Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E005: Mark Moss - The Game of Wealth
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation as we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class. We are having all annual
- 1:18maintenance fees for clients that secure their wealth before
- 1:21the next Bitcoin epoch. Really enjoyed the way that you
- 1:24really kind of put through the the claim that you made
- 1:27competing against that. It's not competing against
- 1:29technology, it's competing against value itself.
- 1:31That was good. Yeah, yeah, just a little
- 1:34reframing and it's been, it's been fun to see like Michael
- 1:37Saylor's been using that framing and and I didn't know that Jeff
- 1:41Booth was also using that that number that 900 trillion.
- 1:44So yeah, I I've. I've, I've been using that
- 1:48framing for years but I had come up with when I looked at store
- 1:52of value assets I I came up at a lower number but I included
- 1:57other things. So there's like 30 to 40
- 1:58trillion in offshore bank accounts.
- 2:01So like you didn't have that on there.
- 2:02That's certainly a store of value like 30 to 40 trillion.
- 2:05But I came up with, I think I have to go back and look at the
- 2:08math, but it was like 700 trillion.
- 2:10It's sort of the number I came up with and I was like I just
- 2:12kind of looked at the baskets like we have 5% of the basket
- 2:15where where you kind of went thoughtfully through each one
- 2:17and what percentage we might be able to get of each 1.
- 2:19So it's a little bit more in depth.
- 2:20So it's pretty good. But ultimately I mean I've been
- 2:23a venture cap investor, you know now I have the fund right.
- 2:25So we're constantly looking at like trying to gauge future
- 2:28valuations and that's sort of how we D back into it like what
- 2:30are the markets were disrupting, how big are those total markets,
- 2:32what percentage can we acquire? So yeah, I've been using the
- 2:36framework, but I liked yours, the 900 trillion and like I said
- 2:39more thoughtfully, thinking about percentages as opposed to
- 2:41the total basket, I think obviously some baskets you get
- 2:45more of, right. So like offshore bank accounts,
- 2:49like why wouldn't you get all that right, like gold, why
- 2:52wouldn't we get all of that? Obviously real estate, you know,
- 2:55it's different. Most people in Bitcoin don't
- 2:57understand real estate at all. So they they grossly
- 3:00misrepresent that or misunderstand that.
- 3:03So smaller percentage there, right.
- 3:04But anyway, I liked it. And then the other thing that I
- 3:08put up on Twitter this morning that's getting a bunch of
- 3:11traction was when people ask me what price I'll sell my Bitcoin
- 3:14at, I realize they don't understand the game of money.
- 3:18At all. And and ultimately, it's the
- 3:21game of wealth a couple years ago.
- 3:23Well, we can, we can riff into this if you want.
- 3:25Sorry, let's go into the intro. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:28Let's be clear. Bitcoin is an international
- 3:31asset. We are spending like drunken
- 3:34sailors. Bitcoin is the only economic
- 3:37entity. Where the supply is unaffected
- 3:40by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 3:44wealth, you have. To convert that.
- 3:46Currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 3:51durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom
- 4:00and I'm happy to welcome you to the fifth episode of Scarce
- 4:03Assets, a show that examines scarcity, the most fundamental
- 4:07driver of economics and markets, and the scarcest asset of all
- 4:10which is Bitcoin today. I'm delighted to be here with my
- 4:13Co host Jesse Myers and our guest, the multi talented Mark
- 4:16Moss. And I met Mark in person for the
- 4:19first time at a conference in 2018, and I think Mark had
- 4:24advanced farther in his Bitcoin journey than I had at that time.
- 4:27But Mark was friendly and gracious as always, and we had a
- 4:30great conversation over lunch. Fast forward to today, and Mark
- 4:35creates hours of great content every week in an effort to help
- 4:38people learn. He has a popular syndicated
- 4:41radio show on iHeartRadio called The Mark Moss Show.
- 4:45He has published a great book called the UN Communist
- 4:48Manifesto, and he has several successful businesses, many of
- 4:52which center around investing in education.
- 4:55One of the things I love about Mark is he has had success in
- 4:58multiple businesses and industries over multiple market
- 5:01cycles. And he also has a rare ability
- 5:03to understand and communicate both micro details of an
- 5:07investment and also very long cycles along decades and
- 5:11centuries. So I'm delighted he's here with
- 5:13us. And Mark, how are you?
- 5:16Man, Andy, that was good. I'm gonna rip that intro and use
- 5:19that in my bio from now on. Please do.
- 5:22Please do. Let's just point out to the
- 5:24crowd. I say it all the time.
- 5:25People try to call me out on Twitter like I'm embarrassed,
- 5:27but I talk all the time. In 2018, we met.
- 5:29That was a crypto event. It wasn't a Bitcoin event.
- 5:33It sure was. I was a crypto.
- 5:34I was a crypto bro at the time At that, at that point in 2018,
- 5:39I was writing a cryptocurrency research newsletter from 2016 to
- 5:432019. So for four years I was writing
- 5:45every month, you know, 2025 pages of research on different
- 5:48crypto projects, Dex's privacy coins, you know, whatever big
- 5:53write up on XRP, I say buy it, let's buy XRP.
- 5:57It's going to change the world. You know the way they can do
- 5:59this cross-border settlement. We bought it at 17 cents.
- 6:02We closed it at $3.25. We crushed it, but I spent four
- 6:06years down that and finally in 2019, after doing thousands of
- 6:09pages of research, I published going, Nope, this isn't it, and
- 6:13I'm just going full time Bitcoin.
- 6:15So people still call to try to call me out on Twitter.
- 6:17Oh look at this guy. He's a crypto guy.
- 6:18It's like I was. I'm not embarrassed of that
- 6:20because I I came to it through a place of education, not from
- 6:25like a Luddite who doesn't recognize there's like something
- 6:28going on there. So anyway, that was a crypto
- 6:30event. I remember we were sitting
- 6:31outside, I think at lunch at that table.
- 6:33I forget what event that was. But anyway, yeah, way back.
- 6:36It was this, I think it was the start engine something event and
- 6:40just as an indication of those times, right, It was.
- 6:43I think that organization is now gone.
- 6:45I mean it was basically it was crypto altcoin focused and yeah,
- 6:50as far as I know it's lost to the sands of time.
- 6:54I love your discussion though of EU.
- 6:56Turn back to Bitcoin, you're in good company here, you know.
- 7:00Guilty as Charged was an alt corner.
- 7:02Jesse has stories. About that as well as well,
- 7:05yeah. Andy and I have the same war
- 7:07wounds. I don't.
- 7:08I don't have any guilt over it at all, you know, I mean, first
- 7:11of all, I'm a free to maximalist.
- 7:12So like, everyone's free to go do whatever they want.
- 7:15Second of all, I'm a tech guy, right?
- 7:16I started my career on the Internet.
- 7:17I love. I love technology and so I
- 7:21don't, I don't have any guilt or shame with it.
- 7:22I just choose to focus on and build my house on the rock, not
- 7:25in the sand if you will. And so that's sort of the shift.
- 7:29So I mean, whatever, we're all recovering crypto addicts or
- 7:32whatever. But yeah, I don't, I don't come
- 7:34from a from from a shameful place.
- 7:36But yeah, that's the. Best.
- 7:37Yeah, I think we, I think Andy and I both don't have any, like,
- 7:41guilt or shame about it, but I certainly have regret.
- 7:44Regret that I didn't do the homework sooner, that I didn't
- 7:47like. Consider this crazy different
- 7:50perspective of like of this not being about tech but instead
- 7:53being about Austrian economics, which is not what I learned
- 7:56about in school. You know, it took me a while to
- 7:58consider that that was right, and I wish I'd done it sooner.
- 8:02Well, I think you know what and what Andy said the very gracious
- 8:05again intro that he gave me. He said that Mark has made money
- 8:08and across multiple markets and multiple time frames.
- 8:11Basically he was saying I'm old, but you know, I've invested in
- 8:14multiple cycles. And periods experience.
- 8:16The word is experienced. But I think in order to
- 8:19understand really the world, if really if we go really broad
- 8:22with it, certainly economics and certainly Bitcoin, you really
- 8:25have to have multiple disciplines.
