Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Before the Appeal: A California Litigator’s Pre-Appeal Checklist
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Before the Appeal, a California Litigators'
- 0:06Pre -Appeal Checklist. I am Brianna Rucker, Diversity
- 0:10and Inclusion Committee Chair of BHBA's Barrister
- 0:13Section, and I'm super excited to introduce our
- 0:16speakers today, Laura Lim and Kent Toddlin. Kent
- 0:20Tollin is an associate with Greenest, Martin,
- 0:23Stein, and Richland LLP. He has handled appeals
- 0:26before the California Appellate Courts involving
- 0:29commercial real estate, anti -slap law, property
- 0:32rights, secure transactions, contracts, and writs
- 0:36of attachment, among other subjects. Before joining
- 0:39GMSR, Kent was a litigator at a midsize California
- 0:43law firm that, in the trenches experience, gave
- 0:46him a robust understanding of all phases of litigation
- 0:49and makes him well suited to advise clients and
- 0:52trial counsel on preserving issues for appeal.
- 0:55Laura Lim is an associate with Grinnis Martin
- 0:58Stein and Richland LLP, and before joining GMSR,
- 1:03Laura was a research attorney for Justice John
- 1:05S. Wiley Jr. at the California Court of Appeal
- 1:08and a law clerk for Judge George H. Wu in the
- 1:11Central District of California. In her work at
- 1:14both the appellate and trial court levels, Laura
- 1:17drafted opinions and orders spanning a wide range
- 1:20of complex civil issues. Laura also worked at
- 1:23an international law firm as a litigator with
- 1:26an emphasis on data privacy. She helped clients
- 1:29interpret evolving privacy regulations and navigate
- 1:32data breach notification requirements. And without
- 1:36further ado, let's get started. Thank you so
- 1:41much for joining us, everyone. We're so excited
- 1:44to share a little bit about California appeals
- 1:46with you. The purpose of this presentation is
- 1:50to provide an overview of some essential pre
- 1:53-appeal considerations that will help you determine
- 1:57whether you can appeal and help you evaluate
- 2:00the strength of an appeal, all before you even
- 2:03file anything with the appellate court. We will
- 2:07cover five basic tips which fall under three
- 2:11categories. The first category is can you appeal?
- 2:15Within that, we'll go over what exactly is appealable
- 2:19and what's the deadline by which you need to
- 2:22appeal. The second category is assessing whether
- 2:25you should appeal. Within that, we'll cover standards
- 2:29of review and the requirement that the appellant
- 2:33must show prejudice. And finally, we'll go over
- 2:37what it means to have a complete record on appeal
- 2:39and why that's so important. For each tip, we
- 2:44primarily will focus on the appellant's perspective,
- 2:48but we'll also consider the flip side, the respondent's
- 2:51perspective, the perspective of the person who
- 2:54prevailed in the trial court, and we'll go over
- 2:56how that side can assess these same issues. Please
- 3:01feel free to put questions in the Q &A box below.
- 3:04We will try to cover them as we go along. And
- 3:07we're happy to answer them at the end if you
- 3:09have some then too. So with that, I will pass
- 3:13it over to Kent to kick us off with letting us
- 3:16know what exactly is appealable. All right. Thanks,
- 3:20Laura. And thank you, everyone, for being here
- 3:22today. We're really happy to share these tips
- 3:24with you. And as you can see from that previous
- 3:26slide, each tip is really framed as a question.
- 3:29questions that you can ask yourself as you're
- 3:31thinking about whether you want to take an appeal,
- 3:33whether you can, whether you should. So we hope
- 3:36that these five questions just help you to see
- 3:39strategic opportunities and things to be thinking
- 3:41about in that process. So the first one is, is
- 3:45it appealable? So whatever you're trying to appeal
- 3:47from, a judgment, an order, can you actually
- 3:50appeal from it? And so we're going to go over
- 3:52the rule, the general default rule, and then
- 3:54the exceptions. And there are plenty of exceptions
- 3:56to this rule. So the default rule is the one
- 4:00final judgment rule. And so what that means is
- 4:04that there's one final judgment in an action,
- 4:07and that's what you can take an appeal from.
- 4:09So if the case goes to trial, the jury returns
- 4:12its verdict and then judgment is entered, the
- 4:15default rule is that's what you would take your
- 4:17appeal from. And so a couple things to note on
- 4:20this is that it's a statutory, right? It's created
- 4:24by statute and CCP section 904 .1 subdivision
- 4:30A1 is what codifies the one final judgment rule.
- 4:34But there are plenty of exceptions and so that's
- 4:37what we're going to look at next. So you want
- 4:39to ask yourself if it's not the one final judgment,
- 4:42is there an exception that would apply that would
- 4:44make this appealable? Some of those come from
- 4:46CCP section 904 .1 as well. There's several subdivisions
- 4:50that list out different exceptions and we're
- 4:53going to touch on just a few of those to illustrate
- 4:55how this works. So the first exception we have
- 4:59here is an order granting a new trial. So the
- 5:02verdict has been returned and the judge hears
- 5:05a motion for new trial and grants that motion,
- 5:07that's immediately appealable. And so that means,
- 5:10you know, that instead of having to do a new
- 5:11trial again, go through all of that all over,
- 5:14first the party who won at trial and then had
- 5:17that verdict set aside in favor of a new trial
- 5:20could appeal right then. There's also ordered
- 5:23denying JNOV, that's immediately appealable as
- 5:27well. So these first two examples are post -trial
- 5:30motions that would be ruled on and judgment hasn't
- 5:33been entered yet, but they're appealable. There's
- 5:36also some provisional remedies that are appealable
- 5:39under the statute. We have injunctive relief.
- 5:43So this could be an order granting or denying
- 5:47a preliminary injunction, for example. And so
- 5:51if you have filed a motion for preliminary injunction
- 5:55and it's denied, you could take an appeal from
- 5:57that. And that's really helpful to know because
- 6:00this could be at the very beginning of a case,
- 6:02just after the complaint's been filed. It could
- 6:04be in the middle of discovery. Trial is a long
- 6:07way away. And so this is an opportunity to appeal
- 6:11early on if you think that an injunction has
- 6:15been entered against your client that shouldn't
- 6:16have been, or that the court erred by denying
- 6:19your client's request. for a preliminary injunction.
- 6:22Later we'll talk about the standards for how
- 6:24courts assess these kinds of appeals, but right
- 6:26now we're just focusing on what is appealable.
- 6:29And one thing that I want to touch on, we won't
- 6:31go into detail as much with this today, but it's
- 6:34also important to be thinking about when you
- 6:36can't appeal what happens to the order or the
- 6:39judgment you're appealing from. And what I mean
- 6:42by that is will enforcement be stayed or is it
- 6:46still enforceable even as you're appealing? The
- 6:49answer is it depends. And that's a common answer
- 6:52to a lot of our questions as lawyers. And what
- 6:54it depends on for an injunctive relief, for example,
- 6:58is whether the injunction is mandatory or prohibitory.
- 7:01So if you have a mandatory injunction compelling
- 7:03your client to take affirmative action and you
- 7:07appeal from that, not only is it immediately
- 7:09appealable, but the enforcement of the order
- 7:11is stayed during the appeal. But that's not the
- 7:16case for a prohibitory injunction. which restricts
- 7:19your client from taking action and prohibits
- 7:21them from taking certain actions, that is immediately
- 7:24appealable, but enforcement is not automatically
- 7:27stayed by appeal. So again, we're not going to
- 7:29go into all the details of stays, but I just
- 7:31wanted to note that that's something to be thinking
- 7:33about as well as you're thinking about whether
- 7:35something's appealable. What's the consequence
- 7:37of filing a notice of appeal as for the enforceability
- 7:40of what you're appealing from? And then we have
- 7:43another exception listed here. If you have an
- 7:46order, appointing a receiver. So another provisional
- 7:50remedy here, that's immediately appealable. For
- 7:53those of you who have litigated in cases that
- 7:55involve receivers, you know this could be a significant
- 7:57remedy. Maybe a business is really taking a turn
- 8:02for the worse, like things are going south, and
- 8:04one of the party's claims that a receiver is
- 8:06needed to right the ship, basically, to come
- 8:09in and take control. If that application is granted,
- 8:14the party that opposed that application can file
- 8:16an appeal immediately. And that makes sense too.
- 8:19If you have a receiver appointed who would take
- 8:21control of books and records, start making all
- 8:23sorts of decisions to essentially take control
- 8:26of business, you know, you can't really unscramble
- 8:28the egg once that has happened at the end of
- 8:31the litigation. So that shows why that would
- 8:33be an exception to the one final judgment rule
- 8:35as well. So those are a few exceptions under
- 8:38the statute, and there are more. There are more
- 8:41under CCP section 904 .1. There's an order from
- 8:45an anti -slap motion that's immediately appealable
- 8:48as well. And then there's other sources of law,
- 8:51for example, the California Arbitration Act.
