Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Davis Stirling Act: A Practical Overview of California HOA Law
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everyone. My name is Howard Gould. I'm
- 0:07co -chair of the real estate section for the
- 0:09Beverly Hills Bar Association. Great to have
- 0:13everyone with us today for this program about
- 0:15the Davis -Stirling Act. I want to thank Michael
- 0:18Kushner for coming today. Davis -Stirling...
- 0:22Act is hugely important when it comes to HOAs.
- 0:27And as we know, there's HOAs just all over the
- 0:30place, whether it's a high -rise building, low
- 0:34-rise buildings, single -family developments
- 0:37that have common areas. And these are common
- 0:42interest developments. So Michael specializes
- 0:47in this area. He's the founding and managing
- 0:50partner of MBK Chapman PC. And he is a pioneer
- 0:54in homeowner side HOA law in California. He protects
- 0:59homeowners. from what he sees as abusive and
- 1:03mismanaged associations. He represents homeowners
- 1:06in disputes involving abusive boards of directors,
- 1:10selective enforcement, illegal fines, architectural
- 1:14denials, records violations, and other forms
- 1:17of misconduct by HOAs or their management companies.
- 1:21He's developed his own proprietary legal systems
- 1:24for enforcing the Davis -Sterling Act on behalf
- 1:27of homeowners. He's the author of HOA Hell, California
- 1:31Homeowners Definitive Guide to Beating Bad HOAs,
- 1:35which you can find on Amazon. Michael is a UC
- 1:39Berkeley grad and also a grad of the UCLA School
- 1:42of Law. And Michael, thank you for coming. The
- 1:44program's all yours. Thank you, Howard. I appreciate
- 1:47you having me here. What I'd like to do first
- 1:49is share my screen. because I'm going to walk
- 1:52people through a presentation I hope they'll
- 1:55find interesting. I believe they're going to
- 2:00tell you later that we're going to make this
- 2:01entire slideshow available to everybody, as well
- 2:04as a 6 ,000 -word article in the Davis -Stirling
- 2:07Act that is going to be available to everyone,
- 2:13and also a guide, an HOA guide. So with that,
- 2:18I'd like to start by just introducing myself.
- 2:21You know what? I think Howard did a great job,
- 2:23so I don't need to do that. Let's just jump in
- 2:25to what we're going to cover today, or I'm going
- 2:26to do my best to cover today. Obviously, I'm
- 2:29going to talk about the Davis -Stirling Act and
- 2:31what that means. And I've kind of broken it down
- 2:33into eight different groups. The authority and
- 2:37the framework, the governing document hierarchy,
- 2:40open meetings and executive sessions, records
- 2:42access and enforcement, elections. Discipline,
- 2:46and specifically AB 130, a law that went into
- 2:48effect last year. IVR and ADR and architectural
- 2:51assessment. I go through a lot of code sections.
- 2:56They worry about writing them down or memorizing
- 2:57them. You guys are going to get all this anyway.
- 3:00So you could just listen, but I don't think you
- 3:03need to take notes or do anything other than
- 3:06just listen and try to figure out what's coming
- 3:08next. So real quick, Davis -Stirling Act in plain
- 3:13terms, it's our rule book. It's the rule book
- 3:15for California HOAs. And it's found primarily
- 3:19in Civil Code Section 4000 through 6150. And
- 3:23it governs pretty much every major aspect of
- 3:25life in any common interest development in California.
- 3:28And that includes how boards run meetings, how
- 3:31elections are held, how votes are counted, how
- 3:34rules are adopted and enforced, how members inspect
- 3:38records, disciplines imposed, assessments are
- 3:41levied and collected, and and what to do if there's
- 3:44disputes and resolution of disputes. It also
- 3:46covers things like neighbor disputes and things
- 3:49like nuisance and what the HOA obligations are
- 3:53vis -a -vis the HOA as an entity and each of
- 3:56the homeowners as well. But if you take one thing
- 3:58from this slide at least, it's the core principle
- 4:01issue. Every single action that a board of directors
- 4:05takes in an HOA has to trace back to one of three
- 4:09sources. One of the governing documents, California
- 4:13law, or specifically the Davis -Stirling Act,
- 4:16any other federal or state law. So with that,
- 4:22Davis -Stirling is our foundation. It's where
- 4:24we begin everything. There's two common misconceptions
- 4:28about the Davis -Stirling Act. And one of them,
- 4:31and they're polar opposites. One of them is that
- 4:33it only protects boards. And that's not true.
- 4:36And the other is that it's purely homeowner centric.
- 4:39And that's not true. ones believe in the in the
- 4:43former that only protects boards for good reason.
- 4:46There's a huge difference in power just based
- 4:50on the fact that the HOA collects money from
- 4:52everybody. So it has a big purse to play with
- 4:55and it has the power to discipline to find and
- 5:01or to suspend somebody's rights or privileges
- 5:04to utilize common areas. And so just just based
- 5:09on what the law is designed to do H2As have this
- 5:12big power advantage. But the Davis -Stirling
- 5:15Act is written for both. It's written for homeowners
- 5:17and boards, and it gives homeowners a lot of
- 5:20protection. And so the reality here is it's a
- 5:24balance of power. Boards hold a lot of authority,
- 5:27but they are bound by statutory procedures about
- 5:31transparency and due process, and there are lots
- 5:35of statutory limits. And it's by educating understanding
- 5:38and educating our clients about those limits
- 5:42and those obligations that give homeowners ultimately
- 5:45the power that almost even up the playing field.
- 5:49Because most disputes usually come down to whether
- 5:51the board stayed inside the lines or obligated
- 5:53to stay inside. So David Sterling Act is complicated.
- 6:00Not because it's hard to understand when you
- 6:02read individual stat sheets. Some of them are
- 6:04beautifully written and extremely easy plain
- 6:07language and other ones are like reading the
- 6:09tax bill. But that's not why that's an issue.
- 6:11It's because it is a big set of statutes and
- 6:14things are found all over that set. So it's not
- 6:20a structural problem per se, but it's a unintegrated
- 6:25set of statutes. And so if you look at the spread
- 6:29on the screen, this is me organizing it as best
- 6:32I could. And this is a pretty good guide as to
- 6:35where you'll find the different aspects of the
- 6:38Davis -Stirling Act that you as a real estate
- 6:40attorney might want to know. So you've got open
- 6:43meetings. Generally speaking, you'll find stuff
- 6:46about open meetings between 4900 and 4955 of
- 6:50the Civil Code. You've got records, which you'll
- 6:52find at 5200 to 5240. And it goes through elections,
- 6:57discipline, IDR and ADR, architecture, assessments.
- 7:03reserves and disclosures. Now, again, those aren't
- 7:07really official separations. Those are just based
- 7:10on my experience, what I came up with, but they're
- 7:12pretty close to this. It's a fragmentation, though,
- 7:15and that's the practical barrier. Before I go
- 7:19scheme by scheme, and I do want to try to hit
- 7:21all of these, I want to give you a single analytical
- 7:23framework that sits above all of them and applies
- 7:26no matter which one you're in, whether you're
- 7:28in records, assessments, disclosures, and that'll
- 7:32be on this slide. And that is think in terms
- 7:35of authority. First question you want to always
- 7:38ask yourself is the source. What document or
- 7:41statute is giving the board the power to do this
- 7:45thing? Okay. The second is procedure. Did the
- 7:49boy follow the required procedures that are set
- 7:51out in the statute? Or did they diverge from
- 7:56that and act on their own? Third is conflict.
- 7:59Does the action conflict with a higher legal
- 8:02authority? And in the next coming slides, we'll
- 8:05talk about what that authority is and what the
- 8:07statutory basis is. And then is, what's the standard?
- 8:12Is it a reasonableness standard, good faith,
- 8:15or are there higher standards that are more due
- 8:16process oriented? Run every dispute that your
- 8:23client is having with their HOA through those
- 8:25four in this order, source procedure, conflict
- 8:28standard. and it'll tell you fast whether you've
- 8:31got a case and where the board's exposure is.
- 8:38Now, Davis -Stirling Act, specifically 4205 of
- 8:42the Civil Code, lays out the hierarchy of governing
- 8:45authority when it comes to HOAs in California.
- 8:49So, it basically states on top as the governing
- 8:54authority in this order, federal, state, and
- 8:57local law. So obviously, Davis -Stirling Act
- 8:59is the California statute that controls, but
- 9:01to the extent there's a federal law that governs
- 9:05the field, then that's going to trump any California
- 9:08law. And that doesn't happen a lot because most
- 9:11of California laws are actually stricter than
- 9:13the federal version when it comes to HOAs. For
- 9:15example, all the discrimination laws and the
- 9:20accommodation laws that are found in federal
- 9:22law are stricter in California. and it's stricter
- 9:25in the Davis -Stirling Act. So you actually don't
- 9:27run into that problem a lot where federal law
- 9:29will trump the Davis -Stirling Act. But we do
- 9:31run into issues where Davis -Stirling Act needs
- 9:34to trump local law. That happens all the time.
- 9:37So federal, state, and local law trumps everything.
- 9:40And then right underneath that are the recorded
- 9:42CCNRs, the cuttings. And underneath that, you
- 9:47have your articles of incorporation, which for
- 9:4998 % of the cases in California, they're completely
- 9:52irrelevant. So you're almost never gonna have
- 9:55to look at an article and make any sort of decision
- 9:58because they're almost universally completely
- 10:00irrelevant. To the extent you get that one in
- 10:03a hundred, where the article say something that
- 10:07is conflicted with by something lower, articles
- 10:10would control. But CC &R sit on top of that.
- 10:13Underneath the articles, you have the bylaws.
