Latest / Elsies Little Pickles’s Podcast / Living in a Simulation? Unpacking Media, Brands & Manufactured Consent
Transcript
- 0:29Smash that bell grab that button send a link to a friend but more importantly,
- 0:39please please please more importantly donate to our gofundme it's protect your
- 0:46pickles lc's icebreaker mission you can catch that on our social media you can
- 0:52look it up on GoFundMe or you can go fuck yourself.
- 0:57And if anybody doesn't like you... I believe ICE is in Massachusetts now, so...
- 1:02They're about to find out. I was going to say, if anybody doesn't like you sending
- 1:07them the link of us, just put a little bit of nair in their shape.
- 1:10Yeah, that's all. Just a little bit.
- 1:12Maybe a little preparation H in their toothpaste.
- 1:15That reminds me of this prank that I saw online. I just have to point this.
- 1:19I just have to mention this.
- 1:20This guy was, like, getting bullied at school. So every single day for a while,
- 1:27he would hide pineapples around his bully's house and everyone was like,
- 1:33not believing this kid. And he ended up like in a psych ward.
- 1:39The bully did. I had the bully ended up in a fucking psych ward because no one
- 1:44believed that there was no one believe because that's so ridiculous.
- 1:47Like, what do you mean there was a pineapple in the mailbox?
- 1:49Yeah, but I mean, like, I would think his parents would at least be able to
- 1:52go, show me the pineapple, and he'd be able to show them the pineapple.
- 1:57It just sounds dirty. Show me the pineapple.
- 2:00Especially since that's like a swinger symbol. Is it upside down?
- 2:02Yeah, I was just going to say, it's such a swinger symbol.
- 2:06Show me the pineapple. I had two neighbors that had a prank whore.
- 2:12And so it was always a matter of just watching to see what one does to the other.
- 2:17And one night my neighbor next to me, Mike went out to the neighbor across the
- 2:23street before that guy had to go to work.
- 2:25And he jacked up his car, took off his car tires, all four of them and stuck
- 2:29them underneath the car and lowered the car on top of the tires.
- 2:37Poor fucking guy.
- 2:42Oh all right so this is this is gonna be a
- 2:44little bit different podcast because the last two or
- 2:47three i i gotta say by the way i i don't condone really mean pranks or pranks
- 2:53like that so don't do it in the name of us but if you do get it on picture yeah
- 2:58video yeah send it to lc's little pickles at gmail.com not telling me to do
- 3:03anything but if you do do something we'd,
- 3:05Yeah, if it happens to happen.
- 3:08It's not like you don't have a phone. Take a picture. Take a video.
- 3:12So, yeah. So, anyways, what I was saying is that the last three videos,
- 3:15obviously, we've gone through a lot in the last week we can have with our dad
- 3:20dying and then having to, you know, plant the patriarchal pickle.
- 3:27But prior to that, we were very, very Trump-heavy on what we talked about.
- 3:32So I was trying to figure out,
- 3:35What we could do that could be a small pivot, still stay in the field that we like to play in,
- 3:41but just a little bit of a pivot where we're not just fucking pulling our hair
- 3:46out about Trump or talking about war or talking about death or talking about
- 3:50all that, right? So in the course of this.
- 3:54We still have to do a watch along or at least the first three episodes of season
- 4:00one of Ted. Yes, I know. I'm telling you. I know.
- 4:03It's comedical. The second season just came out. As soon as you get me that
- 4:07password, the correct password, I'll be on it like a bonnet.
- 4:11You got it. So during the course of all this, one of our listeners reached out
- 4:17through social media and sent me a link to a video. It's Chase Hughes.
- 4:23Now, I didn't know anything about Chase Hughes. And to be honest with you,
- 4:25I don't know much, if anything, other than what this video was about.
- 4:30But I did find it interesting because it gets a little bit into the woo-woo.
- 4:34And you guys know I like the woo-woo.
- 4:36Oh, yeah. So, woo-woo-woo, he's talking about simulation theory, in a sense.
- 4:43Yeah, not necessarily directly in the sense of, like, we live in a simulation,
- 4:48but more in the sense of, like, the powers that be are creating a simulation
- 4:53of reality for the masses.
- 4:56And I gotta tell you, like, a lot of the points that he makes are obvious.
- 5:02Some of them are just obvious.
- 5:04But there's a couple in there, the way that he kind of frames everything and
- 5:07puts it all together. They go, okay, I see where you're going.
- 5:10This is pretty interesting.
- 5:12It's very manufacturing consent. Yeah. It's kind of the energy I get from it
- 5:18is like the disgraced...
- 5:20Linguist and philosopher, Noam Chomsky, manufacturing consent.
- 5:25So I guess after, first and foremost, anyone that does have show ideas or videos
- 5:32they want us to watch and comment on, please.
- 5:35Let us know what you want to see. Yeah, just send us an email,
- 5:40lcslittlepickles at gmail.com.
- 5:42We're happy to do that.
- 5:45Anyway, so I watched the video and I'm like, I don't know.
- 5:49Like, it's one of those things where it's like, I know we've been doing a lot
- 5:53of sound drops, but when you take part an entire video that I was like on the fence about that.
- 5:59But I, you know, I said, you know what? Fuck it. Let's just clip this up.
- 6:03I tried to get as much in as possible for what he was saying.
- 6:07I tried very, very diligently to not cut out anything except for like the last
- 6:13three minutes because it was mainly pitching his the next show.
- 6:17But Chase Hughes, check him out. OK.
- 6:20And importantly, I'm pretty sure this all falls under fair use.
- 6:24So I'm hoping if not, just have to take it down.
- 6:27But again, we're promoting Chase Hughes. So I don't know why he would be upset
- 6:31that we're talking about him.
- 6:34And it's not like we're going to be talking negatively.
- 6:37It's just our opinions on it.
- 6:39Some of them good, some of them bad, but that's, I mean, you could do that with
- 6:42our show. You know, if you want to do that chase, have at it.
- 6:46Anyways, this is Chase Hughes. This is clip one.
- 6:48And like I said, this is interesting to me because it's framed under simulation
- 6:53theory, but it is more about powers that be manipulating the herd.
- 6:59Another day. I'm about to unpack something that is horrifying.
- 7:03What people call reality, it's all fake.
- 7:10This isn't going to be another YouTube video full of vague fluff. This is not a metaphor.
- 7:17It's just reality being replaced layer by layer.
- 7:21There are six layers, and you've only seen the first one. I'm so excited.
- 7:31Reality.
- 7:34You used to be grounded in direct experience.
- 7:39You lived through it. And now, reality is mediated.
- 7:46You don't experience events anymore. You experience coverage,
- 7:51pre-framed interpretations of ideas, avatars, personality, costumes, personas, and masks.
- 8:02A headline starts.
- 8:18If symbols become dominant, truth becomes optional because truth doesn't need to be accurate anymore.
- 8:25It just needs to be repeatable, emotionally charged, recognizable, and socially enforced.
- 8:32That is the simulation.
- 8:40Brands figured this out first. Because we don't buy products,
- 8:44we buy a story of ourselves. So that's a word that you hear constantly, brand.
- 8:49And it comes from the old Norse word, brander. And it means to burn.
- 8:55Specifically, it means to burn a permanent mark into livestock.
- 8:59So ownership is obvious and sorting animals out is easy.
- 9:04You are being branded by advertisers, political narratives.
- 9:09The system knows what you're going to react to, what you're going to defend,
- 9:13and what you're going to buy and who you're going to hate.
- 9:17I have nothing that I can argue on that. And I would say this,
- 9:22and I know Kiefer knows this, and I think you do too, buddy.
- 9:27I've always been against brand name clothing and stuff like that.
- 9:33I don't like to advertise.
- 9:35I'm going to point out, one, you're wearing a shirt from my college,
- 9:40so there goes your point.
- 9:43I'm not saying it doesn't happen. Okay. Two. But I only do it on things I'm proud of.
- 9:49In your college, I am proud to say that you went to, and I'm proud to say that
- 9:53I spent the money there, and I'm proud to do your education.
- 9:57My second point is it's kind of a non sequitur to jump from what he was talking
- 10:02about before talking about brands to talking about brands. I get what he was trying to do there.
- 10:08Don't get me wrong. I get what he was trying to do. But that leads into my third
- 10:12point, which is in the first portion, he's talking about how now everything
- 10:17is is judged by the individual through their personal media.
- 10:23Right. I would say that everything is judged through a person's phone nowadays.
- 10:28Well, sure. But through the media personalities that any given person follows.
- 10:33For example, I really like Hassan Piker.
- 10:35I really like Vosh. I really like, you know, my preferred live streamers and YouTubers, right?
- 10:42Right. And while I don't disagree with him making that point.
- 10:49He's leading us to believe that it wasn't that way until technology, which is not true.
- 10:57No, it used to be you only had three, maybe four TV stations.
- 11:00You had, you know, your CBS, NBC, and ABC, and then you would have.
- 11:05And before that, you only had the local newspaper and the national newspaper.
- 11:09Yeah. So I get where you're coming from on that. And yes, that's true.
- 11:13My point, I guess, that I'm getting at is we've always worked within filters.
- 11:20We've always worked within. And I think that it's important to work within filters to a degree.
- 11:26You know what I mean? Because, look, when you have, let's take old standard newspaper, right?
- 11:32When you have editors or a senior editor who is like.
- 11:38At bare minimum you have a journalist and then
- 11:40an editor and a senior editor that so
- 11:44that's three people that you have to get through before that story is
- 11:47on the paper and i think that that's that i don't think that that's a
- 11:49bad thing and i'll tell you why i don't think it's a bad thing
- 11:52because they're not just three layers of fact checking
- 11:55three layers of of are we sure three
- 11:58layers of have you checked with legal three layers
- 12:02of where is your where are your
- 12:04sources from you know like like but it's
- 12:07also three layers of well i don't agree with what
- 12:10this guy's saying so i'm going to change this well that's
- 12:13possible too however nowadays especially with social media sub stack you name
- 12:20it youtube and even podcasts all right no one's checking anything and oftentimes
- 12:28especially on social media a bullshit story.
