Latest / Bloomberg Law / Voting Rights Act Circuit Split, Future Wealth Tax in Question
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 0:05Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 0:09Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business app, or listen on demand wherever
- 0:12Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 0:16Speaker 2: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 0:18Speaker 3: I'm Greg Storr and I'm Lydia Wheeler. We're filling in
- 0:21Speaker 3: for June Grasso, who's out this week ahead.
- 0:24Speaker 2: In this hour, we'll talk about a case that asks
- 0:26Speaker 2: the US Supreme Court to decide if Congress has the
- 0:28Speaker 2: authority to tax foreign earnings. Cases being closely watched for
- 0:31Speaker 2: its potential to stop Congress from creating a future wealth tax.
- 0:35Speaker 3: But first, a federal appeals court issued a ruling recently
- 0:38Speaker 3: that seemed to gut the Voting Rates Act, or at
- 0:41Speaker 3: least a key section of it. Joining us now to
- 0:43Speaker 3: explain it all is Carolyn Shapiro, co director of the
- 0:46Speaker 3: Chicago Kent College of Law Institute on the Supreme Court. So, Carolyn,
- 0:51Speaker 3: tell us what the a Circuit Court of Appeals did here.
- 0:55Speaker 4: Bisuka said that the Voting Rights Act of nineteen sixty
- 0:59Speaker 4: five cannot be enforced by private litigants. That the only
- 1:04Speaker 4: way it can be enforced, and in particular the most
- 1:07Speaker 4: operative part today, which is Section two can only be
- 1:12Speaker 4: enforced by the federal government. That's a really remarkable, dramatic,
- 1:19Speaker 4: and just really unwarranted holding. People have been litigating Section
- 1:26Speaker 4: two cases for decades, and it's sort of true that
- 1:30Speaker 4: there's no express Supreme Court opinion that says, in so
- 1:34Speaker 4: many words, there's a private right of action under Section two.
- 1:40Speaker 4: But that's because it's been clear for so long that
- 1:44Speaker 4: there's a right of action under Section two. In fact,
- 1:47Speaker 4: it's been so clear for so long that kind of
- 1:50Speaker 4: keeps reenacting the law on that assumption. This would be
- 1:55Speaker 4: it would be just an incredible upheaval of voting right
- 2:00Speaker 4: litigation and law if this is allowed to stand.
- 2:04Speaker 2: Can you just remind us and our listeners what the
- 2:07Speaker 2: Voting Rights Act does, and in particular what Section two does.
- 2:11Speaker 4: So, the Voting Rights Act of nineteen sixty five is
- 2:13Speaker 4: the law that basically made the Fifteenth Amendment, which allowed
- 2:19Speaker 4: African Americans to vote, made it effective. The Fifteenth Amendment,
- 2:23Speaker 4: of course, was a Reconstruction era amendment shortly after World
- 2:27Speaker 4: the Civil War, and then for many many decades it
- 2:31Speaker 4: was largely ineffective. States in the South found ways to
- 2:36Speaker 4: make it impossible or difficult for African Americans to vote,
- 2:40Speaker 4: and the courts basically allowed that to happen, including the
- 2:44Speaker 4: Supreme Court. In nineteen sixty five, Congress enacted the Voting
- 2:48Speaker 4: Rights Act, and that really changed everything. It made our
- 2:52Speaker 4: country the multi racial democracy that we support to be.
- 2:57Speaker 4: So it's an incredibly important piece of let's aslation. People
- 3:00Speaker 4: often refer to it as the crown jewel of the
- 3:02Speaker 4: civil rights business. Section two of the of the Voting
- 3:06Speaker 4: Rights That provides that where there is a practice or
- 3:13Speaker 4: a set of policies that make it difficult for a
- 3:19Speaker 4: group of minority voters to elect the representatives of their
- 3:23Speaker 4: choice it comparably to the way white voters can that
- 3:28Speaker 4: that can violate the statute. So, for example, the redistricting
- 3:36Speaker 4: is done in such a way so that African Americans
- 3:40Speaker 4: can't elect their own, their favored representatives, that can violate
- 3:47Speaker 4: Section two of the Voting Rights Act. It doesn't require
- 3:50Speaker 4: intentional discrimination. It looks to the effects of certain types
- 3:55Speaker 4: of decisions that states and local governments make about voting.
- 4:00Speaker 4: It's been very important for many years, but it's even
- 4:02Speaker 4: more important than it used to be because In twenty thirteen,
- 4:06Speaker 4: the Supreme Court made the other most significant part of
- 4:11Speaker 4: the voting Right tech inoperative, which is Section five, the
- 4:14Speaker 4: part that required certain jurisdictions to get approval before they
- 4:18Speaker 4: made changes in their voting systems.
- 4:21Speaker 3: Can you back up a little bit for us and
- 4:22Speaker 3: explain how this case came about. I know it was
- 4:25Speaker 3: a lawsuit brought by voters in Arkansas. Is that right?
- 4:29Speaker 5: Yeah?
- 4:30Speaker 4: This is an Arkansas case, and the district court in Arkansas,
- 4:38Speaker 4: I believe, said that it found that there was no
- 4:42Speaker 4: private right of action under section two of the fourteenth Amendment,
- 4:46Speaker 4: and it reached that decision, if I'm remembering correctly, even
- 4:53Speaker 4: without the state having raised the question of its own
- 4:57Speaker 4: accord claiming that there were. It was a jurisdictional question
- 5:01Speaker 4: and that therefore it was required to consider that. This
- 5:05Speaker 4: is a really remarkable overreach. I can't emphasize that enough.
