Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 151: On longevity in the Paris food business with Joshua Fontaine
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. What is it take in Paris today
- 0:14to run a successful restaurant or several of them in a city
- 0:19that's so full of them? Josh Fontaine, who's the Co
- 0:22founder of Candelaria Le Merri Celeste and the newly opened
- 0:25Adobe Renaissance, knows a little something about it.
- 0:28He joins me today to talk about what's changed in the restaurant
- 0:31business since COVID, the proliferation of concept driven
- 0:34restaurants, creating longevity and some of the details he's
- 0:37most proud of at his new restaurant.
- 0:41Josh, welcome back to the show. Thank you Do.
- 0:44You know how long it's been. I know exactly how long it's
- 0:47been, 643 days. For what?
- 0:52That's not accurate, is it? I don't think so.
- 0:54However, it was during COVID when we last recorded together
- 0:59and it was because we were stuck at home and we were talking
- 1:05about the impact of COVID and how you were adjusting your
- 1:10business. So now we are a good like few
- 1:12years out from that mess. How is business?
- 1:17Business is good. It's different than what it was
- 1:20during COVID because at that time I was I had more businesses
- 1:24and more employees and more things to deal with.
- 1:27This is true. You had Le Grand Ver still,
- 1:29right? Yeah, and hero.
- 1:32And I couldn't remember when it. Closed.
- 1:35I was about kind of about the same time.
- 1:39And glass. Glass was right before.
- 1:41OK, so Glass didn't get affected by COVID.
- 1:45But yes, getting through COVID and getting through those
- 1:49problems associated with those places and COVID and all the
- 1:54rest was very time consuming and difficult.
- 1:58But now we're out the other side and you know, obviously I think
- 2:02a lot of people saw post COVID explosion kind of thing, which
- 2:07was. In business you.
- 2:08Mean in business, yeah, which was good.
- 2:09And now what we're seeing as obviously, I'm sure you know, a
- 2:14lot of places not being able to sustain the repayment of their
- 2:19COVID loans. I've heard.
- 2:22Unlike the US work which were forgiven everywhere and it was
- 2:25just free money in France. It was forgiven everywhere I.
- 2:29Think so. I mean, someone's going to Fact
- 2:31Check that. As in someone who's listening?
- 2:33Probably Fact. At least in New York, they were
- 2:36forgiven. OK, OK.
- 2:37Maybe it was a New York Pacific. Far as I know, I think they're
- 2:40kind of forgiven because those were like federal loans, right?
- 2:43So I think a lot of them were forgiven.
- 2:46And so there there's not this like extra monthly payment to
- 2:50pay. And I think those loans also may
- 2:53be falsely supported businesses that would have gone out of
- 2:59business anyway earlier, but now they've have to pay that back
- 3:04plus their regular bank loans plus whatever situation they're
- 3:07in, investors or otherwise. And then it's just become a
- 3:10little bit heavy. So there are a lot of closures,
- 3:14certainly, but there's also a lot of things opening as usual
- 3:18all the time. I did hear that the daily rate
- 3:21of closures right now had gone up in the last six months, like
- 3:25from 5 to 25 or something. Yeah, and and we're certainly,
- 3:29you know, not in the heart of it being in Paris, because Paris is
- 3:33busier than anywhere. Else, but this was specific to
- 3:35Paris. I was wondering actually what
- 3:38you thought the biggest challenges are today for
- 3:42businesses like yours. I think, I think everyone looks
- 3:45at Paris as having kind of handled the pandemic experience
- 3:51more smoothly than other places and then recovered because
- 3:54obviously there was this revenge traveling.
- 3:57And so Paris was full of people and it has been kind of nonstop.
- 4:01But that doesn't necessarily translate to sustained growth in
- 4:06food and retail. Certainly not.
- 4:08And there was, you know, a lot of people were betting on the
- 4:11Olympics to like, bring in a ton of money, which didn't really
- 4:13happen. And I think what you saw in
- 4:17places like London, like post Olympic, like bumps or whatever,
- 4:23I don't really feel like that's a thing.
- 4:25That's also because your your businesses are in their, you
- 4:27know, candle area and the Mari Celeste are in the Marie.
- 4:30Yeah, but just even talking to other people, like, I mean, I'm
- 4:33on like restaurant group, restaurant restaurateur,
- 4:37WhatsApp groups and you see how people complain about things and
- 4:41the problems that they have all the rest.
- 4:45It just depends what kind of business you're trying to run
- 4:49and what what kind of restaurant company you have.
- 4:56If you're kind of, you know, there's definitely been this
- 4:59explosion of concept D restaurants and things like that
- 5:06and like, you know, it's like, I should say restaurants they call
- 5:10it or whatever. For people who don't know, what
- 5:12I should say is explain what you mean by this.
- 5:14It's like Business School. Business School, restaurant
- 5:18groups, which you know, it's fine.
- 5:20It's just like different than a traditional parkour of somebody
- 5:26that would, you know, open a restaurant.
- 5:27I think where generally you'd either come from a family that
- 5:32owned restaurants or had worked on and off in restaurants for a
- 5:36long time or bars or whatever. And then you decide to open your
- 5:41own place, which obviously is like still happens.
