Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / Most Marriage Conflicts Aren’t About Right and Wrong
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. I'm JD from uncoveringintimacy.com and we help couples build intimacy that strengthens their marriage.
- 0:52And today I want to talk about one of the things that comes up a lot in my coaching calls. It looks like this. A couple describes their latest fight.
- 0:59Maybe it's about how the dishwasher got loaded or what time the kids should be in bed or whether you deal with a problem the moment it comes up or sleep on it first.
- 1:08The details change, but two things are always true. Both of them are frustrated and both of them are certain that they are right.
- 1:16And I find myself explaining, again, a principle that is obvious when it's stated, but it doesn't seem to be common for people to operate under.
- 1:23You don't think alike. You never will. And that's okay because most of what you're fighting about doesn't have a right answer.
- 1:30And I said this in passing in the previous post called What Does Biblical Leadership Look Like in a Marriage?
- 1:37And someone in our forum asked if I had a blog post about this topic. And I didn't, but it deserves its own episode.
- 1:45And so here we are. Most marital conflict is not about right and wrong. It's about two reasonable preferences competing.
- 1:52Think about the fights that actually recur in your marriage. How clean the house needs to be before company comes.
- 1:58Whether money left over at the end of the month gets saved or enjoyed. How much detail counts as tell me about your day.
- 2:04You know, whether a birthday is a big deal or just a Tuesday. What counts as initiating sex?
- 2:10You know, preferred love language is employed. None of these have a morally correct answer.
- 2:16Scripture doesn't specify a bedtime. There is no commandment about loading cutlery handle up or handle down.
- 2:22These are preferences formed by your upbringing, your personality, your family culture, and a thousand experiences your spouse wasn't there for.
- 2:28I mean, you could argue, and rightly so, that spoons placed handled up will tend to stack together and then not get clean.
- 2:35But that's still not a moral issue. Those who choose to do it the more ineffective way still aren't sinning by doing so.
- 2:42They just get to rewash dishes when it comes out. That's the extent of their penance for that atrocity.
- 2:47The trouble starts when we promote a preference to a moral issue.
- 2:52Once the fight becomes right versus wrong in your head, everything changes.
- 2:56Compromise stops feeling like flexibility and starts feeling like losing or worse, like condoning something wrong.
- 3:03Your spouse's disagreement stops being a difference and starts being a character flaw.
- 3:07You're no longer negotiating, you're prosecuting.
- 3:10And years ago, buried in a podcast episode about a half a dozen other things, I talked about the concept of a reality tunnel.
- 3:17And I had honestly forgotten about this term until one of my clients brought it up a few months ago because he was ripping through old podcast episodes.
- 3:25And reality tunnels are the idea that each of us experiences the world through our own filter of beliefs, experiences, and assumptions.
- 3:33And then quietly assumes everyone else is in the same tunnel.
- 3:37And marriage makes this worse, not better.
- 3:39Your lives are so intertwined that, of course, you assume your spouse sees things the way that you do.
- 3:44On top of that, we like being right.
- 3:47And one of the main ways we feel validated in being right is when people agree with us.
- 3:53So when your spouse sees things differently, doesn't notice what you notice, doesn't think what you think,
- 3:57it's easier to get angry than to consider that your way might just be a way.
- 4:02And there's a second layer to this, one I covered in the red flags episode.
- 4:05We see our own struggles, intentions, and feelings far better than we see our spouses.
- 4:11You know the whole story behind your preference.
- 4:13You lived it.
- 4:14Their preference just looks like a wrong answer with no reasoning behind it because you weren't there for the reasoning.
- 4:20So it isn't that your wife thinks you can read her mind.
- 4:23It isn't that your husband thinks you're being deliberately difficult.
- 4:26It's that each of you quietly believes your way of thinking is the way and everyone else is a deviation from it.
- 4:34Here's what's interesting.
- 4:35Scripture itself distinguishes between commands and preferences, and it does so in the middle of a church fight.
- 4:40In Romans 14, the early church was divided over two separate arguments, what a believer was allowed to eat and which days were holy.
- 4:47These weren't trivial to the people involved.
- 4:49They felt like matters of faithfulness.
- 4:52And Paul, who was never shy about drawing hard lines when something was actually sin, refuses to draw one in either dispute.
- 4:59On the food question, he says,
- 5:01One person believes he may eat anything while a weak person eats only vegetables.
- 5:05Let not the one who eats despise the one who abstains, and let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him.
- 5:14And on the holy days question, same answer.
- 5:15One person esteems one day better than the other while another esteems all days alike.
- 5:20Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind.
- 5:23And he opens the chapter by telling them to welcome one another, but not to quarrel over opinions.
- 5:30And lands on the instruction I quoted in the leadership post.
- 5:33So then let us pursue what makes for peace and for mutual upbuilding.
- 5:37If the church can hold differing convictions about things its members consider deeply spiritual without dividing over them,
- 5:44then husband and wife can survive differing preferences about what weekends look like, rest or activities.
- 5:49And Proverbs, of course, has something to say here, too.
- 5:53There is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way to death.
- 5:58That verse usually gets preached about sin and fairly, but notice the mechanism it describes.
- 6:04It seems right.
- 6:05Our internal sense of obviously correct is not a reliable instrument.
- 6:09Paul says the same thing more gently.
- 6:11Don't think of yourselves more highly than you ought, but think with sober judgment.
- 6:16Sober judgment includes being able to say, this thing I feel strongly about is a preference, not a principle.
