Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Facebook Philes
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. So people read the Facebook
- 0:23Stories? Yes.
- 0:24How can we not read the Facebook stories?
- 0:26They're really good. And I'm somebody like, I mean
- 0:28loves to ignore Facebook. Stories.
- 0:31This is a clearly Pulitzer Contender for sure.
- 0:36Well, what's funny about it is like the times are we?
- 0:39I guess this is. This is how but here's the
- 0:41reason I actually you know I think the journal is paint be
- 0:45doing a better job on this is that the New York Times was
- 0:47always struck stuck in this situation talking about the
- 0:50election and and Russia with like how can we prove the
- 0:53impact? I mean, you know there's
- 0:55obviously something to be said about whether disinformation
- 0:58cause certain people to not vote.
- 1:00Whatever. But, you know, I remember when
- 1:03it came to privacy and like a lack of interest and user
- 1:05privacy. There was a piece of the times
- 1:07did, in which they were literally taking reporters
- 1:10outside, like, in New York and, like accosting.
- 1:12Regular people showing them how, you know, their data was no
- 1:15longer safe for, or kept private on Facebook and they're like,
- 1:17doesn't this make you mad? Doesn't this make you mad?
- 1:20And it was the strangest story but it was also to be very clear
- 1:22that we're like. Okay look we've got to prove,
- 1:25you know, real world impact of this to be a stronger Pulitzer
- 1:27piece and so they went and did that.
- 1:29And it was this completely forgettable story that I think
- 1:32kind of prove that it's very tough which we were kind of
- 1:34talking about last week with a lot of tech stories to like,
- 1:37explain to lay people why this matters and if you can make the
- 1:42case that that's the reason Trump won.
- 1:43Okay? That's that's something.
- 1:44But what the journal was very effective at with the story?
- 1:49Do you want to give to you want to set up the stories real
- 1:51quick? Just basically what the journal
- 1:54has done is its amass. An enormous Trove of documents
- 1:57and conducted scores of interviews with people who are
- 2:00Company to show essentially that the company knows that it is
- 2:05doing harm in the world. That is really cognizant of
- 2:09this. That it's have full
- 2:10conversations internally with Executives and up to and
- 2:15including the chief executive officer, Mark Zuckerberg and
- 2:19that despite all of this changes were not implemented swiftly and
- 2:23their public facing message has been that these harms that they
- 2:27speak of, so clearly in their own internal Presentations and
- 2:31internal corporate conversations their public facing message.
- 2:33Has been that these harms are not happening and so far, the
- 2:37journal has laid out three and signal that we're going to see
- 2:40more including on things like child sex trafficking.
- 2:43But the three that they've currently laid out, include the
- 2:46idea that Instagram, the popular photo showing up where we see a
- 2:49lot of celebrities and a lot of people looking really great.
- 2:52That Instagram is, has contributed to the deleterious.
- 2:57His can't has contributed to deleterious Mental Health.
- 3:00Flex for young women and that it's known.
- 3:02It's something the company has known something, the company has
- 3:05chosen not to address in order to preserve its business model.
- 3:10It's also shown that the company was well aware of the fact that
- 3:13changes that it made to its algorithm in the way that people
- 3:15share news did not necessarily just increase bonds between
- 3:21users, which was the stated goal made them angry, but it made
- 3:23them anger made them, it created Division and that it encouraged
- 3:27people to share and to engage out of a place of anger, hate
- 3:32lack of trust, and all these things that we are legitimately
- 3:36worried about in terms of its impact on democracy.
- 3:38And then third was the original story that Jeff published which
- 3:43I'm actually pulling up right now.
- 3:45It was that the elite are exempt?
- 3:47Yes, that right there is none from the rules x check process
- 3:51and that not only are Elites exempt but that when Facebook
- 3:55created its own board to adjudicate what to do about
- 3:58high-profile users, It was not honest, with its own board,
- 4:03about the fact that it had a program that whitelisted, the
- 4:08behavior of high-profile users often times but not always bad
- 4:12behavior, right? Yeah.
- 4:15So, of the three pieces that have been published so far.
- 4:17The one that I thought, really made the strongest case that
- 4:21there is real impact to all of these problems is the one about
- 4:25young women and Instagram because, and now I, you know,
- 4:28you we can argue You whether or not I'm interested in you, which
- 4:31one's the worst is an interesting framing.
- 4:34Oh, for sure. The one today about about - you
- 4:38know, anger on Facebook granted, it's also the one I've not read
- 4:40the closest but I just feel like again story.
- 4:46Well, to me, it's the oldest Story.
- 4:47I mean, like we're now mold many years into this discussion over
- 4:52Facebook and social media being - on our national discourse and
- 4:56it only highlighting the most, you know, aggrieved sentiments.
- 4:59And It being useful to Facebook's business model that
- 5:02you know the most outspoken people are the ones who are the
- 5:05angriest. So I just, I'd be shocked if
- 5:07there's anything that feels strongly new to me.
- 5:11Because, aside from the fact that there was internal teams at
- 5:14Facebook showing that we had data to back it up.
- 5:18It's just, we don't know to meet to me, we've been there and I
- 5:20don't, obviously have a problem with people writing more stories
- 5:23about it but I just I'm going to be less influenced by it than
- 5:27something like. Well I thought the anger 12 me
- 5:29my Ranking would be sort of how they treat the elites
- 5:33differently. Then the anger one.
- 5:35Then the teen girls one, I don't know.
- 5:38To me the teen girls story and you know, I have never been a
- 5:41teen girl. No, but it seems, it seems more
- 5:45about sort of, You Know, The Human Condition.
