Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says I Dont Have Time
Transcript
- Lucas: You hear it all the time as a manager. You ask someone to take on a task, or to shift their focus, and the response comes back: 'I don't have time.' Luna: And it's frustrating because it shuts down any further conversation. How do you argue with that? Lucas: Exactly. It feels like a logical endgame — if someone truly has no time, there's nothing to discuss. But in my experience, 'I don't have time' is rarely the real reason. It's a symptom. Luna: A symptom of what, exactly? Lucas: Usually one of three things. First, the task feels low priority to them, even if it's high priority to you. Second, they don't know how to do it efficiently, so they anticipate it taking longer than it should. Third, and this is a big one — they're saying 'I don't have time' because they don't want to admit they don't know how, or they're afraid of failing. Luna: So it's a defense mechanism. Lucas: Right. And your job as a manager is to figure out which of these it is before you try to solve it. If you just say 'make time,' you'll get resentment. If you say 'I'll help you,' but they're actually just overloaded, you'll overwhelm them further. Luna: So what's a practical first step? How do you diagnose which bucket they're in? Lucas: I like an approach I first saw at a company called HelpFlow — they run customer support for SaaS businesses. One of their team leads had a senior rep who kept saying 'I don't have time' to take on a new project. So the lead proposed a time audit with intent. Luna: Time audit with intent — what's that? Lucas: Instead of just tracking time for tracking's sake, they sat down together and mapped out every task the rep did in a typical week, in thirty-minute blocks. Then they categorized each task against the team's top three goals for the quarter. The rep was spending about twelve hours a week on manual reporting — pulling data from three different tools, formatting it in Excel, and emailing it out. But that reporting wasn't tied to any of the top three goals. Luna: And I'm guessing the rep thought that reporting was mandatory. Lucas: Exactly. It had been done that way for years, but nobody had questioned it. The lead found that a simple SQL script could automate ninety percent of it, bringing it down to about thirty minutes a week. That freed up over eleven hours. Luna: But that's a specific case. What if the employee's time audit shows they're genuinely doing high-priority work and still have no room? Lucas: Then you're dealing with a capacity issue, not a priority issue. And that's actually easier to solve, because it's honest. You have to either reduce their workload, extend deadlines, or bring in help. But the key is that the audit gives you data. It moves the conversation from 'I don't have time' to 'here's what I'm spending time on.' Luna: It also forces you as a manager to look at your own assumptions. Maybe you thought something would take an hour, but it actually takes three. Lucas: Exactly. I've had that happen to me. I asked a team member to take on a new client reporting process, and she said 'I don't have time.' I pushed back a little, but she insisted. So we did a mini time audit, and I realized the reporting she was already doing took up forty hours a week on its own. She wasn't being difficult — she was drowning. Luna: So the 'I don't have time' response was actually a cry for help. Lucas: In that case, yes. And I had to apologize and redistribute her workload. But there's another scenario where the employee is using 'I don't have time' to avoid something they find unpleasant or intimidating. Luna: How do you handle that? Because you can't just let them off the hook. Lucas: You can't. But you can reframe the conversation. Instead of saying 'you need to find time,' say 'let's figure out what's making this feel so time-consuming.' Often, they'll admit they're not sure how to approach it, or they're worried they'll do it wrong. That's when you can offer coaching or pair them with someone who's done it before. Luna: It's really about getting underneath the statement. The phrase 'I don't have time' is almost never the root issue. Lucas: Right. And as a manager, your job is to be a detective, not a judge. The moment you get defensive or accuse them of making excuses, you lose the chance to understand the real problem. Luna: One thing I've noticed is that 'I don't have time' can also be a status thing. Some people wear busy-ness as a badge of honor. Lucas: That's a great point. I've worked with people who say 'I don't have time' almost as a way to signal they're indispensable. And ironically, they're often the ones who resist efficiency improvements because it would reduce their perceived importance. Luna: So how do you handle that? Because you can't exactly say 'stop trying to look busy.' Lucas: You shift the reward structure. Make it clear that impact matters more than hours. If someone automates a task and frees up time, that's a win — not a sign that they're less valuable. I had a manager once who publicly praised people for cutting their own workload. It changed the culture pretty quickly. Luna: That's smart. Speaking of impact, I want to circle back to something you said earlier about the time audit with intent. How do you sell that to an employee who's resistant? They might see it as micromanagement. Lucas: That's a real risk. The framing matters a lot. I'd say something like: 'I've noticed you've been stretched thin, and I want to make sure your time is going toward the things that matter most for your growth and for the team. Would you be open to mapping out your week together so we can see if there's anything we can adjust?' Luna: So you're making it about helping them, not auditing them. Lucas: Exactly. And if they still resist, you might have a trust issue. They may not believe you're genuinely trying to help. In that case, you need to address the trust gap first. Luna: Alright, so we've covered diagnosis, the time audit, and how to handle different root causes. Any final practical tip for managers who hear 'I don't have time' tomorrow? Lucas: One simple question: 'What would need to change for this to feel doable?' It's open-ended, non-confrontational, and it invites the employee to be part of the solution. Nine times out of ten, they'll tell you exactly what the obstacle is. Luna: And that might be all you need to move forward. Lucas: Exactly. It's not about forcing time to appear. It's about uncovering the real conversation underneath.