Latest / Reformed Thinking / Christian Practice and Holy Life as the Evidence of Sincerity | Jonathan Edwards
Transcript
- 0:00How do we really know, you know, if someone's Christian faith is
- 0:04is genuine and maybe even harder?
- 0:07What about for ourselves? How do we get that solid
- 0:09assurance in our own walk? Yeah, it's a fundamental
- 0:12question, isn't it? So many people, I think
- 0:14naturally lean on, well, what someone says or maybe a really
- 0:18moving story they tell or even, you know, strong emotions.
- 0:20Right. You see a lot of tears or hear a
- 0:23passionate testimony and you think, OK, that must be real,
- 0:27but is that the most certain way that's.
- 0:29What we want to dig to welcome everyone to reformed thinking,
- 0:32where we try to connect these core truths to, well, how we
- 0:35think. Today and today, we're starting
- 0:37a deep vive into this biblical idea, really looking at it
- 0:40through the lens of Jonathan Edwards, that Christian
- 0:42practice, what we actually do, our holy living, is the the main
- 0:47sign of sincere godliness. Exactly.
- 0:49Edwards had this really insightful way of unpacking how
- 0:54our actions show what's truly in the heart.
- 0:57And this applies whether we're thinking about other people's
- 0:59faith or trying to find that clarity, that assurance for
- 1:01ourselves. So our goal for you today is to
- 1:04really pull out the crucial points on how to recognize true
- 1:07faith. We want to offer some clarity,
- 1:10look at the scriptural backing, and hopefully give you a
- 1:12practical way to view your own walk with God.
- 1:15It's about living it out, not just talking about it.
- 1:18OK, so let's start with how we see sincerity in others.
- 1:22The core idea here, and Edwards really hammers this home, is
- 1:26that visible actions, a consistent, holy way of life.
- 1:30These are the primary, the most distinguishing signs of whether
- 1:34a Christian's faith is sincere, at least to those looking on.
- 1:38And this isn't just like Edward's opinion.
- 1:40He grounds it firmly in Christ's own teaching.
- 1:43You see it so. Clearly right Christ as a point
- 1:45blank you will know them by their fruits.
- 1:47That's Matthew 7. It's a foundational rule for how
- 1:50we recognize faith from the outside.
- 1:52It really cuts against just taking someone's word for it,
- 1:54doesn't it? It's less about the claim, I
- 1:57believe, and much more about, well, what does your life show?
- 2:00And Christ doesn't just state it, He gives that analogy, the
- 2:02one about the tree and its fruit, Luke 6, Matthew 12, He
- 2:06explains, you know a tree by its fruit, not its leaves, not its
- 2:09flowers. It's just it's illogical, he
- 2:13suggests, to think a good tree produces bad fruit, or a bad
- 2:17tree good fruit. So the fruit, the actions become
- 2:21the main diagnostic tool. It's how you tell one tree or
- 2:24one person's spiritual state from another.
- 2:26It's not just a nice picture. It really shows that organic
- 2:29link between who we are inside and what we, you know, produce
- 2:33outwardly. And here's what's really
- 2:34striking what Edwards draws out Christ doesn't tell us to look
- 2:37for other things that we might naturally gravitate towards.
- 2:40Like what specifically? Well, he doesn't say.
- 2:42You'll know them by their eloquent talk or by the amazing
- 2:46stories they tell about their experiences.
- 2:48He doesn't point to really emphatic statements or big
- 2:52emotional. Displays we're even just talking
- 2:53a lot about religious things, or crying easily or interestingly,
- 2:57even the positive feelings we might have towards them.
- 2:59That's a tricky 1. It is, but Christ draws a clear
- 3:02line. He steers us away from relying
- 3:05only on words or, you know, feelings that can come and go.
- 3:08Instead, think about Matthew 516.
- 3:12Let your light so shine before men, that others, seeing your
- 3:15good works, may glorify your Father.
