Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Apportionment and Substantial Medical Evidence: Burden of Proof in Workers’ Compensation
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone and welcome to apportionment and
- 0:08substantial medical evidence burden of proof
- 0:10and workers comp. I'm Michael Falati and I'm
- 0:13chair of the workers compensation law section
- 0:15and a certified workers compensation specialist
- 0:18myself. I'd like to take a moment to plug the
- 0:21workers compensation section of the Beverly Hills
- 0:23Bar Association. It's a fast and and new fast
- 0:27growing and new section of the Beverly Hills
- 0:29Bar Association and I encourage all work on practitioners
- 0:31as well as practitioners in overlapping practice
- 0:34areas such as personal injury, labor and employment,
- 0:38social security disability to get involved and
- 0:40join the section and perhaps even become a section
- 0:42leader. We'll throw my email address and the
- 0:45Beverly Hills Bar Association's help desk email
- 0:47address in the chat so we can be contacted about
- 0:51the section. And now I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:54our speaker for today, John Ajayi. John is a
- 0:57certified specialist in workers' compensation
- 0:59with the State Bar of California and the founder
- 1:01of Ajayi Law Group, with nearly two decades of
- 1:04experience across every asset of California workers'
- 1:08compensation law. from file clerk and hearing
- 1:10representative to litigator and firm founder.
- 1:13Mr. Ajayi is a dedicated advocate for employers,
- 1:16insurance companies, and third party administrators.
- 1:18A graduate of Trinity Law School where he ranked
- 1:20at the top of his class, he built his practice
- 1:23on a foundation of discipline, excellence, and
- 1:26an unwavering belief that failure is not an option.
- 1:29And now let's get started. All right, thank you
- 1:33very much for that, Michael. Welcome everyone.
- 1:35Thank you for having me and let's get into this
- 1:39presentation regarding apportionment and substantial
- 1:42medical evidence. Just as a precursor. Obviously
- 1:46the issue of apportionment is more of a defendant's
- 1:49issue as most everybody knows. However, I think
- 1:52it's very pertinent for applicants councils out
- 1:54there as well to know the ins and outs of apportionment.
- 1:57That way you know how to defend against apportionment
- 2:00and likewise defense attorneys. That way you
- 2:02know how to bolster your apportionment. I'm not
- 2:06going to get into all of the case law regarding
- 2:09apportionment but I will be covering a substantial
- 2:12amount of the statutory law and I'll be going
- 2:14over some panel of decisions, obviously these
- 2:16are not, they're persuasive law per se, but it
- 2:24gets into the nitty -gritty and the meats and
- 2:25potatoes about how the WCAB generally views apportionment
- 2:30and what is expected in terms of the burden of
- 2:33proof. Again, before I begin, let me first get
- 2:39into the disclaimer here. So real quick, the
- 2:44views expressed by myself and the information
- 2:46in the following presentation is intended for
- 2:48general information and educational purposes
- 2:50only. It is not intended to act or substitute
- 2:53as legal advice applicable to any particular
- 2:56factual situation, nor should the views and information
- 2:59be construed to reflect the opinion of any organization
- 3:03that I may be affiliated with, including the
- 3:05Beverly Hills Bar Association. You are advised
- 3:09not to adopt my views without conducting your
- 3:12own independent legal research as a skilled practitioner
- 3:14in the field of workers compensation law in the
- 3:17state of California. And here's my bio at your
- 3:21own discretion. You could go through that. All
- 3:24right, brief introduction. So I call this a death
- 3:28by thousand cuts in terms of what the defendant
- 3:31and the employer is faced when it comes to apportionment.
- 3:36Generally, in workers compensation claims, You
- 3:40might have multiple body parts, multiple conditions
- 3:45that are pled either by multiple specific injuries
- 3:48or a cumulative trauma involving multiple body
- 3:51parts. And when you actually look at each body
- 3:54part on its own where industrial causation is
- 3:56found, there may be arguably Some impairment
- 4:02for each body part that may be nominal some maybe
- 4:05modest and some maybe substantial the point here
- 4:08is that the more body parts there are the more
- 4:12Impairment that you get and the more that it's
- 4:14going to be combined under the combined values
- 4:16chart or added where it's warranted in which
- 4:21case the employer faces the travesty of death
- 4:25by a thousand cuts so it's very very important
- 4:27that regardless of what the level of the impairment
- 4:30is whether it's one percent two percent five
- 4:33percent fifty percent per body part as a defense
- 4:37attorney and employer you always want to look
- 4:40for a way to minimize your client's exposure
- 4:43here so apportionment is your next best bet where
- 4:47you cannot secure a finding of no industrial
- 4:50causation to that body part. Now, a brief hypothetical.
- 4:55This is a fact, a made up case. This is not a
- 4:59real case, but just to kind of stress the point.
- 5:03So apportionment in practice. In this case, the
- 5:06applicant is 57, a warehouse order selector,
- 5:10worked for the employer from June, 2019 through
- 5:13August of 2022. The applicant files a cumulative
- 5:17trauma injury for that period of time for injuries
- 5:21to the lumbar spine, the right shoulder, and
- 5:23the left knee. The QME in orthopedics finds all
- 5:27three body parts industrial with the applicant
- 5:30reaching MMI status as of January 2024. The QME
- 5:34gives an impairment rating for the lumbar spine
- 5:36at 45%, for the right shoulder at 30%, and the
- 5:41left knee at 20%. All of these are obviously
- 5:43after adjustment for age and occupation. Under
- 5:46the combined values chart, that adds up to 70%,
- 5:49which implicates a life pension. And now the
- 5:52applicant's vocational expert is preparing a
- 5:55rebuttal of the PDRS in order to get the applicant
- 5:58deemed to be 100 % permanently totally disabled.
- 6:01So right off the bat, the employer is in a lot
- 6:04of trouble. Now, backstory here, the applicant
- 6:08had a prior 2016 case with a different employer
- 6:11where she sustained an admitted specific low
- 6:13back injury. and that case settled by stipulations
- 6:18with requests for award in 2017 with an award
- 6:21of 18 percent permanent disability to the lumbar
- 6:24spine. She returned to full duty in 2018 and
- 6:28then worked without restrictions until 2021 when
- 6:31she was working for the current employer of the
- 6:34case that we're currently talking about. Now
- 6:36the QME in the 2022 cumulative trauma claim gave
- 6:40an opinion that as to all three body parts, apportionment
- 6:43is not appropriate because the applicant's work
- 6:45activities were the cause of her current condition.
- 6:49No percentage of apportionment, no discussion
- 6:51of the 2017 award was given, and also there were
- 6:57significant records that the defense attorney
- 7:00or the employer in the 2022 CT claim failed to
- 7:04provide to the QME. Now. On the defense's motion
- 7:10to get a supplemental report and conduct a cross
- 7:13-examination of the QME, they provide the QME
- 7:17with the prior award, 2016 and 2019 lumbar spine
- 7:22MRI, a 2009 radiographic x -ray image of the
- 7:27right shoulder, and a 2004 operative report.