- 8:54If you have an order denying a petition to compel
- 8:58arbitration, that's another one that's immediately
- 9:01appealable. And there, otherwise the parties
- 9:04would have to litigate at trial. and there would
- 9:07be no chance to really seek meaningful appellate
- 9:09relief to go to arbitration because then you
- 9:12can't avoid trial if you've already done it.
- 9:14So that helps that it's immediately appealable.
- 9:18If you believe that decision was erroneous, you
- 9:20can file an appeal from that as well. Those are
- 9:23some examples. We've also included an appendix
- 9:25at the end of the slides, and it highlights other
- 9:28examples of well, other sources of law or doctrines
- 9:31that make certain other orders appealable. So
- 9:34hopefully this has shown that, yes, there's a
- 9:35one final judgment rule. That's the default rule.
- 9:38There are many exceptions. And it really pays
- 9:40to know these exceptions. We haven't given an
- 9:44exhaustive list. But if you know these, and especially
- 9:47the ones that come up more often, it's really
- 9:50helpful for you in serving your client to recognize
- 9:53that, oh, OK, we can take an appeal from this
- 9:55now. We don't have to wait. um, this preliminary
- 9:59injunction has been entered and we think it's
- 10:01wrong and we think it's really harming our client,
- 10:03um, could appeal from that now. And otherwise,
- 10:07you know, there might be no meaningful relief
- 10:08at the end of the case, or, um, you might have
- 10:11to wait years to get any sort of relief from
- 10:13say an erroneous injunction. And as a respondent,
- 10:18um, from that perspective, if the other side
- 10:21appeals, you want to be thinking about, you know,
- 10:23is that actually appealable? Can they do that?
- 10:25And if the answer is no, if you don't see any
- 10:28grounds, you've checked all the sources, including
- 10:32CCP Section 904 .1, and you don't see any grounds
- 10:35for it to be appealable, that could be a good
- 10:38opportunity for a motion to dismiss to show that
- 10:41the appellant is asking to appeal from something.
- 10:45where the court does not have jurisdiction. It's
- 10:47a jurisdictional bar. If it's not appealable,
- 10:50then it shouldn't be before the court of appeal.
- 10:51And that could help you to avoid the time and
- 10:54cost and delay of briefing on appeal. And one
- 10:57last thing I'll note before I hand it over to
- 10:59Laura for our next tip is that another reason
- 11:03to know what kinds of orders are appealable is
- 11:05that appeals are use it or lose it. So If one
- 11:09of these orders happens and your client's aggrieved
- 11:11by it and you believe it's erroneous, it's important
- 11:13to recognize it when it happens so that you can
- 11:16protect your client's rights. And with that,
- 11:18I'll turn it over to Laura for our next tip.
- 11:20Thanks, Kent. So our next topic we'll cover is
- 11:25when is the deadline to appeal? And by deadline
- 11:28to appeal, we mean the date by which you need
- 11:31to file the notice of appeal with the Superior
- 11:34Court. This is what kicks off the entire appellate
- 11:37process. The deadline here is jurisdictional.
- 11:40This means that timely filing a notice of appeal
- 11:43vests jurisdiction with the Court of Appeal and
- 11:46generally terminates the trial court's jurisdiction.
- 11:49This is the one appellate deadline you cannot
- 11:52miss. As some of you may know, in the appellate
- 11:55world, deadlines generally can be flexible. Opposing
- 11:59parties will routinely stipulate to extend briefing
- 12:03deadlines. The deadlines, even the court deadlines
- 12:06for some briefs, have a grace period within which
- 12:10you can file your brief, an opening brief, or
- 12:13a respondents brief, and still have it be considered
- 12:16timely filed even if you missed the actual deadline
- 12:19to file the brief, as long as you filed it at
- 12:21some point within that grace period. That is
- 12:24not the case here. This is the one appellate
- 12:27deadline for which there is no grace period.
- 12:30Parties cannot stipulate to extend or shorten,
- 12:34for that matter, the deadline for filing a notice
- 12:38of appeal. And courts have no authority to excuse
- 12:42a tardy filing. There's no relief under CCP 473
- 12:47for a mistake, accident, inadvertence. There
- 12:50isn't anything of that sort. So missing this
- 12:53deadline is, in fact, fatal to the appeal. And
- 12:56so our main practice tip here is definitely heed
- 13:00the deadline and calendar it immediately and
- 13:04file sooner than later. So what is the deadline?
- 13:10Rule 8 .104 generally governs it. The typical
- 13:14deadline is 60 days after service of notice of
- 13:17entry of judgment or notice of entry of order.
- 13:20So either the Superior Court clerk or a party
- 13:24can serve notice of entry. And if nobody serves
- 13:28such notice, then the deadline is 180 days after
- 13:31entry of judgment or entry of order. Again, this
- 13:35is a strict deadline. even if the clerk reenters
- 13:38the same order, or if a party for some reason
- 13:41transmits a second notice of entry, that doesn't
- 13:44restart the appellate clock. But under rule 8
- 13:49.108, The deadline can be extended if the trial
- 13:54court denies certain post -trial motions. The
- 13:57rule lists all the different types of post -trial
- 13:59motions and the corresponding extended deadlines.
- 14:02I won't go through all of them, but for example,
- 14:05say you file a motion for new trial and the court
- 14:09denies that motion. Your deadline to appeal is
- 14:14now the earliest of 30 days after service of
- 14:18the order denying your motion for new trial.
- 14:21or notice of entry of that order, or 180 days
- 14:26after entry of judgment, whichever is sooner.
- 14:29The same deadlines will apply for a motion for
- 14:31JNOV if you file one and it gets denied. I should
- 14:37note though that these extensions only apply
- 14:40if your post -trial motions A are valid and B
- 14:44are timely filed. Otherwise, the deadlines will
- 14:47remain the same. as if you didn't file any post
- 14:50-trial motions. So on the other hand, if you
- 14:54are the respondent, so if you prevailed in the
- 14:57Superior Court, you should still be mindful of
- 14:59the deadline to appeal. Because when the other
- 15:03side files a notice of appeal, you should check
- 15:06to see whether that appeal is indeed timely.
- 15:09And if not, as Ken was kind of saying for orders
- 15:13that indeed are not appealable, you should move
- 15:16for dismissal. And if it makes sense, request
- 15:19a stay of the briefing deadlines until this timeliness
- 15:23issue is resolved. The reason for this is whether
- 15:28or not an appeal is timely isn't always readily
- 15:30available or readily accessible to the Superior
- 15:34Court Clerk, especially if the appellant misses
- 15:36the deadline by, say, a day or two. It's not
- 15:39always immediately obvious and sometimes the
- 15:43court of appeal might not independently realize
- 15:45this error either and they'll dock it the case
- 15:47and in some instances no one will realize until
- 15:52you know all the briefing has been submitted
- 15:54and a court of appeal researcher attorney is
- 15:57combing through the record and notices like oh
- 16:00this wasn't even a timely appeal appeal So it's
- 16:04definitely worth raising the issue before you
- 16:06unnecessarily spend all your time and your clients
- 16:10resources on reviewing the entire record drafting
- 16:14and drafting a brief. This actually recently
- 16:17happened in a case that I was working on. We
- 16:21represented the respondent and we knew that the
- 16:24other side was going to appeal and they filed
- 16:28a notice of appeal one day late. The Superior
- 16:32Court Clerk didn't notice and the Court of Appeal
- 16:34didn't notice at first either. And so the appeal
- 16:38got docketed and we drafted a motion to dismiss.
- 16:42We were prepared to file it. And in the interim,
- 16:46what happened was the Court of Appeal clerk caught
- 16:49on and issued a letter to the parties asking
- 16:53appellant to explain why the appeal shouldn't
- 16:57be dismissed because it's untimely. Long story
- 17:01short, Appellant missed that deadline as well,
- 17:04and the case got dismissed. But we were prepared
- 17:06to file a motion to dismiss if needed. In any
- 17:10event, the main takeaway here is you don't want
- 17:14to miss this deadline. When in doubt, definitely
- 17:17file early to ensure that you preserve your client's
- 17:20rights. And we also advise not waiting until
- 17:24the very last day to file, just to avoid any
- 17:28last minute issues, a glitch in the filing system.
- 17:31Some superior courts have an appellate division
- 17:34where you need to go file in person. And if there's
- 17:39an issue with the attorney service you're using,
- 17:42it's best to leave yourself sufficient buffer
- 17:44time. Yeah. And so with that, I will pass it
- 17:49back to Kent and we'll talk about what happens
- 17:52once we get into the merits of the appeal. Great.
