Latest / Newcomer Pod / Andreessen Horowitz’s Media Empire, Trump vs. Kimmel, Klarna’s $15B IPO Lessons
Transcript
- 0:00Newcomers had a crazy week of stories.
- 0:01Madeline Rembarger took a look at the winners and losers and
- 0:04the Klarna IPO. This was not your traditional
- 0:08venture capital overnight success story.
- 0:10It had a $46 billion valuation. Would it be a good time to go
- 0:15public? Then?
- 0:16Sequoia Capital built in a major position, but there was a lot of
- 0:19money trading hands along the way.
- 0:21I'm sure Tom Duton, who's here on the podcast with us, will
- 0:24have a lot to say about Jimmy Kimmel's temporary ouster from
- 0:29ABC and the pressure from the FCC chair, quoting from his
- 0:33social media post. I can't believe ABC fake news
- 0:36gave Jimmy Kimmel his job back. And then this week, I published
- 0:39a story on Andreessen Horowitz's financial performance.
- 0:41We're going to start the show with that.
- 0:43They've returned a ton of money secretly to limited partners,
- 0:47thanks in part to their savvy crypto investments.
- 0:50And so we'll have a lot of analysis on how Andreessen
- 0:52Horowitz has raised its many, many billions return, some to
- 0:56investors. Without further ado, this is the
- 0:58Newcomer podcast. All right, I, I, this was the
- 1:03white whale to pat myself on the back of venture capital
- 1:08journalism. I think lots of VCs over the
- 1:11years have been trying to figure out how well does Andreessen
- 1:16Horowitz perform? You know, it's a firm fantastic
- 1:19getting itself a lot of attention and controversy,
- 1:23certainly made a ton of Unicorn investments, but it, you know,
- 1:27spins out money like it's shooting out of a bazooka.
- 1:31And so really wanted to get an answer.
- 1:33How's it doing, Madeline? I mean, you followed Andreessen
- 1:37for a long time. What What was your reaction to
- 1:41our story? Yeah.
- 1:42Well, first up, congratulations, Eric.
- 1:44I think that's been our most requested, you know, look behind
- 1:47the hood. What's going on in Andreessen?
- 1:49What are they really doing? You know, and one thing that
- 1:52struck me from the piece, honestly, is I didn't expect
- 1:54them to be doing as well as they are.
- 1:56Does that kind of how you felt in your analysis too?
- 1:58I think everyone talks about how their their rounds are so
- 2:00inflated and they buy out everyone else and their whole
- 2:03game is just, you know, management fees.
- 2:05But seems like a lot of their investments, especially some of
- 2:07their 2010's vintages, are doing quite well.
- 2:10Yeah, just to tick through, you know, like the headline is the
- 2:15firm returned $25 billion net to its backers.
- 2:20So after Andreessen takes its cut 25 billion back, obviously
- 2:25this is a firm that's raised a lot of money.
- 2:27So it's like, OK, makes sense some of it would come, would
- 2:31come back to you. But they, you know, have
- 2:34returned a significant amount and it importantly a huge chunk
- 2:38of it, some $12 billion was in 2021.
- 2:42And if you're, you know, someone who follows tech stocks in 2021,
- 2:47that was madness. That was everybody's investing
- 2:49at terrible prices, at high watermarks.
- 2:51And it's like, what's going on? And I think part of what this
- 2:54story reveals is that in the background, investors were
- 2:59cashing in their winners. So it's like, oh, they were able
- 3:01to raise a bunch of money. A lot of stuff was happening
- 3:03because they're like, we're geniuses, we're rich.
- 3:05We're selling everything at such high prices.
- 3:07And Andreessen in particular was able to see a massive amount of
- 3:13liquidity to its limited partners to its backers in 2021.
- 3:20Right. I mean, I think you know,
- 3:20venture funds we are kind of roughly on a 10 year cycle,
- 3:23right? So 2021 for those vintages at
- 3:27least on per your deck, the 2011, 2012 vintages looked super
- 3:31high performing because about you know, 10 years exit during
- 3:34the boom. Amazing.
- 3:37And of course, they had, I'm sure they had, you know, the
- 3:38companies were good, but you know, it was also a timing game,
- 3:41you know? It's funny, actually, Eric, I
- 3:43remember the last time I think that Andreessen's returns were
- 3:48leaked or in a story was our buddy Rolf Winkler at the
- 3:51Journal had a story that showed that they were pretty good.
- 3:54And I think for some reason, initially, people were skeptical
- 3:57about it at the time. And maybe it wasn't as good as
- 3:59people had thought, but they were solid.
- 4:01And this one, I think, only reaffirms that point.
- 4:04But like, a lot of time has passed between then and now.
- 4:07What were like the big winners? We don't.
- 4:09We don't know all the specifics. Fun to fund.
- 4:11I mean, Coinbase is a key winner for Andreessen.
- 4:16Like flipping, I think crypto tokens has been very lucrative
- 4:19to that for them, like Uniswap and there are a lot of stuff.
- 4:22I mean, one of the things I revealed in this story, which
- 4:24you can read the full thing at newcomer.co, but Andreessen has
- 4:28made $422.7 million from like crypto staking.
- 4:33So like supporting these crypto projects along the way besides
- 4:37like flipping tokens and selling equity in crypto companies.
- 4:42So this is, this is a firm that's run a lot of creative
- 4:44ways to make money from crypto. They're, they're huge investors
- 4:49in data bricks. I think like data bricks is
- 4:51still private. My sense is they still own a lot
- 4:54of it. But like, I, I think when you
- 4:57think about why is Andreessen so successful?
- 5:00I do think like the success of data bricks is certainly one of
- 5:03the key companies that should come to the top of your mind.
- 5:06GitHub and Slack are two that they, they've sold out of.
- 5:10They did well for them as well. And what's interesting is that
- 5:13you look at the different trends like tech type cycles that have
- 5:16happened in the 10 years. Okay, data bricks, I get it.
- 5:20That's about the growth of databases.
- 5:21That's, you know, big data and and that whole industry.
- 5:27So you can see them capitalizing on that, you know, the the Uber
- 5:30for X and on demand world, I guess really Uber is the only
- 5:33big winner. They didn't get anything from
- 5:34that. They're they're in Airbnb and
- 5:36they're in Lyft. Lyft ended up not.