- 7:31of the left knee, which causes the CUME to revise
- 7:34its causation analysis. And that results in the
- 7:37lumbar spine. 20 % of the disability being caused
- 7:41by multi -level degenerative disc disease and
- 7:44facet arthropathy documented on the 2016 MRI.
- 7:48And it shows that it's progressive on the 2019
- 7:51study, independent of work and of note. That
- 7:54is all prior to the employment with the current
- 7:56employer. As to the right shoulder, it's now
- 7:5940 % caused by pre -existing radiographically
- 8:02documented type 3 acromion and rotator cuff tendinosis
- 8:06before 2009. That's being present and unrelated
- 8:11to the current employment. And then finally,
- 8:14the left knee is now reduced to 50 % caused by
- 8:16the 2004 non -industrial ACL reconstruction with
- 8:22residual chondral effects. which the CUNY Appinds
- 8:26would have produced the same disability by this
- 8:28stage in life, regardless of employment. And
- 8:31then finally, the defendant is able to prove
- 8:33demonstrate the 2017 stipulated award and that
- 8:37there's an overlap pursuant to labor code section
- 8:404664 subsection B. I'll get into that a little
- 8:44later in the presentation. After all that, the
- 8:47apportionment now reduce, with apportionment
- 8:49applied, the PD under the CBC drops to 35%. So
- 8:53you can see how that becomes very significant
- 8:57for the employer in terms of mitigating their
- 9:02damages. And then likewise, you can see how damaging
- 9:05it is to the applicant's recovery in this case,
- 9:08which is why I'm, or at least which is what I'm
- 9:13trying to focus this presentation on today. Now,
- 9:17In addressing the issue of apportionment, it's
- 9:19very important that we distinguish causation
- 9:22of injury and causation of disability. Based
- 9:27on my research, a lot of times a QME report is
- 9:31deemed not to constitute substantial medical
- 9:33evidence because either the apportionment analysis
- 9:37or rationale just is very, very conclusory, which
- 9:42happens more often than not, or there's a mix
- 9:46-up between causation of injury versus causation
- 9:48of disability. For the new practitioners out
- 9:52there, causation of injury is basically what
- 9:55caused the injury. It's essentially, did the
- 9:59injury arise out of and occur during the course
- 10:03and scope of the employment? What's causing the
- 10:07injury? That's what we're looking at. Causation
- 10:09of disability focuses on the actual permanent
- 10:12disability coming from an injury. So, it deals
- 10:16with determining an accurate rating for permanent
- 10:18disability and parceling out the causative sources.
- 10:22Now, the guides, the AMA guides, if you go to
- 10:25the AMA guides at page 3, table 1 -1, it defines
- 10:31disability as a change in a person's ability
- 10:33to meet personal, social, or occupational demands
- 10:37or statutory regulatory requirements. It goes
- 10:40further and describes it as a gap between what
- 10:43the person can and can't do or what they want
- 10:46to do. So in other words, you can have impairment
- 10:50but no disability. Likewise, you can have impairment
- 10:54and there be disability. One way to look at it
- 10:57is let's assume that you have an injured worker
- 11:02who was blind in the left eye unrelated to industrial
- 11:09causes. And then because of the employment, they
- 11:11now become blind in the other eye due to a workplace
- 11:14injury. When you think about it, prior to the
- 11:17work -related injury, there was disability to
- 11:20the prior eye. However, the injured worker was
- 11:23still able to do certain things with that injury.
- 11:27So while there's disability related to non -industrial
- 11:31causes, they were still able to conduct certain
- 11:33things. For instance, the injured worker could
- 11:35still drive, they could still work, they could
- 11:37still perform certain activities of daily living,
- 11:40they could move around, they could engage in
- 11:42social engagements. Well, now after the injury
- 11:46they're now 100 % blind so arguably the rating
- 11:51there would be 100 % permanently totally disabled
- 11:54however apportionment would still apply the job
- 11:57for the QME or the AME is to now parcel out what
- 12:00the actual disability was prior to the eye injury
- 12:05so for an example would be Prior to the work
- 12:10-related eye injury, the applicant could still
- 12:11drive. They still had peripheral vision. They
- 12:15were still able to do certain things. However,
- 12:16now they no longer have peripheral vision. So
- 12:20these are the types of things that you want the
- 12:22CUME and the AME to be paying attention to. So
- 12:26don't mix up these two concepts, causation of
- 12:28injury versus causation of disability. And make
- 12:30sure your medical legal provider or even the
- 12:32PTP does not mix those two concepts up. Again,
- 12:37You can have an industrial injury with no residual
- 12:40disability. That could happen. Conversely, you
- 12:43can have an industrial injury with residual disability.
- 12:46All right. And here's a quick chart that helps
- 12:49you understand causation of injury versus causation
- 12:52of disability. I like to call this stick figure
- 12:54guy here Joe. So as you can see here, a box falls
- 12:56on Joe, causes an injury to his arm. Joe slips
- 13:00in a puddle, causes an injury to let's say his
- 13:03knee. And then versus what actual disabilities
- 13:07may have been caused by work or caused by non
- 13:10-industrial causes. All right now the statutory
- 13:13framework and this is this is where you really
- 13:16want to focus on if you haven't really read labor
- 13:18code section 4663 and 4664 I implore you to do
- 13:24so and become very familiar with it. Labor code
- 13:27section 4663 is basically apportionment of permanent
- 13:32disability looking at causation of the disability.
- 13:38So subsection A provides apportionment of permanent
- 13:40disability shall be based on causation. All right.
- 13:44And then subsection B just basically says what
- 13:47the physician is supposed to do in terms of apportionment,
- 13:50they have to address apportionment. Now C is
- 13:53where you really want to dive into it. In order
- 13:55for a physician's report to be considered, complete
- 13:58on the issue of permanent disability, the report
- 14:01must include an apportionment determination.
- 14:04So that means it has to either say there is apportionment
- 14:07or there is no apportionment. Furthermore, a
- 14:10physician shall shall make an apportionment determination
- 14:13by finding what approximate percentage of permanent
- 14:16disability was caused by the direct result of
- 14:20in sorry by the direct result of injury arising
- 14:24out of and occurring in the course of employment
- 14:26and what approximate percentage of the permanent
- 14:29disability was caused by other factors both before
- 14:32and subsequent to the industrial injury including
- 14:35prior industrial injuries. If we jump down to
- 14:40subsection E here however, section 4663 does
- 14:45not apply to certain safety presumptions articulated
- 14:50and enumerated under Labor Code Section 3212
- 14:53through 3213 .2. So you don't get 4663 apportionment
- 14:59to causation of disability to those presumptive
- 15:02injuries for safety officers. And once again,
- 15:07here's another chart with Joe explaining what
- 15:094663 is for your entertainment purposes. Alright,
- 15:14the next one is 4664. This is a presumptive award.
- 15:19The employer shall only be liable for the percentage
- 15:21of permanent disability directly caused by the
- 15:24injury arising out of it in the course of employment.