- 17:57Thank you, Laura. Yeah. So we've covered the
- 18:00first two questions in the category of can you
- 18:02appeal? So now we're assuming that this is an
- 18:06appeal that can be taken. The order is appealable
- 18:09or it's from the final judgment. Notice of appeal
- 18:11was filed timely. And now we're in the world.
- 18:14of the merits or if you're still evaluating whether
- 18:17to appeal, should you appeal? And so that's what
- 18:20this tip and the next one go toward. In this
- 18:22tip here, number three, what is the standard
- 18:25of review? This question to ask yourself. This
- 18:28is really probably the heart of our presentation
- 18:30because once we get into the merits of the appeal,
- 18:32this is a question in every appeal we think about
- 18:36a lot. It's really important. It can be determinative.
- 18:39If not determinative, it can still be very influential
- 18:42in how we view the appeal as the attorneys and
- 18:46certainly how the court of appeal will view it
- 18:49as well. So before we talk about the different
- 18:52standards of review, what is that? What does
- 18:56standard of review mean? Well, it's the threshold
- 18:58issue in every appeal. And what it means is it's
- 19:03the lens through which the court of appeal is
- 19:05going to view the case. It's the amount of deference,
- 19:09the measure of deference that they're going to
- 19:11show to the jury verdict or the trial court statement
- 19:14of decision or an order that the trial court
- 19:17entered. And there's a spectrum here. So this,
- 19:21the court of appeal does not automatically give
- 19:23a fresh look to any appeal that comes before
- 19:25it. Sometimes the court will show quite a bit
- 19:28of deference to the trial court. Other times,
- 19:31no deference. And it depends on the nature of
- 19:33the case, on the nature of the issue. that the
- 19:36appeal focuses on or the issues, plural. So the
- 19:41standard of review is really important for assessing
- 19:44in advance should you take this appeal. It's
- 19:48important to help you and your client count the
- 19:50cost to evaluate your chance of succeeding on
- 19:53appeal. This is an essential step to figure out
- 19:56what your chances of success are. And I hope
- 19:58that as we go through these standards, you'll
- 20:00see the differences and you'll see why this matters
- 20:02so much. At the outset then, once you know the
- 20:07standard of review, you can ask yourself, okay,
- 20:10if this is a difficult standard of review, if
- 20:13the court's going to defer a lot to what happened
- 20:15at the trial court, to what the jury found, what's
- 20:18our best argument under that standard of review?
- 20:20What's our best shot to say, yes, there's a lot
- 20:23of deference here, but this is the appeal that
- 20:26should succeed. This is the appeal that should
- 20:28overcome that deferential standard. Those are
- 20:31the kinds of questions that are really good to
- 20:32ask. at the outset, before you take an appeal,
- 20:35an appeal can take well over a year to brief
- 20:39from beginning to end. The briefs can be very
- 20:41extensive. It can be very costly. And so it's
- 20:44about counting the cost and making a reasoned,
- 20:47thoughtful decision with your client of whether
- 20:49or not you think this appeal is worth pursuing
- 20:51and then figuring out your arguments as part
- 20:55of that. Okay, so as we look at each standard
- 20:59of review, there's one more thing I want to point
- 21:01out before we get into each one. And what we
- 21:04want to do is keep in mind that appellate courts
- 21:06generally do not resolve factual issues, factual
- 21:10disputes, or evidentiary issues. They're really
- 21:13more focused on questions of law as a general
- 21:16rule of thumb. So that basic rule of thumb underlies
- 21:20these standards of review and how much deference
- 21:22they're going to show to a given order of judgment.
- 21:25So with that, there's four standards of review
- 21:27here, and Laura and I are going to go through
- 21:30each of them and take turns here. So I'm going
- 21:32to start with the first one. And it's the substantial
- 21:37evidence standard of review. So what this means
- 21:42is if the Court of Appeal is looking at an appeal
- 21:45that is under the substantial evidence standard
- 21:47of review, that means it's looking for whether
- 21:50there is sufficient evidence to support the order
- 21:53or judgment. And I've got a couple of case law
- 21:55quotes to help illustrate what this means and
- 21:58how it works. So in Schmidt versus Superior Court,
- 22:02in 2020, the court described it as, when a civil
- 22:06appeal challenges findings of fact, the appellate
- 22:08court's power begins and ends with the determination
- 22:12of whether there is any substantial evidence,
- 22:15contradicted or uncontradicted, to support the
- 22:19trial court's findings. And there's a common
- 22:23misconception about this standard. Oftentimes,
- 22:27Fairly often, appellants will want to come to
- 22:29the Court of Appeal and re -argue the evidence.
- 22:32They may want to claim this witness testified
- 22:34X, but it just was not credible. Or, you know,
- 22:38they testified X, but our side testified Y, and
- 22:41that was more believable. The jury really should
- 22:44have believed our side. That was clearly the
- 22:45truth. The other side was not telling the truth.
- 22:48Or argue some sort of other factual issue. Well,
- 22:51if you've gone to trial and the jury has rendered
- 22:54its verdict, it's likely going to be a substantial
- 22:56evidence issue. If it's a factual finding that
- 22:59you're challenging, then that's going to be substantial
- 23:01evidence. And so the misconception here is that
- 23:06the appellate courts, they're not going to resolve
- 23:09conflicts in evidence. And here's another quote
- 23:11from case law. We do not review the evidence
- 23:14to see if there is substantial evidence to support
- 23:17the losing parties version of events, but only
- 23:20to see if substantial evidence exists. to support
- 23:24the verdict in favor of the of the prevailing
- 23:27party. And so just to give kind of a hypothetical
- 23:31example, let's say you go to trial on a breach
- 23:34of contract claim and the plaintiff prevails
- 23:37to the jury returns a verdict in favor of the
- 23:40plaintiff. And let's say you're representing
- 23:43the defendant and you want to appeal from that
- 23:46verdict under the substantial evidence standard
- 23:50questions would be for each element of the claim,
- 23:54was there a contract? Was it breached? Were there
- 23:57damages, for example, as some of the elements,
- 24:00those would be viewed for substantial evidence.
- 24:03The court of appeal would not look to resolve
- 24:05any he said, she said disputes over whether or
- 24:08not they hadn't, say, a handshake deal. They
- 24:11would not really be looking at the credibility
- 24:15of the evidence. That's really for the trier
- 24:19of fact in a bench trial the judge and a jury
- 24:21trial the jury and so that's their province That
- 24:23doesn't mean that a substantial evidence appeal
- 24:25is impossible They can succeed but this is it's
- 24:29more rare to succeed under the standard of review.
- 24:31It's an uphill battle for sure and If it doesn't
- 24:37mean that any evidence whatsoever would satisfy
- 24:40the standard it has to be substantial and there's
- 24:43case law that describes what that means But basically
- 24:46there needs to be enough evidence to pass muster
- 24:49that it wasn't just totally unreasonable for
- 24:52the jury to find in favor of the prevailing party.
- 24:56And so it could be a small bit of evidence, though.
- 24:59It could be one witness's testimony. That testimony
- 25:02could be contradicted. That could qualify as
- 25:05substantial evidence and be enough for the Court
- 25:07of Appeal to affirm. So the takeaway is that
- 25:12this is a difficult hill to climb. And it's important
- 25:15to be aware that you're not re -arguing the evidence
- 25:17in this kind of appeal. That's a mistake that
- 25:20we see. Appellants that might chase an appeal
- 25:23that really has a low standard or a low probability
- 25:26of success, and then they might fail to tailor
- 25:29their argument to the standard of review. If
- 25:31they're arguing factual questions under the substantial
- 25:35evidence standard, that's probably not going
- 25:37to succeed. And so avoiding that, and being able
- 25:42to advise your client thoughtfully as to why
- 25:45or why not it's in their best interest to pursue
- 25:47an appeal really benefits them. And so that's
- 25:52why we want to highlight these standards. Again,
- 25:54it's not impossible to prevail, but it's important
- 25:58to know what you're looking at and what you're
- 26:00trying to tackle under this standard. It's not
- 26:04just a blank slate for the Court of Appeal. There
- 26:06will be quite a bit of deference. So I'll pass
- 26:09it to Laura for our next standard. Thanks, Ken.
- 26:12I see that we do have two questions. Really quickly,
- 26:15we have a question about the case citation for
- 26:18substantial evidence standard of review. At the
- 26:22end of our slides, which I think will be circulated
- 26:24or have been circulated, there is an appendix.
- 26:27And we have case citations for all four standards
- 26:30of review that we will cover today. And so we
- 26:35will circulate those. And if you would like more.