- 5:39Not Lyft wasn't great, that's right, they were the Lyft
- 5:40company but. Airbnb was good, yeah.
- 5:44Yes. So that that was that was a
- 5:45solid return. What what else though?
- 5:48I mean, what other trends were there that Matt, well you
- 5:50mentioned crypto and and they kind of won it the biggest
- 5:53company there. Andreessen's first crypto fund
- 5:56is being held at 7.1 TVPI now after peaking at like 11 TVPI,
- 6:01which I mean, in the weeds of, you know, venture jargon, it's
- 6:06very good. Define the terms which are
- 6:08complicated even to us. So TVPI is total value to paid
- 6:13in capital. So that's like the value of you
- 6:17know, OK, how does venture work? We raise a venture capital firm,
- 6:20say it's a billion dollars. We deploy that money.
- 6:24We invest in startups. Those startups get marked up.
- 6:28We haven't actually exited the position.
- 6:30We still home own these illiquid shares, but the value goes way
- 6:34up. We invest in data bricks.
- 6:36Investors say those shares are now worth a bazillion dollars.
- 6:38We say, oh man, our TVPI has gone up by a ton because we've
- 6:43seen the value skyrocket. That is in contrast to another
- 6:47word that venture capitalists like to throw around, DPI
- 6:50distributed to paid in capital. And that's actual money.
- 6:54Your investors have gone back. DPI is the I feel like really
- 6:58the one of the most important metrics, right?
- 6:59Because that's actually money back in the bank.
- 7:02Money to LP is that is the cash DPITDPI.
- 7:05To deliver, you know, you gotta exit, you have to exit, you
- 7:09know, and, and so, you know, I, these are the numbers I got, you
- 7:13know, from source, They're from two different decks.
- 7:16It's clearly like 1 was, you know, a quarterly update to
- 7:20limited partners. So it seems like they are even
- 7:22to sort of the savvy insiders relying on this TVPI number,
- 7:25which again leans heavily on markups rather than exits alone.
- 7:31But you know, it's sort of paired with the fact that
- 7:34Andreessen has returned a lot of money to investors.
- 7:36So I think their strategy seems to be, hey, we've given you a
- 7:39lot of money. Therefore, like our sense of
- 7:42what these companies are worth is pretty reasonable.
- 7:44Like trust us that like you should pay attention to the
- 7:47total value rather than just the money you've gone back.
- 7:51Because like, why should we rush to get out of like good
- 7:54companies at high, high valuation?
- 7:56So, So yeah, the Andreessen skeptics and I've gotten some
- 7:59emails from them, we'll say DPI, DPI, like tell me what exits
- 8:04they've actually had. Not like what markups, you know,
- 8:07because you know, they mark up their own companies, all the VC
- 8:09firms, you know, want to sort of keep these valuations up to the
- 8:12extent possible, so. They can always double down on
- 8:15another investment, right? They can always, you know, do
- 8:17another follow up round at a crazy even higher valuation.
- 8:20And then it's like great, our numbers are doing so well
- 8:22because we keep back at the same company.
- 8:24So it is still all paper. Just to tick off, you know, some
- 8:27of the big takeaways. So I said 25 billion net
- 8:30tobaccers since the firm was founded in 2009.
- 8:34I think the second big take away is, yeah, their top fund, their
- 8:39third fund was at 9.4 X net total value to paid in capital.
- 8:44So it's been marked up sort of an enormous amount.
- 8:47So clearly they have some great funds.
- 8:50Crypto was really strong for them.
- 8:53Bio has been pretty weak and those funds keep getting marked
- 8:56down. Growth grows a little hard to
- 9:00assess. I mean, it seems good.
- 9:01I mean you sort of need to benchmark them to other ones.
- 9:05But yeah, I think pretty strong. But but overall, and then I
- 9:09think just this amazing. The other bullet that stood out
- 9:12to me is just how large crypto looms for entries and including
- 9:17making revenue from staking crypto currencies and that
- 9:21they're like telling investors like man are you know, I never
- 9:24even heard of SUI. Had you guys heard of this SUI
- 9:27thing? I don't even follow it, but like
- 9:29it's driving like they marked it down by a billion dollars and a
- 9:33quarter. Like Andreessen is swinging,
- 9:35like their assets are swinging dramatically on like obscure
- 9:38crypto products that people are are not tracking.
- 9:41The last thing I we won't tick through all of them.
- 9:43But you know, if you read the story I list, you know, they
- 9:47have companies that they think, you know, might go public, which
- 9:50is obviously interesting to a certain set of investors.
- 9:53So I don't know if you're that invested.
- 9:55Go go subscribe to Newcomer and read the story.
- 9:59OK, so you look at the partners that are responsible for some of
- 10:01their big victories. You've got data bricks, which is
- 10:03Ben Horowitz, and he made like a pretty impression and impressive
- 10:06early bet on a. And go see sort of navigate, I
- 10:10think. Yeah, Andreessen gets a lot of
- 10:11credit to me. For yeah, yeah.
- 10:13And I did a story at the Journal about, about Ali and, and, and
- 10:17data bricks. And Ben actually made their
- 10:18introduction to Microsoft, which was the the first moment where
- 10:21they kind of catapulted outside of just being another startup.
- 10:25And they had this huge Azure partnership and, and that was
- 10:27all Ben making that connection. So he totally deserves credit
- 10:31for a lot of their success. Airbnb from a a couple of years
- 10:35earlier. That's Jeff Jordan.
- 10:37Who's not? Who's there anymore?
- 10:38Yeah, at least if he's there, he's not like one of the, he's
- 10:41not one of the listed investors in their slide deck, so.
- 10:44Yeah, right. And then and then Coinbase,
- 10:47which is Chris Dixon. Chris Dixon, I think.
- 10:50Yeah, Yeah. So I mean, I know this is not
- 10:52uncommon, but for a firm that has like, I think at last count
- 10:56200,000 listed partners at Andreessen Horowitz, it really
- 11:01comes down to like 3 guys more or less that are like powering
- 11:05all their success. Yeah, I mean, Marc, Marc
- 11:08Andreessen, obviously it's like the brand and the vision and I'm
- 11:12I think he's, he's certainly close to some of these deals.