- 5:11Speaker 2: Tell us about the circuit decision and the reasoning there.
- 5:14Speaker 2: Why did they say there was no avoute for.
- 5:16Speaker 4: Private They looked at the language of the statute, and
- 5:20Speaker 4: they looked at the language of the statute in extremely
- 5:24Speaker 4: isolated detail. And it is true. The language of the
- 5:28Speaker 4: statute doesn't contain the words private right of action, and
- 5:31Speaker 4: the language of the statute doesn't say in so many
- 5:33Speaker 4: words that private individuals can do under the statute. There
- 5:39Speaker 4: are many many statutes like that in the federal legislation,
- 5:46Speaker 4: and historically the Court used to be somewhat more open
- 5:51Speaker 4: to inferring of private right of action into particular statutes
- 5:56Speaker 4: than it has become in more recent years. However, it
- 6:00Speaker 4: has also said that where it's been clear that there's
- 6:04Speaker 4: a private right of action in the past, that that
- 6:06Speaker 4: had been inferred in the past, and in particular, where
- 6:09Speaker 4: Congress has reenacted the statute, the Court shouldn't go back
- 6:13Speaker 4: and reparse the language of the statute under the wonders
- 6:18Speaker 4: that did not exist when it was originally enactive. So
- 6:21Speaker 4: it looks what the atificate is to look at the
- 6:25Speaker 4: words of the statute in complete isolation of how the
- 6:29Speaker 4: statute has been applied for decades, and in complete isolation
- 6:33Speaker 4: of the legislative history. With a reenactment of the statute,
- 6:37Speaker 4: where it is extremely clear that Congress intended for people
- 6:41Speaker 4: to be able to bring lawsuits to enforced Section.
- 6:43Speaker 3: Two, what's exactly is the state arguing in this case, the.
- 6:48Speaker 4: State is arguing that they just can't be sued unless
- 6:52Speaker 4: they're being sued by the federal government, which basically means
- 6:55Speaker 4: that if the federal government doesn't have the resources or
- 6:58Speaker 4: the ability, or depending on the administration, that desire to
- 7:03Speaker 4: enforce the Voting Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act doesn't
- 7:05Speaker 4: get enforced. They're saying that a private person or a
- 7:10Speaker 4: private individual such as the NAAFP, or individual voters or
- 7:16Speaker 4: a community organization just simply can't do anything about it,
- 7:20Speaker 4: regardless of how blatant the violation of their voting rights are, you.
- 7:25Speaker 2: Know, cal And one thing that struck me about this
- 7:26Speaker 2: decision is that reading parts of it, at least there
- 7:30Speaker 2: was a congressional report from i think the House and
- 7:33Speaker 2: Senate Judiciary committees that said, we understand this law to
- 7:38Speaker 2: allow for private lawsuits. Is this one of these cases
- 7:43Speaker 2: where the legislative history what Congress intended and was talking
- 7:47Speaker 2: about says one thing, but the language of the statute
- 7:50Speaker 2: at least arguably says something else.
- 7:54Speaker 4: Well, I think that's how the Eighth took it, interpreted
- 7:58Speaker 4: the statute, or chose to interpret with the statute. But
- 8:01Speaker 4: I think that that is a real triumph of form
- 8:06Speaker 4: over substance. The statute itself doesn't expressly say one way
- 8:11Speaker 4: or the other whether there's a private right of action.
- 8:14Speaker 4: It certainly doesn't prohibit there from being one, and historically
- 8:18Speaker 4: it's been appropriate for courts to infer a private right
- 8:23Speaker 4: of action. The Court has again in recent years changed
- 8:28Speaker 4: that approach. But Congress, the Congress that enacted the law
- 8:33Speaker 4: before Congress changed that approach, of course, didn't know that
- 8:36Speaker 4: that was going to happen. They were operating on the
- 8:38Speaker 4: assumption that people have been doing to enforce the voting
- 8:42Speaker 4: right back for a long time and would continue to
- 8:44Speaker 4: do so. And we'll say that in our explanation of
- 8:48Speaker 4: our we enactment of the law. So it's I would
- 8:53Speaker 4: not say that the law says one thing, in the
- 8:55Speaker 4: legislative history says another. But that is at least in part,
- 8:59Speaker 4: how the Eighth Circuit tries to defend its position.
- 9:04Speaker 2: Well.
- 9:04Speaker 3: Coming up in the program, we'll dive deeper into the
- 9:07Speaker 3: recent voting rates ruling out of the Eighth Circuit Court
- 9:09Speaker 3: of Appeals with Carolyn Shapiro. Remember, you can always get
- 9:12Speaker 3: the latest legal news by listening to Bloomberg Law podcast
- 9:15Speaker 3: on Apple, Spotify, or wherever it is you get your podcasts.
- 9:20Speaker 2: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Greg store. This is Bloomberg.
- 9:30Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch the program
- 9:34Speaker 1: weekdays at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg Radio, the tune
- 9:37Speaker 1: in app, Bloomberg dot Com, and the Bloomberg Business App.
- 9:40Speaker 1: You can also listen live on Amazon Alexa from our
- 9:43Speaker 1: flagship New York station, Just say Alexa play Bloomberg eleven thirty.
- 9:50Speaker 2: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Greg Store in for June Grosso.