- 5:48I don't know. It's like, well magazine, it's
- 5:50used to show pictures, you know, like different and also it's,
- 5:54you know, different teen. Girls have different reactions
- 5:57to Instagram. So part of the game of that.
- 6:00Or he is basically to say, you know, oh this subsection, you
- 6:04know, was made much worse but yeah you take any poles, some
- 6:07people felt better because of it.
- 6:09Some people felt worse and sort of the game of the story is to
- 6:12just focus on the people who felt worse because of Instagram.
- 6:17I don't think that's correct. I think that what the story
- 6:20shows us, not just that, I don't think it's the game to show that
- 6:23only people who felt worse, are important.
- 6:26I think, what's important is the hypocrisy where the story A
- 6:30shows that Facebook is cognizant of a problem.
- 6:33Instagram knows about a problem, they discuss the problem, but in
- 6:36public, they say, we found the Instagram.
- 6:39Actually makes people feel better about themselves.
- 6:41That is that would cover up. Rocks of the story.
- 6:43Is a cover up. Yeah, not some game by reporters
- 6:46today. Well, I was nip.
- 6:47You late the idea that teen girls have bad self-esteem and
- 6:51it's Instagram and I and what was so effective about it.
- 6:53To me was they were able to pair the findings from this internal
- 6:56study with public statements that Zuckerberg had made that
- 6:59Adam Very had made in which they work as directly about this
- 7:02topic in there, like, we found that.
- 7:04It's actually good for you. I mean in real story that's been
- 7:10an important use of all three of the stories we've seen so far
- 7:12and I imagine it will be a very important piece of the stories
- 7:15that you know, the subsequent stories in this year company.
- 7:19They can't help lying, you know? And the Wall Street Journal is
- 7:21usually I mean they are very careful here.
- 7:24I think even in calling fit saying that Facebook lied to its
- 7:28oversight board. They quote an of an independent
- 7:32expert who reviewed the journals findings and have that person
- 7:36say that Facebook lied to the board.
- 7:40And I think, I mean that, that shows sort of the Wall Street.
- 7:42Journal's. I think we're straight in.
- 7:45Yeah, we're doing these things which is super interesting but
- 7:47but I mean, it's pretty clear that the Facebook just like lies
- 7:51and lies to everybody. And that allows these stories to
- 7:54keep coming because I mean I didn't I think that one of the
- 8:00What has really been happening and with vis-à-vis Facebook in
- 8:03the media is that after an extraordinary honeymoon period
- 8:07with the press that was like bye.
- 8:11It was almost like the business press forgot that Facebook was a
- 8:14business. It was extreme.
- 8:18You saw even before the 2016 election different reporters,
- 8:25try to show that Facebook had a less than glowing happy side.
- 8:29You saw The Wall Street Journal do in a story called, I believe
- 8:32was what they know which took aim, it all sorts of tech
- 8:36companies, not just Facebook, but the idea of tracking the
- 8:38idea of surveillance, the idea of these companies really
- 8:40understanding us better than we understand ourselves and then
- 8:43selling in mining our data, you saw different reporters right
- 8:47about the fact that Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg?
- 8:51Probably more Mark than Cheryl at that time.
- 8:54How weren't being forthcoming or had made mistakes because of a
- 8:57privacy. And that there was a sense that
- 8:59inside of the Bunny. It was done knowingly, but that
- 9:01publicly, the apology was always.
- 9:03Oh my gosh, we're going to try harder, right?
- 9:06I think my crew, we're getting to a point where because of
- 9:10things like the election. The public is now, more on board
- 9:13for more critical stories about Facebook.
- 9:15The reporters are getting more access to sources in part
- 9:18because there's more discontent with within the company and the
- 9:21company is making bigger and bigger and bigger error.
- 9:25So, it's sort of this perfect storm of these stories are
- 9:28starting to hit and have more More impact even if the
- 9:32reporters can't, for example, prove that, you know, Facebook
- 9:35had this disastrous impact on the election with 100 certitude
- 9:39or even through Porter, can't prove it 100% servitude.
- 9:41That Instagram is making teen girls more likely to have an
- 9:44eating disorder. Certainly the public, you know,
- 9:48the public isn't a place, the reporters are in a place, the
- 9:52cultures and in place where these conversations are just
- 9:54more interesting to us all the recording, right?
- 9:57But another way of saying what you're saying is that Reporters
- 10:00are ruled by the posture of the moment towards a particular
- 10:03entity, right? Early on their way to not.
- 10:06Okay, let me think that because there were reporters who weren't
- 10:09ruled by the posture of the moment who did, right, right?
- 10:12There were investors means but they were dismissed by a lot of
- 10:15what I think is, is interesting, is two things.
- 10:17One, I think there were a lot of people myself included that
- 10:20wondered and maybe thought that in a post Trump World, the need
- 10:24to attack Facebook constantly or sorry to investigate Facebook,
- 10:28very aggressively. Was going to subside because
- 10:32Facebook was sort of seen by many people as the enabler of
- 10:36the Trump presidency for a lot of reasons.
- 10:39And, you know, here we are however, many months in a Biden
- 10:41presidency and there is still huge stories that are coming out
- 10:45from from the big newspapers showing that there are all kinds
- 10:47of problems internally. So, you know, I think there were
- 10:49a lot of people at Facebook that thought it was going to go away.
- 10:52And clearly, it isn't well weird.
- 10:54Contradiction of Facebook obviously, right.