- 12:33Is no one checking anything or is it now crowdsourced? I guess is the question then because.
- 12:38Well, it becomes crowdsourced after the fact, but you know, what's the old expression?
- 12:44A lie can make it around the world before the truth can pull its pants up.
- 12:48And how many people are influenced? How many people are influenced by.
- 12:53I mean, that's the whole basis of the mega movement that you're getting at is like. Exactly.
- 12:57The lie gets out and then.
- 13:00And what can end up happening. We discussed one time on one of our shows early
- 13:04on how people tend to believe the first thing they hear about a person,
- 13:11you know, any subject. Yeah.
- 13:13Yeah. And that's, that's what it is. You know what I mean? They tend that,
- 13:16that's where they, they tend to lean, especially if it falls within the parameters of their own views.
- 13:22So if it agrees with their views, they tend to believe it, especially if it
- 13:28may, even if it's something that they hate.
- 13:30So as an example, you could hate the idea of war, okay, but be happy that Trump
- 13:38took us into war because it's going to make Trump look bad, right?
- 13:43So, like, these two very, very conflicting ideas can exist in the same headspace.
- 13:49Yeah, and that's like a second or third degree cognitive dissonance.
- 13:52Yeah, so, like I said, just off the get-go, and I'm not going to spend,
- 13:58because there's a lot to get through here. So just off the get-go,
- 14:02yes, there are things that I agree with you on.
- 14:05It's a bit of a jump to go from...
- 14:08Where he started to brands. Not to say that he's wrong.
- 14:14No, I'm not saying he's wrong either. I'm not saying that he's incorrect to
- 14:18have made that jump. It is just kind of a non sequitur to jump from what he
- 14:22was talking about to talking about branding.
- 14:24Yeah, and I would agree with you on that. Now, mind you, again,
- 14:27I want to give this guy full credit, Chase Hughes.
- 14:30I'm going to keep saying his name so that hopefully he gets more traffic from this.
- 14:35Yeah, full credit. And again, I want this to be a positive kind of critique,
- 14:40but any critique is going to have a little bit of negative.
- 14:45So that would be my first little bit of negative is you're right.
- 14:49It was a bit of a non sequitur to get there.
- 14:52However, he's not wrong.
- 14:55It's just that was maybe a little clunky, you know, and this guy says he spent
- 15:01a month putting this, this particular piece together.
- 15:03And I don't doubt that. the admin figured
- 15:06everything out first like about human
- 15:09behavior yeah right yeah so like I get it I understand where he's going with
- 15:14that but I'll leave my point I also understand opening the video the way he
- 15:18opened it and then jumping to a kind of a non sequitur like that in order to
- 15:22bridge the gap to where he needs to go because in the beginning it's it's catchy.
- 15:28You know and that's what you gotta do opening of a video you gotta catch the
- 15:33watcher's attention and hopefully maintain it because this is like almost a
- 15:3820-minute video that he did, right? Yeah.
- 15:41But like I said, I think the idea that he starts off basically kind of making
- 15:46you believe that he's talking about simulation theory.
- 15:49And he does play with that throughout the rest of the episode. He does bring it back to.
- 15:56Yeah, but it's less in the sense of like we're all we're all NPCs and more in
- 16:01the sense of the powers that be are creating a simulation of reality for us.
- 16:06Hold that thought and remind me to swing back around to that a little bit later
- 16:11after we get into this a little bit deeper.
- 16:13All right. All right. So here's clip two.
- 16:16So layer number one is mediated reality.
- 16:20This is why the world feels off. It feels theatrical and overacted,
- 16:25scripted, predictable.
- 16:27Because it is.
- 16:32Empires figured this out thousands of years ago. If you control the symbols,
- 16:36you just need to control what people react to.
- 16:41People have to adopt the symbols.
- 16:45Now people are shaped by metrics and algorithms and visibility and approval signals.
- 16:52There's a very secret name for what all these things are, and they are called conditioning signals.
- 17:00Whatever gets rewarded gets repeated. Whatever gets ignored,
- 17:05disappears. So people adopt.
- 17:08They simplify themselves. They exaggerate themselves. They flatten their entire
- 17:12personality to something that's shareable.
- 17:15So they become more extreme, more predictable, more performative.
- 17:19So people aren't asking, is this how I feel?
- 17:22They're asking, how will this be received by other people?
- 17:26And over time, something breaks. Because when your external performance doesn't
- 17:32match your internal experience, there is one universal response.
- 17:39We feel hollow.
- 17:42This is the death of authenticity. All right. So this is why I forgive the non sequitur. Okay.
- 17:50Because while it seems like he's just saying brands as like,
- 17:56you know, your Nike, your Adidas, your, you know, Levi's, your.
- 18:00Sure. But I, I, I understand where you're going.
- 18:03It's, it's the, the non sequitur that sets up. Oh, yeah, no,
- 18:07you are all slaves to appearances more than what you actually care about.
- 18:13No, actually, yes, yes and no on that one. OK, so, yes, I do see that part of it.
- 18:19But the other part of it that I see in that is this idea of,
- 18:24I don't want to say worshipping brands, but that's kind of what we do.
- 18:30And each one of us has our own brands that we just stick with,
- 18:35whether that's because we like the quality, we like the look, we like the name.
- 18:39So let's say, for example, you're Marxism. That's called commodity fetishism.
- 18:43Well, yeah, but I mean, what did he call it? I forget what he called it now.
- 18:47It doesn't matter. Brand loyalty. Essentially, it's brand loyalty.
- 18:50And what they've done, whether it's shoes or clothes or cars or anything,
- 18:59you know, like that actually is a brand right down to your TVs,
- 19:05your refrigerators, your dishwashers, the hats that you wear,
- 19:09everything has a brand on it.
- 19:12And they've conditioned us to that point so that it's.
- 19:18It falls in line. Of course, they're going to be able to brand our politics.
- 19:23So then, you know, if you're a Democrat, you're a Democrat. If you're a Republican,
- 19:27you're a Republican. They don't really care which side you're on.
- 19:30All right. That's the big secret. They don't really care. Yeah.
- 19:33Well, no, because establishment Dems and Republicans do the same shit either way.
- 19:39Democrats are just a little nicer about it. Yeah, they're a little bit more
- 19:42polite and a little bit more concerned about your feelings.
- 19:45But at the end of the day, you've always been right about this part of it.
- 19:48It's kind of a uniparty, so they don't really give a shit if you fall Republican or Democrat.
- 19:55Just like, you know, at the end of the day, it doesn't matter if it's if you're
- 20:00getting your shit from Amazon or you're ordering directly from the manufacturer.
- 20:06You're still getting what you want delivered to you.
- 20:10You know what I mean? Yeah. And so I guess I look at that and I go,
- 20:15okay, we're all a slave to the brands that we prefer for whatever the reason,
- 20:21whether that's quality.
- 20:24Whether it's we like the way the materials used, we like the fit, the feel.
- 20:29We know that it it it's a
- 20:32brand that that will be worth the money
- 20:35i mean how many times have you bought a t-shirt for 50 bucks and wash it once
- 20:39and all of a sudden it fits a barbie doll yeah so like you know there's or it
- 20:44does it loses its shape or whatever whatever the fuck you know what i mean so
- 20:48we do get branded and we get brand minded and when you do that.
- 20:55It narrows the funnel of your overall view because you stop,
- 21:01like, I know where I buy my pants, whether that's jeans or whether it's cargoes, whatever.
- 21:09I know where I buy almost all of my pants.
- 21:14I don't go looking elsewhere because I'm very happy with the quality of where I get my shit.
- 21:20The prices are what I consider to be reasonable. It ticks all of my little boxes Right?
- 21:28So I don't even really bother Looking anywhere else Now does that shut me off?
- 21:34Yeah because that's narrowed That tunnel It's narrowed that funnel So now if
- 21:40they already know That I'm only buying my pants at one place And I'm only buying
- 21:44my shoes at one place And I'm only buying my boots At this other place And I'm
- 21:49only buying my shirts at another place Well they can,
- 21:53they can aggregate that data.
- 21:57And get a pretty good idea of who I am.
- 22:01It's basically the individual person's data equivalent of what you see at protests,
- 22:08which is called kettling.
- 22:09Okay. Where they get, kettling is when the police, like, kind of get everyone into one area.
- 22:17They, like, strategically will, oh, we're shutting down this street and police
- 22:23are coming up the next street.
- 22:24So no protesters are allowed to go up that
- 22:27street so we're going to kind of funnel you into this one area
- 22:30and then shit's going to kick off exactly it's exactly
- 22:33like that but i mean what we don't realize and i think that this is kind of
- 22:38to the broader point of where this is going what we typically don't recognize
- 22:43or realize is that that data is being collected whether we know it or we We
- 22:49don't know it in everything we do.
- 22:51Every time you turn on your phone, every time you look something up online,
- 22:55every time you make a purchase, every time you go to the grocery store and you
- 23:00use your little fucking card so you can get discount fuel.
- 23:04Oh, that doesn't even matter. I don't know if you know this.
- 23:06That doesn't even matter because of all the fucking Wi-Fi and facial recognition
- 23:11that they have. Oh, again, yes. In stores.
- 23:13Even if you walk in and use cash, you'll still get ads for all the shit that you bought.
- 23:19Oh, it has nothing to do with even, like I said, it has nothing to do with a
- 23:23credit card. It has to do with your little Kroger card, your discount savings card.
- 23:29You know, like every fucking store forever had a thousand of these things.
- 23:34And they still do, but now they don't give you a card, a plastic card anymore.
- 23:38Now they just go off of your phone number.
- 23:40It's all on the app, and it goes off of your phone number. I'm going to go out
- 23:43and buy every week a box of suppositives.
- 23:48Suppositories? yeah thank you now Kiefer you'll
- 23:51probably appreciate this you brought up the uniparty and
- 23:55said that I was correct on the uniparty essentially you
- 23:59have no real choice between establishment democrats and republicans because
- 24:03they're going to do the same shit either way and they're going to stomp out
- 24:06any third or fourth or whatever party wants in on the piece of the pie oh yeah which and we'll
- 24:15build this as we go through this video but,
- 24:19That's why everyone should step outside of that range.
