Latest / Politics with Paul / Is Potentialism the Key to American Civic Renewal? w/ Daniel Yudkin | Politics with Paul #79
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Another great guest is untapped for you today, and for such episodes, I always add a
- 0:12disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or against a guest's political views or groups
- 0:17they support, but our topics are always something that people across the political
- 0:21spectrum can get something out of.
- 0:23Our civic culture is in a precarious state and there isn't nearly enough healthy engagement
- 0:30with it.
- 0:31Some people are too scared or apathetic to engage with it meaningfully.
- 0:35Some people want to engage with it, but find it too difficult to do so.
- 0:39Some people engage with it in far too hostile and toxic a manner.
- 0:44And it's now more critical than ever to renew the civic health of America.
- 0:48But that's far easier said than done.
- 0:50So how do we revitalize our civics and get back to more healthily engaging with our political
- 0:57system?
- 0:58Well, my guest today, Daniel Yudkin, may have one of those solutions, a new civic vision
- 1:03called potentialism.
- 1:04Daniel is the director of the Beacon Project, a multi year initiative to identify a new civic
- 1:10vision for America's exhausted majority.
- 1:12The Beacon Project itself is part of the nonpartisan organization More in Common, a
- 1:17nonprofit seeking to understand and address social division.
- 1:21And Danielle's also a visiting scholar with the Wharton School of the University of
- 1:25Pennsylvania.
- 1:27And previously he was a postdoctoral researcher at Yale and earned a PhD in social psychology
- 1:32from New York University.
- 1:34Now, let's talk to Daniel and get his insights into what potentialism is and how it could lead
- 1:40to an American civic renewal.
- 1:42Please welcome Daniel Yudkin to the show.
- 1:45Daniel, thanks for coming on.
- 1:46How are you?
- 1:47I'm good, Paul.
- 1:48Thanks for having me.
- 1:50Hey, absolutely.
- 1:50Really appreciate you being on here.
- 1:52So I always like to go back in time with my guests to their why for what they do and their
- 1:58relation to the episode's topic.
- 2:00So why did you initially become involved in efforts toward civic renewal and political
- 2:05bridge building?
- 2:07My background is in social psychology.
- 2:09I've been studying and interested in human behavior for many, many years, most of my life,
- 2:14in fact.
- 2:14I'm always really interested in sort of what makes people tick, why they do what they do,
- 2:18why they believe what they believe.
- 2:19And so I spent many years in graduate school studying human behavior, human psychology, and
- 2:25and how people make decisions.
- 2:27And I got interested in morality during that time.
- 2:30So one particularly interesting area where people disagree in the way that they understand
- 2:35the world is in their moral decisions, their judgments about right and wrong, good and bad.
- 2:39And so it was through that that I started to become really interested in you know, through
- 2:43that lens of morality, obviously, like, our our political space is one of the places where
- 2:50moral disagreements get amplified, where they become extremely consequential, and where they
- 2:55have an enormous impact on our the trajectory of our country and the way that we live our
- 3:00lives.
- 3:01And so it was through this journey of number one, studying an interest in people, but then
- 3:06trying to dig below the surface and understand kind of how and what makes people disagree
- 3:10about these everyday moral topics, and then what implications those disagreements have for
- 3:15our society and our political sphere, that's how I kind of got interested in this type of
- 3:21stuff.
- 3:22Yeah.
- 3:22That is such a critical aspect.
- 3:24Right?
- 3:24We all have our own sets of morals, things that we believe in our basic set of values, and
- 3:31obviously, are important to have, but of course, we also see a lot of people go too far
- 3:37with it, with their moralized attitudes and so far where they think if they even budge from
- 3:43their point of view that they're being immoral.
- 3:45And obviously, that's one of the really key things to try to address there.
- 3:50But I I I think that's a very noble pursuit, and I I I can really appreciate and relate to
- 3:55that.
- 3:56But before we get to potentialism, I wanna touch a little bit more on the Beacon Project
- 4:02overall.
- 4:03So why was the Beacon Project founded and how did you get involved in it?
- 4:08And was potentialism part of it from the get go?
- 4:11Yeah.
- 4:11The Beacon Project so so I guess the the context here is more in common.
- 4:16So this is the organization that's been around for ten about ten years.
- 4:20And our mission as an organization is to leverage insights from social psychology to
- 4:26better understand and bridge social division.
- 4:30And so we put out a couple reports in 2017, 2018, 2019.
- 4:36One was called hidden tribes, which is an examination of the different of the of the
- 4:41political landscape that suggests that it's not just about us and them.
- 4:44It's not about red versus blue, liberal versus conservative, but actually there's seven
- 4:48different tribes in the American population that hold differing core beliefs, core values,
- 4:55motivations, and weighing ways of seeing the world.
- 4:57And and so this is the kind of our intellectual history.
- 5:02And then and also part of that is identifying this group that we call the exhausted majority.
- 5:07This makes up about two thirds of the American population.
- 5:10This is a group that doesn't really subscribe to the beliefs on either of the political
- 5:14extremes, but actually is much more interested in finding common ground and having more
- 5:19nuanced views.
- 5:20But they're also not as active in the political conversation because they're just not as likely
- 5:23to post on social media and to be involved in sort of political everyday political
- 5:27disagreements.
- 5:28And so building on this research, our work at More in Common has continued to try to kind of
- 5:33figure out how to better understand our political landscape and and how to use those
- 5:38insights to to help us little get a little bit more united and and and work through our
- 5:44divisions.
- 5:45What the Beacon Project is, is an effort to move past the kind of the diagnosis and trying
- 5:53to figure out what's going on now and offer some ideas or invitations or recommendations
- 5:59about where we ought to go from here, where we could go from here.
- 6:02And so what we're trying to do is instead of just saying here's what's wrong, we're trying
- 6:07to say, here's a direction that we could go.
- 6:09Here's a vision for the future that could help us move outside of the current kind of very
- 6:16binary dynamic that we're in, the left versus right dynamic that we're in in our political
- 6:22sphere and really kind of offer a new way of understanding what it means to be an American,
- 6:29what it means to be a person, what it means to be a citizen at this particular moment in time.
