who'd impacted so many people, and they to
- 6:40find happiness in themselves, had to let go of being female identified. And
- 6:46that hurts me in no way at all. I can still be completely feminine
- 6:51identified, completely female identified, And so this idea that like someone else's identity
- 6:58is somehow like encroaching on mine or taking from me or I'm not gonna get
- 7:01enough you know. I mean, that's where it gets super messed up.
- 7:04It's like Chip finding themselves just meant that they were even happier at the end
- 7:10of their lives. Why would we want to crush that? Yeah? If
- 7:15not, because it's our own selfishness, right yeah? I won't me me
- 7:19me, I mean. And the other thing I say this every time I
- 7:23just get blasted on YouTube? Would I say it? But freaking buy a
- 7:28book people like. Getting to They Them is one of my favorite books to
- 7:33hand the older relatives in our family of what on earth is happening here?
- 7:40And everyone? So again, the name of the book is getting to They
- 7:43Them. If none of this makes any sense to you, pick up a
- 7:48book, read read about it, go on YouTube and look at some of
- 7:54the non binary comedians out there. They're freaking hysterical when you get blast for
- 8:00what do you worried about getting blasted about? Uh? I don't know.
- 8:03People don't like that you're supposed to read a book on something that you don't
- 8:07know anything about, Like they would say, how dare you recommend that I
- 8:11read a book on something, yeah, yeah, yeah, right. But
- 8:16if like this is confusing to you, like just like if the weather was
- 8:18confusing to you, or you didn't know what to pack on a trip,
- 8:22you would probably go to someone who was an expert on that subject and learn
- 8:26from them. And we are so lucky right now, and that there's so
- 8:33many people being so gracious and open about their experience and the joy they find
- 8:39and stepping into their experience. It's just lovely. So yeah, you know,
- 8:45at this point, you can listen to a non binary singer, laugh
- 8:50with a non binary comedian, You can read a book by a non binary
- 8:54person and just you know, spend some time with it and see that it's
- 8:58not so scary. And and for folks who are above our generation, who
- 9:03are literal boomers, if you can have a realistic conversation about how gender truly
- 9:09impacted your life, that's some profound stuff. I mean, the gender norms
- 9:15of the forties and fifties were no joke. Like my dearly departed neighbor Pat
- 9:22told the story. She was a woman, she was single her whole life.
- 9:28She bought her own house, which meant like she was one of the
- 9:31first generation of women to not have to have a husband or a father co
- 9:35signed the loan for her. She led this radical life considering that she was
- 9:39about my mom's age. She told this story that in Centralia in the fifties,
- 9:46in gym class, the boys and the girls would both suit up for
- 9:50jim but the boys would play basketball and the girls would just sit in the
- 9:54bleachers in their sports in their little pentaphores for gym class. So, if
- 10:01you were of the boomer generation, have a conversation with your friends about how
- 10:05gender norms impacted your life, what you were allowed, what you lost,
- 10:09what you gained, how you suffered. I mean, let's just all have
- 10:13a conversation about gender. Yeah, yeah, here's stood here's the deep conversations.
- 10:20Kirt Conda absolutely cheers to that. Along those lines patron Leah or leia,
- 10:26I always get that wrong and l l A h leia Leah Yeah,
- 10:33horrible with the vowels and the consonants were confusing about well. She even provides
- 10:37like pronunciation guides in the past, and you just like Tara, Tara Tara
- 10:45for me. Yeah, there's women I won't even say their name. I'll
- 10:48just be like, hey, tee, what's up because I like, I
- 10:50know I'm going to get the a so over, she says. I recently
- 10:52saw a thread on Twitter from a person in Florida whose therapist told her per
- 10:58her employer that clients should not report any plans to have abortions to their therapists
- 11:05until after the fact. This is supposed to be to prevent liability on the
- 11:11end of the therapist and to prevent the therapist from needing to report the plans
- 11:15to obtain an abortion to the state as a part of their mandatory reporter status.
- 11:20I'm vehemently pro choice and am currently getting my MSW and plan to work
- 11:26as a therapist in Missouri where this kind of thing could apply. While I
- 11:31can sort of see how someone who is vehemently anti abortion and being an asshole
- 11:37about it could logic this out to be part of mandatory reporting, I find
- 11:41the concept extremely troubling and unethical. I wanted to know your thoughts about the
- 11:46ethics of this as a provider and how you might approach these limitations if it
- 11:52were you. Thanks so much for all your wonderful content. Yeah, so
- 11:56what's your response. Yeah, So, here we are at the Handmaid's Tale,
- 12:01and that's a little bit scary. Um yeah, I mean all of
- 12:07us are watching these I've just got the mic like, um yeah, all
- 12:16of us are. I am. I'll just speak from my own experience.
- 12:20I am watching all of this just horrified. I heard something similar is happening
- 12:26in Texas where therapists are telling clients the same thing. So this idea that
- 12:35therapists cannot be there for their clients mental health while they're making difficult choices because
- 12:43the state would step in and decide that abortion is akin to child abuse,
- 12:50which is not it. Actually abortion actually helps child wear welfare and is that
- 12:58point is well documented? Um so yeah, it's it's a very very strange
- 13:03time, and I would hope that this isn't true. Therapists tend to be
- 13:11a very thoughtful bunch and don't want to do anything wrong. I'd love to
- 13:16hear from a therapist in Florida or Texas if they're what mandate they've gotten?
- 13:22Um, you know, like, does the state write letter and tell them
- 13:24this is this just what they're deciding on their own volition? Is this in
- 13:28a Florida ethics class? Sometimes with therapists, you don't know, like some
- 13:33therapists kind of decide. Oh, I have to error in the most cautious
- 13:37place. We're famous. Some of us are a little bit more nuanced than
- 13:45that. Yeah, well, so we're recording this and that at the end
- 13:50of March. This episode might come out far later than that, happen in
- 13:54that time, you know. And then, But generally speaking, in our
- 13:58field, since there are so few actions taken against us, there's so few
- 14:01court precedents made. A lot of these questions that have been around for decades,
- 14:07not this one, but similar ones have never really been answered, particularly
- 14:11when you go state by state, because you might have an answer in one
- 14:13state, but that precedent in that state doesn't necessarily apply to a neighboring state.
