Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E054: Gold, Bitcoin, & Counterparty Risk with Mark Valek
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we. Sell.
- 0:27Hey, I say when we sell. Thank you for joining us for
- 0:33this week's episode of The Last Trade, a podcast from On Ramp
- 0:36Media. On today's show, we're joined by
- 0:38Mark Valik, fund manager and partner at Incrementum, an
- 0:41independent asset management company based in Liechtenstein.
- 0:45Incrementum has established themselves as thought leaders in
- 0:48the realm of hard assets, offering various investment
- 0:51funds comprised of gold, precious metals and Bitcoin.
- 0:54Mark discusses his journey to discovering and becoming
- 0:57passionate about sound money. He explains how the existing
- 1:00Fiat monetary system is not sustainable and why he
- 1:03appreciates Austrian economics. Mark also talks about the
- 1:06challenges of starting a fund that combines gold and Bitcoin,
- 1:09and the advantages of blending these two assets in a portfolio.
- 1:12He discusses the current state of the market, the geopolitical
- 1:15backdrop, and the changing dynamics of gold pricing.
- 1:19The conversation explores the importance of counterparty risk,
- 1:21the potential for a banking liquidity crisis, and the role
- 1:24of gold and Bitcoin as hedges against these risks.
- 1:27It delves into the geopolitical tensions and retaliations
- 1:30between nations, as well as the increasing number of problem
- 1:33banks and unrealized losses in the banking sector.
- 1:36The discussion highlights the importance of understanding the
- 1:39challenges of a debt based financial system, the idea that
- 1:42gold and Bitcoin can provide a hedge against counterparty risk
- 1:45and inflation, and the importance of educating
- 1:47individuals about these assets. Now time for the show.
- 1:51There's only three of us. There's going to be four of us.
- 1:53There's only three. The show must go on.
- 1:56You're joined by Mark Valik of Incrementum and the In Gold We
- 2:00Trust Report. Mark, thank you for joining us.
- 2:02Welcome to the show. Thanks for having me and Mark.
- 2:07I know Michael and I are really excited to have you on today
- 2:10because I think the position in which you sit in the firm in
- 2:14which you've built over the last 11 years is really unique in
- 2:18terms of its focused on sound money, but particularly a blend
- 2:23of gold and Bitcoin specifically.
- 2:25So I think the start, start off the conversation, which is learn
- 2:28about yourself, your journey to discovering sound money and why
- 2:33you're so passionate about it and how that rolled into
- 2:36Incrementum, starting that fund and managing that over the last
- 2:4011 years. OK, well I'm native Austrian and
- 2:45that's why I hope you can cope with my Austrian accent.
- 2:52But it's not that. I found Austrian economics in
- 2:57the Austrian university system, but actually only post graduate
- 3:03when I already was fund managed in 2000s roughly shortly before
- 3:09the GFC actually hit. And, and when it then hit, I
- 3:13really fell into that rabbit hole.
- 3:15And what, what amazed me back then was that basically nobody
- 3:21from traditional finance really looked at the financial system
- 3:25critically in the monetary system.
- 3:27So that's one thing I, I, I really wanted to investigate
- 3:32how, how this actually worked. And then with all the QE which
- 3:36came, came up back then in 2008, 2009 and so on, that was really
- 3:43weird. And I think a lot of people
- 3:45actually from the financial sector really didn't know what
- 3:48was going on. But then things seemed to settle
- 3:51down and then things went on. But I didn't buy that.
- 3:56And I, I, I really came to the conclusion that the monetary
- 3:59system was not sustainable. And then I found out about gold.
- 4:03I found out about Austrian economics, which is really, I
- 4:08think interdisciplinary. So you, you, you actually fall
- 4:13fall into the rabbit hole of, of monetary history and I mean in,
- 4:19in, in, in Europe and Austria, Germany, we, we had this
- 4:22hyperinflations 100 years ago. So, so there is some remnants
- 4:27there. Which one already knows from,
- 4:30from, from Peps family stories from from your grandparents and
- 4:34so on. And, and if you, if, if you
- 4:38actually dig into, into all these kind of topics, you, you
- 4:41really find out about this, this, this repeating Fiat scam,
- 4:47I'd call it, which, which, which has been ongoing for, for for
- 4:51several 100 years probably. And, and, and I really thought
- 4:56this is, is, is not the way to how, how things probably should,
- 5:01should, should be at the end of the day, because it's not moral.
- 5:05It's not ethically this monetary system with all the transfer of
- 5:09wealth, which is going on through creation of money.
- 5:13And, and, and on the other hand, I also saw, saw an investment
- 5:18opportunity because my previous job first was fund analysis.
- 5:22I was interviewing hedge fund managers and when I found out
- 5:25about Austrian economics, I started to, to interview these
- 5:29people if, if, if they had heard of it.
- 5:32And most of them said, yes, they know about it, but really they
- 5:35did not. And and then I thought, OK, if
- 5:39there must be some kind of an edge to it.
- 5:41And we started to come up with investment products which
- 5:46basically take into account this unsustainability of, of the
- 5:50monetary system. And that's, that's really why we
- 5:55wanted to, to found our own boutique, which which really I
- 6:00think has a different view on, on the world of monetary system
- 6:05economics and the likes. So that's my little journey in a
- 6:10nutshell I guess. At On Ramp, we believe that
- 6:13Bitcoin will be the most important asset to own in the
- 6:1521st century. Our Multi Institution custody
- 6:18solution is the safest and most secure way to ensure that your
- 6:21Bitcoin remains in your and your family's possession for decades
- 6:24to come. Multi Institution custody
- 6:26maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk, leveraging
- 6:29Bitcoin's native properties to eliminate single points of
- 6:32failure that have historically complicated Bitcoin ownership.
- 6:35On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey.
- 6:38For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 6:42I think it's a similar journey that a lot of us have gone
- 6:45through and welcoming Mark to the show, got through the
- 6:50difficulties there and I so post financial crisis, 2008, 2009,
- 6:58you went through this, this period of really trying to
- 7:01figure out why the financial system was rotten at its core.
- 7:06I think we all agree like we've we've completely broken money as
- 7:10a tool, we cannot price things accurately.
- 7:13And so in terms of recognizing that inefficiency in the market
- 7:18or the corruption in the market and then starting a fund around
- 7:22it in 2013 when you started Incrementum, what is what was
- 7:26the core thesis back then? Has it changed at all?
- 7:30And what is what is your pitch to clients essentially in terms
- 7:34of parking money with Incrementum too deploy in a way
- 7:39that is counter to most traditional asset managers?
- 7:45Well, my first entrepreneurial experience was basically already
- 7:51next to my job as a fund manager with a bullion dealership, which
- 7:54which I Co founded. That was 2011.
- 7:59And also around that time, I think 2012, we we also bought
- 8:06some, some Bitcoin privately, but that was a small allocation
- 8:11back then, which became bigger in, in terms of asset
- 8:17allocation. But, but, but we really are knew
- 8:21that in 2013 we wouldn't be able to integrate this in into a
- 8:26regulated fund because our business is fund management.
- 8:30And 2013 was way too early to, to think about that.
- 8:34But we, we kept on looking at the developments in, in, in the
- 8:39Bitcoin scene and the crypto scene and tried to, to push also
- 8:45to, to start regulated funds with, with Bitcoin exposure.
- 8:50And as we founded our company in, in Liechtenstein, which then
- 8:55happened to be pretty open regarding crypto that that was
- 9:02turned out to be an advantage. But still, it took years and
- 9:05years until we really were able to pull it off.
- 9:08So at the end of the day, our, our first regulated fund, which
- 9:14is combining gold and, and Bitcoin was launched in, in
- 9:19early 2020. So that was quite a journey
- 9:22actually until we were able to, to, to, to start that fund.
- 9:26But next to that fund our, our other, our other strategies are
- 9:34basically resources. So we we have a fund which which
- 9:38has uranium exposure, it's uranium equity funds, we have
- 9:43inflation diversification funds and we have a balanced portfolio
- 9:50all seasons funds. So we've got actually different
- 9:54strategies. And since 2020, we have two
- 9:58strategies which combine precious metals and, and Bitcoin
- 10:02exposure. And that's, that's actually what
- 10:06we do. And, and, and I think the
- 10:08combination of, of, of real assets in terms of commodities
- 10:13and, and, and gold and, and Bitcoin monetary assets, that's,
- 10:17that's I think something which one should be overweight in, in
- 10:22the next years. And that's at least how how we
- 10:26personally invest and that's what we also offer for our
- 10:29clients. Mark taking a a step back on one
- 10:34notice. So your your Co founders who
- 10:36we've spoken with they Ronnie yesterday put out he had
- 10:41retweeted from Crescent cap. They put out the rise of hard
- 10:45assets and it's a we'll we'll attach to it in the show notes,
- 10:48but it's effectively breaking down a research report.
- 10:52And he the quote is to put it plainly, today's Michael Lewis
- 10:55big short opportunity in our view is the ongoing devaluation
- 10:58of Fiat currencies relative to real assets with limited supply,
- 11:01which are imperative to society either as commodities or sound
- 11:05money. And this is, you know, whatever
- 11:07June 2024, you guys coming around this idea in 2013 and
- 11:13coalescing with four Co founders.