- 10:56I mean, Katie talked about this earlier that because the public
- 10:59is now So cynical of Facebook because of the coverage in part,
- 11:03it's much easier to motivate like critical coverage of
- 11:07Facebook, but of course, the public critiques and Facebook
- 11:09are totally different. Right there is the Democrats who
- 11:12hate hate Facebook for a set of reasons and other Republicans
- 11:16who hate Facebook's for perceived bias.
- 11:19But then it's this sort of amalgam of contradictory
- 11:23objections to Facebook that allow sort of these really
- 11:27critical Facebook Stories to have much resonance.
- 11:30I don't know. I I distinctly these stories
- 11:32stay away from politics right with certain areas.
- 11:35Great stories are really impactful in part because they
- 11:39are addressing issues that no matter where you sit on the
- 11:41political Spectrum or what part of the country you live in ya,
- 11:44Urban or rural. You can't have not noticed how
- 11:47toxic things are on Facebook, right?
- 11:49Even this is an original point. But I to me, they read as
- 11:53writing about Facebook as if it's the tobacco industry,
- 11:56right? It's like a really internal
- 11:57research. They did on Of.
- 12:00Here's how they knew what they were selling you is bad.
- 12:04Here's how when the regulator's came to them, they misled an
- 12:08obfuscated. And and so yeah to me this is a
- 12:11series that's really trying to frame Facebook as akin to the
- 12:16tobacco industry. Now we can does a great job of
- 12:20that. Yeah and that's been that's been
- 12:22a comparison that's been going around for a couple of years.
- 12:25Now I remember Marc benioff at some conference a couple of
- 12:28years ago was explicit about Bout that which, you know, I
- 12:31think there's a lot of self-serving nests on the part
- 12:33of tech Executives to call out Facebook.
- 12:35I mean, certainly apple is the best example of that, you know,
- 12:38when Tim Cook was going around saying that they're stealing
- 12:41your data and apple is the Privacy protection company,
- 12:44right? Yeah, there's a lot of that
- 12:46going on there. I have a tough time with the
- 12:48tobacco comparison. I don't think it's a it.
- 12:52I don't think it stands up to much scrutiny other than it
- 12:55speaks to like the power of business.
- 12:56I think there's a huge difference between an addictive
- 12:59Product that has only deleterious health effects to
- 13:03something like, you know, the national discourse that Facebook
- 13:06is affecting or teen self-image. That Facebook is affecting,
- 13:10which are so much more challenging.
- 13:12I mean there's sociological problems are not health
- 13:14problems. You can add are thinking real
- 13:17science, you know, in a decade. I don't know what we could but
- 13:20looking back I think decade that we expect technology to protect
- 13:25us from what we could thinking of decade that this was a
- 13:27hysteria. You know, I mean I thought there
- 13:28was a great there is A great story that Joe Bernstein wrote
- 13:32for. I don't remember where he was
- 13:35orders. Yeah yeah like a buzzfeed
- 13:37reporter. I think we took a year off and
- 13:39did some, you know, I thought deeper anything research
- 13:41fellowships. Yeah.
- 13:43Yeah. And he made a really strong case
- 13:44that like look, we just don't really know the effect that
- 13:47anything has on on the way we think.
- 13:49And you could argue that advertising which is, you know,
- 13:52influential advertising, that is the base of how so much of our
- 13:56economy Works. Maybe that's not even that
- 13:58effective too. And so to basically say there's
- 14:02there's the really cynical argument that the storyline that
- 14:05Facebook is able to manipulate us as fundamentally good for
- 14:08Facebook's business. Because it convinces advertising
- 14:10writers, write its this all-powerful platform with which
- 14:13to control the public. And so, as much as Facebook
- 14:17wants to resist that when it comes to dealing with lawmakers,
- 14:21it's sort of a reputation that it's not totally opposed, right?
- 14:26Just like the idea of cigarettes are extremely addictive, is not
- 14:28necessarily bad for an industry. See, that's trying to convince
- 14:30investors that can always get customer.
- 14:33He's right. It's a great business model.
- 14:35Good. All right.
- 14:36Yeah, yeah. But you know, I wonder what will
- 14:38happen. I mean, to a certain extent
- 14:41despite the fact that it's great reporting in the Wall Street
- 14:44Journal and it's important to expose internal tensions over
- 14:47things like this that some of these subjects are better
- 14:49discussed and like academic journals and and mental health
- 14:52journals because it's their this is going to move the public.
- 14:55Yeah well and also I think Tom the real problem, the real place
- 14:59where the Comparison between the tobacco industry and Facebook
- 15:01breaks down. Is it a backhoe industry was
- 15:03creating a product that we smoked or at least?
- 15:07Then I smoked. But we were creating a product
- 15:09that they could that they could stop not anymore kids, but
- 15:14creating a product that that you we could stop production of you
- 15:18can shut down a tobacco Factory. You don't need to harvest the
- 15:21crop anymore. You cannot make a cigarette.
- 15:24Facebook is creating a product that we actually create as
- 15:27people. And so there's no way to shut
- 15:29down. Down production on Facebook
- 15:31because it would mean, everybody would just have to leave the
- 15:33platform. I just spent the summer in New
- 15:36England, if you are not in a place where for example, small
- 15:39businesses towns Municipal Services have created their own
- 15:44websites, they all live on Facebook, you're not going to
- 15:47know what's going on with your kids elementary school.
- 15:49If you live in rural, Maine, unless you're on Facebook,
- 15:51you're not going to get not know what's going on with your fire
- 15:53department, if you're a Massachusetts, unless you're on
- 15:55Facebook dark. So, I mean, what what so you
- 15:58can't shut off. The cigarette factory when it
- 16:02comes to Facebook. Yeah.
