Latest / The Healthy Church Staff Podcast / When Your Elder Board Micromanages Your Ministry Staff
Transcript
- 0:08Your youth pastor comes to you frustrated.
- 0:11He's just frustrated.
- 0:13And your elder board just told him that he needs to have approval to change Webster Right's format.
- 0:19Your worship leader got questioned about long choices in front of a whole board.
- 0:24Your children's director was asked to defend why she bought construction paper without a purchase order.
- 0:29Yes, these things actually happen in churches, and you're sitting there thinking, when did our board become the fun police?
- 0:38Here's the thing: most boards mean but good intentions don't fix bad boundaries.
- 0:43And if you're dealing with any kind of situation where there's tension between the board and your staff, we're going to talk about it today.
- 0:52We're going to name what's really happening here.
- 0:54And I'm so glad that you joined us here on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast.
- 0:58I'm your host, Todd Rhodes, one of the co-founders over at chemistrystaffing.com.
- 1:03Elder boards don't usually start off micromanaging.
- 1:07It usually begins with one bad experience.
- 1:09Maybe a poor, maybe a staff member made a poor decision, or somebody spent money five years ago where they shouldn't have.
- 1:17So the board adds a layer of approval.
- 1:21It seems innocent at first, and then something else happens.
- 1:24There's another layer and then another.
- 1:26And pretty soon your staff can't breathe without permission.
- 1:29But here's something that boards don't realize.
- 1:33They can very quickly drift into dysfunction.
- 1:38When boards micromanage, staff stop taking initiative.
- 1:42They become order takers instead of leaders.
- 1:45Creativity dies because every idea needs approval.
- 1:49Decision making slows to a literal crawl.
- 1:54And yes, your best people start looking elsewhere when they're micromanaged by a board, or you.
- 1:59And ironically, you get the very thing that boards fear most, and that's poor performance.
- 2:06Listen, your elders aren't trying to sabotage your ministry.
- 2:10They're really, in most cases, trying to protect it.
- 2:13But there is a better way, a healthy, balanced way.
- 2:17Boards should govern, not manage.
- 2:20Let me repeat that.
- 2:23Boards should not manage.
- 2:26Sure, they set the guardrails, but they don't set the GPS route.
- 2:30Think of it like parenting teenagers.
- 2:32You establish boundaries and values, but you don't choose their outfit every morning.
- 2:37Your job as a senior leader in the church is to translate this for both sides.
- 2:42Right?
- 2:43Help your administrative board or your elder team understand the difference between oversight and interference.
- 2:49And at the same time, you need to help your staff understand the difference between accountability and control.
- 2:56So you really tried, you need to try and make it practical.
- 2:59And here's some ways that I think that you can start, if this is an issue in your church, to make things a little bit more practical.
- 3:07First of all, create some clear delegation boundaries with your board.
- 3:10Things like this, I think are really helpful.
- 3:12Staff decisions under$500, or maybe it's$50 or$1,000 or$5,000 in your context.
- 3:19I don't know, but staff decisions under a certain dollar amount don't need approval.
- 3:23Just set that up.
- 3:25And you guys can talk about that.
- 3:27Your elder team, your board can talk about that, and you guys can figure out what works for you.
- 3:32Here's another possibility.
- 3:33Ministry format changes are operational, not governance.
- 3:37So those are things that are usually not handled by the board.
- 3:41Hiring decisions follow this process, not board approval for every candidate.
- 3:46Every church is set up differently here with hiring and firing.
- 3:50I totally get that.
- 3:51But make sure that you know so that there's no overreach either from the board, the pastor, the staff in staffing issues.
- 3:59Give your board what they actually need, and that's regular updates, not permission requests.
- 4:04I served on a board for many years and I wanted updates.
- 4:08I wanted regular updates.
- 4:10I wanted to be communicated with.
- 4:12And I don't need, as a board member, to have really a say in a lot of different things.
- 4:18That's what we, as our elder team, that's what we hired staff to do.
- 4:22Some of those daily things just need to be updated.
- 4:26But it's really important that you communicate with your board.
- 4:29Monthly reports instead of weekly meetings are fine.
- 4:32Dashboards instead of detailed explanations are fine.
- 4:36Results instead of play-by-play commentary, that's fine.
- 4:39And when board members overstep, address it quickly and privately.
- 4:43Something like, hey, Tom, I appreciate your concern about the youth ministry.
- 4:47Let me get you the information you need.
- 4:50And then just a slight redirect.
- 4:52How can we make sure that you feel informed without slowing down our team?
- 4:55Here's your bottom line.
- 4:56Your board's job is to make sure that you're going on the right direction.
- 5:01They set those guardrails.
- 5:03Your board's job is usually not to hold the steering wheel.
- 5:08This week, I think if you can have one conversation, either with a board member who's overstepping or with a staff member who's feeling micromanaged, I think that would be great if this is a problem that you're facing in your church.
- 5:19Start with something like this.
- 5:21Hey, help me understand.
- 5:22Can you help me understand what you need to feel confident about this decision?
- 5:26And then just be quiet and listen.
- 5:28Half the time, micromanagement is really just a request for better communication.
- 5:35Your staff needs room to lead and your board needs peace of mind.
- 5:39And you can give them both.
- 5:41I hope this has been helpful.
- 5:42If you need help with your board, we're here to assist you.
- 5:45We handle church polity issues and governance issues all the time.
- 5:50We have people on our team that are really experienced in helping work through that.
- 5:53If there's an area that you really just need an outside set of eyes and ears, we're here to help you.
- 5:59We're here to assist you however we can.
- 6:00Reach out to me.
- 6:01That's the first way that you can do that.
- 6:03Just reach out, podcast at chemistry staffing.com is my email, podcast at chemistry staffing.com.
- 6:10We'd love to hear from you and see if there's any way that we can help you.
- 6:14This is it for this week.
- 6:15Episode 630 630 is in the books, and we will be back here as we are every Monday through Friday.
- 6:22Hope you'll join me right here on the Healthy Church Step Podcast.
- 6:26Have a great day!