- 10:15Now the bylaws, I like to compare it to the rule
- 10:18book that a baseball umpire Is is reading to
- 10:22decide whether or not that's an infield fly rule
- 10:25or not. It's the rules about how that board is
- 10:29supposed to govern itself. So all the stuff about
- 10:31meetings, all the stuff about selecting a new
- 10:34board member, all the timing notices for elections,
- 10:37that's usually stuff you find in bylaws. It can
- 10:40be in CCNRs, it often is, but the bylaws will
- 10:43almost always have it as well. And then underneath
- 10:46that you have everything else. splitting rules,
- 10:50architectural guidelines, they're called different
- 10:52things, they have different names, but they're
- 10:55basically, these are the things that are either
- 10:58hinted at in an above document, or they're covered,
- 11:01but these lower rules will flesh them out. Almost
- 11:05every HOA in California with more than 10 units
- 11:08is gonna have some sort of set of operating rules.
- 11:10Sometimes they combine them with the architectural
- 11:12rules, sometimes they're separate documents,
- 11:14but those are all equal at the bottom. And that's
- 11:17your hierarchy. If a rule conflicts with the
- 11:19CCNRs, CCNRs win. If a rule conflicts with the
- 11:24articles, unless it's conflicted by the CCNRs,
- 11:27articles win and so forth down the issue here.
- 11:32Now, here's a conflict. And I see, most people
- 11:36don't ever spot this at this stage. A board can't
- 11:39enforce a rule, for example, that blocks solar
- 11:42panels or the construction of an ADU or drought
- 11:46resistant landscaping. because firewall controls.
- 11:50We'll get into some of that later. Those are
- 11:53governed by state law. So to the extent that
- 11:55an HOA CCNRs or bylaws or operating rules try
- 11:59to limit what's governed by statute, they'll
- 12:02automatically lose, even if it's in bulk and
- 12:05white in the recording documents. Now, a frequent
- 12:10abuse by bad HOAs is using an operating rule
- 12:15or a guideline and the architectural guidelines
- 12:17to accomplish something that legally requires
- 12:20an amendment to the CCNRs. That's kind of what
- 12:23I was just getting into a second ago. So the
- 12:26board wants a new substantive restriction, but
- 12:29it doesn't want the membership vote, which is
- 12:31usually on a super majority to amend CCNRs. It
- 12:34doesn't want to record an amendment because it
- 12:36doesn't think it's going to pass. So it does
- 12:38it through a lower form document, like a rule.
- 12:40I'll give you an example. Say the CCNRs permits
- 12:42rentals with no minimum term. So you can have
- 12:46a short -term rental of one day, two days. You
- 12:48can put it on Airbnb. You can do any of that.
- 12:50The CCR permits it, either because it is silent
- 12:54on the issue or because it affirmatively gives
- 12:57that panel. We've seen boards decide, you know
- 13:00what? Short -term rentals are just not good for
- 13:03our community. We want to ban them. We want to
- 13:06ban them to what state law allows, which is anything
- 13:0930 days or lower, we want to ban. So they adopt
- 13:13an operating rule imposing a 30 -day minimum.
- 13:16That's an easy one. That directly conflicts with
- 13:18CCNRs. The rules are not enforceable. Homeowner
- 13:20does not have to follow. We also see that, for
- 13:24example, where HOA in the CCNRs has a rule that
- 13:28says that, let's say, Sprinter vans are not permissible.
- 13:33And then the HOA decides, you know what? Sprinter
- 13:36vans are fine as long as they're not RV conversions.
- 13:39So they say Sprinter Vans are okay unless it's
- 13:42an RV conversion. No, because the CC &R say no
- 13:46Sprinter Vans. It didn't add any kind of a filter
- 13:50or exception to that. So you can't rerun. And
- 13:54we see that happen a lot too. Rules, legitimately
- 14:02speaking, supposed to fill in details or handle
- 14:04things that were referenced in a higher document
- 14:06but not fleshed out. often are used to clarify
- 14:10an existing right that's mentioned in the CCRs,
- 14:13for example, or set published standards on how
- 14:16to view that right. But they can't alter the
- 14:20substance of a right that's granted by a higher
- 14:21doctor. The test is always substance over the
- 14:25label. So as an attorney, if it's form over substance,
- 14:28it's probably not going to be legal. Now we'll
- 14:34start with open meetings and transparency. The
- 14:40most important thing for HOAs at the very top,
- 14:45and in order for them to even work, is that there
- 14:47has to be transparency. In fact, there is a mini
- 14:51within the Davis -Stirling Act called the Open
- 14:53Meeting Act. And it's because of the incredible
- 14:58importance of transparency. And that's why it's
- 15:00baked directly into a part of the Davis -Stirling
- 15:03Act. So the premise is pretty straightforward.
- 15:07make consequential decisions that cost people
- 15:10money and affect people's rights to utilize their
- 15:12personal properties as they see fit. So, and
- 15:16they can do that because it's their job to make
- 15:18sure that money is being spent to maintain, replace
- 15:20and repair common area components, decide things
- 15:24like who to hire, vendor -wise, and they have
- 15:26a lot of important decisions to make. Because
- 15:29those decisions matter and they affect everybody's
- 15:32life on a daily basis, transparency is extremely
- 15:38important. And so the Davis -Stirling Act helps
- 15:40facilitate that in four primary ways. Regulations
- 15:44regarding notice is the first way. Members are
- 15:47entitled, for example, to proper notice in advance
- 15:51of any open meetings. And meetings can include
- 15:56meetings of the board of directors where there's
- 15:57a quorum. Most HOAs in California have five board
- 16:02members. It's just probably, I would say 90%.
- 16:05So three would be a quorum. But even committees
- 16:09that are selected by the board to make decisions
- 16:14and which are seated with at least three board
- 16:17members also have to keep minutes and provide
- 16:22notice and those sorts of things, just like everything
- 16:24else does. So notice is number one, okay? Homeowners
- 16:28are entitled to advance notice of any meeting.
- 16:30The second one is agendas. An open meeting requirement
- 16:34An open meeting requires an agenda, okay? Any
- 16:38committee meeting, any open meeting that homeowners
- 16:42are allowed to attend, and any executive session
- 16:44meeting, which homeowners aren't allowed to attend,
- 16:46but agendas have to be published in advance and
- 16:48they have to be given to all the homeowners,
- 16:50okay? And that's obviously because the board's
- 16:53actions at those meetings are by -law limited
- 16:55to the items that are listed on the agenda. An
- 17:00executive session regarding personnel matters
- 17:03or litigation have to have an agenda that's published
- 17:07to the members, or can that be kept only for
- 17:10the board members? No, and I'll answer that.
- 17:13I'll first say that we are going to go specifically
- 17:15into executive session later on in this. But
- 17:17executive session, what can be discussed? Are
- 17:21there six items that we're going to talk about
- 17:22later? The agenda has to list generally the items
- 17:28to be discussed. So I'll give you an example.
- 17:30One of the more private things is, let's say,
- 17:32discipline on a specific member. The agenda wouldn't
- 17:35need to say, hearing on whether or not to discipline
- 17:39John Smith for violating this rule. It could
- 17:43just say, member discipline issue with two homeless,
- 17:46and leave it at that. It has to say that. Don't
- 17:50have to go into specifics. It's not supposed
- 17:52to betray any of the private material that's
- 17:55being covered, but it has to generally say it
- 17:58so we know, okay, there were two hearings. That's
- 18:00all it needs to be said. But yes, the agenda
- 18:02on executive session has to at least state that.
- 18:05But you could simply say personnel matters and
- 18:08you don't need to name who it is. That's right.
- 18:10You could say go further. I would urge a joy
- 18:13board to say discussing a whether or not to select
- 18:16a new landscaper and leave it at that. You don't
- 18:19have to mention it, but or discussing about the
- 18:21higher a new a new handy person. But you don't
- 18:26have to give a name. Yes, your way would actually
- 18:29suffice for the law. There's a question. There's
- 18:33no limitation on the number of executive board
- 18:36meetings that a board can hold, are there? No.
- 18:39As long as the issues being addressed fall into
- 18:43the statute six, we're going to talk about the
- 18:46fact that the statute is actually problematic
- 18:48and puts the HOAs between a rock and a hard place.
- 18:51I don't normally take that position, but that's
- 18:54an example of a badly written statute. But as
- 18:56long as it falls within The items are all going
- 18:58to be discussed with executive session. If those
- 19:00things come up and they're just, they need to
- 19:02have that kind of meeting a couple of days a
- 19:04week, then that's what's going to happen. There's
- 19:06no way. Thank you. Yeah. So, and then of course
- 19:10we've got attendance, which is members are allowed
- 19:14to attend and observe all open meetings. Again,
- 19:17meetings are executive session and then minutes.
- 19:20Minutes must be kept and the minutes must be
- 19:22finished or at least a Some of the minutes must
- 19:25be finished within 30 days of every meeting.
- 19:28Now, a lot of H2As don't do that. That's a technical
- 19:30violation. It happens all the time. But that's
- 19:32at least what the law says. The operative rule
- 19:35is that last line. Board business can't be conducted
- 19:40inside of a properly noticed open meeting unless
- 19:43it's in one of those exceptions that we just
- 19:45talked about and that we'll talk about later.
- 19:49Can a board take a vote? between scheduled meetings,
- 19:53for example, by email or something if they can't
- 19:57arrange to actually get a meeting together? No.
- 20:01In fact, there's more recent case law on that.
- 20:04We're going to cover that as well later on in
- 20:06this presentation. I'm going to actually cover
- 20:08that specific issue as well. If a decision, and
- 20:13by the way, there's no case law on this. There's
- 20:15a little bit of case law on this. So part of
- 20:17this is my opinion just based on my experience.