- 8:28If you only come at it from 1 discipline, it's really hard to
- 8:31understand and and and just down a bigger scale even on a
- 8:34financial side. You mentioned like Austrian
- 8:36economics, which I love Austrian economics because it pulls in
- 8:39like human psychology, you know, human action as Mises would say.
- 8:43And I find a lot of the, the macro Bros who who I consider
- 8:47friends, they're so in depth in the weeds on the financial data
- 8:53that they missed the forest for the trees.
- 8:55And so they're so looking at. I mean, like, I don't want to
- 8:58call them out on the show, but the king of the euro dollar
- 9:01market will just say that, you know, and I talked to him and
- 9:05he's way smarter than I'll ever be in regards to that.
- 9:08But I I feel that he doesn't understand the human psychology
- 9:11and the human motivations and incentive structures.
- 9:13And like, he misses the bigger global picture of what's going
- 9:16on. And so it doesn't allow his
- 9:18conclusions to be formed the way that I see them anyway.
- 9:21So I I back to making money across multiple markets.
- 9:25I've thought of myself as this generalist.
- 9:28Last summer I took my family to Europe for a month.
- 9:31We went to Florence, which was awesome.
- 9:33And I realized, no, I'm a I'm a renaissance man.
- 9:36Not not a generous because those guys understood multiple
- 9:38disciplines. And so anyway, back to Bitcoin.
- 9:40I think you have to understand multiple disciplines.
- 9:42And back-to-back to crypto if you're just the tech bro.
- 9:46Or really most of crypto are just USD Bros, right?
- 9:49They're just trying to make more U.S. dollars.
- 9:51Some of them are, are they? They think they're tech Bros.
- 9:54But if you understand multiple disciplines, then you understand
- 9:56Bitcoin is is the thing. Yeah, agreed completely.
- 10:00So let's, you know, let's see if we can tease out a little bit
- 10:02more of of your experience across multiple industries here.
- 10:07I mean you mentioned that you were you, you ran a successful
- 10:10business, built a business earlier in the Internet days,
- 10:13you know when when the Internet essentially was becoming much
- 10:15more popular. And then also you built a real
- 10:19estate business and that was, you know, formative for you went
- 10:22through a bubble and a bust and all that good stuff.
- 10:24Are there any, when you think across those experiences other
- 10:28than, you know, reading widely and learning widely and being a
- 10:31Renaissance type of type of thinker investor.
- 10:36What are some of the other lessons that that you've come
- 10:38away with that you think might be helpful to folks that that
- 10:42are on the path? Yeah, sure.
- 10:45I mean that that's a big question.
- 10:46So it depends on what path they're on.
- 10:48So I would say a couple things. First of all, I got, I didn't
- 10:53choose the traditional path. You hear me talk a lot about
- 10:55parallel markets and part of that's just because I've had a
- 10:57very non traditional path to where I'm at today towards
- 11:00building wealth. And so right out of high school
- 11:02I started buying real estate. I started buying bank owned
- 11:04repos and fixing them and I I got 10 down from the bank.
- 11:08They were giving them away, fixed it and flipped it and I
- 11:10went on to fix and flip 100 properties.
- 11:12So I kind of just right away just hit the ground running and
- 11:15I remember being here in Southern California, not not in
- 11:20Silicon Valley, but not too far from that at in those late 90s.
- 11:24I remember I was already up and going, I was doing my real
- 11:27estate thing. My roommate at the time quit his
- 11:29job and became a day trader trading these crazy things
- 11:33called Internet stocks that nobody had heard of in the 90s.
- 11:37And it was like what? What the heck are these?
- 11:38And when we would talk about them, people would look at us
- 11:40like people looked at crypto guys from a couple years ago.
- 11:44So we are day trading these these crypto things.
- 11:47I'm sorry, these Internet things.
- 11:48One big take away from that. Well let me let me go forward
- 11:51and I'll come back to that. In 1999, one of my buddies had
- 11:55this idea to start this Internet business.
- 11:57And of course like I said Silicon Valley is not too far
- 11:59away. The Internet world's blowing up.
- 12:01Everyone that starts at dot com is getting rich.
- 12:04So we had this idea of starting a website where you could shop
- 12:07and you could earn rewards that can go to a charity of your
- 12:09choice which there's like 1000 of those today.
- 12:11But not 99 and there wasn't and there was no way to get on the
- 12:14Internet. And we literally, I had an
- 12:15office at the time and we literally had to set up our own
- 12:18rack, our own servers, 2 servers, RAID, 5 hot swappable
- 12:23hard drives. Because the Internet was
- 12:25decentralized, you had to run your own node if you wanted to
- 12:29get on the Internet. That's an on.
- 12:32Premise On premise. That was the only way.
- 12:34There was no Amazon, there was no cloud services, there was no
- 12:36Shopify whatever, right? So literally we had to set up
- 12:39our own node, our own database, to run our own servers.
- 12:42So that's that's an interesting parallel then, like if we went
- 12:45to the.com boom and bust in 2001.
- 12:48So at the bottom of the bust, after everybody looked stupid
- 12:50and ridiculous, I thought it would be a good idea to start a
- 12:52ecommerce business selling motocross stuff online.
- 12:56And I went to these companies. So I had to spend like 25 grand
- 12:59to build like the most basic like shopping cart because there
- 13:01was no again Shopify. And I went to these companies
- 13:04and I said, hey, I built this website, I want to sell your
- 13:06products on my website and they laughed at me and they told me
- 13:09nobody would ever buy anything online.
- 13:10And this was in 2001, right? But it was because everyone
- 13:14looked sillyafterthe.com bust. And I'm like, I I disagree.
- 13:17I spent the money, I built the website, whatever.
- 13:19I'm happy just to give you the money, whatever they said we
- 13:21don't even want our products being sold on the Internet.
- 13:24So when we, when we got to the crypto boom, you know, I'm like,
- 13:27hey, I've been here before. I've heard this one parallel
- 13:30from that is decentralization going to centralization.
- 13:34The Internet became very centralized obviously now with
- 13:37SSO logins for Google, Facebook, etcetera.
- 13:40And you know obviously Amazon, we can get into that.
- 13:42But another parallel, and I said this about a year ago that that
- 13:45shocked a lot of people and actually it was the consensus
- 13:48conference, which is the crypto conference.
- 13:50I've been going to that also since like 2017 and I I think
- 13:55maybe it was 2022. It was in Austin.
- 13:57I went and I mainly just went for being in Austin and having
- 14:00some meetings around that. And I was at one of the events
- 14:03and it was all Crypto Bros And I remember just thinking to my
- 14:06head and I was asking people what's the most important thing
- 14:08that you saw, what was the most groundbreaking thing you saw,
- 14:09etcetera. And I remember thinking in my
- 14:11head, and then I came out and publicly said this.
- 14:13I said within a couple of years, I think three years.
- 14:14Crypto is gone. Crypto as a category is gone.
- 14:18And the reason why is because when my roommate was trading
- 14:21Internet stocks, there's no such thing as Internet stocks
- 14:24anymore. Yeah, what?
- 14:26Are Internet interesting? They're just companies now.
- 14:29It's just Apple. It's just in it, right?
- 14:30And and what I meant is crypto as a category is just because
- 14:34it's like over here we have like blockchain video games.
- 14:37And over here we have like title and escrow on the blockchain.
- 14:40And over here we have like supply chain man.
- 14:42I'm like, so go to a supply chain management show, go to a
- 14:45real estate show, go to a go to a video game conference, right.
- 14:48And so I think crypto as a category is gone.
- 14:50So that's like some of this historical parallels.
- 14:52You see the way technology comes and goes.
- 14:54Technology always follows a very predictable cycle.
- 14:57There's diffusion of innovation and so that's kind of where I
- 15:01think crypto and Bitcoin sort of fit in from my own experience,
- 15:04having lived through this through multiple cycles, so.
- 15:08Anyway, I love that. I love that color.
- 15:10I love that that parallel. That's a bold.
- 15:13It's a bold call, but when you put the historical context on,
- 15:16it makes complete sense. And and and I'm.
- 15:18And I'm not saying for the crypto Bros, which I know
- 15:21they're not listening to this, and I'm not saying that company
- 15:24still won't try to use blockchain.
- 15:26I'm not saying that like, blockchain is just a database,
- 15:28right? Like they're going to try to do
- 15:29different types of database, sure.
