Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 292: MOMENT with Seth Godin - The World’s Racing to the Bottom. Do This Instead.
Transcript
- 0:00What's the difference between a leader and a manager?
- 0:03This week I'm sharing a moment with you,
- 0:04my conversation with Seth Godin,
- 0:0621 time bestselling author,
- 0:07and the world's most famous marketer.
- 0:10If you want to understand leadership in the age of A only,
- 0:13just listen to the next few minutes.
- 0:15Enjoy.
- 0:16I love that your podcast is about leadership communications.
- 0:20Thank you.
- 0:21Because all leadership is, is communication.
- 0:25That most CEOs are managers.
- 0:29They're not leaders.
- 0:31They use power and authority to get people to do what they're
- 0:35instructed to do.
- 0:37You don't need a lot of communication to do that.
- 0:39You just have to write a memo.
- 0:42Communication and strategy go together
- 0:46because we need people to enroll in the journey
- 0:50to see what we see,
- 0:52because we can't tell them every choice they need to make.
- 0:56And so the indoctrination,
- 0:57the dominant model of,
- 0:59do what I said, exactly what I said,
- 1:02undermines any work that a leader wants to do.
- 1:07What a leader can do is say,
- 1:09I'm going over there,
- 1:10over there specifically,
- 1:12who wants to come with me,
- 1:14who will help us get there.
- 1:17That communication cannot be hidden
- 1:19from the agenda.
- 1:21In fact, it's all there is.
- 1:24There's a quote in the book,
- 1:25which I really like,
- 1:26which is a strategy isn't a map.
- 1:27It's a compass.
- 1:28And I assume this is kind of what you're referring to, right?
- 1:31That there is no certainty,
- 1:32and the sense that there is no map to the destination.
- 1:35But it's a compass.
- 1:36We directly know where we want to go.
- 1:38And that's obviously what leaders need to communicate.
- 1:41And please don't ask me every day
- 1:46first step by step direction.
- 1:49I just gave you a compass.
- 1:51I trust you.
- 1:52Announce what you're doing and then go do it.
- 1:55But do not ask for permission
- 1:58or for me to take responsibility for every step
- 2:01because I don't know.
- 2:03That's the point.
- 2:04I don't know.
- 2:05That's a huge shift,
- 2:06both for employees as well as leaders, right?
- 2:08From the age of certainty to the age of,
- 2:11essentially uncertainty.
- 2:12And from the age of the map to the age of the compass,
- 2:15I like that.
- 2:16But you write that management runs a race to the bottom
- 2:20leadership offers a chance to run for the top,
- 2:22which I sort of underlined three times.
- 2:24I just love this distinction between management and leadership
- 2:28and you make that distinction in the context
- 2:30of the old industrial system and the modern economy,
- 2:33the bottom market economy.
- 2:35Well, so how did Henry Ford pave the earth?
- 2:37He figured out how to make a car.
- 2:40That was one tenth the price of his competition.
- 2:43That cycle of delivering enormous amount of value
- 2:49at a lower price established a lesson
- 2:53that almost no one has forgotten,
- 2:56which is if we just get more machines
- 2:58and turn the dials faster and lower our prices,
- 3:01we will win.
- 3:03The rates of the bottom says,
- 3:05I can cut a corner that the customer
- 3:08realize at least right now and lower my prices.
- 3:12And the problem with the rates of the bottom is you could win.
- 3:15Then you have to live at the bottom
- 3:17where you can come in second, which is even worse.
- 3:20But all you're doing is repeating yesterday
- 3:23but faster and cheaper.
- 3:25A race to the top says there's an innovation over there
- 3:29that people will appreciate.
- 3:30There's a problem to be solved, it hasn't been solved yet.
- 3:34We have to do something that might not work.
- 3:37Later people will copy us, that's fine.
- 3:39Then we'll go do the next thing.
- 3:41But those choices are right in front of us.
- 3:44And now that there are computers
- 3:47that do so much of the brain dead work,
- 3:51it's gonna be easier than ever to race to the bottom.