- 24:24There are kind of only two options to step outside of that range,
- 24:28which is you go farther left or you go farther right.
- 24:30And I would hope everyone would go farther left.
- 24:34You would hope. But to quote, and this is...
- 24:39It's very much McDonald's or Burger King. Those are your two choices.
- 24:43Everything else no longer exists. Well, now it's actually McDonald's and Wendy's,
- 24:49because Burger King's number three.
- 24:51Yes, this is true. Now, Kiefer, you'll appreciate this. I pull this directly
- 24:56from Jesse the Body Ventura.
- 24:59In, in describing when he was the governor of Minnesota, in describing his meeting
- 25:04with Fidel Castro, he said, oh, how authoritarian of them.
- 25:08They only have one party. Look at us, the beacon of freedom.
- 25:12We have two. Yeah. We have two.
- 25:15So I, like I said, I think that. Granted, he ran in for governor as an independent. Yeah.
- 25:22So, I mean, I think, like I said, I get where you're coming from off of the
- 25:26jump with this guy, Chase Hughes.
- 25:29But I think that he did a pretty good job of showing us in the second clip why it started that way.
- 25:38Well, and again, I respect the analysis. And we'll get into this once we get
- 25:42through all the clips, my overall take on his take.
- 25:46I respect the analysis and I respect the position his analysis holds over the uninformed person.
- 25:54Well, I think, too, what people have to understand as they're listening to this
- 25:57is that there are, you know, and we spoke briefly about this earlier,
- 26:03me and Colton, that there is different levels of political engagement and knowledge.
- 26:11And if that doesn't fall into your daily sphere, like it does for the three of us, good on you.
- 26:19You know what I mean? Yeah, you probably have a much better mental state.
- 26:23And you're probably just living life pretty happy overall, except for the annoyance
- 26:28of having a job and having bills to pay.
- 26:30And maybe, you know, not liking the Karen that lives down the street.
- 26:35But I mean, let's face it, even in our family, there are you got cousins that
- 26:39are just not plugged into politics at all. Yeah.
- 26:43And they would hear this and it would it would do something their world.
- 26:48It would shake them up bad.
- 26:50It would probably shake them up really bad.
- 26:53Yeah. However, but with that being said, that's also a reason why it's like
- 26:59when I'm hearing parts of this, I'm like, yeah, duh.
- 27:03I have to remind myself that not everyone is steeped in the daily news cycle
- 27:09the way the three of us are.
- 27:12So, right. Here's clip number three. This is a bit longer one, so buckle in.
- 27:17Which brings us to layer number two, human conditioning.
- 27:21Once this is in place, training is what replaces learning.
- 27:25And they do this through algorithmic reinforcement, repeated narratives,
- 27:29emotional escalation, social punishment, visibility rewards.
- 27:34Information has to change shape because information creates understanding.
- 27:39So the system replaces information with content.
- 27:43And this brings us to layer three, the collapse of information.
- 27:51So what's the difference between information and content?
- 27:54Information answers questions, and content stimulates responses.
- 28:02Most of what fills your feed is not meant to be important.
- 28:06It is meant to occupy attention, trigger emotion, maintain your engagement,
- 28:12and prevent silence from entering your life.
- 28:16Because silence is where thinking happens.
- 28:21This is why everything feels urgent. You feel engaged. You feel aware. You feel more mature.
- 28:28But nothing ever results because resolution ends the engagement cycle.
- 28:35It's designed to make you feel like you're participating in it.
- 28:40Which brings us to layer number four, fear and identity control.
- 28:45Humans evolved to survive in small
- 28:48groups where exclusion meant death that
- 28:52wiring has never changed belonging used
- 28:55to come from family and tribe and shared
- 28:58work with other people but now it comes from follower counts and group identities
- 29:03and digital approval so conformity is enforced with social threat you're quietly
- 29:09warned and you're shown that not reacting might be suspicious Questioning the
- 29:13frame is dangerous. So people react publicly.
- 29:17Why? Fear of ostracism.
- 29:20The fear of being labeled, being seen as one of them. It's constant in the background of everything.
- 29:29And that is not accidental.
- 29:32And obviously, social media didn't invent fear. But it multiplied it by orders
- 29:38of magnitude. And here's why.
- 29:42Fear scales engagement better than any other emotion. It speeds reaction. It reduces nuance.
- 29:51It increases sharing, and it locks your memory in place.
- 29:55So the system learns, it tracks, what spikes your heart rate,
- 30:00what makes you comment, what makes you argue, what makes you pissed off,
- 30:05and it feeds you more of that shit.
- 30:08Every post is a potential punishment that we're dealing with.
- 30:12Hate, panic, fear, and anger become advertising products.
- 30:17The longer you stay emotionally activated, it, the more valuable you become in real dollars.
- 30:24Fear has to be sustained.
- 30:30A stable identity does something dangerous. It resists manipulation.
- 30:36But the system is very clever.
- 30:40In a constant state of moral emergency. Every week there's a new crisis,
- 30:45new outrage, some new villain that's pre-packaged for you, a new law being passed,
- 30:51a new line that you're expected to know.
- 30:53It creates what looks like clarity, but it isn't.
- 30:58Something detonates emotionally that it's immediately buried by the next thing.
- 31:03That's identity fragmentation. When people don't have time to form their values slowly.
- 31:10They accept a prepackaged moral frame. These are ready-made positions.
- 31:16Approved language, approved emotions, approved enemies.
- 31:19Morality stops being something that we develop, and it becomes something that we display.
- 31:27Signaling replaces moral reasoning. Virtue becomes a lapel pin.
- 31:33Ethics become performative.
- 31:35Belief becomes a freaking costume. And once morality is externalized like that,
- 31:41it's easy to control because it's a simulation.
- 31:46It's fake. It can be updated remotely. You can see it in how fast people switch positions.
- 31:55And it's not because they learned some new information, it's just because the frame got changed.
- 32:00And here's the most unsettling part, as if the other ones weren't.
- 32:03People start to feel relief when morality is handed to them,
- 32:08because it removes responsibility.
- 32:10They don't have to think, they just have to align.
- 32:15And alignment feels safe when fear is everywhere. If identity and morality are
- 32:22programmable, division of human beings becomes super easy.
- 32:28And that all comes down to one huge manipulation tool.
- 32:33So, all right, I guess, all right. There's a lot there. There's a lot to unpack there. Okay.
- 32:42A fuck ton. If I may, I would like to start by critiquing his his assertion
- 32:49that morality becomes performative instead of morality already always being performative.
- 32:55And my evidence for that is looking back to John Locke's state of nature.
- 33:01Which is essentially, in a state of nature, humans live a short,
- 33:05brutish life because there are no laws to guide them.
- 33:11There are no principles of morality to stay their hand in any discernible way.
- 33:19Morality is always performative. And I'm not saying that in the sense of,
- 33:24like, I would feel comfortable going out and murdering someone.
- 33:27That's not what I'm saying.
- 33:28But what I am saying is... You could get comfortable with the idea afterwards pretty quickly.
- 33:36What I am saying is absent any kind of moral framework imposed by society,
- 33:42whether that's a Christian morality, whether that's a Jewish morality,
- 33:46whatever, a philosophical morality, it doesn't matter.
- 33:49Without an external moral framework being imposed on society,
- 33:56there are a lot of people who would just go out and murder someone.
- 34:01Okay, so let me... And they wouldn't think twice about it.
- 34:04Let me rebut that to a degree, because, again, I find myself a bit on the fence with that one.
- 34:12And I'm not saying that you're wrong or John Locke is wrong,
- 34:16okay? And we're talking the original John Locke, not the one from Lost.
- 34:21John Locke, the proto-founder of the United States. In many ways, in many ways.
- 34:28The argument that I would have is that, yes, given... If you took a human being
- 34:37prior to any type of civilization, okay?
- 34:42Any type of civilization, any type of tribalism, and let's say you only had
- 34:47it in a pack of less than 20 and.
- 34:53There would still be morality that would be passed on. Imposed by the group. Imposed by the group.
- 34:59Exactly. Which is my point. It is imposed by the group. And it's always been imposed by the group.
- 35:05But it doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
- 35:08No, no. I'm not asserting it doesn't exist. And I'm not asserting that it is invalid.
- 35:14My point is that the performative aspect of morality, The societal pressure
- 35:21to adhere to societal morality is,
- 35:26one, present, and two, the correct reading of the situation.
- 35:33And also, that's the reason for the invention of politics and religion, okay?
- 35:40Exactly. I mean, it's the societal imposition of morality. Of an overall agreed
- 35:47morality for whatever size of city, state, country, whatever.
- 35:54Yes. Yeah. I agree. I agree completely with that.
- 35:57My question is on this, while fully agreeing with you on that and fully agreeing
- 36:04with John Locke on that, my question is this.
- 36:08If you were, let's call it, put into a Tarzan position, right?
- 36:15You're being raised by a fucking gorilla, a chimpanzee, and a lemur.
- 36:22And maybe... Watch me swing. Yeah. Like, maybe that's just how you're being
- 36:27raised. You're being raised in the jungle.
- 36:28Your parents were killed or lost or whatever. Steve, Steve, Steve.
- 36:32We're going to the jungle. Happy as can be.
- 36:36Watch out for that tree if you had the ability to survive from let's say four
- 36:44or five years old with no human contact,
- 36:49I still believe that you would form self-imposed moralities but what would that
- 36:57be based on is my question it would be based on your human emotions and I,
- 37:04At least my opinion is, and you can tear me up for this if you want to,
- 37:09because I'm forming my opinion as I speak.
- 37:12Well, I happen to be part eight, and I still have morals. Yes,
- 37:17I know. I've had to shave your back.
- 37:20My counter to that would be there are tribes that view cannibalism as totally okay.
- 37:27I'm not saying that that would fall under it, okay? But for that person who
- 37:34was four or five years old, left in the jungle,
- 37:39and survived to be 30, 35, 40, whatever...
- 37:45You cannot, as a human being, not have emotion.
- 37:50True. It's just the way it is.
- 37:53And what do we do as human beings? We do everything we can to avoid sadness or the feeling of guilt.