- 26:37citations, please feel free to email us. We're
- 26:40happy to send those along. And then there is
- 26:43another question about appealability. There is
- 26:49a case in which the court refuses to issue a
- 26:52final judgment. And I noticed that the appeal
- 26:55was filed. The question is, can I ask the court
- 26:58to rule on appealability by motion? Without knowing
- 27:03more about the case, it's hard to give to give
- 27:08a direct answer here. The short answer is probably
- 27:14not. But I think what we would advise is knowing
- 27:20that your client doesn't want to spend their
- 27:22resources litigating a full appeal, maybe consult
- 27:25with an appellate lawyer for perhaps 30 minutes
- 27:29or an hour just to get a sense of whether whatever
- 27:33you have appealed is appealable. Yeah, do you
- 27:38have any follow up to that? Yeah, I don't think
- 27:41we can answer specific case questions during
- 27:44this program. But if that's something that you
- 27:47want to reach out to an appellate attorney about,
- 27:50certainly, that could be a good idea to do so.
- 27:53We just can't really go to a specific question
- 27:55there. But hopefully, the content that we're
- 27:58giving helps point you in the right direction
- 28:01of things to consider in that case. So yeah,
- 28:06Laura, do you want to go ahead? Yeah, sure. So
- 28:08our next standard of review we'll cover is the
- 28:11abuse of discretion standard of review, which,
- 28:15as the name implies, applies to the review of
- 28:19discretionary trial court rulings. Discretion
- 28:22doesn't mean that the trial court judge can do
- 28:25whatever they want. It's been described as the
- 28:29sound judgment of the court to be exercised according
- 28:32to the rules of law. So there still are legal
- 28:35parameters, but they're quite broad within those
- 28:38parameters. Under the standard, the reviewing
- 28:42court will disturb a trial court ruling only
- 28:45upon showing of a clear case of abuse. Discretion
- 28:51is abused only when the trial court exceeds all
- 28:54bounds of reason. Rulings that constitute an
- 28:57abuse of discretion have been described as ones
- 29:00that are so irrational or so arbitrary that no
- 29:03reasonable person could agree with it. This,
- 29:07similar to the substantial evidence standard
- 29:09of review, is an exceedingly deferential standard.
- 29:13In deciding whether a ruling constituted an abuse
- 29:16of discretion, the reviewing court will view
- 29:19the light will view the entire record in the
- 29:22light most favorable to the court's ruling. So
- 29:25if there are multiple inferences that can be
- 29:28made from the evidence, from the testimony, the
- 29:32reviewing court has no authority to substitute
- 29:35its own decision of what these inferences are
- 29:39for the trial court's decision. Some examples
- 29:43of these discretionary rulings include granting
- 29:46or denying an injunction, an evidence code section
- 29:50352 ruling on admitting or excluding evidence
- 29:54based on prejudice or how probative it is, the
- 29:59amount of attorney fee awards, and discovery
- 30:02rulings, for instance, motions to compel, protective
- 30:06orders, sanctions. And it makes sense that appellate
- 30:10courts will defer to trial courts in their discretion
- 30:14for these types of very fact -intensive rulings.
- 30:17When I worked as a court of appeal research attorney,
- 30:21we talked about this all the time in chambers.
- 30:24For us, reading the cold record, reading a hearing
- 30:27transcript or a trial transcript on our screens,
- 30:29or sometimes we would have the paper copies,
- 30:32it's really no substitute for actually being
- 30:35there, being physically there to hear witness
- 30:37testimony, see the evidence firsthand, assess
- 30:41someone's body language, their credibility, hear
- 30:43their tone. Because we as the Court of Appeal
- 30:47were so far removed from the proceedings, the
- 30:50Court of Appeal justices really were loath to
- 30:53find an abuse of discretion where there was at
- 30:56least some justification for the ruling. So it's
- 31:00definitely a tough standard of review for the
- 31:03appellant. It's a heavy burden to show that the
- 31:06trial court had no reasonable basis for its action
- 31:08or that no reasonable judge could have made this
- 31:11decision. Courts have described the standard
- 31:14as the appellant facing a daunting task, an uphill
- 31:18battle. One court has even described these cases
- 31:21generally as dead on arrival. But all hope is
- 31:25not lost. I have worked on cases here at this
- 31:28firm where we have prevailed under this standard.
- 31:32In one instance, we were representing the respondent
- 31:36and the No, we were the appellant and our client
- 31:41was appealing a cost of proof attorney fee award.
- 31:47The other side was arguing that our client unreasonably
- 31:52denied requests for admissions and they were
- 31:55seeking to recoup the fees and costs they incurred
- 31:58in proving those issues at trial. In assessing
- 32:04this type of award, the trial court has to consider
- 32:08certain criteria, certain factors. Here, the
- 32:12trial court didn't do so. The court essentially
- 32:15made up a number. The rationale was that from
- 32:21the litigation's inception through trial, in
- 32:25the judge's experience, the level of lawyering
- 32:28by the other side's attorneys was of very high
- 32:31caliber. So just based on years and years of
- 32:34experience, the court decided that this amount
- 32:36was appropriate. So on appeal, we argued that
- 32:40this wasn't a use of discretion. There was no
- 32:44reasonable basis for this number awarded. In
- 32:47fact, there was no basis for this amount. And
- 32:53the court's decision, while there is discretion,
- 32:57it wasn't within the legal parameters required
- 33:00for this type of decision. the Court of Appeal
- 33:03agreed and we secured a reversal. So it's doable,
- 33:09but perhaps this example does illustrate the
- 33:12level of egregiousness that it takes for a reviewing
- 33:16court to say, okay, yes, this was an abusive
- 33:19discretion. We will reverse. So yeah, we've covered
- 33:26two pretty deferential standards of review. I'm
- 33:30going to pass it back to Kent to discuss a more
- 33:34appellant -friendly standard. Sure. So we've
- 33:38talked about how it's not always a fresh slate,
- 33:42not always a fresh look that the court of appeals
- 33:43is going to give. But this next standard, that's
- 33:46what the standard is. The NOVO, our third standard
- 33:49of review, that is a fresh look. The court of
- 33:51appeals is going to not show any deference to
- 33:55the trial court. And it's going to make its own
- 33:57ruling independent of what the trial court decided.
- 34:00And this goes back to our point earlier that
- 34:03kind of the dichotomy between questions of fact
- 34:06and questions of law, de novo is typically for
- 34:09legal questions. And the court of appeal, that's
- 34:12absolutely in the court's wheelhouse. Legal questions
- 34:15is a big part of what the appellate system is
- 34:18for, to make sure there's uniformity of law.
- 34:24Some examples of when de novo applies would be
- 34:27constitutional issues, statutory interpretation,
- 34:31interpretation of writings, that could be contracts,
- 34:33wills, and so on. Anti -slap motions get de novo
- 34:38review as well. And on the contract issue, there
- 34:43is contractual interpretation is reviewed de
- 34:46novo. An exception would be if you have parole
- 34:49evidence and specifically conflicting parole
- 34:51evidence that is um, admissible to, um, to help
- 34:56interpret the writing. That's going to typically
- 34:58be a question for the fact finder. And so I've
- 35:01seen that in cases where it's a de novo review
- 35:04of the, of the contractual interpretation. If
- 35:06it turns on that parole evidence, that extrinsic
- 35:09evidence that's conflicting, and that becomes
- 35:11a factual question of what, say the agreement
- 35:13is ambiguous and two sides thought it meant something
- 35:16different, that, that specific part of it won't
- 35:20be de novo. but in general reviewing a contract
- 35:23will be de novo review. And so this is much more
- 35:27appellant friendly, as Laura was saying, this
- 35:29is a much better territory to be in because you're
- 35:32on more equal footing with the respondent. Not
- 35:36entirely, we'll get to in slide four, there's
- 35:37still more that the appellant has to show, but
- 35:40it's a much better starting point generally than
- 35:43being a substantial evidence review or an abuse
- 35:46of discretion review. And so It can also include,
- 35:50I want to mention, appeals where you have the
- 35:53facts are undisputed. And so the question is
- 35:56a pure question of law. So the fact that there
- 35:58are some facts involved in this determination,
- 36:02if they're undisputed, though, we could still
- 36:04have a pure legal question that we get de novo
- 36:06review from the court of appeal. And I want to
- 36:09pause. I see we have a couple of questions. Let's
- 36:14see. We have one. How do you stack in strict
- 36:16scrutiny versus other constitutional standards
- 36:18under federal versus state constitutional law?
- 36:20That's a great question. So I'll speak to it
- 36:26briefly. We're not as focused on federal today.
- 36:28But if it's interpreting the Constitution, say
- 36:31the California Constitution, whether something
- 36:34is constitutional, that would start as de novo.