- 16:04And and it gets complicated and the journal story dealt with
- 16:07this to about like, well what are the other social media
- 16:10platforms doing and are they better for our mental health
- 16:12than that and I know from covering snap that there is a
- 16:15deep belief on you know, the CEO Evan Spiegel is part.
- 16:18A lot of people there that like we did it right?
- 16:21You know, we have moderated, the new section, we don't allow for
- 16:25Mass amplification of false stories.
- 16:28And then I think the journal story Also mentioned like oh
- 16:30Tick-Tock doesn't really, you know, hurt your mental health
- 16:33because it's more about being fun than it is about, you know.
- 16:36It is fun. Would it take it consumes so
- 16:38much of my time? I mean, it is and I never
- 16:41remember anything. I believe my mental health has
- 16:45been impaired in some, right, right.
- 16:47I feel like I just skipped over that period of time, like I it's
- 16:50just like I'm a racing time for my life where after it's done.
- 16:53I'm like what did I get out of it?
- 16:56You know what I mean? Yeah, I enjoyed it.
- 16:57I guess while I was consuming it, To me, like the craziest
- 17:02kind of cover-up on the part of a corporation that I can think
- 17:06of that's happened in the last however, many decades was X on
- 17:09knowing full, well about global warming.
- 17:12And the fact that they had done studies showing that, you know,
- 17:16the consumption of fossil fuels is contributing to carbon in the
- 17:19atmosphere and raising temperatures because that was
- 17:21something that I don't believe was widely known at all at the
- 17:24time. I mean this was something that
- 17:26was like years and years before Al Gore was making his political
- 17:30Koval career off of it and, you know, like, cigarettes people
- 17:33probably knew for a long time, maybe not that it was addictive
- 17:36but that, you know, it wasn't good for your health.
- 17:38And then with Facebook, there have been a lot of third-party
- 17:40studies that have gone on for a long time.
- 17:42Saying like, yeah, this is really fucking with young girls
- 17:45brains. I think a clear thing on Venus,
- 17:48on the Exxon poor women's Brains to jfy.
- 17:51I say as a senior citizen on the Exxon point, I mean, I just
- 17:55think an important thing to remember in these stories is
- 17:57that the companies think about themselves way More than we do,
- 18:01right? I mean, Facebook is obviously
- 18:03doing this research on themselves, like they
- 18:06professionally. The culture is just much slower
- 18:09to sort of digest all the different problems that these
- 18:12companies have whereas they're professionally interested as a
- 18:15regular routine in the 90s people didn't know about
- 18:19ExxonMobil, the culture, it was in the culture.
- 18:22What the difference was was the no I'm not saying that people
- 18:25didn't know about. No, I was just I was actually
- 18:26harm said about like people not Ali knowing people don't
- 18:31understand the difference was that they were finally nailed
- 18:35through. Variety of things including
- 18:37reporting including Congressional hearings, where
- 18:40documents came to light, showing that their critics had been
- 18:43correct. I may be Exxon like the their
- 18:45initial studies happen in like the late 70s.
- 18:47Yeah. They cover things up for a long
- 18:48time, this might be a tangent but you know what?
- 18:52September 11th. There was this whole like
- 18:55copypasta going around around that flight where the, you know,
- 19:00The people took it over and stopped it from being used by
- 19:03the hijackers. What's nine point ninety?
- 19:05Three. I know my pet like wow the tax
- 19:09just had our 20th anniversary, the tax light with the text
- 19:12people were posting Eric was like for was fake.
- 19:15You know it's like created by some Christian sites.
- 19:17Nopes fact checked in you know they say it ends in a prayer.
- 19:20Like it's based on truth, the facts but they like made a whole
- 19:24fake transcript. Nobody online like gives a fuck
- 19:27about it. Probably more people read that
- 19:29story than have ever. I read my cumulative writing
- 19:33ever and it's just like totally made up and I don't know what's
- 19:37my objection here. It's just that.
- 19:38At the end of the day Facebook's capacity to distribute things is
- 19:42what you know. If you just made up one fake
- 19:45post and told it to one person that would have had a small
- 19:49impact, maybe it would have been wrong or like, deceitful, but it
- 19:52would have been small. But now every major we have all
- 19:56these like fake just for the extinct because of Facebook.
- 20:01I was gonna say in part because of us because Facebook allows
- 20:04you and me to post, pretty much. We don't care about the truth.
- 20:08People don't get it then. So until Facebook, clamps down
- 20:11in some way, right? And our ability to post,
- 20:15whatever we want in real time, they can take it down later but
- 20:19a lot of damage can be done before.
- 20:20It's taken down until that happens, it's really hard to see
- 20:23a solution but as an aside because you guys we've talked
- 20:26about BuzzFeed what's going on with Vice.
- 20:28That's that's falling apart. Like what?
- 20:30Let's go. Is it?
- 20:31It's not happening. Yeah, no snow.
- 20:33Does that mean we have no voice someday with?
- 20:36No, they raised. They raised more money.
- 20:38I can, I can give a shout-out to my, former colleague, Jessica to
- 20:41Uncle who wrote the piece on it. They that you have this back
- 20:44fell apart and they were able to squeeze more money out of their
- 20:47investors. And so, it's your call.
- 20:50Whether investors now that the pivot to videos, always worked
- 20:58out for everyone. Yeah, it's really nice.
- 21:00TV channel at this point. So happy I'm not writing about
- 21:03this shit anymore. So walking a happy isn't vice
- 21:07vice is one of those companies where if you polled reporters
- 21:11back then everybody covering it. What it said, this is a disaster
- 21:14that's never going to work. Oh, is he faster?