- 38:02No one tells you what guilt is. No one tells you to feel guilty.
- 38:07No, it's like an individual materialism.
- 38:10That gets to my point. Sorry, not materialism, utilitarianism.
- 38:14That's what I was looking for.
- 38:16Well, this is where I'm going with that is, is don't you feel that,
- 38:20or don't you think that just by the nature of being a primate with feelings,
- 38:26that that would start to form, even if it was just fucking very rudimentary,
- 38:34some form of morality?
- 38:37I mean, maybe to an extent, but I think that ends when you're hungry.
- 38:41Because like i mean
- 38:44if if it's if it's a state in the state of nature john
- 38:47locke's state of nature okay and i have been starving i have not been able to
- 38:52successfully hunt and i haven't found anything other than a couple of peanuts
- 38:56okay and i encounter another human being that is sleeping.
- 39:05Well, I'm sorry, but that thigh meat's looking pretty cookable and eatable.
- 39:09Well, yeah, but you're under the impression that killing to that particular
- 39:17Tarzan-like person, you're under the impression that, A,
- 39:23they would not see that.
- 39:24To me, morality ends at a hungry stomach.
- 39:27That's where I'm... Okay, but that doesn't... First off, I disagree with that,
- 39:32too, because there are plenty of examples throughout history,
- 39:36whether you're talking Native Americans or whether you're talking modern day hunters,
- 39:41where they hunt the food, they hunt the deer, they hunt the rabbit, the birds, whatever.
- 39:47Already under a societal morality. Well, hold on. Hold on.
- 39:52I guess you could say yes, under a societal morality, even going back as far as cavemen.
- 39:59But at the end of the day, my point being is, is that if you look at the Indians,
- 40:04And specifically, they would say essentially a prayer over that animal.
- 40:12They would thank the animal for the meat.
- 40:14They would thank the animal for the sacrifice.
- 40:17They would thank the animal for feeding their tribe. They would thank the animal.
- 40:21And even to this day, hunters still will take a bite out of a deer's heart as
- 40:28a respectful type of ritual.
- 40:32You know what I mean? And consuming that deer, making that heart of that deer part of them.
- 40:38So I don't see hunting or feeding yourself or being hungry as a moral divide.
- 40:48What I'm saying is, if you were that Tarzan-like creature, and you just went
- 40:55out killing all day, every day, anything that came across your path.
- 41:00Then I think that there would be a cause for concern.
- 41:05But why would that person take more than they could ever possibly use?
- 41:12Now, that's law of the jungle. And now we're getting into capitalism.
- 41:20The law of the day is capitalism.
- 41:22Take every fucking thing. Take everything that they can, even if it's more than
- 41:26they could ever use. And steal what they can't get their hands on.
- 41:30And trip you on the way to the fucking water well.
- 41:33And, like, the level of moral disconnect in the world because of capitalism, to me, is far,
- 41:48far worse than the moral.
- 41:50You're sounding like a true red now. You're sounding like a straight-up Soviet.
- 41:55Shit. But I mean, it sounds more that sounds more morally reprehensible than
- 42:01anything that it sounds more morally reprehensible than anything that a Tarzan like childlike,
- 42:10uneducated, dropped in the fucking jungle type person would ever. I agree.
- 42:17So, so like, all right, that's, let me move on a little bit.
- 42:21Cause I saw you writing, you had more points that you wanted.
- 42:24I got a ton of points here. So, so getting back to the, I want to get back to
- 42:28where you had said the, uh, it's not because of social media.
- 42:33This has always been the case. And then we said that there were three channels.
- 42:37Okay. Yes, there were three channels, but here's the difference between the
- 42:41three channels we grew up with for the news and local and national newspapers versus social media.
- 42:48One, those news shows only came on at a certain time. They were on TV.
- 42:54You couldn't watch them later. You couldn't record them until,
- 42:57what, the mid-80s, late 80s?
- 43:01I mean, you're not going to get any argument out of me that social media is brain rot.
- 43:05I agree. No, no, no. But this is the difference, right? So back then we had,
- 43:09you know, three channels in your local paper, maybe a town paper,
- 43:12and then the national paper.
- 43:14If you were going to buy the papers, if you were going to read the papers,
- 43:18you had to buy the paper. So now it was money out of your pocket.
- 43:21Then you had to spend time actually flipping through the fucking paper and actually
- 43:24reading the paper. All right.
- 43:26I think that that's better because you had to make an investment in your knowledge. Right.
- 43:32First off, secondly, no real argument out of me.
- 43:35It's still propaganda, but no argument out of me. But you could make your mind
- 43:39up on whether or not you agreed with those articles and they were much more
- 43:43thoughtful and they were much more well produced than any fucking social media
- 43:47post, including from journalists today.
- 43:50Sure. Again, you're not getting an argument out of me on that.
- 43:53But so, you know, like when you look at social media, it's nothing but a constant
- 43:58stream 24-7, 365 of just dumpster fire bullshit.
- 44:03Yeah. Right. So you're never going to get to the point where you feel like,
- 44:07you know, everything that you need to know.
- 44:09Whereas at least back in the day when it was just three channels and,
- 44:14you know, a handful of papers across the country.
- 44:17You had time to digest. You had time to actually sit with that information.
- 44:21You had time to digest it. You had time to think about it.
- 44:24You definitely felt as if nothing else.
- 44:27It had been vetted, even with a slant, even with a political slant.
- 44:32Going back to the video that we're dissecting here, he made a point during this
- 44:39last clip where he was discussing the fact that you are thrown information.
- 44:43And then before you even have time to think about it, you're thrown a different story.
- 44:49Exactly. And that's forgetting, you forget the story before the story is resolved.
- 44:53Again, no argument. No argument. I get where he's coming from.
- 44:59Other aspect i think is there is
- 45:02inherently in our
- 45:05lizard brains a tribal need
- 45:09we have to that's more monkey brain maybe monkey brain but but yeah there is
- 45:15still a tribal need there's and and with social media with the ability to walk
- 45:21around with that black mirror in our hand that we call iphone or,
- 45:25or, or whatever, Samsung.
- 45:27It allows you to more easily find your tribe. No, not only does it do,
- 45:32well, it does that, but you're never in their presence.
- 45:35It's all online.
- 45:38And what ends up happening is you actually, because you're, you're finding a
- 45:43tribe online that you're never going to sit with.
- 45:47You're never going to have a drink with. You're never going to go to dinner with.
- 45:49You're never going to have any type of social experience with.
- 45:52It shuts down all of
- 45:55the real life experiences of people that
- 45:58are your friends or could be your friends or
- 46:01are your neighbors or whatever and again you
- 46:04know me i fucking hate people the last thing i want
- 46:07is a goddamn neighbor i don't need any new friends and i'm not interested in
- 46:12fucking going out to dinner but i do see the damage go you should still be able
- 46:17to go and i still see I still see the benefit in that for most people.
- 46:26Now, you're striking on the hot iron that Marx would call alienation.
- 46:33Not to bring it right back to communist literature, but you're talking about alienation,
- 46:41where in the sense of, in this specific case, we are being alienated from other
- 46:50people while being given the illusion of having,
- 46:54the most connectivity with other people we've ever had.
- 46:57Well, yeah, but that's a fact. I mean, we're more connected,
- 47:00but we're also in more of a solitary confinement of our own making.
- 47:05I mean, don't you agree, Keith?
- 47:07I mean, do you think that you are more social face-to-face today than you were in high school?
- 47:21Well, I guess more broadly, just do you have more human connection
- 47:24no i think things
- 47:28like computers cell phones have made
- 47:31it the syndrome of online trolls
- 47:34people say shit behind your back which to them is the same thing as saying it
- 47:40onto a computer because they don't have to worry about retribution like a punch
- 47:45in the face right there's no there's the keyboard cowboys have no fear of any retribution,
- 47:53and this all of course again getting back
- 47:56to the video plays directly into the hand of
- 47:59the powers that be because the more divided we are the more isolated and alienated
- 48:03we are from one another the less likely it is that we recognize we're all getting
- 48:07fucked in the ass by these people well that's that's part of it but the other
- 48:10part of it is the fit in if you can you know what i mean so like you got to
- 48:15fit in somewhere and you know,
- 48:17I mean, let's face it at the end of the day, you're just looking for people that you can either.
- 48:24Virtue signal you're looking for your echo chamber
- 48:27on you're looking for your echo chamber yes and you
- 48:30know you know part part of one of
- 48:33the things that i've been enjoying is i
- 48:36get older and i've made the observation that
- 48:40the older they that i get the less
- 48:42i care about what other people think of me oh i
- 48:45could look i've been that way for fucking 30 plus years if not longer you know
- 48:49that keifer i mean i oh yeah i and to a point so have i obviously well yeah
- 48:56but we were raised by elsie whose motto was fuck everyone yeah but but even
- 49:02the older that i get i'm just like,
- 49:05just don't fucking care i i get the same way okay but i i'm moving out to the
- 49:10middle of nowhere so i can keep people away from me yeah i did the same thing
- 49:14if i like you you know where you'll find me exactly to a city because i want
- 49:19to be i want to be in it i want to meet people,
- 49:23all right i just want to put a couple quick pins in this one the idea of the false morality,
- 49:29you know as far as like wearing the the lapel pin and stuff like that or doing
- 49:34a post or having the flags next to your fucking thing on online or or i agree
- 49:40it's performative or having the bumper sticker but he's right that's what they're
- 49:44doing they're looking for,
- 49:47they're looking for a way to basically announce.
- 49:52Who they are and what they are don't talk to me unless you agree with these
- 49:56things exactly don't talk to me and again it's not that I'm disagreeing with
- 50:02that being the reality of like where we are but my point by bringing up the
- 50:09state of nature my point of bringing up.
- 50:12Morality in general is that that's kind of the entry ticket to being in society
- 50:18is like not necessarily the fact that you have to look like vocally announce or online announce.
- 50:25Don't talk to me unless you agree with these things.
- 50:28I has gone too far in some respects. I think I think the idea of that is ridiculous.
- 50:34I think that the only you know, it's like the old saying of you don't make peace
- 50:39with your with your allies. You make peace with your enemies,
- 50:42and the only way to make peace with your enemies is to have a conversation with them.
