Latest / Orbital Dreams / How Stars Are Born and How They Die _ Science for sleep _ No Mid-Video Ads
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: Tonight, Somewhere in the sky above you, a star is
- 0:07being born, and somewhere else, in the dark between the galaxies,
- 0:13another is quietly coming to its end. Both of these
- 0:17things are happening right now, as they have for billions
- 0:21of years, in a rhythm far older than the earth
- 0:25beneath you. Every star that has ever shone had a beginning,
- 0:30and every one of them will have an end. And
- 0:33the quiet truth will sit with tonight is that those
- 0:36endings are not distant and unrelated to you. They are
- 0:41woven into the iron in your blood, the breath moving
- 0:44through your chest, the simple fact that you are here
- 0:48at all to wonder about any of it. Over the
- 0:52next little while will follow that long story, slowly and gently,
- 0:57from the cold and silent clouds where stars first take shape,
- 1:01through the steady calm of their lives, and on to
- 1:04the many ways they finally let go. Some of it
- 1:08is tender, some of it is almost unimaginably violent, and
- 1:14all of it is true. So let yourself grow still now,
- 1:19let your shoulders soften and the weight of the day
- 1:22slide away, and let your breathing slow on its own.
- 1:27You don't have to hold on to every word you
- 1:30can drift off whenever you like, and the stars will
- 1:33keep turning without you. So let's begin where every star begins,
- 1:39in the cold and in the dark. The iron in
- 1:45your blood was made inside a dying star. This is
- 1:49not a poem or a pretty turn of phrase. It
- 1:52is a plain physical fact. Every atom of iron that
- 1:56carries oxygen through your veins right now, in the quiet
- 2:01of this moment was forged in the heart of a
- 2:04star that lived its whole life and died long before
- 2:07the sun was ever born. The same is true of
- 2:11the calcium holding your bones together, the carbon at the
- 2:16center of nearly every part of you, the oxygen your
- 2:20breathing slowly in and out as you rest. None of
- 2:23it began here on Earth. Almost all of it came
- 2:27first from the stars. To feel how strange that is,
- 2:32you have to travel back to the very beginning of everything,
- 2:36when the universe was young, and I mean truly young.
- 2:39In its first few minutes, there were no stars anywhere.
- 2:43There were no planets, no rocks, no living things. There
- 2:48was only a thin, hot fog spread evenly through all
- 2:52of space. And that fog was made of the simplest
- 2:56ingredients imaginable, mostly hydrogen, the lightest element there is, along
- 3:02with a good amount of helium, and only the faintest
- 3:05whisper of one or two others. That was the entire
- 3:08inventory of creation. No carbon to build living things, no
- 3:13oxygen to breathe, no iron, no gold, no calcium. The
- 3:18early universe was beautifully, almost unbearably plain. So where did
- 3:24all the rest of it come from? Every heavier element,
- 3:28every atom more complex than those first few simple ones,
- 3:32had to be built somewhere, And in all the vast cosmos,
- 3:36there was only one kind of place with the heat
- 3:39and the crushing pressure needed to build them, the deep
- 3:43core of a star. A star, you see, spends its
- 3:47long life as a kind of furnace. In its center,
- 3:51Hydrogen is squeezed and heated until it fuses together into helium,
- 3:56and that fusion is what makes a star shine. But
- 4:01as a star ages and its simplest fuel begins to
- 4:04run low, it learns to fuse heavier things. Helium becomes carbon,
- 4:09carbon becomes oxygen. Step by step, over millions and billions
- 4:15of years, the star works its way up through the elements,
- 4:19building heavier and heavier atoms in its core, the way
- 4:22a slow fire turns light kindling into something denser and
- 4:27deeper and more enduring. And then, for many stars comes
- 4:32the ending. And the ending is where the real alchemy happens.
- 4:38When a massive star reaches the close of its life,
- 4:41it collapses and detonates in an explosion so bright it
- 4:45can briefly outshine an entire galaxy of billions of stars.
- 4:51In the unimaginable heat and fury of that death, the
- 4:55very heaviest elements are forged in moments, and then the
- 5:00the whole rich harvest, the carbon, the oxygen, the iron,
- 5:04all of it is flung outward into space, scattered across
- 5:08light years like seeds thrown from an open hand. And
- 5:11not every element in you was made the same way
- 5:15or in the same kind of star. The carbon and
- 5:18oxygen that fills so much of you were cooked gently
- 5:22over long ages in the quiet cores of ordinary stars.
- 5:28The iron in your blood was forged in the fierce
- 5:31hearts of the heaviest stars and in their explosive deaths.
- 5:35And some of the rarest heaviest things of all. The
- 5:39gold and silver that people have treasured throughout history may
- 5:44have been made in events more violent still in the
- 5:47unimaginable collisions of the burned out cores of dead stars.
- 5:53Something we have only begun to understand in recent years.
- 5:58The matter in your body is not the work of
- 6:00any single star, but a gathering for many, a slow
- 6:05harvest of countless lives and countless endings, mixed together across
- 6:11billions of years, and folded at last into you. For
- 6:15a long time, that scattered material simply drifts, It mixes
- 6:20into the thin gas between the stars, dust and atoms,
- 6:24wandering through the dark for ages. But every so often
- 6:28a cloud of that enriched material begins to gather itself
- 6:32together again, drawn inward by its own gravity, and out
- 6:36of that gathering a new star is born, and around
- 6:40it sometimes new worlds. Our own sun is one of
- 6:44those later generation stars. The earth beneath you, the water
- 6:49in its oceans, the rock under your feet, your own body.
- 6:54All of it was assembled from the ashes of stars
- 6:57that lived and died before our sun even existed. So
- 7:02when someone tells you that you are made of star dust,
- 7:06they are not being sentimental. They are simply describing where
- 7:10your atoms have been. The iron in you was born
- 7:15in a stellar furnace. The oxygen in your every breath
- 7:19was cooked in the belly of a star. Even the
- 7:22hydrogen in the water of your body is older still,
- 7:26most of it formed in the very first minutes of
- 7:30the universe itself, and it has been waiting all this
- 7:34time to become a part of you. There is something
- 7:39quietly staggering in that, my friend, you are not separate
- 7:43from the great story of the stars, watching it from
- 7:46a safe and distant shore. You are part of it.
- 7:50One of the ways the universe has, for a little
- 7:53while of folding its oldest material into something that can
- 7:58look up and wonder. The atoms in your hand have
- 8:02seen the inside of stars. They are billions of years old.
- 8:06They will go on long after you, and one day,
- 8:10far in the future they may find themselves inside something new.
- 8:14For now, though they are yours, resting here in the dark,
- 8:19breathing slow stardust gathered for a time into the shape
- 8:24of you. Stars are born in the coldest places in
- 8:30all the universe. It seems as though it should be
- 8:33the other way around. A star is the hottest thing.
- 8:37Most of us can picture, a roaring sphere of fire,
- 8:41pouring heat and light out across the emptiness. Surely such
- 8:46a thing must be borne somewhere fierce and blazing, And
- 8:50yet the truth runs exactly opposite. The cradle of every
- 8:55star is a place of deep cold, deep silence, and
- 9:00almost perfect darkness. These cradles are enormous clouds of gas
- 9:05and dust, drifting slowly through the spaces between the stars.
- 9:10They are some of the largest single things in any galaxy.
- 9:14A single one can stretch across tens, even hundreds of
- 9:18light years, so vast that light itself, the fastest thing
- 9:23there is, would take longer than a human life, to
- 9:27cross from one side to the other. They hang in
- 9:31the dark like continents of mist, glowing faintly at their edges,
- 9:35utterly black at their hearts. And they are cold, almost
- 9:40impossibly cold. Deep inside one of these clouds, the temperature
- 9:46falls to just a few degrees above the lowest temperature
- 9:49nature allows, the absolute zero, where nearly all motion ceases.
- 9:56It is far colder there than the coldest night that
- 9:58has ever fallen on Earth, colder than anything you could
- 10:02ever touch and survive. In that frigid stillness, the thin
- 10:07gas grows so quiet that delicate molecules can form and
- 10:11hold together, drifting undisturbed for ages. The dust mixed through
- 10:18these clouds is worth picturing too. It is not dust
- 10:22like the kind that gathers on a shelf. These are
- 10:25unimaginably tiny grains, far smaller than a wisp of smoke,
- 10:31flecks of carbon like soot, and grains of silicate like
- 10:35the faintest powder of sand, each one built and scattered
- 10:39by stars that came before. There are countless trillions of them,
- 10:45spread thin through the cloud, and together they are so
- 10:48good at blocking light that they swallow the glow of
- 10:51whatever lies behind. And yet for all their darkness, these
- 10:57clouds are emptier than almost anything we could ever build.
- 11:02The gas within them is thinner than the finest vacuum
- 11:05ever made in any laboratory on Earth, so sparse that
- 11:10handful for handful is closer to nothing than to something.
- 11:16The trick is simply how vast they are spread that
- 11:20whisper thin gas across hundreds of light years, and the
- 11:24total gathers into a staggering sum enough material and a
- 11:28single great cloud to one day build thousands upon thousands
- 11:32of stars. It is one of the quiet wonders of
- 11:36the cosmos that something so close to empty, simply by
- 11:41being so unthinkably large can cradle the makings of a
- 11:45thousand suns. If you could somehow stand at the edge
- 11:49of such a cloud, you would see almost nothing at all,
- 11:53only a wall of darkness, vast and soft and silent.
- 11:57And you can actually witness this for yourself, on a
- 12:01truly dark night, far from any city. Look up at
- 12:05the long band of the Milky Way. The dark rifts
- 12:09and patches that seem to tear gaps in that river
- 12:12of stars are not empty gaps at all. They are
- 12:17these very clouds, near and cold and immense, quietly blotting
- 12:22out the light from behind them. The most famous of them,
- 12:25the great Nursery in the constellation of Orion, hangs there
- 12:30in plain sight as a faint smudge below the Hunter's belt,
- 12:34a place where new stars are being kindled. Even now,
- 12:39here's the quiet paradox at the heart of it. That
- 12:43deep cold is not an obstacle to making a star.
- 12:47It is the very thing that makes a star possible.
- 12:50To see why, picture the gas inside one of these clouds.
- 12:55Every cloud lives caught in a slow, endless tug of war.
- 12:59Its own gravity is forever trying to pull it inward,
- 13:03to gather it together and make it collapse. But the
- 13:06gas also carries warmth and motion, and warmth pushes outward,
- 13:11holding the cloud up and apart, resisting the squeeze. As
- 13:16long as the gas stays warm enough, that outward push wins,
- 13:20and the cloud simply drifts, stable and unchanging for a
- 13:24very long time. But when the gas grows cold, truly
- 13:28deeply cold, that outward push fades away. The motion slows,
- 13:34the resistance weakens, and now in the stillness, gravity can
- 13:39finally begin to win. A cold cloud is a cloud
- 13:43that can fall inward, gather, and one day light a
- 13:46fire at its center. The chill is what allows the
- 13:50collapse to begin. Without the cold, there would be no
- 13:54stars at all. So the warmest, brightest things in existence
- 13:58begin in the coldest, darkest, stillest places. We know of.
- 14:02The fire that will one day pour across the void
- 14:05is conceived in frost and silence. There is something almost
- 14:10tender in that, the thought that the fiercest light needs
- 14:13a quiet cold beginning. That brilliance starts in the deepest dark.
- 14:19For now, though, the cloud simply drifts vast and silent
- 14:23and cold light years across, holding within it the seeds
- 14:27of suns that have not yet begun to shine, no
- 14:30fire yet, no warmth, only the dark and the slow gathering,
- 14:38and all the time in the world, for millions of years,
- 14:44the cloud does nothing at all. It simply drifts, a vast,
- 14:49cold expanse of gas and dust, hanging in the dark
- 14:52between the stars, perfectly content to remain exactly as it is.
- 14:58It could go on this way for an aide, unchanged,
- 15:01neither growing nor collapsing, held in a long and patient ballance,
- 15:07and in many cases that is precisely what happens. A
- 15:11cloud can wait silent and still for longer than the
- 15:15Earth has existed, without ever giving birth to a single star.
- 15:20So something has to change, something has to reach in
- 15:24and tip that ballance to give the cloud the smallest
- 15:28push toward falling inward. The question of what does the
- 15:33pushing is one of the quiet mysteries of house stars
- 15:36are made, and it is a question astronomers are still
- 15:40working to fully answer. Often more than one thing seems
- 15:45to play a part, and it can be hard to
- 15:47say which gave the decisive nudge. There are a few
- 15:51culprits we know of. Sometimes two of these great clouds,
- 15:57wandering slowly through the galaxy drift into one another, and
- 16:02the gentle collision presses their gas together until parts of
- 16:06it begin to collapse. Sometimes a cloud passes through one
- 16:12of the bright spiral arms of its galaxy, where the
- 16:15gas is naturally crowded and compressed, and that extra squeeze
- 16:19is enough to set things falling. And sometimes, most dramatically
- 16:25of all, the push comes from the death of another star.