- 5:43But then you have, you know, also a group of people that have
- 5:49never worked in a restaurant or very little worked in a
- 5:51restaurant. And then they want to or they do
- 5:53open, you know, restaurants. Yeah, that are generally large,
- 6:01loud in terms of like volume, but also in terms of like
- 6:05presents. And very designy.
- 6:07Very designy. It's definitely goes hand in
- 6:09hand with this. Both things go hand in hand with
- 6:12the rise of like social media and how to fill your restaurant
- 6:18and you know, the rise of like trendy trend following for a
- 6:25certain product or a certain ice cream flavor or whatever
- 6:29chocolate flavor. So like customers want to see
- 6:33like that flashy thing that they can take pictures of and and
- 6:35repost. And so like obviously the
- 6:38restauranteur is responding to that with crazy decor, crazy
- 6:42food, you know, in your face, like always like a lot of social
- 6:46media presence. But you know, the fact that you
- 6:48do have these Business School restaurant groups opening is
- 6:52also result of the fact that there's not really also just
- 6:57with the rise of technology in general, there's not really
- 7:00anything else to open because retail like.
- 7:04You mean so other types of businesses?
- 7:06Yeah, like no one's like graduating from, I should say,
- 7:09and wanting to open a bookstore or a music.
- 7:12Shop. Ain't that true?
- 7:13Or like a sock store or whatever, all they want to do is
- 7:17open restaurants. So you have this like
- 7:19multiplication of either people that want to do that and they
- 7:23also have the connections and you know, the financial
- 7:26wherewithal to be able to do these like big groups like all
- 7:28of a sudden out of nowhere. But you also see, just like
- 7:31small shops serving, you know, mono product, Madeline or.
- 7:36Those have faded though. I think that was a mud.
- 7:39Doughnuts and all this stuff. I feel like you see all these
- 7:41things all over the place, just like a mono product or just a
- 7:44shop that's like ultra branded and people are going for it,
- 7:48which is fine. But that's also just because
- 7:51what else are you going to do? You're not going to sell
- 7:53anything that is sold on Amazon. You're not going to sell any
- 7:56books. You're not going to sell any
- 7:57music. And God forbid they come up with
- 7:59a business that helps the world. No, but if you want to open like
- 8:03a brick and mortar shop, like and that's why there's like also
- 8:06this explosion of restaurants because it's they're like, I
- 8:09mean, you see it with like coffee shops, it's like a
- 8:11epidemic. You know, we're on the same St.
- 8:13like before. You're like, OK, this coffee
- 8:15shop in this area is cool. This coffee shop in this area is
- 8:16fine, but now you have like 4 in the same block, block or
- 8:20whatever. And it's obviously
- 8:22unsustainable. There's gonna be a lot of, you
- 8:24know, closures I think with that Same thing with like Cavist.
- 8:28I don't know how many Cavan that your Paris needs, but it's
- 8:33definitely not as many as there are.
- 8:35And it's also because the, the, the barriers to entry for these
- 8:40kind of businesses are so small because generally in Paris, the
- 8:43rent is fairly cheap compared to other places, depending on where
- 8:46you are, but relatively cheap. You don't need any kind of
- 8:50special license. You don't need any extraction
- 8:53system. So you can just sign the lease,
- 8:57break everything and do it yourself And like open a Cav in
- 9:01in a couple weeks, right? It's not that difficult.
- 9:04But that's also the reason why, like everybody that's ever
- 9:07worked in wine doesn't need to open a Cav and every barista
- 9:11doesn't need to open their own coffee shop.
- 9:13But when I'm, I'm just like being an old man complaining
- 9:16because obviously I just opened a restaurant.
- 9:17So it's like, fine, you know, but whatever.
- 9:19But here's the difference. Here's what I'm hearing is the
- 9:22difference is you have put in the the work and the years and
- 9:27you have scaled back in terms of the number of places you've run.
- 9:31You've switched gears and you've been able to acknowledge when
- 9:34some things weren't working anymore or to the level you
- 9:37wanted them to. And then you shifted gears and
- 9:41for a couple years you've been very concentrated on the 1st 2
- 9:46that are still kicking that we love. 1st and 3rd.
- 9:49Oh, first and third. Wait, which was the second
- 9:51class? I didn't remember that the class
- 9:53was actually between the two. OK, Well, given that I'm not a
- 9:56huge drinker and into dive bars, I was not a big, I was not there
- 10:01very often, but I've, but I've been at the others.
- 10:04But in the meantime, you also did something that I think some
- 10:07of your peers in wine and in spirits have not chosen to do,
- 10:11which is launch your own spirit. Right.
- 10:14So you launched like 2 years ago now, right?
- 10:17Or a year and a half ago? Lutes, which is available at all
- 10:20the best places in Paris, Hotels, restaurants, bars.
- 10:24It's sold in shops too, so you can bring it home.
- 10:27Why did you go that route? I just, I mean, the original
- 10:32impetus for Lutes was seeing that France has a big aperitif
- 10:36culture and it has a lot of heritage brands like Dubonnet
- 10:41and Bonal and Susan Salares and San Rafael and on and on and on.