- 50:48Yeah, again, I'm not saying that it hasn't gone too far in many respects.
- 50:52It's gone. Dude, let me tell you something.
- 50:54But my point is morality is imposed by society, and if you want to be a part
- 51:00of society, that's kind of the fucking entry ticket. Yeah, but see, that's the thing.
- 51:04It's having morality imposed on you. I think that this might be one of those
- 51:07generational divides, you being Z, me being X, Keith being X.
- 51:15I think it's one of those generational divides because you've never lived in
- 51:20a world where your morality...
- 51:25All right, so as an example, not only was the divorce rate through the roof,
- 51:29and not only were we latchkey kids, And not only, you know,
- 51:31was there less supervision in general, but you also did have that that kind
- 51:36of Hillary Clinton and takes a village mentality, because even if your mom worked,
- 51:43there's a good chance that your friend's mom didn't.
- 51:46And if they knew your full name, they held you accountable.
- 51:51So you if you fucked up and a name and I'll be damned if on our block,
- 51:57damn near every neighbor knew our name.
- 52:01You know what I mean? They had to. Yeah, well, they ended up knowing our name
- 52:04because one reason or another.
- 52:06Sometimes it was because me and Keith did some shit bad.
- 52:10Right? Again, that's society imposing morality on you guys.
- 52:14It's the difference between radical individualism and at least being warm to collectivism.
- 52:20But here's my point with that, and here's where I think what you mistake with that, okay?
- 52:25My point is that while we had more freedom than any other generation probably
- 52:31in the history of fucking forever.
- 52:34Yeah. Right? We had more freedom in one way, but we were also being watched
- 52:39by people who felt some level of responsibility to make sure that we didn't get hurt.
- 52:48I mean, it didn't always work, as we discussed in the pipe bomb episode.
- 52:56But no one got hurt. No one got hurt.
- 52:59Just a three foot by three foot, just a three foot by three foot patch of ground got fucked up.
- 53:05All right. Now, one other quick note on this, on this last one,
- 53:10the use of the word alignment.
- 53:13This word terrifies me. It bothers me more than any other word.
- 53:19If you know, some people hear anyone say that word.
- 53:22Oh, I hear it a lot. I hear it a fucking lot.
- 53:25I never hear someone say, But you don't pay a lot of attention to the AI world.
- 53:32No, because I think it's a dead technology already. Well, that's the big buzzword in AI.
- 53:39And if you look at the way that he's using it in this video, it's control of people.
- 53:44Get everyone in alignment with your either red or blue, your right or left, your Nike or Adidas.
- 53:53You know what I mean? And you get the same shit no matter what.
- 53:56Exactly. It's made in the same factory. There's just a big vat.
- 54:00Just, there's your tennis shoe. There's your socks.
- 54:04There's your shirt. Reminds me of an episode of SpongeBob where Mr.
- 54:07Krabs sells to a corporate restaurateur and they start making Krabby Patties out of great goo.
- 54:15That's what it is. That's all it is. All right, we'll move on here.
- 54:20All right, so let's continue our dissection of this.
- 54:24Like I said, I still think it's an interesting thing.
- 54:28We haven't done this where we've taken like one kind of little
- 54:31bit longer video and and
- 54:34shared it with the audience so hopefully everyone enjoys because i think it's
- 54:37interesting yeah i mean it's definitely fruitful for conversation yeah and and
- 54:42again i want bring this up at the next the next family dinner yeah yeah this
- 54:48is this is good thanksgiving dinner conversation.
- 54:53Again, though, I want to... All I'm saying is Easter is right around the corner.
- 54:56I want to give Chase Hughes his due.
- 54:58You know what I mean? And hopefully he gets some new viewers from this.
- 55:02So, all right, this is the next clip of that.
- 55:04Layer number five, narrative warfare.
- 55:08So modern news is not here to report on reality.
- 55:11It's designed to completely and totally construct narrative frames.
- 55:16It decides who's a victim, who's a villain, who's righteous,
- 55:20and what questions are allowed. The facts are completely optional.
- 55:25So here's the mechanism. An event happens.
- 55:29Immediately, the story arrives fully formed.
- 55:32And you're told how to feel, who to blame, what it means, and which side you're on.
- 55:39And all this happens before you have time to think.
- 55:42Facts don't radicalize people.
- 55:45Narratives do that. Because narratives come with heroes and enemies and moral
- 55:50certainty and urgency and full-blown permission to hate people.
- 55:56One detail gets amplified, another gets buried, context gets removed,
- 56:02until complexity completely disappears.
- 56:06Nuance is always the first casualty here. Because nuance slows reaction time.
- 56:12And reaction is the product. This is how deliberate demonization works.
- 56:19You don't argue with the other side, you just dehumanize them.
- 56:24They're not human. This is where the left versus right illusion becomes very
- 56:30useful to them. It's audience segmentation.
- 56:33It's two simplified tribes, two emotional markets, two predictable reaction sets.
- 56:40Because while people are fighting each other, nothing upstream is ever examined.
- 56:46This is why wins are celebrated by all these politicians. Even when nothing
- 56:52changes, they're celebrating wins all the time.
- 56:54All these headlines and viral clips give us this placebo of things taking place.
- 57:00Things are happening. And once people are emotionally invested in these narratives,
- 57:05they will defend those narratives even when the narratives hurt them.
- 57:10Because abandoning the story means abandoning the identity.
- 57:15Once narratives are doing the work, politics don't need to govern anymore.
- 57:20The only thing that politics has to do is perform. Which brings us to layer number six.
- 57:25So that is absolutely MAGA right there.
- 57:29Yeah. And I mean, again, like I, I agree. It's not that I disagree.
- 57:35We'll get, we'll get to my overall point once, once we get.
- 57:38So, so my argument on this, unless you want to pipe up Kiefer, do you have thoughts?
- 57:45I really don't. I have issues with thinking we're in a simulation,
- 57:49but as I said to you, both of you, sell me on this,
- 57:54sell me your sides, that did sound very much like conservative America right now.
- 58:00I got the imagery in my head of Christian nationalism, primarily.
- 58:09Yeah, and I mean, he's not wrong. To me, he's not wrong.
- 58:13It's just the fact that he's pointing out a truth about,
- 58:19world like it we're all slaves to the narrative would you would you have always
- 58:26been slaves to the new okay but would you read and i'm not saying that that's
- 58:30right or wrong i think it's wrong but would you reduce that argument though
- 58:35it's like sebastian bach said we're a slave to the grind.
- 58:43Did he say that before or after he he got christina applegate and she ended
- 58:50up leaving she leave brad pitt she left brad pitt made brad pitt drive her mom
- 58:56home yeah that's what i thought,
- 58:58and he did because he's a nice guy yeah he's a nice guy yeah and you look at
- 59:03sebastian bach and from what I hear for as pretty as,
- 59:07pretty as Sebastian Bach was in his 20s and 30s that is a perfect example of a banana going bad.
- 59:18Flash forward you know 30 years yeah
- 59:22he was better looking now yeah he uh I guarantee
- 59:26Brad Pitt but Brad Pitt is still stinky uh
- 59:29you know what I gotta be honest my understanding is he
- 59:32does not shower as often as he should well you know
- 59:35what that that all may be true but that is that
- 59:38is just leveling the playing field for all the other
- 59:41men or maybe i'm just a slave to the fucking narrative yeah
- 59:44you could be but i mean if you think about it if you had to no matter if man
- 59:49woman or whatever if you had to to wake up in the middle of the night and look
- 59:54over and see either sebastian bach laying there or brad pitt laying there which
- 59:59one are you going with no matter what easy choice yeah No matter how bad one sticks.
- 1:00:03I'd be like, when did this middle-aged lesbian with long hair get in my bed? What the hell happened?
- 1:00:17Anyways my point being would you reduce your
- 1:00:20argument yeah but i'm so envious of river right now
- 1:00:23would you
- 1:00:29colton reduce your argument on that to to
- 1:00:33to the the simplest level
- 1:00:36in this i mean in the sense that like yeah i mean there are fucking narratives
- 1:00:41given to us by politicians and given to us by mainstream media and i'm not saying
- 1:00:47that that's right or wrong necessarily you're saying you're saying that it's
- 1:00:53just inherent to the system it's not a it's not a bug it's a feature.
- 1:00:57Exactly exactly like there's not really anything there's not really anything
- 1:01:02being said there Well, I guess my argument to you on that is— Every individual
- 1:01:09and especially every collective,
- 1:01:12whatever that collective is, whatever that group is, has a narrative.
- 1:01:16And you either agree with that narrative or you don't.
- 1:01:20All right, so let's give— Hopefully, you know, you find a narrative that's closest
- 1:01:27to the truth, but no narrative is closest to the truth.
- 1:01:30Let's give social media the benefit of the doubt of having been around for 26, 27 years.
- 1:01:36I don't know when MySpace came on the scene exactly.
- 1:01:40But let's say... Early 2000s. I thought it was 99, but was it early 2000s for MySpace?
- 1:01:46Could have been. I don't know. All right. Let's call it 26 years.
- 1:01:49All I know is that Tom is probably sitting by himself on MySpace going,
- 1:01:53don't you bitches wish you were still here? Yeah.
- 1:01:58So let's give it the benefit of the doubt and say it's been around for 30 years, okay?
- 1:02:03And let's say... 2003, so almost 30 years.
- 1:02:07Okay, so 23 years. And can you do a quick check on Facebook when that went live? 2007.
- 1:02:14Same year as the iPhone came out.
- 1:02:17So now if you think about this, right?
- 1:02:20And roughly in between... Oh, I'm sorry, 2004.
- 1:02:26Oh, okay. For Facebook. So let's call it then, let's call it 24 years, okay?
- 1:02:32Because MySpace was popular, but nowhere near what Facebook did.
- 1:02:37It was popular, but niche, and then Facebook happened, and everyone adopted Facebook. Exactly.
- 1:02:43Never be the first to the gun. And then you ended up with Instagram,
- 1:02:47then you ended up with Twitter, then you ended up with Snapchat,
- 1:02:50then you ended up with Blue Sky, you ended up with all these fucking things, right?