- 11:15I'm curious, was everybody, although I would imagine
- 11:18everybody was a sound money advocate and understood why gold
- 11:21was money, Did everybody come at it together about Bitcoin as
- 11:24well or was there a learning progress to get to that 2020
- 11:27point where you blended in Bitcoin and gold into one of the
- 11:30fun strategies? I mean, the nice thing about our
- 11:35partnership is we, we, we are five partners and we all run our
- 11:39strategies. So we, we, if we are convinced
- 11:43and we want to start a new strategy and we can fund it, we
- 11:46can do it. So I mean, yes, we need the
- 11:48consense of consensus of all the partners.
- 11:52But, but basically that's, that's not a big issue because
- 11:55we, we think relatively alike. I mean, everybody has his own
- 11:59opinions, but but that that that wasn't the issue.
- 12:03The the, the, the more, the, the bigger challenge was basically
- 12:07finding investors not too much because to to convince the
- 12:13investors, but but but due to this new regulatory issue and
- 12:18and then also crypto coming into into place.
- 12:22So, so the, the, the, the, the term crypto was like really
- 12:27still is actually difficult for for banks, but, but especially
- 12:31in 2018-2019, they, they were really, everybody sounded the
- 12:38alarm bells when, when, when, when they realized, OK, this,
- 12:41this fund has crypto exposure and this is the evil thing and
- 12:44money laundering and so on. So you really had to basically
- 12:49over overcome a lot of regulatory obstacles and, and,
- 12:53and talk with compliance officers and, and, and even and
- 12:57if you had the investors which which we did bringing like
- 13:03having having actually the funds coming in into the fund at the
- 13:07time we wanted to start the fund that that that really was was
- 13:10quite troublesome, but we pulled it off.
- 13:14And then just like two weeks after that, Bitcoin started
- 13:18crashing in one week after that, actually we started the fund, I
- 13:22think in, in February 24, 2020. And in the beginning of March,
- 13:28everything crashed, which turned out to be a big opportunity
- 13:32because, I mean, we, we bought, we bought into, into the crash
- 13:37and we, we stuck to our strategy, which was 25% Bitcoin,
- 13:4375% gold. And, and we really, we're, we're
- 13:48actually averaging in, in, in into low prices.
- 13:51So, so we really actually could, could capture most of the upside
- 13:56because the market turned pretty fast in, I don't know, mid, mid
- 14:00March, I think already. So, so that were quite
- 14:05interesting weeks for us. But, but we started off pretty
- 14:10well and, and now things are up and running.
- 14:13And I think we, we also obviously had the first bear
- 14:16market in 2022. And, and, and the concept of,
- 14:22of, of combining precious metals with, with, with Bitcoin again
- 14:26paid, paid off in terms of volatility.
- 14:29Because I think a lot of people then started investing in 2021
- 14:33and then then lost their nerves in 2022 because they were just
- 14:37like not used to this high volatility.
- 14:41And I think that's really a big challenge for traditional
- 14:44investors. And that's, I think also one of
- 14:46the main advantages to, to offer a product which is, which is
- 14:50more which is in a volatility range, which traditional
- 14:56investors are used to. It's like equity kind of
- 14:59volatility and, and, and they're used to these kind of draw downs
- 15:03and they can stomach these kind of draw downs and, and they did.
- 15:07So all our investors basically stick to us and they are, I
- 15:11guess pretty happy at this point again.
- 15:15And I guess that brings up a good plan.
- 15:17I mean, we can get into the overarching macro thesis,
- 15:21particularly as it pertains to everything going on
- 15:24geopolitically and from a monetary aspect today.
- 15:26But I think since we're touching on it now, talking about the
- 15:31blended portfolio of gold and Bitcoin, obviously over its
- 15:35first 15 years, Bitcoin, a lot of the headlines around it are
- 15:38are due to the price volatility and pairing that with gold,
- 15:42which is more stable from a price volatility perspective
- 15:48over time, just due to the fact that it's been around for
- 15:51millennia. What what is pairing these two
- 15:54assets from a volatility perspective do for for a
- 16:00portfolio? Yeah.
- 16:03That's, that's been a point where I perhaps, or my personal
- 16:08opinion is a little bit different to, let's say, the
- 16:12opinion which you typically hear within the Bitcoin space, which
- 16:16is I think when it comes to volatility, people expect
- 16:21Bitcoins volatility to to go down proportionally to to the
- 16:26market cap. I've been hearing this for many
- 16:28years actually. And you can make the argument
- 16:32that this did happen in the first years, but I think it, it,
- 16:35it, it didn't happen actually in the last five years, especially
- 16:39if you look at the, at the draw downs, that last two draw downs
- 16:44during the last two bear markets were pretty much the similar
- 16:49range, I think roughly -77% or so last bear market and, and,
- 16:55and the one before that one perhaps slightly higher, but,
- 16:58but, but pretty pretty much in, in, in this range and, and this
- 17:02with a much higher market cap. So, so this thesis I think is,
- 17:05is not playing out the volatility perhaps in terms of
- 17:08standard deviation has come down.
- 17:12But but, but the Max Rodon, which is really, I think the,
- 17:15the, the better parameter to to watch has not and I don't expect
- 17:21it to to come down much in future also.
- 17:25And obviously the upside was much higher than gold.
- 17:29That's that's also true. So risk adjusted, it's still a
- 17:33great asset, don't get me wrong, but but I think it will always
- 17:37have the challenge of being a high volatility asset.
- 17:41And, and, and as I said, this is a challenge for for a lot of
- 17:44investors just due to perhaps their age or to, due to their
- 17:51risk appetite, right. And if, if, if you can manage
- 17:57this high volatility within with position sizing with within the
- 18:02portfolio, that's actually basic portfolio management, just size
- 18:07your position accordingly. But but that's in practice
- 18:12easier said than done because with this high volatility come
- 18:20high emotions at the behavioral finance traps which come with
- 18:24Bitcoin I think are extremely high.
- 18:26So I think not many people really have managed the risk in
- 18:33a good way, even though, as I said, theoretically it's, it's,
- 18:37it's not a, a very difficult task to do.
- 18:40But in practice, for instance, I mean, we, we, we always preach
- 18:45to rebalance the portfolio and, and, and we do it in our
- 18:49strategies. And I also tell people to, to,
- 18:53to do it by themselves. But, but in practice, who, who
- 18:56really rebalanced? I don't know in November 2022
- 18:59when everything was like full of FTX bankruptcies and the media
- 19:04was all like Bitcoin is dying. Yeah, hardcore Bitcoin has
- 19:08probably took advantage of of of of this opportunity.
- 19:13But but like the the more the people who are newer in in into
- 19:18that game probably did not they did the opposite, I would guess
- 19:22right. So, so, so that is a challenge
- 19:25and, and coming back to what I was going to say, I, I don't
- 19:30think that Bitcoin's volatility will will go down significantly
- 19:34because the one advantage which it has over gold, namely it is
- 19:40not a physical asset, is a disadvantage when it comes to
- 19:43volatility. It's exactly the physical
- 19:46physicality and, and also the the physical properties as a as
- 19:51an industrial metal which which actually counterbalance the
- 19:56volatility. Because if you have high
- 19:59monetary demand of of gold, basically the industrial use
- 20:04cases will be substituted, right.
- 20:08So you will will have lesser demand from from from industry
- 20:11side and you will have higher supply also from the scrap gold
- 20:16side. And this always is like counter
- 20:20cyclical in terms of volatility. And I think this disadvantage.
- 20:26Or advantage doesn't necessarily have to be an advantage, but
- 20:28this difference obviously always will, will, will stay so, so I,
- 20:34I don't think that Bitcoin's volatility will, will ever reach
- 20:39gold's volatility as long as we are in a Fiat standard.
- 20:45If we switch to a Bitcoin standard, then then it's the
- 20:49unit of the count and the volatility could actually be
- 20:52zero as it was in the case of gold until 1971, right?
- 20:57So but, but I, I think we, we will have to wait a while to to
- 21:03get there, I'm afraid. Yeah, I think the natural notion
- 21:08of a finite fixed supply with infinite amount of liquidity in
- 21:12pools obviously keeps that volatility moving and and
- 21:15reducing over time. But to your point, it's still
- 21:18insanely volatile. This notion of the blend is
- 21:21something I've been thinking about for over a year.
- 21:23And So what I found incrementing, I thought it was
- 21:25incredible to see. Mark, have you seen a blend of
- 21:30Bitcoin and gold together in a fun strategy?
- 21:33And then also, how do you think about it from an idea of getting
- 21:38somebody interested in the asset class?
- 21:40Because I think that's the big thing that we forget.
- 21:42And this is something that I think Larry Laparde helped me
- 21:45understand is like from an age perspective, some people just
- 21:49shouldn't and don't need it. Not only do they not need to,
- 21:51but shouldn't have to suffer a 70% drawdown in their net worth.
