Latest / Consumerpedia / 80 - Debt Busters: Real-Life Success Stories
Transcript
- 0:02Credit is a good thing when used properly.
- 0:04Most of us need to take on debt to buy a house or a new car, but
- 0:08when credit is used to acquire things we want but can't afford,
- 0:12that's when the trouble starts. After a while, you can find
- 0:15yourself deep in debt with what seems like no way out.
- 0:19There is a way to climb out of that hole if you know where to
- 0:21go for help and are committed to changing your financial habits.
- 0:25I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:28checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:31consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:35consumers select services, avoid trouble and save money.
- 0:38Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:41any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:45completely independent and objective.
- 0:47Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 0:51the consumer man, Herb Weisbaum. Americans are piling up credit
- 0:56card debt at an alarming pace. The interest rates on these
- 0:59unpaid balances are staggering. 2025 thirty, in some cases 35%,
- 1:05unprecedented. No wonder it seems like there's
- 1:07no way to get that monkey off your back.
- 1:09But as I said, you can do it because our first two guests did
- 1:12it. Let's say hello to Jonathan
- 1:13Unverzad, who is joining us from Cataract Wisconsin.
- 1:16Hi, Jonathan. Hi Herb, how you doing?
- 1:18There really is a cataract Wisconsin.
- 1:20There is. It's so tiny it's
- 1:22unincorporated. Wow.
- 1:23Well, I'm glad we cleared that up.
- 1:25Get it? Full disclosure, I met Jonathan
- 1:27last year at the National Foundation for Credit
- 1:30Counseling's annual conference, and I just knew I had to have
- 1:32him on the podcast. So it's so nice to have you
- 1:34here. How deep in debt were you when
- 1:37you knew you had to get help? We were about 43,000 in
- 1:40unsecured debt. And was there something that
- 1:42happened that made you realize we can't keep going on this way?
- 1:45It wasn't a specific incident. I just said I am sick of this.
- 1:50I wasn't able to sleep at night. You know, when you're in debt,
- 1:54it's all assuming. Every night I would dream about
- 1:56my rich uncle dying and bailing me out.
- 2:00My big problem was I didn't have a rich uncle.
- 2:02So I came to the point where I said if I'm going to get out of
- 2:05debt, things have got to change today.
- 2:07When you were in that position, did you feel like you had done
- 2:10anything irresponsible? Were you just going crazy buying
- 2:12stuff or to just sort of build up little by little?
- 2:15A lot of people's debt story can be medical things or other
- 2:19tragedies. Mine was really.
- 2:21I compare my wife to the Grasshopper and the Ant and
- 2:23Aesop's Fables, where she was the aunt who worked really hard
- 2:27and I was a Grasshopper who just wanted to play.
- 2:30And so our debt was really me just buying things I didn't want
- 2:34to wait for and toys and fun. And so it was really just
- 2:38irresponsibility on my part. So you had a problem with wants
- 2:42versus needs? Exactly.
- 2:44I thought my wants were my needs to the tune of 40, some $1000.
- 2:48Wow, did you have more than one credit card?
- 2:50We had three. And were you just like paying
- 2:53off the minimum or how'd you deal with that?
- 2:55Exactly. Paying off the minimum.
- 2:57And I learned some really interesting things about
- 2:59compound interest. When you pay off the minimum on
- 3:02your credit card, you're actually going backwards.
- 3:04My debt was increasing because of the interest rates.
- 3:07The minimum percentage that we had on our three credit cards
- 3:11was 28.9 on one of them, and two of them were in the 30s.
- 3:15Wow, 30. Percent for another story.
- 3:17I did a calculation with bankrate.com and some of these
- 3:19retail credit cards are a little bit above 30%.
- 3:22If you only made the minimum you would never pay it off.
- 3:24The calculator said Infinity. It just you never pay your debt
- 3:28off if you only pay the minimum for these cards.
- 3:30That's literally what I discovered was happening with
- 3:32us. So could you have succeeded
- 3:34without a counselor there to help you the way and show you
- 3:37what to do? No, no chance.
- 3:39If you really wanna get out of debt, accountability is so
- 3:43important. Well, first of all, if you're in
- 3:45a relationship, you both need to be on the same page if you're
- 3:48working against each other, which my wife and I were for
- 3:51years till I came around. But yeah, we needed a counselor.