- 21:17That's never going to work? Yeah, I mean, obviously
- 21:20reporter. The reporter consensus is wrong.
- 21:22Some of the time but it it is always like, is it like, what
- 21:26are the main ones? That's interesting.
- 21:28Sidebar, I'd be interested to hear the Ones where you think
- 21:31the reporter can? I mean, Facebook dying in the
- 21:33pivot to mobile Facebook? Early days?
- 21:36We report. I mean that was before us but
- 21:39reporters were see entire mythology that the media helps
- 21:42support, that technology companies were were good forces
- 21:47for good in the world rather than John we're talking about,
- 21:50picks on, like particular valve. Okay.
- 21:52Yeah. Alright, face.
- 21:53Where reporters were super wrong on likes?
- 21:56I think there were a lot of people who actually said that
- 21:58Vice was going to be this huge force in media and then to those
- 22:01people believe it or they're just like I'm sure but it'll but
- 22:04Vice was almost all to Disney for a bit.
- 22:06Dollars if somebody believed it for a hot second more more than
- 22:09that. Yeah.
- 22:09I mean it was they yeah it's a complicated story because they
- 22:14like all of these media companies raise a shitload of
- 22:17money during a time where there was a belief that these digital
- 22:21media companies were actually tech companies and should be
- 22:24valued on these like insanely large multiples and that it
- 22:27wasn't going to be two companies that swallowed up all the
- 22:30digital advertising dollars over the next couple of years.
- 22:33And so their growth trajectory is all got completely thrown Own
- 22:36off and I don't know like buzzfeed's probably going to go
- 22:39public through its back so we can see what that looks like.
- 22:42I still think a lot of these companies man were way off here,
- 22:45like it's not like it's like the end of Candyland when you go
- 22:49public, like, you still have to be a company.
- 22:51Is it, is it weird for me to feel like, BuzzFeed is starting
- 22:54to be this like, receptacle for all sorts of companies that
- 22:57can't exit. So, they're just glomming onto
- 22:59buzzfeed's thing. Get out through this back.
- 23:02Like this pack is going to collapse under the weight of 4
- 23:04million Acquisitions before The end of the year.
- 23:08Yeah, I mean, well, this pack Market clearly is already
- 23:11falling apart anyway. I mean, I guess we should have
- 23:14Brian Goldberg on here some week, so he can tell us why.
- 23:17I text, you sent me a quote defending BuzzFeed for one of my
- 23:20newsletters that was like, I just obviously like, well,
- 23:24whatever's good for BuzzFeed is good for me.
- 23:26So I'm gonna say, you know, I will say about about Vice.
- 23:29I don't watch their TV show because it's on cable, I mean,
- 23:32that's it, unbelievably stupid, or it was, I think now, Oh, it's
- 23:36on Hulu or something. I've heard it was pretty good,
- 23:38but like their Tech reporting is good like they're, you know,
- 23:41motherboard has some pretty great stories still.
- 23:44Yeah. Yeah.
- 23:45No. Like yeah, like Joseph Cox who
- 23:47does their kind of security? Cybersecurity stories?
- 23:50Is like he will put out like a great story at least a month.
- 23:55I'm super envious of a lot of their work.
- 23:56So I hope the business does well because it's like, it's still
- 23:59good journalism. It's just I don't know how much
- 24:02stock I put in that business model, right again, we never
- 24:05talked about how I'm so happy. Not the immediate report every
- 24:09every time we have these conversations, it makes me glad
- 24:11her and glad you saw Adam moceri.
- 24:13The head of Instagram, you who was quoted in the teen.
- 24:18Girls story was at the Met Gala, right?
- 24:21Here's one of the chairs Eric get it together.
- 24:23He was one of the she's one of the chairs and I posted the
- 24:26pictures. Like what's the beautiful eyes?
- 24:29What's the Instagram version of Let them eat cake.
- 24:32Like I can't believe he went with the timing of that story.
- 24:36I mean that's true is probably in the works for so long, right?
- 24:40And he agreed to be the chair. Probably a year ago.
- 24:44Yeah. Elsa.
- 24:45His outfit looked like he was like fucking Alice in
- 24:47Wonderland. I mean, everybody.
- 24:50The megaliths out. We're not very good, but You
- 24:54know, what is it about being the head of Instagram that causes
- 24:58these Executives to think that their Fashion Icon.
- 25:00Well, that's sort of interesting.
- 25:01You've actually seen a lot of people from magazines and the
- 25:05fashion world like, Vanity, Fair and bow, go to Amazon, and apple
- 25:09and, you know, Instagram Etc. So, there is this weird way in
- 25:15which the fashion world has been trying to court technology in
- 25:18part because technology, especially Instagram has really
- 25:22taken a lot of Glossy magazine, world's clever way, not just an
- 25:27advertising but also in trend-setting.
- 25:30So if you look at what was happening with this year's New
- 25:33York Fashion Week, you saw a lot of things that didn't really
- 25:36feel like they made sense, they were, they've been on a drawing
- 25:39board for a year and a half speaking to a cultural moment
- 25:42that is no longer exist because life is moving so quickly.
- 25:46And that's what we saw at New York Fashion Week.
- 25:48Whereas people who are on Instagram posting that entire
- 25:51time, they were setting and resetting micro trends.
- 25:54It's for the entire last year and that moves you know,
- 25:58commercial buying that moves merchandise.
- 26:00So you know there's a way in which vogue's ability to tell
- 26:04people what they're going to wear, has been greatly
- 26:06diminished because of a company like Instagram Kevin.
- 26:09So there isn't, so there isn't but it's real value.
- 26:12Anna, Wintour wants Instagram there, I definitely think
- 26:15Instagram is setting fashion far more than Vogue.