- 21:55And so this reality of having some percentage allocated to
- 21:58Bitcoin, well, then you leave the rest to what are they going
- 22:00to hold? You know, again, we know
- 22:02equities, bonds, it's like, does it really make sense?
- 22:04Or where they hold another sound monetary instrument and then
- 22:07they can over time rebalance if it makes sense, whether it's via
- 22:10conviction or just the assets price.
- 22:13So I've always thought of this as a very interesting way to
- 22:15like actually start the conversation with somebody that
- 22:19would historically be away from Bitcoin that understands gold,
- 22:23because there's very few firms that do this.
- 22:25And that's almost a signal to the individual from a macro
- 22:28perspective and specialist perspective that if you can
- 22:31align something that's, you know, 5000 plus year track
- 22:34record along with something that's digital in nature,
- 22:36you're, you're sending the signal that this asset is closer
- 22:39to digital gold than effectively aluminum or, you know, not have
- 22:42value at IE crypto. So just curious, Mark, have you
- 22:46seen this in any thoughts on like how you would this could be
- 22:49introduced from a net new position to somebody?
- 22:52Yeah. I mean you mentioned Larry
- 22:54Leppart, like him a lot. He I think we we think a very in
- 23:01similar ways in in in this relation.
- 23:06Also Charlie Morris has has has a combined product.
- 23:10I don't know if you know him from by by three.
- 23:12So but these really are the only only guys I know who who
- 23:16actually offer combined strategies or I don't know if
- 23:19Larry actually offers a combined strategy, but who who really
- 23:22actually think that the combination makes sense.
- 23:25The Three Musketeers. I think it's a rare breed if you
- 23:29if you like gold and Bitcoin together, but also like big
- 23:35names like Ray Dalio, who I would consider probably the king
- 23:39of strategic asset allocation. He, he said, I think two or
- 23:44three years ago, I like my gold with sprinkles of Bitcoin on it,
- 23:50which I think is a really nice quote.
- 23:52And I thought it vindicated our thesis pretty pretty much.
- 23:57And, and it's not only him. I mean, if you, if you follow
- 24:01discussions in the, in the mainstream financial media, I,
- 24:05it seems to me at least gold and Bitcoin are mentioned more and
- 24:10more together. So I think this is a natural
- 24:14convergence which which is happening when, when you discuss
- 24:18about these topics and, and, and then I think also that, and we
- 24:22wrote about this I think in 2019 in our in gold Redrust report.
- 24:27We thought back then that this will be kind of going forward
- 24:32kind of perhaps a little bit similar to like, like like an
- 24:37equity bond portfolio. It would be like a building
- 24:39block of, of a traditional portfolio, gold Bitcoin building
- 24:44block, which you can basically add to, to your equity bond
- 24:49allocation, right? And I think there will be more
- 24:52and more managers who, who offer some kind of strategies like
- 24:57like these because, because it just makes sense in, in terms of
- 25:03risk, risk adjusted rewards. So probably there are more by
- 25:09now. I I know of us three and as I
- 25:14said, perhaps there are more managers by now.
- 25:20Yeah. And I think it's a good point to
- 25:22jump into the current state of the market and why gold and
- 25:28Bitcoin have had really good years over the last.
- 25:31I mean Bitcoin since the beginning of 2023 is up I think
- 25:37well over 150% at this point are around their.
- 25:41Gold obviously has been breaking out to the upside, hitting new
- 25:45all time highs. And when you juxtapose that to
- 25:49the geopolitical backdrop, you have the US government $34
- 25:54trillion in debt, 220 plus trillion in unfunded
- 25:59liabilities. You have what many would say is
- 26:03somewhat of a political crisis here in the US as well as
- 26:06everything's become hyper partisan.
- 26:09Obviously, we have the Russia Ukraine war which led to the
- 26:14seizure of Russian treasury assets and we've had many
- 26:19conversations not we, but BRICS countries particularly have had
- 26:23many conversations about diversifying away from the
- 26:26dollar system due to the risk that has become apparent there
- 26:30from a custody perspective. And at the same time, you, you
- 26:35can see this in charts as well, particularly with China
- 26:39accelerating their their offloading of U.S.
- 26:41Treasuries at the same time that they're accelerating their
- 26:45buying of gold. And so in the terms of where we
- 26:49stand today in June 2024, Mark, would you consider this like a a
- 26:55massive inflection point that is somewhat anomalous over the last
- 27:0150 years? Especially when it comes to
- 27:07gold, I think that's actually the biggest surprise.
- 27:09If you look at the I mean, Bitcoin still seems to be
- 27:15following this it's four year cycles.
- 27:17So I think that's basically more or less doing what we could have
- 27:21expected, right. But gold gold actually is now
- 27:26showing a a new playbook. And that's also the new light
- 27:29light motif of our new in gold. We trust report the new gold
- 27:34playbook And what we what do we mean by that?
- 27:37Because I mean, you did a good job of already pointing out a
- 27:43lot of arguments or explanations for for for gold's good
- 27:48performance recently. But if, if you look at the one,
- 27:52the most influential factor traditionally regarding the gold
- 27:58price that were real yields, the US dollar, right?
- 28:04So you have rising real yields, then typically you have falling
- 28:09gold price and vice versa. So if you have basically, I
- 28:13mean, the opportunity cost of holding gold is, is, is real
- 28:18yields basically, right? So that, that correlation worked
- 28:22pretty well for, for many years and, and that really got crushed
- 28:27in, in I'd say mid 2022. And one of the big reasons
- 28:33probably was the seizure of, of, of, of Russian assets assets.
- 28:39The sanctions mean the whole world was shown that Treasuries
- 28:44or European bonds for that matter are not the riskiest
- 28:52asset, contrary to what one has to I think still fill out in the
- 28:58CFA program. You have to say, OK, Treasury
- 29:02bonds is the riskiest asset, but it's not right if there is a
- 29:05counterparty risk related to to that asset.
- 29:10And, and I think central banks woke up to that reality and you
- 29:17saw you, you can see this in, in the statistics they have been
- 29:21wrapping up their, their gold purchases hugely.
- 29:26You had quarterly purchases of roughly sorry yearly purchases
- 29:35of roughly 250 tons during the last 1010 years and starting
- 29:40from 2022 you now have 1000 tons.
- 29:43So basically quadrupling of of the central bank purchasing and
- 29:50this is what you're now showing is basically this divergent of
- 29:54of the real rates relative to the gold price.
- 29:57So one could actually make the case, since real yields have
- 30:01risen, especially in the US and are positive also one could make
- 30:08the case quite a strong case that at least according to the
- 30:12old gold playbook, the gold price would actually have to
- 30:17sold off significantly. And the opposite happened.
- 30:21Yeah. And this is basically the new
- 30:24reality when it comes to gold purchases.
- 30:30The the the big advantage of gold is that it has no
- 30:37counterparty risk. And this is obviously hugely
- 30:44respected again, by by by central banks around the world.
- 30:50We do live in, in, in, in some really I I think serious times
- 30:59when it comes to geopolitics. We the the last light motif was
- 31:03showdown and we talked about the geopolitical showdown, which is
- 31:07obviously ongoing and, and started especially going was
- 31:13kicked into high gear in 2022. And yeah, this is this is 1
- 31:18manifestation of, of the geopolitical showdown.
- 31:23Gold is being redistubbled as neutral reserve asset.
- 31:28And Logan, if you Scroll down one more slide to page 10.
- 31:32I think this is also really interesting chart and
- 31:35illuminating that people are favoring physical gold over ETF
- 31:41products specifically. I'm sure this is a product of
- 31:43central banks buying directly, But building on this point in
- 31:47this chart specifically, do you think there has been a an
- 31:53investor appetite to favor physical over paper exposure via
- 31:58something like an ETF due to, I mean, many people would say
- 32:03they're conspiracy theories, but I think they're pretty, pretty
- 32:08well documented at this point with gold price fixing in London
- 32:14and other bullion depositories. I believe in 2020 there was a
- 32:20problem with COMEX in the London exchange as well, the LME.
- 32:25Do you think people are demanding physical because they
- 32:28really want to hold the good thing and they don't trust the
- 32:31paper markets? And if so, could that demand for
- 32:34physical bullion corrupt what many believe to be price fixing
- 32:40that has been going on for decades?
- 32:44Yeah, that's, that's a big topic.
- 32:46There's a big question. I mean the the graph which you
- 32:48just which we just saw, perhaps you can just put it up once
- 32:53more. I think one has to think about
- 32:56who, who are we talking. I mean, this is a global market
- 32:59obviously for gold and the very different types of investors.
- 33:02And what we are seeing here is gold ETFs, right?
- 33:08And gold ETFs are usually used by financial investors who who
- 33:13don't really I think have these kind of fears mainly, you know.
- 33:18So I think that's really interesting that basically these
- 33:24investors are acting according to the old gold playbook.
- 33:28They think they, they, they see that bonds yield some, they have
- 33:36a, have a, have an interesting yield again.
- 33:38And, and therefore they sold off their, their, their gold
- 33:41holdings. And as I said, if, if, if the
- 33:45traditional playbook would have helped, probably the, the, the
- 33:48gold price would have fallen, right?
