Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Druckenmiller’s Liquidity Strategy Explained: If You Really Want to Time The Market
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are tackling a subject
- 0:04that is well, it's basically the Mount Everest of investing.
- 0:08We're talking about the absolute gold standard of global macro
- 0:12trading. It really is.
- 0:14I mean, the the term gets thrown around a lot, but this is one of
- 0:16the few cases where it actually fits.
- 0:18There are great investors, and then there's the tear this guy
- 0:20occupies. We're talking of course about
- 0:23Stanley Druckenmiller. And just to set the stage for
- 0:26anyone who doesn't know the stats, we're looking at a 30
- 0:28year track record, 30 years of about 30% annualized returns.
- 0:32Which is already incredible. But here's the kicker, the stat
- 0:35that really matters. He did it without a single
- 0:37losing year, not one. Yeah.
- 0:40And if you know anything about probability in the markets that
- 0:43that borders on statistically impossible, it really makes you
- 0:46wonder if he's even playing the same game as everyone else.
- 0:48That's exactly the feeling I got reading through this.
- 0:50You know, the easy answer is to just say, oh, he's a genius or
- 0:52he has a gut feeling. But the source material we're
- 0:55unpacking, specifically Druckenmiller's Daily Technical
- 0:58charts explained, just completely blows that idea up.
- 1:01It does. This isn't magic, it's not gut.
- 1:03It's a very specific, very disciplined framework.
- 1:07And it all starts at 40 AM. It does.
- 1:09And that's what we're going to do in this deep dive, decode
- 1:12that routine. We're not just looking at his
- 1:14biography, we're essentially looking over his shoulder at his
- 1:16dashboard. We're going to breakdown the
- 1:18charts, the indicators, the mental models he uses.
- 1:21And the mission here is really to bridge that gap, you know?
- 1:23Yeah, usually you've got 2 camps.
- 1:25You're either a fundamental investor.
- 1:27Right. Looking at earnings, PE ratios,
- 1:30all that. Or you're technical, just
- 1:31staring at lines on a chart. Druckenmiller seems to
- 1:34completely reject that split. He sees that split as a
- 1:37liability. His whole philosophy is that
- 1:39fundamentals tell you what to buy or sell.
- 1:41They give you the story, but they're terrible, just awful at
- 1:44telling you when. OK, so he uses the technicals to
- 1:47time his fundamental ideas. Exactly.
- 1:50The charts are there to confirm or deny what he thinks is
- 1:53happening out there in the real economy.
- 1:55So let's start where he starts, 4:00 in the morning.
- 1:57Why? I mean, why on earth that early?
- 1:59Is it just that billionaire hustle thing?
- 2:01No, no, it's not for show. It's purely functional.
- 2:04Think about it. Global markets are completely
- 2:05interconnected by 4 Bolero AM here.
- 2:08Europe is opening up. Asia is winding down.
- 2:12OK, so he needs to see what happened overnight.
- 2:14He needs to assess that overseas price action immediately.
- 2:18Capital flows like water. You know what happens in Tokyo
- 2:21impacts London, which then impacts New York.
- 2:24So he's not reacting, he's anticipating, looking for where
- 2:27the puck is going to be. That's the perfect way to put
- 2:29it. He's trying to visualize the
- 2:30world 18, maybe 20-4 months from now.
- 2:34He's using these early morning charts to test a thesis about
- 2:36the future, not just see what happened yesterday.
- 2:39OK, so he's there, coffee in hand.
- 2:40What's the very first thing he's looking at?
- 2:42This was, for me, the first big surprise in the research.
- 2:45He's not looking at earnings reports.
- 2:46No, and this is where, According to him, most investors get it
- 2:49wrong right from the start. He explicitly believes that
- 2:52relying on earnings to predict the market is a mistake.
- 2:56That sounds like heresy. I mean, we're all taught that
- 2:58stock prices are just the present value of future
- 3:00earnings. If earnings don't move the
- 3:02market, what on earth does? Liquidity.