- 3:18Seeing the works, not just hearing about them, that really
- 3:22challenges our tendency, I think, to trust a compelling
- 3:24stories, sometimes more than consistent, maybe less flashy
- 3:27conduct. And this focus on practice, on
- 3:30works, it gets strong reinforcement from the apostles
- 3:32too. Look at Paul in Hebrew six.
- 3:35He talks about people who had these initial illuminations,
- 3:38tasted the heavenly gift, but then fell away.
- 3:40But when Paul feels confident about the Christian Hebrews, he
- 3:43doesn't base it on, say, detailed accounts of their
- 3:46conversion narratives. No, he points to their work and
- 3:48labor of love, how they minister to other believers.
- 3:51Their actions were the proof. That makes sense.
- 3:53What about elsewhere? Well, Philippians 2 Paul holds
- 3:56up Timothy. Why?
- 3:58Because Timothy's service in the Gospel show he prioritized
- 4:01Christ's interests over his own game.
- 4:03He contrast Timothy with others who just seek their own.
- 4:06Timothy's actions demonstrated his heart.
- 4:08And John says something similar right in three John.
- 4:11Absolutely. He's joyful about Gaius, not
- 4:14because Gaius gave a great testimony, but because he was
- 4:17walking in the truth and showed charity, practical care for
- 4:21fellow believers and even strangers.
- 4:23He even gives that rule, doesn't he?
- 4:25He that does good is of God, but he that does evil has not seen
- 4:29God. It really puts actions front and
- 4:32Center for discerning where someone's life is sourced.
- 4:35And then you have James. He's maybe the most direct about
- 4:38it. James 2.18 Show me your faith
- 4:41without your works, and I will show you my faith by my works.
- 4:44He flat out says works are superior to just words as
- 4:48evidence of faith. He argues that even telling your
- 4:51story is still just showing faith by words, which he sees as
- 4:54well vastly short of showing it through deeds.
- 4:57Exactly. James isn't knocking faith
- 4:59itself, obviously. He's arguing against a faith
- 5:02that just stays in the realm of talk, of profession without
- 5:04practice. He's pushing us to see the
- 5:06tangible results of belief. And, you know, it's not just
- 5:08scripture, Edwards points out. That basic reason, just common
- 5:11sense, backs us up too well, The idea that men's deeds are better
- 5:16and more loyal interpretations of their minds than their words.
- 5:20Isn't that something we kind of intuitively know across
- 5:23cultures, across time? When you really want to know
- 5:26someone's intentions, you watch what they do consistently.
- 5:29That's a great point. Actions reveal character in a
- 5:32way words often can't. Edwards uses some everyday
- 5:35analogies. Think about friendship.
- 5:37OK. Someone's steady self giving
- 5:40actions in a friendship. That's much stronger proof of
- 5:43real friendship than, as Edwards puts it, 1000 earnest
- 5:46declarations. So apply that to Christ.
- 5:48Someone who actually exerts themselves, denies themselves
- 5:51for Christ's honor. That gives stronger evidence of
- 5:54love than someone who talks a big game about their love but,
- 5:58you know, avoids any difficult service or personal cost.
- 6:01Precisely if the person who shows up who acts, not just the
- 6:04one who talks about it. Or think about being detached
- 6:06from worldly things, Edwards suggests.
- 6:09Someone whose behavior shows they're ready to forsake worldly
- 6:11comforts for duty. Someone who freely gives for
- 6:14religious or charitable causes. That person gives more credible
- 6:18evidence of being weaned from the world than someone who just
- 6:21says they feel that way but is actually, you know, quite
- 6:24acquisitive or hates parting with money.
- 6:27The actions show the real priority.
- 6:30Right. And humility too.
- 6:32Walking humbly, being patient when things are tough, being
- 6:35meek with people. That's better evidence of
- 6:37genuine humility than someone telling you how unworthy they
- 6:40felt during some past experience.
- 6:42Especially, Edwards notes, if that same person then acts
- 6:45proudly or gets easily offended or can't handle disagreement,
- 6:49the actions betray the words. He's highlighting that clash
- 6:52between the professed Interstate and the actual outward behavior.
- 6:55And love for others, showing kindness, bearing burdens,
- 6:59sacrificing for people's well-being.