- 33:52But if you think about it, this as I said are Western, probably
- 33:55most of them are U.S. Financial investors and they
- 34:00rightly so, do not have to care so much about counterparty risks
- 34:04for now when it, when it comes to bonds, it's, it's probably
- 34:09mainly, I don't know, central banks from, from countries
- 34:14which, which perhaps are not so favorable to the US.
- 34:19And, and, and, and, and I think you could make the argument
- 34:23these financial investors are acting rational, right, Because
- 34:27they, I mean, 5 1/2 percent yield on, on the short term
- 34:32Treasury note. That's, that's, that's quite
- 34:35interesting if you have official evaluation rate of, I don't
- 34:39know, 333 percentage points or something like that, right.
- 34:43So you, you, you didn't get two 2 1/2 percent real yields for
- 34:48for decades, in fact, right. So, so gold isn't so interesting
- 34:51for Western investors, but it's much more interesting for for
- 34:56Eastern investors, if you will, or, or, or the global S if you
- 35:00want to call it that term. And, and this is also the the
- 35:06divergent. I think Western, Western
- 35:09investors haven't haven't really woken up to the fact that that
- 35:13perhaps counterparty risk also will at some point be imminent
- 35:18for, for them. And excuse me.
- 35:24And also on the inflation side, that's also one point which we
- 35:28point out it's the inflation expectations really are stable.
- 35:35I mean it really amazes me that that the, the, the, the
- 35:39mainstream financial investor from the West really thinks we
- 35:43are done with inflation. Everything is good now.
- 35:46That was really like only two, two year anomaly.
- 35:51But given the fact that we're so indebted and this trajectory is
- 35:55really only going to go up, especially with with the higher
- 35:59financing costs. I think if you look at history
- 36:02that suggests that we will have another inflation, inflationary
- 36:06waves coming sooner or later and then Western investors may
- 36:11change their mind pretty, pretty fast on their gold exposures.
- 36:17Yeah, it's it's so fascinating on like the regional differences
- 36:21and this notion of counterparty risk and who cares and who
- 36:24doesn't. Mark, I'd love to Mark Connors
- 36:26on your side. When you, we've talked about
- 36:27this before in your previous roles in Wall Street when it
- 36:30comes to pricing risk and explaining risk.
- 36:32Like how much of that is happening right now with the
- 36:34interest in Bitcoin or as it looked at as we've traditionally
- 36:37seen as like a high, you know, beta, like tech play and people
- 36:40are coming at it from a, you know, perspective that's
- 36:42completely different than this. And where have you seen those
- 36:44themes start to like converge? So you're, you're giving me a
- 36:49little bit of PTSD from being a a risk manager during O8 when
- 36:54you know, you, you kind of just put some information out about
- 36:57the changing, you know, yield structures or, you know, some of
- 37:01the failures in the like where the hard assets went soft at the
- 37:06banks as far as asset backed securities and what that would
- 37:09be. Michael, no one cares about
- 37:12counterparty risk. They really don't.
- 37:14And and I I say that knowing things can change, but it is a
- 37:18show me game. They really need to be showed
- 37:21the door. They need to be showed the risk.
- 37:25Everybody, all the major financial institutions have been
- 37:28instilled are incentivized to take the path of least
- 37:31resistance. So Lehman did it when it started
- 37:34to get hot. They didn't sell their assets.
- 37:37All they did was move down the yield curve, the term structure
- 37:41from wholesale, which is safe out one 2-3 years to overnight,
- 37:45which is cheaper in order to keep their game going.
- 37:48And then we know what happened when JP Morgan and others
- 37:51finally said we're not going to lend to you.
- 37:53So I don't think counterparty risk is there.
- 37:56I think in the last 10 or 15 minutes, what Mark was talking
- 37:59about, which is one of the biggest, you know, to continue
- 38:02the incentive structure topic that I talked about, incentivize
- 38:06for ease, not for preventing stepwise risk of counterparty
- 38:12failure. The global S where people are
- 38:15starved for stability, that's where Bitcoin and gold I I think
- 38:19are going to be there. The fact that we can still
- 38:22invest in the S&P and have a company like NVIDIA pop up from
- 38:27nowhere and to give us value. I mean, the S&P is, is a good
- 38:31thing and bad thing. It, it helps maintain buying
- 38:34power, you know, at like a 7 to 12% gain because it's a momentum
- 38:40fund. It's got who knows what the next
- 38:41name is going to be. As I said, no one saw NVIDIA
- 38:45coming, but here we are with our, you know, equity focused
- 38:48portfolios doing fine. I, I, I, I think that the
- 38:55regionalization of awareness will be #1 the second point I
- 39:00want to talk about, which is gap risk and counterparty risk is, I
- 39:06mean, again, Michael Tanguna, this is what you've been working
- 39:09on, on the, on the risk free curve or cap M pricing model.
- 39:15You know, what is the hurdle rate for risk?
- 39:18And Mark, you also touched on it.
- 39:21I mean, I think that gold chart you had really does speak to
- 39:25that and talking about counterparty risk, if we can
- 39:30show that's not really just a short term preference, but a
- 39:34step wise, you know, a sea change in people saying this is
- 39:38now my risk free rate and there's a reason why treasuries
- 39:43have a higher yield and gold is being bought even though real
- 39:45rates are high because the games changed.
- 39:48And you know, I'll stop there. But I agree and we're all here
- 39:53for a reason. We are uncomfortable with the
- 39:56current financial system and we think it's just starting to
- 39:59shift. And that gold treasuries chart
- 40:03may be one of the best windows onto that dynamic.
- 40:09Yeah. The the part that you referenced
- 40:12that we all know of is the counterparty risk doesn't matter
- 40:15until it does. And the situation we're in, we
- 40:19know, everyone knows it's been listening.
- 40:20This is we're there's a one way train where we're headed.
- 40:24So you have to be ahead of the counterparty risk.
- 40:26Most in the West aren't concerned about it, but like
- 40:28this is the key drivers like it's coming to that point.
- 40:31And that's why gold and Bitcoin have these properties that you
- 40:33can free yourself from counterparty risk or actually
- 40:36provide redundancies in it. And that's like the benefit of
- 40:39the Bitcoin side of like we're almost like the Canary in the
- 40:41coal mine. They're not your keys, not your
- 40:43coin and all these things. We've already seen the collapses
- 40:45of a quasi, you know, bank runs. And so they give you that kind
- 40:49of like, you know, strength or the, the, the they give you the,
- 40:55the fortitude to figure out what are the best practices.
- 40:59And so nobody cares, but they're they're going to have to.
- 41:02And I think that's the idea here is you can, if you can create
- 41:04the solutions that are seamless and also get ahead of it.
- 41:09I think is a big is a big thing. This reminds me of when we
- 41:12launched the trust and we allowed for in kind delivery and
- 41:15and individuals would reference like Sprott and Oz and some of
- 41:18these other ones that Mark probably is familiar with that
- 41:20allow for redemptions. But then the second comment was
- 41:23like, oh, nobody ever, nobody ever uses that.
- 41:26Or I'm the only one that uses it because and it's like, yeah,
- 41:28nobody uses it because, you know, in the West, you're not
- 41:30concerned about your bank going down.
- 41:32You're not concerned about counterparty risk.
- 41:33But again, as we know, there's too much debt, not enough
- 41:36dollars. Counterparty risk will rear Ted
- 41:38at a certain point. And you don't want to be left
- 41:40with your whole, you know, life savings sitting on the other
- 41:43side of that trade. Whether you've been buying
- 41:46Bitcoin for years or just getting started on your journey,
- 41:48our Multi Institution Custody solution is the safest and
- 41:51easiest way to custody your Bitcoin.
- 41:53With On Ramp and our partners at Bitco and Coincover, you can
- 41:56sleep soundly at night knowing that your Bitcoin is safe from
- 41:58exchange failures, the loss of seed phrases and broken hardware
- 42:02devices. On Ramp's Multi Institution
- 42:04Custody solution eliminates any single point of failure,
- 42:07distributes counterparty risk, and minimizes required trust,
- 42:11all while providing greater assurances that a client's
- 42:13Bitcoin is secure and auditable on chain.
- 42:16As a client of On Ramp, your assets live in a multi sig vault
- 42:19controlled by three distinct entities, none of which have
- 42:22unilateral control. On Ramp provides products and
- 42:24services that honor our clients ownership and control of the
- 42:27underlying asset. To learn more about Multi
- 42:30Institution Custody, check us out at On rampbitcoin.com.
- 42:34That brings up another point too in terms of counterparty risk on
- 42:38the international geopolitical level and then at the micro
- 42:43level in terms of people being access the money in their bank
- 42:47accounts. And there's been two recent
- 42:50developments in those two different areas.
- 42:53I think we should definitely touch on, which is at the
- 42:54geopolitical international level, many people focus on what
- 42:59the US and Western nations did to Russia's treasury assets a
- 43:03couple of years ago. And it seems that I believe it
- 43:08was last month, there was retaliation on behalf of Russia
- 43:12saying, all right, you're going to freeze our treasury assets,
- 43:14We're going to freeze some Western bank assets that are
- 43:16held within the country. And they did that last month,
- 43:20but I think it flew under the radar.