- 11:15And and I don't it's, there are like crypto tokens.
- 11:20There is a Slack deal early. Honestly, they had this whole
- 11:23Skype investment early on that was sort of important to them.
- 11:26So there have been others. But yeah, I mean, it's even at
- 11:31this scale where they're investing and they're raising,
- 11:33you know, $3 billion funds. It's it's home runs, but it's
- 11:38not just home runs where you lead the Series A.
- 11:40It's like you lead the Series A and you say, oh, man, this is
- 11:42the good one. Like back up the truck.
- 11:44And that's why I think with like General Catalysts and Stripe,
- 11:48you know, Andreessen and Coinbase and data bricks, you
- 11:51see these firms that are raising massive war chests.
- 11:54Like really you gobble up a lot of these companies.
- 11:57I mean, we published the returns of Lightspeed a couple months
- 12:00ago and like they were a little more diversified.
- 12:04Like I actually had the tables of like how each fund broke
- 12:07down. But you know, there were
- 12:09companies like Rubric where that that would be like a huge
- 12:12section of of the returns for the fund.
- 12:15Yeah. I mean, even in the decks,
- 12:16they'll like make the graphic just like this is the companies,
- 12:19you know, these are the companies that have built the
- 12:22big returns. They're upfront about that as
- 12:24well and when they're pitching their investors.
- 12:27On the crypto side and to connect it to Marc Andreessen, I
- 12:31think I was debating this with another reporter a couple months
- 12:33back, but I think one of the impressive things that
- 12:35Andreessen has done in terms of like infiltrating the Trump
- 12:38administration is basically setting policy for crypto.
- 12:42And you look at, you know, what they managed to do with the SEC
- 12:46and and I don't know if any of their well, Coinbase, were they
- 12:49were they ever under SEC investigation?
- 12:51Yeah, yeah. In any event, like it's
- 12:54obviously a much friendlier administration to crypto than
- 12:57than Biden was. And policy wise, this was a huge
- 13:00victory for Andreessen and and probably drove some of the
- 13:02accumulation and in value of of their crypto holdings is the
- 13:05fact that like they seem to play a major role in setting policy.
- 13:09It was very crypto friendly and other stakes are worth a lot
- 13:12more. So like that to me is maybe the
- 13:14Marc Andreessen. And then if he doesn't get her
- 13:16playbook again on AI, which I guess I'm more supportive on the
- 13:19AI for. I mean, to me on crypto, the
- 13:22Biden administration, with the benefit of hindsight, clearly
- 13:25fumble by having their regulatory approach to crypto be
- 13:28like, we're going to make you afraid, but we're not going to
- 13:31actually tell you whether it's legal or not.
- 13:32And like, that just created this terrible situation where it felt
- 13:35like the lawbreakers almost performed better than the rule
- 13:39followers because you were sort of, if you were willing to
- 13:41ignore regulators, you survived. Have you followed the rules?
- 13:44You got hammered. So I think that was bad.
- 13:47And, you know, now it seems like we're in a world where like,
- 13:50crypto, OK. And like crypto is allowing like
- 13:54the biggest public corruption of all time with Trump like in his
- 13:59mean point like. It's like we've swung from like
- 14:02too strict. You don't have to swing from the
- 14:04from too strict to free for all right?
- 14:06There is a ground. Worst, like there's so many bad
- 14:08things going on in Trump. We're going to talk about more
- 14:10on them on this episode. But the public corruption of
- 14:12Trump's crypto holdings is egregious.
- 14:16And the crypto world's, you know, like regulatory work
- 14:20certainly laid the groundwork for what's happening with Trump
- 14:23coin. So I'm certainly frustrated
- 14:26about that, even if, you know, I think there's some valuable
- 14:29things to come out of crypto. If you look at their job as a VC
- 14:33firm, though, like they're about, you know, returning to
- 14:36their, you know, investors. They're all about VPI, Troy and
- 14:39like. Troy, the Honesty of the
- 14:40American government. Yeah, it means that Melania gets
- 14:43a meme coin like, great. Well, one piece also that I
- 14:47think we haven't touched on from your story is how much
- 14:49Andreessen's media ambitions loom in the future of the fund.
- 14:53I mean, they were kind of the classic, you know, fun that's
- 14:56gonna turn into a media company. And they've had so many
- 14:59different media arms that they've tried to do over time.
- 15:01But it does seem like that's a big focus for the firm right in
- 15:05what you were they literally? Calling in the Deck a media
- 15:07company that monetizes through venture capital, like, man,
- 15:11every media company should be jealous.
- 15:13That's one. And then they they talk about
- 15:15the compounding value of content.
- 15:18So at once it's very affirming to what we in the media classes
- 15:21do. On the other hand, clearly
- 15:24Andreessen Horowitz has a much Better Business model than any
- 15:28of us in the media business. So kudos to them.
- 15:31But yeah, what do you guys make of just how seriously they
- 15:34profess to take editorial content and and media?
- 15:38Well, look, like you said it in your initial piece on it, it
- 15:40didn't work. You know, they don't really have
- 15:43this Direct Line. They don't really have this
- 15:45Direct Line to the public, to the, the, the customers that
- 15:49obviates us. And I'm not even saying this
- 15:50defensively. Like I would have, you know,
- 15:52that there are certain examples of, I think successful media
- 15:54arms within VC firms. Like I think pirate wires,
- 15:58they're getting a little weird these days.
- 15:59But like, I give them credit. I don't think a lot of the yeah.
- 16:03Well, did you? They had some shit about like
- 16:04donating blood, Like you have to donate all your blood.
- 16:08Yeah, I, I'd love to talk about it with Mike, your buddy, but
- 16:12listen on on the Andreessen stuff.
- 16:14Like it's one of those things where like if you were
- 16:17successful, you can claim any rationale for the reason you
- 16:19were successful. So but the numbers that you have
- 16:22proved they've returned money or they have prospective money they
- 16:25can return to investors. They're a very successful firm.
- 16:27Also, they have this media strategy.
- 16:29Whether the media strategy is responsible for their success is
- 16:33very debatable. And I think like they can, they
- 16:35can dictate the terms of that because they they they are
- 16:37successful. But I'm very skeptical.