- 9:53Speaker 2: We've been speaking with Carolyn Shapiro of Chicago Kent College
- 9:56Speaker 2: of Law about the recent ruling out of the Eighth
- 9:58Speaker 2: US Circuit Court of Appeals on the Voting Rights Act. So, Carolyn,
- 10:02Speaker 2: we talked a lot about this ruling coming out of
- 10:04Speaker 2: the Circuit of a very conservative appeals court.
- 10:08Speaker 5: There was a.
- 10:08Speaker 2: Supreme Court decision a couple of years ago that perhaps
- 10:12Speaker 2: laid the groundwork for this, a concurring opinion by Justice
- 10:16Speaker 2: Neil Gorsich. Can you tell us a little bit about that.
- 10:20Speaker 4: Yeah, So this is a case called Burnovitch that came
- 10:23Speaker 4: out of Arizona, and in this case, it was a
- 10:26Speaker 4: Section two lawsuit that challenged a number of practices in
- 10:31Speaker 4: Arizona having to do with the ability for people to
- 10:35Speaker 4: use mail in ballots and things like that. It was
- 10:39Speaker 4: what's called a vote denial claim as opposed to vote dilution,
- 10:43Speaker 4: So it didn't have to do with redistricting. It had
- 10:45Speaker 4: to do with other practices. And the Supreme Court read
- 10:49Speaker 4: Section two in that context fairly narrowly, but did not
- 10:53Speaker 4: address the question of whether there's a private right of action,
- 10:57Speaker 4: and in fact that wasn't presented. Scursich wrote a concurrence
- 11:02Speaker 4: in which joined by Justice Thomas. In that concurrence, he said,
- 11:05Speaker 4: you know, nobody's raised this question, but it's been a
- 11:10Speaker 4: sort of a question that other courts have asked in
- 11:13Speaker 4: the past, and he cited a district Court opinion from
- 11:18Speaker 4: the nineteen eighties as his example of why this is
- 11:21Speaker 4: remains an open question, which I have to say not
- 11:23Speaker 4: it might be very persuasive, but he put it out
- 11:27Speaker 4: there for litigants to pick up, and of course they did.
- 11:31Speaker 4: That's that's why he did it. And people who read
- 11:35Speaker 4: the court opinions are looking for those kinds of invitations.
- 11:39Speaker 4: So both courts, as in the District Court in this
- 11:43Speaker 4: Arkansas case, and the litigants in the Arkansas case and
- 11:47Speaker 4: in other cases now as well, are starting to make
- 11:50Speaker 4: that argument and to say, hey, this is an open question,
- 11:54Speaker 4: maybe there's no private right of action, and pushing the
- 11:58Speaker 4: appeals courts to make rulings on that question.
- 12:02Speaker 3: So, Carolyn, we talked about how the Eighth Circuit Court
- 12:04Speaker 3: of Appeals here ruled there's no private right of action
- 12:07Speaker 3: for litigans to come and sue to enforce Section two
- 12:10Speaker 3: of the Voting Rights Act. But the New Orleans based
- 12:13Speaker 3: Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a ruling recently on
- 12:16Speaker 3: this too. What did that court say?
- 12:19Speaker 4: That court said that there is a private right of action.
- 12:22Speaker 4: It didn't do a super deep dive into the statute
- 12:28Speaker 4: of this quite the same sort that the Eighth Circuit
- 12:31Speaker 4: did in sort of parsing the language the way the
- 12:34Speaker 4: Eighth Circuit did, but it basically said, you know, there's
- 12:37Speaker 4: always been a private right of action here, and we
- 12:41Speaker 4: don't think that this is there's a basis for changing
- 12:44Speaker 4: that in this moment. That's the law of our circuit,
- 12:46Speaker 4: and that's the law we're going to apply.
- 12:49Speaker 2: You know, Carolyn, some listeners may be thinking that there
- 12:52Speaker 2: was this case out of Alabama in the Supreme Court
- 12:56Speaker 2: in its last term, and that was a lawsuit brought
- 12:59Speaker 2: by private litigants, and the Supreme Court did something pretty
- 13:03Speaker 2: significant in rejecting a republican drawn congressional map there. So,
- 13:09Speaker 2: can you explain how it can be if there is
- 13:12Speaker 2: an explanation that the Supreme Court keeps acting like there
- 13:16Speaker 2: is a private right of action and yet this issue
- 13:19Speaker 2: apparently is open enough that a federal appeals court decided
- 13:23Speaker 2: that there is no private right of action.
- 13:26Speaker 4: Well, I would dispute that really is an open question,
- 13:30Speaker 4: in part for exactly the reason that you say everybody
- 13:33Speaker 4: has assumed and has assumed is maybe the wrong word.
- 13:37Speaker 4: It is. It's an established feature of the law, and
- 13:41Speaker 4: Congress itself has assumed that there's a private right of
- 13:44Speaker 4: action in its re enactment of the law repeatedly. But
- 13:49Speaker 4: it's because it is the case that there is not
- 13:51Speaker 4: an opinion that says, in so many words, there is
- 13:55Speaker 4: a private right of action. And you have Justice cour
- 13:58Speaker 4: Such issuing this invitation, joined by Justice Thomas. Suddenly there's
- 14:04Speaker 4: an opportunity for forlitigants and courts to say, well, wait
- 14:08Speaker 4: a minute, let's see how clever we can be and
- 14:10Speaker 4: come up with an argument that what everybody's always thought
- 14:13Speaker 4: was true isn't true. Which this is sort of a
- 14:16Speaker 4: strange way, in my view, to the law to operate,
- 14:22Speaker 4: and I do think it's quite inconsistent with the case
- 14:25Speaker 4: you mentioned out of Alabama, Alan versus Milligan. In Alan
- 14:29Speaker 4: versus Milligan, the court went out of its way to say,
- 14:33Speaker 4: there's forty years of precedent here. It was not. The
- 14:38Speaker 4: question was not what whether there's a private right of action.