- 14:18So like an example that I'm thinking of is people who treat folks who
- 14:24are undocumented and all the legal issues that come up with that. But yeah,
- 14:31yeah, I also remember hearing I can't remember exactly where the ethics experts
- 14:37landed, but if someone had HIV and they were having sex, Oh,
- 14:39yeah, that's a classic. There was classic Kirk conduct. Yeah, there
- 14:43was. I remember talk about how it was maybe it was considered illegal if
- 14:48you don't report that person or something. Yeah, for a lot of therapists
- 14:54in these jurisdictions, I'm guessing that they are going to be careful, but
- 15:00they will probably it is just anecdotally. They'll probably err on the side of
- 15:05Look, if a client wants to talk about their upcoming abortion, I'm not
- 15:09going to tell them not to talk with me about it, but I'm going
- 15:11to be careful how I document it. I might also even just tell the
- 15:15client, Look, you and I, we can't talk about the fact that
- 15:18you even talked about it with me, So right, that's a whole other
- 15:20point. So don't tell other people that you told me, because I could
- 15:24actually get in trouble. I don't know that, but I don't want to
- 15:28create a world where you, as a client can't talk about your life in
- 15:33this way. So go ahead and talk about it, but just for my
- 15:37sake, don't tell the people that you told me, and it won't be
- 15:39in your record. I can't reflect any records. I don't know if I
- 15:43can get in trouble, so I don't know if a lot of therapists will
- 15:46do that. You could absolutely consider that to be an example of where ethics
- 15:52and morality diverge from legality, which has happened throughout our history obviously, and
- 15:56also the urge to rebel against the imperialist state. Like here I am,
- 16:03I'm staring in all of this Star Wars stuff, and I'm thinking, you
- 16:08know, it's definitely a Darth Vader. This is a fucking Darth mayor momentum,
- 16:15right, Like, if imperial forces are coming at me, I'm gonna
- 16:21work for the real emotional person that's in front of me. And addressing the
- 16:29need or desire to terminate a pregnancy is a gift that I will never deny
- 16:36a client. How we're going to deal with it in the current political landscape
- 16:41is another story. But you know, I'm with the resistance here. Thank
- 16:47god we live on the West coast, yes, I would say, and
- 16:51our freedoms are well protected here. But also like looking, I think it
- 16:56was in Kansas where this was on the ballot to deny women abortions, and
- 17:00people went door to door to address with their neighbors what it meant to people
- 17:06of reproductive age that their ability to have an abortion would be taken away.
- 17:11And so this idea that it doesn't have to be decided by our government the
- 17:18right to choose, but actually the person whose body it is can choose quite
- 17:22easily and for their own health and and for their doctor to help them make
- 17:27that choice. Yeah. So I think what will happen is there will be
- 17:34in the next five years this will become more of a legal reality tested in
- 17:41courts with when it comes to physicians, but with therapists. I'm guessing at
- 17:47some point it's going to come up and we're going to see how the court
- 17:52system reacts to this. We could even end up in the Supreme Court.
- 17:56Who knows, but or there's a chance that, like with HIV from what
- 18:02I remember, there's a lot of talk about that and there's a lot of
- 18:06worry about it, but in the end, it just never came to be
- 18:11tested. And don't call me on that, of course, But one of
- 18:15the ways that this would be tested is if you did have a client who
- 18:18told a therapist that they were going to you know, you could imagine it
- 18:21would be like a teenager, like a seventeen year old, and she crosses
- 18:25state lines to get an abortion. The parents find out, they're upset.
- 18:29They asked the seventeen year old, you know, who knew about this?
- 18:33And seventeen year old says, well, my therapist did or it's in the
- 18:37record or something, and the parents alert the authorities, the authorities try to
- 18:41go after the therapist. That sort of scenario is it's pretty rare that kind
- 18:45of that kind of action. It could happen, of course, but people
- 18:48don't typically go after therapists in this way. But I don't know, as
- 18:53I say that scenario out loud, you know, I could imagine that happening,
- 18:57especially in today's climate. Get even see anti abortion activists Trump trying to
- 19:03create a situation like that so they get into therapist. And also, I
- 19:07mean, there's a way in which really our client records are really protected.
- 19:11It's not that you can't just access the client's records, right, So it
- 19:15would be interesting to see if the therapist doesn't document the same conversation in which
- 19:22the client reports. This just makes sense, you know, would there be
- 19:26weight in that way in court either way or as a part of covering your
- 19:33own ass but still providing good therapy, you have this seventeen year old person
- 19:38who is talking about possible beginning an abortion, and as a part of your
- 19:44covering your own ass, you're just like, so, I just have to
- 19:47tell you that there's a legality here. I want to inform you there's also
- 19:51there's a possible morality exploration here, I suppose, and we can talk about
- 19:56that, and then you document that part of it, right, that you
- 20:00you informed them of what the laws are and what maybe their parents would want
- 20:03them to do or something, and that the therapist documents that they said to
- 20:08the client, you should consider this. But then after that you talk about
- 20:12so tell me. So now I've got that other way, let's go ahead
- 20:15and tell me. And then as a therapist, you're not encouraging or discouraging.
- 20:19You're just listening and validating and going along with You're not pushing back obviously,
- 20:26and you're giving the vibe that you're okay with what's happening, or you're
- 20:30not saying it's a bad thing, and you document that you just listened.
- 20:37But there's no clear indication of influence from a therapist, which really shouldn't be
- 20:42happening anyway. Yeah, yeah, I mean, what could a therapist possibly
- 20:48It's funny. I mean, I do give referrals, so I mean,
- 20:52and I could see too, like they're giving a referral to a crisis line
- 20:56for real details or something like. It would be interesting to see state by
- 21:00state, like could I mention the states where it is legal? Or yeah,
- 21:06there's just a ton I don't know with this question, and people in
- 21:08these states rise up, yeah, like and write us, I mean,
- 21:11we want to know what it's really like. You can you can change this
- 21:15with your votes. That's what we do in these That's why in our state
- 21:22of Washington we don't have this problem because we have a majority voice in this
- 21:27part of the world. Try to get out there and and vote and change
- 21:32people's minds about just a lot of things, including this. So it's it's
- 21:36not we're not doomed by any means. All Right, it's take a break,
- 21:38we get back. Let's talk about how we're not doomed. What do
- 21:41you say, I've been I'm down. All right, we're back from the
- 21:48break. So let's all get Rebecca's Instagram follower account to above a thousand.
- 21:55Go to our text on Instagram that's our t X tea and become a follower,
- 22:02and you can be that thousandth follower, that coveted thousandth follower. You
- 22:07don't get a prize or nothing, but you do get you do get cute
- 22:11photos of my dog. Yeah, an occasional well done food photograph. Yeah,
- 22:18you get exclusive photos of me and Kirk. Yeah. Yeah, photos
- 22:25you won't see anywhere else. So our text at Instagram do it now?
- 22:29Anonymous Samuel Patron from Norway. I love international questions. She says, I've
- 22:34learned in therapy over the last two years that I have trauma. I have
- 22:37done EMDR and it seems to have calmed down my reactivity a lot. However,
- 22:42I seem to have gathered other friends with trauma. It's like we get
- 22:47each other. I really struggle to connect with what seems to be healthy,
- 22:52mainstream people. I hear you, Like Rebecca, I also make fast comments
- 22:57about details I see in my surroundings. Do you know what she's referring to
- 23:02you? But yeah, that you just kind of call it like it is.
