Household Items: Toilet Talk, Disagreements about Rules, and Audience Suggestions

The Desert Island Podcast · Apr 14, 2026 · 39m

Want to add your opinions and thoughts on this week's picks? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Each host picked three "household items" to bring along to their deserted island. But the rules weren't set in stone in advance, so things got a little off the rails.

One island is much more bougie than the others, but is he making the smartest choices? Find out where the guys stand on starting their own fires and hear some of the excellent audience submissions.

And if we get 100 followers on Instagram, Mitch will attempt to make fire, so make sure you follow over…