- 43:22But to me, that signals an escalation in terms of
- 43:25counterparty risk at the global level in these monetary payment
- 43:30systems and banking systems that have been erected.
- 43:33And so it took a couple years for rush to retaliate and seize
- 43:38Western funds held within its borders, but it did that last
- 43:41month. And does that create a moment
- 43:45where it becomes more normalized to do these things?
- 43:48Does that accelerate all the themes that we're that we've
- 43:51been talking about for the last 45 minutes?
- 43:53And then on the micro level, the FDIC came out with the report,
- 43:57quarterly report on the state of the banking sector and the
- 44:01number of banks, quote, UN quote problem banks as defined by the
- 44:05FDIC increased by 20%, but the amount of assets held by the
- 44:10quote UN quote problem banks increased 5.2 X.
- 44:12So I believe $180 billion. And then the FDIC also announced
- 44:18that there is over $500 billion in unrealized losses sitting on
- 44:23these bank balance sheets in the US, predominantly driven by
- 44:26commercial real estate and residential real estate.
- 44:30And so is there, Mark Valika, a scenario developing where
- 44:36counterparty risk is going to be at the fore because of of two
- 44:41things, the ratcheting up of the back and forth at the
- 44:45geopolitical level and then also another banking liquidity crisis
- 44:49potentially on the horizon? Yeah.
- 44:52I mean, we talked about the geopolitical tangent a little
- 44:55bit already and it's ongoing and probably will, I don't know,
- 45:01hopefully not, but seems to be escalating or at least doesn't
- 45:07seem to be de escalating, unfortunately.
- 45:09But I think it, it, it makes sense to step back for, for, for
- 45:15a second, because I mean, when we talk about counterparty risk,
- 45:19what, what are we talking about systemically?
- 45:23And I mean, we, we wrote a book Austrian School for investors in
- 45:28investing between inflation and deflation.
- 45:31And we thought about this title obviously.
- 45:36And this investing between inflation and deflation is I
- 45:41think brought along because we are in a debt, we have debt
- 45:46based financial system and not many people are talking about
- 45:50that fact because this discussion with between between
- 45:54deflationists and inflationists has been ongoing since decades.
- 46:00And, and I think both have a point, right.
- 46:03Because I mean when we talk about counterparty risk in an
- 46:07extreme case, we are talking about debt deflation or hyper
- 46:12deflation. And theoretically that can
- 46:16happen in a debt based system that's basically always looming
- 46:21over us. We talked about the financial
- 46:23crisis, the crisis 2008. That would have been huge debt
- 46:27deflation if, if, if central banks wouldn't have done what
- 46:31what they did. I mean, I wasn't a fan of that,
- 46:33but I, I, I, I can understand systemically, I can understand
- 46:37why they did it exactly to prevent this debt deflation.
- 46:42So, so this is always basically systemically a possibility.
- 46:47And I think it both extremes get more, more and more likely.
- 46:54I mean, this balance is more and more difficult to, to be been
- 46:57achieved. So to one extent, or perhaps
- 47:00even has to salute central banks how they've been able to, to
- 47:05manage it so, so, so long. But if, if, if we really get to,
- 47:11to, to, to, to a point where where the central bank would
- 47:15theoretically print too slow or react too slowly, then then this
- 47:22is a real, I think this is a real, a real threat, right?
- 47:27But in practice, we have this unpacked Fiat monetary system.
- 47:31And I think all, I mean, 2008 and 2020 basically already
- 47:37showed the way forward. We, we will never, I, I think it
- 47:41was very unlikely that we, that they print too slowly, right?
- 47:45Because I mean, I don't know how many billions, trillions did
- 47:49they print in, in, in 2020? I think 567 within a few, few
- 47:54months. It was really crazy amounts of,
- 47:57of currency which they created and, and they, they had the
- 48:01reason to do so, right, to prevent this debt deflation.
- 48:04And I think this will be at the end of the day, always the, the
- 48:08route that the way out because it's the the easy way out.
- 48:12But, but on, on a short term basis, we, we, we, we could see
- 48:17some kind of debt deflation or counterparty risk or and, and,
- 48:22and this is, this is and, and now coming back to gold and
- 48:25Bitcoin, that's, I think the beauty of these assets.
- 48:28They, they basically as long, especially if you, if you have
- 48:32the premise that Bitcoin also has no counterparty risk, which
- 48:38I think one can make the argument, but definitely with
- 48:40gold, I think that's very clear. You, you are hedged in in both
- 48:45of these extreme cases, right? And and I think this is
- 48:49important to understand and I think this is also another big
- 48:54argument in favour of these these two assets for for either
- 48:58of these extreme scenarios. Yeah, that's a, that's a great
- 49:03point in the sense of like you have counterparty risk on both
- 49:05sides of the curve on the short term, if you're just
- 49:08counterparty just goes to zero. And then on the long curve,
- 49:11because of the erosion of your purchasing power, if you're not
- 49:14holding gold or Bitcoin effectively right?
- 49:16Right. And that's the beauty of these
- 49:18assets. They are without the
- 49:20counterparty risk and they basically are not inflatable.
- 49:25So gold's being inflated, but they're at a very, very low
- 49:28rate. So with with 1 1/2% per per
- 49:31annum and and that's why I think that these are increasingly
- 49:36important supplements for your portfolio.
- 49:42Mark Connors, one of the question for you on the going
- 49:45back to the educating, you know, we do a lot of this on on this
- 49:50pod is for individuals that are into Bitcoin to go to their
- 49:52family, friends, colleagues, peers.
- 49:55Connor's on your side. How do you feel about that
- 49:57notion of whether it's a blend or being able to start with
- 50:01somebody that's into gold and talk about a strategy that has
- 50:04this blend there? It seems like there's something
- 50:07there that hasn't really been done that could really
- 50:09accelerate the learning curve for a lot of individuals.
- 50:13Yeah, it's almost like, well, look at what we have the ETF.
- 50:19So people say I know that animal and it's you know today I think
- 50:22is the second largest inflows after almost a little over four
- 50:26months of having the ETF. So that's an example Michael of
- 50:29just give them what they know. Folks my age and I think younger
- 50:35aren't as much into gold. They're getting, they're getting
- 50:39a little bit more awareness mark.
- 50:42So maybe you'll be getting you're getting more calls that
- 50:44way from, you know, people in their in their 40s and 50s who
- 50:48may be having a longer view of things or aware that things
- 50:51don't last forever, I should say.
- 50:54So I think goal, I'll start with the general portfolio and then
- 51:01I'll touch on how Bitcoin can be presented to a person already
- 51:06aware of goals, qualities from counterparting and inflation
- 51:10into basement. And I think it's about loss.
- 51:13So I, I just had a friend over the weekend, we were chatting
- 51:16and he said, I'm in, you know, I want to make an investment.
- 51:20How should I do it? And he said, Mark, listen, we're
- 51:22good. If it goes to 0, like, you know,
- 51:25he's like, we're, we're good. I'm just going to put a little
- 51:28bit in and, and I mention that because people are not familiar
- 51:32with it. So they are going to go worst
- 51:33case and they're going to be investing a small amount and
- 51:37they're they're either it's you, me or other people, Michael, I
- 51:41know Marty's been doing this forever who get people to the
- 51:45starting line and ready to, you know, to to jump on the gun when
- 51:50the gun sounds for them to buy it.
- 51:51I, when we get into that line, they're only going to want
- 51:54enough where it doesn't cause a divorce or pain or other
- 52:00disruption in their life because they can't really price the
- 52:04reason we're talking about. So since you can't price, it's
- 52:08hard. All models have that that
- 52:11default risk. It's it's that's like to solve
- 52:13for. It's always the hardest part of
- 52:15the model. There's not enough data.
- 52:17So instead trying to price that difficult thing that even
- 52:19modelers can't do in finance, they simply say there's
- 52:22something here. I really can't get my head
- 52:24around it. I want to start with enough that
- 52:27I can lose not ideal approach, but it's practical and that's
- 52:32why I think everybody gets to that 3% allocation on, even
- 52:38though we don't like the 6040 on the 6040 because I've shown in
- 52:43our work and other people have that a 3% rebalanced allocation
- 52:47of Bitcoin. And again, sorry for the 6040,
- 52:51but that's what we know back to what people are familiar with it
- 52:54does it barely changes the worst drawdown in any five year
- 52:59period. It's like 20 point 21.4% versus
- 53:0320.8 for the standard 6040 because it does dovetail,
- 53:08because it isn't correlated because you're rebalancing.
- 53:11So that to me is it get them in with, you know, the you know,
- 53:15what do you want to call it the sugar wrapped approach and then
- 53:19let them feel it and go on from there.
- 53:21So that's what I what I think. I think it's hard to sell the
- 53:24insurance wrap. Some people like it.
- 53:27Most people feel uneasy. They're feeling the unsoundness,
- 53:30they're feeling that they're missing out.