- 23:06Yeah, okay, fast comments about the details. It's like my friends
- 23:10get those. I'm often told I'm hilarious, but it seems I'm perceived as
- 23:15odd and too much by most people. I get it. Rebecca mentioned something
- 23:19similar from school auctions. Yes, I would love for you to dig deeper
- 23:23on this. I too have a narcissistic and exploiting mom who would choose all
- 23:29these men over us kids. I moved out as a sixteen year old.
- 23:33I have difficulty asking for help. Being assertive is also hard. Rebecca and
- 23:37I seem to have a lot in common, but I can tell that she
- 23:41has come much further in her healing, or at least in her analysis.
- 23:45Would love to hear would love to hear more about friendships and social relationships from
- 23:51Rebecca. Yeah, I mean, I totally hear you, anonymous patron in
- 23:55norway that you know. I think if you have been through a lot,
- 24:00you play less with the social norms. You play less in kind of regular
- 24:06social constructs because you don't really care and they haven't really served you and they
- 24:11haven't benefited you in any way. So yeah, there is a way in
- 24:15which my comments people consider them off color or too loud or inappropriate. And
- 24:22it's because I'm just not kind of playing I'm really bad at playing nice.
- 24:27It's not worth my time, which means that like you put me at the
- 24:32school auction, and it's going to be trouble because everybody else is like so
- 24:37buttoned down, So just talking about the weather and Seattle sports teams. So
- 24:42I'll tell this example, this is really interesting. I might have told the
- 24:47story already. So it was school auction for Garfield High School in Seattle,
- 24:51in Washington, one of the most diverse school high schools we have go Bulldogs,
- 25:00and so it's this really diverse community and the music program, oh excellent.
- 25:06I think they win like Jazz at Lincoln Center, like every other year.
- 25:11They have a fantastic drum line. It used to be when I was
- 25:15really sad, I would track down videos of their drum line. Mackailmore went
- 25:19there, Yeah, really fantastic place. Produces a lot of really amazing kids.
- 25:26I was lucky enough to get to hang out with a bunch of those
- 25:27amazing kids. So so I'm so I'm at the school auction, and I'm
- 25:33kind of expecting that it was just odd. I thought the auctioneer would reflect
- 25:38that community. But no, he's like the most heterosexual guy and saying things
- 25:47like, you know which lucky husband is gonna buy this next? I am
- 25:52for their lucky wife. Oh my god. It's like half the kids in
- 25:56the room are queer, half the parents are que well, even if not,
- 26:00like what the fuck? Yeah? And so who was it? Do
- 26:06you know who? I don't know that it wasn't a famous person. No,
- 26:08no, no, because sometimes John Curly do you know? Oh lord,
- 26:12no, wasn't John Curly because you know he does those things. So
- 26:17I when I left, I left them with a list of like, Hi,
- 26:19this auctioneer was inappropriate for this community. If you want people like me
- 26:22to come back next year, do not have this person as an auctioneer.
- 26:26Here are several appropriate auctioneers for this community. But it was really interesting.
- 26:33I was at the table and like people were getting nervous, and somebody looked
- 26:37at me, like are you going to say something? And I said to
- 26:41them, oh, honey, I don't come to these events to see myself
- 26:45reflected, And like the whole table just kind of went silent because I fucking
- 26:49called it out right. But it was like so Seattle, like people kind
- 26:56of want to acknowledge that's inappropriate, but they like don't want to hear you
- 26:59go off right. And you know, I know, because of my trauma
- 27:03background, if something needs to be said, I'm just going to say it,
- 27:07and not everybody's comfortable with that. Yeah, So is it true that
- 27:14you are further along in your healing? Like how did you get there?
- 27:18Probably know? But you know, I think we've talked about this. I
- 27:22think I added it up for my trauma podcast with you. I think I've
- 27:25spent over one hundred thousand dollars on therapy in my lifetime over thirty years.
- 27:30I mean, is that therapy involved for you? Oh my god, I've
- 27:33done everything. I've done a couple of rounds of NDR And what sort of
- 27:37transformations do you have to go through? Breathing? I had to learn how
- 27:45to breathe. I had to learn how to self regulate and co regulate with
- 27:49another person. I had to learn how to trust my gut and trust when
- 27:56a situation was wrong instead of downplaying it yeah or being like, oh,
- 28:00it'll just get better, that that person will get over their co condiction.
- 28:07I had to learn when situations were just too dangerous and I needed to leave.
- 28:11I had to learn to head towards the light head, towards people who
- 28:15were good to me. God, there's so many things I had to learn.
- 28:22I had to learn that I was worthy of love. How did you
- 28:25do that? I mean, gosh, so many therapy sessions for me in
- 28:32my therapist. So just try to get me to get present in the room
- 28:34so that meant, like, you know, feel the chair, breathing,
- 28:37tell the piece of my story, tolerated, be witnessed that my story is
- 28:41really messed up, knowing that my story doesn't define me, you know.
- 28:48I mean, there's just countless small steps. And I know people often like
- 28:52compare each other. So I don't know how old you are, but I'm
- 28:56fifty two. So you know, at different times in the spiral, you
- 29:03learn different lessons. Having a kid, I learned all those lessons again brutally.
- 29:11Nothing pushes your drama buttons like having a kid. It sounds like you
- 29:15had to learn that you matter. Yeah, my opinion matters, even though
- 29:22intellectually you would know that twenty five years ago, but you didn't feel it
- 29:27necessarily or that I got to not only did it matter, but I got
- 29:32to act on my opinion. You could take up space. Yeah, it's
- 29:34okay to be you. Yeah, you're not going to be and there's going
- 29:38to be people who really enjoy me too. I mean, i'd say,
- 29:42you know, when you have a narcissistic mother, you just assume all the
- 29:48time that you've got it wrong or you're going to be rejected, And over
- 29:53time you meet people who don't reject you and enjoy you and are like,
- 29:59hey, do more that that was freaking hysterical or I really learned something from
- 30:03you. I mean, that was one of the really interesting things. So
- 30:08Chips Memorial had an open mic at the end and I was the last person
- 30:12to speak, and I was coming off the stage and Rebecca M. Davis,
- 30:18who's a very famous MC actress in Seattle. You've probably seen her in
- 30:22productions, she grabbed my hand as I was coming off the stage to thank
- 30:27me. It was just like this really simple, poignant moment. I was
- 30:33like, oh, I just took up space and it spoke to one of
- 30:38my favorite performers. It spoke to her in her heart, you know like
- 30:42that. I think when you've been through a lot of trauma, you can
- 30:45kind of miss those moments. I describe it to my clients as shivasana.