- 7:01That's more believable proof of love than just talking about
- 7:04loving feelings while acting selfishly or or being
- 7:06argumentative. You see, words are cheap.
- 7:09Strong feelings can easily produce words.
- 7:11It doesn't cost much to say you love God or others.
- 7:13But Christian practice living it out.
- 7:16That's, as Edward says, a costly, demanding thing.
- 7:19It requires self denial. Which makes it much harder for
- 7:21hypocrites to fake consistently. It's easier to talk like a St.
- 7:25than to act like 1. The path isn't defined by words,
- 7:29but by doing. This helps filter out
- 7:31superficial claims. Look where someone's resources,
- 7:34time, money, energy actually go. That tells you a lot.
- 7:37So let's define this visible Christian practice a bit more.
- 7:41What does this positive display of holiness actually look like?
- 7:45It's clearly more than just being, you know, a decent person
- 7:48or not committing obvious big sins, right?
- 7:50That doesn't make your light shine in the way Christ meant.
- 7:53Edwards isn't talking about just being polite or outwardly moral.
- 7:57It's something more distinctively spiritual.
- 7:59So what is it then? It needs, he says, a great
- 8:02positive appearance, appearance of holiness in men's visible
- 8:04behavior. Not perfection, obviously, but a
- 8:07consistent direction, a life that looks like a life of
- 8:10serving God, trying to follow Christ's example and gospel
- 8:14rules like in the Sermon on the Mount or Romans 12 across the
- 8:17board. So universal obedience is key.
- 8:20Manifesting love and fear of God.
- 8:22Fulfilling duties towards others, fellow Christians and
- 8:25enemies. Showing meekness, forgiveness,
- 8:27mercy, selflessness. Doing good for souls and bodies.
- 8:32Yes, all of that. And consistent personal conduct
- 8:34too. Things like temperance,
- 8:36mortification of sin, humble conversation, controlling the
- 8:39tongue or rather using it for God's glory and blessing others.
- 8:43And it's not just on Sundays. It's about walking as Christians
- 8:46in all places and at all seasons.
- 8:48In worship, yes, but also in families, among neighbors, in
- 8:51daily life, in business, in conversation towards everyone,
- 8:55friends, enemies, superiors, inferiors, equals.
- 8:58It's a holistic view. True faith shapes everything.
- 9:01They should appear earnestly engaged in the service of God
- 9:04and mankind, working at it, being constant, steadfast, even
- 9:07when facing difficulties or temptations.
- 9:09And showing a willingness to deny themselves, maybe even
- 9:12suffer for God, for Christ, for the faith, for the good of other
- 9:15believers. A readiness to let go of
- 9:17anything rather than compromise their loyalty to Christ, making
- 9:21His honor the priority. Exactly.
- 9:23It's doing good things. But from that specific Christ
- 9:27centered motive, their whole way of being might carry, as Edwards
- 9:32beautifully puts it, a sweet odor of Christian graces and
- 9:35heavenly dispositions. And when you see that kind of
- 9:39consistent, visible life, Edwards argues, it's vastly
- 9:44beyond the fairest and brightest story of particular steps and
- 9:47passages of experience that ever was told.
- 9:50The actions speak with a clarity and weight that even the most
- 9:52moving personal narrative can't quite match in terms of external
- 9:56evidence. OK, that makes a lot of sense
- 9:58about practice being the main visible sign.
- 10:00But that leads to another crucial point.
- 10:02You mentioned the need for a proper Christian profession,
- 10:04right? Practice assumes something else
- 10:06is already in place. That's right.
- 10:07While practice is the chief visible sign, it always
- 10:10presupposes an open declaration of being a Christian.
- 10:13Without that profession, the whole framework for judging
- 10:16fruits doesn't really apply in the same way.
- 10:18So the. Rules about judging fruits.
- 10:20They're given for professing Christians, people who identify
- 10:23as part of the Christian community.