- 14:40Speaker 4: The question was how that private right of action operates
- 14:44Speaker 4: or what it takes to prove a violation of Section
- 14:47Speaker 4: two of the Voting Rights Act. The court went out
- 14:49Speaker 4: of its way to say, we are not up ending
- 14:52Speaker 4: forty decades of present forty years of precedent. It's this
- 14:57Speaker 4: is the way the law has been, and we don't
- 14:59Speaker 4: think it appropriate to change it. So well, it didn't
- 15:03Speaker 4: speak directly to the question that the Eighth Circuit has
- 15:05Speaker 4: now ruled on. It certainly indicated a significant fidelity to
- 15:11Speaker 4: an understanding of the statute that has been widespread, again
- 15:17Speaker 4: not just in the Court, also in Congress.
- 15:21Speaker 3: It sounds like there's a real circuit split here between
- 15:24Speaker 3: the Eighth Circuit and the Fifth Circuit. So isn't this
- 15:27Speaker 3: now present a question that the Supreme Court is going
- 15:31Speaker 3: to have to resolve?
- 15:33Speaker 4: Yes, I think it does. The only possibility that would
- 15:37Speaker 4: prevent that from happening would be if the Eighth Circuit
- 15:40Speaker 4: Court of Appeals takes the case en banc, which would
- 15:44Speaker 4: mean that the full Court would reconsider the question issued
- 15:49Speaker 4: the decision made by the three judge panel and there
- 15:52Speaker 4: was a dissent, so there were two judges who ruled
- 15:56Speaker 4: that there's no private right of action and one judge
- 15:58Speaker 4: who dissented. I don't know how likely it is that
- 16:02Speaker 4: Theates if it will do that, and on the assumption
- 16:05Speaker 4: that it doesn't, or if it does take it on blank,
- 16:08Speaker 4: that it comes out the same way, then yes, I
- 16:10Speaker 4: think the Supreme Court will certainly have to take this
- 16:12Speaker 4: case and we'll have to settle a question once and
- 16:15Speaker 4: for all. Based on the Alabama case, I think it's
- 16:19Speaker 4: quite unlikely that the Supreme Court would affirm the eighth
- 16:23Speaker 4: of it.
- 16:24Speaker 2: That sounds right to me in terms of where the
- 16:26Speaker 2: Supreme Court seems to be on this question. But in
- 16:29Speaker 2: the event we're both wrong. In the Supreme Court agrees
- 16:32Speaker 2: with the Eighth Circuit and says no private right of action.
- 16:36Speaker 2: Can you just describe the implications of that? What would
- 16:39Speaker 2: be left of the Voting Rights Act after that sort
- 16:42Speaker 2: of decision?
- 16:44Speaker 4: The Voting Rights Act would be really astonishingly ineffective. We
- 16:50Speaker 4: have already lost Section five, as I mentioned before, the
- 16:54Speaker 4: part of Voting Rights Act that required covered jurisdictions to
- 16:59Speaker 4: get permissions for making changes and they're voting and election system.
- 17:03Speaker 4: That was within hours after the Supreme Court issued that opinion,
- 17:07Speaker 4: and Shelby County versus Holder States that had been required
- 17:12Speaker 4: to get that kind of preclearance started enacting laws literally
- 17:17Speaker 4: immediately that would never have been able to be pre
- 17:21Speaker 4: cleared and that have had the effect of making it
- 17:24Speaker 4: harder for minority voters to exercise their rights. Section two
- 17:29Speaker 4: was actually one of the reasons that the Supreme Court said, well,
- 17:33Speaker 4: it's okay in that opinion. It's not the end of
- 17:37Speaker 4: the world for us to get rid of the operation
- 17:40Speaker 4: of Section five because there's still Section two lawsuits and
- 17:43Speaker 4: its specifically noted that those losses can be brought by individuals,
- 17:47Speaker 4: by private litigants. So on that point, the Court itself
- 17:52Speaker 4: has operated on that assumption in the absence of private plaintiffs,
- 17:57Speaker 4: the only way these lawsuits could be brought would be
- 17:59Speaker 4: by the Partment of Justice, and the Department of Justice
- 18:02Speaker 4: just simply doesn't have the resources to bring all of
- 18:05Speaker 4: the lawsuits that are brought by private plaintiffs, and under
- 18:09Speaker 4: some administrations really has indicated no interests at all and
- 18:13Speaker 4: enforcing the voting like that.
- 18:15Speaker 3: So, Carolyn, if you and Greg are both right here
- 18:18Speaker 3: and the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals decision is overturned
- 18:22Speaker 3: by the Supreme Court, does that settle all future disputes
- 18:25Speaker 3: over Section two of the Voting Rights Act.
- 18:28Speaker 4: Well, certainly doesn't settle all future disputes over Section two.
- 18:32Speaker 4: Litigates are going to come up with other arguments. There
- 18:34Speaker 4: are always going to be questions about its scope and
- 18:37Speaker 4: its application in different circumstances. But it would settle that
- 18:42Speaker 4: question whether or not there's a private light of action.