- 10:46But most French people and certainly most foreigners that
- 10:49are not in the industry don't really know about or drink these
- 10:52brands. And at the same time, Italy also
- 10:55has a big aperitif culture and has very strong brands that
- 10:58everybody knows and everybody loves worldwide.
- 11:01And I just thought that was, you know, unusual that even in a
- 11:05country like France that has its own culture that on every
- 11:08terrace, everyone's drinking big Italian brands.
- 11:10So the idea was to kind of slightly modernize and and touch
- 11:17up the French aperitif culture with an aperitif that is a
- 11:22little bit more of the moment in terms of how it's made and.
- 11:27How's it made? Just with all natural
- 11:29ingredients, real plants, herbs, no artificial colors or flavors
- 11:34or anything like that. Lower sugar, recycled bottle,
- 11:37recycled label, all this other stuff.
- 11:40So a little bit more conscious what I would, you know, what
- 11:43people around me think of as things that they look at, look
- 11:46for in what they consume these days.
- 11:48And also the fact that Paris itself didn't have, you know,
- 11:51its own iconic aperitif like Marseille might have Pestis.
- 11:55Pestis right, because luteus is named for.
- 11:59Yeah, Paris. The city of Paris.
- 12:01The idea of, of Lutez is to have, you know, Paris have its
- 12:06own aperitif and to have people drinking something other than
- 12:11an, after all, spritz when they're sitting on the terrace
- 12:14of, of, in Parisian cafes. Probably not the best timing to
- 12:18launch that worldwide trends of or at least in the Western world
- 12:22of of drinking are, you know, going down.
- 12:25But it seems like there's more data.
- 12:27Cyclical as well, yeah. And also, isn't there more data
- 12:30about people drinking less beer and wine but not necessarily
- 12:33cocktails? Yeah, cocktails are staying
- 12:36pretty strong, but there was like this trend towards what
- 12:40they call premiumization for a long time in the spirits
- 12:43industry. And like a lot of the bigger
- 12:45companies were just kind of offloading any small brands that
- 12:48were like kind of supermarket vodkas or like down market
- 12:53things and putting all their money into promoting kind of
- 12:58premium and super premium booze. That trend has kind of stopped
- 13:04and is reversing a little bit as you have this global anxiety.
- 13:10Yeah, finances. Or famine.
- 13:12All of those big. Issues, finances, no French
- 13:15government, etcetera, etcetera. Yes, we should, we should add a
- 13:20little bit of an alert that we are recording on the day that
- 13:22our Prime Minister resigned after having named a government
- 13:26just last night. So we're in a great, great spot.
- 13:32But Lutest is really interesting and I know that when I lead
- 13:36tours people are really interested in trying it because
- 13:41it's not something you can currently get everywhere under
- 13:45the sun. No, no, no.
- 13:46It's just France, UK, Denmark and Sweden at the moment.
- 13:51And originally you were looking to bring that to the US Is that
- 13:54a bit? Is that on hold?
- 13:56It's on hold at the moment, certainly, yeah.
- 13:58For obvious reasons. Yeah, tariffs, et cetera, but
- 14:01also just not the right time. It's better to do it on more of
- 14:04like a positive upswing, I think than, but you can't, you can't
- 14:09really predict that either. So Lutez has taken a bit of a
- 14:12backseat while we open the Renaissance, but it's still
- 14:16kicking along and you can still find it in plenty of bars and
- 14:19restaurants. And you can get it for home.
- 14:21And you can get it at home for home orders on yeah Maison de
- 14:25Whiskey website for example. But this, as you were starting
- 14:29to say, at a renaissance. So this is what I really want to
- 14:32also get to because your trajectory has been very with
- 14:36Karina, your business partner has been very interesting.
- 14:39You've really disrupted the food scene and the and the bar scene
- 14:43here. Both of you have been here from
- 14:46a time when, you know, specialty cocktails and creative dishes
- 14:50were not did not have great prominence and were laggards in
- 14:56the sort of global scene. And then you put them on the map
- 14:58and now out of Renaissance at Plaza Voltaire are off of it is
- 15:04kind of a throwback. I mean, it is a throwback.
- 15:07You're you're reviving something wonderfully old and beloved in
- 15:12the neighborhood. And one of the things you said
- 15:15to me that didn't make my story for tea, unfortunately, even
- 15:18though I wanted it to, was I, I really liked what you said to
- 15:22me. And I hope you'll say it again
- 15:23right now. So please, you know, remember
- 15:24exactly what you told me about why there's this shift in what
- 15:29you want to be doing as a why, what you want to be running as a
- 15:33business. I think it's a reflection of
- 15:37where we are in our lives and in our career, but also as a
- 15:39reaction of what we were talking about earlier of the
- 15:42brandification of the restaurant scene.
- 15:46Whereas before we were kind of always looking to like do
- 15:51something new and add something and find like a gap in the
- 15:55market and be inspired by this, that and the other and then try
- 15:59to like maybe bring it to France, which something you can
- 16:02understand maybe when you're a, you know, not a native Parisian.