- 15:32But what I'm saying is crypto as a category is just gone.
- 15:35Just like Internet as a category is gone.
- 15:37Imagine having a trade show today.
- 15:38An Internet trade show? Like, what would that even be?
- 15:41You know what I mean? It makes no sense.
- 15:44Agreed, agreed. Well, that's, that's really
- 15:47helpful context. What about as it relates to your
- 15:49entrepreneurial journey? I mean, you know, launching a
- 15:52business that's Internet based 20 years ago and now you know
- 15:58many of your businesses and activities, your educational
- 16:01activities are are all Internet based.
- 16:04Is there something that's different today, 20 years later,
- 16:08in a much more developed Internet ecosystem, or do the
- 16:12same rules kind of apply? Well, I like to say principles
- 16:16are few, Methods are many. So there's core principles of
- 16:20life. The ways that we apply those,
- 16:22the methods that we apply them. There's a million, right?
- 16:24So I think the core principles are the same.
- 16:26But you know, obviously, as I already said, right, like back
- 16:29then, I had to build my own server just to get on the
- 16:31Internet. Today we can just like spin one
- 16:33up. And so things have definitely
- 16:35gotten easier. I've said many times, I think,
- 16:38you know, making money today is easier than it's ever been in
- 16:41the history of the world for two main reasons.
- 16:45One, we literally have trillions of dollars just sloshing around
- 16:51the economy. Yeah.
- 16:52Trillions of dollars. And if we want to get into the
- 16:54macro side, we can. But obviously, like, people are
- 16:56like, Oh my gosh, like the market should have crashed two
- 16:58years ago, but they haven't. Yeah, because we put $12
- 17:00trillion into the economy, right?
- 17:02That's still rushing. So it's like, man, all you have
- 17:04to do is just like put a net out and grab that number one, number
- 17:06two, the tools. So anybody with this, I can
- 17:10learn anything. I can meet anybody and I can do
- 17:14anything from this. People are like, you gotta go to
- 17:18college to build your network. Really.
- 17:20I've been at Michael Saylors house three times and I never
- 17:22went to college with him. I met him through this, right?
- 17:25So I mean, obviously us as well. So I think 1 the tools are
- 17:29there. It's never, never been easier
- 17:32because the tools that we have obviously at the point that the
- 17:33Internet's at as well and because of the amount of money
- 17:37that's sloshing around in the ecosystem at the same time.
- 17:39So while this is another another sort of point that obviously I
- 17:44think about a lot, but I, but I wrote this down on Friday.
- 17:46I was at this event and a macro guy was up there talking about
- 17:51the the the debt and the amount of currency and circulation and
- 17:54the inflation and all these things.
- 17:56And he said that they want to be in the government, They want
- 18:00inflation to inflate away their debt.
- 18:03Yeah, I had put something on. I got locked out of my Twitter
- 18:07account for five months, a hacker who got in and set my two
- 18:09FAS out for five months. I spent much time on Instagram,
- 18:12so now now I'm on Instagram quite a bit.
- 18:15I I put up a post on Instagram and I said unsuccessful.
- 18:18People think the game is rigged against them.
- 18:21Successful people realize the game is rigged and learn how to
- 18:24play. And So what We you and I, were
- 18:28all guilty of inflation, inflation, inflation.
- 18:30They're stealing our life, they're stealing our value and
- 18:32facing this theft, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 18:34Our purchasing power is going down, etcetera, yes, but the
- 18:37unsuccessful people seize that and think that's rigged against
- 18:39them. I can't get ahead.
- 18:40They're stealing my wealth. The successful people go, well,
- 18:43if they're doing it to inflate away their debt, that means
- 18:45they're also inflating away my debt.
- 18:48That's pretty good. Well, what does inflation do?
- 18:52Well, it makes things more expensive, like assets.
- 18:56So maybe I should buy assets and I should use debt.
- 18:58That'd be a pretty good idea. They'll push the value of my
- 19:02assets up and pay off my loans at the same time.
- 19:04I like that. And so those are some like
- 19:07realizations that I've sort of had lately.
- 19:11Interesting entering concept. If you wanna talk, I did.
- 19:14And just just one more piece real quick.
- 19:17A couple years ago I did a video on how to retire off of Bitcoin.
- 19:21Spoiler alert, it's using debt against it, right?
- 19:24So you hold scarce assets, you never sell them and use debt to
- 19:26leverage against it. Putting out a new report, it's
- 19:29almost done and it's it's a full report on why you don't sell
- 19:34assets. The goal is to get more assets,
- 19:36leveraging debt, debt for tax efficiency.
- 19:40And then I have a calculator so you can put in how much Bitcoin
- 19:44you have. And then I have like a rate of a
- 19:46projected rate of return. Jesse will like this.
- 19:48I'm just kind of coming out of left field thinking of like what
- 19:51a projected rate of return might be over the next 20 years and
- 19:53then how much debt you would have to leverage to pull out,
- 19:56how much money and spoiler alert on this, I'll stop and then
- 20:00we'll talk about it. But at like $100,000 of of
- 20:03Bitcoin, if you wait five years, you could keep it about a 10%
- 20:09debt leverage every single year, about 10% of debt per year to
- 20:14maintain. Well, with a a a rate of
- 20:17inflation, you can start about $100,000 a year free cash flow
- 20:20up to about 200,000 in a year 20.
- 20:22Without ever going above 10% leverage on your on your Bitcoin
- 20:26so. I'm keen to read that again,
- 20:30that report, Yeah, no, I'm, I'm definitely keen to read that,
- 20:32that report, Mark. And you know, one of my feelings
- 20:35about debt and leverage in Bitcoin is there's some kinds of
- 20:38debt that makes sense and there are others that don't because
- 20:42you got the risk of getting liquidated, getting rugged.
- 20:45But I'm optimistic that in the coming years, the debt market
- 20:49for Bitcoin is likely to to develop significantly.
- 20:53What do you think, Jesse? Yeah, I I I wrote a piece about
- 20:56this in 2021 called Asset DNA explaining the speculative
- 21:03attack. It was all about like
- 21:06highlighting how assets tend to exponentially increase in value
- 21:11over time in Fiat terms, in nominal terms.
- 21:15And obviously there's other forms of of assets that are
- 21:18really consumption. You know, where you're, you're
- 21:21destroying value by driving your car or you know, holding airline
- 21:26miles because they get diluted away.
- 21:29And you know, those things are it's the DNA of of these
- 21:32different asset types. Some appreciate in value, some
- 21:35decrease in value and dollars decrease in purchasing power
- 21:39over time in exponential, exponential fashion.
- 21:42Whereas Bitcoin, because of its increasing scarcity, increases
- 21:46exponentially over time in its purchasing power.
- 21:49And so that's the seed for the speculative attack for Bitcoin.
- 21:53If if you can borrow dollars today, wait for a sufficient
- 21:57amount of time for the asset DNA to manifest as a divergent in
- 22:02purchasing power between Bitcoin and dollars, and then sell a
- 22:06little bit of the Bitcoin to settle the debt that is now
- 22:09decreased in purchasing power in in in nominal dollar terms.
- 22:14That's the playbook that micro strategy has been using to to an
- 22:19extent and it's there for everyone to take.
- 22:22However, there's a lot of risk and volatility in managing that
- 22:26appropriately. Frankly, I've always been a
- 22:28little too afraid to touch it because I I don't want to be
- 22:31liquidated. So I just hold and and that's
- 22:34enough. But that opportunity is there
- 22:37for anybody who's willing to do it.
- 22:38Let's break that down a little bit, though.
- 22:41It's not as big, bad and scary as you might make it out to out
- 22:45to seem. So first I want to say, Jesse,
- 22:48you did a great job of the technical details of a
- 22:50speculative attack. That paper came out I think Was
- 22:54it Pierre wrote it or was it bitstein that?
- 22:56Wrote it but like 2014. Yeah, 2014 wrote that.
- 23:00Read Rich Dad, Poor Dad, right. He talks about good debt versus
- 23:03bad debt, right. So just go read that.
- 23:04It's very basic. Everyone can understand that.
- 23:06But let's talk about that for a second.
- 23:07So, Wall, you have Dave Ramsey. On one side of the table says
- 23:14don't use debt. Never use debt.