- 1:02:55Mm-hmm. So, the narratives are, it's not just news that you're getting on social
- 1:03:02media, it's not just fucking cute videos of kittens.
- 1:03:07Dogs were pictures of food that people are eating, which by the way is one of
- 1:03:12the most depressing fucking things about being my age.
- 1:03:16All the hot chicks that I went to high school with now do nothing but take pictures of their food.
- 1:03:23And then you see one picture of them and you realize they ate all that food. Quick side note.
- 1:03:29Yeah. I mean, aside from that quick side note, the one of the,
- 1:03:31one of the most depressing things is people saying Instagram eats first.
- 1:03:39So i'm guilty though of taking pictures of
- 1:03:42my food and posting it however i
- 1:03:46don't generally care what other people think to me that's
- 1:03:49a reminder that i was there yeah which
- 1:03:53i mean to me that's a different thing it'll pop
- 1:03:56up again oh i should go back to that yeah let me tell you i don't buy into any
- 1:04:01of that and the last thing i want to do is take pictures of my food okay But
- 1:04:07I guess my point here is when you recognize how...
- 1:04:15Social media forms your opinions. And I include YouTube. I mean, this guy included.
- 1:04:21When you realize how much social media is influencing your opinions and your
- 1:04:25attitudes. And my God, YouTube, I just read, has surpassed like all of the media
- 1:04:33companies as far as ad revenue combined.
- 1:04:36Like everyone. I mean, yeah. I mean, there are ads on every single video,
- 1:04:40basically. You know, so like.
- 1:04:42They're the most. I was watching a video, and I do tend to time how often an
- 1:04:49ad pops up, and I've seen it as quickly as every two minutes.
- 1:04:54I don't doubt that. At which point, I close the video and find something else to watch, personally.
- 1:05:02But when you come to the realization that a company that's less than 30 years
- 1:05:10old, but definitely probably even less than 20. YouTube is 21.
- 1:05:1521. Okay. So YouTube's 21 years.
- 1:05:17YouTube can drink a beer. In 21 years, YouTube was able to create an environment that...
- 1:05:28Was able to garner the
- 1:05:31interest of advertisers at such a rate that
- 1:05:35it surpassed not one
- 1:05:38of the media companies but all of the
- 1:05:41media companies and not individually but combined
- 1:05:44what the fuck does that tell
- 1:05:47you about where this is all going because to
- 1:05:50me that tells me yeah they got a great business
- 1:05:53model but i also remember when people
- 1:05:56were like i can't believe that they're actually advertising
- 1:05:59they're doing advertising on youtube i remember being outraged myself like what
- 1:06:05what do you mean an ad on youtube which means the whole point of youtube is
- 1:06:10that there's no ads well yeah but but and then they started that pay model so
- 1:06:17you could skip the ads youtube premium So now,
- 1:06:19between YouTube Premium and between the ads,
- 1:06:23they've got you coming and going.
- 1:06:25If you don't want the ads, great. You're out of pocket. They're still making the money.
- 1:06:31Yeah, which I refused. Personally, I refuse to pay for YouTube. I agree.
- 1:06:37I refuse to pay for it, too. But... Kiefer is nodding his head.
- 1:06:41The listeners can't see that. But Kiefer is nodding his head.
- 1:06:44Yeah. Yeah, it's a crux because much like YouTube, Netflix, Hulu,
- 1:06:53Disney, all of them, just the basic paid, paid.
- 1:06:59Yeah, I'm already paying you.
- 1:07:02You get ads which at first
- 1:07:06i'm like uh this is so annoying but at
- 1:07:09the same time it gives me the opportunity oh it's
- 1:07:13got a timer i've got 45 seconds to skip this ad
- 1:07:16and go take a leak and i don't have to see it yeah well
- 1:07:19there is yeah which is fair i for me if i'm watching a
- 1:07:22movie i i don't want an ad in the middle of my movie no so
- 1:07:26like you i in that respect i'm i get
- 1:07:29it but like for you all right gang let's see
- 1:07:32who this monster really is this message
- 1:07:35is brought to you by late stage capitalism and viagra because everything's watching
- 1:07:45everything diabetes dancing in the supermarket let me tell you i counted in
- 1:07:51the course of probably about a half hour roughly.
- 1:07:56On CNN I don't think that there was one commercial that wasn't a fucking major drug company,
- 1:08:04which is really funny that you say that because I've been for a while I've been
- 1:08:09tracking just mentally like what ads I'm getting on YouTube and most recently
- 1:08:14it's some new like stock trading website,
- 1:08:20and I skip it as soon as I can so I couldn't tell you what it actually is,
- 1:08:25like what the website is.
- 1:08:26And I don't want to give them the fucking cloud anyway. So fuck that.
- 1:08:30But I've also been surprisingly getting a lot of post postpartum depression ads.
- 1:08:36You know why? Because they know you're of age to have a to have a child.
- 1:08:42Yeah. And they know you're of age that whether that child has a mother that
- 1:08:47is married to you or not, you still have to deal with it early on.
- 1:08:52And again, this gets back, I'm sorry, Keith, but this gets back to the whole
- 1:08:56idea of collection of data.
- 1:08:57There are data farms in this fucking country that have all of our information
- 1:09:02and we don't even know it.
- 1:09:04They know everything. They know fucking everything and we can't even ask for a copy of that file.
- 1:09:09We're not allowed to know what they know about us.
- 1:09:14Kill them all. Guillotines exist for a reason. I see it's so many medication
- 1:09:20ads and it makes me every single time it pops up,
- 1:09:26all I can think of is the United States and I think it's New Zealand.
- 1:09:31Are they only two countries where they can show medication ads?
- 1:09:36So then I start thinking, what ads are they showing in other countries?
- 1:09:41Yeah. Really? I mean, how are they keeping their media alive without big pharma?
- 1:09:50All right. So we got two. And then there's so much blowback on people having VPNs. Oh, God.
- 1:09:57Trying to figure out how to stop people from using VPNs. It's like, why?
- 1:10:02Why don't you want me to see programming in Britain?
- 1:10:06VPNs don't necessarily. Yeah. And that you just hit it. VPNs don't necessarily
- 1:10:11block ads. They just give you ads from different areas.
- 1:10:14Yeah, that's what I want to see. But what they have caught on to and what they
- 1:10:19have been able to do is if you have an ad blocker VPN, they,
- 1:10:24if you have that active, like YouTube, for example, just won't work.
- 1:10:30Well, aren't they motherfuckers? Let's continue. Ready? This is the theater of power.
- 1:10:36Modern politics is not a system for solving problems, and I think you would agree.
- 1:10:43It is a stage with roles and costumes and very predictable conflict arcs.
- 1:10:56Visibility alignment signaling performative
- 1:11:01outrage and symbolic gestures this is
- 1:11:04why hearings that we see on tv all the time they look dramatic they accomplish
- 1:11:08jack shit this is why speeches feel emotional and change nothing this is why
- 1:11:15scandals cycle endlessly through the news with no consequence seriously where
- 1:11:20are all the epstein criminals going to jail.
- 1:11:22If politics were about results, it wouldn't need an audience.
- 1:11:27This is why the same behaviors repeat. That's why corruption has become background noise in politics.
- 1:11:34That's why people say, nothing surprises me anymore. That numbness.
- 1:11:40Some people think it's apathy. It's not. It's conditioning.
- 1:11:45Right and wrong are replaced with team loyalty. But people aren't asking, is this right?
- 1:11:51They're asking, is this our side? This is where left versus right becomes useful again.
- 1:11:58Two sides, two very predictable emotional responses, endless conflict with no resolution.
- 1:12:06While all these people are arguing over symbols, the actual sources of instability
- 1:12:11remain completely untouched.
- 1:12:16Politics is a distraction machine. It's a constant stream of drama that absorbs
- 1:12:21attention and releases nothing of value.
- 1:12:26So let me say this super plainly in a way that maybe will make perfect sense.
- 1:12:32Most political content exists to keep you emotionally occupied,
- 1:12:36not materially informed.
- 1:12:39The goal is not progress. You know what the goal is?
- 1:12:44Engagement. Once politics is theater, events themselves become props.
- 1:12:50Most people think manipulation means lying. It does not.
- 1:12:55The most effective manipulation leaves the facts intact and controls how those facts are experienced.
- 1:13:03An event happens, and before anybody can orient to it, what shows up?
- 1:13:08The frame arrives immediately. So they tell you what the event means.
- 1:13:14Why it matters, who the enemy is, what emotion you're supposed to feel,
- 1:13:19and which conclusions you are supposed to adopt.
- 1:13:22This is before you've even touched the real event itself.
- 1:13:27How current events are absolutely engineered. It is 100% not at the level of reality.
- 1:13:35It's at the level of interpretation.
- 1:13:38It's dumbed down because they think you are a moron because complexity doesn't mobilize anybody.
- 1:13:46Simplicity does. And once framing is centralized, people will defend the interpretation,
- 1:13:52like they witnessed the event themselves, because emotionally, they did.
- 1:13:57This creates a dangerous illusion.
- 1:14:01People feel like participants when they're actually spectators.
- 1:14:06They feel informed when they've only been pointed in a direction.
- 1:14:10They feel certain when they've been guided, and whoever controls the stories
- 1:14:15controls the responses.
- 1:14:18Events are framed once politics is theater
- 1:14:21and identity is unstable story becomes the
- 1:14:24final weapon and that my friends
- 1:14:28is a fucking fact story is
- 1:14:31the weapon it's the way that they gaslight us
- 1:14:34into the gaslight what we know are
- 1:14:37facts they gaslight us and then they they piss on
- 1:14:40our shoes and they tell us it's raining you didn't hear
- 1:14:43all right let me back up just a second what the
- 1:14:46fuck has congress done what like literally
- 1:14:49aside from the big beautiful bill and passing
- 1:14:53the epstein file release transparency
- 1:14:56act a transparency act aside from those two things what has congress done they
- 1:15:04authorized an automatic draft registration well oh they did do that yeah well
- 1:15:11i can tell you they've had Bondi, Patel,
- 1:15:13and Noam in front of them, and they didn't do shit.