- 16:09But at this point in our career, we're kind of over that kind of
- 16:14thing. And in any case, as we said, the
- 16:16rate of like openings and the internationalization of the
- 16:21Paris kind of FNB scene, you know, there's not really like
- 16:27every global trend or any kind of like niche product is already
- 16:31like here or on its way. And I'm less interested in kind
- 16:35of following trends or trying to open like the next new thing
- 16:41that no one's ever heard of anymore, which must have might
- 16:44have been the case with Kendall Ari at the time.
- 16:47Or, you know, when we tried it, when we opened Hero and we're
- 16:52doing like the Korean fried chicken thing with our chef and
- 16:55that had that had worked in Korea and seen that first hand.
- 16:59But you know, we open Hero, but then there's also like 10 other
- 17:02places like that that are still around today.
- 17:04So it's kind of that's not really our niche anymore.
- 17:08But also we're not super interested in in in that.
- 17:10And I'm trying to like build more long term businesses, build
- 17:16things that are institutions. In their own right.
- 17:20Yeah, in their own right. And that's, it wasn't what we
- 17:22were trying to do with Candelaria and Mary Celeste when
- 17:24we open them, but it's kind of just happened by circumstance
- 17:29and timing and luck. Certainly with those two places,
- 17:34it seems like, you know, they're both going strong after about 15
- 17:37years. So like with those places, you
- 17:40know, after COVID, like what we said was we were trying to like,
- 17:44OK, trim the fat of the places that we're like taking up a lot
- 17:47of our time, but weren't necessarily like successful
- 17:50financially or otherwise offload those recent ourselves.
- 17:56Focus on the two places that were successful, try to make
- 18:00them more successful both by reinvesting in the
- 18:05infrastructure of the place, reinvesting in the teams,
- 18:08refocusing on the details. That may be because we're moving
- 18:11a little bit quickly before that maybe we've overlooked.
- 18:13So going back and going over the bathrooms or the kitchen or you
- 18:20know, the facade or all these things that we could have tried
- 18:24to improve like 5 or 10% better in all, all the areas.
- 18:27So with La Renaissance, it's completely different situation
- 18:31where we're taking over new business, which is the first
- 18:33time we've ever taken over an existing business, but kept the
- 18:37name, the general vibe, the layout and just tried to kind of
- 18:44do the same to that Renaissance. What we've been doing to marry
- 18:46Celeste and Candelaria over the past 3-4 years, which is, you
- 18:50know, give it a big refresh in terms of decor.
- 18:54But it's still recognizable as a an older world.
- 18:57Yeah, certainly, yeah, yeah. And we kept like the same layout
- 19:00of the room. We kept the same banquets.
- 19:02We kept, you know, the same guy that made them originally, like
- 19:05took them out, reupholstered them, fixed like the rips and
- 19:08tears and then just brought them back.
- 19:10A lot of the marble and mirrors and all that is original.
- 19:14The mosaic floor is original. But we just, you know, had
- 19:17someone come in and restore that and fix like the holes and the
- 19:21missing tiles. The bar is exactly where the bar
- 19:23used to be in the same kind of S shaped like slight S shape that
- 19:27it used to be, which is not great for economically.
- 19:30It's not the best thing to do when you're trying to like
- 19:32rebuild the bar stations and all the rest because it's a lot
- 19:35easier just to work in a straight line.
- 19:36But we decided to keep that because it adds a lot of charm
- 19:40and, you know, and it's much more beautiful in the long run.
- 19:43So the idea was just to give it a big refresh, kind of restore
- 19:48it to its original grander. I don't know if it's grander,
- 19:51but elegance or, you know, bring out its natural beauty while
- 19:56respecting the history of the space.
- 19:58And also just do the same in terms of food and drink of
- 20:01course as well. Upgrade it, Yeah.
- 20:03And if you guys hadn't taken it over, like let's say you had
- 20:07lost out to someone else, do you think that every other
- 20:11interested party would have taken over the existing business
- 20:14or would they have said that's in the past, that's an old
- 20:18chapter, and now we're moving on with a new concept.
- 20:20From, from what it seemed like is that, you know, the woman
- 20:26that sold it to us, Regine, who ran it for the past 35 years.
- 20:29She's also the owner of the walls of the space, the actual
- 20:33real estate and the restaurant was for sale.
- 20:36At one point someone like, you know, signed a preliminary deal
- 20:41but then didn't get the financing for it.
- 20:43So then she took it off the market and then it kind of went
- 20:46back on the market. So I'd thought it was already
- 20:48sold. Like I'd heard like echoes of it
- 20:51year or two ago when it came back on the market and we were
- 20:55kind of like slowly looking around for a new project, but
- 20:57nothing that was, you know, we weren't like urgently needing to
- 21:01do something, but. And I wasn't necessarily looking
- 21:04the 11th because there's a lot of, you know, it's quite dense
- 21:07already. But when the agent showed me
- 21:11that, I was like, Oh yeah, I know that place and it's very
- 21:13special and there's definitely something to be done there.
- 21:16And I think that regime would from what it seemed like she
- 21:21wasn't talking to just anyone. She wanted to really like kind
- 21:25of almost interview the person taking over to make sure that
- 21:27that legacy was preserved or improved upon.
- 21:31And not just, it's a restaurant with a full liquor license and
- 21:34a, and a full extraction system and a tariff.