- 16:39So, so one of my early viral stories was in January 2021, and
- 16:44it was about, it was the unauthorized story of Andreessen
- 16:46Horowitz. And it was basically arguing
- 16:48that Margaret Wen Mockers, their chief marketing officer, was
- 16:51like sort of the third most important person at the firm,
- 16:54that she'd basically helped the Ben and Mark build up this
- 16:58reputation in the media. You know, Mark famously penned
- 17:02an op-ed that said software is eating the world in the Wall
- 17:05Street Journal. Like that sort of using the
- 17:07media both through like op eds and being quote machines and
- 17:11leaking and whispering like was key to Andreessen's strategy on
- 17:15the way up. And then sort of during the
- 17:18pandemic and Trump won Andreessen, Marc Andreessen's
- 17:22politics change, maybe Margit's politics change.
- 17:25And the firm just sort of sours on the media class.
- 17:28And all of a sudden they're like, they're not cooperative,
- 17:30they're hostile and they're trying to build their own
- 17:33apparatus. And I think that that's when I
- 17:36write the story. Then they try to launch future,
- 17:38which is I think what Tom is referencing, which is their own
- 17:41publication, like we're really gonna do it is gonna be a media
- 17:43property. And that thing like fumble.
- 17:46Almost immediately, it felt like they had no day 2 strategy.
- 17:49They had a bunch of posts on day one.
- 17:50And then it's like, what's the plan, guys?
- 17:52The problem with media is you have to keep doing it day after
- 17:54day. So that failed.
- 17:57But like they were dominant in clubhouse when that was cool.
- 18:00They have which has failed very successful podcast.
- 18:03They you know. Not a top podcast though.
- 18:05Compared compared to the venture industry, they are the noisiest
- 18:09and most paid attention to, compared to like Mr. Beast,
- 18:13they're smaller, but you know, their podcast is bigger than
- 18:15this one. So like we are a media business
- 18:18smaller than theirs. So they, it depends how you
- 18:22measure their success. And then the latest is they've
- 18:25hired Eric Tornberg, the founder of Turpentine Media, to be a
- 18:29true general partner and try and again make them successful
- 18:34influencers. To to me, the only thing that I
- 18:37think they deserve credit for as a media entity is crypto policy.
- 18:42I just think like they spun their brand into a way that got
- 18:45influence in the Trump administration, which is very
- 18:47responsive to podcasts, to, you know, to apparently, you know,
- 18:51scammy crypto, you know, schemes.
- 18:55But if you again, like going back to the things that drove
- 18:58most of their success, Martine Casado, sorry, you know, Ben
- 19:01Horowitz with OK, he's somewhat of a figure though, although,
- 19:04you know, he's a little bit more like middle of the road, I think
- 19:07than some of the extremer takes coming from people like Marc
- 19:10Andreessen, Chris Dixon, not out there all that much, not a very
- 19:13aggressive, you know, a media attacking figure.
- 19:17And then Jeff Jordan, who again, is not really in the picture all
- 19:19that much. So I just really want to push
- 19:22back on this idea that it drove their success.
- 19:24Like they made a lot of savvy bets.
- 19:28A key, yes, but a key insight of Andreessen Horowitz to me was
- 19:32that the real constituency is the founder.
- 19:35And that normally in like finance and old school venture
- 19:39capital, the people you're trying to communicate to are
- 19:42limited partners and limited partners are sort of
- 19:44conservative. They're the investors of venture
- 19:46capital firms. So you have this sort of like
- 19:48austere, like reserved brand that sort of says like we're the
- 19:52gatekeepers. And I think Andreessen realized,
- 19:55no, like founders are the customers because if we can get
- 19:57great founders to care about Andreessen Horowitz.
- 20:00Then they'll take our money, we'll have great returns, LP's
- 20:03will be happy. Like forget LP's.
- 20:04Like obviously we do some, you know, they do some to make LP's
- 20:07happy. But like, the customer is the
- 20:09founder and they hammer that message.
- 20:11And so while it's not like competitive with The New York
- 20:14Times in terms of reach, I think founders heard I need to go to
- 20:18Andreessen Horowitz if I want credibility, if I want all these
- 20:20platform tools. And I think that message was
- 20:23received. And that's part of why
- 20:24Andreessen's been able to get sort of the exits and the
- 20:27investment level that they wanted.
- 20:29I don't know, Madeline. What do you think?
- 20:31Yeah, I think I think you're on to something there.
- 20:33I do think that by focusing on founders first as sort of their
- 20:38audience rather than the LP's they have attracted, you know,
- 20:42people view them as the funds that you want to get to help
- 20:46build your cap table, even if of course there's equal amounts of
- 20:48skeptics that say Andreessen will fund anyone.
- 20:51Like clearly based on these returns, they've done quite
- 20:53well. So founders know that founders
- 20:56want to check from injuries and even if it's, you know, it's
- 20:58some inflated valuation because it adds the So they're clearly
- 21:02conscious of the brand. I will say though, kind of to
- 21:05Tom's side, I just think it's tough given like how
- 21:10unsuccessful their media adventures have been.
- 21:13I mean, obviously our podcast is smaller.
- 21:15I get that, but like it just to me seems like they they they
- 21:19shut it down like the clubhouses didn't work.
- 21:21I don't know. I think they but they do try
- 21:23things. I'll give them that.
- 21:24They, yeah, they jump. They're not widely, you know,
- 21:27they're somewhere in the middle. They're their media efforts.
- 21:29But their middle, they're gonna get ribs to middle of the road.
- 21:31But their branding efforts and their marketing and brand is
- 21:34very successful. Yeah, and that has been huge for
- 21:37them. Of course BC firms are brands,
- 21:39but I think more than anyone and recent has perfected that as a
- 21:43business model. Yeah.
- 21:44All right. For our second story, so we
- 21:46wanted to talk about Jimmy Kimmel.
- 21:48It's an irresistible topic, you know, Newcomer.