- 3:04It's the Federal Reserve. It's the broader movement of
- 3:07money and credit. For Druckenmiller liquidity, the
- 3:11expansion and contraction of money, is the single most
- 3:14important variable. Period.
- 3:15So his dashboard is tracking things like the Fed funds rate,
- 3:19central bank balance sheets. Exactly.
- 3:21Money supply growth. He's tracking the fuel, not the
- 3:24car. That's a great analogy.
- 3:26You can have a Ferrari of a company with amazing earnings,
- 3:29but if the Fed is sucking the gas, the liquidity out of the
- 3:32system. That car is going nowhere, and
- 3:34conversely, if there's a flood of liquidity, even a plunker of
- 3:37a company can get pushed uphill for a while.
- 3:38OK, this brings us to a concept in the notes, the second
- 3:41derivative. Now this sounds a little like
- 3:44calculus class, which might scare some people, right?
- 3:46Can you break that down? Why does he focus on the rate of
- 3:48change? It's because the market is
- 3:50always looking forward. It's a discounting mechanism.
- 3:53If you wait for the economy to actually recover, you know, wait
- 3:57for GDP to turn positive, you've already missed the entire trade.
- 4:00So you're looking for the term before the turn.
- 4:02You're looking for when things stop getting worse as quickly.
- 4:06The second derivative is about spotting when the rate of
- 4:09decline slows down. Give me a concrete example, OK?
- 4:12Think about a recession. Everything's getting worse.
- 4:16Unemployment is going up month after month, but then one month
- 4:20unemployment goes up, but less than it did the month before.
- 4:23So it's still bad, but it's getting less bad.
- 4:26That's precisely that is the inflection point.
- 4:29That's the second derivative turning positive, and that's
- 4:31often when you buy. The sources point out that
- 4:34markets often rally 6 to 12 months before an economic
- 4:37recovery is obvious in the data. Because they're pricing in the
- 4:40Fed easing that just started, and the reverse is true too,
- 4:43right? Absolutely.
- 4:44When the economy is booming, everyone's hiring, earnings are
- 4:47at record highs. That's awful when he's selling
- 4:49because he knows the Fed is about to tap the brakes.
- 4:51He sees the liquidity headwind coming before it hits the
- 4:54headlines. It's a very contrarian way of
- 4:57thinking. You have to be willing to look
- 4:58stupid for a while. Oh for sure, Or at least feel
- 5:00really uncomfortable. If a trade feels comfortable,
- 5:02you're probably too late. OK, let's shift from the macro
- 5:05liquidity view to the actual charts.
- 5:07The outline calls this the primary filter, and it's a line
- 5:10I think a lot of people know, but maybe don't use it this way.
- 5:13The 200 day moving average. Yes, this is the definitive
- 5:16regime filter. He treats it like a binary
- 5:19switch for his entire portfolio. A switch.
- 5:22So it's that simple, just on or off.
- 5:24In terms of his aggression, yes. If the price of an index, say
- 5:27the S&P 500, is above its 200 day simple moving average, the
- 5:31environment is offensive. And offensive means?
- 5:35It means you swing for the fences, you make those high
- 5:37conviction big bets. You can use leverage.
- 5:39You're playing to win. And if the price breaks below
- 5:42that line? The switch flips instantly.
- 5:44It becomes defense, defense, defense.
- 5:46Your focus shifts immediately to capital preservation.
- 5:48You're not trying to be a hero anymore.
- 5:50You're just trying not to lose money.
- 5:52But what about all the noise? Markets are choppy.
- 5:54I mean, what if it dips below for a day and then pops right
- 5:56back up? You sell everything and then buy
- 5:58it back 24 hours later. That's the danger the whip saw.
- 6:02So to counter that, the source material talks about a couple of
- 6:04nuances. First is the slope of the line.