- 10:25Yes, the rules are to help discern the truth of their
- 10:28claim. They aren't meant for judging,
- 10:31say, someone from a completely different faith background, or
- 10:35an atheist, or someone who explicitly denies Christianity
- 10:39based on whether their actions look good by some general
- 10:42standard. It's about assessing the
- 10:44sincerity of those who claim to be Christian.
- 10:47So if someone explicitly says I am not a Christian, then no
- 10:51matter how virtuous they might appear outwardly, we wouldn't
- 10:54apply these rules to somehow conclude they are a sincere
- 10:57Christian. Correct, Edwards uses the image.
- 10:59Fruits must be joined with open flowers.
- 11:01Bells and pomegranates go together.
- 11:03The outward life needs to be connected to an explicit
- 11:06profession of faith in Christ. So the profession is, as he
- 11:09says, requisite and necessary for the rule of judging by
- 11:12fruits to even make sense. Right.
- 11:14But, and this is key, it's not the main thing or the
- 11:17distinguishing part of the evidence itself.
- 11:19It's like, you know, having a physical body is necessary to be
- 11:22human, but it's not what distinguishes you as human among
- 11:25other creatures. The profession is the starting
- 11:28point, the claim being made. The visible fruit then validates
- 11:32that claim. OK, So what constitutes a proper
- 11:34Christian profession then? What needs to be declared?
- 11:37It has to declare all that is necessary to his being a
- 11:41Christian. Essentially, you need to profess
- 11:43the core elements, the very essence of Christianity.
- 11:46And what are those essentials, either stated outright or
- 11:49clearly implied? Well first, obviously belief in
- 11:52Christ and basic gospel doctrines, professing that Jesus
- 11:54is the Messiah, that he atoned for our sins and other
- 11:57foundational truths. That's non negotiable.
- 12:00Makes sense? What else?
- 12:01Repentance A clear declaration of turning from sin.
- 12:06This includes acknowledging your own sinfulness.
- 12:08Understand you justly deserve God's wrath, renouncing sin,
- 12:11being humbled by it, and recognizing God's justice even
- 12:15if you were condemned. Think of the baptism of
- 12:17repentance in the Gospels, people confessing their sins.
- 12:20So a real turning away from the old.
- 12:22Life, yes, and then embracing Christ as Savior, A wholehearted
- 12:26acceptance of Him as your only Savior, relying on Him, joyfully
- 12:29receiving the gospel message, depending on His righteousness
- 12:32and strength, rejoicing in Him alone is your hope and portion.
- 12:35Like Isaiah, prophecies are those who gladly received the
- 12:38Word and Acts. It's a complete reliance on
- 12:40Christ, not yourself. Absolutely, and it also involves
- 12:43love for Christ and renouncing worldliness, declaring love for
- 12:47Christ above everything else, and a willingness to forsake all
- 12:50for his sake, letting go of worldly attachments, being
- 12:53willing to sell all for the treasure of knowing Him.
- 12:56It's a fundamental shift in values.
- 12:58What about commitment to God? Crucial professing to give
- 13:02yourself up entirely forever to Christ and to God through Him,
- 13:06submitting to Him as King, giving Him your heart, your
- 13:09whole being. A resolved willingness to obey
- 13:11all God's commands, even the hard self denying ones.
- 13:15Dedicating your whole life to His service.
- 13:17Like those covenant declarations in the Old Testament, A total
- 13:20allegiance. Exactly showing your whole heart
- 13:22and soul are in these engagements.
- 13:24And finally, love for others, manifesting forgiveness towards
- 13:27those who've hurt you, a general goodwill to mankind and a heart
- 13:31united to Christ's people, loving them as brothers and
- 13:33sisters, wanting to worship and serve God alongside them.
- 13:36So professing these things signifies that the person is, or
- 13:41at least believes they are, experiencing these things
- 13:44inwardly. Yes, that they are conscious to
- 13:46or do experience such things in their hearts.
- 13:50Now how they profess matters too.
- 13:52How so? It needs to be done first
- 13:55understandingly. The person has to seem
- 13:57sufficiently instructed in basic Christian principles to actually
- 14:01grasp what they're saying. Words are meaningless if the
- 14:03speaker doesn't comprehend them. So no, just rattling off creedal
- 14:07statements without understanding, right?