- 3:55And, and quite honestly, the counselor, the biggest thing
- 3:58they helped us with is we cut up all our credit cards and then
- 4:02they made an agreement with the credit card companies to get
- 4:05those rates down. I believe at that time they got
- 4:08our rates down to 9 or 10% on every card with the agreement
- 4:12that we would not use the cards until they were completely paid
- 4:16off. But my wife, Hope and I took a
- 4:18step further than that. We cut up our cards immediately
- 4:22when we got into the program. And you weren't supposed to open
- 4:25any new credit cards, right? Oh yeah.
- 4:26If you opened a new credit card, they kick you out.
- 4:29They made it very clear you can't be naughty here or you're
- 4:32going to be out of the program. And so that accountability was
- 4:36really huge to say we, we've got to do everything right because
- 4:40of what they're helping us with. So how long did it take you to
- 4:42get the monkey off your back? We were scheduled for a little
- 4:46over five years and we did it several months under five years
- 4:50every chance we could get. We paid more than was due each
- 4:54month. And how does it feel to be debt
- 4:56free? We're 10 years post debt free
- 4:59now and it's a completely different life.
- 5:02I have had many of my friends and others come to me talking
- 5:05about debt and I send them down to a credit counseling agency if
- 5:09they're willing to do that because it's life changing when
- 5:12you get into debt. Like unsecured debt.
- 5:14I was, you think it's kind of fun because you're buying all
- 5:18these things and all these wants, like you said, but what
- 5:21you don't realize is you're really actually creating some
- 5:24bondage. And that's what happened to me
- 5:27now. I couldn't do what I wanted to
- 5:29do. We didn't have any freedom to do
- 5:31extra things. And so debt is very deceptive.
- 5:34It's fun at first, but in the long term it really messes with
- 5:39your peace and your just even ability to be generous.
- 5:42Sounds like you couldn't even enjoy all the toys you bought
- 5:44because you had this burden on your shoulders.
- 5:46Oh, exactly. It was a tremendous.
- 5:49Burden. So as I recall when I met you,
- 5:51you have a boatload of kids, right?
- 5:53We have 11 children. How did you involve your kids in
- 5:56this debt repayment process without creating additional
- 5:59stress? We didn't want our children to
- 6:01repeat the cycle that we had gotten into.
- 6:04And so we wanted to train them while they were young at home.
- 6:07So we brought them in on the situation right away and said,
- 6:11here's the deal. Dad's accumulated some debt
- 6:14here. We're going to get out of it,
- 6:15but it's going to take all of us working together.
- 6:18And so they were with us every step of the way.
- 6:21One of the fun things that my wife did is that she makes the
- 6:25dish called jambalaya that our children really like.
- 6:28It's like a Cajun thing, like a spicy rice dish.
- 6:32Love it. She made it with kielbasa.
- 6:34That was the meat she added in. But she all our children who
- 6:37love seafood, she said. When we get out of debt, we're
- 6:40going to have kielbasa with shrimp in there.
- 6:43And so every month as we made our payment, my wife would say,
- 6:47all right, we're one payment closer to shrimp.
- 6:49We're one payment closer to shrimp.
- 6:51It had become such a fun thing that even at the time when we
- 6:55were doing it, we had to do a a cashier's check from the bank to
- 7:01send to the credit. So every month when my wife went
- 7:03into the bank, she had gotten to know a teller there named Mindy,
- 7:07and she had heard the story. So Mindy was like 01 month
- 7:11closer to shrimp. And that was kind of a fun thing
- 7:14for our kids to look forward to. And you?
- 7:17Believe you have instilled financial lessons in them that
- 7:20will help them deal with their future.
- 7:22At that time, all my children were living at home.
- 7:25Six of them are now married and have children themselves. 20
- 7:29grandkids are, with three on the way.
- 7:31Wow. And every one of my children.
- 7:34I say this with no credit to myself.
- 7:37Every one of my children is so financially responsible that I
- 7:40have peace of knowing they're not going to repeat Dad's
- 7:43mistakes. Am I to assume some of these are
- 7:45adopted? None of them are adopted.