- 20:20which I think is pretty well -developed and it's
- 20:22probably pretty trustworthy. But the case law
- 20:27goes a little further than the statute, so the
- 20:29courts have interpreted the statute pretty broadly
- 20:31to allow some sort of discussion. You have these
- 20:35town halls that are permitted. What can't happen
- 20:37is there can't be a decision to act or not act,
- 20:41or even a decision to do it at a later time.
- 20:45Unless it's something to say, look, We'll make
- 20:48a decision during our open meeting on this. That
- 20:50you can say. But if you start to cross that line
- 20:53into, OK, how do we feel we want to go? Which
- 20:56direction we want to go? You're now in the decision
- 20:57-making category. You have violated the law.
- 21:01If I might go back to the prior. Topic I'm sorry
- 21:04just for a moment because we had a question that
- 21:05came in late and I had another comment but about
- 21:09the hierarchy of things just people obviously
- 21:12would hopefully realize that the CCNR is a recorded
- 21:15so you can get those as recorded documents but
- 21:17when your client or somebody is buying something
- 21:21in a. of Strava -Stirling development. The bylaws
- 21:25are something that you need to get as part of
- 21:28a package. Most HOAs are going to charge some
- 21:31fee when the new owner comes in to give them
- 21:34the package that's required to be delivered.
- 21:36But you need to make certain you're getting that
- 21:38package, which also includes financial information
- 21:41that you'll look at on the association. And then
- 21:44the question that we had is, if a CCNR provision
- 21:49prohibiting obstruction of neighborhood views
- 21:52that indirectly leads to the inability to build
- 21:56an ADU in a backyard enforceable. And I'm in
- 21:59an HOA, but we're not Davis -Stirling. And we
- 22:01have this problem all the time with view obstructions.
- 22:06But on a Davis -Stirling development, their question
- 22:08is, if it's view restricted in the CCNRs, can
- 22:12that mean if your ADU is going to block views,
- 22:14you can't build it? OK, and that is a great question.
- 22:19And it's one of the ones that we've gotten before.
- 22:21And I've got an article on that somewhere on
- 22:23my website under the Libraries tab. I've got
- 22:26a fact sheet on that issue. There's some case
- 22:28law, not a lot. There might be one or two cases,
- 22:31as I recall off the top of my head, that go into
- 22:33that. The public policy behind ADU's is very
- 22:37strong. And as a result, when there's a challenge
- 22:43between a specific view, and by the way, the
- 22:46CCNRs would have to be, there would have to be
- 22:48a very specific view coordinate, like by mathematical
- 22:52footage or angle. That is not going to trump
- 22:57ADU. So if there was a way to construct the ADU
- 23:01so it doesn't block the view that is protected
- 23:03under the governing documents, then an HOA can
- 23:06require that. But if there's no way to do it,
- 23:10if the property is situated such that The HOA,
- 23:14that there's no way to build a compliant ADU
- 23:17on the property without looking at view, the
- 23:20ADU is going to drop. That's at least the way
- 23:22it looks like the courts are going right now.
- 23:26And that creates some difficulties when it happens,
- 23:32but we've actually seen that happen very few
- 23:34times. We consult 30 to 50 new clients. a week.
- 23:41It might be probably closer to 50 clients a week.
- 23:45And I can count on one hand in the last couple
- 23:46of years that issue has come up. Now, view stuff
- 23:49comes up all the time, but not in terms of an
- 23:52ADU. Thank you. Yeah. I think that's the best
- 23:56I can give right now. So we've just kind of talked
- 24:01about the Open Meeting Act. Now let's talk about
- 24:05the fact that the label isn't what's important.
- 24:07Again, For most part, the Davis -Stirling Act
- 24:11is written in plain English. And it does a relatively
- 24:16good job of passing a message on that it's really
- 24:20form over substance. So if you've got a gathering
- 24:23or a quorum of directors, so if you've got three
- 24:27directors meeting at the pool or talking on an
- 24:30email, and they are deliberating about HOA -related
- 24:33business or making decisions, it's a board meeting.
- 24:38And it doesn't matter if they call it a planning
- 24:40session or a town hall or a workshop or an informal
- 24:43meeting or an email chain. We see that all the
- 24:45time. It's the delivery meeting or making decisions
- 24:49on substantive HOA -related business that makes
- 24:52it a meeting, no matter what they call it. So
- 24:57if they're calling it a town hall and it's really
- 24:59not, it's going further, then they've violated
- 25:02the notice, the agenda, the member attendance
- 25:05rights, and the minutes requirement. That's what
- 25:08gets H2As in trouble. There is a nuance though,
- 25:11and you gotta be precise. The statutes list here,
- 25:16discuss, or deliberate. This is what I was talking
- 25:19about a second ago. If you look at Civil Code
- 25:224090, 4090, in the definition section, the key
- 25:27point for your practices is that it defines board
- 25:30meeting very functionally by what the directors
- 25:33are doing. not by what they're calling it. So
- 25:38that label is less important than the substance.
- 25:44Looking at the statute itself, it uses those
- 25:48words. It uses, let's see, if it's deciding,
- 25:57deliberating or hearing or discussing, okay?
- 26:01A genuinely informational gathering, like where
- 26:04members ask questions and the board gives updates.
- 26:07Let's say there's a major construction event
- 26:10that's gonna be occurring throughout the community.
- 26:11New roofs are going on. There might be a town
- 26:14hall where the board sits in front, meets in
- 26:17the green area somewhere and answers questions
- 26:19that are being peppered to them by the homeowners.
- 26:21And, hey, what's the status here? What's going
- 26:23on? Will we hire this guy and this company starting
- 26:26soon? Those don't require any deliberation or
- 26:29decisions. It's truly informational. Those are
- 26:31true town hall meetings. Those aren't open meetings.
- 26:33You don't have to abide by anything because they're
- 26:36not deliberating or hearing anything. But when
- 26:40you get a gathering where they cross into deliberation
- 26:45or where they actually vote and make a decision,
- 26:48now you've crossed that line and it requires
- 26:50the different elements that we talked about in
- 26:53the prior slide, the notice, the right for homeowners
- 26:56to attend, an agenda in advance, and the minutes.
- 27:03You'll find these obligations, by the way, for
- 27:05the most part, we're talking about the Davis
- 27:07-Stirling Act today, but some of this is also
- 27:09found in the corporations code because 99 % of
- 27:12the H2As in California are mutual benefit nonprofit
- 27:15corporations. The corporations code is often
- 27:18going to be important and it's going to control.
- 27:23If there's a conflict, by the way, between something
- 27:26in the corporations code, we find this a couple
- 27:28of times. And the Davis -Stirling Act relating
- 27:31to HOA matter, Davis -Stirling Act will control
- 27:33over the corporation's code. So members' right
- 27:37to speak is a big issue that comes up a lot more
- 27:41than you might think. Civil Code 4925 and 4930
- 27:46gives members the right to speak at a board meeting.
- 27:48And for those of you who live in HOAs, you've
- 27:51known this under different names. A lot of them
- 27:52call it the open forum or open floor session.
- 27:55And this is where it's offered at the beginning
- 27:57of a meeting where they give homeowners a minute
- 27:59or two to say something. That is required. Now,
- 28:05HOAs can control the timing on that. They have
- 28:07to allow a reasonable amount of time. And courts
- 28:09have held that two minutes is reasonable. So
- 28:12they have to allow sufficient time. But they
- 28:15have to have that session, whether it's at the
- 28:18beginning or the end of a meeting, they've got
- 28:20to have that open floor. 4925 gives members a
- 28:24set amount of time to speak on matters related.
- 28:27So what does that mean? Matters related, because
- 28:28a lot of boarders, this is where a lot of H .O
- 28:31.A. boards will use this statute to ban somebody
- 28:35from speaking because it's not on the agenda.
- 28:37Okay? A board can set reasonable time limits,
- 28:42as I've said, and they can enforce basic rules
- 28:44of decorum, you know, using foul language, interrupting
- 28:48other people, being threatening, that sort of
- 28:50thing. They can shut you down for that. OK, that
- 28:52makes sense. What they can't do is shout somebody
- 28:56down or mute them because they're speaking about
- 28:59things that are not on the agenda. And this is
- 29:00in 4930. It's crystal clear. Agendas are for
- 29:04boards, not for members. So during open forum,
- 29:07members are not limited to items on the agenda.
- 29:10They can speak about any topic they want as long
- 29:13as it's related in some way to the HOA or life
- 29:17in an HOA. And that's almost carte blanche, to
- 29:20be honest. And we see this abuse all the time.
- 29:24You have people, either if you're attending on
- 29:26Zoom, they shut your Zoom off or they mute you,
- 29:28or they will mute your microphone if they don't
- 29:31like what you're talking about. If you're calling
- 29:33out board members for committing all sorts of
- 29:36wrongs, from gross negligence to embezzlement
- 29:38or fraud, they'll often shut you down. They can't
- 29:41do that. That's illegal. If you have a client
- 29:42that comes to you and they get downed down or
- 29:45silenced for raising issues with the assessments
- 29:48or elections or the unfairness of it, and they're
- 29:51shut down, you've got, there's a weapon right
- 29:53there that you've got, that the board's actually
- 29:55violating the law, and specifically 4930. Now,
- 29:59let's talk about those six topics, an executive
- 30:01session. And I'll also talk partly about the
- 30:05problem, a very real problem that exists. First
- 30:08of all, courts have said executive session is
- 30:10an exhaustive list, it's not a catch -all. So,
- 30:14that means that you can only discuss the things
- 30:17that are referenced in the statute. So Civil
- 30:20Code 4935 is the Executive Session Statute. It's
- 30:24the only one. The single most important thing
- 30:27to understand about it is that this is it. There
- 30:31are six things that are listed here. And that
- 30:36leaves a major problem. Let's first talk about
- 30:38those things. So one, litigation, pending or
- 30:41anticipated litigation, or current litigation.