- 6:06A flat 200 day average doesn't tell you much.
- 6:09You want to see a rising line for bull market and a falling
- 6:12line for a bear. OK, so direction matters.
- 6:15And what was the other part? A confirmation rule.
- 6:17Yeah, this is key. His framework suggests you wait
- 6:21for confirmation. A trend change is really only
- 6:23validated if the moving average itself starts to turn, or you
- 6:27wait for the price to move, say half a percent to 1% beyond the
- 6:31line to confirm. It's a real break, not just
- 6:34noise. What's a filter for the static?
- 6:36Exactly, and historically this has been a lifesaver.
- 6:39The sources cite the 1987 crash. Black Monday, the big one.
- 6:43Right. And what's fascinating is that
- 6:45major corrections like that almost never happened when the
- 6:48market is at a 52 week high. They're almost always preceded
- 6:51by the price breaking below that 200 day moving average.
- 6:54It's the early warning system. The Canary in the coal mine.
- 6:56If you respect that line, you likely won't be holding a full
- 6:59bag of stocks when the bottom really falls out.
- 7:01Speaking of things falling apart, that leads us right into
- 7:03market breadth. Because an index like the S&P
- 7:07500, it can lie, can't it? It can.
- 7:10Absolutely lie. It's market cap weighted so the
- 7:12biggest companies have all the influence.
- 7:14You can have a situation where you know a few mega cap tech
- 7:17stocks are soaring, making the index look great, but underneath
- 7:20the surface 497 other stocks are actually down.
- 7:23We've definitely seen that movie.
- 7:24Before we have and Druckenmiller treats that as a massive yellow
- 7:28light. He calls it internal rot.
- 7:30That's such a vivid image. The apple looks shiny on the
- 7:33outside, but it's rotting from the core.
- 7:35How does he actually diagnose that?
- 7:37He uses the advanced decline line, the AG line.
- 7:40It's a really simple metric. You just take the number of
- 7:42stocks that went up that day and subtract the number that went
- 7:44down, and you plot that cumulative number.
- 7:47And you want that line to be moving up with the S&P 500?
- 7:49Exactly. You want broad participation.
- 7:51You want the troops to be following the generals up the
- 7:53hill. The real danger signal, the
- 7:55flashing red light, is divergent.
- 7:57That's when the price index makes a new high, but the AD
- 8:00line makes a lower high. Meaning the soldiers are
- 8:02starting to retreat while the generals are still charging
- 8:04ahead. And we know how that ends.
- 8:06Eventually the generals get shot, and looking back, this was
- 8:09the key signal before the 87 crash.
- 8:12The indices look strong, but the breath, the participation, it
- 8:17just wasn't there. That divergent is what told him
- 8:20to get bearish before the crash. It's amazing how it's all about
- 8:22human psychology. These patterns just repeat.
- 8:24So we have the 200 Day for trend, Breath for health.
- 8:28Now for something that sounds like a horror movie title, The
- 8:32Three Death Nails. It sounds dramatic, but it's
- 8:34accurate. Yeah.
- 8:35These are three specific macro indicators that when they rise
- 8:38at the same time create a perfect storm for the market.
- 8:41OK, lay them out for US nail #1. Nail #1 rising interest rates.
- 8:45He's looking at the 10 year treasury yield.
- 8:47When rates go up, the discount rate on future earnings goes up.
- 8:51It makes stocks, especially those high growth tech stocks,
- 8:53mathematically less valuable. It's like adding gravity to
- 8:56stock prices. Got it nail #2.
- 8:59A strong U.S. dollar. When the DXY index trends up, it
- 9:03tightens financial conditions everywhere.
- 9:04It hurts US multinationals because their foreign profits
- 9:07translate back into fewer dollars.
- 9:09But it also crushes emerging markets that have debt in
- 9:12dollars. It just squeezes the whole
- 9:13global system. OK, and the final nail in the
- 9:15coffin. Rising crude oil prices.