- 18:45Speaker 3: Our thanks to Carolyn Shapiro, co director of the Chicago
- 18:48Speaker 3: Kent College of Law Institute on the Supreme Court. Coming
- 18:51Speaker 3: up next on Bloomberg Law Show, we'll talk about a
- 18:54Speaker 3: tax case that could have big implications for a future
- 18:57Speaker 3: wealth tax. I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Greg Store.
- 19:00Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg.
- 19:09Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Lawn Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 19:13Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio
- 19:16Speaker 1: app and the Bloomberg Business app, or listen on demand
- 19:19Speaker 1: wherever you get your podcast.
- 19:23Speaker 2: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Greg Storr in for June Grosso.
- 19:27Speaker 2: Let's get now to that big tax case the Supreme
- 19:29Speaker 2: Court is hearing over foreign earnings. It's been closely watched
- 19:32Speaker 2: for its potential to upend other parts of the tax
- 19:35Speaker 2: code and potentially affect a future wealth tax. Joining us
- 19:39Speaker 2: to discuss it is Michael Rappaport. He is a Bloomberg
- 19:43Speaker 2: Industries reporter covering tax Michael, thanks so much for joining us.
- 19:47Speaker 5: Thanks for having me so tell us.
- 19:49Speaker 2: A little background about this case. Who are the people
- 19:52Speaker 2: involved in How did they get to the Supreme Court?
- 19:55Speaker 5: Sure the planeff Sir Charleston Kathleen Moore, a retired couple
- 19:59Speaker 5: from Washington State, and they are challenging a tax bill
- 20:02Speaker 5: of fourteen thousand, seven or twenty nine dollars that they
- 20:06Speaker 5: had to pay on the earnings of Kisen Kraft, which
- 20:08Speaker 5: is a machine tool company. Based in India, in which
- 20:11Speaker 5: they'd invested because Charles Moore was a friend and former
- 20:13Speaker 5: colleague of the company's CEO. They contend that the tax
- 20:17Speaker 5: that was imposed on them is unconstitutional because it was
- 20:20Speaker 5: based on corporate earnings from kisen Kraft that were not
- 20:22Speaker 5: actually distributed to them. The lower courts ruled against them,
- 20:25Speaker 5: but they took their Supreme Court and the High Court agreed.
- 20:27Speaker 1: To hear it.
- 20:28Speaker 3: What exactly is this tax? Is a new and where
- 20:30Speaker 3: did it come from?
- 20:32Speaker 5: The tax is known as the Mandatory Repatriation Tax or
- 20:35Speaker 5: the Transition Tax, which was part of the Tax Cuts
- 20:38Speaker 5: and Jobs Act, the Big Tax the Overhault back in
- 20:40Speaker 5: twenty seventeen. This is a one time tax on companies
- 20:43Speaker 5: accumulated foreign earnings. Big US companies had been stashing their
- 20:47Speaker 5: foreign earnings overseas for many years rather than bring them
- 20:50Speaker 5: back to the US and have them taxed at US
- 20:52Speaker 5: corporate tax rates, which at the time were relatively high.
- 20:55Speaker 5: What the twenty seventeen law did, besides lowering the corporate
- 20:58Speaker 5: tax rate, was to change the whole time system so
- 21:00Speaker 5: that all earnings of US companies would be tax going forward,
- 21:03Speaker 5: no matter where in the world they were located. The
- 21:05Speaker 5: mandatary repatriation tax was a one time catchup tax imposed
- 21:09Speaker 5: on those accumulated earnings to make sure that they wouldn't
- 21:11Speaker 5: be entirely free from US taxation. But it also applies
- 21:15Speaker 5: to people like the Moors who had a significant stake
- 21:17Speaker 5: in a foreign company about thirteen percent of their case,
- 21:20Speaker 5: at thirty percent stake in Kis and craft And they
- 21:22Speaker 5: were taxing kins and Crafts earnings even though they didn't
- 21:24Speaker 5: actually receive any distribution of those earnings that falls out
- 21:27Speaker 5: of the same military repatriation tax. And the Mores claim
- 21:30Speaker 5: that that's unconstitutional.
- 21:32Speaker 2: And so why do they claim it's unconstitutional? What's the
- 21:35Speaker 2: argument that the Moors are making in this case?
- 21:38Speaker 5: This hinges on what's called realization. The Moors claim that
- 21:42Speaker 5: it's improper on the sixteenth Amendment of the Constitution, which
- 21:45Speaker 5: established the USN Tax, to tax them in this fashion
- 21:48Speaker 5: because they didn't realize didn't actually receive any distribution of
- 21:52Speaker 5: those earnings. The government's response to that is that the
- 21:56Speaker 5: tax is legal in the sixtieth Amendment, that it does,
- 21:59Speaker 5: in fact Congress to tax a shareholder's share of undistributed
- 22:03Speaker 5: or unrealized corporate earnings. As income to the shareholders. In fact,
- 22:07Speaker 5: the government says Congress has done so numerous times in
- 22:10Speaker 5: the one hundred and ten years since the sixteenth Membal
- 22:12Speaker 5: was ratified. It's imposed taxes like taxes on companies, foreign income,
- 22:16Speaker 5: and partnership taxes to follow the same principle that you
- 22:19Speaker 5: don't always have to realize income in order to tax
- 22:22Speaker 5: on it, and the court has upheld those provisions in
- 22:25Speaker 5: the past.
- 22:26Speaker 3: So what's the government arguing here?
- 22:28Speaker 5: Then?
- 22:28Speaker 3: On the other side, as I.