- 7:47They're all biological. Wow, OK.
- 7:50Who you need to meet is my wife. Someday, then you'll be.
- 7:52Amazed. I guess there's not.
- 7:54I guess there's not a lot to do in Cataract, Wisconsin.
- 7:58Jonathan, you have an incredibly inspiring story, and I want to
- 8:01thank you for sharing it with us.
- 8:03And remember what I promised you at the conference.
- 8:05You come to Seattle, and I'm going to buy you the best salmon
- 8:08dinner you've ever had. Forget about those little shrimp
- 8:10in the jambalaya. You're going to get salmon.
- 8:11OK. Oh.
- 8:12Man, I'm holding you to that herb I'm looking forward to.
- 8:15It all righty well straight ahead another inspiring story.
- 8:18A woman who had eight credit cards and 70,000 dollars in debt
- 8:22before she turned her financial life around.
- 8:24I'm her wife's mom, the consumer man, and this is Consumer Pedia
- 8:28powered by checkbook.org. If you like what you hear, we
- 8:31hope you'll consider being a consumer PDS supporter by using
- 8:35the link at the bottom of the show notes to make a small
- 8:37contribution each month. And remember, if you live in one
- 8:40of these 7 metro areas, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle,
- 8:45San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul or Washington DC, get
- 8:49your free 30 day subscription by going to book.org/consumer
- 8:53Pedia. Jonica Nixon is a certified
- 8:57career coach and yoga instructor who lives in Maryland.
- 8:59I also met Jonica at that NFCC conference last year and found
- 9:03her enthusiasm to be contagious. Hello Herb, it's so good to talk
- 9:07with you again. Your story starts when you had
- 9:10eight credit cards and were $100,000 in debt, so you picked
- 9:14up the phone and called the nonprofit credit counselor.
- 9:17Tell us about that period in your life.
- 9:18I think my son was about 3 and we just moved, moved into a new
- 9:23home that was incredibly huge. I'll say we had about 28
- 9:27windows. I did not know how much it was
- 9:31going to cost to get window dressing for 28 windows.
- 9:36And that's probably when I knew this was going in a different
- 9:39direction and we might have bit off more than we can chew about
- 9:42a year, not just a year into our home, but we are barely making
- 9:47minimum payments. We definitely got the mortgage
- 9:49down, but when it came to daily living and and putting my son
- 9:52into daycare, we were running at a very thin margin of financial
- 9:58resources to live. And as I understand, you just
- 10:01made a call out of curiosity to see what this is all about,
- 10:04right? I talked to a couple of my
- 10:06girlfriends, very ashamed about it and kind of asked on the cuff
- 10:09because people are thinking, you know, you have this big home,
- 10:12y'all are living great. And I said, you know, how do you
- 10:15all manage finances, like general budgeting, just kind of
- 10:18piquing their interest. And no one really gave me an
- 10:21answer. And I was like, OK, no one's
- 10:22really talking about this. I remember calling my bank who I
- 10:25had a credit card with, and I asked are there some services?
- 10:28And they said, no, we don't. But if you check the resources
- 10:31on our website, I'm sure you can come across some things.
- 10:33So they gave me one of their websites and I come through
- 10:36there where I found Money Management International.
- 10:40And I gave them a call just to see what's this thing about?
- 10:44You know, you hear about credit card consolidation, whether it
- 10:48be TV or whether you're, say, watching YouTube and you see an
- 10:50advertisement, but you're wondering like, what's the
- 10:52cause? What's the catch?
- 10:54Is my credit going to be impacted positively or negative?
- 10:58What am I now selling my soul to in another way?
- 11:01And just a general conversation. She went over the program with
- 11:05me, the representative, and she said, I'll send you a couple of
- 11:08pieces of information, just review it.
- 11:10And so I talked it over at the time with my partner and decided
- 11:13to dive a little bit deeper into a conversation.
- 11:16Then you had to submit all of your credit card information,
- 11:19how much you owe, so they could calculate and let you know what
- 11:22your fee would be and what they could potentially negotiate.
- 11:24So I actually had over almost $100,000 worth of debt that they
- 11:29were able to consolidate down and that I only paid $70,000
- 11:34for. Wow, that's amazing.