- 15:27Now, the idea here is that if there's a prior
- 15:30award, it's presumed that the disability associated
- 15:34to that prior award is there for life. It doesn't
- 15:37go away. So if you have, if there's a prior award,
- 15:41whether it's a finding an award, a stipulation
- 15:43with request for award, that's approved by the
- 15:45WCAB, or a case that settles by compromise and
- 15:49release where it's approved, there's an order
- 15:51approving compromise and release, the disability
- 15:54associated to each body part is presumed to be
- 15:56there for life. So you get 4664 presumptive apportionment
- 16:02there. However, there are certain things that
- 16:04you have to do in order to make sure you get
- 16:08that 4664 presumptive award. It's not automatic.
- 16:12You have to prove that the prior award exists.
- 16:16In other words, there was a stipulation with
- 16:18the Quest for Award that was approved by the
- 16:20WCAB. And then you have to show an overlap of
- 16:23the actual disability. And again, I will get
- 16:26into that a little later into the presentation
- 16:28here. And once again, we have another chart here
- 16:32describing 4664. Again, burden of proof is on
- 16:38the defendant. Apportionment is a defendant issue.
- 16:41Because the employer is the party who benefits
- 16:43from finding of apportionment, the employer must
- 16:45bear the burden of demonstrating that apportionment
- 16:47is appropriate. If you have the applicant giving
- 16:51the applicant the burden of proof on apportionment
- 16:53is essentially asking the applicant to prove
- 16:55a negative. The closest thing that I would say
- 16:59that the applicant has in terms of their obligation
- 17:02in my opinion on the issue of apportionment would
- 17:04be back here if you look at 40 section 4663 subsection
- 17:10d an employee who claims an industrial injury
- 17:13shall upon request disclose all previous permanent
- 17:17disabilities or physical impairments now to me
- 17:20what that means is that the the defendant has
- 17:23to ask the employee or the applicant of any prior
- 17:28injuries, disabilities, whatnot. And that typically
- 17:30is gonna come up in your depositions. So you
- 17:32wanna make sure that in your depositions, you're
- 17:34bringing those issues up. Sidebar here too, if
- 17:38you look at the application for adjudication
- 17:40of claim towards the end of the application,
- 17:42there's actually a section where it asks about
- 17:45prior injuries or prior disabilities. So that's
- 17:49about as far as it goes for the applicant. Now,
- 17:53it's not a burden where If they don't disclose
- 17:58it, there's a penalty to them per se. But it's
- 18:02something worth keeping in mind for the defendant
- 18:05that you really have to delve into those issues
- 18:07in your deposition and you have to understand
- 18:09again that the burden of proof on apportionment
- 18:12is on you. So get buff doing it. All right. What
- 18:18is the burden of proof? Substantial medical evidence.
- 18:20We're looking at the Escobedo case and all the
- 18:22cases that came after Escobedo or that articulate
- 18:25what the board is actually looking for. Now pursuant
- 18:28to Escobedo for a report to constitute substantial
- 18:31medical evidence, the physician's opinion and
- 18:35conclusions must be predicated and framed in
- 18:39terms of reasonable medical probability. Make
- 18:42sure that the doctor is not saying something
- 18:46like, without any burden of doubt or reasonable
- 18:57doubt, the injury occurred. If they say anything
- 19:00other than it is more likely or not that the
- 19:03injury happened or within reasonable medical
- 19:06probability, you need to challenge the doctor's
- 19:08finding or at least get the doctor to rehabilitate
- 19:12that phrasing. It's very, very important. I've
- 19:15actually had CUME reports thrown out because
- 19:19the CUME did not phrase their findings or conclusions
- 19:23however logical that they may have been within
- 19:27reasonable medical probability. That's your first
- 19:29prong. The next thing that the doctor has to
- 19:32do is that the report must set forth clinical
- 19:35or scientific reasoning behind the physician's
- 19:37opinions and conclusions rather than merely stating
- 19:40a bare conclusion. So it's got to be well explained.
- 19:44It can't just be conclusory. It can't just be
- 19:46it's because that's why. It has to give a good
- 19:51explanation of why the doctor finds as they find.
- 19:55So it has to be a reasoned conclusion. Then next,
- 20:00the medical opinion must be based on pertinent
- 20:03facts, germane medical information and adequate
- 20:05medical history and physical examination of the
- 20:08patient. In that scenario, you want to make sure
- 20:14that the doctor's examination and their recitation
- 20:17of the facts that they get at the time of the
- 20:19examination is somewhat on par with the facts
- 20:22that come up in the deposition or the facts that
- 20:24come up in the application for adjudication of
- 20:26claim or any other thing that's relevant or pertinent
- 20:29like witness interviews and whatnot. You want
- 20:33to make sure that if they're referencing medical
- 20:35literature, that it's relevant and germane to
- 20:38the actual issue. literature that hasn't been
- 20:43debunked. So you want to look at those things
- 20:46as well. To summarize all of that, in other words,
- 20:49the report must be based on adequate medical
- 20:51history, examination, and facts. The opinion
- 20:53must not be speculative and must set forth reasoning
- 20:57behind the conclusions. And the opinion must
- 21:00be stated within reasonable medical probability.
- 21:03In terms of speculative, watch out for that as
- 21:06well. Speculative in terms of, you might have
- 21:10a CUME say, give a diagnosis for a body part,
- 21:15say a knee, and they say there's a meniscal tear,
- 21:19but they haven't looked at any medical reports,
- 21:22any objective findings, whether it's an MRI,
- 21:24CT scan, or an x -ray that actually shows or
- 21:26talks about a meniscal tear. I'd argue that that's
- 21:31speculative. You want to make sure that the doctor
- 21:33is seeing records that show that, or they have
- 21:35a reasonable reason to know that there's an actual
- 21:40meniscal tear or pathology beyond the actual
- 21:43physical examination. A lot of times the physical
- 21:45examination is enough, but personally, I like
- 21:48to see more than just the physical examination.
- 21:51Oh, and here's Jill again, talking about the
- 21:53Escobedo Substantial Medical Evidence Standard.
- 21:57Now, when it comes to the issue of apportionment,
- 22:02the Escobedo standard applies to all issues in
- 22:05a case, generally speaking. However, when it
- 22:08comes to the issue of apportionment, they have
- 22:13to also explicitly disclose their familiarity
- 22:16with the legal concepts of apportionment. They
- 22:20have to describe in detail the exact nature of
- 22:24the apportionable disability. They have to explain
- 22:27the how and why similar to what we just talked
- 22:29about in a well -reasoned reporting. A disability
- 22:32is causally related to industrial injury versus
- 22:36non -industrial factors, all right? Now, how
- 22:39did that standard play out in the actual Escobedo
- 22:42case? Now in Escobedo, quick case brief here,
- 22:45the applicant alleged an injury to the left knee
- 22:47and then the right knee as a compensable consequence
- 22:50of the left knee injury. The applicant had...