- 21:36So you could easily just break everything and RIP it down and
- 21:40rebuild it. But have that all those like
- 21:42things that restaurant people look for when they're when
- 21:44they're opening a restaurant. So it could easily be anything
- 21:48but. The neighbors would have been
- 21:49really. Oh yeah.
- 21:51The neighbors love this place. Yeah, and the last descendant of
- 21:54the family that sold it to Regine, as far as I know, the
- 21:58last living descendant is in the building still.
- 22:00Oh, wow. Lives on the 6th floor.
- 22:03And she's come down and she has like 3 or 4 old photos that
- 22:06showed us of like, her parents behind the bar in like, the
- 22:091950s, like, you know, her mother and her and with like,
- 22:13the old coffee machine with the three, like, giant urns and
- 22:16things like that. So we have some people coming in
- 22:20that say there were big regulars and they're like, they don't
- 22:23even recognize that we did anything so good.
- 22:26They're like, yeah, yeah, like, oh, you didn't change it.
- 22:29I'm like, well. We did.
- 22:32Cost a pretty penny not to change anything, but yes, we
- 22:35did. So like I like that also that it
- 22:38looks like and then other people come in that, you know, are
- 22:40regulars and like, Oh yeah, this space needed, you know, needed
- 22:44this. And you guys really just like
- 22:46upgrade. And that's like a testament to
- 22:48Joanna's work who who worked with us on it and also the the
- 22:53team that to do the actual renovation work.
- 22:56But I do love this one detail, which I hope that people
- 22:58listening when they go, they will pay attention to, which I
- 23:01guess it's easier to see during the day.
- 23:03But you have this fresco and these lampshades that you had
- 23:07custom designed and painted. And they feature some historical
- 23:12figures in this, like whimsical. Yeah, this like whimsical
- 23:15design, but they also include some modern contemporary
- 23:19figures. What was the what was your the
- 23:22thought process behind that? And who are some of the figures?
- 23:25We definitely like to do, I mean, you can't really see a lot
- 23:28of it anymore in Kendallaria because, you know, things have
- 23:32unfortunately degraded. Then we had to, you know,
- 23:34renovate and and things like that because we built
- 23:37Kendallaria, especially in a very tight budget.
- 23:39Mary's list also, but we always like to have some small details
- 23:43that are maybe not the most intelligent in terms of budget
- 23:48or or otherwise, but that really make the place special and stand
- 23:53out. And it's not necessarily like in
- 23:55your face, but if you notice, you notice.
- 23:56And then it's like extra little pleasure of being there.
- 24:01And those frescoes are certainly, as anyone knows or
- 24:06has anyone that's been to Benmelman's Bar in New York, you
- 24:08know, very influenced by Benmelman's Bar, which is a
- 24:12beautiful old place in the Carlisle Hotel Uptown.
- 24:17And we were thinking when we're building it that we were missing
- 24:20this kind of, you know, the place has a lot of inherent
- 24:22beauty, but it doesn't have that extra touch of like, it's like
- 24:28when you go to, I don't know, Clown Bar or what's the place in
- 24:32the La Pellette in the six where you have these, like, super
- 24:36beautiful original details that no one in their right mind would
- 24:41do today because either they're too fragile or it's too
- 24:44expensive or whatever. So we're like, OK, let's get a
- 24:47little extra money together and be able to, you know, find some
- 24:51artists and bring them over and to to do this kind of detailed
- 24:55frescoes. So we got two people from
- 24:58actually Londoners Harry Darby and Anna Hodgson, who, you know,
- 25:04we communicated a lot with them and Karina had seen their work
- 25:06before in London and we brought them over for about a week.
- 25:11We gave them a little bit of inspiration from historical
- 25:13figures of the neighborhood and. Like.
- 25:15Like Pearl ashes and the sisters that used to live in the convent
- 25:22up the road that used to exist. Like my dog running around with
- 25:27Leon's with Leon, who is Karina's son.
- 25:32And Leon Bloom, right? Leon Bloom also because Leon,
- 25:35it's like you have Leon Bloom there as well.
- 25:38Voltaire and Berlin like Berlin lived not too far from there
- 25:41apparently. Voltaire obviously French
- 25:44Revolution, but we're right near like.
- 25:46Plus Voltaire. Plus, well, it's actually plus
- 25:48Leon. Bloom Oh, that's right.
- 25:49I always say Metro Voltaire. That's right.
- 25:52But all these like historical characters that were around the
- 25:55neighborhood. And so, yeah, they spent the
- 25:58week kind of drawing on that. And then we had all of the
- 26:02lights. Lampshades.
- 26:03That's again something you'd have to point out.
- 26:07Or like one person out of a few 100 that's come by have been
- 26:11like, oh, wow, what's that like? But it's, you know, the kind of
- 26:13people that would notice that. And I'm like, oh, of course you
- 26:15notice, you know, yeah. Because you're like an artist or
- 26:19sensitive soul. But like, you know, they're very
- 26:22small lampshades, but they're all hand painted individually
- 26:24with different scenes and you know, the artists were like, oh,
- 26:27do you really want everyone to be different?