- 26:18I would say even much more. Like what you're saying 10x?
- 26:21I agree. 100%. I just think the laughable.
- 26:24Thing is that the person who happens to run the corporate
- 26:27structure that is Instagram matters no style at all in that
- 26:30world. You know, like all you're doing
- 26:31is channeling like a long tail of fashion.
- 26:34People the corporate structures. I mean, if you receive your
- 26:37medal and moved to San Francisco and we went, I think we went to
- 26:42a bar, we met, we had to leave because I was the only reward, I
- 26:49think Valencia area Mission, it was so hilarious, man ever seen.
- 26:54Anything like it like he sure it's paired with slacks paired
- 26:58with man, Bernice Ox. Well, it's back to like the
- 27:03fashion Tech connection to. I mean this is what has been
- 27:06going on for a couple of years in the funniest example of it.
- 27:09To me was the I think it's still probably going to happen but the
- 27:12Vanity Fair Tech media new establishment which was mostly
- 27:20old. Entertainment Executives and
- 27:23their six people, but one year, they had Kevin Systrom.
- 27:25Who was then the still the CEO of Instagram on stage with.
- 27:30I think interviewed by maybe on a winter or something like that.
- 27:33Yeah, info and Lena Dunham. And yeah, and I was seeing like
- 27:41Kevin up on stage, talking about Paris, fashion week or some shit
- 27:44like that dress, like he was in sprockets or something.
- 27:47And it was like, this is something about this job.
- 27:51Yeah, something about this job, like warps the brains of tech
- 27:55Executives to think that they're, like, fashion forward
- 27:58and just just wealth. Fucking like, yeah, I guess
- 28:00that's who they're all like. Carl logging.
- 28:03And like, three weeks earlier. They were.
- 28:04Yeah, they were probably hanging out on zux, like, you know,
- 28:06Kawaii compound like wearing, you know, sandals and socks and
- 28:11whatever thoughts are actually kind of in right now.
- 28:13Tom are they? But that is why they get
- 28:16invited, but they but coming back to it, Eric was saying
- 28:20about how the irony of having atomos Airy at the Met Gala as
- 28:24this devastating story is coming out about his company's, you
- 28:29know, impact on young, women was certainly not lost on a lot of
- 28:32people on social media. Also, what I found, fascinating
- 28:35about that story with it. Most Terry gave on the record
- 28:39quotes and the here they gave up all the stories they've given on
- 28:43the earth. We all know the executives do
- 28:45not do that, unless they think they must and that's another
- 28:49great indication. The Wall Street Journal had the
- 28:52goods, because there is one story, he would have gone on the
- 28:56record if he did not. I would love to know like Just
- 29:02the, who the LIE, obviously, who you want to know who's leaking,
- 29:05but like a company like Facebook, I mean, Katie maybe is
- 29:09closer to it than I am. But, I mean, they have lots of
- 29:13like X sort of democrat Obama, Thai people running around in
- 29:17high level like policy, comms job.
- 29:20I just have to imagine like execs or, you know, execs are
- 29:24flipping on them, both in policy and columns, and Leadership some
- 29:28of the people giving quotes are like.
- 29:29I mean, it's just like, at what point Point the company, it
- 29:33would be so hard to have a coherent sort of corporate
- 29:36response in an organization like Facebook, where I imagine people
- 29:40and gay people are engaging directly with those reporters
- 29:44because they have and also it's a company that tells you, you go
- 29:47there to have like these principles.
- 29:49So then everybody feels entitled to sort of, you know, defend
- 29:53themselves to the reporters. I mean, it must be a mess to
- 29:57deal with PR on that story. I cannot imagine it's sort of a
- 30:01Lockdown situation. Where you have like this one
- 30:04calms person going to the Wall Street Journal and it's totally
- 30:07controlled. It must be pretty, pretty
- 30:10chaotic would be my my guess. I don't know if you guys have
- 30:13thoughts on that. I just wonder at this point, how
- 30:17much, Facebook cares? I mean, it's obviously care
- 30:20enough, well, because Zach has complete control over the board
- 30:24and everything the company dry, so he can never be removed.
- 30:26So, how much do you like when you're can never get new right?
- 30:30This isn't new for them. I mean, when the New York Times
- 30:32and others did their Spate of stories, a couple years ago and
- 30:35they hauled Zuck in front of Congress multiple times and now
- 30:39Facebook is worth over a trillion dollars and it's very
- 30:43unclear, you know regulatory Why's what people are going.
- 30:46I know there are antitrust suits and those are messy and I
- 30:49definitely defer to Katie. I'm like, you know, the
- 30:51trajectory that those will go on, but, like, at some point
- 30:53like Facebook, you know, they don't want to be seen as the
- 30:56villain in public, but if they can do that, and also compensate
- 30:59people, you know, their Executives and their employees
- 31:02and the stock keeps going up for the time being.
- 31:04Maybe they're just happy to like take the punches on Twitter.
- 31:06Well, I think enough people like I don't one way to read these
- 31:10stories to me, is that There are a lot of people at Facebook,
- 31:14creating reports because they don't like Facebook, they want
- 31:17it to change. They think they should reform,
- 31:18right? Then that doesn't happen.
- 31:19Why doesn't happen? Because Mark Zuckerberg is in
- 31:22charge. He's a dictator in Chief with
- 31:24Sheryl Sandberg, his loyal lieutenant.
- 31:26And so even if you are a super senior, the company, you're not
- 31:29going to succeed in getting them to change.