- 6:34That's fascinating.
- 6:35So more in common, this is probably oversimplified, but more in common is probably
- 6:40more of the here's the research that shows how we're divided, but the Beacon Project's more
- 6:46about the practical how do we actually solve that division then.
- 6:50Yeah.
- 6:50I mean, it's a little bit more there's a bit of both on both sides.
- 6:53Of course, at More in Common, we are focused on some solutions as well.
- 6:56And the Beacon Project is also involved in quite lot of research.
- 6:59So we are also trying to kind of like do some survey work and do focus groups, have
- 7:03conversations, interviews with Americans to try to figure out how they're feeling and what we
- 7:08can do to address their their basic concerns.
- 7:10But yes, the Beacon Project is really focused on kind of also just not the here and now kind
- 7:17of like the five years, ten years, twenty years from now, the longer time horizon.
- 7:22What kinds of changes do we need to make in our society and how can we reimagine what it means
- 7:29to, what our obligations are to each other, what are our rights and responsibilities as
- 7:33people in this moment, and that can re, how can we reimagine the answers to those questions in
- 7:39a way that kind of moves past the divisions that we're are so entrenched in right now.
- 7:47And unfortunately, that's something I don't think we focus on enough.
- 7:51Even in the greater depolarization space, sometimes we don't focus too enough on what is
- 7:59our responsibilities to each other.
- 8:00I mean, yes, obviously talking about how to come together more and to find more common
- 8:04ground, but then beyond this kind of goes a little bit further than that, I think, then
- 8:09sometimes the depolarization movement goes.
- 8:12So I can really appreciate that.
- 8:14A couple of the things that really stood out to me from earlier in that answer was, you know,
- 8:19the the seven tribes.
- 8:20I thought that was a really interesting division.
- 8:23I've seen different studies.
- 8:24I've kinda tried to do something similar.
- 8:26I remember back in I say, I wanna say it was, 2016, probably right around the twenty sixteen
- 8:30election when Pew Research Center had something similar where they they broke down the
- 8:36Republican and Democratic parties into four factions for lack of a better term.
- 8:40Yeah.
- 8:40So I always find that kind of thing fascinating.
- 8:43And then, of course, when you bring up how there's a huge portion of people who are part
- 8:48of this exhaustive majority, but a lot of times, they're not as active in politics, and
- 8:53that's what makes these polarized voices seem amplified and seem so much more numerous than
- 8:59they actually are.
- 9:00But for the now for the crux of this discussion, on the Beacon Project's website,
- 9:04potentialism is, to quote the website, it's grounded in a single maxim.
- 9:09Everyone has something to offer, a gift, and they write a responsibility to develop that
- 9:14gift and share it with others.
- 9:16So in your own words, can you expound further on what that means, including why it is both a
- 9:20right and a responsibility?
- 9:23Yeah.
- 9:23So to kind of back up a little bit, one thing that we noticed in our research at More in
- 9:29Common is a core tension in how people think about and navigate topics around rights and
- 9:38responsibilities.
- 9:39You know, on on one side, you have this is this is kind of broad brush strokes, typically what
- 9:46we, you know, what we among people on the left, there's a real emphasis on sort of like what
- 9:52are the minimum conditions for justice that could allow people to thrive?
- 9:55What are our what are our rights?
- 9:56What do we deserve from the state in order to be able to be able to live flourishing lives?
- 10:01On the right, you have a lot of discourse around personal responsibility.
- 10:06You gotta lift yourself up by our bootstraps and make the most of your life.
- 10:10And the reality is that most Americans don't see things in those kinds of black and white
- 10:16terms.
- 10:16They think of ourselves as meeting minimum conditions that we need to be able to thrive
- 10:21and that we should have a functional and responsive and efficient government that allows
- 10:25people these kind of minimum conditions.
- 10:27But there's also a degree to which individuals and and and people have an obligation both to
- 10:33themselves and to the people around them to make the most of those opportunities and to to
- 10:38kind of like pursue their own goals and and to to reflect on what it is they can do to both
- 10:47contribute in a local sense and then also contribute to the civic community that we have
- 10:52as as Americans.
- 10:53And so this fundamental insight that we arrived at kind of through our research at More in
- 10:59Common leads to the idea that if you're trying to craft a narrative that is that can transcend
- 11:07our current divisions, what you wanna be looking for is a way of blending these
- 11:11competing impulses that is not just sort of like, oh, let's meet in the middle.
- 11:16It's just like centrism, but offers a coherent vision and a clear understanding of what are
- 11:25the limits and what is the extent of those rights and responsibilities.
- 11:29So that was the kind of task we set ourselves when it came to developing this framework that
- 11:34we're calling potentialism.
- 11:36Now what potentialism does is it starts starts with a kind of a basic assumption or or or
- 11:43observation about human nature.
- 11:45And what that is that everybody has something everyone has something to offer.
- 11:48Everyone has something to contribute.
- 11:51And and so, you know, the the question then is, you know, if we assume that everyone has
- 11:56something to contribute, what kind of a society do we wanna try to build?
- 12:00And the first thing you might say is, well, what you want is a society in which everybody
- 12:04has the opportunity to to contribute, to develop themselves, and to develop that
- 12:08contribution.
- 12:09But that's not the whole story because if we have something of value that other people that
- 12:15can improve other people's lives, we don't just have a right to share that gift.
- 12:19We also have a responsibility to do so.
- 12:22And so this is the very simple idea at the core of potentialism, which is everybody has a gift.
- 12:29And what we want is a society in which everyone has the opportunity, a right to develop that
- 12:34gift, but we also recognize we have a culture of responsibility where we all individually
- 12:39recognize that part of our obligations as members of this society is to cultivate
- 12:46ourselves in such a way as to be able to share that gift and develop it and improve others'
- 12:51lives in the process.
- 12:52So this is the kind of the central, like, the crux of this framework and the and the kind of
- 12:59the invitation or the the question that we're we're we're exploring with this is, what would
- 13:07it look like to take this fairly simple idea, this fairly simple framework that everyone has
- 13:13something to contribute.
- 13:15And what would it look like to instantiate that as a genuine political philosophy?