- 22:29Speaker 5: Said, the government's argument is that the repatriot text is legal,
- 22:34Speaker 5: that in fact, there have been cases in which unrealized
- 22:37Speaker 5: income is taxable, such as tax on foreign income, tax
- 22:40Speaker 5: tax on partnerships, and courts have upheld those provisions.
- 22:44Speaker 2: What are the key precedents here? It seems pretty remarkable
- 22:48Speaker 2: that the sixteenth Amendment has been around this long and
- 22:51Speaker 2: the Court has never clearly answered what seems to be
- 22:55Speaker 2: a pretty basic question about what it covers.
- 22:59Speaker 5: Well, I wanted to keep precedents certainly from the standpoint
- 23:02Speaker 5: of what the Moors are claiming, is a case called
- 23:05Speaker 5: Eisner versus Macomber, which is from nineteen twenty. The Moors
- 23:09Speaker 5: claim that that case rules out taxes unrealized income. What
- 23:14Speaker 5: the government says and responses is that, well, that case
- 23:17Speaker 5: was in a very limited context. It was limited to
- 23:19Speaker 5: cases in which a company pays a stock dividend to
- 23:22Speaker 5: a shareholder, and that the court has repeatedly refused to
- 23:25Speaker 5: extend that principle beyond that limited sort of circumstances.
- 23:29Speaker 3: So if the court strikes down this tax, what are
- 23:32Speaker 3: the implications for the rest of the tax code.
- 23:34Speaker 5: Well, the first and most obvious implication is if you
- 23:37Speaker 5: strike down the mandatary repatriation tax, it could trigger enormous
- 23:40Speaker 5: tax refunds for some of the giant multinational companies that
- 23:43Speaker 5: had been paying billions of dollars in these taxes over
- 23:46Speaker 5: the last several years, such as Apple, Microsoft, Pfiser. The
- 23:50Speaker 5: government has projected that the tax would bring in a
- 23:52Speaker 5: total of three hundred and forty billion dollars over ten years.
- 23:55Speaker 5: So we're talking about something that could hugely benefit big companies,
- 23:58Speaker 5: that could really blow a hole and government revenue. Beyond that,
- 24:01Speaker 5: though that, there's a lot of concern among people in
- 24:04Speaker 5: tax world, and it's kind of much roomed. Ever since
- 24:06Speaker 5: the court agreed to hear the case, that if you
- 24:08Speaker 5: strike down the repatriation tax. It also calls into question
- 24:11Speaker 5: other parts of the tax code that similarly are levied
- 24:14Speaker 5: on corporate income that hasn't been distributed to the shareholder.
- 24:17Speaker 5: The same principle behind the repatriation tax also applies in
- 24:20Speaker 5: a lot of existing provisions in tax code. So, for instance,
- 24:23Speaker 5: you have taxes on foreign income what's called Subpart F,
- 24:27Speaker 5: which applies to certain taxes on certain kinds of income
- 24:30Speaker 5: from the foreign affiliates of US companies guilty, the tax
- 24:33Speaker 5: on Global Intangible Low tax Income, which is the US
- 24:37Speaker 5: mindium tax on the company's foreign income. Taxes on partnerships
- 24:40Speaker 5: because their profits are taxable to the individual partners even
- 24:43Speaker 5: when they are even when the earnings aren't distributed. Mark
- 24:45Speaker 5: to market situations, taxes leving on the current market value
- 24:49Speaker 5: of certain kinds of assets like regulative futures contracts, even
- 24:52Speaker 5: something like taxes on the zero coupon bonds, which taxpayers
- 24:55Speaker 5: have to pay taxes on each year but don't actually
- 24:57Speaker 5: receive payment until the bond's mature. All those kinds of
- 24:59Speaker 5: wa under the same kind of principle as the mandatory
- 25:02Speaker 5: repatriation tax, and there are other such situations. Paul Ryan
- 25:06Speaker 5: the former Speaker of the House has suggested that ruling
- 25:09Speaker 5: in favor of the Moors could affect a third of
- 25:10Speaker 5: the entire tax code.
- 25:12Speaker 2: So do the Moors in their allies acknowledge what you
- 25:17Speaker 2: just said, agree with what you just said.
- 25:18Speaker 5: Do they.
- 25:21Speaker 2: Accept that this will have such a big effect on
- 25:23Speaker 2: the tax code or are they arguing, Hey, this is
- 25:25Speaker 2: actually a narrow case and there's a way you can
- 25:27Speaker 2: resolve it in our favor without having all these big implications.
- 25:32Speaker 5: But the Mores, in their supporters claim is that the
- 25:36Speaker 5: mandatary repatriation tax is distinguishable from all these other provisions,
- 25:39Speaker 5: and the details are very in the weeds and legalistic,
- 25:43Speaker 5: but basically they claim that this is something separate from
- 25:47Speaker 5: things like Subpart F and some of the other provisions,
- 25:49Speaker 5: so that you can rule in the Moor's favor and
- 25:51Speaker 5: strike down the repatriation tax and not have any of
- 25:55Speaker 5: this other stuff affected. Some of the more supporters the
- 25:57Speaker 5: US Chamber of Commerce claimed in it's front of the
- 25:59Speaker 5: court brief that the people who are concerned about this
- 26:02Speaker 5: were engaging in hysteria and barely overstating the potential impact.
- 26:08Speaker 5: What the people opposed to the More say, the people
- 26:11Speaker 5: who want to see the court uphold the mandatary repatriation tax.