- 14:09And second, honestly, there needs to be good reason to
- 14:12believe the person is genuinely expressing what's in their
- 14:15heart, not just, you know, going through the motions of a
- 14:18customary form or using ambiguous language and.
- 14:21Edward says the best evidence of that honesty is.
- 14:24A practice that agrees with the profession.
- 14:26It always comes back to that the life validates the words.
- 14:29Now, what about what's not necessary for a valid
- 14:31profession? This seems important, especially
- 14:34given some church traditions. It is really important, Edward
- 14:37stresses. It's not necessary for someone
- 14:40to give a detailed account of the particular steps and method
- 14:44by which the Holy Spirit worked in their hearts to bring about
- 14:47these essential things, especially not in a way that
- 14:49was, you know, consciously perceived step by step by them
- 14:53at the time. So you don't.
- 14:54You don't need to be able to recount a specific dateable
- 14:56conversion experience with all the psychological stages mapped
- 15:00out. Exactly.
- 15:01He says Scripture shows no footstep of the apostles or
- 15:04early church leaders requiring such detailed narratives for
- 15:07acceptance into fellowship. They required a profession of
- 15:11the things wrought, the faith, the repentance, the love, but no
- 15:15account of the manner of working.
- 15:16That's a significant distinction.
- 15:18It is, while sharing specific experiences can sometimes be
- 15:21helpful, maybe especially in significant cases like
- 15:23ordination, making it a requirement for accepting
- 15:26someone as a genuine Christian or ignoring the weightier
- 15:29evidence of practice that Edwards argues is unscriptural.
- 15:34So a clear story of conversion might add luster, as he puts it,
- 15:38but it's not the main or essential proof.
- 15:40Precisely the focus should remain on the professed faith
- 15:44and the lived out practice. OK, this helps clarify the role
- 15:47of profession versus practice when looking at others.
- 15:49But what about assurance for ourselves?
- 15:51How does practice function there?
- 15:53This is where it gets really personal for your own
- 15:56conscience, Edwards argues. Christian practice provides a
- 15:59direct, immediate, internal witness to the genuineness of
- 16:03your godliness. It's based on the internal acts
- 16:06and exertions of your soul that direct your outward behavior.
- 16:09So it's not just about observing my own outward actions like
- 16:12someone else would. Not solely, no.
- 16:14It's about the awareness behind those actions.
- 16:17Scripture points to this too. Think of first John 2.3.
- 16:20Hereby we do know that we know Him if we keep His commandments.
- 16:24That knowing comes from the doing, which stems from an inner
- 16:27commitment. And that often refers to the
- 16:29command to love one another, which starts in the heart,
- 16:31right? Yes, it's an act of the mind,
- 16:33the heart carried out in practice or first.
- 16:36John 3.1819 Let us not love in Word, neither in tongue, but in
- 16:41deed and in truth. And hereby we know that we are
- 16:44of the truth and shall assure our hearts assurance comes from
- 16:47loving indeed in truth. Paul in Hebrews 6/2.
- 16:51He saw the Hebrews work and labor of love not just as
- 16:54evidence to him, but as something that gave them
- 16:56assurance, the full assurance of hope.
- 16:58Right, and Galatians 6.4 Let every man prove his own work, so
- 17:02shall he have rejoicing in himself.
- 17:04That in turn, rejoicing comes from examining your own work,
- 17:07your practice. Psalm 119.6 also connects having
- 17:11respect to God's commands with not being ashamed, implying
- 17:14boldness and assurance. Even Christ's teaching in
- 17:17Matthew 7, distinguishing the wise man who does his sayings
- 17:20from the foolish man who only hears them, that seems like a
- 17:22rule for self judgment too. Practice leads to steadfastness
- 17:25assurance. And importantly, those sayings
- 17:27include inward things being poor in spirit, pure in heart, loving
- 17:31enemies. The outward action is rooted in
- 17:33an inner disposition that Edwards believes we can be
- 17:36conscious of. John 14.21 as well.