- 13:20As something that actually grounds our understanding of what the basic social contract
- 13:30is in in America.
- 13:33And and that's the sort of that's the question.
- 13:35What you know, how how does it differ from other philosophies?
- 13:38Does it differ from from liberalism, from conservatism?
- 13:41What does it look like to to start with the this this core maxim of everyone has a right
- 13:46and responsibility to develop and share their gifts?
- 13:48So that's the kind of the initial impetus behind this behind this part.
- 13:53Something you said at the towards the beginning of the answer, I can really appreciate and
- 13:57something I think needs to be advertised for lack of a better term more often is to
- 14:02paraphrase what you said, it's not centrism for its own sake because I don't just just because
- 14:07you're center of the road, that doesn't necessarily mean that you're in the right
- 14:10either.
- 14:11Just doing it because it's centrism.
- 14:13You're still taking a position, and that's that's still gonna make people not want to come
- 14:18and understand what other people have to say.
- 14:20But I think that's such an important part to say how there's a right and a responsibility.
- 14:26You know, when you take rights versus more of a a left concern and responsibility is more of a
- 14:31right concern and blend those two together.
- 14:33It's there is a reasonable blending of those two like you like you mentioned.
- 14:38And also, you know, one of my big things is, you know, lack of political efficacy that we
- 14:45see today.
- 14:46And so I really would love to see how potentialism can really help improve that
- 14:52because it's you know, somebody might hear potentialism, of course, we'll get more into
- 14:56this question a little bit later on.
- 14:58But somebody might look at and say, potentialism, oh, that sounds like a little too
- 15:03flowery and philosophical.
- 15:05But no, you are talking about a very practical way of how do we get these gifts out of people
- 15:09and how do they each of them use this gift.
- 15:12If you can successfully convince people, hey, you all have a gift for how you can help
- 15:18positively impact civics in this country, that is inherently going to improve efficacy as
- 15:24well.
- 15:24So I'm I'm really intrigued to see how potential potentialism can really improve that.
- 15:29Yeah.
- 15:30Yeah.
- 15:30It is it is a it's it is an interesting just to respond to this idea.
- 15:34Right?
- 15:34The idea of a gift.
- 15:35And I think people are inherently there's an inherent suspicion at the idea that, you know,
- 15:40because, you know, in the past, the idea of a gift has been used to to, you know, argue, oh,
- 15:45everyone's gifted and everyone's special and everyone's a unique flower.
- 15:49Right?
- 15:50And of course, to conservative ears, they hear that and they often will sort of associate it
- 15:55with some of the the excesses of of of liberal education in which everybody's a winner,
- 16:03everyone gets a a gold star and a trophy, you know, that sort of thing.
- 16:06There's some cliches and stereotypes around that as a liberal you know, in terms of liberal
- 16:10education.
- 16:10Education.
- 16:11But and so and so, you know, it is important, but let but let's take it literally for a
- 16:15second.
- 16:15Right?
- 16:16Like, the idea that everybody has something to contribute.
- 16:19Right?
- 16:19What what would it mean to say the opposite of that?
- 16:21That's to say that some people have nothing to offer.
- 16:24That some people have absolutely nothing to offer society.
- 16:27And to me, the idea that when we form, with the nature of the social contract, a social
- 16:32contract is an agreement we make with each other, right?
- 16:34And it's an agreement for mutual benefit.
- 16:36And the implication when we're signing a social contract with each other is that there's some
- 16:41sort of mutual advantage that emerges from the fact that we are making an agreement with each
- 16:47other to live together in a society.
- 16:49And so inherent in the idea of signing a contract is the inherent agency and value of
- 16:56the person that you are engaged in that contract with.
- 16:58And so to me, there's something actually fundamental about the assumption that everybody
- 17:04has something to offer.
- 17:05Now does that mean that everyone's gonna be the next LeBron James or everyone's gonna be the
- 17:08next Elon Musk, the next billionaire?
- 17:10No.
- 17:10No.
- 17:11Doesn't mean that.
- 17:12What it means is that we start from the assumption that there is something of value
- 17:18that everyone has to contribute to society.
- 17:21And and we proceed with that as a as a founding as a founding assumption.
- 17:25And then we ask what it means to structure our society with that as the basic premise.
- 17:30And these these gifts can be small or large, you know, you can you can there's there's an
- 17:34enormous amount of value that that comes from being a caregiver or a teacher or or a parent
- 17:42or people who are serving vital roles in our society without which our society wouldn't be
- 17:47able to function.
- 17:48Those are gifts too.
- 17:49And so part of part of what potentialism also tries to do is to assert respect and dignity
- 18:01for the different ways that people have for for contributing.
- 18:06And to kind of remove the the current our current focus on things like influence and how
- 18:12many followers do you have and how much wealth and power do you have.
- 18:16And to get back to a place where we assert the fundamental dignity of every person.
- 18:22And as a function of that dignity, their right and obligation to contribute.
- 18:26So and so to that extent, just to go back to this point, I do agree that, like, there is an
- 18:32inherent suspicion with the notion of everyone having a gift.
- 18:36But actually, if you think about it and we take it literally and we get a wet rid of some of
- 18:40the stuff, the baggage that has been associated with, I think that almost everyone would agree
- 18:45that that it it is true.
- 18:47I think that's a really great clarification to make there and I would I would certainly agree
- 18:52with that, you know, because there is that, you know, when you're selling for lack of a better
- 18:57term, this vision, obviously, you have to account for any potential pushback.
- 19:03Like in this case, if somebody says, oh, it's too flowery.
- 19:05It's too, oh, we're talking about gifts.
- 19:07But you're not saying that everybody has the same exact gift or same level of gift, but they
- 19:12all can make some sort of contribution even if it's just something very small, like simply
- 19:16just sharing civic or educational resources, for example.
- 19:21Sure.
- 19:22Yeah.
- 19:23One one of the most current concerning issues of today is not just us distrusting each other
- 19:30as citizens, kinda like what we just sort of touched on now, but our distrust and antagonism
- 19:36toward political institutions, whether it's congress or US supreme court and whether you
- 19:43know, regardless of how much government institutions have done it to themselves, there
- 19:47is this level of distrust that is just it's just way too high.