- 22:52pre -existing or underlying arthritis dating
- 22:55back 10 years to the left knee injury. However,
- 22:59prior to the left knee injury, she experienced
- 23:01no symptoms with either knee. The CUME in that
- 23:04case apportioned 50 % of the disability to pre
- 23:10-existing arthritis and the WCAB allowed this
- 23:13because of the trivial nature of the left knee
- 23:16injury. The almost immediate onset of the right
- 23:19knee symptoms post left knee injury and the obvious
- 23:22significant degenerative arthritis in both knees
- 23:24reflected in diagnostic studies secured prior
- 23:27to and post surgery. And I'm going to highlight
- 23:30here the diagnostic studies. Again, this is why.
- 23:34I like to see more than just the physical examination.
- 23:37I want to know that the doctor is looking at
- 23:38actual reports. They're looking at diagnostic
- 23:41imaging. They have objective findings beyond
- 23:44just the physical examination and the applicant's
- 23:47subjective complaints. Obviously, this is a very
- 23:50rudimentary case brief of the Escobedo decision,
- 23:53but I'm hoping you get the idea, especially when
- 23:57we highlight the other issues and the other cases
- 24:00that I'm about to discuss now. A couple reasons
- 24:02why an apportionment opinion might fail. First
- 24:07issue here, apportionment to causation of injury
- 24:09instead of disability. And this is the first
- 24:11thing that I talked about, distinguishing causation
- 24:14of injury versus causation of disability. Now
- 24:184663, again, provides for apportionment to disability
- 24:22and not causation to injury. We'll look at the
- 24:26Ruben Vega versus Heaviland. case. Again, this
- 24:29is a panel decision. Don't go citing this in
- 24:32your arguments in court. It's persuasive, but
- 24:35nobody has to necessarily follow it. Now, with
- 24:39this one, you have a specific admitted injury
- 24:41in 2017 involving the neck and the low back.
- 24:44While working as a landscape laborer, there was
- 24:46also an injury in the form of headaches. The
- 24:49orthopedic amy initially assigned a 5 % WPI to
- 24:52the cervical spine and the lumbar spine respectively,
- 24:55so the applicant is in a DRE category two. pursues
- 24:59the AME guides. As to the issue of apportionment,
- 25:02and I believe that AME did a good job here, AME
- 25:05says, with respect to the cervical spine, I note
- 25:08essentially unchanged appearance, at least by
- 25:11review of radiographic reports from a CT scan
- 25:13in 2007. to an MRI in 2017. This would indicate
- 25:18long -standing underlying degenerative changes
- 25:21of the cervical spine without additional evidence
- 25:23of acute trauma on recent MRI. Such underlying
- 25:27degenerative changes certainly could represent
- 25:29ongoing neck pain, stiffness, and radiating symptoms
- 25:32to the upper extremities. In my opinion, 70 %
- 25:38of the examinee's current impairment and disability
- 25:41with respect to the cervical spine is apportioned
- 25:43to pre -existing or underlying degenerative changes,
- 25:46and 30 % to the industrial injury. The doctor
- 25:49essentially says the same thing regarding the
- 25:52lumbar spine. However, we have a plot twist.
- 25:54The applicant goes and has cervical -spine fusion.
- 25:59Then the applicant is revaluated by the AME,
- 26:01and then the AME places the applicant in a DRE
- 26:03category. I believe this is DRE category four.
- 26:06with a 25 whole person impairment. However, the
- 26:10AME maintains his prior opinion as to apportionment,
- 26:13which, surprise surprise, the board rejects it.
- 26:16And citing Escobedo, the board says, Section
- 26:204663, subsection C, not only prescribes what
- 26:24determinations a reporting physician must make
- 26:27with respect to apportionment, it also prescribes
- 26:30what standards the WCAV must use in deciding
- 26:32apportionment. That is, Both the reporting physician
- 26:36and the WCAB must make determinations of what
- 26:39percentage of the permanent disability was directly
- 26:41caused by the industrial injury and what percentage
- 26:44was caused by other factors. All right, this
- 26:48is very important. Now, moving forward, the WCAB
- 26:53then opined that the orthopedic AME's apportionment
- 26:55scheme did not constitute substantial medical
- 26:57evidence because the AME did not adequately address
- 27:03the causation of applicant's disability. I believe
- 27:06he did that the first time, however post -surgery
- 27:10he did not. Causation of disability requires
- 27:13an analysis based upon critical thinking. The
- 27:16orthopedic amy's explanation of apportionment
- 27:18is not based upon facts of the applicant's case.
- 27:22Now here the WCAV noted that the applicant's
- 27:24disability was cervical fusion, which warranted
- 27:27a DRE category four, which is different than
- 27:29a DRE category two placement prior to the surgery.
- 27:33The WCAV further noted that the doctor's own
- 27:35report does not justify his finding of apportionment
- 27:38when the applicant's range of motions measurements
- 27:40are taken into consideration. post surgery, the
- 27:43range of motion measurements were worse than
- 27:45the pre -surgery measurements. So even if you
- 27:48consider whether the spine should be rated under
- 27:54the DRE methodology versus the range of motion
- 27:57methodology, in my opinion, the range of motion
- 28:01methodology would likely apply here and it's
- 28:04worse. So that means that the rating would probably
- 28:07be higher than a 25%. WPI. So essentially what
- 28:14the board is saying here is that we get it, there's
- 28:18pre -existing issues, but the applicant had surgery,
- 28:22the applicant had medical treatment, which we'll
- 28:24get into the Heikida case a little later, and
- 28:27that increased the disability further, limiting
- 28:31range of motion among many other factors. For
- 28:34that reason, the board rejected the apportionment
- 28:38opinion here. Next one is you have a conclusory
- 28:42finding with insufficient reasoning. And again,
- 28:45this is one of the most common ones that I see
- 28:48come across my desk. So here you have the Lewis
- 28:51Pantoja case. Again, panel decision. 2018 date
- 28:57of injury, finding an award for multiple body
- 28:59parts with 66 % PD after apportionment. The AME
- 29:04apportioned 15 % of the bilateral shoulder disability
- 29:07to nicotine abuse. 25 % of the lumbar spine and
- 29:12left lower limb disability to an anatomic peculiarity,
- 29:16making the applicant vulnerable to foraminal
- 29:18stenosis, and 80 % to the 2018 date of injury.
- 29:24Now, let's pay attention to the math here for
- 29:28the lumbar spine, 80 % to the actual industrial
- 29:32injury and 25 % to an anatomic peculiarity. Then
- 29:38the AME also apportioned 10 % of the neck disability
- 29:42to non -industrial causes, i .e., the nicotine
- 29:44use and degenerative changes. The WCAB reversed
- 29:48the apportionment, in other words, rejected it
- 29:51and awarded 72 % permanent disability, which
- 29:54is going to implicate the life pension, opining
- 29:57that the mere fact that a report addresses the
- 29:59issue of causation of permanent disability and
- 30:02makes an apportionment determination by finding
- 30:04the approximate relative percentages of an industrial
- 30:07injury and non -industrial causation does not
- 30:10necessarily render the report one upon which
- 30:13the WCAV may rely. If a physician opines that
- 30:16a percentage of disability is caused by degenerative
- 30:19disease, the physician must explain the nature
- 30:22of the disease and how and why it is causing
- 30:24disability at the time of the evaluation. With
- 30:29regard to this issue, the board observed that
- 30:32after the 2018 date of injury, applicant underwent
- 30:34surgical intervention for the shoulders and neck.