- 11:36You saved a lot of money. They got your interest rate I
- 11:38believe down to 9%. Yes.
- 11:40So it took you 49 months to do it?
- 11:42Were you ever thinking about maybe I should drop out or or
- 11:46how did you stay encouraged to continue doing this?
- 11:48I did not stay encouraged at all.
- 11:50I did not think about dropping out because it was actually
- 11:52cheaper for me to pay my $1500 a month payment with money
- 11:57management than to pay those eight credit cards and their
- 12:00minimum payment. So I stuck it out, but I did not
- 12:04use any of their resources for two years.
- 12:06I was in complete denial. It was about the two year mark
- 12:09where I started opening up my statements.
- 12:12And they have a very a lot of cool features on their website,
- 12:15but also as a part of your statement that shows you how
- 12:17you're paying down where they're paying money to.
- 12:19And I started seeing some of the cars were already paid off.
- 12:22And I was ecstatic because I never imagined these cars being
- 12:28paid down on my own. So it was like checkmarks,
- 12:30checkmarks, checkmarks. And I wanted to see more.
- 12:33So I started to go on their website and looking at the
- 12:36calculator and it would say how many more months you had when
- 12:39your end date was? And it just became so inspiring
- 12:42to myself to say, Oh my gosh, we did it, we did it.
- 12:45We're getting there. It's almost there.
- 12:46There's a light at the end of the tunnel.
- 12:48And luckily for you, you chose a nonprofit credit counselor.
- 12:51The good guys who are looking out for you, so they got you in
- 12:53the right direction. You decided to go public with
- 12:55your story. I saw a couple of TV stories you
- 12:58were in. You actually cut off your credit
- 12:59cards on TV, is that right? I did.
- 13:02Why did you do that? Why did you go public?
- 13:04The shame was over. And I think even in the work
- 13:07that I do as a career coach, many people are ashamed about
- 13:11the career interview process or applying for jobs or feeling
- 13:15like you're not getting in. And oftentimes we don't share
- 13:17our stories. We don't recognize that there is
- 13:20solidarity among us, US and there is support and
- 13:24cheerleading among us. And I recognize as I was
- 13:28starting to pay down and also starting to be more vocal with
- 13:31my friends about, hey, you all, I'm in this program.
- 13:33This is what I've done. More people were like, I had no
- 13:36idea. So if we don't start bringing
- 13:39awareness to the things that we're doing that are positive
- 13:41because we will go share our latest haul of clothes that we
- 13:44brought or, you know, I saved this money when I, you know, did
- 13:47this couponing. But what are we talking about
- 13:50when it comes to investment and debt management?
- 13:53And we weren't doing that. So I wanted to let people know,
- 13:56even though what you see on the peripheral people everyday,
- 13:59people are still living in complete debt.
- 14:02They're not identifying their wants versus their needs.
- 14:04We are all human in this. No one is perfect.
- 14:07And I don't want you to think I put on my pants any differently
- 14:09than you do. I've had to struggle and get
- 14:12through some things. But that doesn't mean that I'm
- 14:14not still great, right? It doesn't mean I'm not still a
- 14:16good communicator. It doesn't mean I'm not still a
- 14:18great career coach just because I went through this said thing.
- 14:21I got through it, I shared it with you, and I want to inspire
- 14:25you to tell whatever it is that your truth is.
- 14:27Speaking of putting pants on, you not only got rid of your
- 14:30day, but you also lost weight, so I guess you had to buy some
- 14:32new clothes. How much did you lose and do you
- 14:34think the two were related? I definitely think the two were
- 14:37related. I lost 50 lbs actually it was a
- 14:40total of 60 and then I have been able to keep it off.
- 14:45I feel like I'm in the best shape both physically and
- 14:49financially of my life. One of the beautiful things
- 14:52about being in debt, I decided to work, or as they say when
- 14:56you're in the water, ride the wave instead of going against
- 14:59it. And that meant to do some things
- 15:01differently with my life instead of saying in a deficit mode, I
- 15:05can't, we can't, no, you can't. It was what can we do?
- 15:09What are the unlimited options that exist for us when we can't
- 15:12go out and get dinner tonight? Can we go to the grocery store
- 15:15and maybe plan a little bit better?