- 19:52It's way it's going way overboard.
- 19:55But a lot of times, it's also based on our political views about who occupies these
- 20:00institutions as well.
- 20:02But for other people, it is a fundamental distrust regardless of who runs these
- 20:06institutions.
- 20:07So how does potentialism address and alleviate this problem?
- 20:12Yeah.
- 20:14Look, this is not a recent thing.
- 20:16The decline in trust in American institutions has been going on for the last fifty years and
- 20:22it is has a number of different factors.
- 20:24But what I would argue is probably the most important and salient factor is that people
- 20:29just don't feel like these institutions are working for them.
- 20:32They don't feel as though those institutions reflect their true concerns.
- 20:37They don't feel like there's any they that they are effective kind of representatives of
- 20:43people's own beliefs and values.
- 20:45And so I think the first thing that I would say to this is is to say, look, we have now found
- 20:52that the exhausted majority holds a variety of different views that they don't feel like are
- 20:59represented in the political system, in the political apparatus.
- 21:01And so no wonder they're disillusioned because they don't feel as though their beliefs have a
- 21:08have a voice in this conversation.
- 21:10And then, of course, there's procedural problems too.
- 21:12Right?
- 21:12There's gridlock.
- 21:13There's congress not being effective.
- 21:16There's the filibuster.
- 21:17All of these sort of technical elements as well, which are obviously critical.
- 21:21What we're focusing on with potentialism is like, okay.
- 21:25Can we at the very least start to develop a language that inspires and that offers a
- 21:31positive vision that feels fresher and different from what we have so far?
- 21:36And ultimately, the the the aspiration is, look, can we build from this set of principles
- 21:44a political can we give political force to this set of principles in such a way that those
- 21:50types of principles ultimately get instantiated in positions of power in the government?
- 21:56And if those positions of power in the government do end up reflecting this particular
- 22:01set of principles, and if it is the case that people actually embrace these principles, maybe
- 22:06that could be the first step towards having people re store trust in the government because
- 22:13they'll at least feel as though their views and their values are being reflected by the people
- 22:18who are representing them in in Washington DC.
- 22:21Yeah.
- 22:21That makes a lot of sense.
- 22:22It's it's sort of a more indirect way that potentialism could really help alleviate this
- 22:28distress, would I guess.
- 22:29I think that's right.
- 22:30I think you gotta look, you gotta pick your lane, know?
- 22:32Like, you know, potentialism is potentialism is a political philosophy.
- 22:36It is not a it is not a technocratic solution to a to a particular problem.
- 22:45It is not sort of like ranked choice voting.
- 22:46Great.
- 22:47Love ranked choice voting.
- 22:48Love those people.
- 22:49You know, some of the other you know, all these other sort of proposals to how to make our
- 22:52government more more representative, like fully support those.
- 22:55But potentialism is is parallel to those is trying to offer a new coherent framework of a
- 23:02philosophy that can allow us to make sense of some of the questions of what our rights and
- 23:08responsibilities are as members of a civic community in America at this point in time.
- 23:14Right, and I think that really goes, it's a nice segue into the next question, we also
- 23:18talked about it a couple of questions ago with practical versus the philosophical.
- 23:23And of course, you need both of those things when it comes to especially these ambitious
- 23:27initiatives, especially where American civics is concerned.
- 23:31So let's go a little bit more into the practical.
- 23:35What research backs up the potential of, well, potentialism, and how do you how ready do
- 23:41you think the public is right now for potentialism?
- 23:44So I mentioned some of this research about the kind of the the rights and responsibilities
- 23:48portion of this.
- 23:49So that that is a fundamental we've we've seen that to be a fundamental schism in in the
- 23:54American discourse.
- 23:55And so to the extent that potentialism is offering a more balanced approach to those to
- 24:01that kind of binary those binary concepts, I think that's one source of evidence that that
- 24:07it could resonate.
- 24:08But even more to the point, the Beacon Project conducted a large survey survey of the American
- 24:14population last year.
- 24:17We basically asked them.
- 24:18We're like, to what extent do you agree with this statement that that our country should be
- 24:22based on a deal of rights and responsibilities.
- 24:25We have a right to develop ourselves, to have education, dignity, opportunity, but we also
- 24:30have a responsibility to use those opportunities in service of improving our own
- 24:36lives and the lives of the people around us and our neighbors and and our country to give back.
- 24:40How do you feel about that?
- 24:43How would you feel about that deal?
- 24:44Does that reflect the way that you think about this?
- 24:46And we got we got so it was about four out of five Americans from all political points of
- 24:52view, left, right, and center, with almost no difference in levels of agreement across the
- 24:59political divide are in favor of this.
- 25:02So there's evidence that even at a sort of a at a conceptual level, there's there's support for
- 25:08this type of idea.
- 25:09Now you might say, well, yes, but like, know, when the rubber meets the road, are people
- 25:13gonna agree?
- 25:13And and maybe this is kind of just like a a pie in the sky abstract idea, but when it really
- 25:17gets down to it, you're gonna you know, that number's gonna drop.
- 25:20And then also you might say, well, what about that remaining 20%?
- 25:23Well, the remaining so so so let me respond to both.
- 25:26I don't even know if you're thinking of those questions, but I'm gonna answer them both.
- 25:29Go right ahead.
- 25:30So what about the 20%?
- 25:31Well well, potentialism is not intended as a totalizing universal philosophy.
- 25:38It's not meant for everybody to agree with.
- 25:40It's meant to offer a home for people who have a particular set of views about this notion of
- 25:48that everyone has has a gift and we have a right and responsibility to share it.
- 25:52So in that sense, it's in in the sort of the positive sense of the word, it's meant to offer
- 25:57represent a faction in the American population that's advocating for a particular type of
- 26:02social change.
- 26:03And, again, I mean faction in the sense of that, like, a flourishing democracy is
- 26:08comprised of people with different points of view that are that are jockeying and engaged in
- 26:13discourse and advocating for particular things in order to to kind of enact that social
- 26:18change.
- 26:18Now when it comes to, you know, would you lose, you know, would people would you have less
- 26:25agreement if if you got if you got more concrete?