- 26:15Speaker 5: Is that it's not that simple. You can't really strike
- 26:19Speaker 5: down one and preserve the rest. So if you strike
- 26:22Speaker 5: down the mandatary repatriation tax, then really could have ripple
- 26:24Speaker 5: effects and call into question a lot of these other provisions.
- 26:27Speaker 3: You mentioned that there's about three hundred and forty billion
- 26:30Speaker 3: dollars at stake here and that you know, overturning this
- 26:34Speaker 3: could really blow a hole in government revenue. Has the
- 26:37Speaker 3: government talked about kind of what they use that revenue
- 26:39Speaker 3: for and what you know the implications could be.
- 26:42Speaker 5: Well, the government attended the mandatary repatriation tax its kind
- 26:45Speaker 5: of a pay for for some of the other things
- 26:48Speaker 5: that it was some of the other changes that it
- 26:51Speaker 5: made in the tax cuts and job sects, such as
- 26:53Speaker 5: lowering the corporate tax rate from what had been thirty
- 26:56Speaker 5: five percent down to twenty one percent. This was intended,
- 27:00Speaker 5: as I said, to make up for some of that
- 27:02Speaker 5: lost revenue, and also to make sure that some of
- 27:04Speaker 5: these accumulator earnings that companies had piled up overseas over
- 27:08Speaker 5: many years wouldn't go completely untaxed. When the government decided
- 27:12Speaker 5: to change its tax system and tax all of us
- 27:15Speaker 5: companies income going forward.
- 27:17Speaker 2: Michael, let's talk briefly and we can continue after the
- 27:21Speaker 2: break that you want to about implications for a wealth tax.
- 27:24Speaker 2: These our hypothetical proposals right now, But what does this
- 27:28Speaker 2: case mean for those proposals.
- 27:30Speaker 5: A ruling in the Moors favor might preclude attempts to
- 27:33Speaker 5: impose a wealth tax because it's based on the same
- 27:35Speaker 5: kind of principles. A wealth tax would be based on
- 27:38Speaker 5: the accumulated value of a wealthy person's assets. In other words,
- 27:42Speaker 5: value that hasn't actually been monetized by the taxpayer. If
- 27:44Speaker 5: you own a stake in a public company that has
- 27:47Speaker 5: accumulated tremendously in value that's pay per wealth. You have
- 27:51Speaker 5: not actually realized that income. You haven't even sold the shares.
- 27:54Speaker 5: You haven't received that as income. As long as you
- 27:58Speaker 5: don't sell that asset, that means accumulative value is an
- 28:01Speaker 5: unrealized game. And if the court strikes down the mandatary
- 28:03Speaker 5: repatriation tax because it says you can tax unrealized games,
- 28:07Speaker 5: that could mean you can oppose a well tax because
- 28:09Speaker 5: it would tax on realized gains.
- 28:11Speaker 2: Michael tell us a little bit about this kind of
- 28:14Speaker 2: side dispute, or maybe it's a central dispute about Charles
- 28:17Speaker 2: Moore's involvement with his company. Why is that a controversy
- 28:21Speaker 2: and how might it affect the case?
- 28:24Speaker 5: Charles Moore has portrayed himself and his wife as simple
- 28:27Speaker 5: passive outside shareholders and kisen Kraft, the Indian company, issue
- 28:31Speaker 5: here that they had no control of what the Kis
- 28:33Speaker 5: and Craft distributed its urnings to shareholders. Since this case
- 28:36Speaker 5: hinges on whether undistributed corporate income can be taxed, that
- 28:40Speaker 5: could be significant. But what Charles Moore didn't say in
- 28:42Speaker 5: his followings to the Supreme Court is that and this
- 28:45Speaker 5: is shown in kisen Kraft's corporate documents. In India, Charles
- 28:48Speaker 5: Moore was essentially a corporate insider there. He was a
- 28:50Speaker 5: director of the company for five years. He received thousands
- 28:53Speaker 5: of dollars in travel reingbursons for the company, even though
- 28:55Speaker 5: he claimed in his followings that he never received any
- 28:58Speaker 5: payments from the company. He advanced only twoitter fifty thousand
- 29:01Speaker 5: downlished the Kais and Craft and the form what was
- 29:03Speaker 5: called share application money that was later refunded to him.
- 29:06Speaker 5: He appears to have sold some of the shares to
- 29:08Speaker 5: the company's CEO, as I said, was a friend and
- 29:11Speaker 5: former colleague of his. All the suggests that he would
- 29:14Speaker 5: have had at least some sort of voice in what
- 29:16Speaker 5: the COIs and Craft did in fact distrie of its
- 29:18Speaker 5: turnings to the shareholders. Now the question is does all
- 29:21Speaker 5: this matter to the case, And people in the tax
- 29:23Speaker 5: world are kind of split about that. Some people think, yes,
- 29:26Speaker 5: it does matter that the Wars haven't told the full
- 29:29Speaker 5: story to the court, that it speaks to their credibility
- 29:31Speaker 5: and to their portrayal of themselves as ordinary taxpayers and
- 29:34Speaker 5: kind of a David versus Golide situation. Other people contend well,
- 29:38Speaker 5: even if Charles Wore was more deeply involved with the
- 29:41Speaker 5: company that he said, it doesn't affect the central issue
- 29:44Speaker 5: in the case. It doesn't speak to whether the mandatary
- 29:46Speaker 5: repatriation tax is unconstitutional. It doesn't speak to whether it's
- 29:49Speaker 5: legal the tax income that the taxpayer hasn't realized. So
- 29:52Speaker 5: these people think that at the end of the day,
- 29:53Speaker 5: it does not matter to the ultimate outcome of the case.