- 53:32And if you given enough approach, like we got four
- 53:35people here who have, you know, some time, not that we're long
- 53:39in the tooth, but hopefully we're long on knowledge in the
- 53:41space. And if we're spend time talking
- 53:44about it, I think we're getting attention.
- 53:45So that's what I think. I think, yeah, sales, you got to
- 53:48minimize the downside through traditional viewpoints of what
- 53:54we call a tear sheet, the statistics anyway.
- 53:58And Mark, I don't know what your thoughts are.
- 54:00I'd love to hear how people are approaching that mixed portfolio
- 54:05that you're talking about. Yeah, it's, it's very different.
- 54:11I mean it's very different depending to whom you talk,
- 54:14obviously, right. I mean perhaps general thought
- 54:18regarding gold and Bitcoin. I mean, I personally, I, I go to
- 54:23to, to, to events like traditional fund events,
- 54:27traditional finance event, if you will.
- 54:29I, I go to gold events and I go to Bitcoin events and I really
- 54:32enjoy the Bitcoin events most. Why is that?
- 54:35Because there is some kind of positivity and some kind of
- 54:38constructive vibe there, right? The gold events mostly, I think
- 54:46the, the vibe is, is is rather negative.
- 54:50Perhaps you, you could you, you have the fear, perhaps a little
- 54:54bit more there and, and, and, and, and perhaps you have, I
- 54:57don't know, the greed or perhaps the, the, the, the, the, the
- 55:00fantasy on, on the Bitcoin side, right?
- 55:03And then, then the traditional finance.
- 55:04That's, that's like a, a dinosaur which is dying.
- 55:08It's, it's really bad going there.
- 55:10But but in, in, in, in this kind of, I mean, so if, because you
- 55:15mentioned insurance, right? I mean, it's, I think it's, it's
- 55:17easier to to to sell like a positive vision, right then then
- 55:22a negative vision. If you, if you talk about
- 55:24insurance, you talk about some kind of things which, which
- 55:28which may go wrong and a lot of things which are going wrong
- 55:31unfortunately and could become even worse, right.
- 55:35But but, but still, I think people rather like to to, to
- 55:38think about positive things. So, so that a positive vision
- 55:41about Bitcoin, I think is, is really a strong, strong
- 55:45argument. Obviously, I mean, I know what
- 55:47you're, you're saying. It's, it's, it's, it's a very
- 55:49big topic and, and, and, and for, for beginners, talking
- 55:53about the Bitcoin standard and all the ramification of the
- 55:56ramifications of the current monetary system.
- 55:59That's, that's, that's, that's too much.
- 56:01You know, you can't, you can't start with that.
- 56:02I, I, I get that. But but but talking about like a
- 56:07positive vibe and and and changing, changing the system.
- 56:13I think this is this is a better sell than talking about the
- 56:17insurance and some all all the things that potentially could
- 56:20could go wrong. That's that's my feeling.
- 56:24It's it's kind of unfortunate like this how far we've come
- 56:26because I think like when we go back, we'll this will just be
- 56:29standard. You know, Marty talks about a
- 56:30lot about like going from a level of you own the asset free,
- 56:34a counterparty risk and you can start to move up the stack as
- 56:36you want to get comfortable. But it's like we talk about
- 56:39notion of counterparty risk and all these other concepts.
- 56:42It's just like optionality, right?
- 56:44Doesn't anybody want optionality or the ability to be free of,
- 56:47you know, the, you know, you think about like always joke
- 56:50around. We have, you know, these
- 56:51different products we offer, but anytime we have a conversation,
- 56:55if somebody's between Coinbase or 12 words on a piece of paper
- 56:59and any pick any device, it's always the 12 words and the
- 57:02device, unless it's somebody that's like 90 plus years old,
- 57:05simply because like they have the optionality, like they can
- 57:08take their assets. They can't wake up one day and
- 57:10their phone says, like, sorry, you're, you can't log in or, you
- 57:14know, anybody listening to this, try to go to Coinbase and move
- 57:16assets around. They don't make it easy if they
- 57:18let you take it off. And so this notion of like, how
- 57:21do we get back to, you know, having some kind of
- 57:22responsibility for just knowing who our counterparties are and
- 57:26thinking through them critically?
- 57:28Like that's how I think about it.
- 57:29It's less about what I've obviously been looking at this
- 57:31for a long time as everybody here.
- 57:34But that notion that we're this far out, we reference how much
- 57:37trillions have been printed where inflation is.
- 57:39It's probably closer to 20%, honestly.
- 57:41You go to the store, but we're still like, that's OK.
- 57:44You know, I wanna NVIDIA and that's my purchasing power.
- 57:47And, and the, the, the bar keeps moving, right?
- 57:49Because I think Marky referenced 9 to 12%, but I'm convinced like
- 57:52whatever the number of the SMP, we're still plus 5% in real
- 57:56terms from an inflation perspective, which leaves
- 58:00basically nothing out there other than probably Bitcoin and
- 58:04some gold hybrid, if that to like outpace inflation Where
- 58:08we're going because it's only accelerating is the thing that I
- 58:10don't think most people talk about.
- 58:12We talked to the pension this past week and we talked, I
- 58:15talked to one yesterday and they were talking about, well, we're
- 58:16good, we're funded. I was like, are you like in real
- 58:19terms or nominal terms? And he was like, oh, nobody
- 58:21brings that up. Like when they actually going to
- 58:23get their 60,000 or 80,000 lbs, is it really going to buy
- 58:28anything relative to what they thought they were when they
- 58:30started allocating? I mean, yeah.
- 58:33And just go, go ahead. Marco, sorry.
- 58:37Excuse me, no, I just wanted to say I think we also all probably
- 58:42especially US investors which typically have AUS equity bias
- 58:45when they invest, they they are very biased regarding the last
- 58:5240 years. So, so, so the collective
- 58:55mindset has been very positive when it comes to equity
- 59:00investing. But, but there are scenarios
- 59:02where you actually have where you had I think 16 years from
- 59:08from 1966 to 1982 where you we didn't get anywhere with
- 59:13equities. And in real, in real terms, you
- 59:15actually lost a lot of money investing in equities during a
- 59:19stagflation. I, I, I, I wouldn't be so, so
- 59:23sure that like going forward, the equity, the, the SNP and the
- 59:27NASDAQ or what what have you is, is, is basically your perfect
- 59:32inflation hedge. I mean, that could go, that
- 59:34could go pretty turn, turn pretty sour once you have longer
- 59:42terms, longer time frame with higher interest rates, right?
- 59:45If you have a second inflationary wave, you saw, you
- 59:48saw 2022, I think that that could, that could come back
- 59:54again, right? So I wouldn't, I wouldn't, I
- 59:56think historically you had, you had stocks and gold, basically a
- 1:00:01combination of stocks and gold keeping your, your purchasing
- 1:00:04powers. And, and these two assets
- 1:00:07basically switched, each had their run a few decades, right?
- 1:00:12And and, and, and, and equities also.
- 1:00:15I mean, it's, it's, it's not a given that equities rise.
- 1:00:18I just wanted to throw that in. Well, it's actually the
- 1:00:22opposite, Productivity goes down and number of dollars created go
- 1:00:25up, which causes more dollars chasing few fewer goods from an
- 1:00:30equity. And think about how many
- 1:00:33companies are staying private now because of the restrictions
- 1:00:36of of being public. So the access to some of these
- 1:00:39companies that that maybe are highly productive are choosing,
- 1:00:44you know, to stay out of the public reporting realm.
- 1:00:48Because I mean, I think taxes, the income tax and property tax
- 1:00:54rate are always focused, but the number of taxes that are coming
- 1:00:58out and fees are, are the hidden taxes that are bedeviling
- 1:01:03homeowners sales, you know, individuals and companies alike.
- 1:01:08So you know, Marco, good, good point on equities historically
- 1:01:14because sure, I mean gold went up what 14 or 16 times in the
- 1:01:1970s on high Vol. So you know, that's, I bring it
- 1:01:23up as a Bitcoin focused firm because that's what we're seeing
- 1:01:26higher Vol, you know, and then on the upside, and I think that
- 1:01:32is, as you said over 40 years, that's there's not institutional
- 1:01:36memory about how things had been or maybe not always are as we've
- 1:01:41seen in the last in the prior 40 years.
- 1:01:46That also brings up like the question of if there is a sub
- 1:01:51sector of allocators are being somewhat complacent and really
- 1:01:56just running the playbook the last 30 to 50 years and thinking
- 1:02:00that that's going to be the playbook.
- 1:02:01I think we believe that things are changing rapidly and people
- 1:02:05better wake up to that fact. But with that in mind, Mark,
- 1:02:10what what do you think the world looks like on the other side of
- 1:02:15of this transition to hard assets geopolitically from a
- 1:02:19monetary perspective? Do you think we are at the
- 1:02:22beginning stages of a massive disruption of how international
- 1:02:26commerce and banking actually operates?
- 1:02:31Yeah. I mean, the one thing I learned
- 1:02:33is you don't really don't know the future.
- 1:02:36And I mean, it's always interesting to, to speculate,
- 1:02:39but my gut feeling is Bitcoin will save us.