- 16:29This last one is worth resting on for a moment.
- 16:33When a massive star reaches the end of its life,
- 16:37it explodes, hurling its outer layers into space at tremendous speed.
- 16:43That blast spreads outward through the surrounding darkness like a
- 16:46ripple moving across still water, a vast shell of gas
- 16:51racing into the spaces between the stars. And if that
- 16:55expanding wave happens to reach a cold, quiet cloud near by,
- 17:00it presses into it like a hand into soft clay.
- 17:04The cloud is compressed, its gas is driven together, and
- 17:09in the places where it is squeezed hardest, gravity finally
- 17:13takes hold and the slow collapse begins. Think about what
- 17:17that means. The death of one star can be the
- 17:21very thing that calls new stars into being. The ending
- 17:25becomes a beginning, a star that has lived out its
- 17:29entire life and let go in a final burst of
- 17:33light reaches across the dark and stirs a sleeping cloud awake,
- 17:38and from that stirring new suns are born. There is
- 17:42a kind of inheritance in it. One generation of stars
- 17:47seeds the birth of the next, not only with the
- 17:50elements they forged, but with the very push that sets
- 17:55the next generation falling into place. We even have reason
- 18:00to think something like this may have happened at the
- 18:03birth of our own son. Tucked inside the oldest rocks
- 18:08of our solar system, in ancient meteorites that have survived
- 18:12since the very beginning, scientists have found the faint traces
- 18:17of certain rare materials, the kind that are made only
- 18:21in the hearts of exploding stars and that do not
- 18:25linger for long. Their presence is a clue, a hint
- 18:30that a nearby star may have died not long before
- 18:33our son was born, and that its death may have
- 18:37helped trigger the collapse of the cloud that became our home.
- 18:41This is not certain. It remains one possible story among
- 18:45a few, but it is a real and serious idea,
- 18:50and it carries a quiet wonder of its own. That
- 18:53our Sun and the Earth, and you may owe your
- 18:57existence in part to the death of a star whose
- 19:01name we will never know. And when a cloud is
- 19:04finally tipped in to collapse, it rarely makes just one star.
- 19:09A single great cloud, once it begins to fall, tends
- 19:13to break apart into many smaller knots, each gathering inward
- 19:17on its own, so that stars are most often born
- 19:21not alone, but together, in broods of hundreds or even
- 19:26thousands at a time. They form as siblings, kindled side
- 19:30by side from the same dark cradle, before the slow
- 19:34turning of the galaxy gently draws them apart over the ages,
- 19:39scattering them across the sky, until each one drifts alone.
- 19:44Even our own son most likely was born among such
- 19:47kin brothers and sisters, long since lost to the great drift,
- 19:52wandering the galaxy, now unrecognized and far away. It is
- 19:58humbling to sit with the thought that beginnings so often
- 20:01need an ending to set them in motion, that stillness
- 20:05sometimes has to be broken before anything new can grow.
- 20:10That a cloud might wait, patient and unchanging for an age,
- 20:15until at last something reaches in from far away and
- 20:18whispers gently now. And when that moment comes, it is
- 20:24almost imperceptible. There is no sudden flash, no great event
- 20:29to market. Somewhere deep in the dark, in a cloud
- 20:33light years wide, a faint shiver passes through the gas.
- 20:37A region that had been holding itself apart begins ever
- 20:41so slowly to fall inward toward its own center. Nothing
- 20:45about it looks like a star, yet it will take
- 20:49a vast stretch of time before it does. But the
- 20:52long gathering has begun, and in the quiet of the dark,
- 20:56the first stirrings of a new sun have been set
- 21:00in motion. At last. Once a cloud begins to fall,
- 21:06it falls for a very long time. There is nothing
- 21:10sudden about the birth of a star. The collapse that
- 21:14makes one unfolds across hundreds of thousands of years, slow,
- 21:18beyond anything, we can easily feel a gathering so patient
- 21:23that in any single human lifetime you would never see
- 21:27it move at all. And yet move it does, pulled
- 21:32by its own gravity, The gas in one corner of
- 21:35a great cold cloud begins to drift inward, every part
- 21:39of it falling gently toward a common center, like snow
- 21:43settling toward the bottom of a deep and silent well.
- 21:47As the gas falls, something quietly remarkable happens. It begins
- 21:52to grow warm. This is one of those simple truths
- 21:56of nature that feels almost magical when you first meet it.
- 22:00When things fall together and squeeze, they heat up. The
- 22:06gas at the center is pressed harder and harder by
- 22:10everything piling in around it, and under that mounting pressure,
- 22:15the cold begins to lift. A faint warmth kindles in
- 22:19the heart of the collapsing cloud, deep inside its dusty shell,
- 22:23hidden from view. This warm, growing core has a name.
- 22:28We call it a protostar, a star in the making,
- 22:32not yet truly shining, but no longer merely cold gas.
- 22:37It glows softly and a kind of light our eyes
- 22:39cannot see, a deep infrared warmth buried in the dark.
- 22:44If it seems strange that simply falling together should make
- 22:48a thing grow hot, you have felt a small echo
- 22:51of it yourself. Press the air down in a bicycle pump,
- 22:56and the pump grows warm beneath your hand. Squeeze anything
- 23:00tightly enough, quickly enough, and it heats. In the collapsing
- 23:05core of a forming star, that same plain rule plays
- 23:09out on an unimaginable scale. The weight of an entire
- 23:13cloud bears down on the center, pressing the gas there
- 23:17harder and harder, and the temperature climbs and climbs. What
- 23:22began as some of the coldest material in the universe
- 23:26slowly turns warm, then hot, then hotter, still, all of
- 23:31it driven by nothing more than the patient, relentless pull
- 23:35of gravity, gathering everything inward. And as the cloud draws inward,
- 23:40it does something beautiful. It begins to spin. Every cloud
- 23:45carries some faint, lazy turning to begin with, far too
- 23:49slow to notice, But as it shrinks, that turning speeds up,
- 23:55the same way a skater pulls in her arms and
- 23:58spins faster, or water so quicker. As it nears the drain,
- 24:02the gathering cloud whirls more and more rapidly, and that
- 24:06spinning flattens it. What was once a shapeless blob is
- 24:10pressed over time into a broad, slowly turning disc, with
- 24:15the warm, young protostar glowing at its very center. That
- 24:20disc is where the star takes its meals. Gas and
- 24:24dust spiral slowly inward across it, drifting down onto the
- 24:28growing core, feeding it, adding to it, helping it swell
- 24:32and warm, And in the outer reaches of that same disc,
- 24:37far from the center, something else is quietly beginning. The
- 24:41leftover dust and grains begin to clump and stick and
- 24:45gather the first faint seeds of what may one day
- 24:48become planets. The very disc that feeds a newborn star
- 24:54is also the place where worlds are sown. There is
- 24:58one more thing the newborn does, and it remains one
- 25:01of the lovelier puzzles in all of this, Even as
- 25:05it draws gas inward. A young protostar fires two great
- 25:10jets of material straight out from its poles, narrow beams
- 25:14of gas flung into space in opposite directions, racing outward
- 25:20for light years, lighting up where they strike the surrounding cloud.
- 25:26We can see these jets glowing across the dark in
- 25:29many a stellar nursery, and yet exactly how a forming
- 25:34star launches them is something we still do not fully understand.
- 25:39We believe it has to do with magnetic fields twisted
- 25:42and wound up by all that spinning, flinging some of
- 25:45the gas away even as the rest falls in. But
- 25:49the full picture is still being worked out. A new
- 25:53born star, it seems, breathes out as it feeds, and
- 25:57we are still learning how sit for a moment with
- 26:01the shape of what is happening here. Out of a cold, formless,
- 26:06drifting cloud, with no plan and no hand to guide it,
- 26:10order is quietly emerging in the dark. A center forms,
- 26:14the hole gathers itself into a turning disk. A warmth
- 26:19kindles where there was only chill. Worlds begin faintly to
- 26:24take shape in the outer rings. All of it arises
- 26:27simply from gravity and time and the slow, certain pull
- 26:31of things toward one another. There is a kind of
- 26:34grace in that that something so structured and so finely
- 26:39arranged should come all on its own out of so
- 26:43much shapeless dark. And so the long gathering continues, hidden
- 26:48away inside its dusty veil, a soft glow at the center,
- 26:53growing warmer with each passing age, A great disk turning
- 26:58slowly around it, feeding it grain by grain, two faint
- 27:02jets reaching out into the night. Not yet a star,
- 27:05not quite, but something gathering itself patiently toward the moment
- 27:10it will shine. For now it rests there in the dark,
- 27:14warm and turning, taking its time, with no need to
- 27:18hurry toward anything at all. There is a single moment
- 27:25when a ball of gas becomes a star. For all
- 27:29the long ages of gathering and falling and slow warming
- 27:32that come before it. The true beginning of a star
- 27:35comes down in the end to a threshold, a line
- 27:39that is crossed in the deep heart of the collapsing cloud.
- 27:44On one side of that line, there is only warm gas,
- 27:47glowing faintly, pressed together but still dark. On the other side,
- 27:52there is a star, truly a light, shining with its
- 27:56own fire. And what carries it across is heat, simply heat,
- 28:03rising and rising in the core until it reaches a
- 28:06number that changes everything. That number is around ten million degrees.
- 28:13As the heart of a forming star is squeezed tighter
- 28:16and tighter by all the weight pressing in from above,
- 28:20its temperature climbs past anything found on Earth, past the
- 28:25heat of any flame you've ever felt, on and on
- 28:29until the very center reaches that staggering threshold, and there,
- 28:33at ten million degrees, something new awakens. The cores of
- 28:38hydrogen atoms packed in unimaginably close and moving unimaginably fast,
- 28:44begin to slam together and fuse, merging, joining, becoming helium,
- 28:50and releasing a flood of energy. As they do. The
- 28:53fire at the center of a star has been lit
- 28:56fusion has begun, and it will not stop in many
- 29:00stars for billions of years. This is the moment of ignition,
- 29:05the instant a gathering of gas finally earns the name
- 29:08of star. And from that instant onward, everything about the
- 29:13object changes. Before it was only falling inward, collapsing under
- 29:18its own weight, with nothing to hold it up. But
- 29:22now with fusion burning at its center, a great outpouring
- 29:26of energy pushes outward from the core, pressing back against
- 29:31all that crushing weight, And those two mighty forces, gravity
- 29:37pulling endlessly inward and the fire pushing endlessly outward, settle
- 29:42into a balance. That balance is the secret to a
- 29:46star's long life, and it is worth pausing to take
- 29:49in just how exquisite it is. Picture it, gravity, immense
- 29:55and tireless, forever trying to crush the star down into nothing,
- 30:00and against it, the heat of fusion, forever pushing back out,
- 30:04trying to blow the star apart. Neither one wins. They
- 30:09hold each other in a near perfect stand off, poised
- 30:12against one another so finely that the star neither collapses
- 30:17nor explodes, but simply holds its shape and shines. A
- 30:22star is not a still or settled thing at all.
- 30:25It is a balance, a truce between two opposing powers,
- 30:30held steady for an unthinkable span of time, and the
- 30:34wonder of it is how stable that truce can be.
- 30:38Should the core ever burn a touch too hot, it
- 30:41swells outward just slightly, which cools it and gently slows
- 30:46the fire back down. Should it cool a touch too much,
- 30:50gravity presses in a little harder, which warms it and
- 30:53coaxes the fire back up. The star corrects itself over
- 30:58and over without thought or effort, settling always back toward balance.
- 31:04It is this quiet, self steadying that lets a star
- 31:07shine on calm and even for ages on end, a
- 31:11fire that tends itself, trimming its own flame, holding its
- 31:16own light steady across the dark. Our own sun has
- 31:20been holding that balance for nearly five billion years, and
- 31:23it is doing so this very moment while you rest
- 31:28in its core. Every single second it fuses hundreds of
- 31:32millions of tons of hydrogen into helium, an outpouring of
- 31:37energy almost beyond words, and yet so perfectly matched by
- 31:41the inward pull of the Sun's own weight, that the
- 31:45result seen from the outside is simply a calm and
- 31:49even light. The sunlight that warms your face on an
- 31:53ordinary afternoon is the gentle surface of that titanic balanced fire, fury,
- 32:00held so steadily in check that it reaches us as
- 32:04nothing more than warmth. When a young star first reaches
- 32:07this balance, we say it has settled into the long,
- 32:11stable prime of its life. The frantic gathering is over,
- 32:17the collapse has ended. The dusty veil that hid it
- 32:21begins slowly to clear away, and at last the new
- 32:25star's light breaks free and shines out into the surrounding
- 32:28night for the first time. After all that falling in
- 32:32the dark, after all that patient warming, the star simply
- 32:36begins quietly to do the one thing it will now
- 32:40do for almost all the rest of its existence. It shines.
- 32:46There is a kind of peace in that settling. After
- 32:49the long unrest of being borne, all that falling, all
- 32:53that gathering, all that mounting heat, the new star comes
- 32:58to rest in a balance it can for billions of years.