- 26:29Or can we just do the same thing for all of them?
- 26:30Like no, they ought to be different.
- 26:32So there's like what, 12356? I mean 1010 or 12 like very
- 26:38small lamp shades, which are also made by the Super old
- 26:42lampshade dude. Two women O2 women, two older
- 26:46women 2 debts down off bestie that work, you know, in a
- 26:52business that's been there for 100 years making just lampshades
- 26:55and you have to go and it's a beautiful place to to visit if
- 26:58you ever need a lampshade. I mean, who wouldn't?
- 27:00Yeah, I need to. Create a lampshade just to go
- 27:03there, just to hang out with the women and let's listen to them,
- 27:05like bicker between themselves. It's very, very cool experience.
- 27:09So that's a place that Joanna had worked with previously and
- 27:12knew about, but it's not someplace like you would even
- 27:15find on. It's like you can't find it on
- 27:17Google, you know? But they were like, you know,
- 27:20enthralled by the opportunity to make these lampshades.
- 27:24So they cut out the lampshades for we sent them to the artist.
- 27:27The artist painted on them. Then we brought them back and
- 27:28they made them all, made them all up.
- 27:30So. You're keeping their days
- 27:32interesting too. Exactly.
- 27:34So it's nice to be able to, you know, work with these small
- 27:36artisans and and like keep that going, like small French
- 27:40artisans on on different aspects of it and they love the result.
- 27:45So, yeah, in any case, the idea behind investing and taking the
- 27:50time and something like that is to again, make a place that is
- 27:55like we're trying to think on much longer time frames where
- 28:02I'm not, we're not trying to, you know, OK, what's like Paris
- 28:06missing like right now and like, let's get it open and do
- 28:08something. Let's jump on a smash burger
- 28:11trend or pizza thing or whatever.
- 28:13Let's try to just build a solid business that can be around for
- 28:18another 20-30 forty years before we're ready to to sell it and
- 28:23keep the heritage of that space. Or, you know, maybe in someday
- 28:27it'll be like create its own heritage, but at least build the
- 28:30kind of business that has staying power.
- 28:32Staying power. Yeah.
- 28:33And in terms of the space itself, in terms of the offer,
- 28:37in terms of the infrastructure of the space, in terms of
- 28:42financial returns and all these things that are very important
- 28:45for businesses that no one likes to talk about.
- 28:47But there's no point in opening a place that's not profitable or
- 28:51that can never be profitable. You know, it's always stunned me
- 28:54are the businesses that open that seem like they were given
- 28:58loans without a viable business plan and I and I and I don't
- 29:02understand why the banks even give out money for some of these
- 29:05things. Maybe it's not the bank, maybe
- 29:08it's their family money or their own money or investor money or
- 29:11something like that, but yes. There's there's like a
- 29:14proliferation of batshit ideas that you see.
- 29:19Oh yeah. Emerging.
- 29:22And, you know, you can see from a mile away that they're not
- 29:24going to be there in a few years and it's just going to be, you
- 29:27know, recycled through and everything will be out the door.
- 29:31But do you remember before you even open Kendall area like
- 29:34Paris was a city that where not a lot changed and we all, you
- 29:39know, felt a certain way about that opposite direction to the
- 29:42point where it's become almost, it feels too easy for people to
- 29:46just open things up and then the turnover is high, certainly.
- 29:51And, you know, people always used to be like, oh, it's hard
- 29:53to open a business in France and some aspects are harder than the
- 29:57US But in general, like the financial barriers are not as
- 30:01high as like in New York. And you also do because of like,
- 30:04the way businesses work here, which we're not going to get
- 30:07into now. But it's, you know, banks will
- 30:09lend to a place like a restaurant, whereas like in the
- 30:12US at least, you need to generally have all that money be
- 30:16privately raised. And mostly in the UK as well,
- 30:20unless you're already a very successful restaurant person,
- 30:22like a bank is not necessary, is not going to lend money to a
- 30:25first time or even a second time restaurateur.
- 30:28So you need to have, you know, either your own money or
- 30:33investor money lined up to open a place.
- 30:37Yeah, here it's very bank a little.
- 30:38Bit bank driven banks you know you need.
- 30:41To have some money but banks will loan to you well so if
- 30:44we're if we're. Thinking about you being here.
- 30:47I mean, we've been here almost about about the same time,
- 30:49right? Almost 20 years, yes.
- 30:51So yeah. What year?
- 30:52Did you get here 2006 end of two. 1006, yeah.
- 30:56And. You think about how things have
- 30:57changed and how you know some things are progressing in a way
- 31:00that we like and in some in ways we don't like.
- 31:03What do you think Paris does? Still does very well.
- 31:07And what do you think needs a little work in terms of
- 31:13restaurants or in terms of? Just keep it F&B.
- 31:15Let's. Limit it to F and.
- 31:17B But I do think like that is something different than a place
- 31:22like New York and London where if you are successful and you
- 31:25make like an institution kind of place or you're lucky enough or
- 31:30whatever, the stars align to the point where you have like a
- 31:34successful business. You do have a certain amount of
- 31:37protection here that you don't in other countries where your
- 31:42landlord can't arbitrarily raise your rent to whatever they want.