- 30:51So in yoga, after you've done all the crazy stretches, you're supposed to
- 30:53lie down for ten minutes and let it all kind of resettle in your body.
- 30:59And I think when you're a traumas of whatever, you're like, you
- 31:02know, oh I felt something, and keep going and maybe you know,
- 31:04you know, you can really rush through life and so slowing way down,
- 31:10Like, how long do I need to integrate that? Yeah, I need
- 31:12some more time for myself. I need to eat more good food. I
- 31:17need to eat more chocolate, I need to eat more bad food. You
- 31:19know. But like just finding your own rhythm, it's really a thing.
- 31:26Yeah, well that is glorious that you went on that, that journey.
- 31:33I mean, yeah, obviously there's a lot of details to that, but
- 31:38I'm guessing inspirational to people. Well, and no patron that there are a
- 31:47lot of dark days, you know, it's not it's not a kind of
- 31:49an uphill. It's definitely like the spiral analogy. Better. There's gonna be
- 31:56times where you're able to integrate. There's gonna be times where you get even
- 31:59mores and you're thinking maybe you're worse off. And then there's going to be
- 32:04a moment where you're like, oh, I got something here, and I
- 32:07really see it in the people around me, just the people that are in
- 32:14my life. I'm like, look at that person, They're freaking amazing,
- 32:17you know. I mean it just or I see it at my own kid,
- 32:20Like look at my healthy teen successfully working and going to school and having
- 32:28friends and yeah, tiving hobbies. So yeah, sometimes if you can't see
- 32:34the markers in yourself, it's a beautiful marker that you've got friends to laugh
- 32:37at your jokes. I mean, if someone doesn't laugh at my jokes,
- 32:39I literally can't spend time with them. So the fact that you've found people
- 32:44that get your sense of humor, you know, not everybody's gonna think you're
- 32:46funny. Not everybody's that smart. Yeah. I feel like I remember you
- 32:52saying to me that someone or you'd heard before that you were too much for
- 32:58them, and I remember immediately just singing, huh, like, that's not
- 33:02my experience of you at all. I have another friend that is told that
- 33:07that's his insecurity. He'll say, yeah, you know, I get told
- 33:12that I'm too much for them, And I'm constantly worried that I'm going to
- 33:16be too much for people. But I have a hard time not being me
- 33:22or something. And I don't know, I can't really figure out what it
- 33:27is that other people are reacting to you and for you. I wonder if
- 33:30it's just that they equate being real and authentic and honest and having the normal
- 33:37ups and downs of one's emotional life and reactivity that they interpret it as a
- 33:44threat or that they have to fix it, or that you're going to turn
- 33:49on them. You know, I think this isn't how I see it,
- 33:52but I think a lot of people will have this heuristic. If you have
- 33:55someone that's always polite and always nice and never assertive, you will generalize that.
- 34:00I think there's this tendency to generalize that towards I'm always safe with that
- 34:05person, but that's not what I experience. What I experience is that person
- 34:08is a bottled up night beare right, I don't want to know that person
- 34:14because late at night, you know, it's like gremlins. Like you put
- 34:17water on that person after midnight, it's gonna get messy. I mean,
- 34:22not necessarily, but at the very least if someone I want to see variety
- 34:27in the people I know, well, it is trust inducing in that,
- 34:31Like with you, I know that you'll say things. You will say what's
- 34:36on your mind, and so I know that you're not hiding anything. And
- 34:39if there is something that you want to get off your chest, even if
- 34:44it's directed at me, you'll say it, and that makes me feel more
- 34:49safe. You know, life has moments of annoyance with the people that you
- 34:55love or you want to ask them for something. And if you're not getting
- 35:00annoyed, if you're close relationships, aren't getting annoyed with you sometimes or they
- 35:06aren't expressing annoyance with you sometimes the one you don't have close enough relationships,
- 35:10or two you have people in your life who are hiding things from you,
- 35:15and that just doesn't lend itself to happiness and security and closeness. You know
- 35:20that, you know, we evolved to get annoyed. It's it's there for
- 35:22a reason. In the caveman days, when there would be someone that would
- 35:27be sleeping with their cold feet pressed up against your back, you get annoyed
- 35:31with it and it interferes with your sleep, and so we evolved to go,
- 35:37mom, you know, Sarah has her Sarah what would be a name
- 35:43of a Yeah, has her cold feet against my bag? Again? Yeah,
- 35:47it's it's it's normal and it should be happening all the time. And
- 35:51to be constantly polite and fake, I just I don't want to. I
- 35:54don't want to be around that. Yeah. More crankiness everyone, it's healthy.
- 35:59Yeah, yeah, um, another question and then we'll get to a
- 36:06topic you want you wanted to talk about today, But before that I can't
- 36:08remember long time patron Simone. She says, when seeking therapy, is it
- 36:15acceptable to ask a practitioner what their views are on moral topics such as vaccines?
- 36:21Just chiming in here, vaccines is not a moral topic, it's a
- 36:24scientific one. This this confusion between morality and science and ethics, I find
- 36:34and I know that there's many different definitions of moral. But people will say,
- 36:37like, I'm against gay marriage because it's a it's a moral, and
- 36:40I'm like, that's not a moral. That's a bigoted notion from I guess
- 36:45you're the pulpit that you're, the church that you go to. That's not
- 36:50morality. It's immoral that you're anti gay marriage. That's immoral. You know,
- 36:57on on a fundamental level, it is wrong, it's harmful, It
- 37:01is not your place. It is a completely made up, weird idea that
- 37:06you get from God knows where. That is a moral. So being against
- 37:10vaccines is being against the data. It's like walking outside when the sun is
- 37:16shining and saying the sun isn't shining. Are there problems with the vaccines?
- 37:21Yeah? But on average, and especially when you talk about large populations,
- 37:25you talk to any anyone who understands anything about biology. You talk to any
- 37:30competent physician, any scientists, they will say it's a better idea if everyone
- 37:34gets vaccinated, unless there's a serious reason as to why they can't, a
- 37:37legitimate reason anyway, So some a moral topic, but that's not what simone
- 37:42is just. Yeah, I was doing remote therapy through an online app.
- 37:47Recently it became clear that my therapist might be an any vaccine stance, might
- 37:53take an anti vaccine stance. It didn't affect our work directly since we weren't
- 37:59since we were working remotely, you know, meaning that if the therapist wasn't
- 38:02vaccinated in that kind. But it really disturbed me that she was anti vaccine.
- 38:07I have extremely strong opinions about this, and some of my relational problems
- 38:12have to deal with politics and vaccines dividing my family. It made me not
- 38:16want to work with the therapist anymore. I am so repulsed by this.