- 33:02Two vast forces, gravity and fire, no longer at war,
- 33:07but somehow at ease with one another, leaning into each
- 33:10other so gently that the result is simply a steady glow,
- 33:15a newborn sun finding its balance in the dark and
- 33:18beginning the long, calm work of shining, Some stars never
- 33:26quite managed to be borne. In the same cold clouds
- 33:30where suns are kindled, there are objects that came so
- 33:33close to becoming stars, and in the end fell just short.
- 33:38They gathered, they collapsed, They warmed at the center, exactly
- 33:44as a true star does, but they could not quite
- 33:48gather enough, not quite enough weight, not quite enough heat,
- 33:53to cross that final threshold and light the steady fire
- 33:56of fusion at their hearts. And so instead of blazing
- 34:00into stars, they became something stranger and quieter. We call
- 34:06them brown dwarfs, and they are, in a sense, the
- 34:09universe's almost stars. The difference comes down to mass, to
- 34:15how much material an object manages to gather as it forms.
- 34:20To truly become a star. To kindle the lasting fusion
- 34:24that lets it shine for ages, an object needs to
- 34:28pull together a great deal of gas. There is a
- 34:31kind of minimum, a lower limit below which the core
- 34:35simply never gets hot enough, no matter how long it waits.
- 34:39That limit sits at roughly eight percent of the mass
- 34:42of our sun, which still sounds enormous and is, but
- 34:46in the language of stars, it is the bareest minimum
- 34:50gather less than that, and the central fire never properly
- 34:54catches the object, worms and glows, and then can only
- 34:59slowly cool. A brown dwarf lives in the strange country
- 35:03just below that line. It is far heavier than any planet,
- 35:08many tens of times the mass of a world like Jupiter,
- 35:12yet still too light to be a true star. For
- 35:16a brief while in its youth, it can manage a faint,
- 35:19partial sort of fusion, burning through a rare and delicate
- 35:24form of hydrogen that ignites more easily than the ordinary kind.
- 35:29But that special fuel is scarce, and it does not last.
- 35:34Before long it is spent, The faint inner fire sputters out,
- 35:39and the brown dwarf is left to do the only
- 35:41thing left to it, to glow softly from the warmth
- 35:45of its own making, and to cool very slowly across
- 35:49billions of years. If you could see one up close,
- 35:54it would not look like a star at all. It
- 35:56would be a dim, sullen ember, glowing it deep and
- 36:00dusky red or fainter. Still, some of the coolest are
- 36:05so gentle in their warmth that their surfaces are barely
- 36:08hotter than a cup of tea, or no warmer than
- 36:11a summer's day. They shine mostly in light. Our eyes
- 36:16cannot catch a quiet infrared warmth radiating into the dark.
- 36:22And because they are so faint that they are remarkably
- 36:25hard to find, the space around us may be scattered
- 36:29with them, drifting unseen and unremarked. And only in recent
- 36:34decades have our instruments grown keen enough to begin picking
- 36:38them out of the dark, one dim shape at a time.
- 36:43It was not until late in the twentieth century that
- 36:47we found the first one for certain glimpsed at last,
- 36:51as a faint companion beside another star, a discovery that
- 36:56proved these in between objects were truly out there and
- 37:00not merely a possibility on paper. Since then we have
- 37:04found a great many more, and we have come to
- 37:07suspect they are remarkably common, drifting in great numbers through
- 37:12the dark spaces between the stars, a whole shadow population
- 37:17of almost stars, too faint to have ever caught our eye,
- 37:21quietly filling the night. There is a real puzzle, too,
- 37:26in saying exactly where a brown dwarf ends and a
- 37:30giant planet begins. The line between them is genuinely blurry,
- 37:35and astronomers still debate just where to draw it. Both
- 37:40can be cold and dim, both can be wrapped in
- 37:43clouds and storms. The deepest difference lies in how they
- 37:48were born, whether an object gathered directly out of a
- 37:51collapsing cloud, the way a star does, or whether it
- 37:56grew slowly within the disk circling some other star, the
- 38:00way a planet does. But from the outside, a heavy
- 38:04planet and a light brown dwarf can look maddeningly alike,
- 38:09and telling the two apart is not always a simple thing.
- 38:14It is hard not to feel something gentle, almost wistful,
- 38:18toward these objects. They are the ones who came so close.
- 38:22They began exactly as stars begin, with all the same
- 38:27gathering and falling and warming, and they reached for the
- 38:30same fire every star reaches for. They simply did not
- 38:35have quite enough to grasp it. And rather than flaring
- 38:38into brilliance and then dying in some grand display, a
- 38:43brown dwarf does neither. It only fades endlessly, patiently, growing
- 38:49a little dimmer and a little cooler with each passing age,
- 38:53for spans of time longer than the universe has yet existed.
- 38:58There is no ending for it final act, only a
- 39:02slow and quiet dimming that goes on and on and on,
- 39:07and so they drift out there in the dark, the
- 39:10almost stars, too grand to be planets, too faint to
- 39:15be suns, glowing with the last warmth of a fire
- 39:18that never fully caught, cooling so slowly that on any
- 39:22scale we can feel, they seem hardly to change at all,
- 39:26dim embers alone in the great dark, holding what little
- 39:30light they have and letting it go so gently you
- 39:34would never see it fade. The biggest stars die the youngest.
- 39:43It is one of the strangest truths in the whole
- 39:46life story of the stars, and it runs against everything
- 39:50our instincts tell us. You would think that a star
- 39:54with more fuel would live longer, that the great, heavy,
- 39:57brilliant giants with so much mo more material to burn
- 40:01would shine on for far greater spans than the small
- 40:05and modest ones. But the opposite is true, and dramatically so.
- 40:12The most massive stars live the shortest lives of all,
- 40:16and the smallest, faintest stars are the ones that endure
- 40:20almost without end. To understand why, picture two stars side
- 40:25by side. One is a giant many times the mass
- 40:29of our sun, hundreds of times brighter, a fierce blue
- 40:32white beacon, blazing in the dark. The other is a
- 40:35small red star, a fraction of the Sun's mass, glowing
- 40:39dim and cool and quiet. The giant does indeed hold
- 40:45far more fuel, but it burns through that fuel at
- 40:48a furious, almost reckless pace, pouring out light so lavishly
- 40:53that for all its greater store, it empties itself astonishingly fast.
- 40:59The life little red star, by contrast, is endlessly frugal.
- 41:04It sits at its fuel, burning so gently and so
- 41:08slowly that it can keep its small flame alive for
- 41:11an almost unimaginable length of time. The numbers, when you
- 41:16hold them up, are staggering. A star several times heavier
- 41:20than the Sun may burn through its entire life in
- 41:24only a few tens of millions of years, a mere flicker.
- 41:28By the measure of the cosmos. The very largest stars,
- 41:32the rare and enormous giants, can race through their whole
- 41:36existence in just a few million years, flaring brilliantly and
- 41:41then dying, while the universe around them has scarcely aged
- 41:45at all. Our own Sun, a modest middleweight takes a
- 41:50far gentler path, something close to ten billion years from
- 41:54birth to death, with roughly half of that still ahead
- 41:58of it. But the small red stars are the true
- 42:02champions of endurance. The faintest of them can shine on
- 42:07for hundreds of billions, perhaps even trillions of years, far
- 42:13far longer than the entire age of the universe so far.
- 42:18And here is a thought that is almost difficult to
- 42:21hold in the mind. The universe, as best we can tell,
- 42:25is somewhere near fourteen billion years old. That sounds like
- 42:29an eternity. And yet it is not nearly long enough
- 42:33for even a single one of those small red stars
- 42:37to have reached the end of its life. Not one.
- 42:41Every dim red dwarf that has ever formed in all
- 42:45the long history of the cosmos is still out there, shining,
- 42:49with vast ages of life still ahead of it. They
- 42:53are so frugal, so patient, that the universe itself has
- 42:57not yet existed long enough to watch even the oldest
- 43:01of them grow old. They will still be glowing quietly
- 43:06long after stars like our sun have come and gone.
- 43:11There is a way to read this whole story, written
- 43:14right into the colors of the stars, if you know
- 43:16how to look. The color of a star is a
- 43:20quiet announcement of how hot it burns and so in
- 43:24its way of how it will live and die. The
- 43:28blue white stars are the fierce and massive ones, blazing hottest,
- 43:33doomed to the shortest lives. The yellow stars, like our
- 43:37own sun, burn cooler and steadier and last far longer.
- 43:42And the deep red stars are the coolest and smallest,
- 43:46the frugal ones, the ones that will outlast nearly everything.
- 43:51So on a clear night, when you find a star
- 43:53with a faint blue cast, you are gazing at something
- 43:57brilliant and fleeting. And when you findind one glowing soft
- 44:01and red, you may be looking at a star that
- 44:04will still be shining long after the blue one and
- 44:08the sun, and perhaps even the Earth have faded into
- 44:12the dark. There is a quiet lesson hiding in this
- 44:17if you care to find one. The brightest stars, the
- 44:21ones that burn most fiercely and shine most gloriously, are
- 44:25precisely the ones whose lives are shortest. Their brilliance is
- 44:30bought at the price of their brevity. And the small, dim,
- 44:34unremarkable stars, the ones that would never catch your eye,
- 44:39that glow so faintly you might never notice them at all,
- 44:42are the ones that endure almost forever. It is a
- 44:47strange arithmetic, and not always a fair seeming one, that
- 44:52splendor and longevity should pull so firmly in opposite directions,
- 44:57that to shine the brightest is somehow to burn out
- 45:00the soonest. You can picture them together, the two ends
- 45:06of this great divide, the brilliant giant, blazing blue, white
- 45:11and furious, magnificent and doomed, pouring out more light in
- 45:16a single moment than its small cousin will manage in
- 45:19an age, and destined to be gone in the blink
- 45:22of a cosmic eye. And beside it, in the mind's eye,
- 45:27the little red ember, modest and slow and almost shy
- 45:31in its faint glow, asking so little of itself that
- 45:35will still be quietly burning long after the giant has died,
- 45:39long after our own sun is gone, perhaps long after
- 45:43almost everything else we know has faded into the dark.
- 45:47It is a gentle thing to rest on here, in
- 45:50the quiet, that the loudest light goes first, that the
- 45:55softest endures, and that somewhere out there, even now, a
- 46:00small red star is shining its patient, frugal shine, utterly unhurried,
- 46:06in no danger at all, with more time ahead of
- 46:09it than the whole history of everything that has yet
- 46:13come to pass. For almost the whole of its life,
- 46:19a star does nothing dramatic at all. We love to
- 46:23tell the story of how stars are born, with all
- 46:26its gathering and collapsing and the first great kindling of fire,
- 46:31and we love to tell the story of how they die,
- 46:34with all the drama that brings. But between those two
- 46:39bright moments lies something we rarely speak of, something far
- 46:43longer and far quieter than either. The vast middle, the long,
- 46:49calm prime of a star's life, when it simply shines,
- 46:54steady and even, asking nothing and changing almost not at all.
- 47:00And when I say this middle is long, I mean
- 47:02it is long beyond any easy reckoning. For a star
- 47:06like our sun. The fierce drama of birth is over
- 47:09in a cosmic eye blink, and the drama of its
- 47:12eventual death will be over quickly too. But the calm
- 47:17stretch in between lasts something close to ten billion years,
- 47:22ten billion years of just shining. It is by far
- 47:26the greatest part of any star's existence, so much so
- 47:30that if you could glance at the sky at some
- 47:33random moment in the long history of the universe, nearly
- 47:36every star you saw would be living out this quiet,
- 47:40steady middle, neither being born nor dying, simply burning on
- 47:47our own Sun is there right now. It is something
- 47:51like four and a half billion years old, which means
- 47:54it has already spent a span of time we can
- 47:58hardly imagine doing nothing more than this rising and setting,
- 48:03warming the Earth, holding its planets close, pouring out the
- 48:08same gentle light morning after morning. And it sits, as
- 48:11best we can tell, at roughly the midpoint of its calm.
- 48:16Around half of its long, steady life is behind it,
- 48:19around half still lies ahead. The Sun, in a sense,
- 48:24is in the unhurried middle of its days. What makes
- 48:28this possible is a balance held with extraordinary patience. Deepen
- 48:33the star's core fusion pours energy outward, and that outward
- 48:38push presses back exactly against the inward pull of the
- 48:42star's own enormous weight. The two forces lean against each
- 48:47other so evenly that the star neither swells nor shrinks,
- 48:52but simply holds its shape and glows. And the truly
- 48:56remarkable thing is how forgiving that balance is. Should the
- 49:00core ever burn a touch too hot, the star eases
- 49:04outward just slightly and cools itself back down. Should it
- 49:10ever cool a touch too much, it settles inward just slightly,
- 49:14and warms itself back up, over and over, without thought,
- 49:18without effort, the star corrects itself, nudging, always back towards steadiness.