- 3:54Many of my peers are starting to use AI
- 3:57to do their writing, their posting, their social.
- 4:01Okay, well then what are they gonna do?
- 4:03Because it's all gonna become this sort of great jelly.
- 4:06And people will tell.
- 4:09They'll tell its average stuff for average people.
- 4:12And you can't build something in that way.
- 4:15So what do you recommend that leaders do?
- 4:18Because I could hear almost many of them saying,
- 4:21I hear you say that makes a lot of sense.
- 4:23I would love to work on these intricate, difficult,
- 4:26challenging problems that will make my day,
- 4:29but by organization isn't there yet.
- 4:31We still in the industry mindset.
- 4:33Well, the first thing I would say is you have a choice.
- 4:37The people who listen to this podcast
- 4:39are some of the most leverage, smartest,
- 4:41kindest people in the world in terms of being mindful
- 4:45about their power.
- 4:47I'm sure Steve Balmer is not listening.
- 4:51And so you get a choice.
- 4:54And if the place you are working truly will not let you
- 4:59do the work that needs to be done,
- 5:01you don't get tomorrow over again.
- 5:04You should leave.
- 5:06But I don't believe that's the case in most organizations.
- 5:09I think the case in most organizations is you are hoping
- 5:13your boss will give you a blank check approval
- 5:17and encouragement to go do something that might not work.
- 5:20And if it doesn't work, she will take all the blame.
- 5:23That's unlikely to happen in any organization.
- 5:26Instead, you have the opportunity in 10 minutes a day
- 5:30or 20 minutes a day or an hour a day
- 5:33to start modeling a new behavior and see who follows you.
- 5:37And part of the reason I go to all the trouble
- 5:40of making books, which has cost me my vocal cords,
- 5:44is you can share them.
- 5:47And if you can get five people in your organization
- 5:49to read a book and talk to each other about it,
- 5:53things are more likely to change.
- 5:55And we saw this with a song of significance
- 5:58and I'm hoping it will happen with this strategy as well,
- 6:01which is if you don't talk about it,
- 6:03it's not gonna get better.
- 6:04Yeah, exactly.
- 6:06And what do you say?
- 6:07I mean, we've focused our business so far,
- 6:08but what do you say this also applies to governments?
- 6:10Because governments are so central to our well-being,
- 6:15certainly from our perspective.
- 6:16And the challenge I see is that they find it even harder
- 6:21to reform, to modernize for various reasons and good reasons.
- 6:25But there isn't even the pressure at the stock market
- 6:29or they can't hire new employees
- 6:32or all the things to put pressure on business to modernize.
- 6:36Yeah, I gave it a long talk yesterday
- 6:39to an important nonprofit, they have the same issue.
- 6:43It's about the enrollment.
- 6:45If I was the secretary of whatever in the cabinet,
- 6:48I would start a team and I'd say,
- 6:50this is the team that gets the good snacks,
- 6:52I'm inviting you to be on it.
- 6:55We need to shine the non-believers,
- 6:56the people in government or industry
- 6:59that wanna maintain the status quo aren't evil,
- 7:02they're not bad, that's just what they signed up for.
- 7:05They signed up for the affiliation and status
- 7:07to come from the status quo.
- 7:10But we've seen change happen.
- 7:12Every government agency is now powered by computers.
- 7:15None of them were powered by computers 40 years ago.
- 7:19Change happens.
- 7:20So we're not gonna get it by having a standing ovation
- 7:24and the unanimous vote.
- 7:26It's gonna happen because we're gonna start small teams
- 7:28that change things.
- 7:30If you look at New York City, which is 10 miles from here,
- 7:34Mike Bloomberg put the 311 system in place.
- 7:38Now he was in charge,
- 7:40but the number of people who worked on it at the beginning
- 7:43was probably a dozen and finding small projects
- 7:49that then create visible successes,
- 7:52creates the conditions scaffolding
- 7:55for the next project to work even better.