- 23:16Pay off your debt as fast as you can.
- 23:18On the other side, you have Robert Kiyosaki.
- 23:20All right, Robert Kiyosaki became a billionaire by using
- 23:22debt. Donald Trump became a
- 23:25billionaire by using debt. Grant Cardone became a
- 23:28billionaire by using debt. So you first of all, what game
- 23:30are we playing? I didn't make the rules.
- 23:33I'm just in the game playing. We are in a debt based monetary
- 23:37system. That means money is created
- 23:40through debt, not through savings.
- 23:43Now I get the Austrian School of Economics and I want that world.
- 23:46I'm I'm actively building towards that world, but that's
- 23:48not the world that we're in. So I'm playing the game that
- 23:50we're in. So people, when I was a kid, I
- 23:53remember you know, hearing all the time my parents might say
- 23:55like I wish I had a money tree. We do.
- 23:58We have a money tree. Literally, if I want $1,000,000
- 24:02to buy an apartment building or a business, I just go to my
- 24:05money tree. That's the bank.
- 24:07They give me $1,000,000, I go buy like the money's there now,
- 24:11Magic. So.
- 24:12So money is created through debt issuance.
- 24:15That's the game. So the Dave Ramsey's of the
- 24:17world. But to the point that you're
- 24:19making, I want to talk about this risk to the point you're
- 24:20making. It's very risky.
- 24:22Debt is leverage. Leverage works two ways.
- 24:25It builds up faster, tear downs faster.
- 24:27I like to say that debt is like debt is like fire.
- 24:31I can use fire to warm my house and cook my food or it can burn
- 24:35my house down. Now Robert Kiyosaki, who is my
- 24:38mentor, he's now one of my good friends.
- 24:39He told me we were on a live stream on his show together and
- 24:42he said Dave Ramsey is right for most people because most people
- 24:45are too stupid to know how to use debt.
- 24:48So think about like a little kid, a 5 year old kid.
- 24:50Like you wouldn't let that kid play with fire because that they
- 24:53don't know how to handle fire. Like a 5 year old kid, they
- 24:55could light the house on fire, right?
- 24:56But hopefully as an adult you're mature enough and you're smart
- 24:59enough to know how to manage fire properly.
- 25:02So part of it is your skill set. I like to say that risk is not
- 25:05in the investment, it's in the investor.
- 25:08If I were to take you guys to Hawaii with me right now, we go
- 25:11to the North Shore pipeline waves are 30 feet and I'm like,
- 25:13hey, let's go swimming. At 30 foot waves, you guys would
- 25:16probably drowned. But yet there's hundreds of guys
- 25:18out there surfing every day and they're just having fun.
- 25:21The risk isn't in the wave, it's in the person in the water.
- 25:23That makes sense. So I think of a debt and
- 25:26leverage the same way the Kiyosaki, the Trump, the Cardone
- 25:29have done pretty well with it. The average person gets
- 25:31themselves in trouble because they're going on vacations and
- 25:33dinners with that. OK, so that's the first thing.
- 25:35Now let's talk more about this. So that's the first thing.
- 25:39So if I really want to build wealth, I have to use debt.
- 25:41As you said, micro strategy is using this platform or this
- 25:44strategy perfectly, but I want to go back to the the the risk
- 25:48specifically. So Andy said he's sort of afraid
- 25:50of it because he doesn't want to get rugged.
- 25:52So let's just think about this. Now use some general numbers
- 25:55here. If I buy Bitcoin today at
- 25:58whatever it's at 50,000, whatever it's at 60, whatever,
- 26:0162,000. I have a block clock but I can't
- 26:03see it from where I'm. Saying it's moving quickly.
- 26:05It's moving mostly upward, mostly in One Direction.
- 26:08Let's just let's say I buy it at 50,000, OK?
- 26:10And it goes to 100,000, right? So now I'm sitting on $200,000
- 26:14worth of Bitcoin and I'd like to go buy something else.
- 26:19I'd like to go buy a car. I need a new truck for my
- 26:21delivery business. I want productive assets, not
- 26:25unpressed. So I want a new delivery truck
- 26:26for my business to scale. I want a new apartment to rent
- 26:29or whatever it may be. So I have two options.
- 26:32Option one is I sell the Bitcoin.
- 26:34That's option one. If I sell the Bitcoin, I pay
- 26:37tax. I'm in California.
- 26:38I'm at the top, top tax bracket, so half of that goes to taxes.
- 26:42Half option one sell the Bitcoin.
- 26:45I no longer have the Bitcoin and half of my money goes to the
- 26:48government. Option two is I borrow 50%
- 26:53against the Bitcoin. That income is now tax free and
- 26:58I still have the Bitcoin to continue to go up in value.
- 27:02Now let's talk about the risk. So the risk is that I could get,
- 27:06Andy said get rugged, Jesse said.
- 27:08Maybe the leverage wipes you out.
- 27:10So what does that look like? So first of all, when I, when I
- 27:13think about risk management, the one rule that I learned early on
- 27:17is very generally, what's the worst that can happen and am I
- 27:21OK with that? So what's the worst that can
- 27:24happen? I lose all the Bitcoin.
- 27:25I can't cover the leverage. They rug me, they steal it,
- 27:29whatever. OK, Well, let's see.
- 27:32So if that were to happen, well, I still got the money out of it
- 27:36and I no longer have the Bitcoin.
- 27:37I'm actually no worse off than I would be if I would have just
- 27:40sold it in the first place. Now we can tweak the numbers a
- 27:45little bit. We can tweak the numbers a
- 27:47little bit and we can different tax brackets and we can get into
- 27:50the weeds on this for sure. But I'm, we're talking generally
- 27:52here, right? So if I sold the Bitcoin, gave
- 27:55half of it to taxes because I'm in California at the top tax
- 27:58bracket, or I borrowed 50% against it and I lost it, I kind
- 28:02of end up at about this, about the same place, more or less,
- 28:05except the difference is now I have the other asset.
- 28:10When you pitch it that way now, that seems pretty appealing.
- 28:14Now that's the worst that can happen.
- 28:16That's the worst. Now, how do we mitigate for
- 28:18this? So Andy said, if we get rugged,
- 28:20so I borrow with Unchained capital and I keep one of my
- 28:22keys, I don't get rugged. Yeah, Jesse said.
- 28:27I'm afraid of the leverage. If I get margin called, I can't
- 28:29cover. So in my calculation, I'm only
- 28:31borrowing 10% of my stack. What happens is when people
- 28:35borrow 50% of their stack and they can't cover the leverage,
- 28:38if I'm only borrowing against 10%, I should be able to meet
- 28:41any margin call that happens, because historically Bitcoin
- 28:46drawdowns have been getting less and less and less.
- 28:48We saw 95%, now we're down to 80%.
- 28:50Probably the next big drawdown will probably be 60%.
- 28:54So if I'm only leveraging a 10% of my stack, I should be able to
- 28:57cover any margin call that happens.
- 29:00Now again, maybe not. Maybe we have a 95%.
- 29:03Draw it out again and you're over leveraged.
- 29:05That's what happened to me in 2008.
- 29:07I sold multiple businesses. I built up 10s of millions of
- 29:10dollars of real estate in 2008. I got rugged, the central banks
- 29:14rugged me and I couldn't carry my property.
- 29:16I had levered them up. I had multiple 8 figures at
- 29:21about a 60% LTV, but in California real estate dropped
- 29:2660% in one year and I couldn't cover, I couldn't meet the
- 29:32margin call and I lost it, right?
- 29:34So it happened to me. So again, the worst that can
- 29:36happen is I end up about the same if I would have sold the
- 29:38Bitcoin. Best case scenario if I'm only
- 29:40borrowing 10%, I should be able to meet that and so we sort of
- 29:42mitigate that. So anyway.
- 29:45Well, it's helpful to have that perspective, especially from
- 29:47someone who's lived, you know, lived through the massive margin
- 29:50call even in an asset class like real estate, which doesn't mark
- 29:55to market quite as frequently as as Bitcoin.
- 29:59I'd love to get your take your perspective on a couple of
- 30:01things. First of all, we're talking
- 30:03about borrowing against Bitcoin instead of selling it.