- 15:17So I started to eat more consistent meals and that helped
- 15:20me meal plan. And in meal planning, I was
- 15:23eating much of the same thing. So I was able to stretch out
- 15:27whatever I was buying more succinctly.
- 15:29We started removing things. We started bartering things that
- 15:33were my sons. And we started saying, OK, well,
- 15:35my son is, you know, he can't fit this anymore.
- 15:37Do you all need it? I started becoming very open and
- 15:41vulnerable to say to other people, you know, we can swap.
- 15:44Would you like to trade? Because I didn't have the money.
- 15:48And instead of saying I didn't have right living in the, I
- 15:51don't, I was living in the, if I just open my mouth and say the
- 15:55thing that I need or present the opportunity, maybe someone will
- 15:58walk into that invitation. And they did.
- 16:00We started playing board games. We started having movie nights
- 16:03at home with older movies that were on DVD.
- 16:05And my son was like, what's the DVD?
- 16:07But we had them. So it's like pulling those out,
- 16:10really having more intentional family time.
- 16:12And back to the exercising. The exercising, I never went to
- 16:15a gym. I never paid for gym membership
- 16:17to lose those 50 lbs. So I would start my morning with
- 16:20exercise just to remember, you know what, you're getting ready
- 16:23to go into work. It's OK.
- 16:24You might not have a whole bunch of money, but we're going to
- 16:26make do. Jonica, you are just so
- 16:28positive. You must be an amazing career
- 16:30counselor and Wellness coach. Thank you for sharing your story
- 16:33with us. Absolutely.
- 16:34Thank you so much for having this conversation with me.
- 16:36So Jonica and Jonathan are just two examples of what can be done
- 16:40with hard work and proper guidance.
- 16:41Up next, some of the nuts and bolts about debt management +2
- 16:45Good to be true Debt settlement offers to avoid.
- 16:47I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and you're listening to
- 16:50Consumer Pedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 16:53Consumer Pedia. Fast facts Americans are piling
- 16:58up so much credit card debt, many card holders can't pay it
- 17:01off in a timely manner. A new survey from bankrate.com
- 17:05shows 48% of the adults in this country who have credit cards
- 17:09carry debt from month to month. 53% of those carrying a balance
- 17:13have been in debt for at least a year.
- 17:15The primary reason for taking on more credit card debt was an
- 17:18emergency or unexpected expense followed by today expenses.
- 17:23Of those carrying balances, 3 and 10 expected to pay off their
- 17:26credit card debt within a year, while 41% said it would take
- 17:30between one and five years. Sadly, 6% said they don't think
- 17:34they'll ever get out of credit card debt.
- 17:38Helping people deal with it is something nonprofit credit
- 17:40counselors do every day. But how do they do it?
- 17:43And what exactly does debt consolidation entail?
- 17:45Here to help us with that is Laura Ciccarelli, an NFCC
- 17:48certified credit counselor with American Financial Solutions, a
- 17:52nonprofit agency in Bremerton, WA, just to West of Seattle.
- 17:55Hey, Herb, how are you? So what's the first thing that
- 17:58happens when a new client calls and says?
- 18:00I need some help. Yeah.
- 18:01So we first start by getting an overview of that client's
- 18:04situation. There's no one-size-fits-all
- 18:06answer that applies to everybody's finances.
- 18:08So we start by getting an overview of their concerns,
- 18:11their debt load, their budget, the types of accounts they have,
- 18:14and that way we can come up with a solution that's tailored to
- 18:17their particular set of concerns and their pain points as well as
- 18:20their long term financial goals. And chances are most listeners
- 18:23don't know how a debt management program works.
- 18:25Could you explain? So when you're on a debt
- 18:27management plan, the nonprofit that you're working with can
- 18:30obtain benefits on your behalf that will be applied to your
- 18:33unsecured debt. So that typically means
- 18:35significantly reduced interest rates, often to under 10%,
- 18:38sometimes even under 5. We can also reduce minimum
- 18:41monthly payments and stop late or over the limit fees and
- 18:45ending any collection activity if it's occurring, you know,
- 18:47depending on whether or not accounts are delinquent at the
- 18:49time of enrollment. It's not a refinance or a loan.