- 38:20Is it okay or ethical to make sure that potential new therapists share my view
- 38:24on vaccines? Rebecca, what do you think? Yeah? I mean,
- 38:29I think there are going to be issues these days that you probably want to
- 38:35be on the same page with. With your therapist. I know a lot
- 38:38of my colleagues are very clear on their websites about where they are in that
- 38:45they'll only see vaccinated people. And there's probably the other side as well.
- 38:52I mean, you know, people come to me because they know I'm pro
- 38:59gay, I'm pro abortion, they know I'm pro poly, they know I'm
- 39:05pro they know I'm a raging feminist, they know I'm Jewish. You know.
- 39:09Like, so we are in a time you know, it used to
- 39:14be like therapist, blank slate, you wouldn't know anything about your therapist.
- 39:19But I think the times that we're in are really different. So if you
- 39:22had a therapist for yourself who had some opposing points of view that didn't relate
- 39:29to the therapy, but somehow you just heard or you saw on their Instagram
- 39:32or something, what would you do? And so you like the therapist?
- 39:37Right, Yeah, I mean I might have to have a conversation. I
- 39:39mean the theme here is am I safe with you? And so, you
- 39:45know, I think that's something especially at this day and age, we're constantly
- 39:49asking each other, like, you know, can we co regulate together?
- 39:53I'm trying to think if I ever have had a client, I mean a
- 39:57therapist that said something to me that made me question so hard. Yeah,
- 40:02we've never known as much as we know about each other as we do now,
- 40:07right, so that I think we're kind of in a new time with
- 40:09that. I mean, for you and me in Seattle, we can pretty
- 40:15much know that there's a really good chance that our therapists share our point of
- 40:20view about a lot of things. Yeah, because we are such a you
- 40:22know, not extremely but kind of a micro monoculture when it comes to certain
- 40:29ideas. You know, my neighborhood, for example, and the surrounding neighborhoods
- 40:34I don't see. If I didn't if I wasn't online or watching the news,
- 40:38I wouldn't know that existed, or yeah, Trump or Republicans existed,
- 40:44or anti gay people, you know, I wouldn't know that those people were
- 40:47alive. But you know, you step outside of Seattle, you go up
- 40:52to Lynnwood, or you go to Bellevue, or you know for other places.
- 40:58I mean, Bellevue is pretty liberal too, obviously. But for me,
- 41:00the only analogy I can think of our actual situation is when I had
- 41:05a client who saw in my disclosure that I was pro LGBTQ, and he
- 41:09coded that as I'm liberal, and which he was correct, and he was
- 41:15Republican and worked in finance, and what's conservative And he in the first or
- 41:22second session asked me, so I see in the disclosure that this and this
- 41:29is that going to be a problem and so, and it wasn't for me.
- 41:31I could see how it might be for some therapists. And of course
- 41:34you should disclose that in your disclosure and screen people out. It is a
- 41:38questionable practice if you're discriminating against people. But we could talk about that at
- 41:44another time. But if you're okay with it, and I was, I
- 41:47with a client who is conservative, even a client who voted for Trump and
- 41:52wears a Maga hat, like, I see people beyond those beliefs. I
- 41:59see the core of the human being. And I have enough love to give
- 42:02those people as well. And if they come to therapy and good faith,
- 42:07even if they're talking about half the session how much they love Trump, I
- 42:12just don't. I just don't think of people like that. It's just content.
- 42:16Yeah, right Like now, if I'm sitting on the bus next to
- 42:20someone as their rant, that's a different situation. But with a client,
- 42:23it's almost always the case that my clients will have some point of view or
- 42:29some value or some lifestyle that at the very least I can't identify with,
- 42:32and maybe even think in my personal life that would be a problem for me
- 42:37if we were friends or if we were a family member. But the philosophy
- 42:44or the place or the sacredness of therapy is so beyond that kind of detail
- 42:51to me. So if, for example, simone, your therapist being anti
- 42:57vaccine is also roller to us, and that they the therapist would see beyond
- 43:04that and would not create an unsafe environment for you, then I would say,
- 43:08you know, consider that. And I think that I get it that
- 43:13given the landscape and given just how contentious things are when you're in come.
- 43:19I mean, like for me, it's just so weird. Like with a
- 43:21maga person, it's just so weird for me to even see them. I
- 43:24don't even know if I've ever seen a maga hat in real life. I
- 43:28think I've only seen it on television, and ninety nine percent of the time
- 43:31it's on Donald Trump's head. But I'm pretty sure there are millions of them
- 43:37all over the place and other communities, you know, And if I ran
- 43:40into someone like that in my personal life, Like, I imagine I would
- 43:45have a fair amount of rage and it would be really hard for me to
- 43:51restrain. You know, if I was at a family get together and one
- 43:54of my family members was wearing a Maga hat, like, I don't know,
- 43:58if I wouldn't leave, I might just be I can't fuck that.
- 44:00I can't, I just can't. I'm out. I got better things to
- 44:04do than to sit here, And I just want to knock that hat off
- 44:07that person. But so if you if you saw a picture of your therapist
- 44:13in a Mega hat, could you continue to be their clients? Right?
- 44:16That be a safe environment for you? If I really like them, then
- 44:22yeah, yeah, I It's deeper than that, and I and that's why
- 44:27I'm I guess that's my point is I worry for our society that we label
- 44:30people as it encapsulates the other, as encapsulates their entire personality. And I
- 44:37think it is the dehumanization. It's a basically it's basically a dehumanization subset.
- 44:43You will see a Maga hat and dehumanize them or reduce them to that one
- 44:47thing instead of really noting of all the similarities. In fact, I have
- 44:53this philosophy and the science demonstrates this as well, but I actually get a
- 44:58lot of emotional stat faction by reading research and also following YouTubers and other commentators
- 45:05who actually will point out the similarities between a progressive liberal and a MAGA person.
- 45:12There are so many things that they agree on and the differences are notable,
- 45:17but they are the things that are only talked about. We share so
- 45:22much in common with our fellow Americans, regardless of their political leanings, and
- 45:27I feel like, at the very least that should be discussed at times,
- 45:30because I feel like if we only talk about the differences, then we get
- 45:35what we get, which is what we got, and it's getting not pretty.
- 45:37It's getting worse. It's getting worse and worse and worse. Yeah,
- 45:40this got is getting more gotten. And I guess if I were to really
- 45:45follow that philosophy fully, then if I had a family member with a MAGA
- 45:50hat, then I should shut the fuck up and just hug yeah, yeah,
- 45:55yeah, yeah. I mean there is a you know, I think
- 45:59there's what you kind of want from your therapist, and then there's what you
- 46:06can get. Are you going to agree and absolutely everything? Probably not?
- 46:10Are there lines in the sand for you? Then stay true to that.