- 30:06I think you tweeted recently about about selling Bitcoin, or
- 30:10someone asked you about when you would sell your Bitcoin, which
- 30:14prompted an interesting response.
- 30:16I'm wondering if your answer is never or what the answer is, but
- 30:20I'd also like to talk about how much flow you see from real
- 30:23estate into Bitcoin, so tackle those however you'd like.
- 30:26Yeah, so I posted that on Twitter this morning and I said
- 30:28when people ask me, which they ask me all the time, and I'm
- 30:30sure you get asked all the time at the same time as is, at what
- 30:33price will you sell your Bitcoin?
- 30:35And what I said is when people ask me that, I just look at them
- 30:38and say, you have no idea the game that we're playing.
- 30:42You just don't like, you don't know that we're in a game.
- 30:45If you don't know you're playing a game, how are you going to win
- 30:47if you don't know the objective of the game?
- 30:48If I came over to your house with a stack of board games and
- 30:50I'm like, hey, let's play this game, you're like, OK, well,
- 30:52what is it? What's the objective?
- 30:54What are the rules? Who are the players?
- 30:56Right. Like things like that.
- 30:57So again, one, we're in a debt based monetary system.
- 31:00Most people don't understand that 2.
- 31:03The game is to acquire assets. The goal is to earn money and
- 31:09use the money to acquire assets. My goal is like, hopefully
- 31:14you're looking at your financial statements every month.
- 31:16Andy, you're you're a finance guy.
- 31:18You should, you know, you certainly know this.
- 31:20One of the three reports you should look at every month is
- 31:22your balance sheet. I call it your scorecard.
- 31:25What are my assets? The goal is for me throughout my
- 31:28life, for my assets to grow. Now, obviously there's higher
- 31:32goals than just gaining assets. But in the game of money, let's
- 31:35say my goal is to gain is to build my assets every month.
- 31:39I want my assets to be more, more, more, more, more, more,
- 31:41right? So when people say, what, at
- 31:44what price will you sell your Bitcoin?
- 31:45It's like the goal isn't to sell assets to get more dollars.
- 31:48The goal is to earn more dollars to buy more assets.
- 31:51So first of all, you don't even understand the game.
- 31:53That's number one. That's the broad game.
- 31:56Then we get into the intricacies of the game, which is dead tax
- 31:59efficiency, which we already went through.
- 32:01So I don't need to recap all that, but it's just like most
- 32:04people are so financially illiterate that they don't even
- 32:07understand the game that we're playing.
- 32:10I mean, if you've played Monopoly, you understand the
- 32:12game of Monopoly is to get as many assets as we possibly can.
- 32:16That's the game. That's how you win the game of
- 32:17Monopoly if you play the Game of Life.
- 32:19I used to play with my kids, The Game of life.
- 32:21Same deal. Robert Kiyasaki's game.
- 32:24Rich, Dad, I'm sorry. Cash flow, amazing game.
- 32:27If everyone will play that game one time per month, it will
- 32:30change your life. I'm not joking.
- 32:33So anyway, the game is to acquire assets and then there's
- 32:36ways that different strategy we can employ.
- 32:38Like I said, tax, efficiency, debt, etcetera.
- 32:40So anyway, that that was the kind of the point of the tweet.
- 32:42Most people don't understand. The goal is to gain assets.
- 32:44Now what type of assets do we want to gain?
- 32:47There's three main types of assets.
- 32:48I think about #1 are scarce assets.
- 32:52So in an highly inflationary environment like we're in today,
- 32:55inflation pushes most assets up, but it pushes scarce assets up
- 33:01even much faster. So if you look at, let's just
- 33:05real estate is basically a perfect proxy for for inflation.
- 33:08So if you look at, we've had about a 40% increase in the
- 33:10money supply in the last 3-4 years.
- 33:13US median real estate went up about 40%.
- 33:15Austin, the fastest growing city in the United States, went up
- 33:17about 40%. But in Austin, there's a lake
- 33:20called Lake Travis, and on the lake there's homes on the lake.
- 33:24On the water, there's only a couple of them and they went up
- 33:27by 200%. OK, That's the difference of
- 33:31scarce assets versus regular assets.
- 33:34So one we have scarce assets that could also be fine art,
- 33:37that could be collectibles, you know, old cars.
- 33:40Obviously Bitcoin fits into that category.
- 33:43My buddy down the street here has like 2 old Mustangs he
- 33:46bought for like 50-60 thousand each.
- 33:47They're both worth over $5 million today, right?
- 33:50Scarce assets. He had Shelby signed the glove
- 33:52box on one of them. It's a scarce asset.
- 33:55So we want scarce assets #2. We want energy intensive assets.
- 33:59These are assets that can't just be recreated, right?
- 34:02So gold fits into this like commodities fit into this,
- 34:05Cattle fits into this. Things that just can't be
- 34:07artificially inflated, Those are good.
- 34:09Obviously not as good as as as as scarce assets obviously.
- 34:14And then the third type of asset is neither scarce nor energy
- 34:18intensive and I might use some of those for more speculative
- 34:21purposes. So you might think of like
- 34:23equities would fit into that. I typically don't encourage
- 34:26anyone to play in that game because you ain't got no edge
- 34:28there unless you're a high frequency trader with billions
- 34:30of dollars. You have no edge there.
- 34:31Don't play with that game. But maybe, you know, P/E, VC
- 34:35funds, you know, I have the Bitcoin Opportunity Fund for
- 34:37example. I might put it into into that
- 34:39type of a category. So that's kind of how I think
- 34:41about it. So I think about earning my
- 34:43wealth, creating wealth by providing value to the market,
- 34:47earning dollars, earning money and then taking that money.
- 34:50And instead of investing, I think of it as saving.
- 34:52I save my wealth in real estate and Bitcoin and by by shifting
- 34:58that from investing into Bitcoin or investing into real estate
- 35:02and now thinking of just saving there, it gives me a long term
- 35:05perspective and then I don't get caught into this trap of when
- 35:07are you going to sell. I love that, yeah.
- 35:11The the framing of saving versus investing is one that a lot of
- 35:14people stumble over. I stumble over too.
- 35:17I mean, we were we were talking with Pierre and Morgan Rashard
- 35:20on our last episode about about exactly that.
- 35:23And I was trying to pin them down on well really what is
- 35:25saving versus versus investing. And I think that it's, I think
- 35:30it's important for people to think about for their own lives
- 35:33and make their, their allocations and their decisions
- 35:35based on. But, but some of these ideas are
- 35:37a little bit fuzzy, a little bit a little bit slippery.
- 35:41Yeah. Mark, I'm curious like in your
- 35:44time in Bitcoin, how has your perception of like saving in
- 35:49real estate versus saving in Bitcoin evolved and where is
- 35:52that at today? Yeah, so this is the next part
- 35:55about the money game. So if we play a game, some
- 35:58people are better at games than others.
- 35:59So if I've been playing this board game for five years and
- 36:02I've played 100 of opponents and then I play you for the first
- 36:04time, I have all kinds of tips, tricks, strategies that I know
- 36:07how to do in the game and you don't.
- 36:09And this is where unfortunately most of the world falls in and
- 36:13and a lot of bitcoiners fall into this trap.
- 36:14They don't understand the game and they haven't played the game
- 36:17enough to know the strategies in the game.
- 36:19The rich do. OK, so there's two main
- 36:23strategies that you can really speed up your wealth
- 36:25accumulation. Bitcoin.
- 36:27Michael Saylor understands this very well.
- 36:29One, we already talked about debt, but two, your single
- 36:34largest loss of wealth is taxes. So I need to figure that
- 36:39strategy out. And then three, so you know, we
- 36:42talk about in economics, we talk about the velocity of money.
- 36:46What's the velocity of money, Andy?
- 36:48Wow, I guess it depends on the the it's.
- 36:50Measuring how fast the dollar moves through the economy.
- 36:53Oh, you mean literally? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:54Yeah, right. So it's like if I gave you 20
- 36:56bucks and then you gave it to Jesse and Jesse gave it to the
- 36:58car mechanic or whatever. So it's like measures, how many
- 37:00times does $1.00 get spent through the economy.
- 37:04I have a whole training on this. I'll, I'll give you the high
- 37:06level version, but I call it velocity of money.
- 37:10And how fast can I move $1.00 through multiple investments?