- 18:53It's basically a structured repayment plan where the client
- 18:55pays back one payment every month that consolidated all of
- 18:58their credit cards into that single monthly payment.
- 19:01That's then split up and dispersed out to each of the
- 19:03different creditors at the new lower rates.
- 19:05So the idea is it's giving consumers access to much more
- 19:09affordable rates than they can get on the open market through a
- 19:11refinance, even if they don't have the best credit in the
- 19:14world. Now you do some wonderful
- 19:16things, but you don't have a magical wand that makes the debt
- 19:18disappear. Clients have to stick with a
- 19:20program and change the way they deal with money, right?
- 19:22That's exactly it. We often talk about debt as
- 19:25being, you know, the symptom rather than the disease.
- 19:28So there's something that led you to be in debt.
- 19:30And it's not to say that people have bad spending habits.
- 19:32You know, it might be that they're overextended after a
- 19:34loss of income or, you know, they were unemployed for a
- 19:37period and and they took on debt to keep all the balls in the air
- 19:40while they went back to work. But there typically is, you
- 19:44know, some financial management aspect that needs to change in
- 19:47order to make sure that we're not just fixing the symptom now,
- 19:49you know, only to to set clients up to have a flare up down the
- 19:52road. So we talked with clients about
- 19:55better budgeting habits, making sure that their budget is
- 19:57balanced every month, wants versus needs.
- 19:59And the goal is to set clients up for success so that even if
- 20:03they paid off this debt in typically a period of about five
- 20:06years, they're not going to wind up.
- 20:08Back in the same situation down the road.
- 20:10And do they need to cut off their credit cards?
- 20:12Is that required? So any account that goes on a
- 20:14debt management plan does get closed or inactivated because of
- 20:17those lower interest rates. You know, if a creditor lowers
- 20:19your interest rate to 5 or 10%, they don't want you to go out
- 20:22and spend additional money on that card.
- 20:24Sure. It's not typically an all or
- 20:26nothing process. Usually you don't have to
- 20:28include all of your cards. So if you had to leave out like
- 20:30one card for emergency is, that's usually permitted.
- 20:33It just depends on who your creditors are and what
- 20:35requirements they have. But a counselor can go over all
- 20:38of the specifics of what your creditors would require to get
- 20:41you set up on this sort of program.
- 20:43And the key point I want to make here and you mentioned it is you
- 20:45can do things a client can't do for themselves, such as
- 20:47negotiate that better interest rate because you have a working
- 20:50relationship with the creditors. That's exactly right.
- 20:53Usually, creditors don't offer these lower rates directly to
- 20:55consumers until accounts are already delinquent.
- 20:58So if a client has fallen behind by, you know, three to four
- 21:01months on their payments, sometimes the creditors will
- 21:03offer these rates to them directly.
- 21:05But even then, they usually only offer the rates for three to
- 21:07four months at a time, usually not longer than a year.
- 21:10With us, we can get the rates set up even if the accounts are
- 21:13still in good standing. There's no delinquency required,
- 21:16and we can lock in these benefits until the debt is paid
- 21:18in full. Is there a charge for the
- 21:19service? Yeah.
- 21:20So nonprofits, do you have to charge a small monthly service
- 21:23fee in order to cover our costs for maintaining a debt
- 21:25management plan for each client? Fees are never over $75 per
- 21:30month, depending on the types of creditors that you have and the
- 21:33amount of work involved. And most nonprofits are a bit
- 21:35flexible with their fee schedule.
- 21:37You know, they look at it and the context of your budget and
- 21:40your creditor payments and they make sure that it's
- 21:41proportionate and that it's still affordable for debt
- 21:44management plan payment is not going to be affordable for you,
- 21:46then obviously we won't set you up for failure.
- 21:49How quickly does the person's credit score start to go up?
- 21:52Is it once you get into the program or do you have to wait
- 21:54until you're completely through it?
- 21:55No, it's once you get into the program.
- 21:57The speed really depends on where your credit score is when
- 22:00you start the program. Usually the lower it is at the
- 22:03outset of the program, the faster it starts to rise.
- 22:06But one way or the other, the debt management plan is designed
- 22:08to improve credit. We maintain a positive payment
- 22:11history. The accounts get paid every
- 22:12month at rates that the creditors have accepted.