- 1:02:46But I also have the feeling that we like going through like a
- 1:02:52birth of a new system, if you, if you will, has a lot of pain.
- 1:02:58Birth is, is a lot of pain involved, unfortunately with,
- 1:03:02with, with the new life form. And, and I think we have to go
- 1:03:07through this. It's my, my, my honest feeling.
- 1:03:11I think like from AI think from a geopolitical standpoint, the
- 1:03:20most of the Western world hasn't really realized how fed up a lot
- 1:03:26of parts of the world are with, with, with the actions of the
- 1:03:30West during the last decades, I guess.
- 1:03:33And, and they haven't also really realized how, how, how
- 1:03:38serious the situation is actually.
- 1:03:40I, I, I think so, unfortunately, but hopefully humanity can, can
- 1:03:46keep the keep the stuff together and, and and and and avoid the
- 1:03:51worst. But when it comes to like the,
- 1:03:55the economic point of view when it comes to to debt, I mean that
- 1:03:59for me is, is, is, is really clear.
- 1:04:02We, we need some kind of a revaluation of for me the, the,
- 1:04:07the, the bigger question is, will this Fiat system be able to
- 1:04:12kick be kicked in another round? What do you mean by that?
- 1:04:17Can, can we reflate the system significantly once more?
- 1:04:22And I think that really has to be done in the next, I don't
- 1:04:26know, five years or something like that, because that
- 1:04:30sustainability really is, is is is is is is a problem.
- 1:04:36And not only gold bugs are talking about this anymore.
- 1:04:40I mean, you talk to Jeff Gunlock, you talk, you listen to
- 1:04:43Jeff Gunlock, you listen to Ray Dalio, listen to all the big
- 1:04:48guys, basically macro investing really like sounding the alarm
- 1:04:53bells louder and louder and, and, and it's, it's it's also
- 1:04:57really not very difficult to see, I think, especially when
- 1:05:01you look at the the refinancing costs.
- 1:05:04So in my view, in order to keep the field system alive, really
- 1:05:10what has to happen is probably an inflation, another round of,
- 1:05:15of inflation. And then basically the question
- 1:05:19is if, if they can stop the inflation, you probably need to
- 1:05:22devalue the dollar 50% or whatever to, to get to more
- 1:05:27sustainable debt levels. And, and that could be achieved
- 1:05:31in, in, in three years or four years with like 1020% inflation
- 1:05:35for 2-3 years. But then the, the difficult task
- 1:05:40is, is, is, is, is getting it back to, to, to lower rates.
- 1:05:44I mean, one has to say the Fed did not did, did, did do quite a
- 1:05:49good job bringing the inflation down.
- 1:05:53Even though Peps officially it's, it's, it's, it's much
- 1:05:56lower than than reality. But, but inflation rates have
- 1:05:58come down. Prices obviously have not.
- 1:06:01But, but it's all about the inflation rate when it comes to,
- 1:06:05when it comes to sustainability. And, but I think we need much
- 1:06:10more, the system needs much more.
- 1:06:12And, and, and we, we'll see what, what that will do to, to
- 1:06:16society also and to like think about all the pension funds and
- 1:06:20think about insurance companies. The big pools of capitals will,
- 1:06:25will, will be hit very hard by, by, by another round of
- 1:06:29inflation. And I, I don't really see a way
- 1:06:34around, around another round of inflation.
- 1:06:39So there that, that will be quite, I think quite a
- 1:06:44challenging environment in the next years.
- 1:06:48That's, that's a scary thought, 'cause I think the last that
- 1:06:52I've seen in terms of the US, it's for every $8 of new debt
- 1:06:57issuance, you're creating $1.00 of of GDP growth.
- 1:07:03And that is an incredibly disconcerting stat.
- 1:07:08And then you couple that with the economic data that's been
- 1:07:11released in recent months, whether it's the Michigan
- 1:07:14consumer confidence number that came in well below expectations.
- 1:07:18We had a terrible jobs report this week.
- 1:07:21There is again that FDIC report that the banking sector is, is a
- 1:07:26bit wobbly right now. And they've done everything they
- 1:07:31can to bring down the rate of inflation.
- 1:07:33As you mentioned, they've done a pretty good job at that.
- 1:07:35But we find ourselves in a situation where prices are still
- 1:07:38high, we have potential liquidity crisis on the horizon.
- 1:07:42We're issuing insane amounts of debt, trillion dollars every
- 1:07:45hundred days since last year. And it's not doing enough to
- 1:07:50like so $8 of new debt for $1.00 GDP growth.
- 1:07:56And that's not doing the trick to think of like what that
- 1:07:59number actually has to hit to to to drive growth that reinflates
- 1:08:04the economy is there's almost mind numbing, somewhat scary.
- 1:08:09Yeah. Yeah, I think this.
- 1:08:11Or go ahead, Mark. I was just on that on that point
- 1:08:14about the $8 get you $1.00, you know the term we used to have in
- 1:08:18the trading desk for a trade that that was unprofitable was
- 1:08:22yeah, that's hard to make up on volume.
- 1:08:24So like you can't even be faster or because it's just going to
- 1:08:28lose your money every day. Marty on that and the.
- 1:08:33A. Corollary or a byproduct of that
- 1:08:35debt creation is as we're seeing and we started to show about the
- 1:08:40increase in gold purchases by central banks, especially, you
- 1:08:44know, China, India, Russia and and Japan is that the the next
- 1:08:52buyer is not has not been created yet on the Treasuries.
- 1:08:56So what the Fed is doing now, instead of the Treasury being an
- 1:09:00asset post Bretton Woods to be stored and used and leveraged to
- 1:09:06protect your currency, it is now a liability and it is being
- 1:09:10pushed back into the market just when the producer, the treasury
- 1:09:15is making more. So the Fed is now or the the
- 1:09:21banking system is, is looking at changing this, this Byzantine
- 1:09:27regulation called supplementary leverage ratio.
- 1:09:31That was emergency, an emergency put in during COVID.
- 1:09:33It means, hey, listen, banks, you can buy as many treasuries
- 1:09:36as you want and we won't charge you.
- 1:09:39So in other words, you get free interest even though then it
- 1:09:41wasn't a lot. They're looking to bring that
- 1:09:44back in. So back about the bank failures
- 1:09:48that Marty and Mark you talked about, about the FDIC, was it 60
- 1:09:52odd banks, half a trillion dollars of losses unrealized.
- 1:09:58And Mark, you mentioned banking losses in the running banks.
- 1:10:02I think the Fed's OK with this. I think they, as you said Mark,
- 1:10:06they will turn on the money printing machine when they need
- 1:10:08to. The Treasury will print debt.
- 1:10:11the Fed is not going to be buying.
- 1:10:14What they're going to be doing is having the purchases being
- 1:10:17done by the banks. So their balance sheet may only
- 1:10:20go up a little bit, but now our the remaining money center banks
- 1:10:24will be the repositories and that'll be where effectively
- 1:10:28monetization of that happens. I know that was a big long
- 1:10:31segment, but the Fed has created new tools and this is another
- 1:10:36one. And all it means is that the
- 1:10:38debasement will continue, but with a different flavor.
- 1:10:43Yeah. Are you referencing the fact
- 1:10:46that they manipulated Basel 3 recently to take treasuries out
- 1:10:50of the reserve ratio? And so now that you give the
- 1:10:54commercial banking system basically the the go ahead to go
- 1:10:59buy as many treasuries as they want.
- 1:11:00So create another demand driver outside of the Fed.
- 1:11:04So look like they're directly monetizing the debt.
- 1:11:07Yep. And and this is boring stuff.
- 1:11:10I mean, we care about it. It's because we that's what we
- 1:11:12do for a living. But you know, it's, it's going
- 1:11:18to have an impact and it's, and it's a driver.
- 1:11:20I think it's, I think Marty, this is one of the reasons why
- 1:11:22we're seeing, you know, Bitcoin up, punching through the low 70s
- 1:11:25again today for a number of reasons, but that's one of them.
- 1:11:30Well, with that reserve ratio, Mark Valik, I don't know if you
- 1:11:33have any thoughts on this, but was that, I mean there was a
- 1:11:36large discussions here in the US, particularly around the end
- 1:11:39of BTFP was a 12 month program initiated in March or April of
- 1:11:462023 that came due and and people were speculating about
- 1:11:51whether or not the Fed would extend that facility.
- 1:11:54They didn't they, they stayed true to their word and wound it
- 1:11:58down. But then shortly after, this
- 1:12:00reserve ratio requirement was changed, and was that
- 1:12:05effectively a continuation of BTFP?
- 1:12:08Maybe not the exact same facility, but one can argue that
- 1:12:12the facility isn't necessary because the treasuries aren't
- 1:12:16part of the reserve ratio anymore.
- 1:12:20I think thoughts Mark just articulated are very interesting
- 1:12:27and thought about similar things.
- 1:12:30I mean, money printers are in the business of printing money,
- 1:12:34right? And they're getting more and
- 1:12:35more sophisticated in it. And I think there are very
- 1:12:39there, there are various reasons.