- 37:14You see, if I can invest $1.10 times, I'm going to build wealth
- 37:18faster than you, 10 times faster.
- 37:21Most people have never thought about this.
- 37:23So like, I'm just going to go buy my Bitcoin and I'm going to
- 37:25sit the 6.25 Bitcoin in there and I'm going to go huddle on a
- 37:28hill and I'll come back in 10 years.
- 37:30I'll be rich. OK, that's cool.
- 37:33I'll build wealth 10 times faster than you and my house
- 37:35will be bigger on the hill, right?
- 37:36And how? Because I can spend $1.00
- 37:38multiple times. How do you do that?
- 37:40So let's talk about real estate, for example.
- 37:43We can we this is, there's multiple layers.
- 37:46Some people have figured out how to spend or invest $1.00 two
- 37:48times. Some people can figure how to do
- 37:50it three times. Some people can figure out
- 37:5245678. The more times you can do it,
- 37:55obviously, the faster you can build your wealth, right.
- 37:56So let's think about this. So the first number one thing is
- 38:00I don't want to pay taxes. That's the number one thing
- 38:02because right now in California at the income bracket, I'm in
- 38:05half my wealth is gone. OK, So I'm at a major
- 38:09disadvantage right off the bat. So if I could keep 100% of my
- 38:14wealth, could I grow wealth faster?
- 38:16Of course. Big time.
- 38:16OK, so how could I do that? How could I pay no tax legally?
- 38:20Legally is the is the keyword there.
- 38:22One I could move to Puerto Rico. I did that.
- 38:24I moved in 2021. That was awesome by the way.
- 38:26I loved Puerto Rico. I would have stayed.
- 38:29It's just my girls are like teenagers and it's not a good
- 38:31place to raise teenage girls in my opinion.
- 38:32My wife loved it too Anyway, So one you can move to Puerto Rico,
- 38:35that's an option. Go hang out with David Bailey,
- 38:38Super cool dude. I like David, but we can just
- 38:41use real estate. So let me give you an example.
- 38:43Thanks to Donald Trump. He passed something called
- 38:45accelerated depreciation. Accelerated depreciation means I
- 38:48can buy an asset, I can take all the depreciation in one year.
- 38:52Now that's been going away, it was at 100%.
- 38:54Now it was at 80% last year, but I believe it's getting re
- 38:57renewed and it's going to go back to 100%.
- 38:59So for example in 2022 I made $1,000,000 of profit.
- 39:04So option one, I give 500,000 to the government and they use it
- 39:10for things that I don't approve of or and I I give 500 to them.
- 39:15They use it for things I don't want and I keep 500 left or I
- 39:18buy a million dollar piece of real estate and only put 200,000
- 39:23down. I get $1,000,000 of write off.
- 39:27Now I have 800,000 in my bank and $1,000,000 property.
- 39:31That's cash flowing and building equity for me.
- 39:34And the thanks to inflation, they're paying it off for me.
- 39:37So now instead of 500, I have 800 and $1,000,000 property.
- 39:42So right off the bat, that's pretty good.
- 39:44You would say that's a better deal.
- 39:46People don't understand this about real estate.
- 39:48Oh, real estate's a scam. Bitcoin's going to go up faster
- 39:50than real estate. OK, cool.
- 39:52That's just that's just the first layer of the strategy.
- 39:54Actually, we'd even go one step further.
- 39:56I'm sure you guys have heard of like the infinite banking
- 39:58concept or be your own bank kind of a thing.
- 40:00So I can be my own bank so I can put money and tax advantage
- 40:04into. Maybe I'd use real estate first
- 40:06'cause I can get out of the taxes.
- 40:08Now, I'm not your tax professional.
- 40:11You might have questions about that, like for example, but
- 40:14Mark, can't you only write that against a passive income?
- 40:16And I have to be a full time real estate professional?
- 40:18Yes, that's part of the thing. But there's a loophole that if I
- 40:22put it into an Airbnb property and I run the Airbnb property,
- 40:24at least I think one time in that tax year, I can take 100%.
- 40:29So again, you got to understand the freaking game here, man.
- 40:31So right off the bat, I'm I have 300,000 more cash in my bank and
- 40:36I have $1,000,000 asset going up now.
- 40:39I think real estate's up 50% in three years from now.
- 40:41Inflation is freaking raging. It ain't it ain't.
- 40:43Sure back down. So now in two years from now, I
- 40:46take $500,000 out of the property on debt again tax free.
- 40:54And then I go put it all into Bitcoin.
- 40:55So now I got the 800 plus the five, I put that into Bitcoin.
- 40:58I got 1.3 million in Bitcoin. Then if Bitcoin's been
- 41:02compounded at 200% annual growth rate, let's say it doesn't
- 41:04continue that, let's call it 50%.
- 41:06So now I got 1.8 million in Bitcoin in two years from now at
- 41:0950 percent, 50% compound annual growth rate.
- 41:11Jesse, you're the number guy. Now I got 3, four $5,000,000 in
- 41:14in Bitcoin. I borrow 50% of that, again tax
- 41:17free $2,000,000 and I go put it in the next asset and I put in
- 41:22the next asset. And while you made $1,000,000
- 41:25and you got stuck with 500, now I'm sitting on 4 or $5,000,000
- 41:31And this is a very oversimplified strategy.
- 41:33It gets way more complex and there's multiple layers you can
- 41:35add to this. You asked specifically about
- 41:37real estate, but that's one of the key pieces.
- 41:40Yeah, I love that example. There's a few lessons there.
- 41:42One is, as you right rightly pointed out, debt is your friend
- 41:47in the system. In the game we're playing,
- 41:50number one. Number two, it pays to get into
- 41:52the details, get into the weeds on tax law, including and
- 41:56especially on real estate, 'cause I had the same
- 41:58conversation with, you know, clients and other people.
- 42:01Also, you know, usual disclaimer, none of this says
- 42:04financial advice, do your own homework.
- 42:06Check. Check all the facts, check
- 42:08marks, facts. But but yeah, there are lots and
- 42:11lots of tax loopholes in particular that favor real
- 42:15estate, and it always has been true.
- 42:19And I think it's still true. I think the other thing, and and
- 42:22I'm sure you guys have seen this and it's it's, it's changed a
- 42:25lot. I get like thousands of comments
- 42:27a week across my platform. So I I I see this a lot.
- 42:30But people have lost, like, the ability to understand there's
- 42:34nuance and everything. And they like, everybody thinks
- 42:37like black and white. It has to be this or that,
- 42:39right? They they, they've lost the
- 42:41nuance. They've lost that.
- 42:43They've lost the fact that there's like everything.
- 42:45There's no such thing as probabilities.
- 42:47There's certainties as probabilities and everything has
- 42:51a trade off. Everything's a trade off.
- 42:53So I'm not saying, and this is what most bitcoiners say, oh,
- 42:57real estate's a scam, buy Bitcoin.
- 42:58I'm not saying to buy real estate and don't buy Bitcoin.
- 43:01I'm saying buy both with the same dollar, that's what I'm
- 43:05saying. But own both for the same price,
- 43:09own more of both at the same time.
- 43:12And so it's a strategy to acquire more Bitcoin at the end
- 43:15of the day by leveraging other assets.
- 43:18Yeah, there's a there's a concept in them in like my MBA
- 43:22program of, you know, inventory turns, you know when you're
- 43:26running a business. So you're trying to make sure
- 43:28that you have not a ton of inventory on hand, but you're
- 43:30trying to turn that over a bunch of times.
- 43:32You're trying to sell a lot while keeping not a ton on your
- 43:35books, See. And you're applying the same
- 43:38concept of like how do you get more efficient about putting to
- 43:41work what you have your dollar, your dollar is your inventory
- 43:45here and to get more and more out of it by turning it more
- 43:49times I. Mean that's a that's a good way
- 43:52to look at it but I think it's more, I think it's more in line
- 43:55with the velocity of money. Right.
- 43:57They measure they they measure how many times a dollar moves
- 44:00through the economy. I'm measuring how many times I
- 44:02can get a dollar to move through an investment.
- 44:04But but inventory is a is a is one way to look at it.
- 44:07So inventory as I said I I sold e-commerce.
- 44:10I make you know maybe a average 30% profit margin.
