Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Recover From a Career Mistake Without Destroying Your Reputation
Transcript
- Lucas: So, you've made a mistake at work. Not a small one — the kind that gets noticed, the kind that leaves a mark. Maybe it was a public misfire in a presentation, a data error in a report that went to leadership, or a poorly timed email that landed in the wrong inboxes. Luna: And suddenly you're wondering if this one moment is going to define how people see you from now on. Lucas: Exactly. That's the fear. And it's not irrational — reputations are fragile. But the research on workplace mistakes actually suggests something counterintuitive: how you handle the aftermath often matters more than the mistake itself. Luna: I've heard of the 'apology paradox' — this idea that apologizing too much can actually damage your credibility. Is that what you're getting at? Lucas: Partially. That's a concept Wharton professor Maurice Schweitzer has studied extensively. He found that while people expect an apology, an overly effusive or repeated apology can backfire — it signals incompetence or lack of confidence. The key is to apologize once, clearly, and then pivot to repair. Luna: So don't grovel. Don't keep bringing it up. But what does 'repair' look like in practice? Lucas: Let me give you a concrete example. A few years ago, a product team at a major tech company — I'll leave the name out — launched a feature that had a critical bug. It affected thousands of users for about six hours. The team lead sent a company-wide email within an hour of the bug being discovered. It said: 'We made a mistake. Here's what happened. Here's what we're doing to fix it. And here's how we'll prevent it from happening again.' Luna: That's refreshingly direct. No blame-shifting, no hedging? Lucas: None. And interestingly, the team's internal reputation actually improved after that. People saw them as accountable and competent — because they owned it fast and focused on fixing the problem, not on saving face. Luna: It's almost like a mistake can become a trust-building moment if handled right. Lucas: Right. Schweitzer calls it the 'trust repair' model. It has three components: an acknowledgment of the violation, an acceptance of responsibility, and a credible commitment to change. If you skip any of those, the repair doesn't stick. Luna: Where do people typically go wrong? Lucas: The most common error is trying to minimize or deflect — phrases like 'mistakes were made' or 'there were contributing factors.' That signals evasion, which erodes trust faster than the original mistake. The second is apologizing too many times, which signals you don't trust yourself to fix it. Luna: So the sweet spot is: one clear apology, then demonstrate learning and action. Lucas: Exactly. And here's where it gets specific: you need to calibrate your response to the severity of the mistake. A missed deadline might warrant a quick acknowledgement to your team. A public error that affects clients might require a broader communication plan. Luna: How do you gauge severity in the moment when emotions are high? Lucas: That's a great question. Schweitzer suggests asking yourself: who was harmed, and how much? If the answer is 'no one really' — maybe you just embarrassed yourself — then a casual acknowledgment over coffee might be sufficient. If it impacted others' work or the company's reputation, you need a more structured response. Luna: I also think about the timing. The product team example — they responded within an hour. That speed shows you take it seriously. Lucas: Absolutely. Delay is often interpreted as avoidance. Even if you don't have all the answers, an initial 'we're looking into it' can go a long way, as long as you follow up with specifics. Luna: And what about the follow-through? The apology is just the start. Lucas: The follow-through is where most people drop the ball. You have to demonstrate that you've actually changed the process or behavior that led to the mistake. That might mean implementing a new checklist, scheduling a review meeting, or adding a step in the workflow. And you need to communicate that change clearly. Luna: So it's not just about saying sorry — it's about showing you've learned. Lucas: Right. And if you do that well, the long-term effect can actually be positive. There's research showing that leaders who admit mistakes are perceived as more authentic and trustworthy — because vulnerability, when paired with competence, builds connection. Luna: But there's a caveat, right? You can't have a pattern of mistakes. One-time errors are forgivable; chronic carelessness is a different story. Lucas: Exactly. The recovery playbook only works if the mistake is an exception, not a pattern. If you're repeatedly apologizing for similar issues, the trust repair model breaks down — because the 'credible commitment to change' part becomes unbelievable. Luna: So one big mistake? You can recover. A series of small ones? That's a different conversation. Lucas: And that's a useful way to think about your own track record. If you find yourself in a pattern, you need to step back and address the root cause before the next apology. Luna: You know, this reminds me of something I read about the 'failure resume' — people who keep a log of their mistakes and what they learned. It's a way to normalize error and show growth. Lucas: That's a great practice. In fact, some executives I've interviewed actually share their failure resumes with their teams to model accountability. It signals that the team is a safe place to acknowledge mistakes. Luna: Alright, so let's say you've made the mistake, you've apologized appropriately, and you're implementing changes. How do you know if your reputation has actually recovered? Lucas: You look for behavioral cues. Do colleagues still seek you out for input? Are you included in key meetings? Do people reference the mistake as a learning moment rather than a character flaw? If yes, you're probably in good shape. Luna: And if not? Lucas: Then you may need to have direct conversations with key stakeholders. Something like: 'I know that incident affected your confidence in me. I've taken these steps to address it. Is there anything else you need from me?' Luna: That takes courage — but it also shows you're invested in the relationship. Lucas: It does. And that investment matters because the alternative — hoping it will just blow over — rarely works. Trust is rebuilt through action, not time alone. Luna: And if we've helped you think through a tricky career situation or decision, we'd love to keep this show free and independent. We don't run ads because we think that respects your time and attention. If you'd like to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, listener support is what keeps us ad-free. No pressure, but every contribution helps us keep doing deep dives like this. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. One more thing I want to touch on: when should you NOT apologize? Lucas: Great point. Schweitzer's research also shows that in some cases, apologizing can actually make things worse — if the mistake is ambiguous and you're not sure you were at fault, a premature apology can be seen as an admission of guilt. You need to investigate first. Luna: So don't rush to apologize if you're not sure you actually caused the problem. Lucas: Right. Instead, say something like: 'I want to understand what happened. Can we walk through the timeline together?' That opens the door to a constructive conversation without assuming blame. Luna: That's a much more strategic approach than reflexively saying sorry. Lucas: Exactly. And it's consistent with the overall principle: focus on repair, not on self-protection. The people who recover best from mistakes are the ones who see the error as a problem to solve, not a threat to their ego. Luna: That's a mindset shift worth making. Because we will all make mistakes at some point. Lucas: Absolutely. And if you handle them well, they can actually become part of your professional narrative — a story of how you grew and became more resilient. Luna: Alright, I think that's a good note to end on. Thanks for listening, everyone.