- 46:15I could not see someone who was anti drag. So let's just give that
- 46:22as an example. Since it's like, so I can not see a therapist,
- 46:24yes, could you see a client, yes, But for someone to
- 46:29hold my emotional space, I would need them to appreciate and endure and feel
- 46:35comfortable in the world that I feel comfortable with. Do you, Mike,
- 46:39do I agree with all of my clients? No, but I am holding
- 46:44the frame of therapy for them. What if the therapist was anti drag but
- 46:49in therapy as you're talking about drag or drag related topics, they embody in
- 46:58their soul have no will or I don't have any see if sniff it out?
- 47:05Yeah, yeah, I mean there's a gut thing here. And I
- 47:07think I know, you know, when like someone does not get the world
- 47:12that you're talking about at all. But also like I know, therapists are
- 47:15really hard to find right now, Like are you going to find kind of
- 47:19your absolute perfect therapist right now? Maybe not? Yeah, yeah, And
- 47:25I just think that we should all do our best. But also I think,
- 47:31given especially like the Twitter culture, that we should be cautious about this.
- 47:40There needs to be a word for it. This like one view rejection
- 47:45of someone I don't know, Like, so I would think of it as
- 47:49a single issue voter. Okay, yeah, so single issue rejection. Single
- 47:54yeah, rejecting someone on the basis of a single issue, reducing someone to
- 47:59a single issue, making assumptions about someone based on a single issue, right,
- 48:04Because it's possible that, for simone, if you have someone that's if
- 48:08you have a therapist anti vaccine, you might also think they're they have all
- 48:13sorts of views that are not of your views. Also, there might be
- 48:17this assumption that they're like you're saying they're not safe. There are some craze
- 48:22lunatic that it will try to gaslight you into believing that vaccines are bad or
- 48:28I don't know, it could be. You know, it's not out of
- 48:30the realm of possibility, but it's not necessarily true. So anyway, it's
- 48:36take a break and we get back. Let's talk about force forgiveness, which
- 48:40is what you're so Rebecca, you texted me randomly a week ago ish and
- 48:50said, let's talk about forced forgiveness, and I thought, huh, that
- 48:52sounds like an interesting topic. What's the background for this idea? So I
- 48:58this has just always kind of been out there for me, this idea of
- 49:00a forgiveness practice and that you had to forgive your abuser or the person that
- 49:05wronged you for your healing. We've talked about this in the past about my
- 49:09own experience, but I just thought it was really interesting that was back in
- 49:15the news again, like, do you is forgiveness kind of necessary? And
- 49:20what's the culture that produces this idea that you have to forgive? What is
- 49:25that about? Well? I did a whole deep dive on apologies and as
- 49:34a part of that, I felt compelled to also do a mini deep dive
- 49:37on forgiveness. And it's complicated because what do we mean by forgiveness. For
- 49:44a lot of people, they mean forgiveness. So I have a list of
- 49:47things that, at least for me, and my definition forgiveness is not the
- 49:52following things. Forgiveness is not forgetting necessarily, because for example, if you
- 50:01forgave your abuser, would that mean you just forgot it. Also, forgiving
- 50:07is not forgiving someone for harming someone else, Like you can't forgive someone for
- 50:15abusing someone else because that only they can forgive that person. Also, it's
- 50:21not excusing the person. It's not pardoning the person. It's not necessarily letting
- 50:25go. It's not condoning, it's not minimizing. It's not necessarily a reconciliation.
- 50:30You can forgive someone and say, yeah, but I don't ever want
- 50:34to see you again. You know, I forgive you, but I don't.
- 50:37I'm drawing a boundary. Also, forgive. Forgiveness is not suppressing your
- 50:43anger. You can have anger after forgiveness. It's also not a social there's
- 50:49also not a social obligation for forgiveness. It's not there's also not a morality,
- 50:53you know, because that's one thing that I talked a lot about,
- 50:57because you know, Christians have to forgive. Well so toxic toxic forgiving.
- 51:04It's a there's debate forget. Is this what we're talking about? Well know
- 51:09the there if you talk to some Christians, they will in my view,
- 51:15they will simplify the human experience and also perhaps what God is trying to tell
- 51:23you that they will simplify it to you need to rush to forgiveness. It's
- 51:29a sin not to forgive. But there's philosophy within Christian you know, the
- 51:34Christian dialectic that that is not what the Bible, that's not what God tells
- 51:39you to do that, definitely, that's the Jewish God. Jewish God is
- 51:43not forgiving. So yeah, and that but and that's the whole. That's
- 51:49one of the main differences that that Christians will delineate from other religions is that
- 51:55Jesus forgave, you know, you turned the other cheek of eye for an
- 52:00eye, that kind of thing. And it's an important exploration. But but
- 52:09many, many people in the Christian culture, whether they identify as Christians or
- 52:15not. But if you're an American culture, you live in a dominant Christian
- 52:20culture, you will have this notion that somehow you're being wrong, or you're
- 52:27being a bad person, or you're holding on to anger, or you're being
- 52:30purposely vindictive if you're not forgiving. And that is just a ridiculous notion.
- 52:35Forgiveness is a it's a process. It's a voluntary process. You're under no
- 52:40obligation to forgive. You can choose to never forgive the rest of your life.
- 52:45And there's no necessarily a problem with that, obviously, But also we
- 52:51have to define what forgiveness means to begin with. Well, and I'm really
- 52:54you know, I'm kind of really struck by the kind of Gwyneth pell Trow
- 53:00goop, Like you know, I'm just open, I'm just feeling good.
- 53:05I'm just the best meat. And that idea that that best meat doesn't hold
- 53:08like the complexity of that person's life. That makes sense. Like sometimes I
- 53:14feel like forgiveness really wipes away how deeply impactful something has been on somebody.
- 53:22So are you saying, like the Gwyneth Peltro type people will deny their own
- 53:28trauma and anger and act like everything's fine. It's from what I've seen and
- 53:32what's targeted. Like I am the Gwyneth Peltro I'm one of the targeted demographics
- 53:37for my age, and so I get a lot of that stuff of like
- 53:40just feel good, just you know, open your yoni to the stone and
- 53:45everything will be better, really open to the stone. Yes, she had
- 53:50these stones that she sold that were like supposed to make everything better that they
- 53:54had to take off the market because it was false advertise. The more I
- 53:58hear about Gwyneth Paltrow and her product, the more I think she has a
- 54:00fetish about forcing things up people She may and Gwyneth, if you'd like to
- 54:07write in so that we can talk about this we'd be happy to talk about
- 54:09it with you. So let me take this. She doesn't want to talk
- 54:13with me, because would I would lay out the little I know of the
- 54:16pseudoscientific claims and the harmful claims that she has propagated. I don't think she
- 54:22wants to talk to me, So let me just spin it the other way.