- 21:52Here at Newcomer, we're obviously very focused on how
- 21:55our business is doing. We try not to think about the
- 21:58government too much. But then sometimes, especially
- 22:02in a strongman democracy that we seem to be living in right now,
- 22:06the government looms too large. So we we felt compelled to call
- 22:11out the meddling from the FCC and the Trump administration in
- 22:17the case of 1 Jimmy Kimmel. So we we said business leaders
- 22:22dance to Trump's tune. The Trump trade is ethically
- 22:25bankrupt and riskier than it seems.
- 22:28It's time to sell. This is sort of a team effort
- 22:32piece. So this this is not my line.
- 22:35I think Jonathan Weber, our editor, pulled this, he said.
- 22:40As a matter of personal and professional ethics, we're quite
- 22:42surprised that people with plenty of means who have climbed
- 22:45to the summit of corporate power have opted to grovel at Trump's
- 22:49feet. He's obviously talking about,
- 22:51you know, Disney basically capitulating here.
- 22:53And Bob Iger, like, why'd you roll over?
- 22:56And we write, we understand that Trump represents a real threat
- 22:59to their business interests. But as the prices line from
- 23:02billions goes, what's the point of having fuck you money if you
- 23:06never say fuck you? And that that was the piece.
- 23:09And like, I do think enough people sort of shouting like man
- 23:13Eiger, etcetera. Why are you guys so weak here
- 23:17and spineless? Got ABC to sort of like reverse
- 23:21course, bring back Jimmy Kimmel and hopefully hold the line.
- 23:24I don't know. Yeah.
- 23:26Tom, I mean, you follow media so closely.
- 23:28Obviously you lived in LA for a long time, wrote about
- 23:31Hollywood. What?
- 23:32Where? Where do you see?
- 23:34You know, we made this sort of a business story, but it's really
- 23:36a Hollywood story. What do you make about it?
- 23:38Make of it sort of from inside Hollywood.
- 23:41It's so. Funny how in the midst of a
- 23:43crisis everyone becomes experts on the topic that just popped
- 23:47up. So remember when everyone was
- 23:48like experts on NATO after Russia invaded Ukraine and we
- 23:52became extremely knowledgeable about like the insurance and
- 23:54outs of like membership countries in NATO and COVID,
- 23:57everyone became. Virologists.
- 24:00We were epidemiologists. And virologists.
- 24:02So now we're all ratings experts and you know, the, the smart
- 24:06conservative take after Jimmy Kimmel was like, ah, this was
- 24:08them of cutting bait. This was ABC cutting bait on a
- 24:11low rated show, which is just like I understand that that was
- 24:14the spin that Paramount gave when they cut when they
- 24:18announced they were going to be shutting down Stephen Colbert's
- 24:21show and getting rid of the late night franchise entirely.
- 24:24This was completely like wrong headed and just goes to show
- 24:26that like, you know, you know, kind of self professed experts
- 24:30and, you know, quick studies on a business that they otherwise
- 24:33have no fucking clue about really leads people to very,
- 24:36very dumb ideas, which is like ABC has been dying to get rid of
- 24:39Jimmy Kimmel all of these years. And because of a controversy,
- 24:41they cut bait mid epis, you know, just before the recording.
- 24:44So they it was just like, it doesn't like you think it was
- 24:46like a. Well positioned show for ABC.
- 24:49No, I mean it was. Yes I don't even know where to
- 24:53start with these things like late night as a genre has been
- 24:56in decline. If you look at the ratings, no
- 24:57one really watches broadcast television anymore and these
- 24:59shows that air at 11:30 on local affiliates are not enticing to
- 25:04most people that watch TV. The rating the views on YouTube
- 25:07far outstrip what what the the live ratings are.
- 25:10So anyone who's trying to make a, you know, what the reach of
- 25:13these shows is, is based on its TV ratings, doesn't take into
- 25:17account that these are basically web shows at this point.
- 25:19And I was listening to Bill Simmons.
- 25:20He's making the point Jimmy Kimmel leads ABC up front.
- 25:23He's like a big part of the ABC brand.
- 25:24Like they use him for a lot of stuff.
- 25:26They like him. They.
- 25:27Like him, he is a huge bonding you're.
- 25:29Responding to the disingenuous like, you know, like argument
- 25:34about smart take like that was the thing.
- 25:35That annoyed me, right? Like that became the like.
- 25:37Yeah. Oh, I really know how the
- 25:39business works. Some of the publications that we
- 25:43like. A Dylan Byers take but.
- 25:45I'm maybe he didn't write no Dylan as much as I.
- 25:47Really despise the guy and I don't mind saying that on the
- 25:49podcast as much as I truly dislike him and what he does as
- 25:53a journalist. Like he understands how media
- 25:54works, so he wasn't dumb enough to really think that that's
- 25:57what. But also his classic Trump that
- 25:59Trump. Keeps me like even after Jimmy
- 26:01Kimmel came back, he's like, no, I'm trying to get rid of like
- 26:04Jimmy Kimmel. I mean, literally like tweets
- 26:06out like, oh, I got ABCI basically extorted ABC for like
- 26:10$19 million or whatever. Maybe I need to do that again.
- 26:13You know, it's just like all these conservatives like, you
- 26:15know, try to come up with the most like, you know, Fairmont
- 26:17intellectual. Speech like.
- 26:19Business rationalist. Reason.
- 26:21For this. And then it's just like, no, I
- 26:23did exactly what I said and I'll do.
- 26:25Yeah, it's. This is why Trump is like maybe
- 26:29a uniting figure in other ways, because he just fucking says the
- 26:33thing that is the most basic and like uninformed, not informed,
- 26:37like unenlightened version of what's going on.
- 26:38Like you have all these people trying to create the
- 26:41intellectual framework for Trumpism and it's like, Nah,
- 26:43it's just this guy's peak and ego.
- 26:45And you know, he has no interest in standards and and checks and
- 26:50balances and all that shit. So I mean the FCC.
- 26:53Chair literally said this can go the easy way or the hard way,
- 26:55you know, it's just like it's yeah, it's literally like a
- 26:58mafia like behavior. Yeah, I I saw some.
- 27:02People trying to say that like, it was unfortunate that he said
- 27:04that because it, it was somewhat coincidental to, you know, the,
- 27:08the, the effect. Like, had he not said that, it's
- 27:09possible that Sinclair and and Nexstar might still.
- 27:14Right, right. Well, they wouldn't.