- 49:24It is this quiet, self tending that lets a star
- 49:27shine on calm and even for ages without end. That
- 49:32is not to say nothing changes at all across these
- 49:36vast spans. A star, like the Sun, does, brighten very slowly,
- 49:42so slowly that the change would be utterly invisible across
- 49:45any human life, or even across the whole span of
- 49:49human history. When the Sun was young, long before the
- 49:53Earth had oceans or air worth breathing, it shone noticeably
- 49:58fainter than it does to day, and it will go
- 50:01on brightening by the gentlest of degrees across the ages
- 50:05still to come. But this is change measured against the
- 50:09clock of the cosmos, not against ours. To anything that
- 50:14lives and dies as quickly as we do, the Sun
- 50:18is simply constant, the same warm presence it has always been,
- 50:23and it is worth remembering what that long steadiness makes
- 50:27possible life. As far as we know, it needs time,
- 50:32vast and unhurried time to take hold and unfold it
- 50:37took billions of years for the first faint living things
- 50:40on earth to slowly become forests and creatures, and eventually us.
- 50:46None of that could have happened around a star that
- 50:49flickered or flared or changed its mood from age to age.
- 50:54It could only happen around a star content to shine
- 50:57the same way, deadly and reliably for an almost unthinkable
- 51:03span of time. The long calm of a star is
- 51:08not merely an empty waiting. It is the very stillness
- 51:12in which worlds grow quiet enough and steady enough for
- 51:16life to slowly begin. There is something quietly moving in
- 51:20that constancy. If you let yourself feel it. We tend
- 51:24to be drawn to the dramatic moments, the beginnings and
- 51:28the endings, the flares and the collapses. Those are the
- 51:32stories worth telling, we think. And yet the deepest truth
- 51:37of a star's existence is not found in those rare
- 51:40and violent instants. It is found here in the long calm,
- 51:45in the patient, faithful, almost uneventful work of simply shining,
- 51:50held steady for billions of years. Most of what a star, ever, is,
- 51:56it is quietly. And so the sun goes on as
- 51:59it has for an age, and as it will for
- 52:02an age more the same light it gave to the
- 52:05first living things in the sea, the same light that
- 52:09will fall on whatever comes long after us, rising and setting,
- 52:14warming and holding, asking for nothing, a steady glow in
- 52:18the dark, kept faithfully alight in the long and unhurried
- 52:23middle of its days. By the strict rules of physics,
- 52:30the sun should not be able to shine. It is
- 52:33a strange thing to say about the most familiar object
- 52:36in our sky, the very source of nearly all our
- 52:40light and warmth. And yet if you take the ordinary,
- 52:45common sense laws that govern the everyday world and apply
- 52:49them carefully to the heart of the Sun, you reach
- 52:52a baffling conclusion. The Sun's core, hot as it is,
- 52:57simply is not hot enough to burn. By those rules,
- 53:01it should be dark. To see the problem, you have
- 53:05to look at what fusion actually asks of the matter
- 53:08inside a star. The sun shines by pressing the tiny
- 53:13cores of hydrogen atoms together until they merge and become helium,
- 53:17releasing energy as they join. But these cores each carry
- 53:22a positive electric charge. And you may remember, perhaps from
- 53:27playing with magnets as a child, how stubbornly like charges
- 53:31push one another apart. The closer you bring two of them,
- 53:36the harder they shove back. To force two hydrogen cores
- 53:41close enough to actually merge, you have to overcome that
- 53:45fierce repulsion, and that takes tremendous speed, which is to say,
- 53:50tremendous heat. The center of the sun is staggeringly hot,
- 53:56somewhere around fifteen million degrees. I think that would be
- 54:01more than enough. But when you do the careful arithmetic,
- 54:05you find that even at fifteen million degrees, the hydrogen
- 54:09cores are moving far too slowly. They approach one another,
- 54:14they feel that mounting electrical shove, and they are turned
- 54:18back long before they ever touch. By the plain rules
- 54:23of the everyday world, the particles in the Sun's heart
- 54:26should simply bounce off each other again and again forever,
- 54:31and never fuse at all. The fire should never light,
- 54:36and yet the sun shines. So what is really happening.
- 54:42The answer lies in one of the deepest and strangest
- 54:45truths we have ever uncovered about reality, a truth that
- 54:49only reveals itself at the very smallest scales of nature,
- 54:55down in the world of the tiniest particles. Things do
- 54:58not behave with the sun. Solid certainty we are used to.
- 55:02A particle is not quite a hard little ball sitting
- 55:06in one definite place. It is something blurrier, hazier, more
- 55:11like a faint smear of possibility, spread thinly across a
- 55:16small region of space. And because of that haziness, a
- 55:20particle can sometimes turn up where it has no business being.
- 55:24It can appear on the far side of a barrier
- 55:27it never had the energy to climb over. This gentle
- 55:31ghostliness has a name. We call it tunneling. Picture a
- 55:36ball that does not have enough push to roll up
- 55:39and over a hill, and yet every so often simply
- 55:43finds itself on the other side, as though it had
- 55:47quietly slipped through the hill, rather than over it. In
- 55:51the world we live in, that never happens. But in
- 55:55the world of the very small it happens all the time,
- 55:59and it is exactly what allows the sun to shine.
- 56:04The hydrogen cores in the Sun's heart cannot, by rights
- 56:08get close enough to merge, but every now and then,
- 56:12by the faint and patient magic of tunneling, one of
- 56:15them slips through the wall of repulsion it could never cross,
- 56:19and finds itself near enough to fuse. After all, it
- 56:23almost never happens for any single particle. The odds in
- 56:28anyone encounter are vanishingly small. But the Sun's core holds
- 56:33an unimaginable number of particles colliding an unimaginable number of times,
- 56:39and across all those countless tries, the rare miracle becomes
- 56:43a steady, reliable trickle. Enough fusion sparks to light a star,
- 56:49enough to warm a world, enough in time to make you.
- 56:54In fact, the whole process is so reluctant, so delicately improbable,
- 57:00that it unfolds with astonishing slowness. And that slowness is
- 57:04a quiet blessing. Because the Sun burns its fuel so grudgingly,
- 57:10dribbling out its energy a little at a time rather
- 57:13than all at once, it can keep shining steadily for
- 57:17billions upon billions of years, a more eager star would
- 57:22have spent itself long ago. It is the very difficulty
- 57:26of fusion, the very fact that it should barely be
- 57:30possible at all, that gives the Sun its long and
- 57:33gentle life. There is something humbling in this when you
- 57:37sit with it, the warmth on your face, the light
- 57:41that fills your days, the sheer ordinary reliability of the
- 57:45sun in the sky. All of it rests on a
- 57:48ghostly quantum trick, a faint slipping through that, by the
- 57:53rules we live among, should not happen at all. The
- 57:57most dependable thing in our world is built upon one
- 58:01of the least intuitive truths in all of nature. Reality,
- 58:06it turns out, is stranger and far more generous at
- 58:10its smallest scales than our ordinary eyes could ever guess.
- 58:15And so deep in the heart of the sun, the
- 58:18quiet magic goes on this very moment, as it has
- 58:22for ages, countless, tiny particles, drawn close, and turned away,
- 58:27and drawn close again, and here and there, against all
- 58:31the odds, one of them gently passing through a wall
- 58:35it could never climb, joining with another, and giving off
- 58:39a small flicker of light, Trillions upon trillions of those
- 58:44small flickers, all together becoming the steady glow that warms
- 58:49you now. The warmth on your skin today is far
- 58:55far older than this morning. Sunlight feels like the most
- 58:59immediate thing in the world. You step outside, and there
- 59:04it is, falling on your face, warming your hands, seeming
- 59:08to arrive in the very instant the sun clears the horizon.
- 59:13It feels new, fresh born, just now, But the truth
- 59:17hidden inside That warmth is one of the loveliest in
- 59:20all of nature, and it has to do with deep,
- 59:23deep time. The light that warms you does, in one sense,
- 59:28arrive quickly once it leaves the bright surface of the
- 59:32Sun and races across the emptiness toward the Earth. It
- 59:36makes the whole journey, nearly one hundred million miles of it,
- 59:40in only about eight minutes. So the sunlight touching you
- 59:45at any given moment did indeed leave the Sun's surface
- 59:49just eight minutes ago. If the Sun were somehow to vanish,
- 59:54you would go on feeling its warmth and seeing its
- 59:58light for those eight final minutes before the sky went dark.
- 1:00:05But here's the secret. That eight minute dash across space
- 1:00:09is only the very last easy step of a journey
- 1:00:12that began an unimaginably long time before. Because the energy
- 1:00:17in that sunlight was not made at the Sun's surface.
- 1:00:21It was made far below deep in the Sun's core
- 1:00:25where fusion burns. And getting out from that core to
- 1:00:28the surface that is the hard part. That is the
- 1:00:32part that takes an age to understand. Why picture the
- 1:00:37inside of the sun not as open and clear, but
- 1:00:40as almost impossibly crowded and dense the energy borne in
- 1:00:45the core tries to travel outward, but it cannot fly straight.
- 1:00:50Almost the instant it sets off, it slams into a
- 1:00:54particle and is swallowed, and then flung back out again
- 1:00:58in some random new direct A moment later, the same
- 1:01:02thing happens, and again and again. The energy does not
- 1:01:08journey outward so much as stagger lurching this way in that,
- 1:01:12taking one tiny blind step after another through a dense
- 1:01:16and endless crowd, knocked off course untold trillions of times.
- 1:01:21It is a little like trying to cross a vast hall,
- 1:01:24packed shoulder to shoulder with people, where every single step
- 1:01:29sends you carming off someone new, so that for all
- 1:01:33your motion you drift outward only the slightest bit at
- 1:01:37a time. And the sun is enormous. So this blind, staggering,
- 1:01:44endlessly deflected passage from the core to the surface takes
- 1:01:48a length of time that is genuinely hard to believe.
- 1:01:52By some careful estimates, it may take many thousands of years,
- 1:01:57By others, far longer stetill tens or even hundreds of
- 1:02:02thousands of years of bouncing and stumbling through the crowded
- 1:02:05dark just to climb from the Sun's heart to its
- 1:02:09shining surface. Only then, finally free, does the energy leap
- 1:02:14across space to reach you in its quick last eight minutes.
- 1:02:20I should be honest with you about one thing, because
- 1:02:24the truth is even stranger than the simple version. It
- 1:02:27is not really one single ray of light that survives
- 1:02:31the whole long passage. As the energy is swallowed and
- 1:02:35flung out over and over, it is changed and handed
- 1:02:39along from particle to particle, like a message whispered down
- 1:02:43an endless line. So it is the energy itself, more
- 1:02:47than any single unchanging beam, that carries this deep antiquity
- 1:02:52within it, that that makes the wonder no smaller. The
- 1:02:57warmth you feel still rose from a fire that was
- 1:03:01burning before this morning by an almost incomprehensible stretch of time.
- 1:03:07Let yourself sit with what that means. The light that
- 1:03:11warms your face today may have begun its slow climb
- 1:03:15out of the sart in an age when great sheets
- 1:03:18of ice still lay across much of the earth, when
- 1:03:22the world looked utterly unlike the one you know, and
- 1:03:26no city and no written word yet existed anywhere upon
- 1:03:30it that ancient energy has been working its way patiently
- 1:03:35outward through all the years since, through the whole long
- 1:03:39sweep of history, only to surface at last and cross
- 1:03:44the final gulf and arrive gently on your skin. Here now,
- 1:03:49in this quiet moment. There is a strange tenderness in
- 1:03:53being warmed by something so old. We think of sunlight
- 1:03:57as the very emblem of the present, of bright mornings
- 1:04:00and fresh beginnings, and yet every warm ray carries within
- 1:04:05it the patient labor of the distant past, a journey
- 1:04:09begun in a time long before anyone was here to
- 1:04:12feel it. The sun is, in a way, always reaching
- 1:04:17us out of its own deep history. So the next
- 1:04:20time you stand in the sun and feel that simple,
- 1:04:23ordinary warmth settle over you, you might remember what it truly is,
- 1:04:29not something new at all, but something ancient energy that
- 1:04:34waited an age and the crowded dark, stumbling slowly toward
- 1:04:38the light, so that one day, long after it set out,
- 1:04:41it could rest for a moment, soft and warm on you.
- 1:04:50When the sun finally runs out of fuel, it will
- 1:04:53not fade quietly away. It will swell. This is one
- 1:04:57of the great surprises in the life story of a star.
- 1:05:01We tend to imagine that when a fire runs low
- 1:05:04on fuel, it shrinks and dims and gutters out. But
- 1:05:08a star like the sun does something stranger and far grander.
- 1:05:12As it begins to die. It grows. It balloons outward,
- 1:05:17swelling into a vast, glowing giant, many times its present size,
- 1:05:22until it dwarfs the star it once was. The ending
- 1:05:26of such a star is not a fading at all.
- 1:05:29It is an enormous slow expansion. To picture how this happens,
- 1:05:34you have to look to the core, where the star
- 1:05:37has spent its whole long life fusing hydrogen into helium.