- 54:25Because I had a kind of a profound experience, there was reason for
- 54:30me to reach out to world famous trauma trainer doctor Janina Fisher, and I
- 54:35had a question for her about working with clients that were hopeless and she always
- 54:42does. She wrote right back, and she said she said that she tells
- 54:47clients that hopelessness is a body memory of how hopeless they felt at the time
- 54:57of the trauma occurring. And when I think about, like, you know,
- 55:00just forgive, just kind of move on, give that person back love,
- 55:07that doesn't reflect how profoundly we've been damaged in the moment by these situations.
- 55:15And although hopelessness can be kind of awful, I see in my clients
- 55:22more activation and more healing if we can sit with the hopelessness for a while,
- 55:29as oppose if we have to rush right over it to forgiveness. Not
- 55:31that like forgiveness isn't out there, but just like, let's not miss the
- 55:37growth that can happen from sitting with uncomfortable feelings. Yeah, and I had
- 55:45to think, think a long time about what forgiveness exactly is, and I
- 55:50kept changing. In fact, as I was doing the deep dive, I
- 55:52even started changing the definition even further. And there's a lot of definitions of
- 55:55it. But here's the definition that I landed on, which it's long.
- 56:00It's longer than the definition for apology. So forgiveness is an intentional process,
- 56:06so you're doing it intentionally that eventually results. Eventually results because a lot of
- 56:12people will be like, okay, I just forgive or can't you just forgive
- 56:14me? And it's like, well, I can start to go on an
- 56:17intentional process that will eventually result at a decision. You know, you're eventually
- 56:24deciding to end one's negative attitudes and feelings towards the transgressor. So it doesn't
- 56:30mean that you don't have anger at times. It doesn't mean that you don't
- 56:35judge that person for having harmed you. It doesn't you know, you might
- 56:37have all those feelings still, but generally speaking, and it's you know,
- 56:42where's the line between ending your negative attitudes and feelings versus occasionally also hating that
- 56:50that person harmed you. You know, it's a it's a squishy area.
- 56:54And also to contrast it with acceptance of an apology, So you can accept
- 57:00someone's apology, like I accept your apology, but you don't necessarily forgive them.
- 57:04You're like, I accept that what you accept your apology is mostly sufficient,
- 57:10and I appreciate that you apologized. You can say that without forgiving.
- 57:16You can also forgive without ever getting an apology, depending right, So it's
- 57:21an intentional process that eventually results in a decision to end one's negative like in
- 57:28the stark example of having been sexually abused as a child, and you end
- 57:32up going on an intentional process that eventually results in a decision to end your
- 57:37negative attitude, soars that person. At that point, when you reach that
- 57:42point of forgiveness, are you still have anger? You still remember, you're
- 57:46still traumatized, You're still damaged, You're still angry, you still judge,
- 57:53and you one way of looking at it is you don't in your mind and
- 58:00have an overall negative association with that person. You might have some compassion for
- 58:07them that you might understand them. Whether you interact with them or not is
- 58:10irrelevant, but say if you did, you might be able to actually have
- 58:15an interaction with them. You don't forget, you might have upwellings of trauma,
- 58:21you might have links of anger, but you have crossed over a threshold
- 58:25that I think most of us know what that feels like when like with you
- 58:30know, I think a real common example is in a long term relationship,
- 58:36there's a lot of constant transgressions and forgiveness, whether there's apologies or not,
- 58:42and there's that point where you're in the cycle of conflicts, say three days
- 58:47after ups and downs, you eventually just crossed the threshold where you know.
- 58:53For me, with my wife, I can feel that threshold being crossed where
- 58:59I feel like I can be relaxed and normal around her as opposed to uptight
- 59:07and angry and hurt. It doesn't mean I forget what happened. Does it
- 59:12mean that I'm not still kind of pissed about it a little bit, But
- 59:15there's a there's a feeling as a vibe of crossing that threshold, and I
- 59:21think it's important to recognize that because it's a it's an emotional process, an
- 59:28intentional emotional process that you go on, and for some people, you might
- 59:30go on that intentional emotional process for fifteen years and never crossed that threshold because
- 59:36you got a lot of shit to work out, so that that forgiveness takes
- 59:39a long time. You know, a lot of it has to do with
- 59:42healing. A lot of it might depend on an apology, on someone making
- 59:46up for it. It might not, but a lot of it might depend
- 59:51on having the damage of the transgression healed from a variety of ways. So
- 1:00:00you know it's complicated. So what brought up this idea of being forced to
- 1:00:06forgive for you? Well, I mean definitely with the passing of my mom
- 1:00:09in those days right before, so many of her friends were like, you
- 1:00:15have to forgive her right now, and I was like, really, So
- 1:00:17what do you think they're coming from? What are they operating from? I
- 1:00:21have thought about this a lot. I think that they needed to feel like
- 1:00:27my mother was a really good person, and the idea that her own daughter
- 1:00:34was very angry at her was hard for them to hold and made them uncomfortable.
- 1:00:38That the idea that Rosella had been such a bad mom that her daughter
- 1:00:44would not forgive her in her final moments. I mean that's like if you
- 1:00:46think and also I mean think about how forgiveness is portrayed in the movies,
- 1:00:51and like, you know, the idea that I wouldn't do it. Talk
- 1:00:54about our earlier question of like not I'm not complying to social norms, right,
- 1:01:00We're not having the story about the moment acially about something like that.
- 1:01:04Yeah, So the idea that this older person could say to me, Rebecca
- 1:01:09would be good and forgive your mom, and I could say no, no,
- 1:01:15why, why would I? How? And how? And then everything
- 1:01:20I discovered at the house when I was there, I was like, thank
- 1:01:23god I didn't forgive her. If you can imagine if I'd forgiven her,
- 1:01:25gone there cleaned up all that stuff that showed how complicit she was in my
- 1:01:30abuse. Yeah, yeah, it's a pattern. I think it's also a
- 1:01:36human bias, a preference that there's no messiness in the world, and thus
- 1:01:43if someone has a complicated feeling, you want to snuff it out as an
- 1:01:46outsider, which I just find to be so strange, Like what is it
- 1:01:50to these other people? I mean, they can have their relationship with her,
- 1:01:53and they can think she's a wonderful person. That's that they're entitled to
- 1:01:57that and they can recognize huh, I guess she wasn't great to her daughter
- 1:02:02that you know, those things can exist together. They're having cognitive dissonance.
- 1:02:07I'm not right, but they're very uncomfortable that Rosella will not be attended to
- 1:02:13by her daughter in the end. Right, you're not going to them and
- 1:02:15say you have to recognize that she was a bitch and until until you do,
- 1:02:19then, you know, I think another myth out there is that if
- 1:02:23you don't forgive, it will cause damage in you. Yeah, I mean
- 1:02:28so many. That's what the Rabbi said to me. It's like, if
- 1:02:30you don't do this now, you'll feel really sorry. And you know,
- 1:02:36I'm a pretty attuned person. I kind of did some soul searching and it
- 1:02:38was like, yeah, I don't I don't think that's true. Yeah.