- 30:37However, the AME used boilerplate apportionment
- 30:39language spread across multiple reports. This
- 30:43is quite typical for some doctors out there where
- 30:47they'll issue an MMI report and then they'll
- 30:51provide their apportionment findings. and then
- 30:54stuff happens afterwards. There's new medical
- 30:56records that are given to the doctor. Here there's
- 30:59surgery that happened. There's additional medical
- 31:01treatment and the apportionment doesn't change
- 31:02and the doctor just does a cut and paste. If
- 31:04you're the defense attorney and you're seeing
- 31:06that report in, you might want to develop the
- 31:08record and make sure that the cut and paste isn't
- 31:10just a cut and paste. They have to consider all
- 31:12the extra things that have happened. In other
- 31:15words, you want to look at the facts that are
- 31:17germane to the issue as they exist at the current
- 31:21time. Here the WCB rejected the nicotine abuse
- 31:25and the degenerative changes reference because
- 31:28no further reasoning or explanation was provided
- 31:30by the AME. In other words, it was conclusory.
- 31:34The WCB also rejected the anatomic peculiarity
- 31:38reference because it lacked reasoning to bridge
- 31:41the gap between the existence of the peculiarity
- 31:44and the current disability. In other words, why?
- 31:49Yes, he has this anatomic peculiarity, but why
- 31:54is it causing disability? Why and how is it causing
- 31:56disability now? And finally, the WCV was not
- 32:00too favorable about the 25 % plus 80 % math here.
- 32:04Generally speaking, permanent disability for
- 32:07any one body part cannot exceed 100%. So if you
- 32:10have a lumbar spine at, what, 105%, Lucy has
- 32:14a lot of explaining to do. All right, next one.
- 32:19Impairment and disability conflation. Greg O
- 32:25'Brien versus Covenant Living. This is also a
- 32:28panel decision. We have an F &A for injury to
- 32:32the left knee with no legal basis for apportionment.
- 32:34The defendant filed a petition for reconsideration.
- 32:38Now following the industrial injury, the applicant
- 32:40underwent left total knee replacement, then a
- 32:42subsequent revision total knee replacement procedure.
- 32:45So two surgeries. The PQME post -surgery diagnosed
- 32:48left knee arthritis and status post total knee
- 32:51replacement. And then the PQME said, arthritis
- 32:54of the knee is most often the result of many
- 32:56factors, including genetics, previous injury,
- 32:59and daily activity over many years. The industrial
- 33:02injury caused an aggravation of the preexisting,
- 33:04although asymptomatic at the time left knee arthritis.
- 33:08Makes sense to me. Sounds like it should be a
- 33:11winning argument. And then the PQME provided
- 33:1315 % WPI, whole person impairment, and apportioned
- 33:1750 % of the disability to the industrial injury
- 33:19and the remainder to the pre -existing arthritis.
- 33:23Now, the applicant here worked for this employer
- 33:26for nine and a half years. The PQME observed
- 33:30that there were no prior left knee complaints
- 33:32prior to the actual industrial injury. However,
- 33:35the objective medical evidence showed the presence
- 33:36of degenerative changes. So we have a bit of
- 33:39a conundrum here. You've got evidence of pathology
- 33:43of the arthritis. You have the PQME reasoning
- 33:47that arthritis takes time to develop. And then
- 33:50you have an injured worker here who worked for
- 33:52the employer for almost 10 years. So you would
- 33:57think that there should be apportionment and
- 33:59arguably so there should be apportionment in
- 34:01my opinion however the board rejected the apportionment
- 34:04opinion meaning 50 % to industrial and 50 % to
- 34:07non -industrial because the PQME did not address
- 34:11causation of disability instead the PQME apportion
- 34:14to impairment you can't apportion to impairment
- 34:17impairment is not subject to apportionment disability
- 34:20is now what the PQME is supposed to do is they're
- 34:23supposed to determine the extent of the impairment
- 34:25using the AMA guides then that impairment is
- 34:28adjusted for age and occupation. And then the
- 34:30PQME is supposed to talk about the disabilities
- 34:32and what kind of disability did the injured worker
- 34:36have as a result of the arthritis prior to the
- 34:39injury and arguably prior to the first surgery
- 34:42and the second surgery. That was missing here.
- 34:46As to the error here, The board opined that even
- 34:50assuming arguendo that the PQMe meant to apportion
- 34:52to causation of disability and not causation
- 34:54of impairment, causation of disability requires
- 34:57an appropriate analysis. Here the PQMe diagnosed
- 35:00applicant with left knee arthritis status post
- 35:02total knee arthroplasty. The cause of injury
- 35:06is repetitive kneeling, lifting, and twisting
- 35:09required of his job. and that was aggravated
- 35:15to the pre -existing, although asymptomatic at
- 35:17the time, left knee arthritis. The PQME assigned
- 35:20left knee impairment pursuant to the AME guides
- 35:22using table 17 -33, impairment estimate for certain
- 35:26lower extremity impairment, total knee replacement,
- 35:29good result of 37%, in consideration for pain,
- 35:33range of motion, and stability pursuant to table
- 35:3617 -35. So essentially the PQME is giving a whole
- 35:40person impairment considering the surgeries but
- 35:43then apportioning 50 % of that to the pre -existing
- 35:47arthritis. Here the applicant's disability is
- 35:50caused by impairment from total knee replacement
- 35:52with pain, range of motion, limitation and stability
- 35:55measured by maximum movement in any direction,
- 35:58not arthritis. The PQME failed to explain how
- 36:01and why applicants arthritis caused or contributed
- 36:04to his disability. Applicants pre -existing arthritis
- 36:07may have put applicant at an increased risk of
- 36:10sustaining injury or damages from injury, but
- 36:12apportionment is improper without arthritis being
- 36:15a signed causation of disability. Now, if I were
- 36:18the defense attorney here, arguably 50 % apportionment
- 36:22sounds great, but you're not going to get that.
- 36:24I would try to develop the record to make sure
- 36:26you get some apportionment, whether it's 5%,
- 36:2810 % because in the grand scheme of things, it
- 36:30still mitigates your client's exposure. Next
- 36:36issue, increased risk or vulnerability reason.
- 36:39We're looking at the same case here. It's pretty
- 36:41much the same rationale. The WCAB acknowledged
- 36:44that there was no asymptomatic pre -existing
- 36:47left knee arthritis as reported by the PQMe.