- 26:27Certainly, would expect that as well.
- 26:29The point is not like a percent of Americans are potentialists, but it's more just to show
- 26:34that there is an inherent level to degree to which this set of ideas resonates and it is
- 26:40nonpartisan.
- 26:41And so that is initial evidence that that this kind of way of thinking has some purchase,
- 26:48could have some purchase on on people's vision for the future.
- 26:51Yeah.
- 26:52And you know, that that's a great point.
- 26:54I I really appreciate you, you know, taking that time to you know that, you some of the
- 26:58things that people are gonna say in response because we do, you know, not just in in this
- 27:02case, but in plenty of other situations where people say, you know, we support, you know,
- 27:08constitutional interpretation of something, for example, but then when it's somebody that they
- 27:13tend to support, then they're a little bit more lax on how much they support the constitution,
- 27:18that kind of thing.
- 27:19So that is a very good point to bring up.
- 27:23It is just about how you activate that feeling if people that idea of how ready they are for
- 27:29the potentialism.
- 27:30But, you know, you you you said it how not everybody's going to agree and it's not meant
- 27:35to have everybody agree this idea of potentialism because you're never gonna find
- 27:39any sort of statement that people are gonna a 100% agree on.
- 27:43If there is one, I'd love to hear what it is.
- 27:45You yeah.
- 27:46You you won't the 20% is probably never gonna agree.
- 27:49Maybe a few of them will break off, and they'll they'll see what potentialism does for
- 27:54everybody else, and maybe then they'll be convinced, but it is hard to convince those
- 27:58people.
- 27:58But it kind of also speaks to what you were talking about earlier.
- 28:02You know?
- 28:03Not everybody lots of people don't really think ideologically.
- 28:06You hear all these appeals about conservative and liberal, and that's more for people, you
- 28:14know, quote unquote elites who are in politics and then the most ardently partisan and
- 28:21ideological voters, but most people don't really think in those ideological terms, and
- 28:26even sometimes when they do, they have different concepts of what those ideologies
- 28:30even mean.
- 28:30So it kinda goes back to what you were saying with that.
- 28:34And so this is actually another great way to get into this next question because you were
- 28:40just talking about these potential counterarguments, because it's always
- 28:43beneficial to be prepared for any sort of counterarguments to whatever it is that you're
- 28:48proposing, especially from the most polarized people in this case.
- 28:51And so one particular one that I wanna try to get your take on various arguments you hear
- 28:59about depolarization in general or that it's impractical, it's too flowery and touchy feely,
- 29:05woo woo, and so on.
- 29:07So what do you say to those potential accusations being levied against potentialism?
- 29:11I know you kind of already got into that already, but let's let's get into that a little
- 29:15bit more.
- 29:16Yeah.
- 29:18I guess, do you mean like, of it being like because maybe I'll I'll I'll respond to to your
- 29:25question this way.
- 29:26Democracy needs polarization.
- 29:28Democracy needs disagreement.
- 29:30Disagreement of people with different views.
- 29:32You don't want a democracy where everybody believes the same thing and holds the same
- 29:37commitments.
- 29:38What you want is a democracy where people can in the in the using the words of Spencer Cox
- 29:44and Julia Minson, are both doing phenomenal work in this space.
- 29:49Utah governor Spencer Cox, Julia Minson is a Harvard professor.
- 29:52People need to be able to disagree better.
- 29:54That's the point.
- 29:55We need to be able to have disagreements, but do it in a way that's productive rather than
- 30:00leads to distrust and hate and and, you know, lack of cooperation, conflict, that sort of
- 30:06thing.
- 30:07And so, you know, that is the sort of the set of background conditions that are necessary in
- 30:14order for the kind of discourse that we want in our democracy to flourish.
- 30:21And that's, you know, that's essentially pluralism.
- 30:24Pluralism is the sort of the word that people use right now to to describe the the approach
- 30:30that what we want to be able to do, what the the approach that we wanna be able to take in
- 30:35navigating our disagreements.
- 30:38Now where does potentialism fall in this?
- 30:41Potentialism represents one viewpoint in this hopefully kind of fractious and boisterous.
- 30:53I guess fractious is the wrong word.
- 30:55Let's call it a boisterous disagreement.
- 30:57Potentialism represents one view in this conversation of and a political identity
- 31:06representing an advocacy for a particular type of social change.
- 31:11Namely, a society that ensure ensures and seeks to ensure that everybody has the opportunity to
- 31:17develop their gifts and a culture in which people recognize that they have an obligation,
- 31:24engage in that personal development, and also to help other people do the same.
- 31:28Right?
- 31:28There's a kind of an emergent property of potentialism where if I'm cultivating my gifts,
- 31:32it makes it easier for you to cultivate yours, and we all have a role to play in each other's
- 31:36lives and kind of identify, oh, oh, you're really good at that.
- 31:39Oh, yeah.
- 31:39You should call you should you should do that more.
- 31:41That really helped or whatever, blah blah blah.
- 31:43So what the what potentialism is advocating for is that type of culture of of support and
- 31:49opportunity and also a culture of responsibility.
- 31:53And and so and that it is it is not intended to get rid of political disagreement, but it's
- 32:00intended to operate in a in a environment in which we have a more respectful and productive
- 32:06way of disagreeing with each other about these types of questions.
- 32:11That is such an important point to bring up as well as just the whole, you need some level of
- 32:17disagreement.
- 32:17I mean, it's gonna happen anyways, but if it like you said, if we're just agreeing on
- 32:22everything, that's not you're not really actually thinking about anything.
- 32:27You're you're really just there's no real critical thinking going on about specific
- 32:33policies or people running for office, and you need those things.
- 32:36It's just, of course, this is talking about trying to push back against the excessiveness
- 32:42of that disagreement where it starts to become an existential crisis because somebody
- 32:47disagreed with us.
- 32:49But you do need that level of disagreement and it would just be incredibly boring if we all
- 32:53thought it.
- 32:54Exactly the same thing about everything, then there'd be so many unintended consequences of
- 32:58things that we miss because we just all said, Oh yeah, this policy, it's got everything
- 33:04figured out and nobody really thought about it from a different point of view.