- 1:02:43I don't think flying across the country to a state where I can't eat any
- 1:02:46of the food to attend to a woman that doesn't want me there. I
- 1:02:52don't think anything is going to get resolved in these next three days. Yeah,
- 1:02:58yeah, yeah. And it also just has to do with our general
- 1:03:02discounting of emotions in general. You know, there's also a myth out there
- 1:03:07that I don't feel like you and I might live in this world, but
- 1:03:10there are certain groups of people where you must unconditionally love and appreciate and respect
- 1:03:17your parents, regardless of what they do. And to not love your parents,
- 1:03:23to not forgive your parents, to talk ill of your parents is somehow
- 1:03:27like a sacrilegious thing, and it automatically means you're a bad person. It
- 1:03:32means you're a bad kid, You're you don't appreciate. And I just want
- 1:03:37to say, and I have said, of these people, well, you
- 1:03:39know, God bless you that you had parents that allowed you to have that
- 1:03:45attitude. I mean I did. My parents are wonderful and it would be
- 1:03:50a complete dick move if I were to be addict to them in any sort
- 1:03:53of a way. I mean, they had to deal with me as a
- 1:03:55thirteen year old christ say but I mean, no joke, But but that's
- 1:04:02my parents. So not everyone has parents like that, and to apply that
- 1:04:09rule to everyone is is I just don't understand why people have this obsession with
- 1:04:15controlling how other people feel and think, right, I mean, I think
- 1:04:18it's some of it is assuming that these social norms. It goes back to
- 1:04:23the non binary conversation that we were having at the beginning. They assume that
- 1:04:26these social norms are needed for our society to function, but it's actually not
- 1:04:31true. I can not love my mom and live a perfectly happy life.
- 1:04:39And I always say this to my clients, like, if it was possible
- 1:04:42to love her, I would, Yeah. Right, That's the thing that
- 1:04:45I always say as well, not always, but is that the road to
- 1:04:50cognitively and verbally rejecting blood's parents has so many barriers to it that for someone
- 1:04:57to finally get there, it means it. It's as they could. They
- 1:05:01should have been that. Most people who get to where you're at should have
- 1:05:05been their way earlier. But they kept holding on. They kept hoping,
- 1:05:10they kept trying, they kept pleading, they kept barking up that tree,
- 1:05:13they kept banging their head against the wall. I mean, I don't know
- 1:05:16anyone who just flippantly decides to conclude that their parents were harmful overall, and
- 1:05:24or that they hated their parents or something. There's so many internal pressures and
- 1:05:28maybe even some kind of biological mandate or something to try to make you want
- 1:05:33to be part of the tribe, right, Yeah, yeah, so when
- 1:05:35someone gets there. In fact, if anything is a society, we should
- 1:05:40be telling people the opposite of Like, you know, you might be in
- 1:05:43a category of individual where it'd be a lot healthier if you drew boundaries and
- 1:05:47concluded that your parents or parents are a negative overall element in your life and
- 1:05:56you're holding on way too long to false hope and a social expectation of you
- 1:06:02need to try to make it work because of this magical idea that they're your
- 1:06:06biological parents and somehow that obligates you. Way more people are in that category
- 1:06:13that needed that that should be allowed and maybe pushed towards hatred of their parents
- 1:06:18because of the resistance to that, you know. So the fact that you
- 1:06:23got there. Whenever I hear that from someone, I'm like, oh boy,
- 1:06:28you must have been through some serious shit. It's great. I mean,
- 1:06:30I think it's indoubtedly justified when when someone hates their parent, assume that
- 1:06:35it is a hundred percent justifies. Yeah. I mean I always say to
- 1:06:39people like, you know, in what way do I possibly benefit from being
- 1:06:44estranged from my mother? If you think about how much our culture tells us
- 1:06:48that I need a mother and I need family and family is the most important
- 1:06:53thing. And you know, imagine by the time I'm fifteen, I'm like,
- 1:06:58oh, my mother is toxic. I have to do what I can
- 1:07:03to stay away from her. And then nothing throughout my adult life dissuades me
- 1:07:09from that. Now Asterix to you parents out there who have kids who might
- 1:07:15exhibit that they hate you and you didn't deserve it. Seemingly, there are
- 1:07:21some kids, maybe even young adult kids who might say things like they hate
- 1:07:27you, but in the end, that's not the place that they land.
- 1:07:31You know, lots of kids will go through a lot of difficulties for one
- 1:07:34reason or another, and they might go through a phase of hating deeply deep.
- 1:07:39I've been there with families where there'd be a kid who, at least
- 1:07:44from the looks of it, there wasn't a justifiable reason as to why this
- 1:07:47kid was just so really bullying of one of their parents. And with help,
- 1:07:53and I would never tell the kid, you have to love your parents,
- 1:07:56and you can't do that. But with emotional help and communication and attachment
- 1:08:02and venting, a lot of the times, if not all the time,
- 1:08:06the kid would emerge out of that face. So it's not like every time
- 1:08:11a kid or an adult child hates their parents, it's not without its difficulty
- 1:08:16or that it's always quote unquote justified. So and that's why I'm using the
- 1:08:20word estranged versus hate, because there's also a piece of physical proximity. Like
- 1:08:27lots of kids say they hate their parents, but they still are in their
- 1:08:31orbit. And there's another story where it's not safe to be in their orbit.
- 1:08:38And like I have tons of friends whose teenagers are just being super toxic
- 1:08:43right now, but they also come home for visits or you know, there's
- 1:08:46like an attunement or an attempt to connect. That's really different than when you're
- 1:08:51truly a strange from someone and you just can't connect in any way. Right,
- 1:08:56Yeah, I think there's, Yeah, there's a difference between having some
- 1:08:59difficult these and concluding that overall this person a is not a good idea to
- 1:09:06have in my life, that kind of thing, you know. So I
- 1:09:09don't know, I guess that's complicated. But there when I hear the things
- 1:09:13that I hear from you, I'm just like, I don't need to hear
- 1:09:15any justification. People don't get to where you're at unless there's more than enough
- 1:09:20justification, you know. Anyway, all right, Okay, let's end it
- 1:09:27there. Okay, it's been fun. What's the final word, Rebecca.
- 1:09:30The final word is take care of yourself, because well, you should take
- 1:09:34care of yourself because it's the right thing to do to yourself. And going
- 1:09:41to therapy and eating right, getting good sleep, flossing, taking some time
- 1:09:45after yoga to just stare at the ceiling and soak it in is what you
- 1:09:49should be doing. And self love is glorious. When you love yourself,
- 1:09:57you're glorious to be around, and you are going to crazily attract other people
- 1:10:01who are glorious as well.