- 36:38And then if there's further case law as to what
- 36:42kind of scrutiny is given. Yes, that could affect
- 36:44the interpretation as well. So that is certainly
- 36:48something to consider as well in this constitutional
- 36:50issues. And then someone's asking, is it worth
- 36:54appealing discovery motions time wise? What is
- 36:57the estimated time for resolving this type of
- 37:00appeal? Laura, I can take it or you can either
- 37:03way. Yeah, I can take this one. The answer is,
- 37:07as with most things, it depends. It depends on
- 37:11the impact of this discovery motion, what's important
- 37:16to your client. We have some clients who like
- 37:21using appeals as settlement negotiation tactics.
- 37:27And so it really depends on... how important
- 37:31is this to your client in the long run and how
- 37:33it impacts the overall case. Time estimate for
- 37:38resolving these types of appeals, it also very
- 37:41much depends. When I was working in the court
- 37:43of appeal, I was in the second district here
- 37:46in Los Angeles and every single division had
- 37:49a different... timeframe within which they would
- 37:53complete an appeal. Some divisions had a huge
- 37:55backlog and others were a lot more efficient.
- 37:58It really just depends on where you land division
- 38:02-wise and who the justices are. The complexity
- 38:06of the case often impacts, you know, if it's
- 38:10a really long record and is a very fact -intensive
- 38:13appeal, it often will take the research attorney
- 38:16assigned to the case a long time to sift through
- 38:18all of it. And it also even depends on if the
- 38:22panel can agree. If there's some discussion about
- 38:26whether we should go one way or the other, then
- 38:29that takes time. And on the other hand, if it's
- 38:33a very straightforward appeal, the facts are
- 38:35simple. And that's also hard to assess from the
- 38:37litigator's side, too. It just depends on like
- 38:40what the justices are interested in and the amount
- 38:43of time that they spend on these issues. So hopefully
- 38:48that's a little helpful, even though it's a little
- 38:49bit, it's not a direct answer, but it really
- 38:52just depends on the type of case. Oh, yeah. Pardon
- 38:55me, Laura. I was just going to add that generally,
- 38:57as Laura mentioned, those would fall under abusive
- 38:59discretion. There's going to be a lot of deference
- 39:02shown. And a good way to think about it under
- 39:05abuse of discretion is, is this something where
- 39:07the trial court really could have gone either
- 39:08way? Or is it just so clearly wrong? And now,
- 39:13as a former trial lawyer, I know that I often
- 39:15feel like I'm clearly right. Another side is
- 39:17clearly wrong. It's good to take a step back
- 39:19and just think about, OK, if I had to pitch this
- 39:21to somebody else and show that there's just no
- 39:23other way to rule that the trial court absolutely
- 39:26got it wrong, is that effective here? Or is this?
- 39:29you know really like they could have gone either
- 39:31way even though I don't like the ruling you could
- 39:34think about that you could even talk with a colleague
- 39:36or another attorney and just kind of from someone
- 39:39who isn't right in the middle of it sometimes
- 39:41that's helpful to to see but I think that that's
- 39:45that's a key a key question to be thinking about
- 39:47you know is it really could have gone either
- 39:49way or is it just something that's totally wrong
- 39:51that'll be an important question to be able to
- 39:54think through so the the next one and thank you
- 39:56for these questions I see, are all summary judgment
- 40:01motions subject to de novo review? Does de novo
- 40:04allow for re -arguing the facts of the case?
- 40:06As to the first part of that question, Laura
- 40:08is actually going to get to that in a moment,
- 40:10so we'll set that aside for a minute. And do
- 40:12you re -argue the facts of the case? It's kind
- 40:14of hard to say out of context, but usually it's
- 40:17a legal issue, so there's not as much argument
- 40:21about the facts under de novo. Every case is
- 40:23a little bit different, but typically, the focus
- 40:26how the appeal will be teed up is you could be
- 40:29arguing about what a contract means and that's
- 40:32that's kind of factual but it's ultimately a
- 40:34legal question about undisputed facts you have
- 40:36words on the page what do they mean so it's not
- 40:40really as much about re -arguing facts it's about
- 40:43showing that there was legal error is what I
- 40:46would say and then the last question I don't
- 40:51know if we could really speak as much about like
- 40:54the reputation read de novo review. But if you're
- 40:58curious about just appeals in different districts,
- 41:00the judicial council publishes a report annually
- 41:03that shows like how many appeals are being handled
- 41:06at a high level, kind of how appeals being granted
- 41:11versus not. So that doesn't get maybe into as
- 41:13much detail as this question, but there are some
- 41:16interesting statistics out there to see case
- 41:18flow, to see some trends that the judicial council
- 41:21shares. Laura, do you have anything you want
- 41:24to add on that one? Not really. I mean, even
- 41:27from my time working there, I don't know that
- 41:29there was a general reputation regarding certain
- 41:32standards of review. At least where I worked,
- 41:38the justices really did try to adhere to those
- 41:40standards. Like if it was turnover review, like
- 41:42we really do take a fresh look at everything.
- 41:44And if it's a more deferential standard, like
- 41:47substantial evidence or abusive discretion, the
- 41:50tendency is just to defer to the trial court,
- 41:55just given the nature of us being so far removed
- 41:58from the facts. Sure. So I think I'm finished
- 42:05with de novo there. It's deferring to the trial
- 42:08court, not deferring, taking a fresh look. So
- 42:10I'll pass it to Laura for our fourth and final
- 42:13standard on this slide. So our final standard
- 42:17of review we'll cover is a standard of review
- 42:21where the evidence is taken in the light most
- 42:24favorable to the appellant. In certain narrow
- 42:28circumstances, the appellant court will view
- 42:31the evidence in this light, the one most favorable
- 42:35to the party that lost. in the Superior Court
- 42:39and will accept as true or will accept as true
- 42:42the allegations in the appellant's pleadings.
- 42:45For example, if there was a demerit sustain,
- 42:48the allegations in the complaint would be accepted
- 42:51as true. The standard obviously is very helpful
- 42:55for the appellant because when the standard of
- 42:58review presumes the truth of the evidence in
- 43:01your favor, You have far greater leeway on appeal.
- 43:05For example, in your statement of the facts in
- 43:08your opening brief, you're able to emphasize
- 43:11the evidence that's favorable to you. You aren't
- 43:14restricted by these substantial evidence restrictions
- 43:17that we've discussed earlier. Examples of orders
- 43:23or rulings to which this standard applies is,
- 43:27as I was saying earlier, when a demurrer is sustained,
- 43:29the court of appeal will assume the truth of
- 43:32all the facts properly pleaded by the appellant.
- 43:36Or if there is an instructional error, when you're
- 43:38claiming that the trial judge gave an erroneous
- 43:42jury instruction or erroneously refused a particular
- 43:46instruction, the reviewing court will view the
- 43:49evidence in the light most favorable to the claim
- 43:53of instructional error, meaning the court will
- 43:56assume that the jury might have believed the
- 43:59evidence upon which this instruction favorable
- 44:02to your side was based. Another example is a
- 44:09JNOB grant or a non -suit or verdict. The appellate
- 44:13court will view the evidence in the light most
- 44:15favorable to the appellant, so the party that
- 44:18obtained the jury verdict, which got vacated
- 44:21or, you know, that the outcome ended up going
- 44:25the other way based on the JNOB grant. Similarly,
- 44:30for appeals from judgments after a non -suit
- 44:33or a directed verdict, the reviewing court will
- 44:37reverse if substantial evidence supports the
- 44:41appellant's case, so if substantial evidence
- 44:43supports your side. And this relates to the summary
- 44:46judgment question we had earlier. When a summary
- 44:50when summary judgment is granted and the party
- 44:55subject to that judgment appeals, the reviewing
- 45:00court will view the evidence in the light most
- 45:03favorable to the appellant. So the party against
- 45:05whom summary judgment was entered. And the reviewing
- 45:09court will resolve all doubts about the propriety
- 45:13of granting the motion in favor of the motion's
- 45:16denial. So it's a pretty favorable standard when
- 45:19the the reviewing court is reviewing the facts
- 45:22and the evidence. It's a little bit tricky because
- 45:26the overall standard of review for granting of
- 45:31motion for summary judgment, so the overall grant
- 45:33or denial of summary judgment, is subject to
- 45:36independent review on appeal. So whether the
- 45:39trial court got it right is something that the
- 45:42appellate court will independently review. But
- 45:46the facts, the underlying facts. and the evidence
- 45:49are viewed through a lens that is favorable to
- 45:53the party that did not prevail. And I think that's
- 45:59all I had for this fourth standard of review.