- 31:31So then that creates a whole apparatus of people, they're
- 31:33creating the reports somehow, those reports are getting leaked
- 31:36to the Wall Street Journal. There's like, you could see a
- 31:40lot of Facebook, be no line. And with these Wall Street
- 31:44Journal stories because they want change at the top, right?
- 31:48So, to save, Facebook thinks is sort of incoherent.
- 31:52I think you would say there's the Mark Zuckerberg view where
- 31:56he's sort of stopping all these lower level decisions and then
- 31:59there are the sort of Executives that are loyal to him.
- 32:02And then there are these sort of more sort of professional
- 32:04Executives. In the more those executives are
- 32:06tied in to the actual Rank and file.
- 32:08They're going to be responsive obviously to the findings that
- 32:11those rank-and-file are. Seen and are getting ignored.
- 32:14So I would love to know, I mean obviously this is a reportable
- 32:20thing that would be a frustrating to the reporters.
- 32:22Probably. But just yeah, how much of how
- 32:25much of Facebook itself is on board with?
- 32:28Yeah, I don't know. The company is also trying to
- 32:30figure that out as well. I mean worship we should we
- 32:35could put a pin in this one and have Casey Newton on some time
- 32:38who obviously would know more directly than it's so hard on
- 32:42poverty. Like easier for me to say this
- 32:44because I don't have her Facebook so I can just
- 32:46extrapolate from other stories, but I feel like once once you're
- 32:53on the be, the one thing you can't really talk about is the
- 32:56level of like how much are people sort of defecting even
- 32:59when they're sort of principal actors for the company?
- 33:04I think there's zero upside and any of us ever talking about our
- 33:07sources. But every new tapes including
- 33:11that we shouldn't You don't you think?
- 33:14I'm out of school here as a reporter to say it was.
- 33:16No, I'm just saying that I've told my sources.
- 33:18I won't tell people who they are and so I keep that promise.
- 33:21I don't know, that's our premium episodes.
- 33:26We can talk more explicitly about who we talk, but I just, I
- 33:29mean these stories reflect an organization that is not happy
- 33:32tribal that you'll true. I mean, if the organization was
- 33:35happy, Banks, wouldn't really come in organizations really
- 33:38naughty and they were no leaks that I'm right, this, by the
- 33:41way, is like the fundamental thing that At people in Tech,
- 33:43don't understand about reporting and it happens every fucking
- 33:46time when they're just like, why to reporters keep writing
- 33:49negative stories about these companies.
- 33:50And it's like because the employees that your company's
- 33:53don't like the way things are going.
- 33:54And I don't like working there. They're mad at you and they're
- 33:56talking to us. Yes.
- 33:57It's like you were blaming the wrong person.
- 33:59Exactly. Can you can complain on the
- 34:00margins about like angles and stuff?
- 34:02But like, you know, like the beatings will continue so long
- 34:05as morale, doesn't mean, you wouldn't want to look inside.
- 34:08Mmm. Yeah.
- 34:09But not in the way that you want to which is just to ruin.
- 34:11We actually And actually, they don't want to look inside,
- 34:15speaking of tech spending. By the way, we're coming here,
- 34:18the day after the California recall, resoundingly defeated by
- 34:24people, actually deciding to vote.
- 34:26And I got to say, for the certain Tech Executives that
- 34:29spent money on the voting to recall, I wouldn't call that
- 34:32good Roi. Doug Leone, great investment,
- 34:36David Sachs. Well done.
- 34:38Peter teal, what did Peter tell us?
- 34:41I don't remember. I think so, yeah.
- 34:43I'm not going to weigh out on this.
- 34:44You guys stop it. You can your business reporter?
- 34:49You can talk about Roi. Like it's like, I just it's not
- 34:53it's because I did not, I am not as I didn't do it.
- 34:59I didn't study the California recall as Tom did or you did.
- 35:03And so I would just be I don't like to speak about things.
- 35:05I know nothing about. Yeah, well we could come back to
- 35:09this one another time but I would say the every no vote Next
- 35:13Shopkins book, the contrary and I'm a fifth of the way through
- 35:16its good and good. It really frames so far.
- 35:19The whole Peter teal world is like a sort of political Club,
- 35:23more than anything that a big you know, David Sachs Keith her
- 35:26boys. Like the thing they shared was
- 35:29conservative libertarian incoherent in some cases
- 35:33politics and so it's super interesting light of the recall
- 35:37effort, but I think everybody we should finish reading.
- 35:41You guys should get the book I should fit.
- 35:42Yeah. Yeah, before we talk, I'm
- 35:43excited to read it. I'm I wonder though with Peter
- 35:47teal, does the media over rate, how important he is?
- 35:51He's on the board of Facebook. I mean he's I mean, he was the
- 35:55president's around people just want to say.
- 35:58I mean, it's like, do we do well, here does the media over
- 36:01rate. How important the president
- 36:02United States is like, I guess, maybe, but like Peters.
- 36:05That's a lie. That's a lie.
- 36:13It was like the biggest most important donor to President
- 36:17Trump, right? I mean, he will go do, I do
- 36:20things like Robert Mercer lung terms of his political influence
- 36:24and in terms of his business influence, I mean he's on the
- 36:28board of one of the scariest come.
- 36:29He's a billionaire. All these guys have these.
- 36:31All these guys have power in ways that I never fully
- 36:33understand but I just don't want to go too far in this because
- 36:37I'm looking forward to reading my exes, but Zuckerberg is more
- 36:39important than Peter teal. Is that the question?
- 36:41Certainly, the Pure or the coke Brothers.
- 36:43Or the living one? Yeah.
- 36:47What? Living one?
- 36:49He didn't go back to the tape on that replay.