- 1:15:16I mean, it's a bit different for Noam now, but that has nothing to do with Congress.
- 1:15:21Congress didn't make that happen. Again, this just strikes to the heart of what
- 1:15:26we were discussing earlier, which is.
- 1:15:29We criticize other countries for having uniparties and look at how fucking free we are.
- 1:15:36We have two parties and they do the same fucking shit. Well,
- 1:15:39but that's because we have peacocking fucking politicians who don't do shit.
- 1:15:43They spend more fucking time. I don't care who I don't care who it is.
- 1:15:48We criticize China for having a uniparty. But guess what?
- 1:15:51That uniparty has gotten high speed rail into even the farthest reaches of their
- 1:15:57country. They've lifted 800 million people out of poverty.
- 1:16:03Now, is that our definition of poverty? No, but they have.
- 1:16:08Yeah, I mean, their definition of poverty was you didn't have fucking shoes
- 1:16:13and you might only have a diaper wrap.
- 1:16:16Look, I'm not saying that I'm not saying that China is the beacon of hope here.
- 1:16:23What I am saying is we criticize other countries for having a uniparty,
- 1:16:27but we have, oh, how free we are. We have two parties.
- 1:16:31And still don't get shit done. And don't get shit done.
- 1:16:34Yeah. We didn't have money for fucking health care, but we have a billion dollars
- 1:16:39a day for a war that no one wants to be in.
- 1:16:43So Hegseth can buy fucking Steinway pianos and $500,000 violins for his higher
- 1:16:50ups. Yeah, I mean, like, this is getting to the point where it's like,
- 1:16:54no one wanted the war in Iran.
- 1:16:57Everyone wanted health care. What the fuck are we doing?
- 1:17:01But the story is Trump saying, oh, we're winning this in ways that we didn't
- 1:17:07even think that we could win it.
- 1:17:08And you could say that we've already won it, but we haven't won it enough.
- 1:17:12And the Straits of Vermeer is basically over, but we are escalating.
- 1:17:15Yeah, and the Straits of Vermeuse are perfectly safe.
- 1:17:19And literally while he was saying that, there was an American ship getting bombed.
- 1:17:24The fuck okay yeah so so this is this we have we have a president who spends
- 1:17:31more time on social media than he does on his golf course and he spends a fuckload
- 1:17:36of time on his golf course,
- 1:17:38this is the world we're living in and and so whether you think that this is
- 1:17:43a simulation theory in the in the or discussion of simulation theory in the
- 1:17:47strictest sense or whether you think it's a discussion of simulation being pushed
- 1:17:53on the the the the people i'm more with the latter,
- 1:17:58so am i so am i but no matter how you look at it they are simulating and manipulating.
- 1:18:08Our views and they're doing it in a way that keeps it simple one side or the other,
- 1:18:16I have a perfect slogan that is thrown around that defines exactly that. And can you guess it?
- 1:18:24Have at it. Vote blue no matter who.
- 1:18:27Well, I mean, like. Yeah. Well, look at Georgia.
- 1:18:32That seat that Green has stepped down from. Yeah.
- 1:18:38Is now turning blue. Oh, is it?
- 1:18:41Yeah. Yeah, it is. I did not see that story. it's not certain yet they're still
- 1:18:46doing the runoff but like it's,
- 1:18:48it's looking bad for the Republicans a lot
- 1:18:52of these but whether that Democrat wins that
- 1:18:55seat or not they're gonna do the same fucking shit that the Republicans would
- 1:18:59have done but they're gonna be vocally pro-gay about it yeah and then other
- 1:19:06quick news more good news actually
- 1:19:09and I'm being sarcastic about that the United States Supreme Court
- 1:19:14ruled that Donald Trump does not have presidential immunity in relation to subpoenas
- 1:19:20connected to the Epstein investigations.
- 1:19:26Well, you know what that means. Because he wasn't doing it as an official act of the presidency.
- 1:19:33Let me ask you this. When did that announcement come down?
- 1:19:36I do believe today. And tomorrow we launch the nukes.
- 1:19:42Yeah, most likely. Most likely.
- 1:19:46Or the 51st state of Israel does. Yeah. Somebody is going. That would be the 52nd state.
- 1:19:53Well, the 53rd state, because you were forgetting Venezuela and Canada. Canada.
- 1:20:00And the hopes for Greenland. But they're not, like, fully locked in the states
- 1:20:04yet. I'm sorry, 54th. Israel has been locked in as a state since 1947.
- 1:20:09You gotta keep in mind. It's actually the 54th state, because my bad,
- 1:20:14I forgot about Greenland. Yeah. All right.
- 1:20:17Let's wrap this up with the last clip here.
- 1:20:22Humans don't understand the world through facts alone they understand it through,
- 1:20:28mythic structure that wiring is
- 1:20:31ancient it predates language and it's
- 1:20:35incredibly easy to hijack this is where the global hero's journey comes in every
- 1:20:40major narrative that you're fed now follows the exact same template i guarantee
- 1:20:45you hero becomes your side the villain becomes the other side.
- 1:20:50The victim becomes the justification.
- 1:20:53Once those roles get assigned, logic is not required anymore because archetypes
- 1:20:59bypass human reasoning.
- 1:21:01And once stories take over, morality becomes symbolic.
- 1:21:06It turns into symbols and slogans and flags and hashtags and profile frames on social media.
- 1:21:14Virtues, not something you do, it's something you deploy now.
- 1:21:17That's when morality starts to look like stickers, because stickers are visible.
- 1:21:24What's the currency of this simulation that we're in right now? It's visibility.
- 1:21:29When morality becomes symbolic, it stops being moral. It's just a performance.
- 1:21:35This is why people are going to defend a story, even when the story contradicts reality.
- 1:21:41Stories don't need to be true. They just need to make you feel like a good person.
- 1:21:46And there's only four things they need to give people. A role,
- 1:21:51purpose, an enemy, and relief from uncertainty.
- 1:21:55And once you see this layer, everything below it snaps into focus.
- 1:22:00The media, the politics, the fear, the division, the identity weapon,
- 1:22:06they are not separate layers of manipulation.
- 1:22:10Story is the oldest control system that we have.
- 1:22:14A symbolic layer replacing reality. simulated people adapting to narratives and incentives.
- 1:22:22Nothing here requires conspiracy, just incentives.
- 1:22:29Seeing the simulation doesn't make you superior. It doesn't make you enlightened.
- 1:22:34It doesn't make you immune to everything. It gives you some orientation.
- 1:22:39You stop reacting on cue. You stop mistaking symbols for substance.
- 1:22:44And you don't need to convince anybody. You don't need to expose anything.
- 1:22:48You don't need to fight against the stage or rage against the machine.
- 1:22:53Once you see the machinery, the manipulation stops working the same way.
- 1:22:57The performance feels super obvious And something weird happens The world doesn't
- 1:23:03feel fake anymore It feels like it's covered With a layer of something And reality
- 1:23:09was always there Under the noise, under the fake symbols,
- 1:23:13So First off, I think the most accurate thing He said there was when he was
- 1:23:18talking about You know, whether it's the social media Or whether it's the stickers Because you know what?
- 1:23:23Stickers are cheap And they're effective And they're disposable just like us to the Epstein class.
- 1:23:30We are cheap, It's not that I, effective, and disposable to the upper fucking class.
- 1:23:37It's not that I disagree with that, but like, this is what I'm getting at with
- 1:23:43the morality being imposed by society kind of discussion that we were having earlier.
- 1:23:50Like, yeah, yeah, obviously. Like, like.
- 1:23:55Whatever I believe on a moral level is determined by society.
- 1:24:01It's determined by what I'm engaging with on a daily basis. Yeah, obviously.
- 1:24:06That doesn't invalidate that, you know?
- 1:24:10But additionally, while I understand where he's coming from,
- 1:24:15from the perspective of morality becomes a sticker, at the same time,
- 1:24:21when has it ever not been?
- 1:24:24Well, I think that part of what you got to look at is if all of a sudden there
- 1:24:30was a big morality shift in this country and the bumper sticker turned from the,
- 1:24:36you know, that coexist with all the symbols of all the different religions, right?
- 1:24:43If the bumper sticker turned from coexist to...
- 1:24:48You pull up next to me at the next stoplight, I'm shooting you.
- 1:24:52Would you do that? Because we don't coexist.
- 1:24:56And we definitely don't, I don't think the vast majority, I mean,
- 1:25:01sure, there's a small minority that if given the opportunity,
- 1:25:05whether, you know, like I used to say, like make all drugs legal.
- 1:25:09Because if you never did cocaine, it's not like because it's legal, you're going to.
- 1:25:14And if murder is legal. If you never did, but if you never wanted to.
- 1:25:18Right. But same thing with murder.
- 1:25:20Okay. Same thing with rape. You know, which one of you said about Ricky Gervais,
- 1:25:26I rape as much as I want, which is not at all. That would be me. Yeah.
- 1:25:31So I think that, I think that there's just certain things that are ingrained
- 1:25:35in you as a fucking person that
- 1:25:39maybe you could trace back to societal pressures guiding your morality.
- 1:25:45But I also think that There are just people out there that under any circumstance are not murderers.
- 1:25:51You know what I mean? There's certain people that are always going to be the
- 1:25:54victim, not the assailant.
- 1:25:57And I think that that's their morality. I'd rather die at the hands of the assailant
- 1:26:03than actually have to go to my deathbed knowing that I killed an assailant.
- 1:26:09Sure. I'm not of that opinion. I'm fighting until one of us is dead. I am too.
- 1:26:14I'm not of that opinion either, but it doesn't mean that that opinion does not
- 1:26:20exist. It doesn't mean that that person isn't out there, okay?
- 1:26:25And I'll flat out say it. I think that Elsie, the namesake of the show,
- 1:26:31she would fight to the fucking death. But I don't think that our dad,
- 1:26:37who just passed, I don't think he would.
- 1:26:40I think he would feel like I can't take another person's life. Whatever the way out is.
- 1:26:46Whatever the way out is, is the way I'm taking because I cannot bring myself
- 1:26:52to take another person's life.
- 1:26:54Now, maybe I'm wrong on those two particular. I know I'm right about Elsie.