- 46:03I will go ahead and pass it back to Kent for
- 46:06some perspective from the respondents side. Yeah,
- 46:09thanks, Laura. So as we, oops, I'm sorry. So
- 46:12as we have on here, uh these are basically arranged
- 46:15as being more less to more favorable for the
- 46:17appellant um in terms of these standards so as
- 46:20you uh were able to gather three and four de
- 46:23novo light most favorable to the appellant that's
- 46:25better territory to be in as the appellant and
- 46:28so kind of opposite would be true for the respondent
- 46:30if you're defending um a judgment or or an order
- 46:34on appeal and it's de novo review or light most
- 46:36favorable to the appellant that's that will be
- 46:39um a tougher appeal to defend against potentially
- 46:43And so, the standard of review, both sides should
- 46:45be thinking about this. Before the appeal, at
- 46:48the outset of the appeal, throughout the appeal,
- 46:50it shapes almost everything. It really shapes
- 46:53how you present the case as a respondent. It
- 46:55shapes how you defend against it. And so, just
- 46:58a couple points. You know, part of this depends
- 47:01at a high level on whether or not the appellant
- 47:04really had their day in court. If an MSJ is granted,
- 47:07if a demurrer is sustained, they didn't really
- 47:10get their day in court. That's... uh they didn't
- 47:13get a trial by jury and so there's there's more
- 47:16it's more favorable there but if if you go to
- 47:19trial and you get a verdict from a jury you know
- 47:22absent say jury misconduct or instructional error
- 47:25if you're challenging just the factual determination
- 47:27and the verdict that won't be as beneficial to
- 47:30the impellent because they got their day in court
- 47:32and so just a couple other points from the respondent
- 47:36you know you really just want to consider how
- 47:37does this shape the playing field You know, did
- 47:40the, if it's a substantial evidence appeal, did
- 47:43the appellant fail to cite unfavorable evidence?
- 47:47Did they only cite the evidence that favors their
- 47:49side? There's plenty of case law where appellants
- 47:51misunderstand the standard of review, they want
- 47:54to argue their affirmative case again, and they're
- 47:57not acknowledging the evidence that could support
- 47:59and does support the factual determination below.
- 48:02That's a great thing to call out in a respondents
- 48:04brief. We see this, we see this fairly often
- 48:07where that's not where party's not really acknowledging
- 48:11and tailoring their arguments to the standard
- 48:13of review. If it's abuse of discretion, you know,
- 48:16do they argue why it's an abuse of discretion?
- 48:19Do they argue why it was irrational, arbitrary,
- 48:22how this ruling is one that just could not have
- 48:23been made by a reasonable person? Or are they
- 48:26just trying to re -argue it as if just as they
- 48:29were arguing it to the judge in the first instance?
- 48:31You know, if they're just kind of re -arguing
- 48:33without acknowledging the discretion that the
- 48:35trial court has. That's another good thing to
- 48:37point out as the respondent, really to look at
- 48:40that discretion and an appeal to the trial court's
- 48:44discretion that it has for that kind of ruling.
- 48:48And also sometimes appellants don't discuss the
- 48:51standard of review at all. Certainly you want
- 48:53to be discussing the standard of review in your
- 48:55appellant's brief, your respondent's brief, but
- 48:57sometimes parties don't do that. And that is
- 48:59definitely something that you would want to flag
- 49:01as well. it's essential to framing your case
- 49:06on either side. And for the respondent, really
- 49:09helpful to assess the strength of the appellant's
- 49:11position. Okay, so I'll pass it to Laura for
- 49:15our next one here. Thanks, Kent. Our next topic
- 49:19is assessing whether there was prejudice. So
- 49:24on appeal, it's not enough just to show that
- 49:27there was some error that occurred. the Court
- 49:30of Appeal will reverse or modify a judgment or
- 49:34order only for prejudicial error as opposed to
- 49:38harmless error. In other words, you have to show
- 49:42that the error resulted in a miscarriage of justice,
- 49:45that the error impacted the case's outcome. It
- 49:49has to be reasonably probable that a result more
- 49:54favorable to you, the appellant, would have been
- 49:56reached without this error. What it really boils
- 50:00down to is, did this error matter? As one very
- 50:04simplified example, say, for example, you made
- 50:08a hearsay objection at trial. The trial court
- 50:12overrules that objection. If this is a personal
- 50:16injury case involving a car accident, if the
- 50:18witness said, I heard that plaintiff was intoxicated
- 50:23and got in the car and started driving. then
- 50:26you could quite plausibly argue that the ruling
- 50:30impacted the case's outcome, that allowing the
- 50:32jury to consider this evidence, this hearsay
- 50:34evidence, was prejudicial to your case. On the
- 50:38other hand, if the witness said, I heard that
- 50:40plaintiff was wearing a blue shirt, but in reality,
- 50:43plaintiff was wearing a green shirt. Assuming
- 50:46that what plaintiff was wearing wasn't relevant
- 50:48to the appeal, then you probably will have a
- 50:52tougher time arguing that allowing this hearsay
- 50:55testimony in impacted the case's outcome. And
- 50:59this is a type of error that, while it was erroneous
- 51:01to allow the testimony in, it may fall more on
- 51:04the harmless error side. And the Court of Appeal
- 51:08won't reverse or modify the order or the judgment
- 51:13based on this error. In this context, a probability
- 51:17that the error would have that the absence of
- 51:21the error would have affected the case's outcome.
- 51:24You don't have to prove that it would have been
- 51:27more likely than not that you would have prevailed.
- 51:30You just need to demonstrate that there was a
- 51:34reasonable chance, more than an abstract possibility,
- 51:38that had this error not happened, the outcome
- 51:42would have been different. So the bar is not
- 51:45exceedingly high, but you do still need to make
- 51:47a complete prejudice argument. You can't just
- 51:52say broadly, there was this error and we were
- 51:56prejudiced. You need to, in your opening brief,
- 51:59spell out exactly how this error caused a miscarriage
- 52:03of justice based on the particulars of this case.
- 52:07Otherwise, the reviewing court will deem the
- 52:10error harmless and the outcome won't change.
- 52:17It's also worth noting that the Court of Appeal
- 52:20will review the entire record to determine whether
- 52:24or not an error was harmless or whether or not
- 52:27it was prejudicial. So as you're assessing whether
- 52:31to appeal and assessing the strength of your
- 52:33appeal, it's worth considering in light of the
- 52:35entire record, in light of all of the evidence
- 52:38presented, all of the testimony presented, did
- 52:42this error matter? And even as the respondent,
- 52:46When you're drafting your respondents brief,
- 52:48you really should consider two things regarding
- 52:51this prejudice requirement. One is, did the appellant
- 52:55make the prejudice argument? And two, did that
- 53:00argument have any merit? If the appellant didn't
- 53:03even argue prejudice, which does happen sometimes,
- 53:06then that is an opening for you to say, you know,
- 53:09in your respondents brief, the reviewing court
- 53:13has to affirm because there is a requirement
- 53:16that the appellant show prejudice and they didn't
- 53:19do so here. And they can't do so on reply because
- 53:24you have to raise all of the arguments on appeal
- 53:28for the first time in your opening brief so that
- 53:30the other side can properly respond to them.
- 53:34Also, check to see if there is a way to argue
- 53:37that even if there were error, it was harmless.
- 53:42So that, of course, is very fact -specific. So
- 53:47it just depends on what the error was. And in
- 53:51light of the whole record, was the outcome actually
- 53:54dependent on this? Or did it have an impact on
- 53:57the outcome? There are limited exceptions to
- 54:01this rule. An appellant is not required to demonstrate
- 54:04prejudice if the error is what's called reversible,
- 54:08per se. These are errors that deny a party the
- 54:13constitutional right to a fair hearing. Examples
- 54:17are denial of a right to a jury trial, denial
- 54:20of the right to testify or present evidence and
- 54:23to cross -examine witnesses, essentially constitutional
- 54:27issues. But for the vast, vast majority of cases,
- 54:33you do need to show that the error was prejudicial.