- 36:51They also agreed that the theory that the pre
- 36:55-existing condition was aggravated by the applicant's
- 36:57repetitive job duties. However, the ultimate
- 37:00conclusion was rejected because The PQMe's report
- 37:05did not constitute substantial medical evidence
- 37:07on the issue of apportionment considering the
- 37:09increased risk. WCAB said. Afghans pre -existing
- 37:14arthritis may have put African at an increased
- 37:16risk of sustaining injury or damages from injury,
- 37:19but apportionment is improper without arthritis
- 37:21being a sign causation of disability, and that's
- 37:23where the report fell short. In order for the
- 37:25PQME's reporting to have been substantial medical
- 37:27evidence for apportionment purposes, he would
- 37:29have to explain how and why the non -industrial
- 37:31arthritis caused African's current left knee
- 37:33permanent disability, and the PQME failed to
- 37:36do so. All right, next one, failure to show an
- 37:40overlap. under section 4664 subsection b of the
- 37:45prior award we're looking at jared sanders versus
- 37:48chp here we have a chp officer ct injury ending
- 37:54in 2023 there's an effinate for 34 pd for the
- 37:59lumbar spine after after apportionment to the
- 38:02prior award now keep in mind the lumbar spine
- 38:06That involves the duty belt presumption. That's
- 38:08one of those presumptive injuries that you don't
- 38:11get section 4663 apportionment on. It's barred
- 38:15pursuant to subsection E. However, you can get
- 38:184664 subsection B presumptive apportionment provided
- 38:24that you meet the requirements for it. Here,
- 38:30the applicant challenged the apportionment citing
- 38:32the anti -antribution clause, that's per the
- 38:34duty bail presumption, on the grounds that the
- 38:36defendant failed to prove an overlap of the prior
- 38:39award. At trial, there was a stipulation that
- 38:41the applicant received a prior award of 90 %
- 38:44for the loan of our spine, so you have a stipulation
- 38:46to that. The PQME in the current CT claim placed
- 38:50the applicant in DRE 5 with a 28 % whole person
- 38:54impairment. QME in the prior claim, with the
- 38:57prior award, rated 22 % pull person impairment
- 39:01based on the range of motion analysis in 2018.
- 39:05The applicant underwent lumbar spine fusion in
- 39:072017. PQMe and the current claim did not comment
- 39:10on the overlap issue as between the current and
- 39:14the prior claim involving the lumbar spine. The
- 39:17WCAB rejected the apportionment finding under
- 39:214664 subsection B, not because of the anti -antibution
- 39:25clause, but because Again, the burden of proof
- 39:28is on the defendant to present specific evidence
- 39:31of the prior award and provide evidence of overlap.
- 39:35for which apportionment may be warranted under
- 39:37section 4664, subsection B. WCAV goes on to say,
- 39:41here, the party stipulated that the applicant
- 39:42had a prior award of 19 % permanent disability,
- 39:45but it is unclear how the prior disability was
- 39:48calculated as the award is not in evidence. So
- 39:51requirement number one, not met. You've got to
- 39:53make sure that the award is seen by the CUME.
- 39:56And if you go to trial, it is seen by the trier
- 39:59of fact. And then also, the current... Current
- 40:04record does not establish how the prior award
- 40:06was calculated. And without such evidence, defendant
- 40:08did not meet its burden of proving that there
- 40:11was an overlap. This is relevant because if you
- 40:15go back here, the QME in the current claim used
- 40:19the DRE methodology. And then in the prior claim,
- 40:22it's the range of motion analysis. And this is
- 40:25critical here because again, these are different
- 40:27methods of rating the lumbar spine. So in order
- 40:30to prove the overlap. Think of the overlap as
- 40:33being if you're talking about the spine and you
- 40:37want to show an overlap of the lumbar spine.
- 40:40One of the things that you want to look at is
- 40:42are we talking about the same spinal region?
- 40:45Is it L5 -S1? Is it the same place or is it different?
- 40:49And when you're looking at the range of motion
- 40:51it might include multiple regions of the spine
- 40:54versus when you use the DRE where it might just
- 40:57be one. Obviously you could use the DRE and there'd
- 41:00be multiple you know regions of the spine but
- 41:03the point here is that on recon the board has
- 41:08nothing to go off of they don't know what the
- 41:10prior award was based off of so it the prior
- 41:13award is not shown and you can't show the overlap
- 41:16either so the apportionment fails here all right
- 41:20now next case is sort of similar however it's
- 41:26a 4663 subsection E anti -antribution clause
- 41:32negation where the apportionment is upheld. Now
- 41:36here you have the arbitrator finding an award
- 41:40for presumptive lumbar spine injury at 13 % PDE
- 41:43after apportionment for a prior award under section
- 41:474664 subsection b applicant challenged the apportionment
- 41:50finding citing the anti -antibution clause of
- 41:54section 4663 subsection e however the wcb upheld
- 41:58the fna of the arbitrator because they opined
- 42:02that the arbitrator did not find apportionment
- 42:04based on causation of disability in other words
- 42:07the arbitrator didn't use section 4663 Both of
- 42:10the applicant's disabilities were rated using
- 42:12the exact same method containing the AME guides,
- 42:15which was the range of motion. That wasn't done
- 42:17in the prior case that we just discussed. Both
- 42:20AMEs in both cases found that applicant's impairment
- 42:22was 100 % industrial in accordance with Section
- 42:254663, Subsection E, impermissible apportionment
- 42:30based upon Causation of disability under section
- 42:334663 would occur, for example, if the evaluator
- 42:36opined that the entirety of the applicant's present
- 42:39disability was caused as a progression of the
- 42:44prior injury, and thus the applicant's present
- 42:47industrial disability is nothing. That would
- 42:49be apportionment to causation of disability under
- 42:504663, but that didn't happen here. So this case
- 42:55kind of, you know, enunciates that you can get
- 42:58apportionment for presumptive injuries using
- 43:04section 46, 64 subsection B. However, you want
- 43:08to make sure that you're meeting the requirements
- 43:09here. Now, next one is vocational apportionment.
- 43:13I'm not going to spend too much time on this
- 43:15one because the issue of the NUNES decisions
- 43:20and vocational rehab reports can should get its
- 43:23own entire webinar series. However, here you
- 43:29have a case where there's an F &A for multiple
- 43:32body parts, upper extremity, psych, GERD, 65
- 43:35% PD apportionment. The judge applying that the
- 43:41applicant did not meet his burden of rebutting
- 43:43the AEMI guides and the PDR. It's essentially
- 43:46the applicant which tried to get a voc rehab
- 43:48report that said he's 100 % permanently totally
- 43:51disabled. Both the employer and the applicant
- 43:55brought in their vocational experts. The key
- 43:58takeaway with apportionment and vocational experts,
- 44:02as most of you may already know, is that there
- 44:04is no such thing as vocational apportionment.
- 44:07A vocational expert has to pay attention to what
- 44:10the medical apportionment is pursuant to the
- 44:13medical legal providers, whether it's the PTP,
- 44:15the AME, or the PQME. They have to pay attention
- 44:20to that. Now here, and I know I'm jumping ahead
- 44:25here, here Again in red vocational apportionment
- 44:30is not allowed the board rejected both from the
- 44:34employer and the applicant because the applicant's
- 44:37expert rejected all medical apportionment and
- 44:40found non -industrial vocational apportionment.
- 44:43That's a no -no. That's going to be thrown out.