- 1:12:41I mean, people like also the people in, in, in, in, in these
- 1:12:45positions, they are also aware of these problems.
- 1:12:47And I guess they are thinking about solutions or at least ways
- 1:12:51to be able to kick down the can another another mile or however
- 1:12:57long they can do it. So, so that could be an
- 1:13:00interesting, interesting way to do it, an elegant way to do it,
- 1:13:06more more sophisticated way to do it.
- 1:13:08I mean, it doesn't solve the problem, but it, it, it, it
- 1:13:12postpones the problem. Another interesting, I think way
- 1:13:17I, I heard, I think Paul Ryan talking about this regulatory
- 1:13:23framework for stable coins and specifically referencing them
- 1:13:29being, I think 16th largest buyer of treasury bills, right
- 1:13:35already without the regulation. And basically for making, making
- 1:13:41stable coins through, through a regulatory scheme or a
- 1:13:45regulatory improvement. Even more interesting for
- 1:13:48offshore investment investments and and and being able to
- 1:13:52basically, perhaps he didn't say that, but that's my view counter
- 1:13:58the D dollarization, which may be going on from from central
- 1:14:02banking side via the private banking, sorry, via via the
- 1:14:07private sector. So, so the dollarization I don't
- 1:14:13know for, for for offshore investors, people from, I don't
- 1:14:18know, India to Dubai or wherever sending back and forth stable
- 1:14:22coins, which would perhaps be regulated have the stamp of
- 1:14:26approval of a of AUS regulatory system could be quite attractive
- 1:14:31for, for being used even more as they already are being used.
- 1:14:35And specifically with the thought of attracting new dollar
- 1:14:41buyers, right, the treasury buyers.
- 1:14:44So, so, so they are thinking about these things and, and the
- 1:14:48perhaps probably will come up with, with, with new innovative
- 1:14:52ways. I think that probably will, is
- 1:14:54may also be the reason why as far as I know, it doesn't look
- 1:14:59like, as if the fat coin would, would come.
- 1:15:01So, and I think that's quite a smart move.
- 1:15:06Basically outsourcing this to the private sector and having,
- 1:15:10having overseas investors invest into stable coins, coins and,
- 1:15:15and sucking up fewer treasuries on the way.
- 1:15:19So we're gonna, this game is going to be perhaps longer than
- 1:15:23than we anticipate. But yeah, at some point, I don't
- 1:15:28know. I mean, the problem still
- 1:15:31remains that the, that the budget is in a structural
- 1:15:35deficit. And so you, you always have to
- 1:15:39keep, to pull another rabbit out of the out of the head.
- 1:15:42And I I I guess at some point you run out of rabbits.
- 1:15:48Yeah, the money printer is in the business of printing money.
- 1:15:52That's the that is the title. I know, I know we're tight on
- 1:15:56time. I think the the thing I wanted
- 1:15:58to or at least say before we wrap is Mark, I appreciate you
- 1:16:01coming on. I think this is a big narrative
- 1:16:03that's only going to increase this dynamic between gold and
- 1:16:05Bitcoin because you talked about we don't know how long this
- 1:16:08lasts, whether it's five to 10 years plus.
- 1:16:10But I think a lot of times on the Bitcoin side, we forget that
- 1:16:13like the notion is out there and I know we probably don't believe
- 1:16:16it here. Anybody hears that Bitcoin goes
- 1:16:18from one trillion to 10 trillion and then gold stays at par.
- 1:16:22And the reality is gold marches up at this at the same pace or,
- 1:16:25you know, not same pace, but relative.
- 1:16:28And this will continue and this is how we get out of all this.
- 1:16:31And so that dynamic will continue to exist with
- 1:16:33institutions, individual investors.
- 1:16:35And I think we'll start to see that these synergies play out
- 1:16:37more as more people are educated on the you know, we've been on
- 1:16:41two sides of the spectrum, I think is why they haven't
- 1:16:43converged too much. You have somebody on the gold
- 1:16:44side, they're generally older and come from an Austrian
- 1:16:48background. And then you have something on
- 1:16:49the Bitcoin side that's more tech forward and not thinking
- 1:16:51about gold. And I like to joke around, it's
- 1:16:53like when two disparate ideas converge or or have sex, that's
- 1:16:57when a magic happens. And I think that there's a lot
- 1:16:59of interesting stuff when gold and Bitcoin coming together for
- 1:17:02the next, call it 10 to 20 years that I don't think we talk about
- 1:17:05well enough on the Bitcoin side. The gold bugs and the Bitcoiners
- 1:17:14are fighting each other need to put down their swords and
- 1:17:16realize that we're all philosophically aligned around
- 1:17:19sound money and the fact that the governments and central
- 1:17:22banks have completely corrupted money, I think.
- 1:17:24I. Think we're all fighting the
- 1:17:26same fight. The implementation may be
- 1:17:29different to varying degrees, but philosophically, at its
- 1:17:33core, I think we're we're all very aligned.
- 1:17:35And it's a lot fun. It's a lot.
- 1:17:37It's a lot of better time on the Bitcoin side.
- 1:17:39I like how Mark said he went to, you know, both conferences.
- 1:17:41And that's the thing you hear from like Larry Leopard.
- 1:17:43He's like, yeah, I just kind of got tired of losing.
- 1:17:48He showed up at the conferences. He found a bunch of young people
- 1:17:51that, you know, you said greed in in some of those notions.
- 1:17:54I think that exists. But there's also this notion we
- 1:17:56can actually build a a scalable world.
- 1:17:58You said it's going to save us. There's that hope that lives on
- 1:18:00the other side of, you know, you need a digital money for a
- 1:18:03digital world. Right.
- 1:18:07I hope so. And we all think that's going to
- 1:18:09happen. And let's let's hope it's it.
- 1:18:12It will. And we'll hopefully enjoy the
- 1:18:15fruits of new, new world at some point.
- 1:18:20Yeah. And.
- 1:18:21With all this being said, I do want to make sure that we plug
- 1:18:24the annual report from In Gold We Trust backed by Incrementum.
- 1:18:30This, this year's report, it's over 420 pages long and it's
- 1:18:35just if you're looking to dive into the intricacies of what's
- 1:18:39going on in the geopolitical landscape, how markets are
- 1:18:42reacting to these actions on the geopolitical stage, and why
- 1:18:48Bitcoin and gold specifically makes sense within a portfolio
- 1:18:51and what portfolio construction may look like.
- 1:18:54I think this is a a piece that should be read widely by anybody
- 1:18:59who's taking this this stuff seriously.
- 1:19:04Yeah, thanks for the shout out. It's available for free on in
- 1:19:08gold we trust dot report. By the way, we we've been
- 1:19:13writing about Bitcoin I think since 2015 and have a chapter in
- 1:19:19there every year. And our last last year's
- 1:19:22contribution, we wrote about exactly what you just mentioned
- 1:19:25body regarding the, the, the, the civil war between the sound
- 1:19:31money and within the sound money camp.
- 1:19:33And he said, let's unite. And actually that's the
- 1:19:38differences aren't aren't so big and actually that both go
- 1:19:42together. This year I wrote a small
- 1:19:46chapter regarding free gold and potentially free Bitcoin system,
- 1:19:51which I think is also an interesting thought, perhaps
- 1:19:55once central banks start integrating Bitcoin into their
- 1:19:58reserves. Because that's actually, I think
- 1:20:01still the fundament of of of of the system still is gold.
- 1:20:06Even though we have that most of the system is debt based, but
- 1:20:10the equity of the system currently still is, is gold.
- 1:20:13That's why central banks do have gold.
- 1:20:15And once they start adding, adding Bitcoin to their
- 1:20:19reserves, that could basically perhaps reflate the system in a
- 1:20:25positive way. So perhaps one doesn't have to
- 1:20:29read all the 400 pages, but I think it's for everybody.
- 1:20:33There's something in there. Go check it out in gold.
- 1:20:38We trust dot report Mark thank you for your time.
- 1:20:42Thank you for being on the cutting edge of all this, really
- 1:20:44advocating for Bitcoin to the gold crew for for many years
- 1:20:49now. Because again, like I said and
- 1:20:51you just reiterated, I think we're all aligned need to put
- 1:20:55down our swords and this fight is bigger than the individual
- 1:20:58assets that that we may favor over the other.
- 1:21:03So yeah, that was great. Mark Connors, Michael, anything
- 1:21:06else you guys want to add? No.
- 1:21:09Thanks for joining, Mark. We very much appreciate it.
- 1:21:11Hopefully we'll see you in the States or we'll see you in
- 1:21:13Europe sometime this year or next.
- 1:21:16Yeah, thanks. For the invitation, gentlemen.
- 1:21:19All right. Thanks again, Marco.
- 1:21:21Thanks, Marty. Great.
- 1:21:22Thanks, Mike. Have a great day everybody.
- 1:21:24Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:21:27If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:21:29episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:21:32app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:21:34today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:21:37Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:21:39for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:21:42nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:21:45Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:21:47to hear from you. Visit onramp Bitcoin com contact
- 1:21:51schedule consultation with one of our private client advisors.