- 22:14And because of the lower interest rates, your debt load
- 22:17starts dropping much more quickly than it would if you
- 22:18paid the debt on your own. So your payment history and the
- 22:21amount of debt in your name are the two biggest factors in your
- 22:23credit score. And because we're attacking both
- 22:25those factors, your credit score will start to increase
- 22:28incrementally as you make those payments through the program, as
- 22:31long as you stick with the payments and don't take on
- 22:32additional debt. Typically, credit scores are
- 22:34much, much higher at the end of the program than they were when
- 22:36you started. Americans are dealing with
- 22:39medical debt. Can a nonprofit credit counselor
- 22:42do anything to help those folks? We can, yeah.
- 22:44We can typically set up payment plans that will prevent
- 22:46collection activity, prevent the debts from being sold to
- 22:49collection agencies, and also prevent legal activity from
- 22:52ensuing. Oftentimes there are other
- 22:54solutions for medical debts. There are charity care programs
- 22:57and financial aid available through most medical providers.
- 23:00So if you give a credit counselor a call and want to
- 23:03talk about your medical debt, we can discuss payment plans
- 23:05through us, but we can also typically help you explore their
- 23:08options and figure out the best path for your medical debt
- 23:10specifically. So what about the ads we see in
- 23:13here for debt settlement companies?
- 23:14They make these bold promises. We can make that mountain of
- 23:17debt disappear and repair your credit at the same time.
- 23:20What do we want to know about them?
- 23:21Yeah, I, I have this conversation with clients on a
- 23:23daily basis, actually. And my metaphor of choice is
- 23:27that, you know, if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.
- 23:29It's one of those things where, you know, it just seems like
- 23:31what could possibly be the catch?
- 23:33Somebody's making your debt disappear.
- 23:35But there really is another shoe that drops.
- 23:37The problem with debt settlement agencies is that, first of all,
- 23:39they're for profit. So they tend to charge really
- 23:41high fees. And basically what they do is
- 23:44they take a payment from you every month, but instead of
- 23:46dispersing it out to your creditors, they hold that money
- 23:49in a savings account until your credit cards or loans or
- 23:52whatever debt you're dealing with is several months past due.
- 23:55And at that point, what they try to do is negotiate a settlement.
- 23:57So they basically call your creditors and say, you know,
- 24:00hey, John Smith owes you 10 grand, which you take, you know,
- 24:035 grand since he's already behind, and call it even.
- 24:06The problem is that, first of all, it destroys your credit
- 24:08because, again, your payment history is the biggest chunk of
- 24:10your credit score. So once your accounts start
- 24:12falling behind, your credit's gonna start tumbling very, very
- 24:14quickly. It takes much more time to build
- 24:16credit than it takes to destroy it.
- 24:18The second problem is that there's nothing that settlement
- 24:20agencies can do to prevent lawsuits and collection
- 24:23activities while those accounts are falling behind.
- 24:25So, you know, you're gonna start getting the collection calls and
- 24:27the letters, which obviously are stressful, but worse than that,
- 24:30you can be sued. You know, if your accounts are
- 24:32falling behind, a creditor can take you to court and attempt to
- 24:34garnish your paychecks or come after your assets.
- 24:37And some settlement agencies will say that they can offer you
- 24:41the services of their attorney in the event of a lawsuit.
- 24:43But you know, the problem with that is that if I go rob my
- 24:46neighbor's house and I leave my fingerprints all over, you know,
- 24:48I can hire the best attorney in the world, but realistically,
- 24:51I'm probably going to jail, right?
- 24:52It's the same thing with lawsuits.
- 24:54There's also tax liability. So if you settle a debt for less
- 24:57than you owe and you save more than $600.00, it's considered a
- 25:00gift of income. And depending on your tax
- 25:02bracket, you can get a 1099 at the end of the year, basically
- 25:04taxing you on the money that you quote UN quote saved through the
- 25:07program. And the biggest problem is that
- 25:10none of these ramifications are typically discussed upfront.
- 25:12You know, I deal with clients everyday who enter these
- 25:15settlement programs and they're calling us because all of a
- 25:18sudden they're getting sued and they didn't know that that was
- 25:20going to happen or all of a sudden their credit is dropping
- 25:22and they didn't know that it was going to happen.