- 30:46That's pre -booked. anything related to litigation
- 30:50or the threat of litigation can be discussed
- 30:52in executive session. Second one is third party
- 30:55contracts. So that's whether it's contracts with
- 30:58a vendor, contracts with a management company,
- 31:00contracts with a handy person, contracts with
- 31:02landscapers, whatever contract that the H -Wave
- 31:06had to enter with any third party is allowed
- 31:09to be done in executive session. Third is member
- 31:12discipline. Now this is actually up to the homeowner.
- 31:14Technically the statute says that if the homeowner's
- 31:18request This should be done in executive session,
- 31:21which implies pretty strongly that if a homeowner
- 31:23never requested, it could be done in an open
- 31:25meeting. Except most HOAs just protect themselves,
- 31:30automatically have an executive session, and
- 31:32automatically do it in a private hearing, and
- 31:35that's permissible. This, in all matters, is
- 31:39number four. And that's people that actually
- 31:41work for you that are employed as either W -2
- 31:44or 1099. But really, it's for the W -2 employees.
- 31:48And depending on the size of your HOA, some HOAs,
- 31:51a lot of smaller HOAs don't have any full -time
- 31:54employees. But the bigger ones will have their
- 31:57own group of landscapers. Instead of farming
- 31:59it out, they'll have their own people. Or they'll
- 32:01have one or two handy people. That's what personnel
- 32:06matters. And so we're talking about employee
- 32:07issues. And of course, that's going to be private.
- 32:09And then payment plans, somebody's running, you
- 32:12know, got a homeowner, it's running into a problem
- 32:15keeping up with either the regular monthly dues,
- 32:17their assessments, or they have trouble paying
- 32:19a special assessment, they reach some sort of
- 32:21agreement, get on a payment plan, that has to
- 32:25be done in private and therefore is acceptable
- 32:27in executive session. And the last one is, the
- 32:30board has to decide whether or not to pursue
- 32:33foreclosure against somebody that hasn't paid
- 32:35an assessment, that has to be done in private
- 32:38and therefore, needs to be discussed in executive
- 32:41session. Now, that's it. If you go to some of
- 32:44the larger HOA site platforms, including the
- 32:48biggest one in California, and you look at their
- 32:51website, and you look at their articles on executive
- 32:54session, they have a lot of stuff to this list,
- 32:57and that is illegal. And that's a problem because
- 32:59guess what? In many cases, the HOAs are right.
- 33:04But the problem is the statute says what it says.
- 33:06And because of that, until they amend that statute
- 33:10or the court makes a decision that says we're
- 33:13going to expand the reading, it's actually illegal.
- 33:16I'll give you a great example. If it doesn't
- 33:18fall into these, it absolutely should be private.
- 33:22And that is you have a homeowner who wants to
- 33:24be able to board a seat. They've got some sort
- 33:26of disability, and they want to seek an accommodation.
- 33:28So you have a homeowner with mobility issues.
- 33:31And they want to have a red -curved area right
- 33:33by their house. painted white for them or painted
- 33:37a different color so they can use it, you know,
- 33:39a handicap zone so they can use it as a parking
- 33:41area. That shouldn't be public. That should be
- 33:45private. And yet it doesn't fall under any of
- 33:48these. Well, it could. You had a home that was
- 33:53disabled start parking in a place that wasn't
- 33:55legal and they set a hearing notice out and at
- 33:57the hearing, member discipline, they reached
- 34:00an agreement It wouldn't be covered there, but
- 34:03only because of that member discipline aspect.
- 34:05But a homeowner doing the right thing and trying
- 34:07to go into the interactive process that's required
- 34:10by state and federal law would be a loop if they
- 34:14follow the statute directly, because there's
- 34:17no mechanism for this to be private, and it should
- 34:19be. It's not anybody else's business what disability
- 34:22somebody has and what accommodations they're
- 34:24asking for. And yet you have a huge gap in the
- 34:28law. I've written on this and we've actually
- 34:31been trying to work with our legislature to try
- 34:33to get an amendment to 49 .35 to open up that
- 34:38list a little bit more because it helps homeowners.
- 34:40I represent homeowners and if I represent a disabled
- 34:43homeowner, I want that homeowner to be comfortable
- 34:45asking for an accommodation without having to
- 34:48worry about whether or not this is going to become,
- 34:50you know, public record for the community. We
- 34:54did have a question as to whether an HOA member
- 34:57can have access to committee meetings. Okay,
- 35:03committee meeting. There is a quarter of directors,
- 35:07that is, they have power. Then yes, if, however,
- 35:12you have one or two directors and then you just
- 35:14have members at large and they have to report
- 35:17to the board, then no, you don't. What about
- 35:21an architectural committee meeting? I've got
- 35:24an article right on point on my website on that.
- 35:27It's the same rule. If the architectural committee
- 35:31is composed of three or more directors, then
- 35:34they can make architectural decisions about going
- 35:36to the board at large. If they can do that, then
- 35:39they are the board because it's a quorum, at
- 35:42least the quorum acting and therefore it's subject
- 35:44to the open meeting act. If it's the president
- 35:48of the board and then some homeowners at large,
- 35:50then nothing they do can be definitive. They
- 35:53make a recommendation, and it might be a rubber
- 35:55stamp, but at least technically they gotta go
- 35:57to the board and let the board decide, then you
- 35:59would not need to hold a meeting. What if the
- 36:02architectural committee makes a decision initially,
- 36:04but there's a right of an appeal to the board?
- 36:07No, that's a meeting. Because there's already
- 36:09a right of appeal built into the statute. That
- 36:11already exists. So you know we're at 40 minutes.
- 36:15Okay, I'm going to speed up a lot. Let's talk
- 36:19about records and enforcement. I am going to
- 36:20go much quicker because I do want to allow for
- 36:22a question and answer as well. And all of the
- 36:25stuff that I'm talking about in here, I've included
- 36:28in the handout a 6 ,000 word article that I wrote
- 36:32that goes through this in even more detail that
- 36:35goes through the entire Davis -Stirling Act.
- 36:36So you'll find all this in that. But basically,
- 36:39when we talk about 5 ,200, we're talking about
- 36:415 ,200 EPSAT, which is anywhere from 5 ,200 through
- 36:445 ,325, let's say. Um, and hope you just have
- 36:50an incredibly broad light to a whole lot of documents.
- 36:53Basically, the HOA is spending money from a homeowner,
- 36:57you know, spending homeowner money to do or make
- 36:59decisions that clients are going to or the members
- 37:02are going to have a right to see that document.
- 37:04So it includes, you know, not only the traditional
- 37:07financial stuff like bank statements and copies
- 37:10of checks and, and ledgers and, and invoices
- 37:14and, and taxes and all that, but also all of
- 37:17the government documents, election materials,
- 37:19reserve materials, the Balcony Inspection Act,
- 37:22even attorney -client fee agreement, which is
- 37:25normally privileged, but that document is not
- 37:28privileged, it's specifically permitted under
- 37:31the 5200 documents. It's actually quite broad,
- 37:34so if you've never looked at that statute, I
- 37:35recommend you look at it because it's, homeowners
- 37:38can really get a lot of documents. And there
- 37:41are some real teeth. A board that will not give,
- 37:44documents that they are obligated to give to
- 37:46a homeowner can get $500 in sanctions per category
- 37:51of document they request and a one -way statute
- 37:54for attorney's fees and costs. And so, this is
- 38:00what we do all the time and we've gotten, you
- 38:03know, our typical 5200 demand will include anywhere
- 38:06from 15 to 20 categories of documents. Well,
- 38:09let's say you're asking for around 20 categories
- 38:11of documents at $500 a piece, You're over $10
- 38:14,000 in sanctions alone. Never mind attorneys
- 38:18fees. So there is a very, very strong fee shifting
- 38:23aspect to the 5200 right. And it is a powerful
- 38:26right. And it's these documents that all the
- 38:28homeowners to the best of their ability figure
- 38:32out what's going on with their age away. Stuff
- 38:33that should be in there that aren't or things
- 38:36that don't make sense that are conflicting with
- 38:38prior things or give people evidence that, hey,
- 38:41we might have an investment problem. a gross
- 38:44negligence problem. And the statutory deadlines,
- 38:47there's three that you got to know about, and
- 38:49it's very easy. Five days, 10 days, and 30 days.
- 38:52Five days, the membership list. And by the way,
- 38:55membership list is the only one of all the documents
- 38:59that you're entitled to see as a homeowner. It's
- 39:01the only one that they can require you to have
- 39:04a legitimate reason for. And it's a very, very
- 39:07broad reason. It's basically any legitimate reason
- 39:10that relates to the business of the HOA. They
- 39:13can make you state Every other document you can
- 39:17have one because you want and they doesn't matter
- 39:19why they have no say So that's got to be done
- 39:22in five minutes and by the way that includes
- 39:24email addresses phone numbers names and property
- 39:28addresses and the only exception is if a homeowner
- 39:30has opted out in writing that a homeowner can
- 39:33opt out of having their name disclosed of their
- 39:35address or all of their information but other
- 39:38than that and that almost never happens you would
- 39:40like to see the name of everybody, where they
- 39:42live, their emails, all that. So that's five
- 39:44days. 10 days, basically current financials.