- 33:07I think that's a perfectly fine practical way to respond to those people who might feel that
- 33:13it's it's too abstract, I guess.
- 33:16Yeah.
- 33:16And as for the actual implementation of potentialism, excuse me, we must also go up
- 33:22against the various reasons people have for not wanting to engage with politics.
- 33:26May maybe they are open to potentialism, but they just, for whatever reason, don't want to
- 33:33get involved.
- 33:34And I wanna go through several of the most common reasons that people have just to see how
- 33:38you would use potentialism to convince these groups of people that they can and should
- 33:43engage in American civics.
- 33:45So first up, how do you sell potentialism to these citizens who think they just they have
- 33:50nothing to offer, that they have incredibly low political efficacy like we brought up earlier,
- 33:55whether it's they think they can't understand politics or that they can't make an impact,
- 34:00what do you say to people to try to those kinds of people to get them to understand how
- 34:04potentialism can benefit them?
- 34:06What do you
- 34:07say to your friend who says, I have nothing to offer, have nothing to I am I'm not good for
- 34:10anything.
- 34:11What do you say to that person?
- 34:12You say I disagree.
- 34:15And and and ultimately you are yourself going to have to see you're gonna have to come to
- 34:22that change of mindset yourself.
- 34:26No one can do that for you.
- 34:27No one can make you see your own worth.
- 34:31No one can force that on you.
- 34:33That has to come you you need to arrive and make that journey yourself.
- 34:36But what but what potentialism says is we believe you have value.
- 34:41And and we believe that if you were to come to arrive at that belief, that your life would be
- 34:47better.
- 34:48And you will experience a greater sense of meaning and connection and those things are
- 34:53available.
- 34:54And in fact, actually, part of what we're trying to do is to make those things more
- 34:57available by giving you the opportunity and making systemic changes to ensure that people
- 35:02have those opportunities.
- 35:03So, look, there's a huge amount of isolation and alienation and loneliness and anxiety in
- 35:09our in society right now, and there's no one easy fix for that.
- 35:13But part of the I think that the sort of what potentialism says is that we need to be making
- 35:19changes at two levels.
- 35:20We need to be making a change at the levels of systems.
- 35:24We need to be able to change institutions to be able to provide people more opportunities to
- 35:29connect, more resources, better education, more public transportation so people can get to
- 35:34public parks, you know, that sort of thing, and connect with each other that way.
- 35:38So institutional change, but also cultural change.
- 35:40Cultural change meaning a change in the set of norms and values that we hold as a society
- 35:47about what about individual worth and the fact that everyone's contribution, everyone's
- 35:54individual role is everyone is playing a critical role even in the sort of, like, the
- 36:00little corners of the country where they're not typically paid attention to.
- 36:05And so the the cultural change is a is a change towards a deeper recognition of the important
- 36:11role that every everybody plays in creating the society that we want.
- 36:15It's kinda like that what you said at the beginning, it's kinda like the the phrase, you
- 36:20can lead a horse to water, but you can't make them drink.
- 36:22Right.
- 36:23You know, you you you can give them all of the information about potentialism, about how it
- 36:27can benefit them, but ultimately, they're gonna be have to be the ones to accept that.
- 36:31But I do think though that potentialism has, not to make the pun again, but that has the
- 36:38potential to really convince these people that there is really something that they have to
- 36:44offer.
- 36:44It's a different way to really package that idea where it's just instead of just telling
- 36:48people, You should go vote more.
- 36:50You should go learn more about politics.
- 36:53They might understand, yeah, probably, but it's not really truly convincing them that they have
- 37:00something that they can contribute to our civic culture.
- 37:04Civic life.
- 37:05Yeah.
- 37:05Yeah.
- 37:05Exactly.
- 37:06Yeah.
- 37:07And you know, and and I exactly right.
- 37:09I mean, there will always be people who are who resist that and and, you know, it's important
- 37:15for the for the theory and for the the application of the theory that nobody is
- 37:21coerced into coming to a certain set of beliefs.
- 37:26You know, as you said, leading to the horse, there's there's an invitation to to adopt a
- 37:30particular worldview that that I have value.
- 37:33I have something to offer.
- 37:34And that and that part of what it means to live a good life is to figure out what that is.
- 37:39But if
- 37:39but but it's it it is an invitation.
- 37:42It is not a an assertion or a demand.
- 37:47Yeah, and there is the one thing about trying to convince people that they have nothing to
- 37:52offer, but there are some people who think that they have something to offer or understand they
- 37:57have something to offer, but they're now just simply too afraid to engage with politics.
- 38:01So let's talk about this group.
- 38:04And and it's understandable to be afraid to engage in politics considering the uptick in
- 38:09violence that we've seen, assassinations and attempted assassinations, and just the
- 38:13increasing toxicity and political discussions.
- 38:15People don't wanna get into arguments with strangers, family, friends.
- 38:20But how do
- 38:20you sell potentialism to the people who are just too afraid to engage with politics?
- 38:27Well, I wanna make a clarification here because I think it's important to note that engagement
- 38:34and contribution does not necessarily need to be about politics at all.
- 38:39Doesn't need to be a political act.
- 38:42If you're if you're taking care of a dementia patient and working with them over the course
- 38:46of years and, you know, their mental acuity is gone, they don't even know who you are half the
- 38:51time, that's a contribution.
- 38:53That's not political.
- 38:54It happens in a in a society, and to that extent, we all are playing active roles in
- 39:00creating a society.
- 39:01But I would caution to use the word political to describe many of the gifts and ways of
- 39:07contributing that people have because the exact reason that you mentioned, which is that most
- 39:12people don't care about politics.
- 39:14Most Americans think about politics in the same way that I think about hockey.
- 39:17So they know that it's happening.
- 39:20They know that some people are excited about it, but that's basically as far as their
- 39:25understanding goes.
- 39:26And so I think it's really important to realize that for the vast majority of Americans, it's
- 39:32not about being politically engaged.
- 39:34It's about finding ways of adding value to your own life, to the lives of the people around
- 39:40you, including your neighbors and your friends and the people that you work with and the
- 39:43people at your gym and the people down the road and the people in your town.