- 1:05:42Across billions of years, That core slowly fills with helium ash,
- 1:05:47the spent remains of the fire, until at last the
- 1:05:51hydrogen at the very center is all but gone. And
- 1:05:55here's where things turn surprising. With its central fire fault,
- 1:06:00the core can no longer push back hard enough against
- 1:06:03the crushing weight pressing in upon it, so the core
- 1:06:07begins to contract, squeezing tighter and growing hotter. But that
- 1:06:13rising heat kindles a fresh ring of fire in a
- 1:06:17shell of hydrogen wrapped around the shrinking core, and this
- 1:06:21new burning shell pours out energy so fiercely that it
- 1:06:25drives the entire outer body of the star outward in
- 1:06:29a great swelling tide, the heart contracts and the outer
- 1:06:34reaches balloon. The star grows vast, precisely because deep inside
- 1:06:41it has begun to fail. As it swells, its outer
- 1:06:45layers stretch thinner and cooler, and a cooler surface glows
- 1:06:49a deeper, softer red, So the dying giant is not
- 1:06:53a fierce blue white blaze, but something gentler to look upon,
- 1:06:57a huge, ruddy, slowly pulsive globe, glowing the warm color
- 1:07:02of an ember, vast and calm and strangely beautiful. A
- 1:07:07star like the Sun, in this stage can grow to
- 1:07:09many tens, even hundreds of times its former width. It
- 1:07:13is a transformation almost beyond imagining the modest yellow Sun
- 1:07:19we know blown up into a great red giant that
- 1:07:22would loom enormous in the sky. And this is where
- 1:07:26the story turns close to home, for our own Sun
- 1:07:30will one day do exactly this, some five billion years
- 1:07:34from now, a span so vast it can scarcely be felt,
- 1:07:39the Sun will swell into a red giant, expanding outward
- 1:07:43across the inner Solar system. It will almost certainly engulf
- 1:07:48the small, scorched world of Mercury, and then Venus swallowing
- 1:07:52them into its glowing bulk, and the Earth, our own Earth,
- 1:07:57sits right at the uncertain edge. The Sun may well
- 1:08:01grow large enough to swallow it too, drowning the whole
- 1:08:04of our world in its slow red fire. Or our
- 1:08:07planet may, by a narrow grace, escape being consumed and
- 1:08:12instead be left scorched and barren just beyond the giant's reach.
- 1:08:18Which of these will happen, scientists still genuinely debate, for
- 1:08:23it depends on subtle things, like how much of its
- 1:08:26own matter the swelling Sun sheds away, and how that
- 1:08:31loosens its gravitational grip on the planet circling it. We
- 1:08:36do not yet know the Earth's final fate with certainty,
- 1:08:40but either way, the gentle world we know will be
- 1:08:43long gone, transformed utterly by the slow death swelling of
- 1:08:48the star that gave it life. There is no need
- 1:08:52to feel any dread in this, though, my friend, the
- 1:08:56day lies an almost unimaginable distance away, billions of years
- 1:09:01from now, far beyond not only our own brief lives,
- 1:09:05but very likely beyond anything we would still recognize as ourselves.
- 1:09:11It is less a warning than a quiet fact about
- 1:09:14the deep shape of time, that even the sun, the
- 1:09:18very emblem of permanence, is living out a story with
- 1:09:21a final chapter, and that its ending will not be
- 1:09:25a whimper, but a vast and glowing expansion into the dark.
- 1:09:30It is a strange thought to rest on that a
- 1:09:33thing can grow largest at the very end. We so
- 1:09:37often imagine endings as a drawing in, a shrinking, a quiet,
- 1:09:42diminishing toward nothing. But a dying star does the opposite.
- 1:09:47It reaches outward, swelling grander and softer and redder than
- 1:09:51it ever was in all its long life, filling more
- 1:09:54of the sky than it ever filled before. Its death
- 1:09:58is an unfurling. Its ending is an opening out and
- 1:10:03so far in the future where the small, bright sun,
- 1:10:06once hung, there will instead glow a great red, giant,
- 1:10:10immense and unhurried, the warm color of a dying ember,
- 1:10:14pulsing gently against the dark, a star grown vast in
- 1:10:19its final age, casting its soft red light across a
- 1:10:23changed and silent solar system, taking its long, slow time
- 1:10:27to let go. When a star, like the sun, dies,
- 1:10:34it exhales a glowing ring of light into space. There
- 1:10:38are many ways for a star to come to its end,
- 1:10:42and some of them are violet, almost beyond comprehension. But
- 1:10:47the death of a gentle, ordinary star like our own
- 1:10:50sun is something altogether different. It is one of the
- 1:10:54loveliest sights in all the universe, a slow, quiet letting
- 1:10:59go that leaves behind a glowing shell of breath taking delicacy,
- 1:11:04like a soul of colored light cast softly into the dark.
- 1:11:09Here is how it comes to pass. As a star,
- 1:11:12like the sun, reaches the very end of its long life,
- 1:11:16its outer layers grow loose and unsettled, no longer held
- 1:11:20firmly to the star, and gently, over many thousands of years,
- 1:11:25the star begins to breathe them away, sloughing off its
- 1:11:29outermost shells of gas in slow expanding waves, like rings
- 1:11:34of smoke drifting outward from a single quiet source. What
- 1:11:38is left behind at the center is the star's bare,
- 1:11:41exposed heart, a tiny, fiercely hot core all that remains
- 1:11:46of the once mighty star, And that hot core pours
- 1:11:51out a flood of invisible light, a kind of light
- 1:11:54beyond the violet edge of what our eyes can see.
- 1:11:58As that flood washes over them, the expanding shells of
- 1:12:01gas drifting around it, it makes them glow, kindling the
- 1:12:06gas into soft luminous color, the way a hidden lamp
- 1:12:10can set a veil of mist alight. The result is
- 1:12:14one of the most beautiful objects in the heavens. These
- 1:12:18glowing shells take on the most extraordinary shapes, luminous rings
- 1:12:24and globes, delicate hour glasses, soft glowing eyes, intricate nested petals,
- 1:12:31like some cosmic flower opening in slow motion. They shine
- 1:12:36in tender colors, gentle greens and blues and reds, each
- 1:12:40one different, each one of fragile work of art painted
- 1:12:44in light and gas across the dark. If you have
- 1:12:48ever seen a photograph of one of these, a great
- 1:12:51glowing ring hanging in the blackness, or a vast luminous
- 1:12:55eye with a single bright point at its center, then
- 1:12:59you have seen the actual death of a star, like
- 1:13:02our sun, captured in its quiet beauty. There is a
- 1:13:07small curiosity in their name which says something about how
- 1:13:11we first came to know them. Long ago. When astronomers
- 1:13:15first glimpsed these glowing shapes through their early telescopes, they
- 1:13:20could make out only small, round, softly shining discs, and
- 1:13:26they thought these looked rather like the pale disks of
- 1:13:29distant planets, so they called them planetary nebulae, as though
- 1:13:35they had something to do with planets. They do not.
- 1:13:39The name was a gentle mistake born of dim and
- 1:13:43early eyes, and it has simply stuck through all the
- 1:13:46years since. These glowing shells have nothing to do with
- 1:13:51planets at all. They are the cast off breath of
- 1:13:54dying stars. Exactly why they take such intricate and varied
- 1:13:59shape is still, in part a quiet mystery. You might
- 1:14:04expect a star to puff out a simple, even sphere,
- 1:14:08like a balloon, swelling in every direction at once, and
- 1:14:12yet so many of these shells are anything but simple.
- 1:14:16Pinched into hourglasses, wound into spirals, sculpted into delicate, symmetrical wings.
- 1:14:24Scientists are still working to understand fully why. They suspect
- 1:14:29the answer lies in things like the spin of the
- 1:14:31dying star or its tangled magnetic fields, where the unseen
- 1:14:36tug of a companion star circling close by all of them,
- 1:14:40shaping the outflowing gas as it drifts away. But the
- 1:14:45full picture is not yet settled, and some of the
- 1:14:48loveliest of these shapes still hold their secrets, And there
- 1:14:53is a tenderness too, in how fleeting they are. For
- 1:14:57all their beauty, these glowing shells do not last. They
- 1:15:01drift outward and slowly thin and fade, dispersing into the
- 1:15:06wider dark over a span of merely tens of thousands
- 1:15:10of years, the briefest flicker by the measure of the cosmos,
- 1:15:15the star spends billions of years living, and then, in
- 1:15:18its dying, paints this one fragile, luminous thing that glows
- 1:15:23for only a cosmic moment before it scatters and is gone,
- 1:15:29a brief and beautiful farewell written in light across the night,
- 1:15:33and then quietly erased. There is something gentle to carry
- 1:15:37away from this if you like. We so often imagine
- 1:15:41death as something dark and grim, But here, at the
- 1:15:45close of an ordinary star's long life, the universe does
- 1:15:50something almost impossibly lovely. It takes the ending and makes
- 1:15:55it luminous. It turns a death into one of the
- 1:15:59most beautiful sights. There is a soft glow of color
- 1:16:03unfurling slowly in the dark, fragile, fleeting and quietly radiant,
- 1:16:09And so it hangs there for its little while, that
- 1:16:12glowing shell, a ring or a flower, or an eye
- 1:16:15of softly colored light, drifting gently outward into the black,
- 1:16:19with one tiny, fierce ember of a star glowing at
- 1:16:23its very heart, slowly fading, slowly dispersing a last, quiet,
- 1:16:29beautiful breath exhaled into the dark. A single spoonful of
- 1:16:37a dead star can weigh more than a truck. It
- 1:16:41sounds like something invented, a number made up to a maze,
- 1:16:45but it is simply true, and it describes one of
- 1:16:48the strangest objects in the universe, the small, dense, slowly
- 1:16:53cooling ember that a star like our sun leaves behind
- 1:16:57when its long life is finally over. We call it
- 1:17:01a white dwarf, and to understand it is to feel
- 1:17:04the floor of your intuition gently give way. Picture what
- 1:17:09happens at the very end. A star like the Sun,
- 1:17:13having lived out its life and gently shed its outer layers,
- 1:17:17leaves behind only its core, the bare exposed heart of
- 1:17:22the star. That heart no longer burns, the great fire
- 1:17:27that sustained it has gone out at last, and with
- 1:17:30no more energy pouring outward to hold it up, the
- 1:17:34core has nothing left to resist the crushing pull of
- 1:17:38its own gravity, so it collapses inward, squeezing down and
- 1:17:42down upon itself until something remarkable is left. Roughly the
- 1:17:47entire mass of a star, very nearly as heavy as
- 1:17:51the Sun, packed into a sphere no larger than the Earth.
- 1:17:57Let that settle for a moment. The Sun is wide
- 1:18:00enough to swallow a million earths, and a white dwarf
- 1:18:04takes very nearly all of the Sun's matter and crushes
- 1:18:07it into a ball the size of our small planet.
- 1:18:12The material inside is squeezed to a density almost impossible
- 1:18:16to picture, which is why that single spoonful of it
- 1:18:20would weigh as much as a heavy truck here on Earth,
- 1:18:23and why a small bucketful would outweigh a mountain. It
- 1:18:28is quite simply some of the densest matter found anywhere
- 1:18:32in nature. Now, you might wonder, if the fire has
- 1:18:37gone out and there is nothing burning to push back,
- 1:18:41what stops the collapse? Why does the core not simply
- 1:18:45keep falling in upon itself, forever crushed smaller and smaller
- 1:18:50without end. The answer is one of the deepest and
- 1:18:54most surprising truths in all of physics. What holds a
- 1:18:59white dwarf up is something far stranger than heat or
- 1:19:03fire or any force you would ever meet in everyday life.
- 1:19:08It is a deep rule from the hidden world of
- 1:19:11the very small, a law of nature which says that
- 1:19:15the tiniest particles within the star simply refuse to be
- 1:19:19packed too closely together. Crowd then past a certain point,
- 1:19:24and they push back with a fierce and unyielding resistance,
- 1:19:29not because they are hot, but simply because that crowding
- 1:19:33is forbidden by the deep rules of how matter is
- 1:19:36allowed to be. It is a kind of quantum stubbornness,
- 1:19:41an invisible defiance written into the very fabric of the
- 1:19:45particles themselves, and it is the one thing standing between
- 1:19:49the dead star and total collapse, a delicate, ghostly pressure
- 1:19:55holding up the weight of a whole crushed sun. When
- 1:19:59a white dwarf is first laid bare, it is searingly hot,
- 1:20:04glowing a brilliant white from the leftover warmth of the
- 1:20:07star it once was. But it has no fire left
- 1:20:12to renew that heat, and so it can only do
- 1:20:15one thing. Slowly, across the longest stretches of time imaginable,
- 1:20:20it cools like a coal pulled from a dying hearth
- 1:20:24and set aside. It gives up its warmth little by
- 1:20:28little into the cold of space. Fading gradually from white
- 1:20:32to yellow to a deep and sullen red, growing dimmer
- 1:20:36and dimmer over billions upon billions of years. It is
- 1:20:40a long, patient, gentle fading, the quiet afterglow of a
- 1:20:45star ebbing slowly toward dark. And there is one more
- 1:20:48wonder hidden inside these cooling embers, though I will tell
- 1:20:53it to you carefully the way the science asks. As
- 1:20:57a white dwarf cools the matter deep within, it is
- 1:21:01thought to begin settling into an ordered crystalline pattern, the
- 1:21:06particles arranging themselves into a vast, regular structure, almost as
- 1:21:11water freezes into ice. Because that interior is rich in carbon.