- 27:15Have had like this sort of smoking gun of, of, you know,
- 27:18First Amendment violation on a fucking podcast, right?
- 27:21Where so, so it ended up kind of being counter to the, to the
- 27:24truth, which was really that ABC has just been dying to offload
- 27:26Jimmy Kimmel, which is so dumb. But I mean, look back to the
- 27:30tech angle of it. If we can try to like keep this
- 27:32somewhat grounded and what we're supposedly experts on.
- 27:36I mean, like one of the biggest things that you saw coming out
- 27:39of like tech support for, for the Trump administration was the
- 27:44bridging of a bridging of free speech on the platforms, right?
- 27:47That that, you know, the Biden administration leaned on
- 27:49Facebook and and leaned on well, any Twitter, obviously with the
- 27:54whole Twitter Files things to get ideas that were not publicly
- 27:58acceptable. I don't even know which were the
- 27:59ones because a lot of the stuff happened during Trump, you know,
- 28:01like maybe lab leak theory. I guess the Hunter Biden laptop
- 28:06was was the number one thing that they point to.
- 28:08But this became like a core animating philosophy for.
- 28:14Trump. Supporting tech people that like
- 28:16Biden was anti free speech. We believe as our first
- 28:18principle that free speech is the most important thing and
- 28:21platforms and everyone should be allowed to it.
- 28:24They were not as outspoken as they probably should have, but
- 28:26there were some, there were definitely some I saw out there
- 28:29saying like this is this is mildly concerning.
- 28:31You know the content moderation stuff is a.
- 28:33Minefield that like, Oh my God, it's almost like a whole nother
- 28:36can of worms. But your your your point here is
- 28:39just, you know, if the she was on the other.
- 28:42Foot animated during the Biden. Administration about the
- 28:44influence on social media and the impact on free speech.
- 28:46Their rallying cry was free speech.
- 28:48And here we were in the media class being like, well, it's not
- 28:50really free speech. Quibble, quibble, quibble.
- 28:52And now you have like, what feels like very direct speech
- 28:56and like, a lot of people are silent.
- 28:57I mean, Ted Cruz and others did did speak up.
- 29:00I think Mitch McConnell, you know, Jimmy Kimmel in his
- 29:03monologue on the comeback, thanked, you know, Ted Cruz for
- 29:08for defending him, basically. So there were a couple.
- 29:11But yeah, it's it's always disappointing that people can
- 29:14have free speeches or rallying cry when they're in the
- 29:16opposition and then not stand by it.
- 29:20Yeah. And if it truly is?
- 29:21Like your first principle that that is the most important thing
- 29:23to you, then like you really should have been a little bit
- 29:27like sure there was support for him.
- 29:28They should have been madder about it 'cause if the shoe was
- 29:30on the other foot, they would be apoplectic.
- 29:32You know, if this was, you know, Biden in charge and he got, I
- 29:36don't even know who the, the allegory would be on the left,
- 29:39but you know, whatever. Like centrist right wing version
- 29:41that was like. Yeah, well, but he's on cable.
- 29:44I mean, that's the problem. Like it's such a specific issue
- 29:47with with with because it's, you know, the FCC overseas
- 29:51affiliates, they don't oversee cable.
- 29:53So you can just say whatever the hell you want on cable.
- 29:55So anyway, I don't have the perfect analogy here, but the
- 29:57fact is, if this was, and I think I was complaining about
- 30:00this Eric in a group chat that we're in, like, you know, if
- 30:02this was about like, because the initial claim about why it was
- 30:05OK for Brendan Carr to like threaten Jimmy, was that like,
- 30:08well, implying that, you know, Tyler Robinson was MAGA is just
- 30:11false. Like you're spreading
- 30:12misinformation and you know, you there should be consequences for
- 30:16spreading misinformation. No one really knows what his
- 30:19beliefs are. This guy, you know, we have like
- 30:22Joe Rogan. 'S like, oh, you really offended
- 30:24people by going against the narrative.
- 30:25Not did I really accept the narrative?
- 30:27You know, it's like this is like they're all mad, but they're
- 30:30also all conspiracy theorists. So at once it's like, OK, we're
- 30:33holding we're going to get really angry that you're defying
- 30:36like the government narrative on what happened at the same time,
- 30:39we're the conspiracy people who don't believe it.
- 30:41You know, it's just like, why you guys so mad at Jimmy Kimmel?
- 30:43Besides, like you've all I don't even I don't think there was
- 30:46that. There was some organic
- 30:48groundswell, but this was clearly like top down.
- 30:50You didn't feel like the anger at Jimmy Kimmel, Like I don't I
- 30:54don't know. I did not feel well.
- 30:55I didn't. I mean, you know, and a lot of
- 30:57the reporting on it was just like this viral clip of Jimmy
- 31:00Kimmel saying this. I had never heard this monologue
- 31:02thing until the Brendan Carr incident.
- 31:04Like, I don't remember everyone kind of being extremely mad.
- 31:06And you know who had a great column about this?
- 31:09Yeah. From the ropes was was Nate
- 31:11Silver wrote a piece that was kind of comparing it to like the
- 31:16post 911 environment where everybody was just so uneasy
- 31:21about what you were allowed to say on air and if you could kind
- 31:24of cross the administration. And hilariously, the analogy
- 31:27that he brought up was, you know, Bill Maher hosted this
- 31:30show politically incorrect. And he got into hot water at the
- 31:32time because he very bizarrely said that the 9/11 hijackers
- 31:37were brave, more brave than the Americans who were like raining
- 31:40missiles on Afghanistan. And that really pissed off the
- 31:44Bush administration. And he ends up getting cancelled
- 31:46and replaced with Jimmy Kimmel. And that's kind of the
- 31:49beginnings of his show was was after they cancelled politically
- 31:52incorrect. But his point was like, you
- 31:55know, the environment we're in is so similar to, you know, the
- 31:58post 911 moment where there's just so much apprehension and
- 32:02and and warring factions over what is allowable speech.
- 32:07Mark Elias, the. Democratic lawyer who rightfully
- 32:11feels very dismayed that all these law firms and media
- 32:15companies are capitulating to Trump.
- 32:17Mark Elias argued you should build anti fragile institutions.