- 25:23You know, they were told that eventually their credit would
- 25:25improve, which theoretically it will because negative remarks
- 25:29drop off your credit after seven years.
- 25:30But that's not the information they were given at the outset.
- 25:33So there's all kinds of issues as far as, you know, your credit
- 25:36rating, the legal liability, the tax liability, and most people
- 25:41go into it blind and they don't know what kind of can of worms
- 25:44they're opening up. I've spoken to way too many
- 25:46victims who paid money and were in worse shape when they got
- 25:48done. So do yourself a favor and do
- 25:50what Jonathan and Jonica did and go with a nonprofit credit
- 25:53counselor, which is what Laura is.
- 25:55Laura Ciccarelli is an NFCC certified credit counselor with
- 25:58American Financial Solutions, a nonprofit in Bremerton, WA.
- 26:02Laura, thank you so much for sharing some time with us.
- 26:05And before we go, I want to bring back Jonathan and Jonica
- 26:08to give us one final answer to this question.
- 26:10You are living proof that debt consolidation works.
- 26:13What advice do you have for people who are feeling
- 26:15overwhelmed by their debt and are considering seeking help?
- 26:18And Jonica, I'm going to start with you.
- 26:20Identifying what your needs are really takes a thoughtful
- 26:23approach of writing down and there are some ways that you can
- 26:27scale back. But do not be afraid, do not
- 26:29think that you are alone. And I think that's where many of
- 26:32us sit. Once you move out of shame and
- 26:35you simply open your mouth and it could be having a
- 26:37conversation with a the credit counsellor to ask about the
- 26:40program, We are often afraid of that for which we are
- 26:43unfamiliar. Having that conversation,
- 26:45understanding what the options are really allows you to expand
- 26:49your own imagination about what exists for you and what can be.
- 26:52And then you can start to say, OK, my wants and my needs are,
- 26:56I'm ready to move forward with this thing that's going to help
- 26:58me reach both my wants and my needs.
- 27:01Jonathan. I think the key is to keep in
- 27:03mind that it's worth it. I don't know anybody that's in
- 27:06debt that is enjoying being in debt.
- 27:09Like we said, there's a lot of stress that comes with that.
- 27:12So you got to get to the point where you say, I want this to be
- 27:14over. And I really appreciate what
- 27:16Jonica said too. We looked for a lot of ways
- 27:19while we were budgeting hard, while we made sacrifices, but
- 27:22you still have to find other creative ways to have fun.
- 27:26You don't have to spend money to enjoy life.
- 27:29And so if you can have fun at the same time you're getting out
- 27:33of debt. You get to the point where I'm
- 27:3610 years post being in debt. We are more generous than we've
- 27:40ever been in our lives. That's one of the real benefits
- 27:43in my mind of getting out of debt is that we can help people
- 27:47who are in debt or who are struggling or who need a hand up
- 27:51because we don't have that burden ourselves.
- 27:53It's totally worth it. Again, I would put in a plug for
- 27:57any NFCC organization. Look them up.
- 28:00You will not regret it. Thank you, Jonathan.
- 28:02Thank you, Jonica and thanks Laura.
- 28:04So nice to have you with us. If you are now encouraged to do
- 28:07something about your financial situation, find a non profit
- 28:10credit counselor who will work for you and with you.
- 28:13Go to the National Foundation for Credit Counseling website,
- 28:16nfcc.org. That's nfcc.org.
- 28:22Well, that's it for this edition of Consumer Pedia.
- 28:24We hope you'll rate the episode and follow us on Apple podcast,
- 28:28Spotify or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 28:31Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 28:35Another way you can support this show is to follow us on Consumer
- 28:37Pedia video on Facebook and Instagram and at my
- 28:40Consumerpedia on X, formerly Twitter.
- 28:43I'm Herb Weisbaum. Thank you for listening.
- 28:46Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 28:49We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 28:52smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 28:54help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 28:58ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 29:01If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 29:04Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 29:08Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 29:12Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 29:15subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 29:18If you like what you've heard, we hope you'll become a
- 29:20supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show notes to
- 29:23make a small contribution each month.
- 29:26Consumer Pedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 29:29money and make smarter choices.