- 17:39He that hath my commandments and keepeth them, He it is that
- 17:43loveth me. The keeping flows from loving.
- 17:46And passages like Revelation 2.23 or Jeremiah 17.9 to 10,
- 17:51where God searches hearts to render according to works.
- 17:54That implies works include the inner disposition, the heart
- 17:57attitude, not just the external notion.
- 17:59Otherwise, why search the heart? Hezekiah also pleads based on
- 18:03walking in truth and with a perfect heart.
- 18:06So when Scripture talks about good works or keeping commands
- 18:09as evidence for our own conscience, it's more than just
- 18:12the physical movements. Much more without the internal
- 18:15elements, the intention, the will, the motive rooted in
- 18:18grace. Outward actions are, Edward says
- 18:20colorfully, no more good works than the regular motions of a
- 18:23clock. They aren't truly your spiritual
- 18:26actions. So what is it then?
- 18:27What's the core? It's the obedience and fruit of
- 18:29the man, which means the obedience of the soul, the acts
- 18:32and practice of the soul. It's the practical exercise, the
- 18:35exertion of inward holiness that occurs in an obedient act.
- 18:38It's Grace working through the commanding acts of the will that
- 18:41direct the outward action. OK, so Edwards makes the
- 18:44distinction here, right between different kinds of grace acting
- 18:47in the soul. Yes, he talks about, on one
- 18:49hand, imminent acts. These are exercises of grace
- 18:53that sort of begin and end within the soul.
- 18:55Think contemplation, maybe a feeling of love that doesn't
- 18:59immediately translate into an outward deed.
- 19:01It's real, but it stays internal at that moment.
- 19:05That feeling of warmth or conviction that just sits there
- 19:07for a bit. Kind of, yeah.
- 19:09It doesn't directly relate to something to be done externally
- 19:13right then. These, he says, are distinct
- 19:15from practice as the key sign for assurance.
- 19:18So what's the other kind? The kind that is the key sign.
- 19:21Those are the practical or effective exercises of grace.
- 19:24These do immediately respect something to be done.
- 19:27They are the producing acts where grace manifests in
- 19:30obedience. It's the exertions of grace in
- 19:33the commanding acts of the will directing the outward actions.
- 19:36Can you give an example? Sure, think of a believer giving
- 19:39a cup of cold water out of genuine charity flowing from
- 19:42grace, or someone willingly enduring persecution because of
- 19:46their supreme love for Christ. The act of the will motivated by
- 19:51grace commanding the body. That is the practice of the
- 19:54soul. So the decision of the will
- 19:56driven by grace is the action as far as our inner self is
- 20:00concerned. It includes the aim, the
- 20:02intention, the respect for God in that moment.
- 20:05Exactly. God looks on the heart.
- 20:06That inward grace driven decision is the spiritual core.
- 20:10And this practice of the soul, this inner exertion, is
- 20:12something thing we can be directly aware of, more so than
- 20:15even the outward action itself. That's Edward's point.
- 20:18While others see the outward motion, your own conscience has
- 20:21a direct view of the exertion of the soul which directs and
- 20:24commands that motion. You are immediately aware of
- 20:27your own intention, the choice your will is making in a way no
- 20:30one else can be as a primary internal witness.
- 20:33But there has to be consistency right between the inner command
- 20:36and the outer action. Absolutely, he says.
- 20:39It would be ridiculous for someone to claim their will was
- 20:41commanding them to go to worship while their feet were carrying
- 20:44them to a Tavern. Nature itself links the command
- 20:47of the will, involuntary actions to the body's movement.
- 20:50So you can't really separate them.
- 20:52This connection effectively refutes anyone trying to claim
- 20:55inner godliness while living an outwardly wicked life.
- 20:58Precisely. It effectually cuts off all
- 21:01pretensions to evidence of godliness.
- 21:04If the external life is consistently contrary.
- 21:07The practice of the soul and the actions it commands are united,
- 21:10providing a basis for true self assurance or exposing self
- 21:13deception. OK, that leads us to the last
- 21:15part, some key distinctions and the limits of all this.