- 6:24So how do you tell a preference from a principle?
- 6:26When you're in the middle of it, everything feels like a principle.
- 6:29So there are three questions to ask about a recurring conflict.
- 6:32Number one, is a biblical principle being violated?
- 6:35Not would God probably agree with me, but a principle you can actually name.
- 6:40Honestly, honesty, faithfulness, stewardship, treating your spouse with love and respect.
- 6:45If you can't say which principle is at stake without stretching, there probably isn't one.
- 6:50And be honest here.
- 6:50Most of our daily conflicts fail this test immediately.
- 6:54Second is, does it cause real damage?
- 6:57Some things aren't commanded either way, but still matter.
- 7:00Choices that harm your health, your finances, your children's well-being.
- 7:03Real damage is measurable and would look like damage to a neutral observer.
- 7:08I would be annoyed is not damage.
- 7:10I think my way of is better parenting is also not damage.
- 7:14Number three is, or is it just not how I would do it?
- 7:17If it failed the first two tests and this is what's left, it's a preference.
- 7:22It's allowed to stay unresolved, be traded or handed to whichever of you cares more.
- 7:28One guardrail on this, abuse is never a preference level issue.
- 7:32And sin doesn't become acceptable because you both agreed to it.
- 7:35Agreement is not a moral sanitizer.
- 7:38In Acts 5 verse 9, we have this verse,
- 7:40How is it that you have agreed together to test the spirit of the Lord?
- 7:43Sapphira went along with her husband and it didn't protect her.
- 7:46I wrote more about that boundary in the leadership post, so I won't repeat it here.
- 7:51But nothing in this article is about tolerating harm.
- 7:54It is about deflating the fights that were never about harm in the first place.
- 7:57The corollary to this is, just because you feel hurt, doesn't mean you've been harmed.
- 8:03Hurt feelings are real, but they're information, not a verdict.
- 8:07Some of what gets labeled a trigger these days is a strong preference being challenged.
- 8:11Real trauma exists, but this bothers me and this is harming me are different claims,
- 8:16and a marriage needs to be able to tell them apart.
- 8:19So, what do you do when it's a preference?
- 8:21Number one is, get curious, not angry.
- 8:24When your spouse does something that seems obviously wrong to you,
- 8:27the assumption underneath your anger is usually that they had no good reason.
- 8:31In my experience, they almost always had a reason.
- 8:34That reason might be, I didn't think that was important, because to them it wasn't.
- 8:38But don't assume that they weren't thinking.
- 8:40Ask what they're seeing that you're not.
- 8:42I tell coaching clients this constantly.
- 8:45Assume your spouse loves you, and whenever their behavior seems to say otherwise,
- 8:49then investigate before you convict.
- 8:52The second is, respond to what they said, not your interpretation of it.
- 8:57A huge share of preference fights happen mostly inside of your own head.
- 9:01Your spouse says something, you interpret it, and then you argue with the interpretation.
- 9:06Confirming what they actually meant before responding sounds simple,
- 9:08but it's hard to put into practice, which is why I wrote up a four-step process to practice it.
- 9:13It's in the show notes.
- 9:15Number three is, pick your battles.
- 9:17As I said in the resiliency episode, not everything is worth a fight,
- 9:21and fighting about everything fills a marriage with constant dispute.
- 9:25Some differences need discussing, many just need room.
- 9:29And lastly, let some differences stand.
- 9:32I know couples where one is vegetarian by conviction and the other isn't,
- 9:35where one keeps Halloween at arm's length and the other one hands out candy,
- 9:39where one grows through group Bible study and the other grows best alone with a journal,
- 9:44and the marriages hold.
- 9:45In How to Use Conflict to Create Intimacy, I made the case that a conflict may not even be the result of sin,
- 9:52just of free will.
- 9:54Within the Godhead, we see differing perspectives and distinct personalities handled so well
- 9:59that the result is perfect unity.
- 10:01Difference is not the enemy of oneness.
- 10:04Handling difference badly is.
- 10:07And lastly, remember, unity is not uniformity.
- 10:10God's design for marriage is that two become one flesh, not one brain.
- 10:14If he had wanted you married to someone who thinks exactly like you, he could have arranged it.
- 10:19And you have learned much less and grown much less and have been far more confident in some opinions
- 10:25that deserve challenging.
- 10:26The goal was never to think alike.
- 10:29The goal is to love someone who doesn't think like you without needing to fix that about them.
- 10:35So if you want to implement this, try this.
- 10:38Together, you list your last three conflicts.
- 10:40Run each one through the three questions above and agree on a label.
- 10:45Is this a command?
- 10:46Is this damage?
- 10:47Or is this preference?
- 10:48And then talk about what changes if you both start treating the preferences like preferences.
- 10:54My guess is that the argument gets a lot smaller once neither of you has to be right or wrong for it to end.
- 11:01That's all I wanted to talk about today.
- 11:02If you like discussing topics about this and you wish you had a community where you could
- 11:06talk through things like this, share your experiences, argue in a way that is productive,
- 11:12but also lets you dig into deep topics, then consider checking out our supporter forum.
- 11:17We have an amazing group of people there who love to talk about things, love to debate things,
- 11:22love to tackle difficult issues.
- 11:25And we talk about everything under the sun.
- 11:27There is a link in the show notes if you're interested, and I highly recommend it because
- 11:33it comes with a whole bunch of perks as well.
- 11:36And that's it for today.
- 11:37I'll talk to you next time.