- 44:45And then they rejected the defendant's expert
- 44:47because that expert provided extensive legal
- 44:50discussions and legal conclusions that are outside
- 44:52of the vocational expert's expertise. And then
- 44:55the defense expert also reported that applicant
- 44:58had no additional rateable vocational disability
- 45:01and then disregarded medical impairments. observed
- 45:04by the CUMEs, and then also said that the applicant
- 45:08was insufficiently motivated to return to work,
- 45:11which glossed over the fact that the applicant
- 45:13actually was interested in becoming a teacher.
- 45:15So both of those reports were tossed out. This
- 45:19is a quick one, sequencing apportionment premature.
- 45:22So this is a case where you have, and I don't
- 45:26understand how this even went to trial, but anyway,
- 45:30the applicant, there's an FNA, For industrial
- 45:34injury for for irritable bowel syndrome, but
- 45:36no compensable psych injury. There's no PD. The
- 45:39applicant was an MMI yet there. So there was
- 45:41no that the PD had not been addressed. However,
- 45:43there was the Q me. Gave an opinion on apportionments,
- 45:48so it's it's. They put the. They put the cart
- 45:52before the horse, essentially. The Afghans challenged
- 45:55the F &A on the issue of apportionment and the
- 45:57WCB granted the petition and amended the decision
- 46:01to defer the issue of apportionment because apportionment
- 46:03findings were premature without having first
- 46:05determined the issue of PD. Remember, Labor Code
- 46:08Section 4663, Section C says that you have to
- 46:14determine what the PD is first and then get to
- 46:16the apportionment issue. All right. Other issues
- 46:21with apportionment, so where you have multiple
- 46:23dates of injury, the wonderful Benson decision,
- 46:26when you have two or more distinct industrial
- 46:28injuries that combine to cause permanent disability,
- 46:31the physician is supposed to portion as between
- 46:35each date of injury. So you might have multiple
- 46:36specific injuries or multiple CTs or a combination
- 46:40of both. The between injury apportionment itself
- 46:45needs an analysis. That's within reasonable medical
- 46:48probability. You have to the doctor has to explain
- 46:51it. They can't just say it's because that's why
- 46:54so Escobedo applies here as well. Now, it is
- 46:58possible that a single combined award will be
- 47:02issued, but only where the evaluator genuinely
- 47:05cannot parcel out the relative. contributions
- 47:08and that inability is explained. You might see
- 47:12that phrase in terms of the injuries are inextricably
- 47:17intertwined. For example, you might have, let's
- 47:19say you have three specific injuries. Each specific
- 47:23injury has different, you know, orthopedic body
- 47:27parts. The applicant's been taking non -steroidal
- 47:29anti -inflammatory medication. And then there's
- 47:31also a claim of irritable bowel syndrome, GERD,
- 47:34some gastrointestinal issues because of the use
- 47:37of those NSAID medications. And the internal
- 47:41QME then opines and says, well, I can't parse
- 47:44a lot because the internal injury claim, because
- 47:49he's been using them across all of the the medication
- 47:53across all dates of injuries is why he was using
- 47:55the medications. In other words, I can't parcel
- 47:58them out. In that case, then you might get one
- 48:01combined award for the internal injury claims.
- 48:06All right. Then going into apportionment to heredity
- 48:09and genetics, City of Jackson, in this case,
- 48:12the applicant was diagnosed with cervical degenerative
- 48:14disc disease. The PQME found three studies demonstrating
- 48:18heredity and genetics cost 75 % of the disc degeneration.
- 48:23PQME apportioned 49 % of the disability to genetics.
- 48:28The board initially rejected it, saying doing
- 48:30so allows impermissible apportionment. impermissible
- 48:35immutable factors. However, the appeals courts
- 48:38rejected that, explaining that SB 899 in section
- 48:424663 specifically required apportionment to causation
- 48:45of disability, which includes the natural progression
- 48:47of non -industrial conditions, pre -existing
- 48:50disability, post -injury disabling events, asymptomatic
- 48:54prior conditions, and retroactive prophylactic
- 48:56work restrictions. The appellate court also concluded
- 49:00that Pekumi's opinion constitutes substantial
- 49:03medical evidence because he explained all this
- 49:06stuff and it was phrased within reasonable medical
- 49:10probability. Point here being is that you can
- 49:12apportion to heredity and genetics, but again,
- 49:15you've got to have a very, very solid explanation
- 49:18from your medical legal provider. Apportionment
- 49:21to asymptomatic conditions, same situation here.
- 49:24A police officer suffered several blows to the
- 49:27head during a canine training exercise in this
- 49:29is the city of Petroluma taste the Linde decision.
- 49:33After the training he's experienced severe headaches
- 49:36for several days. A month later he lost vision
- 49:38in his left eye. The PQE opined that, but for
- 49:42the work -related injury, applicant would have
- 49:44retained a lot of the vision in his left eye,
- 49:47noting that even without the blows to the head,
- 49:50he would have lost some vision in his left eye
- 49:52due to underlying vascular spasticity. The PQE
- 49:55then apportioned 85 % of the non -industrial
- 49:59disability to vascular spasticity and the remaining
- 50:0115 % to industrial causes. The board rejected
- 50:04it, and then the appellate court reversed it.
- 50:09finding that the PQME understand the distinction
- 50:11between the causes of injury and the causes of
- 50:13disability. Although the QME referred to the
- 50:16underlying condition as putting the applicant
- 50:18at a higher risk or suffering the disability,
- 50:20the court found that it did not change the fact
- 50:22that the applicant had an underlying condition
- 50:25that was along with the workplace injury, a cause
- 50:28of the impaired vision. The key point here again,
- 50:32the doctor has got to make sure that they really
- 50:34explain what the disability is. Sorry, what the
- 50:40non -industrial condition is and what the disability
- 50:42related to that non -industrial condition is.
- 50:47Here, it's the vascular spasticity. And essentially,
- 50:50what the doctor was saying is that with that
- 50:52vascular spasticity, even if he didn't have the
- 50:54blows to the head, he would have lost vision
- 50:56in his left eye. The blows to the head just accelerated
- 50:59that. All right, now we get to the hykita. So
- 51:02the hykita case basically you don't get apportionment
- 51:06where you have a high KEDA situation. Now, in
- 51:08this case, following an industrially related
- 51:10carpal tunnel surgery, the Afghan developed chronic
- 51:12regional pain syndrome. They amy apportion 90
- 51:15% of the disability to industrial factors and
- 51:17the remaining 10 % to non -industrial factors.
- 51:20The appellate court rejected the apportionment
- 51:21finding here, opining that injured workers are
- 51:25entitled to reasonable medical treatment required
- 51:27to cure or relieve from the effects of the industrial
- 51:29injury pursuant to labor code section 4600 without
- 51:33apportionment. So you can't apportion medical
- 51:35treatment, you can't apportion PD here because
- 51:39essentially the argument is that the medical
- 51:41treatment caused the disability. So in a high
- 51:45-key situation you don't get the apportionment.