- 54:38And as I alluded to earlier, there's really no
- 54:41set formula for determining prejudice. The legal
- 54:44effect, of course, of any error necessarily depends
- 54:47on each case's circumstances. There are some
- 54:50factors you can consider as you form your prejudice
- 54:54argument or assess its strength. If this was
- 54:58a jury trial, for example, consider whether the
- 55:01verdict was close. If the verdict was unanimous,
- 55:05it might be tougher to argue that had this error
- 55:09not happened, the jury would have gone the other
- 55:15way. But on the flip side, if it was a civil
- 55:19case and it was a 9 -3 verdict, that can be helpful
- 55:23for arguing prejudice. Another example is considering
- 55:28whether the trial court cured the error. A reviewing
- 55:32court won't deem an error prejudicial if the
- 55:37trial court sufficiently admonished the jury
- 55:41to disregard a certain portion of testimony,
- 55:44for example, or gave a curative instruction or
- 55:48a limiting instruction to cure this improper
- 55:51evidence or improper argument. That, of course,
- 55:54is still very fact specific, but consider whether
- 55:57the court did that and whether a ruling court
- 56:00perhaps might deem that sufficient. Another thing
- 56:04to consider is whether the admitted or excluded
- 56:08evidence mattered. We talked about that a little
- 56:10bit earlier with what exactly was the evidence
- 56:13that was admitted or excluded, how much of your
- 56:19case depended on that. One way to assess is to
- 56:24look at the other side's closing argument. What
- 56:28did closing counsel argue? What did they focus
- 56:30on? Was this evidence heavily featured in that
- 56:34argument? Finally, another factor you might want
- 56:38to consider is did the jury ask questions? If,
- 56:41for instance, the jury asked one or perhaps multiple
- 56:44questions pertaining to the error that you claim
- 56:47happened, that is that will help bolster your
- 56:52prejudice argument. On the other hand, if the
- 56:55jury asked zero questions and returned a verdict
- 56:59in less than an hour, that probably will make
- 57:02it harder for you to argue that the error was
- 57:05prejudicial. And this, of course, is not an exhaustive
- 57:09list. There are other non -jury trial scenarios.
- 57:12For instance, if there was a procedural error
- 57:16that there was a case in which the court erroneously
- 57:21didn't sign an order granting a motion for summary
- 57:25judgment or until like well after trial was over
- 57:29on some uncertain issues. The appellate court
- 57:36deemed that a harmless error because all it would
- 57:40really do to cure the error would be bake you
- 57:43the judgment, go back and have the trial court
- 57:45sign the previous summary adjudication order,
- 57:49and then continue on with the process. And so
- 57:51it really had no substantive impact on the case.
- 57:57And so the bottom line really is consider, did
- 58:00it matter if this error did occur? how, to what
- 58:06extent did it matter, and why did it matter.
- 58:09These are all things that we need to be clear
- 58:12on as we're presenting our appeal before the
- 58:16court. I do see that we have some questions.
- 58:23I'll pause. Yeah, I think one of them we covered
- 58:26in the other one was answered in the chat. Oh,
- 58:29I see. I see. OK. Yeah, I think that's a great
- 58:31point. With any standard review questions, it's
- 58:33pretty specific. The Rudder Guide, Civil Appeals,
- 58:36and RITS treat us as an excellent resource to
- 58:40explore those specific ones. So we hope certainly
- 58:42that's a helpful resource for questions like
- 58:44that. Yes, we refer to it as our Bible at GMSR.
- 58:51Definitely recommend. Well, should I go on to
- 58:54number five? Yeah, so I'll pass it back to Kent
- 58:56to go over. I see that we're almost out of time.
- 58:59So we will try to quickly wrap up. Yeah, this
- 59:02slide will be shorter. So it's just one more
- 59:04question to think about. And really, this one
- 59:06is a little different from the others in that
- 59:08really before and during trial, during the litigation
- 59:12is really the time to be thinking about record
- 59:14preservation. After the verdict has been delivered,
- 59:19it might be too late. it very well may be too
- 59:21late to make a record. So it's something to be
- 59:24thinking about as you're trying a case, because
- 59:27this quote really shows why. This is from the
- 59:30Court of Appeal describing what they call the
- 59:32three immutable rules of appellate practice.
- 59:35First, take great care to prepare a complete
- 59:37record. Second, if it's not in the record, it
- 59:39didn't happen. And third, when in doubt, refer
- 59:42back to rules one and two. And that's a rule
- 59:44that we think about a lot on appeal, because
- 59:47Laura was talking earlier about it in her experience
- 59:50working at the Court of Appeal with Justice Wiley
- 59:53that the trial court, the jury, they see this
- 59:56happen. They see witnesses on the stand. They
- 59:58see things play out. And then on appeal, it's
- 1:00:00really on paper. It's the reporter's transcript
- 1:00:02of what happened. It's the appendix that shows
- 1:00:04all the exhibits. And so it's important to think
- 1:00:07about how is this going to look on paper. what
- 1:00:09is the record going to reflect for appeal? And
- 1:00:12generally, it's the appellant's burden to furnish
- 1:00:15a complete record. If they fail to do that, there's
- 1:00:18all sorts of, perhaps the appeal could be just
- 1:00:21dismissed or kind of automatic affirmance, or
- 1:00:25if not that. Um, at least inference is drawn
- 1:00:28against the appellant and in favor of the respondent,
- 1:00:30which might also lead to a quick. Affirmance
- 1:00:33so having a complete record is really important.
- 1:00:36A couple a few examples of deficiencies before
- 1:00:38we wrap up here that we see. an unreported sidebar.
- 1:00:42You know, you're discussing an evidentiary objection,
- 1:00:44the judge calls the attorneys over to discuss
- 1:00:46it, so the jury can't hear. You want the court
- 1:00:48reporter there with you. And if they're not there
- 1:00:50with you right then, you want to put it on the
- 1:00:52record at your first opportunity. Maybe that
- 1:00:55happens, break for lunch, and after lunch, when
- 1:00:57the reporter's back and the jury's not yet in.
- 1:00:59asked to paraphrase the core points of that discussion
- 1:01:02on the record so that it's there. And of course,
- 1:01:06if opposing counsel would have the opportunity
- 1:01:07to object if they believe that you didn't describe
- 1:01:09the court's ruling accurately or the party's
- 1:01:12argument. And if they don't object, then that's
- 1:01:14on the record. And that's clear. That's what
- 1:01:15happened. So even if you miss it right at the
- 1:01:18moment, later on in trial, there's a chance to
- 1:01:22get that on the record. And we also think about
- 1:01:25what is the evidence you're going to put into
- 1:01:26a summary judgment motion or opposition. You
- 1:01:29know, especially in an opposition, if you lose
- 1:01:31and summary judgments granted against your client,
- 1:01:33that's another example. What's in the record
- 1:01:35that you can point to to say this is the evidence
- 1:01:38of a tribal issue of material fact. And returning
- 1:01:41to our trial examples, video deposition testimony
- 1:01:44is is fairly common at trial, whether it's from
- 1:01:47a zoom deposition or in person, a video recording
- 1:01:50can be used for a witness who's unavailable,
- 1:01:53he's not going to travel from out of state, whatever
- 1:01:55the case may be. But you need to put in the record
- 1:01:58what was the testimony that was played. And really,
- 1:02:03in my opinion, the best way to do that would
- 1:02:05be the transcript from the deposition that shows
- 1:02:08these are the exits that were played. You would
- 1:02:10lodge those with the trial court. If that's not
- 1:02:12done, there's nothing in the record showing what
- 1:02:15this witness testified to. Then that's that's
- 1:02:18difficult for the appellant. The Court of Appeal
- 1:02:20could infer that it actually supported the the
- 1:02:24respondents position that it supports the judgment.
- 1:02:26And so that that could be very difficult to overcome
- 1:02:29without a full record. And then we also have
- 1:02:33nonverbal gestures. So if witness points and
- 1:02:37they you ask them how far away were you from
- 1:02:39the intersection when the accident happened?
- 1:02:41And they say, oh, it's about here to the exit
- 1:02:43sign. And they point to the back of the courthouse.
- 1:02:45It's perfectly clear to everyone there. not going
- 1:02:48to be clear to the Court of Appeal what that
- 1:02:50means, or really the appellate attorneys like
- 1:02:51us who are reviewing the record would have no
- 1:02:53idea. That could be, I don't know, 40 feet, 60
- 1:02:56feet, 100 feet. We don't know. Courtrooms vary
- 1:02:58in size, and we don't know where the witness
- 1:03:00is sitting. There's many other examples. They
- 1:03:02might say, they might point to this document.
- 1:03:05You know, it's an exhibit in front of them. But
- 1:03:07on appeal, we might not know what they're talking
- 1:03:08about, or they might draw on a demonstrative.