- 1:21:16People sometimes speak with a poet's license of a dying
- 1:21:21star slowly turning into something like an enormous diamond in
- 1:21:25the sky. The truth is more subtle than the lovely
- 1:21:29image suggests, and the crystal of a white dwarf is
- 1:21:32not really a jewel you could ever hold in your hand.
- 1:21:36But the heart of the idea does rest on real evidence.
- 1:21:40These dead stars do appear to crystallize as they cool,
- 1:21:44turning slowly over unimaginable ages into something solid and ordered
- 1:21:50and still. It is a strange and quiet fate to
- 1:21:55sit with a star that once blazed for billions of years,
- 1:21:59that warmed worlds and lit up the dark, ending its
- 1:22:03days as a small, dense, slowly freezing ember, held together
- 1:22:08by nothing more than a ghostly rule of the quantum world,
- 1:22:12cooling so gradually that it will go on glowing faintly
- 1:22:16for longer than the universe has yet existed. There is
- 1:22:20no violence in it, and no drama, only a long,
- 1:22:24soft fade towards stillness. And so it rests there in
- 1:22:28the dark, the dead heart of a star, Earth sized,
- 1:22:33impossibly heavy, glowing, faint and patient against the black, slowly cooling,
- 1:22:39slowly dimming, slowly turning to crystal and quiet, taking all
- 1:22:44the time in the universe to fade gently towards sleep.
- 1:22:51There is a kind of star that does not exist
- 1:22:54yet anywhere in the universe. This is not because it
- 1:22:58is rare or hidden or too far away to see.
- 1:23:02It is because the universe itself is still far too
- 1:23:06young to have made even a single one. These stars
- 1:23:10are written into the laws of physics, predicted with quiet confidence,
- 1:23:15waiting in the deep future, and yet not one of
- 1:23:18them has ever existed in all the time that has
- 1:23:21passed since the beginning. We call them black dwarfs, and
- 1:23:26to understand them is to peer further into the future
- 1:23:30than almost anything else we know how to imagine. To
- 1:23:34see where they come from, picture the small ember that
- 1:23:38a star like our sun leaves behind when it dies.
- 1:23:42After such a star has lived out its long life
- 1:23:45and gently let go of its outer layers, what remains
- 1:23:49at the center is its bare, exposed heart, a small, dense,
- 1:23:54fiercely hot sphere, roughly the mass of the Sun, packed
- 1:23:59into a ball no bigger than the Earth. When it
- 1:24:02is first laid bare, this dead heart glows a brilliant white,
- 1:24:07lit by all the left over warmth of the star
- 1:24:09it once was. But its fire has gone out. It
- 1:24:13makes no new heat, and so it can only do
- 1:24:16one thing across the long ages to come cool. It
- 1:24:21cools the way a coal cools after it is lifted
- 1:24:25from the fire, giving up its warmth slowly into the
- 1:24:28cold around it. But a dead star is so hot
- 1:24:32and holds its heat so stubbornly that this cooling takes
- 1:24:36a length of time almost beyond comprehension. It fades over
- 1:24:41billions of years, from white to yellow to orange to
- 1:24:45a deep and sullen, red, dimming all the while, and
- 1:24:49then it keeps fading, growing redder and dimmer still for
- 1:24:53longer and longer stretches of time. Only at the very
- 1:24:58end of this almost endless, when the last of its
- 1:25:01warmth has finally drained away and it no longer glows
- 1:25:05at all, not even faintly, does it become a black dwarf,
- 1:25:10a cold, dark, silent sphere, the fully extinguished cinder of
- 1:25:15a star. Now Here is the part that is difficult
- 1:25:19to hold in the mind. How long does it take
- 1:25:22for a dead star to cool all the way down
- 1:25:24to darkness like this? The answer is something on the
- 1:25:28order of a thousand trillion years, perhaps even longer. It
- 1:25:33is a span of time so vast that our ordinary
- 1:25:37words begin to fail us. And the universe, as best
- 1:25:41we can tell, has so far existed for only about
- 1:25:44fourteen billion years. Set those two numbers side by side,
- 1:25:50and you find that the universe has lived through only
- 1:25:53the tiniest sliver of the time. It would take for
- 1:25:56even one black dwarf to form action of a percent
- 1:26:02far less than that. And so the simple, astonishing truth
- 1:26:05is this, There are no black dwarfs, not one anywhere
- 1:26:11in all of existence, Every single dead star that has
- 1:26:15ever formed in the entire history of the cosmos is
- 1:26:19still warm enough to glow, still slowly cooling, still ages
- 1:26:24upon ages away from going fully dark. The black dwarf
- 1:26:29is real in our understanding and certain in our physics,
- 1:26:33and yet it remains for now purely a thing of
- 1:26:36the future, a kind of object the universe has simply
- 1:26:40not yet had the time to create. There is something
- 1:26:44quietly profound in that, if you let yourself rest on it.
- 1:26:49We are so used to thinking of science as the
- 1:26:52study of what is of stars. We can see of
- 1:26:56things that are out there right now. But here's a
- 1:26:59thing that we can describe in detail and speak of
- 1:27:02with confidence that has never existed and will not exist
- 1:27:07for an almost unimaginable stretch of time. It is less
- 1:27:12a discovery than a kind of prophecy, a glimpse of
- 1:27:16the deep, deep future of the universe, when the bright
- 1:27:20era of shining stars has long since passed, and the dark,
- 1:27:24cold cinders of dead suns drift quietly through a far
- 1:27:28older and dimmer cosmos than the one we know. Picture
- 1:27:33that far off time, if you gently can the galaxies
- 1:27:37grown ancient, the last of the bright stars, long since
- 1:27:41burned out and scattered through the immense dark, The cold
- 1:27:45black embers of stars that died unthinkable ages before, sphere
- 1:27:50after silence, sphere, no longer glowing, simply drifting, holding the
- 1:27:55last cold memory of the fire they once were. It
- 1:27:59is a vision of an almost perfect stillness waiting at
- 1:28:02the far end of time. But not yet. For now,
- 1:28:07every dead star in the sky is still glowing, still warm,
- 1:28:12still slowly fading through the long red twilight of its cooling.
- 1:28:16The great darkness lies ahead of them, in eternity away,
- 1:28:21and so the black dwarfs wait, patient and unborn, in
- 1:28:25a future so distant that the universe itself has scarcely begun.
- 1:28:29The journey there not gone, not yet here, only waiting
- 1:28:34quietly in the deep future for a cold that has
- 1:28:37not yet come. A star's entire fate comes down in
- 1:28:45the end to a single number. It is a strange
- 1:28:49and beautiful thing that the universe should work this way,
- 1:28:53that whether a dying star fades away in gentle peace
- 1:28:57or tears itself apart in unimaginable violence, should be decided
- 1:29:02so cleanly by something as simple and exact as a number.
- 1:29:08But it is true. There is a precise line drawn
- 1:29:12across the masses of the stars, and which side of
- 1:29:15that line a star falls on determines, with almost no
- 1:29:19room for argument, how it will need its end. To
- 1:29:23understand the line, you have to picture what holds up
- 1:29:27the dead heart of a star. When a star, like
- 1:29:30the Sun dies, its core is left behind, no longer burning,
- 1:29:36with nothing left to push back against the crushing weight
- 1:29:39of its own gravity. You might think it would simply
- 1:29:43collapse away into nothing. But something stops it, something strange
- 1:29:48and quiet, drawn from the hidden rules of the very
- 1:29:52small deep within that crushed matter. The tiniest particles refuse
- 1:29:58to be packed too closely together. Press them past a
- 1:30:02certain point, and they push back with a fierce and
- 1:30:06unyielding resistance, not because they are hot, but simply because
- 1:30:11nature forbids them to be crowded any tighter. It is
- 1:30:16this quiet defiance, this refusal of the smallest particles to
- 1:30:21be squeezed beyond a certain limit, that holds the dead
- 1:30:24star up and keeps it from falling in upon itself.
- 1:30:29But that resistance has its limits. It can hold up
- 1:30:32only so much weight, and this is where the magic
- 1:30:36number comes.
- 1:30:36Speaker 2: In.
- 1:30:38Speaker 1: If the dead core weighs less than about one and
- 1:30:41a half times the mass of our Sun, then that
- 1:30:44quiet quantum stubbornness is strong enough to win. The core
- 1:30:48settles into a stable, dense ember, and it will simply
- 1:30:53rest there, cooling slowly and gently, for ages upon ages,
- 1:30:59a peaceful death. But if the core weighs even a
- 1:31:02little more than that, more than roughly one and a
- 1:31:05half suns, then the weight becomes too great. The stubborn
- 1:31:10resistance of the particles is overwhelmed, it can no longer hold,
- 1:31:15and the core, having lost its last defense, collapses catastrophically
- 1:31:21in a fraction of a second, setting off one of
- 1:31:24the most violent events the universe has ever known, one
- 1:31:28and a half times the mass of the Sun. That
- 1:31:31is the line on one side, a gentle fading into
- 1:31:35the long dark, on the other, a cataclysm. The whole
- 1:31:40difference between a quiet ending and a violent one rests
- 1:31:44on whether a dying star carries a little less or
- 1:31:48a little more than that single quantity of matter. What
- 1:31:53I find most wonderful about this number is the story
- 1:31:57of how we came to know it. It was worked
- 1:31:59out nearly a century ago by a young man of
- 1:32:03just nineteen or twenty years old. He was traveling by
- 1:32:07ship from his home in India to study in England,
- 1:32:11a long sea voyage of many days across the open ocean,
- 1:32:15and somewhere out on that water, with nothing but the
- 1:32:18waves around him and time on his hands, this young
- 1:32:22man took up his pen and worked through the mathematics
- 1:32:25of how a dead star holds itself up, and found,
- 1:32:29to his quiet astonishment, that there was a limit that,
- 1:32:34above a certain mass, no dead star could survive. He
- 1:32:39had glimpsed the very line that divides the fates of
- 1:32:42the stars, and he had done it as a teenager
- 1:32:46alone at the rail of a ship in the middle
- 1:32:49of the sea. For a long while, the great and
- 1:32:54established scientists of the day did not want to believe him.
- 1:32:59The idea seen too strange, too troubling, that a star
- 1:33:03could be doomed by its own weight to collapse beyond
- 1:33:06all saving. His result was doubted and dismissed, and argued against.
- 1:33:12But the young man's mathematics was sound, and the universe,
- 1:33:17it turned out, agreed with him. We call it the
- 1:33:21Chandra Sekhar limit. Now after that young man at the
- 1:33:25rail of the ship and it stands today as one
- 1:33:28of the deep and settled truths of how stars live
- 1:33:32and die. There is something that stirs the heart in
- 1:33:35that image, the young person far from home catching sight
- 1:33:40of a profound and hidden truth that the wisest minds
- 1:33:44of the age had missed, simply by following the mathematics
- 1:33:48wherever it led. It is a quiet reminder that the
- 1:33:52universe keeps even its deepest secrets out in the open, waiting,
- 1:33:57and that sometimes it is the patient and the unafraid
- 1:34:01who first catch sight of them, and the number itself
- 1:34:05goes on quietly governing the heavens, indifferent to who found it.