- 39:47And then 30 days is everything else. That's it.
- 39:51We talked about the fee shifting already. I did
- 39:52that in the last, once I can skip that. Now we
- 39:58move into elections. So elections are governed
- 40:01by 5 ,100 to 5 ,145. Elections, not just electing
- 40:07a director, but whether or not the CCOs need
- 40:09to be amended. whether or not a special assessment
- 40:11of over, you know, 5 % of the budgeted expenses
- 40:15for that year, because that requires homeowner
- 40:18a vote, that's what I mean by election. Elections
- 40:20in the HOA are done by secret ballot, require
- 40:24selection of either one or three independent
- 40:26inspectors, and all of them must give equal access
- 40:29to candidates and board members. So if there's
- 40:32a Facebook that is operated by the HOA and a
- 40:35board member is running for election, let's say,
- 40:38is talking about him or herself, then they've
- 40:41got to open it up to all the candidates equal,
- 40:43say with use of the clubhouse or any other amenities.
- 40:47So the bottom line on elections in HOAs is they
- 40:51must be fair. They must be impartial. They must
- 40:54be secret. And homeowners that want to fight
- 41:00an unfair election or something that's been done
- 41:02illegally, they have a year to do it. And they
- 41:05can do it in small claims court and they can
- 41:07do it in superior court. 5110, for example, is
- 41:11the process that requires the independent inspector.
- 41:14What makes them independent? Well, it can't be
- 41:16a board member. It can't be anybody that's running
- 41:19for the board. It can't be a family member of
- 41:21anybody running for the board. It can't be anyone
- 41:23that's under a contract with the HOA. For example,
- 41:27so many HOAs select their management company
- 41:29or somebody from the management company to be
- 41:31an inspector. It's completely illegal because
- 41:33management companies are under contract, but
- 41:35yet you see it every day. can't do that. It's
- 41:38got to be completely independent, so they have
- 41:40to be 18 or older, and it got to be completely
- 41:42independent. It can be a homeowner that's not
- 41:45running, but that homeowner better understand
- 41:47the legal duties. So a lot of HOAs, especially
- 41:50well -run ones, use professional management companies
- 41:52that run, or professional inspector companies
- 41:54that do only this. Especially now that we've
- 41:57got electronic voting, if your HOA goes that
- 42:00way, you want somebody that understands all the
- 42:03ins and outs of how to run those electronic voting
- 42:05machines. or the electronic voting algorithms.
- 42:07You need somebody that knows that because it
- 42:09is complicated. I once overturned an election
- 42:12at a two tower development on Ocean Avenue in
- 42:15Santa Monica where somebody acting as an inspector
- 42:17of election walked around to the other side of
- 42:19the table to turn in a bunch of proxies and they
- 42:22put up a new slate that got elected supposedly
- 42:24at that election. Was that the two white buildings
- 42:29right on the ocean near the pier? 515 Ocean Avenue.
- 42:37Okay, I think if I think I know which bill is
- 42:40wrong. We litigated against that HOA on several
- 42:42occasions. That HOA has had a monumental history
- 42:47of being very badly run. So I'm not surprised
- 42:50to hear that. But great comment. Thank you on
- 42:53that. Let's talk about manipulation and how to
- 42:56challenge it because you see and this is what
- 43:00you was just talking about. The best HOAs manipulate
- 43:04elections in a variety of ways, okay? The tactics
- 43:07that I've got listed here, the incumbent protection
- 43:11playbook used by that HOA is all over the place.
- 43:14So nomination notices, for example, that go out
- 43:16late or not at all, or candidates get disqualified
- 43:19or invented on pretextual grounds, the violation
- 43:24of the statute, or the political success to association
- 43:27media. We see that a lot with Facebook or...
- 43:30or HOA owned or HOA managed websites. We see
- 43:34that a lot. Where the board slate gets the newsletter
- 43:37and the challenges get nothing. Board slate gets
- 43:39to utilize all these tools and the challenges
- 43:41get nothing. That's illegal. Or misuse of HOA
- 43:45resources to campaign for incumbents. Here's
- 43:49a big one, last minute rule changes. Or last
- 43:51minute change in the slate. You can't do that.
- 43:56When you stack a couple of these together, you
- 43:58get really bad results and turnout. So if it's
- 44:04a bad HOA, they're trying to engineer the election.
- 44:06It's very obvious what they're doing. It's easy
- 44:08to spot. That's the good thing. So under 5145,
- 44:12a member can challenge the election in court,
- 44:15and relief is very broad. And courts can, including
- 44:18small claims, which is not the norm, they can
- 44:21have compliance. They can order injunctive relief.
- 44:23They can invalidate results. They can require
- 44:26that procedures be corrected, they can require
- 44:27a new election, they can impose statutory penalties,
- 44:31they can award attorney's fees. Again, one -way
- 44:33statute, even if the homeowner wins and they
- 44:37prove that the, if the HOA wins and they prove
- 44:41that the homeowner's case was frivolous, they
- 44:43still only get their costs, they don't get fees.
- 44:45So it's very powerful fee -shifting on this.
- 44:48So they were certainly, that's very clear, do
- 44:50not mess with elections. Yes, Howard. Yeah, they
- 44:53may order that new election under the auspices
- 44:56of, for example, a retired judge, which they
- 44:58did in my case, and that in order to make certain
- 45:01things are fair. And there was a question that
- 45:04if you don't have an independent inspector of
- 45:06election, what's the remedy? And I think that's
- 45:08the remedy, then you go in to have the election
- 45:10overturned at a new election. So here's what
- 45:13the courts have said on when to overturn the
- 45:16election. But not having an inspector is enough
- 45:18by itself. If the thing that was done wrong,
- 45:22would have reasonably made a difference in the
- 45:25outcome, then they will throw the whole election
- 45:27out. If it's a de minimis issue, and it wouldn't
- 45:31have made a difference in the end result, then
- 45:34of course it's gonna be a lot less likely to
- 45:36throw the entire election out. But if you don't
- 45:40have an inspector, that election's done. Because
- 45:44the inspector's the only one that's allowed to
- 45:46have custody of or access to any of the ballots.
- 45:50and the only one that's allowed to open the ballots
- 45:53and put them in the little hoppers for the count.
- 45:58You cannot have a board member storing ballots
- 46:00in the garage. You can't have the ballots being
- 46:04received by the management company and then sent
- 46:06to the inspector. Can't do any of that. If you
- 46:08don't have an inspector, you've just multiplied
- 46:10the wrongs there. So your election is over before
- 46:14it even started, if that's the case. You don't
- 46:16see that a lot anymore, but to the extent you
- 46:18did, it'd be a slam dunk. Oh, thanks. That's
- 46:21a great clarification. Thank you. So next is
- 46:23discipline, disputes, and money. And discipline
- 46:26is the big one because I'm sure the lawyers that
- 46:29are sitting on here have all heard of AB 130.
- 46:32It went into effect mid -year last year. And
- 46:35it took an issue that absolutely needed to be
- 46:40addressed in litigation. But it is such a stupid
- 46:44law. It was passed as a last -minute amendment.
- 46:48on an ombudsman, I always have trouble with this
- 46:51word, ombudsman budgetary bill. It didn't even,
- 46:56it sailed through committee. It left a whole
- 46:59host of unintended consequences out that have
- 47:02made it a complete mess that we are now seeing
- 47:05come to fruition. I've made a bunch of predictions.
- 47:07The week that it came out, that went into effect
- 47:10and all the predictions I made a year ago are
- 47:13coming through now. It did do certain things
- 47:16that were good. and one of the big the most famous
- 47:18thing it did was is it said guess what guys hundred
- 47:22dollar cap on all fines for violation of a rule
- 47:25so all those fine schedules that had escalating
- 47:28fines illegal gone okay uh so let's talk about
- 47:33ab 130 in general first ab 130 affected a lot
- 47:37of different statutes by the way including the
- 47:39eight the uh adu statute and the solar statutes
- 47:42uh but it's big the most uh affected had was
- 47:47on two parts of the Civil Code in the Davis -Strong
- 47:49Act, 5850 and 5855. And those govern discipline.
- 47:54And there are four requirements. If you miss
- 47:57any of them, you being the 828, or to miss any
- 47:59of these, it's failed with the discipline. So
- 48:02there has to be a published fine schedule. And
- 48:04the fine schedule has to have the fines illegally
- 48:06stated. It's got to get rid of anything over
- 48:08100. If there's no a published fine schedule,
- 48:14no discipline. You can discipline. I guess you
- 48:17could say naughty, naughty, or you could maybe
- 48:19suspend rights, but you cannot find them. That
- 48:23part would be illegal. Two, notice under 5855,
- 48:28a 10 -day notice. If you're going to set a hearing,
- 48:31you've got to give at least 10 days before the
- 48:32hearing date. You've got to state the violation.