- 29:57Speaker 5: For what it's worth, the government has not shown any
- 29:59Speaker 5: sign that it intends to make an issue out of this,
- 30:01Speaker 5: so it's very possible. It might not come up during
- 30:03Speaker 5: the oral arguments on Tuesday. We don't know whether any
- 30:06Speaker 5: of the justices have taken note of this issue, so
- 30:09Speaker 5: we'll have to wait and see about that.
- 30:11Speaker 3: You mentioned earlier about the implications that this case could
- 30:15Speaker 3: have on a future wealth tax. Can you talk about
- 30:18Speaker 3: who has been calling for a wealth tax and kind
- 30:21Speaker 3: of the history there and kind of why we don't
- 30:23Speaker 3: already have that.
- 30:24Speaker 5: Well, it's actually kind of started before the Court agreed
- 30:27Speaker 5: to take the case, because some conservative groups urged the
- 30:30Speaker 5: Court to accept to hear this case exactly for that reason,
- 30:33Speaker 5: because they want the Court to use this case to
- 30:36Speaker 5: rule future wealth tax off limits. Now, Democrats continue to
- 30:41Speaker 5: press andw with proposals for a wealth tax. The latest
- 30:44Speaker 5: attempt was introducing the Senate ships a few days ago
- 30:47Speaker 5: by Senator Ron Wide and the chairman of the Center
- 30:49Speaker 5: Finance Committee. He insists that such a tax would be constitutional.
- 30:53Speaker 5: President Biden has called for a wealth tax also or
- 30:55Speaker 5: a billionaire's tax, as a court where assets above a
- 30:59Speaker 5: certain level would be taxed, whether or not would be realized.
- 31:02Speaker 5: As of right now, however, a wealth tax is still
- 31:05Speaker 5: very much in the nascent stages. There's no indication that's
- 31:08Speaker 5: going to pass anytime soon. Congress is having difficulty agreeing
- 31:12Speaker 5: on anything much these days, and even Wide admits that
- 31:16Speaker 5: proposal of this nature probably wouldn't be acting on for
- 31:18Speaker 5: some time yet.
- 31:20Speaker 2: Michael, we only have thirty seconds left or so. But
- 31:23Speaker 2: do you have any strong feelings, based on what the
- 31:27Speaker 2: quarters that are done in the past, about how this
- 31:29Speaker 2: case is likely to come out?
- 31:31Speaker 5: It's really hard to say. I mean, part of the
- 31:33Speaker 5: reason that some of the people in tax world have
- 31:37Speaker 5: been trumpeting the potential implications of this so loudly is
- 31:41Speaker 5: because they know that the justices, while they obviously are
- 31:44Speaker 5: legal experts, are not tax law experts. Tax flow is
- 31:47Speaker 5: extremely in the weeds and detailed and complex, and they
- 31:50Speaker 5: want to make sure that the justices before they rule,
- 31:53Speaker 5: or aware of the potential implications for the rest of
- 31:55Speaker 5: the tax code. And it's really hard to say but
- 31:58Speaker 5: how the court is going to come down this, But
- 32:01Speaker 5: this particular court has shown a tendency to not confine
- 32:05Speaker 5: its rulings to narrow issues, so it's certainly in the
- 32:09Speaker 5: realm of possibility that they could rule broadly in this case.
- 32:13Speaker 5: And if they do, in factor, won't favor the Moores issues,
- 32:16Speaker 5: something that could have significant implications for other provisions in
- 32:20Speaker 5: the tax code.
- 32:21Speaker 3: That's Michael Rappaport, a senior reporter at Bloomberg Tax and Accounting.
- 32:25Speaker 3: Thanks so much for joining us. Well, Greg, One thing
- 32:28Speaker 3: we didn't chat about with Michael is the controversy here
- 32:31Speaker 3: involving Justice Alito in this case. You know over one
- 32:35Speaker 3: of the attorneys that's actually arguing, I think David Rivkin,
- 32:39Speaker 3: you know he's going to be before the court. Can
- 32:41Speaker 3: you talk about the relationship with Alito there and what's
- 32:45Speaker 3: going on?
- 32:45Speaker 2: Yeah, really unusual situation. David ri Rivken, a well known
- 32:48Speaker 2: conservative lawyer, co wrote to Wall Street Journal Articles opinion
- 32:54Speaker 2: pieces with an opinion a writer at the Wall Street
- 32:57Speaker 2: Journal in which basically gave Justice Alito a four to
- 33:00Speaker 2: say some things, and he talked about he talked about
- 33:03Speaker 2: the leak of the ruling in the abortion case. People
- 33:07Speaker 2: have said that was an inappropriate thing to happen, and
- 33:10Speaker 2: Democrats have called for Justice Alito to recuse from this
- 33:14Speaker 2: case because of David Rifkins's involvement. And then Justice Alito
- 33:17Speaker 2: back in September put out a statement in which he
- 33:21Speaker 2: said I'm not going to recuse. There's nothing out of
- 33:23Speaker 2: the ordinary about these interviews, nothing to see here, and
- 33:27Speaker 2: so every indication is he is going to participate in
- 33:30Speaker 2: this case.
- 33:32Speaker 3: Wow, that's really interesting, you know, especially given all the
- 33:35Speaker 3: ethics controversies. And that does it for this edition of
- 33:37Speaker 3: the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm Lydia Wheeler and.
- 33:39Speaker 2: I'm Greg Storr. This is being pl