- 1:34:12Every star that has ever died has been sorted by it,
- 1:34:16without exception, weighed against that single threshold and sent toward
- 1:34:21one fate or the other, a gentle line drawn by
- 1:34:25nature across the masses of the stars, dividing all the
- 1:34:28dying suns in the sky into the peaceful and the violent, exact,
- 1:34:35silent and settled, long before any of us were ever
- 1:34:38here to wonder at it. For a few weeks, a
- 1:34:45single dying star can outshine an entire galaxy. Think about
- 1:34:50what that means. A galaxy holds hundreds of billions of stars,
- 1:34:55a vast city of suns spread across distances the mind
- 1:35:00can barely hold. And yet when one giant star comes
- 1:35:04to the end of its life and explodes, that single
- 1:35:07death can blaze so brightly that for a little while
- 1:35:11it pours out more light than all those hundreds of
- 1:35:14billions of stars put together, one point in the dark,
- 1:35:19briefly outshining everything around it. This is a supernova, and
- 1:35:24it is among the most violent and most magnificent events
- 1:35:28the universe has ever produced. It happens only to the giants,
- 1:35:33the great massive stars, many times heavier than our sun,
- 1:35:37that burn through their lives in a furious blaze and
- 1:35:41die young. Such as star spends its whole existence holding
- 1:35:45itself up by the outward push of the fire and
- 1:35:48its core. But when that fire finally falters and goes out,
- 1:35:55there is nothing left to resist the inward crush of
- 1:35:58the star's own colossal wind, and so the core collapses,
- 1:36:03not slowly and not gently, but all at once, falling
- 1:36:07inward upon itself in less than a single second, an
- 1:36:11entire core's worth of matter plunging together at a sizeable
- 1:36:15fraction of the speed of light. Then it stops abruptly
- 1:36:20and violently. The collapsing core slams into itself and is
- 1:36:25crushed about as far as nature will allow, becoming in
- 1:36:29an instant almost impossibly rigid and dense, and the rest
- 1:36:35of the star, still rushing inward, slams down onto that
- 1:36:39suddenly unyielding heart and rebounds. A titanic shock tears back
- 1:36:45outward through the body of the star, and in a
- 1:36:48matter of moments, the whole, vast, outer bulk of it
- 1:36:51is blown apart and flung into space, hurled outward at
- 1:36:55speeds that scatter the wreckage across light years. The star
- 1:37:00is torn open and its insides are cast out into
- 1:37:04the dark in a flash of light bright enough to
- 1:37:07be seen clear across the universe. And here's the part
- 1:37:12that turns this violence into something almost sacred. In the
- 1:37:18unimaginable heat and pressure of that explosion, new elements are forged,
- 1:37:24heavier kinds of matter, cooked into being in the fury
- 1:37:28of the blast, and then they are scattered outward, seeded
- 1:37:32into the surrounding darkness, mingling into the thin gas that
- 1:37:36drifts between the stars. The iron and the other heavy
- 1:37:40materials that come to wander through space that one day
- 1:37:45gather into new worlds that become the very stuff of
- 1:37:48planets and oceans and living things. Much of it is
- 1:37:52borne here in the death explosions of giant stars. The
- 1:37:57most violent ending in all of nature, turns out to
- 1:38:00be one of its most creative acts. A star tears
- 1:38:05itself apart, and in doing so, it sows the seeds
- 1:38:09of everything that will come after. These explosions are rare
- 1:38:13in any one galaxy, flaring up only now and then
- 1:38:17across the long centuries, but every so often one has
- 1:38:23blazed close enough for human eyes to witness. Nearly a
- 1:38:28thousand years ago, in the year ten fifty four, watchers
- 1:38:32of the sky in China and elsewhere recorded this sudden
- 1:38:36appearance of a brilliant new star, so bright that for
- 1:38:39several weeks it could be seen even in broad daylight,
- 1:38:43shining against the blue. Then slowly it faded, and after
- 1:38:47a time it vanished from view altogether. What they had
- 1:38:52seen was a giant star dying a supernova far across
- 1:38:56the galaxy. And if you look today at the very
- 1:39:00place in the sky where that new star once blazed,
- 1:39:03you find a beautiful, tangled cloud of glowing wreckage, still
- 1:39:08drifting outward into space nearly a thousand years on, the
- 1:39:12scattered remains of that ancient death. There is something that
- 1:39:18stirs deep in the chest at the thought of it,
- 1:39:22that a star's death could be so bright that ordinary
- 1:39:26people would stop and stare and write it down a
- 1:39:29thousand years ago, that the same explosions which tear stars
- 1:39:34apart are the very forges that made the iron in
- 1:39:38our blood and the calcium in our bones. The universe
- 1:39:43builds its most precious things in its most violent moments,
- 1:39:48and then scatters them gently across the ages, waiting for
- 1:39:52them to gather again into something new. And so it
- 1:39:56blazes for its little while, a single dying giant, brighter
- 1:40:01than a hundred billion suns, a fierce new point of
- 1:40:04light hanging in the dark. And then slowly, over the
- 1:40:08following weeks, it dims and softens and fades, settling at
- 1:40:14last into a quiet, expanding cloud of glowing debris drifting
- 1:40:19outward into the night, a death that lit up the heavens,
- 1:40:23sinking gently back into the dark, leaving its scattered gifts behind.
- 1:40:31At this very moment, trillions of ghostly particles are passing
- 1:40:36straight through your body, and you cannot feel a single one.
- 1:40:41They stream through you, constantly, silently, by the countless trillions
- 1:40:47every second, tiny phantoms of matter, pouring out of the
- 1:40:51sun and racing across space in every direction. They pass
- 1:40:57through your skin, through your bones, through the chair beneath you,
- 1:41:01and the ground below that, because though none of it
- 1:41:05were even there, most of them sail straight through the
- 1:41:09entire Earth, in one side and out the other, without
- 1:41:12ever once touching a thing. We call these particles neutrinos,
- 1:41:18and they are among the faintest, shyest, most ghostly things
- 1:41:23in all of nature. What makes them so ghostly is
- 1:41:27that they barely interact with ordinary matter at all. The
- 1:41:31solid world around you, which feels so firm and impassable,
- 1:41:36is to a neutrino, almost entirely empty space, and it
- 1:41:40slips through the gaps with ease. You could line up
- 1:41:43a wall of solid leads stretching for light years, and
- 1:41:47a great many neutrinos would still pass clean through it
- 1:41:52without so much as a flicker. They are real, They
- 1:41:56carry energy. They are pouring through you right now as
- 1:42:00you rest, and yet they touch us so rarely, so faintly,
- 1:42:05that for almost all of history, we never even knew
- 1:42:09they were there, And those neutrinos come to us straight
- 1:42:13from the deepest place there is. Every time two bits
- 1:42:17of matter fused together in the Sun's core, a neutrino
- 1:42:21is born, and because almost nothing can stop it, it
- 1:42:25flies directly out of the Sun's heart and across space
- 1:42:28to us, untouched in a matter of minutes. Think of
- 1:42:34what that means. The light of the Sun is shaped
- 1:42:37and scattered and slowed on its long way out, But
- 1:42:41a neutrino carries an unspoiled message from the very center
- 1:42:46of the star, the one kind of messenger that can
- 1:42:49reach us directly from a place we could never hope
- 1:42:52to see with our eyes. When these ghostly particles pass
- 1:42:57through you, some of them have come unhiite, hindered all
- 1:43:01the way from the fiery core of the Sun itself.
- 1:43:04But their shyness hides something remarkable. Because neutrinos pass through
- 1:43:10nearly everything, they can carry news out of places that
- 1:43:15nothing else can escape. And the most extraordinary place they
- 1:43:21escape from is the very heart of a dying star.
- 1:43:25When a giant star collapses and explodes, the violence at
- 1:43:29its core is beyond all imagining, and in that collapse,
- 1:43:33an almost incomprehensible flood of neutrinos is created, so many
- 1:43:39of them and carrying so much of the dying star's
- 1:43:43energy that they make up the overwhelming bulk of everything
- 1:43:47the explosion releases. Nearly all of the titanic energy of
- 1:43:52a star's death pours out not as light, but as
- 1:43:56this silent torrent of ghost particles fleeing the catastrophe at
- 1:44:00almost the speed of light. The light we see, brilliant
- 1:44:05as it is, is only a small leftover. The true
- 1:44:09story of the star's death is told in neutrinos, and
- 1:44:13once we managed to catch them. In the year nineteen
- 1:44:18eighty seven, deep inside detectors buried far underground, scientists recorded
- 1:44:23a faint, sudden burst, just a couple of dozen of
- 1:44:27these ghostly particles arriving together in the space of seconds.
- 1:44:32They had come from a giant star that had exploded
- 1:44:35in a small neighboring galaxy far across the gulf of space,
- 1:44:40after traveling for something like one hundred and sixty thousand
- 1:44:44years to reach us. For the first time in all
- 1:44:48of history, human beings had caught the ghosts fleeing a
- 1:44:52dying star, and here is the detail that gives me
- 1:44:56a gentle chill. Those neutrinos arrived a few hours before
- 1:45:02the light of the explosion did, because they slipped straight
- 1:45:06out of the collapsing core and flew directly toward us.
- 1:45:10While the light had to struggle its way up through
- 1:45:13the star's outer layers. The silent ghosts reached us first,
- 1:45:18the faint early heralds of the catastrophe, carrying the news
- 1:45:23ahead of the blaze, just two dozen tiny particles after
- 1:45:29a journey of one hundred and sixty thousand years, and
- 1:45:34from those few faint ghosts, we learned that our understanding
- 1:45:38of how giant stars die was right, that the heart
- 1:45:43of such a death really does pour out its energy
- 1:45:46in this silent, invisible flood, a mere handful of phantoms
- 1:45:51caught deep underground, confirming the hidden inner workings of a
- 1:45:55dying star one hundred and sixty thousand years and a
- 1:45:59whole galaxy away. There is something quietly staggering in that
- 1:46:05all around us, all the time, this ghostly traffic is
- 1:46:09passing neutrinos from our own sun, pouring through us by
- 1:46:13the trillions every second, and among them, ever so rarely,
- 1:46:18the faint whispers of distant stars dying in the dark.
- 1:46:22We move through an unseen storm of these gentle phantoms,
- 1:46:26utterly unaware, our bodies no more an obstacle to them
- 1:46:30than a clear window is to light. The universe is
- 1:46:34far busier and far more crowded with quiet messengers than
- 1:46:39our senses could ever tell us, And so they pass
- 1:46:43through you now, in this still moment, countless silent ghosts,
- 1:46:48weightless and unfelt, streaming out of the Sun and in
- 1:46:52from the depths of space, carrying within them the news
- 1:46:56of fire and collapse from places unimaginably fall away through
- 1:47:02your hands, through your heart, through the whole sleeping Earth,
- 1:47:06and out the other side, never pausing, never touching, simply
- 1:47:11passing through, on and on into the dark. Imagine taking
- 1:47:18the entire Sun and crushing it down until it would
- 1:47:21fit inside a single city. It sounds impossible, and yet
- 1:47:26the universe does exactly this. When certain giant stars die,
- 1:47:31they leave behind a remnant so dense, so unimaginably compressed,
- 1:47:37that it defeats every instinct we have about how matter
- 1:47:40is supposed to behave an entire star's worth of material,
- 1:47:45more mass than our whole sun, squeeze down into a
- 1:47:48ball only a dozen miles or so across, a star
- 1:47:53shrunk to the size of a town. We call it
- 1:47:56a neutron star, and it is one of the strangest
- 1:47:59things that exists anywhere in nature. The numbers are almost
- 1:48:03impossible to feel. Take a single spoonful of the material
- 1:48:08inside a neutron star, just a small scoop the size
- 1:48:12of a sugar cube, and here on Earth that tiny
- 1:48:16piece would weigh about as much as an entire mountain,
- 1:48:20one sugar cube as heavy as a mountain. The matter
- 1:48:25has been crushed so tightly that the empty space inside
- 1:48:29ordinary atoms has been almost entirely squeezed out, leaving behind
- 1:48:35something so dense that our usual words for heavy stop
- 1:48:39meaning very much at all. If you could somehow hold
- 1:48:44a mere thimbleful of it, the weight of all of
- 1:48:47humanity put together, would be resting in the palm of
- 1:48:50your hand. How does something like this even come to be?
- 1:48:55When a giant star collapses at the end of its life,
- 1:48:59the crush of gravity becomes so ferocious that it forces
- 1:49:03the tiny pieces of matter together far harder than anything
- 1:49:06we could ever hope to reproduce. The particles inside are
- 1:49:11jammed so tightly against one another that they merge and transform,
- 1:49:16and what is left is a single, smooth, almost unimaginably
- 1:49:21dense sphere, held up just barely by the last desperate
- 1:49:26refusal of its particles to be packed any tighter. Still,
- 1:49:31it is gravity and the deep rules of the very small,
- 1:49:36locked together in a standoff at the very edge of
- 1:49:39what is possible, a whole sun's worth of matter balanced
- 1:49:43on the nice edge of total collapse, and the strangeness
- 1:49:49only deepens the closer you look. The pull of gravity
- 1:49:52at the surface of a neutron star is so ferocious
- 1:49:56that it beggars belief. Hundreds of billions of time, stronger
- 1:50:01than the gentle tug that holds you to the Earth.
- 1:50:05A pebble drop from even a small height would strike
- 1:50:09that surface faster than anything we could ever hope to launch.