- 9:18He just sees oil as a tax. It's a tax on every consumer at
- 9:21the gas pump, and it's a tax on every manufacturer through
- 9:24higher input costs. So if you see rates up, the
- 9:27dollar up and oil up all at once.
- 9:30You run for the hills. Yeah, the synthesis is that when
- 9:32those 3 converge, the macro environment is officially
- 9:35hostile. It doesn't matter how good your
- 9:36stock picking is, the tide is going out on everyone.
- 9:39You just have to respect the downtrend.
- 9:41I love how clear and unambiguous that is.
- 9:43It removes the guesswork. Now let's pivot to something a
- 9:45bit more granular. He also looks at specific
- 9:48sectors for clues, right? Yeah, he sees the market as this
- 9:51living thing. He looks at the circulatory
- 9:53system, which for him is the transportation sector,
- 9:55specifically trucking stocks. Trucking.
- 9:58Why not tech or banks? As nothing gets sold in the real
- 10:01world if it doesn't get moved on a truck.
- 10:04If the charts for trucking stocks are breaking down, it's a
- 10:07real time signal that the volume of goods moving through the
- 10:10economy is dropping, and that signal shows up way before the
- 10:13official GDP data comes out. It's data from the ground floor
- 10:17and he also watches housing and retail.
- 10:19Housing is the most sensitive to interest rates, so it's the
- 10:21Canary in the coal mine for Fed policy.
- 10:23If housing starts to roll over, you know the rate hikes are
- 10:26starting to bite. And for retail, he looks at what
- 10:29they call granny retail, the XRTETF, to see if the average
- 10:32person is actually spending money.
- 10:34OK, now there was 1 industry insight in the notes that really
- 10:37just blew my mind. It was about the chemical
- 10:40industry and it felt completely backward.
- 10:42Oh yeah, this is classic Druckenmiller, he says.
- 10:44You did not buy chemical stocks when their earnings are good.
- 10:47Which is what everyone else would do.
- 10:49Oh, Dow had a great quarter. Time to buy.
- 10:51Exactly. But that's the trap.
- 10:52You buy chemical stocks when capacity has left the industry.
- 10:56Unpack that for me. High capacity.
- 10:58Because chemicals are a commodity, when earnings are
- 11:00great, every company rushes to build new plants to chase those
- 11:04profits. But a plant takes years to
- 11:06build. By the time it comes online, the
- 11:08market is flooded with supply, prices collapse and margins get
- 11:11crushed. So the announcement of new plant
- 11:13construction, That's a sell signal?
- 11:16That is wild. You sell on the good news of
- 11:18expansion. And you buy when companies are
- 11:21going bankrupt and shutting down plants because when that
- 11:24capacity leaves, pricing power comes back to the survivors.
- 11:27It's just a perfect example of looking at supply, not just
- 11:31current income. This all brings us to the mental
- 11:33game because you can have all these charts and rules, but if
- 11:36you can't actually pull the trigger, it's all useless.
- 11:39The notes mentioned something called Delta Roc.
- 11:41Right. This goes back to that second
- 11:42derivative idea we talked about, but applied to momentum.
- 11:45He's measuring the acceleration or deceleration of a trend.
- 11:48How is that different from just seeing the price go up?
- 11:51Well, think about throwing a ball in the air for a moment.
- 11:53It's still going up, but gravity is slowing it down.
- 11:56Its velocity is positive, but its acceleration is negative.
- 12:00He wants to spot that deceleration.
- 12:03It helps him catch the bottoms of pessimism or the peaks of
- 12:06euphoria. Speaking of crowds, there's a
- 12:08great quote in here from his mentor.
- 12:09Sparrows drill. 60 million Frenchmen can't be wrong.
- 12:14I love that quote. It's a metaphor for the market.
- 12:17Drills taught him that the market price contains the
- 12:19collective intelligence of millions of participants.