- 51:48Now contrast that with the justice case where
- 51:51the applicant fell at work injured her left knee
- 51:54Then she developed right knee issues as a compensable
- 51:56consequences. She then underwent total bilateral
- 51:59knee replacement. The AME opined that the knee
- 52:02replacement was not necessary because the left
- 52:04knee injury resulted in a meniscal tear. However,
- 52:07but for the non -industrial pre -existing arthritic
- 52:13condition of the knees, the knee replacement
- 52:15would not have been necessary. Then apportioned
- 52:1850 % of the disabilities to industrial causes
- 52:20and the remainders of pre -existing arthritic
- 52:22condition. The board rejected this. However,
- 52:24the appellate court reversed, opining that the
- 52:28disability here was not caused entirely by medical
- 52:30treatment but the pre -existing condition. The
- 52:34takeaway here is that if the medical treatment
- 52:38100 % causes the disability, you don't get apportionment
- 52:41under IKEDA. However, if it doesn't cause it
- 52:45by 100%, you get apportionment. And you're going
- 52:48to get apportionment under causation to disability.
- 52:52And we discussed the NUNES issues. Something
- 52:57to consider, compensable consequence claims.
- 52:58This isn't exactly apportionment. This is Labor
- 53:02Code Section 4660. point one subsection c subsection
- 53:07one this is where the increase of pd is not allowed
- 53:11where sleep dysfunction sexual dysfunction or
- 53:14a psych disorder is a compensable consequence
- 53:16of a physical injury it's not exactly apportionment
- 53:19but what it does is that it will reduce um let's
- 53:23say you have a compensable psych claim or psych
- 53:27injury as a compensable consequence of a low
- 53:29back injury and the psych PD is, let's say 40%.
- 53:33Well, if that's psych... claim is 100 % predicated
- 53:37upon a compensable consequence of the physical
- 53:39injury. Well, guess what? Your client's not going
- 53:41to have to pay the increase in permanent disability
- 53:45unless that psych disability falls within one
- 53:49of the enumerated exceptions for psych claims.
- 53:52Not going to get into that now, but something
- 53:55worth considering in terms of apportionment.
- 53:57Again, this is not exactly apportionment. Now,
- 54:00I read an article a while back about whether
- 54:04or not the WCB is requiring higher standards
- 54:07in apportionment determinations and how apportionment
- 54:11is extremely difficult and a really heavy burden
- 54:14for the employer to carry. Personally, I don't
- 54:18think that the WCB is requiring higher standards.
- 54:21I think it should be phrased more in terms of
- 54:24the reporting of doctors and developing the records
- 54:26needs to be looked at very closely to make sure
- 54:29that your apportionment opinion has four legs
- 54:32to stand on. It's a solid table. Now, again,
- 54:36most cases where apportionment opinions failed
- 54:38or they're rejected are linked to deficiency
- 54:40in the reasoning for apportionment. So arguably,
- 54:44as defense counsel, you should be able to develop
- 54:47those issues. Emphasizing my point here, if we
- 54:52go back to the Pantolia case, one of the first
- 54:55cases that we discussed here, Commissioner Jose
- 54:58Arazo dissented in that case. And I think he
- 55:04gets the point. He drives the point. home. He
- 55:08basically says, The word approximate is used
- 55:11twice in section 4663 subsection c as the correct
- 55:14and unambiguous standard for use by medical evaluators.
- 55:18To address the perceived crisis in skyrocketing
- 55:21workers' compensation costs, apportionment by
- 55:23approximate percentage should not be a difficult
- 55:25burden for a defendant to establish. Further,
- 55:28it is clear that the plain language of the new
- 55:31statutory scheme requires apportionment to each
- 55:33cause of a permanent disability including each
- 55:35distinct industrial injury. As noted by my colleagues,
- 55:40the burden of proving apportionment of permanent
- 55:41disability falls on the employer because it is
- 55:43the employer that benefits from apportionment.
- 55:45Section 4663, however, requires no more than
- 55:49a doctor made a determination based on his medical
- 55:52expertise of the approximate percentage of permanent
- 55:54disability caused by a degenerative condition.
- 55:57Even where the percentages provided are approximations
- 56:01that are not precise and require some intuition
- 56:04and medical judgment, This does not mean the
- 56:07conclusions are speculative. So I joined Commissioner
- 56:12Razo with that dissent, or at least with regards
- 56:16to the rationale as far as whether or not the
- 56:19WCAB is requiring a higher apportionment reporting
- 56:23standards. It's really making sure that the doctors
- 56:26are, their reports are well -reasoned and within
- 56:31the Escobedo standards here. We're running out
- 56:34of time, and I want to make sure that we have
- 56:36some time here for the Q &A, if there are any
- 56:40Q &As here. But this portion of the slides here,
- 56:46please feel free to go back and review it, the
- 56:51hypothetical. I put in some explanations here
- 56:55in terms of the things that we just talked about
- 56:57and how they apply, how they would apply in this
- 57:03hypothetical here. But let me jump to the Q &A's.
- 57:09Okay, we have one question here. I don't think
- 57:134663D requires only that a defendant needs to
- 57:17ask. I think applicants have an obligation. Okay,
- 57:19so the question here, here, well, it's more of
- 57:21a statement. 4663 subsection D requires only
- 57:25that a defendant needs to ask. I think applicants
- 57:26have an obligation to disclose it. Yes, I agree
- 57:30with you. However, you have to take into consideration,
- 57:35and this is something that I've struggled with
- 57:38in practice for a while too. You have to take
- 57:41into consideration that some of these cases,
- 57:43you might have a case where the injured worker
- 57:46is trying to defraud the system, where they're
- 57:49actually... actively, intentionally trying to
- 57:52not disclose prior injuries or prior disabilities.
- 57:56I have a few cases like that, and they don't
- 57:59tell that to the applicant attorney. So the applicant
- 58:01attorney doesn't know. Likewise, you have cases
- 58:05where the injured worker just has a vague recollection
- 58:09of what the injuries are. They're not medical
- 58:11practitioners. They don't know what a disability
- 58:12is really. So what they tell you might not be
- 58:16factual. In that scenario, because the defendant
- 58:23has the burden of proof on apportionment, I take
- 58:26the position that it is my job and it's my duty
- 58:29to make sure that I ask those questions. I'm
- 58:31not going to rely on the applicant to disclose
- 58:33that information to me. I'm not going to rely
- 58:36on the applicant attorney to disclose that information
- 58:38to me. That's the defense attorney's job because
- 58:41if they don't and you don't ask, then your client
- 58:46pays the price for it. So that's that's kind
- 58:49of how I see it but nonetheless I do agree with
- 58:52you on that position. Okay I don't know I don't
- 59:01see any further questions please feel free to
- 59:04you know drop in any additional questions if
- 59:07you want but we are close to being out of time
- 59:10in the event and I like to do this quite often
- 59:15with these presentations that I give. If something
- 59:18comes up, you think of a question or you have
- 59:22an idea that you would like to spitball, I welcome
- 59:26questions after the fact or commentary after
- 59:29the fact. My contact information is here. Please
- 59:33feel free to reach out. Again, it has been a
- 59:36pleasure making this presentation here.