- 32:20And you know, I, I am proud that like a newcomer we can it's it's
- 32:24easier for us easier. It's like we can hold the line
- 32:27seemingly more comfortably than ABC and CBS partially because
- 32:32it's like, who the hell are these guys?
- 32:33But also just like we're not dependent on, you know, Trump to
- 32:37approve random mergers. And so there's something nice
- 32:41about just being independent. Most, you know, you know,
- 32:44obviously we have different revenue streams, but none that
- 32:48see pressure points from the Trump administration at the
- 32:50moment. We we should talk about.
- 32:52That for a bit actually, because like, I don't want to be too
- 32:54self aggrandizing and congratulatory about like, you
- 32:57know, us making our money from independent media.
- 33:00But like, if anything, I think it is, if there's anything to be
- 33:03learned from this ridiculous episode, is that like corporate
- 33:06media as an as an entity is increasingly useless.
- 33:10If, if, if they're not going to stand up to the administration
- 33:14in a, in a, in a serious way, then what value do they have?
- 33:17Their their business has been under attack for, for years.
- 33:19Like just as a financially, you know, their audiences are
- 33:24shrinking. Their hold on the culture is
- 33:26still there, but I think increasingly tenuous because of
- 33:29like non, you know, mainstream distribution platforms and, and
- 33:32the video that comes out of that.
- 33:33So, like, and you look at these people that end up kind of
- 33:36getting kicked off of mainstream television, like Stephen
- 33:38Colbert, what's he going to end up doing after he leaves CBS?
- 33:41Probably he'll do a podcast. You know, like, like, like Jimmy
- 33:44Kimmel might be more influential.
- 33:45I mean, that was the thing with Jimmy Kimmel.
- 33:46He would probably be bigger. Yeah.
- 33:49Well, I don't know. Do you believe that would be
- 33:51bigger on his own? Well, I mean.
- 33:52You could look at the Conan example, right?
- 33:54Like Conan's podcast is wildly successful after he cancelled
- 33:57TBS, Yeah. Yeah, I mean, so I mean
- 34:00obviously. TBS is smaller, but but you
- 34:03could make the argument that he could, you know, have built
- 34:05something quite successfully independently after this, you
- 34:08know, we'll have he's back on the air.
- 34:10So we don't know, but other people have done this before.
- 34:12Yeah. So like.
- 34:13Like the culture wars may still gravitate towards things that
- 34:17are coming out of mainstream media because it's closer to a
- 34:20monoculture than anything else we have.
- 34:22But like, the trends are so clear right now.
- 34:25And I, you know, like, there's this sports podcaster, Dan
- 34:30Levittard, who's like ESPN, former ESPN, and he was making
- 34:33this point pretty, pretty smartly that I guess I said
- 34:36earlier, which is like, what's the value of, of, of corporate
- 34:39media anymore? If if they're if they're not
- 34:41going to do anything substantial, you know, use what,
- 34:45what remaining pieces of power that they have to push back on
- 34:48this stuff. And I don't know, like it makes
- 34:51me feel good about where I'm at. Like I was at the Wall Street
- 34:53Journal for. Yeah, I mean like I was.
- 34:56At the Wall Street Journal for a couple of years, they, by the
- 34:57way, like did a really bad job covering the, the, the shooting
- 35:02and, and put out a story with a completely inaccurate headline
- 35:05about, about, you know, transgender ideology being, you
- 35:08know, a key part and why this guy killed Charlie Kirk.
- 35:11And they've not done a very good job because there was something
- 35:14written like. Notices bulge owo on the bullet
- 35:17like some meme reference. Like it's not even.
- 35:19How could you even There's a law.
- 35:20Enforcement brief that you know, they accurately reported that
- 35:24there was some law enforcement brief, but it's like you need
- 35:27the underlying thing to be true and it was weaponized.
- 35:29You need to. See what the brief says, right?
- 35:32Yeah. So I, I guess like, you know,
- 35:36we'll see what happens, but I wouldn't be surprised if we five
- 35:39years from now and look, look at the growth of independent media
- 35:43and see, you know, the Jimmy Kimmel moment is at least very
- 35:47indicative of where the power balances are.
- 35:50And, and like where, where the momentum is, is, is headed.
- 35:53And what it means for like a united society is a whole other
- 35:56thing. If, if everybody is like, you
- 35:59know, reading the, the various sub stacks and, and podcasts and
- 36:02whatever that they agree with, but it just seems like there's
- 36:06no turning back from it. And if corporate media doesn't
- 36:08have any, anything, you know, foundational to what they do
- 36:12that gets people interested in them and, and, and finding that
- 36:16they have value, then like it's not, it's not going to go, it's
- 36:18not going to go well for them with that.
- 36:22Inspiring point for independent media and sad point for
- 36:26corporate media. We can brag about one story
- 36:29we're proud of. Madeline had a great story on
- 36:31the Buy now pay later company Klarna which went public a
- 36:35couple weeks ago. Stock price is down marginally
- 36:39but still way up from the depths of the post 21 heyday.
- 36:45So yeah, way. Up from it's 2022 mega dollars
- 36:49and lows for Klarna. You want to give us who are, who
- 36:51are the winners and losers in terms of the investors and the
- 36:54Klarna IPO? Yeah, absolutely.
- 36:56I would say Sequoia is a very big winner.
- 37:00Sequoia got in at the Series A and got about 1/4 of the company
- 37:05there. I think it was Chris Holton at
- 37:10the time was the principal who made the introduction of the
- 37:13Klarna founders to Michael Moritz.
- 37:15They liked the idea. They bought on back in, I think
- 37:19it was 2010, but the company had been founded in, you know, 2005.
- 37:23So you know, it had been working along in Europe.
- 37:26But this was the first big BC I was very proud by.
- 37:29The way somebody, somebody DM me like Chris Olson really found
- 37:32that company for Sequoia and I went and checked.
- 37:34I was like, yeah, that's in our story.
- 37:36Like, I'm glad. I'm glad.
- 37:38You had that in there because it's like it's easy for the
- 37:40junior part. I I always like that in the
- 37:42story of the cap table, like who's the, you know, the big
- 37:44famous partner or, you know, on these good deals, like Mike
- 37:47Moritz takes the deal. And obviously they do a lot
- 37:50along the way help the company succeed.