- 39:48So potentialism is not about necessarily about contributing politically.
- 39:53It's about finding ways of expanding your understanding of how you can show up for other
- 40:00people, period.
- 40:02But let and let and if I don't mind so so so so that, I guess, I think, will will connect to
- 40:06the to the to what you were saying about people being afraid.
- 40:08I think people are afraid because they don't see politics as something that's important in
- 40:12their lives, but that's okay.
- 40:13The the fear is not, like, it's not about engaging in in it's not about being politically
- 40:21active, it's just about being active, period, in your own life.
- 40:25I think it's
- 40:25a shame that you you couldn't care less about hockey.
- 40:27I enjoy hockey, but, hey, different strokes for different folks.
- 40:30But something that you just pointed out there that I think is a very critical distinction.
- 40:36I I believe it was my guest a couple weeks ago, Felicia Kolaros, that mentioned this too was
- 40:41there's a difference between being civically engaged and politically engaged.
- 40:45And like you said, if you say political engagement, a lot of people are just gonna tune
- 40:50out for various reasons.
- 40:51In in in this case, talking about people who are afraid to engage with politics.
- 40:56But, you know, you can frame it in a different way and say, this is not about politics.
- 41:00This is just about your community.
- 41:02This is about you caring about your community and being civically responsible to them and
- 41:08them being civically responsible to you.
- 41:09And I think that's a very important distinction to make for those people because I think
- 41:14there's a lot less of a hesitation to be like, oh, yeah.
- 41:18You know what?
- 41:18It's my community.
- 41:19I I do have a responsibility to them because they're not I don't think they'll be as fearful
- 41:23of that.
- 41:23But the last grip I wanted to of of civically reluctant people I wanted to focus on, you
- 41:29actually just touched on them a bit.
- 41:31Some people think that engaging with politics is pointless.
- 41:35It's boring.
- 41:36It doesn't affect them.
- 41:37It's not about the fact that they think they don't have anything to contribute or that
- 41:40they're afraid.
- 41:40They just do not care, like you said.
- 41:43So how do you sell potentialism to those people, or can you really sell potentialism to
- 41:48those people?
- 41:49Yeah.
- 41:50I mean, I I I would say I would say very similar to what I just said, which is it's not
- 41:54about politics.
- 41:56And so if you're afraid about being politically engaged, that's not that's not what's going on
- 42:01here.
- 42:01What we're talking about is showing up for each other.
- 42:03And we're talking about enriching your own life by figuring out what it is that you can do to
- 42:08contribute because you're going to experience a greater sense of meaning.
- 42:11You're going to experience a greater sense of connection when you, when you figure out what
- 42:14that is and when you develop it and share it.
- 42:17So for the people who don't wanna engage in politics, that's that's totally fine.
- 42:23We don't we don't need to talk politics at all.
- 42:25We're talking about contributions.
- 42:26We're talking about showing up for ourselves.
- 42:28We're showing up talking about showing up for each other.
- 42:30We're not talking about politics.
- 42:32I think that's a that's a very reasonable way to address that concern.
- 42:36I I think there will people will be more caring about their community as apart from politics,
- 42:43like you said.
- 42:43And I I I think there is a through line through each of those, I think, different groups of
- 42:51civically reluctant people, but, of course, can't treat them all the exact same way, but
- 42:55there is still a similar through line for them is that there is that distinction of civics
- 43:01versus or civic engagement versus political engagement.
- 43:04Now, obviously, we'd still like to have more people being politically engaged, but we can
- 43:09always start a little bit smaller, get the civic engagement going first, and then we can
- 43:14start seeing more of the political engagement follow.
- 43:16So I always like to make sure to and I know we obviously, we've we've had some actionable and
- 43:22practical stuff already, but I like to at least focus one specific question in guest episodes
- 43:27explicitly on actionable tips that viewers and listeners can take away and implement.
- 43:33So how can people get involved in the promotion of potentialism of actually showcasing its
- 43:40values and with the Beacon Project overall?
- 43:43The best thing you can do is go we have there's a very short little blog post on potentialism.
- 43:50It's about it's a five minute read.
- 43:52I encourage anyone who's listening to this podcast, go check it out, read it, see how it
- 43:57sits with you.
- 43:58And if you if you know someone who you think might be interested in it, send it to them.
- 44:03That's basically all that we're trying to do right now.
- 44:05We I would love for as many people to be aware of this.
- 44:11We're calling it a prototype.
- 44:12It's a prototype.
- 44:13It's not a finished product.
- 44:14This is not like, oh, we're rolling out the final thing and everyone needs to accept this
- 44:20thing whole hog.
- 44:21This is an experiment.
- 44:22This is a dialogue.
- 44:24This is a invitation to anyone who feels like there may be a member of the exhausted majority
- 44:33who wants something new, but who also holds hope for the future to explore what it might
- 44:39look like to develop a new way of understanding how we what we owe each other as as Americans
- 44:45and and people right now, and how we can create the kind of society that we want.
- 44:50So the experiment is one that involves a lot of feedback and is very open and receptive to how
- 44:56people feel about this.
- 44:58And my invitation to your listeners would be number one, Paul, if you wanna include the link
- 45:03to the to the blog post on on the, on the resources that accompany this podcast, go check
- 45:09it out, leave a comment and let me know how you think what do you think about it and then share
- 45:14it with whoever you think might be interested in it, that would be the best thing you could
- 45:17do.
- 45:18Yeah, I actually am gonna ask you at the end any links you wanna share, so I'll be sure to
- 45:22include that as well, but I really appreciate the honesty about you talking about it as a
- 45:27prototype.
- 45:27Now, I'm somebody who very much struggles with the I struggle with the trying to make things
- 45:32perfect instead of good and and roll it out because sometimes people just wanna wait till
- 45:36something's a finished product.
- 45:38But you admit that, hey.
- 45:39This is this is just a first step we're trying to get this ball rolling.
- 45:43And it also opens it to the public for potential suggestions from them too, how they
- 45:49can also refine it because ultimately, potentialism is about the gift that they can
- 45:54contribute to our civic culture.