- 44:13You know for example typically about a 90 day turn on that
- 44:16inventory. So that means I'm turning my
- 44:17inventory 4 * a year. So at 30% * 4 if I could turn it
- 44:21every month now I get 12 * 30%, right?
- 44:24Right. So I think that but but that
- 44:25kind of is more like a compounding turn versus I think
- 44:28the velocity is like how can how can $1.00 move through the
- 44:31economy 5 faster? Or how could $1.00 move through
- 44:33my investments faster? Mm hmm.
- 44:36Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 44:38exploring any of these topics further, or wanna learn more
- 44:41about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 44:44allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 44:49We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 44:52Yeah, I love that idea. I love that.
- 44:54So let's let's riff a little more on the velocity of money
- 44:57because we got a question from our friend Mark Hemby, and he's
- 45:02interested in accelerated inflation scenarios.
- 45:05I mean, we talked about hyper hyperinflation, but maybe we'd
- 45:09go there. What's?
- 45:10Twitter earlier. Oh, from Twitter early OK, got.
- 45:12It. Oh, yeah.
- 45:13Yeah. No, sorry.
- 45:14Not not live. Yeah.
- 45:17I always try to you know pepper in one or two questions from
- 45:21from the Twitter crew. So yeah.
- 45:23So you know what are your thoughts on and you and if you
- 45:27want to tie tie this into larger, you know cycles of
- 45:29history, maybe that would be fruitful.
- 45:32But what are you preparing for in terms of the average
- 45:35inflation rate over the next decade or so you know and and
- 45:38how much velocity there's going to be in in Fiat money and how
- 45:44that affects your your strategies we've been talking
- 45:46about? As far as like what will the
- 45:50velocity of the money be in the, you know, in the future, next
- 45:54couple years, decade, whatever. I I I wouldn't say I necessarily
- 45:57keep that into my consideration that fits into like the overall
- 45:59inflation conversation, right, because obviously they're like
- 46:02measuring velocity to like manage inflation.
- 46:05So I wouldn't necessarily look at the the way the government
- 46:08measures the velocity of money as something that I'm really
- 46:09focused on. But in regards to inflation,
- 46:13even when inflation was like 8-9 percent a couple years ago, I
- 46:16was on YouTube saying that this will, this will be the lowest in
- 46:19some of the lowest inflation we'll see for the rest of the
- 46:21decade. So I'm a huge inflation bull.
- 46:24I think that inflation comes in waves.
- 46:26We've seen a a disinflationary pulse and now it looks like we
- 46:30bottomed and we're starting to see the inflation creep back up
- 46:32again. I saw on the Twitter post you
- 46:36put Andy, someone was a little salty and it's like Oh yeah,
- 46:39Mark's going to talk about cycles and this and that.
- 46:41But I think that's important to understand.
- 46:43Part of the cycle that we talked about is the I talked about all
- 46:47the time is, is the the pendulum swinging from centralization to
- 46:49decentralization. I've been talking about this for
- 46:52a couple years. I I think I broke it out for the
- 46:53first time in 2020 when we were still heading towards peak
- 46:59centralization. I think we're starting to see
- 47:01that. And I said peak centralization
- 47:03peaks at 2025 S like next year. But I think we're starting to
- 47:05see the pendulum swinging back. But specifically in regards to
- 47:08inflation because we're like globalism is dead.
- 47:13Globalization is is digressing at this point like the age of
- 47:19global cooperation and just in time supply chains that's over
- 47:22like that's done and and and it's all about restoring.
- 47:26What does restoring do? It pushes up inflation.
- 47:30So we have we have multiple factors going into this
- 47:33obviously. So the for my cycle thesis the
- 47:36guy on Twitter didn't want to hear me talk about again.
- 47:38I think it's I do. I want to hear.
- 47:39I want to hear at least a little.
- 47:41But I think it's an important framework.
- 47:42So if the world, if the world continues to move towards
- 47:45decentralization, which history tells us it is and I think it's
- 47:47pretty apparent for anyone paying attention that's a major
- 47:50inflationary push that OK, so that's that's one.
- 47:53Then we have that we're in at the end of this you know,
- 47:56sovereign debt cycle. So there's three cycles that I
- 47:59chart. One is this political revolution
- 48:02cycle which is centralization, decentralization 2 is the
- 48:04financial revolution cycle, it's an 80 year cycle.
- 48:07So we're at the end of that. And then the third one is the
- 48:10technological revolution cycle which is a 50 year cycle.
- 48:13So all three are converging right now or the hater online.
- 48:15Sorry I have to recap that for you.
- 48:17But if you, if you, if you take that into consideration, so one
- 48:20as the world decentralizes, that's a massively inflationary
- 48:23re onshoring, but not just re onshoring ships getting attacked
- 48:27in the Red Sea. Right.
- 48:30Less global cooperation, supply chains breaking down.
- 48:32So it's not just about re onshoring, everything gets more
- 48:35expensive that way, right? But then two, we're at the end
- 48:38of this debt cycle. And so at this end of the debt
- 48:40cycle, we're stuck printing massive amounts of money.
- 48:46So we know, per the Keynesian multiplier, that, as you know,
- 48:50the goal is to spend $0.50 of debt to get a dollar worth of
- 48:53growth. Right now, today, we're spending
- 48:55a dollar worth of debt, or I should say borrowing a dollar in
- 48:58debt to get $0.40 of growth. So it's a lot of diminishing
- 49:01returns, right? So eventually it gets less,
- 49:03less, less, less, less. I think this cycle ends in a
- 49:05whimper, not a bang like everybody thinks it is.
- 49:07And so the diminishing returns, we have $0.40 of growth, 30
- 49:10cents, 20 cents, $0.10 and eventually there's no growth
- 49:12left. And so we're witnessing that and
- 49:14we're witnessing these weird anomalies like Japan entering a
- 49:17technical recession, but the Nikki index is hitting an all
- 49:19time high in Europe. The same thing.
- 49:22Europe's in a technical recession, but yet their markets
- 49:24are all time highs. And so that, you know, Lynn
- 49:27Alden's a champion of the sort of fiscal dominance theory, you
- 49:31know, not theory, but the the talking about that and I and I
- 49:34agree. So as we get deeper in debt, the
- 49:37law of dimension returns, we have to keep digging deeper,
- 49:39deeper, deeper. So that's massively inflationary
- 49:41and then we have the. Print more and more debt to
- 49:44service the deficits and then that is stimulative to the
- 49:48overall money supply and inflation and everything.
- 49:50Yeah. And and and then the third, the
- 49:52third piece is, is, is the demographics.
- 49:56I think it was mid 2000s. Harry Dent Junior wrote a book
- 50:00called The Demographic Cliff and Harry Dent Junior is the broken
- 50:04clock that has been calling for a 90% crash for a decade and
- 50:08he'll eventually be right. I've read five of his books
- 50:11because his research is amazing and I think his research is
- 50:14right. His conclusions have been wrong,
- 50:17but he was the first one that really brought this demographic
- 50:19problem to my to my forefront. Peter Zion talks about it a lot.
- 50:22I mean, there's been plenty of books written about it.
- 50:24Elon Musk says it's probably the largest risk that we have to our
- 50:27civilization right now. And so that's obviously massive
- 50:30deflation or inflationary as well.
- 50:32So anyway, I'm an inflation bull.
- 50:34I think we see massive inflation.
- 50:35I said earlier, I think real estate's up 50% in three years
- 50:38from now. I think part of what I was going
- 50:41to do in this report, I was telling you about how to retire
- 50:44of Bitcoin. I wanted to chart and Jesse,
- 50:47maybe you could do this 'cause you're smarter than me in this
- 50:49regard. This isn't my classical.
- 50:51Trend Jesse to work. That's good.
- 50:52That's what he's here. For I wanted to chart the rate
- 50:55of inflation. So if you look at like the
- 50:57Fred's M2 money chart, for example, and you and you draw
- 51:00trend lines. I've used it many times.
- 51:02Just draw a trend line up to 1971 and then from 1971 to like
- 51:072000, and then from 2000 to 2008 and then 2008 to 2020 and then
- 51:102020 up and you see the trend line.
- 51:14Yep. So then if you if you if you
- 51:16looked at those trend lines then measured the rates of inflation
- 51:19change, we might be able to project out where that inflation
- 51:23rate goes to, to answer this question.