- 1:50:14To lift yourself the height of a single step there
- 1:50:17would demand more effort than scaling the tallest mountain on Earth,
- 1:50:23and wound around many of these stars are magnetic fields
- 1:50:27of almost incomprehensible power, trillions of times stronger than our
- 1:50:32own planets, invisible and immense, threading out into the dark
- 1:50:37around them. Everything about these objects sits at the very
- 1:50:43outer edge of what nature seems willing to allow. And
- 1:50:48then there is what these objects do, which is perhaps
- 1:50:51stranger still. Many neutron stars spin and not gently. Picture
- 1:50:57a whole crushed star heavier than the Sun, on turning
- 1:51:01round and round many hundreds of times every single second,
- 1:51:06a blur of impossible motion. As they spin, some of
- 1:51:10them sweet beams of energy out from their poles, sending
- 1:51:14those beams turning around and around like the light of
- 1:51:18a lighthouse wheeling in the night. And if one of
- 1:51:22those beams happens to sweep across the Earth, then once
- 1:51:25with every single turn of the star, a faint pulse
- 1:51:29reaches us, flick flick, flick, arriving with a steadiness so
- 1:51:34astonishing that these spinning stars keep better time than almost
- 1:51:39any clock we have ever built. When the first of
- 1:51:43these steady pulses was discovered long ago, it was so regular,
- 1:51:48so precise, so unlike anything anyone expected to find in
- 1:51:53the natural sky, that for a brief and wonderful moment,
- 1:51:57the scientists who found it half wondered whether they might
- 1:52:01be hearing a signal from some distant civilization. They even
- 1:52:05nicknamed it half in jest after little Green men, but
- 1:52:11it was no message from anyone. It was something far
- 1:52:15stranger and grander, the dead, spinning heart of a giant star,
- 1:52:19sweeping its beam across the cosmos, keeping its perfect, tireless time,
- 1:52:26entirely on its own. There is something that quiets the
- 1:52:31mind in the thought of these objects. That nature can
- 1:52:35take a whole star and crush it into something the
- 1:52:38size of a city, so dense that a spoonful outweighs
- 1:52:42a mountain, and then set it spinning hundreds of times
- 1:52:46a second, with a steadiness beyond any machine, And that
- 1:52:50there are countless such objects out there, scattered through the galaxy,
- 1:52:56turning silently in the dark. The universe holds extreme, so
- 1:53:01far beyond our everyday world that we can barely find
- 1:53:04the words for them. And yet they are real, and
- 1:53:07they are out there right now, keeping their faithful time.
- 1:53:12And so it spins on in the deep dark, that
- 1:53:16impossible sphere, a whole sun crushed into the space of
- 1:53:20a city, turning and turning, sweeping its quiet beam across
- 1:53:25the emptiness. A lighthouse no one built, keeping watch over nothing,
- 1:53:31counting out the moments with a patience that will outlast
- 1:53:35almost everything, round and round in the silence, faithful and strange,
- 1:53:41in the long dark between the stars. When the very
- 1:53:48largest stars die, they fall and never stop falling. Most
- 1:53:53dying stars, however violent their end, leave something behind, a
- 1:53:58dense ember, a spinning remnant, some final object resting in
- 1:54:03the dark. But the most massive stars of all do
- 1:54:07something stranger and more absolute. When such a giant reaches
- 1:54:12the end of its life and its core collapses, there
- 1:54:15is no force left in all of nature strong enough
- 1:54:19to halt the fall. Nothing can stop it. The core
- 1:54:23simply keeps collapsing inward and inward, smaller and denser, without limit,
- 1:54:29until it has crushed itself down past the point of
- 1:54:32all return. And what it leaves behind is a black hole,
- 1:54:37a place where gravity has won so completely that not
- 1:54:41even light can escape. To picture what that means, you
- 1:54:46have to think about what it takes to leave something behind.
- 1:54:50Throw a ball up into the air, and it slows
- 1:54:53and stops and falls back because the Earth's gravity pulls
- 1:54:57it home. Throw it hard and enough, fast enough, and
- 1:55:02it could escape into space entirely. Every object has a
- 1:55:06certain speed you would need to reach in order to
- 1:55:10break free. Of its gravity and never fall back. For
- 1:55:14the Earth, that speed is very fast, but reachable for
- 1:55:18the Sun faster still. But for a black hole, gravity
- 1:55:24is so overwhelmingly strong that the speed you would need
- 1:55:27to escape it climbs past the speed of light itself.
- 1:55:31And since nothing in the universe can travel faster than light,
- 1:55:35nothing at all can escape. No rocket could ever power
- 1:55:40its way back out, and no ray of light can
- 1:55:43flee it either. Once something crosses that fatal boundary, there
- 1:55:47is no coming back. Ever. That boundary has a name.
- 1:55:52It is called the horizon, a sphere of no return
- 1:55:56surrounding the black hole, unmarked and invisible but utterly absolute.
- 1:56:02Outside it, escape is still possible. Cross it, even by
- 1:56:06a hare, and you are bound forever to fall inward,
- 1:56:10with no path back to the universe you came from.
- 1:56:13It is less a surface than a threshold drawn in
- 1:56:17empty space, a line beyond which the very word out
- 1:56:22simply ceases to have any meaning. And here's one of
- 1:56:26the strangest and most haunting things about that boundary. Suppose
- 1:56:31you could watch from a safe distance as something fell
- 1:56:34toward a black hole, a glowing object drifting slowly in
- 1:56:40You would expect to see it fall in and vanish,
- 1:56:43But that is not what you would see. Instead, as
- 1:56:47it neared the horizon, you would see it appear to
- 1:56:50slow down. The closer it drifted to that fatal edge,
- 1:56:54the more it would seem to linger, its motion, stretching out,
- 1:56:58its light, growing immer and redder, and at the very
- 1:57:02horizon itself, it would appear to freeze, hanging there, fading, slowing,
- 1:57:09never quite crossing, its final moments, stretched out toward forever
- 1:57:14before your eyes. Time itself runs differently in the grip
- 1:57:19of such gravity, and from the outside, the last instant
- 1:57:23of the fall seems to take an eternity. The black
- 1:57:27hole keeps frozen at its very edge, a kind of
- 1:57:31fading ghost of everything that has ever fallen toward it.
- 1:57:35I should be honest with you about something, my friend,
- 1:57:39because it is part of the wonder what happens deep
- 1:57:42inside beyond the horizon we do not truly know. Our
- 1:57:47finest theories tell us that everything rushes toward a central
- 1:57:52point of unimaginable density. But at that point, the very
- 1:57:57laws of physics that have carried us all this way
- 1:58:00stop making sense. The mathematics breaks down. It hands us
- 1:58:06answers that cannot be real, and quietly admits that here
- 1:58:11our understanding has reached its edge. The inside of a
- 1:58:14black hole is one of the few places in all
- 1:58:17the universe where we must simply say we do not
- 1:58:21yet know. There is a deeper truth waiting there, some
- 1:58:26law we have not yet found, and until we find it,
- 1:58:30the heart of a black hole remains a genuine mystery,
- 1:58:34perhaps the deepest one there is. There is something humbling
- 1:58:39and strangely peaceful in arriving at that edge. We can
- 1:58:44follow the lives and deaths of the stars all the
- 1:58:47way to this final place, the most complete ending that
- 1:58:51matter can have, And here, at last the universe keeps
- 1:58:56a secret we cannot yet read, a perfect darkness ringed
- 1:59:00by the gently bent and glowing light of everything behind it,
- 1:59:04folding within it. We know not what, And so it
- 1:59:08rests there in the deep dark, silent and absolute, a
- 1:59:12sphere of pure shadow, the final remnant of a once
- 1:59:16blazing giant, bending the light of distant stars softly around
- 1:59:21its unseen edge, the quietest place in all of creation,
- 1:59:25the one ending from which nothing returns, keeping its ancient secret,
- 1:59:30patient and still in the long night between the stars,
- 1:59:39nothing in the universe is ever truly lost. When a
- 1:59:43star dies, whether it fades into a quiet ember or
- 1:59:47tears itself apart in a final blaze, it does not
- 1:59:50simply vanish from the story. The matter it was made of,
- 1:59:55the elements it forged across its long life and in
- 1:59:58its death are not just. They are released, scattered outward
- 2:00:03into the dark, mingled back into the thin, drifting gas
- 2:00:07that fills the spaces between the stars, and there slowly,
- 2:00:12patiently over ages. They wait until one day, gathered up
- 2:00:17by gravity, they begin to come together again, and out
- 2:00:20of the remains of stars that died, new stars are born.
- 2:00:25This is the great cycle that turns at the heart
- 2:00:28of everything, and once you see it, you can never
- 2:00:31quite unsee it. Each generation of stars lives and shines
- 2:00:37and dies, and in dying enriches the darkness with the
- 2:00:41elements it made. The next generation forms from that enriched material,
- 2:00:47inheriting the gifts of all the stars that came before,
- 2:00:52and those new stars, in their turn, will live and
- 2:00:55die and give themselves back again, seating the dark of
- 2:01:00the stars that follow birth and death are not opposites,
- 2:01:04here not enemies. They are two halves of a single
- 2:01:09turning wheel, each one endlessly feeding the other around and around,
- 2:01:14through all the long ages of the cosmos, and the
- 2:01:18gentle truth, the one I would most like to leave
- 2:01:21resting in your mind is that you are part of
- 2:01:24this wheel. The sun overhead was built from the scattered
- 2:01:28remains of older stars, stars that lived and died before
- 2:01:32it was ever born. The earth beneath you was gathered
- 2:01:36from that same enriched material. And your own body. The
- 2:01:41iron tearing breath through your blood, the calcium holding up
- 2:01:46your bones, the very atoms that make you. All of
- 2:01:49it was forged inside stars that died long ago, scattered
- 2:01:54into the dark, and gathered up once more, across billions
- 2:01:58of years, into the shape of you. You are not
- 2:02:03separate from the life and death of the stars. You
- 2:02:06are one of its passing forms, a way that old
- 2:02:10starlight has for a little while of gathering itself together
- 2:02:15and looking up at the sky it came from. There
- 2:02:18is a deep comfort in that, if you let it
- 2:02:21settle over you in the quiet. We tend to think
- 2:02:25of endings as final, as a vanishing into nothing, but
- 2:02:30the universe does not seem to work that way. In
- 2:02:34the great cycle of the stars, an ending is only
- 2:02:37ever a turning, a giving back, a scattering of gifts,
- 2:02:41a setting of the stage for something new. The dust
- 2:02:46of dead stars becomes the heart of living ones. The
- 2:02:50remains of one generation become the substance of the next.
- 2:02:54Nothing is wasted, nothing is lost. It only changes and
- 2:02:59moves on and becomes part of whatever comes after. And
- 2:03:03this turning has happened many times over already. The atoms
- 2:03:07that make you up did not come from just one star,
- 2:03:11but quite possibly from several, passing through cycle after cycle,
- 2:03:16gathered and scattered and gathered again, across spans of time
- 2:03:20too long to truly feel. Each atom in your hand
- 2:03:24is a traveler with a history far longer than the
- 2:03:28Earth itself, a quiet veteran of the wheel, having been
- 2:03:33part of who knows how many stars and clouds and
- 2:03:36worlds before it ever became for this brief moment a
- 2:03:40part of you. You are not standing at the beginning
- 2:03:44of this story, nor at its end. You are one
- 2:03:48turn of a wheel that has been spinning since long
- 2:03:51before the sun, and that will go on spinning long after.
- 2:03:56So when you look up on some clear night at
- 2:03:59all those distant points of light, you might remember that
- 2:04:03you are not a stranger gazing at something far away.
- 2:04:08You are looking at your own family, at the very
- 2:04:11kind of thing you are made of, at the long
- 2:04:15lineage of fire and dust that you, yourself belong to
- 2:04:19the stars. And you are part of the same unbroken story,
- 2:04:24the same slow wheel of dust becoming light and light
- 2:04:27becoming dust, turning quietly across more time than the mind
- 2:04:32can ever hold. And it is still turning now this
- 2:04:36very moment. In every corner of the sky. Somewhere, even
- 2:04:41as you rest, old stars are letting go of the
- 2:04:44elements they made, breathing them out softly into the dark.
- 2:04:49And somewhere else, in some cold and quiet cloud, those
- 2:04:53scattered gifts are gathering together once more, beginning the slow
- 2:04:58fall inward that will one day become a new star,
- 2:05:02and perhaps new worlds, and perhaps in time new wonderers
- 2:05:06to look up and ask where it all came from.
- 2:05:10You are made of stars that died so that you
- 2:05:13could be here, and one day, far beyond all of this,
- 2:05:18the atoms that are you now will move on again
- 2:05:21and become part of something new in their turn. There
- 2:05:25is no ending in that, only the long, gentle turning
- 2:05:29of the wheel dust to starlight and starlight to dust
- 2:05:33around and around through all the quiet ages of the universe.
- 2:05:38Rest now beneath it all. You are a small warm
- 2:05:43gathering of ancient starlight, held together for a little while
- 2:05:47here in the dark. And the great slow wheel turns
- 2:05:50on as it always has, carrying you gently with it
- 2:05:54among the stars, and gently our journey among the stars
- 2:06:03comes to its end. If you are still awake, drifting
- 2:06:08somewhere in the quiet with me, there is no need
- 2:06:11to stir. Another story is waiting whenever you would like it,
- 2:06:16another slow wander through the wonders of the cosmos, ready
- 2:06:20to carry you onward into the dark. Let it begin
- 2:06:24when you are ready, and simply close your eyes again.
- 2:06:28And if sleep has already found you, then let it
- 2:06:31keep you. You have nowhere to be and nothing to
- 2:06:35hold on to. The stars will go on turning patiently
- 2:06:39far above the soft and sleeping world, just as they
- 2:06:42always have and just as they always will. Rest Now,
- 2:06:46my friend, you are a small warm gathering of ancient starlight,
- 2:06:51safe here in the dark. Sweet dreams among the stars.
- 2:08:21Speaker 2: Or the woman nam must almost nons Do you know
- 2:10:01what