- 1:03:11You ask them to draw, where were you when it
- 1:03:13happened, or... with the cars were coming from
- 1:03:16which direction or whatever the case might be,
- 1:03:18you want to get that in the record, whether it's
- 1:03:21saying aloud, you can clarify in your questions
- 1:03:24or asking to have it moved into evidence that
- 1:03:28they drew on an exhibit. There's all sorts of
- 1:03:31things you can do to get it in the record. So
- 1:03:34those are a few examples. And just one last point
- 1:03:36that goes to record issues generally, it's kind
- 1:03:39of a one off, but we felt that it belongs in
- 1:03:41this category because it's a prerequisite. for
- 1:03:44appealing. In general, a motion for new trial
- 1:03:46is not required to appeal, but there's a very
- 1:03:49critical exception. If you want to challenge
- 1:03:52damages as excessive or inadequate on appeal,
- 1:03:55you have to file a motion for new trial. The
- 1:03:58trial judge essentially sits as the 13th juror
- 1:04:01in trial and can evaluate whether the damages
- 1:04:05award is just out of bounds, or if it's within
- 1:04:08the range what the jury could have awarded. And
- 1:04:11if you don't file that motion for new trial,
- 1:04:15and then you want to challenge damages as excessive
- 1:04:17or inadequate, you won't be able to challenge
- 1:04:19that on appeal. And so from the respondent's
- 1:04:23viewpoint, really, it's a pretty straightforward
- 1:04:25tip if the appellate doesn't furnish a complete
- 1:04:28record. That's something to call out, especially
- 1:04:31anything that's important or is just a clear
- 1:04:34gap in the record. That's really helpful to point
- 1:04:38out. And remember, whether you're the appellant
- 1:04:40or the respondent, remember that if it's not
- 1:04:43in the record, it didn't happen. That can favor
- 1:04:45the respondent, but on either side, you really
- 1:04:47want to be aware of that. So. With that, that
- 1:04:53concludes our presentation. We also have appendix
- 1:04:57slides as well with more content. And we welcome
- 1:04:59other questions. I'm going to check the Q &A.
- 1:05:01I think I see. see a few here. Laura, do you
- 1:05:05wanna take any? I'll start reading. Yeah, sure.
- 1:05:07I was going to say, in response to, there's one
- 1:05:08question that asked, what is something you wish
- 1:05:11trial partners thought more about that affects
- 1:05:13appeals and chances of appeal? It's exactly what
- 1:05:16Kent was just talking about. Furnish a complete
- 1:05:19record. There are several instances in which
- 1:05:22trial counsel has told me. We had this unreported
- 1:05:26conversation with the judge and the judge said
- 1:05:29XYZ or opposing counsel said XYZ and we asked,
- 1:05:32is it in the record? And they said, no, the court
- 1:05:34reporter had gone home for the day already. So
- 1:05:36if that occurs, definitely put it back on the
- 1:05:40record at the next day of trial or find some
- 1:05:43other way to. to complete the record that way,
- 1:05:46especially if there is a crucial discussion being
- 1:05:49held. As Kent was saying, if it's not in the
- 1:05:51record, it didn't happen in the appellate world.
- 1:05:55So definitely being mindful of having everything
- 1:05:57recorded, always having either, if not in a transcript,
- 1:06:03then by declaration. It's a lot easier to complete
- 1:06:08the record in the trial. We can't really add
- 1:06:11to it after. after the trial court proceedings
- 1:06:14are over. That's a really good question. I'll
- 1:06:17just bounce off of that and say I think something,
- 1:06:20I think that's absolutely right with the record.
- 1:06:22I think one or two other things I think of are
- 1:06:25jury instructions in the verdict form. I think
- 1:06:28those are really crucial too. Jury instructions
- 1:06:31are a fairly, a more common source of reversible
- 1:06:35error. Laura talked earlier about how you view
- 1:06:37the evidence in the light most favorable to the
- 1:06:39appellant. So it's already helping the appellant
- 1:06:41on an instructional challenge. And if an instruction
- 1:06:45states the law wrong, the presumption is that
- 1:06:48the jury follows the instructions unless there's
- 1:06:50evidence to the contrary. Often there won't be
- 1:06:52evidence to the contrary. So we have an erroneous
- 1:06:54instruction. Trial happened, you can't really
- 1:06:58get inside the jury's head to know what they
- 1:07:00were doing, what they thought of that instruction.
- 1:07:03And so there can be a good prejudice argument
- 1:07:05there if they were told the wrong law. But often
- 1:07:08time, you know, it's... It's very busy being
- 1:07:11a trial lawyer and you're focused on your opening,
- 1:07:13your closing and the witness examinations and
- 1:07:15everything that goes into trial and jury instructions
- 1:07:17get on the back burner. It's really helpful if
- 1:07:20you can think about them before trial. I think
- 1:07:22it helps shape the case too and the verdict form
- 1:07:24goes hand in hand with the jury instructions
- 1:07:26there. And if you have a problem on the verdict
- 1:07:28form, especially if it's a special verdict form
- 1:07:31and you're the plaintiff and you fail to get
- 1:07:33the findings that you need to support your case.
- 1:07:36there's no inferences that are gonna help you.
- 1:07:38If the jury fails to make the findings that you
- 1:07:40needed, that's, you know, you could be out of
- 1:07:43luck. And yeah, as far as, yeah, I think those
- 1:07:49are just things that not only are they important
- 1:07:51for appeal, they can really help your strategy
- 1:07:52all throughout the case. And, you know, I'm not
- 1:07:55a trial lawyer anymore. Looking back, I would
- 1:07:57have done that more. If I could tell myself as
- 1:08:00a second, third, fourth year associate in litigation,
- 1:08:02I would have been trying to do the jury instructions
- 1:08:04in the special verdict form early in the case.
- 1:08:07So that was really thinking about the case through
- 1:08:08the lens of the jury was going to hear. So it's
- 1:08:10a great question. And we have a couple others
- 1:08:14here. Is a denial of emotion to enforce settlement?
- 1:08:18an appealable order. I don't want to answer off
- 1:08:22the cuff, Laura, unless you know. I would say
- 1:08:25that's a great one for the Rudder Guide Civil
- 1:08:27Appeals and Rits as well that we call the treatise.
- 1:08:30It's really helpful. It sounds like it could
- 1:08:32be. I have not dealt with that one specifically.
- 1:08:36But the treatise is really helpful for these
- 1:08:38specific examples. So that is a question to look
- 1:08:42for there. I wish I could answer it off the cuff
- 1:08:44right now. But unfortunately, I don't yet have
- 1:08:46the treatise memorized. Lauren, do you want to
- 1:08:49take another question? Sure. The question about
- 1:08:51what if a proper does not order the transcript
- 1:08:53record. This is assuming that the proper is on
- 1:08:56the other side and you're representing a client.
- 1:09:00And if the proper is the appellant, So once the
- 1:09:05notice of appeal is filed, the respondent also
- 1:09:07can file a notice designating record on appeal.
- 1:09:11We didn't go over that process today because
- 1:09:14that happens after the notice of appeal is filed,
- 1:09:17not pre -appeal. But there are ways for the respondent
- 1:09:21to also designate the transcript or record. So
- 1:09:27all is not lost if the appellant doesn't order
- 1:09:31copies of those. And then we have a question
- 1:09:35about would a defendant's motion for directed
- 1:09:36verdict or non -suit granted after the opening
- 1:09:38statement to the jury be considered per se a
- 1:09:41denial of the constitutional right to a jury
- 1:09:43trial? So I think what we're getting at here
- 1:09:45is like, is that reversible per se? If it's erroneous,
- 1:09:48is it automatically reversible? And so that would
- 1:09:51go to our slides on standard of review and prejudice.
- 1:09:57So under standard review, the motion for directed
- 1:09:59verdict or non -suit, if that's granted, that's
- 1:10:02going to be reviewed in the light most favorable
- 1:10:04to the appellant to see you know was there really
- 1:10:06did they really have a case you know did the
- 1:10:08trial court air by by throwing it out and I'm
- 1:10:11not sure offhand if it's reversible per se. If
- 1:10:15not, it sounds like generally a strong case for
- 1:10:18prejudice, right? The prejudice is I did not
- 1:10:20get to present my case to the jury and I had
- 1:10:22a case. It's a good argument. I don't think offhand
- 1:10:26that it's per se. The reversible per se is a
- 1:10:28fairly narrowly drawn category, but certainly
- 1:10:31if I were handling that kind of specific appeal,
- 1:10:34I would look into that to see because if it's
- 1:10:37not it's not per se, still there could be a good
- 1:10:41prejudice argument. But Laura, do you have anything
- 1:10:43to add on that one? Not without looking into
- 1:10:47it further, but yeah, agreed. We certainly welcome
- 1:10:52other questions. We know people may need to go
- 1:10:54as well. We went over our time and we hope this
- 1:10:57was very helpful for everyone. We very much appreciate
- 1:11:00all the questions. They've been thoughtful and
- 1:11:03just helpful to to help us engage with you all
- 1:11:06and answer your concerns. And our emails are
- 1:11:08listed on the last slide in case you have follow
- 1:11:10-up questions and we're happy to chat about those
- 1:11:14offline too. So we'll just we'll stay for a couple
- 1:11:17minutes and then if there's no questions we'll
- 1:11:19be complete but feel free if you have any other
- 1:11:21questions to submit. Yeah thanks again. In the
- 1:11:29interest of time, I say it's best that we just
- 1:11:31leave it here. Thank you both so much for this
- 1:11:33fantastic presentation and I hope our attendees
- 1:11:36enjoy the rest of their day. Thanks everyone.