- 12:22It's just inherently smarter than any one person.
- 12:25So if you've done your homework, you love a company, but the
- 12:27stock is tanking. The price is probably right and
- 12:29you are wrong. It's about having a deep respect
- 12:31for price action. If your story conflicts with the
- 12:34chart, you have to assume the market knows something you
- 12:36don't. Which leads to this final, maybe
- 12:38controversial point. Stop losses.
- 12:41Druckenmiller apparently hates mechanical stop losses.
- 12:44He calls them the dumbest concept but it's very nuanced.
- 12:47He doesn't like setting a rule like I'll sell if it drops 10%.
- 12:50Uses what he calls thesis based. Exits OK.
- 12:53What's the difference? The difference is intellectual
- 12:55honesty. If he buys a stock for a
- 12:57specific reason, say a liquidity catalyst, and that catalyst
- 13:02disappears or the chart breaks down in a way that invalidates
- 13:05the reason he bought it, he's out immediately.
- 13:09Even if he's only down like 1% even.
- 13:11If he's up 1%, he exits because the reason for the trade is
- 13:14gone. He doesn't wait for a 10% loss
- 13:16to tell him he was wrong. So you basically have to wake up
- 13:19every morning and re justify every single position in your
- 13:21portfolio. Every single day he talks about
- 13:24being able to wipe the slate clean.
- 13:26You can't be married to yesterday's position.
- 13:28If the facts change, you change. Now that is incredibly demanding
- 13:31mentally to admit you were wrong that.
- 13:33Quickly it is. It requires checking your ego at
- 13:35the door every morning, but that's the price you pay for 30%
- 13:38annualized returns. So as we wrap this up, the
- 13:40sources do mention the style is getting harder, you know, with
- 13:43algorithms and machine trading adding so much noise.
- 13:46It has. The machines can create a lot of
- 13:48volatility and false signals around those same technical
- 13:51levels. He's admitted that the signals
- 13:53are a bit duller now and that he has to mix the framework with a
- 13:56dose of instinct to survive. But the core toolkit that
- 14:01remains the same. Let's recap it just as a
- 14:03checklist for everyone listening.
- 14:05It starts with a liquidity check.
- 14:06Don't fight the Fed. Second the primary filter.
- 14:10Use the 200 day average as your offense defense switch, 3rd
- 14:14check for internal rot with market breath and 4th watch for
- 14:18the three deaf nails, rising rates, dollar and oil.
- 14:22And if those nails are hammering down, just step aside.
- 14:24Cash is a position. It's off of the best position.
- 14:26So here's the thought we want to leave you with.
- 14:28It goes back to that 60 million Frenchman idea.
- 14:30If the market is smarter than you, take a hard look at your
- 14:32portfolio right now. Are you holding on to anything
- 14:34just because you think you know something while the price action
- 14:37is screaming that you're wrong? That is, the uncomfortable
- 14:39question, isn't? It it is, but asking it might
- 14:42just save your portfolio. And Speaking of keeping track of
- 14:45these big signals, we actually have a tool that can help.
- 14:48That's right, to track total market temperature, welcome to
- 14:50search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple
- 14:54App Store. EOAE, Babel Store, Post, Shaw,
- 14:58AOL, Buffett Indicator and if you found this deep dive
- 15:02valuable and you want to get access to more advanced content,
- 15:05you can always join the Deep Value Club membership and don't.
- 15:07Forget to follow us on your favorite podcast platform.
- 15:10All right, disclaimer all the analysis here is based on
- 15:14publicly available sources. It's for educational purposes
- 15:17only and is not investment advice.
- 15:20Please do your own due diligence before making any investment
- 15:23decisions. If you want to listen to our
- 15:25full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced
- 15:28contents, welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or
- 15:31subscribe to us on Apple Spotify Podcasts Channel, Deep Value
- 15:35Investing and Deep Values dot AI.
- 15:47I.