- 48:34Here's what you did wrong. Here's what we're
- 48:37thinking of doing to you. Here's your hearing
- 48:39date. Here's the time. See you then. And then,
- 48:42of course, you have to have that hearing and
- 48:44a member is permitted to appear, whether by Zoom
- 48:47or in person is up to the people deciding. It's
- 48:50not important, but they have a right to appear
- 48:52and, more importantly, respond to anything that's
- 48:55being, to any of the allegations that have been
- 48:57set forth against them and to introduce evidence,
- 49:00to provide pictures or statements from other
- 49:03homeowners, anything that they feel will help
- 49:05their case. The hearing should be held in executive
- 49:07session and homeowners have an absolute legal
- 49:10right to bring an attorney. Now, the HOA does,
- 49:12too. And then the HOA must, at termination of
- 49:18the hearing, within 14 days, give a written decision
- 49:21and send it out to the homeowner. Those have
- 49:25to be required. If any of those are skipped,
- 49:28then you're done as a board. You skip notice,
- 49:30you skip the hearing, or you rubber stamp the
- 49:32outcome, miss that 14 -day deadline, discipline
- 49:34fails. So this is a great little checklist for
- 49:39a client. You look to these, no fine schedule,
- 49:42done. Ten day notice, done, et cetera. Now, here's
- 49:48the discipline regime. It capped, paid violation
- 49:52at $100, so you can never have a bigger fine
- 49:56than that. And then you get a lot of HAAs that
- 49:58go, oh, okay, here's what we're gonna do. We're
- 49:59gonna do something called stacking. We're gonna
- 50:02send you a hearing letter on Monday for this
- 50:04illegal whatever. And then we're going to send
- 50:06you another one on Tuesday, another one on Wednesday,
- 50:08another one on Thursday, and we're going to set
- 50:09different hearings. We're going to fine you $100
- 50:10per. That won't work. It's all one violation.
- 50:14Won't work. Now, I won't get into it in this,
- 50:17but I do get into it in the article. That creates,
- 50:20that's one of the big problems that AB 130 created
- 50:22because it incentivizes homeowners to say, you
- 50:25know what? That's cost of doing business. I'm
- 50:27going to build this illegal balcony, and then
- 50:29I'm just going to take the fine. So it's forcing
- 50:31HLAs into skipping finding and going right to
- 50:34a lawsuit to enforce governing documents, which
- 50:36is more expensive for everybody. It is a mess.
- 50:38And if we're seeing it happen right now, well,
- 50:42a hundred dollars on the limit, no interest or
- 50:44late fees on discipline or fines, basically for
- 50:48discipline money. If they don't pay, you don't
- 50:50get interest. You don't get late fees. There's
- 50:52no pure rights that are built into, uh, into,
- 50:57uh, 58, 50, 58, 55, for example, If they notice
- 51:02a hearing, because I have something hanging in
- 51:06the common area I'm not supposed to have, and
- 51:08my hearing is set for 10 days later, and between
- 51:11the time of the notice and the hearing, I fix
- 51:14the issue. I take care of it. The hearing must
- 51:16go off -counter. There can be no hearing, and
- 51:18there can be no fine. It just must be, oh, thank
- 51:21you. You're done. OK, we're good. That's it.
- 51:24You have a right to post hearing or during hearing
- 51:26a IVR, internal dispute resolution. Again, that's
- 51:30a homeowner, right? Not an HOA, right? And then
- 51:33you can actually enter into agreements. This
- 51:35isn't new. This existed in the former statute,
- 51:38but it was refined a little bit. You can enter
- 51:41into enforceable agreements at the hearing that
- 51:44are enforceable in court. So the five things
- 51:48to remember, basically, are AD 130 to a lot of
- 51:53things, but it limited to $500. It banned interest
- 51:56and late fees. it provided cure rights, it gave
- 52:00rights to post -hearing IDR, and it tightened
- 52:03out the enforceable hearing agreement that could
- 52:07be reached during the hearing. Now, there's two
- 52:11pre -litigation tools that are important in HOA
- 52:15law. One of them is IDR, 5900 -5915, and the
- 52:19other one is ADR. I'm going to be very brief
- 52:21about this. ADR is completely voluntary on the
- 52:26part of the homeowner. No matter what governing
- 52:30documents say, there are a lot of governing documents
- 52:32out there that say before you can engage in ADR
- 52:35or file a lawsuit, you must engage in IDR. Those
- 52:38are void as a matter of law, okay? ADR is mandatory
- 52:42if a homeowner requests it. And all that means
- 52:45is that at least one member of the board is agreed
- 52:48to sit down with the homeowner and try to work
- 52:51out their dispute informally. Both sides can
- 52:53have their lawyers there at their own expense,
- 52:57but nothing, it's just sitting down with the
- 53:00other side and trying to talk it out. In my experience,
- 53:04unless you have a board that is just mistaken
- 53:06and good faith on something and you just need
- 53:08to clear it up, in which case IDR is a good idea,
- 53:11it's usually a waste of time. If you're dealing
- 53:12with egos, if you're dealing with bad feelings
- 53:15or hatred that we see between certain homeowners
- 53:18and their board, IDR is always a waste of time.
- 53:21It's always can't require it, but they must agree
- 53:24to it. And if they don't, they get a lot of trouble.
- 53:27ADR is a little different. If you are bringing
- 53:31a claim for injunctive declaratory writ relief,
- 53:37you are bringing those claims in conjunction
- 53:39with money damages on less than $12 ,500, IP
- 53:44small claims court. You must engage in ADR before
- 53:48you can file a lawsuit. That goes for both sides.
- 53:50And in the context of the Davis -Stirling Act,
- 53:53ADR means mediation. In all the other cases,
- 53:56it's not required. And in most cases, if you
- 53:59can have damages, actual money damages are going
- 54:02to be more than $12 ,500. So it's almost never
- 54:05actually required unless seeking injunctive writ
- 54:08and or declaratory relief. So I would say we
- 54:12push most people into ADR, but in most cases,
- 54:14it's not technically required. But all the cases
- 54:18where it's required, You must engage in that
- 54:21because if you didn't, the other side calls you
- 54:23out. They can demand. That demand is going to
- 54:25get sustained with leave to amend, but it will
- 54:27be sustained. More importantly, there's a consequence
- 54:32for failing to abide by an ADR demand when it
- 54:36is required. And here's what we nail a lot of
- 54:39HOAs. An HOA, for example, refuses an ADR demand
- 54:44and they end up This case goes to trial and the
- 54:48HLA ends up prevailing. The judge can take their
- 54:53refusal to engage in ADR into account in deciding
- 54:56on whether or not to award them attorney's fees.
- 54:59And let's say they have 150 grand attorney's
- 55:02fees. A judge, we've seen judges say, well, and
- 55:06these are, we've never lost, knock on wood, we've
- 55:09never lost in court. But we've seen this happen
- 55:12where judges have said, well, HLA, I'm gonna
- 55:15give you 10 ,000 because you could have resolved
- 55:18this at ADR, tried and you rejected it and forced
- 55:21them to go through this. Judges can do that.
- 55:25And so there's a, because of that, very few H2As
- 55:28nowadays refuse a valid ADR domain. Now, let's
- 55:34go to 4765, perhaps one of the most important
- 55:37statutes in the Davis -Stirling Act because that's
- 55:39where the architectural control is found. So
- 55:42architectural authority on an HOA is wrong, but
- 55:45it's not a personal taste type of authority.
- 55:49Its entire purpose is to anchor in principle
- 55:53that an HOA has a reasonable right to make good
- 55:59faith requirements or good faith decisions on
- 56:02things that will affect the aesthetic of the
- 56:05neighborhood. CC and honors that They can ban
- 56:14something that is, let's say, not harmonious,
- 56:17but there has to be a good faith basis for it.
- 56:20Decisions by an architectural committee or by
- 56:23a board can't be arbitrary, they can't be capricious.
- 56:26If they are grounded in a limitation set forth
- 56:30in one of the governing documents, CCNRs or rules,
- 56:34and it's applied evenly, there's no selective
- 56:37enforcement, and it's not arbitrary and not capricious,
- 56:40if it's reasonable, then it's going to be upheld
- 56:42as a power to limit. But there has to be a written
- 56:46standard. There has to be written reasons. And
- 56:48that's the thing. If you get denied, the HOA
- 56:52has to tell you why you were denied. They're
- 56:54supposed to tell you what you're trying to get,
- 56:57what this fence or this balcony is violating
- 56:58this section of the CCNRs. Here's what you need
- 57:01to do to fix it. That's what they're supposed
- 57:03to do. So you ask yourself, what do you demand
- 57:08in a denial? It's got to have, it's got to state
- 57:10the written standard that's being relied on.
- 57:12It's got to have a written reason. The version
- 57:14of the guideline being applied, the decision
- 57:16maker's names, if you're on the board or committee
- 57:19that voted a certain way, and then comparable
- 57:21approvals showing how similar requests were treated,
- 57:23you can demand, okay? Always make sure the HOA
- 57:28provides a written description of all of them.
- 57:32And I make that demand in writing on behalf of
- 57:34a client. And if an HOA says no, I can't force
- 57:37them on a couple of those, I can't force it,
- 57:39but boy does that look bad to record. Now, there
- 57:42are certain things that have, and we talked at
- 57:45the beginning about these statutorily protected
- 57:47rights, that HOAs have very little to no discretionary
- 57:53powers. And the big six are solar energy, ADUs,
- 57:58alternative dwelling units, like grand flats,
- 58:01that sort of thing. direct resistant landscaping,
- 58:03flags and clotheslines, satellite dishes, and
- 58:06EV charging. The public policy behind each of
- 58:09those are powerful. And this slide is a good
- 58:13example of a harder limit on architectural control
- 58:16because California was very strongly overpowered
- 58:19and overrides authority by HOAs when it comes
- 58:22to these things. So for example, let's talk about
- 58:27solar energy systems. The code basically says,
- 58:31it's 714 and 714 .1. The code basically says,
- 58:36if, you know, an HOA can prevent you from installing
- 58:39solar panels if it's going to somehow affect
- 58:42somebody else's rights, or it's going to create
- 58:45a health and safety issue somehow. In nine days,
- 58:49with technology being the way it is, that's coming
- 58:52less and less. It used to be, there used to be
- 58:54some fire hazards with really cheap materials.