- 51:25I I I haven't done that, but I, I was thinking along those
- 51:27lines. I had dinner with Brent Johnson,
- 51:30Mr. Santiago capital of Milkshake theory Guy a few weeks
- 51:34ago and we were talking about this and you know he thinks
- 51:38we'll see $100 trillion in debt before anything big happens to
- 51:42the dollar. And I I agree with that.
- 51:45So what does inflation look like as we get to $100 trillion in
- 51:48debt? I think we could map it out, I
- 51:50don't know. But I see massive inflation
- 51:52ahead of ahead of us, which again is bad for everybody, but
- 51:57if you can't beat them, join them.
- 51:58So I'm just going to take on a lot of fixed rate debt and I'm
- 52:01going to buy assets that go up with inflation.
- 52:04Yeah. That's right.
- 52:06I actually did that analysis in in 2020 of of taking M2 is in my
- 52:12opinion the best indicator of true inflation.
- 52:14Like forget about you know what what the government says M2 is
- 52:19what's actually happening. And I did that analysis of like
- 52:22it was like 5% kegger of money supply like a decade ago and
- 52:28then it ratcheted up. Of course I did it in 2020 And
- 52:31so that year it was like 17% you know because of the the COVID
- 52:36stimulus. But yeah, we we are seeing that
- 52:39ratcheting up of the the, the slope there which in my opinion
- 52:45is the, you know when you when you iron out what's actually
- 52:50happening, the net of it is growth of money supply directly
- 52:54translation into inflation. It may take some time, but
- 52:58that's what's actually driving it.
- 53:00Yeah, it's the Austrians, the Austrian definition of
- 53:02inflation, which I mean, as Michael Saylor points out and
- 53:05Austrians have pointed out forever, trying to measure
- 53:08inflation with a single number is like, ridiculous.
- 53:10Yeah, prices going up, what they call consumer price inflation is
- 53:13the is the result of inflation. It's the it's it's what what
- 53:18happens after inflation happens. It's the end of the chain and to
- 53:23to your other point of like you know that we may have bottomed
- 53:27in in inflation right now. We may be heading to another
- 53:30wave of it, which is just what happened in the 70s.
- 53:33And I like it feels like to me human psychology hasn't changed,
- 53:37markets haven't really changed, like the the economics hasn't
- 53:41hasn't changed. So it seems quite likely that we
- 53:45would have the same sort of pattern of behavior and bullwhip
- 53:49effect inflation that we had then happening now.
- 53:53Well, there's a lot that's changed.
- 53:54As a matter of fact, I made a video saying this time is
- 53:56different, which is the famous last words.
- 53:59But I think it is different and there's a lot that's changed and
- 54:01I think drawing well, I think it's important to draw parallels
- 54:04from history. Obviously I use history as my
- 54:05guide. I think we also have to realize
- 54:10the answers have changed. Albert Einstein was a professor
- 54:14and every year he would give out a test to his students at the at
- 54:17the college. And every year he was giving out
- 54:20the exact same test with the exact same questions.
- 54:23And one of his student aides came up and said, Einstein, I
- 54:27hate to bring this up, but are you aware this is the exact same
- 54:30test that you gave out the year before?
- 54:32And Einstein's, like, yeah, I did.
- 54:34And they said, well, why would you do that?
- 54:36Because the students have the answers and they can just give
- 54:38these students the answers. And he said because the answers
- 54:41have changed. You see as things change, as new
- 54:45information comes in, we have to understand that what we thought
- 54:47was the answer changes. So what do I mean that
- 54:50specifically I I believe and I've made the case in my videos
- 54:54breaking down the data in this. But the way that the central
- 54:57banks, not just the Fed, but all central banks, but specifically
- 55:00the Fed and all central banks, the way that they interact in
- 55:03the markets changed in 2008. It's the first time we saw QE,
- 55:08right. And and and not to dig too deep
- 55:14into that, I got a couple minutes left here not to dig too
- 55:16deep into that. But in 2008, just for some
- 55:19perspective here it was the first time we saw QE.
- 55:21OK, so that's a big deal. So when you're looking at the
- 55:2470s or whatever, like we didn't, they didn't do that back then.
- 55:27So that's, that's, that's number one.
- 55:28Number two, we can see how it's changed since since then.
- 55:33So for example in 2008, in 2006, home building starts were down
- 55:3826 percent, 26%. That's a crash.
- 55:42It took thirty months, 30 months, almost three years
- 55:46before the Fed intervened in the markets.
- 55:49Three years. Bear Stearns is widely accepted
- 55:52as the trigger point that caused the entire banking system to
- 55:55collapse. When Bear Stearns collapsed, it
- 55:57took seven months to get $100 billion approved in 2023.
- 56:02When the banks collapsed, how long did it take?
- 56:046. Days, yeah.
- 56:06Also, Hank Paulson had to get down on his knees and and beg
- 56:10for the money. Right.
- 56:11And that's another big piece and that's part of the reason why it
- 56:13took so long, right, because it had all these approval processes
- 56:17and things like that. There was 700 billion in TARP
- 56:19plus the plus another some extra stimulus.
- 56:22It was about I think a little over a trillion dollars at the
- 56:24end of stimulating in 2008. In 2020, how much was it between
- 56:27Fed between fiscal and monetary is about 11 trillion.
- 56:31From 1:00 to 11:00 you see how things change.
- 56:34But it's even more than that. In 2020, the Fed set up 13 SPVS
- 56:4013. They were buying equities.
- 56:44That changed. It's different.
- 56:46We didn't do that before. We didn't do that in 2020.
- 56:49We didn't. And.
- 56:49And then now today, all these banks have swap lines.
- 56:53Countries, they all have swap lines.
- 56:55So back to getting on your knees and begging.
- 56:58They have credit cards like I give my kids credit cards.
- 57:00If you run into trouble, use the credit.
- 57:02You don't have to call me. Here's the money in advance.
- 57:04Now we have all these nations with swap lines.
- 57:08We have all these funny facilities that are set up.
- 57:10We we saw it with the BTFPI mean.
- 57:12So things are different, things are way different today.
- 57:16And so I think sure, yeah, use history for sure, but like to
- 57:20try to go, well, you know, this is what it's been like for so
- 57:23long. Yeah, but the answer's changed
- 57:25in my opinion. Yeah.
- 57:26Well, that's sage advice, Mark. This has been a phenomenal
- 57:30conversation. Really appreciate you coming on
- 57:33and doing it with us. I just want to ask you, before
- 57:36we wrap up here, any final thoughts, any what are the
- 57:40places that people can can continue to learn from you?
- 57:44Yeah, I mean I'm all, I'm all over just search Mark Moss.
- 57:47But I do a couple videos a week on YouTube breaking down mostly
- 57:50financial topics. You know mostly these these,
- 57:54these types of topics we're talking about right here.
- 57:56I think all my content is Bitcoin content, but I don't,
- 57:59it's not about Bitcoin all the time.
- 58:01It's more about why, Like why, right?
- 58:04So it's more of these types of financial topics, like stuff
- 58:06that we discussed here. I'm pretty active on Twitter now
- 58:09that I got my account back, so you can find me there at 1 Mark
- 58:12Moss. Or just go to my website,
- 58:131markmoss.com. Everything's linked there and
- 58:15I'll be putting up this. I don't know when you're going
- 58:17to air this thing, but probably by next week I'll have that
- 58:21Bitcoin How to retire a Bitcoin report and calculator up.
- 58:24Excellent. Well, yeah, go ahead.
- 58:26I look forward to digging into that.
- 58:28That's I think that's the Holy Grail for for all of us.
- 58:31And so getting smart and, you know, understanding the risks
- 58:35and being prudent about it is is going to be a big part of being
- 58:38a a successful bitcoiner over the next decade or two.
- 58:42Maybe I'll send, maybe I'll send it over to you for a little
- 58:44proofread before I publish it, just so you can help me out with
- 58:46it a little bit. Love to see it?
- 58:49Well, I look forward to seeing that report.
- 58:51I really love the content that you put out.
- 58:53Mark, thank you so much for sharing your skills and talents
- 58:57and experience and knowledge and on behalf of on RAMP that's been
- 59:01scarce assets.