- 31:45Your lease is pretty much forever.
- 31:47Yeah and you know once you get over if you took out a bank
- 31:51loan, for example, bank loans here, like 7 years for a
- 31:54business, you know, once you get over that hump, you're like and
- 31:58you're in a pretty good spot. So I definitely think that, you
- 32:02know, in terms of long term supportive businesses, that
- 32:06definitely helps. And that way you can also, you
- 32:10know, spend the time and energy and money into making kind of a,
- 32:14a business that can last a long time.
- 32:16You know, it won't be taken out from under your feet, right?
- 32:19Because in New York, like, you know, if you're successful and
- 32:22landlords going to raise your rent after 10 years to an
- 32:25unsustainable level, and if you're not successful, you're
- 32:27about a business very quickly because your rent is already
- 32:31high no matter what. And London, you have these like
- 32:335 year rent reviews upward zone upward only rent reviews that
- 32:38are built into every lease, which means that every five
- 32:41years you need to get into like if you're lucky, a discussion
- 32:44and for a lot of people on argument or legal battle, every
- 32:47five years to, you know, not basically evict you.
- 32:50And so a lot of you know, you do have long term institutions, but
- 32:54those are generally the people that own the real estate that
- 32:56they're in. But if you're in a landlord
- 32:58situation, you can never be sure.
- 33:01Be sure so you know that's a. France like that's a very.
- 33:05Positive thing I think, and also the fact that because again of
- 33:10like this Fondaco mass system, it actually it costs a lot of
- 33:14money to get into a space generally because you're buying
- 33:17an existing business and all of the reputation and intangible
- 33:21and tangible things that go along with that.
- 33:23But because that's there, A, that's why banks lend to you
- 33:27because they know they have something to take if you're not
- 33:29successful. And B, you're also creating
- 33:33equity and like long term wealth and that thing because at some
- 33:37point if you want to sell it, you'll be able to sell that.
- 33:39And that's, it's not just like you're paying rent and it's just
- 33:43going to landlord and then the money is out the window.
- 33:45It's, you know, you're not paying to own the space, but
- 33:47you're paying to own the intangible business, which has a
- 33:50value and that's something you can like retire on later.
- 33:53So, you know, when we bought the space from Regine, she's not
- 33:57like we had to buy it. And she went and retired to the
- 34:00South of France, you know, so you can actually own the wall,
- 34:03the the mule. The walls she owns.
- 34:05She owns the walls. As well, which is a separate
- 34:08transaction which we do not own. So she's our landlord, but she
- 34:11also has vested interest in our success, of course.
- 34:14And she's like, she knows because she was a restaurant
- 34:16owner that you have to give someone a reasonable rent and
- 34:19conditions and everything for them to be able to work
- 34:21correctly, or else then they're going to.
- 34:23They'll just fail. Yeah, they're going to.
- 34:24Fail and then her space is. Going to be empty and it's going
- 34:26to be up to her to pay her her loan or whatever.
- 34:28So it's nice if you can be a restaurant owner and then, you
- 34:32know, sell your sell your business at some point and then
- 34:35be able to actually like retire and have a good life in a
- 34:38moderately successful restaurant.
- 34:39Not something that's like, you know, doing millions and
- 34:41millions of turnover a year. So that's a.
- 34:45Big positive. Where do you think there's room
- 34:48for improvement in the scene? I would say just in general.
- 34:52Like because of, you know, the lack of barriers necessarily of
- 34:55making a place just I guess rehashing what we already spoke
- 34:58about. I think that there needs to be
- 35:01and this is, I mean, it can only I guess, unless you're going to
- 35:03come in with some weird government policy or whatever,
- 35:06but I don't think that's necessary.
- 35:08Maybe some more self reflection on the terms on the on the for
- 35:12new restaurant tours or even existing restaurant tours and
- 35:15being like, is this a good business?
- 35:17Is this work? I don't know.
- 35:19It's hard to say, but is it worth it?
- 35:22For the neighborhood, right? Like is it going to change the
- 35:24very spirit of a place you know? Yeah, I would just say more self
- 35:30reflection and is it less? Opportunistic business ideas,
- 35:36surfing on trends that are that, you know, going in are short
- 35:40lived. Yeah, yeah, trend.
- 35:42Surfing. Trying to, you know, like make a
- 35:45quick buck in the restaurant industry.
- 35:47Is that even a thing? It shouldn't be a thing.
- 35:50I don't think, but I think some people think it's a thing and
- 35:55maybe showing a little bit more respect for your clients and
- 36:00just being like, OK, am I doing this for the right reasons or am
- 36:03I doing it just because, like I said, it's just like a business
- 36:05opportunity, right? I agree.
- 36:08And also maybe less macha, less macho macha.
- 36:12Oh, less. Macha, certainly.
- 36:13Less macho and less macha. Less.
- 36:16Lines. Less, fewer lines, Yeah, the the
- 36:20the line. Situation is out of control in
- 36:22this town right now. Yeah, which never used.