- 58:56You don't see that anymore. Solar energy systems
- 58:58basically says, hey, HOA, if you're demanding
- 59:02of the homeowner is going to the energy capacity
- 59:07by 10 % so that maybe the amount of wattage that
- 59:10this thing can save by 20 % or 10 % or increases
- 59:15the cost of this solar energy system by $1 ,000
- 59:17or more, you have no say. That is very powerful
- 59:21because pretty much every solar company out there
- 59:25has dealt with HOAs, there's 60 ,000 in California
- 59:28alone. So they know exactly how to position these
- 59:31things, these applications, they take care of
- 59:33it for you. And they almost make it impossible
- 59:35for an HOA to do anything. In fact, it's such
- 59:38a powerful system or such a powerful policy that
- 59:41even condo owners with a shared roof, think about
- 59:45this, they have a right to solar panels. In every
- 59:49other case, HOAs have an almost godlike universal
- 59:53power over common area. They could shut you down
- 59:55on the common area whenever they want. But when
- 59:57it comes to solar energy, even condo owners have
- 1:00:01a statutory right to put solar panels on their
- 1:00:04pro -recent portion of the roof. And as long
- 1:00:08as their panels don't block somebody else's light
- 1:00:12or interfere with somebody else's, then the HOA
- 1:00:15can't do a damn thing about it. And that is a
- 1:00:18very powerful right. We're talking Common area.
- 1:00:21I don't want to go up on the common area route.
- 1:00:23I want to install solar panels on my pro rata
- 1:00:25portion. They can't stop it. That's how powerful
- 1:00:27this one is. And the same with all these other
- 1:00:30issues. And I've got articles on all of these
- 1:00:32on my website if you want to go look at those
- 1:00:33to get details. Assessments and collections.
- 1:00:39Let me start with the evidence. This is controlled
- 1:00:42primarily by 5600, 5605, and 5615. And there
- 1:00:48are two kinds of assessments. The first kind
- 1:00:51is the general dues, the amount of money that
- 1:00:53you pay, that everybody pays their H -O -A every
- 1:00:56month or every quarter, depending on how your
- 1:00:57H -O -A works. That's the normal dues that are
- 1:00:59repeated. Those are just your general, you know,
- 1:01:03you want to be part of the H -O -A, you got to
- 1:01:04pay this every month or every quarter. Those
- 1:01:06are general dues. Those are called general assessments.
- 1:01:08Then there's special assessments. Those are one
- 1:01:11-time charges to pay for a specific thing, whatever
- 1:01:13that is. When it comes to, and by the way, assessments
- 1:01:17does not include fines for discipline. That's
- 1:01:19important. but when it comes to assessments we
- 1:01:21have one rule and one rule only we tell everybody
- 1:01:24and it's because there's no right topic set in
- 1:01:27california davis stirling act does not recognize
- 1:01:29that and a lot of people will say look i know
- 1:01:32for a fact that this special assessment they're
- 1:01:34trying to pass is way more than the five percent
- 1:01:38limit set forth in the code and i'm not going
- 1:01:40to pay it because it's illegal homeowners can't
- 1:01:42do that so we tell everybody that comes to us
- 1:01:46if they've been withholding an assessment hey
- 1:01:49You want to earn your money as a lawyer? You
- 1:01:51tell them, pay the assessment and then challenge
- 1:01:54them. You don't waive anything by paying. You
- 1:01:57don't waive a damn thing. There's no such thing
- 1:01:59as a waiver. You don't even have to write on
- 1:02:01the check paying under protest. You don't have
- 1:02:03to do it. Tell them to pay and then go out to
- 1:02:06the HOA. You'll always get that back. HOA has
- 1:02:09assets. They always have insurance and they have
- 1:02:11assets. You'll get it back. Never run into a
- 1:02:13situation where HOA couldn't pay when they had
- 1:02:16an attorney's fees clause or any fines. levied
- 1:02:18against them or penalties by the court. So 5
- 1:02:24,600 requires HOAs to collect enough money to
- 1:02:28do what they're obligated to do. Whatever it
- 1:02:30costs to ruin that HOA, to maintain, repair,
- 1:02:34replace common areas, and do all the things that
- 1:02:36these CCNRs require them to do, they have to
- 1:02:39get enough money to do it. They aren't supposed
- 1:02:41to collect more. They have to collect the amount
- 1:02:44it costs to do what they're supposed to do. Put
- 1:02:46some in reserve. which we'll talk about in a
- 1:02:49second. So that's 5600. That's an HOA obligation.
- 1:02:53We have to collect money from you. Then there's
- 1:02:56limits. Those limits are found in 5605 and 5615.
- 1:03:00And 5605 restricts increases above statutory
- 1:03:03thresholds. So general assessments, an HOA without
- 1:03:06a member vote can raise 20 % from the last year's
- 1:03:10assessment. So if you're paying $300 a month
- 1:03:14for your HOA, then the next year without a member
- 1:03:18vote can raise that to 360. But if they want
- 1:03:22to go one dollar above that, they got to take
- 1:03:23it to the members in a secret election with all
- 1:03:26the stuff we talked about before. When it comes
- 1:03:28to special assessments, a board can unilaterally
- 1:03:32pass a special assessment if it's less than 5
- 1:03:35% of the budgeted gross expenses from that year's
- 1:03:38budget. And there is an exception. I'll get to
- 1:03:41it in an emergency. We'll get to that in a minute.
- 1:03:43But absent a real emergency, that's their limit.
- 1:03:46Anything more than that goes to the homeowners.
- 1:03:48And that doesn't mean it's per assessment. That's
- 1:03:51for the year. So if you have more than one special
- 1:03:53assessment, they can't break it out so they're
- 1:03:55all smaller than 5%. It doesn't work that way.
- 1:03:58OK? Now, again, if you do remember nothing else
- 1:04:02about this entire presentation, pay first, challenge
- 1:04:07later. Never withhold an assessment. Let's talk
- 1:04:10about reserve studies. and the balcony law and
- 1:04:13reserves because that is a very big part of this.
- 1:04:15So California HOAs are required to conduct a
- 1:04:18reserve study, full reserve study every three
- 1:04:20years. And of course they're required to give
- 1:04:23a summary of that reserve study every year as
- 1:04:25part of their annual mandatory disclosures. And
- 1:04:28you find the mandatory disclosures in which I'll
- 1:04:31talk about in the next slide briefly. But the
- 1:04:33reserve studies are governed by 5550. So what
- 1:04:38is a reserve study? It's a visual inspection
- 1:04:40of all major common area components. The trees,
- 1:04:45the roads, the fences, the clubhouse, the pool,
- 1:04:47the jacuzzi, the garages, the roof, if you're
- 1:04:52in a condo. What happens? The HOA owns and maintains,
- 1:04:58is gonna ask to be netted as a line item in the
- 1:05:00reserve study. And a big important part of the
- 1:05:08reserve study is this. Number this percent number
- 1:05:11that's always given in the percentage and it's
- 1:05:13the percent funded number So what is this reserve
- 1:05:16study supposed to do? It's supposed to tell you
- 1:05:19okay for this component This thing has let's
- 1:05:23say it's a roof This the roof on each of the
- 1:05:26condo buildings has a useful life of X amount
- 1:05:28of years roofs are 25 to 30 years now, right?
- 1:05:31So it's a useful life of 25 to 30 years Here's
- 1:05:34what year we're in now. We're in your two or
- 1:05:36three or 20, whatever it is. Here's how many
- 1:05:40years lived based on that useful life? And here's
- 1:05:45how much based on today's dollars we think it
- 1:05:48will cost to when it comes time at the end of
- 1:05:50that life to replace that component. So we will
- 1:05:53rip this roof off, put a new roof on, how much
- 1:05:55is that going to cost? Now, since boards can't
- 1:05:57see the future and can't see what inflation and
- 1:06:00the cost of supplies, because nobody could foresee
- 1:06:02COVID, let's say, you might not know in 20 years
- 1:06:05what it will cost. So of course, you've got to
- 1:06:06deal with, OK, what will it cost today? OK? So
- 1:06:09here's the important thing. The percent funded
- 1:06:15number is the percent that says, okay, if everything
- 1:06:19that was coming due this year, everything that
- 1:06:22needed to be replaced this year was coming through,
- 1:06:28what percent of the amount of money it would
- 1:06:30take to do all that do we have ready to go? That's
- 1:06:33your percent funded. So there's a rule of, there's
- 1:06:36a rule of, I like to use, and it's different
- 1:06:38than the, there's a federal, there's a federal,
- 1:06:41it's an advisory agency out there that's kind
- 1:06:43of governed by the people in this industry. So
- 1:06:47it's not government related at all and it has
- 1:06:48no force of law. They issue an opinion every
- 1:06:51year and I think they're way too generous. I
- 1:06:53can go with the more conservative Michael Kushner
- 1:06:55one, which is if your HOA is anywhere in the
- 1:06:5980%, you are stellar. You are in great shape.
- 1:07:02I've never seen an HOA above 84 % in my entire
- 1:07:06career as a percent funder. Never seen it, okay?