- 45:57And so it also makes sense that they can also help contribute to refining potentialism and
- 46:04making it a finished product like you were alluding to.
- 46:07So can definitely appreciate that.
- 46:10So we're just about running up on the end of this episode.
- 46:14But before I get to the final final question, a random question, any final thoughts you'd like
- 46:20to share on potentialism, civic renewal, or depolarization, or civic culture in general?
- 46:26Yeah.
- 46:26The thought I'd like to share is that I think a lot of people, anyone who's listening to this
- 46:32is kind of there's a sense that we're really in a dark time in America.
- 46:37There's an enormous amount of concern about where where we're headed as a country, how
- 46:42we're gonna navigate our divisions, whether we're ever gonna be able to get back to a place
- 46:46where we can see eye to eye and make progress on some of the most important issues that we're
- 46:52all facing regardless of our political identity.
- 46:56And I like I really feel that.
- 46:58And I also feel as though moments like this are often some of the best opportunities to really
- 47:06go back to first principles, to ask ourselves what kind of a society and life we wanna create
- 47:12for ourselves and to really innovate and create something better and different.
- 47:17And so what I I would encourage the people who are feeling hopeless to imagine is, okay, where
- 47:24can we what can we make out of this and where can we how can we build from here to a better
- 47:30future?
- 47:31So that's that's where I that's where I get hope from, which is like, okay, in this moment
- 47:38of concern and suffering, is there an opportunity for I think that's a very great way
- 47:46to end this topic
- 47:48on potentialism.
- 47:49So definitely something for not just for those of you listening to mull over, but for me as
- 47:54well.
- 47:55So I really wanna thank you for all of those insights that you brought, Daniel.
- 47:59We're gonna go ahead and get to the final portion of this interview, the random question
- 48:04of the day.
- 48:04So for those of you who are listening who are new to the podcast, I like to ask random non
- 48:10political questions of my guests just to get a different side of them.
- 48:13And sometimes these can be a little bit more, not depressing topics, but they can be a little
- 48:18bit more existential, can be a little bit tough to deal with.
- 48:22So sometimes add a little bit of levity to it.
- 48:24So for you, Daniel, today's random question of the day is, what is a hobby you'd like to
- 48:30develop though you may not have the time or patience for?
- 48:33Oh, well, I'm gonna say two.
- 48:35One is that I have been a in a past life, I was a jazz pianist and this was a major hobby of
- 48:40mine.
- 48:40And then at at for a little while, it's a little bit more than a hobby, but it is
- 48:44something that I have not really it has sort of, like, been difficult to balance and get as
- 48:50much time at the piano as I would like with with this new work that we're doing as well as
- 48:55having a three year old at home.
- 48:57That is something that I would like to do more of.
- 48:59The other thing I would like to do more of is I was speaking to a friend about running a
- 49:03triathlon, and I feel like it's the kind of thing that I would really enjoy.
- 49:07I would love to get really into some pretty major, like, long term feats of athletic
- 49:14prowess, although I'm far from that at this point.
- 49:17So that is an aspiration, maybe one for down the road.
- 49:21But, yeah, those would be the two.
- 49:23Nice.
- 49:23I'm not I am not a I am not musically talented.
- 49:28So maybe if I really worked at it, I could be something decent at it.
- 49:32Obviously, it would be cool to be able to play guitar or drums or anything like that.
- 49:36But one thing that would be really cool for me to develop, I have a whole bunch of other
- 49:40hobbies, you know, outside of political science, so it it'd be hard to devote time to
- 49:45this as well.
- 49:46But something that I would like to really get into is woodworking because my grandpa, my
- 49:52mom's dad, he he was a woodworker.
- 49:55He he carved a lot.
- 49:56He also did some painting too, but woodworking was much more what I remember him doing.
- 50:00He had all sorts of figurines.
- 50:01There's actually have hanging up a I think it's like a flintlock pistol that he carved hanging
- 50:07up in my room here.
- 50:08So he he carved a lot of cool stuff.
- 50:10But, yeah, that's that's something that maybe maybe at some point I actually will get
- 50:15involved in.
- 50:16And there is a little bit of that nostalgia, you know, going up to Virginia to my
- 50:19grandparents' old house, and he had that shed that he'd work on woodworking in all the time
- 50:24or he'd do it in the garage as well.
- 50:25So that would be something really cool to develop.
- 50:28Love that.
- 50:29That's great.
- 50:30Yeah.
- 50:31But maybe one day.
- 50:32But any case Maybe one day.
- 50:33Yeah.
- 50:34Yeah.
- 50:34That's cool.
- 50:36Yeah.
- 50:36But in any case, Daniel, thank you so much for your time and for all the insights that you
- 50:41provided here.
- 50:42So real quick, any links that you want me to put in the show notes besides the the blog post
- 50:48that you were talking about?
- 50:50Yeah.
- 50:50You could put you could put the potential potentialism link and then you could link to
- 50:54the Beacon Project And that would that would probably oh, and then the other one that I
- 51:00would add is is a link called civiccivicprofile.us.
- 51:03It's a it's a new website that the Beacon Project just put out that is like, letting
- 51:09people explore how they think about what what we owe each other as Americans and what it
- 51:15means to be civically engaged.
- 51:16Nice.
- 51:17Okay.
- 51:17That that's that's something that's new to me too, so I'll be sure to go check it out.
- 51:21So I will have all those links in the show notes.
- 51:22As for my links, my my LinkedIn profile, which I I write on frequently, my medium.com profile,
- 51:30which I write on from time to time, my Facebook page, Paul Raider author and speaker, my five
- 51:36day educational email course about how we can all more effectively mitigate toxicity and
- 51:42polarization and some of the key mistakes we make in that endeavor and how we fix those
- 51:46mistakes.
- 51:47My book that I wrote on amazon.com, ebook and paperback format.
- 51:52My email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot com and my website, Paul Raider dot org.
- 51:59But that is gonna wrap things up for today's episode.
- 52:02Thank you all so much for listening, and please like, comment, subscribe, and share on YouTube,
- 52:07Spotify, and Apple Podcasts, and anywhere else that you see these links on the Internet.
- 52:12So thank you all so much, and we'll see you next time.