- 36:56Yeah. I just I mean, I don't know that
- 36:58ranking extremely wealthy, people who are able to call,
- 37:01almost anybody at the world, when it whoever they want,
- 37:03whenever they want is really a useful exercise, but like I'll
- 37:07do it. I guess.
- 37:08No, I would agree is to Proclaim his that if you control attack
- 37:11platform, Like Facebook or Twitter, you're more powerful
- 37:15than people who just have money. I don't know if Tom is I would
- 37:19buy on to that. Here's my question.
- 37:20Here's my contrarian question. It's like Duggar does the media
- 37:25over rate his particular does he Loom very large in the mind of a
- 37:29lot of reporters because of his role in The Gawker suit that you
- 37:34know very specifically cast him as but he succeed at what one of
- 37:37the biggest villains. So much of politics is all T
- 37:40fucking killed a new site like that's right.
- 37:42No one's done. Done that before and and you
- 37:45know where he funded a suit that that effectively did that.
- 37:47And I shall I just wonder, I mean freedom of the press.
- 37:51Yeah. I mean that's real impact.
- 37:53Yeah and I just wanted had that not happened but he still was a
- 37:56guy that gave money to Trump in was you know sitting at the
- 37:59right hand and all that other stuff if he would matter as much
- 38:02but Gawker is how we just covered in.
- 38:04Just give us an example of why he matters more than other
- 38:07investors. You literally just gave us an
- 38:09example of why he matters more than other investors.
- 38:11He was a mistake. The reason he killed Gawker was,
- 38:14he was getting covered a ton of already so be even even aside
- 38:18from the reason he was right. Even aside from the reason he
- 38:20killed it, the fact that by your own admission, he did something
- 38:24no other really investors ever done.
- 38:26That had run short of an impact on the press and an impact and
- 38:29we think of like how money can stifle freedom of the press that
- 38:34doesn't that indicate that he is possibly more important than
- 38:37other investors? I'm not saying things like some
- 38:39Puppet Master. I'm saying the time like Tom's
- 38:42the one dressed like he's I know and understand and that, you
- 38:51know, basically says that there were a lot of crazy, kooky sort
- 38:54of anti-climate change, level type people that teal suggested
- 38:59Trumbo Point. And even you know, the Trump
- 39:03people were Steve band and we're like, these are two kooky for us
- 39:08and teal didn't get a lot of those but I mean, some of, you
- 39:11know, the CTO was a teal I think there were some people.
- 39:14There are teal guys over the administration but it sure.
- 39:17Could he pick the Secretary of Defense?
- 39:19It didn't seem like it. So, yeah, I mean, I don't, but I
- 39:22don't really believe in Puppet Masters, but in terms of
- 39:25billionaires that are super powerful, I think he's much more
- 39:28powerful than his actual wealth, or there are much richer people,
- 39:31there are less less powerful. I have very realistic.
- 39:36I got a, I have to I have to make this phone call.
- 39:40It's because I need this information.
- 39:42And so I gotta go unlike Eric. I'm I'm not gonna tell you who
- 39:48my sources are. I didn't tell him Eric's, not
- 39:53going to pressure me into revealing how I get information
- 39:57joking. No, I do have to go because I
- 40:00have to make this call and great.
- 40:02So I hope that you guys are good of America, you know?
- 40:04I hope you come up with a definitive ranking of which Tech
- 40:09billionaires are the most influential vis-à-vis, how much
- 40:12they're By the press and please shoot that over to me because
- 40:16I'm curious to see it. It's a changing.
- 40:18It will be exchanging. Yeah, it'll be like a power
- 40:20ranking list. Yeah.
- 40:21Get. Can we start doing a power
- 40:23ranking list on the pool? Yeah, well, we could run in my
- 40:26work, my friends desperately want me to do more power
- 40:28rankings, just for clickability. I've been opposed to truly sort
- 40:34of capricious judgments just because I have a following, but
- 40:38I do think it'd be good. People want to consume list of
- 40:41who's in, who's out? Shouts.
- 40:43Oh yeah, absolutely. Well isn't that all that she you
- 40:46know I'm actually getting slacked out by co-workers to I
- 40:49guess I do my God. Yeah.
- 41:00Eric you have to do the same job.
- 41:01We have to do is just you have no boxes, all right?
- 41:04Exactly. So I can procrastinate then do
- 41:06it at two in the morning and run a very good sort of mental
- 41:09health experience, right? You're also offer Two weeks to.
- 41:13So you better you better burn that oil for the next couple
- 41:16days while Katie and I have to figure out what to talk about.
- 41:19Yeah. All right we can we can call it
- 41:21though. Okay bye.
- 41:23Bye Katie. So I guess once again We've
- 41:26Ended episode with Katie having to do a real job and now she
- 41:29disappear last episode. Yes, yes, she disappeared
- 41:33because there wouldn't even last episode is coming into her movie
- 41:35theater and she had to like, talk them down and then when she
- 41:38came back on the zoom called, we were already gone.
- 41:40But we ended the last episode without her and I think that's
- 41:43gonna have to be like a weekly thing.
- 41:44Now she's only the, he's a special guests.
- 41:48It's her, it's her duties. Maybe don't include your Napa.
- 41:52So yeah, she's a pain. So, work on Sally, goodbye.
- 42:06Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 42:08Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 42:10Goodbye. think that's gonna have to be like a weekly thing.
- 41:44Now she's only the, he's a special guests.
- 41:48It's her, it's her duties. Maybe don't include your Napa.
- 41:52So yeah, she's a pain. So, work on Sally, goodbye.
- 42:06Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 42:08Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 42:10Goodbye.