- 37:51And then, you know, founders are often loyal to that person.
- 37:54But yeah, Chris Olson who's still an investor, I think it
- 37:56drive capital source deal for Sequoia, yes.
- 38:01So important credit where credit is due, but Sequoia I think
- 38:04followed. I would say the Savvy Venture
- 38:06model, the closest with the corner story over the 20 years,
- 38:09it was private, you know, they were coming in when it made
- 38:13sense and then, you know, advising the company along the
- 38:16way. But they sabbily held out of the
- 38:20crazy super high inflated valuations and the just
- 38:23everything's online shopping post pandemic interest rate
- 38:2502021 rounds. So Sequoia did not invest in
- 38:29either of the two really big SoftBank rounds that were led
- 38:31then that happened then and then they came back in and bought
- 38:34another huge bulk of shares when the valuation was down to I
- 38:37think 6.7 billion in 2022. And then of course, first
- 38:42segment. In this story, actually first
- 38:44first segment in this podcast 2021, do you want to make money?
- 38:48You needed to play that the right way, right?
- 38:51You needed to sell and so or sell or at least not buy.
- 38:55And in the case of Sequoia, they did not buy Klarna shares at
- 38:59what like a 31 billion valuations, I think it got
- 39:03above. 40 at it got above 40 at one point too.
- 39:05Oh wow, and now it's for. The second one. 16 yes.
- 39:10So you could not. You should.
- 39:11Not have been buying like SoftBank in 2021, correct?
- 39:16But another player to your point again about buying smart and
- 39:20selling high, the private equity firm Premiera came in which I
- 39:24think had been under covered at this point around kind of 2017
- 39:28in the middle of the sort of rapid growth phase for Karna and
- 39:32then exited pretty much half of their holdings in 2021 at the
- 39:37peak. So they are no longer they're
- 39:38not on the they're not on the S1 or the F1 because it's a
- 39:41European company, but they're not on the F1.
- 39:43Their name isn't mentioned, you know, in the current large
- 39:46stockholders, but they exited in 2021.
- 39:48So it was an incredible deal for them versus, you know, Guy was a
- 39:51principal. At the time, what's his name?
- 39:53We need to give the partner who did the.
- 39:55Deal was Andrew Young at Premier who's still there.
- 39:59But yeah, Congrats to Andrew, seriously.
- 40:02I mean, it was we, we have to do our little TV stand they have.
- 40:04Gongs and shit when people are doing.
- 40:06We're not quite that. Yeah.
- 40:07Shameless winner Andrew. Young, you know.
- 40:11The Ding Ding, Ding. DST in.
- 40:13General Atlantic, they did OK, but not great.
- 40:16They did OK, yeah. They came in.
- 40:18So that's another point I would list them in sort of the mid
- 40:20tier because they came in, you know, in 2011 right after
- 40:24Sequoia did. But then they exited to in that
- 40:27round that Premier bought in. So Premier bought some of their
- 40:29shares as well when they came in in the middle and it was a solid
- 40:32exit, but it was, you know, kind of like a 2.5 X ish when you
- 40:37could have had something a lot bigger if you had held in both
- 40:40Sequoia kind of doing the classic way, you know, get in
- 40:43early, advise the company venture model, biggest steward,
- 40:46largest shareholder outside of the founders, you know, like
- 40:50they can claim that they can be the best venture firm.
- 40:53But Karna, I think shows that you could have won big on this
- 40:57without doing the venture playbook, frankly, because it
- 41:00was private for so long. And now we have all these
- 41:01unicorns that have been private for so long too, that I feel
- 41:04like we'll see more of these wins in the middle than we used
- 41:07to to to step. Back.
- 41:09OK, So whether you're a venture capitalist or an investor, like
- 41:14what, what lessons can you learn from this story?
- 41:18I think there are a couple and you guys are welcome to jump in
- 41:22with some. I mean, I think one lesson is if
- 41:25you invest in a good company and hold for a long time, you'll do
- 41:29pretty well. I mean, Sequoia bought early.
- 41:32The company had lots of up and downs.
- 41:34They believed in the company. Now they're up at the IPO.
- 41:38So I think that's one. The other is sort of the the
- 41:42opposite, which is if you're going to trade things along the
- 41:45way, you really need to be smart about where you are in the
- 41:49market. Because there were people who
- 41:51came into a good company in 2021 and that was a terrible deal.
- 41:55And they're people who came in before that and sold out.
- 41:58You could come in after 2021 when there were all these
- 42:01markdowns and you would have done well.
- 42:03So you, you do sort of need to get the timing right, yeah.
- 42:07Except to your point, yeah, if you would have come in at 2022,
- 42:10you would have been up at IPO and that you have only been in
- 42:13the company for a couple years before they went public versus,
- 42:16you know, holding the whole way through.
- 42:18Sequoia does have the largest gain on capital of any of the
- 42:22firms to be fair though. So I will give points to the
- 42:24venture model there. They made the most raw money,
- 42:28but the case against. Sequoia is the time value of
- 42:32money, right? They had to wait a long time to
- 42:35see these returns. So I would rather be Premiera in
- 42:41this case. I, well, I'd rather build the
- 42:43institution of Sequoia, supporting founders like going
- 42:45along, being sort of reliable, like I think a lot of credit to
- 42:49them and just like standing by a good company, a good founder.
- 42:51So I think that's admirable if you were optimizing purely for
- 42:55let's make some money, the do a good deal at the right time in
- 42:59the company's history, exit when everybody's losing their fucking
- 43:02minds and be like, this is too much money to like stay in this
- 43:05company forever. Like Premier as a financial
- 43:08institution played it really well.
- 43:11All right, well, great story. We'll have more, We'll have more
- 43:13stories as the captive. It seems like IPO activity is
- 43:16picking up a little bit. So I think we're gonna try to
- 43:18revive this format and track who the winners, mostly winners, I
- 43:24guess, when you're going public, but sometimes losers like
- 43:27SoftBank. No offense.
- 43:29Yeah, thank you for tuning in to this weeks episode of the
- 43:33podcast. Listen to new episodes every
- 43:35week wherever you get your podcasts, and subscribe to The
- 43:37Sub Stack at newcomer.co.