- 21:18We need to understand how the evidence works differently for
- 21:21others versus ourselves, and accept that external judgments
- 21:24aren't foolproof. Right.
- 21:26So comparing external versus internal evidence, evidence to
- 21:29others mainly relies on what is visible to them.
- 21:32Outward actions, behavior. That's all they have direct
- 21:34access to. But evidence to your own
- 21:36conscience focuses on that in our practice which is visible to
- 21:40our own consciences, that inner exertion of the soul, the
- 21:43commanding act of the will. You see that directly?
- 21:47Yes, it's like watching a car versus driving it.
- 21:50The driver has immediate awareness of the intention and
- 21:53control. Yet these two aspects, inner and
- 21:56outer, are linked, right? They aren't totally separate
- 21:58things. Not at all.
- 22:00Outward actions in a believer are connected to that practical
- 22:03exertion of grace in the will. A claim of inner godliness is
- 22:07contradicted by a life of outward wickedness because the
- 22:10will and the body's actions are normally united by, as Edwards
- 22:14puts it, an unalterable law of nature, involuntary acts.
- 22:18So what about the limits when we're judging others?
- 22:20Can we ever be absolutely certain about someone else's
- 22:22state based on their actions? Edward says no.
- 22:25Well, Christian practice is the best evidence that mankind can
- 22:28have externally. No external manifestations and
- 22:31outward appearances whatsoever are infallible evidences of
- 22:34grace to others. Absolute certainty is impossible
- 22:38for us observing from the outside.
- 22:39Why not? What are the limitations?
- 22:41Well, pretty obviously we see not his heart.
- 22:43We don't know the inner motives perfectly.
- 22:46Second, we don't see all of a person's external behavior much
- 22:49as private. And 3rd, it's impossible
- 22:52certainly to determine how far a man may go in imitating grace
- 22:56from other principles, maybe fear or desire for reputation or
- 22:59even self deception. We just don't have the full
- 23:01picture. But Despite that lack of
- 23:03absolute certainty, these visible signs are sufficient for
- 23:06practical purposes for guiding our conduct in the Church and
- 23:10the world. Yes, they are enough to guide us
- 23:12in how we treat fellow professors, to embrace
- 23:15professors as Saints for fellowship and ministry in this
- 23:18life. We act based on the best
- 23:20evidence available, making charitable judgments based on
- 23:23profession and practice. And finally, while we can't have
- 23:26infallible certainty about others, Edward suggests that our
- 23:29own conscience, viewing the practice of the soul, can
- 23:32potentially reach a sure assurance.
- 23:34That's the powerful implication, he says.
- 23:37If others could see so much of what belongs to men's practice
- 23:40as their own consciences may see of it, it might be an infallible
- 23:44evidence of their state. That internal view, grasping the
- 23:48conscious, grace driven choices of the will, directing our
- 23:51actions that can provide a solid, reliable witness to
- 23:54ourselves about our true spiritual standing.
- 23:57It's an assurance grounded in the reality of grace, actively
- 24:01working through our will and actions.
- 24:03So wrapping this up for today, we've seen how Edwards argues
- 24:06that Christian practice, our visible deeds flowing from the
- 24:09inner workings of our will prompted by grace, really is the
- 24:12chief sign of genuine faith. And that this evidence looks a
- 24:16bit different from the outside looking in, compared to the
- 24:18direct view our own conscience has.
- 24:21And all of this, of course, presupposes a clear
- 24:23understanding and honest profession of faith in Christ.
- 24:26It leaves us with something to really think about if our
- 24:28practice stemming from that interactivity of the soul, can
- 24:31offer us a sure witness of grace.
- 24:33Well, what does that mean for how you live each moment?
- 24:36How might a constant awareness of this practice of the soul,
- 24:39the choices your will makes, the intentions behind your actions,
- 24:43how might that shape your walk of faith, even in the most
- 24:45private times, knowing that God, as we've said, looks directly on
- 24:49the heart?