- 36:25To happen now, but now it's just because, you know, and I would
- 36:29be shocked and also appalled that if one day like something I
- 36:33was doing became like some TikTok trend because that's
- 36:37always going to end at some point and probably quite
- 36:39quickly. And you're going to lose all
- 36:41your real customers because people are waiting in line for
- 36:45your profiteroles or whatever that they're saw online or
- 36:48something that became AI. Wish it were preferred viral.
- 36:51Yeah. I mean, I'd feel honestly less
- 36:53irritated if they were profiteroles that people were
- 36:55lining up. Yeah, but that much?
- 36:57That much? Aligned near my Celeste a couple
- 36:59weeks ago is insane. No, it was 3 days.
- 37:02Of people getting up at 5:00 in the morning or getting in line
- 37:05at 5:00 in the morning. I don't even know what it was,
- 37:07but then it was. An influence.
- 37:08It was this woman. This young woman who is a Tik
- 37:11toker who has her own matcha brand that is apparently infused
- 37:15with collagen or some nonsense, and they were there for her as
- 37:19much as they were for this drink.
- 37:21And you know, you're sigh, that's like an obvious like.
- 37:25You know thing also I would say less pop ups.
- 37:29Well, we're in. Pop up mania right now, yeah.
- 37:33But it's like pop up purgatory where you just like the things
- 37:36are just like, you know, it's the same thing over and over
- 37:40everywhere. And I understand on one hand the
- 37:44interest of the chefs to do pop up things because, you know,
- 37:48they're generally decently paid and you don't have to
- 37:51necessarily do all the hard work or the repetitive work of like
- 37:56when you have a full time job somewhere.
- 37:58So understand the interest at the same time, you know, a lot
- 38:01of these places that are based on pop ups, it's also like semi
- 38:05legal because half the people that are coming over from
- 38:08overseas, obviously they don't have a work visa to come and
- 38:12work in France, right? So their business is based on an
- 38:15illegal concept, which, you know, that's their choice to to
- 38:20open. But I would never do that.
- 38:22And it also, it has an effect on quote, UN quote, real
- 38:25restaurants where it's increasingly difficult to hire.
- 38:29You can't match the salaries, but they're not even salaries
- 38:33that people are getting when they're doing pop ups because
- 38:35sometimes they're paid in cash, sometimes they're just paid on a
- 38:38factor. So it's great for the restaurant
- 38:41owner because they don't have to pay any kind of social charges
- 38:43or healthcare or vacation to their whole staff.
- 38:46And the person working, they might see a big fat check after
- 38:51working in a place for two weeks, but then they're
- 38:54unemployed for a couple weeks or a month or whatever.
- 38:56And you know, they're not having their vacations reimburse or
- 39:00paid for, they're not having any healthcare included and all
- 39:02these other advantages that make France like a pretty decent
- 39:06place if you're an employee. So yes, I would say less pop
- 39:10ups. Like there's enough pop ups.
- 39:12Not every place needs to be a pop up place.
- 39:13There's a couple places that do it super well.
- 39:16Place like early June for example, which is, which is a
- 39:18fixed place and. Has visiting guest chefs, Yeah.
- 39:23But not everyone needs to do a pop up in every random like wine
- 39:26bar or whatever in Paris. I think that's a little bit
- 39:30much. And that's also, you know, it's
- 39:32contributes or is maybe a symptom of trend following.
- 39:36And, you know, I understand a place they need to like have
- 39:39something to talk about all the time to bring people in or
- 39:43whatever. And you know, it's just how it
- 39:44goes. But maybe if people like
- 39:47customers were a little little less interested in always going
- 39:50to a new thing and you know, could be become regular, it's
- 39:53pretty nice being in a regular a regular in a place.
- 39:56So I mean, I encourage all your. Listeners to become.
- 39:58Regulars in five or ten places and get treated nicely people
- 40:04know your name you're supporting like local business and jobs and
- 40:09the local economy instead of always like OK I'm going to go
- 40:13to the new restaurant here here's like the you know you
- 40:16read the newsletter here's the new 10 places that open in Paris
- 40:20and like OK let's. Reserve here one one day and
- 40:23reserve here another day and reserve here next week.
- 40:25And let's like do every new place that we see in timeout or
- 40:28whatever every week, which is fine.
- 40:30I like going to new places too, but it's nice going back to the
- 40:33to the old places. And that's also what Paris.
- 40:36Has done quite well is be a place that people, especially
- 40:39travelers, come back to year after year and they often go
- 40:41back to the same places. So you want to be able to create
- 40:44businesses that have that longevity.
- 40:47Yeah, I mean, I'm sure. Like a place like Chez Yours or
- 40:50whatever has the same French people going there for the past
- 40:5350 years and the same American tours that every summer when
- 40:56they come to Paris, they always go like twice a week to Chez
- 40:59Yours for a month or whatever. That's great.
- 41:01Well, now they can go to other. Renaissance.
- 41:03Exactly, Josh. Come be regular.
- 41:05Thank you for taking time. Out of your busy opening month
- 41:09schedule and I know it's not been easy, but it's been great
- 41:14to see it shine again. Thank you very much.
- 41:16Thanks for having. Me.
- 41:19That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 41:22be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 41:25scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 41:27conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 41:30subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 41:33what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 41:36from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 41:40Substack at Treinto.