- 1:27:00I mean, she would fucking kill somebody in the fucking grocery store for cutting
- 1:27:03line. I'm looking at her wrong. Yeah, she was. You know what, though?
- 1:27:07In the wise words of Neil Perry from the song Free Will by Rush,
- 1:27:13if you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice. Well, yeah.
- 1:27:19Yeah, I mean, that's the thing is he was a prolific reader. He was a prolific
- 1:27:23motorcyclist, so he had a lot
- 1:27:25of time for wind therapy and thoughts to actually exist between his ears.
- 1:27:30And that's something else that we don't see anymore. We don't see people taking
- 1:27:33time to actually formulate an actual thought, taking time to contemplate because
- 1:27:38we don't have time and we don't have time not because that time doesn't exist.
- 1:27:42We don't have time because we're constantly doom scrolling and trying to fill
- 1:27:47the fucking void, which is in all of us because of the fact that at the end of the day,
- 1:27:54all we can do is get up, go to work, try to make some fucking money and try
- 1:27:58to put fucking food on the table.
- 1:28:00Now my overall take on the video I guess I have two takes.
- 1:28:07And Kiefer, since you didn't get an opportunity to watch the video,
- 1:28:12I'm curious how you feel having heard some clips from the video.
- 1:28:16I have two different takes.
- 1:28:19My official take is he himself is a brand, and he's trying to sell an idea.
- 1:28:26Yeah. So are we. So are we. I can't fault him for that because we're doing the same thing.
- 1:28:32On i i have to differentiate
- 1:28:35between the politically involved and the politically uninvolved because
- 1:28:39all three of us are politically involved right so i'll
- 1:28:43start with the politically uninvolved take which is
- 1:28:46this is earth-shattering information now on the other hand for the politically
- 1:28:53involved person watching and listening to this video digesting this video i
- 1:29:00go back to the Talking Heads line from Psycho Killer,
- 1:29:05which is, he's talking a lot, but he's not saying anything.
- 1:29:09And my biggest piece of evidence for that point is the fact that he ends the
- 1:29:16video talking about all these societal ills,
- 1:29:20talking about how reality is being simulated for us by the powers that be,
- 1:29:24by saying, you don't have to rage against the machine.
- 1:29:28I understand that he said just knowing this helps bring down the machine. I disagree.
- 1:29:35I don't think that's accurate.
- 1:29:37Because, going back to a previous episode, I'm of the opinion that if you're
- 1:29:43not willing to put your nuts on the table about something that you believe.
- 1:29:48Then you don't believe that thing.
- 1:29:52Look, you were also raised to have the courage of your convictions and to,
- 1:29:59without fear of repercussion, express your opinion.
- 1:30:05Yeah. So I think that the framing that you have of it is accurate for how you
- 1:30:12were raised, but not necessarily accurate for the intention of the video.
- 1:30:19Well, again, for someone that's politically uninvolved, this is earth shattering
- 1:30:24information to be to be told.
- 1:30:26Well, yeah, but I mean, it's also a politically involved perspective.
- 1:30:31It falls under the category for me of the same Rogan's fear bro philosophy where
- 1:30:38they say all these things.
- 1:30:41But they're not saying anything. They are talking all of this shit,
- 1:30:46but they don't say anything. So I'm going to disagree with you.
- 1:30:49All right. So my take on it is I believe that whether politically involved or
- 1:30:56not politically involved, you can watch that video. And again, it's Chase Hughes.
- 1:31:02And A, you can enjoy it because the quality and the production value is top
- 1:31:09notch. I mean, he did a great job, right?
- 1:31:12Especially considering a lot of the slop that's out there nowadays.
- 1:31:17But I thought he did a really great job. I thought he did a really great job.
- 1:31:22I thought he made his point.
- 1:31:24And I thought he made his point available for everyone.
- 1:31:27So there was something for the political class like us.
- 1:31:32To be able to chew on and dissect and pull every little possible string to see
- 1:31:41what that string would let loose.
- 1:31:44I think it created an opportunity for conversation, not just for us,
- 1:31:49but hopefully a conversation for our listeners to have with their friends and families.
- 1:31:54I think he did a great job.
- 1:31:57Now, do I get where you're coming from, that you could pick up that kind of
- 1:32:01Rogan, bro, podcaster, universe vibe? Sure.
- 1:32:10But...
- 1:32:12He's also the most popular fucking podcaster in the world. And his clips,
- 1:32:17not only on YouTube, but his downloads on the podcast.
- 1:32:23He's making millions off of that. People like that.
- 1:32:27Now, they like being told the problem, but no solution.
- 1:32:31Well, sometimes there's not at least being advocated against a solution.
- 1:32:35Well, because in this case, he's being he's directly saying you don't have to
- 1:32:40go rage against the machine. Well, see, this is, again, where I disagree with you on that.
- 1:32:44What I see him saying in that is once you recognize the signal, you can ignore it.
- 1:32:54Once you understand what's being done, it can't be done to you.
- 1:32:59So I'll give you an example.
- 1:33:01Every person has dealt with in some form or fashion throughout their life a bully.
- 1:33:07And when you recognize or at that moment when you realize that bully is bullying
- 1:33:13you because they're insecure. And if I if I can push that insecurity button
- 1:33:18on that bully, then I don't have a bully anymore.
- 1:33:22And that's not ignoring it. That's raging against the machine.
- 1:33:25I don't think that's raging against the machine. Because you know what?
- 1:33:29Sometimes the way that you get to the bully is by ignoring the bully.
- 1:33:33Like, you can say whatever you want, man. It doesn't affect me.
- 1:33:37You can be as mean and as cruel and as hurtful as you want to.
- 1:33:42Your opinion of me matters not one fucking bit. and sometimes not giving a fuck.
- 1:33:53Actually the most effective tool. I mean, every circumstance is different. I agree with that.
- 1:34:00But at the same time, when you're talking about a societal level,
- 1:34:05my ignoring the manufactured consent, say, for the war in Iran,
- 1:34:10okay, means fuck all for the seven other neighbors just in my building.
- 1:34:18It means fuck all that I'm ignoring it.
- 1:34:23Because all seven of my neighbors may not be ignoring it and may be buying into
- 1:34:29that manufactured consent.
- 1:34:31And now I can talk to them, but they're already being propagandized.
- 1:34:36Yeah, but you also have to recognize that there are some levels of the propaganda.
- 1:34:40There's some levels of the reality. There's some levels of the gaslighting that
- 1:34:45you're never going to be able to overcome as far as society goes.
- 1:34:51But you can know that you're
- 1:34:55not being fooled and that's what it takes is each
- 1:34:58person individually waking up from the machine it's like you know the matrix
- 1:35:04when neo sits up in the fucking goo and pulls this fucking thing out of his
- 1:35:09head and they rescue him right and bring him on board with morpheus.
- 1:35:16You wake up the machine can't control you
- 1:35:19and that's all this shit is it's just a machine and
- 1:35:23that's why i like the idea of of it's all a
- 1:35:26simulation because once you wake up you
- 1:35:29may be part of a minority just like morpheus and
- 1:35:33trinity and neo right but the
- 1:35:37machine it can't quite
- 1:35:40manipulate you or use you as
- 1:35:43a battery like it did before you're not contributing to
- 1:35:46the problem you are ignoring the
- 1:35:49fact of any authority from that
- 1:35:52machine any authority from that problem any reality
- 1:35:56or truth that that problem tries to
- 1:36:00gaslight you with and i think to me which mean
- 1:36:03which to me it takes not only an active effort
- 1:36:06on the individual level but an active effort on the community level
- 1:36:09you have to be talking to the people around you
- 1:36:12you know you have to be getting other
- 1:36:15people to recognize that this is bullshit and well.
- 1:36:19Then that by by laying it out as
- 1:36:22you individually don't have to rage against the
- 1:36:25machine means you're you're being given permission to
- 1:36:29not encourage others to rage against the
- 1:36:32machine all right so let's use a little bit of biblical on this
- 1:36:35when what did jesus say if if
- 1:36:38somebody slapped you across the face turn the other
- 1:36:41cheek right yeah because you're taking the
- 1:36:44power away from the bully and i don't even buy
- 1:36:47into christianity or any religion but that's a great fucking lesson when somebody
- 1:36:52does you wrong turn the other cheek you know why it fucks them up it fucks them
- 1:36:57up but at the same time some of the books that were actually removed from the
- 1:37:04Bible at the council of Nicaea.
- 1:37:06Say fucking slap the shit out of them.
- 1:37:11A child ran into Jesus while running. And so Jesus struck him dead.
- 1:37:17Sometimes, you know, a little motherfucker comes up on you too quick.
- 1:37:20You know, it's more of a reflex than it is an intent.
- 1:37:25Before we wrap this up, Kiefer. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:37:29You opened this by saying, bring your case to me.
- 1:37:35Who has the more convincing case based on the evidence presented?
- 1:37:39Oh, shit. Go ahead. Be honest. You don't have to butter me up.
- 1:37:46Is he talking a lot but not saying anything and you should in fact rage against
- 1:37:50the machine individually because that encourages your community to rage against
- 1:37:54the machine? Yes. Or, okay.
- 1:37:58Alright, but my argument against that actually be correct at the same time.
- 1:38:02However, I feel like what I've listened to is a very broad generalization of
- 1:38:09an idea that really doesn't have,
- 1:38:14strong evidence of us being in a simulation.
- 1:38:18I think that that's where he made his mistake was calling it a simulation.
- 1:38:21I think he should have called it a manipulation because I think we're all in a manipulation.
- 1:38:27Oh, yeah. Oh, for sure. Yeah, you're not going to get an argument there.
- 1:38:31Everyone tries to manipulate everybody all the time.
- 1:38:35What's the saying? Fool me once.
- 1:38:39I won't get fooled again. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice,
- 1:38:42I won't get fooled again. Thank you. Thank you. Big W.
- 1:38:47Smarter than Trump. Yeah. Hey, who would have thought we'd ever say that?
- 1:38:52And with that, I don't know where else to leave it. So that's another Elsie's
- 1:38:56Little Pickles because W is smarter than Trump.