- 1:07:10If you're anywhere in the 70s, you're good. You're
- 1:07:13good. Good stuff. If you're between 65 and 70%,
- 1:07:18pay attention, but I wouldn't worry. 60 to 65,
- 1:07:22I'm a little worried and I'm starting to pay
- 1:07:24close attention. Anything from 55 to 59, I'm
- 1:07:29very worried. and I'm looking and I'm asking
- 1:07:31questions I'm looking at documents but anything
- 1:07:34below 55 it's an emergency. You are guaranteed
- 1:07:37at some point down the way your homeowners are
- 1:07:40going to be paying a special assessment to fix
- 1:07:43something major or to fund the reserves. Something's
- 1:07:46going to happen and it's going to be bad. What
- 1:07:48has triggered this now is the balcony law which
- 1:07:52you find in 5551 because the balcony law contrary
- 1:07:55to what you might have read online by some so
- 1:07:57-called experts should have known better that
- 1:07:59only had a requirement that all HOAs need to
- 1:08:02do their initial balcony inspections, SB326,
- 1:08:07no later than January 1st, 2025, not 2026, which
- 1:08:11has been bandied around. To the extent they haven't
- 1:08:14done that, they're already in violation. And
- 1:08:15this came because of a disaster that occurred
- 1:08:17in Berkeley in 2015 when a company collapsed
- 1:08:20and killed six students and severely injured
- 1:08:2213 other people. You have these components that
- 1:08:25are partly made of wood or that are these cantilevered
- 1:08:29that are either entirely or partly made of wood.
- 1:08:35And you know, as well as I do, that almost all
- 1:08:37California construction has wood in its undercores.
- 1:08:40So it's pretty much anything, okay? Those are
- 1:08:43things that are part of this balcony law. Every
- 1:08:46nine years there has to be an inspection by only
- 1:08:49one or two people can do it. A licensed architect
- 1:08:53or a civil or structural engineer. Period. That's
- 1:08:57it. they've got to come and they've got to do
- 1:08:59a percentage sample and close up eyes on inspection
- 1:09:05of every component that fits in a lot. So all
- 1:09:09those balconies decks experience their elevated
- 1:09:12elements is what we call okay have to be looked
- 1:09:14at and if the this inspector sees something concerning
- 1:09:20they have to do some destructive testing as well
- 1:09:22then they have to issue a report and if you one
- 1:09:24of those HOAs that ignores that report because
- 1:09:26it's going to be a 20 million dollar fix and
- 1:09:29somebody dies. You are in big trouble, okay?
- 1:09:34We've got video. I talked about this on my podcast.
- 1:09:37We have video of two kids moving an entire stairway,
- 1:09:41an exterior staircase back and forth. You could
- 1:09:43see the stuff going on the outside of the building
- 1:09:46buckling and cracking. These kids were doing
- 1:09:48it, just two kids on their own weight. That should
- 1:09:52have been a red tag. That thing totally failed.
- 1:09:54That thing is not replaced immediately. We should
- 1:09:57move along a little bit, Michael. I'll go faster.
- 1:10:01Now, mandatory annual disclosures are required
- 1:10:03every year. There are two kinds. There are financial
- 1:10:05disclosures that are governed by 5 ,300, and
- 1:10:08then policy statements. The discipline policy,
- 1:10:11the finding structure, all that has to be set
- 1:10:12forth. That's also where they provide a summary
- 1:10:15of the reserve study, and the percent funded
- 1:10:19number must be on that. You'll find that in the
- 1:10:21annual budget report. Okay, take a list. This
- 1:10:26entire thing is going to take away anything.
- 1:10:29Authority is the first place you start. What's
- 1:10:31the source? Procedure, the conflict, and the
- 1:10:33standard. So run every dispute through those.
- 1:10:36Second one is the law sits in this hierarchy.
- 1:10:39Under 4205, you've got laws, then you've got
- 1:10:43your CCRs, then your articles, your bios, and
- 1:10:46then all the different kinds of rules that exist
- 1:10:47underneath. Three, procedure, acts of leverage,
- 1:10:51open meetings, rules for dab lines, disciplinary
- 1:10:53due process. They create defenses and they're
- 1:10:55all powerful fee -shifting statutes that even
- 1:10:58that playing field for homeowners. Number four,
- 1:11:01records. Always get them. You have a right to
- 1:11:03them under 5 ,200. Your client has a right to
- 1:11:05them. It's easy to get. And there are significant
- 1:11:08penalties in fee -shifting for failures to do
- 1:11:10that. And then, of course, when it comes to assessments,
- 1:11:13pay, then fight. I'll say one other thing because
- 1:11:16I didn't mention it. And that is, well, not a
- 1:11:19lot. I was going to cover the emergency exception
- 1:11:21to the assessment, so you can find that on my
- 1:11:24website in any article. And that pretty much
- 1:11:28runs us through the end. Yeah. Michael, so we
- 1:11:31have a ton of questions, most of which we're
- 1:11:34not going to be able to reach, and some are very
- 1:11:36specific. I encourage people to send those to
- 1:11:38Michael. by email afterwards, there are one or
- 1:11:42two things that I'd like to hit real quickly,
- 1:11:45which is one question that I think is real important
- 1:11:47here is, when is an HOA not covered by Davis
- 1:11:50Sterling? Okay. I'll give you a great example,
- 1:11:53because it's the most common. When it comes to
- 1:11:55manufactured housing, those are, people might
- 1:11:58know those as people that live in trailer parks,
- 1:12:01okay? When it comes to manufactured housing,
- 1:12:03they can choose whether or not to be governed
- 1:12:05by the, Manufactured Housing Act, right? There's
- 1:12:10a separate that is much less robust than the
- 1:12:13Davis -Stirling. Or they can be governed by the
- 1:12:16Davis -Stirling Act. But if an HOA, if they recorded
- 1:12:20a set of CCNRs, they're on a common area, then
- 1:12:24they're going to be a common interest development
- 1:12:25they're going to have to abide by Davis -Stirling.
- 1:12:27In California, we don't have co -ops as much
- 1:12:31as other states. Back East, there's co -ops all
- 1:12:33over. Co -ops can also have a choice. You have
- 1:12:36very few of those here, but co -ops are one where
- 1:12:38you can go either way and decide. But for the
- 1:12:41most part, because we don't have those, you know,
- 1:12:43those apartment conversions, condos, townhomes,
- 1:12:46single -family homes, there's an HOA. If there's
- 1:12:49a set of CCNRs or there's common area, you have
- 1:12:51to be something Davis -Stirling. So what are
- 1:12:54the things for people to take away? Because I'm
- 1:12:56dealing with one of these is if there's no common
- 1:12:59area, you're not Davis -Stirling. If there's
- 1:13:01no common area, you're not, there's no HOA. You
- 1:13:05don't fall under David Sterling Act. David Sterling
- 1:13:07Act requires property that's owned by the individuals
- 1:13:10in conjunction with common area. So there needs
- 1:13:13to be at least some bushes, something. For example,
- 1:13:17I know of one community that has view restrictions.
- 1:13:20They owned property at one time, but they don't
- 1:13:23any longer. And consequently, their position
- 1:13:26is that they're not a David Sterling HOA. They
- 1:13:29wouldn't be. If there's no comment, what you
- 1:13:31just said was all they have is some They have
- 1:13:33a mutual agreement or contract between owners
- 1:13:36that live in a certain area to protect view quarters.
- 1:13:39But if there's no common area, they are not subject
- 1:13:41to Davis -Stirling. They just have contractual
- 1:13:44rights vis -a -vis each other. So that's a very
- 1:13:47big distinction to keep in mind. There's a very
- 1:13:49general question that I think is relevant to
- 1:13:52a lot of this, which is if there's some rule
- 1:13:54that just seems unreasonable, nonsensical, how
- 1:13:58do you go about challenging something like that?
- 1:14:01Always, and this will be telling the clients
- 1:14:02before they are clients. They come consult with
- 1:14:04us and we say, look, you can do this part yourself,
- 1:14:06or we can get involved. You write an email or
- 1:14:09a letter to the manager or to the board, depending
- 1:14:12on how your H -way is configured. In that email,
- 1:14:15you stay very professional. You stay non -emotional.
- 1:14:18You don't take shots because you've got to assume
- 1:14:20a judge or a jury is going to read this. And
- 1:14:21you want to come across as reasonable. You don't
- 1:14:23want to come across as crazy. So you send them
- 1:14:27a letter saying, hey, you passed this rule. This
- 1:14:30rule is not reasonable for the following reasons.
- 1:14:33Here's what our CCR say, or here's what the law
- 1:14:36says, depending if it's applicable. Please explain
- 1:14:38the basis that you guys have for passing this
- 1:14:42rule, because 4350 says the rule has to be reasonable.
- 1:14:47That is the number one rule for rules. They have
- 1:14:49to be reasonable. Reasonableness, by the way,
- 1:14:51is an objective standard, not a subjective standard.
- 1:14:54The view of a person, let's say, that's a vegan
- 1:14:56that lives next door has a very you know visceral
- 1:15:00moral hatred of meat and you are smoking meat
- 1:15:02on weekends and you barbeque be truly a nuisance
- 1:15:07to them because it really bothers them but that's
- 1:15:08not that's a subjective issue so they couldn't
- 1:15:11pass a rule banning that it wouldn't be reasonable
- 1:15:13we want to obviously apologize to all the people
- 1:15:18whose questions we can't get to there have been
- 1:15:20like probably over 30 questions i am so sorry
- 1:15:22for talking too much i apologize that's no problem
- 1:15:25is it i'm going to stay a little later i am I
- 1:15:28think anybody else that ought to just send those
- 1:15:31to you directly because some of them are really
- 1:15:35specific things that are probably not of interest
- 1:15:38to the whole group necessarily. But we want to
- 1:15:41apologize if we didn't get to all those, but
- 1:15:43it was a great presentation, Mike, a lot of very
- 1:15:46interesting information. I thought you're...
- 1:15:48material is very well organized to present the
- 1:15:53whole picture of what's there. And I've done
- 1:15:55HOA law for a long time. And really appreciate
- 1:15:59you coming and putting on this presentation for
- 1:16:02the Beverly Hills Bar. And we want to thank everybody
- 1:16:05who attended for coming. Thank you all very much.