Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Doing Great
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this assumption out there that asking for a raise is easiest when your company is absolutely killing it. Record profits, rising stock, hiring spree — what could stand in the way, right? Luna: And yet, so many people tell me they feel even more stuck in that situation. It's almost like they don't want to rock the boat when everyone's celebrating. Lucas: Exactly. And part of it is the classic 'the rising tide lifts all boats' fallacy — managers assume you're already happy because the company is doing well. But your paycheck doesn't automatically scale with the share price. Luna: So today we're tackling that specific scenario: your company is thriving, and you still need to ask for more. What's the smart play? Lucas: Let's start with a real example. I was talking to a product manager at a fast-growing SaaS company — let's call her Priya. Her company had just reported another quarter of thirty percent year-over-year revenue growth, and they were hiring like crazy. Luna: Sounds like the perfect moment to ask, right? Lucas: You'd think. But when she went to her manager, the first response was, 'We're already paying you at the top of the band.' And that was it. No discussion, no data, just a closed door. Luna: Ouch. So what did she do? Lucas: She came back a month later with three specific things: first, the market data showing her role at comparable companies was paying fifteen to twenty percent more. Second, a list of concrete projects she'd led that directly contributed to that revenue growth. And third, a clear number — she asked for a fifteen percent increase, presented as a range, not a demand. Luna: And how did that go? Lucas: She got twelve percent, which was honestly above what her manager initially said was possible. But the key was that she didn't just say 'the company is making money, so I want a raise.' She tied her ask to her own contribution and to the external market. Luna: That's the crucial distinction. Company success is the backdrop, but your case has to be about you. Lucas: And that's the trap a lot of people fall into. They assume that because the company is doing well, they don't need to do the homework. But actually, it's the opposite — the better the company looks, the more you need to prove that your compensation hasn't been left behind. Luna: So what's the first step? Before you even book the meeting? Lucas: You have to get your market data straight. Look at comparable roles, same industry, same geography, similar company size. Sites like Levels.fyi or Glassdoor can give you a baseline, but don't just screenshot the median — you want to understand the range and where you fall based on your experience and impact. Luna: And I'd add that you should also look at how your own company has raised its compensation bands. If they've been hiring aggressively at higher salaries than your current one, that's a strong signal. Lucas: Exactly. That's the 'new hire versus existing employee' gap, and it's been a huge issue this year, especially in tech. We've heard so many stories of people discovering they're earning twenty percent less than the person who just joined their team with similar experience. Luna: Which is demoralizing, but also gives you a concrete talking point. 'You're paying new hires X, and I've been here for two years with proven results. That's not fair.' Lucas: That kind of fairness argument can be powerful, but you have to be careful. Don't come across as entitled or angry. Frame it as a business issue: you want to ensure your compensation is competitive so you can continue to perform at your best. Luna: And you should also prep your list of accomplishments. Not just 'I did my job' but specific, measurable wins that align with company goals. Did you increase retention? Save costs? Drive feature adoption? Lucas: Priya brought a one-page sheet with three bullet points per quarter, each tied to a metric. That made it impossible for her manager to dismiss her. She wasn't asking for a raise because the company was rich; she was showing that she was a significant reason the company was rich. Luna: Before you go in, how do you decide on the number? Just ask for a percentage increase? Lucas: It's better to anchor with a total compensation figure, not just base salary. So if you're making one hundred twenty thousand, and market data says one hundred forty to one hundred fifty, you ask for one hundred forty-five. That gives you room to negotiate down to one thirty-eight or so. Luna: And you should also think about the timing. Is there a moment when the company is more likely to say yes? Like right after a big win or during annual budget planning? Lucas: Absolutely. If your company just landed a massive contract or announced record earnings — like Priya's quarter — that's a natural moment. But also, if there's a performance review cycle coming up, align your ask with that. Never ask when your manager is stressed about a looming deadline or during a hiring freeze. Luna: This is exactly the kind of practical advice we love to give because it applies to so many people. And if today's episode is giving you that 'aha' moment that could change how you approach your next conversation, we want to keep that going. The way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps us keep producing episodes like this. Lucas: Yeah, it genuinely makes a difference. We're not asking for much, just enough to keep the lights on and the mics warm. Every little bit is appreciated, and it keeps the show independent. Luna: So back to that conversation with your manager. What's the actual words you should use? Can you give us a template? Lucas: Sure. You might say: 'I've really enjoyed the growth we've seen this year, and I want to make sure my compensation reflects my contribution. Based on market research and my track record, I'm looking for a base salary of X, which is in line with comparable roles. I'd love to work together to make that happen.' Luna: That's direct but not aggressive. And you're making it a collaborative conversation, not a demand. Lucas: Right. And if your manager says 'the budget is tight' even though the company is printing money, you can gently push back. 'I understand budgets are set annually, but given the company's performance, I'd hope there's flexibility. Can we review this at the next cycle and set a clear date to revisit?' Luna: That's smart to get a commitment. Otherwise, you might get a vague 'we'll look into it' and never hear back. Lucas: Exactly. And another pitfall is asking for a raise based solely on your tenure. 'I've been here three years, so I deserve more' — that doesn't work, especially when the company is doing well because they feel they're already rewarding loyalty with stock options or bonuses. Luna: So you have to make the case that your compensation is lagging the market, not just that you've been there a while. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing: don't compare yourself to a specific coworker. 'John makes more than me' is a toxic argument. It's about the role and the market, not about John. Luna: What about the psychological barrier? A lot of people feel guilty asking when the company is doing well, like they should be grateful. Lucas: That's real. But remember, you're not asking for charity. You're asking to be paid fairly for the value you create. In a thriving company, labor is more valuable, not less. The surplus is there — you're just asking for your share. Luna: And if the answer is still no, what then? Lucas: Then you have a decision to make. If the company is doing well and they're not willing to pay you market rate, that's a signal. Maybe it's time to leverage that strong performance on your resume and look elsewhere. You might be surprised what the market offers. Luna: And that's a great segue to next week's episode, where we'll talk about how to use a job offer as leverage without burning bridges. Lucas: Stay tuned for that. But for now, if you're in a thriving company and you're feeling underpaid, take the time to prepare your case. The data is your friend. And remember, you're not being greedy — you're being professional. Luna: Thanks for joining us, and we'll see you next time.